Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
1
TITLE: AUTOMATED MECHANICAL STRESS ASSAY FOR SCREENING
CLEANING INGREDIENTS
FIELD OF THE INVENTION
This invention relates to an automated assay for testing real
application performance of cleaning ingredients by testing them
on mechanically stressed surfaces. The invention also relates to
surfaces and other devices adapted for application in the
automated assay and to cleaning ingredient identified by the
assay and subsequently produced.
to BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
It has been the object for researchers in the detergent industry
to continuously search for new ingredients for use in cleaning
compositions, which improves the cleaning effects of these
compositions. In the field of surface cleaning, such as textiles
of fabrics most people believe, that the flow of a liquid
cleaning solution also called the washing liquor against and/or
through a surface is sufficient for achieving a good cleaning
process and accordingly that such conditions are suitable when
the cleaning effect of new cleaning ingredients and/or
zo compositions are evaluated to identify improvements.
Various artificial methods have over time been developed
to provide tools for simulating a cleaning process and for
testing cleaning effects. However using artificial methods often
results in the finding of promising cleaning ingredients or
z5 compositions, which despite the predictions from the artificial
methods does not provide the expected improvement when applied
to real cleaning processes. Accordingly, in order to test and
make reliable predictions on the cleaning effect of new
ingredients or compositions, the skilled person has had adopt
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
2
full scale cleaning processes and real surfaces, such as
cleaning fabrics in a washing machine to provide useful results.
WO 99/34011 describes a method for assaying wash performance
of new enzymes and/or detergent formulations.
The published Danish patent application PA 1997 00507
describes an assay for analyzing cellulolytic detergent
to enzymes.
S'IJN~IARY OF THE INVENTION
Our research has shown that, besides contact between washing
liquor and a fabric, the mechanical stress, which in real life
applications is conferred to the fabric, is also of major
i5 importance. However, tests using full scale washing methods are
difficult to automate and have a very limited sampling capacity
rendering these method expensive and laborious. Moreover, some
effects in a cleaning process may be very difficult or even
impossible to assess using full scale washing methods. The
zo present invention enables us of remedying these limitations by
providing:
A method for testing cleaning effect of a compound or
compositions thereof said method comprising:
z5 (a) Preparing a liquid sample of less than 10 ml comprising the
test compound,
(b) applying liquid sample to a stained surface,
(c) applying mechanical stress to the stained surface by
contacting it with a body present in the liquid sample,
30 (d) evaluating the cleaning effect of applying solution and
mechanical stress on the stained surface.
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
3
As this method is particularly suitable for automated
testing of small volume samples, the invention also relates to a
device developed for testing cleaning effect of a composition,
said device comprising:
(a) at least one container having a volume of less than 10 ml,
preferably less than 2 ml, most preferably less than 0.2 ml,
(b) at least one body capable of moving inside the container,
(c) at least one stained surface and
(d) means for providing movement of the body relatively to the
to stained surface.
The invention in accordance with these aspects provides
means easily automated for testing of cleaning compositions,
means which, through the use of small test samples less than 10
ml, preferably less than 2 ml, most preferably less than 0.2
ml , offers a large sampling capacity and through the element of
mechanical stress offers simulation of the cleaning process
comparable to real life or full scale cleaning processes.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE TABLES AND DRAWINGS
2o Figure 1 is a drawing showing the principle of using a permanent
magnet for providing mechanical force to a stained fabric.
Figure 2 shows the results of testing effect of a xyloglucanase
enzyme on a stained fabric in a test method using a permanent
magnet for providing mechanical force to a stained fabric.
Figure 3 is drawings showing cross sections of different types
of assemblies suitable for use in testing effects of cleaning
ingredients.
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
4
Figure 4 shows a cross section an assemble comprising a micro
plate fitted with a lid and a stained fabric, the assembly being
suitable for use in testing effects of cleaning ingredients.
Figure 5 shows an assembly such as given in figure 4, mounted on
a device for generating mechanical force.
Figure 6 shows the results of testing different protease enzymes
in a commercial 96 well test plate with a single Coherent
to stained fabric covering all well openings of the commercial
plate, the test plate and stained fabric mounted on the device
of figure 5 without addition of a movable body to the wells.
Figure 7 shows the results of testing different protease enzymes
in the a 96 well custom made test plate assembly according to
(figure 4 with a single coherent stained fabric covering all well
openings of the plate, the test plate and stained fabric mounted
on the device of figure 5 without addition of a movable body to
the wells.
Figure 8 shows the cleaning performance of 23 different pectate
lyases and concentration 0.1 ppm (A) and 1 ppm (B) when tested
using the method and system of the invention in terms of light
reflected from stained fabrics cleaned with the pectate lyases.
Figure 9 shows the cleaning performance of 4 different hard
surface cleaning products (3 commercial and 1 experimental)
measured using conventional techniques (B) and the using the
method and system of the present invention (A).
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
Figure 10 shows a schematic cross section of an assembled device
particularly suitable for carrying out the method of the
invention.
5 Figure 11 shows the difference in cleaning performance of a
commercial detergent when dissolved in soft water (0 mM
Ca2+/Mga+) and in hard water (10 mM Ca2+/Mga+) against different
grass stains (A-F) impregnated on fabric when tested using the
method and system of the invention.
to
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
The method
One object of the invention is to provide a method for testing
the cleaning effect of compounds on a stained surface using only
small sample volumes less than 10 ml while, but which simulates
and is comparable to real cleaning processes performed e.g. in a
washing machine. One challenge in developing such a method is
the implementation of the mechanical stress factor in a small
sample volume system. It is to be understood that the system is
2o a collection of functional members or tools used to carry out
the method of the invention such as containers, stained
surfaces, bodies or samples, and/or means for sealing,
temperature control, pressure control etc. as described, infra.
The method we have developed, simulating full scale
z5 cleaning of surfaces, is easily automated and it is possible and
even feasible to employ conventional testing vessels e.g. arrays
of small containers, such as wells of a micro plate. The method
and devices developed for performing the method allows to
simulate cleaning processes on surfaces like fabrics at a micro
ao scale even using extremely small sample volumes such as below 50
~.1. The evaluation of cleaning effect of compounds such as new
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
6
enzymes, can be done using this method at a 50.000 to 500.000
times smaller quantities than it is required for a full scale
cleaning process. Basically the method provides a predictive
system with the capability to be incorporated in high throughput
facilities as it is established in the pharmaceutical industry.
This new tool can therefore accelerate dramatically the
development effort of new and improved cleaning compounds and/or
compositions by providing the capability to test ingredients at
high numbers and of low quantities.
to The test compound
The purpose of the present invention is to provide means of
identifying compounds or compositions thereof providing improved
cleaning of a stained surface.
