Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02437119 2003-07-30
WO 02/066156 PCT/GB02/00243
A COMBINATION OF A GUARD BED AND A CATALYST BED
This invention relates to catalysts and in particular to copper catalysts.
Copper catalysts are often employed for reactions involving hydrogen, for
example
simple hydrogenation reactions, e.g. the hydrogenation of aldehydes to
alcohols, for methanol
synthesis (where carbon oxides are reacted with hydrogen), methanol
decomposition (where
methanol, often in admixture with steam, is decomposed to form hydrogen and
carbon oxides)
and the shift reaction (where carbon monoxide is reacted with steam to produce
hydrogen and
carbon dioxide) and the reverse shift reaction. Often, in order to obtain the
optimum activity
and stability of the catalyst, the catalyst is made with the copper in a
highly dispersed form, for
example by precipitation of a copper compound in the presence of, or together
with, one or
more support materials, especially zinc, magnesium, chromium and/or aluminium
compounds.
Following such precipitation, the composition is heated to convert the copper
compounds, and,
if necessary also support materials, to the corresponding oxides. Prior to use
for the desired
reaction, the copper oxide is reduced to metallic copper. Particularly
suitable catalysts for the
above reactions are copper/zinc oxide/alumina and copper/zinc oxide/chromia
compositions.
In some cases part of the zinc may be replaced by magnesium and/or part of the
alumina or
chromic may be replaced by ceria or a rare earth such as lanthana.
The copper catalysts are readily de-activated by the presence of chlorine
compounds,
such as hydrogen chloride, in the process gas undergoing the reaction. Traces
of such
chlorine compounds may arise from contaminants in the materials, for example
hydrocarbon
feedstock, steam, or air employed to make the process gas. Such chlorine
compounds react
with the active copper, forming copper chloride. Since copper chloride is
relatively low melting,
at the temperatures at which the catalysts are commonly employed, e.g. 150-
300°C, the copper
is mobilised and tends to aggregate resulting in a loss of dispersion of the
copper and
consequent loss of activity of the catalyst. Also where zinc and/or magnesium
oxide is a
component of the catalyst, likewise the corresponding chlorides may be formed,
and these
likewise are liable to be mobilised resulting in loss of the stabilising
effect of the zinc or
magnesium oxides, again with the consequent loss of dispersion and activity of
the copper.
It has been proposed in our co-pending PCT application WO 01/17674 to employ a
guard
bed upstream of the copper catalyst wherein the guard bed is a particulate
composition
containing a lead compound and a support therefor. That application discloses
that the guard
bed particles may be made by impregnating particles of the support with a
solution of a suitable
lead salt, for example lead nitrate, by precipitating an appropriate lead
compound in the
presence of particles of the support material, or by co-precipitating a lead
compound and the
support, or a precursor to the support. The preferred lead compound was lead
nitrate.
However, there is a risk when using lead nitrate that, in the event of a plant
upset, water may
CA 02437119 2003-07-30
WO 02/066156 PCT/GB02/00243
2
condense on the guard bed and leach the lead nitrate from the support and wash
it on to the
downstream copper catalyst. Lead compounds tend to poison copper catalysts and
so there is
the risk that the activity of the copper catalysts may be diminished. For this
reason it may be
preferable to use a lead compound that is not soluble in water. While lead
oxide is insoluble,
we have found that it is not very effective as a chloride guard under some
process conditions.
However we have found that lead carbonate and basic lead carbonate are
effective chloride
guards. While the aforementioned PCT application suggested that lead carbonate
or basic
lead carbonate could be employed, it did not specifically disclose the
production of guard beds
containing such lead compounds.
We have found that shaped units suitable for use as guard beds can be made
simply
from finely divided lead carbonate and/or basic lead carbonate.
Accordingly the present invention provides a combination comprising a bed of a
particulate copper-containing catalyst and, upstream of the catalyst bed, a
guard bed of shaped
units formed from lead carbonate and/or basic lead carbonate particles having
an average (by
weight) particle size below 100 pm. Particularly the lead carbonate and/or
basic lead
carbonate particles have an average (by weight) particle size below below 50
pm and
preferably substantially all the particles have a size below 120 pm.
