Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR THE DEPOSITION, DETECTION AND
IDENTIFICATION OF THREAT AGENTS
RELATED APPLICATIONS
This application claims the benefit of U.S. Patent Application No. 60/651,375
filed
February 9, 2005 entitled Development of a Biological Raman Electrostatic
Detector
Identifier (BioREDI) Sensor.
FIELD OF DISCLOSURE
This application relates generally to systems and methods for detecting and
identifying hazardous agents.
BACKGROUND
Deployment of threat agents poses significant threats to both human and
economic
heath. This threat is compounded by a limited ability to detect deployment of
the agents.
Prior art detection strategies rely on separate instrumentation for detection
and
identification of the threat agent. Conventional means of detecting airborne
matter
include relatively non-specific optical and spectroscopic methods, including
laser
scattering, ultraviolet laser induced fluorescence (UV-LIF) and laser induced
breakdown
spectroscopy (LIBS). Conventional means to identify a threat agent include wet
chemical
methods or spectroscopic methods. Reagent-based identification of biological
threat
agents includes methods such as specific antibodies, genetic markers and
propagation in
culture. While highly specific, these identification methods are time-
consuming, labor-
intensive and costly. Spectroscopic means, for identification, provide an
alternative to
reagent-based identification methods and include mass spectrometry, infrared
spectroscopy, Raman spectroscopy, and imaging spectrometry. Mass spectrometry
is
limited by sensitivity to background interference. Infrared spectroscopy
exhibits low
1
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
sensitivity. Raman spectroscopy can be implemented in several different
configurations,
including normal Raman spectroscopy, UV resonance Raman spectroscopy, surface
enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS) and non-linear Raman spectroscopy. While
normal Raman spectroscopy has demonstrated adequate sensitivity and
specificity for
detection of airborne matter, other forms of Raman spectroscopy suffer from
inadequate
sensitivity, specificity or signature robustness. Prior art imaging
spectroscopy is limited
by the need to switch from a broad band light source, for optical imaging, to
a
substantially monochromatic light source for spectroscopic imaging. This
results in a
signification time period between detection and identification during which
time the
sample may degrade.
The present disclosure describes a reagent free sensor using Raman
spectroscopy
and Raman imaging spectroscopy to detect and identify a sample simultaneous
with
sample deposition. The system and methods of the present disclosure may
operate in
either a trigger mode or an identification mode. The present disclosure
describes an
approach that reduces system and method complexity by using a single
illumination
source.
SUMMARY
The present disclosure provides a system and method for depositing a sample of
a
threat agent onto a substrate. The threat agent is detected and identified
substantially
coincident in time with the deposition of the sample of the threat agent onto
the substrate.
Optionally, a fiber array spectral translator that converts a non-linear field
of view of a
portion of the substrate containing the sample to a curvilinear map coupled to
an entrance
slit of a spectrometer is used to collect spatially-resolved Raman spectra
suitable for
identifying the threat agent.
2
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
In one embodiment, the threat agent deposited on the substrate is illuminated,
via a
single illumination source, with a plurality of photons to thereby produce
elastic scattered
photons and Raman scattered photons. Identifying the threat agent may be
performed by
analyzing the elastic scattered photons, produced by the threat agent on the
substrate,
using elastic scattering imaging to form an image of the threat agent, and
analyzing the
Raman scattered photons, produced by the threat agent on the substrate, using
Raman
spectroscopy. A Raman spectrum may be compared to at least one reference Raman
library spectrum to identify the threat agent. Analysis of the Raman scattered
photons
may further include generating Raman spectra anywhere within the Raman shift
range of
about 0 cm-1 to about 3500 cm 1 at a spectral resolution less than 20 cm 1.
Analysis of
the Raman scattered photons may further include generating multiple spatially
independent image channels simultaneously within a Raman shift of about 0 cm-1
to about
.
3500 cm 1 at a full spectral resolution less than 20 cm-1
In one embodiment, analysis of the elastic scattered photons produced by the
threat
agent includes automatically focusing the image of the threat agent on the
substrate using
one of the following: a CMOS detector, a CCD detector or a high frame rate
digital
detector, in combination with a feedback control mechanism. Analysis of the
Raman
scattered photons also may include passing the Raman scattered photons through
a device
selected from the group consisting of a tunable filter, a band pass filter, a
liquid crystal
tunable filter, an interferometer, an acousto optic tunable filter and a
dispersive optical
device, to produce the plurality of spatially resolved Raman spectra. Analysis
of the
Raman scattered photons may also include passing the Raman scattered photons
through
one of the following: a line scan spectrometer; a multi-point spectrometer; a
single point
spectrometer; and area imaging spectrometer spectrometer.
