Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02536366 2006-02-17
WO 2005/018863 PCT/US2004/026625
GAS METAL ARC WELDING OF COATED STEELS
Field of the Invention
[0001] This invention relates to gas metal arc
welding and more particularly, to an improved process
for gas metal arc welding which can significantly
improve weld quality and appearance as well as provide
higher productivity for welding coated steels, e.g.,
galvanized, galvannealed and aluminized steels.
Background of the Invention
[0002] Gas metal arc welding, commonly referred to
as "GMAW" or "MIG" welding, is an electric arc welding
process in which the arc is shielded from the ambient
atmosphere by a gas or a mixture of gases. Metal is
transferred to a workpiece through the arc from a
consumable wire electrode. The consumable wire
electrode is continuously fed into the arc at a
preselected speed corresponding to a given deposition
rate for a given wire size.
[0003] The optimum type of metal transfer employed
with the gas metal arc process is a spray arc where
fine metal droplets are transferred in a very
controlled manner across the arc gap. Very little
spatter is produced using this welding technique. The
type of metal transfer can be obtained only with a
certain combination of shielding gases and welding
parameters and thus is generally produced only within a
fairly narrow range of conditions.
[0004] Typically gas metal arc welding shielding
gases have comprised solely carbon dioxide or have
comprised mixtures of argon, carbon dioxide oxygen or
CA 02536366 2006-02-17
WO 2005/018863 PCT/US2004/026625
- 2 -
helium. Each known shielding gas has a specific known
range within which the process with that gas will
perform acceptably well. Helium, if employed in the
gas mixture, is present in a concentration generally
exceeding 20 percent and is used to impart special
characteristics to the weld but only when its high cost
can be justified.
[0005] The use of coated steels has increased over
the past few years. Typical problems experienced when
arc welding coated steels include heavy spatter,
porosity, poor bead appearance, and burn-off and fuming
of the coating adjacent to the weld area. In many
applications, poor weld bead appearance and poor weld
quality are significant problems for the fabricator.
Existing shielding gas/wire combinations for gas metal
arc welding have not performed well on materials with
galvanized, galvannealed or aluminized coatings.
[0006] Accordingly, it is an object of this
invention to provide an improved gas metal arc welding
method which can effectively reduce weld spatter,
increase bead wetting and minimize porosity when
joining galvanized, galvannealed or aluminized steels.
This overall improvement in weld quality will lead to
higher productivity and reduced welding costs for the
user.
[0007] It is another object of this invention to
provide an improved gas metal arc welding method which
can employ a shielding gas which does not require the
presence of a large concentration of helium and yet
achieves a comparable improvement in desired weld
characteristics.
CA 02536366 2006-02-17
WO 2005/018863 PCT/US2004/026625
- 3 -
Summary of the Invention
[0008] This invention relates in part to a method
for gas metal arc welding with a consumable wire
electrode comprising:
(a) forming an arc between said consumable wire
electrode and a coated steel workpiece;
(b) maintaining a substantially constant arc
voltage between said consumable wire electrode and the
coated steel workpiece;
(c) feeding the consumable wire electrode through
a welding torch contact tube into said arc;
(d) transferring metal from the consumable wire
electrode to the coated steel workpiece; and
(e) shielding the arc with a gas mixture
consisting essentially of:
(i) from 6 to 10 volume percent carbon
dioxide;
(ii) from 6 to 10 volume percent helium;
and
(iii) the balance argon.
[0009] This invention also relates in part to a
shielding gas mixture for use with gas metal arc
welding of coated steels consisting essentially of:
(i) from 6 to 10 volume percent carbon
dioxide;
(ii) from 6 to less than 10 volume percent
helium; and
(iii) the balance argon.
[0010] As used herein, the term "coated steel" means
galvanized, galvannealed or aluminized steels. By
practicing the method of this invention, a user can
successfully weld coated steels with improved quality
CA 02536366 2006-02-17
WO 2005/018863 PCT/US2004/026625
- 4 -
of the weld joints produced. The shielding gas
mixtures of this invention allow users to maintain
maximum manufacturing flexibility through the use of
one gas mixture and multiple wire types without
compromises normally associated with other gas mixtures
available in the marketplace. The shielding gas
mixtures are cost effective and easy to implement in
either cylinder packaging or bulk form.
Brief Description of the Drawings
[0011 Fig. No. 1 is a schematic diagram of an
illustrative system useful for carrying out the method
of this invention. Fig. 2 depicts a gas composition
comparison for galvanized coated steel. Fig. 3 depicts
a gas composition comparison for galvannealed coated
steel.