The compound or compositions thereof in the context of the
invention is preferably selected from compounds known to be
incorporated in detergent compositions such as enzymes and/or
enzyme stabilizers, inhibitors, enhancers, co-factors, builders,
builder systems, bleach systems, bleach activators, metal
containing bleach catalyst, optical brighteners, , nonionic -,
2o anionic -, cationic -, zwitterionic and amphoteric surfactants,
fabric softening agents, softening clays, clay flocculants, dye-
transfer inhibiting agents, polymeric soil release agents, clay
soil removal agents, anti-soil redeposition agents, polymeric
dispersing systems, chelating agents, alkoxylated
polycarboxylates, perfumes, perfume systems, carrier systems,
dyes and pigments, fabric care agents, color care agents and the
like. Further, also compounds which are present in the water
used to form a washing liquor may contain relevant test
compounds. Such compounds include dissolved salts, such as salts
of Ca and/or Mg which will determine the hardness of the water,
or salts of carbonate, nitrate, chloride, sulfate and/or
phosphate.
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
7
Typical enzymes used in fabric care and cleaning products
are proteases, lipases, amylases, cellulose hydrolyzing enzymes
such as cellulases, carbohydrases such as mannanases or
pectatlyases, transferases, oxidoreductases and like, preferably
the enzymes are alkaline enzymes characterized by having their
catalytic optimums between pH 7-12, more preferably high
alkaline having their catalytic optimums between pH 9-12.
The liquid sample
In the present invention a liquid sample is prepared comprising
to the compound and/or the composition to be tested. The sample is
preferably an aqueous solution or dispersion of the test
compound or composition, but it may also be non-aqueous of
nature, which may be relevant when testing compounds suitable
for use in non-aqueous cleaning liquids.
In a preferred embodiment the liquid sample is prepared by
first preparing a base solution and/or dispersion and
transferring predefined amounts hereof to a test vessel or
container. The compound or composition may then be added to the
vessels in minute amounts, preferably in solution. In accordance
2o with the invention, the liquid sample thus prepared have a
volume of less than 10 ml, preferably less than 2 ml, most
preferably less than 0.2 ml, but the method works with
considerably less volume, which is feasible to increase the
sample capacity. Accordingly the sample volume is comparable to
the well volume of commercially available micro plates. A
suitable volume is less than the well volume of a 24 well micro
plate, preferably less than the volume of a well on a 96, 384 or
1536 well plate. Based on the type of micro plate, the volume
can be chosen between 5 - 95% of the volume of the well, which
ao is 3.7 ml, 320 ~tl, 160 ~.1, and 14 ~.1, respectively.
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
8
The surface
Surface materials relevant to be employed in the present
invention are materials used in real life, which are subjected
to cleaning processes. Such materials may be inorganic such as
metal, ceramic, glass, enamel concrete, rock, marble, gypsum or
composite combinations thereof. The material may also be mainly
organic by nature such as plastic, rubber, wood, paper,
leather, fur, paint or fabric. A preferred surface is a
fabric. The fabric may be any fabric made from natural plant
to fibers, animal based fibres or synthetic fibres or combinations
thereof. The fabric may be woven or non-woven or soft or
stiff. Most preferred fabrics are cellulose containing fabrics
such textiles (woven) and tissues (non woven) and animal based
fabrics such as wool.
A stained surface may be achieved by employing any
conventional staining techniques associating a stain
comprising a traceable compound or composition to the surface
and/or associating the traceable compound or composition
itself to the surface.
2o Suitable traceable compounds includes dyes such as light
absorbing or fluorescent dye, radioactive compounds, reactive
compounds, such a catalysts and/or activators capable of
performing measurable interaction with substrates. Such
compound may be associated directly or indirectly to the
z5 surface by covalent bonding, ionic bonding and/or hydrogen
bonding.
The surface may also be stained with a particulate
Composition such carbon particles, e.g. carbon black or iron
oxides.
3o In a preferred embodiment the surface is stained by a
soiling composition comprising the traceable compound or
composition. Such soiling composition is preferably a
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
9
naturally occurring soiling such as grass, mud, clay, coffee,
tea, blood, egg, lard, moulds (damp stained) or the
composition may made of processed naturally occurring soiling,
such as butter, processed meat, dyed lard, oil, make up, spice
blends, processed tomatoes (ketchup or puree), chocolate, ice
cream, cacao, baby food and the like. The soiling may also
preferably be a man made composition comprising compounds
selected from refined protein compositions, refined
polysaccharide compositions, refined fatty acid compositions,
to refined triglyceride compositions or other refined biological
or non-biological compounds.
Most fabrics are stained by applying the staining
material as it is or as an aqueous solution onto the fabric
surface by soaking, brushing and/or spraying. The stained
fabrics will be dried before testing. There is also a group of
colourless materials, which bind soil and particles onto
surfaces. Carbohydrates like Guaran Gum, Locust Bean Gum and
starch and the like are belonging to this group of materials,
which are attracting soil materials. One example of preparing
2o stain with such materials is as follows:
1) Dissolving the soil binding material Guar Gum in a aqueous
solution at a level of 0.1 to 1 0.
2) Applying the solution onto the fabric surface by soaking,
brushing, or spraying onto the surface.
a5 3) Removal of the access gum material by washing the coated
fabrics in a commercial washing machine (Miele, short cycle,
40°C) without detergent .
4) Staining of the coated fabrics in a commercial washing
machine (Miele, short cycle, 40°C) by adding 0.1 to 1% of
3o clay, carbon black, iron oxide and/or other
pigments/particular soiling materials into the wash machine
without detergent.
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
Fabric surfaces having a range of different stainings are
commercially available under the trade name EMPA~ swatches
marketed by EMPA St. Gallen, Lerchfeldstrasse 5, CH-9014 St.
Gallen, Switzerland.
5 The body
For applying mechanical stress to the surface the present
invention requires a body present in the liquid sample
comprising the test compound. It is necessary that the body has
a size and shape which allows the body to go into the container
to holding the liquid sample, so that the body is present in the
liquid sample. Preferably the body has a size and a shape, which
allows the body to move in multiple directions within the
container holding the sample and the body. The size and shape of
the body should also preferably allow the body to be submersed
i5 in the sample.
The body is made of a material, which is preferably
insoluble in the solution. The body is preferably rigid, but it
may also be flexible and it may have a smooth or a rough
surface. It is important that the body material is predominately
2o inert, i.e. that the body does not chemically interact with the
sample or vice versa. Accordingly the body material is made from
durable materials. Such materials may be inorganic such as
metal, ceramic, glass, enamel concrete, rock, marble, gypsum or
composite combinations thereof or organic such as plastic,
25 rubber or combinations thereof. Preferably the material is
sufficiently ductile to prevent breakage of the body upon
collision. with the stained surface or container walls. The
body may also be any suitable material coated with said inert
and ductile material.
3o In a preferred embodiment the body comprises a metal,
more preferably a ferromagnetic metal such as iron or alloys
thereof or a composite comprising such metals or alloys. To
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
11
inhibit corrosion of metals, the body is preferably coated
with a layer of inert material such as organic polymers,
separating the metals) from any outer corrosive media.
