Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02218669 1997-10-21
Mo4592C
MD-94-48-AC-C
A PROCESS FOR REDUCING DITHIOCARBAZINATE BUILDUP IN
THE PREPARATION OF METHYL DITHIOCARBAZINATE
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
Field of the Invention:
The present invention relates to an improved process for preparing
methyl dithiocarbazinate. More specifically, the invention relates to an
improved process for improving the yield and/or purity of methyl
dithiocarbazinate.
Brief Description of the Prior Art:
The prior art disclosures of the processes for preparing methyl
dithiocarbazinate are limited by the paucity of information on reported
experimental procedures and the excessive cost of commercial scale
procedures. Laboratory reports present little information on how reaction
temperatures would affect production of undesirable by-products, yield
and purity, impact on waste treatment operations and the like.
Commercial scale procedures are expensive because they involve the
use of expensive reagents and/or expensive techniques such as
separation of intermediate products and recrystallization of the final
product.
Audrieth et al., J. Organic Chem., Vol. 19, pp. 733-741 (1954)
discloses a process for preparing methyl dithiocarbazinate and converting
it to thiocarbohydrazide. The process comprises a dropwise addition of
1.04 moles of carbon disulfide to 1.18 moles of potassium hydroxide and
1.1 moles of 85% hydrazine in 200 mi. of ethanol, in an ice bath. A
heavy yellow oil containing potassium dithiocarbazinate separates during
the addition. The resulting mixture is stirred and chilled and two volumes
CA 02218669 1997-10-21
Mo4592C - 2 -
of ether are added to cause separation of more of the desired product
(potassium dithiocarbazinate).
The oily layer is separated from the ether-alcohol layer and filtered
to remove a small amount of an unidentified solid that is formed. The
clear yellow solution is then dissolved in 300 ml. of water. The resulting
solution is cooled in an ice bath and 1.05 moles of methyl iodide are
added in approximately 10 batches. The reaction vessel is shaken and
cooled alternately after each such addition until the methyl iodide is
consumed. The reaction mixture is allowed to stand for several hours,
being shaken occasionally to permit complete.reaction. The methyl
dithiocarbazinate is collected and recrystallized from ethanol.
Methyl dithiocarbazinate (24.4 gm., 0.2 mole) was dissolved in
200 ml. of absolute ethanol and 18 ml. (0.3 mole of hydrazine) of 85%
hydrazine hydrate was added. The resulting solution was refluxed until
no more solid thiocarbohydrazide precipitated (about 45 minutes). A small
amount of 3-hydrazino-4-amino-5-mercapto-1,2,4-triazole that had formed
was removed as follows. The reaction mixture was chilled, and the
resulting solid product was collected and recrystallized from water
acidified with a few drops of hydrochloric acid.
U.S. Patent 4,696,938 discloses a process for preparing and using
methyl hydrazinecarbodithioate as an intermediate in the preparation of 6-
aryi-pyridine thiosemicarbazones. Methyl dithio-carbazinate is prepared
as follows. Hydrazine hydrate (150 g) is added to a cooled (O C)
solution of potassium hydroxide in water (240 ml.) and 2-propanol (200
ml.). Pre-cooled carbon disulfide (182 ml.) is then added dropwise to the
stirred reaction mixture, while maintaining an internal temperature below
10 C. After the addition is complete, stirring is continued for a further
one hour. Cooled methyl iodide (426 g) is added dropwise over 1'/2
hours. The resulting white precipitate is collected by filtration and
CA 02218669 1997-10-21
Mo4592C -3-
washed with cooled water. The crude product is recrystallized from
methylene chloride.
To form 6-aryl-pyridine thiosemicarbazone, methyl dithiocar-
bazinate is reacted in a suitable solvent such as alcohol. The reaction
product is treated with selenium dioxide in a suitable ethereal solvent
such as tetrahydrofuran or 1,4-dioxane.
S. Losanitch, J. Chem. Soc., Vol. 119, pp. 763-765 (1921)
discloses a process for preparing methyl dithiocarbazinate by first
obtaining ammonium dithiocarbazinate and reacting it with methyl iodide.
The ammonium dithiocarbazinate is obtained as follows. A solution of
hydrazine hydrate in alcohol, containing a large excess of ammonia, is
slowly treated with cooling with the corresponding quantity of carbon
disulfide. The methyl dithiocarbazinate is formed by treating the
ammonium salt in a dilute alcohol solution with methyl iodide.
