Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
1339880
038-164A
PRECIPITATED ENCAPSULATED PAPER PIGMENTS AND METHODS
Technical Field
This invention relates to novel composite paper
pigments and methods for their preparation, and more
particularly relates to paper pigments useful as
fillers and comprising a mineral nucleus coated with a
substantially continuous uniform layer of a material
which functions as a paper pigment.
Backqround Art
It is well known in the art to use various types
of minerals as paper coating and filler pigments. In
particular, sodium aluminosilicates are well known as
paper fillers, as are various forms of clay such as
kaolin. It is also known in the art to modify minerals
by application of surface coatings of various inorganic
compositions. Thus, U. S. Patent 3,849,149 to Swift et
al, 1974, discloses a method of modifying the surface
properties of particulate mineral materials by forming
on the surface of the particles a coating which has a
significant number of acidic sites. According to this
patent, the surface of certain natural aluminosilicate
2 1339883
minerals including kaolin and bentonite can be modified
to give an enhanced acidic reaction by a procedure
involving heat treatment. This patent also discloses
that the surfaces of such clay mineral particles can be
provided with acidic coatings to achieve reproducibly a
variety of acidic surfaces. This patent discloses a
pigment or filler material consisting of a particulate
mineral such as kaolin or bentonite having a surface
coating which has a significant number of acidic sites
which have PKA values of less than 2.8. A main object
of this patent is to place the acidic surface coatings
on the mineral so that additional coatings of organic
materials such as silanes can be applied to the
mineral.
U. S. Patents 4,026,721, 4,072,537, and 4,117,1gl
to Kurrle, disclose a composite silicate pigment for
use in paper prepared by a precipitation reaction
wherein spherical, hydrous metal silicate particles are
precipitated on the planar surfaces of clay particles
which have a platelet type structure. This composite
pigment in the specific embo~iment of these patents is
a kaolin clay component having a platelet type
structure with a planar surface and having a metal
silicate component in the form of spherical particles
of an alkaline earth metal silicate precipitated on the
planar surfaces of the clay platelets. According to
this patent, when incorporated into paper, the metal
silicate particles act as spacers between individual
clay particles to create additional air interfaces on
sheet drying.
In published PCT Application No. WO 87/07884,
published December 30, 1987, of this assignee, there
are disclosed compositions which may be used as paper
pigments which comprise reaction products of kaolin
3 1~3~8
with an alkali metal silicate or similar reactant. In
these compositions, there is produced an altered kaolin
nucleus which has a rim, edge or border which comprises
the reaction product of the kaolin and the alkali metal
silicate or similar reactant. Thus this product is not
a composite pigment but rather is the reaction product
of the kaolin with the alkali metal silicate or similar
reactant.
The present invention provides an improved coated
mineral pigment which is useful as a paper pigment,
coating pigment and filler which is distinct from these
prior art compositions.
Disclosure of the Invention
It is accordingly one object of the present
invention to provide a novel mineral pigment useful as
a paper pigment.
A further object of the invention is to provide a
paper pigment comprising a precipitated, encapsulated
composite product which contains a substantially inert
mineral nucleus contA;ning a substantially uniform
coating of an active paper pigment.
An even further object of the present invention is
to provide a precipitated, encapsulated composite
product useful as a paper pigment and as a filler
which comprises a mineral nucleus having coated thereon
a substantially continuous substantially uniform layer
of a silicate reaction product or equivalent.
Also provided by the present invention is a novel
process for preparation of the composite products of
the invention.
Other objects and advantages of the present
invention will become apparent as the description
thereof proceeds.
4 ~33'~8~0
In satisfaction of the foregoing objects and
advantages there is provided by this invention a
precipitated, encapsulated composite product comprising a
mineral nucleus substantially coated with a layer of
substantially continuous uniform coating of an active paper
pigment. More particularly there is provided a composite
product comprising a mineral nucleus selected from the
group consisting of leached clays, talcs, micas,
serpertinite, montmorillonites, hydrated alumina, calcium
carbonate, magnesium carbonate, ground limestone,
diatomaceous earth, and mixtures thereof, coated with a
substantially continuous substantially uniform coating of
an active paper pigment.
The present invention also provides a method for
production of this composite product by formation of the
active paper pigment coating in situ in the presence of the
substantially inert mineral nucleus, the reaction being
carried out under alkaline conditions.
