Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
~ 165~
This invention relates to a method and apparatus fordetermining heat flux through heated wall members of heat emit-
ting equipment. ~ore particularly, the invention relates to a
method and apparatus for controlling the energy balance in a
molten salt reduction cell by determining the heat flux through
the cell walls and thereafter adjusting the energy added to the
cell to control frozen electrolytic lateral ledge thickness.
Control of heat energy may be an important considera-
tion in the proper operation of rotary kilns, furnaces and molten
salt reduction cells, for example. Heat balance control can
singly or in combination maximize rates of reaction, minimize
heat losses and stabilize operation of the device. For example,
in aluminum reduction cells, it is desirable to operate a cell
with a nearly constant frozen lateral ledge or side crust layer
for most efficient operation. Freezing and melting of the side
crust due to changes in the cell heat balance can theoretically
be kept within small limits by adjusting the cell energy input
based on crust thickness measurements. However, the side crust
;~ generally cannot be measured directly on a regular basis for all
cells.
~- It has been suggested that the thickness of the lateral
ledges of frozen electrolyte in a cell for the electrolytic
recovery of aluminum can be controlled by using the changes of
level of the anode. U.S. Patent 3,900,371, issued ~ugust 19,
1975, discloses a method of moving the anode beam to minimize a
difference between the measured instantaneous ohrnic cell resis-
tance and the base resistance. It has also been suggested that
the energy balance in an aluminum reduction cell can be con-
trolled by measuring temperature in the side cathodic lining of
the cell and comparing the measured temperature with a reference
temperature. U.S. Patent 4,045,309, issued August 30, 1977,
, . ~
~, discloses such a method whereafter the irnmersion level of the
-- 1 --
~;
,
7 2 ~
anodes is adjusted within the electrolyte. The method involves a
certain time lag which permits the method to be useful for slow
disturbances in the heat balance; however, the system will be
unable to correct faster changes.
The interrelationship of many factors of a reduction
cell are the subject of an article entitled "Variations of Side
Lining Temperature, Anode Position and Current/Voltage Load in
Aluminum Reduction Cells", by Paulsen et al, Light Metals, 1980,
which reports an investigation concerning the dynamic behavior of
the side ledge thickness and the combined data of temperature,
anode position and current/voltage to give information suited for
computer control of the cell.
Calculated and measured values of heat fluxes can be
used in determining the thickness of frozen ledges within a
molten salt reduction cell, as shown in the article entitled
"Calculating Thickness o Containing Walls Frozen from Melt", by
W. E. Haupin, Journal of Metals, July 1971. A rise in heat flux
indicates a thinning of the ledge and a lowering in heat flux
indicates a thickening of the ledge. Melting of the ledge
absorbs heat and freezing of the ledge gives up heat tendiny to
hold the electrolytic bath temperature constant. Under aggres-
sive conditions in a molten salt reduction cell, for example! it
is sometimes impractical to measure the temperature or heat flux
within a furnace or reduction cell. Measurement of heat flux
through the wall, however, appears to be more sensitive to
changes in heat balance than measurements of absolute temperature
within the electrolyte and offers an opportunity to give better
control to aluminum reduction cells. The use of heat flow trans-
ducers or sensors to measure heat passing through the walls of
the cell can aid the control of heat input and maintain a more
constant balance of the cell.
Heat flow sensors to determine heat flux, essentially
2 -
~ ~B~7~
in one dimension along the axis of a probe and thereby control
heat input into an apparatus to maintain heat balance are known.
U.S. Patent 3,267,726, issued August 23, 1966, relates to a probe
arranged on a longitudinal axis having a probe member and a
support member attached as by w~lding to the outer surface of the
wall through which the heat flux is to be determined. Arranged
in the probe are thermocouple junctions 26 and 23 which provide
the heat transfer measuring function between the hot junction 26
extending to the interior surface of the wall and the junction 23
located outside the wall. U.S. Patent 3,437,325, issued April 8,
1969, similarly discloses a control apparatus for a rotary kiln
by measuring the heat loss through walls of the kiln using
differential thermocouple locations with innermost thermocoupl~
88' and outermost thermocouple 86'.
