Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02556958 1997-05-26
AN IMPROVED GASKET FOR USE WITH
AN AIR BRAKE HOSE COUPLING MEMBER
This application is a divisional application of co-pending application
2,206,069,
filed May 26, 1997.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
Technical Field
The invention relates to a gasket for use in detachably connecting two similar
coupling members on the ends of air brake hoses for railroad cars to form an
airtight connection. More particularly, the invention relates to an improved
air brake
hose coupling member having improved sealing means that provide better
alignment and sealing during coupling with a similar member on an adjacent
railroad car. Specifically, the invention relates to an improved gasket
incorporating
a tamped entrance angle and a wide sealing surface for providing better
alignment
and sealing during coupling with another similar member.
Background Information
Railroad cars having pneumatic brake systems use flexible air hoses which
extend the length of the train by spanning between separate yet adjacent
railroad
cars. Typically, at least one flexible hose extends from the front to the back
of a
railroad car with a fluid connection branching off to the emergency brake
system
1
CA 02556958 1997-05-26
midway therebetween. A coupling member is attached to each end of each
flexible
hose for detachably connecting the hose sections of adjacent cars together
when
individual railroad cars are joined to form a unit train. These coupling
members
whether connected to another or not, are suspended from the end of the car and
hang a short distance above the ground or railroad tracks. Overall, these
couplings
are designed and manufactured to meet the requirements of the Association of
American Railroads and are generally similar, so as to be compatible and
interchangeable with those of other manufacturers.
As is well known in the art, these couplings are joined together by pulling
the
hoses from adjacent cars upward, pushing the sealing gaskets on the coupling
members at the end of each hose into aligned and abutting relationship, and
then
rotating the coupling members downward which interengages mating flanges and
lugs extending from the coupling members. If properly performed, this results
in a
sealed fluid passage between air hoses on adjacent railroad cars whereby the
air
pressure in the hose lines maintains the brakes of all of the individual cars
in an
°oft" position. Any significant reduction in air pressure within these
hose lines
actuates the brakes in all of the individual cars to an "on" or braking
position. If the
train were to derail, or cars were to accidentally separate, or if for any
other reason
the air was to leak resulting in decreased pressure then all of the cars go
into this
braking position. Thus, accidental separation of the coupling between two
sections
of air hose will apply the emergency car brakes, resulting in sudden stopping
of a
train with the subsequent delay, inconvenience and expense as well as chance
of
accidents, and therefor any accidental disconnection of the couplings needs to
be
avoided.
Clearly, each connection of adjacent coupling members is critical since.only
one leak stops the entire train. However in operation, the couplings are often
difficult to properly align. Improper alignment often either results in an
ineffective
(leaky) seal or no seal at all. However, in many cases the tolerances in the
couplings allow the downward rotational motion locking motion anyway even
though
2
CA 02556958 1997-05-26
the coupling members are misaligned. When two coupling members are misaligned
yet locked, the connection may or may not seal. When sealing does not occur,
the
brakes do not release thereby prohibiting movement of the train. These locked
brakes force a brakeman to inspect the connections to find the unsealed
connection, which once found can then be relocked in hopefully an aligned
manner.
This inspection and relocking is a time consuming event. (n addition, the
brakeman
may find that the seal has been damaged. In this case, the seal must also be
replaced prior to relocking.
An even more drastic scenario is where the misaligned coupling members
improperly seal. In this case, the improper seal may hold the pneumatic
pressure
for awhile or until sufficiently jarred such as during standard operation. If
the seal
is not capable of holding standard operational pressures of 60 to 90 p.s.i.,
and the
seal fails during operation then undesirable emergency braking occurs which
stops
the train. The failed coupling must be found, fixed or replaced, and recoupled
before the train can move. This is again a time consuming event.
In addition, even when alignment is proper, the sealing surfaces of the
gasket must be able to withstand upwards of 90 p.s.i. during operation. As is
well
known in the art, the seal must be sufficient to hold this pressure while not
inhibiting
the coupling member's ability to separate along the hose axis during a
standard
disconnect. Current seal designs sometimes fail in holding the pneumatic
pressure
resulting in these seals leaking either slowly or rapidly which releases the
pneumatic pressure which causes emergency brake activation.
