Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02676972 2009-07-29
WO 2008/097073 PCT/NL20071050553
Dd011011-LG/td.
Method and system for establishing a telephone connection
FIELD OF THE INVENTION
The invention relates to the field of establishing a
telephone connection. More specifically, the invention relates
to the field of establishing a telephone connection between a
first subscriber device (A-subscriber device) and a second sub-
scriber device (B-subscriber device) in a telephone system
arranged for connecting said A-subscriber device and B-
subscriber device.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
Telephone calls are progressively experienced as intru-
sions in the daily life of people. Even more than e.g. e-mail
spam messages, unsolicited telephone calls are considered unde-
sired, time-consuming and annoying. Furthermore, the field of e-
mail spam prevention has seen considerable development, whereas
filters for unsolicited telephone calls appear to have advanced
less.
Therefore, various options have been considered in re-
ducing unsolicited telephone calls.
US 2006/0147014 discloses a telephone handling l.i_st for
multiple users. The handling of incoming phone calls includes
receiving an indication from one or more call recipients re-
flecting a desire to block future calls from a call source. The
call source is identified by the phone number of the call
source. A number of received indications reflecting a desire to
block future calls from the call source is determined and com-
pared to a threshold. An identifier of the call source is added
to a list of call sources from which future calls are specially
handled when the num.ber of indications meets the threshold. Han-
dling an incoming call from an undesired call source includes
receiving an indication of a call piaced to a call recipient. A
source of the call is identified. Whether the identified call
source is included in the list of call sources from which future
CA 02676972 2009-07-29
WO 2008/047073 PCT(NL2007/050553
2
calls are specially handled is determined. Special handling is
applied to the call when the identified call source is included
in the list.
The method of the prior art can be circumvented easily
by using another call source, i.e. another telephone number.
There exists a need in the art for an improved method of reduc-
unsolicited telephone calls.
ing
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
It is an object of the present invention to provide a
method and system that improves the prior art method and system
of reducing unsolicited telephone calls.
To that end, a method is proposed for establishing a
telephone connection between a first subscriber device (A-
subscriber device) and a second subscriber device (B-subscriber
device) in a telephone system. The telephone system is arranged
for connecting the A-subscriber device (the calling party) and
the B-subscriber device (the called party). The method includes
receiving a request from the A-subscriber device to establish a
connection with the B-subscriber device and also receiving a
personal identity code of a user of said A-subscriber device.
The connection can be established between the A-subscriber de-
vice and the B-subscriber device only after having received said
personal identity code of said user of said A-subscriber device.
The applicant also proposes one or more computer pro-
grams and a carrier containing one or more of these computer
programs for carrying out the method.
Furthermore, a telephone system is proposed for estab-
lishing a telephone connection between a first subscriber device
(A-subscriber device) and a second subscriber device (B-
subscriber device). The system comprises a request receiver
adapted for receiving a request from the A-subscriber device to
establish a connection with the B-subscriber device and an iden-
tity code receiver adapted for receiving a personal identity
code of a user of said A-subscriber device. Also provide'd is a
connection establisher adapted for establishing said connection
between said A-subscriber device and said B-subscriber device
CA 02676972 2009-07-29
WO 2003/047073 PCTtNL2047/050553
3
only after having received said personal identity code of said
user of said A-subscriber device.
It should be appreciated that the telephone 'system may
include a system or network of a conventional fixed system (e.g
POTS), a mobile or wireless telecommunication system, combina-
tions thereof as well as internet telephony using e.g. voice
over IP techniques (VoIP).
It should further be appreciated that the personal
identity code may comprise one or more parts.
It should also be appreciated that the telephone system
does not necessarily refer to a client-server system. The inven-
tion may also be applicable in peer-to-peer networks, such as
e.g. used for bittorrent applications, wherein a telephone sys-
tem or (some) functionality may be considered to be part of one
of more of the user devices participating in the peer-to-peer
network.
