Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
~'Æ~5
STRESS CONTROL COLLAR
Background of the Invention
This invention relates generally to mechanical
joints and, more particularly, to a collar for controlling
stress in a mechanical joint subjected to movement and high
temperatures.
A steam reformer, also known as a steam-methane
reformer, is used to produce hydrogen gas by passing a mix-
ture of methane and steam through a heated catalyst. The
catalyst is normally contained within tubes positioned within
a heated chamber. In the design and construction of steam
reformers and other similar equipment, the gas which is
produced is transferred from the catalyst tubes to an outlet
manifold by a plurality of small tubes, commonly referred to
as "pigtails". The pigtails are subjected to significant
bending stresses due in part to thermal expansion and con-
traction which occurs during start-up and shut-down of the
reformer, and in part due to the bowing or bending which
frequently occurs in the relatively-long catalyst tubes.
The pigtails are connected at their ends to the
catalyst tube and the outlet manifold, respectfully, by
extension elements, commonly called weldolets, which are
conical-shaped elements having a central bore aligned with
holes provided in the walls of the catalyst tube and the
outlet manifold. The weldolets are welded to the surfaces
of the catalyst tube and the manifold, and the ends of the
pigtails, in turn, are welded to the weldolet.
Numerous failures have been experienced in the
pigtails at the points where they are welded to the weldolets.
These failures are the result of the concentration of stress
occurring at the tip of the weld which joins the pigtail to
the weldolet. These failures, which are normally cracks in
the wall of the pigtails, are propagated by a combination of
thermal fatigue and grain boundary oxidation caused by the
stress concentration aggravated by the bending stresses.
The weld which joins the pigtail to the weldolet,
in addition to creating a mechanical notch with the con-
comitant stress concentration associated therewith, also
degrades the yield strength of the material in the heat-
affected zone of the weld, thus also causing a metallurgical
notch.
Summary of the Invention
Accordingly, it~is an object of the present
invention to provide a control collar to reduce stress-
related failures in mechanical joints.
Another object of the present invention is to pro-
vide a control collar of the above type which reduces
failures caused by thermal fatigue and grain boundary
oxidation in a weld.
Yet another object of the present invention is
to provide a control collar of the above type which does not
degrade the yield strength of the material in the heat-
affected zone of the weld.
.~.-,~ , .
~J~8~5
A further object of the present invention is to
provide a control collar of the above type which increases
; the reliability of welded joints.
A still further object of the present invention is ,~
to provide a control collar of the above type which reduces
failures caused by thermal stress and fatigue occurring in
welded conduits used for conducting gases from a steam
reformer.
Toward the fulfillment of these and other objects,
the stress control collar of the present invention is of
the same alloy composition as the gas-transfer tubing, or
pigtail, used in a steam reformer, and is placed over the
outer diameter of the pigtail in the area where the pigtail
is welded to a weldolet of the steam reformer. In preparing
this joint, the pigtail is first welded to the weldolet with
a fillet weld, and then the stress control collar is welded
to the pigtail at the point of its attachment to the weldolet.
The inner diameter of the stress control collar closely fits
over the outer diameter of the pigtail, and the inner edge
of the free end of the control collar is shaped to provide a
smooth contour at the point of maximum bending movement of
the control collar, thus removing a possible point of contact
between the control collar and the pigtail as the pigtail
bends due to thermal stresses and physical movement within
the steam reformer.
1 ZB~
In one broad aspect the invention comprehends a
welded interconnection for connecting a cylindrical member
in registry with an opening extending through a second member,
the members being subjected to thermally induced relative
bending therebetween. The interconnection comprises a tubular
extension connected at one end to the second member and defines
a through bore in registry with the opening, the tubular
extension having a counterbore at its other end for receiving
an end portion of the cylindrical member, and a first weld
connects the other end of the tubular extension to an outer
surface portion of the cylindrical member. A collar displaces,
from the region of the weld, the mechanical stress caused by
the bending. The collar extends over a portion of the
cylindrical member with the inner end of the collar located
proximate to the first weld. A second weld connects the inner
end of the collar with the first weld and the cylindrical
member, the collar being fabricated from the same material as
the cylindrical member.
.~
l~Z~45
Brief Description of the Drawings
The above description, as well as further objects,
features and advantages of the present invention, will be
more fully appreciated by reference to the following
description of a presently-preferred but nonetheless
illustrative embodiment in accordance with the present
invention, when taken in connection with the accompanying
drawings, wherein:
Figure 1 is a cross-sectional view of a portion of
a steam reformer showing the stress control collars of the
present invention provided at the ends of a gas-transfer
tubing; and
Figure 2 shows, to an enlarged scale, one of the
stress control collars of Figure 1.
