Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02443955 2003-10-14
WO 02/086239 PCT/FI02/00324
1
Method and system in control o~ coating colour recipe
The invention relates to a method and system in control of a coating colour
recipe, as disclosed in the preambles of the independent claims presented
below.
The chemical composition of coating mix in manufacture, that is, for example
its
pigment, binder and thickener composition and the amount of other additives,
are determined on the basis of a coating colour recipe. The coating colour
recipe determines the amounts and/or ratios of the various components of the
coating mix. According to the colour coating recipe, the coating mix may
contain, for example, 50 parts calcium carbonate, 50 parts kaolin, 10 parts
latex
and 0.1 parts lye, that is, the sum of the ratio of the components may be
greater than 100. Control of the coating colour recipe in this connection
refers
to measures, whose purpose is to produce a new coating mix complying with
the coating colour recipe, or to make a partly recycled coating mix as close
as
possible to the coating mix according to the coating colour recipe.
In the manufacture of coating mix, recycled mix, that is, for example, coating
mix collected from the machine cycle, or recovered mix, is used as one
component to reduce manufacturing costs. Concentrate, that is, mix recovered
by filtering (for example by means of an ultrafilter or nanofilter) from
collected
waters containing coating, is also often used in coating mix manufacture. In
addition, in coating change, that is, in connection with changing the coating
colour recipe, the aim is to recover the old coating. Recovery takes place
partly
by pumping the coating mix from the machine cycle to a recovery tank. Coating
mix is also conveyed to the recovery tank partly along with the washing
waters.
The dry matter content of the fraction obtained through recovery by these two
methods may vary considerably, being typically between 0.5-65%. The
collection methods and different methods for treating the fractions also cause
chemical changes in the properties of the coating. For example, in
ultrafiltration,
CA 02443955 2003-10-14
WO 02/086239 PCT/FI02/00324
2
small-molecule components, such as, for example, the dextrines of the starch
contained in the coating mix, pass through the filter with the water, whereby
the
structure of the coating mix changes as the amount of small-molecule
components changes.
The properties of the mix in the machine cycle are known to change in
connection with the coating process. The changes are caused, among other
things, by the migration of binder, water, optical brightener and other
components to the base paper. Some of the changes are also due to the
evaporation of water when the coating is in contact with air, for example, in
the
return trough and on the surFace of the machine chest. The water balance of
the machine cycle may also change due to the effect of external factors, such
as, for example, cleaning showers and condensate waters.
Due to the effect among other things, of the changes and uncertainty factors
described above, in known solutions the concentrate is typically almost always
treated in terms of the calculation as a pigment. However, in addition to
pigment, the concentrate also contains many other components, such as latex.
If the chemical composition of the concentrate, that is, the amount of
components contained in it, or their ratio, were known, then for example in
coating mix manufacture, the amount of latex could be reduced, which would
result in considerable cost savings.
Furthermore, changes in the properties of coating mix affect the quality of
the
final coating and the runnability of the coating process. Thus, for example, a
decrease in the amount of thickener and latex will increase the viscosity of
the
coating mix, which will have a significant effect on the runnability of the
coating
process. Furthermore, it is also known that using concentrate in the
manufacture of coating mix will decrease the viscosity of the finished coating
mix.
CA 02443955 2003-10-14
WO 02/086239 PCT/FI02/00324
3
Thus a need has arisen to measure the properties of coating .mix in the
machine cycle and during coating mix recovery. There has also arisen a need
to control the properties of the coating mix to be made on the basis of the
properties of the coating mix when ready and when used for coating.
European patent application EP 0 962 769 discloses a method and an
apparatus for measuring the properties of a composition or component used in
paper or board manufacture. According to the application, a sample taken of
the composition is measured for dry matter content, viscosity and pH. A
problem with the solution presented in the application is that it does not
reveal
the chemical composition of the composition. Thus, for example, the real cause
of a change in viscosity of the composition cannot be discovered, which means
that it is difficult to so remedy the problem effectively and efficiently.
