Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
SP 29499 SL CA 02671842 2009-06-02
1
PROCESS FOR IMPROVING THE ADHESION OF CARBON FIBRES
WITH REGARD TO AN ORGANIC MATRIX
DESCRIPTION
TECHNICAL FIELD
The present invention relates to a process
which makes it possible to improve the adhesion of
carbon fibres with regard to an organic matrix forming,
with these fibres, a composite material and resulting
from the chain polymerization of a curable resin.
This process, which makes it possible to
obtain composite materials with noteworthy properties
of resistance to stresses, both transverse (that is to
say, perpendicular to the axis of the carbon fibres)
and longitudinal (that is to say, in the axis of the
carbon fibres), is very particularly advantageous in
the aeronautical and aerospatial industries, in
particular in the manufacture of components of large
dimensions, such as, for example, wing unit or fuselage
components.
However, it can also be used in other types
of industry, such as the shipbuilding, railway or motor
vehicle industries, the armaments industry, for example
in the production of components participating in the
construction of missiles or of missile launch tubes, or
also that of sports and leisure articles, for example
in the production of articles intended for water sports
and for sports which involve sliding.
SP 29499 SL CA 02671842 2009-06-02
2
STATE OF THE PRIOR ART
Composite materials are heterogeneous
materials which make it possible to make use of the
exceptional mechanical properties of materials, the
manufacture of which is only known in the form of
fibres (and not in bulk form), by embedding them in a
matrix formed of a cured organic polymer (or resin),
which makes it possible to bond the fibres to one
another, to distribute the stresses in the composite
material and to protect the fibres against chemical
attacks.
A necessary condition for the production of
a high-performance composite material is that the
bonding between the fibres and the matrix of which it
is composed be good. This is because, if the
fibres/matrix bonding is inadequate, then a composite
material is obtained with mediocre transverse
mechanical properties (such as resistance to shearing)
and thus with very limited possibilities of use,
components made of composite materials generally being
intended to operate under a state of three-directional
stress.
Carbon is chemically rather unreactive and
naturally exhibits a low adhesion with regard to
polymer matrices. Consequently, manufacturers of carbon
fibres have straightaway sought to adapt their fibres
to the resins intended to be used as matrices by
manufacturers of components made of composite
materials.
Thus it is that the following have been
proposed:
SP 29499 SL CA 02671842 2009-06-02
3
1) surface treatments
which are all
targeted at creating, at the surface of the fibres,
functional groups capable of reacting with chemical
functional groups carried by the resins; they are
mainly electrolytic or chemical oxidation treatments
(see, for example, JP-A-3076869 [1]) but other types of
treatment have also been described, such as plasma heat
treatments (see, for example,
EP-A-1 484 435 [2]),
electrolysis in an acidic or basic medium
(EP-A-0 640 702 [3]) or the implantation of atoms of Si
or B type (JP-B-2002-327374 [4]);
2) the use of specific sizing agents, that
is to say by the deposition, on the surface of the
fibres, of products having the role of enhancing the
compatibility of the fibres with regard to the resins,
of facilitating their impregnation by the resins and of
providing "attaching" between the fibres and the
matrices formed by the polymerization of these resins;
generally, the sizing agents used are polymers or
copolymers with complex chemical structures, the choice
of which is mainly guided by experience; and
3) the grafting to the surface of the
fibres of an elastomeric phase (Wu et al., Carbon, 34,
59-67, 1996 [5]) or of polymers of polyester, vinyl
polymer (in particular polystyrene) or polyacetal type
(Tsubokawa, Carbon, 31, 1257-1263, 1993 [6]) capable,
here again, of enhancing the compatibility of the
fibres with regard to the resins.
It should be noted that sizing agents are
also used on the carbon fibres for other objectives
than that of improving the bonding thereof with an
SP 29499 SL CA 02671842 2009-06-02
4
organic matrix, such as, for example, that of
facilitating the handling thereof.
While the treatments mentioned above are
generally relatively effective in the case of matrices
obtained by thermal polymerization of resins (that is
to say, polymerization induced by heat), it turns out
that they are not effective or insufficiently effective
when the matrices are produced with resins, the
polymerization of which is induced by light radiation
(visible or ultraviolet light) or ionizing radiation
(13 or y radiation or X-rays).
