Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02297838 2000-01-20
~ . ,' .
. . m - s . . = r s ~ a i
- r t s =
' = .. . + = e = = a " Method of manufacturing phosphine compound
The present invention relates to a phosphine compound which is useful as a
component
of a catalyst system which may be used in the carbonylation of olefins, and in
particular
to a method of manufacturing such phosphine compounds.
WO 96/19434 discloses a process for the carbonylation of ethylene and a
catalyst
system for use therein. The catalyst system described in that document
comprises a
bidentate phosphine ligand of general formula (R3 C)2P-L'-X-L2-P-(C-R3)2 , in
which each
R is independently a pendant, optionally substituted, organic group through
which the
group is linked to tertiary carbon atom C; L', LZ are independently a linking
group
selected from an optionally substituted lower alkylene chain connecting the
respective
phosphorous atom to the group X and X is a bridging group comprising an
optionally
substituted aryl moiety to which the phosphorous atoms are linked on available
adjacent
carbon atoms; and a Group VIII metal or compound thereof. One example of such
a
bidentate phosphine ligand is bis (di tbutyl phosphino)-o-xylene.
Such catalysts may be made by mixing the phosphine ligand with a suitable
source of
palladium such as palladium acetate. WO 96/19434 describes the preparation of
one
form of the ligand via the phosphonium salt produced from the reaction of the
appropriate
secondary phosphine with the corresponding aromatic dihalide. In the preferred
form of
the phosphine Iigand in WO 96/19434, R is a lower alkyl group, in particular
methyl. A
problem with manufacturing this ligand by the route described is that the
secondary
phosphine which is used (e.g. di tbutyl phosphine) is toxic, highly reactive,
smelly and
flammable. We have also found that the reaction is low yielding and converts
some of
the di 'butyl phosphine to a non-reclaimable waste product which must be
disposed of.
Zvezdina et al (VINITI 3581 -80, Chemical Abstracts Vol 96 (1992) 52409)
describe a
method of forming 1,2-ethynediylbis[bis(1-methylethyl)phosphine] by reaction
of
dibromoethynyldimagnesium with di-isopropyl chlorophosphine to produce ligands
for
hydroformylation catalysts.
A paper by M.F. Lappert & T.R. Martin (J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans., 1982
p1952)
describes the preparation of various metallocyclic compounds via a di-Grignard
synthesis
route.
CA 02297838 2006-01-27
1a
We have now found that phosphine ligands of the type described in WO 96/19434
may
be prepared by a high yielding route using more benign materials which produce
less
waste product than the route described in WO 96/19434.
CA 02297838 2000-01-20
WO 99/09040 PCT/GB98/02392
2
According to the invention, a method of manufacturing a compound of general
formula
(R3-C)2P-L'-X-L2-P-(C-R,)Z (I), in which each R is independently a pendant,
optionally
substituted, organic group through which the group is linked to tertiary
carbon atom C; L',
L2 are independently a linking group selected from an optionally substituted
lower alkylene
chain connecting the respective phosphorous atom to the group X and X is a
bridging
group comprising an optionally substituted aryl moiety to which the
phosphorous atoms
are linked on available adjacent carbon atoms comprises the steps of
i) reacting together a compound of formula A-L'-X-LZ-A (II), in which A is a
halogen atom,
with a metal M in a suitable solvent to form an intermediate compound of
formula
A-M-L'-X-Lz-M-A (III),
ii) reacting said intermediate compound (III) with a compound of formula (R3
C)zP-A' (IV),
where A' is a halogen atom which may be the same as or different from A, to
form said
compound (I).
The compound (I) of general formula (R; C)zP-L'-X-LZ-P-(C-R3)2 may be useful
as a
component of a catalyst compound. In particular WO 96/19434 describes the use
of such
compounds as bidentate ligands which, when used together with a Group VIII
metal such
as palladium, are effective catalysts for the carbonylation of olefins.
The pendant, optionally substituted organic groups, R may be independently
selected
from a wide range of components. Preferably, the pendant groups are optionally
substituted lower alkyl, e.g. C, _e, and may be branched or linear. Each R
group may be
the same as or different from each other R group. It is preferred that
(R3 C)ZP-L'-X-L2-P-(C-R3)Z is symmetrical in that both (C-R,)2 groupings are
the same.
Particularly preferred is when the organic groups, R, when associated with
their respective
carbon atom, form composite groups which are at least as sterically hindering
as
tert-butyl. Steric hindrance in this context is as discussed at page 14 et seq
of
"Homogeneous Transition Metal Catalysis - A Gentle Art", by C Masters,
published by
Chapman and Hall, 1981.
The linking groups, L' and L2, are independently selected from an optionally
substituted,
particularly lower alkyl, e.g. C, to C,, substituted, lower alkylene, e.g. C,
to C4 chain.
Especially preferred is when both L' and L2 are methylene.
