Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02280840 1999-08-09
WO 98/37813 PCT/US98/03535
1
FABRIC PROSTHESIS AND PROCESS FOR PREPARING THE SAME
Technical Field
The present invention relates to a fabric prosthesis
and a process for making and using the same. More
particularly, the present invention relates to an
unexpectedly supple polypropylene monofilament mesh of
desirable properties such as superior strength and handling
as compared to surgical meshes of equal or greater thickness
and weight, and a process for making the same.
Background Art
Fabric prosthetic devices for use in surgical
procedures are disclosed in U.S. Patent Nos. 2,671,44;
3,054,406; 3,124,136; 3,276,448; 4,347,847; 4,452,245;
4,633,873; 4,655,221; 4,838,884; 5,002,551; 5,116,357;
4,147,374; 5,292,328; 5,368,602; 5,297,331; 5,425,740 and
5,433,996. Known types of mesh or fabric devices range from
meshes constructed from resins, such as those disclosed in
U.S. Patent Nos. 2,671,444 and 3,124,136, to surgical meshes
constructed of yarns or multifilament threads, such as that
disclosed in U.S. Patent No. 5,292,328. Most of the prior
art surgical mesh or fabric prosthetic devices were designed
for use in a wide variety of internal surgical procedures,
such as for example pressure encapsulation and repair of
traumatically damaged organs such as the spleen, liver or
kidney, or the repair of abdominal or chest wall defects,
hernias, urinary tract defects or the like.
It is believed that although nonabsorbable prosthetic
meshes constructed from polypropylene monofilament induces a
CA 02280840 1999-08-09
WO 98/37813 PCT/US98/03535
2
good fibroblastic response to ensure prompt fixation and
integration with tissue at the surgical repair site, it has
a poor hand and is too stiff and cumbersome for some
surgical procedures. A need thereby exists for a
polypropylene monofilament mesh which induces good
fibroblastic response to ensure prompt fixation and
integration with tissue at the surgical repair site which it
is known to do and is supple enough to be easily manipulated
for use in any surgical procedure routinely requiring such a
device including giant prosthetic reinforcement of the
visceral sac.
Disclosure of Invention
The fabric prosthesis of the present invention is
generally comprised of a supple, flexible mesh material
which is non-ravelling when cut. The fabric is made of
tricot knit monofilament polypropylene which is thinner and
lighter in weight than current commercially available
products while possessing superior strength and suppleness.
Prior to the present invention, a "supple" monofilament
polypropylene mesh was not considered possible as stated in
U.S. Patent No. 5,292,328 incorporated herein by reference.
However, the surprising suppleness of the subject fabric,
obtained through the unique process of the present invention
allows for greater control, conformability and suturability
of the mesh in the variety of surgical procedures which
require such devices.
The process for producing the subject supple
monofilament polypropylene mesh eliminates the filament
annealing process step, allows for the doubling of the
____ _._ . T
CA 02280840 1999-08-09
WO 98/37813 PCT/US98/03535
3
typical filament production line speed without compromising
quality and provides for the use of a water soluble spin
finish each of which increases the rate of production and
decreases associated costs.
Accordingly, it is an object of the present invention
to provide a process which yields a surgical prosthetic
device which is of lower weight and thickness than currently
marketed devices with increased strength and suppleness for
various internal surgical uses such as those noted above.
It is a further object to provide a monofilament
polypropylene mesh which induces a good fibroblastic
response and is supple and easily manipulated.
It is a further object of the present invention to
provide a process for making the surgical prosthetic device
of the present invention which requires less time to produce
and is more economically manufactured.
It is a still further object of the present invention
to provide a surgical prosthetic device produced through a
process which eliminates the need for a filament annealing
process.
Still other objects, features and advantages of the
present invention shall become apparent in view of the
following detailed description when considered in connection
with the accompanying example.
Models) for Carrying Out the Invention
The surgical mesh of the present invention is generally
comprised of a thin, flexible monofilament polypropylene
mesh material having any one of a variety of different
configurations depending on the intended application of the
CA 02280840 19'99-08-09
WO 98/37813 PCT/US98/03535
4
mesh in a surgical procedure. The dimensions of the mesh are
only limited by the practical size for its intended surgical
use. Dimensions within the range of 1/2 x 3 inches to 12 x
16 inches with a thickness of .3 to .8 mm but preferably
about .6 mm has been found desirable for surgical handling
ease. A weight within the range of 2.0 to 4.0 ounces but
most preferably 3.0 ounces per square yard is desired for
adequate strength and manageability. A drawing which
describes the shape and/or geometric configuration of the
subject mesh or fabric is not necessary for understanding
the present invention. Any person skilled in the art of mesh
or fabric will know how to manufacture and how to use the
subject invention by reading this specification, generally,
and the example, specifically. The surgical mesh of the
present invention comprises tricot l~nitted polypropylene
monofilament indicated for use in the repair of soft tissue
defects, e.g., hernia repair, chest wall reconstruction or
like procedures as noted briefly above requiring the
addition of a reinforcing or bridging material.
