Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02643036 2008-08-19
WO 2007/100966
PCT/US2007/061819
CERAMIC/METALLIC DENTAL ABUTMENT
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
1. Field of the Invention.
[0001] The present invention relates to dental prosthetics and, in
particular, to a
ceramic/metallic abutment for use with a dental implant as part of a
prosthodontic restoration.
2. Description of the Related Art.
[0002] Dental implants are commonly used as anchoring members in
prosthodontic
restorations to provide prosthetic teeth at one or more edentulous sites in a
patient's dentition
at which the patient's original natural teeth have been lost or damaged.
Typically, known
implant systems include a dental implant made from a suitable biocompatible
material, such
as titanium. The dental implant is typically threaded into a bore which is
drilled into the
patient's mandible or maxilla at the edentulous site. The implant provides an
anchoring
member for a dental abutment, which in turn provides an interface between the
implant and a
dental restoration. The restoration is typically a porcelain crown fashioned
according to
known methods to replicate the shape of the tooth being replaced.
[0003] Many current dental implant surgeries are performed in two stages.
In the
initial or first stage, an incision is made in the patient's gingiva at an
edentulous side, and a
bore is drilled into the patient's mandible or maxilla at the edentulous site,
followed by
threading or impacting a dental implant into the bore using a suitable driver.
Thereafter, a
cap is fitted onto the implant to close the abutment coupling structure of the
implant, and the
gingiva is sutured over the implant. Over a period of several months, the
patient's jaw bone
grows around the implant to securely anchor the implant in the surrounding
bone, a process
known as osseointegration.
[0004] In a second stage of the procedure following osseointegration, the
dentist
surgically reopens the gingiva at the implant site and secures an abutment and
optionally, a
temporary prosthesis or temporary healing member, to the implant. Then, a
suitable
permanent prosthesis or crown is fashioned, such as from one or more
impressions taken of
the abutment and the surrounding gingival tissue and dentition. In the final
stage, the
temporary prosthesis or healing member is removed and replaced with the
permanent
prosthesis, which is attached to the abutment with cement or with a fastener,
for example.
CA 02643036 2008-08-19
WO 2007/100966
PCT/US2007/061819
[0005] Typically, abutments are made from a biocompatible metal, such as
titanium,
or from a ceramic material. Advantages of titanium abutments include
structural strength and
relative ease of manufacture. However, if recession of the gingival tissue
occurs around the
implant and abutment after implantation, there is the potential that a portion
of the metal of
the abutment beneath the crown may become exposed, such that the grey color of
the
titanium is visible, which is aesthetically disadvantageous.
[0006] Ceramic abutments are harder than titanium abutments, and have the
additional advantage of providing a light, tooth-like color such that, in the
event of gingival
recession, the light color of any exposed portions of the abutment
substantially match the
color of the crown and appear tooth-like to preserve aesthetics.
[0007] What is needed is an abutment which is an improvement over the
foregoing.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
[0008] The present invention provides a ceramic/metallic dental abutment
for use
with an implant, the abutment generally including a ceramic body portion
having a base
region, a transgingival region, and a supragingival region. The base region
includes an anti-
rotational implant interface, such as an external polygonal fitting, for
engaging a cooperating
internal polygonal fitting of an implant to prevent relative rotation between
the abutment and
the implant. The ceramic abutment body portion additionally includes a metal
implant
contact portion for contacting the implant and providing a load-bearing, metal-
on-metal
interface between the abutment and the implant.
[0009] In one embodiment, the implant contact portion is provided in the
form of an
annular metal ring made of titanium, for example, which is attached to the
abutment via a
press-fit connection, an adhesive connection, a shrink-fit connection, a
brazed connection, or
in another suitable manner. The implant contact portion is disposed
substantially at the
interface between the base region and the transgingival region of the
abutment, and is
dimensioned such that, when the abutment is connected to the implant, the
implant contact
portion is substantially entirely contained within the outer periphery of the
open proximal end
of the implant. Therefore, after attachment of the abutment to the implant,
the implant
contact portion is not visible and does not contact soft tissue surrounding
the abutment.