Description of the Preferred Embodiment
Referring specifically to Figure 1 of the drawings,
the reference numeral 10 refers generally to a steam reformer,
only a portion of which is shown, which is defined in part
by an exterior wall 12 provided on its inner surface with a
suitable, thermal insulation material 14. A manifold box 16
extending to the right in Figure 1 is defined by an upper
wall 16a, which is attached at one edge to the wall 12 of
the steam reformer lO, and a parallel lower wall 16b. While
not specifically shown, it is understood that front, back
and end walls are positioned cooperatively with the upper
and lower walls 16a and 16b, respectively, to complete
the structure of the manifold box 16 enclosing an outlet
~QZ~
manifold 18, which will be described more fully below. The
upper and lower walls 16a and 16b of the manifold box 16
are appropriately supported by support elements l9a and l9b,
respectively, which, while not specifically shown, are
suitably attached at one end to the wall 12 of the steam
reformer 10.
Positioned within the interior 20 of the steam
reformer 10 is a plurality of catalyst tubes 22, one of which
is shown in Figure 1. The catalyst tubes 22 are normally
positioned in parallel rows, with each row extending per-
pendicularly to the plane of Figure 1, and extend vertically
within the steam reformer 10.
The catalyst tube 22 may be an elongated, cylindrical
tube of a suitable, heat-resistant material, which is open
at its upper end (not shown). As an illustrative example
only, the catalyst tube 22 may be four to six inches in
diameter and 30 to 40 feet in length. As shown in Figure 1,
the lower portion of the catalyst tube 22 is provided with
an outer, circumferential flange 23, to which is attached a
disk 24 which closes the bottom of the catalyst tube.
To accommodate movement of the catalyst tube 22
resulting from the bowing of the tube along its length and
thermal expansion and contraction, each tube is supported to
permit a limited degree of movement vertically and trans-
versely, into and from the plane of Figure 1. To this end,
an annular support ring 26 is secured to the outer periphery
of the flange 23. A support assembly, which includes a
pair of upper support elements 27 and a pair of lower
support elements 28 positioned diametrically with respect to
the catalyst tube 22, is provided which cooperates with the
support ring 26 to permit movement of the catalyst tube in
the directions indicated above. Each lower support element
28 may be a conventional beam of C-shape cross section having
spaced, parallel flanges 28a and 28b, with the lower flange
28b being secured to a frame member 29. Each upper support
element 27 may also be a conventional, structural element,
such as a right-angle bar, which is connected to its
corresponding lower support element 28 by a spacer block
; 30 with a horizontal side 27a of the upper support élement
positioned parallel to the upper flange 28a of the lower
support element. Each side 27a and its corresponding upper
flange 28a are spaced sufficiently to permit the support ring
26 to be disposed therebetween and to be provided with a
limited degree of vertical movement.
Normally, the weight of the catalyst tube 22 is
transmitted by the support ring 26 to the upper flanges 28a
of the support elements 28. To reduce friction as the support
ring 26 slides along the upper flanges 28a, the upper and
lower surfaces of the support ring are provided with anti-
friction elements 31 of a suitable material, such as Teflon
disks. The parallel surfaces of the upper flanges 28a and
the sides 27a of the support elements 28 and 27, respectively,
which cooperate with the support ring 26, are also provided
with anti-friction elements 32.
-- 7 --
A pair of biasing assemblies 33 is provided for
each catalyst tube 22 which biases the support ring 26 in
supporting contact with the flanges 28a. Each biasing
assembly 33 includes a support tab 34, which may be a ring, or
two separate elements diametrically attached to the outer
surface of the catalyst tube 22, provided adjacent to the
lower portion of the catalyst tube. A tubular sleeve 35 is
affixed to the upper surface of each support tab 34, and a
resilient element 36, such as a spring, is disposed within the
sleeve. One end of each resilient element 36 rests within a
recess 34a provided in the surface of the support tab 34,
and the other end extends beyond the upper edge of the
sleeve 35 and presses against the lower surface of a plate 37
attached to the catalyst tube 22. One edge of the lower wall
16b of the manifold box 16 rests on the plate 37. By this
arrangement, the wall 16b is resiliently supported at one
edge, and the weight of the wall tends to counteract
vertical movement of the catalyst tube 22, causing the
catalyst tube to rest on the support element 28.
