Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02200674 1999-11-02
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
This invention relates generally to fasteners,
and more particularly concerns methods of installing
rivets to obtain compressive clamp-up retained between
two sheets, so as to inhibit interface movement
(fretting), and thereby to enhance fatigue life of the
sheets.
This invention also relates to a method of
protection and controlled riveting that inhibits
corrosion, particularly in outer skin attachment of
aircraft.
Corrosion of and around rivet connections on
aircraft severely impacts the structure life, preventing
the aircraft from attaining its potential fatigue and
service life. The corrosion types are primarily
exfoliation, electrolytic and stress related. There is
need for improvements to reduce or eliminate potential
corrosion problems. As will be seen, the protective
coatings, sealants and methods disclosed herein,
together with dimensional control of the rivets and
workpiece holes/counterbores, can effectively minimize
or eliminate exfoliation, electrolytic and stress
corrosion in aircraft structures.
There is also need for obtaining such retained
clamp-up on a consistent basis, as where a large number
of coated rivets are used to interconnect sheet members,
- 2 -
CA 02200674 1997-08-25
such as lap joints and crown splices of aircraft
fuselage skins. There is also need to obtain enhanced
fatigue life of such interconnected sheets, and to
inhibit fretting between such sheets.
SUI~IARY OF THE INVENTION
A maj or obj ect of the invention is to apply
protective coatings and sealants to rivets which can,
upon installation, fill in rough finishes, edges,
tapers, out of round counterbores, in order to eliminate
bare workpiece corrosion sites, and eliminate air gap
possibility under the rivet head at the countersink.
The protective coating also acts as a barrier
to prevent electrolytic corrosion, and when the coating
is current carrying, becomes bonded electrically,
reducing potential lightning strike damage.
Basically, the method of the invention
involves clamping together of two workpiece sheets using
a rivet, one sheet having a bore, and a counterbore
which is frusto-conical and tapers forwardly between a
side of the one sheet and the bore, and toward the bore,
the steps of the method including:
a) providing a metallic rivet having an
axially extending shank defining an axis, the rivet
metal consisting essentially of fine-grained, ductile,
aluminum alloy,
b) providing the rivet with a head having an
end face and a forwardly tapered frusto-conical section
located forwardly of the end face,
- 3 -
CA 02200674 1997-08-25
c) installing the shank in the bore and the
head in the counterbore so that the periphery of the
head end face is substantially flush with the work
surface, the end face formed to provide a ring-shaped
dome protruding axially in a rearward direction, the
dome located to extend about the axis in substantially
axial alignment with the outer surface of the shank,
d) the rivet head provided with a peripheral
side wall spaced radially from a side wall defined by
the workpiece counterbore, and the space between the
side walls having a volume A,
e) the dome provided with a metallic volume
B,
f) and wherein volume B exceeds volume A,
such that when the dome is flattened during rivet
deformation, the rivet head side wall is radially
expanded into volume A and pushes outwardly against the
workpiece counterbore side wall to deform the latter
radially outwardly,
g) and providing barrier material between
the rivet side wall and the workpiece counterbore side
wall to fill interstices between the side wall upon
radially outward deforming of the workpiece counterbore
side wall.
Another object is to coat the barrier onto the
rivet side wall prior to the rivet deformation, and to
a thickness variation of about .0002 to .006 inches.
Such material may be a sealant or an anti-corrosion
material, or a combination of a barrier coating and
sealant. Deformation of the rivet head causes forcing
- 4 -
CA 02200674 1997-08-25
of the barrier material against the work counterbore
side wall, and into metallic interstices.
A further object is to provide barrier coating
on the rivet ring dome, whereby dome flattening causes
the barrier material to penetrate into metallic
interstices at the surface of the flattened dome and
adjacent the outermost extent of the radially expanded
head side wall, during the radial expansion of the head
side wall.
