Language selection

Search

Patent 2378693 Summary

Third-party information liability

Some of the information on this Web page has been provided by external sources. The Government of Canada is not responsible for the accuracy, reliability or currency of the information supplied by external sources. Users wishing to rely upon this information should consult directly with the source of the information. Content provided by external sources is not subject to official languages, privacy and accessibility requirements.

Claims and Abstract availability

Any discrepancies in the text and image of the Claims and Abstract are due to differing posting times. Text of the Claims and Abstract are posted:

  • At the time the application is open to public inspection;
  • At the time of issue of the patent (grant).
(12) Patent Application: (11) CA 2378693
(54) English Title: PROPAGATING WAVE EARTH FORMATION RESISTIVITY MEASURING ARRANGEMENT
(54) French Title: SYSTEME DE MESURE DE LA RESISTIVITE D'UNE FORMATION SOUTERRAINE AUX ONDES DE PROPAGATION
Status: Deemed Abandoned and Beyond the Period of Reinstatement - Pending Response to Notice of Disregarded Communication
Bibliographic Data
(51) International Patent Classification (IPC):
  • G01V 3/30 (2006.01)
(72) Inventors :
  • FRASER, EDWARD C. (United States of America)
  • MORE, HENRY (United States of America)
(73) Owners :
  • HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL INC.
(71) Applicants :
  • HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL INC. (United States of America)
(74) Agent: GOWLING WLG (CANADA) LLPGOWLING WLG (CANADA) LLP
(74) Associate agent:
(45) Issued:
(86) PCT Filing Date: 2000-06-02
(87) Open to Public Inspection: 2001-01-18
Examination requested: 2005-05-25
Availability of licence: N/A
Dedicated to the Public: N/A
(25) Language of filing: English

Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT): Yes
(86) PCT Filing Number: PCT/US2000/015118
(87) International Publication Number: WO 2001004662
(85) National Entry: 2002-01-08

(30) Application Priority Data:
Application No. Country/Territory Date
60/143,065 (United States of America) 1999-07-09
60/144,710 (United States of America) 1999-07-20

Abstracts

English Abstract


Propagating wave resistivity of a surrounding earth formation is measured by
apparatus in a well bore being formed while drilling. The apparatus has a
sonde (310) positioned within a drill collar (302) that has its exterior
proximate the earth formation during passage of a drill device. The sonde has
one or more transmitting antennae (315-1, 315-4) on the housing exterior at
first positions that transmit interrogating signals to the earth formation and
one or more receiving antennae (315-2, 315-3) that receive signals
corresponding to the interrogating signals from the earth formation. The
housing (330) has a substantially smooth exterior surface and the antennae are
wound in recesses (312-1, 312-2, 312-3, 312-4) in the housing which are filled
to be flush with the smooth exterior surface. The drill collar (302) is
structured to pass the interrogating signals from the transmitting antennae on
the sonde to the earth formation and to pass the signals from the earth
formation corresponding to the interrogating signals to the receiving antennae
on the sonde.


French Abstract

La résistivité d'une formation souterraine aux ondes de propagation est mesurée par un appareil placé dans un puits en cours de forage. Cet appareil comprend une sonde (310) placée à l'intérieur d'un collier de forage (302) dont la surface extérieure est placée proche de la formation souterraine pendant le passage d'un dispositif de forage. Ladite sonde comporte une ou plusieurs antennes émettrices (315-1, 315-4) sur la surface extérieure du logement, dans des premières positions, antennes qui transmettent des signaux d'interrogation à la formation souterraine, et une ou plusieurs antennes réceptrices (315-2, 315-3) qui reçoivent les signaux correspondant aux signaux d'interrogation provenant de la formation souterraine. Le logement (330) présente une surface extérieure sensiblement uniforme et les antennes sont enroulées dans des évidements (312-1, 312-2, 312-3, 312-4), ménagés dans le logement, ces évidements étant remplis de façon à se trouver à niveau avec la surface extérieure uniforme du logement. Le collier de forage (302) est structuré de façon à transmettre les signaux d'interrogation provenant des antennes émettrices placées sur la sonde jusqu'à la formation souterraine et pour transmettre les signaux provenant de la formation souterraine correspondant aux signaux d'interrogation jusqu'aux antennes réceptrices placées sur la sonde.

Claims

Note: Claims are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.


6. What is claimed is:
1. Apparatus for measuring parameters of an
earth formation surrounding a well bore being formed by a
drill device comprising:
a hollow drill collar structure having plural
sections with an exterior proximate to the earth formation
during passage of the drill device into the well bore; and
a sonde within the drill collar structure
including:
a housing;
one or more one transmitting antennae
wound at first positions in an exterior surface of the
housing positioned within a first section of the drill collar
structure for transmitting interrogating signals to the earth
formation; and
one or more receiving
antennae wound at second positions in the exterior surface of
the housing spaced from the first positions and positioned in
the first section of the drill collar structure for receiving
signals from the earth formation in response to the
interrogating signals;
wherein the first section of the
drill collar structure passes the interrogating signals from
the transmitting antennae on the sonde through to the earth
formation surrounding the well bore and passes the signals
responsive to the interrogating signals from the earth
23

formation surrounding the well bore through to the receiving
antennae on the sonde.
2. The apparatus of Claim 1,
wherein the exterior surface of the housing of the sonde is
substantially smooth and includes a recess in which each
transmitting antenna is wound and a recess in which each
receiving antenna is wound, the recesses with the wound
antennae being filled with a non-conductive material with an
outer surface that is substantially flush with the
substantially smooth exterior surface of the housing.
3. The apparatus of Claim 1, wherein the drill
collar structure includes a second section which comprises a
structure for supporting a lower end of the sonde.
4. The apparatus of Claim 3, wherein the
structure for supporting the lower end of sonde in the second
section of the drill collar structure contacts a lower end of
the sonde to position the sonde in the drill collar
structure.
5. The apparatus of Claim 1, wherein the drill
collar structure first section is transparent to the
interrogating signals from the transmitting antennae and is
transparent to the signals from the earth formation
corresponding to the interrogating signals.
24