By receiving a personal identity code of a user, the
telephone system is able to actually recognize the person that
is requesting services of the system instead of only recognizing
the device that is tzsed. Consequently, the telephone system can
apply measures to a particular user instead of only to a device
as a result of the received authentication information. In other
words, measures applied to a particular users cannot be avoided
or circumvented by using a different device. An example of such
a measure may be restricting the access of a particular user to
services of the telecommunication system.
The embodiments of claims 2 and 16 provide the advan-
tage of a subscriber-only telephone system.
The embodiment of claims 3 and 17 provide the advantage
that the A-subscriber device code (e.g. the telephone number)
can be coupled to personal identity code.
The embodiments of claims 4 and 18 allows the user of
the A-subscriber device to call the B-subscriber subscriber de-
vice only if the user of the B-subscriber device is known by the
telephone system by his or her personal identity code.
The embodiments of claims 5 and 19 provides the user of
the B-subscriber device with the possibility to restrict access
CA 02676972 2009-07-29
WO 20081097073 PCTfNL20071030553
4
to the telephone system for the user of the A-subscriber device
if the telephone call is perceived by the user of the B-
subscriber device as unsolicited or undesired. Access is re-
stricted on the basis of the personal identity code of the user
of the A-subscriber device and, therefore, this user cannot sim-
ply circumvent this measure by using a different A-subscriber
device. The personal identity code may e.g. be stored such that
further attempts to establish a connection by the person owning
the code are first checked against this storage before a connec-
tion can be established.
It should be appreciated, however, that access restric-
tions may only apply if more than a single access restriction
signal has been received for a particular user, either from the
user of the same B-subscriber device or from users of other B-
subscriber devices during cther calls.
The embodiments of claims 6 and 20 define measures for
restricting the access to the telephone system. In response to
receiving the access restricting signal from the B-subscriber
device, the telephone call that triggered the user of the B-
subscriber device to issue the access restricting signal mav be
terminated. Furthermore, if multiple calls were made in parallel
(e.g. from a call centre), all these calls can be terminated.
Also, further (future) connects.onscan be prevented.
The embodiments of claims 7 and 21 provides several
mechanisms for mitigating restriction of the access rights to
the telephone system. In particular, the applicant proposes to
restrict access to the telephone system for the user of the A-
subscriber device for which the at least one access restriction
signal was received in dependence of a communication history be-
tween said user ancl said user of the B-subscription.device from
which the access restriction signal was received. As an example,
access restriction to the telephone system may be performed im-
mediately if the user of the A-subscriber device is unknown to
the user of the B-subscriber device (e.g. if the users have not
called each other previously). However, if the calling party and
called party know each other, access to the telephone system is
not restricted at once (but possibly only after several access
CA 02676972 2009-07-29
}
WO 2008/097073 PCT/NL2007/050553
restriction signals have been received for different telephone
calJ.s). The communication history between users of the telephone
system can be traced on the basis of the received personal i.den-
tity codes.
5 The embodiments of ciaims 8 and 22 provides another
measure for mitigating access restriction to the telephone sys-
tem for the user of the A-subscriber device.
'
The embodiments of claims 9 and 23 provide the advan-
tage that the user of the A-subscriber device may be warned in
~(7 advance of the access restriction. A pre-programmed warning sig-
nal may be provided.
The embodiments of claims 10 and 24 allows that the re-
cipient of a telephone call determines whether other future
recipients may receive telephone calls from the user of the A-
a5 subscriber device.
The embodiments of claims 11 and 25 prevent sniffing of
personal identity codes. Secured communication can be obtained
by e.g. encrypting data and/or by using secure connections.
The embodiments of claims 12 and 26 provide subscribers
20 with the possibility to approve telephone communication with
each other prior to establishing the telephone connection. In
particular, users may use their telephones to dial each others
number (possibly in combination with the personal identity
codes). If the telephone system receives the telephone numbers
25 and the personal identity, the approval may be deemed to be
given. Reference is made to a co-pending international patent
application of the applicant ("Method and system for prior ap-
proval of telephone communicat'Lon") filed on the same date as
the present application, the contents of the international ap-
30 plication being incorporated in the present application by
reference in its entirety.
The invention also relates to a telephone device for
use in the method and system as described above. In particular,
the telephony device should be adapted to issue the personal
35 identity code to the telephone system for setting up the connec-
tion.
