Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02242643 l998-07-09
WO97/27715 PCT/SE96/00111
METHOD FOR DENSIFYING A TRANS~~ ~K AND R~1V~K
NETWORK FOR MOBILE TELEPHONY
.
The present invention relates to a method for densifying a
transmitter and receiver network for mobile telephony.
Although the present invention can be applied to different
types of mo~ile telephone systems, it will be described in
the followin~ with respect to a GSM mobile telephone system.
The capacity of a mobile telephone system is restricted by
interferences between different transmitter and receiver
units. Each transmitter and receiver unit includes an antenna
~or transmitting and receiving signals to and from a mobile
telephone. Communication is effected on different predeter-
mined frequencies, i.e. channels.
Two different types o~ interference must be taken into
account when planning an antenna network, particularly in
municipal en~ironments. Interference between two channels on
one and the same frequency is one type of interference. In
the case of the GSM system, this type of interference means
that the carrier signal mus$ be stronger than the interfer-
ence signal ~y more than 9 dB. When this criterion is not
~ulfilled, speech ~uality is poor and there is a risk of the
call being lost, i.e. broken-off.
The other type of interference is caused by the carrier
s~gnal bein~ disturbed by a closely adjacent channel. The
di~ferent permitted channels are numbered in the GSM system.
For instanc~, channel 72 may be disturbed by either channel
71 or 73. In the case of this type of interference, the
~arrier signal must not be weaker than a closely adjacent
channel by more than 9 dB in the GSM system.
~hen planning a network of antennas operating on different
channels~ it is necessary to take the aforesaid interferences
CA 02242643 lss8-07-o9
WO97127715 PCT/S~96/00111
into account. This applies primarily to municipal environ-
ments, in which the antennas are placed relatively close
together so as to make achievable a high traffic intensity
with regard to the number of simultaneous calls.
There are a number o~ di~erent accepted models on which a
networ~ can be based. The majority of these models include
~o-called three-sector sites, ~-~n;ng that a base station is
equipped with three directional antennas, normally 60-degree
antennas, the directions of which are mutually spaced by 120
degrees. Each antenna is supplied with one or more channels
and forms a so-called geographic cell. The antennas belonging
to a base station are supplied with different frequencies.
The base stations are positioned in accordance with a
pattern f in which the cells form an hexagonal configuration.
Which channels are transmitted in which antennas is deter-
mined by the ~requency pattern chosen.
A typical frequency pattern is a 4/12-pattern. In this case,
all available frequencies are used once on four base stations
including twelve cells. Positioning of the base stations and
the cell ~requencies are repeated in a repetitive pattern
with the cells ~orming said hexagonal configuration, so that
each cell that has one particular frequency will be spaced
as ~ar as possible from an ad~acent cell that has the same
~requency. In other words, this requires at least twelve
channels are needed to obtain a 4/12-pattern with one channel
per cell. Each cell can be supplied with two channels,
provided that twenty-four channels are available.
3~
When capacity is deficient, a denser frequency pattern can
be chosen. One such frequency pattern is a 3/9-pattern,
meaning that all available ~requencies have been used once
on three base stations which include nine cells. Thus, in
order to increase capacity in comparison with a 4/l2-pattern
with twenty-four channels, twenty-seven channels are used
with each cell being equipped with three channels. There is
CA 02242643 l998-07-os
WO97/27715 PCT/SE96/00111
a great deal of uncertainty with regard to the function of
a 3/s-pattern, because of the serious risk that interference
problems will occur with subsequent poor speech quality.
A further pattern, namely a 2/12-pattern, has been described.
In this pattern, each base station has six sectors and the
channels end up in accordance with a given pattern. The 2/12-
pattern is highly prone to interference problems.
When needing to increase the capacity of a mobile network,
a number of dif~erent measures can be taken. The first step
in this regard is to add a channel, provided that further
channels are available. In the case of a 4/12-pattern, the
access to thirty-six channels would mean that three channels
can be used with each cell.
Provided that twenty-four channels are used in a 4/12-
pattern, capacity can be increased by switching to a 3/9-
pattern without needing to build new base stations. A 3/9-
pattern~ which requires twenty-seven channels, cannot be used
to the full when only twenty-four channèls are available.
However, this means that the ~requencies are repeated more
fre~uently, which leads to quality impairment.