The subject surgical mesh is produced from
polypropylene monofilament fibers approximately 0.003 to
0.008 inches in diameter but preferably approximately 0.006
inches (6 mil or 0.152 mm) in diameter to achieve the
desired strength, i.e., a ball burst load of 60 to 75 kgf.
In general, the polypropylene monofilament fibers used
in the production of the subject surgical mesh are prepared
as known to those skilled in the art and disclosed in U.S.
Patent Nos. 3,630,205, 4,911,165 and 5,217,485 each
incorporated herein by reference. More specifically, the
__ ..__._. _.......___ ._~._...__.~ _.__.__
CA 02280840 1999-08-09
WO 98/37813 PCT/US98/03535
polypropylene monofilament fibers used in the present mesh
are produced by a process comprising the steps of:
a) extruding polypropylene through one or more
orifices;
5 b) quenching the polypropylene rapidly in a water bath
to produce one or more filaments;
c) drawing the filament at least once;
d) applying a water soluble spin finish; and
e) collecting on a spool.
In carrying out the process of producing the mesh of
the present invention, the preferred polypropylene resin for
filament production is a surgical suture grade resin having
an isotactic index of 97 (97% isotactic) or above but
preferably having an isotactic index of 98 or 99 (98% or 99%
isotactic), and a melt flow rate of from about 3.5 to 4.5
gms/10 min. but preferably 4 gms/10 min. to achieve a
desirable production viscosity. The polypropylene resin
extruded as a filament has a denier between 100 and 200 but
preferably 150 to achieve desirable strength and handling
characteristics.
The described surgical suture grade resin is extruded
at a flat temperature of approximately 225°C through at
least one orifice and rapidly quenched in a water bath of
approximately 25°C. The filament produced is drawn at least
once but most preferably twice to align the polymer
molecules to improve physical characteristics and enhance
the overall quality thereof. The first drawing is carried
out at a temperature of approximately 120°C at a draw ratio
of approximately 5.93:1. The second drawing is carried out
at a temperature of approximately 130°C at a draw ratio of
CA 02280840 1999-08-09
WO 98/37813 PCT/US98/03535
6
approximately 1.43:1. It was found that the two draws as
described herein allowed the output line speed to be
increased from 185 feet per minute to 370 feet per minute
without void formation or increased frays.
A water soluble spin finish is then applied to the
extruded and drawn filament. Suitable spin finish lubricants
may be selected from the group consisting of water-soluble
low molecular weight, i.e., approximately 200 to 10,000
molecular weight, CZ_~ polyalkyl glycol coatings. The
preferred spin finish is polyethylene glycol) 400
monopelargonate lubricant which is easily removed in water
and has favorable toxicology. Another water soluble
lubricant which can be implemented in the present invention
is Lurol'° manufactured by Goulston Technologies but the same
is not preferred. The selected spin finish is preferably
applied to the polypropylene filament between the last draw
godget and the spool winder heads which are used to wind the
filament onto collection spools. One method of applying the
finish lubricant includes the use of a cellulose sponge with
half depth slits therein wetted with a 50:50 volume: volume
solution of the finish lubricant in water. The sponge is
wetted with the solution by pouring the same over the
sponge. The filaments are then passed through the sponge
slits to lubricate the filaments.
An alternate method of lubricating the filament
includes the use of a 6 inch aluminum cylinder combined with
a drive system to cause the cylinder to rotate about its
axis through a finish reservoir filled with lubricant. The
reservoir is filled with 100% finish which coats the
_.__.~..~_~~_~_~._ . __._.___._ .. ~
CA 02280840 1999-08-09
WO 98/37813 PCT/US98/03535
7
cylinder upon rotation thereof through the reservoir. Each
filament is passed over the coated cylinder surface at about
a 5 or 10 percent contact angle. A cylinder roll speed of
approximately 1 revolution per minute has been found to
provide sufficient lubricant on the fiber for ease in the
subsequent knitting thereof.