Sandstr6m et al, Arkiv For Kemi, 4(1952) 297, discloses a process
for preparing ethyldithiocarbazinate. The process involves the separation
of hydrazinium dithiocarbazinate from an ethanol-water mixture and the
reaction of the hydrazinium dithiocarbazinate with ethyl bromide in an
ethanol-water mixture.
U.S. Patent 3,284,482 discloses a process for preparing
chlorobenzyl esters of dithiocarbazinic acid as follows. To a solution
comprising 85% hydrazine, 25% sodium hydroxide and 300 ml. of water
is added carbon disulfide, dropwise at 10 to 15 C over 20 minutes.
External cooling is removed and the reaction mixture is stirred for an hour
at 25 to 30 C. Then, trichlorobenzyl chloride is added in one portion to
the reaction mixture which is stirred for 24 hours at 25 to 30 C to
produce the corresponding trichlorobenzyl dithiocarbazinate. The product
is then extracted with ethyl ether. The ether solution is washed with
water until it becomes neutral, is dried over sodium sulfate, and the ether
is removed in vacuo.
CA 02218669 1997-10-21
Mo4592C - 4 -
British Patent Specification 1,274,521 discloses dithiocarbazinic
ester derivatives by reacting dithiocarbazinic acid esters with an oxo
compound. The dithiocarbazinic acid is prepared by reacting hydrazine
hydrate with carbon disulfide in alcohol medium in the presence of
potassium hydroxide, ammonia or excess hydrazine hydrate.
After isolation, the dithiocarbazinic acid salt is converted into an
ester by an alkylating or aralkylating step. This step is carried out in
water, a mixture of water and alcohol or in alcohol. Alternately, the ester
can be prepared in a single reactor. The alkylating or aralkylating agent is
added to the dithiocarbazinic acid salt solution prepared by the above
method. The alkylating or aralkylating agents disclosed by the patent
are: dimethyl sulfate, diethyl sulfate, allyl chloride, n-butyl iodide, n-
octyl
ester, n-dodecyl bromide, cetyl bromide, benzyl chloride, p-chlorobenzyl
chloride, p-isopropylbenzyl bromide, p-n-butylbenzyl bromide, and alpha-
methylbenzyl chloride.
As would be realized from the foregoing, there is a need for an
economic process, i.e., a more facile and cost efficient process for
preparing methyl dithiocarbazinate. By the present invention, there is
provided such an improved process for preparing methyl dithiocar-
bazinate.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
In accordance with the foregoing, the present invention
encompasses an improved process for preparing methyl dithiocarbazinate
by reacting carbon disulfide and hydrazine to form hydrazinium
dithiocarbazinate, followed by methylating the dithiocarbazinate with
methyl bromide. The improvement comprises conducting the reaction of
the carbon disulfide and the hydrazine in the presence of a non-alcoholic
solvent to reduce dithiocarbazinate buildup on a surface to which it is
exposed. The molar ratio of solvent to carbon disulfide is from about
CA 02218669 1997-10-21
Mo4592C -5-
0.4:1 to about 3:1, and is preferably from about 0.5:1 to about 3:1. Water
is also preferably added.
The amount of solvent significantly exceeds the amount that is
ordinarily employed in the prior art preparation of the hydrazinium
dithiocarbazinate. Typically, the molar ratio of solvent to carbon disulfide
in the prior art processes was 0.3:1 or less. It is relatively easy to
ascertain reduction of surface buildup of dithiocarbazinate, typically, on
the walls of reaction vessels, containers, conduits, or an apparatus
therein. It has been found that about a two fold increase in the amount of
solvent that is ordinarily employed can provide reduction in buildup.
Amounts of solvent in excess of what is required to reduce buildup can
adversely affect recovery of the reaction product or result in undue
solvent stripping. This buildup is most clearly seen in pilot scale or
industrial scale equipment but can be observed in laboratory scale
equipment whose agitation style and intensity closely match industrial
scale equipment. The use of increased solvent also provides the ability
to produce a far more concentrated product slurry than is possible with
water only or with water and lower levels of solvent. In the prior art,
MDTC slurries with 25% or lower concentration were all that could be
handled and transferred on an industrial scale. With the use of increased
levels of solvent, slurries of 30 to 40% MDTC can be handled and
transferred on an industrial scale. This provides a dramatic increase in
the volumetric efficiency of production equipment with the corresponding
reduction in product costs and waste generation.
