Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
203~917
PHOTOELECTRIC MENSURATION DEVI OE AND METHOD
FOR DETERMINING PDC CUTTER WEAR
TECHNICAL FIELD OF THE INVENTION
This inventlon relates generally to a drill blt
having polycrystalline diamond compact (PDC) cutter
elements. More particularly, but not by way of
limltation, this invention relates to apparatus for
measuring and determining the amount of wear on each
polycrystalline diamond compact cutter element in a
drill bit.
,
.
`
'~
- 2 2~3~917
BACKGROUND OF 'lh~ INVENTION
Although thls inventlon ls applicable for measuring
the wear on varlous irregularly shaped ob~ects, lt has
been found to be particularly useful in the envlronment
of PDC cutter elements. Therefore, wlthout llmlting the
appllcability of the lnvention to "PDC cutter elements~,
the lnvention will be described ln such environment.
This lnvention is also appllcable for measurlng the
surface area of various substantially flat, irregularly
shaped ok~ects.
Polycrystalline dlamond compact cutter elements are
readlly commerclally avallable. Round top PDC cutter
elements generally comprise a cyllndrical stud of
tungsten carblde having an angular planar face formed at
- 15 one end of the stud. A generally cylindrical wafer of
tungsten carbide is brazed onto the planar face with the
opposite exposed face of the wafer comprising a layer of
polycrystalllne dlamonds. It will be appreclated that
the PDC cutter elements are available in a variety of
- 20 shapes other than round top, such shapes as chlsel top,
; flat top, etc. The cutter elements may be customized to
almost any shape wlth an electrlcal dlscharge machlne.
Sophlstlcated computer programs are used to
~' accurately and efflclently positlon the PDC cutter
elements on the drlll blt so that each cutter element
removes a predetermined volume of rock. As the cutter
~` elements become worn, the drlll blt becomes dull and the
,~ efficiency of the drill bit decreases until the dull
drill bit is replaced with a new drlll bit. The dull
drlll bit ls sent back to design and manufacturing for
evaluation. Wear data from the cutter elements is used
to correct and adjust the mathematical models that are
; used to design bits and predict wear. Wear data ls also
used to determine if the bit is rerunable, or if the bit
~ . . . . . . . . . .
. .
''
.
20319~7
can be repalred, and lf so, whlch cutters should be
replaced.
It wlll be appreclated that lt ls very lmportant
and beneflclal to be able to economically and accurately
determlne the amount of wesr on each cutter element ln
the drlll bit not only to obtain maximum and efficient
use of the drlll blt ln the fleld prlor to changlng out
the drlll bit but also in optimizing the deslgn of the
drlll blt and to make consistent declslons concerning
repalr and rerun of blts.
The present method of attemptlng to determlne the
amount of wear on each cutter element whlle the drlll
bit ls ln the field is by the use of a straight edge
;- ruler havlng a mllllmeter scale thereon to attempt to
lS measure a wear flat. Thls method ls not very
satlsfactory because the mllllmeter scale readability ls
about 1 millimeter which introduces a great amount of
~rror. In additlon, there normally ls not a flat
portlon on the wear surface of the cutter element as
there are all types of surface geometry lnvolved with
the wear surface on each cutter element. Also, the
vertical height of the remalning portlon of the cutter
may be attempted to be measured by the ruler and the
same measurement error is lntroduced. Therefore, it is
generally recognlzed that the ruler method is not
accurate enough to provlde the data needed to modify the
mathematlcal wear patterns and the design programs for
the drlll bits. Additionally, scale measurement ignores
the orlginal positionlng of the cutter ln relatlon to
- 30 the body of the blt. For example, a partlcular design
may expose only 75~ (by area) of a cutter above the body
of the bit. Therefore, conversion tables or graphs must
be used each time a measurement ls taken to determine
.. . . . . . . .. . .. . . .
2~3~917
:
the true wear of the cutter as a percentage of its new
condltlon.
A more accurate method of measurlng wear of cutter
elements ls the ink grid method. ~nk ls placed on the
` S face of the cutter element and then a small plece of
paper ls pressed agalnst the inked surface to transfer
; the shape of the face of the cutter element to the
paper. The paper i5 placed under a grld network and the
number of sguares and partlal squares are counted and
compared to the number of squares for a new cutter
- element to try and determine the amount of wear to the
worn cutter element.
A more accurate and expenslve method of measurlng
wear of the cutter elements ls by use of a CMM machine
which includes an element that is moved along the worn
surface of the cutter element and data points (6 to 8)
are taken. Sophisticated computer programs convert the
"i information from the data points lnto an image of the
cutter element and determlnes the amount of wear. It
takes approximately 3 1/2 hours to do a 6 3/4 lnch drill
bit and the CMM machine is extremely capital intenslve,
time consuming, and expensive to use.