CA 02676972 2009-07-29
WO 2008/097073 PCT/iKL2007/050553
6
Hereinafter, embodiments of the invention will be de-
scribed in further detail. It should be appreciated, however,
that these embodiments may not be construed as limiting the
scope of protection for the present invention.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
In the drawings:
FIG. 1 is a schematic illustration of a communication
system for performing a method according to an embodiment of the
invention;
FIG. 2 is a schematic illustration of,a telephone sys-
tem according to an embodiment of the invention;
FIG. 3 is a schematic illustration of a telephone de-
vice according to an embodiment of the invention;
FIG. 4 is a time diagram illustrating steps of a method
according to a first embodiment of the invention;
FIG. 5 is a time diaqram illustrating steps of a method
according to a second embodiment of the invention;
FIG. 6 is a time diagram illustrating steps of a method
according to a third embodiment of the invention; and
FIG. 7 is a time diagram illustrating steps of a method
according to a fourth embodiment of the invention.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
Details about telecommunication infrastructures and
procedures for establishing and terminating a telephone connec-
tion
are assumed to be known to the skilled person and will not
be described. As an example, for GSM telephony, reference is
made to the book "The GSM System for Mobile Communications" by
M. Mouly and M. Pautet, 1992 (ISBN 2-9057190-0-7). For UMTS te-
lephony, reference is made to the book "WCDMA for UMTS"; edited
by Harri Holma and Antti Toskala, 2001 (ISBN 0 471 48687 6) FIG. 1 shows a
telephone infrastructure 1 comprising a
telephone system 2. The telephone system 2, which may e.g. com-
prise a server, is connected via a first telecommunication =
network 3 to an A-subscriber device 4 and via a second telecom-
munication network 5 to a B-subscriber device 6. The first and
CA 02676972 2009-07-29
WO 2008/097073 PCT/NL2007/050553
7
second telecommunication networks 3, 5 may comprise one or more
wired or wireless networks. In the situation of FIG. 1, the A-
subscriber device 4 is connected to the telephone system 2 via a
wired network, whereas the B-subscriber device 6 is partly con-
nected via a wireless access network. The telephone
infrastructure 1 may also be suitable for internet telephony,
including VoIP telephony. The A-subscriber device 4 and B-
subscriber device 6 may be any type of device suitable for te-
lephony communication. The telephone system 2 enables the
establishment of a telephone connection via the networks 3 and 5
between the A-subscriber device 4 and the B-subscriber device 6.
of course, networks 3 and 5 may be the same network or networks
using the same technology. In accordance with telephony conven-
tion, the A-subscriber device 4 (the call source) is assumed to
be used by the calling party and the B-subscriber device (the
call destination)is assumed to be used by the called party.
The specific functions of the telephone system 2 are
schematically illustrated i.n FIG. 2 and will now be described in
further detail. The telephone system 2 comprises a processor 10
and a memory 11 and is configured to allow communication with
both the A-subscriber device and the B-subscriber device via the
networks 3, 5. It should be appreciated that the telephone sys-
tem 2 is normally capable of connecting to more than the two
telephone devices shown in FIG. 1. It should also be appreciated
that the functions may be largely implemented as software code
portions of one or more computer programs executed by the proc-
essor 10 (tasks may be distributed over multiple processors).
The telep:^aone server 2 comprises a request receiver 13
adapted for receiving a request from the A-subscriber device 4
to establish a connection with the B-subscriber device 6. The
telephone server 2 a:.so comprises an identity code receiver 14
adapted for receiving a personal identity code of a user of the
A-subscriber device 4 and a connection establisher 15 adapted
for establishing the connection between the A-subscriber device '
4 and the B-subscriber device 6 only after receiving the per-
sonal identity code of the user of the A-subscriber device 4.
Although for individual consumers, each user (or family) pref-
CA 02676972 2009-07-29
WO 2008/097073 PCT/ATL20070050553
8
erably owns a unique personal identity code, it may in some case
be advantageous to assign a common identity code to groups of
users (e.g. companies), such as call centres, in order to allow
measures being applied to a call centre in its entirety.