6. The apparatus of Claim 5, wherein the drill
collar first section is made of a fiberglass epoxy.
7. The apparatus of Claim 1, wherein the drill
collar structure first section is made of a conductive
material and includes one or more slotted portions each
positioned to provide passage of the interrogating signals
from a transmitting antenna to the earth formation and one or
more slotted portions each positioned to provide passage of
signals from the earth formation corresponding to the
interrogating signals to the receiving antenna.
8. The apparatus of Claim 7, wherein the slots of
each slotted portion are filled with a material transparent
to the interrogating signals from the transmitting antennae
and to the signals from the earth formation corresponding to
the interrogating signals.
9. The apparatus of Claim 7, wherein the drill
collar structure includes a second section comprising a
support for supporting the sonde in a position so that each
transmitting antenna radiates interrogating signals through
slots of one of the slotted portions of the drill collar
structure first section and each receiving antenna receives
signals from the earth formation corresponding to the
25

interrogating signals through slots of one of the slotted
portions of the drill collar structure first section.
10. The apparatus of Claim 1, wherein the sonde
further comprises a structure for receiving a retrieving unit
thereto.
11. The apparatus of Claim 10, wherein the
structure for receiving a retrieving unit to the sonde
includes a unit at an upper end of the sonde for attaching a
retrieving wire thereto.
12. A sonde in apparatus for measuring parameters
of an earth formation surrounding a well bore being formed by
a drill device having a drill collar structure with plural
sections comprising:
a housing positioned in the drill collar
structure;
one or more one transmitting antennae wound at
first positions in an exterior surface of the housing
positioned in a first section of the drill collar structure
for transmitting interrogating signals to the earth
formation;
one or more receiving antennae wound at second
positions in the exterior surface of the housing spaced from
the first positions and positioned in the first section of
26

the drill collar structure for receiving signals from the
earth formation in response to the interrogating signals;
wherein the first section of drill collar
drill collar structure passes the interrogating signals from
the one or more transmitting antennae on the sonde through to
the earth formation surrounding the well bore and passes the
signals corresponding to the interrogating signals from the
earth formation surrounding the well bore pass to the
receiving antenna on the sonde.
13. A sonde in apparatus for measuring parameters
of an earth formation surrounding a well bore being formed by
a drill device having a drill collar structure according to
Claim 12, wherein the exterior surface of the sonde housing
is substantially smooth and includes a recess into which each
transmitting antenna is wound and a recess into which each
receiving antenna is wound, the recesses with the wound
antennae being filled with a non-conductive material with an
outer surface substantially flush with the substantially
smooth exterior surface of the housing.
14. A sonde in apparatus for measuring parameters
of an earth formation surrounding a well bore being formed by
a drill device having a drill collar structure according to
Claim 12, wherein the drill collar structure includes a
support for supporting a lower end of the sonde.
27

15. A sonde in apparatus for measuring parameters
of an earth formation surrounding a well bore being formed by
a drill device having a drill collar structure according to
Claim 14, wherein the support for supporting the lower end of
the sonde in the drill collar contacts the lower end of the
sonde.
16. A sonde in apparatus for measuring parameters
of an earth formation surrounding a well bore being formed by
a drill device having a drill collar structure according to
Claim 12, wherein the first section of the drill collar
structure is transparent to the interrogating signals from
the transmitting antennae and is transparent to the signals
from the earth formation corresponding to the interrogating
signals.
17. A sonde in apparatus for measuring parameters
of an earth formation surrounding a well bore being formed by
a drill device having a drill collar structure according to
Claim 16, wherein the material of the drill collar structure
first section is a fiber glass epoxy.
18. A sonde in apparatus for measuring parameters
of an earth formation surrounding a well bore being formed by
a drill device having a drill collar structure according to
Claim 12, wherein the first section of the drill collar
structure is made of a conductive material and includes one
28

or more slotted portions each positioned to provide passage
of the interrogating signals from the transmitting antenna to
the earth formation and passage of signals from the earth
formation corresponding to the interrogating signals to the
receiving antenna.
19. A sonde in apparatus for measuring parameters
of an earth formation surrounding a well bore being formed by
a drill device having a drill collar structure according to
Claim 18, wherein slots of each slotted portion are filled
with a material transparent to the interrogating signals from
the transmitting antennae and transparent to the signals from
the earth formation corresponding to the interrogating
signals.
20. A sonde in apparatus for measuring parameters
of an earth formation surrounding a well bore being formed by
a drill device having a drill collar structure according to
Claim 18, wherein a second section of the drill collar
structure includes a support for supporting the sonde so that
each transmitting antenna radiates interrogating signals
through slots of one of the slotted portions and each
receiving antenna receives signals from the earth formation
corresponding to the interrogating signals through the slots
of one of the slotted portions.
21. A sonde in apparatus for measuring
29

parameters of an earth formation surrounding a well bore
being formed by a drill device having a drill collar
structure according to Claim 12, wherein the sonde further
comprises a structure for receiving a retrieving unit.
22. A sonde in apparatus for measuring parameters
of an earth formation surrounding a well bore being formed by
a drill device having a drill collar structure according to
Claim 21, wherein the structure for receiving a retrieving
unit includes a spear point unit at an upper end of the sonde
for attaching a retrieving wire thereto.
23. A method for measuring parameters of an earth
formation surrounding a well bore being formed by a drill
device having a sonde in a drill collar structure having
plural sections, the sonde having one or more transmitting
antennae wound at axially spaced first positions in an
exterior surface of a housing of the sonde positioned in a
first section of the drill collar structure for propagating
interrogation signals to the earth formation surrounding the
drill collar and one or more receiving antennae wound at
axially spaced second positions in the exterior surface of
the sonde housing positioned in the first section of the
drill collar structure for receiving signals corresponding to
the interrogating signals from the earth formation
surrounding the drill collar, method comprising the steps of:
passing the interrogating signals from the
30

transmitting antennae on the sonde housing through the drill
collar to the earth formation surrounding the drill collar;
and
passing the signals corresponding to the
interrogating signals from the surrounding earth formation
through the drill collar to the receiving antenna on the
sonde housing.
24. The method of Claim 23, wherein
the exterior surface of the housing is substantially smooth,
each transmitting antenna and receiving antenna is wound in a
recess in the exterior surface of the housing and the
recesses having the wound antennae are filled with a non-
conductive material having an outer surface that is
substantially flush with the substantially smooth exterior
surface of the housing.
25. The method of Claim 23, wherein
a second section of the drill collar structure includes a
support for detachably supporting a lower end of the sonde.
26. The method of Claim 25, wherein
the support in the second section of the drill collar
contacts the lower end of the sonde.
27. The method of Claim 23, wherein
the first section of the drill collar is made of a material
31