3
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
In one embodiment, the elastic scattered photons and the Raman scattered
photons
are collected using an optical system, wherein said illumination source is
located along an
optical path, and said substrate is located along a plane wherein the optical
path or the
deposition apparatus is at an angle other than 90 with respect to the
substrate plane.
In one embodiment, the system and method for depositing and identifying the
threat agent operates in a trigger mode that detects a presence or absence of
the threat
agent, and an identification mode that identifies the threat agent. The
trigger mode may
use a trigger time period and the identification mode may use an
identification time
period, and wherein the trigger time period is less than the identification
time period. In
one embodiment, the identification mode is initiated upon detecting the
presence of the
threat agent in the trigger mode. An additional amount of the threat agent may
be
accumulated during operation in the identification mode. In one embodiment,
the
identification mode may be initiated substantially simultaneous upon detecting
the present
of the threat agent in the trigger mode.
Depositing the threat agent onto the substrate may be accomplished using
ultrasonic deposition, electro spray and inertial impaction of the threat
agent onto the
substrate. In one embodiment, depositing the sample of the threat agent onto
the substrate
includes depositing at least 50 particles onto the substrate. Depositing the
sample of the
threat agent onto the substrate may include collecting air from a confined
environment or
an outside environment.
The threat agent may be hazardous agent comprising a bacterium, virus,
protozoan, biological toxin, fungus, a chemical agent, a radiological material
and an
explosive material and/or may be an airborne particulate matter or aerosol
matter.
4
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
In accordance with a further aspect, the present disclosure provides a system
and
method for depositing a sample of a threat agent onto a substrate. A single
illumination
source illuminates the threat agent deposited on the substrate with a
plurality of photons to
thereby produce elastic scattered photons and Raman scattered photons. The
threat agent
on the substrate is identified. The system and method operate in a trigger
mode that
detects the presence or absence of the threat agent, and an identification
mode that
identifies the threat agent. Optionally, a fiber array spectral translator
that converts a non-
linear field of view of a portion of the substrate containing the sample to a
curvilinear map
coupled to an entrance slit of a spectrometer which is used for identifying
the threat agent.
Deposition of the sample of the threat agent onto the substrate may occur
prior to
identification of the threat agent on the substrate. A background level of the
substrate
may be identified before deposition of the sample of the threat agent onto the
substrate. In
this embodiment, identifying the threat agent on the substrate occurs
substantially
coincident in time with or after the depositing of the sample of the threat
agent onto the
substrate.
In accordance with a further aspect, the present disclosure provides a system
and
method for depositing a sample of a threat agent onto a substrate. The
deposition of the
threat agent onto the substrate is visually observed by analyzing the elastic
scattered
photons produced by the threat agent using elastic scatter imaging to form an
image of the
threat agent on the substrate, wherein depositing of the threat agent is
substantially
coincident in time with visually observing of the deposition of the threat
agent. Analyzing
the elastic scattered photons produced by the threat agent may include
automatically
focusing the image of the threat agent on the substrate using a CMOS detector,
a CCD
detector or a high frame rate digital detector, in combination with a feedback
control
5
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
mechanism. The elastic scattered photons may be collected via an optical
system, wherein
the optical system is positioned relative to the substrate and moved relative
to the position
of the substrate to focus the image of the threat agent on the substrate.
Image contrast in
the image of the threat agent on the substrate may be improved by removing an
interference pattern of the illumination source via mode scrambling and frame
averaging.
Visually observing deposition of the threat agent onto the substrate is
performed without a
spectrometer.
In accordance with a still further aspect, the present disclosure provides a
system
and method for depositing a sample of a threat agent onto a substrate. A
single
illumination source illuminates the threat agent on the substrate with a
plurality of photons
to thereby produce elastic scattered photons. Deposition of the threat agent
onto the
substrate is visually observed by analyzing the elastic scattered photons
produced by the
threat agent using elastic scatter imaging to form an image of the threat
agent on the
substrate.
In accordance with a still further aspect, the present disclosure provides a
system
and method for identifying a sample of a threat agent that is deposited onto a
substrate. A
first optical collection device collects at least one of the following:
elastic scattered light
produced by the threat agent, and Raman scattered light produced by the threat
agent. A
second optical collection device collects Raman scattered light produced by
the threat
agent, wherein the second optical collection device comprises a two
dimensional non-
linear array of optical fibers drawn into a one dimensional fiber stack that
converts a non-
linear field of view into a curvilinear map, wherein the curvilinear fiber
stack is coupled to
an entrance slit of a Raman spectrometer. The threat agent deposited on the
substrate is
identified using Raman spectroscopy.
6
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
In accordance with yet a further aspect, the present disclosure provides a
system
and method for identifying a sample of a threat agent that is deposited onto a
substrate.