Such heat flow sensors are more complicated than
thermocouple devices which measure temperature. U.S. Patent
3,016,412, issued January 9, 1962, discloses a thermocouple
device having an elongated tubular body 1 of refractory or high
heat resistant material such as stainless steel or Inconel having
mounted therein a pair of thermocouple lead wires forming a
bimetallic junction. U.S. Patent 3,503,260, issued ~arch 31,
1970, relates to a thermocouple pyrometer using thermocouple
leads of constantan and chromel and in which the thermocouples
can be serially connected.
What is needed, however, is a method and apparatus for
measuring heat flux from the wall of a furnace or reduction cell
which is inexpensive and less complicated than prior art devices,
yet takes advantage of the heat flux measurement as being more
sensitive to changes in heat balance than temperature in order to
give a better control of the reduction cell. The apparatus
should include an inexpensive heat flow sensor that outputs a
relatively large signal but that is very small and does not
~ 1~57.2~
interrupt or affect the heat flow from the surface being measured.
Furthermore, the apparatus should be capable of operating at
surface temperatures up to 800C and it should be able to be
quickly installed on hot wall surfaces of the cell or furnace
without the need to shut down the cell or furnace. The method
and apparatus should also have the capability of measuring
surface temperature as well as the heat flow from the wall member
being measured.
In accordance with the present invention, an automatic
control apparatus for maintaining a predetermined energy balance
in a furnace or cell comprises a relatively short and thin heat
flow sensor having a first thermocouple and a second thermocouple
located within opposite closed ends of a hollow thermally con-
ductive body. Each thermocouple is a bimetallic junction of a
first and second wire of the same dissimilar metals and is
electrically insulated from the conductive body. The first wire
of the first thermocouple and the first wire of the second
thermocouple are of the same metal and electrically connect the
junctions of the first and second thermocouples. The second wire
Of the first and second thermocouples each extends to a location
intermediate the closed ends of the body and to an instrument
responsive to the electrical potential between the first and
second thermocouples. The sensor is secured by one closed end of
the sensor body to an outside surface of the wall member to
extend substantially perpendicular to a location on the wall
without significantly affecting the heat flow from the wall
surface being measured. The instrument responsive to the elec-
tric potential measures an electrical signal generated by the
temperature difference between the first and second thermocouples
of the sensor. A means is provided for determining the heat flow
through the wall member as a function of the temperature dif-
ference and maintaining the predetermined energy balance by
-- 4
~ ~572~
adjusting the amount of energy added. The apparatus for sensing
the heat flow can be interfaced with the computer to aid control
of reduction cells, for example, by controlling the frozen ledge
thickness and result in a more stable bath ratio (NaF/AlF3) and
stable reduction cell.
A method of controlling the energy balance using the
apparatus is also provided.
Figure 1 is a schematic flow diagram of the method of
the present invention.
Figure 2 is a cross-sectional view of a portion of an
aluminum reduction cell showing a heat flow sensor of the present
invention.
Figure 3 is an enlarged partial cross-sectional view of
the sensor in Figure 2.
Figure 3a is an alternate embodiment of the sensor of
Figure 3.
Figure 4 is a calibration curve of the sensor of the
present invention.
Figure 5 is a graph of heat flux versus time for an
aluminum reduction cell including the present invention.
Figure 6 is a comparison graph of pot average standard
re8istance versus time for a line of typical aluminum reduction
cells and cells controlled by the present invention.
Generally, the method of the present invention may be
useful on kilns, furnaces and molten salt reduction cells where
heat flux measurements would provide useful data in the efficient
operation of the equipment. For purposes of brevity, the method
and apparatus of the present invention will be described with
regard to heat flux measurements on aluminum reduction cells
though numerous other applications are within the scope of the
present invention.