The present invention also provides a paper containing
a filler pigment which comprises a composite product
comprising a mineral nucleus coated with a layer of a
substantially continuous uniform coating of an active paper
pigment.
Brief Description of Drawings
Reference is now made to the drawings accompanying the
application wherein:
Figure 1 is an SEM photomicrograph magnified 10,000
times of a milled product produced according to a specific
embodiment of the invention;
Figure 2 is an SEM photomicrograph magnified 10,000
times of a commercial kaolin clay product, Hydrasperse~
which can be used as a starting material in preparation of
the products of the invention;
Figure 3 is a physical mixture of an active commercial
modified alkali metal alumino silicate paper pigment, and
the Hydrasperse~ kaolin clay of Figure 2 magnified 10,000
times;
s ~33~883
Figure 4 is a process flow diagram for preparation
of a product according to a specific embodiment of the
invention;
Figures 5A-SI are SEM photomicrographs at lO,OOOX
magnification showing a timed sequence of the
appearance of products of a specific embodiment
according to the present invention;
Figures 6A-6C are SEM photomicrographs of products
produced according to Example 1 of Kurrle U. S. Patent
No. 4,026,721;
Figures 7A-7C are SEM photomicrographs at lO,OOOX
magnification of products produced according to Example
2 of Kurrle U. S. Patent 4,026,721;
Figure 8 is a paper performance comparison of the
lS product of Example 1 of U. S. Patent 4,026,721 of
Kurrle compared to the product of the present
invention; and
Figure 9 is a paper performance comparison of an
alumina analog of a product of U. S. Patent 4,026,721
of Kurrle, Example 1.
Best Mode for CarrYinq out the Invention
The product of this invention is a precipitated,
encapsulated composite product which comprises a
mineral nucleus or core which is coated or encapsulated
with a substantially continuous substantially uniform
layer of an active paper pigment. The coating is
substantially uniform and encases at least about 80%
and preferably up to 100% of the mineral nucleus. The
thickness of the coating may range from about 0.3
microns to about 1.0 microns.
In this invention the term "active paper pigment~'
means any material which will enhance the
characteristics of paper when incorporated therein. By
6 1~3~,~80
this is meant that the active paper pigment will
increase the opacity, sheet brightness and/or optical
performance of paper by standard methods of
measurement. In general, such active paper pigments
include metal silicates, precipitated silicas, alkali
metal aluminocarbonates, and the like as better
described hereinafter.
The composite products of the present invention
provide paper enhancement characteristics equivalent to
or better than conventional paper pigments even though
the major portion of the product is not a paper
pigment. Thus, the composite product of the invention
achieves all the advantages of an active paper pigment
at substantially lower cost because a substantial
portion of the product is a material not conventionally
used as a paper pigment.
The products of the present invention exhibit an
unexpected increase in performance as paper fillers and
paper coatings over- the average performance which one
would expect from the individual components or a
physical blend. Thus, it has been found that the TAPPI
opacity is increased over comparative measurements for
either the mineral nucleus or the active paper pigment
measured under the same conditions. Similarly,
brightness of paper is increased by the product of the
present invention as compared with the mineral nucleus.
Moreover, the product of the present invention exhibits
improved values over a physical blend of the mineral
nucleus and the active paper pigment.
On a weight basis, the product of the present
invention will contain from about 10% to about 90% of
the active paper pigment to about 90% to 10~ of the
mineral nucleus. With respect to opacity, the
preferred amount of active paper pigment contained in
1~3~80
the composition should range from about 25 to 75% by
weight with the mineral nucleus comprising from about
75 to 25% by weight. With respect to brightness, it is
preferred that the active paper pigment comprise from
about 75 to 95% by weight with the amount of mineral
nucleus comprising from about 5% to 25% by weight.
