Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
METHODS AND APPARATUS FOR MANUFACTURING OPERATIONS
INVENTORS
James N. Buttrick, Jr.
Theodore M. Boyl-Davis
Roger A. Gage
Darrell D. Jones
Paul R. Arntson
Ronald W. Outous
Lyle Wallace
FIELD OF THE INVENTION
The present disclosure relates to methods and apparatus for improved
manufacturing
operations, and more specifically, to methods and apparatus for performing
counterbalance-
assisted manufacturing operations, opposing-force support systems, neutral-
axis rack
systems, non-contact position sensing systems, and servo-controlled
manufacturing
operations.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
The fabrication of large structures may involve the performance of large
numbers of
manufacturing operations, such as the drilling of a large number of holes in
the components
of the structure. Conventional structures that require a large number of
drilling operations
include, for example, aircraft, missiles, ships, railcars, sheet metal
buildings, and other
similar structures. In particular, conventional aircraft fabrication processes
typically involve
the drilling of a large number of holes in wing sections of the aircraft to
allow these sections
to be attached to each other and to the airframe with fasteners (e.g. rivets).
Other types of
manufacturing operations that may be involved in the construction of
structures include
riveting, cutting, welding, sanding, measuring and inspecting operations.
A variety of devices have been developed to facilitate drilling operations
involving
the drilling of a large number of holes. For example, U.S. Patent No.
4,850,763 issued to
Jack et al. discloses a drilling system that includes a pair of rails
temporarily attached to an
1
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
aircraft fuselage. A support carriage is slideably coupled to the rails and
supports a drill
assembly. A template attached to the aircraft fuselage provides an index of
the desired
locations of the holes that are to be formed in the aircraft fuselage. As the
carriage is moved
along the rails, a locking mechanism (or trigger) interacts with the template
to securely
position the carriage for a subsequent drilling operation.
Although desirable results have been achieved using the prior art drilling
systems,
some disadvantages have been noted. The drill assemblies that are
conventionally used for
such operations typically weigh approximately twenty pounds, and may be
relatively bulky
and awkward to handle. These attributes may lead to operator fatigue, and may
reduce the
efficiency of the fabrication process. Furthermore, the weight and bulk of the
drill assembly
may cause the supporting assembly of the rails and the carriage to sag, twist,
or bend,
depending on the orientation of the fuselage section under work, which may
result in
inaccuracies or misalignment of the resulting holes.
In addition, the performance of prior art drill assemblies may be reduced when
operating on relatively lighter, more flexible structures. In such cases,
drill thrust may
become too high and may cause undesirable bending or structural deflection of
the
workpiece, which may in turn result in reduced hole quality. Also, on such
relatively light,
flexible structures, the forces applied by the drilling system on the
structure may require
careful control to avoid overexertion against the structure. This may slow the
manufacturing
operation and reduce throughput.
Furthermore, the ability to accurately position a manufacturing tool over a
workpiece
may be compromised when the structure is contoured. This is particularly true
when the
structure is a complex contoured structure that is curved in multiple planes
of curvature.
Because position accuracy may be reduced, manufacturing operations on such
structures may
require increased delays due to a need for increased checking and adjusting of
the position of
the manufacturing tool, and may also require additional repairs and reworking
of the
workpiece due to inaccuracies in the manufacturing operations.
Prior art manufacturing assemblies typically need to be carefully oriented on
the
workpiece prior to performing manufacturing operations to ensure that the
manufacturing
operations are performed in the proper locations. Orienting the prior art
assemblies on the
workpiece may require physical contacts between the support carriage or other
portions of
the assembly and one or more contact points on the workpiece. Such physical
contacts may
2
CA 02529904 2009-08-06
be subject to degradation, especially through repeated usage, and may also
adversely
impact the quality of some types of workpiece surfaces.
Furthermore, prior art manufacturing assemblies typically include a controller
that is positioned remotely from the support carriage that supports a tool
assembly
over the workpiece, as disclosed, f o r example, in U. S. Patent No. 6,550,
129 B I
issued to Buttrick and U. S. Patent No. 6,073, 326 issued to Banks et al.. In
such
systems, control signals for commanding movement of the support carriage and
for
controlling manufacturing operations using the tool assembly are transmitted
via a
system of control cables that extend between the remotely-positioned
controller and
the components of the support carriage and the tool assembly. Although
desirable
results have been achieved using such manufacturing assemblies, the extent of
movement of the support carriage and the operation of the tool assembly may be
limited by the lengths of the control cables or by the mobility of the
controller within
the confines of the manufacturing environment.
In addition, prior art manufacturing tools may be undesirably heavy,
particularly pneumatically-driven tools and other tools assembled from
conventional
components having individual housings and support bearings. At least some
conventional pneumatically-driven tools do not provide precise controllability
for
performing manufacturing operations. Some pneumatic drill assemblies, for
example,
do not allow precise control of drill feed rate or rotational speed.
For the foregoing reasons, an unmet need exists for improved apparatus and
methods for performing manufacturing operations.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
The present invention is directed to methods and apparatus for improved
manufacturing operations.
In accordance with one aspect of the invention, there is provided an apparatus
for supporting a tool relative to a surface of a workpiece. The apparatus
includes a
base, and a tool support coupled to the base and moveable along a translation
axis
relative to the base, the tool support being configured to be coupled to the
tool, at least
one of the base and the tool support being further configured to operatively
position
the tool relative to the workpiece for performing a manufacturing operation on
the
workpiece. The apparatus also includes a biasing device having a first portion
operatively coupled to the base and a second portion coupled to the tool
support, the
3
CA 02529904 2009-08-06
first and second portions being moveably coupled and configured to apply a
biasing
force to the tool support to at least partially counterbalance a force exerted
on the tool
support along the translation axis by a weight of the tool coupled to the tool
support.
The biasing device includes a pneumatic actuator. The apparatus also includes
a
control valve coupled to the pneumatic actuator, the control valve being
configured to
adjustably control at least one of a magnitude and a direction of a biasing
force
applied to the tool support by adjustably controlling a pressure within the
pneumatic
actuator.
The biasing device may be further configured to adjustably apply the biasing
force, and the apparatus may further include a control mechanism coupled to
the
biasing device and configured to adjustably control a magnitude of the biasing
force.
The control mechanism may be further configured to control a direction of the
biasing force.
The tool support may be moveable in a first direction along the translation
axis, and in a second direction along the translation axis opposite to the
first direction.
The biasing device may include a motor, and the motor may be at least one of
a constant torque motor and a non-constant torque motor.
The biasing device may be biasable along a biasing axis that may be aligned
with the translation axis.
The biasing device may be controllably biasable in a biasing direction along a
biasing axis.
In accordance with another aspect of the invention, there is provided an
apparatus for supporting a tool relative to a surface of a workpiece. The
apparatus
includes a base configured to be attached to the workpiece. The base includes
at least
one elongated rail member, and a plurality of vacuum attachment devices
connected
to the at least one rail member and configured to be coupleable to the surface
of the
workpiece. The base also includes a carriage assembly moveably coupled to the
at
least one rail member. The carriage assembly includes a drive assembly having
a
drive motor operatively engaging the at least one rail member and configured
to drive
the carriage assembly along the at least one rail member along a movement
axis. The
apparatus also includes a tool support coupled to the carriage assembly and
moveable
along a translation axis relative to the carriage assembly, the tool support
being
configured to be coupled to the tool. The apparatus also includes a biasing
device
having a first portion operatively coupled to the base and a second portion
coupled to
4
CA 02529904 2009-08-06
the tool support, the first and second portions being moveably coupled and
configured
to apply a biasing force to the tool support to at least partially
counterbalance a force
exerted on the tool support along the translation axis by a weight of the tool
coupled
to the tool support. The biasing device includes a pneumatic actuator. The
apparatus
further includes a control valve coupled to the pneumatic actuator, the
control valve
being configured to adjustably control at least one of a magnitude and a
direction of a
biasing force applied to the tool support by adjustably controlling a pressure
within
the pneumatic actuator.
The translation axis may be at least partially transverse to the at least one
elongated rail member.
In accordance with another aspect of the invention, there is provided an
apparatus for performing a manufacturing operation on a surface of a
workpiece. The
apparatus includes a base, and a tool support moveably coupled to the base and
moveable along a translation axis relative to the base, at least one of the
base and the
tool support being configured to operatively position the tool relative to the
workpiece
for performing the manufacturing operation on the workpiece. The apparatus
also
includes a manufacturing tool coupled to the tool support and configured to be
engageable with the surface of the workpiece to perform the manufacturing
operation
on the surface of the workpiece. The apparatus also includes a biasing device
having a
first portion coupled to the base and a second portion coupled to the tool
support, the
first and second portions being moveably coupled and configured to apply a
biasing
force to the tool support to at least partially counterbalance a force exerted
on the tool
support along the translation axis by a weight of the manufacturing tool. The
biasing
device includes a pneumatic actuator, and a control valve is coupled to the
pneumatic
actuator, the control valve being configured to adjustably control at least
one of a
magnitude and a direction of a biasing force applied to the tool support by
adjustably
controlling a pressure within the pneumatic actuator.
The biasing device may be further configured to adjustably apply the biasing
force, and the apparatus may further include a control mechanism coupled to
the
biasing device and configured to adjustably control a magnitude of the biasing
force.
The control mechanism may be further configured to control a direction of the
biasing force.
The biasing device may include a motor, and the motor may be at least one of
a constant torque motor and a non-constant torque motor.
4a
CA 02529904 2009-08-06
The biasing device may be biasable along a biasing axis that may be aligned
with the translation axis.
The biasing device may be controllably biasable in a biasing direction along a
biasing axis.
In accordance with another aspect of the invention, there is provided a method
of performing a manufacturing operation on a surface of a workpiece. The
method
involves detachably securing a support member to the surface of the workpiece,
and
moveably attaching a manufacturing tool to the support member, the
manufacturing
tool being moveable relative to the support member along a translation
direction over
the surface of the workpiece. The method also involves securely engaging the
manufacturing tool with the surface of the workpiece, and with the
manufacturing tool
securely engaged with the surface of the workpiece, detaching the support
member
from the surface of the workpiece. The method also involves, with the
manufacturing
tool securely engaged with the surface of the workpiece, moving the support
member
relative to the manufacturing tool.
Detachably securing a support member to the surface of the workpiece may
involve detachably securing a pair of elongated rail members to the surface of
the
workpiece.
Detachably securing a support member to the surface of the workpiece may
involve providing a vacuum to a vacuum assembly to detachably secure the
support
member to the surface of the workpiece.
Moving the support member relative to the manufacturing tool may involve
moving the support member along an x-axis relative to the manufacturing tool,
and
the x-axis may be approximately perpendicular with the translation direction.
Moving the support member relative to the manufacturing tool may involve
moving the support member along an x-axis relative to the manufacturing tool,
and
the x-axis may be approximately perpendicular with the translation direction
and with
a local normal to the surface of the workpiece.
In accordance with another aspect of the invention, there is provided an
apparatus for performing a manufacturing operation on a workpiece. The
apparatus
includes a base configured to be positioned proximate the workpiece, and a
tool
support assembly having a first component coupled to the base and a second
component moveable along a translation axis relative to the first component,
the
second component being configured to be coupled to a tool operable to perform
the
4b
CA 02529904 2009-08-06
manufacturing operation on the workpiece. The apparatus also includes a
biasing
device including a first portion coupled to the first component, and a second
portion
coupled to the second component, the first and second portions being moveably
coupled and configured to apply a biasing force to the second component to at
least
partially counterbalance a force exerted on the second component along the
translation axis by a weight of the tool support assembly and the tool during
performance of the manufacturing operation. T he biasing device also includes
a
control component configured to adjustably control at least one of a magnitude
and a
direction of the biasing force applied to the second component.
The control component may be further configured to adjustably control a flow
of pressurized medium to the biasing device.
The first and second portions of the biasing device may be coupled to define a
chamber, and the control component may include a control valve configured to
adjustably control a flow of pressurized medium to the chamber.
The base may further include at least one elongated rail member, and a
plurality of vacuum attachment devices connected to the at least one rail
member and
configured to be coupleable to the surface of the workpiece.
The first component of the tool support assembly may include a carriage
assembly moveably coupled to the at least one rail member, and the carriage
assembly
may include a drive assembly having a drive motor operatively engaging the at
least
one rail member and configured to drive the carriage assembly along the at
least one
rail member.
The base may include first and second elongated flexible rails, the rails
being
spaced apart and approximately parallel to each other, and a plurality of
vacuum
attachment devices connected to each rail and spaced at intervals therealong
for
releasably attaching each rail to the workpiece by vacuum, and the first
component of
the tool support assembly may include a carriage moveably engaging the first
and
second elongated flexible rails, the carriage being moveable along the rails
to position
the tool support assembly at various locations relative to the workpiece.
The assembly may further include a manufacturing tool operatively coupled to
the second component and configured to perform the manufacturing operation on
the
workpiece.
In accordance with another aspect of the invention, there is provided an
assembly for performing a manufacturing operation on a workpiece. The assembly
4c
CA 02529904 2009-08-06
includes a base configured to be attached to the workpiece, and a tool
assembly. The
tool assembly includes a first component coupled to the base, a second
component
moveable along a translation axis relative to the first component, and a
manufacturing
tool operatively coupled to the second component and configured to perform the
manufacturing operation on the workpiece. The assembly also includes a biasing
device that includes a first portion coupled to the first component, a second
portion
coupled to the second component, the first and second portions being moveably
coupled to define a chamber, and a control component configured to adjustably
control a flow of pressurized medium to the chamber to apply a biasing force
to the
second component to at least partially counterbalance a force exerted on the
second
component along the translation axis by a weight of the tool assembly during
performance of the manufacturing operation.
The control component may be further configured to control at least one of a
magnitude and a direction of the biasing force applied to the second
component.
The base may further include at least one elongated rail member, and a
plurality of vacuum attachment devices connected to the at least one rail
member and
configured to be coupleable to the surface of the workpiece.
