Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02668810 2011-03-11
-1
TITLE: PHOTOELASTIC LAYER WITH
INTEGRATED POLARIZER
TECHNICAL FIELD
[001 ] This invention relates to the field of structural monitoring, stress
and strain detection,
non-destructive testing, and failure detection. In particular, the invention
relates to an
improved photoelastic layer for photoelastic inspections and testing.
CA 02668810 2009-06-11
-2-
BACKGROUND ART
Stress and Strain Measurement
[0003] Strain, e, is a dimensionless response to stress expressed as a
fraction, e = DUL0,
where Lo is the original length of the object and AL is the change in length
of the object when
stress is applied. Stress, s, is a measure of force per unit area given by F/A
where F is the
force being applied and A is the area it is being applied to. Because stress
cannot be
measured directly in practice, strain is measured instead. The stress in an
object is related to
the strain by the Young's Modulus, E, which is given by the following
relationship:
E = s (F / A) = stress/strain.
[0004] lee! (ALI Lo)
[0005] Knowing the Elastic Modulus of a given material, the stress in the
material can be
determined by measuring the strain. Traditionally, stress and strain
measurements have been
accomplished by a number of different methods. Some of these methods are
described
below:
Photoelastic Techniques
[0006] Photoelastic techniques are optical techniques for detecting stress and
strain that
exploit the photoelastic properties of certain materials. The speed of
propagation of light in
transparent materials is generally slower than in a vacuum or in air. The
ratio of the speed of
light in a given material to the speed of light in a vacuum is called the
index of refraction of
that material. In homogeneous materials, the index of refraction is constant
regardless of the
direction of propagation or plane of vibration of the light. In other
materials, strain in the
material causes the index of refraction to change depending on the direction
of propagation
of light. These materials, which can be optically isotropic when unstrained,
become
optically anisotropic when strain is present.
CA 02668810 2011-03-11
-3-
[007] Materials that become optically anisotropic when stressed are known as
photoelastic
materials. The change in index of refraction relative to index axis in the
material can typically
be related to the stress and strain in the material by observing and
quantifying the photoelastic
effect. The photoelastic effect is caused by alternately constructive and
destructive
interference between light rays that have undergone relative retardation, or
phase shift, in the
stressed photoelastic material. When illuminated with polarized light and
viewed through a
polarizing filter, fringe patterns become visible in the photoelastic material
that reveal the
overall stress and strain distribution in the part and show the locations and
magnitudes of the
stresses and strains in the part. A person skilled in the art of photoelastic
analysis can
interpret and measure these patterns.
[008] Photoelastic analysis techniques can be useful because the results are
visual and
relatively easy to interpret. However, photoelastic analysis has traditionally
been limited to
R&D and laboratory testing applications because of a number of factors. First,
the coatings
are difficult to put on and do not lend themselves well to application to
production parts.
Secondly, specialized equipment is required to conduct the tests and to make
the fringe
patterns reveal themselves. The specialized equipment includes a source of
polarized light
and another polarizing filter to view the test specimen through. The second
polarizing filter
can be integrated into an instrument known as a polarizer. This equipment can
be costly and
difficult to find. A second problem with traditional photoelastic analysis
techniques is the
need to illuminate the part with polarized light. This usually requires a dark
room and
precludes inspections in the presence of non-polarized ambient light and makes
outdoor
inspections difficult.
Photoelastic Coatings
[009] Photoelastic coatings are available from companies such as Measurements
Group in
sheet form, and also in a liquid plastic form that is cast onto a part and
then bonded on using
adhesive. Lam and Ellens disclose a method for applying a photoelastic coating
using
powder coating techniques (US Patent No. 6,650,405) that is low cost, easy to
apply, and
can be used on parts with
CA 02668810 2009-06-11
-4-
parts with complex three-dimensional shapes. The application of a photoelastic
coating
using powder coating methods is much less expensive than applying of
traditional
photoelastic coatings, and for example is suitable for application to parts
that are made in
higher quantities for field use. Once powder coated with the photoelastic
layer, the parts and
structures can then be inspected in service using photoelastic techniques to
determine if any
strain is present in the part or if any plastic deformation has occurred.
Applying a
photoelastic layer using powder coating methods can be a useful and low cost
method of
monitoring parts and can increase public safety by helping with early
detection of failures
before they become catastrophic.