An elongated catalyst support tube 38, which is
closed at both ends, is concentrically disposed within the
catalyst tube 22. The lower end of the catalyst support
tube 38 rests on the disk 24, and the upper end is closed by
a conical top 39. The conical top 39 of the support tube 38
is provided with perforations 40 to permit the passage there-
through of the gas produced in the catalyst tube 22. An
opening 41 is provided in the wall of the catalyst support
~2~45
tube 38 to provide means through which the gas within the
interior of the catalyst support tube may be discharged. The
outer diameter of the catalyst support tube 38 is smaller than
the inner diameter of the catalyst tube 22 to provide an
annular space 42 between these tubes. A quantity of catalyst
is placed within the catalyst tube 22 to form a column
supported by the conical top 39 of the catalyst support tube
38. Any suitable catalyst which reacts with a mixture of
steam and methane to produce hydrogen may be used, such as
ceramic elements in the form of rings which are coated with
nickel.
With continuing reference to Figure 1, the
structure for removing the gas from the catalyst tube 22 to
the outlet manifold 18 includes a gas-transfer tubing or pig-
lS tail 44 which is attached at its ends to extension outlets or
weldolets 46 and provided with a control collar 48. The
details of the joint between the ends of the pigtail 44 and
the catalyst tube 22 at one end and the outlet manifold 18
at the other end are shown in Figure 2. Since the joint
between the pigtail 44 and the catalyst tube 22 is identical
-to the joint between the pigtail and the outlet manifold 18,
the description of Figure 2 is applicable to both joints.
As shown in Figure 2, an opening 22a is provided in
the wall of the catalyst tube 22, at a vertical elevation
substantially aligned with the opening 41 provided in the
catalyst support tube 38. The weldolet 46 is provided with an
internal bore 46a of substantially the same diameter as the
2~5
opening 22a in the catalyst tube 22, and the weldolet is
suitably attached to the exterior wall of the catalyst tube,
such as by a weld 49, so that the bore and the opening are
horizontally aligned. The free end of the weldolet 46, which
may be of a truncated-cone configuration, has a counterbore
46b concentric with the bore 46a, but of a larger diameter.
The diameter of the counterbore 46b is sufficient to receive
the end of the pigtail 44, and the pigtail is positioned
within the counterbore to provide a narrow gap 50 between the
end of the pigtail and the end of the counterbore. The pig-
tail 44 is suitably attached to the end of the weldolet 46,
such as by a fillet weld 51, and is supported by the weldolet.
The control collar 48 is concentrically positioned
over the portion of the pigtail 44 which is adjacent to the
weldolet 46. As shown in Figure 2, the control collar 48 may
be a length of tubing having an inner diameter just slightly
larger than the outer diameter of the pigtail 44 to permit
sliding of the collar onto the pigtail. The end of the
collar 48 which is adjacent to the weldolet 46 is attached to
the fillet weld 51 and to the pigtail 44 by another weld 52.
The inner circumferential edge 48a of the free end of the
control collar 48 adjacent to the surface of the pigtail 44
is provided with a smooth contour so that when the pigtail
bends as a result of the differences in the thermal exp~nsion
and contraction between the catalyst tube 22 and the outlet
manifold 18, the control collar has no sharp edges which
could damage the surface of the pigtail.
-- 10 --
~z~
The material of the control collar 48 is the same
as the material of the pigtail 44 so that the coefficient of
the thermal expansion of the material of the two elements are
identical to eliminate any possibility of thermal stresses
being induced by different rates of expansion due to
differences in materials. As an example only, the pigtail 44
and the control collar 48 may be made from an alloy commonly
known as Incoloy 800, a material which is suitable for high-
temperature applications.
The outlet manifold 18 may be a tubing of suitable
size and material, and is positioned with its longitudinal
axis extending perpendicularly to the plane of Figure 1.
To accommodate motion transmitted to the outlet manifold 18
from the catalyst tube 22 by the pigtail 44, the outlet
manifold is supported to permit transverse and longitudinal
motion relative to its longitudinal axis, as seen in
Figure 1. To accommodate the movement along its longitudinal
axis, the outlet manifold 18 is provided with longitudinally-
extending runners 54, which are positioned diametrically
along the surface of the outlet manifold and extend sub-
stantially the length of the outlet manifold. The runners 54
cooperate with upper and lower guide channels 55 and 56,
respectively, which are attached to the inner surfaces of
the upper and lower walls 16a and 16b. The outlet manifold 18
is also provided at predetermined intervals along its length
-- 11 --
s
with elastic support assemblies (not shown), which may be
structurally similar to the biasing assembly 33 which co-
operate with the catalyst tube 22. These elastic support
assemblies permit a limited degree of vertical motion of
the outlet manifold 18 and the pigtail 44 attached thereto.
