Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02440528 2003-09-10
1
IONIC LIQUIDS AS SELECTIVE ADDITIVES FOR THE SEPARATION OF
CLOSE-BOILING OR AZEOTROPIC MIXTURES
The invention relates to a process and a method for separating
close-boiling or azeotropic mixtures by using ionic liquids as
selective additives in rectification.
Numerous liquid mixtures occur in industry which cannot be
separated by conventional rectification but rather are preferably
separated by extractive rectification [Stichlmair, S. and Fair,
J., Distillation, ISBN 0-471-25241-7, page 241 et seq.]. This
state of affairs is due to the similar boiling behavior of the
components of the mixture, that is to say their property of
distributing themselves between the vapor and liquid phase in
almost or exactly equimolar proportions at a defined pressure and
a defined temperature.
The effort of separating a binary liquid mixture composed of the
components i and j by rectification is reflected in what is known
as the separation factor aij, the distribution coefficient of
components i and j. The closer the separation factor approaches
the value one the more effort the separation of the components of
the mixture by conventional rectification requires, since either
the number of theoretical plates in the distillation column
andlor the reflux ratio at the top of the column must be
increased. If the separation factor assumes the value one an
azeotropic point is reached and further enrichment of the
components of the mixture is no longer possible, even if the
number of theoretical plates or the ref lux ratio is increased. in
general when making use of the separation factor it has to be
borne in mind that it can be greater than or less than 1
depending on whether the distribution coefficient of the low
boiler is in the numerator or in the denominator. Normally the
low boiler is placed in the numerator so that the separation
factor is great than 1.
A procedure frequently employed in industry for separating
close-boiling systems - by which is meant a separation factor
less than 1.2 for instance - or azeotropic systems involves
adding a selective additive, commonly referred to as the
entrainer, to an extractive rectification. A suitable additive
influences the separation factor by selective interaction with
one or more of the components of the mixture so that separation
of the close-boiling or azeotropically boiling components of the
0050/53318 CA 02440528 2003-09-10
2
mixture is made possible. In extractive rectification the
components obtained at the top and bottom of the column due to
the action of the entrainer are the target components for the
column.
A measure of the intensity of the interactions of the entrainer
with one or more of the components of the mixture is provided by
what is known as selectivity. Selectivity is defined as the ratio
of the limiting activity coefficient of component i to the
limiting activity coefficient of component j, components i and j
being present at an infinite degree of dilution in the entrainer
[Schult, C. J. et. al.; Infinite-dilution activity coefficients
.for several solutes in hexadecane and in n-methyl-2-pyrrolidone
(NMP): experimental measurements and UNIFAC predictions; Fluid
Phase Equilibria 179 (2001) pp.117-129]. As expounded by Schult
et. al., a higher entrainer selectivity results in a higher
relative volatility, a lower reflux ratio and hence in lower
separating costs. As disclosed later on, the aim is to achieve as
high a selectivity as possible, e.g. greater than 1.3, preferably
greater than 2Ø
The surprising discovery of the suitability of some ionic liquids
for the separation of azeotropic and/or close-boiling mixtures on
the basis of the entrainer selectivity and of the separation
factor is shown below. The activity coefficients playing a key
role in entrainer selectivity at infinite dilution can be
determined by a variety of methods, preferably by using
gas-liquid chromatography (GLC or GLPC) [Schult, C. J. et. al.;
Infinite-dilution activity coefficients for several solutes in
hexadecane and in n-methyl-2-pyrrolidone (NMP): experimental
measurements and UNIFAC predictions; Fluid Phase Equilibria 179
(2001) pp.117-129] and equations (4) and (6) used in the latter
publication by Schult et. al.
On grounds of costs, the aim is to minimize the amount of
additive to be employed. The entrainer is advantageously present
substantially in the liquid phase in the column. Large volumes
might result in an enlargement of the column diameter but would
always give rise to an increased pressure loss in the vapor phase
in the column and hence also to a greater energy loss.
Accordingly, an increase in the quantity of entrainer results in
increased capital and operating costs.
For a given column length and the same reflux ratio the higher
separation factor yields a purer product or for a given column
length and degree of purity of the overhead product the higher
separation factor results in a lower reflux ratio and hence in
CA 02440528 2009-08-25
3
energy savings. For a given degree of purity and a given reflux
ratio an increase in the quantity of entrainer and a higher
separation factor results in savings in capital costs due to
shortening of the length of the column. By these means the design
engineer has the power to minimize capital or running costs
(energy costs) on the basis of circumstances specific to the
site.
The invention relates to a process in which a novel
class of substances, ionic liquids, is employed for separating
close-boiling or azeotropic liquid mixtures since these ionic
liquids are surprisingly superioz, to the conventional additives.
The superiority can be seen directly in the selectivity and
separation factor. when a suitable ionic liquid is used the
separation factor at the azeotropic point is further removed from
the value of one than is the case when equivalent quantities of a
conventional additive are used.
More specifically the invention as broadly claimed relative to a process for
separating components of a mixture corriprising liquids or condensable gases
in the
condensed state comprising:
introducing an entrainer into the mixture,
wherein the entrainer is an ionic liquid and brings about a change in the
separation
factor of the components to be separated divergent from one;
wherein the ionic liquid is present at a total concentration of 5 to 90 mol %
in
the liquid phase, and
wherein the separation is carried out by extractive rectification.
The invention as claimed also relative to a process for separating components
of a
feed of liquids or condensable gases in the condensed state, wherein the
separation is carried out by extractive. rectification in a column, said
method
comprising:
introducing the feed to the column,
CA 02440528 2009-08-25
3a
introducing the feed to the column,
introducing an entrainer to the column above the feed,
obtaining the low-boiling component or components of the feed stream at the
top of the column,
obtaining a liquid mixture comprising all other components of the feed
stream, as bottom product, together with said entrainer at the bottom of the
column,
and
working up the liquid mixture, comprising the bottom product and entrainer,
at the bottom of the column in such a vvay that said entrainer is recovered
and the
components of the bottom product are obtained as a further fraction,
wherein the column is operated iri countercurrent flow,
wherein the entrainer is an ionic liquid and brings about a change in the
separation factor of the components to be separated divergent from one, and
wherein the ionic liquid is presen1: at a total concentration of 5 to 90 mol %
in
the liquid phase.