Structural Monitoring
[0010] Structures such as buildings, bridges, airplanes, and other critical
structures are prone
to failure. Failure can happen with significant loss of life and property, as
evidenced by the
recent collapse of the 1-35 bridge in Minnesota. As such, structural
monitoring is becoming
an even more important field that can have a significant positive impact on
public health and
safety.
[0011 ] Prior art approaches to structural monitoring typically involve
expensive monitoring
devices and expensive monitoring systems. A prior art system involving the use
of a linear
transducer is disclosed by Arms (US patent number 6,588,282). The transducer
has two
components that move relative to one another, and a clamping mechanism is used
to prevent
the shortening of the relative strain between the two components. This system
has
disadvantages because of the moving parts involved, and the precise
orientation required for
those moving parts to work. Also, the system requires some sort of electronic
system to
detect the signal. These factors combine to make this system expensive and
less suitable for
large scale deployment for structural monitoring.
[0012] Another prior-art approach to structural monitoring is disclosed by
Brennen (US
patent number 6,928,881). Brennen's approach involves the use of strain gauges
mounted in
a housing along with instrumentation that records and stores the stress levels
experienced by
CA 02668810 2009-06-11
-5-
the structure. While this approach can give an accurate time history of
stresses experienced
by a structure, it is prohibitively expensive because of the use of on-board
monitoring and
storage. The collection of all the historical stress data is overkill and
unnecessary. The
regular storage and retrieval of all the data is too expensive and requires
excessively frequent
visits to perform downloads. Also, because data will only be recorded at a
certain sampling
rate, it is possible with Brennen's system to miss key events such as stress
strain peaks. This
could lead to false conclusions regarding the safety of the structure because
key peak events
have been missed. Increasing the sampling rate to try to capture these peak
key events
means more data needs to be stored. Reducing the sampling rate in order to
reduce the
amount of data stored only makes the problem of missing key events worse.
[0013] Bilder et al, (US Patent number 5,534,289) discloses a method of
structural crack
detection that involves the use of microcapsules in a coating that will burst
and change the
colour of a second coating layer. The coatings also provide environmental
protection for the
structural part. This method however can only detect cracks, and the
requirement of
microcapsules containing coloured dyes makes the method difficult and
expensive.
[0014] Prior art photoelastic layers are limited in their applicability to
structural monitoring
because of several reasons. One reason is that photoelastic analysis typically
requires a
polarized light source, and large structures in the field such as bridges are
hard to shield
from ambient light and hard to illuminate with polarized light. Another reason
is that
photoelastic analysis typically requires specialized equipment such as a
polarized light
source and a detector with a built in polarizer to see the fringe patterns.
Photoelastic
analysis has also typically been limited to laboratory environments.
Traditional photoelastic
analysis techniques are not well suited to larger structures and analysis in
outdoors
situations.
Problems With Prior Art
[0015] From the description above, it can be seen that prior art methods of
photoelastic
analysis and structural monitoring can suffer from one or more of the
following problems:
CA 02668810 2009-06-11
-6-
[0016] - An external source of polarized light is required to inspect
structures or devices
with photoelastic coatings or properties.
[0017] - Inspections in daylight cannot be performed without the need to block
out the
ambient light. Blocking out the ambient light to perform an inspection is not
very practical
on a structure such as a bridge when the area in question is not very
accessible and the bridge
is already being illuminated by ambient light from the sun.
[0018] - Inspections with traditional photoelastic techniques require a
polarized light source
to illuminate the object being inspected in order to perform the inspection.
Ambient light
cannot be used. This can make it difficult to perform inspections on objects
and structures at
a distance, particularly when ambient light is present.
[0019] - Inspections cannot be made on structures from a distance. For
example,
inspections cannot be made from ground level on high bridges or overpasses
using
magnifying optics such as a telescope or telephoto lens on a camera because of
the need to
illuminate the photoelastic layer or photoelastic-coated monitoring device
with polarized
light.
[0020] - Specialized imaging and detection equipment designed for photoelastic
analysis is
required to perform the inspections. Regular imaging equipment such as digital
cameras
cannot be used to perform the inspections. This increases the cost of
inspections.