The product of the present invention may be
prepared by any procedure which will produce a paper
pigment having good characteristics in which a mineral
nucleus is substantially encased within a substantially
uniform layer of an active paper pigment. However,
according to the present invention, it has been found
that for best results, the product should be prepared
under alkaline conditions and the active paper pigment
under in situ conditions in the presence of the mineral
nucleus. A particularly preferred method of
preparation is to provide an agitated reactor and
prepare the product under batch conditions. Under such
procedures, the reactants required for forming the
product are preferably added simultaneously to the
agitated reactor over a short period of time. It is
generally preferred to initially begin addition of the
reactants necessary to form the active paper pigment
until formation of the active paper pigment actually
2S begins. At that point, a slurry of the mineral nucleus
material is added to the agitated reactor either all at
once or slowly. Thereafter, the r~m~;n;ng reactants
are continued to be added under alkaline conditions
until all reactants are added and the reaction is
completed. The resulting composite product is then
recovered, preferably washed to remove impurities such
as soluble salts and the product recovered. Milling of
the product and possibly spray drying may also be
carried out to form the final product.
8 1~8~0
In this reaction for preparation of the product,
it is preferred to conduct the_ reaction so as to
provide a steady and gradual increase in reaction pH
until the reaction is completed. The reaction in the
presence of the mineral nucleus is usually operated at
a pH of above 7.0 and preferably at a pH in the range
of about 8.0 to 9Ø The final pH for the reactions
may range from 5.0 to 10.0, depending on the reaction
and use of the final product. The temperature of the
reaction preferably ranges from about 40~C to 100~C and
more preferably from about 50~C to 75~C~ The reaction
is carried out under batch conditions, usually at
atmospheric pressure.
In formation of the products of the present
invention, the preferred mineral nucleus is
substantially inert and is a mineral including kaolins,
kaolinites, talcs, micas, serpertinite, mont-
morillonites, or acid leached minerals such as clays or
bauxite. A commercially available acid leached clay is
J Essellar~, from J. M. Huber Corporation. Other mineral
nuclei which may be used include hydrated alumina,
precipitated calcium carbonate (PCC), ultrafine ground
limestone (UFGL), magnesium carbonate, and diatomaceous
earths. Obviously equivalent materials and mixtures of
these materials may also bè used in the invention.
The coating to be applied to the mineral may
comprise any active paper pigment which is operable in
accordance with the process of the invention and which
will form a substantially uniform and continuous
coating so as to substantially encapsulate the mineral.
The active paper pigment is preferably a metal silicate
including synthetic alkali metal silicates, synthetic
alkali metal aluminosilicates, synthetic alkaline
earth metal silicates, synthetic alkaline earth metal
9 ~33~;3~
aluminosilicates, and mixtures thereof. Other active
paper pigments which may be used are precipitated
silicas, alkaline earth aluminocarbonates, and mixtures
thereof.
Within these groups of reactants, certain
combinations are particularly useful and the following
Table 1 shows a matrix of illustrations of useful and
preferred combinations within the scope of the
invention.
~33~3
,
. ** ."~****
_ a
~ c,
..,
u
a
~
U7
a~
~r
t)
__
u~
al
._
r r
._
A
. _1 . ~
al
X ~ ,~
,, ~ a t~
C7
O U
U * lt * . .
S p,~
._~
7 ,~
~
G
~ . . . *
u
r
~ ~ . .
as I
U 5 0
a ~~
~ r
U
'~7 G7 c,
uJ O
-- r a ~:
aJ ~ U ~
13~9~~
11
A particularly preferred embodiment of the invention
includes kaolinite mineral nuclei with synthetic alkali
metal silicates and synthetic alkali metal aluminosilicates
being coated thereon. Preferred kaolinite nuclei for use
in the invention are the clays sold commercially by the
J.M. Huber Corporation under the tradename Hydragloss~ and
Hydrasperse~.
A particularly preferred coating material is a
modified precipitated aluminosilicate pigment such as
described in U.S. Patents 3,798,046, 3,909,286 and its
reissue RE 30,568, all to Robert C. Fitton, and assigned to
the same assignee as the application. The pigments
disclosed in these patents are alkaline earth modified
alkali metal aluminosilicate pigments. These pigments are
produced by introducing dilute solutions of an alkali metal
silicate and a water soluble salt of aluminum and a strong
acid, such as aluminum sulfate, into an aqueous reaction
media containing dispersed therein an alkaline earth metal
salt or hydroxide. When solutions of the alkali metal
silicate and aluminum sulfate are added to the reaction
mass which contains the alkaline earth metal salt or
hydroxide, the latter serves as a nucleus or nucleating
agent which alters the structure of the resulting modified
pigment. Thus, when this pigment serves as a coating on
the mineral in the present invention, the nucleus or
mineral core will comprise an alkaline earth metal salt or
hydroxide having coated thereon the reaction product of the
alkali metal silicate and aluminum sulfate.