transparent to the interrogating signals from the
transmitting antenna on the sonde and is transparent to the
signals from the earth formation corresponding to the
interrogating signals.
28. The method of Claim 27, wherein
the material of the drill collar is a fiber glass epoxy.
29. The method of Claim 23, wherein
the first section of the drill collar structure is made of a
conductive material and includes one or more slotted portions
each positioned to provide passage of the interrogating
signals from a transmitting antenna on the sonde to the earth
formation and passage of signals from the earth formation
corresponding to the interrogating signals to the receiving
antenna.
30. The method of Claim 29, wherein slots of each
slotted portion are filled with a material transparent to the
interrogating signals from the transmitting antennae and
transparent to the signals from the earth formation
corresponding to the interrogating signals.
31. The method of Claim 29, wherein the
second section of the drill collar structure supports the
sonde so that each transmitting antenna radiates the
interrogating signals through slots of one of the slotted
32

portions and each receiving antenna receives signals from the
earth formation corresponding to the interrogating signals
through the slots of one of the slotted portions.
32. The method of Claim 23, wherein the sonde
receives a unit for retrieving the sonde from the well bore.
33. The method of Claim 32, wherein the
receiving unit of the sonde receives the retrieving unit by
attaching a retrieving wire to a spear point at a top end of
the sonde.
34. Apparatus for measuring propagating
resistivity of an earth formation surrounding a well bore
being drilled comprising:
a drill collar having plural tubular
sections adjacent to the well bore during passage of a drill
bit into the well bore; and
a sonde positioned in the drill collar
structure including:
a generally cylindrical housing having an
exterior surface with a set of spaced circumferential
recesses therein, the recesses being positioned in a first
section of the drill collar structure;
first and second loop antennae each wound
in one of the circumferential recesses for transmitting
interrogating signals to the surrounding earth formation;
33

third and fourth loop antennae each one
wound in one of the circumferential recesses for receiving
signals corresponding to the interrogating signals from the
surrounding earth formation,
wherein the first section of drill collar
structure passes the interrogating signals from the
transmitting loop antenna on the sonde to the earth formation
surrounding the well bore and passes the signals responsive
to the interrogating signals from the earth formation
surrounding the well bore through to the receiving antenna on
the sonde,
wherein the exterior surface of the sonde
housing is substantially smooth and each loop antenna recess
is filled with a non-conductive material flush with the
substantially smooth exterior surface, and
wherein a second section of the drill
collar lower than the first section includes a support for
detachably supporting a lower end of the sonde so that the
sonde is retrievable from the well bore.
35. The apparatus of Claim 34, wherein the
first section of the drill collar is transparent to the
interrogating signals from the transmitting loop antennae and
is transparent to the signals from the surrounding earth
formation corresponding to the interrogating signals.
34

36. The apparatus of Claim 34, wherein the
first section of the drill collar is made of a conductive
material and includes a set of slots aligned with each of the
circumferential recesses in the sonde for passing
interrogating signals from the transmitting loop antennae to
the surrounding earth formation and for passing signals from
the earth formation to the receiving loop antennae
corresponding to the interrogating signals.
37. Apparatus for measuring characteristics of an
earth formation surrounding a well bore comprising:
drill collar means having plural sections
proximate the earth formation;
means for measuring propagating wave
resistivity of the surrounding earth formation including:
housing means within the drill
collar means;
circumferential recesses in the
exterior surface of the housing in a first section of the
drill collar means;
transmitting means in one or more of
the circumferential recesses for transmitting interrogating
signals to the surrounding earth formation;
receiving means in one or more of
the circumferential recesses for receiving signals from the
surrounding earth formation corresponding to the
interrogating signals,
35

wherein the first section of the drill
collar means passes the interrogating signals from the
transmitting means to the surrounding earth formation and
passes the signals corresponding to the interrogating signals
from the surrounding earth formation to the receiving means.
38. The apparatus of Claim 37, wherein an
exterior surface of the housing means is subtantially smooth
and the circumferential recesses are filled to be
substantially flush with the exterior surface of the sonde
housing.
39. The apparatus of Claim 37, wherein the
drill collar means includes a second section including
support means for supporting a lower end of the housing means
so that the sonde can be lifted up the well bore.
40. The apparatus of Claim 39, wherein the
drill collar means first section includes plural slotted
portions for providing passage of the interrogating signals
from the one or more transmitting means to the earth
formation and passage of signals corresponding to the
interrogating signals from the earth formation to the one or
more receiving means when the lower end of the housing means
is supported on the drill collar means.
36

41. The apparatus of Claim 37, wherein the
first section of the drill collar means is transparent to the
interrogating signals from the transmitting means and is
transparent to the signals corresponding to the interrogating
signals from the surrounding earth formation.
42. The apparatus of Claim 37 wherein the
housing means further comprises means for connecting to a
unit for retrieving the propagating wave resistivity
measuring means from the well bore.
43. Apparatus for measuring parameters of an
earth formation surrounding a well bore being formed by a
drill device comprising:
a hollow drill collar having plural sections
with an exterior proximate to the earth formation during
passage of the drill device into the well bore; and
a sonde within the drill collar structure
including:
a housing;
one or more one transmitting antennae wound at
first positions in an exterior surface of the housing
positioned within the first section of the drill collar
structure for transmitting interrogating signals to the
earth formation;
one or more receiving antennae wound at
second positions in the exterior surface of the housing
37

spaced from the first positions and positioned in the first
section of the drill collar structure for receiving signals
from the earth formation in response to the interrogating
signals;
wherein a second section of the drill collar
structure includes a support for detachably supporting a
lower end of the sonde so that the sonde is retrievable from
the well bore.
44. Apparatus according to Claim 43, wherein the
support in second section of the drill collar structure for
detachably supporting the lower end of the sonde includes a
structure that contacts the lower end of the sonde.
45. Apparatus according to Claim 44, wherein the
sonde further includes a structure at an upper end for
receiving a device to retrieve the sonde from the well bore.
46. The apparatus of Claim 45, wherein the
structure for receiving a retrieval device includes a spear
point at an upper end of the sonde for receiving an overshot
device.
38

Description

Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.