~'~ The present inventlon ls portable, is relatlvely
inexpenslve, ls extremely accurate and extremely fast.
The wear of the cutter elements on a 6 3/4 inch drill
bit can be determined in five mi~utes or less and the
results will be more accurate than if the CMM machine
was used. The data may be fed from this invention to a
portable computer and taken back to the offlce.
. .
: .
, .
,
.
.. ~, . . . .
., -,~
.
.: .
:'' . , ,' ~ ' '
.
~03~17
s
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
This lnventlon provides a method and apparatus for
determlnlng the amount of material removed from an
lrregularly shaped ob~ect and comprlses a llght source,
a photocell positloned to receive llght from the llght
source and a current-measuring read-out device
operatively connected to the photocell to provide an
indication of the current output of the photocell. The
current-measuring read-out device dlsplays a reading
lndlcatlve of the amount of materlal removed from the
lrregularly shaped ob~ect when the lrregularly shaped
ob~ect, with the material mlsslng therefrom, ls placed
in position against the photocell so the llght from the
, llght source strikes the photocell where the materlal ls
misslng. A computer may be operatively connected to the
current-measuring read-out device to recelve a readout
; therefrom which is lndlcative of the amount of materialremoved from the lrregularly shaped ob~ect. This
lnventlon also provldes a method and apparatus for
~,~ 20 measuring the surface area of a substantially flat,
lrregularly shaped ob~ect.
i
.. . . . .. ..
;, " .-
. .
~''
'
''
,; ~
6 203~ 917
,
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF ~HE DRAWINGS
9ther advantages and features of the lnventlon will
become more apparent wlth reference to the followlng
detalled descrlptlon of a presently preferred embodiment
thereof ln connectlon with the accompanylng drawings,
-. whereln llke reference numerals have been applled to
llke elements, ln whlch:
- FIGURE 1 ls an exemplary drlll blt havlng PDC
cutter elements mounted thereln:
FIGURE 2 ls a side elevational view of a PDC cutter
element;
~ FIGURE 3 ls a front elevatlonal vlew of a PDC
- cutter element;
'' FIGURE 4 lS a rear elevatlonal vlew of a PDC cutter
-. lS element;
FIGURE 5 is a rear elevatlonal view of a worn PDC
-. cutter element;
i FIGURE 6 ls a rear elevational view of a different
worn PDC cutter element;
; 20 FIGURE 7 is a simplified schematic, in block
diagram form, of the present invention;
FIGURE 8 is a bottom plan vlew of the housing of
the present invention;
FIGURE 9 is an end elevatlonal view of the housing
of the present invention;
FIGURE 10 is a sectlonal vlew of the hand-held
; analyzer constructed in accordance with the invention;
, and
FIGURE 11 is a front elevatlonal view showing an
30 exemplary shape of the photocell of the present
~ invention.
. . ..
~' '
, .:
., .
. ~........................................................... .
,, '
' '
'~'
.
7 2031917
DETAITEn DESCRIPTION
Referring to the drawing and FIGURE 1 ln
partlcular, PDC cutter elements 10 are shown mounted ln
the body 12 of a drill blt 14 that ls shown ln a
slmpllfled figuratlon for lllustratlon only.
Wlth reference to FIGURE 2, an unmounted PDC cutter
` element 10 ls shown in a slde elevatlonal vlew and
comprlses a cyllndrical stud 16 formed of a tungsten
carblde materlal havlng, ad~acent one end thereof, an
angled planar face 18 formed thereon. A generally
cyllndrlcal portlon or tungsten carblde wafer 20 having
opposed planar fa¢es ls bonded, as by brazlng, to the
; angled planar face 18 of the stud 16 along one of lts
faces. A layer of polycrystalllne dlamond materlal or
cuttlng wafer 22, formlng the cuttlng face of the cutter
element 10 ls bonded to the opposite face. The exterlor
termlnal end 24 of the cyllndrlcal stud 16 ad~acent the
wafer 20 is generally contoured, such as at 26 to
conform generally to the outer clrcular circumference of
the wafer 20.
FIGURE 3 ls a front elevatlonal view of the PDC
cutter element 10, wh$1e FIGURE 4 ls a rear elevational
!~ view of the PDC cutter element 10. The wear whlch
occurs on and to the PDC cutter element 10 ls prlmarily
concentrated to the upper half of the cutting wafer 22,
tungsten carbide wafer 20 and exterlor terminal end 24.
FIGURES 5 and 6 disclose exemplary wear patterns on
a PDC cutter element 10 as vlewed from the rear. It
wlll be appreciated that any attempt to measure the wear
~: 30 by uslng a ruler or the lnk grld method could result ln
a great deal of time and less than accurate results.
With reference to FIGURE 7, shown therein and
generally deslgnated by the reference character 30 is a
PDC cutter wear analyzer that is constructed in
. ~
~ .