These and other objects and advantages of the
invention, as well as the details of an illustrative
embodiment, will be more fully understood from the
following specification and drawings, in which:
DRAWING DESCRIPTION
Fig. 1 is an elevation taken in section
showing a rivet inserted in a workpiece;
Fig. 2 is a view like Fig. 1 but showing the
rivet during squeeze deformation;
Fig. 2a is a view like Fig. 2 but showing the
rivet after completed deformation, a buck-tail having
been formed;
Fig. 3 is an enlarged fragmentary section
showing a rivet head of one (minimum) size relationship
to a work counterbore;
Fig. 4 is a view like Fig. 3 showing the rivet
head of another (maximum) size relationship to a work
counterbore;
- 5 -
CA 02200674 1997-08-25
Fig. 5 is an exploded view showing elements of
a rivet in relation to elements of a work bore and
counterbore;
Fig. 6_a is an enlarged section showing initial
seating of a rivet in work sheets;
Fig. 6b_ is like Fig. 6a_ but shows the position
of the rivet and sheets after driving of the rivet;
Figs. 7(a)--(e) are views showing progressive
stages in rivet deformation;
Fig. 8 is an enlarged section showing barrier
material on the rivet;
Fig. 9 is like Fig. 8 but showing
installation;
Fig. 10 is a further enlarged section showing
barrier material in interstices in the rivet and work
walls;
Fig. 11 is a view showing an air gap, when
barrier material is not used; and
Fig. 12 is an enlarged fragmentary section
showing barrier deformation at the head raised edge,
after deformation.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
In Fig. 1, two panels 111 and 112 (metal,
glass fiber, composites, etc.) define the workpiece 110.
A main bore 113 extends in both panels--a counterbore
209 and a tapered countersink 114 in panel 111. The
bore and countersink have a common forwardly extending
axis 116.
- 6 -
CA 02200674 1997-08-25
The fine-grain, ductile, aluminum alloy rivet
118 has an axially extending shank 119 inserted
forwardly in and through bore 113, with clearance as
indicated. The rivet shank or tail projects forwardly
of panel 112. The rivet head 120 has an end face 121
(forming a ring-shaped dome) facing rearwardly and
spaced above the upper surface of 111. A cylindrical
section 208 of the rivet is bounded by cylindrical wall
209; and a forwardly tapered, frusto-conical section 122
of the rivet is spaced forwardly of section 208.
The rivet is progressively deformed as by
machine squeeze or by hammers 124 and 125 to flatten the
protruding head dome 121, and simultaneously to form
the upset or buck-tail 126 seen in Fig. 2a_. The arrows
at the head 120 cross section show the directions of
metal deformation during flattening of the dome. In
this regard, head metal adjacent tapered surface 122a_
tends to flow toward and around annular corner 130 at
the intersection of bore 113 with countersink 114, due
to the fact that force imparted to the rivet head by
deformation is centrally directed through the ring dome
crest toward the corner 130 defining a convexly annular
extrusion surface for rivet metal flow thereover.
The rivet, as in Fig. 1, has an annular
periphery 121_a of the end face 121 that is substantially
flush with the work surface 131; in addition, the end
face forms ring dome 132 protruding axially in a
rearward direction. This dome is generally ring-shaped
and extends about axis 116. The extent of rearward
protrusion of the dome is such that the entire head end
CA 02200674 1997-08-25
face 121 extends substantially above (prior to
deformation) and parallel with the work surface. Upon
completion of rivet deformation, as indicated at 121b_ in
Fig. 2~, the dome is substantially eliminated. End face
121 then protrudes between .001 and .006 inches above
the level of work surface 131.
The dome, being ring-shaped, is radially
located rearwardly of the countersink 114, whereby the
rivet head material remains in engagement with the
countersink and does not form a clearance therewith in
response to dome flattening. For best results, the dome
radially outer extent 132, which flares outwardly and
forwardly, is substantially entirely located in axially
spaced relation to the countersink, i.e., the tapered
countersink 114. The flare at 132a_, toward the head
outermost periphery, is at an angle controlled to assure
that its outer periphery is in a plane normal to axis
116. Further, the dome crest portion 132 is in
substantial axial alignment with the shank outer surface
119, and also work bore 113. The height "d" (see Fig.
3) of the crest above the level of 121_a is between 0.004
and 0.016 inches, for best results.
Accordingly, during the riveting process, the
rivet head tapered surface 122_a, throughout
substantially its entire length, remains seated against
the countersink 114, and no spring-back is produced to
the extent that clearance would develop, after
installation is completed.