[0010] In one embodiment, the proximal end of the implant includes an
annular
chamfer disposed at an oblique angle with respect to the longitudinal axis of
the implant and
abutment, and the implant contact portion of the abutment includes a contact
surface disposed
at a cooperating angle for engagement with the implant chamfer. The internal
polygonal
2
CA 02643036 2013-07-15
fitting of the implant may be greater in length than the external polygonal
fitting of the
abutment such that, upon receipt of the external polygonal abutment fitting
into the internal
polygonal implant fitting, relative rotation between the abutment and implant
is prevented
while axial loads from the abutment, such as occlusal and/or mastication
loads, for example,
are transferred to the implant only through the implant contact portion for
improved
resistance to wear.
[0011] In one form thereof, the present invention provides a dental
abutment,
including a ceramic body portion defining a longitudinal axis, and including a
base region
with an anti-rotational implant interface, a transgingival region, and a
supragingival region; a
bore extending through the body portion along the longitudinal axis; and a
metal implant
contact portion attached to the body portion and disposed adjacent the implant
interface.
[00121 In another form thereof, the present invention provides a dental
abutment,
including a ceramic body portion having a longitudinal axis, a bore extending
through the
body portion along the longitudinal axis, and an anti-rotational implant
interface; and metal
implant contact means attached to the body portion for axial load-bearing
contact with an
implant.
100131 In a further form thereof, the present invention provides, in
combination, a
dental implant, including an externally threaded body having a distal end and
a proximal end;
a bore extending into the proximal end, the bore including a threaded portion
and a first anti-
rotational interface; and a dental abutment, including a ceramic body portion
including a
second anti-rotational interface cooperable with the first anti-rotational
interface of the
implant whereby relative rotation between the abutment and the implant is
prevented; and a
metal contact portion abuttable with the proximal end of the implant.
[0013.11 According to one aspect of the present invention there is provided
in
combination a dental implant, comprising: an externally threaded body having a
distal end
and a proximal end, the proximal end including a first anti-rotational
interface and a threaded
portion; a dental abutment, comprising: a ceramic body portion defining a
longitudinal axis,
and including a base with a second anti-rotational interface cooperable with
the first anti-
rotational interface of the implant whereby relative rotation between the
abutment and the
implant is prevented; a metal contact portion that is other than an anti-
rotational interface and
comprising at least two transversely spaced portions relative to the
longitudinal axis, the base
extending directly between the at least two transversely spaced portions for
extending toward
3
CA 02643036 2013-07-15
the implant, the metal contact portion being abuttable with the proximal end
of the implant;
and a screw configured for threadedly connecting the dental implant to the
dental abutment
and configured for engaging a screw seating surface on the dental abutment,
wherein the
implant includes a chamfer disposed at an oblique angle with respect to the
axis; and wherein
the metal contact portion includes a contact surface configured to engage the
chamfer, and an
inner portion disposed radially inward from the contact surface and extending
over the
chamfer so that a space is maintained between the metal contact portion and
the chamfer, the
ceramic body being substantially longitudinally supported at the chamfer.
[0013.2] According to a further aspect of the present invention there is
provided a
dental device generally defining a longitudinal axis and comprising a dental
implant having a
coronal end forming a coronal opening with a chamfer surface extending at an
oblique angle
relative to the longitudinal axis; and an abutment for attachment to the
coronal end of the
implant, the abutment comprising: a ceramic body forming an anti-rotational
connection with
the implant; and a metal contact portion that is other than an anti-rotational
connection and
having a contact surface for engaging the implant and a lower surface disposed
radially
inward from the contact surface; the lower surface extending generally at the
oblique angle
and generally parallel to the chamfer surface; the lower surface being
disposed to directly
face the chamfer surface while maintaining a space between the lower surface
and the
chamfer surface; wherein the metal contact portion is a ring with an outer
portion extending
substantially perpendicular to the longitudinal axis and forming the contact
surface, the metal
contact portion further comprising an annular conical wall extending apically
as the conical
wall extends radially inward from the outer portion, wherein the conical wall
forms the lower
surface.
