Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
1053S00
This invention relates to food, and more particular-
ly to textured protein that is useful in formulating fabri-
cated foods for human and animal consumption.
Protein deficiency is common t~roughout many parts
of the world, with protein malnutrition being the most wide
spread and serious nutritional problem in the underdeveloped
areas of the world. Rapidly increasing population of the
world is further worsening the shortage of protein supply.
It is, therefore, necessary to utilize the available protein
lQ supply in a manner that is most efficientO High quality meat
is one of the most popular sources of diet protein, and the
American population has developed taste for the texture,
flavor and mouthfeel of meat products. However, present
~; economic conditions have led to scarcity of high quality meat
products necessitating the development of meat analogs from
more readily available components that are less expensive~
Furthermore, the presence of cholesterol and highly saturated
fats in meat limit their intake by people with certain health
problems such as atherosclerosis. Another sector of world
population does not consume meats due to religious or personal
beliefs. Therefore, a need exists for the development of
palatable, high-quality protein foods from new and more readily
available secondary protein sources. There are many sources
` of secondary protein available. Besides high quality meat,
other animal proteins are lower quality meat, poultry, fish,
eggs, milk and milk productsO Soybeans, peanuts, cereals and
other plant or vegetable proteins are the other major second-
ary protein sources. However, many of these plant proteins and
-1- ~
lOS35()0
animal protein lack the required palatability and appeaxance
to make them suitable for use. Various methods of modifica-
tion of these protein sources are being used to make them
more palatable both from taste and visual standpoints and
therefore, more acceptableO Processes also have been develop-
ed to utilize animal and plant proteins in fabricating foods
similar in appearance, texture, flavor and taste to the
natural foods already acceptedO
By high quality meat is meant the customary parts of
slaughtered animals ordinarily sold for human consumption.
By low quality meat is meant the edible parts of slaughtered
animal suitabla for human consumption but unacceptable to
humans from an aesthetic or appearance point of view. If this
low ~uality meat and other referenced animal protein are modi-
fied to have the appearance of high quality meat, an additional
source of acceptable protein is provided.
By milk products is meant those protein containing
products derived from milkO For example, casein and casein
salts are protein products derived from milk. Typical edible
casein salts include sodium caseinate, calcium caseinate,
ammonium caseinate, magnesium caseinate and other edible casein
salts. Modified mil~ produc~s having the characteristics of
high ~uality meat are also more acceptable than the milk pro-
duct.
One such modification process for making meat analogs
is basically known as texturization of proteinsO m ere are
' ~
1053500
three basic processes for forming texturized protains. There
is a spinning process, an extrusion process, and a glass-puff-
ing extrusion processO The spinning process involves extrud-
ing a protein dope or solution through a die into a coagula-
tion bath to form fibers. The problem becomes obvious during
the extrusion of the dope and the determination of a proper
coagulation bathO In the extrusion process, high pressures
and temperatures are used to form a plexilaminate. In this
product the cells of the product are longer in the direction
of the extrusion. The glass-puffing process is also a high
pressure and high temperature processO The use of high pras-
sure and high temperature requires sophisticated, expensive
equipment, capital and skills to handle. The high temperature
~; and pressure also damages the protein thus processedO Further-
more, the protein thus being processed still retains some of
its undesirable flavor and taste characteristics. For exampleO
the taste of the protein has not been improvedO The type of
; protein being processed may well not have the desired palat-
ability or aesthetic acceptability. Thus D while there exist
processes for forming suitable texturized proteins, many pro-
- blems still remain to be solved in producing acceptable protein
substitutes for meat.