In this case the body may be any suitable nut, bolt,
screw, bed or ball, preferred bodies have a surface comprising
at least one edge or corner like a rectangular body.
Any shape like spherical, round-flat, disk shape, cube
shape, elongated cube shape, cylindrical round shape,
cylindrical rectangular shape, star shape, hexagonal shape,
to and like is suitable which fulfils the requirements for size
and shape to fit into the test container.
The choice of body material is important for the choice
of method for transferring kinetic energy (movement) to the I
body. The size, shape, mass and surface texture is important
for the type and amount of mechanical stress the body is
capable of conferring to the stained surface.
Depending on the type of compound to be tested excellent
results have been obtained with 3-5 rectangular stainless
steel bodies (3 x 1.6 x 1.9 mm) per container in a 96 well
2o plate or stainless steel balls or beads having a diameter of 3
mm or less.
Application of liquid sample and mechanical stress to the
stained surface.
In the method of the invention the stained surface must be
a5 placed where the body and the sample solution has access to the
stained surface. Having the sample and the body in a container
the stained surface may be placed in any position from the
bottom to the top of the container. Preferably the stained
surface is placed at the top or the bottom of the container and
3o more preferably the stained surface functions as a cover on an
opening in the container.
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
12
When the stained surface is placed below sample level in
the container (submersed), the application of the liquid sample
to the stained surface is continuous, while when the stained
surface is placed above sample level in the container
s application of the liquid sample to the surface depends on
movement of liquid sample relative to the stained surface to
allow liquid to contact the surface. This may be achieved by
movement of the liquid, movement of the stained surface a
combination thereof.
to The mechanical stress may be conferred to the stained
surface by providing movement of the body relative to the
stained surface, which allows the body to collide with the
stained surface. This may be achieved by movement of the body,
movement of the stained surface a combination thereof.
15 In the preferred embodiment of the stained surface acting
as a lid on top of the container, the application of sample
liquid and mechanical stress to the stained surface may
advantageously be combined. In this case the mechanical stress
may be provided to the to the stained surface by moving the body
2o and allowing it to collide with the surface. However, as the
body moves from having contact with the liquid sample, e.g. by
being submersed therein, some sample liquid will adhere to the
body and when the body collide with the stained surface some of
liquid sample adhering to the body will be deposited or applied
25 on the surface. Further, repeating movement and collision
between surface and body will provide exchange of previously
deposited sample and fresh sample, so that changes in the sample
liquid deposited on the stained surface, e.g. as a result of
interaction between stain and sample liquid, will be
3o equilibrating with un-deposited sample liquid. Accordingly, by
employing this system application of both liquid sample and
mechanical stress may be achieved by moving the body. This
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
13
system further solves problems related to having the stained
surface present inside the container, e.g. submersed in the
liquid sample. Firstly, such submersed surfaces has to be cut
into very small pieces to fit into the containers encompassed by
the invention, which may be a tedious procedure, secondly, a
submersed surface may interfere with movement of the body, as
stained surface and body may get entangled with each other
inhibiting or changing the movement pattern, third, the
mechanical stress conferred to the stained surface by collision
to with the body may occur in an irregular and non-reproducible
manner, introducing increased levels of noise into the
evaluation of the cleaning effect, fourth, if evaluation of the
cleaning effect is includes analyzing the stained surface this
process is difficult to automate because each stained surface is
to handled individually. The second, third and fourth problem
may, however, be somewhat remedied by attaching the stained
surface to the bottom of the container, which may be feasible if
the method for evaluating the cleaning effect of the liquid
samples allows such a setup, e.g. if measurement can be made on
2o the liquid sample or on the stained surface through the bottom
wall of the container.
Movement of liquid sample, the body and/or the stained
surface may be provided for by employing a force, preferably an
oscillating force. The term oscillating as used in this context
means that the force is following a directional and amplitudical
repetition scheme, preferably a periodical pattern, in amplitude
and direction. As an example an applied force may repeatedly act
first upwards and then downwards on the body (or any other
element of the invention) and/or it may act first towards one
3o side and then towards the opposite side and/or from front to
back. The force might be applied in a regular, periodic
oscillating manner or completely in random, non-periodic
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
14
irregular manner. An oscillating force also encompasses
combinations of these directional forces, i.e. in altering force
patterns such as applying upward and downwards force for defined
period of time followed by applying side wards forces for period
of time followed again by up and downwards forces and so on. By
applying an oscillating force the collisions between body and
stained surface are repeated many times conferring significant
mechanical stress to the stained surface.
to Various types of forces may be employed to achieve
movement of the liquid sample, the body and/or the stained
surf ace .
The oscillating force may be mechanical of nature e.g. by
applying external movement to all or selected parts of the
system, which subsequently confers movement to the liquid
sample, the body and/or the stained surface. This may be
achieved by subjecting the system or parts of the system to
shaking and/or vibration, e.g. by vibrating the container
holding the liquid sample, the body and the stained surface.
2o Mechanical forces includes subjecting the system or parts of the
system to motion waves such as sound waves, preferably of higher
frequency such as ultra sonic waves.
Other suitable forces are forces capable of acting on
selected system elements having special properties. Such forces
include magnetic, electromagnetic, electrostatic and/or
electrical forces. Magnetic or electromagnetic forces for
example act only on magnetizable materials such as ferromagnetic
materials. Accordingly it is possible to employ forces, which
acts only on selected elements of the system. One advantage of
a0 applying these types of forces is that these forces act on
susceptible elements though force fields, which may act on
susceptible materials over distance penetrating non-susceptible
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
materials. Accordingly it is possible the apply force to a
system element, such as the susceptible body, e.g. through a
non-susceptible container wall. As an. example a magnetic force
field will act on an ferromagnetic containing body through the
5 wall of a plastic, glass or non-ferromagnetic metal container.
In a preferred embodiment the force includes at least one
force field selected from magnetic field, electromagnetic field,
electrostatic field and electric field.
In a further preferred embodiment is preferred to employ a
to force acting on anal moving the body only whereby, as described
supra, both application of liquid sample and mechanical stress
to the stained surface may be achieved independent of the
position of the surface. More preferably the force includes a
magnetic or electromagnetic field and the body comprises a
15 magnetically susceptible material, such as a ferromagnetic
material. It is to be understood that in this embodiment, the
force may also act on components of the liquid sample on a
molecular level, such as ions or it may act on fixed members of
the system elements, but it does not directly induce movement of
2o the liquid sample, the stained surface, the container or other
elements (such as tables, container holder etc.) used to carry
out the method of the invention.
The present invention also encompasses employment of
combinations of different force types such as combination of
a5 mechanical force and magnetic force fields.
In a most preferred embodiment the force is applied to a
magnetizable body by moving a magnet relatively to the container
containing the body, thus altering the magnetic field affecting
the body or the force is a mechanical vibration force applied to
3o an assembly comprising body, container and stained fabric.
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
16
A suitable system consists of a micro plate and a source
of field force on top of the plate. A modification is an
additional force field at the bottom of micro plate.