The threat agent is illuminated via an illumination source with a plurality of
photons to
thereby produce photons transmitted, reflected, emitted or Raman scattered by
the threat
agent. An optical system collects elastic scatter photons produced by the
threat agent and
at least one of photons transmitted, reflected, emitted or Raman scattered by
the threat
agent, wherein said illumination source is located along an optical path, and
said substrate
is located along a plane wherein the optical path or the deposition apparatus
is at an angle
other than 90 with respect to the substrate plane. The depth of field of the
optical system
is extended by passing at least one of the following through a phase mask:
elastic scattered
photons, and photons transmitted, reflected, emitted or Raman scattered by the
threat
agent.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
The accompanying drawings, which are included to provide further
understanding of the disclosure and are incorporated in and constitute a part
of this
specification, illustrate embodiments of the disclosure and, together with the
description,
serve to explain the principles of the disclosure.
In the drawings:
Figure 1 illustrates a system used in connection with the present disclosure;
Figure 2 illustrates a device used in the system of this disclosure;
Figures 3A and 3B illustrate an elastic scatter image produced by the
system and methods of the present disclosure;
7
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
Figure 4A, 4B, 4C and 4D illustrate Raman imaging analysis using the
system and methods of the present disclosure; and
Figure 5 illustrates the estimated sensitivity of detection and identification
using the system and methods of the present disclosure.
DESCRIPTION OF THE EMBODIMENTS
Reference will now be made in detail to the embodiments of the present
disclosure, examples of which are illustrated in the accompanying drawings.
Wherever
possible, the same reference numbers will be used throughout the drawings to
refer to the
same or like parts.
Figure 1 illustrates system 100 which may be used to carry out the methods of
the
present disclosure. System 100 includes a deposition means 101 and a detector
means
113. The deposition means may include an air intake port 104, which is open to
the
surrounding environment 102, a collector 106, a concentrator 108, a sample
109, a
deposition substrate 110 (e.g., a compact disc), substrate plane 111 and a
substrate
positioning mechanism 112. The identification means 113 comprises a first
optical
system 114, an optional phase mask 115, a beam splitter 116, a second optical
system 117,
an optical path 119, an elastic scattering image detector 118, an illumination
source 122, a
dichroic mirror 120, a mirror 124, a spectroscopic detector 126, spectrometer
127 and a
processor 128 having a spectral library 130.
As illustrated in Figure 1, the sample is collected from the surrounding
environment 102 and then concentrated. The sample may comprise airborne
particulate
matter or aerosol matter. The surrounding environment 102 includes a confined
environment and an outside environment. The confined environment includes a
building,
8
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
storage container, plane, train or other mass transportation vehicle and a
human
respiratory system. To collect air from a confined environment, system 100 is
connected
to the air conditioning or heating system of a building, vehicle or storage
container that
circulates air to the confined environment.
The sample collected and identified by system 100 includes a threat agent. The
threat agent comprises a hazardous agent and includes a bacterium, virus,
protozoan,
biological toxin, fungus, a chemical agent, a radiological material and an
explosive
material. The bacterium includes Anthrax, Bacillus, Streptococcus,
Staphylococcus,
Escherichia, Erwinia, and Pseudomonas. The virus includes a pathogenic virus
selected
from smallpox, influenza and E. bola viruses. The biological toxin includes
ricin. The
hazardous substance is any substance that may cause disease, injury,
discomfort, pain, or
death to an animal such as a human.
The sample may be collected and concentrated using a variety of devices. In
one
embodiment, the sample is collected using an aerosol collector in combination
with a
virtual impactor which eliminates air and concentrates the sample. In second
embodiment, the sample is collected using an aerosol collector in combination
with a
liquid concentrator. This collection and concentration process takes place on
the order of
a fraction of a second to minutes depending on the velocity of the collecting
air. The
concentrated sample is subsequently deposited onto the surface of the
substrate. The
sample may be deposited onto the surface of the substrate using inertial
impaction,
ultrasonic deposition, and electro spray deposition.
In one embodiment, ultrasonic deposition is used to deposit the sample onto
the
substrate. In one embodiment, a wet walled cyclone collector may be used to
collect
aerosol and particulate matter. The analyte-containing fluid, which can be
connected to a
9
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
reservoir, including a water storage tank, can be used to provide analyte-
containing fluid
to the ultrasonic nozzle liquid inlet port. The ultrasonic nozzle may also
contain a
compressed air inlet to focus the deposition of the liquid input onto the
substrate surface.
The ultrasonic spray device may be used to perform a plurality of spray
applications over
the same spatial location to increase the analyte concentration in a desired
field of view.
In one embodiment, ultrasonic spray devices such those manufactured by Sono-
Tek
Corporation of Milton, NY may be used for implementing the present disclosure.
