Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
1118S70
AD 4904
Process for Ma-nufacturing Shaped
Polyester Article Using Scrap Materials
Description
Technical Field
5This invention relates to a continuous pro-
cess for manufacturing a shaped article of polyester
material. The polyester material is a combination of
virgin polyester and scrap polyester. The virgin
polyester and the scrap polyester are blended in the
polyester polymerization process at a point and in a
manner to: assure complete combination of the compo-
nents; reduce degradation and discoloration; avoid
detrimental side reactions; improve the quality of
shaped articles made using the polyester material;
and increase the capacity of the polyester manufactur-
ing facility.
Background Art
In continuous polycondensation processes
for manufacture of high molecular weight polyester
materials, the reactants are generally polymerized in
a closed stream under conditions of elevated tempera-
ture and reduced pressure. The final step in such
polycondensation processes is conducted in a reaction
vessel, hereinafter termed a "polymerization finisher"
wherein a stream of low viscosity, low molecular
: ~ j .. ,
1118S70
weight polyester prepolymer is introduced into one
end and, under conditions of elevated temperature and
reduced pressure, the stream is removed from the other
end as a high viscosity high molecular weight poly-
ester. A polymerization finisher is generally a cyl-
indrical vessel having its longitudinal axis disposed
in a substantially horizontal plane and having an in-
let for low molecular weight liquid at one end, an
outlet for high molecular weight liquid at the other
end, and at least one outlet for maintaining reduced
pressure in the vessel and withdrawing water and other
vaporous by-products from the vessel. Examples of
polymerization finishers are disclosed in United
States Patent Nos. 3,248,180 and 3,057,702.
Polymerization finishers are generally fitted with
means for agitating the liquid during the course of
the liquid through the finisher; and the outlet for
high molecular weight liquid is generally downstream
from the agitating means in a pool reservoir for the
high molecular weight liquid.
It is well known that processes for manu-
facturing shaped articles from high molecular wei~ht
polyesters result in a large amount of scrap which
scrap must be disposed of by some means. For economic
reasons, the most satisfactory means for disposing of
scrap polyester material is to reuse the material by
returning it or its components to the stream of the
polyester manufacturing process.
Scrap has been introduced to the stream by
being dissolved in one of the monomers upstream from
the finisher and before polymerization of the pre-
polymer has been started. In United States Patent No.
2,933,476 issued April 19, 1960, it is disclosed to
. ~
,
1118S70
add flaked scrap polyethylene terephthalate to the
monomer stream in an amount which may be fro~ ten to
thirty percent of the total polymer product. Scrap
has also been added to the stream by being dissolved
in the prepolymer stream at the entrance of the poly-
merization finisher. Such early addition of poly-
ethylene terephthalate film does permit recycle
utilization of scrap material but tends to cause upsets
in the process by virtue of the addition of fully poly-
merized material ~o monomer or prepolymer streams.Such early addition causes decrease in demand from the
monomer supply units. Moreover, additional power is
required for early addition of scrap, first to dis-
solve, and then to move, the polymer-containing stream
of increased viscosity.
Scrap has been introduced to the stream by
being glycolyzed to break the scrap into monomer and
oligomer for repolymerization. In United States Patent
No. 3,257,335 issued June 21, 1966, it is disclosed to
depolymerize polyester materials and to add the de-
polymerized material to a polyester manufacturing
stream. Such depolymerization provides means for re-
cycling scrap polyester material without appreciable ~ ~
increase in the viscosity of reactant streams; but ~-
additional power is required to dissolve, depolymer-
ize, and repolymerize the scrap material. Addition-
ally, scrap recycle by depolymerization causes decrease
in demand from the monomer supply and does not provide
any increase in the capacity of polymerization equip-
ment. Scrap depolymerized by glycolysis results information of ethers, such as diethylene glycol, which
ethers become incorporated as ether-linkages in poly-
ester made from the scrap. Polyesters with such
~118570
ether-linkages present, exhibit undesirable properties
as do products made from such polyesters.
Scrap has also been introduced into the
polymer stream by melting the scrap and blending it
with completely polymerized virgin polymer. United
States Patent No. 3,652,466, issued March 28, 1972;
Defensive Publication T 870,010, published January 13,
1970; and British Patent No. 1,358,342, published
~uly 3, 1974, all relate to reclaiming polyester by
comminuting polyester scrap in accordance with various
methods. Each reference discloses that the comminuted
scrap can then be blended with completely polymerized
virgin polyester material. British Patent No.