[0021] - Two polarizing filters are typically required with traditional
photoelastic
techniques. These traditional photoelastic techniques typically require a
light source, a
polarizing filter to polarize the light from the light source, and a second
polarizing filter to
view the part through.
[0022] - Current methods for monitoring structural components such as bridges,
buildings,
and components such as aircraft landing gear are expensive and do not allow an
inspector to
determine whether the structure has experienced excessive stress strain levels
or not.
CA 02668810 2009-06-11
-7-
[0023] - Current stress and strain detection and analysis techniques including
photoelastic
techniques, strain gauges, and other techniques are not well adapted to use in
the field,
particularly for long-term low-cost monitoring. Monitoring of stresses and
strains in the
field using existing instruments and methods typically requires constant
monitoring and
logging of data to capture the stress strain history of the structure and
part. This can be
problematic and expensive.
[0024] - Without some sort of data-logging, many existing stress and strain
detection
techniques are not able to communicate to the inspector that a certain level
of stress and
strain has been experienced by the structure or part even when the structure
is no longer
experiencing that stress level.
[0025] - Existing methods for detecting when stress and strain levels have
been exceeded
can be expensive to build, to install, and to perform regular inspections on.
[0026] In summary, current stress strain detection techniques suffer from a
number of
problems that make their use in structural monitoring problematic and have
prevented the
growth of structural monitoring solutions for improving public safety. In
particular,
photoelastic analysis has been prevented from gaining more widespread
acceptance in
structural monitoring because traditional photoelastic techniques have not
been appropriate
for use in structural monitoring.
SUMMARY OF INVENTION
[0027] In accordance with the present invention, a photoelastic layer for
detecting stress and
strain is described. The photoelastic layer comprises a photoelastic material
that when
strained refracts light anisotropically. The photoelastic layer further
comprises a polarizer
attached directly to the photoelastic material.
[0028] Also in accordance with the present invention, a photoelastic
monitoring device is
described for structural monitoring. The photoelastic monitoring either
comprises a
CA 02668810 2009-06-11
-8-
photoelastic material or comprises a photoelastic coating applied to a non
photoelastic base
material. A reflective layer may be applied on the base material between the
base material
and the photoelastic coating. The photoelastic device further comprises a
polarizer attached
or coated directly over at least a portion of the photoelastic material or
coating. The
photoelastic monitoring device is designed to be attached to a structure or a
part. The
monitoring device is attached to the structure in such a way that stresses and
strains from the
structure are transmitted into the photoelastic monitoring device. When a
certain
predetermined stress or strain is reached, the monitoring device may deform
plastically.
[0029] Also in accordance with the present invention, a method is described
for photoelastic
analysis. The method comprises providing a photoelastic material to be
analyzed for stresses
and strains. A polarizer is attached directly on top of at least a portion of
the photoelastic
material. The polarizer is attached in such a way such that the photoelastic
material can be
illuminated with regular light through the polarizer, and such that light can
be reflected back
through the photoelastic material and back through the polarizer to the
observer or the
detector. The method comprises illuminating the polarizer with light, and
viewing the
reflections of light that have traveled through the polarizer, through the
photoelastic
material, and been reflected back through the photoelastic material and back
through the
same polarizing layer. Observing or detecting fringe patterns in the reflected
light indicate
the presence of strain or plastic deformation in the photoelastic material.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF DRAWINGS
[0030] Having thus generally described the nature of the invention, reference
will now be
made to the accompanying drawings, showing by way of illustration several
embodiments
thereof, and in which:
[0031 ] FIG. 1 is a schematic view of a photoelastic layer for structural
monitoring with an
integrated polarizer according to an embodiment of the present invention;
CA 02668810 2009-06-11
-9-
[0032] FIG. 2 is a schematic view of a photoelastic layer for structural
monitoring with an
integrated polarizer according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0033] FIG. 3 is a is diagrammatic view showing the use of a photoelastic
layer with an
integrated polarizer according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0034] FIG. 4 is a general view of a photoelastic monitoring device with an
integrated
polarizer according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0035] FIG. 5 is a is diagrammatic view showing the use of a photoelastic
monitoring device
with an integrated polarizer according to an embodiment of the present
invention;
[0036] FIG. 6 is a diagrammatic view showing the use of a photoelastic layer
with an
integrated polarizer according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0037] FIG. 7 is a flow chart showing a series of steps for inspecting a
structure using a
photoelastic layer with an integrated polarizer according to an embodiment of
the present
invention.