The preferred pigments described herein are finely
divided precipitated white powdery compositions which
comprise chemically bound oxides of magnesium, sodium,
12 13~ g 883
aluminum and silicon in a uniform matrix, substantially
all of the discreet particles of which are less than
one micron in diameter. The molar ratio of SiO2 to
Na2O is about 10.0 to 13.0:1 and the molar ratio of
Na2O to A12O3 is from about 0.3 to 1.0:1. The alkaline
earth metal oxide is present in an amount of from about
0.1 to 8~ based on the dry weight of the composition
having a specific gravity of 2.0 to 2.4. The preferred
silicate of this patent includes magnesium as an
alkaline earth metal and sodium as the alkali metal.
A particularly preferred method for practicing the
process of the present invention is set forth in the
process flow diagram of Figure 4. This flow diagram
illustrates the preferred embodiment wherein the
mineral is kaolinite and the coating is a sodium
magnesium aluminosilicate product of the type described
in Fitton Reissue Patent 30,568. In this process,
aqueous reaction media of sodium silicate, aluminum
sulfate or alum and magnesium hydroxide are prepared
and placed in reactors 1, 2 and 3, respectively as
shown. A slurry of kaolinite or kaolin is provided in
reactor 4. Agitated reactor 5 is provided which is
maintained under good conditions of agitation. The
magnesium hydroxide reaction medium is added to the
reactor and a small amount of the aluminum sulfate
solution is then added to the magnesium hydroxide. At
this point, the r~;ning aluminum sulfate and sodium
silicate solutions are continued to be added
simultaneously at temperatures generally in the range
of about 50-100~C, preferably 60~C, while maintaining
the slow addition rate with good agitation. At this
point the slurry of kaolin is added while maint~i n ing
sufficient agitation to suspend the kaolin particles
and while continuing the simultaneous addition of the
13 1~3!3~0
aluminum sulfate and sodium silicate. The total time
for addition of the kaolin slurry is usually less than
about ten minutes on a batch basis. After the kaolin
is added, the remaining silicate and aluminum sulfate
solutions are continued to be added for a period of
time ranging from 20 minutes to 1 hour. Thereafter the
addition of the aluminum sulfate is discontinued and
the reaction slurry is stirred until the
precipitation/encapsulation reaction is complete. The
pH is then adjusted to the range of about 8.0 to 10.0
by addition of excess sodium silicate solution for this
reaction. The resulting slurry is then passed to
filter 7 from which the product is removed by line 8 to
dispersion mill 9 for grinding to a desired particle
size. The product may then be recovered at line 10.
Optionally, where additional drying is desired, the
product is passed by line 11 to drier 12 from which the
dried product is recovered at 13.
It is of course to be understood that any reaction
procedure can be used if sufficient reaction time is
provided for the paper pigment reactant to form the
generally uniform coating on the mineral nucleus. For
example the magnesium hydroxide and kaolin slurry could
be provided in the reactor to which aluminum sulfate is
added with agitation. Thereafter the sodium silicate
solution can be added simultaneously with aluminum
sulfate solution in sufficient rates to provide a
gradual increase in pH during precipitation.
Thereafter the pH of the reaction slurry is adjusted to
the desired range.
The following examples are presented to illustrate
the invention but it is not to be considered as limited
thereto. In the Examples and throughout the
14 ~98~0
specification, parts are by weight unless otherwise
indicated.
Example 1
A batch of pigment is prepared by adding to 1020g
of H2O at 60~C, 248.40g of clay slurry contAin;ng
69.79% kaolin and sufficient Mg(OH)2 slurry to provide
0.53% Mg(OH)2 in the total aqueous slurry. To this
slurry, clarified alum is added with agitation to yield
a concentration of 0.75% Al2(SO4)3. To this slurry,
831.6g of sodium silicate solution containing 8.69%
Na2O and 22.39% SiO2 is added simultaneously with
349.35g of alum solution contA;n;ng 28.33% Al2(SO4)3.