Another problem is that the secondary protein source
individually may la~k the required nutritional completeness
customarily considered acceptable for a protein source. A
possible solution to point toward nutritional completeness is
combining at least two secondary proteins in one product. The
--3--
1053500
process of combining two or more secondary proteins to form
a meat analog suffers from the same difficulties as forming
a meat analog from a single protein source~
In the prior art spun protein processes, there is
an effluent disposal problemO m is effluent results from
the basic nature of prior art wet processesO In order to
treat the raw protein, the raw material is dissolved in an
alkali mediumO For example, soy protein isolate can be
dissolved in sodium hydroxide solution to form a protein
dope. This solution of protein is then extruded into an
acid coagulation bathO This acid bath coagulates the protein,
and the protein fibers are formed. The fibers thus formed are
tender and must be hardened in a salt solution bath to make
them suitable for use. Thus, there are three basic steps in
the prior art for forming spun protein fibers~ In each of the
three basic steps a liquid residue is left after the process
is complete. It becomes a problem to dispose of these resi-
duesO
; Recent developments in protein texturization which
avoid some problems in protein texturization include the sheet-
ing and film forming technologies. These technologies, how-
ever, require forming and partial drying of a particular pro-
duct before that product can be shaped and texturized. In
addition, the textured product loses its shape and identity
upon cooking unless pretreated with denaturing agents such as
acids and salts~ The liquid residues left in the denaturing
--4--
: . ?
~ 053500
or fixing process are similar to those in the spinning pro-
cess and aggravate the waste disposal problemO
Therefore, it is desirable to develop a process for
protein texturization that is simple, inexpensiveJ with mini-
mum waste disposal problems, and having no adverse effect on
the nutrition and flavor of the protein being texturized.
ThereforeO it i9 an object of this invention to pro-
vide an improved protein product.
Also, an object of this invention is to provide an
i~proved protein product from readily available materials.
A further object of this invention is to provide an
improved textuxed proteinO
It is a still further object of this invention to
provide a process for forming a textured protein from a slurry
directly.
Another object of this invention is to provide a
process for forming a textured protein having an improved
meat-like-texture.
Yet another object of this invention is to provide
a process for making a textured protein and avoid the efflu-
ent problem~
A further object of this invention i9 to provide a
process for forming a textured protein without adversely
affecting the nutritional properties of protein.
Another object of this invention is to provide an
improved textured protein product from highly nutritional
--5--
lOS35~)C)
proteins or blends of nutritionally complementary proteinsO
These and other ob~ects of the invention are accom-
plished by hydrating a protein from plant or animal source or
any blend thereof, recovering the protein, shaping the pro-
tein into desired shapes and sizes, and sub~ecting the protein
to a hydrophobic mediumO
A textured protein product is obtained by hydrating
a plant and/or animal protein, recovering the protein by manip-
ulating the pH, temperature, and/or ionic equilibrium of the
aqueous environment, forming the recovered protein into desired
shape, and subjecting the shaped pieces to a selected hydro-
phobic li~uid medium.
Many possible protein sources exist which are suit-
able for use in this process. The critical feature of the
~; protein source is that it contains between about 1% and 98%
by weight protein. More preferably the vegetable protein
source should ~ontain about 65-95% by weight protein. Most
; preferably the protein content of the vegetable protein source ;~
should be about 90% by weight of the source. ~egetable pro-
tein sources for use in this invention include soy protein,
; cottonseed protein, sesame protein, peanut proteinO cereal
protein, and mixtures thereof. Other suitable protein sources
are also operable in this invention provided, however, they
meet the protein content requirement set forth above. Within
the cereal protein family, those especially suitable for use
in this invention include wheat gluten, oat protein, and corn
protein. Animal protein sources such as milk, blood, salts of
- -6-
1~)53500
casein, and albumen may be used individually or in blends with
plant proteins. Low quality meat as defined above is also
suitable for use either alone or in combinationO Thus, it
may be seen that the secondary protein and mixtures thereof,
as defined above, are suitable for use in this invention. A
simple test known in the art determines a suitable combination
to provide desired level of nutrition in the product.
The secondary protein source~ which is more readily
available but still produces desirable products as to pala-
tability and ease of manufacture, is the soy protein. Of
course, there are many soy protein sources -- including soy
flour, soy protein concentrate, and soy protein isolate in
order of increasing proteins. Additionally, one or more pro-
tein sources are suitable for use in this product and process.