The guard bed is in the form of shaped units: these preferably have maximum
and
minimum dimensions in the range 1.5 to 20 mm, particularly 3 to 6 mm. The
aspect ratio of the
shaped units, i.e. the ratio of the maximum to minimum dimensions, is
preferably less than 2.
The shaped units may be of regular shape, e.g. spheres, cylinders etc. and may
be made
by a "dry" technique wherein a powder composition is compacted to the desired
shape, in e.g.
a pelleting machine, or a "wet" method wherein a powder composition is mixed
with a suitable
liquid to form a paste which is then extruded to the desired cross section and
the extrudate is
cut or broken into units of the requisite length. A granulation method may
alternatively be
employed wherein a powder composition is mixed with a small amount of liquid,
often water,
insufficient to give a paste, and the resulting damp mixture granulated or
pelletised by means of
a pellet mill, for example of the type used for pelleting animal feedstuffs,
wherein the mixture to
be pelleted is charged to a rotating perforate cylinder through the
perforations of which the
mixture is forced by a bar or roller within the cylinder. The resulting
extruded mixture is cut
from the surface of the rotating cylinder by a doctor knife positioned to give
pellets of the
desired length.
Where a "wet" shaping technique is employed, the shaped units are preferably
dried
before use.
The shaped units are preferably formed from a mixture of the lead carbonate
and/or
basic lead carbonate particles and finely divided support particles of an
inert material such as
CA 02437119 2003-07-30
WO 02/066156 PCT/GB02/00243
3
alumina, a hydrated alumina, chromic, zirconia, titanic, or, less preferably,
silica. Alumina, or
hydrated alumina, is the preferred support.
Whichever shaping method is used to form the shaped units, a processing aid
such as a
lubricant and/or a binder is preferably incorporated into the powder
composition. Lubricants,
which are generally employed when a "dry" processing route such as pelleting
is used include
graphite, fatty acids and salts thereof such as stearates. Binders that may be
used may be
inorganic, for example a clay, e.g. attapulgite, bentonite, sepiolite or
colloidal magnesium
aluminium silicate, or a cement, e.g. a calcium aluminate cement, or organic,
e.g. a soluble
carbohydrate such as starch, alginate or xanthan gum; a cellulose ether, e.g.
hydroxy methyl
cellulose; a protein; a polyvinyl alcohol, ester, acetal, or ether or mixed
derivative e.g. a partially
hydrolysed polyvinyl acetate; a polyalkylene oxide; a polyacrylate or
methacrylate; or
polyacrylamide or polymethacrylamide. Organic binders are preferred. The
amount of binder
employed is generally 0.5 to 10%, particularly 1 to 5%, by weight, based upon
the combined
weights of the lead compound, support (if any), and binder.
Preferred compositions, containing a binder and a support, have a lead content
of 5 to
75%, particularly 10 to 60%, by weight of lead (expressed as metal) and based
upon the
combined weights of the lead compound, support, and binder.
If an organic binder is used, then irrespective of whether a wet or dry
shaping method is
employed, the shaped units are preferably calcined in air to burn out the
binder. The
calcination temperature is preferably in the range 200 to 400°C,
preferably below the
decomposition temperature of the lead compound. Preferably the guard bed
material has a
BET surface area greater than 50m2/g and most preferably greater than 125mz/g.
We have
found that the calcination process may increase the surface area of the guard
bed material.
For example, absorbents made from basic lead carbonate and alumina trihydrate
and calcined
at 300°C typically have a BET surface area of approximately 150m~/g.
The guard bed and the catalyst bed are used as fixed beds and may be in the
same
vessel or in different vessels, with the guard bed upstream of the catalyst
bed. Preferably the
process gas flows down through the catalyst bed: thus where the guard and
catalyst beds are
in the same vessel, the guard bed may be a layer of the guard bed particles on
top of the
catalyst bed particles. If desired there may be a layer of an inert material
between the guard
bed and the catalyst bed to facilitate replenishment of the guard bed without
disturbing the
catalyst bed.
Therefore according to a further aspect of the invention we provide a process
for
performing a catalytic reaction using a bed of a copper-containing catalyst,
comprising passing
a process gas through a guard bed of shaped units formed from lead carbonate
and/or basic
CA 02437119 2003-07-30
WO 02/066156 PCT/GB02/00243
4
lead carbonate particles having an average (by weight) particle size below 100
pm and then
passing said process gas through the bed of copper-containing catalyst.