Furthermore, for example, from the patent application WO 99/14579 there is
known a method and device for measuring the properties of paper by directing
an infrared beam onto the surface of a moving paper web. A beam that has
passed through or been reflected from the web is divided into wavelength
components by means of a spectrograph and the signals are measured for the
various wavelength components, on the basis of which signals the properties of
the paper are determined. The application does not, however, disclose the use
of the measurement results in the control and/or regulation of coating mix
manufacture.
Patent application WO 99/41590 discloses a method and device for measuring
the amount of coating on a moving substrate based on reflection measurement.
In accordance with the publication, the amount of calcium carbonate is
measured by measuring the absorption peak of calcium carbonate in the
wavelength range, which is approximately 3.95 micrometres and/or the amount
of kaolin is measured by measuring the absorption peak of kaolin in the
wavelength range, which is approximately 2.7 micrometres. According to the
CA 02443955 2003-10-14
WO 02/086239 PCT/FI02/00324
4
publication, the measurement results are used for determining the thickness of
the coating and not for controlling or regulating coating manufacture.
In addition, Pentti Niemela and Janne Suhonen have, in their article "An
Industrial Raman Spectrometer for Process Measurement Applications",
presented a measuring device based on Raman spectroscopy for measuring
the chemical properties of matter.
In the present invention it has been recognised that by measuring the
properties of coating mix and/or the recyclable mix used for coating mix
manufacture, the coating mix and its manufacture, especially the coating
colour
recipe, can be controlled and managed efficiently.
The aim of the method and system relating to the present invention is,
therefore, to eliminate, or at least substantially reduce the problems due to
the
above-mentioned prior art, and to provide a method and system in the control
of coating mix, by means of which the chemical composition of coating mix can
be reliably determined, and which composition data will be used in the
manufacture of coating mix.
Another aim of the method and system relating to the present invention is to
make possible the manufacture of a new coating mix by utilising recycled
coating mix as efficiently as possible.
A further aim of the present invention is to attempt to predict changes taking
place in the coating mix, such as changes in viscosity or water retention.
In order to achieve the above-mentioned aims among others, the method and
system relating to the invention are characterised mainly by what is disclosed
in
the characterising parts of the appended independent claims.
CA 02443955 2003-10-14
WO 02/086239 PCT/FI02/00324
In a typical method according to the invention, measurement is taken from
finished coating mix and/or recycled coating mix used for the manufacture of
new coating mix. Finished coating mix in this connection refers to both
coating
mix discharged from a mixer used for mixing the components in coating mix
5 manufacture, which coating mix is then conveyed to the coating apparatus
either directly or via one or more containers, and coating mix already applied
to
the surface of the material. On the basis of the result of measurement carried
out in this way, the ratios and/or amount of the components fed into the
coating
mix to be manufactured and/or recycled are controlled. In a preferred method
according to the invention, the amounts and/or ratios of components obtained
as measurement results are compared with the amounts and/or ratios
according to the recipe for the coating mix to be made, and control of the
ratios
and/or amount of the components fed into the coating mix to be made and/or
recycled is carried out on the basis of the said comparison. In this
connection,
the recipe for the coating mix to be made refers to the amount and/or ratio of
the coating mix components when the coating mix is made completely of new
components.
In a preferred method according to the invention, measurement is carried out
on the machine cycle. The measuring device used in the method is then
connected either directly to the coating mix transfer line or to a separate
sampling line, to which the coating mix is conveyed from the machine cycle.
Furthermore, the measurement is most preferably carried out essentially
continuously. When measurement is carried out on the machine cycle, no
separate sampling and sample transfer, for example, to a laboratory, are
required, which makes measurement faster and more reliable. In this case, in
addition, an on-line type measuring method can be realised, which method
measures the properties of the coating mix continuously or at desired
intervals.
In one most preferable method relating to the invention, the amount of binder
and/or thickener contained in the coating mix is measured from the coating
mix.
In this case, changes in the properties of the coating mix can be predicted
CA 02443955 2003-10-14
WO 02/086239 PCT/FI02/00324
6
particularly well, and the amount of binder or thickener can be increased or
decreased if necessary. Most preferably, the amount of binder and/or thickener
can be measured by comparing their ratio, for example, to the pigment.