By ionic liquids is meant those defined by Wasserscheid and Keim
in Angewandte Chemie 2000, 112, 3926-3945. The ionic liquids
group of substances represents a new type of solvent. As set out
in the above publication ionic liquids are salts of nonmolecular,
ionic nature which melt at relatively low temperatures. They are
already in the molten state at relatively low temperatures less
than 200 C, preferably less thaii 150 C, particularly preferably
less than 100 C and at the same time are of relatively low
viscosity. They are highly soluble in a large number of organic,
inorganic and polymeric substances.
By comparison with ionic salts, ionic liquids are molten at
substantially lower temperatures (below 200 C as a rule) and
often have a melting point below 0 C, in some cases down to
-96 C, which is important for the industrial implementation of
extractive rectification.
CA 02440528 2009-08-25
3b
Moreover, ionic liquids are usually nonflammable, noncorrosive,
of low viscosity and are exceptional by having an immeasurable
vapor pressure.
Compounds designated according to the invention as ionic liquids
are those which have at least or.ie positive and at least one
negative charge but are overall neutral in charge and have a
melting point below 200 C, preferably below 100, particularly
preferably below 50 C.
0050/53318 CA 02440528 2003-09-10
4
Ionic liquids can also exhibit a plurality of positive or
negative charges, for example 1 to 5, preferably 1 to 4,
particularly preferably 1 to 3, very particularly preferably 1 to
2, but in particular one negative and one positive charge each.
The charges may be found at various localized or delocalized
regions inside a molecule, that is to say like betaine, or be
distributed in each case over a separate anion and cation. Those
ionic liquids are preferred which are built up out of at least
one cation and at least one anion. As stated above, the cation
and anion may be singly or multiply charged, preferably singly
charged.
Of course mixtures of different ionic liquids are also
conceivable.
Preferred cations are ammonium or phosphonium ions or those
cations containing at least a five- to six-membered heterocycle
possessing at least one phosphorus or nitrogen atom and
optionally an oxygen or sulfur atom, particularly preferably
those compounds containing at least one five- to six-membered
heterocycle possessing one, two or three nitrogen atoms and a
sulfur or an oxygen atom, very particularly preferably those
having one or two nitrogen atoms.
Particularly preferred ionic liquids are those having a molecular
weight of less than 1,000 g/mol, very particularly preferably
less than 350 g/mol.
Furthermore those cations are preferred which are selected from
compounds of the formulae (Ia) to (Iw):
Rz
Ra ~
R3 *R1
R7
(a) (b) (C)
0050/53318 CA 02440528 2003-09-10
R4 R3 R1
R3 N R2 R2 I`O R7
~
Ri''N ~ R7 iN
5
R l i p Ri R2 R3 R4
R7
(d) (e)
R4 Nn
R7 R2 N~N~ R' R5~ ~ N R' RI Rs R4 R'
R3 R2 Ri R4 R3 R2
(9) (h) Q)
Ri ii R7 R6 R5
~ N~ O 7 R6 Nn
~R2
5 N.,~ R O
R1,,N IRz
R
R3 7
R" 3 R2 R5 R4 ~ R~
R
U) (k) (1)
R5 R4 RS R4
R6 R3 RS ~44 R2 / R7
o
R1 ~N T 0 R7 R1 ,N Q R7 R3 g~
3L~'Rl
R
2 R2 R3
(m) (n) (0)
R2 R7 R3 R7 R3
N~O N-N U+ N-N
N
`" R2
/ ~ , ~ Ri ~N1
R3 0 Rl R O+
47
(P) (q) (~)
0050/53318 CA 02440528 2003-09-10
6
R1 R7 R' R3 R4
N-
~ ~IV 2
R3 \ Rs ~ R7 R O A_ ~.L R5
A
R2 R2 R1 R7
(s) (t) (u)
R' R7
IO+
R1-N- R3 Rj _p ~ R3
I (
R2 R2
(V) (W)
as well as oligopolymers or polymers containing these structures,
where
R1, R2, R3, R4, R5, R6 and R7 independently of one another each
stand for C1 - C18 alkyl, C2 - C18 alkyl optionally interrupted by
one or more oxygen and/or sulfur atoms and/or one or more
substituted or unsubstituted iznino groups, C6 - C12 aryl, C5 - C12
cycloalkyl or a five- to six-membered heterocycle possessing
oxygen, nitrogen and/or sulfur atoms, or two of them jointly form
an unsaturated, saturated or aromatic ring optionally interrupted
by one or more oxygen and/or sulfur atoms and/or one or more
substituted or unsubstituted imino groups, wherein said residues
can each be substituted by functional groups, aryl, alkyl,
aryloxy, alkyloxy, halogen, hetero atoms and/or heterocycles.
R1, R2, R3, R4, R5 and R6 can additionally represent hydrogen.
Moreover, R7 can stand for C1 - C18 alkyloyl (alkylcarbonyl), C1 -
C18- alkyloxycarbonyl, C5 - C12 cycloalkylcarbonyl or C6 - C12
aryloyl (arylcarbonyl), wherein said residues can be substituted
by functional groups, aryl, alkyl, aryloxy, alkyloxy, halogen,
hetero atoms and/or heterocycles.