As shown in Figure 1, the inner surfaces of the walls 16a
and 16b of the manifold box 16, as well as the guide channels
55 and 56 are lined with suitable thermal insulation
material to protect these structures.
In operation, the interior 20 of the steam reformer
10 is heated in a known manner, such as with natural gas or
fuel oil, to approximately 1,000 to l,100F. Each of the
catalyst tubes 22 within the steam reformer 10 is provided with
a charge of catalyst to a suitable height within the catalyst
tube. A mixture of steam and methane is introduced by suit-
able means (not shown) through the open, upper end of each of
the catalyst tubes 22, with the mixture flowing downwardly
through the catalyst column. The hydrogen gas produced by
reaction between the steam and methane in the presence of the
catalyst and high temperature is collected in the annular
space 42 between the catalyst tube 22 and the catalyst support
tube 38, and also in the interior volume of the catalyst
support tube since the hydrogen gas may pass through the
perforations 40 in the conical top 39 of the catalyst support
tube. A portion of the steam-methane mixture will also pass
through the perforations 40, and will collect in the bottom of
the catalyst support tube 38 and be removed by conventional
means which have not been shown.
- 12 -
~ z~g~
The hydrogen gas which is collected within the
catalyst support tube 38 passes through the opening 41 and,
along with the gas which has collected in the space 42, passes
through the opening 22a in the wall of the catalyst tube 22.
The hydrogen gas then flows through the central bore 46a of
the weldolet 46 and the interior passage of the pigtail 44,
and into the outlet manifold 18 through an opening (not shown)
provided in the wall of the manifold, which may be sub-
stantially similar to the opening 22a in the wall of the
catalyst tube 22.
During start-up and shut-down of the steam reformer
10 and during normal operations, thermal expansion and con-
traction and bowing of the catalyst tube 22 along its length
will produce sliding and vertical movement of the catalyst
tube, which are effectively accommodated by the annular
support ring 26 and the support assembly including support
elements 27 and 28, in the manner described above. Similarly,
vertical and longitudinal movement of the outlet manifold 18
are also effectively accommodated in the manner described
above. Since the control collar 48 and the pigtail 44 are
both made of the same material, there are no thermal stresses
induced by differential thermal expansion and contractions.
Differential movement between the catalyst tube 22 and the
outlet manifold 18 are effectively countered by the manner
in which these two elements are suspended and supported so
that differential displacements do not adversely affect the
structural integrity or function of the pigtail 44, or the
interconnection between the pigtail and the weldolet 46, the
catalyst tube 22, or the manifold 18.
~z~s
The length of the control collar 48 is sufficient
to displace the point of maximum bending movement of the
pigtail 44, from the normal location in the vicinity of the
fillet weld 51 when a control collar is not used, to the
vicinity of the free end of the control collar. The point
of maximum bending movement is accordingly moved away from a
zone of potential mechanical stress concentration and
metallurgical weakness to the end of the control collar which
is not near a weld, and is further from any part of the
assembly subjected to a welding operation.
While not specifically shown in the drawings, it is
understood that a pigtail 44 would connect each of the plurality
of catalyst tubes 22 to a suitable opening provided in the
outlet manifold 18, and the pigtails would be disposed sub-
stantially parallel to the pigtail shown in Figure 1. It isunderstood, of course, that each of these pigtails will be
provided at both ends with a control collar 48, sucll as show
more particularly in Figure 2, and as also shown the wall
thiekness of the control eollar is greater than the wall
thiekness of the pigtail and the axial length of the eollar
is greater than the outside diameter of the pigtail. Also,
while not speeifieally shown in the drawings to enhanee the
elarity of presentation, it is understood that the steam
reformer 10, the assembly of eatalyst tubes 22, and -the outlet
manifold 18, as well as the struetures assoeiated therewith
are appropriately supported to permit operation and cooperation
in substantially the manner herein described.
- 14 -
4,5
Of course, variations of the specific construction
and arrangement of the steam reformer and the control collar
disclosed above can be made by those skilled in the art
without departing from the invention as defined in the
appended claims.
- 15 -
