Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
-1-
W.E. 55237
PATENT
Apparatus for Impact Testing for Electric generator
stator Wedge Tightness
Back round of the Invention
Field of the Invention
This invention relates to apparatus for remotely
testing electric generator stator wedge tightness with the
rotor in place. More particularly, it relates to such
apparatus which includes a remotely controlled carriag a
small enough to fit into the air gap between the generator
rotor and stator, and carryzng an' impactor to induce
vibration in the wedges which is measured by an eddy current
device.
Background Infarmation
During scheduled and some forced outages of
electric utility steam driven electric generators, one of
the major concerns is the condition of the stator coils.
Many tests are performed to guantify stator integrity. The
most time consuming of these tests has been the test of
stator wedge tightness since it has required removal of the
rotor to gain access to the stator bore area, specifically
the tooth tip area where the wedges are located. Eemoval of
the rotor requires two to three days alone. The accepted
industry method of testing stator wedge tightness is for a
technician to "tap" the wedge, feel the resulting vibration,
and listen to the sound. A loose wedge will vibrate more
than a tight one, and can be felt with the fingers. In
-2-
addition, a loose wedge will emit a characteristic hollow
sound, which the experienced technician quickly learns to
recognize as a loose wedge.
It is very important that wedge tightness be
carefully ascertained and corrected if deficient because the
tightness of the stator wedge is the only structural
element that prevents stator coil vibration due to the
combined effects of magnetic and mechanical loading. Field
experience has shown that failure to hold the stator coil
stationary in the stator slot permits ever increasing levels
of vibration leading to deterioration and finally failure of
the stator mica insulation and, in many instances, grounding
or "flashover" of the coils. When this occurs, the
owner/operator of the unit is faced with a time-consuming
and expensive rewinding process. For these reasons, stator
wedge tightness is of interest during routine outages, and
not just when the rotor is removed.
One of the difficulties in testing wedge tightness
without removal of the rotor is that there is as little as
1-1/2 inches of clearance between the stator bore and the
retainer ring through which apparatus may be inserted to
inspect the wedges distributed along the length of the
stator. Another difficulty is that the wedges are made of
non-conductive, non-magnetically permeable material such as;
for example, fiberglass coated with ~evlar which is,
compared to other materials such as steel, an absorbent of
mechanical energy so that the techniques available for
measuring tightness are limited. An additional difficulty,
especially in the case of an impact tester, is that the
stator coils extend radially outward about a horizontal axis
such that the effect of gravity on the impactor varies with
the angular position of the stator wedge being tested.
CA 02019216 1999-04-13
-3-
Commonly owned U.S. Patent No. 4,889,000
discloses a low profile remotely controlled carriage for
insertion into the gap between the rotor and stator of an
electric generator for performing inspections. The carriage
is positioned over a wedge with the aid of a miniaturized
television camera. A solenoid when energized strikes the
wedge and a microphone records the acoustic response. It
has been found, however, that it is desirable to apply a
larger and more repeatable impact force to the wedge than
can be developed by a solenoid. It has also been found that
it is difficult to assess with a computer the acoustic
response recorded by the microphone.
The inspection apparatus of U.S. Patent No. 4,889,000 also
includes an eddy current tester which is used to assess the condition of the
insulation between stator laminations. Commonly owned U.S. patent no.
4,803,563 also discloses an eddy current tester mounted on a carriage inserted
between the rotor and stator of an electric generator for inspecting the
insulation between the stator laminations. The carriage in patent no.
4,803,563
2 0 is held in place against the stator by permanent magnetics embedded in the
carriage chassis.
Other attempts have been made to quantify the
"tap, listen and feel" process for testing stator wedge
tightness. A mechanical impedance probe has been developed
which is based upon the recognition that during a resonance
sweep, a tight wedge will resonate (shift phase) at a
slightly higher frequency than a loose one. This method
does not discriminate between different degrees of looseness
nor does the apparatus have sufficient power to resonate
-4-
wedges of the size arid style used with the larger steam
driven units. In addition, the unit is too large to fit
into the rotor stator air gap.
Another type of apparatus for measuring wedge
tightness uses a force measurement system. The theory of
operation is that when an impact force is applied to a
stator wedge, the hammer will maintain contact with a loose
wedge for a longer interval before recoiling than with the
same wedge in a tight condition. This has been confirmed,
however, the sensitivity of the test does not permit clear
discrimination between the tight and loose conditions.
Furthermore, a version of such a device small enough for use
in the air gap of the generator has not been developed.