1,264,338, published February 23, 1972 discloses that
scrap polyester material can be refed along with fresh
polyester to a film forming extruder. Such blending
of molten scrap polyester with molten virgin polyester
requires a separate blending step independent of the
polyester polymerization process. Such blending of
materials is generally conducted under atmospheric or
superatmospheric pressures without occasion for re-
lease of dissolved or occluded gases from the scrap
material.
Disclosure of the Invention
This invention involves a continuous process
for manufacturing a shaped article of polyester mater-
ial by extruding a molten blend of scrap polyester and
virgin polyester. In this invention, the process for
blending scrap polyester and virgin polyester is con-
ducted as a final step in the polyester polymerization
process.
Accordingly, there is provided a continuous
process for manufacturing a shaped article of
1118570
polyester material comprising the steps of: con-
tinuously polymerizing polyester in a closed, flowing,
steady state polymerizing stream by a polycondensation
reaction comFrising adding low viscosity, low molec-
ular weight polyester prepolymer to the beginning ofthe stream, maintaining conditions in the stream at
eievated temperature and reduced pressure, and remov-
ing water and other polycondensation by-products from
the stream to yield high viscosity, high molecular
10 weight virgin polyester at the end of the stream; add- ~.
ing scrap polyester to the virgin polyester at the end
of the stream to yield polyester material blend; with-
drawing polyester material blend from the polymerizing~ ;
stream; and forcing the polyester material blend
through an extrusion die.
More specifically, there is provided a
continuous process for manufacting a shaped article
of polyester material comprising the steps of: con-
tinuously operating a polymerization finisher to man-
ufacture high viscosity, high molecular weight virginpolyester; adding scrap polyester to the virgin poly-
ester in the finisher to yield polyester material
blend; withdrawing polyester material blend from the
finisher; and forcing the polyester material blend
through an extrusion die.
In its preferred form the process of this
invention relates to manufacturing a polyester film ~.
web and includes additional steps of trimming scrap
polyester from the film web, once extruded, and
transporting the scrap polyester back 40 the point
where the scrap polyester is added to the virgin
polyester.
Polyester material blend forced through
- 1118570
an extrusion die yields a shaped article whether the
shaped article is cast film, fiber, or ribbon and
whether it is later stretched or chopped into flakes
or pellets.
Polyesters and polyester material as used
herein, mean the linear polycondensation product of
an aromatic dicarboxylic acid and a dihydric alcohol.
Prepolymer as used herein, means a low molecular
weight polymer of such acid and alcohol. Aromatic
10 dicarboxylic acids include terephthalic acid, iso- ;~
~phthalic acid, 4,4'-diphenyl-dicarboxylic acid, 2,6-
naphthalenedicarboxyli¢ acid, and the like. Dihydric
alcohols include, lower alkane diols with from 2-10 ~
carbon atoms, including ethylene glycol, propylene -
glycol, butylene glycol, cyclohexanedimethanol, and
the like. The preferred polyesters are polyethylene
terephthalate, polybutylene terephthalate, and
poly(l,4-cyclohexanedimethylene terephthalate) or
copolymers thereof which are manufactured in a process
utilizing a polymerization finisher. Polyethylene
terephthalate will be used hereinafter as an exemp-
lary polyester for purposes of discussing the inven-
tion.
The low viscosity, low molecular weight ,
polyester prepolymer added to the inlet end of the
finisher is made by condensing dihydroxyethyl tere-
phthalate obtained from an ester exchange reaction
between dimethyl terephthalate and ethylene glycol or
obtained from glycolysis of completely polymerized
polyester. Such condensation is discussed in U.S.
Patent No. 2,465,319. The prepolymer is usually
made to exhibit an intrinsic viscosity of about 0.1
to 0.4 which is believed to correspond to a molecular
,~
.. .. . ...
s - . - : :. ~ . -
18S~O
of about 1000 to 8000. Intrinsic viscosity is de-
termined in a solvent of 40:60, by weight, mixture
of phenol and tetrachloroethane at 30C with a
polyester concentration in grams per 100 cubic
centimeters of solution, as described in u.S~ Patent
No. 2,727,882. The intrinsic viscosity and the molec-
ular weight of polyester increase as the water and
other glycol condensation by-products are removed and
the polyester proceeds through the finisher. At the
end of the finisher, the completely polymerized poly-
ester exhibits an intrinsic viscosity of about 0.5 to
1.2 which is believed to correspond to a molecular
weight or about 10,000 to 40,000. The completely
polymerized polyester product of the reaction in the
finisher will hereinafter be termed virgin polyester.