DESCRIPTION OF EMBODIMENTS
[0038] The following detailed description includes references to the
accompanying
drawings, which form a part of the detailed description. The drawings show, by
way of
illustration, specific embodiments in which the invention may be practiced.
These
embodiments, which are also referred to herein as "examples", are described in
sufficient
detail to enable those skilled in the art to practice the invention. The
embodiments may be
combined, other embodiments may be utilized, or structural, mechanical, and
material
composition changes may be made without departing from the scope of the
present
invention. The following detailed description is, therefore, not to be taken
in a limiting
CA 02668810 2009-06-11
-10-
sense, and the scope of the present invention is defined by the appended
claims and their
equivalents.
[0039] The present invention provides an improved photoelastic layer with an
integrated
polarizer. Traditionally, the polarizers required for photoelastic analysis
were stand-alone
filters or were built into the light source and the detecting equipment.
Photoelastic analysis
was carried out in dark laboratories so the test piece could be illuminated
with polarized
light. These techniques were not suitable for outside inspections or
structural monitoring.
Integrating a polarizer into a photoelastic layer provides a number of
advantages. A
polarizer is attached directly to or within a certain distance of the
photoelastic material.
Light travels through the polarizer to reach the photoelastic material. It
then travels through
the photoelastic material, reflects back through the photoelastic material and
then through
the same polarizer. The integreated polarizer may cover all of the
photoelastic material, or
only a portion of the photoelastic material.
[0040] The integrated polarizer greatly simplifies the equipment necessary for
conducting
photoelastic analysis and inspections. For example, a photoelastic layer with
an integrated
polarizer makes the use of a regular light source and a regular camera
possible for viewing
fringe patterns in the photoelastic material. This makes photoelastic
inspections and analysis
much simpler, easier, and lower cost, especially out in the field. In addition
to removing the
need for a special polarized light source, a photoelastic layer with an
integrated polarizer can
even remove the need for a light source to do the analysis, particular in
outdoor settings
where there is sunlight and ambient available to illuminate the photoelastic
material through
the integrated polarizer. Traditionally, any ambient light would typically
have to be blocked
out to perform the test with a polarized light source. The integrated
polarizer has the
advantage that blocking of ambient light is not required, and in fact the
ambient light can be
used as the light source.
[0041 ] By moving cost from the inspection to the photoelastic layer, the
photoelastic layer
with integrated plolarizer can greatly facilitate quick and easy inspections
of large structures
CA 02668810 2009-06-11
-11-
such as bridges and buildings. This invention makes the use of photoelastic
analysis for
structural monitoring applications more feasible and lower cost.
DESCRIPTION OF EXAMPLE WITH INTEGRATED POLARIZER - FIG. 1
[0042] FIG. I. is a schematic diagram showing an example of a photoelastic
layer 100 with
an integrated polarizer 110 according to an embodiment of the present
invention. A
polarizer 110 is integrated into a photoelastic layer 100 comprising a
photoelastic material
120, a reflective layer 130, and integrated polarizer 110. Photoelastic layer
100 is attached
onto a structure 140. Reflective layer 130, photoelastic material 120, and
polarizer 110 can
be applied structure 140 individually, or combined together into a laminated
unit first before
attaching to structure 140. Reflective layer 130 and photoelastic material 120
can also be
formed into a sheet and bonded onto structure 140 (for example by using
adhesives such as
epoxy or pressure sensitive film) before polarizer 110 is attached. An example
of a
photoelastic sheet combining a reflective layer and a photoelastic material is
the PS-1
material available from Measurements Group of Raleigh, North Carolina.
[0043] Photoelastic material 120 and reflective layer 130 can be applied using
a number of
techniques, including powder coating, coating with wet paint, or laminating.
Structure 140
can be a part to be analyzed such as the landing gear of an aircraft, or a
structure to be
monitored such as a bridge or a building. Polarizer 110 can attached to
photoelastic material
120 and structure 140 using adhesives, pressure sensitive films, heat,
pressure, bolts, rivets,
tape, or other means. Polarizer 110 can cover all of the photoelastic material
120, or it can
cover only a portion of photoelastic material 130, as is shown in FIG. 1.