There is a need therefore for improved apparatus
for determining generator stator wedge tightness,
There is also need for such a apparatus which can
provide a more vigorous quantitative assessment of wedge
tightness.
There is an associated need for such apparatus
which can provide a consistent quantitative assessment
through all the orientations required to test wedge
tightness around the stator.
There is a further need for such apparatus which
can determine wedge tightness without removal of the rotor.
Brief nescron o:~~the~.,~.
A full understanding of the invention can be
gained fro~i the following description of the preferred
embodiments when read in conjunction with the accompanying
drawings in which:
Figure 1 is a schematic view of an electric
generator with the inspection system of the invention in
-5--
~~~~~i~
place to perform an inspection of generator stator wedge
tightness.
Figure 2 is a fragmentary isometric view of a
portion of the stator of the electric generator of Figure 1
illustrating the manner in which the stator coil is held in
place.
Figure 3 is rear view of the low profile main
carriage of the inspection system of the invention shown in
place within the electric generator of Figure 1.
Figure 4 is a top plan view of the low profile
main carriage of the inspection system of the invention with
the top cover removed.
Figure 5 is a view of a portion of Figure 4 shown
at an enlarged scale.
Figure 6 is a vertical section through the portion
of the low profile carriage shown in Figure 5 taken along
the line VI-VI.
Figure ? is plan view of the detector and gripper
portions of the low profile carriage.
Figure 8 is a vertical section of the detector and
gripper taken along the line VIII-VIII in Figure 7.
Figure g is a top plan view of another embodiment
of a low profile carriage in accordance with the invention.
Figure ZO is a vertical section in enlarged scale
through part of the modified carriage shown in Figure 9
taken along the line XwX.
Descriptio n of the Preferred Embodiments
Figure 1 illustrates schematically a large steam
turbine driven electric power generator 1 with the
3p inspection system 3 of the invention in place for measuring
-6-
201~~16
generator stator wedge tightness. The generator 1 includes
a rotor 5 mounted for rotation within a stator 7. A narrow
gap 9 is formed between the rotor retainer ring 11 and the
stator. In some electric generators, this gap 9 can be as
narrow as one and half inches. The stator 7 includes stator
coils 13 positioned between longitudinally extending stator
teeth 15.
As shown more clearly in Figures 2, the stator
teeth 15 which are made of laminations 17 form stator slots
19 in which stator coils 13 are stacked in pairs, one on top
of the other. The stator coils 13 are retained in the slots
19 by shims 21, sections of ripple springs 23, and stator
wedges 25 having beveled edges 27 which engage
correspondingly shaped grooves 29 in the sidewalk of the
stator teeth 15. The ripple spring sections 23 are
compressed between the stator wedges and shims 2I to
generate a force which firmly holds the coils in place.
aver time, the ripple springs can lose their resiliency so
that the wedges become loose. As previously mentioned, this
permits the coils 13 to vibrate which can result in damage
to the coil and eventual failure of the coil insulation.
The present invention inspects stator wedge tightness so
that corrective action can be taken before this occurs.
Returning to Figure 1, the inspection system 3 of
the inventian includes a low profile main carriage 31 which
is inserted in the narrow gap 9 between the rotor and stator
and travels along the stator slot inspecting the wedges for
tightness. As will be seen, the low profile main carriage
31 carries an impactor which sets up vibrations in the
stator wedges and a detector which generates electric
signals in response to those vibrations. The low profile
carriage 31 also carries a miniature television camera which
the operator can use to successively position the low
-7-
profile main carriage over successive stator wedges in the
slot and by which he can monitor operation of the
impactor. Electrical signals to and from the low profile
main carriage to control positioning of the carriage and
operation of the impactor and the detector, and data signals
from the detector are carried by an electrical cable 33
connected between the low profile main carriage 31 and a
console 35. Similarly, control and video signals to and
from the video camera are carried between the main carriage
and the console by cable 37. The cable 33 is connected to
an electronic control box 39 while the cable 37 carrying the
video signals is connected to a monitor 4I. The electronic
control box 39 includes a display 43 and a key pad 45
through which the operator can interface with and control
the isispection system. The monitor 41, permits the operator
to position the main carriage 3I over a selected stator
wedge and to observe operation of the impactor.
Referring especially to Figures 3 through 8, the
low profile main carriage 31 has a chassis 47 made of a non-
electrically conductive, non-magnetically permeable material
.such as fiberglass. Rotatably mounted along each side of
the chassis 47 are four wheels 49. The rear wheels 49 are
mounted on a shaft 51 which is driven through a timing belt
50 by an electric motor 53 mounted on the chassis 47.