The first component of the tool assembly may include a carriage assembly
moveably coupled to the at least one rail member, the carriage assembly
including a
drive assembly having a drive motor operatively engaging the at least one rail
member and configured to drive the carriage assembly along the at least one
rail
member.
The base may further include first and second elongated flexible rails, the
rails
being spaced apart and approximately parallel to each other, and a plurality
of vacuum
attachment devices connected to each rail and spaced at intervals therealong
for
releasably attaching each rail to the workpiece by vacuum. The first component
of the
tool support assembly may include a carriage moveably
engaging the first and second elongated flexible rails, the carriage being
moveable
along the rails to position the tool assembly at various locations relative to
the
workpiece.
In accordance with another aspect of the invention, there is provided a method
of performing a manufacturing operation on a workpiece. The method involves
moveably supporting a manufacturing tool relative to the workpiece using a
tool
4d
CA 02529904 2009-08-06
assembly having a first component and a second component moveably coupled to
the
first component and to the manufacturing tool, the second component being
moveable
along a translation direction with respect to the first component. The method
also
involves applying a biasing force to the second component of the tool assembly
using
a biasing device having a first portion coupled to the first component and a
second
portion coupled to the second component, the first and second portions being
moveably coupled and configured to apply the biasing force to at least
partially
counterbalance a force applied to the second component by a weight of the
manufacturing tool. The method further involves controllably adjusting at
least one of
a magnitude and a direction of the biasing force applied to the second
component, and
performing the manufacturing operation on the workpiece using the
manufacturing
tool.
Controllably adjusting at least one of a magnitude and a direction of the
biasing force may involve controllably adjusting a flow of pressurized medium
to the
biasing device.
The first and second portions of the biasing device may be coupled to define a
chamber, and controllably adjusting at least one of a magnitude and a
direction of the
biasing force may involve controllably adjusting a flow of pressurized medium
to the
chamber.
The first portion of the tool assembly may include a carriage. Moveably
supporting a manufacturing tool relative to the workpiece may involve coupling
at
least one elongated rail to the workpiece, and moveably coupling the carriage
to the at
least one elongated rail.
The manufacturing operation on the workpiece may occur simultaneously with
applying a biasing force to the second component of the tool support assembly.
Performing the manufacturing operation on the workpiece may occur
simultaneously with controllably adjusting at least one of a magnitude and a
direction
of the biasing force.
Performing the manufacturing operation on the workpiece may occur
simultaneously with moveably supporting a manufacturing tool relative to the
workpiece.
As described more fully below, apparatus and methods in accordance with the
present invention may advantageously reduce the amount of fatigue experienced
by
4e
CA 02529904 2009-08-06
an operator of a manufacturing tool, and may improve the efficiency and
accuracy of
the manufacturing operations performed with the manufacturing tool.
In another embodiment, an apparatus for supporting a manufacturing tool
relative to a workpiece includes a track assembly adapted to be attached to
the
workpiece, and a carriage moveably coupled to the track assembly. The carriage
includes a tool support adapted to receive and support a manufacturing tool.
An
opposing-force support assembly is operatively coupled to the carriage and is
adapted
to be secured to the workpiece. The opposing-force support assembly at least
partially
counterbalances a manufacturing force exerted on the workpiece by the
manufacturing tool. Deflections of a workpiece during a manufacturing
operation
may be reduced, thereby improving the accuracy, consistency, efficiency, and
throughput of the manufacturing operation.
In a further embodiment of the invention, an apparatus for supporting a
manufacturing tool relative to a workpiece includes a track assembly adapted
to be
attached to the workpiece and including at least one rail, the rail having a
longitudinally-extending neutral axis and a rack extending along a pitch line
that at
least approximately coincides with the longitudinally-extending neutral axis.
In
alternate embodiments, the rack includes a plurality of wedge-shaped apertures
or a
plurality of conically-shaped apertures. Improvements in position control of a
manufacturing tool may be achieved, thereby improving the accuracy,
consistency,
efficiency, and throughput of the manufacturing operation.
In yet another embodiment, an apparatus for performing a manufacturing
operation on a workpiece includes a track assembly adapted to be attached to
the
workpiece, a carriage assembly moveably coupled to the track assembly and
moveable relative to the workpiece, and a position sensor. The position sensor
is
operatively coupled to the carriage assembly and includes a sensor element
adapted to
be operatively positioned relative to the workpiece. The sensor element is
further
adapted to detect at least one edge of an index feature on the workpiece from
a
distance away from the index feature. Because the sensor element detects an
edge of
the index feature from a distance away from the index feature, the sensor
element
advantageously does not physically contact the index feature, and may
therefore
provide improved reliability and maintainability in comparison with prior art
systems.
4f
CA 02529904 2009-08-06
In another embodiment, an apparatus for performing a manufacturing
operation on a workpiece includes a track assembly adapted to be attached to
the
workpiece, a carriage assembly moveably coupled to the track assembly and
moveable relative to the workpiece, and a position sensor operatively coupled
to the
carriage assembly. The position sensor includes a sensor element adapted to be
operatively positioned relative to the workpiece, and a sensing circuit having
a first
portion coupled to the sensing element, the first portion being adapted to
receive an
analog input signal and provide a conditioned analog output signal on a first
output
node. The sensing circuit further includes a second portion coupled to the
first portion
to and adapted to receive the conditioned analog output signal and to provide
a digital
output signal on a second output node. Thus, the sensor element advantageously
provides both analog and digital output signals to the relevant controller
apparatus,
thereby improving the versatility and accuracy of the manufacturing system.
In a further embodiment, an apparatus for performing a manufacturing
operation on a workpiece including a track assembly adapted to be attached to
the
workpiece, a carriage assembly moveably coupled to the track assembly and
including
a drive assembly operable to translate the carriage assembly along the track
assembly,
and a controller mounted on the carriage assembly and operatively coupled to
the
drive assembly. The controller is adapted to transmit control signals to the
drive
assembly to control movement of the carriage assembly over the workpiece.
Because
the controller is mounted on the carriage assembly, the carriage assembly may
operate
autonomously to perform manufacturing operations on the workpiece, and the
amount
of support equipment may be reduced.
In still another embodiment, an apparatus for performing a manufacturing
operation on a workpiece includes a base member, a drive platform spaced apart
from
the base member by a separation distance, and a plurality of guide members
extending
between the drive platform and the base member. At least one of the drive
platform
and the base member are moveable along the guide members to increase or
decrease
the separation distance. The apparatus also includes a drive member
operatively
coupled between the drive platform and the base member, and a servo motor
operatively coupled to the drive member. As the servo motor drives the drive
member, the separation distance is varied. In an alternate embodiment, a
4g
CA 02529904 2009-08-06
manufacturing tool may be coupled to at least one of the drive platform and
the base
member, and as the motor drives the drive member, the manufacturing tool is
engaged
with the workpiece. Again, as described more fully below, apparatus and
methods in
accordance with the present invention may advantageously improve the accuracy,
efficiency, and throughput of manufacturing operations on a workpiece.
5
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
The preferred and alternative embodiments of the present invention are
described in
detail below with reference to the following drawings.
FIGURE 1 is an isometric view of a support assembly for performing
manufacturing
operations on a workpiece in accordance with an embodiment of the invention;
FIGURE 2 is an isometric view of the support assembly of FIGURE 1 coupled with
a
drill assembly in accordance with an embodiment of the invention;
FIGURE 3 is a side elevational view of the support assembly and drill assembly
of
FIGURE 2;
FIGURE 4 is an isometric view of a carriage assembly being engaged with the
track
assembly of FIGURE 1;
FIGURE 5 is an isometric view of the carriage assembly being secured to the
track
assembly of FIGURE 1;
FIGURE 6 is an isometric view of the counterbalance assembly of FIGURE 1 in a
first biasing position;
FIGURE 7 is an isometric view of the counterbalance assembly of FIGURE 1 in a
second biasing position;
FIGURE 8 is an isometric view of a drill assembly being coupled with the
counterbalance assembly of FIGURE 1;
FIGURE 9 is an isometric view of an alternate embodiment of a track assembly
and a
carriage assembly for use with a support assembly in accordance with another
embodiment
of the invention;
FIGURE 10 is an enlarged, partial isometric top view of the track assembly and
a
portion of the carriage assembly of FIGURE 9;
FIGURE 11 is an enlarged, partial isometric bottom view of the track assembly
and a
portion of the carriage assembly of FIGURE 9;
FIGURE 12 is an isometric view of a manufacturing assembly for performing
manufacturing operations on a workpiece in accordance with yet another
embodiment of the
invention;
FIGURE 13 is an isometric view of the manufacturing assembly of FIGURE 12
engaged with a contoured workpiece in accordance with an alternate embodiment
of the
invention;
6
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
FIGURE 14 is a front isometric view of a manufacturing assembly having an
opposing-force support assembly for performing manufacturing operations on a
workpiece in
accordance with an embodiment of the invention;
FIGURE 15 is a rear isometric view of the manufacturing assembly of FIGURE 14;
FIGURE 16 is a lower isometric view of the manufacturing assembly of FIGURE
14;
FIGURE 17 is an enlarged, front isometric view of the opposing-force support
assembly of the manufacturing assembly of FIGURE 14;
FIGURE 18 is an enlarged, rear isometric view of the opposing-force support
assembly of the manufacturing assembly of FIGURE 14;
FIGURE 19 is an enlarged upper isometric view of a first drive gear engaged
with the
integrally-formed rack of the rail of FIGURE 14;
FIGURE 20 is an enlarged partial isometric view of a rail of the track
assembly of
FIGURE 14;
FIGURE 21 is an enlarged, top elevational partial view of the rail of FIGURE
14;
FIGURE 22 is an enlarged, side cross-sectional view of a portion of the rail
taken
along line A-A of FIGURE 21;
FIGURE 23 is a front elevational view of a manufacturing assembly having a
position
sensor assembly in accordance with an embodiment of the invention;
FIGURE 24 is an upper isometric view of a track assembly and a carriage
assembly
of the manufacturing assembly of FIGURE 23;
FIGURE 25 is an enlarged, partial isometric view of a sensor assembly and
control
assembly of the manufacturing assembly of FIGURE 23;
FIGURE 26 is a side isometric view of a sensor of the sensor assembly of
FIGURE
25;
FIGURE 27 is a bottom isometric view of the sensor of FIGURE 26;
FIGURE 28 is a flowchart of a method of position determination in accordance
with
an embodiment of the invention;
FIGURE 29 is a schematic representation of the method of position
determination of
FIGURE 28;
FIGURE 30 is a graph of a representative signal level of a sensor sweep used
to
detect a position of an index feature in accordance with an embodiment of the
invention;
FIGURE 31 is a control circuit for performing a position determination in
accordance
with another alternate embodiment of the invention;
7
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
FIGURE 32 is a schematic representation of a manufacturing assembly in
accordance
with yet another embodiment of the invention;
FIGURE 33 is an enlarged, front elevational view of a servo-controlled tool
assembly
of the manufacturing assembly of FIGURE 24;
FIGURE 34 is a partially-exposed top elevational view of the servo-controlled
tool
assembly of FIGURE 33; and
FIGURE 35 is a side elevational view of the servo-controlled tool assembly of
FIGURE 33.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
The present invention relates to methods and apparatus for improved
manufacturing
operations, and more specifically, to methods and apparatus for performing
counterbalanced
drilling operations on aircraft fuselage sections. Many specific details of
certain
embodiments of the invention are set forth in the following description and in
FIGURES 1-
35 to provide a thorough understanding of such embodiments. One skilled in the
art,
however, will understand that the present invention may have additional
embodiments, or
that the present invention may be practiced without several of the details
described in the
following description.
Counterbalance-Assisted Manufacturing Operations
FIGURE 1 is an isometric view a support assembly 100 for performing
manufacturing operations on a workpiece 102 in accordance with an embodiment
of the
invention. In this embodiment, the support assembly 100 includes an elongated
track
assembly 110 attachable to the workpiece 102, a carriage assembly 120 moveably
coupled to
the track assembly 110, and a counterbalance assembly 130 coupled to the
carriage assembly
120. As described more fully below, because the support assembly 100 having
the
counterbalance assembly 130 may advantageously reduce the loads borne by an
operator 104
(partially visible) during a manufacturing operation, the support assembly 100
may reduce
operator fatigue, and may improve the efficiency and quality of the
manufacturing operation.
As shown in FIGURE 1, the track assembly 110 includes a beam 112 equipped with
a
plurality of vacuum cup assemblies 114. The vacuum cup assemblies 114 are
fluidly coupled
to a vacuum line 116 leading to a vacuum source 118, such as a vacuum pump or
the like. A
vacuum control valve 115 is coupled between the vacuum line 116 and the vacuum
cup
8
CA 02529904 2009-08-06
assemblies 114 and allows vacuum to be controllably removed or applied to the
vacuum cup assemblies 114 during, for example, mounting and removal of the
track
assembly 110 to and from the workpiece 102. The vacuum cup assemblies 114 are
of
known construction and may be of the type disclosed, for example, in U.S.
Patent No.
6,467,385 BI issued to Buttrick et al., or U.S. Patent No. 6,210,084 B1 issued
to
Banks et al. In alternate embodiments, the vacuum cup assemblies 114 may be
replaced with other types of attachment assemblies, including magnetic
attachment
assemblies, bolts or other threaded attachment members, or any other suitable
attachment assemblies. In some embodiments, the beam 112 of the track assembly
110 may be relatively rigid and inflexible, and in other embodiments, the beam
112
may be a flexible or partially-flexible beam that may be bent and twisted to
conform
to the surface contours of the workpiece 102, as described more fully below.