[0013.3] According to another aspect of the present invention there is
provided a
dental abutment configured for connection to a dental implant, comprising a
ceramic body
portion having a base region, a coronal region, a transgingival region
disposed between the
base and coronal regions, and a notch in an external surface of the ceramic
body portion
disposed proximate an intersection of the base region and the transgingival
region having an
annular shelf extending radially outwardly from the base region, the notch
having an annular
rim extending upwardly from the annular shelf, and an annular base wall
extending radially
outwardly from an upper end of the annular rim opposite the annular shelf; and
a metal
contact portion in the form of an annular ring made of metal and received in
the notch of the
ceramic body portion to engage the dental implant so that all axial loads are
transferred to the
3a
CA 02643036 2013-07-15
dental implant only via the metal contact portion, the metal contact portion
having an annular
inner surface facing and engaging the annular rim, an annular top surface
facing and
engaging the annular base wall and an outer contact surface having a conical
portion disposed
at an oblique angle with respect to a longitudinal axis defined by the ceramic
body portion to
match an angle of a chamfer of the dental implant.
10013.41 According to a still further aspect of the present invention there
is provided a
dental abutment configured for connection to a dental implant, comprising a
ceramic body
portion having a base region, a coronal region, a transgingival region
disposed between the
base and coronal regions, and a notch in an external surface of the ceramic
body portion
disposed proximate an intersection of the base region and the transgingival
region having an
annular shelf extending radially outwardly from the base region, the notch
having an annular
rim extending upwardly from the annular shelf, and an annular base wall
extending radially
outwardly from an upper end of the annular rim opposite the annular shelf; and
a metal
contact portion in the form of an annular ring being made of metal and being
received in the
notch of the ceramic body to engage the dental implant so that all axial loads
are transferred
to the dental implant only via the metal contact portion, the metal contact
portion having an
annular inner surface facing and engaging the annular rim, an annular top
surface facing and
engaging the annular base wall, and an outer contact surface having a conical
portion
generally extending at an oblique angle relative to a longitudinal axis
defined by the ceramic
body portion, and a flat outer end surface extending radially outward from the
conical
portion.
[0013.51 According to one aspect of the present invention there is provided
a dental
abutment configured for connection to a dental implant, comprising a ceramic
body portion
having a base region, a coronal region, a transgingival region disposed
between the base and
coronal regions, and a notch in an external surface of the ceramic body
portion disposed
proximate an intersection of the base region and the transgingival region
having an annular
shelf extending radially outwardly from the base region, the notch having an
annular rim
extending upwardly from the annular shelf, and an annular base wall extending
radially
outwardly from an upper end of the annular rim opposite the annular shelf; and
a metal
contact portion in the form of an annular ring being made of metal and being
mounted on the
annular rim of the notch, the metal contact portion having an outer rim
portion having an
apical outer end surface and a corona( top surface extending parallel to the
apical outer end
3b
CA 02643036 2013-07-15
surface, and a conical portion extending apically from the apical outer end
surface of the
outer rim portion.
[0013.6] According to a further aspect of the present invention there is
provided a
dental abutment configured for connection to a dental implant, the dental
abutment
comprising a ceramic body portion including: a notch surface forming a notch;
and an apical
ceramic base portion shaped for engaging the dental implant in an anti-
rotational connection;
and a metal contact portion made of metal and disposed on the ceramic body
portion, the
metal contact portion being configured to engage the dental implant, the metal
contact
portion including an inner conical portion extending inwardly as it extends
apically, the metal
contact portion including an outer rim portion extending radially outward from
the inner
conical portion, wherein the notch of the ceramic body portion is configured
to receive the
metal contact portion.
[0013.7] According to yet another aspect of the present invention there is
provided a
dental abutment configured for connection to a dental implant, the dental
abutment
comprising a ceramic body portion including a longitudinal axis and a notch
surface forming
a notch; and a metal contact portion being made of metal and being disposed on
the ceramic
body, the metal contact portion being configured to engage the dental implant,
the metal
contact portion including an inner portion extending at an oblique angle
relative to the
longitudinal axis, the metal contact portion including a flat outer portion
extending radially
outwardly from the inner portion, wherein the notch of the ceramic body
portion is
configured to receive the metal contact portion, and wherein, with the metal
contact portion
received within the notch, the notch surface and the inner portion are
separated by a space.