In the method according to the invention, for example, NIR-, MIR-, IR- or
Raman-spectroscopy can be used as a measuring method, or another method
by means of which the chemical properties of a substance can be measured
and/or determined.
A typical system according to the present invention comprises at least means
for taking measurements from finished coating mix andlor the coating mix to be
recycled for making new coating mix, and means for controlling on the basis of
the measurement result the ratios and/or amount of the components fed into
the coating mix to be made andlor recycled. A preferred system according to
the invention also comprises means for comparing the amounts and/or ratios of
components obtained as a result of the measurement with the amounts and/or
ratios according to the coating mix recipe, and means for controlling the
ratios
and/or amount of the components fed into the coating mix to be made and/or
recycled on the basis of the above comparison.
The system may also be implemented in a preferred manner in such a way that
the means for measuring the amount of at least one component or the ratio of
one or more components from the coating mix are mounted on the coating mix
transfer line. In another preferred system according to the invention, the
means
for measuring the amount of at least one component or the ratio of one or more
components from the coating mix are mounted on the container containing
coating mix. When the above-mentioned means are located directly on the
coating mix transfer line and/or the container containing coating mix, it is
ensured that the object of measurement is a sample representing the true state
of the coating mix.
CA 02443955 2003-10-14
WO 02/086239 PCT/FI02/00324
7
The system according to the present invention may also be realised in a
preferred manner in such a way that the means for measuring the amount of at
least one component or the ratio of one or more components are connected to
the coating mix transfer line and/or the container containing coating mix on
one
or more sampling lines. By means of the sampling lines, the system can be
moved to a location preferable from the point of view of the usability of the
system, such as installation or maintenance. Furthermore, by bringing the
coating mix to be measured from several points to one place, one measuring
device of the system according to the invention can be used for measurement
at several measuring points.
Typically, the method according to the invention is implemented by means of a
computer software product that can be directly loaded into the main memory of
the computer, or by means of a computer software product that is stored on a
computer-readable medium, the computer software product containing the
program code elements required for implementing the method according to the
invention when the said computer software product is run in the computer. A
computer software product in this connection refers to independent computer
software or part of computer software, which may comprise one or more
program code elements. A program code element refers to an element
consisting of one or more instructions or commands in computer-readable form.
A computer-readable medium in this connection refers to all such media in
which data, instructions, commands, series of instructions or commands or the
like, which are computer-readable, can be stored permanently or temporarily.
Such media are, for example, fixed discs, mass memories, buffer storages,
disks and CD-ROMs.
One typical above-mentioned computer software product, which is stored on a
computer-readable medium, comprises at least the following program code
elements:
CA 02443955 2003-10-14
WO 02/086239 PCT/FI02/00324
8
- a program code element making it possible for the computer to receive
measurement data from one or more measuring devices measuring coating mix
properties,
- a program code element enabling the computer to compare the properties of
the coating mix based on measurement data with the target properties, and
- a program code element for enabling the computer to control the feed of the
coating mix components in the manufacture of coating mix when the computer
software product is run in a computer.
By means of the computer software product, the method according to the
invention for controlling the coating mix can be used in a computer or as a
part
of another device, which comprises the means for running the computer
software product in such a way that the method according to the invention can
be automated by means of it.
One preferred computer software product according to the invention
additionally comprises a program code element for enabling the computer to
store - preferably in a database - data on the target properties of one or
more
coating mixes. The above-mentioned program code element thus makes it
possible to use the method for measuring several difFerent coating mix types.
One preferred computer software product according to the invention comprises
a program code element for enabling the computer to store in a database at
least the measurement data it has received andlor comparison data on the
properties of the coating mix obtained on the basis of measurement data
compared to the target properties. Thanks to the above-mentioned program
code element, a database can be obtained, from which, for example, the
behaviour of the coating mix as a function of time can easily be monitored.