Generally, Figure 1 illustrates a flow chart of the
~;
;~' ~' ,: , . ,
3~ 7~
method of the present invention which includes providing a double
thermocouple heat flow sensor and electrically connecting the
sensor to measure the electrical potential between the two
thermocouples. From that measured electrical signal, the heat
flow from the reduction cell can be determined, a predetermined
energy balance can be maintained by adjusting the energy input
into the reduction cell and the thickness of the frozen elec-
trolyte lateral ledge can be controlled.
Figure 2 is a cross-sectional view of a portion of a
reduction cell 12 having a double thermocouple heat flo~ sensor
10 attached to the outer wall of the cell. Cell 12 is of a
conventional structure having an outer shell or sheathing 14,
usually steel, and an inner thermal insulation 16 between the
outer sheathing 14 and inner carbonaceous lining 18 on the sides
and bottom of the cell. When in operation, cell 12 will also
include molten aluminum 22 and electrolytic bath 24 in which a
carbonaceous anode 26 is immersed. It is also conventional to
have a frozen electrolytic lateral ledge or side crust layer 20
extending along the interior of the sides of the cell 12 defining
a cavity containing molten aluminum 22 and bath 24. Heat flow
sensor 10 is shown attached to the outer sheathing 14 of cell 12
for measuring heat flux. Sensor 10 is relatively short, thin and
thermally conductive to act as a heat radiation/convection fin
for heat to travel along the sensor for measuring heat flux
without significantly affecting the heat flow from the wall
surface being measured.
Figure 3 is an enlarged cross-sectional view of Figure 2
illustrating the structure of heat flow sensor 10 of the present
invention for measuring heat flow (shown by the arrows) from cell
3~ 12. Heat flow sensor 10 is shown including a close-ended hollow
thermally conductive body 30 having therein a first thermocouple
36 at closed end 32 of sensor 10 and a second thermocouple 38 at
-- 6 --
.
7 ~ ~3
closed end 34 at the opposite end of sensor 10. Body 30 can be
made of any of v~rious materials to provide sufficient rigidity
to protect the thermocouples contained therein, as long as lt is
made of a thermally conductive material, s~ch as stainless steel
or Inconel. Body 30 may be a one-piece tubular body or may be
made from two or more tubular portions secured together. Figure 3
illustrates sensor 10 preferably made from two separate tubular
members.
In an alternative embodiment of Figure 3a, body 30 of
sensor 10 is shown to be of one-piece tubular construction having
an access opening intermediate the closed ends for electrically
connecting the thermocouples. Such a one-piece body may be an
advantageous sensor configuration provided the economics and
techniques of fabricating are desirable.
Sensor 10 preferably includes a generally elongated
body 30 which can be attached or secured to an outside surface of
the wall member of the reduction cell by one closed end 32 or 34
of the sensor body 30 which extends substantially perpendicular
to a location on the wall. Sensor 10 may be secured by welding,
preferably by capacitor discharge welding which permits quick and
efficient attachment of sensor 10 to the outside wall of reduc-
tion cell 12 even while the cell is in operation. It is important
that weld 28 securing sensor 10 to sheathing 14 be small in cross
section such as not to significantly affect the heat flow from
the wall surface being measured at the point of attachment.
The overall size of sensor 10 is a critical feature of
the present invention. The sensor must be relatively short and
thin to minimize erroneous effects that could be caused by
ambient air movement and temperature of the air surrounding the
aluminum reduction cell. Sensor 10 may be less than 3 inches but
more than 1 inch in length. The cross-sectional dimension, width
or diameter, should be less than 1/4 inch but can be as small as
7 ~ ~
is practically possible to make. Preferably, the sensor ranges
from 1-1/2 to 2-1/2 inches long with a most preferred length of
about 2 inches and a width on the order of 1/16 inch in diameter.