Polarizer 110 can
also be applied using powder coating, spraying, or wet coating an appropriate
material onto
photoelastic material 110. An example of a material that can be used to make
integrated
polarizer 110 is a polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) polymer. Other materials are
possible.
Examples of PVA polarizers and other types of polarizers are available from
American
Polarizers, Inc. of Reading, Pennsylvania. Integrated polarizer 110 can also
comprise a
quarter wave plate for changing linearly polarized light to circularly
polarized light and vice
versa. Reflective layer 130 can be used to enhance the reflection of light
back through
CA 02668810 2009-06-11
-12-
photoelastic material 120. However, reflective layer 130 may not be necessary
if the surface
of structure 140 is appropriate for creating a reflection back through
photoelastic material
120 and polarizer 110.
DESCRIPTION OF EXAMPLE WITH INTEGRATED POLARIZER - FIG. 2
[00441 FIG. 2 is a schematic diagram showing a photoelastic layer 200 with an
integrated
polarizer 110 according to an embodiment of the present invention. In this
embodiment,
polarizer 110 is attached to photoelastic material 120 with spacers 180.
Spacer 180 can be
for example a double-sided adhesive or an epoxy, or it can be a mechanical
spacer. Spacer
180 can bond a portion of polarizer 110 to photoelastic material 120, or, in
the case of a
transparent or optically clear material it can bond substantially all of
polarizer 110 to
photoelastic material 120. The thickness of the spacer 180 can be kept to a
minimum in
order to make it easier for the reflected light to pass through polarizer 110.
For example, the
thickness of spacer 180 can be from zero to 100 mm, or from zero to 1,000 mm
thick. In an
example, polarizer 110 can be a sheet of circular polarizing material
available from
Edmunds Optics of Barrington, N.J. The circular polarizing material comprises
a linear
polarizer with a 1/4k retarder to produce circularly polarized light. Other
polarizing
materials are possible. Photoelastic material 120 can be a layer of
transparent or translucent
powder coat material that is applied electrostatically as a powder and fused
together with
heat, as disclosed by Lam et at. in US Patent 6,650,405. Spacer 180 can be a
50 micron
thick optically clear laminating adhesive 8172 from 3M of St. Paul, Minnesota.
Other
photoelastic materials and other spacer materials are also possible.
[0045] Referring again to FIG. 2., photoelastic material 120 is bonded to
reflective layer
130. Reflective layer 130 is bonded to substrate 140. In one example,
reflective layer 130
can be a near-chrome powder coat also applied electrostatically in powder form
and fused
together with heat. Substrate 140 can be any sort of structure or part that is
to be inspected
or analyzed for stress strain. For example, substrate 140 can be a gusset
plate in a bridge, a
steel beam in a building, or a frame member in a piece of heavy earth-moving
equipment.
CA 02668810 2009-06-11
-13-
[0046] Photoelastic analysis can be carried out by illuminating photoelastic
layer 200 with a
light source 160. Ambient light or light from the sun can also be used to
illuminate
photoelastic layer 200. Light 140 from light source 160 travels through
polarizer 110 and
into photoelastic material 120. It travels through photoelastic material 120,
reflects off the
surface of reflective layer 130, and travels back through photoelastic
material 120 and
polarizer 110. Reflected light 150 can be detected and recorded by a camera
170 or some
other instrument, or it can be viewed by an observer to determine if any
fringe patterns are
evident in the reflected light. Fringe patterns indicate the degree of stress
and strain being
experienced by photoelastic material 120, which if properly bonded to
structure 140
indicates the amount of stress strain being experienced by structure 140. The
number and
appearance of the fringe patterns in evidence for a certain stress and strain
level depends on
the material properties and the thickness of photoelastic material 120. If
structure 140 is no
longer under load, the presence of fringe patterns can indicate that plastic
deformation has
occurred in structure 140. This can indicate that structure 140 has
experienced loads that are
sufficient to cause the material in structure 140 to reach and exceed the
yield point of the
material. After an inspection to detect fringe patterns, polarizer 110 can
remain attached to
photoelastic material 120 so as to be ready for the next inspection.