Chains 55 engage sprockets 57 to drive all of the drive
wheels 49 with the motet 53. An encoder 52 also driven by
timing belt 50 provides signals representing carriage
movement to the electronic control box 39 for determining
the position of the carriage. A number of acre half inch
diameter and one inch diameter neodymium magnets 59 and 61
respectively are distributed over the chassis 47. These
magnets secure the main carriage to the stator for all
locations of the stator slots around the interior of the
_g_
stator. Guides 63 mounted on the bottom of the chassis 47
engage the stator slot 19 as seen in Figure 3 to direct the
main carriage along a selected slot. Parts 63' of the
guides 63 are movable laterally with respect to a fixed part
63" to adjust the width of the guide to accommodate for
variations in the width of the stator slots in different
machines. As described to this point, the main carriage 31
is similar to that described in g.8. patent no. 4,803,563.
The main carriage 31 carries an impactor 65 and a
vibration detector 67. The vibration detector 67 is mounted
on a seismically isolated detector carriage 69 disposed in
an aperture 71 in the chassis 4? of the main carriage 31.
This detector carriage 69 is supported by four free-turning
wheels 73 and has its own set of neodymium magnets 75 to
I5 secure it to the stator in all orientations. The detector
carriage 69 is selectively coupled with the main carriage by
a gripper 77 mounted on the chassis 47 by mounting 79. The
gripper 77 has a pair of jaws 81 which are opened and closed
by a motor 82 having a threaded shaft 83 journaled in
support 88 and engaging a traveling nut 84 carrying a pair
of actuating arms 85 pinned to the jaws 81. tripper 77
positions the detector carriage 69 within the aperture 71 by
gripping a rod 80 so that the detector carriage 69 is
seismically isolated from the remainder of the main carriage
by the gap 86 when the the jaws 81 are opened. This seismic
isolation of the detector assures that the deflection
measurements made by the detector are not magnified by the
direct transmission of movement of . the impactor through the
main carriage.
The impactor 65 includes an impactor head 87
pivotally mounted by a pair of support arms 89 for movement
along an arcuate path 91. A hemispherical nose 93 on the
impactor head concentrates the force generated by the
impactor which is measured by a force cell 95.
-9-
The impactor 65 must generate enough force to
compress the ripple spring 23 beneath the stator wedge 25.
The tighter the wedge, the greater the force required to
achieve this. It has been determined that energy in excess
of one foot pound which generates a force at the point of
impact of at least two hundred pounds is required for
reliable wedge tightness measurement. While the impactor
head 87 has a sizeable mass, the length of the stroke over
which it can be accelerated is restricted by the width of
the air gap between the stator and the rotor. Furthermore,
gravity cannot be relied upon to accelerate the impactor
head since the impactor must be able to operate in all
orientations including up side down. The invention includes
a mechanism 97 for applying a selected driving force to the
I5 impactor head.
The driving force mechanism 97 includes a pair
helical tension springs 99 connected to the pivot arm 89
through cables l0I secured to pins 103 extending laterally
from uprights 105 mounted on the pivot arms. The cables 101
are reeved around the detector carriage by pulleys 107 and
directed upward to pins 103 by pulleys 109. It will be
noted that the axes of the springs 99 lie in the plane of
the main carriage 31 so that they may be extended the
required length to generate the appropriate driving force
for the impadtor within the limited space available between
the rotor and stator . Connected to the other end of each of
the springs 99 is a cable 111 which is wound on a windless
pulley 113. The windless pulleys 113 are mounted on a
common shaft 115 driven by a motor 117 through pinion gear
119 and gear 120.
A latch mechanism 121 which retains the impact
head in a cocked position shown in full Line in Figure 6
includes a latch pin 123 which slides in a teflon bearing
-10-
201921
125 supported by a support bracket 127 straddling the pivot
arms 89. The latch pin 123 engages a notch 128 in a cross
bar 129 spanning the pivot arms 89. The latch pin 123 is
retracted by a pulsing do solenoid 131. A spring 133 biases
the latch pin 123 to the latched position. By control of
the motor 117, appropriate tension can be applied to the
springs 99 so that the impactor 65 generates a constant
impact force for alI orientations of the main carriage 31.
A return spring 135 returns the impactor head 87 to the
cocked position when tension on the springs 99 is relieved.
A miniature television camera 136 is mounted on
the low profile carriage to provide the operator with a view
of the impactor and detector for positioning the carriage
and observing the test.
The vibration detector 67 mounted on the detector
carriage 69 includes an eddy current detector 137. Since
the stator wedges are electrically non-conducting, a wedge
follower 139 which is at least in part electrically
conducting is also provided. In the embodiment shown in
Figures 7 and 8, the wedge follower is a vacuum cup 141.