Following the lubrication of the filament, the mesh of
the present invention can be fabricated from the non-
annealed filament employing known and conventional knitting
apparatus and techniques. Preferably, the subject mesh is
manufactured using a tricot knitting machine with single bar
action and 14 needles per inch. Optionally, an extra
filament of monofilament polypropylene can be used in the
fabric selvages in accordance with methods known to those
skilled the art to simplify the knitting process and to
improve the selvage appearance.
Once the polypropylene monofilament has been knitted
into the desired mesh, the spin finish is removed using
water. A standard washing machine may be used to wash the
mesh and optionally a detergent and/or defoamer may be used.
The wash water temperature is preferably approximately 130°F
with a cold water rinse to minimize shrinkage.
The mesh after washed and air dried is heat set at
145°C for 10 minutes to eliminate curling and set the
filaments. Increasing the temperature to 150°C yielded
decreases in the physical properties of the mesh and lower
temperatures resulted in filaments being "set" to a lesser
degree and a coarser "hand" or feel to the fabric.
The heat set mesh may be cut to the desired dimensions
using any suitable cutting technique such as but not limited
CA 02280840 19'99-08-09
WO 98/37813 PCT/US98/03535
8
to hot knife, laser or ultrasonic knife. Preferably, the
mesh is cut using a hot knife for economical considerations
to fuse the edges and thereby trap any loose cut ends.
The mesh may be packaged using any suitable means and
materials known in the art. The preferred packaging is a
polyethylene terphthalate film fused to non-woven
polyethylene terphthate web coated with polyethylene resin
to form a pouch with an optional interior paper folder. The
folder is advantageous for positioning the mesh for easy
extraction during a surgical procedure.
Any suitable sterilization technique known to those
skilled in the art may be used such as steam autoclaving,
pre-vacuum steam autoclaving or ethylene oxide. However,
ethylene oxide sterilization is preferred for ease and
effectiveness.
It can also be advantageous to provide the surgical
mesh of the present invention with a clearly visible color
pattern such as for example in the form of a grid of two
differently colored filaments. Such a pattern can facilitate
proper orientation of the mesh at the surgical repair site.
The polypropylene monofilament mesh of the present
invention is further described in the following example.
EXAMPLE:
The conditions of melt spinning the polypropylene
monofilament fiber for the subject surgical mesh and the
specific properties of the mesh are set forth in the
following Tables 1 through 4:
___.~~_~.-_ ..~._.. -.._ _ . T
CA 02280840 1999-08-09
WO 98/37813 PCT/US98/03535
9
TABLE l: Polypropylene Monofilament Manufacturing Conditions
Operating Conditions
Component Conditions Component Conditions
Extruder Barrel Temp., 225"C Spinneret Pressure, 1000-2500
"C psi
Hlock Temp. , "C 225"C First Draw Oven, "C 120"C
Clamp Temp. , "C 225"C Draw Ratio 5. 93
Spinneret Temp. , "C 225"C Second Draw Oven, 130"C
"C
No. of Spinneret Orifices 8 Draw Ratio 1.43
Diameter of Spinneret .02 inch
1 0 Orifices, inch
TABLE 2: Filament Properties
Denier 150
Straight Pull
Strength, kgf 1.2 - 2.0
1 5 Breaking Elongation, percent 18-27
Young's Modulus, kpsi 740-950
TABLE 3: Knitting Conditions
Knitting Machine: 14 gauge 1-bar
tricot Knitter
2 0 Length of Filament/Rack, inches 79-86
Length of Mesh/Rack, inches 12-14
TABLE 4: Monofilament Polypropylene Surgical Mesh
Properties
Weight, oz./sq. yd. 2.88
2 5 Thickness, mm .59
Ball Burst Load, kgf 70.9
Hall Burst Displacement, inches .48
The unique process of the present invention described
in detail herein unexpectedly produces a polypropylene
30 monofilament surgical mesh of improved physical properties,
such as increased suppleness and strength. The present mesh
is characterized by having a compliancy similar to that of a
polyester mesh or multifilament mesh so as to be suitable
for use as a prosthetic device in hernioplasty procedures
35 and in particular suitable as a prosthetic device for giant
prosthetic reinforcement of the visceral sac.
While the present invention has been described in
detail herein, it will be manifest to those skilled in the
art that various modifications and variations of the
CA 02280840 19'99-08-09
WO 98/37813 PCT/US98/03535
invention may be constructed without departing from the
spirit and scope of the underlying inventive concept and
that the same is not limited to the particular forms herein
described except insofar as indicated by the scope of the
5 appended claims.