This is because experience shows that the
composites obtained with resins polymerized under
radiation exhibit transverse mechanical performances
which are markedly inferior to those of the better
composites produced with resins polymerized by the
thermal route, which is conventionally interpreted as
=
the fact that the fibres/matrix bonding remains
inadequate despite the treatments applied to the carbon
fibres by the manufacturers thereof.
In point of fact, the polymerization of
resins under radiation moreover exhibits a number of
advantages with respect to the polymerization of resins
by the thermal route, these advantages being related in
particular to the possibility of operating without
autoclaves and thus of more easily manufacturing
composite components which are large in size or complex
in structure and of obtaining much higher
polymerization rates, which makes possible higher
production rates for lower costs.
SP 29499 SL CA 02671842 2009-06-02
It would thus be desirable to succeed in
improving the adhesion of carbon fibres with regard to
a polymer matrix in the case where this matrix is
obtained by polymerization under radiation of a curable
5 resin and more specifically of a resin having chain
polymerization since, in practice, the resins which are
capable of polymerizing under radiation are resins, the
polymerization of which takes place by a chain
mechanism.
In the context of their studies, the
Inventors found that if functional groups capable of
acting as chain transfer agents during the
polymerization of the resin are grafted to the surface
of carbon fibres, then a significant improvement in the
fibres/matrix adhesion is obtained, probably because
these functional groups are converted, during the
polymerization of the resin, into active radical or
ionic centres, by reaction with growing polymer chains,
and are then capable of initiating the formation, from
the surface of the fibres, of new polymer chains which
are covalently bonded to this surface from the time
they are created and which subsequently facilitate the
transfer of the stresses from the matrix to the fibres.
However, they also found that some of the
functional groups present at the surface of the carbon
fibres before this grafting is carried out - and which
are inherent in the process by which these fibres were
obtained - are capable of exerting an inhibiting effect
on the chain polymerization of resins and of thus
limiting the benefit obtained by the introduction of
SP 29499 SL CA 02671842 2009-06-02
6
functional groups capable of acting as chain transfer
agents.
The present invention is based on this
double observation.
ACCOUNT OF THE INVENTION
A subject-matter of the present invention
is thus a process for improving the adhesion of carbon
fibres with regard to an organic matrix forming, with
these fibres, a composite material, this composite
material being obtained by bringing the fibres into
contact with a resin which can be cured by chain
polymerization, followed by polymerization of the
resin, which process consists in coating the surface of
the carbon fibres, before these fibres are brought into
contact with the resin, with a polymer film comprising
functional groups capable of acting as chain transfer
agents during the polymerization of said resin.
Thus, according to the invention, it is by
coating the surface of the carbon fibres, before the
latter participate in the process for the manufacture
of the composite material, with a polymer film which
makes it possible simultaneously:
= to isolate the surface of the fibres
from the medium in which they occur and in particular
from the resin and thus to prevent the polymerization
of this resin from being inhibited by the functional
groups present on the surface of the fibres as a result
of the process by which they are manufactured,
SP 29499 SL CA 02671842 2009-06-02
7
= to confer a homogeneous surface state on
the fibres, the surface of the polymer film effectively
substituting for the surface of these fibres, and
= to cover the fibres with functional
groups which are all capable of acting as chain
transfer agents during the polymerization of the resin,
that the adhesion of these fibres with regard to the
organic matrix is increased.
The carbon fibres as obtained by
conventional processes for the pyrolysis of
polyacrylonitrile (PAN), rayon, viscose, pitch and
other oil residues are each composed of a multitude of
monofilaments which can be more or less bonded to one
another according to the treatments to which these
fibres were subjected during the manufacture thereof.
For this reason, in that which precedes and in that
which follows, the term "surface of the fibres" is
understood to mean both the surface of the
monofilaments themselves and the surface of assemblages
resulting from the bonding of a plurality of
monofilaments to one another. In the same way, the term
"surface of a fibre" is understood to mean both the
surface of a monofilament and that of an assemblage
resulting from the bonding of several monofilaments to
one another.