. . . . . . . . .
. " .
,:.
':
:.
8 2~31917
accordance wlth the lnventlon. PDC cutter wear analyzer
30 comprises a light source 32 posltioned at a constant
and predetenmined dlstance from photocell 34 and at a
constant and predetermined angle wlth respect to the
-~ ~ generally flat surface of photocell 34. This results ln
light source 32 providing a constant flux denslty of
light energy 33 to the photocell 34. Power source 36
supplies power to llght source 32 and radlometer 38 such
as ls available from International Llght, Newburyport,
; 10 Maine. It wlll be appreclated that separate power
sources may be used to provlde power to llght source 32
and radlometer 38. For portable use, llght source 32
could be a 9 or 12 volt llght bulb. The radlometer from
Internatlonal Llght ls deslgned to accept elther a DC
lS portable (battery) power source or the 120 volts AC from
a standard electrlcal outlet to provlde versatllity
regardlng lts operation and use. The invention can be
portable and can be used ln the fleld at the drill slte
as well as in the offlce. Radlometer 38 recelves an
electrlcal signal from photocell 34 which ls
proportlonal to the value of lumlnous intensity or flux
denslty recelved by the photocell 34 and provldes a
~ dlrect vlsual read-out of the percent of wear on the
- cutter surface of the PDC cutter element 10. Radiometer
38 also provldes a slgnal to a small portable computer
40, whlch signal also provides the amount of wear whlch
` has occurred to the PDC cutter element 10 such that the
computer 40 may store the information for later
analysis.
With reference to FIGURES 8-10, the PDC cutter wear
analyzer 30 ls contained in a hand-held fixture or
houslng 42. A cavity 44 is formed in one end of housing
42 $nto which photocell 34 is mounted. The mounting of
the photocell 34 ls such that the faFe 46 of cutting
. .
,
.
"'' '
, .
.. . .
,. . .
9 203~917
wafer 22 will rest or set flush against the surface of
; photocell 34 and block any light from llght source 32
from reaching the photocell ~n the area where the face
46 contacts the surface of the photocell 34. In the
S areas where the face 46 does not contact the surface, lf
such areas exist, light from light source 32 wlll strlke
photocell 34. Bracket 48 supports and holds both
` photocell 34 and llght source 32 wlthln cavlty 44.
Bracket 48 ls shaped to leave a portlon of photocell 34
uncovered wlth the uncovered portion being of a slze and
shape to accommodate the face 46 of cuttlng wafer 22.
The uncovered portlon should closely approxlmate the
slze and shape of face 46 for best results. For a round
top face cutter type of PDC cutter element 10, the
uncovered portion of the photocell 34 would be clrcular
ln shape. It will be appreciated that it ls not
necessary for the geometry of the photocell 34 to
exactly mlrror the proflle of the lrregularly shaped
ob~ect to be measured. One of the advantages of the
lnventlon ls that lt wlll measure a chlsel shaped cutter
on the same photocell 34 as wlll measure a round shaped
cutter. The radlometer 38 wlll establlsh a zero point
at any arbltrary inltlal light level, as well as a 100%
point at any arbltrary llght level wlthln the llmits of
the photocell's absorptlon rate. It is only necessary
that the surface to be placed against the photocell 34
ls generally flat since photodlodes are not yet
available mounted on matching curved surfaces. Llght
source 32 ls operatlvely connected to power source 36 by
leads s0 and 52 whlle photocell 34 ls operatively
connected to radiometer 38 by leads 54 and 56 with all
leads exlting housing 42 through aperture 58.
Wlth reference to FIGURE 11, one example of the
shape of the surface of photocell 34, which ls exposed
:
.~'
,
, - . :
.. . . ~ .
lo ~0~ ~17
,
.
- to llght energy 33 when the round top face cutter type
- of PDC cutter element 10 ls not posltloned on the
surface of the photocell, ls dlsclosed. It wlll be
appreciated that the shape of the surface of photocell
34 could be different for dlfferent shaped ob~ects, but
that ls not necessary.
In operatlon of thls lnventlon, the lnventlon would
be calibrated for 0~ wear uslng a new PDC cutter element
10 or one wlthout any wear. Power from power source 36
is applied to light source 32 and radlometer 38. A new
PDC cutter element 10 is inserted lnto cavlty 44 of
houslng 42 and posltloned as shown ln FIGURE 10 to cover
photocell 34 and block a representatlve portlon of llght
from llght source 32 reachlng photocell 34. The new PDC
cutter element or one wlthout any wear ls consldered to
be the standard whose area ls predetermlned to represent
0'4 wear regardless of the amount of llght, lf any, which
strlkes photocell 34. Uslng the proper control on
radiometer 33, the read-out from radlometer 33 is set to
zero, whlch lndlcates that the amount of llght, lf any,
strlking the photocell ls to be established as zero wear
on the cutter element. The new PDC cutter element 10 ls
then removed from houslng 42.