The greatest advantage of the present invention is that by measuring the
amount of thickener and binder contained in the coating to be recycled, the
recipe for preparing fresh coating mix can be changed in such a way that the
CA 02443955 2003-10-14
WO 02/086239 PCT/FI02/00324
9
amounts of binder and thickener in the finished coating mix remain constant
irrespective of whether concentrate is used in the recipe or not. This results
in
considerable cost savings, since the amount of the components incurring the
greatest costs can be reduced in manufacture by utilising the components
contained in the recyclable coating mix as efficiently as possible.
A further advantage of the present invention is that when the properties of
the
coating mix to be recycled, such as binder content, etc are known, it is easy
to
predict the amount of binder needed in coating mix manufacture for the fresh
coating. The final amount of binder can, in a preferred case, be checked by
the
same method that is used for measuring the properties of recyclable coating.
Furthermore, by means of the method and system according to the present
invention, the properties of the coating mix can be kept more stable than
before, whereby the runnability of the coating station will improve and there
will
be fewer interruptions caused by coating.
The invention is described in greater detail in the following, .with reference
to
the appended drawing, in which
Figure 1 shows diagrammatically the system relating to the invention as part
of the machine cycle,
Figure 2 shows diagrammatically a second example of the location of the
measuring device used in the system as part of the machine cycle,
Figure 3 shows an example of an application of the method according to the
invention as a flow chart.
Figure 4 shows, by way of an example, a measurement result of the method
relating to the invention,
Figure 5 shows, by way of an example, a measurement result of the method
relating to the invention on the base line, and
Figure 6 shows, by way of an example, a measurement result base line
corrected of the method relating to the invention.
CA 02443955 2003-10-14
WO 02/086239 PCT/FI02/00324
Figure 1 shows diagrammatically and by way of an example the system
according to the present invention when mounted as part of a machine cycle.
Of the machine cycle, Figure 1 shows, for example, a recovery tank 1 for
5 washing waters recovered from the coating station. From the washing water
recovery tank 1, the washing water containing coating mix is conveyed to an
ultrafilter 2, from where the reject, that is, concentrate is conveyed to a
concentrate tank 3. The permeate, that is, the water contained in the washing
water, can be conveyed to a channel and from there further to a purification
10 plant, or it may be utilised elsewhere in the paper manufacturing process.
Further, of the machine cycle is shown a residual mix tank 4 for residual mix,
that is, for example, coating mix recovered from the coating machine or mix
kitchens, a mixer 5 and a coating station tank 6. The pipes acting as transfer
lines are marked with reference numeral 7. The machine cycle also comprises
many other devices and parts, such as various pumps and valves, which are
not shown in Figure 1 in order to simplify the Figure. For example, many other
substances are typically also conveyed to the mixer 5, such substances as, for
example, carbonate, kaolin, latex, CMC (carboxymethylcellulose), thickener
and optical brightener.
Alternative and illustrative locations for the measuring device used in the
system are marked with reference numerals 8a-8d. Reference numeral 8a
shows a measuring device mounted on the transfer line between the
concentrate tank 3 and the mixer 5. Reference numeral 8b refers to a
measuring device located between the residual mix tank 4 and the mixer 5.
Under reference numeral 8c is shown a measuring device, which is located
between the mixer and the coating station tank and thus used for measuring
the finished coating mix. The measuring device located in the coating station
tank 6 is marked with reference numeral 8d. The measuring device 8d located
in the coating station tank can be replaced by conveying coating mix from the
coating station tank by a separate sampling line 9, for example, to the
measuring device 8c, as shown in Figure 1.
CA 02443955 2003-10-14
WO 02/086239 PCT/FI02/00324
11
Figure 2 shows diagrammatically and by way of an example, another
alternative solution for locating the measuring device used in the system
according to the invention. According to Figure 2, the measuring device 10 is
connected to the transfer lines 7 by means of the sample lines 9, along which
a
sample of the concentrate, residual mix and finished coating mix is conveyed
to
be measured. The measuring device 10 is implemented in such a way that it
has means for synchronising sampling, which means that it is possible to take
measurements from the desired transfer line at desired intervals. The
measured sample can be returned to the transfer line or it may be conveyed,
for example, to the residual mix tank (handling of the measured sample is not
shown in the Figure).