If the length of the sensor is too short, then there will be an
insufficient temperature difference between the first and second
thermocouples 36 and 38 within sensor 10 such that the electrical
signal output may be more difficult to measure.
Development work established the criticality of the
length as a result of numerous tests of sensors of varying
1~ length. Sensor 10 of Figure 3 having about a 1/16 inch diameter
was tested on the sides and bottoms of various aluminum reduction
cell pots and calibrated for measuring heat flux. It was found
that the length of about 2 inches unexpectedly provided a sensor
that produced an electrical signal that was a function only of
the position of the surface (i.e. vertical or horizontal~ being
measured and the heat flux from the surface. No correction or
calibration was required for surface temperature, ambient tem-
perature or varying air currents. The calibration curves are
shown in Figure 4 and will be discussed below.
Sensor 10 includes a first thermocouple located within
body 30 adjacent closed end 3Z of sensor 10. As shown in Figure 3,
first thermocouple 36 is the hot junction thermocouple whereas
second thermocoupla 38 located within body 30 adjacent closed end
34 is the cold junction thermocouple. Each thermocouple is a
bimetallic junction formed by two electrically conducting wires
40 and 42. First thermocouple and second thermocouple are each
comprised of two wires 40 and 42 of the same dissimilar metals.
Wires 40 and 42 may be made of any of various metals having
different thermoelectric potential properties. Some conventional
3Q thermocouple materials are copper, alumel, iron, constantan and
chromeI. Preferably chromel and constantan wire may be used in
order to reduce oxidation of lead wires from sensor 10 to
-- 8 --
recording instruments and because such wire materials generate a
relatively high electromotive force (EMF) signal. It does not
appear significant which material is used for wire 40 and which
is used for wire 42 as long as each wire is eIectrically con-
nected to responsive instruments by wire of the same material.
The thermocouples 36 and 38 located within body 30 of
sensor 10 are electrically connected together. AS shown in
Figure 3, first wire, wire 42, of first thermocouple 36 is
electrically connected with wire 42 of the same metal of second
thermocouple 38 at a location intermediate the closed ends 32 and
34 of sensor body 30. Wire 42 of each thermocouple may be
electrically connected within body 30 or wires 42 may exit body
30 through an opening or openings at a location intermediate
closed ends 32 and 34, as shown in Figure 3. A single wire which
also acts as the first wire, wire 42, of each thermocouple 36 and
38 in sensor 10 may be used to electrically connect the junctions
of thermocouple~ 36 and 38, as shown in Figure 3a. It is also
shown in Figure 3 that each second wire, wire 40, of first
thermocouple 36 and second thermocouple 38 extends out of sensor
body 30 at a location intermediate the closed ends 32 and 34 of
sensor body 30. In the alternative, wire 40 of each thermocouple
may terminate within body 30 at a location intermediate the
closed ends without extending out of sensor body 30. Inter-
mediate location means a location between closed ends 32 and 34
and preferably about half way between ends 32 and 34.
It has been found that connecting electrical leads to
first and second thermocouples 36 and 38 at a location inter-
mediate the ends provides a sensor that can be calibrated with no
significant variation in output between individual sensors.
Development experience taught that eLectrically connecting the
; first and second thermocouples adjacent the cold junction end of
the sensor resulted in each individual sensor having a peculiar
_ g _
1 1657.2fi
calibration curve. There was little or no repeatability between
individual sensors. Sensor 10 of the present invention, however,
has overcome those problems.
Preferably, heat flow sensor 10 of the present inven-
tion is arranged with the electrical connections between thermo-
couples 36 and 38 of sensor 10 at locations intermediate the
closed ends of body 30. Such an arrangement facilitates body 30
and its contents to act as a heat radiation/convection fin so
that heat from the reduction cell can travel along the tube and
the contents with little impediment. Heat flow sensors made in
accordance with the present invention provide dependable results
with the output of the cold ~unction thermocouple 38 that can be
duplicated in order to achieve the same EMF output for each
sensor.
