Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02725353 2010-11-23
WO 2009/148824
PCT/US2009/044616
DISTRIBUTED VIBRATION SENSING SYSTEM USING MULTIMODE FIBER
BACKGROUND
[0001] Coherent Rayleigh noise (CRN) acquisition is a technique usable in
an
optical time domain reflectometry (OTDR) system which allows very small
changes in
the length and/or temperature of an optical fiber to be detected. As changes
in the length
of the optical fiber may be related to strain and/or a disturbance imparted on
the fiber, a
CRN acquisition system can be particularly useful to measure parameters
indicative of a
problem or potential problem with an elongate structure in proximity to the
optical fiber,
such as an energy cable, a pipeline, etc. As one example, CRN can be used to
detect an
encroachment, on an energy cable, for example caused by inadvertent or
deliberate
digging in the vicinity of the cable. In addition, it could be used to detect
partial
discharge (PD) through either the vibration induced by PD or the heat
generated. Because
partial discharge occurs in energy cables prior to complete installation
failure, the
vibration caused by the partial discharge can be detected via a CRN technique,
thus
enabling remedial action to be taken prior to damage or failure occurring. CRN
also has
applications in intrusion detection, as well as in the detection of acoustic
events, such as
flow-induced noise. Yet further, when used in conjunction with a distributed
temperature
sensor (DTS) system, data obtained from DTS installations may be refined based
on a
distributed measurement of vibration or disturbance obtained from the CRN
measurement.
[0002] To our knowledge, no commercial installations exist where DTS and
CRN
are used simultaneously. The most common approach to DTS has been Raman OTDR,
with some suppliers also offering Raman optical frequency-domain reflectometry
(OFDR). Traditionally, DTS measurements over moderate distances (e.g., up to
10km)
have been carried out on multimode fiber, owing to the higher backscatter
factor in these
fibers, i.e. the higher ratio of usable Raman signal returned to the energy
launched into
1
CA 02725353 2010-11-23
WO 2009/148824
PCT/US2009/044616
the fiber. There are many thousands of DTS installations worldwide using
multimode
fiber.
[0003] In contrast, it has hitherto been thought that CRN measurements
required a
single mode fiber to provide a high contrast as a result of a single spatial
mode.
However, the use of single-mode fiber for DTS measurements degrades the
performance
(relative to that obtainable on multimode fiber) in Raman systems, at least
over moderate
distances. Thus an installation requiring DTS and CRN in the same region of
interest
would generally require two separate fibers: a multimode fiber for DTS
measurements
and a single-mode fiber for CRN measurements. The installation of separate
fibers,
however, is not particularly desirable, particularly in terms of cost, as well
as in terms of
the engineering required to install additional fibers. Alternatively, because
the use of
multimode fibers for CRN measurements has been avoided since multimode fibers
do not
produce Rayleigh backscatter that has sufficient contrast for phase changes to
be detected
by a data acquisition system, a single single-mode fiber could be employed for
both DTS
and CRN measurements. However, such an arrangement will result in a compromise
in
the DTS performance. Because of these limitations, pre-existing DTS
installations using
multimode fiber have been unavailable to use for CRN measurements because of
the
nature of the fiber in place.
SUMMARY
[0004] In an embodiment of the invention, an OTDR system for sensing a
disturbance to an elongate structure comprises a multimode sensing optical
fiber disposed
proximate the elongate structure, and an optical source configured to output a
pulse of
light for launching into the multimode sensing optical fiber. The system
further includes
a data acquisition system to detect Rayleigh backscattered light produced by
the
multimode sensing optical fiber in response to the pulse of light. The data
acquisition
system is configured to detect a single spatial mode of the Rayleigh
backscattered light
2
CA 02725353 2013-12-23
78543-334
and to produce a signal indicative of a disturbance to the elongate structure
based on the
detected single spatial mode of the Rayleigh backscattered light.