The deposition device deposits a plurality of sample particles 109 onto the
substrate 110. In one embodiment, at least 1 sample particle is deposited onto
the
substrate. In another embodiment, at least 50 sample particles are deposited
onto the
substrate. In another embodiment, at least about 50 - 250 sample particles are
deposited
onto the substrate. In another embodiment, at least about 250 - 2500 sample
particles are
deposited onto the substrate. In another embodiment, at least about 2500 -
10,000 sample
particles are deposited onto the substrate. In another embodiment, at least
about 10,000 -
100,000 sample particles are deposited onto the substrate. In another
embodiment, at least
about 100,000-1,000,000 sample particles are deposited onto the substrate.
With further reference to Figure 1, system 100 uses a single illumination
source
122, directed along an optical path 119, to illuminate the sample with a
plurality of
photons to thereby produce elastic scattered photons and photons transmitted,
reflected,
emitted or Raman scattered by the sample. In one embodiment, the illumination
source
illuminates the sample with a plurality of photons to produce elastic
scattered photons and
Raman scattered photons. The illumination source includes a low power laser.
Low
power lasers manufactured by Coherent Inc, Santa Clara, CA or the Spectra-
Physics
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
Division of Newport Inc., Mountain View, CA are suitable. In one embodiment,
the
optical path 119 of the illumination source 122 is at an angle other than 90
from the plane
111 defined by the two dimensional substrate 110. In another embodiment the
deposition
means 101 is at an angle other than 90 from the plane 111 defined by the two
dimensional substrate 110.
With further reference to Figure 1, system 100 has a first optical system 114.
In
one embodiment, the optical system 114, collects elastic scattered photons,
produced by
the sample. In a second embodiment, the optical system 114, collects elastic
scattered
photons and Raman scattered photons produced by the sample. In a third
embodiment,
the optical systeni 114, collects elastic scattered photons, and at least one
of photons
transmitted, reflected, emitted or Raman scattered produced by the sample.
With further reference to Figure 1, system 100 may include a phase mask 115.
The phase mask 115 will be used to extend the depth of field of the optic
system by
passing through the phase mask 115 at least one of elastic scattered photons
and photons
transmitted, reflected, emitted or Raman scattered produced by the sample.
One embodiment of the system 100 may include a second optical system, a fiber
array spectral translator ("FAST"). With reference to Figure 2, the FAST
system 200
includes a first lens 206, an illumination source 208, a first filter 210, a
second filter 212 a
second lens 214, a first end of a fiber bundle 216 and a second end of the
fiber bundle 218
which is connected to a spectrometer 220. The first lens 206 acts as a
collecting lens
which focuses the illumination source onto the sample 204 and collects all
photons, other
than elastic scattered photons, at wavelengths other than laser wavelength;
this includes
photons emitted or Raman scattered by the sample. Photons transmitted or
reflected by
the sample will have the same wavelength as the laser and will be blocked by
filter
11
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
element 212. Lens 206 collimates the photons produced by the sample projecting
the
photons into infinity. The second lens 214 is used in combination with the
first lens 206
to form images at the final focal plane of the second lens 214. The first end
of the fiber
bundle 216 is comprised of a two dimensional non-linear array of fiber
bundles. The
second end of the fiber bundle 218 is comprised of a curvilinear array of
fiber bundles
wherein curvilinear may include a straight line as well as a curved line
configurations.
In one embodiment of the present disclosure, system 100 utilizes an elastic
scatter
imaging detector 118 to visually observe deposition and form an image of the
sample on
the substrate by analyzing elastic scattered photons produced by the sample.
The image is
used to assess sample deposition density, morphology and focusing. In one
embodiment,
the elastic scatter imaging, to visually observe deposition, is used in the
absence of an
imaging spectrometer. In a second embodiment, system 100 employs an elastic
scatter
imaging detector 118 in combination with a spectrometer 127 for identification
of the
sample. In one embodiment, the elastic scatter imaging detection and
spectrometric
identification are performed simultaneously, using a single low power
illumination source
for identification of the sample.
With further reference to Figure 1, the elastic scatter imaging detector 118
is
comprised of one of the following of a CMOS detector, a CCD detector and a
high frame
rate digital detector. The system uses the detector 118 in combination with a
feedback
and control mechanism to automatically focus the sample under the collection
optic. In
one embodiment, a light gathering objective of the optical system 114 is moved
relative to
the position of the substrate to focus the image of the sample on the
substrate. The
12
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
spectrometer 127 could employ detectors such as CCDs, CMOS, CIDs (charge
injection
device), diode arrays, photomultiplier tube (PMT), PMT array, avalanche
photodiode.