The carriage assembly 120 shown in FIGURE 1 includes a base member 122
having a plurality of carriage bearings 124 that rollably engage upper and
lower edges
113a, 113b of the beam 112. Thus, the carriage assembly 120 may translate back
and
forth along the length of the beam 112 along an x-axis. In alternate
embodiments, the
carriage bearings 124 may be replaced with rollers, gears, slide members,
rubber
wheels, or other suitable coupling devices. In a particular embodiment, the
carriage
bearings 124 may be replaced with pinion gears that engage with a toothed rack
portion (e.g. positioned on the upper edge 113a) of the beam 112. The carriage
assembly 120 further includes a pair of locking mechanisms 126 attached to the
base
member 122 and engageable with the beam 112 of the track assembly 110. In this
embodiment, the locking mechanisms 126 are hingeably coupled to the base
member
122 and may extend through the base member 122 into a securing engagement with
the beam 112, leaving the carriage assembly 120 free to traverse along the x-
axis of
the beam 112, but otherwise preventing the carriage assembly 120 from becoming
disengaged from the track assembly 110. A carriage lock 137 (FIGURE 3) is
coupled
to the base member 122 and may be engaged with the track assembly 110 to
secure
the carriage assembly 120 in a desired position on the track assembly 110.
With continued reference to FIGURE 1, the counterbalance assembly 130 includes
an
elongated rail 132 moveably coupled to the carriage assembly 120, the rail 132
being
moveable along a y-axis with respect to the carriage assembly 120. In this
embodiment, the rail 132 is moveably engaged with the base member 122 of the
carriage assembly 120 by a plurality of rail bearings 133. In the embodiment
shown
in FIGURE 1, the y-axis (or tool translation axis) is perpendicular to the x-
axis, and
both the y-axis and the x-axis are
9
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
perpendicular to a local normal to the surface of the workpiece 102. In
alternate
embodiments, the y-axis (and the x-axis) may be oriented at different angles
with respect to
the local normal to the surface of the workpiece 102, such as when the
workpiece 102 has
contoured surface, especially a workpiece 102 having a compound contoured
surface (i.e. a
surface that has curvature in multiple planes of curvature). It may be
appreciated, however,
that the y-axis of the support assembly 100 may be positioned such that the y-
axis has at least
a component that is perpendicular to the local normal to the surface of the
workpiece 102, so
that the y-axis is at least partially perpendicular to the local normal. In
other words, the y-
axis is preferably not aligned with the local normal to the surface of the
workpiece 102.
As further shown in FIGURE 1, a tool support 134 is coupled to the rail 132
and
projects outwardly therefrom. A biasing cylinder (or counterbalance device)
136 has a first
portion coupled to the carriage assembly 120 and a second portion coupled to
the rail 132 (or
to the tool support 134). The first and second portions of the biasing
cylinder 136 are
moveable relative to each other. In alternate embodiments, the biasing
cylinder 136 may
include a pneumatic cylinder, a hydraulic cylinder, one or more spring
members, or any other
suitable counterbalance device. Preferably, the counterbalance device 136 is
controllably
biasable by a control mechanism that permits the operator to engage and
disengage a biasing
force applied by the counterbalance device 136, and also to control the
magnitude of the
biasing force. As further shown in FIGURE 1, a supply line 138 leading to a
source of
pressurized fluid (e.g. air or hydraulic fluid) is coupled to a counterbalance
control valve 140
which controls the pressure within the biasing cylinder 136. In one
embodiment, the biasing
cylinder 136 is biasable in a single direction (e.g. either up or down along
the y-axis) by
applying pressure into the biasing cylinder 136 via the counterbalance control
valve 140.
Alternately, the biasing cylinder 136 may be selectively biased in both first
and second
directions (e.g. both up and down along the y-axis) by means of the
counterbalance control
valve 140. In a preferred embodiment, the counterbalance control valve 140 may
be
adjustable to control the biasing direction and the amount of biasing pressure
within the
biasing cylinder 136, which in turn controls the amount of biasing force
applied by the
biasing cylinder 136 on the tool support 134.
In one particular embodiment, the support assembly 100 in accordance with an
embodiment of the present invention may be employed in drilling operations.
For example,
FIGURES 2 and 3 are isometric and side elevational views, respectively, of the
support
assembly 100 of FIGURE 1 coupled with a drill assembly 160 in accordance with
one
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
embodiment of the invention. In this embodiment, the drill assembly 160
includes a drilling
device 162 coupled to a support bracket 164 that is, in turn, coupled to the
tool support 134
of the counterbalance assembly 130. The drilling device 162 may include a
clamp collet 166
that may be securely engaged into a hole in the workpiece 102. The drilling
device 162 may
be any known drilling device suitable for performing drilling operations on a
workpiece,
including, for example, those drilling devices commercially-available from
Cooper Tools,
Inc. of Lexington, South Carolina, West Coast Industries, Inc. of Seattle,
Washington,
Recoules, S.A. of Ozoir-la-Ferriere, France, and from Global Industrial
Technologies, Inc. of
Dallas, Texas.
In operation, the vacuum control valve 115 (FIGURE 1) may be actuated to
disengage the vacuum source 118 from the vacuum assemblies 114, allowing the
track
assembly 110 to be positioned at a desired location on the workpiece 102. The
vacuum
control valve 115 may then be re-actuated to engage the vacuum source 118 with
the vacuum
assemblies 114, securely engaging the track assembly 110 to the workpiece 102.
Next, the
carriage assembly 120 maybe coupled to the track assembly 110. FIGURE 4 is an
isometric
view of a carriage assembly 120 being engaged with the track assembly 110. As
shown in
FIGURE 4, the uppermost carriage bearings 124 may be positioned in contact
with the upper
edge 113a of the beam 112 of the track assembly 110 in a tipped or canted
position, and then
the carriage assembly 120 may be rotated downwardly until the lowermost
carriage bearings
124 engage the lower edge 113b of the beam 112.
With the carriage assembly 120 positioned on the rail assembly 110, the
carriage
assembly 120 may be secured to the track assembly 110 such that the carriage
assembly 120
may move back and forth along the x-axis of the track assembly 110, but will
otherwise not
become separated from the track assembly 110. FIGURE 5 is an isometric view of
the
carriage assembly 120 being secured to the track assembly 110 by an operator
104 by
pressing the locking mechanisms 126 of the carriage assembly 120 into
engagement with the
beam 112 of the track assembly 110.
Next, with the supply line 138 coupled to the counterbalance control valve
140, the
operator 104 may adjust a biasing pressure within the biasing cylinder 136 by
actuating the
counterbalance control valve 140, thereby providing a desired amount of
biasing force along
the y-axis. For example, FIGURE 6 is an isometric view of the counterbalance
assembly 130
positioned in a first biasing position 170, and FIGURE 7 is an isometric view
of the
counterbalance assembly 130 positioned in a second biasing position 172. In
the first biasing
11
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
position 170 (FIGURE 6), the counterbalance control valve 140 is closed so
that there is no
biasing pressure within the biasing cylinder 136, thereby allowing gravity to
drive the rail
136 and the tool support 134 downwardly with respect to the track assembly
110.
Conversely, in the second biasing position 172 (FIGURE 7), the counterbalance
control valve
140 is actuated to provide a biasing pressure within the biasing cylinder 136
that tends to
drive the rail 136 and the tool support 134 upwardly with respect to the track
assembly 110.
It will be appreciated that the biasing cylinder 136 may be used to
counterbalance the
weight of a tool assembly 160 mounted on the counterbalance assembly 130. In
some
embodiments, the tool assembly 160 may be mounted below the track assembly 110
such
that the counterbalance assembly 130 tends to pull the tool assembly 160
toward the track
assembly 110. In alternate embodiments, the tool assembly 160 may be mounted
above the
track assembly 110 so that the counterbalance assembly 130 tends to push the
tool assembly
160 away from the track assembly 110.
A manufacturing tool may then be coupled to the counterbalance assembly 130
for
performing a manufacturing process on the workpiece 102. For example, FIGURE 8
is an
isometric view of the drill assembly 160 (FIGURE 3) being coupled with the
counterbalance
assembly 130. Specifically, the support bracket 164 coupled to the drilling
device 162 may
be slideably engaged onto the tool support 134 by the operator 104, and may be
secured into
position by, for example, one or more locking screws 168 (FIGURE 3). In one
embodiment,
a hole template 106 (FIGURE 2) may be affixed to the workpiece 102 to provide
a guide for
where a plurality of holes 107 are to be drilled into the workpiece 102 using
the drilling
assembly 160.
With the drilling assembly 160 (or other manufacturing tool) secured to the
counterbalance assembly 130, the operator may adjust the counterbalance
control valve 140
so that the tool support 134 is biased upwardly along the y-axis (FIGURE 7),
and so that the
pressure within the biasing cylinder 136 counterbalances (or counteracts) a
gravitational
force on the drilling assembly 160. In a preferred method of operation, the
biasing force
exerted by the biasing cylinder 136 on the tool support 134 approximately
balances the
weight of the drilling assembly 160, such that the drilling assembly 160
"floats" on the
support assembly 100 and may be moved along the y-axis with a relatively small
amount of
force applied by the operator 104. Thus, the operator 104 may position the
drilling assembly
160 in a desired position along the x-axis by translating the carriage
assembly 120 along the
track assembly 110, and in a desired position along the y-axis by sliding the
rail 136 up or
12
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
down with respect to the carriage assembly 120, with relatively little effort.
Of course, in
alternate modes of operation, the biasing force exerted by the biasing
cylinder 136 may be
adjusted to be less than or greater than the weight of the drilling assembly
160 as desired.
In an alternate method of operation, the support assembly 100 may be secured
to the
workpiece 102, and a manufacturing tool (e.g. the drilling assembly 160) may
be attached to
the carriage assembly 120 of the support assembly 100. Next, the drilling
assembly 160 may
be securely engaged with the workpiece 102, such as, for example, by engaging
the clamp
collet 166 of the drill assembly 160 through a hole 107 in the workpiece 102.
With the
drilling assembly 160 secured to the workpiece 102, the support assembly 100
may then be
disengaged from the workpiece 102 such that the support assembly 100 is
supported by the
drilling assembly 160 attached to the workpiece 102. The support assembly 100
may then be
moved (or translated) with respect to the drilling assembly 160 to a different
location on the
workpiece 102, with the support assembly 100 remaining moveably coupled to the
drilling
assembly 160 during this portion of the process. With the support assembly 100
positioned
at a new location on the workpiece 102, the support assembly 100 may be re-
engaged with
the workpiece 102, and the manufacturing operations with the manufacturing
tool may be
resumed along a new section of the workpiece 102.
In one particular embodiment, after the drilling assembly 160 (or other
manufacturing
tool) is secured to the workpiece 102, and with the drilling assembly 160
coupled to the
counterbalance assembly 130, the counterbalance control valve 140 of the
counterbalance
assembly 130 may be adjusted to provide a biasing force in a direction that
counterbalances
the gravitational force on the support assembly 100. In this way, the
counterbalance
assembly 130 may be used to assist the operator 104 in the re-positioning of
the support
assembly 100 on the workpiece 102. In a preferred embodiment, the
counterbalance
assembly 130 is adjusted to approximately equal the gravitational force on the
support
assembly 100 so that when the support assembly 100 is disengaged from the
workpiece 102
and is supported by the drilling assembly 160 secured to the workpiece 102,
the support
assembly 100 may be easily translated (rolled or slid) through the carriage
assembly 120
similar to a carriage on a relatively-older model typewriter.
The support assembly 100 may provide significant advantages over prior art
apparatus and methods for performing manufacturing operations on the workpiece
102.
Because the counterbalance assembly may be adjusted to counterbalance the
weight of a
manufacturing tool, the operator is not required to bear the weight of the
manufacturing tool
13
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
while performing the manufacturing operation. The operator is therefore less
likely to
become fatigued during the manufacturing operation, which may improve the
operator's
satisfaction and comfort during performance of the manufacturing operation.
Reducing the
operator's fatigue may also lead to improved efficiency and improved accuracy
in the
performance of the manufacturing operation. Furthermore, reducing the fatigue
of the
operator may be especially advantageous for those manufacturing operations
that require a
large number of operations using the manufacturing tool on the workpiece.
The support assembly 100 may also advantageously improve the quality of the
manufacturing operations by ensuring accurate, consistent positioning of the
manufacturing
tool with respect to the workpiece. Because the support assembly 100 supports
and controls
the orientation of the manufacturing tool with respect to the surface of the
workpiece, the
manufacturing operations may be more accurately and consistently conducted.
The operator
does not need to support the weight of the manufacturing tool during the
manufacturing
operation, but rather, may remain involved in moving the manufacturing tool to
the desired
location and operating the controls of the manufacturing tool to perform the
desired
operation. Thus, the orientation of the manufacturing tool with respect to the
surface of the
workpiece may be un-effected by fatigue or skill level of the operator.
Furthermore, because support assemblies in accordance with the present
invention
may be easily moved along the surface of the workpiece, the speed with which
manufacturing operations may be performed may be increased. As noted above,
with a
manufacturing tool securely engaged with the workpiece, the support assembly
100 may be
detached from the workpiece and may be moveably translated relative to the
manufacturing
tool to a new location on the workpiece. At the new location, the support
assembly may be
re-engaged with the workpiece, and the manufacturing operations may be
permitted to
continue. The counterbalance assembly may be used to facilitate this process
by providing a
biasing force that counterbalances the weight of the support assembly, thereby
assisting the
operator with translation of the support assembly to the new location. Thus,
the apparatus
and methods in accordance with the present invention may provide yet another
improvement
in the efficiency of manufacturing operations.
It may be appreciated that support assemblies in accordance with the present
invention, including the particular embodiment of the support assembly 100
described above,
may be used to provide counterbalancing support to a wide variety of
manufacturing tools,
and that the teachings of the present invention are not limited to
manufacturing operations
14
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
that involve drilling. For example, support assemblies in accordance with the
present
invention may be used to support riveters, mechanical and electromagnetic dent
pullers,
welders, wrenches, clamps, sanders, nailers, screw guns, or virtually any
other desired type
of manufacturing tools or measuring instruments.
It may also be appreciated that a variety of alternate embodiments of
apparatus and
methods may be conceived in accordance with the present invention, and that
the invention is
not limited to the particular apparatus and methods described above and shown
in the
accompanying figures. For example, it may be noted that the track assembly 110
and the
carriage assembly 120 may be eliminated, and that the counterbalance assembly
130 may
simply be secured directly to the workpiece 102 by one or more attachment
assemblies (e.g.
vacuum cup assemblies 114), to allow counterbalanced manufacturing operations
at a single
point on the workpiece 102, or along a single line of points on the workpiece
102 that may be
parallel with the y-axis. Furthermore, the counterbalance assembly 130 may be
modified or
inverted with respect to the carriage assembly 120 so that the tool support
134 is positioned
above the track assembly 110 rather than below the track assembly 110.