[0005] In accordance with another embodiment of the invention, a
method for sensing
a disturbance to an elongate structure comprises providing a multimode sensing
optical fiber
disposed proximate the elongate structure, and launching a pulse of light into
the multimode
fiber. The method further comprises detecting a single spatial mode of
Rayleigh backscattered
light produced by the multimode fiber in response to the pulse of light, and
producing a signal
indicative of a disturbance of the elongate structure based on the detected
single spatial mode.
[0005a] In accordance with another embodiment of the invention, there
is provided an
optical time domain reflectometry (OTDR) system, comprising: a multimode
sensing optical
fiber; an optical source configured to output a pulse of light for launching
into the multimode
sensing optical fiber; an optical detector; and a single spatial mode
filtering system coupled
between the multimode sensing optical fiber and the optical detector, the
single spatial mode
filtering system configured to select for detection by the optical detector a
single speckle of
Rayleigh backscattered light produced by the multimode sensing optical fiber
in response to
the pulse of light.
[0005b] In accordance with another embodiment of the invention, there
is provided a
method for sensing a disturbance to an elongate structure, comprising:
providing a multimode
sensing optical fiber disposed proximate the elongate structure; launching a
pulse of light into
the multimode sensing optical fiber; selecting a single speckle of Rayleigh
backscattered light
produced by the multimode sensing optical fiber in response to the pulse of
light; and
generating a signal indicative of a disturbance to the elongate structure
based on the selected
single speckle.
[0005c] In accordance with another embodiment of the invention, there
is provided a
method of retrofitting an optical time domain reflectometry (OTDR)
installation having a
multimode sensing optical fiber deployed proximate an elongate structure, an
optical source
for launching a pulse of light into the multimode sensing optical fiber, and
an optical detector
for detecting Rayleigh backscattered light produced by the multimode sensing
optical fiber in
3
CA 02725353 2013-12-23
78543-334
response to the launched pulse of light, the method comprising: coupling a
single spatial mode
filtering system between the multimode sensing optical fiber and the optical
detector, wherein
the single spatial mode filtering system is configured to select a single
speckle of the Rayleigh
backscattered light produced by the multimode sensing optical fiber in
response to the
launched pulse of light.
[0006] Other or alternative features will become apparent from the
following
description, from the drawings, and from the claims.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0007] Fig. 1 is a graph illustrating the loss in contrast when a
multimode fiber is used
for CRN measurements as compared to a single-mode fiber.
[0008] Fig. 2 is a block diagram of a prior art OTDR system with CRN
acquisition
that is implemented using a single mode sensing optical fiber.
[0009] Fig. 3 is a block diagram of an OTDR system with CRN
acquisition using a
multimode sensing optical fiber, in accordance with an embodiment of the
invention.
[0010] Fig. 4 is a block diagram of an exemplary embodiment of the OTDR
system of
Fig. 3, in accordance with an embodiment of the invention.
[00111 Fig. 5 is a block diagram of another exemplary embodiment of
the OTDR
system of Fig. 3, in accordance with an embodiment of the invention.
[0012] Fig. 6 is a block diagram of a coherent detection arrangement
used with the
system of Fig. 3, in accordance with an embodiment of the invention.
3a
CA 02725353 2010-11-23
WO 2009/148824
PCT/US2009/044616
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0013] Detection or monitoring of parameters over the length of an elongate
structure can be achieved by deploying one or more optical fibers along the
structure and
using optical time domain reflectometry (OTDR). OTDR involves launching an
appropriate optical signal into a sensing optical fiber and then detecting
returned signals
which could be indicative of a problem or a potential problem with the
elongate structure.
For instance, the acquisition of coherent Rayleigh noise can be used to
monitor generally
fast-changing parameters, such as strain or vibration transients that may
result from third-
party interference events, natural phenomena, partial discharge events, etc.