Therein
0050/53318 CA 02440528 2003-09-10
7
C1 - C18 alkyl optionally substituted by functional groups, aryl,
alkyl, aryloxy,.alkyloxy, halogen, hetero atoms and/or
heterocycles stands by way of example for methyl, ethyl, propyl,
isopropyl, n-butyl, sec-butyl, tert-butyl, pentyl, hexyl, heptyl,
octyl, 2-ethylhexyl, 2,4,4-trimethylpentyl, decyl, dodecyl,
tetradecyl, heptadecyl, octadecyl, 1,1-dimethylpropyl,
1,1-dimethylbutyl, 1,1,3,3-tetramethylbutyl, benzyl,
1-phenylethyl, 2-phenylethyl, a,a-dimethylbenzyl, benzhydryl,
p-tolylmethyl, i-(p-butylphenyl)ethyl, p-chlorobenzyl,
2,4-dichlorobenzyl, p-methoxybenzyl, m-ethoxybenzyl,
2-cyanoethyl, 2-cyanopropyl, 2-methoxycarbonylethyl,
2-ethoxycarbonylethyl, 2-butoxycarbonylpropyl,
1,2-di-(methoxycarbonyl)ethyl, 2-methoxyethyl, 2-ethoxyethyl,
2-butoxyethyl, diethoxymethyl, diethoxyethyl, 1,3-dioxolan-2-yl,
1,3-dioxan-2-yl, 2-methyl-1,3-dioxolan-2-yl,
4-methyl-1,3-dioxolan-2-yl, 2-isopropoxyethyl, 2-butoxypropyl,
2-octyloxyethyl, chloromethyl, 2-chloroethyl, trichloromethyl,
trifluoromethyl, 1,1-dimethyl-2-chloroethyl, 2-methoxyisopropyl,
2-ethoxyethyl, butylthiomethyl, 2-dodecylthioethyl,
2-phenylthioethyl, 2,2,2-trifluoroethyl, 2-hydroxyethyl,
2-hydroxypropyl, 3-hydroxypropyl, 4-hydroxybutyl, 6-hydroxyhexyl,
2-aminoethyl, 2-aminopropyl, 3-aminopropyl, 4-aminobutyl,
6-aminohexyl, 2-methylaminoethyl, 2-methylaminopropyl,
3-methylaminopropyl, 4-methylaminobutyl, 6-methylaminohexyl,
2-dimethylaminoethyl, 2-dimethylaminopropyl,
3-dimethylaminopropyl, 4-dimethylaminobutyl,
6-dimethylaminohexyl, 2-hydroxy-2,2-dimethylethyl,
2-phenoxyethyl, 2-phenoxypropyl, 3-phenoxypropyl, 4-phenoxybutyl,
6-phenoxyhexyl, 2-methoxyethyl, 2-methoxypropyl, 3-methoxypropyl,
4-methoxybutyl, 6-methoxyhexyl, 2-ethoxyethyl, 2-ethoxypropyl,
3-ethoxypropyl, 4-ethoxybutyl or 6-ethoxyhexyl and,
C2 - C18 alkyl optionally interrupted by one or more oxygen and/or
sulfur atoms and/or one or more substituted or unsubstituted
iinino groups stands by way of example for 5-hydroxy-3-oxapentyl,
8-hydroxy-3,6-dioxaoctyl, 11-hydroxy-3,6,9-trioxaundecyl,
7-hydroxy-4-oxa-heptyl, 11-hydroxy-4,8-dioxaundecyl,
15-hydroxy-4,8,12-trioxapentadecyl, 9-hydroxy-5-oxa-nonyl,
14-hydroxy-5,10-oxatetradecyl, 5-methoxy-3-oxapentyl, -
8-methoxy-3,6-dioxaoctyl, 11-methoxy-3,6,9-trioxaundecyl,
7-methoxy-4-oxaheptyl, 11-methoxy-4,8-dioxaundecyl,
15-methoxy-4,8,12-trioxapentadecyl, 9-methoxy-5-oxanonyl,
14-methoxy-5,10-oxatetradecyl, 5-ethoxy-3-oxapentyl,
8-ethoxy-3,6-dioxaoctyl, il-ethoxy-3,6,9-trioxaundecyl,
7-ethoxy-4-oxa-heptyl, i1-ethoxy-4,8-dioxaundecyl,
0050/53318 CA 02440528 2003-09-10
8
15-ethoxy-4,8,12-trioxapentadecyl, 9-ethoxy-5-oxa-nonyl or
14-ethoxy-5,10-oxatetradecyl.
If two radicals form a ring these radicals may jointly stand for
1,3-propylene, 1,4-butylene, 2-oxa-1,3-propylene,
1-oxa-1,3-propylene, 2-oxa-l,3-propylene, 1-oxa-l,3-propenylene,
1-aza-1,3-propenylene, 1-(C1-C4 alkyl)-1-aza-1,3-propenylene,
1,4-buta-l,3-dienylene, 1-aza-1,4-buta-1,3-dienylene or
2-aza-l,4-buta-l,3-dienylene.
The number of oxygen and/or sulfur atoms and/or imino groups is
not limited. In general there are no more than 5 in the radical,
preferably no more than 4 and very particularly preferably no
more than 3.
Furthermore, between two hetero atoms there is usually at least
one carbon atom, preferably at least_two.
Substituted and unsubstituted imino groups can be by way of
example imino, methylimino, iso-propylimino, n-butylimino or
tert-butylimino.