In this regard, note that the central
concavity or recess at 133 in Fig. 3 of the head rear
_ g _
CA 02200674 1997-08-25
face becomes filled-in during rivet head deformation,
i.e., ring-dome flattening, and by shank material
back-filling as the shank column collapses and expansion
occurs. Deformation forces, indicated by the arrows in
Fig. 2 remains concentrated in alignment with the
countersink 114, whereby the head metal is constantly
forcibly urged toward that countersink to prevent
development of clearances. Consistency of complete
filling of recesses 133 in multiple rivets holding the
sheets clamped together is obtained by use of
fine-grained, ductile aluminum alloy, as referred to
below.
As riveting proceeds, the head metal bounded
by head wall 209, and located between dome 132 and
section 122, is typically deformed toward work
counterbore 209 (see Fig. 3) to fill the annular
clearance.
In actual practice, and as regards production
rivets, and for best results, when the dome is flattened
during rivet deformation, the rivet head side wall is
radially expanded and pushes outwardly against the
workpiece counterbore side wall to deform the latter
radially outwardly.
Fig. 3 shows a minimum head diameter (at 209),
maximum counterbore (at 210) relationship, whereby the
rivet head seats forwardly at 114, as shown; and Fig. 4
shows a maximum head diameter (at 209), minimum
counterbore (at 210) relationship, whereby the rivet
head seats rearwardly so that dome 132 protrudes
rearwardly from the work, prior to deformation.
_ g _
CA 02200674 1997-08-25
Upon deformation, counterbore 210 is expanded
radially outwardly by expansion of wall 209, as the dome
is flattened. The desired deformation of the dome 132
will occur during riveting, to maintain the walls 209
and 210 in radial compression and peripheral tension, as
desired. Also, a buck-tail is formed, as described
herein, for clamp-up creation.
In both Figs. 3 and 4, fine-grained aluminum
shank metal is extruded upwardly (see arrow 400) to fill
the recess bounded by the ring dome, during dome
flattening, and the top of the rivet head remains above
(i.e., rearward of) the plane of the work surface 131.
Typically, the rivet metal (which preferably
consists of fine-grained aluminum alloy, for enhancing
metal flow at 400) is softer than the work metal. For
example, the work panel has a tensile strength
substantially in excess of the rivet tensile strength,
for best results. Thus, the rivet and work will expand
and contract at rates to prevent radial gaps during
temperature change.
In a typical example, the head maximum
diameter is within the range .258 to .256 inches; and
the head side wall has an axial length of about .012 to
.042 inches. Also, the side wall length plus the axial
length of the head that tapers toward the shank, is
within the range .022 and .104 inches.
Referring now to Fig. 5, it is like Fig. 3,
but shows elements axially exploded. Clearances are
shown between wall 209 and counterbore 210, as exist
upon rivet insertion (but prior to deformation), and
- 10 -
CA 02200674 1997-08-25
between shank 119a_ and bore 113. Also, merely for
better identification, slight axial separation is shown
between tapered seat 114 and head tapered surface 114
(120° taper angle as seen in Fig. 1), and between convex
corner 130 and concave outer surface 223 of transitional
section 220.
The volumes of the cylindrical section 208,
frusto-conical section 122, and transitional section 220
are controlled, or predetermined, in relation to the
dimensions diameter of the workpiece bore 113, and the
dimensions (axial and radial) of the workpiece
counterbores 114 and 210, such that upon flattening of
the dome upon rivet deformation, the dome has a
flattened surface which lies between limits defined as
about
- flush with the workpiece outer surface
- protruding 0.006 inches from the
workpiece outer surface.
This assures aerodynamic flushness, and is assured by
use of the fine-grained aluminum alloy of the rivet, to
achieve desired metal flow, as described.
Another important aspect lies in defining and
maintaining two radii R1 and RZ, such that RZ is between
95% and 75% of R1, (50-25% difference) where:
- Rl is the radius of concave surface 223
in axial radial planes (surface 223 being
annular)
- RZ is the radius of workpiece convex
surface 130, in axial radial planes,
surface 130 being annular and slidably
- 11 -
. ~ CA 02200674 1997-08-25
engaged by surface 223 upon rivet
deformation.