The telephone system also contains a storage module 16
for storing the personal identity code of the user of the A-
subscriber device 4. The personal identity code may be pre-
stored in the storage module, e.g. while entering a subscription
of the user for use of the telephone system 2. A determination
module 17 is provided that is adapted for determining if the
personal identity code received by the identity code receiver 14
matches the personal identity code stored by the storage module
16. The processor 10 may be programmed such that the connection
establisher 15 only establishes the connection between the A-
subscriber device 4 and the B-subscriber device 6 if the per-
sonal identity code received by the personal identity code
receiver 14 matches the personal identity code stored by the
storage module 16.
The telephone system 2 also contains a device code re-
ceiver 18 adapted for receiving a code of the A-subscriber
device 4. The device code e.g. comprises the telephone number of
the A-subscriber device 4, a code similar to a telephone number
(e.g. the IMSI) andfor a hardware code (such as the IMEI number
or a MAC adress of the A-subscriber device 4). It should be ap-
preciated that the device code may also be a common code of a
call centre.
The storage modudule 16 may also be configured for
storing at least a personal identity code of a user of the B-
subscriber device. Again, the storage module 16 may pre-store
such a code on entering the subscription of the user of the B-
subscriber device 6 in the telephone system 2. The request re-
ceiver 13 may be adapted for filtering a telephone number of the
B-subscriber device 6.from the request for establishing the
telephone connection. The telephone system 2 may be arranged
such that the connection establisher 15 establishes the tele-
phone connection only if the storage module 16 has stored the
personal identity code of the user of the B-subscriber device 6
CA 02676972 2009-07-29
WO 2008/097073 PCT/NL20071050553
9
for the received telephone number. This link can e.g. be made
via the telephone number of the B-subscriber device 6 that i_s
received by the request receiver 13.
The availability of the personal identity code of the
users of the A-subscriber device 4 and/or the B-subscriber de-
vice 6 allows the telephone system 2 to identify users
requesting services from the telephone system 2. The users may
be connected to devices by the telephone system 2, e.g, by link-
ing the received personal identity code to one or more known
device codes or bv receiving the device code from the A-
subscriber device 4 and/or B-subscriber device 6 in the nrocess
of establishing a connection or during the connection. The
availability of the personal identity code (possibly in combina-
tion with other identity codes and/or one or more device codes) 15 provides
the telephone system 2 with the possibility to trigger
actions directed to one or more particular users.
In particular, the telephone system 2 comprises an ac-
cess restriction receiver 19 adapted for receiving one or more
access restriction signals. The telephone system 2 also com-
prises an access restrictor 20 adapted to restrict access to the
telephone system 2 for the user of said A-subscriber device 4 in
response to receiving the one or more access restriction sig-
nals. If the access restriction receiver 19 receives an access
restriction signal (e.g. from the B-subscriber device 6), the
telephone system 2 determines the personal identity code of the
user of the A-subscriber device 4 that was engaged in the tele-
phone call and for which the access restriction signal was
received. The personal identity code is remembered, e.g. by
flagging the personal identity code of user of the A-subscriber
device 4 (or an associated field) in a database or by storing
the personal identity code of the user of the A-subscriber de-
vice 4 in a separate register.
There exist various possibilities for restricting ac-
cess to the telephone system 2.
The telephone system 2 may have a connecti..on terminator
21 adapted for terminating the ongoing connection with the A-
subscriber device 4. The connection terminator 21 may also be
d t
CA 02676972 2009-07-29
WO 2008J097073 PCTINi,2007(050553
configured for terminating one or more co-existing connections
with the A-subscriber device 4. The latter option may be used if
the user of the A-subscriber device 4 for which the access re-
striction signal was received was engaged in multiple calls. In
5 this situation, each of these calls may be terminated. It should
be clear that the user of the A-subscriber device 4 was not nec-
essarily the calling party in all these multiple calls.
In particular, the telephone system 2 may also contain
a connedtion preventor 2 2 adapted for preventing establishment
10 of further connections for user of said A-subscriber device 4.