CA 02378693 2002-O1-08
WO 01/04662 PCT/US00/15118
PROPAGATING WAVE EARTH FORMATION RESISTIVITY
MEASURING ARRANGEMENT
1. Field Of the Invention
The invention relates to measurement of geophysical
parameters in earth formations surrounding well bores and,
more particularly, to apparatus for measuring the resistivity
of earth formations in drilling operations.
2. Background Of the Invention
In oil and gas exploration in which well bores are drilled,
the well boring apparatus includes a drill collar to which a
drill bit is attached. A drilling fluid is pumped to the
drill bit through the drill collar. The drilling fluid
exiting from the drill bit is returned to the surface through
the space between the exterior of the drill collar and the
already drilled portion of well bore.
Resistivity measurements are generally performed in the well
bore to determine the characteristics of the surrounding
earth formations. These resistivity measurements may be
performed by measuring the conduction of electrical current
using an arrangement of electrodes within the well bore in a
wireline system or using an arrangement of electrodes mounted
on a drill collar in a measurement performed while drilling

CA 02378693 2002-O1-08
WO 01/04662 PCT/US00/15118
system. Low frequency induction coils on the drill collar
exterior may be used instead of the electrodes.
Alternatively, propagating wave resistivity measurements may
be performed utilizing transmitting and receiving loop
antennas operating at higher frequencies in the range from
400 KHz to 2 MHz. The electronic equipment associated with
the electrodes or the loop antennae is housed in a sonde
positioned within the drill collar. The sonde has a
generally tubular metallic housing and mountings in the
l0 housing for electronic equipment used in the measurements.
Where electrodes or low frequency loop antennae are used,
they are located in recesses on the surface of the drill
collar for measurements made while drilling. For the
propagating wave resistivity measurements in the 400 KHz to 2
MHz range, one or more pairs of transmitting and receiving
antennas may be wound on the exterior of a metal drill collar
since the 400 KHz to 2 MHz signals do not propagate through
the conductive drill collar.
An exemplary arrangement using antennas mounted on the
exterior surface of a drill collar and electronic equipment
in a sonde inside the drill collar is disclosed in U.S.
Patent 5,892,361 issued April 6, 1999. With the transmitting
and receiving antennae on the exterior of the drill collar,
the drilling fluid flows in the annulus between the sonde and
the interior surface of the drill collar and connections are
required between the electronic equipment associated with the
2

CA 02378693 2002-O1-08
WO 01/04662 PCT/US00/15118
antennae inside the sonde and the antennae on the drill
collar exterior. Such connections make it very difficult to
retrieve the propagating wave resistivity measuring apparatus
from the well bore. Alternatively, the electronic equipment
may be mounted in the drill collar itself as disclosed in
U.S. Patent 5,402,068 issued March 28, 1995. In the drill
collar mounting arrangement, the transmitting and receiving
antennae as well as the electronic equipment associated
therewith are a part of the drill collar and are not
l0 retrievable. The antennae may also be arranged to be
proximate to the interior of the drill collar on extensions
connected to the sonde so that the drilling fluid flows in
the space between the sonde and the antennae. With this
structure, it is also very difficult to retrieve the sonde
from the well bore.
3. Brief Summary of the Invention
The invention is directed to a propagating wave resistivity
measuring arrangement in a well bore. The measurement
arrangement is adapted to determine properties of earth
formations surrounding the well bore in which a sonde that
houses electronic equipment is positioned in one section of a
drill collar structure having plural sections that adjoins
the earth formation. The sonde houses devices for processing
of signals for the propagating wave resistivity measurements
and devices for communicating the results of the propagating
3

CA 02378693 2002-O1-08
WO 01/04662 PCT/US00/15118
wave resistivity measurements to the surface end of the well
bore.
According to the invention, one or more transmitting antennae
in the exterior of the sonde housing at first positions
generate interrogating signals for transmission to the earth
formation surrounding the drill collar and one or more
receiving antennae in the exterior of the sonde housing at
second positions spaced from first positions receive signals
corresponding to the interrogating signals from the earth
formation surrounding a first section of drill collar
structure. The drill collar passes the interrogating signals
from the transmitting antennae on the sonde into the earth
formation and passes signals responsive to the interrogating
signals from the earth formation to the receiving antennae on
the sonde.
According to one aspect of the invention, the exterior
surface of the sonde is smooth for laminar drilling fluid
flow in the annular passageway between the sonde and the
interior surface of the first section of the drill collar
structure. Each transmitting antenna is inserted into a
recess at a first position on the exterior surface of the
sonde and each receiving antenna is inserted into a recess at
a second position on the exterior surface of the sonde. The
recesses in which the antennae are inserted are filled with a
4

CA 02378693 2002-O1-08
WO 01/04662 PCT/US00/15118
non-conductive material that is substantially flush with the
smooth surface of the housing exterior.
According to another aspect of the invention, a lower end of
the sonde is supported in a predetermined position within the
drill collar structure on a support in a second section of
the drill collar structure located below the first section of
the drill collar. The support orients the sonde in a
predetermined longitudinal and rotational positions within
the drill collar structure.
According to yet another aspect of the invention, the first
section of the drill collar structure is made of a material
such as a fiber glass epoxy that is transparent to the
interrogating signals from the transmitting antennae and to
the signals from the earth formation corresponding to the
interrogating signals.
According to yet another aspect of the invention, the first
section of the drill collar structure is made of a conductive
material and includes slotted portions each positioned to
provide passage of the interrogating signals from a
transmitting antenna to the earth formation and passage of
signals from the earth formation corresponding to the
interrogating signals to a receiving antenna. The support in
the second section of the drill collar structure for the
sonde is adapted to position the sonde so that each
transmitting antenna radiates interrogating signals through
5

CA 02378693 2002-O1-08
WO 01/04662 PCT/US00/15118
the slots therein and each receiving antenna receives signals
from the earth formation corresponding to the interrogating
signals through the slots therein.
According to yet another aspect of the invention, the sonde
includes a device at an upper end that receives apparatus for
retrieving the sonde from the well bore such as a spear point
shaped top section which can be latched with a standard
overshot.
In one embodiment illustrative of the invention, a
sonde has one or more transmitting antennae in spaced
relationship with one or more receiving antennae. The
antennae are wound in recesses of a smooth exterior surface
of the sonde housing. The recesses are filled with a non-
conductive material to be flush with the smooth exterior
surface. The sonde is positioned within a non-conductive
section of a drill collar structure inserted in a well bore
with the lower end of the sonde supported in a predetermined
position by a second section of the drill collar structure.
Drilling fluid flows down the inside of the drill collar
around the smooth exterior surface of the sonde and then,
having exited through the drill bit, between the exterior
surface of the drill collar and the well bore. The upper end
of the sonde has a spear point structure for connection to a
wire line to the sonde from the well bore.
6