Furthermore, the carriage assembly 120 and the track assembly 110 may assume a
wide variety of alternate embodiments. For example, in one embodiment, the
counterbalance
assembly 130 may be coupled to the rail and carriage assembly taught by U.S.
Patent No.
4,850,763 issued to Jack et al. In yet another embodiment, the counterbalance
assembly 130
may be used in combination with any of the carriage assemblies and track
assemblies
disclosed in co-pending, commonly owned U.S. Patent Application No.
10/016,524, which
application is incorporated herein by reference.
Specifically, FIGURE 9 is an isometric view of an alternate embodiment of a
track
assembly 210 and a carriage assembly 220 for use in a support assembly 200 in
accordance
with another embodiment of the invention, as disclosed in U.S. Patent
Application No.
10/016,524. FIGURES 10 and 11 are enlarged, partial isometric top and bottom
views,
respectively, of the track assembly 210 and the carriage assembly 220 of
FIGURE 9.
As shown in FIGURES 9-11, the track assembly 210 includes a pair of rails 22,
24 to
which a plurality of attachment devices, preferably in the form of vacuum cup
assemblies
114 (FIGURE 1) are releasably affixed at spaced intervals along the length of
each rail. The
rails 22, 24 preferably have a width substantially greater than their
thickness such that they
are substantially stiffer in bending about an axis that extends in the
thickness direction than
they are about an axis that extends in the width direction. The rails 22, 24
are oriented
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
approximately parallel to each other, although the lateral spacing between the
rails 22, 24 can
vary when the rails 22, 24 are mounted on a compound-contoured workpiece
surface.
Preferably, the rails 22, 24 are rigidly affixed to each other at only one end
by a connecting
member 28a, which fixes the lateral spacing between the rails at that end. At
other locations
along the rails 22, 24, the spacing between the rails 22, 24 can vary as
noted. There can be
another connecting member 28b at the opposite end of the rails 22, 24, but
this connecting
member 28b may provide a "floating" connection that allows the spacing between
the rails
22, 24 to adjust as needed depending on the contour of the workpiece 102
surface.
The widths of the rails 22, 24 extend substantially parallel to the surface of
the
workpiece 102 when the vacuum cup assemblies 114 are attached to the workpiece
surface
102. Because the rails 22, 24 may bend relatively easily about the widthwise
directions and
to twist about their longitudinal axes, the rails 22, 24 may flex and twist as
needed to
substantially follow the surface of the workpiece 102 and the vacuum cup
assemblies 114
maintain each rail at a substantially constant distance from the surface of
the workpiece 102.
In this manner, the major surfaces of the rails 22, 24 may be substantially
perpendicular to
the surface normal of the workpiece 102 at any point along each rail.
With continued reference to FIGURES 9-11, mounted on the rails 22, 24 is a
carriage
assembly 220 that may translate along the rails 22, 24 by virtue of rollers 32
that are mounted
on a first base member 30 of the carriage 220 and engage the rails 22, 24. The
first base
member 30 of the carriage assembly 220 in the illustrated embodiment comprises
a plate-
shaped member. The rollers 32 are mounted along each of the opposite side
edges of the first
base member 30. More particularly, spring plates 34 and 36 (best shown in
FIGURE 11) are
attached to the first base member 30 adjacent to a lower surface thereof at
each of the
opposite side edges of the first base member. The spring plates 34, 36 are
affixed to the first
base member 30 at locations 37 (FIGURE 11) spaced inwardly from the opposite
ends of the
spring plates 34, 36, such that each spring plate has two opposite end
portions that are
cantilevered from the first base member 30. The rollers 32 are mounted on
these
cantilevered end portions of the spring plates 34, 36. There are two opposing
rollers 32
mounted on each cantilevered end portion of each of the spring plates 34, 36.
Each rail 22,
24 is received between the opposing rollers 32. The rails 22, 24 preferably
have V-shaped
edges engaged by the rollers 32, and the rollers 32 are V-groove rollers
having V-shaped
grooves that receive the V-shaped edges of the rails 22, 24. The rollers 32
thus prevent
16
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
relative movement between the rollers 32 and rails 22, 24 in the direction
along the rotational
axes of the rollers 32, which axes are substantially normal to the workpiece
surface 102.
The spring plates 34, 36 on which the rollers 32 are mounted may flex and
twist as
needed (i.e. as dictated by the contour of the workpiece surface 102 as the
carriage assembly
220 traverses the rails 22, 24) to allow a limited degree of relative movement
to occur
between the first base member 30 and the rollers 32. This is facilitated by
making the spring
plates 34, 36 relatively narrow at their middles and wider at their ends, so
that the plates 34,
36 preferentially bend and twist at approximately the middle rather than at
the ends where the
rollers 32 are mounted. Thus, a limited degree of relative movement can occur
between the
first base member 30 and the rails 22, 24. The net result is that the support
assembly 200
enables the carriage assembly 220 to traverse the rails 22, 24 along the X-
axis (i.e. the axis
parallel to the length direction of the rails 22, 24) even though the rails
22, 24 may be
bending and twisting in somewhat different ways relative to each, other. In
effect, the rails
22, 24 conform to the contour of the workpiece surface 102 and thus
approximate a normal to
the surface at any point along the path defined by the rails 22, 24.
Consequently, a reference
axis of the carriage assembly 220 (in the illustrated embodiment, an axis
normal to the plane
of the first base member 30) is maintained substantially normal to the
workpiece surface 102
at any position of the carriage assembly 220 along the rails 22, 24.
As best shown in FIGURE 9, a rack 38 for a rack and pinion arrangement is
mounted
along the surface of the rail 24 that faces the spring plate 36, and the
carriage assembly 220
includes a first motor 40 and associated gearbox 42 mounted on the spring
plate 36. An
output shaft from the gearbox 42 has a pinion gear 44 mounted thereon, and the
spring plate
36 includes a window 46 (FIGURE 10) that the pinion gear 44 extends through to
engage the
rack 38 on the rail 24. Thus, rotation of the pinion gear 44 by the first
motor 40 drives the
carriage assembly 220 along the rails 22, 24. It may be appreciated that the
rail 24 having the
rack 38 comprises a reference rail relative to which the X-axis positioning of
the carriage
assembly 220 may be performed. No attempt is necessary to determine or control
the X-axis
positioning of the carriage assembly 220 relative to the other rail 22.
To improve accuracy of the X-axis position of the carriage assembly 220, the
pinion
gear 44 may have a constant height relative to the rack 38 at any point along
the reference
rail 24. To accomplish this height control, the rotation axis of the pinion
gear 44 may
preferably lie in the same plane as that defined by the rotational axes of the
two rollers 32
mounted on the end of the spring plate 36. More particularly, the axes of the
rollers 32 may
17
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
be substantially parallel to each other and substantially normal to the
workpiece surface 102,
and the axis of the pinion gear 44 may be substantially parallel to the
workpiece surface 102
and may lie in the plane of the roller axes.
As further shown in FIGURES 9-11, the carriage assembly 220 further includes a
second base member 50 slideably mounted atop the first base member 30 so that
the second
base member 50 can slide back and forth along a Y-axis direction perpendicular
to the X-axis
direction. More particularly, rails 52, 54 are affixed to the opposite edges
of the first base
member 30, and rollers 56 are mounted on the second base member 50 for
engaging the rails
52, 54. A rack 58 for a rack and pinion arrangement is affixed to the first
base member 30
along the edge thereof adjacent to the rail 54 (see FIGURE 10). A second motor
60 and
associated second gearbox 62 are mounted on a plate 64 that is affixed to the
second base
member 50 adjacent to the rack 58. The plate 64 includes a window
therethrough, and the
output shaft of the second gearbox 62 extends through the window and drives a
pinion gear
66 that engages the rack 58. Thus, rotation of the pinion gear 66 by the
second motor 60
drives the second base member along the rails 52, 54 in the Y-axis direction.
In operation, the counterbalance assembly 130 described above with reference
to
FIGURES 1-8 may be coupled to the second base member 50 of the carriage
assembly 220
shown in FIGURE 9, with the rail 132 aligned with the Y-axis, and a
manufacturing tool may
be coupled to the counterbalance assembly 130. Counterbalance-assisted
manufacturing
operations may then be performed substantially in accordance with the
procedures and
methods described above. Movement of the carriage assembly 220 along the x-
axis may be
provided by a combination of force applied by the operator 104 and/or by the
first motor 40.
Similarly, positioning of the manufacturing tool along the y-axis may be
provided by a
combination of force applied by the operation 104 and/or the second motor 60.
In further
embodiments, gross positioning of the manufacturing tool may be provided by
the first and
second motors 40, 60, and fine positioning may be provided by the operator
104, or vice
versa. Thus, the above-described advantages of apparatus and methods in
accordance with
the present invention may be achieved using a carriage assembly having one or
motors that
provide driving force for positioning of the manufacturing tool.
FIGURES 12 and 13 are isometric views of a manufacturing assembly 300 for
performing manufacturing operations on a contoured workpiece 302 in accordance
with yet
another embodiment of the invention. In this embodiment, the manufacturing
assembly 300
a track assembly 310, a carriage assembly 320 moveably coupled to the track
assembly 310,
18
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
and a counterbalance assembly 330 coupled to the carriage assembly 320. Many
of the
details of the manufacturing assembly 300 are similar or identical to the
previously described
embodiments. Therefore, for the sake of brevity, only significant differences
between the
manufacturing assembly 300 will be discussed below.
As best shown in FIGURE 12, the counterbalance assembly 330 includes a motor
332
that drives a coupling member 334 that, in turn, engages with the track
assembly 310. More
specifically, in the embodiment shown in FIGURE 12, the coupling member 334 is
a gear
that engages with a rack 314 formed in a beam 312 of the track assembly 310. A
tool
assembly 360 is coupled to the carriage assembly 320 and for performing a
manufacturing
operation on the workpiece 302. In alternate embodiments, the motor 332 maybe
a constant
torque motor, a constant force motor, a variable torque motor, a constant
current motor, or
any other suitable motor. In one particular embodiment, the motor 332 is an
electric
servomotor.
As shown in FIGURE 13, in operation, the track assembly 310 may be affixed to
the
contoured workpiece 302 such that gravitational forces tend to pull the
carriage and tool
assemblies 320, 360 along the length of the track assembly 310 in a generally
downward
direction 370. The counterbalance assembly 330, however, may counteract the
gravitational
forces by actuating the coupling member 334 (the gear) to exert a
counterbalancing force
against the gravitational forces in a generally upward direction 372, thereby
holding the
carriage assembly 320 and the tool assembly 360 at a desired station on the
workpiece 302.
Preferably, the counterbalance assembly 330 may resist the gravitational
forces exerted on
the carriage assembly 320 and the tool assembly 360, however, may allow the
carriage
assembly 320 to be moved by the manual application of force on the
manufacturing assembly
300 by an operator when positioning the tool assembly 360 in a desired
position for
performing a manufacturing operation.
The manufacturing assembly 300 shown in FIGURES 12 and 13 may provide the
above-noted advantages of reduced operator fatigue and improved manufacturing
throughput
using a motor-based counterbalancing assembly 330. Because the motor 332
counterbalances gravitational forces acting in the downward direction 370, an
operator is not
required to exert manual force on the manufacturing assembly to prevent the
carriage
assembly 320 from rolling down the track assembly 310 during positioning or
during
performance of the manufacturing operation. Also, because the counterbalancing
assembly
19
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
330 uses the motor 332, the counterbalancing cylinder and associated pneumatic
lines and
pump may be eliminated.
It will be appreciated that in the support assembly 100 described above with
respect
to FIGURES 1-8, the biasing cylinder could be replaced with a motor and
coupling device
similar to the embodiment of the manufacturing assembly 300 shown in FIGURES
12 and
13. Thus, a motor-based counterbalancing assembly could be implemented to
counterbalance
forces acting along the longitudinal axis of the track assembly (FIGURES 12
and 13) or
transverse to the longitudinal axis of the track assembly (FIGURES 1-8). In
this way, the
manufacturing assembly 300 demonstrates that counterbalancing assemblies in
accordance
with the present invention may be implemented using a variety of
counterbalancing devices,
and may be used to counterbalance gravitational forces acting along or
transversely to the
longitudinal axis of the track assembly. Indeed, embodiments of the present
invention may
be implemented to counterbalance forces acting in substantially any direction
relative to the
track assembly to assist the operator with manufacturing operations, and to
improve the
performance of a wide variety of different manufacturing operations on
workpieces having
substantially flat or complex contoured surfaces.
Manufacturing Operations Using Opposing-Force Support Systems
FIGURE 14 is a front isometric view of a manufacturing assembly 400 having an
opposing-force support assembly 460 for performing manufacturing operations on
a
workpiece 402 in accordance with an embodiment of the invention. In this
embodiment, the
manufacturing assembly 400 includes a track assembly 410 attachable to the
workpiece 402,
and a carriage assembly 420 moveably coupled to the track assembly 410. A tool
assembly
450 (e.g. a drilling assembly) is operatively coupled to the carriage assembly
420 such that
the tool assembly 450 may be engaged with the workpiece 402. As shown in
FIGURE 14,
the opposing-force support assembly 460 is coupled to the carriage assembly
420 and is
detachably secured to the workpiece 402. Because the opposing-force support
assembly 460
may support the workpiece 402 during manufacturing operations, the
manufacturing
assembly 400 may advantageously reduce or eliminate deflections of the
workpiece 402, and
may improve the efficiency and quality of the manufacturing operation, as
described more
fully below.