Detailed Description of the Invention
[0012 As indicated above, this invention relates in
part to method for gas metal arc welding with a
consumable wire electrode comprising:
(a) forming an arc between said consumable wire
electrode and a coated steel workpiece;
(b) maintaining a substantially constant arc
voltage between said consumable wire electrode and the
coated steel workpiece;
(c) feeding the consumable wire electrode through
a welding torch contact tube into said arc;
(d) transferring metal from the consumable wire
electrode to the coated steel workpiece; and
(e) shielding the arc with a gas mixture
consisting essentially of:
CA 02536366 2006-02-17
WO 2005/018863 PCT/US2004/026625
_ 5 -
(i) from 6 to 10 volume percent carbon
dioxide;
(ii) from 6 to 10 volume percent helium;
and
(iii) the balance argon.
[0013) This invention also relates in part to a
shielding gas mixture for use with gas metal arc
welding of coated steels consisting essentially of:
(i) from 6 to 10 volume percent carbon
dioxide;
(ii) from 6 to 10 volume percent helium;
and
(iii) the balance argon.
[0014 The invention can be described in further
detail with reference to Fig. 1, Fig. 2 and Fig. 3.
Referring to Fig. 1, consumable wire electrode 1 is
drawn from reel 12 by feed roll 14 through contact tube
16 in gas shielded arc welding torch 2. The consumable
wire electrode may have a diameter within the range of
from 0.023 to 0.062 inch and may be composed of any
suitable metal composition appropriate for the
particular welding application. Preferably, the
consumable wire electrode is a solid wire, more
preferably a solid wire having silicon content of from
about 0.5 to 1.0 weight percent of the total wire
chemistry. The consumable wire electrode may also be a
metal-cored wire developed to weld on coated steels or
a flux-cored wire. Solid GMAW wires with an American
Welding Society (AWS) classification of ER70S-X are
preferred consumable wire electrodes for use in this
invention with a low silicon content wire such as an
AWS ER70S-3 wire being more preferred.
CA 02536366 2006-02-17
WO 2005/018863 PCT/US2004/026625
- 6 -
[0015] Any suitable gas shielded torch may be used
to carry out the method of this invention. The torch
may be either manually operated or mechanized. In the
embodiment illustrated in Fig. 1, torch 2 is a
mechanized torch. Feed roll 14 is driven by drive
motor 3 contained in wire feeding unit 18 which can
feed wire at the speeds necessary to achieve the
desired deposition rates.
[0016] Power supply 20 supplies power to both wire
feeding unit 18 and torch 2. Power supply 20 is
voltage controlled and of the constant potential type.
[0017] In operation, an arc 4 is established between
consumable electrode 1 and workpiece 5 by energizing
power supply 20 feeding the electrode into direct
contact with the workpiece. The arc voltage between
the electrode and the workpiece is kept substantially
constant during the welding process. By "substantially
constant" it is meant that the arc voltage varies not
more than 5 percent from the set point during the
welding process. The arc voltage setpoint is at a
point where a~stable arc can be achieved for whichever
transfer mode is chosen. The method of this invention
is particularly advantageous for use with the short
circuiting transfer, spray transfer, and pulsed spray
transfer modes of metal transfer. The substantially
constant voltage allows for a self-regulating welding
condition in that as the arc length varies during
welding, the wire melt off rate also varies to keep the
arc voltage substantially constant. This allows for
stable welding conditions to be maintained with uniform
weld penetration and bead shape. The arc voltage is
generally within the range of from about 17 to 40
CA 02536366 2006-02-17
WO 2005/018863 PCT/US2004/026625
volts, preferably from about 22 to 32 volts, with the
current varying between 150 to 200 amperes. The
consumable wire electrode is fed through welding torch
contact tube 16 into the arc and metal is transferred
from the electrode to the workpiece. The preferred
welding position is in the horizontal or flat position.
[0018] The electrode 1 is fed through the contact
tube 16 into the arc 4 formed between the electrode 1
and workpiece 5. Contact tube 16 is connected through
torch 2 to power supply 20 for supplying power to
electrode 1. Workpiece 5 is connected to ground in
common with the power supply ground.
[0019] The arc is shielded from the ambient
atmosphere by a gas mixture consisting essentially of
from 6 to 10 percent, preferably from 7 to 9 percent,
and more preferably 7.5 to 8.5 percent carbon dioxide,
from 6 to 10 percent, preferably from 7 to 9 percent,
and more preferably from 7.5 to 8.5 percent helium,
with the balance being argon. The percentages are in
volume percent. A carbon dioxide or helium
concentration in the shielding gas lower than about 6
percent or greater than about 10 percent may have a
deleterious effect on the weld quality.