Thus, a current problem exists surrounding alignment of the gaskets of two
adjacent coupling members which only if aligned seal properly and allow for
proper
connection and separation. In sum, it has been found that standard prior art
gaskets such as that shown in Fig. 8 are not conducive to proper alignment and
engagement as is required for necessary sealing of coupled air brake hose
coupling members at the standard air brake pressures of between 60 p.s.i. and
90
p.s.i. Overall, improper alignment of the gaskets causes poor or ineffective
sealing
3
CA 02556958 1997-05-26
due to gasket misalignment which results in a higher likelihood of uncoupling
of air
hose couplings due to misalignment of the gaskets, or poor sealing both of
which
result in too little pull apart resistance whereby said lack of separation
resistance
causes the air hose couplings to fall apart which immediately throws the
entire train
into an emergency brake application. All of this results in added costs and
time,
both of which are undesirable.
Thus, a need has existed for an improved air brake hose coupling member
which enables rapid connection of hose sections in the heretofore usual manner
without additional manipulations being required, which does not affect the
usual
rotational connection, separation and operation of such coupling members, and
which does not affect the usual axial separation and operation of such
coupling
members while preventing or considerably reducing premature uncoupling of the
attached members in an axial manner due to improper gasket alignment and/or
poor
sealing.
OBJECTIVES AND SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
Objectives of the invention include providing an improved air brake hose
coupling member which meets the requirements of the Association of American
Railroads or Society of Automotive Engineers and which is compatible or
interchangeable with existing coupling members being used.
It is a further object of the invention to provide an improved air brake hose
coupling member having a gasket that properly aligns with a corresponding
gasket
on a corresponding coupling member when coupled together.
A still further objective is to provide such an improved air brake hose
coupling member having a gasket with tamped, rounded, beveled or otherwise
reduced corner or entrance angles for allowing easier interaction between
corresponding gaskets when adjacent coupling members are coupled.
Another objective of the invention is to provide an improved air brake hose
4
CA 02556958 1997-05-26
coupling member that is designed to prohibit the air hose couplings from
coming
apart until sufficient force is supplied to disengage the gaskets where the
gaskets
in the improved invention supply sufficient pull apart resistance thereby
prohibiting
accidental pull apart which causes the air hose couplings to fall apart
thereby
immediately throwing the entire train into an emergency brake application.
A further objective is to provide an enlarged surface area on the gaskets of
air hose couplings so as to significantly increase the pull apart resistance.
Still other advantages and benefits of the invention will become apparent to
those skilled in the art upon a reading and understanding of the following
summary
and detailed description.
Accordingly, the present invention satisfies these and other objects.
Specifically, the present invention relates to an improved gasket for use with
an air
brake hose coupling member.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
A preferred embodiment of the invention, illustrative of the best mode in
which applicant has contemplated applying the principles, is set forth in the
following description and is shown in the drawings and is particularly and
distinctly
pointed out and set forth in the appended claims.
Fig. 1 is a perspective view of the improved gasket construction;
Fig. 2 is a side elevation view of the improved gasket of Fig. 1 mounted in
an end coupling of an air brake hose;
Fig. 3 is a plan view looking in the direction of Arrows 3-3, Fig. 2;
Fig. 4 is an enlarged fragmentary sectional view of the coupling of Fig. 2;
Fig. 5 is an enlarged sectional view of the gasket of Fig. 1;
Fig. 6 is a further enlarged fragmentary sectional view of a portion of the
gasket of Fig. 5;
Fig. 7 is a fragmentary sectional view similar to Fig. 6 of a modified
CA 02556958 1997-05-26
embodiment of the gasket; and
Fig. 8 is an enlarged sectional view of a prior art gasket.
Similar numerals refer to similar parts throughout the drawings.
DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT
The improved gasket for use with an air brake hose coupling member of the
present invention is indicated generally at 10, and is best shown in Figs. 1,
4 and
5, and its environment is best shown in Figs. 2-4. In use, two coupling
members
are coupled together to form a closed air passageway from one member to the
other thereby coupling hoses in series as is well known in the art. The
coupling
member may be any of the air brake coupling members known in the art, all of
which are similar in most respects to the coupling members shown in U.S. Pat.
Nos.
3,879,066 and 5,388,864, except that the present invention has the improved
gasket described below, which replaces the gaskets of these prior air coupling
members.
The preferred embodiment of gasket 10 of the present invention, as is best
shown in Figs. 1 and 5, and in enlarged detail in Fig. 6 and in enlarged
detail with
slight modification in Fig. 7, is a one-piece molded polymer that is generally
ring-
shaped with a hole 11 therein. Specifically, ring-shaped gasket 10 has a top
surface 12, a lip 13 extending upward from top surface 12, an annular inner
surface
14, an angled or beveled edge 15 extending from lip 13 to inner surface 14, a
bottom surface 16, a tamped or beveled edge 17 extending in a flared or
rounded
fashion from bottom surface 16, and an annular outer surface 18 with an
annular
groove 19 molded therein. Annular outer surface 18 specifically includes lower
annular outer surface 20 and upper annular outer surface 21, while groove 19
includes upper side wall 22, lower side wall 23, and a base 24.
The configuration of gasket 10 as described above defines three major parts
of the gasket, namely a head 30, a neck 31, and a flange 32. Specifically,
gasket
6
CA 02556958 1997-05-26
is configured with cylindrical neck 31 having one beveled edge 15 and with two
outward radial projections in head 30 and flange 32.
In design, gasket 10 is preferably molded such that top surface 12, lower
side wall 23, bottom surface 16, upper annular outer surface 21, lower annular
outer surface 20, base 24, and annular inner surface 14 are each substantially
planar. 'Top surface 12, lower side wall 23, and bottom surface 16 are in
parallel
planes, and similarly, upper annular outer surface 21, lower annular outer
surface
20, base 24, and annular inner surface 14 are each in planes parallel to each
other.
In contrast, lip 13 rises from planar top surface 12 and meets with beveled
edge 15.
Beveled edge 15 extends from lip 13 to annular inner surface 14 in a conical
manner with respect to a center axis extending through hole 11 in gasket 10
and
around which the gasket is uniformly formed. In addition, upper side wall 22
is
preferably not planar with lower side wall 23 and instead slopes closer to
lower side
wall 23 as upper side wall 22 extends radially inward toward central axis A.
Ramped edge 17 is also not planar with bottom surface 16 and instead slopes
closer to groove 19 as the tamped edge 17 extends radially outward toward the
central axis A resulting in a flange 32 of reduced thickness at its outermost
edge.
In accordance with the present invention, the novel and critical features of
gasket 10 include (1 ) formation of this flange 32 by extending the bottom
surface
16 out beyond the neck 31 as shown in Fig. 5 rather than having the bottom
surface
end at neck 31 as shown in the prior art of Fig. 8, and (2) angling of an
outermost
portion of the flange 32 to form this tamped edge 17 as shown in Fig. 5. The
flange
32 defines a~~large bottom surface thereby supplying significantly improved
holding
of gaskets in compression when abutted in a locked relationship during use as
described below. Flange 32 extends out from neck 31, and preferentially
extends
out from neck 31 to outer surface 21 of head 30 as indicated by distance B in
Fig.
6 or distance D in Fig. 7, or beyond outer surface 21 as is shown by distance
B plus
C in Fig. 6 or distance D plus E plus F in Fig. 7.
In addition to adding flange 32, the gasket also includes the tamped edge
7
CA 02556958 1997-05-26
17 which supplies a nonbinding or inhibiting edge on each gasket for assisting
in
alignment prior to locking of two coupling members as described below. This
tamped edge is any surface nonplanar with bottom surface 16 as is shown in two
select embodiments in Figs. 6 and 7. In the first embodiment as shown in Fig.