CA 02378693 2002-O1-08
WO 01/04662 PCT/US00/15118
In another embodiment illustrative of the invention, a sonde
has one or more transmitting antennae in spaced relation to
one or more receiving antennae along its length. Each
antenna is wound in a recess of a smooth exterior surface of
the sonde. The sonde is positioned in a metal section of a
drill collar structure inserted into a well bore. The
antenna recesses are filled to be flush with the smooth
exterior surface and the drill collar has slotted portions
positioned along the axis of the sonde aligned with the
antennae. The slots are filled with a material transparent
to the interrogating signals from the transmitting antennae
and to the signals from the earth formation corresponding to
the interrogating signals. Processing apparatus associated
with the antennae are housed within the sonde. Drilling fluid
is pumped down around the sonde within a wash pipe proximate
the interior surface of the drill collar and up to the
surface of the earth formation around the exterior of the
drill collar. The lower end of the sonde is supported in a
second section of the drill collar structure in a
predetermined position so that the interrogating signals from
the transmitting antennae pass through the slots to the
surrounding earth formation and the signals from the earth
formation corresponding to the interrogating signals pass
through the slots to the receiving antennae.
7

CA 02378693 2002-O1-08
WO 01/04662 PCT/US00/15118
The invention will be better understood from the following
more detailed description taken together with the
accompanying drawings and the claims.
4. Brief Description of the Drawinas
Fig. 1 shows a general diagram of a system for drilling and
measuring propagating wave resistivity in an earth formation
surrounding a well bore;
Fig. 2 illustrates an arrangement of a sonde in a drill
collar structure for propagating wave resistivity
measurements while drilling according to the prior art.
Fig. 3 depicts apparatus for propagating resistivity
measurement while drilling housed in a sonde within a non-
metallic drill collar structure according to one embodiment
of the invention;
Fig. 4 depicts apparatus for propagating wave resistivity
measurement while drilling housed in a sonde within a
metallic drill collar structure according to another
embodiment of the invention;
Fig. 5 shows the slot structure of the metallic drill collar
structure used in the embodiment of Fig. 4;
8

CA 02378693 2002-O1-08
WO 01/04662 PCT/US00/15118
Fig. 6 illustrates the arrangement of electronic equipment
housed in the sonde in the embodiments of Figs. 3 and 4;
Fig. 7 illustrates a structure that supports the sonde in the
drill collar structure of Figs. 3 and 4;
Fig. 8 illustrates an arrangement for retrieving the sonde of
the embodiments of Figs. 3 and 4 from the well bore of Fig.
1; and
Fig. 9 shows an alternative drill collar structure for the
embodiment of Fig. 4.
5. Detailed Description
Fig. 1 is a schematic diagram showing a well bore 1 being
drilled in an earth formation 50 using a drilling rig that
includes a derrick 3, a derrick floor 5, a drill string 7, a
drill collar 10 and a drill bit structure 28. In drilling, a
drilling fluid or "mud" is pumped down through the drill
collar 10 by a pump (not shown) and the drill bit structure
28 for drilling. After passing through the drill bit
structure, the drilling fluid is returned to the surface of
the earth formation 50 between the exterior of the drill
collar 10 and the well bore 1.
9

CA 02378693 2002-O1-08
WO 01/04662 PCT/US00/15118
During the drilling, the propagating wave resistivity of the
earth formation 50 surrounding the well bore is measured by
apparatus within the drill collar section 10. The measuring
apparatus includes spaced apart transmitting antennae
radiating interrogating signals in the frequency range of 400
KHz to 2 MHz into the earth formation, spaced apart receiving
antennae for receiving signals corresponding to the
interrogating signals and processing apparatus that processes
the received signals to determine the propagating wave
resistivity.
Fig. 2 shows a prior art arrangement of propagating wave
resistivity measurement apparatus in a tubular metal drill
collar 200. In Fig. 2, a sonde 210 having a tubular housing
230 is shown affixed to and centered in a drill collar 200.
Drilling fluid flows in the annular space between the
exterior of the sonde and the interior surface of the drill
collar. Since the annular space is interrupted by
connection/supports 218-1 through 218-4, the drilling fluid
flow is somewhat restricted. The metal drill collar 200 has
axially positioned circumferential recesses 212-l, 212-2,
212-3 and 212-4. A transmitting loop antenna 215-1 is wound
in the recess 212-1 and a transmitting loop antenna 215-4 is
wound in the recess 212-4. A receiving loop antenna 215-2 is
wound in the recess 212-2 and a receiving loop antenna 215-3
is wound in the recess 212-3.

CA 02378693 2002-O1-08
WO 01/04662 PCT/US00/15118
The transmitting loop antennae 215-1 receives timed signals
in the frequency range from 400 KHz to 2 MHz from a
transmitter within the housing of the sonde 210 through a
connection structure 218-1. The transmitting loop antenna
215-4 receives differently timed signals from another
transmitter in the sonde 210 through a connection structure
218-4. The transmitting loop antennae 215-1 and 215-4 operate
to transmit differently timed interrogating signals to the
surrounding earth formation. Signals responsive to the
interrogating signals that are returned from the earth
formation to the drill collar 210 are picked up by the
receiving antennae 215-2 and 215-3. The returned signals
from the receiving antennae are applied to a receiver in the
sonde through the connection structures 218-2 and 218-3 and
IS are processed by a processor in the sonde to generate
propagating wave resistivity data.
Since the metal drill collar is not transparent to the
interrogating and return signals in the frequency range of
400 KHz to 2 MHz, it is necessary to locate the antennae 212-
1 to 212-4 on the exterior of the drill collar. It is also
necessary to provide connections through the connection
structures 218-1 through 218-4 for interrogating signals
generated by transmitters within the sonde and for receiving
and processing return signals from earth formation in
receivers and processors in the sonde. Alternatively, a
sonde may not be used and the transmitter, receiver and
11