In fact, any reasonable mixture of the proteins listed above
can be used to form the product of this inventionO A particu-
lar suitable protein mixture is about a 1:1 ratio of sodium
caseinate and soy protein isolate - although other ratios and
protein sources are used~
The soy protein is the preferred product for this
-~ invention because it is abundantly available in this country.
Soy protein ingredients are the most commonly available in the
marketplace at a relatively low cost. Of all the commercially
available protein ingredients, soy protein has very acceptable
nutritive properties. Soy protein is also abundantly manufac-
tured for use in human food products, whereas the other oil
seed proteins and cereal proteins are not as readily available.
-7-
1053'300
Any form of a desired vegetable protein is suitable for use
in this invention whether it is the concentrate, isolate, or
flour. The only critical feature of the vegetable protein
source is that it has the desired protein content. As above
stated the desired protein conkent is broadly from about 1% to
about 98% protein by weight. More preferably the protein
content of the ~egetable protein is about 50% to about 98%
protein by weight of the vegetable protein~ ~os~ preferably
about 90% by weight is suitable for use in the invention.
The texture, flavor, and nutritional quality of the
textured product is controlled by the selection of protein or
protein blend, extent of treatment of the slurry or dough,
selection of acid, amount of water retained in the recovered
protein, selection of the hydrophobic r,~edium and the time and
temperature of treatment in the hydroE,hobic liguid. A soft
elastic texture, if desirable, is obtained by using sodium
caseinate or sodium caseinate-soy isolate blend as the protein
source in the slurry, citric, lactric or tartaric acid for
recovering protein, retaining 60-70% water in the recovered
protein and fixing the protein in a fat bath adjusted at 200C.
While it is not desired to be bound by any particu-
lar theory covering the operation of this invention, never-
theless, the following postulate is offered. The trea~ment
of the protein with water causes binding of water by the hy-
drophilic groups of protein, thereby hydrating the protein
molecules. In the hydrated stateO protein molecules are more
flexible and are more prane to structural changes. The hy-
105~500
drated protein molecules in water normally have hydrophilicgroups extending outwards and hydrophobic or lyophilic groups
towards the inside of the molecule When the hydrated protein
is subjected to treatment with fat or oil, the hydrophobic
groups tend to come to the surface of the protain molecule
because of the affinity of hydrophobic groups for fat. On the
other hand the hydrophilic groups are repelled by fat towards
the inside of the protein molecule. A massive change in pro-
tein structure and the resulting interactions between various
groups of protein produce a textured protein that is insoluble
in water and does not disintegrate upon cooking.
To the selected protein or protein blend, water is
added in sufficient quantity to form either a slurry or a
dough in order to hydrate the protein. It is critical to hy-
drate the protein. The most effective hydration of the protein
is achieved in slurryO A suitable slurry contains up to about
- 20% by weight solids based on the weight of the slurry. More
preferably, the slurry contains about 5% to about 15% by weight~
solids. Most preferably the slurry con~ains about 9% to about
11% by weight solidsD At this solids concentration which is
indicated as most preferred for the slurryO the most complete
hydration is obtained in the protein~ Thuso the water in the
slurry is used most efficiently at this concentration. Of courseD
a slurry is only formed if the starting protein is a solid.
Above about 20% by weight solids, the combination of protein
and water loses the liquid characteristic of the slurryO and
becomes more viscous to approach a dough-like consistency. The
_g_
:
,
~053,500
percentages of solids around 20 is not a precise dividing
line between liquid characteristics of a slurry and vi~cous
dough characteristicsO The distinction between slurry and
dough depends on the protein or protein mixture being used in
the water. Whether or not a dough or a slurry is formed at a
particular solids concentration in the water is easily deter-
mined by a person having ordinary skill in the art. In case
of a liquid protein source such as milk or blood, addition of
water is not necessaryO
10An interaction between the various components of
the protein source provides conditioning of the dough or slurry
and is usually accomplished by heating and/or using selected
polysaccharides. ~ypical polysaccharides that may be used are
carrageenanO carboxymethylcellulose, sodium alginate, guar gum,
gum arabic, and others that interact with proteins. ~he addi-
tion of small amounts of polysaccharides assures more complete
recovery of proteins.