Furthermore, in that which precedes and in
that which follows, the term "polymerization" should be
understood as comprising not only the formation of
polymer chains by bonding of monomers or prepolymers to
one another but also the formation of a three-
dimensional network by the establishment of bonds
SP 29499 SL CA 02671842 2009-06-02
8
between these polymer chains, which is commonly known
as crosslinking.
In accordance with the invention, the
functional groups which the polymer film comprises can
be chosen from the many functional groups known to be
capable of acting as chain transfer agents in a chain
polymerization, it being understood that the selection
will preferably be made of that or those which are
capable of resulting in a film/matrix bond which is the
most satisfactory possible, in view of the curable
resin which has to be used or the conditions under
which the latter has to be polymerized.
In this respect, it is entirely possible to
evaluate the effect of different functional groups on
the adhesion of carbon fibres with regard to a matrix
obtained from a specific resin or under specific
polymerization conditions, for example by subjecting
fibres, which will have been coated beforehand with a
polymer film comprising one of these functional groups,
to a test conventionally used to assess the mechanical
properties of a fibres/matrix interface, such as, for
example, a loosening test of the type of that described
in Example 1 below, and by comparing the results
obtained for the different functional groups thus
tested.
Mention may in particular be made as
functional groups capable of acting as chain transfer
agents, of the -I, -Br, -Cl, -F, -SH, -OH, -NH-, -NH2,
-PH-, -PH2 or =S functional groups and also carbon-
based functional groups which are devoid of a
heteroatom but which can give rise to radical transfer,
SP 29499 SL CA 02671842 2009-06-02
9
such as, for example, optionally substituted allyl or
benzyl -CH functional groups.
It turns out that, in the context of their
studies, the inventors have found that thiol (-SH)
functional groups make it possible to obtain a
particularly significant improvement in the adhesion of
carbon fibres with regard to organic matrices, in
particular when these matrices are obtained by
polymerization of epoxy acrylate resins under ionizing
radiation.
Consequently, thiol functional groups are
those which are preferred.
In accordance with the invention, it is
possible to coat the surface of the carbon fibres with
said polymer film in different ways.
Specifically, it is possible first of all
to polymerize, on the surface of the fibres, a
polymerizable monomer which comprises a functional
group capable of acting as chain transfer agent, in
which case a polymer film is obtained which comprises,
from the moment of its formation on the surface of the
fibres, functional groups capable of acting as chain
transfer agents.
Thus, for example, in the case where it is
desirable for the functional groups capable of acting
as chain transfer agents to be thiol functional groups,
the polymer film can be obtained by polymerization of a
polymerizable mercaptan, such as, for example,
2-propene-1-thiol, also known under the name of allyl
mercaptan.
SP 29499 SL CA 02671842 2009-06-02
It is also possible to polymerize, on the
surface of the fibres, a monomer which comprises a
functional group which can be subsequently converted,
by chemical reaction, to a functional group capable of
5 acting as chain transfer agent, in which case a polymer
film is obtained which comprises functional groups
which are secondarily converted to functional groups
capable of acting as chain transfer agents.
It is also possible to polymerize, on the
10 surface of the fibres, a polymerizable monomer which
comprises a functional group appropriate for making
possible the grafting of a functional group capable of
acting as chain transfer agent, in which case a polymer
film is obtained onto which functional groups capable
of acting as chain transfer agents are secondarily
grafted.
In this case, the grafting can be carried
out by reacting the functional groups present at the
surface of the polymer film with an organic compound
which comprises a functional group capable of acting as
chain transfer agent or which generates, during the
reaction, groups comprising such a functional group.
Thus, for example, in the case where it is
desirable for the functional groups capable of acting
as chain transfer agents to be thiol functional groups,
it is possible to deposit, on the surface of the
fibres, a polymer film comprising carboxyl functional
groups and then to react these carboxyl functional
groups with an episulphide which, by ring opening,
becomes covalently bonded to these carboxyl functional
SP 29499 SL CA 02671842 2009-06-02
11
groups and simultaneously generates groups comprising a
thiol functional group.
A polymer film comprising carboxyl
functional groups is, for example, a film obtained by
polymerization of a polymerizable acid or of a
polymerizable acid derivative, such as, for example, an
acid anhydride, since the anhydride functional groups
spontaneously hydrolyse to give carboxylic acid
functional groups in ambient air. Mention may be made,
as examples of polymerizable acid, of acrylic acid and
methacrylic acid and, as example of polymerizable acid
anhydride, of maleic anhydride.