By this process, one can unexpectedly obtain products of high
purity (up to about 98%) and high yields (up to about 87%) with a 30 to
40% slurry concentration. In contrast, the prior art could not ordinarily
attain product purity higher than 90 to 92% without further purification,
and yields that were at 83% or higher and MDTC slurry concentration of
25% or lower were required for industrial use. Without being bound by
CA 02218669 1997-10-21
Mo4592C - 6 -
any particular theory of the invention, it is believed that this process
effects suspension of the solid product in a form that is easily mixed and
transported. Apparently, the prior art process is unable to effect easy
suspension and transportation of the solid product without excessive
dilution. The invention is described more fully hereunder.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
As afore-stated, the claimed invention relates to an improved
process for preparing methyl dithiocarbazinate by reacting carbon
disulfide with hydrazine in a non-alcoholic solvent to form hydrazinium
dithiocarbazinate. This is followed by methylating the hydrazinium
dithiocarbazinate with methyl bromide to form methyl dithiocarbazinate.
The improvement here comprises reducing buildup of dithiocarbazinate
on the surface of the vessel by providing an increased level of solvent to
reduce the buildup. The increased level of solvent can be added prior to
or after the addition of carbon disulfide.
In the embodiment of the invention, referred to as the "HDTC
process", the invention comprises reacting carbon disulfide with hydrazine
in an effective ratio to form a reaction product containing hyradrazinium
dithiocarbazinate. The resulting product comprising dithiocarbazinate is
reacted with methyl bromide to produce high yields of methyl
dithiocarbazinate.
In preparing the hydrazinium dithiocarbazinate by the HDTC
process, hydrazine typically in the form of hydrazine hydrate, and carbon
disulfide can be reacted in a mole ratio of from about 4:1 to about 2:1
and preferably from about 2:1 to about 2.4:1. The HDTC process can be
represented by the following reaction scheme.
CA 02218669 1997-10-21
M04592C - 7 -
s
II
2 H2N-NH2 + CS2 --- ~ H2N-N~S-+H3N-NH2
I
H
S S
11 11
H2N-N/\ShH3N-NH2 + CH3Br 2b H2N-N/,~\ S-CH3 + H2N-NH3+-Br (I~
H H
HDTC MDTC
It is a distinct feature of the invention that one can harness the
reaction medium to provide an improved process for preparing methyl
dithiocarbazinate. As the reaction medium, one can employ a buildup
reducing amount of a nonaqueous solvent. Preferably, the reaction
mixture also contains water. When used, the molar ratio of water to
carbon disulfide is from about 2:1 to about 10:1 and is preferably from
about 2:1 to about 5:1. Useful non-alcoholic solvents are aprotic
solvents. Illustratively, one can employ an aliphatic or aromatic
hydrocarbon solvent. The aliphatic hydrocarbon can be selected from the
group consisting of alkanes such as pentane, hexane, and heptane. The
aromatic hydrocarbon can be selected from the group consisting of
toluene, benzene and xylenes. Toluene is preferred. The molar ratio of
solvent to carbon disulfide ranges from about 0.4:1 to about 3:1 and
preferably from about 0.5:1 to 3:1. Unlike many prior art processes, the
reaction mixture (which may contain water) does not contain alcoholic
solvents.
The above reactions can be conducted at a temperature of about
0 to 35 C and preferably 5 to 25 C over a period of about 1 to 4 hours
and preferably 1 to 2 hours, at a pH of about 8 to 14 and preferably 9 to
14.
---- - --------
CA 02218669 1997-10-21
Mo4592C - 8 -
The resulting dithiocarbazinate is reacted (methylated) with methyl
bromide. The mole ratio of methyl bromide to dithiocarbazinate can be
from about 1.5 to 1.02:1, and preferably 1.05:1. Typically, methyl
bromide is introduced into the reaction vessel containing the hydrazanium
dithiocarbazinate by bubbling it through. While this reaction can be
conducted in another reaction vessel, it is typically conducted in the same
reaction vessel as used in preparing the dithiocarbazinate. The reaction
medium employed in the methylation reaction is essentially the same as
the reaction medium described above.
The reaction conditions for the preparation of methyl dithiocar-
bazinate can be as follows. The pH range of the reaction mixture can be
about 8 to 14 and preferably 14 to 9, at a temperature of about 0 to 35 C
and preferably 5 to 25 C, for about 0.5 to 3 hours and preferably 1 to 2
hours. The reaction can be conducted without isolating the dithiocar-
bazinate salts. It is also a distinct feature of the invention that the
methylating reaction can be conducted without the use of expensive
reaction catalysts such as sodium iodide. In accordance with this
invention, the methylating reaction consists essentially of reacting the
reaction product containing the dithiocarbazinate with methyl bromide.