Another ~ethod employed in this regard involves the use of
microcells. Microcells are small base stations of limited
range, placed on the walls of buildings for instance, about
5-~o metres above street level. A large number of microcells
is a~le to relieve a superordinate network, i.e. the standard
base s~ations. One drawback with microcells is that they
c~ver only a small area, which results in a variation in
signal strength on the part o~ a user who moves quickly
between the cells, since large variations in signal strength
occur when turning round street corners. Another drawback
resides in the cost o~ each microcell. The indoor coverage
a~orded by a microcell is also poor.
CA 02242643 1998-07-09
WO9712771~ PCTtSE96/00111
The present invention solves the problem of markedly increas-
ing the capacity of the network within a desired geographical
area, with a limited number of available channels.
The present invention thus relates to a method for densifying
a transmitter and receiver network for mobile telephony, said
network being comprised of base stations which each have
three cells whose directions are mutually spaced by 120
degrees, wherein a base station belonging to the three cells
operates on mutually different channels, i.e. frequencies,
wherein at least four different base stations have mutually
different frequency-sets in the cells, so that each of said
cells the ~our base stations operates at different frequen-
cies, wherein base stations are so placed in relation to each
other that the cells form an hexagonal pattern with base
stations of different frequency-sets being placed in a
repetitive pattern, i.e. a so-called 4/12-fre~uency pattern,
wherein base stations are placed generally equidistantly from
one another along two or more generally parallel and straight
lines, wherein each alternate base station in a first line
has a given first frequency-set and each other base station
has a given second frequency-set, wherein each alternate base
station has a gi~en third frequency-set along a second line
and each other base station has a given fourth frequency-set
along said second line, wherein by virtue of the hexagonal
pattern ~he base stations along one line are displaced in
relation to the base stations on an adjacent line by a
distance corresponding generally to half the distance between
two base stations lying along one and the same line, and
3~ wherein the method is characterized in that a first densifi-
cation is achieved by causing a centre base station that has
a first frequency-set and is located in a generally rhomboi-
dal pa~tern whose corners consist in the four base stations
that are located nearest the centre base station and have
mutually the same fre~uency-set, i.e. a second frequency-set,
to change its fre~uency-set to the same fre~uency-set as said
base stations located in the corners o~ said rhomboidal
~ tv SHEEr ~ t)
;
CA 02242643 1998-07-09
WO97J~7715 PCT/SE96100111
pattern; ~y arranging further base stations inwardly of the
confines of said rhomboidal pattern; and selecting the
frequency-sets of respective further base stations so that
the frequency or frequencies of their cells will deviate from
the frequency or frequencies of the cells of the nearest base
stations.
The invention will now be described in more detail with
reference to exemplifying embodiments thereof and also with
reference to the accompanying drawings, in which
Figure 1 illustrates a cell structure according to a 4/12-
pattern;
Figure 2 illustrates part of the cell structure in Figure 1
in larger scale, in which densification is effected in a
first stage in accordance with the invention; and
Figure 3 illustrates part of the cell structure in Figure 1
in larger scale, in which densification is effected in a
first and a second stage in accordance with the invention.
Figure 1 illustrates a conventional 4/12-pattern of the
aforesaid ~ind. The reference numeral 1 identifies a base
sta~ion, each of which is surrounded by three hexagonal cells
2, 3, 4. The cells thus form the aforesaid hexagonal pattern.
The numerals 1 to 12 shown in the centres of the different
cells refe~ to the channel group, or ~requency-set, transmit-
ted in respective cells. Each channel group may consist of
one freq~ency or of two or more frequencies, depending on the
number of frequencies available to the net operator.
~he present invention relates to such a network for mobile
telephony. The network is thus comprised of a large number
of ~ase stations 1, each having three cells 2, 3, 4, the
directions of which are mutually spaced by 120 degrees,
wherein belonging to a base station the three cells operate
CA 02242643 1998-07-09
WO9712771~ PCT/SE96/00111
on mutually different channels, i.e. frequencies. The networ~
includes at least four dif~erent base stations with cells
that have mutually different frequency-sets in the cells, so
that each of the cells o~ the four base stations will operate
- on a frequency that is different to the others. The base
stations l are positioned relative to one another such that
the cells 2, 3, 4 in the networ~ form an hexagonal pattern
with base stations having different fre~uency-sets being
placed in a repetitive pattern, i.e. a so-called 4/12-
frequency pattern.