One or more polysaccharides may be added to the
slurry in order to condition the slurryO This conditioning is
used individually or in combination with heat to provide the
total conditioning of the slurry or doughu About 0.1 to about
10% by weight polysaccharides based on the weight of protein
being used is suitable for use in the conditioning process~
~ore preferably about 0~5 to about 5% b~ weight polysaccharide
;is used~ Most preferably about 2% to about 3% by weight poly-
saccharide is used. The most preferred range achieves the
desired gelling and conditioning of the protein at the most
-10- :
~: .
10531500
economical use of material, time and processingO
If a slurry is formed the pH of the final material
is then adjusted until precipitation of protein occurs as a
gelatinous mass. The desired pH is generally lower than 7.0
and preferably in the range of 400 to 6Ø Most preferably,
the pH ranges from 4.5 to about 5.50 The pH adjustment is
a~complished by using any suitable edible acia or mixture of
acids~ An especially suitable acid is citric acid. Other
suitable acids include lactic, tartaric, succinic, malic,
fumaricO phosphoricO hydrochloric, and sulfuric. If the acid
is added to a slurry, the protein effectively precipitates and
settles out to be recovered by filtration. If the acid is
added to a doughO it must be blended so that a uniform dis-
tribution of the acid in the dough is achieved. The most
effective way to add the acid to the slurry is to heat the
slurry to the boiling point of the slurry. In this fashion,
the precipitation from the slurry and the hydration of the
protein source is more effective. However, any heating treat-
ment combined with the acid treatment is operable for a treat-
ment of the slurry.
Whether the protein is precipitated from a water
~ slurry, formed into a dough, or hydrated in another suitable
- fashion, the next step i~ a shaping of the hydrated protein
source. This shaping is generally effected by pressing the
; hydrated protein source to form a continuous mass and then
obtaining small pieces of the resultant mass. The small pieces
may be obtained by cutting. Alternatively, the hydrated pro-
--11--
~,~
., , :
1053500
tein may be sifted through screens of different mesh sizes
to obtain piec~s of different sizes.
Pressing pressures for the hydrated protein range up
to about 10,000 pounds per square inch gauge. Preferably the
pressing pressure ranges from about 20000 to 10,000 pounds per
square inch gauge. More preferably, the pressing pressure is
about 3,000 to about 5,000 pounds per square inch gaugeO
Above 10,000 pounds pressure is usable but undesirable. The
undesirability is~due to the increased equipment and other
10 factors in creating the higher pressure.
After shaping the protein is treated in a hydrophobic
mediumO Basically, the formed material is heated in an edible
oil for a period of timeO Preferably the heating temperature
ranges from 145C~ to about 275C~ m e heating time ranges
from about 10 to about 200 seconds. More preferably, the heat-
ing time ranges from about 15 to about 120 seconds. M~st pre-
ferably, the heating time is from about 30 to about 100 seconds.
The heating time decreases as the temperature increases. Suit-
able vegetable oils for treating the hydrated protein include
20 those materials which are liquid at the heating temperature.
Typical examples of the edible oil or fat include corn oilO
soybean oil, oat oil, cottonseed oil, hydrogenated oils, mar-
garines, shortenings, milk fat and other fats from animal
sources, More preferably the temperature ranges from 175C. t
; to 225C.
The final product is a textured protein having a meat-
like texture. Standard acceptable coloring and flavor can be
-12- -
- , , .
- .