In one embodiment of the present disclosure, the elastic scatter image of the
sample is collected on the detector and mode scrambling and frame averaging
are used to
improve the image contrast by removing the interference pattern of the
illumination
source producing the final image. Figures 3A and 3B illustrate an elastic
scatter image of
human epithelial cells obtained by one embodiment of the system of the present
disclosure. A low power laser source illuminated the sample of human
epithelial cells to
generate the elastic scatter image of the sample which produces a high cross
section
elastic scatter image signal. However, the elastic scatter image is typically
masked by the
presence of a laser interference pattern. The laser interference pattern is
removed by mode
scrambling and frame averaging. As illustrated in Figure 3A, the human
epithelial cells
are not readily observable due to the presence of a laser interference (i.e.
speckle) pattern
masking the presence of the inherently low contrast cellular object within the
field of view
of the 20X objective employed to capture the image. As illustrated in Figure
3B, the cell
is readily observable by using a fiber optic to scramble the modes traversing
the fiber
optic, which effectively makes the monochromatic laser light incoherent. A
plurality of
images is time averaged and the cellular image contrast is enhanced by
effective
suppression of the coherent laser speckle pattern. To obtain the image in
Figure 3B, ten
images were each collected at 30 frames per second.
In another embodiment of the present disclosure, the elastic scatter image of
the
sample is obtained by collecting the scattered photons using an optical
system, wherein
the optical path 119 of the illumination source 122 or the deposition means
101 is at an
angle other than 90 from the plane 111 defined by the two dimensional
substrate 110. In
13
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
one embodiment, this is achieved by operating the objective, which collects
the elastic
scattered photons, at 60 off axis from the plane of the substrate. This
embodiment
produces a finite rectangular region of interest in focus but this region of
interest will be
smaller than the objective field of view. In order to compensate for the out
of focus
regions of interest, extended depth of field ("EDF") optical compensation may
be used to
image over the full field of view of the microscope objective. To implement
EDF, a phase
mask will be located in the elastic scatter image collection optical path to
modify the
incoherent optical system in such a way that the point spread function ("PSF")
is
insensitive to misfocus, while forming an optical transfer function ("OTF")
that has no
regions of zero values within its pass band. Because the OTF has no regions of
zeros,
digital processing can be used to "restore" the sampled intermediate image.
Further,
because the OTF is less sensitive to misfocus, the same digital processing
restores the
image for all values of misfocus. This combined optical/digital systems
produces a PSF
that is comparable to that of the diffraction limited PSF, but over a far
larger region of
focus. Typically, an 8X increase in the DOF is achievable.
In another embodiment, system 100 utilizes a spectrometer 127 in combination
with an elastic scatter imaging detector 118 to identify the sample. The
elastic scattered
photons, produced by the threat agent, are analyzed using elastic scatter
imaging to
produce an image of the sample on the substrate. In one embodiment, a
spectrometer is
used to analyze at least one of photons transmitted, reflected, emitted or
Raman scattered
by the sample, using spectroscopy. In another embodiment, a spectrometer is
used to
analyze at least one of photons transmitted, reflected, emitted or Raman
scattered by the
sample, using spectroscopic imaging to produce a plurality of spatially
resolved spectra.
The spectrometer may operate in one or more of the following spectral ranges:
the
14
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
ultraviolet (UV), visible, near infrared, and mid-infrared. The spectrometer
may operate
to collect images based on the following detection modalities: UV, visible,
near-IR or
mid-IR absorption imaging in either transmission or reflectance modes; Raman
scatter
imaging; fluorescence; photoluminescence; chemiluminescence; and
electroluminescence
imaging. The spectrometer may operate in conjunction with polarized light
microscopy
and/or differential interference contrast imaging. Photons transmitted,
reflected, emitted
or Raman scattered by the sample, are passed through a filter to produce a
plurality of
spatially resolved spectra. The filter may be a tunable filter, a band pass
filter, a liquid
crystal tunable filter, an interferometer, an acousto optic tunable filter or
a dispersive
optical device. The photons transmitted, reflected, emitted or Raman scattered
may be
passed through a spectrometer which may be a line scan spectrometer; a multi-
point
spectrometer; a single point scan spectrometer or area imaging spectrometer.
In one
embodiment, the spectrometer may be used in an imaging mode to produce a
plurality of
spatially resolved spectra arising from the sample volume illuminated by the
illumination
source. In another embodiment, the spectrometer may be used in a non-imaging
mode by
summing all of the spectra collected in the imaging mode to form a composite
spectrum
arising from the sample volume illuminated by the illumination source. In
another
embodiment, the spectrometer may be used in a non-imaging mode to collect a
composite
spectrum arising from the sample volume illuminated by the illumination
source.
In one embodiment, the spectrometer includes a Raman imaging spectrometer that
analyzes Raman scattered photons produced by the sample. In one embodiment,
Raman
imaging spectrometer generates Raman spectra anywhere within the range of
Raman shift
of 0-3500 cm 1 at a full spectral resolution of less than 20 cm"1. In one
embodiment, the
Raman imaging spectrometer simultaneously captures multiple spatially
independent
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
spectra, up to 1000, within the range of Raman shift of 0-3500 cm-1 at a full
spectral
resolution of less than 20 cm-1. In one embodiment, the spectrometer comprises
a Raman
line imaging spectrometer. In another embodiment, the spectrometer comprises a
dispersive Raman line imaging spectrometer.