The residence time of the polymerizing
material in the finisher of a polyester manufacturing
process is from about 2 to 4 or 5 hours; and the
scrap is added to the finisher so near to the outlet
end that the residence time for the scrap in the
finisher is only about 5 to lOor 15minutes. Finishers
usually have a pool or reservoir volume of relatively
low agitation at the end into which completely poly-
merized virgin polyester flows. By the process of
this invention, scrap polyester is introduced into the
finisher in the vicinity of the pool. It is preferred
that the scrap polyester is added to the virgin poly-
ester at substantially the same point in the finisher
along the stream as the polyester material blend is
withdrawn.
Degradation and discoloration of polyester
materials is significantly increased by exposure to
elevated temperatures. In the case of polyethylene
1118~o
terephthalate, the temperature of the stream of
material in the finisher is from about 260-300C for
prepolymer at the inlet end to about 280-310~C for
virgin polymer at the outlet end; -- the temperature
S of the polyester being a function of the vapor pres-
sure of the material undergoing polycondensation.
While the elevated temperature in the finisher is
important to completion of the polymerization, once the
polymerization is completed, the elevated temperature
only serves to promote degradation during transfer of
the polyester from the finisher. It has been found
difficult, in the past, to cool polyester by conven-
tional heat exchange methods, at the end of the fin-
isher,to decrease degradation. By adding the scrap
polyester to the outlet end of the finis~er at a
temperature which is less than the temperature of vir-
gin polymer at that point, the virgin polymer is cooled;
and, to the extent of that cooling, the tendency for
degradation is removed. Scrap polyester is generally
added to the finisher in molten form at a temperature
adequate to provide material which will flow and mix
readily with the virgin polyester. Scrap polyester is
generally added at a temperature of about 270C --
about 20C below the temperature of ~irgin polyester
at conclusion of the polymerization. A temperature
difference of as little as 2C may yield significant
improvement and a temperature difference of as much as
50C is possible; -- the temperature of polyester ma-
terial at the end of the finisher being the weighted
average o the temperature of the scrap polyester and
the virgin polyester. The process of this invention
reduces the tendency for degradation and discoloration
of the polyester material by providing a means to cool
the polyester material prior to its withdrawal from
the finisher.
The degree of cooling to be realized by in-
troduction of scrap polyester at a temperature of less
- . . . .
- 1118S~O
than the temperature of the virgin polyester, is a
function of the amount of scrap to be added to the
finisher. ~enefits of the invention are realized
whenever scrap polyester is recycled. That is to say,
practice of the invention has no lower limit for the
amount of scrap polyester to be used. It can be said
that the process is usually run with a scrap recycle
rate wherein about 20 to 50 weight percent of the
polyester material blend is scrap. It is possible,
however, to shut the supply of virgin polyester off
completely and operate with scrap polyester alone,
such as in a case where repairs must be made in the
polymerizing equipment and it is desired to maintain
pol~er flow through the extrusion die. The amount
of scrap polyester which is added to the finisher is
easily and quickly controlled and can be rapidly ad- -
justed to accommodate changes in the supply of virgin
polyester to maintain a constant supply of polyester
material blend. Scrap polyester can be supplied di-
rectly from a shaped article manufacturing line and
the scrap can be held in storage or holding bins until
it is required for use in the process of this inven-
tion.
The capacity of a finisher is limited by
residence time required for prepolymer in the finisher
at polymerization conditions. In a polymerizing sys-
tem operating at capacity,introduction of scrap up-
stream from the finisher, or even upstream in the fin-
isher, itself, reduces residence time for prepolymer.
In practice of the process of the present invention,
residence time of prepolymer is not altered and the
capacity of the polymerizing system is directly in-
creased by the amount of scrap polyester added to the
virgin polyester. A finisher operating at full capa-
city can produce 50 percent more polyester material byadding scrap polyester in the amount of 50 percent of
the original capacity.
11i8570
By introducing the scrap polyester into the
end of the finisher in accordance with the process of
this invention, the scrap polyester is subjected to a
reduced pressure of a degree adequate to cause trapped
gases to escape from the scrap polyester. Without such
exposure to reduced pressure, gases in the scrap poly-
ester would be passed on to the shaped article, when
made, and could cause deterioration or breakage of the
article. For example, in the manufacture of polyester
films, the presence of such gases would cause holes in
the film and might cause a rupture in the film web.
Complete blending of scrap polyester with -~
virgin polyester is necessary to obtain a uniform - r'~
polyester product. Addition of scrap polyester to
virgin polyester at the end of the finisher provides
adequate agitation to afford complete blending without
a separate process step.