[0014] In typical CRN detection systems, a highly coherent and frequency-
stable
optical source launches a pulse of light into the sensing optical fiber. The
resulting
Rayleigh backscattered signal is observed as a function of time that has
elapsed from the
launching of the pulse. As a result of the long coherence length of the
source,
backscattered light from different scatterers within a section of the optical
fiber defined
by the pulse duration have a stable phase relationship and interference occurs
at a
detector. The interference process provides a high contrast from which
information can
be extracted, but only if there is a vector summation of the electric field re-
radiated by
each scatter resulting in a high contrast. Generally, it has been thought that
the high
contrast could only be achieved using a single-mode fiber. More particularly,
when a
multimode fiber is used, the near field of the multimode backscatter that is
detected by
the detection system consists of a number of spots or speckles, each of which
has a phase
that is random relative to that of other spots. When this light reaches the
detector, each of
the spots has a good contrast. However, the summation of the spots tends to a
mean
value. In mathematical terms, each spot (assuming a single polarization) has a
negative
exponential probability distribution and the sum of the intensity of multiple
spots has a F
distribution as given in the equation below:
4
CA 02725353 2010-11-23
WO 2009/148824
PCT/US2009/044616
/3/ (1) = /(m-1) exp(¨MI/ I) /[(M ¨ 1)!(// M)m II 0
= 0 otherwise
[0015] For a single-mode fiber, M = 1 (or 2, if two polarizations are
present).
However, in multimode fibers, the number of spots is typically more than 100
and the
probability distribution is approximated by a Gaussian distribution, with the
values
tightly distributed around the mean. Thus, for a multimode fiber, the contrast
in the
detected signal all but disappears. This reduction in contrast between a
single-mode fiber
and a multimode fiber is illustrated in the graph 10 of Fig. 1, where it can
be seen that the
probability distribution narrows substantially as the number of spots and/or
polarizations
"M" increase. Accordingly, in general, coherent OTDR in a multimode optical
fiber does
not result in the same contrast- and phase-sensitive effects as exist for
single-mode fibers,
owing to the phase averaging over multiple spots. Because of this phase
averaging, CRN
acquisition techniques have generally been thought to not be suited for use
with
multimode fibers.
[0016] Turning now to Fig. 2, a block diagram of a prior art coherent OTDR
system
that detects Rayleigh backscatter is shown. The OTDR system 100 includes a
narrow
band pulsed optical source 102 which is configured to launch a pulse of light
into a
single-mode sensing optical fiber 104 through a beam splitter 106. In the
embodiment
illustrated, the sensing fiber 104 is deployed proximate an elongate structure
113.
However, in other embodiments, the fiber 104 may be coupled with or contained
with the
structure 113.
[0017] Referring still to Fig. 2, reflections from various scatterers in
the sensing
optical fiber 104, such as Brillouin backscatter, Raman backscatter, and
coherent
Rayleigh noise, are directed to a data acquisition system 107 by the beam
splitter 106. In
the embodiment illustrated in Fig. 2, the data acquisition system 107 includes
an optical
detector 108 that detects the reflected signals, an amplification and
acquisition system
CA 02725353 2010-11-23
WO 2009/148824
PCT/US2009/044616
110 that amplifies and acquires the desired signals detected by the optical
detector 108,
and a signal processing unit 112 that processes the acquired data and converts
it into
information that corresponds to various detected conditions, such as a
vibration or
disturbance, that may provide information about the state of an elongate
structure 113
proximate to which the sensing optical fiber 104 is deployed. This information
may be
output from the signal processing unit 112 as an output signal 118 that is
indicative of the
detected condition. For instance, the output signal 118 may be provided to a
user
interface, stored in a memory of a data storage system, etc.