Evaluation of cleaning effect
Evaluation of the cleaning effect of a sample liquid may be
achieved by analyzing the stained surface, the liquid sample or
both after subjecting the stained surface to the liquid sample
and the mechanical stress. A suitable choice of method will
depend on the type of stain, which is used.
to It may be feasible to measure changes of either surface
or the liquid sample or both. Various methods are known to the
art and includes optical methods, optical methods combined
with coupled reaction between staining compounds and
indicators, enzyme assays, physical measurements of altered
surface properties chromatographic or fluorimetric methods,
spectroscopic methods, radioactive labeling methods,
immunochemical methods such as ELISA and more. If the stain is
a more or less complex soiling composition it is usually more
feasible to analyse the stained surface e.g. by measuring the
2o stained surface reflectance of light with suitable
reflectometers or colorimeters.
The testing device
As described, supra, this invention also relates to a device
suitable for testing cleaning effect of a composition, said
device comprising:
(a) at least one container having a volume of less than 10 ml,
preferably less than 2 ml, most preferably less than 0.2 ml,
(b) at least one body capable of moving inside the container,
(c) at least one stained surface, preferably a stained fabric
a o and
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
17
(d) means for providing movement of the body relatively to the
stained surface.
The advantageous features of speed and capacity in
testing compounds provided by the present invention relies to
a major extent on the assembly of equipment making up the
testing device. Accordingly, an important aspect of the
invention is the practical applicability of the stained
surface. In order to achieve the optimal capacity and speed in
the present assay it is, as described supra, preferred to use
to a stained surface which functions as a lid on the container in
which the test sample is placed. Within this embodiment it is
further preferred that the stained surface, as a coherent
entity, has a dimension, which makes it capable of acting as a
lid on two or more containers simultaneously. More preferably
the stained surface have a dimension, which makes it capable
of acting as a lid on an array or arrays of containers
simultaneously enables. The embodiment of using a stained
surface having a dimension, which makes it capable of acting
as a lid on numerous test containers is very important indeed
2o not only considering test capacity but also considering the
accuracy of the testing. For many stained surfaces, such as
fabrics, there may be variations between different entities of
the same type of surface. For example variations in the
texture and firmness between different parts of a cloth, from
which stained fabric sub-pieces are made, may cause variations
between fabric sub-pieces in stainability and ability to
interact with test compound(s). However, by choosing a test
assembly which requires that the stained fabric has a certain
dimension, which, as a coherent entity, is capable acting as a
lid for numerous test containers, it is secured that the
stained fabric used to test compounds in each individual
container has a lowered variation in texture, firmness and
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
18
staining, because it, taken as a coherent entity must
originate from the same part or area of e.g. the cloth from
which it is taken. The term "coherent" in this context is to
be understood in the broadest sense, but preferably that the
fabric is in one coherent woven or non woven piece without
seams or stitches or other fastening means, which may make the
fabric surface less uniform.
Accordingly, the present invention also relates to an
assembly suitable for use in testing effect of cleaning
to ingredients, e.g. in the device as described above, which
through a special combination of containers and stained fabric
provide for high speed and capacity as well as good accuracy
in testing cleaning ingredients, such as enzymes. Accordingly,
the present invention provides an assembly comprising at least
is one container and a stained coherent fabric, wherein the
container comprises at least one opening covered and/or lidded
with the stained coherent fabric. The invention also
encompasses an assembly comprising a container and a stained
coherent fabric, wherein the container comprises two
20 oppositely positioned openings and at least one, preferably
both of said openings are Covered and/or lidded with a stained
coherent fabric. In one preferred embodiment the assembly
further comprises least one body in each container for
providing mechanical stress to the stained fabric, as
25 described supra, preferably within the container. In another
preferred embodiment the assembly comprises an array of
containers, wherein each container comprises one or more
openings and optionally one or more bodies and wherein the
stained coherent fabric covers and/or lids at least one of the
30 openings in each container. In a further preferred embodiment
the array of containers is a micro plate comprising 24, 96,
384 or 1536 containers or wells and the stained coherent
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
19
fabric have a preferred dimension within 0.2-10 cm by 0.2-15
cm, preferably a dimension enabling the stained fabric to
cover all the wells in the micro plate.
The term "cover/lid" in this context is to be understood
in the sense that the stained fabric covers the opening of a
container by being in contact with the edges of the opening.
Preferably the assembly comprises an additional support
lid or cover located in the assembly so that the fabric is
placed between the support lid and the container opening. The
to support lid is preferably made from a material, which is
impermeable to the liquid sample in the container and has a
dimension which makes the support lid rigid enough. to support
the fabric and prevent the fabric from moving away from the
opening when subjected to mechanical force. The assembly also
preferably comprise means for fastening the support lid to the
container so that the fabric may act as a sealing gasket . One
important feature in this context is that the contact zone
between the fabric and the edge of the opening is small so
that the pressure holding the fabric in contact with the
zo container opening, when the support lid is fastened to the
container, is sufficient to seal the container, using the
fabric as a gasket. This is important to prevent or inhibit
that liquid sample from one container contaminates, through
capillary movement, an adjacent container. To improve contact
z5 pressure between fabric and container opening by minimizing
the contact zone, the edge of container openings and
interconnecting surface between containers and the side of the
support lid facing the fabric are designed so that they form a
line toward each other instead of a surface. This can be
3o achieved by designing the support lid and containers so that
the interconnecting surface between containers in an array and
the surface of the support lid facing the fabric are
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
essentially unparallel, i.e. greater or less than about 180°.
Examples of this design is given e.g. in figure 3.
Also other elements may be added to the assembly, such as
devices for providing mechanical force to the body, the sample,
5 the fabric or a combination, means for controlling temperature,
devices for measuring properties of the stained fabric or the
test sample. For convenience the assembly comprising container,
stained fabric and optionally a support lid is from hereon
referred to as the "primary assembly" and assemblies comprising
to additional elements are referred to as "secondary assemblies".
Accordingly the present invention encompasses any test system
comprising primary or secondary assemblies.
In one embodiment of the invention a secondary assembly
comprises a device for providing mechanical force, the device
15 preferably comprises a piston in a cylinder construction for
generating vibration or shaking force, which is transferable
to the stained fabric. Preferably the piston device is
connected, via a rigid plate, suitable for mounting and/or
fastening the primary assembly, to the primary assembly. The
zo piston based device is preferably driven by a pneumatic or
hydraulic system, using compression and/or expansion of air or
liquid to move the piston relative to the cylinder. In a
preferred embodiment the cylinder or the piston is fastened on
the rigid plate at the opposite side (preferably to bottom
z5 side) of the primary assembly and this secondary assembly is
connected to a stationary support construction via an elastic
material capable of moderating movement of this secondary
assembly. In this construction mechanical force in the form of
vibration is transferred to the primary assembly (and to the
3o stained fabric and movable body within the test container) by
the weight displacement and/or acceleration by which ever of
the cylinder or piston, which is not connected to the rigid
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
21
plate. This displacement is achieved by moving the piston or
cylinder relatively to the other elements of the secondary
assembly by means of a hydraulic or pneumatic system. Such
devices for providing mechanical force are commercially
available e.g. from Copenhagen Vibrator Product, Denmark.