SUBSTITUTE SHEET ( rule 26 )
CA 02297838 2006-01-27
3
The bridging group X is an aryl moiety, e.g. a phenyl group, which may be
optionally =
substituted, provided that the two phosphorus atoms are linked to adjacent
carbon atoms,
e.g. at the I and 2 positions on the phenyl group. Optional substitution of
the aryl moiety
may be by other organic groups, e.g. alkyl, particuiarly C, .e , aryl, alkoxy,
carbalkoxy, halo,
nitro, trihalomethyl and cyano. Furthermore, the aryl moiety may be a fused
polycydic
group, e.g. naphthalene, biphenylene or indene.
Examples of compounds (I) which may advantageously be made by the method
according
to the invention are described in WO 96/19434,
and include bis (di-tert-butyl phosphino) - o - xylene (also known as 1,2 bis
(di-tert-butylphosphinomethyl) benzene), bis (di-t-neopentyl phosphino) - o -
xylene and
bis 1, 2 (di-tert-butyl phosphino methyl ) naphthalene.
M may be any suitable metal which forms a polar organometaliic group on
reaction with
an alkyl halide. Suitable metals include those of Group 11 and Group IIB, e.g.
magnesium,
calcium, zinc, cadmium, mercury, aluminium, gallium, indium, tin and lead. The
preferred
metal is magnesium. When magnesium is used, the compound (I11) is known as a
di-Grignard compound. The magnesium may be in any convenient form such as
tumings,
chips, granules, ribbon etc, but it is preferred to use magnesium powder.
The nature of the compound (li) is dependent upon the nature of the product
compound
(I) which is required. When the L' and L 2 are both methylene groups and X is
an
unsubstituted phenyl group, the preferred starting material is a,a' dichloro-o-
xylene. A is a
halogen atom. The preferred halogen is chlorine although other halogens, e.g.
bromine
may be effective.
We have found that the compound (II) is beneficially added to the metal
gradually, e.g.
dropwise or by use of another means for achieving a slow addition, e.g. a
controllable
pump.
The formation of di-Grignard compounds, e.g. o-C6H4(CHZMgCI)z , is described
by M.F.
Lappert et al in J. Chem Soc. Dalton Trans. (1982) p.1959. This paper
describes the
preparation of metallocyclic compounds via a di-Grignard reaction, but the
practical
preparation of di-Grignard compounds is well described and may be useful in
the
CA 02297838 2000-01-20
WO 99/09040 PCT/GB98/02392
4
preparation of compound (III) of this invention. Thus, following the teaching
of this
document, which is incorporated herein as a reference, the yield of a di-
Grignard
compound may be increased if THF is used as a solvent and when the
concentration of
the compound (II) and thus of a resulting di-Grignard compound (I11) in the
solvent is
relatively low, e.g. less than about 0.1 mole/I, preferably of the order of
about 0.075
mole/I.
The nature of the phosphine compound (IV) is dependent upon the product
compound to
be prepared. The pendant, optionally substituted organic groups, R may be
independently selected from a wide range of components. Preferably, the
pendant groups
are optionally substituted lower alkyl, e.g. C, _e, and may be branched or
linear. Each R
group may be the same as or different from each other R group. It is preferred
that
(R3 C)2P-L'-X-L2-P-(C-R,)2 is symmetrical in that both (C-R,)2 groupings are
the same. A'
is preferably a chlorine or bromine or iodine atom. As an example, when each R
group is
a methyl group, i.e. when (C-R3)2 is t-butyl, then the phosphine compound (IV)
may be di
t-butylchlorophosphine. The compound (IV) may be obtained by synthesis, e.g.
via a
Grignard reaction in which (R3 C)MgCI is reacted with PC13 or by other
synthetic methods
known in the art. Some suitable materials may also be available commercially.
The phosphine compound (IV) may be added to the compound (III) at amounts in
excess
of the stoichiometric amount required. Preferably the ratio of compound (IV)
to compound
(III) is at least 2:1, although faster reaction rates can be achieved if the
ratio is greater,
e.g. at least 4:1. However, the increase in the rate of reaction achieved at
these higher
ratios must be offset by the economics of using more phosphine compound.
Usually the
ratio of compound (IV) to compound (111) would be less than 20:1, preferably
less than
about 10:1.
The solvent used must not contain any component which reacts with the
intermediate
compound, and suitable such solvents will be well known to the skilled
chemist. Favoured
solvents include dry etheric solvents such as tetrahydrofuran (THF), dioxane
and
dimethoxyethane. The preferred solvent is THF. The formation of a di-Grignard
compound must be carried out in dry conditions because water reacts with the
Grignard
compound to produce H-L'-X-LZ-H in a side reaction.
SUBSTITUTE SHEET (rule 26 )
_._ , _
CA 02297838 2000-01-20
WO 99/09040 PCT/GB98/02392
The reaction between compound (III) and Compound (IV) may be heated to
increase the
rate of reaction, if required. However, if the reaction is particularly rapid,
the reaction may
be more easily controlled in the absence of additional heat or with cooling.
The reduction
of the rate of reaction in this way may be beneficial in reducing side
reactions in certain
5 systems. As an example, we have found that when compound (IV) is a
chlorophosphine
the reaction may be easily controlled and a satisfactory rate achieved if
heated slightly,
e.g. the reaction is carried out at a temperature of about 50 C. However,
when the
corresponding bromophosphine is used instead of the chlorophosphine, the
reaction may
be very rapid at room temperature and thus no additional heat is needed and
cooling the
reaction mixture may be advantageous.