FIGURES 15 and 16 are rear and lower isometric views, respectively, of the
manufacturing assembly 400 of FIGURE 14. In this embodiment, the track
assembly 410
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
includes a pair of beams 412, each beam 412 being equipped with a plurality of
vacuum cup
assemblies 414. The vacuum cup assemblies 414 are fluidly coupled to one or
more vacuum
lines 416 leading to a vacuum source 418 (not shown), such as a vacuum pump or
the like,
such that vacuum may be controllably applied to (and removed from) the vacuum
cup
assemblies 414 during, for example, mounting, re-positioning, and removal of
the track
assembly 410 to and from the workpiece 402. The vacuum cup assemblies 414 are
of known
construction and may be of the type disclosed, for example, in U.S. Patent No.
6,467,385 B1
issued to Buttrick et al., or U.S. Patent No. 6,210,084 B1 issued to Banks et
al. In alternate
embodiments, the vacuum cup assemblies 414 may be replaced with other types of
attachment assemblies, including magnetic attachment assemblies, bolts or
other threaded
attachment members, or any other suitable attachment assemblies.
With continued reference to FIGURES 14-16, the carriage assembly 420 includes
an
x-axis (or first) carriage 422 and a y-axis (or second) carriage 424. The x-
axis carriage 422
includes a base member 426 having a plurality of rollers 428 that rollably
engage the edges
of the beams 412. Thus, the x-axis carriage 422 may translate back and forth
along the
length of the beams 412 along an x-axis that is aligned with the longitudinal
axes of the
beams 412. In alternate embodiments, the rollers 428 may be replaced with
carriage
bearings, gears, slide members, rubber wheels, or other suitable coupling
devices. In one
particular embodiment, the rollers 428 may be replaced with pinion gears that
engage a
toothed or serrated rack portion of one or both of the beams 412. As shown in
FIGURE 15,
the x-axis carriage 422 further includes a first drive motor 430 that is
operatively coupled to a
first gear 432. In this embodiment, the first gear 432 projects through the
base member 426
and engages with drive apertures 413 disposed in one of the beams 412. A
controller 434 is
positioned on the x-axis carriage 422 and is operatively coupled to the first
drive motor 430.
Similarly, the y-axis carriage 424 includes a support member 436 slideably
coupled to
a slot 438 disposed in the base member 426 of the x-axis carriage 422 (FIGURE
14). A
second drive motor 440 is attached to the x-axis carriage 422 and to the
support member 436,
and is also operatively coupled to the controller 434. As shown in FIGURE 14,
in this
embodiment, the second drive motor 440 drives a shaft (or screw) 442 that
engages a ball nut
444 coupled to the support member 436. Thus, the second drive motor 440 may
drive the
support member 436 of the y-axis carriage 424 along a y-axis oriented
transversely to the x-
axis.
21
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
As best shown in FIGURE 14, the tool assembly 450 is coupled to the support
member 436 of the y-axis carriage 424 and may be operatively coupled to the
controller 434.
In this embodiment, the tool assembly 450 includes a drill spindle module 452
and a pressure
foot 454 (FIGURE 16) that is controllably engageable with the workpiece 402
during a
drilling operation. The drill spindle module 452 is controllably engageable
with the
workpiece 402 along a z-axis which is approximately aligned with a local
normal to the
workpiece 402. The drill spindle module 452 may be any known drilling device
suitable for
performing drilling operations, including, for example, those drilling devices
commercially-
available from Cooper Tools, Inc. of Lexington, South Carolina, West Coast
Industries, Inc.
of Seattle, Washington, Recoules, S.A. of Ozoir-la-Ferriere, France, or from
Global
Industrial Technologies, Inc. of Dallas, Texas.
FIGURES 17 and 18 are enlarged, front and rear isometric views, respectively,
of the
opposing-force support assembly 460 of the manufacturing assembly 400 of
FIGURE 14. In
this embodiment, the opposing-force support assembly 460 includes a clamp-up
actuator 462
having a clamp-up pin 464 that is engageable with the workpiece 402. A first
(or y-axis)
actuator 466 is coupled to the clamp-up actuator 462 and to a first baseplate
468, and is
extendible along the y-axis. The first baseplate 468 is slideably coupled to a
pair of first
auxiliary rails 470 mounted on a second baseplate 472. Similarly, the second
baseplate 470
is slideably coupled to second auxiliary rails 474 mounted on the x-axis
carriage 422. As
best shown in FIGURE 18, the first auxiliary rails 470 are approximately
parallel with the x-
axis, and the second auxiliary rails 474 are approximately parallel with the z-
axis. A second
(or x-axis) actuator 476 is coupled between the first baseplate 468 and the
second baseplate
472, and is extendible along the x-axis. A third (or z-axis) actuator 478 is
coupled between
the second baseplate 472 and to the x-axis carriage 422, and is extendible
along the z-axis.
The first, second, and third actuators 466, 476, 478 may be operatively
coupled to the
controller 434. Thus, the first, second, and third actuators 466, 476, 478 may
be used to
controllably position the clamp-up pin 464 of the opposing-force support
assembly 460 at a
desired location along the y-axis, the x-axis, and the z-axis, respectively.
It will be appreciated that the clamp-up actuator 462 may be any type of
suitable
actuator, including a hydraulic, pneumatic, or electrically-driven actuator.
Similarly, the
first, second and third actuators 466, 476, 478 may be hydraulic, pneumatic,
electric, or any
other suitable type of actuators. In one particular embodiment, the first,
second and third
actuators 466, 476, 478 are so-called "return to home" pneumatic actuators
that are coupled
22
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
by one or more pneumatic supply lines 479 (FIGURES 17 and 18) to a source of
pressurized
air (not shown).
In operation, the manufacturing assembly 400 may be mounted onto the workpiece
402 and vacuum may be provided to the vacuum assemblies 414, thereby securing
the track
assembly 410 in a desired position. A hole 403 may be formed in the workpiece
402 in any
desired manner, such as during fabrication of the workpiece 402, or using the
tool assembly
450 or another drilling device. Next, the clamp-up pin 464 may be positioned
in the hole
403. The positioning of the clamp-up pin 464 into the hole 403 may be
accomplished in a
variety of ways. For example, the position of the clamp-up pin 464 along the x-
axis may be
accomplished by controllably positioning the x-axis carriage 422 using the
first drive motor
430, or controllably positioning the first baseplate 468 along the first
auxiliary rails 470 using
the second actuator 476, or by a combination of both of these methods.
Similarly, the
position of the clamp-up pin 464 along the y-axis may be accomplished by
controllably
positioning the y-axis carriage 424 using the second drive motor 440, or by
controllably
actuating the first actuator 466, or both. Finally, the position of the clamp-
up pin 464 along
the z-axis may be accomplished by controllably positioning the second
baseplate 472 along
the second auxiliary rails 470 using the third actuator 478. In one particular
embodiment, the
x-axis and y-axis carriages 422, 424 are employed to perform coarse,
relatively large scale
positioning, and the second and first actuators 476, 466 are used to provide
finer, relatively
small scale positioning of the clamp-up pin 464 along the x- and y-axes,
respectively.
The above-described positioning of the opposing-force support assembly 460 may
be
accomplished in an automated or semi-automated manner using the controller 434
equipped
with conventional, computerized numerically-controlled (CNC) methods and
algorithms.
Alternately, the positioning may be performed manually by an operator, such
as, for
example, by temporarily disabling or neutralizing the above-referenced motors
and actuators
of the carriage and clamp-up assemblies 420, 460 to permit the opposing-force
support
assembly 460 to be positioned manually.
With further reference to FIGURES 14-18, after the clamp-up pin 464 is
positioned
within the hole 403, the clamp-up actuator 462 may be actuated to securely
engage the
clamp-up pin 464 within the hole 403, thereby fixing the position of the
opposing-force
support assembly 460 with respect to the workpiece 402. After the clamp-up
assembly 460 is
securely engaged with the workpiece 402, the tool assembly 450 may be used to
perform
manufacturing operations on the workpiece 402. Specifically, in the embodiment
shown in
23
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
FIGURES 14-16, the drill spindle module 452 may be operated to drill one or
more
additional holes 403 into the workpiece 402. For example, the additional holes
403 may be
created by controllably positioning the tool assembly 450 using the carriage
assembly 420 in
an automated or semi-automated manner using the controller 434 and
conventional CNC
methods and algorithms. Because the opposing-force support assembly 460 is
moveably
secured to the carriage assembly 420, the carriage assembly 420 may be used to
re-position
the tool assembly 450 without detaching the opposing-force support assembly
460 from the
workpiece 402. Thus, with the opposing-force support assembly 460 secured to
the
workpiece 402, the tool assembly 450 may be successively and repeatedly
repositioned at a
plurality of desired locations on the workpiece 402 to perform manufacturing
operations.
After one or more manufacturing operations have been performed on the
workpiece
402, the opposing-force support assembly 460 may be detached from the
workpiece 402 by
deactivating the clamp-up actuator 462 and removing the clamp-up pin 464 from
the hole
403. If desired, the opposing-force support assembly 460 may then be
repositioned to a new
location and may be secured again to the workpiece, 402 by inserting the clamp-
up pin 464
into a different hole 403 (such as one of the newly formed holes) and
actuating the opposing-
force support assembly 460 in the manner described above. With the opposing-
force support
assembly 460 secured to the workpiece 402 in the new location, additional
manufacturing
operations may be conducted on the workpiece 402 as desired.
Manufacturing assemblies having opposing support systems in accordance with
the
teachings of the present invention may advantageously improve the quality of
manufacturing
operations on a workpiece. Because the opposing-force support assembly 460
opposingly
supports (or counterbalances) the workpiece during the application of forces
on the
workpiece by the tool assembly 450, the workpiece 402 may be less likely to
bend or deflect
during the manufacturing process, especially for relatively thin or relatively
flexible
workpieces. Since deflections of the workpiece 402 may be reduced or
eliminated, the
orientation of the tool assembly 450 with respect to the workpiece 402 may be
more easily
maintained by the carriage assembly 420. Thus, the manufacturing operations
may be more
accurately and consistently conducted using the manufacturing assembly 400.
Because the
manufacturing operations may be more accurately and consistently performed,
the costs
associated with inspecting and reworking the workpiece 402 during the
manufacturing
operation may be reduced.
24
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
The manufacturing assembly 400 having the opposing-force support assembly 460
may also improve the speed with which manufacturing operations may be
performed.
Because the opposing-force support assembly 460 provides opposing support to
the
workpiece 402 during manufacturing operations, the tool assembly 450 may be
more
forcefully applied to the workpiece 402. In this way, the speed with which the
manufacturing operations are performed may be increased, and the efficiency
and throughput
of the manufacturing operations may be improved.
It will be appreciated that a wide variety of suitable embodiments of opposing
support
assemblies 460 may be conceived in accordance with the teachings of the
present invention.
For example, a variety of clamp-up pins 464 and clamp-up actuators 462 are
known that may
be employed to secure the opposing-force support assembly 460 to the workpiece
402,
including, for example, a collet device of the type generally disclosed in
U.S. Patent No.
4,396,318 issued to Jensen et al., U.S. Patent No. 5,395,187 issued to
Slesinski et al., and
U.S. Patent No. 6,036,409 issued to Rissler, or a clamping device of the type
generally
disclosed in U.S. Patent No. 5,482,411 issued to McGlasson and U.S. Patent No.
6,283,684
B1 issued to Jarvis. In one alternate embodiment, the hole 403 may be a
threaded hole 403,
and the clamp-up pin 464 may be a threaded member that threadedly engages the
threaded
hole 403. In further embodiments, the clamp-up pin 464 and clamp-up actuator
462 may be
replaced with any other suitable securing devices, including one or more of
the above-
referenced vacuum cup assemblies 414, magnets, or other electro-magnetic
apparatus, such
as, for example, an apparatus that exerts a force on a workpiece in a manner
similar to the
electromagnetic dent remover apparatus commercially-available from
Electroimpact, Inc. of
Everett, Washington.
It may also be appreciated that manufacturing assemblies in accordance with
the
present invention, including the particular embodiment of the manufacturing
assembly 400
described above, may be used to provide opposing support to a wide variety of
manufacturing tools, and that the teachings of the present invention are not
limited simply'to
manufacturing operations that involve drilling. For example, manufacturing
assemblies
having opposing support assemblies in accordance with the present invention
may be used to
support riveters, mechanical and electromagnetic dent pullers, welders,
wrenches, clamps,
sanders, nailers, screw guns, or virtually any other desired type of
manufacturing tools or
measuring instruments.
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
It may also be appreciated that a variety of alternate embodiments of
apparatus and
methods may be conceived in accordance with the present invention, and that
the invention is
not limited to the particular apparatus and methods described above and shown
in the
accompanying figures. For example, it may be noted that the carriage assembly
420 and the
track assembly 410 may assume a wide variety of alternate embodiments. For
example, in
one embodiment, the opposing-force support assembly 460 may be coupled to the
rail and
carriage assembly taught by U.S. Patent No. 4,850,763 issued to Jack et al. In
yet another
embodiment, the opposing-force support assembly 460 may be used in combination
with any
of the carriage assemblies and track assemblies disclosed in co-pending,
commonly owned
U.S. Patent Application No. 10/016,524, which application is incorporated
herein by
reference.
Specifically, in one alternate embodiment, opposing-force support systems may
be
used in combination with the track assembly 210 and carriage assembly 220
described above
with reference to FIGURES 9-11. More specifically, as shown in FIGURE 9,
mounted atop
the y-axis carriage is a clamp ring assembly 70. The clamp ring assembly 70
may be used to
support and secure a tool assembly 450, such as the drill spindle module 452
described
above. The tool assembly 450 may be extended through a window in the y-axis
carriage 50
(visible in FIGURE 10), and through a window in the x-axis carriage 30
(visible in FIGURE
11) that is elongated in the y-axis direction. The axis of the tool assembly
450 may be
approximately parallel to the z-axis, and thus may be substantially normal to
the workpiece
402.
In operation, the opposing-force support assembly 460 described above with
reference to FIGURES 14-18 may be coupled to the carriage assembly 220 shown
in
FIGURES 9-11 in any suitable manner, and a manufacturing tool assembly 450 may
be
coupled to the carriage assembly 220 (e.g., to the clamp ring assembly 70).