An alternative to the piston-cylinder construction is a
device comprising an engine spinning a mass element, such as a
driving wheel, having a heterogeneous mass distribution, said
device connected to the primary device and to a stationary
to support construction via a rigid plate. To moderate movement the
rigid plate may be connected to a stationary support via an
elastic material, such as rubber. When the mass element spins,
the heterogeneous mass distribution will cause repetitive
displacement of mass and will confer vibration to the primary
assembly and the container holding the test sample.
In a particular embodiment the secondary assembly comprise
the element of the secondary assembly depicted in figure 10.
Here at least one engine (1) (preferably two electric engines
having opposite spin directions) is rigidly connected to a rigid
2o plate (5) for holding a primary assembly. The engines) spins
one or more heterogeneous mass elements (2) capable of vibrating
the rigid holder plate (5). A rigid lid plate (4) is connected
by flexible elements (3) (preferably one or more springs) to the
engine (s) (1) and the rigid holder plate (5) . Between the lid
plate (4) and the holder plate (5) there is a slit (10) for
holding a primary assembly. The width of the slit (10) is
dimensioned so that the flexible elements have to be compressed
in order to insert a primary assembly and so that the flexible
elements (3) will press the lid plate (4) against the container
openings of the primary assembly once inserted into the slit
(10). The elements 1-5 are connected to a base construction (8)
through flexible elements (7) (preferably one or more springs).
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
22
The secondary assembly comprises means for compressing the
flexible elements (3) holding the rigid lid plate (4) when the
primary assembly is to be inserted or removed. These compressing
means may in particular be connected to base construction (8).
The means for compressing the flexible elements (3) may comprise
an engine driven gearbox ( 9 ) which a . g . via threaded bolt ( 12 )
and a rigid construction ( 6 ) may drive one or more rods ( 11 ) ,
e.g. through holes or bushings in the holder plate (5) against
the lid plate (4) whereby the flexible elements (3) are
to compressed. The engines) (1) may further be connected to means
for controlling the rotation speed e.g. a frequency controller.
Still further, the secondary assembly may comprise means for
regulating the temperature of a primary assembly placed in the
slit (10). In a particular embodiment the whole secondary
assembly in encased in an insulated casing wherein the
temperature is controlled by a thermostatted air heater. Hence
the invention provides in this embodiment: An assembly
comprising at least one engine capable of spinning at least one
heterogeneously distributed mass, said engine rigidly connected
ao to a rigid holder plate for holding an array of containers and
said engine connected to a rigid lid plate via a first set of
flexible elements and wherein the holder plate and the lid plate
forms a slit for positioning an array of containers and wherein
said holder plate is connected via a second set of flexible
a5 elements to a base construction, said second set of flexible
elements allowing the vibrational movements of the holder plate,
the lid plate, the engine and the first set of flexible
elements.
In another embodiment the assembly comprises a magnetic
3o device which comprises a permanent magnet or an electromagnet.
In the case of a permanent magnet such as a Neodymium Iron
Boran magnet, the magnetic device also comprise means for
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
23
providing movement of the magnet relative to a magnetizable
body comprised in the container of the primary assembly
applying an alternating magnetic force to a magnetizable body
present in the container.
In a specific embodiment this secondary assembly
preferably is a carousel construction comprising
(a) a horizontal rotatable support surface comprising means
for fastening, in a position different from the rotational
center, a container containing a movable and magnetizable body
to and a least one opening covered with the stained coherent
fabric,
(b) a permanent magnet connected to the axis, enabling
variation in the magnetic field applied to the container upon
rotating the support and
(c) means for rotating either the magnet, the support surface
or both so as to create a relative movement between magnet and
support surface.
The magnet is preferably placed in a fixed position so
that the support surface is the only movable part and so that
2o the test containers) upon rotation is allowed to come into
sufficient proximity of the magnet so that a magnetic field is
applied to the body in the test container, which is sufficient
to move the body within the container towards the magnet.
The invention also relates to the use of a coherent
a5 stained fabric as cover and/or lid on an array of at least
two, preferably at least 24, more preferably at least 96
containers having a volume of less than 10 ml for testing
cleaning ingredients.
Special method embodiments
3o Although for most enzymes acting directly on the cellulose in
textile, severe mechanical stress of the stained surface is
important, we have also found that when testing cleaning
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
24
effect of non cellulolytic enzymes such as protease, lipase
amylase and oxidoreductase on stained fabric, the mechanical
stress provided by repeatedly moving the sample liquid against
the fabric surprisingly gives test results which is very
similar to results obtained in real laundry processes. This
may be achieved by shaking or vibrating containers holding the
liquid samples and moving the liquid against the stained
fabric. Combined with the finding that a coherent stained
fabric may be used to test liquid samples in more than one
to container simultaneously by using the fabric as a lid and seal
on the containers (see description of the primary assemblies,
supra) these findings provide a powerful tool for automated
testing of these enzymes. Accordingly, the present invention
also relates to a method for testing cleaning effect of non
cellulolytic enzymes said method comprising:
(a) Preparing liquid samples comprising the non-cellulolytic
enzyme in an assembly according to any of the claims 30-40,
with the proviso that the container does not contain a solid
body capable of moving inside the container,
(b) repeatedly applying liquid sample to the stained fabric,
(c) evaluating the cleaning effect of applying solution on the
stained fabric.
This embodiment of course also encompasses within step (a) use
of all primary assemblies as described, supra for testing
cleaning ingredients.
EXAMPLES
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
Example 1 - Evaluation of cleaning effects of mechanical
stress in a model washing machine
Effect of mechanical stress on stain removal performance:
Light reflectance values of fabrics having different stains
s washed in a Launder-O-Meter at low and at high mechanical
conditions.
Preparation:
Stained fabrics were obtained from Equest Market Research
to Limited, Equest House, Greencroft Industrial Park, Annfield
Plain, Stanley, Co. Durham, DH9 7YB, England, a Launder-O-
Meter with 500 ml beakers was obtained from Roaches England
LTD, Washtec and a liquid detergent Ariel Futur was used.
15 Test procedure:
A wash solution of 200 ml city water with 1.3 ml Ariel Futur
liquid detergent and 5 stained fabrics (4 x 4 cm) was added to
each beaker. In beakers wherein low mechanical stress was to
be tested no bodies were added, while in beakers wherein high
2o mechanical stress were to be tested were added 10 Teflon
coated star magnets (24 mm diameter) and 30 steel nuts (25 mm
diameter). The stained fabric was washed in the Launder-O-
meter for 30 minutes wash at 40° C with or without.
z5 Evaluation of cleaning effect:
Light reflectance values of the stained fabrics were measures
by a Spectrafash 500 equipment from "datacolor international".