Rates of addition are adjusted to provide a gradual
increase in pH during the precipitation. Sufficient
agitation to suspend the kaolin particles is
maintained. The final reaction slurry is adjusted to
9.2 pH. The pigment is recovered by filtration,
washed, and dispersed to form a pigment slurry. The
slurry may, depending on the specific application, be
dried and milled. A finely divided pigment results.
Example 2
A batch is produced by preparing 1031.41g of an
aqueous reaction medium containing 0.65% Mg(OH)2.
Clarified alum is added slowly with agitation to yield
a concentration of 0.92% Al2(SO4)3 at 60~C. At this
point, simultaneous addition of alum and sodium
silicate containing 28.33% Al2(SO4)3 at 60~C and
containing 8.69% Na2O and 22.39% SiO2, at 60 C,
respectively is started and continued at a slow rate
while maintaining good agitation for 6.5 minutes. At
this point, the addition of 154.20g of a slurry of clay
contAin;ng 69.70% kaolin is started while maint~;n;ng
~L3~39~
sufficient agitation to suspend the kaolin particles
and continuing simultaneous addition of alum and sodium
silicate. Total clay addition requires preferably less
than 5 minutes. Additions of silicate and alum
solution are continued for a total of 35 minutes. The
addition of alum is discontinued and the reaction
slurry brought to 9.2 pH with excess sodium silicate
solution. The pigment is recovered and washed to
remove soluble salts. The washed pigment slurry is
adjusted to pH of 8.0 with alum containing 28.33%
A12(SO4)3. The pigment slurry is milled to produce
finely dispersed particles before being dried and
milled. This product is useful either in dry or in
slurry form depending on the specific application.
ExamPle 3
Rather than producing the expected paper optional
performance, samples of pigments prepared by the method
of Example 2 exhibit an unexpected boost in performance
over the weighted average performance of the individual
components or the physical blend. Table 2 following
illustrates the performance advantage gained from
pigments of this invention. In Table 2 the effect of
the level of kaolin present in the pigment on paper
optical properties is illustrated. In Table 2 the
paper optical performance is presented as determined by
actual tests and based on a calculated performance.
The pigment composition obtained according to the
method of Example 2 contained 70% of the sodium
magnesium aluminosilicate formed as a precipitate and
30% of kaolin nucleus. The pigments were evaluated in
paper with respect to TAPPI opacity and with respect to
ISO brightness. The table sets forth the actual
performance for both opacity and brightness at low
16 1~3~883
levels of 3% and 6~ and compares actual performance,
calculated performance, and the performance of a
physical blend of the kaolin and the sodium magnesium
alumino pigment or precipitate. Note that the
calculated performance includes the performance for the
reaction product as well as for each of the individual
components, kaolin and precipitate.
TABLE 2
Paper Optical Performance
Actual vs Calculated
Pigment composition of 70% precipitate and 30% Kaolin
TAPPI Opacity ISO Briyh~.ess
Piqment3% filler 6% filler 3% filler 6% filler
Actual ~LLq~ 84.1 86.9 86.3 87.2
~A1~11 Ated ~L~r~ ~ 82.9 85.6 86.1 87.0
(70/30)
100% Kao~n 81.0 84.0 84.4 83.9
100% Precipitate 83.7 86.3 86.8 88.3
Physical Blend (70/30) 83.0 85.6 86.5 87.3
In the following Table 3, the effect of the level
of kaolin nucleus present in the pigment on paper
optical properties is illustrated. In this work, the
procedure of Example 2 was used while varying the
amount of kaolin as the mineral nucleus and the amount
of coating or active paper pigment being formed. From
the table it will be seen that the pigment composition
contains precipitate and kaolin ranging from 0% to 100%
;~ 3~8~
in increments of 25. Thereafter optical performance of
the pigments was evaluated by preparing handsheets
using accepted st~n~rd TAPPI methods. In all cases
samples of pigments were added as slurries to a
st~n~rd pulp blend to yield the single filler fine
paper furnish. Handsheets were evaluated using
standard ISO methods (2469, 2470, 2471, and 3680) for
determining paper opacity (calculated TAPPI) and
brightness (ISO). Optical properties were measured
using a Technidyne, Technibright TB-lC. In this table
it will be seen that the preferred products with
respect to opacity will contain at least about 25% of
the precipitate and from about 25-75% of the kaolin
nucleus. With respect to brightness, greater amounts
of the precipitate appear to increase the brightness
values. The table indicates that 6% filler amounts
using at least 50% of the paper active pigment or
precipitate provides the excellent brightness values.