6,
vamped edge 17 is a generally planar surface that is a° out of plane
from bottom
surface 16. In the second embodiment as shown in Fig. 7, tamped edge 17
changes slope in its midsection such that a first portion of tamped edge 17
that is
adjacent bottom surface 16 is ~° out of plane from bottom surface 16
while a second
portion of tamped edge 17 that is adjacent lower annular outer surface 20
flares
even further and is Y°.out of plane from the first portion and thus
~3° + y° out of plane
from bottom surface 16.
In one embodiment, a is 5°, while (3 is 3° and y is 2°.
The angles disclosed
and the slope changing, stepping or lack thereof approach used to transition
from
bottom surface 16 to surface 20 are the best mode, however, the present
invention
contemplates that the tamped edge could be flared away from bottom surface 16
at any other angle or in any other stepped or slope changing manner such as
with
three different angles rather than one or two, or in a curved rather than a
planar
manner with or without multiple planes of differing slopes.
In one example, gasket 10 is designed and sized as follows. Hole 11 is
1.1875 inches wide. The diameter across gasket 10 at outer surface 21 is
nominally 1.812 inches and ranges from a minimum of 1.796 inches to a maximum
of 1.828 inches. The diameter across gasket 10 at base 24 in groove 19 is
nominally 1.5 inches and ranges from a minimum of 1.484 inches to a maximum of
1.515 inches. The diameter across gasket 10 at outer surface 20 is nominally
2.062
inches and ranges from a minimum of 2.046 inches to a maximum of 2.078 inches.
The diameter across the gasket 10 at lip 13 is nominally 1.398 inches and
ranges
from a minimum of 1.383 inches to a maximum of 1.413 inches. The height of
gasket 10 from bottom surface 16 to top surface 12 is nominally 0.343 inch and
ranges from a minimum of 0.341 inch to a maximum of 0.354 inch. The height of
8
CA 02556958 1997-05-26
gasket 10 from bottom surface 16 to lip 13 is nominally 0.382 inch and ranges
from
a minimum of 0.380 inch to a maximum of 0.393 inch. The height of gasket 10
along outer surface 18 from top surface 12 to sloped upper side wall 22 is
nominally
0.140 inches and ranges from a minimum of 0.135 inches to a maximum of 0.145
inches. The height of gasket 10 from top surface 12 to the intersection of
base 23
and upper side wall 22 is nominally 0.171 inch and ranges from a minimum of
0.166
inch to a maximum of 0.176 inch. The height of gasket 10 from lower side wall
23
to bottom surface 16 is nominally 0.064 inch and ranges from a minimum of
0.060
inch to a maximum of 0.067 inch. The height of gasket 10 along outer surface
20
from lower side wall 23 to vamped edge 17 is nominally 0.054 inch and ranges
from
a minimum of 0.047 inch to a maximum of 0.0531.
The result of the wide sealing surface as dimensioned in this example is a
sealing surface area of three to four times that of the prior art such as that
shown
in Fig. 8. Specifically, the surface area of the improved gasket of the
present
invention is approximately 2.2 to 2.3 in.Z based upon the above example. In
contrast, the same example without the improved wide sealing surface would
have
a width of the gasket across the bottom surface that is the same as the width
across
base 24 and would therefore have a surface area of 0.6 to 0.7 in.2. This
significant
increase in surface area results in vastly improved sealing.
Preferably gasket 10 is molded from an elastomeric polymer, although
gasket 10 may be molded from any material capable of forming a seal. In one
embodiment, the gasket is butadiene rubber. In any embodiment, the material
the
gasket is made of may include an ozone inhibitor. Furthermore, in the
preferred
embodiment, the gasket is a rubber gasket with an ozone inhibitor where the
rubber
is a softer rubber such as one having a Shore A hardness in the range of 60 to
70
durometer, and preferably 65 durometer. This hardness range provides a softer
rubber than the prior art (typically 70 to 80 Shore A hardness) thereby
providing
more supple in cold weather resulting in better sealing.