That is, if the user of the A-subscriber device 4 desires to
make another call and if the telephone system 2 identifies the
user as being flagged in response to receiving one or more ac-
cess restrictions signals for this user, the connection
preventor 22 prevents that a telephone connection is established
with the desired B-subscriber device. It should be clear that
this measure cannot be circumvented by using a different A-
subscriber device 4, since also for the further call the per-
sonal identity code should be sent before, with or followi.ng the
request for establishing a telephone connection. The telephone
system 2 will then determine that a telephone connection should
not be set up for this user.
Moreover, the connection preventor 22 may, alterna-
tively or in addition to the measure described in the previous
paragraph, prevent that the user of the A-subscriber device 4 is
called (i.e. the user of the A-subscriber device 4 is now a
calling party). The storage module 16 of the telephone system 2
stores one or more telephone numbers (or associated information)
of the A-subscriber device and links one or more of these tele-
phone riuinbers to the personal iderltity code. If a request is
made to establish a telephone connection with a B-subscriber de-
vice, the telephone system 2 determines the personal identity
code linked to the telephone numbe.r_ of the A-subscriber device
4. If the telephone system 2 determines that access restrictions
apply for the user being assigned this personal identity code,
the connection will not be established by using the connection
CA 02676972 2009-07-29
WO 2068l097073 PCTlNL2007(050553
11
preventor 22. The calling party may be informed of this situa-
tion by the telephone system 2.
If a company or another group of people is assigned a
common personal identity code, the measures may apply to the
company or group. It is also possible to combine a common code
of a particular company or group with a personal code of a user
within that company or group. Measures may then either apply to
the company or group (on the basis of the common personal iden-
tity code) andlor to a person of the company or group (on the
basis of the personal identity code). As an example, a company
may receive a warning signal from the telephone system 2 on the
basis of the common personal..i..dentity code of the company, while
the above measures apply in full to a particular user of that
company that was engaged in the teleptione call during which the
access restriction signal was received. The telephone system 2
is aware of both the company identity code and the personal
ident.:i..ty code in such a situation.
It should be appreciated that the measures described in
the previous paragraphs do not necessarily apply already in re-
sponse to a single access restriction signal. The number of
access restriction signals before access to the telephone system
2 is restricted may be set. As an example, 50, 25, 10, 5, 2 or 1
acess restriction signals may need to be received by the tele-
phone system 2 for a particular personal identity code before
access is restricted to the telephone system, 2.
It will be clear that the measures described above can
be harsh for a particular user of the A-subscriber device 4.
This is particularly true if receipt of a single access restric-
tion signal (or only a few) is sufficient for the telephone
system 2 to restrict access. To mitigate this situation, the
telephone system 2 comprises an assessor module 23. The assessor
module 23 is adapted to control the access restrictor 20 such
that restricting access to the telephone system 2 for the user
of the A-subscriber device 4 is e.g. dependent on the number of
times that access has been restricted for this user and/or the
number of access restriction signals that have been received for
CA 02676972 2009-07-29
WO 2008/097073 PCTlNI,2007I050553
12
this user. Also, the telephone system 2 may be configured to re-
strict access for a particular time period, using a timer 24
In particular, the telephone system 2 is configured to
take account of a telephone communication history between the
user of the A-subscriber device 4 and the user of the B-
subscriber device 6 from which the access restriction signal was
received. As an example, access restriction to the telephone
system 2 may be performed immediately if the user of the A-
subscriber device 4 is unknown to the user of the B-subscriber
device 6 (e.g. if the users have not called each other previ-
ously) and this user transmits an access restriction signal.
However, if the calling party and the called party know each
other, access to the telephone system 2 is not restricted at
once (but possibly only after several access restriction signals
have been received for different telephone calls, either from
the same user of the B-subscriber device or from other users).
The assessor module 23, therefore, is configured to keep track
of past phone calls between users (e.g. on the basis of the per-
sonal identity codes of the calling and called parties).