Photoelastic layer 200
with an integrated polarizer 110 has the advantage that the inspector does not
need to carry
around any polarizers or sources of polarized light as with traditional
photoelastic analysis in
order to conduct the inspection. Inspections can be performed with non-
specialized
instruments such as a regular digital camera. If the inspection location is
far away from the
inspector, a camera with a telephoto lens can be used to perform the
inspection.
DESCRIPTION OF PHOTOELASTIC LAYER WITH INTEGRATED POLARIZER - FIG.
3
[0047] FIG. 3 is a general view of a photoelastic layer with an integrated
polarizer according
to an embodiment of the present invention. A layer of photoelastic material
310 is attached
to a structure 320 to be monitored or tested. Photoelastic material 310 in
this example can
be applied by a number of methods as in previously described embodiments. For
example it
can be applied using powder coat methods as described by Lam et al. in US
Patent No.
CA 02668810 2009-06-11
-14-
6,650,405 or as a liquid coating. It can also be applied as a sheet of
photoelastic material
that is bonded onto the surface of structure 320. The photoelastic layer may
comprise a
reflective layer interposed between the photoelastic material 310 and the
surface of structure
320. A polarizer 300 is integrated into the photoelastic layer by attaching it
over at least a
portion of photoelastic material 310. Alternatively, polarizer 300 can be
attached over the
entirety of photoelastic material 310. Attaching polarizer 300 over only a
small portion of
photoelastic material 310 has the advantage of lower cost and focussing the
attention of
inspectors and test personnel on areas of interest. Attaching polarizer 300
over the entirety
of photoelastic material 310 has the advantage of being able to identify where
high stresses
and strains in structure 320 are occurring or have occurred. This can be
particularly useful if
the stress strain distribution in structure 320 is not previously known.
Polarizer 300 can be
attached to photelastic material 310 and structure 320 using adhesives,
screws, rivets, or
some other means of attachment. Alternatively, it could be sprayed on our
coated on using
liquid techniques.
[0048] Structure 320 could be a part such as a landing strut on an aircraft, a
rafter in a
building, or a truss member on a bridge. Integrated polarizer 300 can simplify
and reduce
the cost of inspections of structure 320. Inspections can be performed by
illuminating
integrated polarizer 300 with light 140 from a light source 160, and viewing
the reflected
light 180 that passes through polarizer 300 and photoelastic material 310.
Fringe patterns
can be observed by an observer, or they can be detected and recorded by a
camera 170. For
situations where it would be impractical to illuminate polarizer 300 (e.g., on
a bridge
structure in daylight), ambient light from a source such as the sun could be
used in place of
light source 160. Integrated polarizer 300 stays fixed to photoelastic
material 310 and
greatly facilitates future inspections or multiple inspections on the same
area.
[0049] Another significant benefit of the photoelastic layer with integrated
polarizer 300 is
inspections can be performed at a distance by equipping camera 170 with a
telephoto lens.
For example, a truss on a bridge that is not easily accessible due to its
height from the
ground can be readily inspected using ambient light from the sun for the light
source and by
using a pair of binoculars or a telephoto lens on a camera. The data collected
using such a
CA 02668810 2009-06-11
-15-
method can be easily understand and easily interpreted. The data can also be
easily
transmitted via electronic or other means for further analysis. All of these
factors can help to
simplify inspections and reduce inspection costs, thereby increasing safety by
allowing more
frequent and regular inspections.
DESCRIPTION OF EXAMPLE OF MONITORING DEVICE WITH INTEGRATED
POLARIZING LAYER - FIG. 4
[0050] FIG. 4 shows a general view of a structural monitoring device with an
integrated
polarizer, according to an embodiment of the present invention. Monitoring
device 400 is an
example of a photoelastic device designed for structural monitoring.
Monitoring device 400
has ends 440, means 460 for attachment to a structure to be monitored, and a
detection zone
430. In the embodiment shown FIG. 4, monitoring device 400 comprises a base
material
420 that has been coated with a reflective layer 470 and a with a photoelastic
material 450.
An integrated polarizer 410 is attached on top of photoelastic material 450 in
detection zone
430. Alternatively, integrated polarizer 410 can cover the entireity of
photoelastic material
450.