The vacuum cap 141 is suspended from a roughly X shaped
mounting plate 143 with four depending support rods 144 by
helical extension springs 145. The mounting plate 143 has a
pair of upstanding shafts 147 which slide in linear bearing s
149 mounted on the detector carriage 69. A rack 151
projecting from the mounting plate 143 is engaged by a
pinion gear 153 on the shaft of a motor 155. Operation of
the motor 155 raises and lowers the mounting plate 143 to
selectively bring the vacuum cup 141 into contact with the
adjacent stator wedge. In the extended position, a limit
switch 159 turns on a vacuum pump (not shown] which
evacuates the vacuum cup 141 through a vacuum hose 161 to
securely attach the vacuum cup 141 to the adjacent stator
-11-
~~i~~~~
wedge so that the vacuum cap 141 accurately follows
deflection of the stator wedge resulting from the vibrations
set up by the impactor 65. The vacuum cup 141 is a nylon
disc 142 with a rubber ring 146 secured to its lower
surface. To provide the electrically conductive material
required for operation of the eddy current detector, a piece
of copper foil 163 is attached to the vacuum cup 141.
The eddy current detector I37 comprises an eddy
current coil 165 mounted in the base 167 of a generally T
shaped sensor holder 169 which extends through a hole 171 in
the mounting plate 143. Linear bearings 173 in the arms I75
of the fi shaped sensor holder 169 ride on a pair of shafts
177 mounted on the detector carriage 69 so that the eddy
current coil 165 can be raised and lowered to a fixed
distance from the vacuum cup 14I by a moor 179 having a
pinion gear 181 which engages a rack I83 secured to the
sensor holder 169.
In operation, the low profile main carriage 31 is
inserted through the gap 9 between the rotor 5 and stator 7
of the electric generator 1 with the guides 63 engaging the
mouth of a selected stator slot 19. The magnets 59 and 61
hold the carriage 31 in place against the stator regardless
of the position of the selected stator slot 19 around the
stator. The drive motor 53 is then energized to drive the
low profile main carriage 31 along the slot to position the
carriage, as observed on the monitor 41, so that the
impactor nose 87 will strike the so-called "sweet spot" or
wedge centroid of a selected wedge while the vacuum cup 141
is positioned to monitor the vibration at the end of the
wedge. positioning the impactor in this manner produces
maximum wedge vibration for a given impact.
-12-
With the impactor positioned at the desired spot
over the selected wedge, the motor 83 is operated to open
the clamp 77 and isalate the detector carriage 69 from the
main carriage 31. The magnets 75 hold the detector carriage
69 in position against the stator. The motor 155 is then
operated to extend the vacuum cup 141 into contact with the
selected wedge and operation of limit switch 159 turns on
the vacuum pump to apply a vacuum through vacuum line 161 to
firmly secure the vacuum cup 141 to the selected wedge.
Motor 179 is then operated in a fast mode to extend the eddy
current coil 165 toward the piece of copper foil 163 secured
to the vacuum cup 141. At a predetermined distance from the
vacuum cug 141, the motor 179 is slowed down and the eddy
current voltage is closely monitored for rapid decrease to
zero which occurs at the pre-calibrated balance point,
selected in the exemplary system to be 0.025 inches from the
foil on the vacuum cup: At this point, the vacuum cup 141
and the eddy current coil 165 are correctly positioned and
ready for measurement of a wedge impact.
Tn preparation for an impact, the impactor head is
held in the cocked position by the latch pin I23. The motor
117 is operated to turn the windlass pulleys 113 to preload
the tension springs 99 and thereby apply a driving force to
the impactor head through cables 101. The motor 117 has an
integral encoder which enables the control system to rotate
the shaft of motor 117, and hence the windless pulleys 113,
the correct number of turns. for example, when the impactor
is operating "upside down" in the generator 12 a'clock
position, the impactor is working against gravity and
slightly more spring tension is required than in the 6
o'clock position. Adjusting spring tension for unit
orientation assures consistent impact forces independent of
unit orientation.