[0018] As explained above, if the optical fiber in Fig. 2 were a multimode
optical
fiber, essentially no contrast may be detected in the interference from the
coherent
Rayleigh noise that is detected at the detector 108. Accordingly, the
arrangement
illustrated in Fig. 2 is not well-suited to detecting vibration or
disturbances when the
sensing optical fiber 104 is of the multimode type. However, in accordance
with an
embodiment of the invention, it is possible to modify or retrofit the fiber
infrastructure of
Fig. 2 when a multimode fiber is in place in an existing installation such
that CRN
techniques may be used. Such modification may be particularly useful since
there are
many existing installations of multimode optical fibers used for DTS and other
applications in existing infrastructures, such as energy cables, railway
tunnels, liquefied
unloading pipelines, process vessels, etc. By modifying the existing fiber
infrastructure,
these previously installed multimode optical fibers may be used for a CRN
acquisition
system either alone or in combination with a DTS acquisition system.
[0019] Turning now to Fig. 3, an exemplary embodiment of the invention is
shown
in which an existing multimode fiber infrastructure has been modified to
provide for use
of a multimode optical fiber as the sensing optical fiber in an OTDR system
used for
CRN measurements. Specifically, as shown in Fig. 3, a single spatial mode
filtering
system 120 that forces selection of a single speckle from the returned
Rayleigh
backscatter is placed in the path between a multimode sensing optical fiber
116 and a
6
CA 02725353 2010-11-23
WO 2009/148824
PCT/US2009/044616
data acquisition system 107. Such a single spatial mode filtering system 120
also
eliminates the phase variation arising from collecting multiple speckle spots,
thus
ensuring good contrast of the resulting coherent backscatter signal.
[0020] In addition to modifying the existing fiber infrastructure by adding
the
single spatial mode filtering system 120, the optical source 102 and the data
acquisition
system 107 also may be modified as necessary to appropriately interrogate and
acquire
the information from the Rayleigh backscatter produced by the multimode
sensing fiber
116. For instance, an existing optical source may be replaced by a narrow band
pulsed
source that is more suited for coherent Rayleigh interrogation. Alternatively,
an existing
optical source may remain in place and a narrow band pulsed source may be
added
specifically for interrogating the multimode sensing fiber 116 for acquiring
Rayleigh
backscatter. Likewise, the detector and amplification and acquisition modules
in the data
acquisition system 107 may be configured as appropriate to detect and acquire
the
Rayleigh backscatter.
[00211 For instance, in one embodiment, the optical source 102 is a narrow-
band
pulsed source which includes a distributed feedback fiber laser. The source
102 may
operate at a 1550 nanometer wavelength and have a line width on the order of 2
kHz or
less. The source 102 further may have a frequency stability that is better
than 1
MHz/minute. To launch a pulse into the sensing optical fiber 116, the source
102 may
include a modulator (e.g., an acoustic-optic modulator) to extract a pulse
from the
continuous output of the distributed feedback fiber laser 102. In one
embodiment of the
invention, the width of the pulse extracted from the continuous output is
approximately
80-100 nanoseconds. In some embodiments of the invention, amplification of the
pulse
also may be desirable. In embodiments of the invention in which optical
amplification is
used to boost the pulse, spectral filtering may be used at either the source
102 or prior to
a detector 108 of the data acquisition system 107 to reduce the effects of
amplified
spontaneous emission in the optical amplifier. In such embodiments, it may
also be
7
CA 02725353 2010-11-23
WO 2009/148824
PCT/US2009/044616
desirable to time-gate the amplified pulses to eliminate amplified spontaneous
emission
between pulses.
[0022] In the embodiment illustrated in Fig. 3, the beam splitter 106
function, the
launching of the pulse into the multimode sensing optical fiber 116, the
selection of the
single speckle of the Rayleigh backscatter and direction of the backscattered
light to the
detector 108 may all be carried out in the single spatial mode filtering
system 120.
[0023] In one embodiment, and as shown in Fig. 4, the single spatial mode
filtering
system 120 includes a single-mode fiber 121 which itself functions as a
spatial filter
because a single-mode fiber only propagates the lowest order spatial mode,
which
requires the light across the entire area of the guided mode to be in phase.