Gasket 10 is designed for use in air brake hose coupling members where
9
CA 02556958 1997-05-26
adjacent gaskets in to-be-coupled coupling members are compressed in an
abutting
arrangement against each other to form a seal capable of holding under
pneumatic
pressures ranging from 60 to 90 or more p.s.i. This gasket is designed for use
in any
coupling member for this use which includes an annular groove for receiving
the
gasket.
One coupling member 40 in which gasket 10 is usable is shown in Figs. 2-4,
although as indicated above, gasket 10 is usable with any coupling member that
employs compressed abutting and receives the gasket in an annular groove as
described below.
Coupling member 40 has a tubular neck 41 which is connected to a usual
flexible pneumatic pressure hose (not shown) of a railroad car braking system
and a
tubular body 42, as shown in Fig. 3. Tubular body 42 has a bore 43 which
terminates
at an inner coupling face 44 (Fig. 3) which is generally flat and has an
annular
configuration and is located on a generally circular body portion 45 of body
42. The
plane of coupling face 44 is generally parallel with the axis of the bore
extending
through body 42 and neck 41, as can be seen in Fig. 2.
The front portion of tubular body 42 terminates in an arcuate flanged body
portion 46 which has a curved front surface and a curved flat top surface. An
arcuate
flange, generally indicated at 47, projects outwardly from body 42 and extends
in a
generally circular fashion generally concentric with and spaced below the
arcuate
front surface. Flange 47 also includes an arcuate-shaped end locking lug 48
which
projects outwardly from body 42 and terminates in a raised rounded lip 49. Lip
49
projects outwardly from lug 48 in a direction away from coupling face 44, as
shown in
Fig. 2.
A stop member is formed on body 42 and projects outwardly from the top
CA 02556958 1997-05-26
portion thereof, and is formed with a notch therein. The stop and notch limit
the
rotational movement of a pair of mated coupling members, that is a pair of
coupling members where the gaskets are in compressed abutting relationship.
An L-shaped annular flange, indicated generally at 52 (Fig. 1 ), extends
laterally 'outward from body 42 and has a leg 53 which extends forwardly in a
generally parallel relationship with body 42. Flange 52 cooperates with
locking lug
48 of the mating coupling member, and vice versa, to couple a pair of members
together. Flange 52 includes an arcuate lip 54 which projects toward coupling
face
44 and interlocks with lip 49 of flange 47 of a corresponding coupling member
when
the two coupling members are rotatably connected together.
An annular recess 55 (Fig. 4) is formed in body 42 about bore 43 adjacent
coupling face 44, for receiving sealing gasket 10 therein. Recess 55 is either
a
square cut groove where opposing sides are parallel and radially extend from
the
bore axis, or alternatively is a sloped cut groove that includes at least one
side that
converges toward the other as the sides extend radially outward (as is shown
in Fig.
4).
In operation, the gasket, when installed; flexes, bends and twists
sufficiently
such that head 30 is forced into bore 43 which is substantially the same size
as
neck 31. once gasket 10 is inserted far enough into bore 43 that head 30
aligns
with annular recess 55, head 30 snuggle seats in recess 55 as shown in Fig. 4
thereby providing a tight seal between gasket 10 and body 42 that is
sufficient to
stand at least 90 p.s.i.
In accordance with the invention, gasket 10, when seated in recess 55,
extends out of bore 43 and flange 32 extends radially away from bore 43
outwardly
over face 44, as shown in Fig. 4. Flange 32 provides a large sealing surface
60 for
improved sealing with an abutted gasket. In addition, flange 32 which extends
out
over face 44 has extra support when abutted against another gasket due to
lower
side wall 23 resting against rigid face 44. Finally, the vamped edge 17
provides for
11
CA 02556958 1997-05-26
better alignment when sealing with another gasket on another coupling member.
When two adjacent train cars have been coupled, the air brake hose lines
of the adjacent cars must also be coupled. Hose sections (not shown) which
connect to neck 41 extend outwardly from the ends of adjacent railroad cars,
and
are connected to the appropriate air lines and associated brake equipment
mounted
on the cars. The coupling member 40 is attached to the end of each of the
hoses
and is located generally under the mechanical coupler mechanism of the
railroad
car so that a trainman can easily grasp members 40 which are supported by a
separate chain or other device connected to the train car to provide support.