In one embodiment, the sample is identified using a spectrometer in
combination
with a fiber array spectral translator. With reference to Figure 4, a
plurality of Raman
spectra were collected on a Chemlmage FALCON II Raman microscope from a
physical
mixture of a sample comprised of ovalbumin ("Ova") and diesel soot ("DS") The
spatially
resolved Raman spectra collected from the sample were mapped to the entrance
slit of the
FALCON II's dispersive Raman spectrometer, using a coherent fiber optic bundle
(FAST). Using FAST, a fiber the circular field of view of the image is
converted to a
curvilinear shape that is mapped to the entrance slit of the spectrometer. The
benefits of
this approach include rapid collection of the full Raman image spectral
hypercube without
the need for spatial or spectral scanning mechanisms. Because multiple Raman
spectra
can be captured within a wide field of view without the need to reposition the
laser,
fluorescence photo bleaching time can be minimized. In addition, the spatially
resolved
Raman spectra map the local heterogeneity of the sample mixture which enables
target
testing based spectral unmixing. As a result, sample mixtures are analyzed in
real time if
sufficient single to noise reduction is achieved. Figure 4A illustrates the
optical image of
Ova/DS under 100X objective magnification. Figure 4B illustrates a dispersive
Raman
spectrum representing the average response of the mixture sample, and Figure
4C
illustrates seven spatially resolved dispersive Raman spectra collected from
the sample
using FAST. Figure 4D illustrates the dispersive Raman spectral image
collected at the
16
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
focal plane of the spectrometer. The seven independent spatial channels images
along the
y axis and the Raman spectrum along the x axis of the focal plane are clearly
visible.
In yet another embodiment, system 100 will utilize a phase mask 115 to extend
the
depth of field of the optical systern. In this embodiment, a sample 109 will
be deposited
onto a substrate 110. The sample will be illuminated via an illumination
source 112 along
an optical path 119 with a plurality of photons producing elastic scattered
photons and at
least one of photons transmitted, reflected, emitted or Raman scattered by the
sample.
The sample may comprise a threat agent. An optical system will collect the
elastic scatter
photons produced by the sample and at least one of photons transmitted,
reflected, emitted
or Raman scattered by the threat agent. The illumination source 122 will be
located along
the optical path 119, and said substrate 110 will be located along a plane 111
wherein the
optical path 119 is at an angle other than 90 with respect to the substrate
plane I 11. In
another embodiment, the deposition means 101 will be located at an angle other
than 90
with respect to the substrate plane 111. The depth of field of the optical
system will be
extended by passing at least one of the following through the phase mask 115:
elastic
scattered photons, and photons transmitted, reflected, emitted or Raman
scattered by the
threat agent. The sample will be identified based at least in part on the
output of the phase
mask 115, by (1) analyzing the elastic scattered photons using elastic
scattering imaging
118 to form an image of the sample; and (2) analyzing at least one of photons
transmitted,
reflected, emitted or Raman scattered by the sample using spectroscopic
imaging 126 to
produce a plurality of spatially resolved spectra. The photons transmitted,
reflected,
emitted or Raman scattered will be passed through a filter to produce a
plurality of
spatially resolved spectra. The sample deposition and identification will
occur:
substantially coincident in time with each other; deposition prior to
identification;
17
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
background identification followed by deposition which may be substantially
coincident
or prior to identification.
The method of the present disclosure provides for deposition, visual
observation
and identification of the sample. In one embodiment, the sample is visually
observed and
identified substantially coincident in time with the deposition of the sample
onto the
surface of the substrate. The deposition process takes place over a fraction
of a second
from the deposition of the first particle to the deposition of a particle
density sufficient to
generate a measurable signal which permits the detection and identification of
the sample,
via the imaging spectrometer. The system of this disclosure has demonstrated
that a
measurable signal, sufficient to visually observe and identify the sample via
Raman
imaging spectroscopy, may be observed in as short as 10 seconds after being
illuminated
by the illumination source. In one embodiment, the particle density, required
for
observation and identification, is 20 sample particles deposited on the
substrate, in the
detector field of view for a five minute identification mode. In another
embodiment, the
sufficient particle density may be as small as 1 particle of a sample
deposited on the
substrate. In the case of bioaerosols, the sample occurs as individual spores
or cells or
aggregates of cells. A single cell generates a measurable Raman signal wherein
the time
period for the Raman process, to generate a measurable signal, is initiated
within
femtoseconds after being illuminated by the illumination source. Therefore,
instantaneous
deposition, observation and identification of a single cell are envisioned.