The invention is of particular utility in relation to the shift reaction. In
this process a
process gas stream containing carbon monoxide and steam, and often other
components such
as hydrogen, carbon dioxide, methane, and/or nitrogen, is passed through a bed
of the copper-
containing catalyst, especially a copper/zinc oxide/alumina or copper/zinc
oxide/chromia
catalyst in which some of the zinc oxide may be replaced by magnesia and/or
some of the
alumina and/or chromic may be replaced by a rare earth, at a temperature in
the range 150 to
300°C, especially at an inlet temperature in the range 150 to
250°C. The process gas
preferably contains 1 to 4% by volume of carbon monoxide, and at least one
mole of steam per
mole of carbon monoxide. Preferably the process gas contains 20 to 50% by
volume of steam.
Typically the process is operated at a wet gas space velocity in the range
2000 to 5000 h-', and
at pressures ranging from atmospheric to 50 bar abs.
In addition to absorbing chloride, it will be appreciated that the lead
species will also
absorb sulphur compounds and so the bed will also act as a sulphur guard bed.
The invention is illustrated by the following examples in which various guard
beds were
tested by charging 0.5 g (about 0.4 ml) of particles of a standard copper
oxide/zinc
oxide/alumina low temperature shift catalyst precursor containing about 50% by
weight of
copper oxide and having a particle size in the range 0.6 - 1.0 mm to a
microreactor with 0.25 g
(about 0.1 ml) of particles of fused alumina of particle size 0.6 - 1.0 mm
disposed as a layer on
top of the shift catalyst precursor and 0.2 ml (about 0.36 g) of the guard
material particles of
particle size 0.6 -1.0 mm on top of the fused alumina particles to give a
total catalyst bed of
volume of about 0.70 ml.
The copper oxide in the catalyst precursor was reduced to metallic copper by
passing a
stream of nitrogen containing 2% by volume of hydrogen down through the
microreactor at a
pressure of about 28 bar abs. at a flow rate of 15 litres/hour (at NTP) while
the microreactor
was heated from ambient temperature to 220°C and held at this
temperature for 95 minutes to
give a total reduction time of 3.5 hours.
The catalyst activity for the water gas shift reaction was determined by
passing
50 litres/hour (at NTP) of a gas mixture comprising 1 part by volume of steam
to 2 parts by
volume of a gas of volume composition H~ 55%, C02 15%, CO 5%, and N~ 25%
through the
microreactor at a temperature of 220°C and a pressure of about 28 bar
abs.
To simulate chloride contamination, after the gas mixture had been passed
through the
catalyst bed for about 6 hours, HCI was added to the gas mixture to give an
HCI concentration
in the wet gas of 1 ppm by volume. Under these fixed test conditions, the
variation of CO
CA 02437119 2003-07-30
WO 02/066156 PCT/GB02/00243
conversion with time on line was measured using in-line infra-red detection. A
decrease in CO
conversion with time is indicative of loss of activity of the catalyst.
Example 1
In this example a chloride absorbent is made from lead carbonate and alumina
trihydrate
5 powders. The lead carbonate powder had a weight average particle size of 4.5
pm with
essentially all of the particles having a size in the range 1 to 60 pm. The
alumina trihydrate
powder had a BET surface area of 0.5 m~lg and a weight average particle size
of 22 pm with
essentially all of the particles having a size in the range 1 to 100 pm.
94 g of the alumina trihydrate powder was mixed for 5 min with 6 g of the lead
carbonate
powder and 2 g of graphite as a lubricant and the mixture formed into squat
cylindrical pellets
of 3 mm diameter and 0.6 mm height using a pelleting machine. The pellets had
a nominal
lead content of 4.6% by weight and a density of 2.3 g/ml.
Example 2
Example 1 was repeated using 88 g of the alumina trihydrate powder and 12 g of
the
lead carbonate powder to give pellets having a nominal lead content of 9.1 %
by weight and
density 2.5 g/ml.
Example 3
Example 1 was repeated using 80 g of the alumina trihydrate powder and 24 g of
the
lead carbonate powder to give pellets having a nominal lead content of 17.6%
by weight and a
density of 2.5 g/ml.