As a result,
amongst the hundreds of speckles across the core of the multimode sensing
fiber 116, the
single mode in the fiber 121 selects a summation of electric fields that can
launch
efficiently into its fundamental mode. The use of a single-mode fiber 121 in
the single
spatial mode filtering system 120 is a particularly robust solution as in that
there is no
risk of misalignment of optics as might otherwise occur if a free-space optics
system
were employed. Further, the use of a single-mode fiber 121 also provides for
the use of
traditional components, such as fiber couplers or circulators, to implement
the beam
splitter 106.
[0024] In alternative embodiments, such as the embodiment illustrated in
Fig. 5, the
selection of a single speckle from the returned backscatter signal may be
achieved by
using free-space optics and a separate spatial filter 114, such as a pinhole
filter to select a
single speckle, or an angular aperture in the far field.
[0025] An alternative embodiment of an OTDR system 130 for either
heterodyne or
homodyne coherent detection of the Rayleigh backscatter is illustrated in Fig.
6. In this
embodiment, a source 132 is a narrow band continuous wave optical source. The
continuous output from the source 132 is split by a beam splitter 134 between
first and
second paths. The first path includes a modulator 136 to modulate the
continuous wave
8
CA 02725353 2010-11-23
WO 2009/148824
PCT/US2009/044616
output from the source 132 and provide a pulse that is then launched into the
multimode
sensing optical fiber 116. The second path from the source 132 provides a
portion of the
output of the continuous wave source 132 (i.e., the local oscillator ) to a
beam combiner
138, where the local oscillator portion of the source 132 overlaps with the
single speckle
selected from the backscattered light received from the sensing fiber 116. The
combined
light then impinges on a detector 140 of a detection and acquisition system
141 that is
responsive to the square of the electric field. When an acousto-optic
modulator 136 is
used in first order to modulate the signal in the first path, the modulator
introduces a
frequency shift. In such an embodiment (i.e., a heterodyne detection scheme),
various
mixing terms are generated, including a term at the difference frequency,
which is equal
to the frequency shift caused by the modulator 136. While it is possible to
implement
coherent detection OTDR without a frequency shift, the use of a frequency
shift allows
for a clear separation between the unshifted light (i.e., the local oscillator
signal in the
second path) and the signal that results from mixing the Rayleigh backscatter
and the
local oscillator. The desired backscatter signal then appears at the
intermediate
frequency, which is equal to the frequency shift provided by the modulator. In
other
embodiments, the coherent detection may be a homodyne detection scheme where
no
frequency shift exists between the pulsed output and the local oscillator.
This may be
achieved by using a modulator that does not shift the laser frequency.
Alternatively
homo dyne detection may be achieved by frequency shifting the local oscillator
portion of
the source 132 in the second path to match exactly the frequency shift in the
pulsed
output, resulting in no net frequency difference between local oscillator and
probe pulse.
[0026] In the embodiment of the system 130 which is illustrated in Fig. 6,
the
amplification and acquisition system 142 may include a narrow band filter
tuned to the
frequency shift so that the relevant frequencies of the Rayleigh backscattered
signal may
be selected and processed by the amplification and acquisition system 142. The
electrical
signal representative of the Rayleigh backscatter detected by the detector 140
may be
9
CA 02725353 2010-11-23
WO 2009/148824
PCT/US2009/044616
processed by the amplification and acquisition system 142 in various different
manners.
For instance, the detected signal may first be amplified and then rectified
and low pass
filtered. The data of interest may then be extracted from the amplified,
rectified and
filtered signal. It should be understood that the single spatial mode
filtering system 120
shown in Fig. 6 may include either a spatial filter 114 (as shown) or a single-
mode fiber
121 (as shown in Fig. 4) to select the single speckle from the Rayleigh
backscatter
produced by the sensing fiber 116.