[0051] Monitoring device 400 including integrated polarizer 410 can be
attached to a
structure or a part to be monitored using attachment points 460, or by
attaching ends 440 to
an underlying structure. Monitoring device 400 is attached in such a way that
stresses and
strains in the underlying structure are transferred into monitoring device 400
and
concentrated into detection zone 430 in a known manner. Monitoring device 400
can be
designed such that it plastically deforms when a certain stress strain level
is experienced by
the structure it is attached to. Inspections can be performed on monitoring
device 400 by
illuminating polarizer 410 with unfiltered light and viewing the reflections
that have
travelled through polarizer 410, through photoelastic material 450, reflected
off reflective
layer 470, and travelled back through photoelastic material 450, and back
through polarizer
410. If device 400 has plastically deformed or is currently experiencing
elastic strain, fringe
patterns will be visible indicating the presence of strain of plastic
deformation. This can
CA 02668810 2009-06-11
-16-
indicate very quickly to an inspector whether the structure being monitored
has experienced
overloading or not.
[0052] In another embodiment, the base material that monitoring device 400 is
made out of
is itself a photoelastic material. For example, the shape of monitoring device
400 could
simply be cut out of a photelastic sheet such as the PS-1 photoelastic
material from
Measurements Group of Raleigh, North Carolina. In this example, the reflective
layer could
be located on the bottom of device 400 as it is with the PS-1 material.
Polarizer 410 could
then be attached directly to the photoelastic material.
[0053] A monitoring device 400 according to the above embodiments could have
the
advantage of very low manufacturing cost. It can be attached to a structure or
a part to be
monitored and provide very useful information about the stresses and strains
that are being
experienced or have been experienced by that structure or part. This could
greatly enhance
public safety and to save on monitoring and inspection costs of structures and
buildings,
helping to address the significant problem of aging infrastructure in North
America.
DESCRIPTION OF EXAMPLE - FIG. 5
[0054] FIG. 5 is a general view of a monitoring device 400 with an integrated
polarizer 410
mounted on a structure 500, according to an embodiment of the present
invention. Structure
500 can be a truss on a bridge, a part of an aircraft landing gear, or any
other structure that is
subjected to loads that can cause stress and strain in a structure. Structure
500 may have
been subjected to loads that are no longer present, or it can still be under
load. To determine
if previous or present loads have caused stresses in excess of a predetermined
amount,
monitoring device 400 can be illuminated with a light source 160. Light source
160 can be
an electrical light source, or it can be any other light source such as
ambient light or daylight
from the sun. Light 140 from the light source passes through integrated
polarizer 410 and
into photoelastic material 420. Reflected light 150 reflects off reflective
layer 470 and
passes back through photoelastic material 420 and back through integrated
polarizer 410.
Stress and strain transferred to photoelastic material 420 from structure 500
causes fringe
CA 02668810 2009-06-11
-17-
patterns to be visible in reflected light 150. The fringe patterns can be
viewed, detected by
an instrument, or recorded by a camera 170. Inspection using a camera 170 or
other detector
can help to reveal whether structure 500 has been overloaded or has
experienced stresses and
strains beyond the safe limit for structure 500. If device 400 shows that
excessive stresses
and strains have been experienced, further action can be taken to remedy the
situation or to
prevent further possible catastrophic failure.
DESCRIPTION OF EXAMPLE OF INTEGRATED POLARIZER - FIG. 6
[0055] FIG. 6 shows a diagrammatic view of a structure 620 coated with a
photoelastic
material 610 with an integrated polarizer 600, according to an embodiment of
the present
invention. Integrated polarizer 600 makes photoelastic inspections of
structure 620 simpler
and reduces the cost of inspections because it removes the need for a
polarized light source
and specialized instruments with polarizing filters to perform photoelastic
inspections on
structure 620. The need for shielding the area of interest from ambient light
such as daylight
can be avoided by locating integrated polarizer 600 in close proximity to
photoelastic
material 610. Integrated polarizer 600 should be attached sufficiently close
to photoelastic
material 610 so that a significant proportion of light 140 from light source
160 that is incident
on the portion of photoelastic material 610 that is of interest passes through
integrated
polarizer 600. Accordingly, the space between integrated polarizer 600 and
photoelastic
material 610 should be from 0 to 1,000 mm., or the space can be from 0 to 100
mm to
further reduce light leakage around the outside of integrated polarizer 600.