As previously stated, it has been found that
recycling scrap polyester by glycolyzing the material
for addition to a monomer stream generates ethers
which become incorporated into the polyester and alter
the properties of the polyester material and products
made from the polyester material. The process of this
invention does not include glycolysis and does not,
25 therefore, generate ethers. ~ :
Scrap polyester is obtained from any source
of material and the scrap need not necessarily have
been previously used. Scrap can be obtained from any
shaped polyester article. Fiber or film from recycled
products can be used. The usual and preferred source
,,., ., , -: .
1118S~O
of scrap polyester is waste material fro~ fiber or
film manufacturing processes. For example, in poly-
ester film manufacture, there may be as much as fifty
percent scrap due to start up waste and edge and slit-
ting trim. Such waste and trim material can of~en beused even if the material has had surface treatments
or includes fillers or coatings. The only considera-
tion in using such treated, filled, or coated scrap
polyester is that the treated polyester or the filler
or coating material must not be present in such amount
that it would adversely affect finished product
quality.
Waste and trim material from manufacturing
processes is often immediately recycled directly into
the polymerization stream and such practice is pre-
ferred. Waste, such as polyethylene terephthalate
edge trim from a film making process, is shredded to
flake form and, if desired, compacted by conventional
means to form pellets. For best results, the flakes
or pellets are dried and then can be melted and ex-
truded at any desired or required rate into the fin-
isher in accordance with this invention. It is
preferred to dry the scrap polyester to water content
of less than about 0.05 weight percent. As has been
previously disclosed in U S. 2,503,251, polyester
flake should be dried before being mixed at any point
into the polyester polymerizing system. Such drying
reduces degradation of the polyester in later handling
steps. With the exception that the scrap polyester is
added at the end of the finisher, other elements of
the recycling process are conventional.
To obtain all of the benefits hereinabove
described and attributed to the process of this
- ~li85~0
invention, as pointed out, scrap polyester must be
added to the polyester polymerizing system at the out-
let end of the polymerizing finisher. Polymerizing
finishers re~resent the heart of extremely complex
polyester polymerizing processes; and, for successful
operation of polymerizing finishers, material streams
and process conditions must be delicately controlled.
A most surprising aspect of the present invention is
that scrap polyester can be added to virgin polyester
at the end of the finisher without upset-
ting the control and operation of the finisher.
Best Mode
As an example of preferred practice of the
process of this invention, direct recycle of scrap
polyester from polyethylene terephthalate film manu-
facture is described. Polyethylene terephthalate
prepolymer is made from about 70 weight percent di-
hydroxyethyl terephthalate and 30 weight percent gly-
colyzed polyethylene terephthalate. The prepolymer is
continuously introduced into the finisher and i5 con-
ducted through the finisher with removal of water and
ethylene glycol polycondensation by-products and
through the film extrusion die to manufacture poly-
ethylene terephthalate film. The film web edges are
trimmed and the trimmed scrap polyester is comminuted
to flakes, compacted to pellets, dried from an ini-
tial water content of from about 0.1 to 0.4 weight
percent to a final water content of from about 0.01
to 0.04 weight percent. The pelletized and dried
scrap polyester flake is conducted to and through a
melter-extruder of conventional design and through the
wall at the end of the finisher over the pool of vir-
gin polyester. Scrap polyester is added to the
1118S70
finisher and, to maintain a constant production rate,
input of prepolymer to the finisher is re~uced. Addi-
tion of scrap polyester is increased until about 20
weight percent of the extruded polyethylene terephthal-
ate film product is recycled scrap polyester. Testsof physical qualities of the film product with increas-
ing scrap polyester content, indicate no detectable
difference between film made wholly from virgin poly-
ester and film made from a blend of virgin polyester
and scrap polyester. Tests included comparative de-
terminations of qualities such as intrinsic viscosity,
color, gel content, dimensional stability and tensile
strength. In the above examples, when scrap polyester
is added at the finisher pool and the prepolymer sup-
ply is decreased an amount corresponding to the scrapadded, the pressure at which the polymerization
finisher can operate is increased by as much as one
millimeter of mercury. Because the rate of polymer-
ization is a function of the pressure in the finisher,
this increase in pressure indicates a potential in-
crease in capacity. Additional prepolymer can be
introduced into the finisher to require the pressure
to be reduced to the pressure which was necessary
before adding scrap polyester.
Similar results would be found when the
scrap polyester is added without decreasing pre-
polymer input to achieve increased production rate.
~ .