When these relationships are maintained, along
with taper angularity of surfaces 114 and 122_a as shown,
(surface 114 intersecting surface 130, and surface 122_a
intersecting surface 223), the shear bearing support of
the rivet is optimized, while tension pull-through
capability of the rivet is assured. This advantage is
realized even when installed in the thinnest possible
sheet (i.e., near knife-edge condition), the areas 300
and 301 (Fig. 2) around the rivet head remain constant,
assuring a high degree (40% minimum of the sheet) of
shear bearing area of the sheet.
Fig. 5 also shows the annular crest portion
132 as located between radially inner and outer limits
(see lines 260 and 261 parallel to axis 116) the radial
gap 262 between lines 260 and 261 being less than 25% of
the radial dimension 264 of the dome cross section, the
gap being in alignment with the shank outer surface.
Comparison of Figs. 6_a and 6~ show that during
rivet deformation, head wall 209 moves radially
outwardly (leftwardly) to engage bore wall 210; and wall
209 further displaces wall 210 leftwardly by amount S1,
the final wall positions indicated at 209' and 210'. At
the same time, shank wall 223 moves radially outwardly
(leftward) and engages bore wall 113; and wall 223
further displaces wall 113 leftwardly by approximate
amount S2, the final wall position indicated at 223' and
113'. In actuality, wall 223' extends at an angle a
relative to its initial position 223, wall 223' flaring
- 12 -
. ~ CA 02200674 1997-08-25
in direction 240. As later described, a "buck-tail" is
formed at the shank end portion, gripping the edge of
the hole in the work, so that equal clamping forces are
produced between the buck-tail and the head angular
portion. Further, rivet metal is displaced (see arrow
241) toward the head recess about which the dome 132
extends, in Fig. 6~, to fill that recess, as the ring
dome is flattened, and the flattened top or rearward
surface 403 is maintained above the level of sheet
surface 431. See also head annular portion 432 formed
by the periphery of the head above extending to adjacent
surface 431, maintaining head surface 403 above the
level of 431. As a result, the deformed rivet locks the
work sheets 111 and 112 in clamped-together condition.
See arrows 420 and 421 in Fig. 2.
For best results the rivet is formed from
fine-grained aluminum alloy wire selected from the
following table group, said selected wire having grain
size and physical characteristics, as listed in the
following table:
Shear
Elongation Strength Grain
Size
Alloy & Diameterin in 2 Inches Min. Max. Maximum
Temper Inches Minimum s Ksi Ksi ASTM E:112
2 5 2017-T4 .092 0.565 14 35 41 7
thru
2024-t4 .092 0.565 13 37 N/A 6
thru
2117-T4 .092 0.565 18 26 N/A 5
thru
2219-T62 .092 0.565 12 30 N/A 5
thru
7050-T73 .092 0.565 14 41 46 5
thru
7050-T715 .092 0.565 15 35 41 5
thru
In this regard, grain size number is inversely
related to actual grain size, and is measured in
- 13 -
CA 02200674 1997-08-25
accordance with ASTM E:112. The grain size numbers are
larger than those previously obtainable, whereby smaller
grains are now made possible leading to substantially
increased flowability of metal in the shank to fill the
recess surrounded by the ring dome. This in turn
enables better consistency in deformation of multiple
rivets in such manner as to hold the work sheets in
retained clamp-up condition, i.e., for reduced fretting.
"Elongation" in the table refers to measured
separation of benchmarks for a specimen during a tension
test, to failure. Prior elongation values of up to 11
or 12 are herein exceeded by use of fine-grained
aluminum alloy, enhancing ductility to promote shank
metal flow toward the recess to be filled in.
Therefore, the present rivet metal is characterized by
high elongation. Also, expansion of the shank adjacent
the outer surface of the lower work sheet causes such
gripping engagement with that sheet as to facilitate
production of clamp-up force as the buck-tail is formed.
Fig. 7 views (a)--(e), show a typical example
of deformation of the present rivet. The 120° rivet
configured as shown is inserted into the structure
comprised of two sheets 111 and 112, or metallic
materials of the composition referred to, with the holes
and counterbores prepared within specified tolerance.
The riveting tooling is employed to apply force to the
rivet "ring domed" head 120, and also on the terminal
end 118, simultaneously. Note that the ring dome crest
is spaced at about .010 inches above the work surface
131, in view 7(a).