Thermocouples 36 and 38 are electrically insulated from
thermally conductive body 30 by any of various conventional
refractory materials. Preferably, magnesium oxide (MgO) has
provided good results. Furthermore, where wires 40 and 42 extend
out of conductive body 30 of sensor 10, a conventional refractory
cement material 50, such as sauereisen cement, may be used to
insulate thermocouple wires 40 and 42 and to securely attach the
wires to sensor 10 to prevent accidental detachment. Figure 3
illustrates second wire 40 of first thermocouple 36 electrically
connected to wire 46A and second wire 40 of second thermocouple
38 electrically connected to wire 46B. Connection to wires 46A
and 46B may be made inside sensor body 30 or outside as shown in
Figure 3. As further shown in Figure 3, wires 40 from each
thermocouple may be connected to lead wires 46A and 46B, made of
the same material as wires 40. Wires 46A and 46~ are electri-
cally connected by a plug 52 into an instrument 54 responsive tothe electrical potential between the first thermocouple 36 and
second thermocouple 38. The measured signal in instrument 54 can
-- 10 --
7.2 ~
then be used to determine the heat flow through the cell wall as
a function of the temperature difference and be used to maintain
the energy balance of the cell.
It has been found that sensor 10 of the present inven-
tion generally can produce more than 10 millivolts and generally
between 15 to 20 millivolts output when attached to the side of
an aluminum reduction cell 12. Preferably, when heat flow sensor
10 is located along the sides of the cell, it is below the level
or interface of molten aluminum 22 and electrolytic bath 24.
Preferably, sensor 10 located on the side of a cell 12 is at a
level which nearly always is opposite molten metal in the cell
even after tapping out some metal. Such a location may be about
2 inches below the minimum molten aluminum height in cell 12.
Furthermore, a plurality of sensors 10 can be located at the same
level about the perimeter of cell 12 with sensors 10 connected in
series. Serially connecting sensors 10 will result in a summing
of the EMF output of each sensor. A resultant average signal can
be provided from the summing if desired. An advantage to such
series connections would result in a larger signal which would be
easier to measure and thus provide a further means to minimize
any fluctuations in heat flux measurements. Sensors 10 can be
serially connected by electrically connecting each sensor by
wires 46A and 46B so that only one lead wire 46A, 46B and plug 52
would be connected to recording instrument 54.
; Calibration of sensor 10 provides for conversion of
; the millivolt signal generated by the sensor to heat flux in
watts/ft.2. For example, the sensor 10 was calibrated for
locations on the horizontal top and bottom and vertical side of a
heat source device giving results as shown in Figure 4. Sensor
10, which was 2 inches long and 1/16 inch in diameter, illus-
trates a calibration from 20 watts/ft.2 to about 1500 watts/ft.2
as a function of the surface position measured and heat flux.
7 ~ ~
The curves, which are developed by computer analysis, below about
400 watts/ft.2 generally follow a quadratic equation and above
about 400 watts/ft.2, the curves are linear. The curves show
that sensor 10 provides more than a one millivolt output at 40
watts/ft.2 and more than 20 millivolts at 1500 watts/ft.2.
The apparatus of the present invention also facilitates
measurement of the temperature at either the hot or cold junction
of sensor 10 in addition to heat flux. A third wire 56 made of
the same material as wires 42 of first and second thermocouples
36 and 38, respectively, can be connected to wires 42, such as at
a point 44 intermediate the closed ends of body 30. A fourth
wire 57 made of the same material as wires 40 can be electrically
connected to wire 40 of either thermocouple 36 or 38, respec-
tively, by either wires 46A or 46B. Wires 56 and 57 may be
electrically connected to a temperature recording instrument 58.