Furthermore,
functional groups stands for carboxy, carboxamido, hydroxy,
di-(C1-C4 alkyl)-amino, C1-C4 alkyloxycarbonyl, cyano or C1-C4
alkyloxy,
C6- C12 aryl optionally substituted by functional groups, aryl,
alkyl, aryloxy, alkyloxy, halogen, hetero atoms and/or
heterocycles stands by way of example for phenyl, tolyl, xylyl,
a-naphthyl, A-naphthyl, 4-diphenylyl, chlorophenyl,
dichlorophenyl, trichlorophenyl, difluorophenyl, methylphenyl,
dimethylphenyl, trimethylphenyl, ethylphenyl, diethylphenyl,
iso-propyiphenyl, tert-butylphenyl, dodecylphenyl, methoxyphenyl,
dimethoxyphenyl, ethoxyphenyl, hexyloxyphenyl, methylnaphthyl,
isopropylnaphthyl, chloronoaphthyl, ethoxynaphthyl,
2,6-dimethylphenyl, 2,4,6-trimethylphenyl, 2,6-dimethoxyphenyl,
2,6-dichlorophenyl, 4-bromophenyl, 2- or 4-nitrophenyl, 2,4- or
2,6-dinitrophenyl, 4-dimethylaminophenyl, 4-acetylphenyl,
methoxyethylphenyl or ethoxymethylphenyl,
C5 - C12 cycloalkyl optionally substituted by functional groups,
aryl, alkyl, aryloxy, alkyloxy, halogen, hetero atoms and/or
heterocycles stands by way of example for cyclopentyl,
cyclohexyl, cyclooctyl, cyclododecyl, methylcyclopentyl,
dimethylcyclopentyl, methylcyclohexyl, dimethylcyclohexyl,
0050/53318 CA 02440528 2003-09-10
9
diethylcyclohexyl, butylcyclohexyl, methoxycyclohexyl,
dimethoxycyclohexyl, diethoxycyclohexyl, butylthiocyclohexyl,
chlorocyclohexyl, dichlorocyclohexyl, dichlorocyclopentyl as well
as a saturated or unsaturated bicyclic system such as norbornyl
or norbornenyl for example,
a five- to six-membered heterocycle possessing oxygen, nitrogen
and/or sulfur atoms stands by way of example for furyl,
thiophenyl, pyrryl, pyridyl, indolyl, benzoxazolyl, dioxolyl,
dioxyl, benzimidazolyl, benzthiazolyl, dimethylpyridyl,
methylquinolyl, dimethylpyrryl, methoxyfuryl, dimethoxypyridyl,
difluoropyridyl, methylthiophenyl, isopropylthiophenyl or
tert-butylthiophenyl and
C1 to C4 alkyl stands by way of example for methyl, ethyl, propyl,
isopropyl, n-butyl, sec-butyl or tert-butyl.
C1 - C18 alkyloyl (alkylcarbonyl) can be by way of example acetyl,
propionyl, n-butyloyl, sec-butyloyl, tert-butyloyl,
2-ethylhexylcarbonyl, decanoyl, dodecanoyl, chioroacetyl,
trichloroacetyl or trifluoroacetyl.
C1 - C18- alkyloxycarbonyl can be by way of example
methyloxycarbonyl, ethyloxycarbonyl, propyloxycarbonyl,
isopropyloxycarbonyl, n-butyloxycarbonyl, sec-butyloxycarbonyl,
tert-butyloxycarbonyl, hexyloxycarbonyl, 2-ethylhexyloxycarbonyl
or benzyloxycarbonyl.
C5 - C12 cycloalkylcarbonyl can be by way of example
cyclopentylcarbonyl, cyclohexylcarbonyl or cyclododecylcarbonyl.
C6 - C12 aryloyl (arylcarbonyl) can be by way of example benzoyl,
toluyl, xyloyl, a-naphthoyl, P-naphthoyl, chlorobenzoyl,
dichlorobenzoyl, trichlorobenzoyl or trimethylbenzoyl.
R1, R2, R3, R4, R5 and R6 independently of one another are
preferably hydrogen, methyl, ethyl, n-butyl, 2-hydroxyethyl,
2-cyanoethyl, 2-(methoxycarbonyl)ethyl, 2-(ethoxycarbonyl)-ethyl,
2-(n-butoxycarbonyl)ethyl, dimethylamino, diethylamino and
chlorine.
R7 is preferably methyl, ethyl, n-butyl, 2-hydroxyethyl,
2-cyanoethyl, 2-(methoxycarbonyl)-ethyl, 2-(ethoxycarbonyl)ethyl,
2-(n-butoxycarbonyl)ethyl, acetyl, propionyl, t-butyryl,
methoxycarbonyl, ethoxycarbonyl or n-butoxycarbonyl.
0050/53318 CA 02440528 2003-09-10
Particularly preferred pyridinium ions (Ia) are those in which
one of the radicals R1 to R5 is methyl, ethyl or chlorine, R7 is
acetyl, methyl, ethyl or n-butyl and all others are hydrogen, or
R3 is dimethylamino, R7 acetyl, methyl, ethyl or n-butyl and all
5 others are hydrogen, or R7 is acetyl, methyl, ethyl or n-butyl and
all others are hydrogen, or R2 is carboxy or carboxamido, R7
acetyl, methyl, ethyl or n-butyl and all others are hydrogen, or
R1 and R2 or R2 and R3 are 1,4-buta-1,3-dienylene, R7 acetyl,
methyl, ethyl or n-butyl and all others are hydrogen.
Particularly preferred pyridazinium ions (Ib) are those in which
one of the groups R1 to R4 is methyl or ethyl, R7 is acetyl,
methyl, ethyl or n-butyl and all others are hydrogen, or R7 is
acetyl, methyl, ethyl or n-butyl and all others are hydrogen.
Particularly preferred pyrimidinium ions (Ic) are those in which
R2 to R4 are hydrogen or methyl, R7 is acetyl, methyl, ethyl or
n-butyl and R1 is hydrogen, methyl or ethyl, or R2 and R4 are
methyl,=R3 is hydrogen and R1 is hydrogen, methyl or ethyl and R7
is acetyl, methyl, ethyl or n-butyl.
Particularly preferred pyrazinium ions (Id) are those in which
R1 to R4 are all methyl and
R7 is acetyl, methyl, ethyl or n-butyl, or R7 is acetyl, methyl,
ethyl or n-butyl and all others are hydrogen.
Particularly preferred imidazolium ions (Ie) are those in which
independently of one another
R1 is selected from methyl, ethyl, n-propyl, n-butyl, n-pentyl,
n-octyl, n-decyl, n-dodecyl, 2-hydroxyethyl or 2-cyanoethyl,
R7 is acetyl, methyl, ethyl or n-butyl and
R2 to R4 independently of one another stand for hydrogen, methyl
or ethyl.
Particularly preferred 1H-pyrazolium ions (If) are those in which
independently of one another
R1 is selected from hydrogen, methyl or ethyl,
R2, R3 and R4 from hydrogen or methyl and
R7 from acetyl, methyl, ethyl or n-butyl.
Particularly preferred 3H-pyrazolium ions (Ig) are those in which
independently of one another
R1 is selected from hydrogen, methyl or ethyl,
R2, R3 and R4 from hydrogen or methyl and
0050/53318 CA 02440528 2003-09-10
11
R7 from acetyl, methyl, ethyl or n-butyl.