System 100 is used in a method of the present disclosure provides for
deposition
and identification of a threat agent. In a preferred embodiment,.the particle
sample
deposition is substantially coincident with identification of the particle
sample. For the
purposes of this application, the term substantially coincident means that
sample
18
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
deposition occurs on approximately the same time period as sample
identification, ideally
without the requirement that the sample substrate be re-positioned relative to
the
deposition apparatus, or detection apparatus during the deposition and
identification
processes. In one embodiment, the time between deposition of analyte on the
substrate
and identification is as short as 10 seconds, under conditions that the sample
is illuminated
continuously by the illumination source. In another embodiment, the particle
sample
identification occurs after sample deposition. In another embodiment, a
background level
measurement of the sample substrate is made followed by sample deposition
which occurs
substantially coincident or prior to identification of the sample.
In another embodiment, system 100 is used in a method of the present
disclosure
provides for deposition and visual observation of a threat agent. In a
preferred
embodiment, the particle sample deposition is substantially coincident with
visual
observation of the particle sample. For the purposes of this application, the
term
substantially coincident means that sample deposition occurs on approximately
the same
time period as sample observation, ideally without the requirement that the
sample
substrate be re-positioned relative to the deposition apparatus, or
detection apparatus during the deposition and observation processes. In one
embodiment,
the time between deposition of analyte on the substrate and observation is as
short as 10
seconds, under conditions that the sample is illuminated continuously by the
illumination
source. In another embodiment, the particle sample observation occurs after
sample
deposition. In another embodiment, a background level measurement of the
sample
substrate is made followed by sample deposition which occurs substantially
coincident or
prior to observation of the sample.
19
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
System 100 may operate in a trigger mode or an identification mode. The
trigger
mode detects the presence of a threat agent and the absence of a threat agent.
The trigger
mode has a trigger time period. The trigger time period may range from a
fraction of a
second to about 60 seconds. At high concentrations of a threat agent, the
trigger time
period may be substantially instantaneous. A one-minute or less trigger cycle
time allows
for sampling the environment dynamically to monitor the onset of threats and
to manage
highly variable background conditions.
The identification mode identifies the threat agent and has an identification
time
period. In one embodiment, the trigger time period is less than the
identification time
period. In another embodiment, the identification mode is initiated upon
detecting the
present of the threat agent in the trigger mode. In another embodiment, the
identification
mode is initiated substantially simultaneously upon detecting the present of
the threat
agent in the trigger mode. In another embodiment, an additional amount of
sample is
accumulated while the system is operating in the identification mode.
If the trigger mode is initiated, system 100 changes over to the confirmation
mode
under the system software. In the confirmation mode, collection and deposition
of
additional particles continues during a continuous 5 minutes interrogation of
the sample
by the imaging system. No movement of the sample or alignment of sample is
needed;
the transition from trigger to confirmation is instantaneous. During the
confirmation time,
all particles are examined due to the continuous collection.
System 100 also includes a processor 128 that determines the mode of operation
and the identification of the sample. The processor employs different
algorithm when
system 100 is operation in the trigger mode or confirmation mode. In one
embodiment,
the algorithm includes constant false alarm rate algorithms. Other algorithms
include
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
target testing, a Bayesian approach and a matched filter approach based on
Mahalanobis
Distance. Approaches to sample identification are disclosed in: U.S. Patent
Application
Serial No. 10/812,233, filed March 29, 2004 entitled Method for Identifying
Components
of a Spectral Analysis; PCT International Appl. No. PCT/US05/013036 filed July
14,
2005 entitled Method and Apparatus for Multimodal Detection; and U.S.
Provisional
Patent Appl. No. 60/688,812, filed July 9, 2005, entitled Forensic Integrated
Search
Technology (FIST) each of which is incorporated herein in its entirety.
To identify the sample, the plurality of spatially resolved spectra, produced
by the
imaging spectrometer, are compared to at least one reference library spectrum
to identify
the threat agent. In one embodiment, the plurality of spatially resolved Raman
spectra are
compared to at least one reference Raman library spectrum to identify the
threat agent.
In one embodiment, processor 128 utilizes a target testing for unmixing
signatures
and searching the measured mixture spectra relative to the pure component
signature
library in an automated fashion. Target testing based spectral unmixing
compares mixture
spectra against pure component library spectra by characterizing the mixture
space using
principal component analysis ("PCA"); ranking the library spectra by
quantifying their
goodness of fit into the mixture data space; and determining by target testing
the number
and identity of the pure spectra present in the mixture sample.
With further reference to Figure 4, the sample was classified as diesel soot
using a
Euclidian Distance (ED) matched filter identifier algorithm. The ED algorithm
assumes
samples are pure components, which was an inaccurate assumption. When the
spatially
resolved dispersive Raman spectra are analyzed using a target testing spectral
unmixing
algorithm, the mixture sample was correctly classified as being comprised of
Ova and
21
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
carbonaceous material, a material class comprised of DS and humic acid,
because of their
Raman spectral similarity.