- 14 -
CA 02200674 1997-08-25
As shown in Fig. 7 (b) , as the squeeze force
increases, the rivet shank 118 begins to swell to form
an annular taper or wedge area at 118b_, under the work
lower surface 112_a. Enlarged extent 118 c_ of the shank
is in axial alignment with the head 120. The ring dome
132 is simultaneously being flattened.
In Fig. 7(b), the dome crest has been
flattened to a spacing of about .008 inches from the
work surface 131; and the bottom surface 132a_ of the
concave recess has been pushed up to a level of about
.003 inches from work upper surface level 131. This
corresponds to backfill of the recess. Also, clamp-up
creation begins, as referred to below. Fig. 7(c) shows
the dome crest level reduced to about .0075 inches from
the surface 131, and the recess bottom surface 132a_
pushed up to a level of about .0055 inches from the work
surface .
With continued squeeze force application, the
tapered shank at 118_d is deformed, as in Fig. 7 (d) to
grippingly or flatly engage at 118c_ the work lower
surface 112_a, about the hole 113, creating compressive
clamping pressure toward the 120° tapered underside of
the head 120. Note that the ring dome crest being
flattened is reduced to a level about .007 inches from
the work surface, and the bottom surface 132_a of the
recess is now elevated to about .0065 inches from that
surf ace .
As more squeeze force is applied, the shank
118 is deformed to form a "buck-tail" shape, adj acent
3 0 the underside 112_a of the work, as seen in Fig . 7 ( a ) .
- 15 -
CA 02200674 1997-08-25
The ring-dome crest and the bottom of the recess are now
at the same spacing, .005 inch, from the work surface,
as shown, whereby the head is now flattened. Such
opposite direction deformation of the ring-dome crest
(down) and the concave recess 132_a (up), which is
facilitated by the fine-grain metallic composition of
the rivet metal, further facilitates desired, consistent
deformation of the rivets to the Fig. 7(e) condition
shown, with retained clamp-up of the work sheets. Such
clamp-up increases fatigue life of the joint, and the
tightly sealed riveted connection inhibits corrosion
development at the work interfaces.
Grain size, for example, is related to average
nominal inches per grain, to grain (edge intercept)
count, for a total of 50 intercepts, and to average
intercept distance, according to the following table:
Minimum Distance
Average NominalAverage InterceptPer Inch For
Grain Size Inches/Grain Distance 50 Intercepts
2 0 5. .0025" .00223" .1115"
5.5 .0020" .00187" .0935"
6 .0018" .00157" .0785"
6.5 .0014" .00132" .0660"
7 .0012" .00111" .0555"
2 5 7.5 .0010" .000940" .0470"
8 .0009" .000787" .03935"
8.5 .0007 .000662" .03310"
9 .0006 .000557" .02785"
30 4.4 RULES
1. Penetration into a grain in the direction
of the test line are scored as half (1/2)
grains.
- 16 -
CA 02200674 1997-08-25
2. Do not count the ends of the test line as
an intercept.
3. A grain extending into the line shall be
counted as one (1) grain.
4. Two (2) or more grain juncture extends
into a line must be counted as one and
one half (1-1/2) grain.
5. Two (2) intercepts with the same grain
shall be counted, total two (2).
Determination of grain size in a sample wire,
from which rivets of the invention are to be formed,
involves for example counting 50 (i.e., a pre-determined
number of) successive grains (at 100 x magnification)
along a straight path crosswise of the end face of a
sheared wire, and determining the length dimension,
i.e., distance occupied by the 50 grains, then dividing
that distance by 50 to determine average intercept
distance. This distance is related to average nominal
inches/grain, and to Grain Size, as referenced herein,
as shown in the above table.
As indicated herein, a sample of wire is
usable for the rivet only, if the determined fine Grain
Size is between 5 and 9, i . a . , the average determined
intercept distance (as determined by counting, above)
lies between .00223 inch and .000557 inch.
It is a further objective of the method of the
invention to enable formation of a larger buck-tail
diameter, as related to rivet initial shank diameter,
during rivet deformation at installation. Such
formation is enabled by use of the fine-grained aluminum
- 17 -
CA 02200674 1997-08-25
alloy described herein. For example, the buck-tail can
now be formed to have a minimum diameter which is at
least 1.4 times the initial undeformed shank diameter,
for a finished rivet. In another example, 7050-T73
alloy is formed to have a minimum buck-tail diameter
which is at least 1.5 times the initial shank diameter.