The base stations are placed generally equidistantly from oneanother along two or more generally parallel and straight
lines. guch lines are referenced 5 and 6 in Figure l. Each
alternate base station along the first line 5 has a given
first frequency-set and each other base station along said
line has a given second fre~uency-set. Each alternate base
station along the second line 6 has a given third frequency-
set and each other base station has a given fourth frequency-
set. As a result of the hexagonal pattern, the base stationsthat lie on a ~irst line 5 are displaced in the longitudinal
direction of the line in relation to the base stations on an
adjacent second line 6 by a distance which corresponds
essentially to half the distance between two base stations
that lie on one and the same line.
It has been said in the aforegoing that the base stations are
spaced generally equidistant from one another along two or
more essentially parallel and straight lines. It has also
bern said that the mutual displacement of base stations along
ad~acent lines corresponds essentially to half the distance
between two base stations that are located on one and the
same line. Figure l illustrates an ideal 4/12-pattern. In
practice, a base station consists of a mast which carries
antennas. It will be understood that it can be di~icult, or
quite impossible, particularly in densely built-up areas, to
CA 02242643 1998-07-09
WO 97~!7715 PCT/SE96/~)0111
erect the base stations in an ideal pattern, due to inacces-
sibility to buildings and the lack of ground on which to
place the base stations. The positions of the base stations
in a virtual network will therefore differ more or less from
the ideal positions shown in Figure 1.
According to the invention, a first densification of the
network is achieved by causing a centre base station 10
having a first frequency-set G and located in a generally
rhomboidal pattern 7 whose corners consist in the four ~ase
stations 11-14 that are located nearest the centre base
station and that have mutually the same second frequency-set
R to change its frequency-set G to the same frequency-set R
as that of the base stations 11-14 at the corners of said
rhomboidal pattern.
The four different frequency sets of the base stations are
referenced G, R, B and S in Figure 1. In addition to base
stations having the frequency-set R and located in the
corners of the rhom~oidal pattern, base stations 23-26 are
also found on respective pairs of opposite sides of the
rhom~oid. These have the frequency-sets S and B respectively.
Nat~ally, each rhomboid in the 4/12-pattern formed by base
stations that have mutually the same frequency-set can be
chosen to densify the network within the rhomboid.
According to the invention, further base stations 15-22 are
arranged within the rhomboid 7; see Figure Z. Figure 2 shows
the rhomboid of Figure 1 in larger scale. The frequency-sets
G, R/ B and S of respective further base stations 15-22 are
selected so that the frequency or frequencies of their
dif~erent cells will differ from the frequency or frequencies
of the cells of the base stations nearest thereto.
It has surprisingly been found that a 4/12-network can be
densified in this way without incurring the interference
CA 02242643 l998-07-09
W097~7715 PCT/SE96/00111
problems mentioned in the introduction. By changing the
frequency-set of the centre base station 10 to the fre~uency-
set of the base stations located in respective corners o~ the
rhomboid, it is possible to choose the frequency-sets for the
further base stations which differ from the frequency-set of
the centre base station 10 and the corner base stations 11-14
and which dif~er from the nearest base stations 15-26,
including the further base stations 15-22.
In speech communication, the cell of each base station will
cover a geographic area which is smaller than the area
covered by each original cell, within which area the base
station concerned will be the strongest base station and
dominate ~ver the cells of surrounding lying base stations.
Th~s, as a result of this densification, a larger number of
~ase stations, and therewith cells, will be available for
communication within the densified area.
The mutual positions of the further base stations and their
positions in relation to the original base stations is not
abso~utely critical, and can be varied. The number of further
base stations can also be varied.
According to another preferred embodiment of the invention,
however, the further base stations 15-22 are eight in number.
The further base stations 15-22 are arranged within the
rhomboid 7 in a rhomboidal pattern which is concentrical with
the rhomboid 7 and which has a side length which is essen-
tially half of the side length of the larger rhomboid. Thus,in Figure 2, the base stations 15, 17, 19 and 21 form the
concentrical smaller rhomboid.
According to this embodiment, the frequency-set of respective
further base stations 15-22 in the concentrical rhomboidal
pattern is the same as the fre~uency-sets in a rhomboid
formed by the original base stations, this rhomboid being
CA 02242643 l998-07-09
WO 97/2771~i PCT/~,CJ'~
displaced parallel with the first-mentioned rhomboid 7 and
having a centre base station which has said second frequency-
set, namely the frequency-set R that the centre base station
has. Such a rhomboid is formed, for instance, by the original
base stations 10, 36-38; see Figure 1. All of these base
stations have originally the frequency-set G.