Particularly preferred 4H-pyrazolium ions (Ih) are those in which
independently of one another
R1 to R4 are selected from hydrogen or methyl and
R7 from acetyl, methyl, ethyl or n-butyl.
Particularly preferred 1-pyrazolinium ions (Ii) are those in
which independently of one another
R1 to R6 are selected from hydrogen or methyl and
R7 from acetyl, methyl, ethyl or n-butyl.
Particularly preferred 2-pyrazolinium ions (Ij) are those in
which independently of one another
R1 is selected from hydrogen, methyl, ethyl or phenyl,
R7 from'acetyl, methyl, ethyl or n-butyl and
R2 to R6 from hydrogen or methyl.
Particularly preferred 3-pyrazolinium ions (Ik) are those in
which independently of one another
R1 or R2 is selected from hydrogen, methyl, ethyl or phenyl,
R7 from acetyl, methyl, ethyl or n-butyl and
R3 to R6 from hydrogen or methyl.
Particularly preferred imidazolinium ions (Il) are those in which
independently of one another
R1 or R2 is selected from hydrogen, methyl, ethyl, n-butyl or
phenyl,
R7 from acetyl, methyl, ethyl or n-butyl and
R3 or R4 from hydrogen, methyl or ethyl and
R5 or R6 from hydrogen or methyl.
Particularly preferred imidazolinium ions (Im) are those in which
independently of one another
R1 or R2 is selected from hydrogen, methyl or ethyl,
R7 from acetyl, methyl, ethyl or n-butyl and
R3 to R6 from hydrogen or methyl.
Particularly preferred imidazolinium ions (In) are those in which
independently of one another
R1, R2 or R3 is selected from hydrogen, methyl or ethyl,
0050/53318 CA 02440528 2003-09-10
12
R7 from acetyl, methyl, ethyl or n-butyl and
R4 to R6 from hydrogen or methyl.
Particularly preferred thiazolium ions (Io) or oxazolium ions
(Ip) are those in which independently of one another
Rl is selected from hydrogen, methyl, ethyl or phenyl,
R7 from acetyl, methyl, ethyl or n-butyl and
R2 or R3 from hydrogen or methyl.
Particularly preferred 1,2,4-triazolium ions (Iq) and (Ir) are
those in which independently of one another
R1 or R2 is selected from hydrogen, methyl, ethyl or phenyl,
R7 from acetyl, methyl, ethyl or n-butyl and
R3 from hydrogen, methyl or phenyl.
Particularly preferred 1,2,3-triazolium ions (Is) and (It) are
those ih which independently of one another
R1 is selected from hydrogen, methyl or ethyl,
R7 from acetyl, methyl, ethyl or n-butyl and
R2 or R3 from hydrogen or methyl, or
R2 and R3 are 1,4-buta-l,3-dienylene and all others are hydrogen.
Particularly preferred pyrrolidinium ions (Iu) are those in which
independently of one another
R1 and R7 are selected from acetyl, methyl, ethyl or n-butyl and
R2, R3, R4 and R5 stand for hydrogen.
Particularly preferred ammonium ions (Iv) are those in which
independently of one another
R7 is selected from acetyl, methyl, ethyl or n-butyl and
R1, R2, and R3 from methyl, ethyl, n-butyl, 2-hydroxyethyl, benzyl
or phenyl.
Particularly preferred phosphonium ions (Iw) are those in which
independently of one another
R7 is selected from acetyl, methyl, ethyl or n-butyl and
R1, R2, and R3 from phenyl, phenoxy, ethoxy and n-butoxy.
Among these the ammonium, phosphonium, pyridinium and imidazolium
ions are preferred.
0050/53318 CA 02440528 2003-09-10
13
very particularly preferred as cations are
1;2-dimethylpyridinium, 1-methyl-2-ethylpyridinium,
1-methyl-2-ethyl-6-methylpyridinium, N-methylpyridinium,
1-butyl-2-methylpyridinium, 1-butyl-2-ethylpyridinium,
1-butyl-2-ethyl-6-methylpyridinium, N-butylpyridinium,
1-butyl-4-methylpyridinium, 1,3-dimethylimidazolium,
1,2,3-trimethylimidazolium, 1-n-butyl-3-methylimidazolium,
1,3,4,5-tetramethylimidazolium, 1,3,4-trimethylimidazolium,
2,3-dimethylimidazolium, 1-butyl-2,3-dimethylimidazolium,
3,4-dimethylimidazolium, 2-ethyl-3,4-dimethylimidazolium,
3-methyl-2-ethylimidazol, 3-butyl-l-methylimidazolium,
3-butyl-l-ethylimidazolium, 3-butyl-1,2-dimethylimidazolium,
1,3-di-n-Butylimidazolium, 3-butyl-1,4,5-trimethylimidazolium,
3-butyl-1,4-dimethylimidazolium, 3-butyl-2-methylimidazolium,
1,3-dibutyl-2-methylimidazolium, 3-butyl-4-methylimidazolium,
3-butyl-2-ethyl-4-methylimidazolium and
3-butyl-2-ethylimidazolium, 1-methyl-3-octylimidazolium and
1-decyl-3-methylimidazolium.
Particularly preferred are 1-butyl-4-methylpyridinium,
1-n-butyl-3-methylimidazolium and 1-n-butyl-3-ethylimidazolium,
For the anions, all anions are conceivable in principle.
Preferred anions are halides, F-, Cl-, Br-, I-, acetate CH3COO-,
trifluoroacetate CF3COO-, triflate CF3S03-, sulfate S042-,
hydrogensulfate HSO4-, methylsulfate CH3OSO3-, ethylsulfate
C2H50S03-, sulfite S032-, hydrogensulfite HS03-, chloroaluminates
A1C14-, A12C17-, A13C110-, tetrabromoaluminate A1Br4-, nitrite NOZ-,
nitrate N03-, chlorocuprate CuC12-, phosphate P043-,
hydrogenphosphate HP042-, dihydrogenphosphate H2P04-, carbonate
C032 and hydrogencarbonate HC03-.