The effect is to electrically connect first wire 42 of a thermo-
couple by third wire 56 and second wire 40 of the same thermo-
couple by fourth wire 57 to instrument 53. The combination 56-
46A will give the hot junction temperature at shell 14. The
combination 56-46B will give the cold junction temperature.
To use the apparatus and method of the present
invention, heat flow sensor 10 can be a preassembled unit having
first and second thermocouples 36 and 38 arranged within hollow
body 30 and electrically insulated from body 30. The particular
configuration of body 30, such as shown in Figures 3 and 3a, and
other configurations depend on manufacturing capabilities however.
At a predetermined location on the sides and perimeter of an
aluminum reduction cell, sensors 10 can be attached to the outer
steel sheathing 14 such as by capacitor discharge ~elding. The
3Q outer surface temperature of the sheathing 14 may range up to
800C and the heat flow sensors lQ of the present invention are
operable up to that temperature. Sensors 10 can then be
- 12 -
electrically connected either individually or in serles to a
recording instrument 54 responsive to the electrical potential
generated by the temperature difference between first and second
thermocouples 36 and 38 of a heat sensor lO.
The temperature difference which produces an electrical
signal can be used to determine the heat flow through the cell
wall as a result of calibration of the sensor outputs. Such
calibration can convert temperature differences directly to heat
flux in BTU/hr.-ft.2 or watts/ft.2. A computer can be used to
convert the sensor outputs through calibration equations. AS a
result of determining the rate of heat flow, the predetermined
energy balance of the aluminum reduction cell can be maintained
by adjusting the amount of energy added to the cell depending
upon the increase or decrease in the heat flux measured at the
cell wall. A rise in heat flux indicates a thinning of the
frozen electrolyte ledge and a decrease in the heat flux indi-
cates a thickening of the ledge 20. In other words, if the cell
is fed more energy than it radiates, the frozen ledge 20 will
melt, while the opposite will be the case if the energy balance
is negative.
The electric signals from the heat flow sensors 10 can
be connected through recording instruments 54 and 58 to a computer
to aid in controlling the energy balance of a reduction cell 12.
Such control has provided encouraging results. AS seen from
Figure 5, a graph of heat flux in watts/ft.2 versus time, the
bath-metal interface heat flux has been lowered anywhere from 16
to 18%. Furthermore, the average standard control resistance on
several pots, as shown in Figure 6 in a graph of pot standard
resistance in ohms versus time, has been lowered anywhere from 3
to 4~ when compared to the average standard control resistance of
the remaining pots not equipped with the present invention.
These results indicate that the frozen ledge 20 on the cell can
- 13 -
be controlled and maintained at a thickness which will in turn
stabilize bath ratio ~NaF/AlF3), cavity size in the pots and
metal depths in the reduction cell.
Though heat flow sensors 10 have been described as
being secured to the sides of aluminum reduction cells 12, the
sensors may be located in other areas not affected by the frozen
electrolytic ledge 20, such as on the bottom of the cell for
purposes other than pot control, for example, to evaluate insula-
tion deterioration.
The present invention thus provides a method and
apparatus which can reduce energy consumption in aluminum reduc-
tion cells and other devices such as furnaces and rotary kilns
where heat flux measurements can be useful for controlled effi-
ciency. The apparatus of the present invention can be easily
installed on existing equipment and is operable up to relatively
high temperatures of 800~C. The apparatus of the present inven-
tion is much lower in cost than heat flow sensors of the prior
art to produce a relatively large output signal which permits the
use of the more sensitive heat flux measurements to control
cells.
Various modifications may be made in the invention
without departing from the spirit thereof or the scope of the
claims, and, therefore, the exact form shown is to be taken as
illustrative only and not in a limiting sense, and lt is desired
that only such limitations shall be placed thereon as are imposed
by the prior art or are specifically set forth in the appended
claims.
- 14 -