~; The lnventlon would then be calibrated for 100%
wear using a PDC cutter element 10 whlch is worn to a
degree that is consldered to be the standard whose area
ls predetermlned to represent 100'4 wear regardless of
: the amount of llght which strikes photocell 34. The
proper control on radlometer 38 ls ad~usted such that
the read-out from radiometer 38 is set at 100%, which
indicates that the amount of llght striking the
photocell is to be establlshed as 100% wear on the
~; cutter. In the situatlon where the cutter element 10
was not completely exposed (e.g., 7s~ by area) above the
;
.
,,
.,,
......
. .:
. . .
:.
,.. . .
.
.~
.,
.
.
.
. . . , ~ .
2031911
'
` body of the drlll blt, then a portion of the cutter
element 10 may be positioned on the photocell 34, ln the
-- invention, which portion would represent the amount of
wear occurrlng when the cutter element was worn down to
the body of the drlll blt. Thls level of wear ls
dètermlned to be the standard to represent 100% wear for
a cutter element 10 wlth thls partlcular amount of
exposure above the body of the drlll blt 13. The
lnventlon ls now ready to lndicate the amount of wear to
each PDC cutter element 10 ln the drlll blt 14.
The houslng ls posltloned over each worn PDC cutter
element 10 as shown ln FIGURE 10 and as soon as the
houslng ls posltloned over the cutter element, the
radlometer wlll provlde a dlrect readlng of the percent
; 15 of wear of that worn PDC cutter element 10. Then, ln
some orderly fashlon, the operator of the invention may
proceed from one cutter element to the next on the drlll
blt 14 and determlne the percent of wear for each PDC
cutter element 10. If the computer (portable~ desk top
or maln frame) ls connected to radiometer 38, the read-
out from radlometer 38 wlll be transferred to the
computer.
- Radlometer 38 has the capability of providlng a
~ reclprocal read-out whlch would provlde an lndlcatlon of
- 25 the percentage of the cutter element whlch remalns ~not
worn away). Therefore, the lnventlon can be used to
determlne the surface area of a substantlally flat,
irregularly shaped ob~ect. Flrst, the lnvention would
be callbrated uslng an ob~ect whose area is known and
` 30 thls would be the standard agalnst whlch the ob~ect wlth
unknown surface area would be measured. An ob~ect whose
surface area ls known, e.g., one square lnch, is
posltloned against photocell 34. Using the proper
control on radiometer 38, the read-out from radiometer
~'
:~'-,,
,
.;. , , , , :
. , ~ ,
' , . .
.
2~31917
12
-, 38 is set at 100%. The standard whose area is known is
removed and with l$ght from light source 32 falllng on
all the surface of photocell 34, the proper control on
radlometer 38 is ad~usted such that the read-out from
radlometer 38 ls set at 0% which indlcates zero area.
The substantlally flat, lrregularly shaped ob~ect, whose
surface area ls unknown, is then placed against the
surface of photocell 34 and the read-out from the
radiometer 3B lndlcates the surface area of the
substantlally flat, irregularly shaped ob~ect as a
percent of the standard whose area ls known.
It will be appreclated that the present lnvention
provldes a portable hand-held unlt, whlch is
lnexpenslve, extremely accurate and extremely fast that
utlllzes the sensltlvlty of a photocell to lumlnous
lntenslty to dlrectly measure the percent wear to a PDC
cutter element ln a drlll bit. The lnventlon
lncorporates a source of constant lumlnosity at a
constant dlstance and angular dlsposltlon to the
photocell. Thls equates to a constant flux density
supplled to the photocell. The photocell ls then
shadowed by an lrregularly shaped ob~ect whlch blocks a
portlon of the llght dlrected toward the photocell. The
change ln electrlcal current from the photocell ls
determined to be proportional to the area of the
photocell whlch was blocked from recelvlng light. Thls
- provides a very fast and very accurate means of
- determinlng the area of an irregularly shaped ob~ect ln
` two dimenslons by provlding the percentage of llght
which reaches the photocell. Fllters and light sources
may be varied to improve accuracy lf the readlngs appear
to be affected by ambient llght.
;;~ Although the present invention has been described
~` with reference to a presently preferred embodiment, it
~.
`'`'';
~ .,,
r~
~.','
.
. . ' .
. . . .
. ' : ' .
.
' '' ' '. ' ' '' . ~
' ' " ' '', - ~:
.,, , ' ~
13 2~31917
will be appreciated by those skilled in the art that
varlous modifications, alternatlves, variations, etc.,
may be made without departins from the splrit and scope
of the ~nvent~n as defined ~n the appended claims.
:
,
- , ..
- ,: . ~: :