Particularly preferred tetrafluoroborate BF4-, hexafluorophosphate
PF6-, bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide (CF3SO2)2N- and tosylate
p-CH3C6H4S03-.
Ionic liquids which are very particularly preferred are those
whose salts exhibit an ET(30) value of > 20, preferably of >30,
particularly preferably of > 40. The ET(30) value is a measure of
polarity and is described by C. Reichardt in Reichardt,
Christian, Solvent Effects in Organic Chemistry, Weinheim: VCH,
1979 - XI, (Monographs in Modern Chemistry 3), ISBN
3-527-25793-4, page 241.
0050/53318 CA 02440528 2003-09-10
14
The change in separation factor brought about by the entrainer
can be determined by a number of methods, preferably by headspace
analysis as published by Hachenberg and Schmidt in
Verfahrenstechnik, 8(1974), 12, pages 343-347. In determining the
effect of the entrainer on the mixture to be separated (the feed)
calculation is generally done on an entrainer-free basis, that is
to say that although the concentration of the entrainer in the
liquid mixture is noted it is not taken into account in the
percentage statement of the concentrations of the target
components.
Suitable ionic liquids are those which at a total concentration
in the liquid of 5 to 90 mol%, preferably 10 to 70 mol%, result
in a change in the separation factor of the target components
relative to one another different from one. This change can be
determined in the described headspace analysis.
The ionic liquid acting as entrainer is selected so that
it has as high a selectivity as possible,
it dissolves homogeneously to a concentration of at least 5
mol% in the mixture of substances to be separated,
it does not undergo any chemical reaction involving rupture
of covalent bonds with either of the components of the
mixture of substances to be separated,
the components of the bottom product can be separated from
the entrainer at low cost by evaporation due to the supply of
heat and/or reduction of pressure or rectification or
extraction or stripping using inert gas or conversion into a
solid phase.
In the rectification column it is not possible to adjust a
constant concentration of the ionic fluid over the entire height
of the column. On the contrary, in the enriching section directly
below the point of addition of the ionic fluid a higher
concentration will set in by comparison with the stripping
section below the feed inlet. The quantified value of 5 - 90 mol%
should be measured directly on the feed plate for the ionic
fluid. In this way a suitable concentration would be ensured in
the enriching section, that is to say just where the azeotrope is
to be broken down.
In order to ensure that the ionic liquid dissolves well in the
mixture to be separated the forces of attraction between the
molecules of the ionic liquid should be approximately just as
great as those between the molecules of the feed. In this case
the intermolecular forces in operation are ionic forces,
0050/53318 CA 02440528 2003-09-10
dipole-dipole forces., induction forces, dispersion forces and
hydrogen bonds, cf. Ullmann's Encyclopedia of Industrial
Chemistry (1993), Vol. A24, pp. 438-439. It is possible to adjust
these forces in the ionic liquids by varying the cations. In this
5 way solubility properties can be regulated. Thus, for example, by
lengthening the chain of the alkyl residue on an
alkylmethylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate the water-repelling
properties increase and hence miscibility with water decreases.
This adjustment of solvation strength is particularly effective
10 in relation to aliphatics, cf. H. Waffenschmidt, Dissertation,
RWTH Aachen, 2000. The anion also has an effect on dissolving
characteristics. Criteria for estimating the dissolving behavior
of an ionic liquid are the dielectric constant of the ionic
liquid and of the feed and the polarity of the mixture.
An embodiment of extractive rectification in a process is
illustrated by Figure 1. "2" is the inflow of the entrainer into
a countercurrent rectification column. Since in conventional
processes the entrainer has a slight but appreciable volatility
relative to the top product (stream 7) separative elements "1"
must be used for separation between the top product and
entrainer. The separative elements "3" and "5" bring about the
desired separation between overhead product and bottom product
under the action of the entrainer, stream "4" is the inflow of
the components to be separated (feed) and stream "6" is bottom
product and the entrainer. Separative elements can be by way of
example plates or ordered or disordered packings.
The process according to the invention has the advantage that -
as mentioned above - the vapor pressure of the pure ionic liquid
and hence also its partial pressure in the mixture with the top
product is approximately equal to zero. Accordingly, in the
process according to the invention the separative elements "1"
may be dispensed with.
The ionic fluid is added preferably in the enriching section
close to the top of the column, particularly preferably in the
uppermost 3 stages, very particularly preferably in the uppermost
stage below the condenser.
A further advantage of the process according to the invention
with ionic liquid as entrainer is that in order to separate the
entrainer from the bottom product various separating operations
may be used. Advantageous embodiments are:
Regeneration of the entrainer by simple evaporation.
0050/53318 CA 02440528 2003-09-10
16
Since the vapor pressure of the pure entrainer and hence also
its partial pressure in the mixture with the bottom product
is approximately equal to zero, an evaporation process can be
run continuously or discontinuously without further
separative elements. Thin film evaporators such as
falling-film or rotary evaporators are particularly suitable
for continuous evaporation. In discontinuous concentration
processes two evaporator stages are run alternately so that
regenerated ionic liquid can be fed continuously to the
extractive rectification column.
Regeneration of the entrainer by means of a stripping column
Since the vapor pressure of the pure entrainer and hence also
its partial pressure in the mixture with the bottom product
is equal to zero the entrainer cannot be completely freed of
bottom product in the countercurrent process by evaporation
alone. In an advantageous embodiment hot gas is conveyed in a
stripping column in countercurrent flow relative to a mixture
of bottom product and entrainer.
Mariy ionic liquids are notable for crystallization or glass
transition temperatures which are well below 0 C. In these
cases particularly simple, low-cost separation and
recirculation of the ionic liquid is possible by
precipitation to form a solid phase. The bottom product is
then obtained in solid form while the entrainer can be
returned as the pure substance to the extractive
rectification process. Precipitation can be carried out in
accordance with the teachings of cooling crystallization,
evaporative crystallization or vacuum crystallization. If the
freezing point of the entrainer is above the freezing point
of the bottom product in a variant of this method the
entrainer is obtained as the solid phase and the bottom
product as the liquid phase.