The compound (I) may be isolated from the reaction mixture by distilling off
the excess
solvent and excess reactants if present, preferably under vacuum, and then
extracting the
product compound into a solvent, e.g. hexane or methanol (preferably hot),
from which it
may be precipitated or recrystallised. Other techniques and reagents for
isolating the
product available to those skilled in the art of organic chemistry may be
found to be
suitable.
The invention will be further described, by way of example only, below.
Exam ip e 1 Preparation of compound (IIII
1.35g (55 mmol) of powdered magnesium was activated by heating at 90 C under
vacuum for 30 minutes, followed by cooling and stirring with a single crystal
of iodine, in
about 40 ml of THF which had been previously distilled under N2 over sodium,
until the
iodine stain was removed. The solution of magnesium iodide was filtered off
and the metal
resuspended in about 40 ml distilled THF. To this was added 2.42g (13.8 mmol)
of
sublimed a,a'-dichloro-ortho-xylene as a solution in THF (140 ml) over a
period of 3 - 4
hours and the reaction mixture stirred overnight. The resulting solution of di-
Grignard
solution was filtered and quenched with 2 mi of degassed water to produce
ortho-xylene.
The ortho-xylene produced was then analysed by gas chromatography, and
compared
with standard solutions made up in the laboratory to determine the yield. The
yield was
estimated to be 91 % based on a,a'-dichloro-ortho-xylene starting material,
confirming that
the reaction produces a high yield of the di-Grignard compound.
Exam lp e 2
SUBSTITUTE SHEET ( ruie 26 )
CA 02297838 2006-01-27
6
Example 1 was repeated except that a,a'-dibromo-ortho-xylene was used instead
of the
dich(oro compound of Example 1. The yield was determined to be 15%. This
reduced
yield compared with Example I is probably due to the increased reactivity of
the bromide
di-Grignard promoting rapid coupling of the Grignard molecules.
Example 3 Preoaration of compound (f)
A di-Grignard compound was made from a,a'-dichloro-ortho-xylene and magnesium
powder, as desoribed in Example 1. The yield of di-Grignard was determined by
GC
analysis of a water quenched sample of the filtered reaction mixture to be
94%. The
resulting filtered di-Grfgnard compound was functionalised by adding the di-
Grignard
dropwise to a vigorously stirred THF solution of a two-fold excess of
di-tert-butylchlorophosphine (as supplied by from Aldrich) which was then
refluxed for 8
hours after the addition was complete. The yield of bis (di-tert-butyl
phosphino)-o -xylene
was determined by 3'P nuclear magnetic resonance to be 55% based on the di-
Grignard
present. A number of other unidentified phosphorous-containing compounds were
also
found in the reaction mixture.
Example 4 Variation of the ratio of compound (IVl : compound (i11)
6.73 g (0.277 moles) of magnesium powder was activated using a single crystal
of iodine
in 125 ml of distilled THF. 12.11 g (0.069 moles) of a,a'-dichlono-octho-
xylene in 875 mis
of distilled THF was added dropwise to the magnesium mixture over a period of
4 hours,
using a Gilson pump to control the rate of addition, and the mixture was
stirred ovemight.
The resulting di-Grignard solution was filtered and a small sample quenched
with water in
order to determine the yield by gas chromatography analysis for orthoxytene.
The
di-Grignard compound was then added to di-t-butylchlorophosphine in varying
proportions as shown in Table I and stirred for up to about 24 hrs at 50 C.
The reaction
end-point was determined by 31P NMR to monitor the formation of product. The
solvent
was removed under vacuum and the resulting waxy solid was recrystallised from
hot
methanol. The yield was calculated based on di-Gtignani and is shown in Table
1.
Table 1
2:1 4:1 8:1
phosphine : diGrignani phosphine : diGrignani phosphtne : diGrignani
yield of bis (di-tert-butyl 42.8 55.3 61.8
phosphino)-o -xylene
CA 02297838 2000-01-20
WO 99/09040 PCT/GB98/02392
7
Exa .rulae5
A di-Grignard compound was made from a,a'-dichloro-ortho-xylene and magnesium
.
powder, as described in Example 1 and added to a solution of a mixture
comprising 80%
w/w of di-t-butylbromophosphine and 20% w/w di-t-butylchlorophosphine. The
reaction
was monitored by 31P NMR analysis of samples extracted from the mixture to
monitor the
formation of product as time progressed. The amount of the bromophosphine in
the
mixture was very rapidly reduced with the consequent rapid formation of bis
(di-tert-butyl
phosphino)-o -xylene product, and the level of the chlorophosphine reduced
much more
slowly. Therefore the bromophosphine reacted more rapidly than the
chlorophosphine to
give the desired product. The bromophosphine was not detected in the mixture
after
about 8 hours, whereas some chlorophosphine remained after 24 hrs. The yield
of
product was 23% based on the di-Grignard reactant.
SUBSTITUTE SHEET ( rule 26 )