The telephone system 2 may also comprise a warning sig-
nal transmitter 25 adapted for providing a warning signal to the
user of the A-subscriber device 4 in response to receiving one
or more access restriction signals. The warning signal may con-
tain information for the user of the A-subscriber device 4 of
possible consequences of further violations. The warning signal
may be transmitted to the A-subscriber device 4 or to another
device when information is avai..]..able how this device can be ad-
dressed. As an example, if the telephone system 2 has
information of an e-mail address of the user of the A-subscriber
device 4, the warning message may be transmitted to this e-mail
address.
Of course, the telephone system 2 may be capable of
connecting multiple subscriber devices. In particular, the tele-
phone system 2 may be arranged for establishing a corinectian
35. with a first B-subscriber device and with a second B-subscriber
device. The access restriction signal receiver 19 may be adapted
for receiving an access restriction signal from the first B-
CA 02676972 2009-07-29
WO 2008!017073 PCT/NL20071450553
13
subscriber device. The connection preventor 22 can be configured
to prevent the second B-subscriber device from receiving tele-
phone calls from a user of the A-subscriber device 4 in response
to receiving said one or more access restriction signals. In
other words, a called party may determine the access of other
future called parties to telephone calls of an A-subscriber de-
vice 4 for which one or more asccess restriction signals were
received.
The telephone system 2 is arranged for receiving at
least the personal identity codes in a secured manner using e.g.
secured connections, data encryption techniques or a combination
of both. These measures reduce the chance that personal ideitity
codes are intercepted by third parties.
The telephone system 2 coiTrprises an approval module 26
adapted for receiving a first approval signal froait a user of A-
subscriber device 4 for telephone communication with a user of
the B-subscriber device 6 and for receiving a second approval
signal from the user of the B-subscriber device 6 for telephone
communication with the user of the A-subscriber device 4. The
approval module 26 controls the connection establisher 7.5 such
that a telephone connection can be established only if both the
first and second approval signal have been received. If an ap-
proval signal is received, the timer 24 may be used to set a
time limit within which the approval signal of the other user
should be received to update the status of the telephone system
2 that a telephone connection is allowed to be established be-
tween the users that have mutually approved future telephone
calls from each other. I;: is noted that the approval module 26
may also be applied independently from receiving personal iden-
tity codes. As an example, the approval may be based on the
telenhone numbers of the A-subscriber device 4 and B-subscriber
device 6 alone.
FIG. 3 is a schematic illustration of a telephone de-
vice, e.g. the A-subscriber device 4 or the B-subscriber device
6 of FIG. 1.
The A-subscriber device 4 contains a processor 30, a
memory 31 (e.g. internal memory, a SIM card or another memory
CA 02676972 2009-07-29
WO 20081097073 PCT/NL2007J050553
14
card) and a keyboard 32. Of course, the A-subscriber device 4
may comprise other cornponents, such as a display.
As explained above, the A-subscriber device 4 should be
capable of transmitting a personal identity code to the tele-
phone system 2. The personal identity code can be made available
in various ways.
.T.n a first example, the personal identity code can be
entered by the user using the keyboard 32. This code can be
stored in the memory 31 and be made available for use when send-
ing a request to establish a telephone connection to the
telephone system 2.
In a second example, the personal identity code may be
entered by the user of the A-subscriber device 4 with the key-
board 32 in combination with the telephone number of the B-
subscriber device 6 with which a connection is sought.
In a third example, the personal identity code is al-
ready stored in Lhe memory 31. Most telep:llone devices allow that
the telephone device may be operated orily after entering a per-
sonal identity number (PIN) or password. The personal identity
code can be made available or retrieved from the memory 31 in
dependence of entering the correct PIN or password. The personal
identity code is available until a PIN or password should be en-
tered. again (e.g. if the telephone device has been switched off
and on again}. In this example, if multiple PINS or passwords
are valid for various users of a single telephone device, sev-
eral personal identity codes may be stored and made available,
linked to the PIN or password, for a single device for multiple
users.
Furthermore, the telephone device 4, 6 may be config-
ured to transmit an access restriction signal to the telephone
system 2 if the user of the telephone device perceives an incom-
phone call as unsolicited or undesired. An access
ing
restriction signal may e.g. be transmitted by operating a dedi-
cated key, a soft key related to a particular function indicated
on a display of the telephone device or a special combination of
keys.