The resulting product containing methyl dithiocarbazinate can be
isolated by any convenient means. Illustratively, methyl dithiocar-
bazinate can be isolated as a wet cake by filtering or centrifuging. The
wet cake can be collected on a vacuum filter and washed with water to
remove impurities such as bromide salts. The resulting cake can be
used as such cake or dried by any convenient means. Illustratively, the
cake can be dried by exposing to temperatures that would effect drying
without causing decomposition. More specifically, the cake can be dried
in a vacuum oven, using a nitrogen sparge at a temperature of about 30
to 40 C. Generally, the methyl dithiocarbazinate purity can be up to
about 95% with variation attributable to washing and/or drying steps.
CA 02218669 1997-10-21
Mo4592C - 9 -
As would be realized from the foregoing, methyl dithiocarbazinate
can be obtained without recrystalization of the reaction product containing
the same. It is, therefore, a distinct feature of the invention that methyl
dithiocarbazinate can be prepared without separating the intermediate
dithiocarbazinate from the reaction medium. As such, the invention
encompasses a process for preparing methyl dithiocarbazinate consisting
essentially of reacting carbon disulfide and hydrazine in a non-alcoholic
solvent, followed by methylating the hydrazinium dithiocarbazinate.
By the process of the invention, one obtains high yields of methyl
dithiocarbazinate in high purity without the associated negative of
dithiocarbazinate build-up on the surface of the reaction vessel and with
a significantly more concentrated slurry than previously practical on an
industrial scale. The elimination of the buildup of solids on the reaction
vessel wall solved several problems. The reaction temperature can be
more closely controlled due to improved heat transfer through the
reaction vessel wall. Secondly, the reduction of available
dithiocarbazinate increases the local methyl bromide concentration
beyond desired limits resulting in increased by-product formation and
subsequent lower yield and purity. Also by this process, one can
eliminate the use of undesirable solvents such as ethanol and
methylating agents such as methyl iodide. The process requires no
isolation of intermediate dithiocarbazinate. The advantages of this
invention with particular respect to yield and purity and the ability to
transfer the product slurry for further processing on an industrial scale are
clear when comparing the examples described below.
These and other aspects of the invention are further illustrated but
are not intended to be limited by the following examples in which all parts
and percentages are by weight unless otherwise specified.
CA 02218669 2003-09-11
Mo4592C - 10 -
EXAMPLES
Example 1
Carbon disulfide (38 g, 0.5 mole) was slowly added (with cooling) to a
mixture of toluene (30 mL - i.e., about 0.3 moles), water (72 mL, 4 moles)
and hydrazine monohydrate (50 g, 1.0 moles) at 25 C. The molar ratio of
solvent to carbon disulfide was about 0.6:1. After the completion of the adds,
the reaction was stirred for 1 hour, then methyl bromide gas (52.3 g, 0.55
moles) was bubbled in the mixture over 2 hours. The resulting white slurry
was stirred for an additional 30 minutes at 25 C then cooled to 5 C and
filtered any time during the batch. The batch was very fluid and easy to
transfer from the reactor. Mixing of the batch was easy to perform. Methyl
dithiocarbazinate (yield 87%, purity 98%) was isolated as a white powder.
Example 2 (Comparative)
A batch was made using the above procedure but with no toluene
present. The batch had large quantities of solids deposited on the vessel
wall during the carbon disulfide addition. The batch had a very high viscosity
which made mixing difficult. The batch could not be poured out of the reactor
and had to be scooped out by hand. Yield was 79% and purity was 87%.
Example 3 (Comparative)
A batch was made using the above procedure but with 15 mL of
toluene (i.e., about 0.15 moles) present. The molar ratio of solvent to carbon
disulfide was about 0.3:1. The batch had large quantities of solids deposited
on the vessel wall during the carbon disulfide addition but not as many as
comparative Example 2. The batch had a high viscosity which made mixing
difficult. Yield was 81 % and purity was 88%.
Although the invention has been described in detail in the foregoing
for the purpose of illustration, it is to be understood that such detail is
solely
for that purpose and that variations can be made therein
---- - -------------------- - - - ------
CA 02218669 1997-10-21
Mo4592C - 11 -
by those skilled in the art without departing from the spirit and scope of
the invention except as it may be limited by the claims.