[0027] It should be noted that in any of the embodiments described above
the
speckle-like signal selected by the single spatial mode filtering system 120
is subject to
fading. In other words, there are combinations of source frequency and fiber
state (e.g.,
temperature, strain and shape) at which the speckle signal fades at a
particular location
along the fiber. In such a case, the intensity of the speckle signal either
vanishes (in
which case the detector 108/140 receives no light to process), or the
derivative of
intensity with respect to fiber strain vanishes. In either of these
situations, the sensing
fiber 116 does not provide useful information at that location. To compensate
for this
type of situation, multiple combinations of spatial filters and acquisition
systems may be
employed, where each such combination acquires the light arriving at a
different speckle.
Statistically, it is unlikely that all speckles will fade simultaneously and
therefore
acquiring a plurality of independent speckles and identifying those that are
providing
useful information provides a more robust signal through independent channel
diversity.
The opportunity to use multiple speckles independently to provide diversity is
unique to
multimode sensing fibres. The process for identifying which speckle signal is
providing
useful information may be implemented, for example, based on the intensity of
the signal
in each channel or on an analysis of the noise in each channel.
[0028] In various embodiments of the invention, the signal processing unit
112 or
144 may be combined with the amplification and acquisition system 110, 142,
respectively, or may be coupled to the amplification and acquisition system
110, 142,
CA 02725353 2010-11-23
WO 2009/148824
PCT/US2009/044616
respectively, through a communication link such as a network. Alternatively,
the signal
processing unit may be part of a control center. In one embodiment, the signal
processing unit comprises a control system having a CPU, a memory, an input
device,
and an output device. The memory may store data and/or algorithms for
identifying
conditions associated with the elongate structure 113 based on the currently-
detected data
as well as historical data. The input device may be a variety of types of
devices, such as
a keyboard, mouse, a touch screen, etc. The output device may include a visual
and/or
audio output device, such as a monitor having a graphical user interface.
[0029] The OTDR system illustrated in Figs. 3-6 may be used in a variety of
different applications to detect disturbances to various different types of
elongate
structures, such as pipelines, electrical cables, etc. For instance, optical
fibers are
commonly installed within or attached to power cables, particularly those at
or above
ratings of 132 KV, in order to monitor the cables' temperature profile.
Typically, in such
installations, the sensing optical fiber is a multimode optical fiber as this
type of fiber is
the type preferred for Raman distributed temperature sensing, particularly
when
measuring temperature at distances of up to ten to fifteen kilometers. By
modifying or
retrofitting the fiber optic infrastructure to include a single spatial mode
filtering system,
such as the system 120 described above, and the appropriately configured
interrogation
equipment (e.g., source 102/132 and detection acquisition system 107/141),
these
previously installed multimode optical fibers may be surveyed or permanently
monitored
for disturbances, such as may occur as a result of inadvertent digging or
partial discharge
events. Thus, the CRN measurement itself may be used to identify the onset or
occurrence of cable failure. In addition, because the CRN measurement is
sensitive to
temperature as well as strain, the addition of the CRN capability to
preexisting systems
may help in the diagnosis of weak changes in temperature and thus to help
interpret the
temperature measurements provided by the detection of Raman scattering.
11
CA 02725353 2010-11-23
WO 2009/148824
PCT/US2009/044616
[0030] There also are many existing installations of multimode optical
fiber in
hydrocarbon wells that are used for distributed temperature sensing to derive
information
regarding steam or water injection in the well or the location of produced
fluid inflow, for
example. In installations in which the multimode optical fiber is tightly
confined to track
the length of the cable into which it is fitted, the modification of the fiber
optic
infrastructure to include the single-mode optics arrangement for acquired CRN
data
described above may be used to detect disturbances (e.g., vibration, small
changes
indicative of disturbances, etc. ) to the monitored cable.
[0031] While the invention has been disclosed with respect to a limited
number of
embodiments, those skilled in the art, having the benefit of this disclosure,
will appreciate
numerous modifications and variations therefrom. It is intended that the
appended claims
cover such modifications and variations as fall within the true spirit and
scope of the
invention.
12