Y w CA 02676972 2009-07-29
WO 20681097073 PCTIlYL2007/050553
L .J
It should be clear that.further examples can be envis-
aged. The telephone device should be configured such that at
least one personal identity code can be transmitted to the tele-
phone system 2. The telephone device may also be configured to
~ transmit a device code, such as the telephone number or related
information.
In tiie sequel of the description, some examples of the
operation of the telephone system 2 will be given with reference
to FIGS. 4-7. It should be appreciated that these examples, or
the steps thereof, may be combined or applied in isolation.
In FIG. 4, in step 40 a request is receivea by the re-
quest receiver 13 of the telephone system 2 from the A-
subscriber device 4 for establishing a telephone connection with
the B-subscriber device 6. In step 41, the personal identity
code of the use.r of the A-subscriber device 4 is also received
by the identity code receiver 14. Of course, the personal iden-
tity code may be received before the request, simultaneously
with the request or after the request for establishing a tele-
phone connection. In response to receiving the personal identity
code, the telephone connection with the B-subscriber device 6 is
established in step 42 using the connection establisher 15.
If the user of the S-subscriber device 6 perceives the
call as desired, the phone call is continued until either of the
parties terminates the connection.
If the user of the B-subscriber device 6 perceives the
call as unsolicited or undesired, the user of the B-subscriber
device 6 may operate the deviCe 6 to transmit an access restric-
tion signal. The access restriction signal receiver 19 of the
telephone system 2 receives the access, restriction signal from
the B-subscriber device 6 in step 43.
The telephone system 2 may restrict access to the user
of the A-subscriber device 4 in various ways.
In FIG. 4, in response to receiving the access restric-
tion signal, the access restrictor 20 blocks the access to the
telephone system 2, indicated by the arrow 44, possibly after
operating the assessor module 23 as described above. Access is
CA 02676972 2009-07-29
WO 20081097073 PCT/NL260711150553
16
restricted by flagging the personal identity code of the user of
the A-subscriber device 4.
If the user of the A-subscriber device 4 attempts to
make another call using the telephone system 2, the device used
by this user should again transmit the personal identity code of
this user. Upon determining that a flag exists for this particu-
lar identity code by the determination module 17, the connection
preventor 22 prevents establishing of a telephone connection for
this subsequent call, indicated by the cross in step 45.
In FIG. 5, step 50 indicates that the telephone system
2 receives the request from the A-subscriber device 4.f..o.r estab-
lishing a telephone connection with the B-subscriber device 6 in
combination wi.th the pe..r.sonal identity code of the user of the
A-subscriber device 4. Step 51 indicates the establishment of
the telephone connection, whereas step 52 again indicates re-
ceiving an access restriction signal from the B-subscriber
device 6 by the access restriction signal receiver 19.
The form of access restriction to the telephone system
2 in F'IG. 5 is different from FIG. 4 (and may thus be applied
instead or in combination with the access restriction illus-
trated and described with reference to FIG. 4).
In FIG. 5, the access restriction signal from the B-
subscriber device 6 triggers the telephorie system 2 to prevent a
connection with another B-subscriber device 6 (indicated as B2).
If the user of the A-subscriber device 4, after one or more ac-
cess restrictions signals have been received, tries to make
another telephone call (either with the same telephorie device or
with another telephone device) to telephone device B2 in step
53, his request for connection and the personal identity code
are received by the telephone system 2. The telephone system 2
determines that the user that was assigned the personal identity
code has been flagged as having received one or more access re-
striction signals. As a consequence, the telephone connection
with telephone device B2 is not established (indicated by the
cross in step 54). Similarly, a new telephone connection with
the B-subscriber device 6 can not be established (steps 55 and
56).