In the system according to the invention all the measuring devices shown in
Figures 1 and 2 are not necessarily needed, but the number and locations of
the measuring devices are determined according to the respective needs
concerning measurement or use. In addition, the system may be implemented
by using measuring devices installed directly on the transfer line or
container,
or by means of sample lines and any sample containers used.
The type and structure of the measuring devices shown in Figures 1 and 2 will
depend on the method used for measurement. One measuring device
applicable to the system is disclosed in the above-mentioned publication "An
Industrial Raman Spectrometer for Process Measurement Applications".
In accordance with what is shown in Figures 1 and 2, the measuring devices
8a-8d and 10 are connected in a manner known as such to a control unit 11
controlling the manufacture of the coating mix in order to transmit the
measurement data from the measuring devices to the said control unit. The
measurement data transferred may be final measurement results on the
amounts and/or ratios of components. The calculation of the measurement
results can also be implemented in such a way that result calculation and/or
CA 02443955 2003-10-14
WO 02/086239 PCT/FI02/00324
12
analysis is carried out partly or completely in the control unit 11. The
control
unit compares the measurement result obtained with the base line of the recipe
for the coating mix to be made and determines the difference between these.
The amount of components in the coating mix to be made or their ratio to each
other is determined on the basis of the difference obtained or the ratio
calculated from the difference. The system may also comprise other means
than the above, such as a computer for calculating or analysing the results.
On
the basis of the measurements made by the measuring devices, the control unit
11 controls, for example, the feed of components into the mixer 5 in a manner
known as such, taking into account the amounts and/or ratios of components
contained in the concentrate and/or residual mix.
The method and system relating to the present invention may also be
implemented in such a way that the properties of the finished coating mix are
measured from the surface of a material web coated with coating mix, for
example, by means of reflection measurement, and this result is used alone or
together with other measurements for controlling and/or regulating the
manufacture of the coating mix to be made.
Figure 3 shows one example of an application of the method according to the
invention as a flow chart. The coating mix or concentrate is measured by
means of a measuring device mounted in conjunction with the machine cycle,
for example, using Raman-spectroscopy. After this, a sample curve of the
measurement signal is drawn. The sample curve is compared with the base
line according to the coating mix recipe to be measured and the difference
between the coating mix to be measured and the recipe is determined. On the
basis of the difference obtained, the amount and/or ratios of the components
fed into the coating mix to be made or recycled is controlled, for example, by
decreasing or increasing the amount of one or more of the coating mix
components. If, for example, concentrate with a high latex content is used as
one of the raw materials in the manufacture of the new coating mix, the amount
of latex fed during manufacture can be reduced compared with the amount
according to
CA 02443955 2003-10-14
WO 02/086239 PCT/FI02/00324
13
the coating mix recipe by the amount of latex contained in the concentrate. In
this way cost savings are achieved as the consumption of latex decreases. In
accordance with the above, measurements based on other than Raman-
spectroscopy can also be used in determining the amounts and/or ratios of
coating mix components.
Figures 4 to 6 show by way of an example a measurement result for two
coating mixes, the first of which contains six parts latex and the second nine
parts latex. A measuring apparatus and method based on Raman-spectroscopy
is used in the measurement. The vertical axis in the Figures shows intensity
and the horizontal axis shows Raman shift.
Figure 4 shows the measurement result given by the measuring device, that is,
the Raman-spectra for the above-mentioned coating mix samples. In Figure 5,
base line corrections have been made to the spectra of Figure 4. The base
lines are shown by broken lines in Figure 5. 1n Figure 6 the spectra are moved
to the base line. The Figures show peaks in different wavelength ranges, which
indicate a difference in the amounts and ratios of the components in the
samples. By comparing these peaks and/or their ranges with the base line, the
ratio of the components and/or the amount of one or more components
contained in the sample can be calculated. After this, the result of the
calculation may be utilised in accordance with the present invention for
controlling and/or regulating coating mix manufacture.
The aim has not been to limit the invention only to the embodiments disclosed
in the previous specification, but it may be varied within the scope of the
inventive idea presented in the claims.