CA 02378693 2002-O1-08
WO 01/04662 PCT/US00/15118
processor associated with the transmitting antennae 215-1 and
215-4 and the receiving antennae 215-2 and 215-3 may be
mounted on the drill collar itself. In either arrangement,
however, the design is relatively complex and expensive and,
in addition, the propagating wave resistivity measurement
equipment is not retrievable independent of the drill collar.
Fig. 3 depicts a sonde in a non-conducting drill collar for a
propagating wave resistivity measurement according to one
embodiment of the invention. Referring to Fig. 3, there is
schematically shown a drill collar structure 300; a non-
conductive measuring section 302 of drill collar structure
300, a sonde 310 in the drill collar structure section 302,
recesses 312-1, 312-2, 312-3 and 312-4, loop antennae 315-1,
315-2, 315-3 and 315-4, a pony section 325 of the drill
collar structure 300, a landing sub section 328 of the drill
collar structure 300 and an attachment structure 335. The
transmitting and receiving antennae of the sonde 310 are
positioned in the measurement section 302, the landing sub
section 328 has a muleshoe device 344 and the pony section
325 connects the measuring section 302 and the landing sub
section 328. The drill collar measuring section 302 may be
made of any suitable non-conducting material such as
fiberglass reinforced epoxy. In order to protect the drill
collar section 302 from rapid wear, wear rings containing
tungsten carbide may be inserted or the drill collar section
12

CA 02378693 2002-O1-08
WO 01/04662 PCT/US00/15118
302 may be coated overall with a hard material such as a
ceramic.
A housing 330 of the sonde 310 in Fig. 3 may be made of
stainless steel or beryllium copper. The housing 330 has a
general shape of a right circular cylinder with a smooth
outer surface. Circumferential recesses 312-1 through 312-4
that are spaced along the axis of the sonde are formed in the
outer surface of the housing. A first transmitting loop
antenna 315-1 is wound in the recess 312-1 and a second
transmitting loop antenna 315-4 is wound in the recess 312-4.
A first receiving loop antenna 315-2 is wound in the recess
312-2 and a second receiving antenna 315-3 is wound in the
recess 312-3. After the antenna 315-1 through 315-4 are
wound, the recesses 312-1 through 312-4 are filled with a
material such as Viton rubber and the surfaces of the filled
recesses are made substantially flush with the smooth surface
of the housing 330. The lower end of the sonde is supported
on a support structure in a landing sub section 328 which is
connected to the section 302 by a pony section 325.
Fig. 7 is a schematic diagram showing one arrangement to
detachably support the sonde 310 on the drill collar 300 of
Fig. 3 so that the sonde can be lifted from the drill collar
and retrieved from the well bore. In Fig. 7, there is shown
the pony section 325 and the landing sub section 328. The
pony section 325 is threadedly attached to the measuring
13

CA 02378693 2002-O1-08
WO 01/04662 PCT/US00/15118
section 302 of the drill collar and the landing sub section
328 is threadedly attached to the pony section 325. The
interior surface of the landing sub section 328 has a
"muleshoe" sleeve 344 which detachably supports an orienting
sleeve 342 of the lower end of the sonde 310 so that the
sonde is longitudinally oriented. A muleshoe pin 346 of the
landing sub section fits into the orienting sleeve 342 of the
lower end of the sonde 310 to rotationally orient the sonde.
Since the sonde 310 is detachably supported by the landing
sub arrangement but is not affixed to the drill collar 300,
the sonde may be retrieved from the drill collar by lifting
it upward in the well bore using a wire line connection to
the attachment structure 335 shown in Fig. 3. The attachment
structure may be a spear point formed at the upper end of the
sonde 310 as shown in Fig. 8. The spear point end 537 of the
upper sonde portion shown in Fig. 8 is positioned in the
center of the drill collar 310 as determined by the sonde
support structure in the landing sub section 328. In
retrieving the sonde 310 from the drill collar 300, a
standard overshot device connected to a wire line is latched
onto the spear point and the sonde is raised in the well bore
1. It is to be understood that structures other than a
muleshoe and a spear point and overshoot device may be
employed to support the sonde and to retrieve the sonde from
the well bore.
14

CA 02378693 2002-O1-08
WO 01/04662 PCT/IJS00/15118
The drill collar 300 is made of a non-conductive material
that is transparent to the interrogating signals from the
transmitting antennae 315-1 and 315-4 and is also transparent
to the responsive return signals from the earth formation
surrounding the drill collar. The electronic equipment
associated with the transmitting and receiving antennae 315-1
through 315-4 is located within the sonde housing and is
directly coupled to the antennae. Accordingly, there is no
restriction to drilling fluid flow from the electromechanical
connections between the sonde and the adjacent drill collar.
Since the entire propagating wave resistivity system is
located in the sonde and the sonde is not affixed to the
drill collar, the sonde may be readily retrieved from the
well bore as disclosed with respect to Fig. 8.
Fig. 4 depicts another embodiment of the invention in which
the sonde is supported in a predetermined position within a
drill collar structure. Shown in Fig. 4 is a drill collar
400 having a metal drill collar measurement section 402, a
wash pipe 405 and a sonde 410. The sonde has recesses 412-l,
412-2, 412-3 and 412-4 into which loop antennae 415-1, 415-2,
415-3 and 415-4 are wound, a lower end orienting sleeve 442
and an upper end attachment section 435. The loop antennae
415-1, 415-2, 415-3 and 415-4 is positioned in the drill
collar structure measurement section 402 and has slotted
portions 421-1, 421-2, 421-3 and 421-4 aligned with the loop
antennae. A landing sub section 428 of the drill collar

CA 02378693 2002-O1-08
WO 01/04662 PCT/US00/15118
includes a structure for detachably supporting the lower end
of the sonde and a pony section 425 connects the measuring
section 402 and the landing sub section 428.
A housing 430 of the sonde 410 has a smooth exterior surface.
The circumferential recesses in the housing 430 are spaced
along the length of the sonde. A first transmitting loop
antenna 415-1 is wound in the recess 412-1 and a second
transmitting loop antenna 415-4 is wound in the recess 412-4.
A first receiving antenna 415-2 is wound in the recess 412-2
and a second receiving antenna 415-3 is wound in the recess
412-3. After winding of the antennae therein, the recesses
are filled with a non-conductive material such as Viton
rubber and the surfaces of the recesses are made
substantially flush with the smooth surface of the housing
430.
The lower end of the sonde is supported on a landing sub
section 428 which is arranged to position the sonde
longitudinally and rotationally. The supporting structure is
substantially the same as that described with respect to Fig.
7 in which an orienting sleeve 442 is detachably supported by
a muleshoe 444. The muleshoe 444 orients the sonde 410
longitudinally and a muleshoe pin 446 orients the sonde
rotationally. The top end of the sonde includes an
attachment unit 435 such as a spear point adapted to be
16