L-values ~ burnt beef ~ Make-up ~ grass/mud ~ chocolate
lce-cream
original stain 42.9 59.2 54.1 64.1
washed with low 57.4 163.5 172.8 74.1
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
26
mechanical stress
washed with high ~ 76.1 ~ 81. 0 ~ 84.2 ~ 88.1
mechanical stress
clean fabric ~ 92.8 ~ 92.8 ~ 92.8 ~ 92.8
noise level about +/- 1.5 units
From this experiment it can be observed that mechanical stress
to the stained fabric has a significant effect on the cleaning
effect of the detergent ingredients.
Example 2 - Testing system 1
A test device was developed according to figure 1, wherein 1
is a movable permanent Neodymium Iron Boran magnet (20 x 2.5 x
l0 1.3 cm) with 12200 Gauss strength; 2 - a stained fabric; 3 are
wells of a 96 well micro plate (350 u1 volume size); 4 -
liquid sample; 5 are magnetizable rectangular stainless steel
bodies (3 x 1.6 x 1.9 mm) which by movement of the magnet and
application of magnetic force jumps up, rolls and scrapes
is against the stained fabric while simultaneously depositing
liquid sample on the fabric.
Example 3 - Testing carbohydrase
The test device of example 2 was used to test a carbohydrate
2o hydrolyzing enzyme. A knitted cotton fabric coated with
tamarind seed flour and carbon black particles was used as
stained fabric, which was cut to a dimension fitting a 96 well
micro plate.
25 Preparation
150 u1 wash liquor containing 1 mg Ariel Futur liquid
detergent and 4 rectangular stainless steel bodies (3 x 1.6 x
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
27
1.9 mm) was added to each well. Every second array wells also
contained 1 ppm of a Xyloglucanase from Bacillus
licheniformis.
Process
The micro plate was heated to 40°C in a water bath and after
assembling the stained fabric to the top of the filled micro
plate, a strong magnet was moved every two seconds over the
stained fabric for 30 minutes.
to
Result
Differences in cleaning effect between wells containing the
enzyme and wells in which the enzyme is absent was visually
detectable as shown in figure 2, wherein "0" denotes no enzyme
and "1" denotes presence of 1 ppm of enzyme in the test
solution. This experiment also shows the benefits of using one
coherent stained fabric covering all 96 wells of the micro
plate, because although all 96 results are to be measured from
this stained fabric, the fabric has a size which is much more
2o easily handled in the measuring procedure, than if 96
individual pieces of stained fabric were to be measured.
Example 4 - correlation of performance in test method versus
real wash procedures
In this example the correlation between real wash performance
and using the method of the invention was evaluated for two
different enzymes.
Enzyme cleaning effect using the method of the
invention was evaluated as described in example 3 using 1 ppm
enzymes levels and 8 replica samples per enzyme. The two
3o different enzymes were A: Xyloglucanase from Bacillus
licheniformis and B: Xyloglucanase from Bacillus firmus. The
cleaning effect was evaluated by measuring the light reflectance
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
28
(L-values) of the portions of stained fabric subjected to the
test solutions and the mechanical stress. A Spectrafash 500
equipment from "Datacolor International" was used.
Enzyme cleaning effect using a real washing process was
evaluated by washing Tamarind seed flour/carbon black stained
fabric (5 x 5 cm swatches) in a Miele W715 washing machine, at
40° C, short cycle together with 0.5 kg realistic items. The
same levels and types of liquid detergent and enzyme were used
and for each enzyme 8 replica washes were preformed. The
to cleaning effect was evaluated by measuring L-values of the
stained fabric after wash.
Results
The results as given in the table below shows and excellent
correlation between using the method and device of the
invention and realistic washing processes
L-values of treated stains
micro plate system (SD) washing machine (SD)
Enzyme
A 62.2 0.7 65.2 1.6
B 57.0 0.5 58.9 0.7
no enzyme 54.3 ~ 0.9 ~ 50.0 ~ 1.5
Example 5 - Container design 1
zo A primary assembly suitable for use in testing cleaning
ingredients was prepared as shown in figure 3(A), wherein (1)
are wells of a micro plate having connecting parts between wells
which are lowered as compared to the edges of the wells; (2) is
a lid having an essentially plane surface facing the micro plate
well; (3) the contact zone between the lid and the well, wherein
the fabric, when inserted between (1) and (2), is compressed to
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
29
form a gasket seal. This assembly provides an excellent seal and
greatly prevents or inhibits the liquid sample from one well to
diffuse or migrate to a neighboring well. This assembly also
provides that the stained fabric surface accessible to liquid
sample and mechanical stress is at least the same as the area of
the opening of the well.
Example 6 - Container design 2
Another primary assembly suitable for use in testing cleaning
ingredients was prepared as shown in figure 3(B), wherein (1)
to are wells of a micro plate having connecting parts between wells
which are lowered as compared to the edges of the wells; (2) is
a lid having elevations fitting into depressions formed around
the wells in the micro plate; (3) is the contact zone between
the lid and the micro plate well, wherein the fabric, when
inserted between (1) and (2), is compressed to form a gasket
seal. This assembly provides a slightly poorer sealing effect
than the assembly of example 5, but has the advantage that the
micro plate part of the contact zone is subjected to less wear
upon use and has increased durability. Also the this assembly
2o provides for the stained fabric surface accessible to liquid
sample and mechanical stress being at least the same as the
inner area of the well opening.
Example 7 - Container design 3
Another primary assembly suitable for use in testing cleaning
a5 ingredients was prepared as shown in figure 3(C), wherein (1)
are wells of a micro plate having connecting parts between wells
which are lowered as compared to the edges of the wells; (2) is
a lid having elevations fitting into the opening of the well
(like a cork) and to depressions formed around the well in the
3o micro plate; (3) is the contact zone between the lid and the
micro plate well, wherein the fabric, when inserted between (1)
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
and (2), is compressed to form a gasket seal. This assembly
provides a slightly poorer seal than the assembly of example 5,
but as in example 6 possesses increased durability because the
micro plate part of the contact zone is subj ected to less wear
5 upon use.
Example 8 - Container design 4
Another primary assembly suitable for use in testing cleaning
ingredients was prepared as shown in figure 3(D), wherein (1)
are wells of a micro plate having connecting parts between wells
to which are heightened as compared to the edges of the wells; (2)
is a lid having elevations fitting into the opening of the wells
(like a cork) ; (3) is the contact zone between the lid and the
micro plate well, wherein the fabric, when inserted between (1)
and (2), is compressed to form a gasket seal.
15 Example 9 - Container design 5
Another primary assembly suitable for use in testing cleaning
ingredients was prepared as shown in figure 3E, which is similar
to the assembly of example 6, with exception that the elevations
of the lid forms curves instead of straight tilted lines. This
zo provides an increased durability.
Example 10 - Container design 6
An another primary assembly suitable for use in testing cleaning
ingredients was prepared as shown in figure 3F, which is similar
to the assembly of example 8, with exception that the elevations
25 Of the lid forms curves instead of straight tilted lines. This
provides an increased durability.