Table 3 is as follows:
~ 13S3~80
18
TABLE 3
Paper Optical Performance vs Pigment Composition
Pigment C~cition TAPPI Opacity ISO Rri~J~ e~
% %
Precipitate Kaolin 3% filler 6% filler 3% filler 6% filler
0 100 81.0 84.0 84.4 83.9
82.4 85.3 85.1 85.3
83.8 86.5 85.8 86.6
84.2 87.0 86.3 87.2
100 0 83.7 86.3 86.8 88.3
Note: Pigment ~ ~1 usingl)~c~~ t1in~ in F~ le 2.
The increase in performance realized by use of the
product of the invention is a result of improved light
scattering capability of the pigment. It appears to be
superior to other pigments which are commonly used as
fillers in paper. In thè following Table 4 are set
forth pigment scattering coefficients for various
combinations of the composite pigment of this invention
using from 50% to 80% of the active paper pigment in
combination with from 20% to 50% of a kaolin nuclei of
a product of the type prepared in Example 2.
Comparisons of the scattering coefficient values were
made for each of these combinations and compared with
the same scattering coefficient values for a calcined
clay and a precipitated sodium aluminosilicate. The
~3539~80
19
scattering coefficient data were calculated using the
appropriate Kubelka-Munk equations. The data is
reported for a loading level of 6% filler.
As may be seen from Table 4, all values of the
product of the invention are substantially improved
over calcined clay or precipitated silicate and
particularly excellent values are shown in products
which contain up to 70 to 80% of the active paper
pigment in combination with 20-30% of the kaolin
nucleus. Table 4 is as follows.
TABLE 4
Pigment Scattering Coefficient
Pigment Composition Scattering Coefficient
% Precipitate% Xaolin @8% filler S, cm
2657
2779
2903
3004
calcined clay - 2343
precipitated silicate - 2572
Example 4
In this Example, the process of Example 2 is
repeated except that in this procedure, ScAnning
Electron Micrographs (SEM) of the product were made at
various steps of the reaction in order to show
development of the product. These SEM photographs are
shown in the attached Figures 5A, 5B, 5C, 5D, 5E, 5F,
5G, 5H and 5I. All of the SEM photographs were taken
at lO,OOOX magnification.
~39,~
With reference to Figures 5A and 5B, it will be
seen that in Figures 5A and 5B, at 10 and 14 minutes
into the reaction, the modified alkali metal
aluminosilicate material is forming as a product prior
to addition of any of the kaolin. The kaolin slurry is
added 15 minutes into the reaction. Figure 5C at 16
minutes shows the mixture of uncoated kaolin particles
and the formed modified alkali metal aluminosilicate.
Figures 5D, 5E, 5F, 5G, 5H and 5I show formation of the
products continuing at 20 minutes, 25 minutes, 30
minutes, 35 minutes, 40 minutes and 43.5 minutes,
respectively. The photomicrograph of Figure 1 shows
the final product after precipitation is complete.
From this series of timed photographs, it will be
seen that the modified alkali metal aluminosilicate
product is initially formed and then precipitates onto
the surfaces of the kaolin platelets or particles.
Example 5
In order to assess the characteristics of the
product produced by Example 2, a comparison was made
using SEM photographs of the mineral nucleus, a kaolin
clay particle, in this case Hydrasperse~, a commercial
kaolin clay available from J. M. Huber Corporation, a
simple mixture of the kaolin clay Hydrasperse~ and the
commercial modified alkali metal alumino silicate
product, and the product of Example 2. Figure 2 shows
the kaolin clay product, Figure 3 shows the physical
mixture of the kaolin clay and the modified alkali
metal aluminosilicate and Figure 1 shows the milled
form of the final product of Example 2, all of these
particles being shown at lO,OOOX magnification.
A comparison of Figures 1, 2 and 3 shows a clear
difference in particle shape, appearance and size
2~ 9~83
between the starting kaolin clay of Figure 2, the
physical mixture of the commerçial modified alkali
metal aluminosilicate paper pigment and the kaolin
Hydrasperse~ and the product according to the present
invention of Figure 1. The product of Figure 1
contains more uniform particles and illustrates a
generally continuous and uniform coating.