CA 02378693 2002-O1-08
WO 01/04662 PCT/US00/15118
connected to a wire from the derrick 3 for retrieving the
sonde from the well bore.
When the sonde 410 is in a supported position on the landing
sub section 428, the sonde is positioned so that the
transmitting loop antennae 415-1 and 415-4 are aligned with
slots of slotted portions 421-1 and 421-4, respectively, of
the measuring portion 402 of the drill collar structure and
the receiving loop antennae 415-2 and 415-3 are aligned with
slots of slotted portions 421-2 and 421-3, respectively, of
the measuring portion 402 of the drill collar structure.
Drilling fluid flowing around the sonde 410 in the drill
collar 400 is contained within a wash pipe 405 in the slotted
drill collar measuring section 402. The wash pipe 405 is
proximate the interior surface of the drill collar section
402. The exterior surface of the wash pipe 405 is sealed to
the interior surface of the drill collar at a point above the
uppermost set of slots by an O ring 439 or other sealing
device and at a point below the lowermost set of slots by an
O ring 440. It is to be understood that other sealing
arrangements may be used in Fig. 4. Each of the slots of
the slotted portions 421-1 through 421-4 is preferably filled
with a non-conductive material that is transparent to the
interrogating signals from the transmitting loop antennae
415-1 and 415-4 and to the return signals from the
surrounding earth formation. The sealing of the exterior of
the wash pipe to the interior of the drill collar prevents
17

CA 02378693 2002-O1-08
WO 01/04662 PCT/US00/15118
the highly pressurized drilling fluid flowing inside the wash
pipe 405 from exiting through the slotted portions of the
sonde.
Fig. 5 illustrates the slot structures in the drill collar
section 402 of Fig. 4. Referring to Fig. 5, in which a set
of slots of slotted portion 421-1 in the drill collar
structure section 402 is located at one end to be aligned
with the transmitting loop antenna 415-1 when lower end of
the sonde 410 is supported in the landing sub section 428 of
the drill collar structure. A set of slots of the slotted
portion 421-4 is located at the lower end of the drill collar
section 402 for alignment with the transmitting loop antenna
415-4. A set of slots of the slotted portion 421-2 in the
drill collar is located on the sonde 410 to be aligned with
the receiving antenna 415-2 and a set of slots of the slotted
portion 412-3 is located on the sonde for alignment with the
receiving antenna 415-3.
The drill collar structure section 402 of Fig. 4 may also be
constructed as shown in Fig. 9 to have fiber-glass epoxy
composite sections aligned with the transmitting antennae and
the receiving antennae wound on the sonde 410. Referring to
Fig. 9, the propagating resistivity measuring section 402 of
the drill collar structure 400 has generally cylindrical
metal sections 930-1, 930-2, 930-3, 930-4 and 930-5. A
generally cylindrical fiber-glass epoxy composite section
18

CA 02378693 2002-O1-08
WO 01/04662 PCT/US00/15118
923-1 is secured between the metal sections 930-1 and 930-2
and is aligned with the transmitting antenna 415-1 for
passage of interrogating signals therethrough to the
surrounding earth formation. Similarly, a cylindrical fiber-
s glass composite section 923-4 between the metal sections 930-
4 and 930-5 is aligned with the transmitting antenna 415-4
for passage of interrogating signals therethrough. A
cylindrical fiber-glass composite section 923-2 between metal
sections 930-2 and 930-3 aligned with the receiving antenna
415-2 allows passage of return signals from the earth
formation to the antenna 415-2. In like manner, a
cylindrical fiber-glass section 923-3 between metal sections
930-3 and 930-4 is aligned with receiving antenna 415-3 to
permit passage of return signals from the earth formation to
the antenna 415-3. The alternating metal and fiber-glass
composite sections of the same diameter of Fig. 9 may be
threadedly connected to form the drill collar structure
section 402. It is to be understood that other arrangements
of interrogating and return signal transparent materials may
be used to assure passage of these signals between the sonde
410 and the surrounding earth formation. For example, a
single fiber-glass composite section may be aligned with both
receiving antennae 414-2 and 415-3.
The electronic equipment associated with the transmitting and
receiving loop antennae 415-1 through 415-4 is located in the
sonde housing 430 and is connected directly to the antennae.
19

CA 02378693 2002-O1-08
WO 01/04662 PCT/US00/15118
As discussed with respect to the embodiment shown in Fig. 3,
the sonde 410 is readily detachable from the drilling collar
400. Accordingly, a wire from the derrick 3 may be lowered
into the well bore and connected to the sonde attachment unit
435 so that the sonde may be retrieved from its supported
position in the drill collar 400. As shown in Fig. 8 and
disclosed with respect to the embodiment of Fig. 3, the sonde
410 may have a spear point end 537 for connection with a wire
line so that the sonde may be lifted off the support
structure in the landing sub section 428 and retrieved from
the well bore.
Fig. 6 shows electronic equipment located inside the housing
330 of the sonde 310 of Fig. 3 or inside the housing 430 of
the sonde 410 of Fig. 4. The electronic equipment includes a
control 601, an upper transmitter 610 and a lower transmitter
615, an upper receiver 620 and a lower receiver 625, a
propagating wave resistivity signal processor 630 and a data
transmitting device 635 such as a mud pulser, an EM telemetry
device or other arrangement well known in the art. The
control 601 controls the operations of the transmitters, the
receivers and the signal processor. The upper transmitter
610 provides an interrogating signal in the range of 400 KHz
to 2 MHz and controls the timing of the operation of
transmitting antenna 315-1 or 415-1. The lower transmitter
615 provides an interrogating signal in the range of 400 KHz
to 2 MHz and controls the timing of the operation of the