Example 11 - Container design 7
An another primary assembly suitable for use in testing cleaning
3o ingredients was prepared as shown in figure 4, which is similar
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
31
to the assembly of example 6, with the exception that this
assembly was made in the standard format of a 96 well plate with
standard size of wells and distances between. wells. Accordingly,
this assembly will fit into standard equipment developed for
this format. (1) is the support lid, (2) is the stained fabric
and (3) is the micro plate.
Example 12 - Testing system 2
A secondary assembly which further comprises a device for
to providing mechanical force to the stained fabric was prepared
as shown in figure 5. In this secondary assembly a primary
assembly of the type described in example 11 was fastened to a
NTK 15 or NTK 25 type pneumatic flask vibrator available from
Copenhagen Vibrator Products, Industrivej 15, 4652 Harlev,
Denmark. This construction is showed in figure 5, wherein the
primary assembly (1) is mounted with bolts (9) on the top side
of a rigid plate (2) and a cylinder (3) is mounted on the down
side of the rigid plate (2), The cylinder (3) surround a piston
(4) with mass elements (5), capable of moving in the
zo longitudinal direction of the cylinder (3) by applying
compressed air to valves or apertures (6) in the cylinder. This
rigid plate (2) is rested on a stationary support (7) via rubber
connectors (8) which is capable of moderating the vibrating
force .
z5 Example 13 - Effect of mechanical stress
Five different microbially derived xyloglucanases; A, B, C, D,
E and one cellulase F were tested with (+) and without (-)
using steel beads to provide mechanical stress using the test
plate of example 11 fitted in the assembly of example 12. Each
so enzyme were diluted to give a final concentration of 1/16,1/8,
1/, %, 1, and 2 ppm in the 96 well plate containing 6.7 g/1
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
32
Ariel Color liquid detergent in 15°dH H20 in a final volume of
160 ~.1. Eight repeats of each dilutions were carried out. A
fabric stained with tamarind gum and carbon black was used.
Each well in which high mechanical stress were to be tested
contained 3x2 mm steel beads, wells wherein low mechanical
stress where to be tested contained no steel beads. Using this
construct the stained fabric was which was washed for 30 min
at 26°C under vibration by the vibrating device.
The cleaning results were evaluated by measuring light
to reflectance of the cleaned fabric.
Results
Enzyme doseEnzyme
~.gjml A- A+ B- B+ C- C+ D- D+ E- E+ F- F+
0 171818821694188018841919165420121552210516481929
0.0313 167120031679202516702015192518301836211617931940
0..0625 174519921859221516202046165019701746197717061924
0.125 180821681914210516051903174620561686198916981946
0.25 174123431693232118141978180521061775225616871997
0.5 186225241867238117992224179421861607231217141848
1 188426391804246817842086180821271830215617471836
2 181524241743232017682190171222341693229816851833
The results show that for each enzyme treatment with the steel
beads increases removal of stain, similar to results
obtainable for real washing processes. Also a ranking of the
different enzyme efficiency could be was deducted from the
results, rendering enzyme A the most efficient enzyme.
zo Example 14 - test of non-cellulolytic enzymes with no body to
induce mechanical stress
In order to show the applicability of the system to other
enzymes a series of proteases were tested using the assembly of
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
33
example 12 using both commercial 96 well test plate and the
custom made test plate of example 11. The proteases were mixed
in amounts of 0, 5, 10, 20 and 40 nanomoles per liter to samples
of a commercial OMO color detergent dissolved in 15°dH water
yielding a pH of about 10.4 in the solution. The test samples
were transferred to the wells of the test plates, and all well
openings in each test plate were subsequently covered by one
single coherent EMPA 117 stained test fabric and a lid. The
wells of the test plate did not contain a body for providing
to mechanical force.
The test plates were then mounted on the assembly of
example 12 and vibrated at 30°C, and after this treatment each
part of the test fabric corresponding to single samples was
evaluated. For both plates a clear indication of samples having
i5 a high protease concentration was observed, so that samples
having higher protease concentrations had removed more stain
from the fabric in an area corresponding to the circumferences
of the wells. However, for the commercial plate it was evident
that the test samples had spread beyond the area of the stained
zo fabric which was circumferenced by the edge of the well (i.e.
the area of the opening of the well ) so that stain removal was
also seen outside the areas of the stained fabric directly
exposed to the test samples. Accordingly, the test samples were
leaking from the wells or migrated through capillary effects to
25 areas of the stained test fabric not directly covering the
opening of the wells. This phenomenon obscured the results of
the test. The results of using a stained fabric with a
commercial 96 well test plate can be seen in figure 6. In figure
6 A-D represents different proteases tested at different
3o concentrations.
Using the custom made test plate, the test samples were
effectively confined to act only on the area of the stained
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
34
fabric covering the opening of the well. Consequently very clear
cleaning results were obtained, where the effect of different
concentrations could easily be identified. Moreover it was
possible to visually determine that protease D had better
cleaning performance than protease A. This result also show that
for proteases and other non-cellulose hydrolyzing enzymes
application of mechanical force by means of a solid body
colliding with the stained fabric is not necessary for these
enzymes. Moreover, this method and system generated results
to which are comparable to the performance of the test enzyme under
real washing conditions those obtainable with a real washing
procedure.
Example 15 - screening fox pectate lyases with improved stain
release properties
23 different pectate lysases were tested for their ability to
remove pectate stain from fabric using a test devise which was
a carousel construction comprising
(a) a horizontal rotatable support disc comprising means for
fastening, in a position different from the rotational
2o centre, of 4 96-well microplates sealed with stained
fabric. Each well contained in addition to liquid sample
5 solid magnetic implements for providing mechanical
stress.
(b) a fixed permanent magnet which was positioned to enable
passing the microplates under the magnet by rotating the
support disc in sufficient proximity to cause the
magnetic implements in the wells to be attracted by the
magnet and to collide with the stained fabric.
(c) an electric engine for rotating the support disk at a
3o constant rate
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
Samples of pectate lyases (8 replicas) at two different
concentrations (1 ppm and 0.1 ppm) were mixed, in each well,
with 150 ~.l of a commercial detergent dissolved in city water
(2.5 mmol/1 hardness). Knitted cotton fabrics impregnated with
5 a citrus peel based pectate stain was positioned over the
microplates covering all the wells and the fabric was fixed
using a lid. A washing process was now simulated by rotating
the support disk at a constant speed so that the microplates
continuously passed closely under the magnet, whereby the
to magnetic implements were lifted towards the magnet thereby
colliding with the fabric sealing the wells. This process was
continued for 30 minutes at 40 °C.
After completing the simulated washing process the light
reflectance of stained fabrics were measured as an indication
15 of how much of the stain which had been cleaned off by each
pectate lyase. The results were inserted in a plot (figure 8),
where the pectate lyases were plotted at the X-axis (numbers
1-23) and the relative reflectance was plotted at the Y-axis.