Manufacturing
operations may then be performed substantially in accordance with the
procedures and
methods described above. Movement of the carriage assembly 220 along the x-
axis may be
provided by a combination of force applied by the operator 404 and/or by the
first motor 40.
Similarly, positioning of the manufacturing tool along the y-axis may be
provided by a
combination of force applied by the operation 404 and/or the second motor 60.
In further
embodiments, gross positioning of the manufacturing tool maybe provided by the
first and
second motors 40, 60, and fine positioning may be provided by the operator
404, or vice
versa. Thus, the above-described advantages may be achieved using alternate
embodiments
26
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
of track assemblies and carriage assemblies to create additional embodiments
of
manufacturing assemblies in accordance with the teachings of the present
invention.
Manufacturing Operations Using Track Members Having a Neutral-Axis Rack
Referring again to FIGURES 14 and 15, in this embodiment, the track assembly
410
includes a pair of flexible beams 412, each beam 412 having an integrally-
formed rack 480.
As described more fully below, the integrally-formed racks 480 may provide
improved
position control of the carriage assembly 420, thereby improving the quality
of
manufacturing operations performed on the workpiece 402.
As further shown in FIGURES 19-21, the rack 480 includes a plurality of
apertures
488 integrally-formed in the rail 412a along the neutral axis 486 of the rail
412a. In other
words, a pitch line of the rack 480 extends along and at least approximately
coincides with
the neutral axis 486 of the rail 412. Bridges 490 are formed between each pair
of successive
apertures 488. As best shown in FIGURE 19, the teeth 435 of the first drive
gear 432 are
engaged at least partially into the apertures 488 and against the bridges 490
of the rack 480.
FIGURE 22 is an enlarged, side cross-sectional view of a portion of the rail
412a
taken along line A-A of FIGURE 21. As shown in FIGURE 22, in this embodiment,
the
apertures 488 are tapered along the stiff axis 482 such that the apertures 488
are wider at a
top surface 487 of the rail 412a and narrower at a bottom surface 489 of the
rail 412a. In one
aspect, the apertures 488 are tapered in a wedge-shaped (or two-dimensional)
manner. In an
alternate aspect, the apertures 488 are partially-conically (or three-
dimensionally) shaped.
As further shown in FIGURE 22, the apertures 488 may be tapered to closely
match the
profile of the teeth 435 of the drive gear 432. In one particular embodiment,
the thickness of
the rail 412 is equal to the length of the tooth 435 of the drive gear 432
(FIGURE 22).
Because the pitch line of the rack 480 at least approximately coincides with
the neutral axis
486, the rack 480 remains aligned along the neutral axis 486 during bending
and flexing of
the rail 412a over the workpiece 402. Thus, the teeth 435 of the drive gear
432 may remain
more positively engaged with the rack 480 as the carriage assembly 420 is
driven over the
track assembly 410, even when the rails 412 are twisted and flexed over
contoured surfaces.
It will be appreciated that the rack 480 may be integrally-formed with the
rail 412
using any desired manufacturing techniques. For example, the rack 480 may be
formed in
the rail 412 after the rail 412 has been formed, such as by milling, drilling,
hogging, or using
27
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
any other suitable methods. Alternately, the rack 480 may be formed
simultaneously with the
formation of the rail 412, such as by casting, stamping, or pressing.
In operation, the manufacturing assembly 400 may be mounted onto the workpiece
402 and vacuum may be provided to the vacuum assemblies 414, thereby securing
the track
assembly 410 in a desired position. The carriage assembly 420 may then be
moved to a
desired position along the track assembly 410, so that the tool assembly 450
may be used to
perform manufacturing operations on the workpiece 402. The controller 434 may
transmit
control signals to the first drive motor 430, rotating the first drive gear
432 which engages
with the integrally-formed rack 480 in the rail 412a. As best shown in FIGURE
22, the teeth
435 of the first drive gear 432 may engaged partially or fully into the
apertures 488 and may
exert a driving force against the bridges 490 of the rack 480, thereby driving
the carriage
assembly 420 along the rails 412 until the carriage assembly 420 reaches the
desired position.
It may be appreciated that the positioning of the carriage assembly 420 on the
track
assembly 410, and the positioning and engagement of the opposing-force support
assembly
460 and the tool assembly 450 with respect to the workpiece 402 may be
accomplished in an
automated or semi-automated manner using the controller 434 equipped with
conventional,
computerized numerically-controlled (CNC) methods and algorithms. Alternately,
the
positioning may be performed manually or partially-manually by an operator,
such as, for
example, by having the operator provide manual control inputs to the
controller 434, or by
temporarily disabling or neutralizing the above-referenced motors and
actuators of the
carriage and clamp-up assemblies 420, 460 to permit manual movement.
Next, the clamp-up pin 464 may be positioned in a hole 403, and the clamp-up
actuator 462 may be actuated, to securely engage the clamp-up pin 464 within
the hole 403,
thereby fixing the position of the opposing-force support assembly 460 with
respect to the
workpiece 402. The tool assembly 450 may then be employed to perform
manufacturing
operations on the workpiece 402. Specifically, in the embodiment shown in
FIGURES 14
and 15, the drill spindle module 452 may be operated to drill one or more
additional holes
403 into the workpiece 402. Like the carriage assembly 420, the tool assembly
450 may be
controlled and operated in an automated or semi-automated manner using the
controller 434
and conventional CNC methods and algorithms.
Manufacturing assemblies having integrally-formed racks in accordance with the
teachings of the present invention may advantageously improve the quality of
manufacturing
operations on a workpiece. Because the rack 480 is integrally-formed with the
rail 412 with
28
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
the pitch line of the rack 480 at least approximately aligned with the neutral
axis 486 of the
rail 412, the teeth 435 of the drive gear 432 remain in positive engagement
with the rack 480
even when the rail 412 is flexed and twisted over contoured surfaces. The
integrally-formed
rack 480 may advantageously permit more accurate positioning of the carriage
assembly 420
on the track assembly 410, and thus, more accurate positioning of the tool
assembly 450 over
the workpiece 402. The manufacturing assembly 400 may therefore provide
improved
accuracy and consistency of manufacturing operations in comparison with prior
art
manufacturing assemblies. Because the manufacturing operations may be more
accurately
and consistently performed, the costs associated with inspecting and reworking
the
workpiece 402 during the manufacturing operation may be reduced.
The manufacturing assembly 400 having the track assembly 410 in accordance
with
the invention may also improve the speed with which manufacturing operations
may be
performed. Because the integrally-formed rack 480 of the track assembly 410
may provide
improved position control of the tool assembly 450 during manufacturing
operations, the tool
assembly 450 may be positioned and operated with relatively fewer delays for
position
checking and position adjustment, and the need for repair and rework of the
manufacturing
operations (e.g. hole reworking etc.) may be reduced. In this way, the speed
with which the
manufacturing operations are performed may be increased, and the efficiency
and throughput
of the manufacturing operations may be improved.
It will be appreciated that manufacturing assemblies in accordance with the
present
invention, including the particular embodiment of the manufacturing assembly
400 described
above, may be used to provide opposing support to a wide variety of
manufacturing tools,
and that the teachings of the present invention are not limited simply to
manufacturing
operations that involve drilling. For example, manufacturing assemblies having
opposing
support assemblies in accordance with the present invention may be used to
support riveters,
mechanical and electromagnetic dent pullers, welders, wrenches, clamps,
sanders, nailers,
screw guns, routers, degreasers, washers, etchers, deburring tools, lasers,
tape applicators, or
virtually any other desired type of manufacturing tools or measuring
instruments.
It may also be appreciated that a variety of alternate embodiments of
apparatus and
methods may be conceived in accordance with the present invention, and that
the invention is
not limited to the particular apparatus and methods described above and shown
in the
accompanying figures. For example, it may be noted that the carriage assembly
420 and the
track assembly 410 may assume a wide variety of alternate embodiments. For
example, in
29
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
alternate embodiments, an integrally-formed rack 480 in accordance with the
present
disclosure may be used in combination with any of the carriage assemblies and
track
assemblies disclosed in co-pending, commonly owned U.S. Patent Application No.
10/016,524, which application has previously been incorporated herein by
reference.
Manufacturing Operations Using Non-Contact Position Sensing
FIGURE 23 is a front elevational view of a manufacturing assembly 500 having a
position sensor assembly 540 in accordance with an embodiment of the
invention. In this
embodiment, the manufacturing assembly 500 includes a track assembly 510
attachable to a
workpiece 20, and a carriage assembly 520 moveably coupled to the track
assembly 510. A
controller 530 is operatively coupled to the position sensor assembly 540 and
to the carriage
assembly 520. As described more fully below, the manufacturing assembly 500
having the
position sensor assembly 540 may advantageously improve the accuracy and
efficiency of
manufacturing operations performed on the workpiece 24.
FIGURE 24 is an upper isometric view of the track assembly 510 and the
carriage
assembly 520 of FIGURE 23 with the position sensor assembly 540 removed. In
this
embodiment, the track assembly 510 and the carriage assembly 520 are
substantially similar
to the track and carriage assembly embodiments described above with respect to
FIGURES
9-11. Therefore, for the sake of brevity, only significant differences shown
in FIGURES 23
and 24 will now be described.
FIGURE 25 is an enlarged, partial isometric view of the position sensor
assembly 540
and the controller 530 of the manufacturing assembly 500 of FIGURE 23. As
shown in
FIGURE 25, the position sensor assembly 540 includes a mount 542 that is
coupled to the
carriage assembly 520 (e.g. to the clamp ring assembly 70), and a sensor 544
that is
operatively coupled to the mount 542. A sensor link 546 is coupled between the
sensor 544
and the controller 530 for transmitting and receiving signals.
FIGURES 26 and 27 are side and bottom isometric views, respectively, of the
sensor
544 of FIGURE 25. As best shown in FIGURE 27, the sensor 544 includes a
sensing
element 548 for transmitting signals toward the workpiece 20, and for
receiving reflected
signals from the workpiece 20, as described more fully below. It will be
appreciated that the
sensor 544 may be any suitable digital or analog sensing element, including,
for example,
those sensors commercially-available from Sunx, Inc. of Des Moines, Iowa, or
from
Keyence, Inc. of American, New Jersey. In one embodiment, the sensing element
548 may
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
be a fiber optic sensing element, and in one particular embodiment, the
sensing element may
be a coaxial fiber optic retro-reflective sensing element. In other alternate
embodiments, for
example, sensor element 548 may include cameras (e.g. DVT camera vision
systems),
magnetic proximity sensors, or any other suitable sensor element. It will be
appreciated that
the signals transmitted from the sensor 544 to the workpiece 20, and reflected
back from the
workpiece 20 to the sensor 544, may be visible light, infrared or ultra-violet
signals, acoustic
signals, or any other desired type of signal.
With reference to FIGURES 23 through 25, the track assembly 510 may be secured
to
the workpiece 20, and the carriage assembly 520 may be used to support the
position sensor
assembly 540 such that the sensing element 548 is pointed toward the workpiece
20. The
position sensor assembly 540 may then be employed to locate the coordinates of
one or more
indexing features (or reference points) located on the workpiece 20. As
described more fully
below, the position sensor assembly 540 provides a capability for the
manufacturing
assembly 500 to determine a positional orientation of the manufacturing
assembly 500 based
on one or more known indexing features (e.g. a hole, a fastener, a bushing, or
other feature)
without physical contact between the sensor assembly 540 and the workpiece 20.
In one aspect, the sensing element 548 includes a bright LED coaxial fiber
optic cable
that uses a lens system to focus incident or illuminating light onto the
workpiece 20. In brief,
the incident light may be transmitted through the center fiber of the coaxial
fiber optic cable,
through a lens, and may be reflected by the surface of the workpiece 20. The
reflected light
may then be collected through the lens and returned to a sensor amplifier
through the outer
portion of the coaxial fiber optic cable. The sensor amplified may then
convert the intensity
of the light into an analog electrical signal. The output from the sensor
amplifier may be
calibrated to a focal point of the lens by reading the reflected light from a
standard white
reflective surface. As the scan path encounters various features on the
surface, the reflected
light may be analyzed and when the collected data match a defined set of
parameters, a
known index feature (e.g. fastener, hole, etc.) can be recognized. The signal
may be read and
correlated to a position on the surface by using feedback from a positioning
system. This
location information may then be used to position other equipment on the
surface of the
workpiece 20, making it possible to control a system of tools or processes, as
described more
fully below.
FIGURE 28 is a flowchart showing a method 600 of position determination using
the
sensor assembly 540 in accordance with an embodiment of the invention. FIGURE
29 is a
31
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
schematic representation of the method 600 of position determination of FIGURE
28. The
steps of the method 600 may be implemented using known programmable or semi-
programmable components and software routines. As shown in FIGURES 28 and 29,
the
method 600 may begin at an initial step 602 in which the position sensor
assembly 540 is
initially positioned proximate to an indexing feature 21 that is to be
detected, such as by an
operator manually positioning the carriage assembly 520 at a suitable location
on the track
assembly 510, and the position sensor assembly 540 begins transmitting one or
more
detection signals 601 onto the workpiece 20 and receiving corresponding
reflected signals
603 back from the workpiece 20. Next, in step 604, the sensor 544 is either
incrementally or
continuously advanced along a first path 605 in a first direction (shown as
the y-direction in
FIGURE 29).
With continued reference to FIGURES 28 and 29, as the sensor 544 is advanced
along the first path 605, the method 600 continues to transmit detection
signals 601 and
monitor the received reflected signals 603 to determine whether a first edge
607 of the index
feature 21 has been detected (step 606). If the sensor 144 is a digital
sensor, the sensor 144
may indicate that the edge has been reached by providing a sensor output that
transitions
from a first well-defined state indicating that the sensor 144 is receiving
reflected signals 603
that are reflecting from the workpiece 20, to a second well-defined state
indicated that the
sensor 144 is receiving reflected signals 603 that are reflecting from the
index feature 21.