The use of ionic fluids as entrainers in extractive rectification
is particularly suitable inter alia for the following
applications, e.g. azeotropes: amines/water, THF/water, formic
acid/water, alcohols/water, acetone/methanol, acetate/water,
acrylate/water or close-boiling mixtures: acetic acid/water, C4
hydrocarbons, C3 hydrocarbons, alkanes/alkenes.
For the following reasons the process according to the invention
is a substantial improvement over the processes in the literature
for conventional extractive rectification.
Ionic liquids are more selective than traditional entrainers.
Due to their high selectivity by comparison with conventional
extractive rectification they allow a lower mass flow rate of
0050/53318 CA 02440528 2003-09-10
17
entrainer to be fed in extractive rectification and/or the
number of separation stages in the extractive rectification
column to be reduced.
Due to the extremely low vapor pressure of the entrainer
various separation operations can be used to separate the
entrainer from the bottom product which by comparison with
the second rectification column in conventional extractive
rectification afford an advantage in terms of running and
capital costs.
The separative elements "1" in conventional extractive
rectification result in separation of the entrainer from the
overhead product, but separation is never complete. Discharge
of portions of ionic liquid via the vapor phase without the
separative elements "1" is not possible due to its extremely
low volatility.
Capital costs are reduced because the separative elements "1"
are not needed.
The process according to the invention is explained below by
means of examples.
Example 1
System to be separated: butene-butane
According to the literature [Gmehling, J, Onken, U and Arlt, W
Vapor-Liquid Equilibrium Data Collection, Dechema Data Series,
Vol. I Part 6a, p. 17) the butene-butane system is a
close-boiling system. The separation factor which was measured by
means of gas-liquid chromatography (GLC) at infinite dilution of
butane and butene in the ionic liquid octylmethylimidazolium
tetrafluoroborate (OMIM - BF4) at 70 C is 0.74.
The calculation of the separation factor as a function of the
activity coefficient was published by Gmehling and Brehm
[Gmehling, J. and Brehm, A. , Grundoperationen (Unit Operations),
ISBN 3-13-687401-3, chapter 3].
Accordingly, the additive interacts more vigorously with butene
than with butane. The powerful effect exhibited by the ionic
liquid OMIM - BF4 on the phase equilibrium of the binary
butene-butane system demonstrates the suitability of OMIM - BF4 as
an entrainer for separating alkanes and alkenes.
0050/53318 CA 02440528 2003-09-10
18
Example 2
System to be separated: cyclohexanol-cyclohexanone
According to the literature [Gmehling, J, Onken, U and Arlt, W
Vapor-Liquid Equilibrium Data Collection, Dechema Data Series,
Vol. I Part 2b, p. 403] the cyclohexanol-cyclohexanone system is
a close-boiling system.
The separation factor which was measured by means of gas-liquid
chromatography at infinite dilution of cyclohexanol and
cyclohexanone in the ionic liquids ethylmethylimidazolium
tetrafluoroborate (EMIM-BF4) and ethylmethylimidazolium
hexafluorophosphate (EMIM-PF6) is 1.66 at 142 C for EMIM-BF4 and
1.61 at 140.8 C for EMIM-PF6. Both ionic liquids bring about an
increase in the separation factor of the cyclohexanol -
cyclohexanone separation system and are thus suitable as
entrainers.
Example 3
System to be separated: acetone-methanol
According to the literature [Gmehling, J, Onken, U and Arlt, W
Vapor-Liquid Equilibrium Data Collection, Dechema Data Series,
Vol. I Part 2a, p. 75] the acetone-methanol system forms an
azeotrope. The separation factor for a mixture of a ketone and an
alcohol, acetone and methanol in this case, was determined by
means of GLC in infinite dilution in the ionic liquids EMIM-BF4r
OMIM-BF4, MMIM-CH3SO4, EMIM-(CF3SO2)2N and EMIM-PF6. These
experiments yielded a separation factor of 2.51 at 70 C for
EMIM-BF4, of 3.15 at 70 C for OMIM-BF4, of 1.3 at 70.5 C for
MMIM-CH3SO4, of 0.5 at 84.6 C for EMIM-(CF3SO2)2N and of 0.67 at
70 C for EMIM-PF6. From these results it may be seen that it is
not just isolated ionic liquids that are suitable as entrainers.
On the contrary, many members of this novel class of substances,
the ionic liquids, are suitable for use as entrainers.
The process according to the invention is explained below by
means of further examples in which headspace analysis is used.
Example 4
Effect of the ionic liquid 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium
tetrafluoroborate on the binary homoazeotropic system
ethanol-water
0050/53318 CA 02440528 2003-09-10
19
Table 1 shows the effect of the additive (entrainer)
1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate on the binary
ethanol-water system at $= 70 C and a molar liquid concentration
of the entrainer of 10 mol% and 50 mol%.
"Ethanol XvVater aEthanol, aEthanol, aEthanol, aEthanol,
[mol %] [mol %] Water Water Water Water
binary system ternary system temary system ternary system
without entrainer containing 50
containing 10 containing 70
according to the mol% of entrainer mol% of entrainer mol% of entrainer
invention according to the
according to the invention according to the
invention invention
0.10 0.90 7.12 4.64 5.74 6.23
0.20 0.80 4.45 3.90 5.49 6.11
0.30 0.70 2.99 3.25 5.17 6.00
0.40 0.60 2.37 .2.70 4.77 5.86
0.50 0.50 1.88 2.41 - 4.57 5.72
0.60 0.40 1.58 2.12 4.38 5.58
0.70 0.30 1.34 1.85 4.20 5.25
0.80 0.20 1.17 1.68 4.02 4.95
0.90 0.10 1.06 1.48 3.99 4.90
0.95 0.05 1.00 1.32 3.56 4.87
Table 1: Separation factor a of the binary, homoazeotropic system
ethanol-water at 70 C using different quantities of the ionic
liquid 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate
The ethanol-water azeotrope occurs at approximately XEthanol
0.95. it is precisely in the range around this that the entrainer
has an effect, even at a concentration of 10 mol% in the liquid
phase. The fact that in this and in the following examples a
higher separation factor is achieved in the peripheral region
without entrainer than with entrainer is not disadvantageous
since:
a) preliminary concentration can be carried out without
entrainer;
b) separation factors about > 5 approximately have virtually no
influence on operating and capital costs.