CA 02378693 2002-O1-08
WO 01/04662 PCT/US00/15118
transmitting antenna 315-4 or 415-4. Upper and lower
receivers 620 and 625 receive signals from the earth
formation returned to antennae 315-2 and 315-3 or 415-2 and
415-3 in response to the interrogating signals. Signal
processor 630 processes the return signals from the receivers
to generate amplitude ratio and phase difference signals
corresponding to the propagating wave resistivity. The coded
signals corresponding to the propagating wave resistivity are
transmitted to the surface by the data transmitting device
635 so that coded signals are picked up at the top of the
well bore.
In operation, upper and lower transmitters 610 and 615
sequentially send interrogating signals to antennae 315-1 and
315-4 or 415-1 and 415-4. Receivers 620 and 625 operate to
receive return signals in response to each of the sequential
interrogating signals. The outputs of receivers 620 and 625
are processed in propagating wave resistivity signal
processor 630 as is well known in the art to determine
propagating wave resistivity of the earth formation
surrounding the drill collar responsive to the return
signals. The output of the propagating wave resistivity
processor 630 is applied to the data transmitter 635 and is
communicated to the top of the well bore.
While the invention has been described by way of particular
illustrative embodiments, it is to be understood that the
21

CA 02378693 2002-O1-08
WO 01/04662 PCT/US00/15118
invention is not limited to the above-described embodiments
but that various changes and modifications may be made by
those of ordinary skill in the art without departing from the
scope and spirit of the invention. Accordingly, the
foregoing embodiments should not be construed as limiting the
scope of the invention which is encompassed instead by the
following claims.
22

Representative Drawing
A single figure which represents the drawing illustrating the invention.
Administrative Status

2024-08-01:As part of the Next Generation Patents (NGP) transition, the Canadian Patents Database (CPD) now contains a more detailed Event History, which replicates the Event Log of our new back-office solution.

Please note that "Inactive:" events refers to events no longer in use in our new back-office solution.

For a clearer understanding of the status of the application/patent presented on this page, the site Disclaimer , as well as the definitions for Patent , Event History , Maintenance Fee  and Payment History  should be consulted.

Event History

Description Date
Inactive: IPC expired 2012-01-01
Inactive: Status info is complete as of Log entry date 2007-07-25
Application Not Reinstated by Deadline 2007-06-04
Time Limit for Reversal Expired 2007-06-04
Inactive: Abandoned - No reply to Office letter 2007-04-10
Deemed Abandoned - Failure to Respond to Maintenance Fee Notice 2006-06-02
Extension of Time for Taking Action Requirements Determined Compliant 2006-04-27
Letter Sent 2006-04-27
Inactive: Extension of time for transfer 2006-04-07
Letter Sent 2005-06-02
Request for Examination Received 2005-05-25
Request for Examination Requirements Determined Compliant 2005-05-25
All Requirements for Examination Determined Compliant 2005-05-25
Letter Sent 2005-04-21
Extension of Time for Taking Action Requirements Determined Compliant 2005-04-21
Inactive: Extension of time for transfer 2005-04-11
Letter Sent 2004-04-29
Extension of Time for Taking Action Requirements Determined Compliant 2004-04-29
Inactive: Extension of time for transfer 2004-04-08
Letter Sent 2003-05-02
Extension of Time for Taking Action Requirements Determined Compliant 2003-05-02
Inactive: Extension of time for transfer 2003-04-09
Inactive: Cover page published 2002-07-03
Inactive: Courtesy letter - Evidence 2002-07-02
Inactive: Notice - National entry - No RFE 2002-06-26
Application Received - PCT 2002-04-30
National Entry Requirements Determined Compliant 2002-01-08
Application Published (Open to Public Inspection) 2001-01-18

Abandonment History

Abandonment Date Reason Reinstatement Date
2006-06-02

Maintenance Fee

The last payment was received on 2005-05-17

Note : If the full payment has not been received on or before the date indicated, a further fee may be required which may be one of the following

  • the reinstatement fee;
  • the late payment fee; or
  • additional fee to reverse deemed expiry.

Please refer to the CIPO Patent Fees web page to see all current fee amounts.

Fee History

Fee Type Anniversary Year Due Date Paid Date
Basic national fee - standard 2002-01-08
MF (application, 2nd anniv.) - standard 02 2002-06-03 2002-05-31
Extension of time 2003-04-09
MF (application, 3rd anniv.) - standard 03 2003-06-02 2003-05-23
Extension of time 2004-04-08
MF (application, 4th anniv.) - standard 04 2004-06-02 2004-05-18
Extension of time 2005-04-11
MF (application, 5th anniv.) - standard 05 2005-06-02 2005-05-17
Request for examination - standard 2005-05-25
Extension of time 2006-04-07
Owners on Record

Note: Records showing the ownership history in alphabetical order.

Current Owners on Record
HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL INC.
Past Owners on Record
EDWARD C. FRASER
HENRY MORE
Past Owners that do not appear in the "Owners on Record" listing will appear in other documentation within the application.
Documents

To view selected files, please enter reCAPTCHA code :



To view images, click a link in the Document Description column. To download the documents, select one or more checkboxes in the first column and then click the "Download Selected in PDF format (Zip Archive)" or the "Download Selected as Single PDF" button.

List of published and non-published patent-specific documents on the CPD .

If you have any difficulty accessing content, you can call the Client Service Centre at 1-866-997-1936 or send them an e-mail at CIPO Client Service Centre.


Document
Description 
Date
(yyyy-mm-dd) 
Number of pages   Size of Image (KB) 
Representative drawing 2002-07-02 1 5
Claims 2002-01-08 16 495
Abstract 2002-01-08 1 60
Drawings 2002-01-08 8 87
Description 2002-01-08 22 754
Cover Page 2002-07-03 1 45
Reminder of maintenance fee due 2002-06-26 1 114
Notice of National Entry 2002-06-26 1 208
Request for evidence or missing transfer 2003-01-09 1 101
Reminder - Request for Examination 2005-02-03 1 115
Acknowledgement of Request for Examination 2005-06-02 1 176
Courtesy - Abandonment Letter (Maintenance Fee) 2006-07-31 1 175
Courtesy - Abandonment Letter (Office letter) 2007-05-22 1 167
PCT 2002-01-08 12 466
Correspondence 2002-06-26 1 25
Correspondence 2003-04-09 1 36
Correspondence 2003-05-02 1 14
Fees 2003-05-23 1 20
Fees 2002-05-31 1 32
Correspondence 2004-04-08 1 31
Correspondence 2004-04-29 1 16
Correspondence 2005-04-11 1 32
Correspondence 2005-04-21 1 16
Correspondence 2006-04-07 1 41
Correspondence 2006-04-27 1 16