With regard to the episulphide, it can, for
example, be propylene sulphide, ethylene sulphide,
cyclohexene sulphide, epithiodecane, epithiododecane or
7-thiabicyclo[4.1.0]heptane.
Whether or not the polymer film
straightaway carries functional groups capable of
acting as chain transfer agents, it is preferable for
this film to form, at the surface of the carbon fibres,
a continuous coating which adheres to this surface and
which has a thickness sufficient to suitably perform
its role of barrier between this surface of the fibres
and the medium in which they occur but which is not
excessively great, in order not to substantially affect
in a detrimental fashion the mechanical properties of
these fibres, in particular their elastic modulus and
their toughness.
Consequently, the polymer film typically
exhibits a thickness ranging from 10 to 50 nm,
SP 29499 SL CA 02671842 2009-06-02
12
preferably from 10 to 30 nm and better still from 15 to
25 nm.
In order to do this, it is preferably
obtained by the "Plasma Assisted Chemical Vapour
Deposition" technique, which is referred to more simply
in the literature as PACVD or plasma polymerization and
which makes it possible to form a very thin polymer
film on the surface of a substrate from a gas phase
comprising the precursor monomer of this polymer. This
deposition technique exhibits, among other advantages,
that of being able to be used for a very great variety
both of monomers and of substrates.
In the context of the invention, it is
preferable for the plasma to be pulsed-mode
radiofrequency-induced, this being because a pulsed
activation of the monomers makes it possible to obtain
a greater degree of retention of the polymer film which
is formed on the surface of the fibres than that which
would be obtained by a continuous activation and thus a
greater functionalization of this surface.
Of course, it is also possible to use
deposition techniques other than plasma polymerization
provided that they lend themselves to the deposition of
polymers, in the form of thin and adherent films, on
carbon-based substrates, which is, for example, the
case with electrodeposition or Chemical Vapour
Deposition (CVD).
Once the carbon fibres have been treated by
the process according to the invention, they can either
be used immediately in the manufacture of components
made of composite materials or can be stored for the
SP 29499 SL CA 02671842 2009-06-02
13
purpose of subsequent use, or can be processed, for
example in the form of preimpregnated mats, for the
purpose of their delivery to manufacturers of
components made of composite materials. This is because
the process according to the invention can be carried
out equally well by the manufacturers of carbon fibres
and by their users.
In addition to the advantages mentioned
above, the process according to the invention also
exhibits those of being applicable to a great many
types of carbon fibres participating in the manufacture
of composite materials (long fibres, medium-length
fibres, short fibres, oxidized fibres, sized fibres,
and the like), of being relatively simple to carry out
and of having a cost entirely compatible with use on an
industrial scale.
Another subject-matter of the invention is
a process for the manufacture of a component made of
composite material comprising carbon fibres and an
organic matrix, which process comprises bringing the
fibres into contact with a resin which can be cured by
chain polymerization, followed by the polymerization of
the resin, and is characterized in that it additionally
comprises the implementation of a process as defined
above, before the fibres are brought into contact with
said resin.
In accordance with the invention, the
curable resin can be chosen from any resin capable of
curing by a chain polymerization mechanism, whether
under the effect of heat or under the effect of light
or ionizing radiation, this being because the Inventors
=SP 29.499 SL CA 02671842 2009-06-02
14
have found, in the context of their studies, that the
process according to the invention is effective both in
the case of a thermosetting resin and of a photo- or
radiation-curable resin.
However, for the reasons set out above, the
resin is preferably chosen from resins which can be
polymerized under radiation and in particular from
resins of multiacrylates type, such as epoxy acrylates,
novolac acrylates and polyurethane acrylates,
bismaleimide resins and epoxide resins, epoxy acrylate
resins being particularly preferred in the case where
the composite material is intended for space or
aeronautical applications.
It is obvious that the manufacture of this
component made of composite material can be carried out
according to any technique known to a person skilled in
the art of composite materials, such as, for example,
simultaneous spray moulding, vacuum moulding, moulding
by low pressure injection of resin (Resin Transfer
Moulding (RTM)), low pressure "wet route" cold press
moulding, compound injection moulding (Bulk Moulding
Compound (BMC)), moulding by compression of
preimpregnated mats (Sheet Moulding Compound (SMC)),
filament winding moulding, centrifugal moulding or
pultrusion moulding.