In ~he case of this embodiment, the smaller rhomboid is
orientated so that the additional base stations 15, 17, 19
and 21 in the corners of the smaller rhomboid have the first
frequency-set, i.e. the freq~ency-set G that the base station
10 had originally.
A typical distance between the original base stations is
about 1,000 metres. As a result of the aforedescribed
densification, the distance between the base stations in the
densified area will be about 500 metres.
Figure 3 illustrates a highly preferred embodiment of the
invention in which the network is further condensed or
densified. Figure 3 illustrates the region concerned in
Figure 2. This further densification around the first-
mentioned centre base station 10 is achieved by causing the
base station to revert back to its original first frequency-
set G. In addition, a further eight base stations 28-35 are
arranged inwardly of the aforesaid smaller rhomboid, i.e. the
rhomboid defined by the base stations 15, 17, 19 and 21. This
further densification of the network is achieved in accor-
dance with the same principles as those applied with the
first densification.
The further densification is thus achieved in a rhomboidal
pattern which is concentrical wlth the smaller rhomboid and
which thus becomes the smallest rhomboid. The smallest
concentrical rhomhoid has a side length which is essentially
half the side length of said smaller rhomboid.
CA 02242643 1998-07-09
WO 97/2~71~ PCT/~;I!.'-.';/~.~Ill
The frequency-set of respective additional base stations
placed in the smallest concentrical rhomboidal pattern is the
same as the frequency-sets in a rhomboid containing the
original base stations, this rhomboid being displaced
parallel with, or coinciding with, the first mentioned
rhomboid 7 and having a centre base station with the first
frequency-set G.
The smallest rhomboid is orientated so that the additional
base stations 28, 30, 32 and 34 in the corners of the
smallest rhomboid have said second frequency-set R.
It has surprisingly been found that this high degree of
densification also avoids the interference problems mentioned
in the introduction, despite the fact that the distance
between the additional base stations 15-21 and 28-35 in the
aforedescribed example is as short as about 250 metres.
According to one preferred embodiment of the invention, the
centre base station and the additional base stations grouped
around the centre base station have a transmission power
which is essentially the same as the transmission power of
remaining base sta~ions. This means that interferences
between two mutually ad~acent base stations that have the
same ~requency-set will be effectively avoided because each
cell is strong within its own area. The network will also
provide highly ef~ective indoor coverage in built-up munici-
pal areas.
According to one preferred embodiment of the invention,
densification in an area outside and adjacent to the first-
mentioned rhomboid 7, extending between the original base
stations 11-14, is achieved in the same way as that described
above inwardly of a rhomboid of the same size as and border-
ing on the first-mentioned rhomboid. Naturally, the network
in any area whatsoever located outside the first-mentioned
rhom~oid can be made denser in the aforesaid manner.
CA 02242643 1998-07-09
WO97~27715 PCT/SE96/00111
It has been said in the aforegoing that the relative posi-
tions of the base stations with regard to each other and with
q regard to the original base stations can be varied and that
the number of further base stations can also be varied.
However, the aforedescribed preferred embodiments are very
important, since a first densification of the network and
also a second densification of the network in accordance with
the aforegoing provides a highly dense network in which
interference problems are avoided.
According to one preferred embodiment of the invention, one
or more of the centre base station and the further base
stations grouped therearound and also other base stations are
caused to transmit and receive signals on tilted antennas
where the lobe points obliquely downwards, so as to limit the
range of respective ant~nn~.
This embodiment can be applied when disturbances would
otherwise occur, for instance due to two cells being too
close together because the antennas cannot be positioned in
any other way. For instance, it may be difficult to choose
optimal positions for the base stations in a densely built-up
area.
The embodiment can also be used in those instances when one
or two of the additional base stations cannot be placed
anywhere at all, for instance due to the presence of water-
ways in municipal built-up areas.
The densification of an existing network according to a 4/12-
pattern has been described in the a~oregoing. It will be
obvious, however, that the inventive method can ~e applied
equally as well to densify conventional 4/12-patterns when
bui~ding a completely new network.
CA 02242643 1998-07-09
WO97/27715 PCT/SE96/00111
Although the invention has been described above with refer-
ence to a number of exemplifying embodiments thereof, it will
be understood that modifications can be made with respect to
the transmission strength of individual base stations or
cells and with regard to their positions forced by practical
circumstances.
The invention shall not therefore be considered limited to
the aforedescribed and illustrated embodiments thereof r since
variations and modifications can be made within the scope of
the following Claims.