Example 6
The apparent similarity between the product as
disclosed in U. S. Patent 4,026,721 to Kurrle prompted
a repeat of the work of Kurrle as in his Example 1.
The product produced according to U. S. Patent
4,026,721 to Kurrle is a calcium silicate formed in
situ by reaction between calcium chloride and sodium
silicate, the calcium silicate reaction product then
being deposited on planar surfaces of a kaolin
substrate. According to the patent, the calcium
silicate is deposited as spherical particles. In the
following work, the calcium silicate is referred to as
Casil. A series of pigments representing 100%
synthetic pigment, 80% synthetic Casil/20% kaolin, and
60% synthetic Casil/40% kaolin, were repeated as
outlined. The experiment was repeated using
Hydragloss~ 90 clay slurry in dry form. All reactant
concentrations were specifically duplicated, however;
3.33 MR sodium silicate was substituted for the 3.22 MR
specified.
Paper optical properties were measured on
handsheets prepared from the Kurrle pigments and
compared with pigments of this invention. Figure 8
illustrates the level of performance by the pigments of
Example 2 (at various levels of kaolin) as compared
with the Kurrle pigments. At all levels of kaolin
content, the Kurrle pigments are deficient in paper
22 ~ 3 ~ 3
optical performance when compared to the products of
Example 2.
Example 7
In additional work, Kurrle Example 1 was repeated
but substituting Al2(SO4)3 14 H2O for CaCl2 2H2O in the
Xurrle reaction. The replacement was made on an
equivalent moles of metal oxide basis ti.e., lAl2O3 =
lCaO). Reaction concentrations were duplicated,
however, once again 3.33 MR sodium silicate was
substituted for the 3.22 MR specified. Additional
aluminum sulfate which was added by Kurrle for pH
adjustment was added or deleted as required to attain
the pigment pH specified in the patent. Samples of
pigment were prepared that contained 40%, 20% and 0%
kaolin, respectively.
Chemical analysis of the synthetic pigment
(containing 40% kaolinite) was then compared with the
synthetic pigment produced by Example 2 (cont~in;ng 40%
kaolin). It is obvious that the pigments produced have
only slight similarities in composition. The pigment
of Example 2 of this invention (cont~in;ng 40% kaolin)
has substantially more Na2O and Al2O3, as well as the
additional MgO.
23 13~9883
Chemical Composition Comparison
Pigment of
this invention Kurrle
A12(S04!3
% LOI 12.0 11.5
% SiO2 57.8 66.6
% A12O3 21.7 17.1
% Na2O 4.6 2.5
% MgO 0.9
Na2S~4 3.1 4.3
Pre dried, 2 hrs, 105~C
Pigment of this invention =
0.35 Na2O:0.10 MgO 2~3 2 2
Kurrle = 0.24 Na2O:A12O3:6.63 SiO2:3.81 H2O.
The claimed pigment is produced with 2.6 MR
silicate which could account for a portion of the
differences in SiO2 level in the chemical composition.
Evaluation of these pigments in paper clearly
shows that the optical performance of pigments produced
by the Kurrle patent are inferior to the pigments of
the invention (Figure 9).
Performance in paper can typically be related to a
pigment's ability to scatter light. Therefore, the
Kubelka-Munk Scattering Coefficients were calculated
using the appropriate equations. Comparison of the
data at 6% filler level clearly shows the superior
light scattering ability of the claimed pigment as
compared with the pigments produced using methods
taught by the Kurrle patent.
24 1~3~80
Comparison of Scattering Coefficients
Pigment Scattering Coeffic~ents
(@60% Kaolin) @ 6% filler, S, cm /q
Kurrle (CaSil) 1834
Kurrle (A12O3) 1340
Pigment of this invention 2389
A detailed evaluation of pigment structure _as
illustrated by the attached, :Scanning Electron
Micrographs of Figures 6A, 6B and 6C and 7A, 7B and 7C,
clearly shows the difference in the two pigments. It
is evident that the Alumina-Kurrle pigment does not
coat the kaolin particles. The micrographs show many
kaolin particles that remain discreet after the
formation of the pigment unlike the claimed pigment in
which the kaolin particles are almost totally coated
with precipitate.