In a
usual air brake hose-coupling procedure, a trainman will grasp a pair of
adjacent
coupling members 40, one in each hand, and bend the hose ends upwardly and
toward each other so that members 40 are in an adjacent position. The coupling
faces 44 are then moved together, bringing gaskets 10 into an abutting
compressed
relationship with respect to each other. The tamped edge 17 assists in this
alignment process by providing a gentle surface that is tamped, beveled,
sloped,
or otherwise not planar with bottom surface 16 so as to allow the gaskets to
be
slowly forced into abutting engagement as well as alignment.
Once the gaskets of adjacent coupling members are abutted, then the
coupling members are rotated downward which interengages mating flanges and
lugs extending from the coupling members. This holds the gaskets in a tight
abutting relationship capable of not leaking at 90 or more p.s.i. The large
sealing
surface 60 on gasket 10 assures that the abutted gaskets will not leak at the
90 or
more p.s.i. This assurance comes from the additional surface area contact
provide
by two large sealing surfaces being in compressed abutting relationship.
Tests have been performed to compare gaskets made under the standard
prior art design as shown in Fig. 8 in comparison to the improved gasket of
Figs.
1, and 4-7. In one test arrangement, the prior art gasket and improved gasket
10
were dimensioned as indicated above in the example except that the prior art
gasket did not include (1 ) flange 32 or (2) any beveled edges on flange 32 or
the
12
CA 02556958 1997-05-26
bottom surface 16, and in addition (3) had a lesser neck thickness than the
nominal
0.156 inch. Thus, in general both gaskets had 1.1875 inches wide center holes
with 1.812 nominal overall diameter and so forth.
The results of these tests include an increased surface area based upon the
addition of flange 32. This increased surface area is of the magnitude of 200%
or
more. The additional surface area supplies additional resistance to pull apart
between two abutting gaskets. All of the improvements resulting in an
increased
pull apart resistance of approximately four times. Specifically, the gasket
with the
increased surface area has been found to resist pull apart up to approximately
1400
foot-pounds at 90 p.s.i. in comparison to approximately 400 to 600 foot-pounds
at
90 p.s.i. in the prior art.
Overall, the improvements of the present invention includes (1 ) adding a
flange 32 which extends outward from the gasket and provides a large surface
area,
(2) beveling the edge of the bottom surface to allow improvement alignment,
and
(3) increasing the neck thickness, all of which function to supply significant
additional resistance to pulling apart of two abutting gaskets. This increased
resistance is of the magnitude of 2 to 3 times more force required to separate
two
mated couplings (force of approximately 1400 foot-pounds is needed rather than
the previously required 400 to 600 foot-pounds). This increased resistance and
improved alignment allows a softer rubber to be used, specifically a rubber
with a
Shore A hardness of less than 70 durometer and in the range of 60 to 70 in
comparison to the prior art at 70 to 80. This softer rubber improves cold
weather
sealing because the gasket is more supple.
Accordingly, the improved gasket for use with an air brake hose coupling
member is simplified, provides an effective, safe, inexpensive, and efficient
device
which achieves all the enumerated objectives, provides for eliminating
difficulties
encountered with prior devices, and solves problems and obtains new results in
the
art.
In the foregoing description, certain terms have been used for brevity,
13
CA 02556958 1997-05-26
clearness and understanding; but no unnecessary limitations are to be implied
therefrom beyond the requirement of the prior art, because such terms are used
for
descriptive purposes and are intended to be broadly construed.
Moreover, the description and illustration of the invention is by way of
example, and the scope of the invention is not limited to the exact details
shown or
described.
Having now described the features, discoveries and principles of the
invention, the manner in which the improved gasket for use with an air brake
hose
coupling member is constructed and used, the characteristics of the
construction,
and the advantageous, new and useful results obtained; the new and useful
structures, devices, elements, arrangements, parts and combinations, are set
forth
in the appended claims.
14