[0013.8] According to a still further aspect of the present invention there
is provided a
dental abutment configured for connection to a dental implant, the dental
abutment
comprising a ceramic body portion including a notch surface forming a notch;
and a metal
contact portion being made of metal and being mounted on the ceramic body
portion, the
metal contact portion including an outer rim portion including an apical
surface and a coronal
surface extending parallel to the apical surface, the metal contact portion
including an inner
portion extending apically from the apical surface of the outer rim portion,
wherein the notch
of the ceramic body portion is configured to receive the metal contact
portion, and wherein,
with the metal contact portion received within the notch, the notch surface
and the inner
portion are separated by a space.
3c
CA 02643036 2013-07-15
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[00141 The above-mentioned and other features and advantages of this
invention, and
the manner of attaining them, will become more apparent and the invention
itself will be
better understood by reference to the following description of embodiments of
the invention
taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, wherein:
[00151 Fig. 1 is a perspective, interproximal view of a ceramic/metallic
abutment in
accordance with the present invention;
[00161 Fig. 2A is a sectional view of the abutment of Fig. 1;
[00171 Fig. 2B is a fragmentary view of a portion of Fig. 2A;
3d
CA 02643036 2008-08-19
WO 2007/100966
PCT/US2007/061819
[0018] Fig. 3 is a sectional, exploded view showing the abutment
together with an
implant and an abutment screw;
[0019] Fig. 4 is a sectional view of the implant, abutment, and abutment
screw of Fig.
3, with the implant implanted within a jawbone and a crown secured to the
abutment;
[0020] Fig. 5 is a sectional view of an angled abutment according to a
further
embodiment; and
[0021] Fig. 6 is an enlarged fragmentary view of a portion of an
abutment according
to another embodiment.
[0022] Corresponding reference characters indicate corresponding parts
throughout
the several views. The exemplifications set out herein illustrate preferred
embodiments of the
invention, and such exemplifications are not to be construed as limiting the
scope of the
invention any manner.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0023] =
Referring first to Figs. 1, 2A, and 2B, a ceramic/metallic dental abutment 10
according to the present invention is shown, which may be used with a dental
implant 12,
such as that shown in Figs. 3 and 4 and described below, to provide a
prosthetic tooth at an
edentulous site in a patient's dentition at which a natural tooth has been
lost or damaged. In
Fig. 1, an interproximal view of abutment 10 is shown, which includes a facial
side 14 and an
opposing lingual side 16, as well as a mesial side 18 and an opposing distal
side (not visible
in Fig. 1). Abutment 10 also generally includes a base region 20 for
interfacing with implant
12, an emergence profile region or transgingival region 22 which extends
through soft
gingival tissue, and a coronal region or supragingival region 24 extending
superiorly of
transgingival region 22 to which a prosthetic tooth or crown 26 may be
attached, as shown in
Fig. 4.
[0024] Abutment
10 includes a body portion 28 made of a suitable ceramic material,
such as aluminum oxide or zirconium oxide, for example, and body portion 28
additionally
includes an implant contact portion 30, described below, which may be made of
a suitable
biocompatible metal, such as titanium, for example. As shown in Fig. 2A, body
portion 28 of
abutment 10 includes a central bore 32 therethrough extending along the
longitudinal axis L1-
L1 of abutment 10, with bore 32 including step 34 for abutting engagement by
the head of an
abutment screw to secure abutment 10 to implant 12 in the manner described
below.
Although transgingival region 22 and supragingival region 24 of abutment 10
extend
4
CA 02643036 2008-08-19
WO 2007/100966
PCT/US2007/061819
substantially along the direction of longitudinal axis L1-L1 in the embodiment
shown in Figs.
1-4, in other embodiments, transgingival region 22 and/or supragingival region
24 of
abutment 10 may be angled away from bore 32 and longitudinal axis L1-L1 as
needed to
conform to the anatomical orientation of the tooth being replaced.
[0025] For example, referring to Fig. 5, an angled abutment 90 is shown
which,
except as described below, is substantially identical to abutment 10, and the
same reference
numerals are used to designate identical features therebetween. In abutment
90, central bore
92 thereof is disposed along central longitudinal axis L1-L1 of abutment 90,
while
supragingival region 94 of abutment 90 is oriented or disposed along an axis
L2-L2 which
angled with respect to central bore 94 and longitudinal axis L1-L1.