Other characteristics and advantages of the
process according to the invention will become more
clearly apparent on reading the remainder of the
description which follows, which relates to an example
of the implementation of this process and which refers
to the appended drawing.
SP 29499 SL CA 02671842 2009-06-02
Of course, this example is given solely by
way of illustration of the subject-matter of the
invention and does not under any circumstances
constitute a limitation on this subject-matter.
5 BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWING
Figure 1 schematically illustrates the
various stages of an exemplary embodiment of the
process according to the invention, in which the
surface of carbon fibres is coated with a polymer film
10 comprising thiol functional groups.
DETAILED ACCOUNT OF AN EXEMPLARY EMBODIMENT OF THE
PROCESS ACCORDING TO THE INVENTION
The present example relates to the
treatment of carbon fibres in order to coat the surface
15 thereof with a polymer film comprising thiol functional
groups.
As can be seen in Figure 1, which
schematically illustrates the stages of this treatment,
the latter comprises:
= the deposition of a film of poly(maleic
anhydride) on the surface of the fibres by pulsed
radiofrequency plasma polymerization of maleic
anhydride; and then
= the grafting of groups comprising a
thiol functional group to the film of poly(maleic
anhydride) thus obtained.
The carbon fibres used are Tenax IMS 5001
fibres sold by Toho Tenax Europe GmbH. They are ex-PAN
fibres having an intermediate modulus and which have
SP 29499 SL CA 02671842 2009-06-02
16
been subjected to a surface electrolytic oxidation
treatment during their manufacture.
The plasma polymerization of maleic
anhydride - which corresponds to stage 1 of Figure 1 -
is carried out using a PACVD device analogous to that
described by Siffer et al. in Analytica Chimica Acta,
539, 289-299, 2005 [7]. In brief, this device comprises
a cylindrical glass reactor around which are wound
coils of copper which make it possible to induce
electrical discharges in the plasma, a radiofrequency
generator and a tuning box which matches the impedance
of the reactor to that of the generator.
The carbon fibres are placed in the reactor
in the form of a tuft, the ends of which are attached
to the two opposite edges of a vertical mounting made
of board or glass.
The following operating parameters are
used:
discharge power: 5 W
pressure: 2.6 x 10-1 mbar
maleic anhydride flow rate: 1.6 x 10-9 kg.s-1
pulse on-time: 20 is
pulse off-time: 1200 is
deposition time: 30 min.
At the end of treatment, the generator is
switched off and the maleic anhydride in the vapour
phase continues to pass through the reactor for
5 minutes.
Carbon fibres are thus obtained, the
surface of which is entirely coated with a film
(referenced 10 in Figure 1) of poly(maleic anhydride)
EP 29499 SL CA 02671842 2009-06-02
17
with a thickness of 20 nm, approximately 32% of the
anhydride functional groups of which have not
polymerized.
As illustrated by stage 2 of Figure 1,
these anhydride functional groups rapidly hydrolyse in
ambient air to give carboxylic acid functional groups.
The grafting of the groups comprising a
thiol functional group - which corresponds to stage 3
of Figure 1 - is carried out by reacting these
carboxylic acid functional groups with propylene
sulphide in an organic solvent and in the presence of
triethylamine. By this reaction, two types of groups
comprising a thiol functional group, the chemical
structures of which are shown in Figure 1, are capable
of becoming attached to the poly(maleic anhydride)
film.
The solvent used is toluene, this being
because its low polarity makes it possible to limit the
occurrence of undesirable side reactions.
The reaction is carried out using 53.6 mmol
of propylene sulphide, 5.7 mmol of triethylamine and
45 ml of toluene per 0.6 g of carbon fibres.
It is carried out in an enclosed
environment, without addition of pressure, at 90 C and
for 10 hours.
In practice, a round-bottomed glass flask
is used. Stirring and the desired temperature are
provided by a heating magnetic stirrer and a magnetic
bar. Furthermore, in order to prevent the fibres from
getting in a tangle around the bar, they are placed in
the round-bottomed flask by being enclosed beforehand
SP 29499 SL CA 02671842 2009-06-02
18
in a nonwoven polypropylene bag which is permeable but
resistant to toluene.