In the plot higher relative reflectance means higher cleaning
2o performance of the pectate lyase. In the plot series A
indicates high pectate lyase concentration in washing liquor
(1 ppm) and series B indicates low concentration of pectate
lyase ( 0 .1 ppm) .
The results clearly show that some pectate lyases are
significantly better than others in removing citrus peel
3o stains. Pectate lyase 1 is clearly best at low dose while
pectate lyase 3 is clearly best at high dose. The results also
shows, in conjunction with examples on the present invention
yielding results very close to those obtained in real washing
processes, screening procedures, involving huge amounts of
s5 samples, can be made using the method of the present
invention, which would be extremely demanding, if not
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
36
impossible, should the screening have been made using real
washing procedures.
Example 1,6 - Screening for effects of water hardness in
different washing conditions
This example shows that the methods and systems of the present
invention also is very useful for testing and screening of
compounds present in a washing liquor, which do not possess
cleaning properties in themselves, but which interferes in the
to washing process by affecting the action of active cleaning
compounds and that the methods and systems of the present
invention generates result fully comparable with those
obtained in a commercial washing machine.
In this example it was tested how two different levels of
water hardness (0 mM and 8 mM) affected the washing process at
European washing condition in the method of the invention, at
North American washing conditions in the method of the
invention and at European conditions in a commercial washing
machine.
2o For the European conditions washing liquors containing 4
g/1 of a commercial European liquid detergent was prepared
with water of low and high hardness.
For the North American conditions a washing liquor
containing 1.2 g/1 of a commercial North American liquid
detergent was prepared with water of low and high hardness.
8 different stains were prepared on knitted cotton
fabrics .
For European conditions the stained fabrics were tested
both by the method of the invention as in example 15 (96 well
3o microplates in the carousel system) and in a commercial
European washing machine (Miele) at 40°C and a 30 minutes wash
time. For the North American conditions the stained fabrics
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
37
were tested by the method of the invention as in example 15 at
32°C and a 12 minutes wash time. 12 replicas were made of each
sample to estimate experimental errors.
The cleaning effect of each sample was evaluated by
measuring the light reflectance of the stained fabric after
cleaning.
The results showed that under European conditions the
method of the present invention generates the same or very
similar stain removal profiles as obtained in a full-scale
to European wash machine.
The results also showed that use of the present invention
enables quantitative prediction of differences in cleaning
performance between European conditions and North American
conditions. The results showed substantial differences for
some stains between North American versus European conditions.
Overall, the system proved to be fully functional also for
screening other compounds than those directly involved in the
cleaning process such as salts, builders, polymers and the
like levels.
Example 17 - screening cleaning compositions for hard surface
cleaning.
This example shows that the methods and systems of the present
invention also is very useful for testing and screening of
improved compounds or compositions used for cleaning hard
surfaces and that the method and system of the present
invention generates result fully comparable with those
obtained in internationally recognized test methods.
In this example the cleaning effect of 3 different
3o commercially available cleaning compositions agents and one
new composition were tested in the methods of the present
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
38
invention and the recognized "wet-abrasion-scrub-test"
conventionally used for testing such compositions.
In the Wet-Abrasion-Scrub Tester four separate sponges
with cleaning composition are scrubbing in a controlled manner
over four soiled hard surfaces. The stain contains a mixture
of grease and particular dirt, which have been heat treated to
get a hard, tenacious soil on the hard surface. The sponges
with the cleaning composition are moving periodically over the
soiled hard surfaces until the tiles are clean and the numbers
to of strokes are counted. These numbers are used to calculate
the Cleaning Index, which is always referring to a benchmark
or reference product. However this approach is a very tedious,
labor and time intensive procedure.
For the Wet-Abrasion-Scrub test stainless steel metal
plates were soiled with an oil mix and Carbon Black based
soiling. The cleaning test was executed with four plates at
room temperature (20°C) in 2 minutes. The strokes were counted
and calculated with "Mr. Proper All Purpose Cleaner" as the
reference.
2o For the test according to the present invention stainless
steel metal plates were cut to the size of a 96 well micro
plate and soiled with an oil mix and Carbon Black based
soiling. All 96 wells were filled with 150 ml of the cleaning
compositions (14 replicates). A test was conducted as in
example 15 at room temperature (20°C) in 2 minutes.
Assessment of the cleaning result was achieved by
measuring light reflectance (via image scan and calibrated
against L scale, wherein the pixel density gave information
about stain removal).
3o The results were inserted in a plot (figure 9), where the
cleaning compositions were plotted at the X-axis (1. - AJAX all
purpose cleaner, 2 - Mr. Proper all purpose cleaner, 3 - new
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
39
cleaning composition and 4 - Mr. Proper W3-spray with bleach)
and the cleaning effect was plotted at the Y-axis. In the plot
series A indicates results from the method of the invention
and B indicates results obtained with the wet-abrasion-scrub-
test.
The results clearly show both systems that some cleaning
compositions are more efficient than others in removing the
selected soiling. The results also shows that results of the
method and system of the present invention are fully
to comparable to those of the far more tedious, laborious and
time intensive wet-abrasion-scrub procedure and that the
method of the present invention may advantageously replace the
conventional method.
l5
Example 18 - testing effect of v~rater hardness on cleaning
performance of protease enzymes
Following example 16 the method of the present invention was
2o used to evaluate the effect of water hardness in the washing
liquor on the removal of different grass stains impregnated on
fabric.
5 in-house stained fabric, impregnated with 5 different
grass stains and 2 commercially available grass stained fabric
z5 (EMPA Switzerland) were tested.
Two washing liquors were prepared by dissolving 4 g/1 of a
commercial detergent in either soft water (0 mM Caz+/Mgz+) or
hard water (10 mM Caz+/Mgz+) .
96 well microplates were filled with 150 ml wash solution
3o prepared from either hard or soft water in 8 replicates. grass
stained fabrics were fitted to the microplates. The stained
fabrics were treated with the wash solutions for 30 minutes at
CA 02429418 2003-05-20
WO 02/42740 PCT/DKO1/00785
40 °C as in example 15 using the carousel system. Assessment of
the stain removal was done by measing the light reflectance of
the cleaned fabric by image scanning calibrated against L scale.
The results were inserted in a plot (figure 11), wherein
5 the fabric having different grass stains were plotted on the X
axis (A = in house made grass stain 1, B - in house made grass
stain 2, - in house made grass stain 3, D = in house made grass
stain 4, E - in house made grass stain 5, F = commercial grass
stain EMPA 164). The reflectance of cleaned fabric (0 mM
to hardness) minus reflectance of cleaned fabric (10 mM hardness)
were plotted on the Y-axis. The results indicated that the water
hardness had a tremendous effect on the cleaning performance of
the detergent on grass stains, while it was different for
different stain types. In figure 11 higher values means more
15 lowering of the performance at high water hardness. Such results
easily obtainable by the method and system of the invention are
important when developing improved detergent compositions.