Example 5
Effect of the ionic liquid 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium
tetrafluoroborate on the binary homoazeotropic system
tetrahydrofuran-water
0050/53318 CA 02440528 2003-09-10
Table 2'shows the effect of the entrainer
1--ethyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate on the binary
tetrahydrofuran (THF)-water system at 70 C and a molar liquid
concentration of the entrainer of 50 mol%.
5
XTHF 'F'ater aTHF, Water aT1iF, Water
[mol %] [mol %] binary system without entrainer ac- ternary system containing
50
cording to the invention mol% of entrainer according to
the invention
10 0.10 0.90 25.54 18.09
0.20 0.80 12.38 16.73
0.30 0.70 7.97 15.37
0.40 0.60 5.59 14.01
0.50 0.50 3.87 12.65
15 0.60 0.40 2.56 11.29
0.70 0.30 1.64 9.93
0.80 0.20 1.10 8.57
0.90 0.10 0.79 7.21
20 Table 2: Separation factor a of the homoazeotropic system
tetrahydrofuran (THF)-water at 70 C with and without the ionic
liquid 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate
The azeotrope at values of XTgF between 0.8 and 0.9 is
impressively removed.
Example 5a
Effect of the ionic liquid 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium
tetrafluorotosylate on the binary homoazeotropic system
tetrahydrofuran-water
Table 2a shows the effect of the entrainer
1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluorotosylate on the binary
tetrahydrofuran (THF)-water system at a pressure of 1 bar and a
molar liquid concentration of the entrainer of 50 mol%.
XTHF 'Water (XTHF, Water
[mol %] [mot %] temary system containing 50 %
of entrainer according to the in-
vention
0.2459 0.7541 23.3
0.3843 0.6157 24.7
0.5355 0.4645 23.8
0.6307 0.3693 22.8
0050/53318 CA 02440528 2003-09-10
21
Table 2a: Separation factor a of the tetrahydrofuran (THF)-water
system at 1 bar with the ionic liquid 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium
tetrafluorotosylate. The measured results shown here were not
obtained by headspace chromatography but rather by means of an
equilibrium apparatus. Here also a distinct increase in the
separation factor relative to the binary system (see Table 2) and
hence the suitability of the ionic fluid as entrainer may be
seen.
Example 6
Effect of the ionic liquid 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium
tetrafluoroborate on the binary homoazeotropic system
propanol-water
Table 3 shows the effect of the entrainer
1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate on the binary
propanol-water system at 85 C and a molar liquid concentration of
the entrainer of 50 mol%.
XPropanol xWater CtPropanol, Water aPropanol, Water
[Mol %] [Mol %] binary system without entrainer ternary system containing
according to the invention 50 mol% of entrainer according
to the invention
0.4 0.6 1.10 3.12
0.6 0.4 0.68 2.46
Table 3: Separation factor a of the homoazeotropic system
propanol-water at 85 C with and without the ionic liquid
1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate
Example 7
Effect of the ionic liquid 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium
tetrafluoroborate on the binary homoazeotropic system
isopropanol-water
Table 4 shows the effect of the entrainer
1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate on the binary
isopropanol-water system at 90 C and a molar liquid concentration
of the entrainer of 50 mol%.
Xlsopropanol xWater aIsopropanol, Water alsopropanol, Water
[Mol %] [Mol %] binary system without entrainer ternary system containing
according to the invention 50 mol% of entrainer according
to the invention
0.4 0.6 2.09 5.73
0.6 0.4 1.29 4.64
0050/53318 CA 02440528 2003-09-10
22
Table 4: Separation factor a of the homoazeotropic system
isopropanol-water at 90 C with and without the ionic liquid
1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate
In Tables 1 to 4 a marked difference is discernible between the
binary phase compositions and the ternary phase equilibrium
compositions formed after addition of the nonvolatile entrainer
according to the invention 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium
tetrafluoroborate. Due to selective interactions with the polar
system component, water, the ionic liquid exercises an
advantageous effect on the separation factor. Moreover, in the
ethanol-water (Table 1) and tetrahydrofuran-water (Table 2)
systems it is clearly evident that the effect of the ionic liquid
on the vapor-liquid phase equilibrium is so great that the
azeotropic point has been broken down, that is to say it no
longer occurs.
Example 8
Advantage of the entrainer according to the invention relative to
conventional entrainers with reference to the example of the
separation of ethanol and water
Table 5 shows for the ethanol-water system the effect of the two
entrainers 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate and
ethanediol on the vapor-liquid phase equilibrium at 70 C for the
entrainer concentration of 50 mol%.
XEthanol XWater aEthanol, Water aEthanol, Water aEthanol, Water
[mol %] [mol %]
binary system with- ternary system contain- ternary system contain-
out entrainer accord- ing 50 mol% ing 50 mol% of entrainer
ing to the invention of ethanediol according to the inven-
tion
0.10 0.90 7.12 4.96 5.74
0.20 0.80 4.45 4.37 5.49
0.30 0.70 2.99 3.77 5.17
0.40 0.60 2.37 3.45 4.77
0.50 0.50 1.88 3.14 4.57
0.60 0.40 1.58 2.82 4.38
0.70 0.30 1.34 2.63 4.20
0.80 0.20 1.17 2.44 4.02
0.90 0.10 1.06 1.83 3.99
0.95 0.05 1.00 1.32 3.56
0050/53318 CA 02440528 2003-09-10
23
Table 5: Comparison of the separation factors a in the
ethanol-water system at 70 C for the conventional entrainer
ethanediol and the entrainer according to the invention
1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate
From Table 5 it emerges that for the same concentration of
entrainer the effect on the vapor-liquid phase equilibrium and
hence the useful effect is distinctly greater in the case of the
ionic liquid, particularly in the azeotropic range.
15
25
35
45