After reacting for 10 hours, the fibres are
subjected to two washing operations with an acetic
acid/toluene (10/90, v/v) solution in order to remove
the triethylamine and finally to two washing operations
with toluene, each washing operation being rapidly
carried out in a beaker.
The fibres are subsequently subjected to a
Soxhlet extraction with toluene for 5 to 6 hours in
order to remove all the impurities liable to be present
at their surface, followed by drying at 40 C for
12 hours under low vacuum. They are then stored in
polyethylene bags which are stored in a desiccator.
The adhesion of the carbon fibres thus
treated with regard to an organic matrix obtained by
chain polymerization of a resin is assessed by a
loosening test. In order to do this, use is made of an
epoxy acrylate resin sold by UCB Chemicals under the
reference E3600.
In brief, this loosening test consists in
immersing the end of a monofilament in a microdrop of
resin, in bringing about the polymerization of the
resin at ambient temperature, either under an electron
beam or by UV irradiation, and in then exerting a
tensile stress on the other end of the monofilament, at
the rate of 1 mm/min, while keeping the drop of resin
stationary.
The tensile force is recorded over time.
The maximum tensile force recorded is regarded as the
SP 29499 SL CA 02671842 2009-06-02
19
force necessary for the loosening of the monofilament
from the cured resin drop.
The InterFacial Shear Strength (IFSS) is
determined using the following formula:
0- f d
r= ___
4L 27171
in which:
represents the diameter of the
monofilament, expressed in metres;
represents the radius of
the
monofilament, expressed in metres;
L represents the length of monofilament
initially inserted into the drop of resin, expressed in
metres;
F represents the force necessary for the
loosening of the monofilament from the cured resin
drop, expressed in newtons, and
f ¨ ________________________
2 (in newton/m2).
;Tr
The IFSS values obtained for the IMS 5001
fibres treated in accordance with the invention are
presented in Table I below.
The IFSS values obtained for, first,
IMS 5001 fibres which have not been subjected to any
treatment and, secondly, IMS 5001 fibres which have had
directly (that is to say without preliminary deposition
of a poly(maleic anhydride) film) grafted to their
surface groups containing a thiol functional group by
reaction of the carboxylic acid groups present at the
surface of these fibres with propylene sulphide under
SP 29499 SL CA 02671842 2009-06-02
conditions analogous to those described above are also
recorded in this table, by way of comparison.
TABLE 1
5
IFSS (MPa)
Fibres
Polymerization Polymerization
under an electron under UV
beam irradiation
Untreated fibres 34 + 3 49 3
Fibres grafted
with carbon-based 59 + 3
groups comprising
a thiol
functional group
Fibres treated in
accordance with 78 + 8 76 + 3
the invention
This table shows that the adhesion of
carbon fibres with regard to a matrix obtained by
polymerization of a resin under light radiation or
10 ionizing radiation is very significantly increased when
the surface of these fibres is coated beforehand with a
polymer film comprising thiol functional groups capable
of acting as chain transfer agents during the
polymerization of the resin.
15 It also shows that while, in the case of
untreated carbon fibres, the adhesion of the fibres
SP 29499 SL CA 02671842 2009-06-02
21
with regard to the matrix is substantially different
according to whether polymerization of the resin is
induced by ultraviolet irradiation or by an electron
beam, there no longer exists a significant difference
between these two methods of induction in the case of
fibres treated in accordance with the invention.
The invention is not in the least limited
to the embodiment which has just been specifically
described. Thus, for example, it is entirely possible
to envisage treating sized carbon fibres by the process
according to the invention, in which case the sizing
agent will be removed beforehand from these fibres, for
example by dissolution by solvents, as is well known in
the state of the art.
DOCUMENTS CITED
[1] JP-A-3076869
[2] EP-A-1 484 435
[3] EP-A-0 640 702
[4] JP-B-2002-327374
[5] Wu et al., Carbon, 34, 59-67, 1996
[6] Tsubokawa, Carbon, 31, 1257-1263, 1993
[7] Sifter et al., Analytica Chimica Acta, 539,
289-299, 2005