Alternately, if the sensor 144 is an analog sensor, the sensor output may be
proportional to
the reflected signals 603 from the workpiece 20 and from the index feature 21,
thereby
providing an indication of when the sensor 144 is over each component,
respectively.
Eventually, based on the reflected signals 603, the first edge 607 (FIGURE 29)
of the
index feature 21 may be detected (step 606). Next, in step 608, the position
of the sensor 544
may be readjusted and a localized, slow speed (or small increment) rescan may
be performed
to determine the coordinates of the first edge 607, and the coordinates of the
first edge 607
are stored. In step 610, the method 600 determines whether the edge that has
just been
detected is a second edge 609 (see FIGURE 29) of the index feature 21, and if
not, the
method 600 repeats steps 604 through 608 to determine and store the
coordinates of the
second edge 609.
Next, in step 612, the method 600 uses the coordinates of the first and second
edges
607, 609 to calculate a first center 611 along the first path 605, and
repositions the sensor 544
at a location spaced apart from the index feature 21 with a value along the
first direction (e.g.
32
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
the y coordinate) that corresponds to the value of the first center 611. The
sensor 544 is then
advanced along a second path 613 (shown as the x direction in FIGURE 29) in
step 614, and
the output from the sensor 544 is monitored to determine whether a first edge
615 of the
index feature 21 along the second path 613 has been detected (step 616). After
the first edge
615 along the second path 613 has been detected, as described above, the
position of the
sensor 544 may be readjusted and a localized, slow speed (or small increment)
rescan may be
performed along the second path 613 to detennine the coordinates of the first
edge 615, and
the coordinates of the first edge 615 along the second path 613 are stored
(step 618). After
storing the coordinates, the method 600 next determines whether the edge that
has just been
detected is a second edge 617 of the index feature 21 along the second path
613 (see
FIGURE 29) in step 620, and if not, the method 600 repeats steps 614 through
618 to
determine and store the coordinates of the second edge 617 along the second
path 613. In
step 622, the method 600 uses the coordinates of the first and second edges
615, 617 along
the second path 613 to calculate a second center 619 (FIGURE 29).
With reference to FIGURE 28, steps 604 through 612 may generally be referred
to as
a first sweep 624 of the sensor 544, and steps 614 through 622 may be referred
to as a second
sweep 626 of the sensor 544. After determining the coordinates of the first
and second
centers 611, 619 using the first and second sweeps 624, 626, the method 600
may simply
assume that the coordinates of an index center of the index feature 21 are the
same as the
coordinates of the second center 619. If this approach is deemed satisfactory
in step 628,
then the method 600 proceeds with outputting the coordinates of the center of
the index
feature 21 in step 630. If additional accuracy or confirmation is desired,
however, the
method 600 may include one or more additional sweeps 632 of the sensor 544.
As shown in FIGURE 28, in an additional sweep 632 is desired, the sensor 544
is
repositioned in step 634 to a location spaced apart from the index feature 21
but having the
same value along the second direction (x coordinate in FIGURE 29) as the
second center
619. Next, the sensor 544 is advanced along a third path 613 (shown as the y
direction in
FIGURE 29) in step 636, and the output from the sensor 544 is monitored to
determine
whether a first edge 623 of the index feature 21 along the third path 621 has
been detected
(step 636). After the first edge 623 along the third path 621 has been
detected, the position of
the sensor 544 may be readjusted and a localized, slow speed (or small
increment) rescan
may be perfonned along the third path 621 to determine the coordinates of the
first edge 623,
and the coordinates of the first edge 623 along the third path 621 are stored
(step 640). After
33
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
storing the coordinates, the method 600 next determines whether the edge that
has just been
detected is a second edge 625 of the index feature 21 along the third path 621
(step 642). If
not, the method 600 repeats steps 236 through 640 to determine and store the
coordinates of
the second edge 625 along the third path 621. In step 646, the method 600 uses
the
coordinates of the first and second edges 623, 625 along the third path 621 to
compute a third
(or additional) center 627.
After the additional sweep 632 is conducted, the method 600 may again
determine
whether the desired degree of accuracy has been reached in step 628. If not,
additional
sweeps similar to the third sweep 632 may be conducted along, for example,
different paths.
If additional sweeps are not desired, then the method 600 proceeds to step
630, and the
coordinates of the index center are output. The results of the third sweep 632
(or more
sweeps) may provide an improved indication of the index center of the index
feature 21. For
example, the index center may be determined as the average of the coordinates
of the second
and third centers 619, 627. After the index center of the index feature 21 is
output (step
630), the method 600 may continue in step 648 to the next phase of
manufacturing
operations.
It may be appreciated that the particular locations and directions of the
first, second,
and third paths 605, 613, 621 of the method 600 may be varied from the
particular
embodiment shown in FIGURE 69, and that the present invention is not limited
to the
particular details described above and shown in the accompanying figure. For
example, the
first direction of the first path may be along the x axis, and the second
direction of the second
path may be along the y axis, or alternately, the first and second paths may
be along any
desired directions across the index feature 21. Preferably, however, the first
and second
paths are orthogonally oriented. It may also be appreciated that the method
600 may be
better suited for locating an index center of an index feature having a round
(or
approximately round) shape, although other shapes of index features may be
employed and
detected using the apparatus and methods in accordance with the present
invention.
FIGURE 30 is a graph 700 of a representative sensor output signal level 702 of
a
sensor sweep 704 used to detect a position of an index feature 21 in
accordance with an
embodiment of the invention. In this embodiment, the index feature 21 is a
fastener head that
is raised above the surface of the surrounding workpiece 20. The signal level
702 of
FIGURE 30 may be provided by an analog type of sensor 544. As shown in FIGURE
30,
during a first portion A of a sensor sweep 704, the signal level 702 is
characterized by a
34
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
generally constant level as reflected signals are receive by the sensor 144
from the surface of
the workpiece 20. In a second portion B, the signal level 702 is characterized
by a
descending level of reflected signals received by the sensor 544 as the
detection signals begin
to impinge on and reflect from a leading edge 706 of the fastener head 21.
As further shown in FIGURE 30, as the sensor sweep 704 continues, the signal
level
702 reaches a first minimum reflection value at a location C, and then enters
a portion D that
is characterized by an ascending signal level as an increasing level of
reflected signals are
received by the sensor 544. Next, the signal level generally levels off during
a next portion E
of the sensor sweep 704 as the sensor 544 begins receiving a relatively
constant level of
reflected signals from the top of the fastener head 21. Continuing the sensor
sweep 704
across the top of the fastener head 21 to a trailing edge 708 of the fastener
head 21, the signal
level 702 eventually is characterized by a relatively substantial descent to a
second minimum
reflection level at a location F, and then rises again to an ambient
reflection level
characteristic of reflections from the surface of the workpiece 20. Iii one
embodiment, the
method 600 described above with reference to FIGURES 28 and 29 performs the
above-
referenced edge determinations (steps 606, 608, 616, 618, 638, and 640) by
assigning the
coordinates of the sensor 544 corresponding to the locations of the first and
second minimum
reflection levels (locations C and F) as being the coordinate positions of the
first and second
edges for each of the paths 605, 613, 621.
More specifically, the leading and trailing edges 706, 708 may be computed
from the
signal level 702 by first computing an ambient reflectivity level (portion A),
such as by
computing a running average of the sensor level 702. During the sensor sweep
704, as the
sensor level 702 drops below a predetermined threshold, such as a
predetermined percentage
of the ambient reflectivity level, an edge detection procedure may be invoked.
The edge
detection procedure may store the minimum sensor value (location C)
corresponding to the
leading edge 706 and the position coordinates thereof, and may also store the
same
information from the minimum sensor value corresponding to the trailing edge
708 (location
F). A center may then be mathematically computed from the positions of the two
minimum
sensor values (locations C and F).
It will be appreciated that the characteristics of the sensor level may vary,
and that
various index features may provide sensor levels having different shapes,
trends, and
characteristics than that shown in the graph 700 of FIGURE 30. Similarly, it
may be
desirable to monitor different aspects of the sensor level other than the
locations of the
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
minimum sensor values, such as, for example, the derivative (or slope) of the
sensor levels.
In one alternate embodiment, for example, the index feature may be a bushing
having a
concave rolled edge. For such a bushing, the edges of the bushing may be more
readily
determined by monitoring a derivative of the sensor level (e.g. with respect
to the distance
traveled by the sensor 144) during a sensor sweep over the bushing. In that
case, the peaks or
maxima of the derivative values may be representative of the rate of change of
the profile of
the surfaces over which the sensor 144 is swept, effectively shifting the
pattern in time by a
constant of differentiation.
In operation, the position sensor assembly 540 may be employed to determine
the
locations of one or more index features 21 on the workpiece 20, thereby
precisely defining
the position of the manufacturing assembly 500 on the workpiece 20. This
information may
then be stored in a memory device of the controller 530. After the position
sensor assembly
540 has been employed for this purpose, the position sensor assembly 540 may
be removed
from the carriage assembly 520, and the tool assembly 550 may be installed on
the carriage
assembly 520. Using command and control information stored in its memory
device, the
controller 530 may then autonomously control the carriage assembly 520 and the
tool
assembly 550 to perform the desired manufacturing operations at the desired
locations on the
workpiece 20. Different tool assemblies may be interchanged to and from the
carriage
assembly 520 to perform different manufacturing operations as desired.
Manufacturing assemblies having the position sensor assembly in accordance
with the
teachings of the present invention may advantageously improve the quality and
efficiency of
manufacturing operations on a workpiece. The position sensor assembly may
provide a
relatively fast, automated method of precisely locating the manufacturing
assembly on the
workpiece using an indexing feature that may already be part of the workpiece
or the
structure. The need for physical contact index points, the accuracy of which
may become
degraded, is thereby reduced or eliminated. The need to precisely position the
track
assembly on the workpiece at the start of manufacturing operations is also
reduced or
eliminated. The position sensor may accurately determine the location of the
manufacturing
assembly on the workpiece, and the data corresponding to the desired locations
of the
manufacturing operations (e.g. the hole pattern for a plurality of drilling
operations) which
are stored in memory may simply be rotated or transformed in machine space
into proper
alignment and orientation with the actual location of the track assembly on
the workpiece
using standard transformation matrix algorithms. In this way, the accuracy,
consistency, and
36
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
efficiency of the manufacturing operations on the workpiece may be improved,
and the costs
associated with performing, inspecting, and reworking the workpiece may be
reduced.
The manufacturing assembly 500 having the position sensor assembly 540 further
provides the capability to detect an index feature on the workpiece 20 without
the need for
physical contact between contact sensors, feeler gauges, or other physical
contact devices on
the carriage assembly 520 and corresponding contact features on the workpiece
20. The
sensor element may detect the index feature from a distance away from the
index feature,
thereby eliminating any need for physical contact between the sensor element
and the index
feature. Because there is no physical contact, the position sensor assembly
may provide
improved performance over alternate sensor systems that require physical
contact and that
may be bent, damaged, or otherwise degraded during transport, storage, or
during the
performance of manufacturing operations. In this way, the position sensor
assembly may
improve the accuracy of the manufacturing processes, and may reduce the labor
associated
with the process of orienting the manufacturing assembly on the workpiece.
Also, the
position sensor assembly may advantageously reduce or eliminate the
possibility of damage
to the surface of the workpiece that may otherwise be caused by physical
contact with the
surface, reducing the need for repairs and reworking of the work-piece. Thus,
the overall
efficiency and throughput of the manufacturing operation may be improved.
It may be appreciated that a variety of alternate embodiments of apparatus and
methods may be conceived in accordance with the present invention, and that
the invention is
not limited to the particular apparatus and methods described above and shown
in the
accompanying figures. For example, it may be noted that the carriage assembly
520 and the
track assembly 510 may assume a wide variety of alternate embodiments,
including, for
example, the rail and carriage assemblies taught by U.S. Patent No. 4,850,763
issued to Jack
et al, and any of the carriage assemblies and track assemblies disclosed in co-
pending,
commonly owned U.S. Patent Application No. 101016,524, which application has
been
previously incorporated herein by reference.
In another aspect, a control circuit 800 may be employed that receives and
enhances
an output signal of an analog sensor of the position sensor assembly 540. For
example,
FIGURE 31 is a sensing circuit 800 for performing a position determination in
accordance
with another alternate embodiment of the invention. In this embodiment, the
sensing circuit
800 includes a comparator stage whereby an output signal 804 of an analog
sensor 806 is
made to function as a digital proximity sensor simultaneously with its use as
an analog
37
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
sensor. As shown in FIGURE 31, the output signal 804 is fed into a first
circuit portion 808
configured to provide a gain and level shift stage. The first circuit portion
808 may provide
an optimal response for different types of workpiece surfaces. A conditioned
analog signal
810 output by the first circuit portion 808 is provided to the controller 530
on an analog
output node 812. Similarly, the conditioned analog signal 810 output by the
first circuit
portion 808 is provided as an input to a second circuit portion 814. The
second circuit
portion 814 is configured as a threshold comparator stage which trips above or
below a given
signal voltage, providing an appropriate digital signal 816 on a digital
output node 818. The
gain, offset, and threshold values of the sensing circuit 800 may be
predetermined constants,
or may be programmable by the controller 530 according to varying operating
conditions.
Manufacturing assemblies that includes the sensing circuit 800 may provide
improved
position accuracy over alternate systems. Because the sensing circuit 800 may
receive an
analog signal from the sensing element and provides both a conditioned analog
output and a
digital output, the sensing circuit may provide a capability of cross-checking
the results of
the position detection of an index feature by enabling the controller to
compare and utilize
both analog and digital output signals. The sensing circuit 800 may also
provide improved
versatility by enabling the position sensor assembly to be utilized with both
analog or digital
controllers or other desired electronic components.
It may be appreciated that the various operations of the manufacturing
assembly 500
may be controlled by the controller 530, including the positioning of the
carriage assembly
520 on the track assembly 510, the operations of the position sensor assembly
540, and the
positioning and engagement of the tool assembly 550 with respect to the
workpiece 20.