It is clearly evident from the data presented that
the claimed pigments and methods of preparation are not
similar to the calcium silicate-Kurrle pigments. The
Alumina analog pigment, while being similar in
composition, differs in structure, appearance and most
importantly, function, from the pigments of the claimed
lnvention.
Example 8
A pigment is produced by preparing 730.0g of an
aqueous reaction medium at 60~C. To this medium is
added 1447.2g of sodium silicate solution cont~ining
5.40% Na2O and 17.00% SiO2 at 60~C, simultaneously with
623.7g of aluminum sulfate solution cont~ining 17.90%
A12(S~4)3- Sufficient agitation is maintained to
suspend the pigment particles. Approximately 5 minutes
1 3 .~ 8 i)
after the start of the simultaneous additions, 206.36g
of ground calcium carbonate slurry (ground limestone)
with 50% solids is added.
Upon completion of simultaneous addition, an
additional 311.85g of aluminum sulfate is added to
reduce the slurry pH to 6.5. The pigment slurry is
recovered, filtered, washed and dried. A finely
divided composite pigment results.
Example 9
A pigment is produced by preparing 1031.41g of an
aqueous reaction medium containing 0.65% Mg(OH)2.
Clarified alum is added slowly with agitation to yield
a concentration of 0.92% A12(SO4)3 at 60 C. At this
point, simultaneous addition of alum and sodium
silicate containing 28.33% A12(SO4)3 at 60 C and 8.96%
Na2O and 22.39% SiO2 at 60~C, respectively is started
and continued at a slow rate maintAin;ng good agitation
for 6.5 minutes. At this point, addition of 346.36g of
a slurry of calcium carbonate (Dolomite Limestone)
containing 50% solids is started while maintAining
sufficient agitation to suspend the pigment particles.
Simultaneous additions are continued for 35 minutes.
The pigment is recovered, washed, dried and milled. A
finely divided composite pigment results.
For comparison purposes, the pigment of Example 9
contA i ni ng 25% ground calcium carbonate was compared
with a second sample produced by combining, as a simple
mixture, 75% synthetic sodium magnesium alumino
silicate and 25% ground calcium carbonate. Using
standard TAPPI and ISO methods described above,
handsheets were produced and evaluated as shown in the
following table. It is clearly evident from the table
that the performance of the novel coalesced pigment is
26 1~ ~9880
superior in opacity and brightness to the weighted
average performance calculated -from the individual
components.
PAPER PERFORMANC~ C0MPARISON
TAPPI OPACITY ISO ~l(;hl.~r S
2Z Filler 4~ Filler2% Filler 4~ Filler
Novel Pi~ment
25Z Dolomite Limestone 87.5 89.0 59.9 61.4
Simple M~ ture
A. Synthetic Al ~nn 87.4 88.9 59.9 62.2
Silicate
B. Ground Limestone 86.0 86.5 56.7 56.2
CAlc~ ted Weight Avg. 87.1 88.3 59.1 60.7
75~a + 25Zb
Unfilled 85.5 -- 58.1 --
Example 10
Using TAPPI standard methods handsheets were
produced from a groundwood furnish. The sheets
cont~;ning novel pigments having two types of carbonate
mineral are compared to other common fillers utilized
in the paper industry in the following table:
27 ~39~80
m ICAL PAPER PERFORMA~G~
TAPPI OPACITY - ISO RRT(;h,~ S
2Z Filler 4Z Filler 2Z Filler 4Z Filler
Novel Pi~ment
25Z Dol m;te TtmPstone 88.8 89.9 55.8 58.2
(Example 8)
Novel Pi~ment
25Z C~lein~ Carbonate 88.5 90.0 56.1 58.5
rle g)
Synthetic Al 'n~ 88.1 89.5 55.9 58.0
Silicate
r,~l~;n~d Clay 88.7 89.8 56.0 58.1
Unfilled 86.6 -- 53.9 --
lS The pigments of this invention ( contA in; ng up to
25~ low cost mineral substrate) offer superior
performance at 4~ filler level to calcined clay or
synthetic alumino pigments.
The invention has been described herein with
reference to certain preferred embodiments. However,
as obvious variations thereon will become apparent to
those skilled in the art, the invention is not to be
considered as limited thereto.