-13-
20~92~6
The wedge tightness test is performed by
energizing the solenoid 131 to withdraw latch pin 123 from
the cross bar 129 permitting the preloaded springs 99 to
apply a driving force to the impactor head 87 causing the
impactor head nose 93 to strike the stator wedge with the
prescribed force. The resulting vibrations set up in the
wedge axe followed by the vacuum cup 141. The eddy current
coil 165 generates a signal which is a function of the
instantaneous spacing between the coil and the suction cup
and therefore representative of wedge deflection. This
arrangement measures wedge deflection with an accuracy which
provides the capability of reliably distinguishing between
the large amplitude vibrations of a loose wedge and the
small amplitude vibrations of a tight wedge. The impactor
is recocked for the next impact by return spring 135 when
tension on the springs 99 is relieved.
figures 9 and 10 illustrate an alternate
embodiment of the invention. The modified carriage 201 has
a chassis 203 which is constructed and driven by wheels 205,
and is held in place against the stator by neodymium magnets
207, similarly to the carriage 31 previously described.
Like the carriage 31, the modified carriage 201 mounts an
impactor 209 and a detector 211. However, in this modified
arrangement, the detector 211 is located at the end of the
carriage 20I with the impactor 209 inboard. This permits
the' carriage to more easily test the last wedge in each
stator slot.
Both the impactor 209 and detector 211 are
modified from the corresponding mechanisms on the carriage
31. The impactor head 213 pivotally mounted by its support
arms 215 is held in the cocked position by a pair of
confronting latch pins 217 which are biased to the latched
position by compression springs 219. The latch pins 217 are
-14-
retracted by a pair of cables 22i which are reeved around
pulleys 223 and wrapped in opposite directions around the
windless pulley 225 on motor 227 mounted on the chassis
203. Preloading is applied to the impactor head in the
cocked position by a pair of tension springs 229 connected
to the impactor head 213 through cables 231 reeved over
pulleys 233 and under pulleys 235 and connected to pins 237
extending laterally from posts 239 an the support arms
215. The other ends of the springs 229 are connected to
cables 241 which are wound on windless pulleys 243. The
windless pulleys 243 are mounted on a common shaft 245
having a gear 247 driven by a motor 249 through pinion
251. The impactor head 213 is biased to the cocked position
by return springs 253 stretched between posts 255 tin the
support arms 2I5 and posts 257 mounted on the chassis. A
miniature television camera 259 positioned between the
support arms 215 of the impactor allows the operator to
position the carriage 201 for testing of a selected stator
wedge and to observe operation of the impactor and the
detector.
The modified detector 211 includes a separate
detector carriage 261 mounted in an aperture 263 in the
chassis 203, but seismically isolated from the chassis 203
and supported by eight foam pads 265. The foam pads may be
made for instance from low density closed cell urethane
foam. Flanges 262 around the tap of the detector carriage
and 264 around the bottom of aperture 263 provide an
interference fit with said foam pads to retain the detector
carriage in said aperture. Separate neodymium magnets 267
secure the detector carriage 261 to the bore of the stator.
The carriage 261 carries an eddy current detector
269 and a wedge follower 271. The wedge follower 271
comprises a foot 273 mounted on the end of a shaft 275 which
-15-
is journaled in a linear bearing 277 on the detector
carriage 261. The foot 273 is biased against the stator
wedge 25 by a helical compression spring 279. In order to
maintain a low mass, the foot 273 is preferably made of a
material such as nylon.. Since such rnaterials are non-
conductive, a copper foil strip 281 is provided on the upper
surface of the foot. While the carriage is being positioned
over a stator wedge, the foot 273 is raised to a retracted
position while the carriage is being positioned over a
stator wedge by a cable 283 reeved over pulleys 285 and
wound on a windless pulley 287 driven by a motor 289. Up
and down limit switches 291 and 293 respectively, control
the motor 289 to position the foot 273 in the extended and
retracted positions. A rod 295 projecting laterally from
the upper end of the shaft 275 is connected to the carriage
261 by a spring 2.97 to maintain the foot aligned with the
eddy current detector.
The eddy current detector 269 includes an eddy
current coil 299 mounted in eddy current coil housing 301.
The housing 301 is supported for vertical movement by a pair
of linear bearings 303 which ride on shafts 305 supported by
the carriage 261. A bracket 307 attached to the eddy
current coil housing 301 supports a rack 309 which engages a
pinion gear 311 driven by a motor 313. Operation of the
motor 313 raises and lowers the eddy current coil. A limit
switch 315 sets the upper limit of travel. The coil 299 is
lowered until the precise distance from the fail 281 on the
foot 273 is reachwd at a preset null position as previously
described.
While specific embodiments of the invention have
been described in detailr it will be appreciated by those
skilled in the art that various modifications and
alternatives to those details could be developed in light of
-16-
the overall teachings of the disclosure. Accordingly, the
particular arrangements disclosed are meant to be
illustrative only and not limiting as to the scope of the
invention which is to be given the full breadth of the
appended claims and any and all equivalents thereof.