CA 02676972 2009-07-29
WO 2008/497073 PCT/NL20071050553
17
In contrast with the embodiment of FIG. 4, in the
situation of E'Ir, 5, the user of the A-subscriber device 4 may
sti.ll be able to establish a telephone connection with other
telephone devices. Whereas access to the telephone device B2 in
FIG. 5 has been restricted (e.g. because the telephone number of
telephone device B2 was explicitly indicated by a user of the B-
subscriber device 6 that transmitted the original access re-
striction signal upon determination in the telephone system 2),
other telephone devices may still be called. As an example, the
telephone system 2 in the embodirnent of FIG. 5 may still enable
the user of the A-subscriber device 4 to establish a telephone
connection to emergency telephone numbers and/or to another se-
lected group of numbers. on the other hand, the user of the A-
subscriber device 4 may only be excluded from making a telephor_e
connection with a selected group of telephone devices or devices
of a particular group of users (possibly indicated by their per-
sonal identity codes). Of course, the selected group may involve
all subscribers.
In FIG. 6, step 60 indicates that the telephone system
2 receives the request from the A-subscriber device 4 for estab-
li.sh.i..ng a telephone connection with the B-subscriber device 6 in
combination with the personal identity code of the user of the
A-subscriber device 4. Step 61 indicates the establishmentof
the telephone connection, whereas step 62 again indicates re-
ceiving an access restriction signa'. from the B-subscriber
device 6 by the acccss restriction signal receiver 19.
The form of access restriction to the telephone systern
2 in FIG. 6 is different frorn FIGS. 4 and 5 (and may thus be ap-
plied instead or in combination with the access restriction
illustrated arnd described with reference to FIG. 4 and/or FIG.
5).
In the embodiment of FIG. 6, the user of the A-
subscriber device 4 for which the o.r.iginal. access restriction
signal has been received is excluded from receiving telephone
calls. If the user of the telephone device B2 attempts to make a
telephone call to the user of the A-subscriber device 4 (step
63), the telephone system 2 will find a flag for the user of the
CA 02676972 2009-07-29
WO 2008/097073 PCT(1YL2007/050553
telephone number of the A-subscriber device 4(and possibly
other telephone numbers).. In reactiori to this finding, the tele-
phone system 2, more particularly the connection preventor 22,
wilJ. prevent in step 64 a telephone connection to be established
with the A-subscriber device 4 (or with the other telephone num-
bers stored in relation to the personal identity code of the
user).
It should be appreciated that in the embodiments of
FIGS. 4-6, the described access restriction may take place by
the access restrictor 20 in response to receiving one or more
access restriction signals by the access restriction signal re-
ceiver 19. In general, but particuiarly if only a single or a
few access restriction signals are sufficient to restrict access
for the user, the access restrictor 20 may be controlled by the
assessor module 23 as described with reference to FIG. 2
Finally, FIG. 7 shows an embodiment using the approval
module 26. It should be noted that this einbodiment can be ap-
plied indcpendently of the use of a personal identity code of
the user of the A-subscriber device 4, although use of this code
is illustrated in FIG. 7.
In FIG. 7, the user of A-subscriber device 4 may re-
quest establishing a telephone connection with the B-subscriber
device 6. This request and the personal identity code of the
user of the A-subscriber device 4 are received in steps 70 and
71. The approval module 26 interprets the request as a first ap-
proval signal for tel.ephone coinmunication with the user of the
B-subscri.ber device 6. The connection establisher 15 does not
yet actually establish the telephone connection, until a corre-
sponding request is received from the B-subscriber device 6
(indicated by steps 72 and 73). This request is interpreted as a
second approval signal for telephone communication with the user
of the B-subscriber device 6. If both approval signals are re-
the connection establisher .1_5 allows establishirig a
telephone connection between the A-subscriber device 4 and the.
B-subscriber device 6(step 74). The telephone connection does
not have to be established immediately.
CA 02676972 2009-07-29
WO 2008I097073 PCT(NI.2007l050553
19
The telephone system 2 may apply the timer 24 to set a
validity period of the f-irst approval signal. If the second ap-
prova3. signal is received in the validity period, the
establishment of a telephone connection is allowed. In order to
make the user of the other tele-ohone device aware of the exis-
tence of the first approval signal, the telephone system. 2 may
apply a notification signal to alert the user of the B-
subscriber device 6. The validity period may be set to e.g. one
hour, one day, one week or two weeks.
1C