These operations may be accomplished in an automated or semi-automated manner
using the
controller 534 equipped with computerized numerically-controlled (CNC) methods
and
algorithms. Alternately, the positioning may be performed manually or
partially-manually
by an operator, such as, for example, by having the operator provide manual
control inputs to
the controller 534, or by temporarily disabling or neutralizing the above-
referenced motors
and actuators of the carriage and clamp-up assemblies 520, 560 to permit
manual movement.
Typically, to provide a desired degree of positional accuracy for performing
manufacturing operations, the index centers of two index features 21 may be
determined
using the methods and apparatus described above. After the one or more index
centers of the
index features 21 have been determined, control algorithms of the
manufacturing assembly
500 may be used to transform a data pattern stored in a memory of a control
system (e.g. in
38
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
the controller 530) into machine space for controlling the manufacturing
operations
performed by the manufacturing assembly 500 on the workpiece 20. These
transformations
may be performed using standard, well-known mathematical algorithms commonly
employed in presently-existing CNC machining processes.
Referring again to FIGURES 23 through 25, in yet another aspect, the
controller 530
may include an entire CNC control system. For example, in one particular
embodiment, the
controller 530 includes an 8-axis servo-controller, and a plurality of servo-
amplifiers, servo-
motors, and air solenoids. Because the controller 530 is attached directly to
the carriage
assembly 520 (e.g. to the y-axis carriage 50), the controller 530 travels with
the carriage
assembly 520 during the performance manufacturing operations. Thus, the links
or cables
between the controller 530 and the other components of the manufacturing
assembly 500 for
transmitting control signals to (and receiving feedback signals from) the
drive motors 40, 60
of the carriage assembly 520, the position sensor assembly 540, the tool
assembly 550, and
any other components of the manufacturing assembly, are greatly reduced or
eliminated. A
controller umbilical 532 (FIGURE 23) may provide control air, electrical
power, and
communication cables from a supply unit 534 to the controller 530.
Alternately, the
controller umbilical 532 may also provide high-volume fluid (e.g. air or
hydraulics) for
powering the tool assembly 550.
The manufacturing assembly 500 having the controller 530 mounted to the
carriage
assembly 520 may further improve the efficiency and throughput of the
manufacturing
operations. Because the controller 530 is mounted on the carriage assembly
520, the amount
of cables extending between the controller 530 and the portions of the
carriage assembly (e.g.
the drive assembly, the position sensor assembly, etc.) and the tool assembly
550 may be
reduced compared with prior art manufacturing assemblies. Thus, the
manufacturing
assembly may provide improved mobility of the carriage assembly over the track
assembly
because the movement of the carriage assembly is not limited by the lengths of
the control
cables extending between the carriage assembly to a remotely-located
controller, or by the
mobility of a remotely-located controller within the confines of the
manufacturing
environment. The combination of the carriage assembly 520 and the controller
530 may
even allow for a single operator to move these components between various
locations to
conduct manufacturing operations at different locations or on different
workpieces, thereby
further improving the efficiency and throughput of the manufacturing process.
39
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
FIGURE 32 is a schematic representation of a manufacturing assembly 900 in
accordance with yet another embodiment of the invention. In this embodiment,
the
manufacturing assembly 900 includes a sensor unit 902 and a pair of tool units
904 operating
on a track assembly 510 (not visible) that is coupled to a contoured workpiece
920. The
sensor and tool units 902, 904 each include a carriage assembly as described
above. The
sensor unit 902 also includes a position sensor assembly 540, while the tool
units 904 include
a tool assembly 550. The sensor and tool units 902, 904 are operatively
coupled to a master
controller 906, such as by wireless or hardwired communication links 908. The
sensor and
tool units 902, 904 may also include a controller 530, as described above.
In operation, each of the sensor and tool units 902, 904 may operate
autonomously
under the control of their respective controllers 530, or semi-autonomously
under the control
of both the controller 530 and the master controller 906, or may be fully
controlled by the
master controller 906. In one embodiment, the sensor unit 902 may perform the
function of
locating various indexing features distributed over the workpiece 920 in the
manner
described above, which information may be transmitted to the master controller
906. The
master controller 906 may then provide command and control signals to one or
more tool
units 904 to precisely position the tool units 904 and to perform the desired
manufacturing
operations on the workpiece 920. Alternately, the locations of the indexing
features may be
transmitted from the sensor unit 902 directly to one or more of the tool units
904, and the tool
units 904 may operate autonomously to perform the desired manufacturing
operations at the
appropriate locations on the workpiece 920. After locating the indexing
features on a first
portion of the workpiece 920, the sensor unit 902 may move automatically to a
next portion,
or may be commanded to proceed to the next portion of the workpiece 920 by the
master
controller 906 to make room for the tool units 904 or to locate additional
index features.
The manufacturing assembly 900 may further improve the efficiency and
throughput
of manufacturing operations. As noted above, because the controller 530 of
each unit 902,
904 is mounted to the carriage assembly 520, the number of cables and wires
associated with
each unit 902, 904 may be reduced, thereby improving the mobility of each unit
over the
workpiece 920. Because the need for cables extending between each of the units
902, 904
and a remotely-located controller may be reduced, the number of different
units 902, 904 that
may be located and operated in relatively close proximity on a single track
assembly may be
increased. Thus, the efficiency and throughput of manufacturing operations may
be
improved.
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
Servo-Controlled Manufacturing Operations
Referring again to FIGURE 24, in one particular embodiment, a manufacturing
assembly 500 in accordance with the present invention includes a track
assembly 510
controllably attachable to a workpiece 20, and a carriage assembly 520
moveably coupled to
the track assembly 510. A controller 530 is mounted on the carriage assembly
and is
operatively coupled to the servo-controlled tool assembly 550 and to the
carriage assembly
520. Again, it will be appreciated that the track assembly 510 and the
carriage assembly 520
are substantially similar to the track and carriage assembly embodiments
described above
with respect to FIGURES 9-11. As described more fully below, the manufacturing
assembly
500 having the servo-controlled tool assembly 550 may advantageously improve
the
accuracy and efficiency of manufacturing operations performed on the workpiece
20.
FIGURE 33 is an enlarged, front elevational view of the servo-controlled tool
assembly 550 of the manufacturing assembly 500 of FIGURE 24. FIGURES 34 and 35
are
exposed top and side elevational views, respectively, of the servo-controlled
tool assembly
550 of FIGURE 33. In this embodiment, the tool assembly 550 includes a drill
spindle
module 552 and a drive unit (or feed unit) 554. The drill spindle module 552
includes a
centrally-disposed motor shaft 556 having armature windings 558 (FIGURE 34)
disposed
thereon. The motor shaft 556 includes a drill holding collet 562 that holds a
drill member
560 that maybe engaged with the workpiece 20.
The motor shaft 556 further includes a lubrication reservoir 555 positioned at
the
upper end. of the motor shaft 556 and a lubrication channel 557 (FIGURE 33)
extending
longitudinally through the length of the motor shaft 556 from the lubrication
reservoir 555 to
the drill member 560 to enable lubricant to be applied through the shaft 556
to the drill
member 560. A pilot bushing 563 extends downwardly about the drill member 560
and
securely engages against the workpiece 20 during a manufacturing operation. A
spindle
motor housing 564 having a plurality of air cooling ports 565 is disposed
about the motor
shaft 556, and a field assembly 566 (FIGURE 34) is positioned within the motor
housing 564
and proximate to the armature windings 558 of the motor shaft 556. The field
assembly 566
may include one or more rare earth permanent magnets that, in combination with
the
armature windings 558, provide a lightweight brushless motor. A top cover 569
(removed in
the partially-exposed view in FIGURE 34) covers the upper portion of the
spindle motor
41
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
housing 564. As further shown in FIGURE 34, a drill speed encoder 568 is
mounted on the
motor shaft 556.
With continued reference to FIGURES 33-35, the drive unit 554 of the tool
assembly
550 includes a base member 570 slideably coupled to a drive platform 572 by
four
circumferentially-spaced guide rods 574. In this embodiment, the drive
platform 572 is
coupled to the drill spindle module 552 while the base member 570 is coupled
to the carriage
assembly 520. The motor shaft 556 of the drill spindle module 552 is rotatably
mounted
through the base member 570 and the drive platform 572 by a rotary bearing
571. Although
the motor housing 564 (and field assembly 566) are shown in the accompanying
figures as
being coupled to the drive platform 572, in alternate embodiments, the motor
housing 564
may be coupled to the base member 570, or to both the base member and the
drive platform
572.
As best shown in FIGURE 33, the drive unit (or feed unit) 554 includes two
ball
screws 576 that extend between the base member 570 and the drive platform 572.
A servo
motor 578 is mounted to the drive platform 572 and is coupled to each of the
ball screws 576
by a drive belt 580 (FIGURE 35). As shown in FIGURE 34, the drive belts 580
are engaged
over a plurality of belt tensioners 582 that help to maintain positive
engagement of the drive
belts 580 with the ball screws 576. The servo motor 578 and the drill spindle
module 552,
including the drill speed encoder 568, are operatively coupled to the
controller 530.
In operation, the carriage assembly 520 is positioned in a desired location
over the
workpiece 20 in the manner described above. The drive unit 554 of the tool
assembly 550
may then be activated by the controller 530, causing the servo motor 578 to
drive the ball
screws 576, propelling the drive platform 572 toward the base member 570, and
thus, driving
the drill spindle module 552 toward the workpiece 20 and engaging the pilot
bushing 563
with the workpiece 20. Similarly, the drill spindle module 552 may be
activated to ready the
drill member 560 for engagement with the workpiece 20. As the drive unit 554
continues to
drive the drive platform 572 toward the base member 570, the drill member 560
is driven
into the workpiece 20, performing the desired manufacturing operation on the
workpiece 20.
After the manufacturing operation is performed, the controller 530 may
transmit appropriate
control signals to the servo motor 578 to rotate the ball screws 576 in the
opposite direction,
thereby drawing the drive platform 572 away from the base member 570 and
withdrawing
the drill spindle module 552 from the workpiece 20. The carriage assembly 520
may then be
repositioned at a new location, and the process repeated as desired.
42
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
Manufacturing assemblies having servo-controlled tool assemblies in accordance
with
the teachings of the present invention may advantageously improve the quality
and efficiency
of manufacturing operations on a workpiece. For example, the servo-controlled
tool
assembly 550 in accordance with the present invention provides an extremely
lightweight
manufacturing apparatus. Specifically, because the tool assembly 550 combines
a field
assembly 566 that may include one or more rare earth magnets with the armature
windings
558 on the motor shaft 556 to provide a brushless motor, the tool assembly 550
may be
considerably lighter than prior art, pneumatically-driven tool assemblies.
Additional weight
savings are achieved by providing the motor shaft 556 that incorporates the
drill holding
collet 562, and that includes the internal lubricant channel 557. Furthermore,
all of the
components of the drill spindle module 552, including the frameless motor, are
provided on
one shaft and share one set of rotary bearings. Thus, servo-controlled tool
assemblies in
accordance with the teachings of the present invention may be substantially
lighter than prior
art tool assemblies, providing improved controllability and accuracy during
manufacturing
operations. Also, because the tool assemblies are more lightweight, the setup
and tear-down
of the manufacturing assembly 500 may be simplified, and the efficiency and
throughput of
the manufacturing operations may be improved.
Furthermore, because the feed rate of the drive unit 554 may be precisely
controlled
via the servo motor 578, the servo-controlled tool assembly 550 may provide
improved
performance over prior art tool assemblies. For example, by monitoring the
rotational speed
of the motor shaft 556 via the speed encoder 568, the controller 530 may
transmit appropriate
control signals to the servo motor 578 (or to the drill spindle module 552) to
provide a
desired relationship between the rotational speed of the shaft and the feed
rate of the drill
spindle module 552. In one embodiment, for example, the controller 530 may
carefully
control the feed rate and/or the rotational speed of the drill spindle module
552 to provide a
maximum drilling rate into the workpiece. Alternately, the controller 530 may
control the
tool assembly to maintain a desired workload on the drill spindle module 552,
or to provide
the highest quality drilling operation. The enhanced controllability of the
servo-controlled
tool assembly 550 may be particularly effective in cases where the physical
characteristics of
the workpiece 20 are variable, such as for a workpiece 20 that includes a
plurality of layers of
different materials having differing hardness values. In this case, the
controller 530 may
quickly and efficiently adjust the feed rate provided by the servo motor 578
to maintain the
desired drilling speed of the drill spindle module 552. Thus, using servo-
controlled tool
43
CA 02529904 2005-12-19
WO 2005/002803 PCT/US2004/020422
assemblies in accordance with the present invention, both the drill speed and
the feed rate
may be precisely controlled to provide optimal performance and to improve
manufacturing
throughput.
It may be appreciated that a variety of alternate embodiments of apparatus and
methods may be conceived in accordance with the present invention, and that
the invention is
not limited to the particular apparatus and methods described above and shown
in the
accompanying figures. For example, it may be noted that the carriage assembly
520 and the
track assembly 510 may assume a wide variety of alternate embodiments,
including, for
example, the rail and carriage assemblies taught by U.S. Patent No. 4,850,763
issued to Jack
et at, and any of the carriage assemblies and track assemblies disclosed in co-
pending,
commonly owned U.S. Patent Application No. 10/016,524, which application has
previously
been incorporated herein by reference.
It may also be noted that in alternate embodiments, the drill spindle module
552 may
be replaced with a wide variety of manufacturing tools to perform any desired
manufacturing
operation on the workpiece 20. In alternate embodiments, for example, the
drill spindle
module 552 may be replaced with one or more riveters, mechanical and
electromagnetic dent
pullers, welders, wrenches, clamps, sanders, nailers, screw guns, routers,
degreasers,
washers, etchers, deburring tools, lasers, tape applicators, or virtually any
other desired type
of manufacturing tools or measuring instruments.
Conclusion
While specific embodiments of the invention have been illustrated and
described
herein, as noted above, many changes can be made without departing from the
spirit and
scope of the invention. Accordingly, the scope of the invention should not be
limited by the
disclosure of the specific embodiments set forth above. Instead, the invention
should be
determined entirely by reference to the claims that follow.
44