This compares with a buck-tail diameter about 1.3 time
the initial shank diameter for prior rivet materials.
Large buck-tails facilitate better retained clamp-up,
the benefits of which are described above.
Referring now to Fig. 8, it shows a rivet 118
having a thin barrier material 400 on its surfaces, such
as at 400 on end face 121 of ring dome 121_a, 400b_ on
the head outer wall 209, and at 400 on the
frusto-conical or tapered surface 122_a. The barrier
thickness is typically between .0002 and .002 inches;
and the protective barrier typically consists of a
sealant, or a coating, or a sealant applied over a
coating.
As examples, the coating may consist of
aluminized particles in a carrier, such as a phenolic
resin, baked onto the rivet surfaces at temperatures
between 200° and 450°F., to volatilize the carrier. A
commercial example is TecKote 8-G or HI-COTE 1.
A sealant example is a flexible polysulfide
epoxy rubber in a sprayable solution. A commercial
example is Courtauld's PRC1436GE2.
Fig. 9, shows the barrier material layer 400b_
displaced outwardly during head expansion toward and
- 18 -
CA 02200674 1997-08-25
into the work counterbore wall 210, i.e., into
interstices at that wall.
Fig. 10 is a greatly magnified view, showing
surface roughness 209_a and 210sa at walls 209 and 210,
forming interstices into which the barrier material 400
penetrates, as shown. Note the variable thickness and
jagged configuration of the material 400b_ filling and
sealing the interstices.
Note also that flattening of the dome results
in extrusion of the barrier material to provide an
overlap at 400 extending on the work, adjacent the work
bore edge, with added sealing effect. Barrier layers
400 and 400b_ may desirably extend to that overlap.
Fig. 9 also shows barrier layer 400c_ urged
against the tapered counterbore at 114a_ of the work
sheet 111, to fill interstices. This eliminates the air
gap 410 as formed in prior installations, as per Fig.
11, where no sealant or coating is employed, as in the
present invention.
In Fig. 8, the volume of the dome 121 may
have a value A; the space between the walls 209 and 210
may have a volume B; and the volumes are such that, when
the dome is flattened during deformation, the wall 209
expands into volume A and pushes outwardly against side
wall 210 to deform it outwardly.
Further, the following relationships are
maintained:
h) the ratio B/A being within the range
1.20:1 to 70:1,
- 19 -
CA 02200674 1997-08-25
i) the head end face formed to define a
recess bounded by the ring-shaped dome, and
j) dome flattening is carried out so that
the shear load bearing areas around the expanded rivet
head have thickness which remains at least 40 0 of the
thickness of the workpiece sheet in which the head is
located.
Also, A and B have one of the following two
relationships:
xl A is within the range .0000120 cubic
inches and .000190 cubic inches; and
B is provided to be within the range
.0000125 cubic inches and .00090
cubic inches,
x2 A is within the range .0000013 cubic
inches and .000013 cubic inches; and
wherein B is within the range
.000029 cubic inches and .00088
cubic inches.
In addition, A is provided to be within the
range .0000120 cubic inches and .000190 cubic inches;
and B is provided to be within the range .0000125 cubic
inches and .00090 cubic inches. Typically, the head
maximum diameter is within the range .121 to .521
inches, and the head side wall has an axial length of
about .012 to .042 inches.
The method includes forming the dome to have
an annular crest portion in substantial axial alignment
with the shank outer surface, and the dome radially
outer extent which defines only about half of the dome
- 20 -
CA 02200674 1997-08-25
being located in axially spaced relation to a forward
taper defined by the forwardly tapered frusto-conical
section, the dome crest portion being rearwardly convex
in axial radial planes. The outermost annular extent of
the crest if located approximately in alignment with the
outer surface of the shank.
Both the rivet and wall are metallic, the
rivet metal softer than the wall metal, and the rivet
consists of one of the following:
i) aluminum
ii) aluminum alloy
iii) titanium
iv) titanium alloy
v) CRES alloy.
- 21 -