1053500
added to the product at a suitable point in the process to
achieve desirable aroma and colorationO For exampleD such
addition may be made to the hydrated protein before the shap-
ing step. In this fashion, the desirability of the product
is improved because it more closely resembles meat.
After treatment in the fat, the product is cooled
and placed in a bath. Preferably the bath is a water bath
which is boiling. This bath step, however, is optional. The
texture is improved by placing the product in this heated
water bath.
It is well recognized in the art that boiling temper-
ature of water on a practical basis is generally around 100C.
due to the differring elevations throughout the United States,
Of course, it is well recognized that the boiling temperature
of water varies with the pressure and that this adjuskment in
the boiling temperature will have no substantial effect on the
process at the points where boiling water is called for, so
long as the temperature of the boiling water is above 90C.
These water temperatures are also applicable for the condition-
ing of the protein whether in slurry or dough form~ Thus, itmay be seen that the post treatment and the conditioning tem-
perature are substantially the same in this processO
Having now disclosed the invention, the following
examples are offered as an illustration thereof without inten-
tion of unduly limiting the invention. Unless otherwise speci-
fied, all parts and percentages are by weight both in the exam-
ples and throughout the specification.
-13-
' ' . ' ' ' ,
10535iO0
Example l
A 10% slurry of soy protein isolate is prepared in
water. The slurry is heated in a closed vessel to 100C. A
calculated amount of 10% citric acid is added to t~e heated
slurry to precipitate the protein. This addition of citric
acid results in a pH ranging from about 4O5 to about 5.0 for
the slurryO The precipitate of soy protein isolate is washed
with cold water to remove excess acidity and then recovered
by filtration. The recovered precipitate is pressed to rs-
move excess water. The pressing forms the soy protein isolateinto a meat-like piece~ This meat-like piece is then cut into
pieces. The pieces are heated in a corn oil bath adjusted to
about 200C~ for a period of about 40 seconds. Then the pieces
are removed from the corn oil bath and cooled to ambient temper-
ature. Finally, the pieces are placed in an enclosed water
bath for a period of about 10 minutes to form a chewy meat-like
texture which is cookable without disintegration. The treat-
ment in the water bath at boiling temperature ranges from about
5 to about 15 minutes and completes the texture forming of the
meat. No salts or other chemical are present in the water bath.
Example 2
To form a dough, lO0 grams of soy protein isolateO
30 mililiters of 10% citric acidO and 40 mililiters of water
are mixed. The resulting dough is pressed and cut into chuDks.
The chunks are heated in a corn oil bath adjusted to 200C. for
a period of 40 seconds~ The pieces are cooled and heated in a
boiling water bath for 5 minutes. The resulting pieces have a
chewy meat-like texture.
-14-
. : . . . ~ -: . . . .
.
l~)S3SOO
Example 3
Example l is repeatedO except that soy flour (50%
protein by weight) is used as the protein source in place of
soy protein isolate. Substantially similar resultq are ob-
tained O
Example 4
Example l is repeated with substantially similar
results, except that soy protein concentrate (70% protein by
weight) is used as the protein source in place of soy protein
isolateO
Example 5
Example 1 is repeated with substantially similar
results except that sodium caseinate is used in place of soy
protein isolate.
Example 6
Homogenized whole, partially skimmed or skim milk is
used in place of 10% slurry of soy protein in Example 1, with
similar resultsO
Example 7
Example 1 is repeated, with substantially similar
results, except that a mixture of soy protein isolate and
sodium caseinate is used in place of soy protein isolate.
Example 8
Example 1 is repeated with substantially similar
results except that 10% hydrochloric acid is used for recover-
ing protein from the slurry~ ~-
`:~
~ -15-
101535~0
EXAMPLE 9
Example 1 Ls repeated wLth substantLally sLmLlar results except
that sodLum algLnate Ls mLxed wLth soy proteLn Lsolate at the rate of 1%
by weLght of proteLn before making the slurry.
,''
~"'
. .
,
~'
: -16-
.. , . . -. . . -