[0020] In a preferred embodiment, the shielding gas
composition should contain about 8 percent helium,
about 8 percent carbon dioxide and the balance argon
with a flow of gas to the weld zone of about 35 to 50
cubic feet per hour. Fig. 2 and Fig. 3 show the impact
of varying the helium content on the quality attributes
of the weld. When welding coated steels, quality is
based mainly on three factors: porosity, spatter and
weld bead appearance. Porosity and spatter should be
CA 02536366 2006-02-17
WO 2005/018863 PCT/US2004/026625
_ 8 _
as low as possible. In Fig. 2 and Fig. 3, the higher
the number, the better the weld quality. Fig. 2 shows
little difference between a shielding gas composition
of argon, carbon dioxide (8 percent), and helium (5
percent) and a shielding gas composition of argon,
carbon dioxide (8 percent), and helium (8 percent),
except that the amount of porosity is much lower with
the shielding gas having the additional 3 percent
helium, i.e., the shielding gas composition of argon,
carbon dioxide (8 percent), and helium (8 percent).
Fig. 2 and Fig. 3 also show a large difference between
a shielding gas composition of argon, carbon dioxide (8
percent), and helium (8 percent) and a shielding gas
composition of argon, carbon dioxide (8 percent), and
helium (15 percent) as the porosity and spatter are
higher and the quality of the bead appearance is low
with the shielding gas having the additional 7 percent
helium, i.e., the shielding gas composition of argon,
carbon dioxide (8 percent), and helium (15 percent).
[0021] Referring to Fig. 1, the shielding gas
mixture useful with this invention may be made up
within gas mixer 22 which receives the component gases
from cylinders 24, 25 and 26. For example, cylinder 24
may contain argon, cylinder 25 may contain carbon
dioxide and cylinder 26 may contain helium. Any other
suitable gas storage container, such as a storage tank,
may also be employed in conjunction with this
invention. Gas mixer 22 can be any conventional gas
mixer which can be set to meter the appropriate gas
from each gas source to establish the gas mixture
useful in this invention. Alternatively, the gas
CA 02536366 2006-02-17
WO 2005/018863 PCT/US2004/026625
- 9 -
mixture of this invention may be supplied already mixed
from a single container.
(0022] The shielding gas mixture useful in this
invention is then passed through conduit means 6 to
torch 2 and is passed through space 27 between contact
tube 16 and torch cup 28 so that it forms a shroud for
shielding arc 4 from the ambient atmosphere.
(0023] The gas metal arc welding method and
shielding gas mixture of this invention enables the
attainment of high quality welds with excellent
appearance. This is particularly important in the
welding of coated steels where appearance is generally
an important factor. The preferred coated steels
useful in this invention include galvanized steel with
zinc coating weight of 60 g/m~2 to 90 g/m~2 and
galvannealed steel with zinc coating weight of 45 g/m~2
to 60g/m~2.
(0024] The gas metal arc welding method and
shielding gas mixture of this invention have also
enabled the attainment of high quality welds with
reduced defects in the v;~elding of coated steels. This
invention employs a combination of shielding gas, wire
type, metal transfer and process type. This
combination substantially improves the quality and
appearance of welds on coated steels. A major factor
in this benefit is the shielding gas composition
selected for use with the other method variables. The
improvements produced include fewer defects, e.g., less
spatter, reduced porosity, less zinc-fuming and burn-
off from the vicinity of the weld joint, and overall
better bead appearance. Productivity increases up to
15 percent or greater may be achieved due to the
CA 02536366 2006-02-17
WO 2005/018863 PCT/US2004/026625
- 10 -
decreased amount of post-weld clean up and rework. In
a preferred embodiment, the practice of the method of
this invention involves gas metal arc welding with
pulsed metal transfer, ari ER70S-3 solid wire, a
shielding gas composition of carbon dioxide (8
percent), helium (8 percent) and argon (balance), for
welding a coated steel base material.
[0025] Heretofore, the ability to achieve high
quality welds over a range of operating conditions and
deposition rates in gas metal arc welding required a
shielding gas mixture containing a high concentration
of helium or the presence of oxygen in conjunction with
helium carbon dioxide and argon. The shielding gas
mixtures of this invention enables excellent gas metal
arc welding utilizing metal transfer by various methods
without using either an expensive mixture containing a
high concentration of helium or a complex mixture which
includes oxygen.
[0026] Various modifications and variations of this
invention will be obvious to a worker skilled in the
art and it is to be understood that such modifications
and variations are to be included within the purview of
this application and the spirit and scope of the
claims.