The target testing algorithm includes the following general steps:
(i) Use PCA on-the mixture spectra to characterize the mixture data space.
(ii) Calculate the angle of projection of each library spectrum with the
mixture
data space. A dot product of a vector with an n-dimensional space. A dot
product of 1.0 represents a perfect fit into the data space.
(iii) Rank all library spectra by the angle of projection into the mixture
data
space.
(iv) Consider all permutations of the top matches as ranked by angle.
Determine the n most likely candidate pure components. Generate all
possible m component solutions, where m varies from 1 to n and is the
number of library spectra in a given solution.
(v) For each candidate solution calculate the correlation coefficient;
calculate
projected library spectra for each set of m component library spectra (given
the known mixture spectra and the known library spectra). Calculate the
correlation coefficient of each projected library spectrum with the actual
library spectrum. The correlation coefficient used as the selection criterion
is the square root of the sum of squares of the dot products for each
member of a given m component solution.
(vi) The most probable solution is the one with the highest correlation
coefficient.
The target testing algorithm requires a Raman signature library that supports
differentiation between threat agents, near neighbors, and clutter independent
of agent
22
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
growth or preparation conditions and sample history. Raman spectra of threat
agents
include certain spectral bands that are highly sensitive to growth conditions
and others that
are relatively insensitive to growth conditions. The detection and
identification
algorithms will focus on spectral bands that maximize agent discrimination,
but minimize
sensitivity to growth conditions. This can minimize signature library
dependence on
unwanted biological contributions to variability.
With further reference to Figure 1, system 100 includes a deposition substrate
110
and substrate positioning mechanism 112. The substrate 110 provides for the
deposition
of a plurality of samples at predetermined sites. The substrate 110 includes a
compact
disk ("CD") configuration or any similar circular or non-circular,
substantially flat surface
of metal or non-metal. The substrate 110 is to enable autonomous focusing of
the Raman
laser on the substrate. In one embodiment, the substrate includes a standard
audio CD
dimensions for the substrate allowing for collection of approximately 1,800
samples on a
standard 120 mm diameter CD. System 100 also includes storage unit capable of
holding
25 substrates to support 30 days worth of sampling, 43,800 samples collected
in 30 days
@ 1,800 samples per substrate. The concept is for the substrate-disks to be
supplied in a
cartridge that can be easily swapped out after 30 days of operation. The
storage system
includes a marking technique to log the archived samples for conditions at the
point of
data collection e.g., time, date, sensor settings, and for sample relocation.
The substrate
positioning device 112 includes a motion stage having two degrees of freedom,
directional
linear motion and rotationally variable. The motion of the substrate
positioning device
112 generates sample deposits in spiral tracks, circular concentric tracks, or
in linear
tracks. The substrates are stored in a storage system designed to protect the
resilience of
23
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
the deposition spots to mechanical shock/vibration, humidity, and other
physicochemical
agents that might degrade their stability.
EXAMPLES
Figure 5 illustrates the estimated sensitivity of Raman imaging spectroscopy
detection technology. The plot compares system 100 estimated signal to noise
("SNR")
vs. bio-aerosol concentration for both trigger and confirmation detection
modes. The
estimations were made using a Chemlmage Raman system performance model.
As shown in Figure 5, increasing the time for detection ("Td") results in
improved
SNR, which enables improved detection sensitivity. In trigger detection mode,
we
estimate a LOD of -800 particles per liter (PPL) cells is achievable. In
confirmation
detection mode, a LOD of 100 PPL cells is achievable. LOD is defined as the
minimum
bio-threat concentration detectable, in a reproducible manner, at a
probability of detection
("Pd") greater than 90%, at the specified Td and a defined probability of
false alarm
("Pfa")= The acceptable false alarm rate is determined by operational
requirements.
However, we have assumed that in trigger detection mode (Td - 30 secs, Pd
>90%), an
acceptable level of false alarms is 5/day (Pfa -1.7x103). In confirmation mode
(Td - 300
secs Pd >90%), the required Pfa is 1/month (Pfa - 1.1x104). The calibration
curves shown
in Figure 5 are generated using a Raman detection SNR performance model.
The present disclosure may be embodied in other specific forms without
departing
from the spirit or essential attributes of the disclosure. Accordingly,
reference should be
made to the appended claims, rather than the foregoing specification, as
indicated the
scope of the disclosure. Although the foregoing description is directed to the
preferred
embodiments of the disclosure, it is noted that other variations and
modification will be
24
CA 02597287 2007-08-08
WO 2007/092009 PCT/US2006/004561
apparent to those skilled in the art, and may be made without departing from
the spirit or
scope of the disclosure.