DESCRIPTION OF EXAMPLE METHOD FOR STRUCTURAL MONITORING USING
A POLARIZER ATTACHED TO A PHOTOELASTIC LAYER - FIG. 7
[0056] FIG. 7 describes a method for monitoring structures or parts to detect
for stress and
strain levels in that structure or part according to an embodiment of the
present invention.
The method comprises a step 700 of providing a structure or part for testing
or monitoring.
The structure or part could be the actual structural part of interest itself,
or it could be a
photoelastic monitoring device designed to attach to a structure or part of
interest. In this
CA 02668810 2009-06-11
-18-
example the method comprises a step 710 of applying a reflective layer to a
structure or part
such as a silver colored paint. If the surface of the structure or part is
adequately reflective
(e.g., the shiny surface of a metallic structure) a reflective layer may not
be required. Next is
a step 720 of applying a photoelastic material to the structure or a portion
of the structure.
The method further comprises a step 730 of attaching an integrated polarizer
or polarizing
layer on top of the photoelastic material. A single integrated polarizer can
be attached over a
portion of the polarizing material in a point of interest, or multiple
integrated polarizers can
be attached at various points of interest on the photoelastic material.
Alternatively, the
integrated polarizer can cover all of the photoelastic material. The points of
interest can be
chosen to correspond to critical areas where regular inspection is desired to
monitor for
excessive stresses or overloading. The structure is at this point ready for
inspection and can
be subjected to test or service loads (step 740). Inspections can be performed
when service
or test loads have been removed, or when service and test loads are still
present. To perform
the inspection, a step 750 comprises illuminating the part of the structure
with the integrated
polarizer with a source of light. The method then comprises a step 760 of
viewing or
detecting reflected light that has traveled through the integrated polarizer,
through the
photoelastic material, reflected off the reflective layer, travelled back
through the
photoelastic material and back through the integrated polarizer to the
observer. The
presence or absence of fringe patterns in the reflected light provides
information regarding
the stress and strain that is being experienced by the structure, or, if
plastic deformation has
occurred, stress and strain that has been experienced by the structure in the
past. Because
the method comprises step 730 of attaching an integrated polarizer to the
photoelastic
material, inspections can be simplified because a regular light source can be
used (including
the sun), and inspections can be performed with regular equipment such as
cameras without
the need for specialized equipment or light sources with polarizing filters.
Inspections can
also be carried out from a distance if need be using for example a telephone
lens mounted on
the camera.
[0057] In summary, the present invention provides a device with an integrated
polarizer
attached to a photoelastic material and a method of applying and using a
photoelastic layer
CA 02668810 2009-06-11
-19-
with an integrated polarizer. From the description above, specific embodiments
of the
present invention may provide one or more of the following advantages:
[0058] -Facilitates and makes possible the use of photoelastic techniques for
inspecting
large structures such as bridge and buildings
[0059] - An external source of polarized light is not required to inspect
structures or devices
with photoelastic layers comprising an integrated polarizer.
[0060] - Inspections in daylight can be performed without the need to block
out the ambient
light. In fact, ambient light could be used as the light source for the
inspection.
[0061 ] - Inspections can be made on structures from a distance. For example,
inspections
can be made from ground level on high bridges or overpasses using magnifying
optics such
as a telescope or telephoto lens on a camera.
[0062] - Regular imaging equipment such as digital cameras can be used to
perform the
inspections without the need for specialized inspection equipment with
polarizing filters or a
polarized light source.
[0063] - Only one integrated polarizer is required to do the inspection
whereas two
polarizing filters are typically required with traditional photoelastic
techniques.
[0064] - The integrated polarizer can be used to indicate key areas of
interest to help guide
an inspector when the integrated polarizer is placed on a portion of the
photoelastic material;
the integrated polarizer can act as "targets" for the inspector.
[0065] Many modifications, substitutions, and improvements will be apparent to
the skilled
artisan without departing from the spirit and scope of the present invention
as described
herein and defined in the claims.
CA 02668810 2009-06-11
-20-
INDUSTRIAL APPLICABILITY
[0066] The present invention has industrial applicability to the field of
photoelastic analysis
and the field of structural monitoring.