[0026] Base region 20 of abutment 10 includes an implant interface,
shown herein as
an external polygonal fitting 36 having a hexagonal shape. In other
embodiments, abutment
could include an internal polygonal fitting and/or a polygonal fitting which
includes more
or less than six sides. Referring additionally to Fig. 2B, at its upper end
adjacent
transgingival region 22, polygonal fitting 36 terminates at shelf 38 adjacent
a notch 40
disposed substantially at the transition of base region 20 and transgingival
region 22, with
notch 40 including annular rim 42 and annular base wall 44 within which
implant contact
portion 30 is fitted, as described below.
[0027] Referring to Fig. 1, transgingival region 22 of abutment 10
includes concave
surface 46 extending toward margin shoulder 48 of transgingival region 22 on
facial side 14
of abutment 10, and another concave surface 50 extending toward margin
shoulder 48 on
lingual side 16 of abutment 10. Margin shoulder 48 is disposed substantially
at the gingival
or gum line, is contoured to follow the gingival line based on the anatomy of
the tooth being
replaced, and includes concave recesses 52 on each of its sides which merge
into the outer
profile of supragingival region 24.
[0028] Referring to Figs. 1, 2A, and 2B, abutment body portion 28
additionally
includes an implant contact portion 30, shown herein in the form of an annular
metal ring, for
example. Implant contact portion 30 may be made of substantially the same
material as
implant 12, such as a suitable biocompatible metal, for example, titanium. As
best shown in
Fig. 2B, implant contact portion 30 generally includes annular inner surface
54 and annular
top surface 56 disposed against rim 42 and base wall 44 of notch 40 of
abutment body portion
28, respectively, as well as an implant contact surface 58 disposed at an
oblique angle with
5
CA 02643036 2008-08-19
WO 2007/100966 PCT/US2007/061819
respect to longitudinal axis L1-L1 of abutment 10, which surface contacts
implant 12 in the
manner described below.
[0029] Implant contact portion 30 may be attached to abutment body
portion 28 via a
press-fit connection, in which implant contact portion 30 is pressed with
force onto rim 42
and against base wall 44 within notch 40 to firmly retain same on body portion
28 of
abutment 10; an adhesive connection, in which a suitable adhesive or cement is
applied
between notch 40 and implant contact portion 30 which, when cured, firmly
secures implant
contact portion 30 to abutment body portion 28 within notch 40; a shrink-fit
connection, in
which implant contact portion 30 is heated, pressed onto rim 42 against base
wall 44 within
notch 40, and is then cooled to shrink the diameter of implant contact portion
30 slightly such
that same is firmly retained to abutment body portion 28; or a brazed
connection, in which
implant contact portion 30 is pressed around rim 42 against base wall 44
within notch 40 and
is then heat brazed to body portion 28.
[0030] Referring to Figs. 3 and 4, implant 12 includes a threaded body
15 which is
implanted into a tapped bore in the jawbone 60 (Fig. 4) of a patient according
to known
surgical techniques. After implant 12 is allowed to osseointegrate within
jawbone 60,
abutment 10 is initially seated on implant 12 by inserting external polygonal
fitting 36 of
abutment 10 into an internal polygonal fitting 62 of implant 12. Also, when
abutment 10 is
seated on implant 12, implant contact portion 30 of abutment 10 engages an
internal annular
chamfer 64 at the proximal end 17 of implant 12. Implant contact surface 58 of
implant
contact portion 30 of abutment 10 and chamfer 64 of implant 12 are
complementary angled at
an oblique angle relative to longitudinal axis L1-L1 of abutment 10 and
implant 12.
[0031] As may be seen in Fig. 4, external polygonal fitting 36 of
abutment 10 is
slightly shorter along the direction of longitudinal axis L1-L1 of abutment 10
and implant 12
than internal polygonal fitting 60 of implant 12, such that an axial clearance
space 66 is
provided within internal polygonal fitting 62 of implant 12 distally of
external polygonal
fitting 36 of abutment 10. In this manner, the engagement between external
polygonal fitting
36 of abutment 10 and internal polygonal fitting 60 of implant 12 prevents
rotation of
abutment 10 with respect to implant 12 without supporting the weight of
abutment 10 and
crown 26 or bearing loads along the direction of longitudinal axis L1-L1 of
abutment 10.