Example 4
Example 1 was repeated using 60 g of the alumina trihydrate powder and 48 g of
the
lead carbonate powder to give pellets having a nominal lead content of 33.8%
by weight and a
density of 2.9 g/ml.
Examale 5 (comparative)
For purposes of comparison a commercially available absorbent comprising lead
oxide
on alumina having a nominal lead content of about 20.5% by weight was
employed.
The materials of Examples 1 to 5 were tested as described above: prior to use
the pellets
were broken down to particles of size 0.6 - 1 mm. Since the material of
Example 5 had a
significantly lower bulk density than the materials of Examples 1 - 4, in this
case a similar
volume (about 0.2 ml) of absorbent was used but its weight was only about 0.19
g.
The % CO conversion was determined for a period of several days with
measurements
being taken at regular intervals. To assist comparison, the CO conversion
measurements were
plotted against time-on-line and a smooth curve drawn through the points for
each sample.
(The individual points showed little variance from the smooth curves). From
these plots, the
CA 02437119 2003-07-30
WO 02/066156 PCT/GB02/00243
6
conversion every 24 hours was determined and the results are shown in the
following Table 1
wherein the % CO conversion figures have been rounded to the nearest integer.
Table 1
Time on CO Conversion
line (%)
(days) Ex 1 Ex 2 Ex 3 Ex 4 Ex 5
1 86 84 86 85 85
2 82 82 84 83 81
3 68 78 83 81 72
4 40 65 80 80 50
0 42 75 79 7
6 64 78 0
7 45 77
8 8 76
9 0 75
73
Example 6
360 g of the alumina trihydrate powder as used in Example 1 was mixed for 5
min with
5 287.4 g of the lead carbonate powder as used in Example 1 to give a powder
mixture having a
nominal lead content of 34.4% by weight. The powder mixture was then dried for
2 hours in an
oven at 110°C and then divided into four parts. One portion was
pelleted as described in
Example 1 with the addition of 2% by weight of graphite as a lubricant. The
other portions were
calcined for 2 hours at various temperatures before addition of 2% by weight
of graphite and
10 pelleting as described above. In each case the pellets had a density of
about 2.9 g/ml. The
weight loss on calcination was also determined. The materials were tested as
described above
and the results are shown in the following Table 2.
CA 02437119 2003-07-30
WO 02/066156 PCT/GB02/00243
7
Table 2
CO Conversion
(l)
Time on line
(days) Calcined Calcined Calcined
at at at
No calcination
200C 300C 400C
1 82 85 86 85
2 79 82 84 83
3 76 80 83 82
4 75 79 82 80
74 78 80 79
6 72 76 78 78
7 71 75 76 77
8 70 74 70 74
9 64 71 58 68
55 65 40 56
Weight loss - 2.4 16.7 21.6
(%)
Example 7
In this example, absorbents are made from basic lead carbonate and alumina
trihydrate.
The alumina trihydrate was the same as that used in Examples 1 to 4. Over
99.5% by weight
5 of the particles of basic lead carbonate had a size below 63 pm.
47.9 g of the basic lead carbonate powder and 60 g of the alumina trihydrate
powder
were mixed to give a powder mixture having a nominal lead content of 35.6%.
The powder
mixture was then dried for 2 hours in an oven at 110°C and then divided
into three parts. One
portion was pelleted as described in Example 1 with the addition of 2% by
weight of graphite as
10 a lubricant. The other portions were calcined for 2 hours at various
temperatures before
addition of 2% by weight of graphite and pelleting as described above. In each
case the pellets
had a density of about 2.7 g/ml except for the sample prepared using a
calcination temperature
of 200°C where the pellets had a density of 2.9 g/ml.
The materials were tested as described above and the results are shown in
Table 3.
CA 02437119 2003-07-30
WO 02/066156 PCT/GB02/00243
Table 3
CO Conversion
Time on line(%)
(days) Calcined Calcined
at at
Undried Dried at
110C
200C 300C
1 79 80 81 86
2 72 73 74 84
3 70 70 72 83
4 70 70 72 82
70 70 72 80
6 70 70 72 79
7 59 70 72 77
8 27 60 53 72
9 2 25 10 48
- 4 0 10