Rather, the metal-on-metal contact between implant contact portion 30 of
abutment 10 and
chamfer 64 of implant 12 supports the weight of abutment 10 and crown 26, as
well as loads
imposed upon abutment 10 and crown 26 along or divergent from the direction of
6
CA 02643036 2008-08-19
WO 2007/100966 PCT/US2007/061819
longitudinal axis L1-L1of abutment 10, such as occlusal and/or mastication
loads, for
example.
[0032] An abutment screw 68, shown in Fig. 3, is provided for securing
abutment 10
to implant 12, and generally includes head 70 with instrument engagement
structure such as
an internal polygonal fitting 71, for example, as well as shank portion 74
extending from
head 70 and having threads 76 thereon distally of head 70. In use, abutment
screw 68 is
inserted through central bore 32 of abutment 10, and threads 76 of abutment
screw 68 are
threaded into internally threaded region 78 of implant 12 with head 70 of
abutment screw 68
initially seating against step 34 within internal bore 32 of abutment 10.
[0033] Thereafter, further tightening of abutment screw 68 presses head
70 thereof
against seat 34 to firmly engage abutment 10 to implant 12 and, more
specifically, to firmly
press implant contact portion 30 of abutment 10 into engagement with chamfer
64 of implant
12, such that the loads imposed via abutment screw 68 along the direction of
longitudinal axis
L1-Li of abutment 10 are transferred to implant 12 directly through implant
contact portion
30. The firm engagement between implant contact portion 30 of abutment 10 and
chamfer 64
of implant 12 minimizes micromotion between abutment 10 and implant 12.
[0034] After abutment screw 68 is tightened, abutment 10 is securely
retained to
implant 12 via the engagement of implant contact portion 30 of abutment 10
with chamfer 64
of implant 12, wherein a small gap may be present between external polygonal
fitting 36 of
abutment 10 and internal polygonal fitting 60 of implant 12 such that direct
contact between
the ceramic material of external polygonal fitting 36 of abutment 10 and the
metal of internal
polygonal fitting 60 of implant 12 is minimized. Advantageously, the metal-on-
metal contact
between implant contact portion 30 and implant 12 provides increased
resistance to wear
therebetween, due to the similarity or identity of the materials of implant
contact portion 30
and implant 12.
[0035] After abutment 10 is secured to implant 12 in the manner described
above,
crown 26 may be attached to supragingival region 24 of abutment 10 via cement,
for
example, to complete the restoration. Advantageously, as can be seen in Figs.
3 and 4,
implant contact portion 30 of abutment 10 is disposed substantially entirely
within the open
proximal end 17 of implant 12 such that implant contact portion 30 is not
visible externally of
the prosthetic and, in the event of recession of gingival tissue 80 around
transgingival region
22 of abutment 10, implant contact portion 30 will not be visible. Further,
receipt of implant
7
CA 02643036 2013-07-15
contact portion 30 substantially entirely within the open proximal end 17 of
implant 12 as
shown in Fig. 4 prevents the metal of implant contact portion 30 from
contacting the soft
gingival tissue 80 around abutment 10 and implant 12.
[0036] As shown in part in Figs. 1 and 2B, ceramic body portion 28 and/or
implant
contact portion 20, in the area of base region 20 and/or transgingival region
22 of abutment
10, may be coated with a thin coating 82 of gold or other metallic or non-
metallic coating,
such as by electroplating or sputtering techniques, for example, such as for
providing a light,
tooth-like coloring for aesthetics.
[0037] Referring to Fig. 6, a portion of an abutment 100 according to
another
embodiment is shown which, except as described below, is identical to abutment
10
described above, and the same reference numerals are used to indicate
identical or
substantially identical features therebetween. Abutment 100 includes contact
portion 102
similar to contact portion 30 described above, and which may be attached to
abutment 100 in
the same manner as contact portion 30 is attached to abutment 10. Contact
portion 102
includes an annular outer end surface 104 dimensioned to seat on a proximal,
outer annular
rim 106 of implant 12, which a small clearance space 108 present between
contact portion
102 and chamfer 64 of implant 12, wherein load are transferred from abutment
100 to implant
12 via outer end surface 104 of contact portion 102 to the proximal, outer
annular rim 106 of
implant 12.
[0038] The scope of the claims should not be limited by the preferred
embodiments
set forth in the examples, but should be given the broadest interpretation
consistent with the
description as a whole.
8
