CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
METHODS AND APPARATUS FOR GENERATING AN ELECTRONIC RECORD
OF A MARKING OPERATION BASED ON MARKING DEVICE ACTUATIONS
Background
[0001] Field service operations may be any operation in which companies
dispatch
technicians and/or other staff to perform certain activities, for example,
installations, services
and/or repairs. Field service operations may exist in various industries,
examples of which
include, but are not limited to, network installations, utility installations,
security systems,
construction, medical equipment, heating, ventilating and air conditioning
(HVAC) and the
like.
[0002] An example of a field service operation in the construction industry is
a so-called
"locate and marking operation," also commonly referred to more simply as a
"locate
operation" (or sometimes merely as "a locate"). In a typical locate operation,
a locate
technician visits a work site in which there is a plan to disturb the ground
(e.g., excavate, dig
one or more holes and/or trenches, bore, etc.) so as to determine a presence
or an absence of
one or more underground facilities (such as various types of utility cables
and pipes) in a dig
area to be excavated or disturbed at the work site. In some instances, a
locate operation may
be requested for a "design" project, in which there may be no immediate plan
to excavate or
otherwise disturb the ground, but nonetheless information about a presence or
absence of one
or more underground facilities at a work site may be valuable to inform a
planning,
permitting and/or engineering design phase of a future construction project.
[0003] In many states, an excavator who plans to disturb ground at a work site
is required
by law to notify any potentially affected underground facility owners prior to
undertaking an
excavation activity. Advanced notice of excavation activities may be provided
by an
excavator (or another party) by contacting a "one-call center." One-call
centers typically are
operated by a consortium of underground facility owners for the purposes of
receiving
excavation notices and in turn notifying facility owners and/or their agents
of a plan to
excavate. As part of an advanced notification, excavators typically provide to
the one-call
center various information relating to the planned activity, including a
location (e.g., address)
of the work site and a description of the dig area to be excavated or
otherwise disturbed at the
work site.
[0004] A locate operation typically is initiated as a result of an excavator
providing an
excavation notice to a one-call center. An excavation notice also is commonly
referred to as
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-2-
a "locate request," and may be provided by the excavator to the one-call
center via an
electronic mail message, information entry via a website maintained by the one-
call center, or
a telephone conversation between the excavator and a human operator at the one-
call center.
The locate request may include an address or some other location-related
information
describing the geographic location of a work site at which the excavation is
to be performed,
as well as a description of the dig area (e.g., a text description), such as
its location relative to
certain landmarks and/or its approximate dimensions, within which there is a
plan to disturb
the ground at the work site. One-call centers similarly may receive locate
requests for design
projects (for which, as discussed above, there may be no immediate plan to
excavate or
otherwise disturb the ground).
[00051 Using the information provided in a locate request for planned
excavation or
design projects, the one-call center identifies certain underground facilities
that may be
present at the indicated work site. For this purpose, many one-call centers
typically maintain
a collection "polygon maps" which indicate, within a given geographic area
over which the
one-call center has jurisdiction, generally where underground facilities may
be found relative
to some geographic reference frame or coordinate system.
[00061 Polygon maps typically are provided to the one-call centers by
underground
facilities owners within the jurisdiction of the one call center ("members" of
the one-call
center). A one-call center first provides the facility owner/member with one
or more maps
(e.g., street or property maps) within the jurisdiction, on which are
superimposed some type
of grid or coordinate system employed by the one-call center as a geographic
frame of
reference. Using the maps provided by the one-call center, the respective
facilities
owners/members draw one or more polygons on each map to indicate an area
within which
their facilities generally are disposed underground (without indicating the
facilities
themselves). These polygons themselves do not precisely indicate geographic
locations of
respective underground facilities; rather, the area enclosed by a given
polygon generally
provides an over-inclusive indication of where a given facilities owner's
underground
facilities are disposed. Different facilities owners/members may draw polygons
of different
sizes around areas including their underground facilities, and in some
instances such
polygons can cover appreciably large geographic regions (e.g., an entire
subdivision of a
residential area), which may further obfuscate the actual/precise location of
respective
underground facilities.
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-3-
[0007] Based on the polygon maps collected from the facilities owners/members,
the one-
call center may in some instances create composite polygon maps to show
polygons of
multiple different members on a single map. Whether using single member or
composite
polygon maps, the one-call center examines the address or location information
provided in
the locate request and identifies a significant buffer zone around an
identified work site so as
to make an over-inclusive identification of facilities owners/members that may
have
underground facilities present (e.g., to err on the side of caution). In
particular, based on this
generally over-inclusive buffer zone around the identified work site (and in
some instances
significantly over-inclusive buffer zone), the one-call center consults the
polygon maps to
identify which member polygons intersect with all or a portion of the buffer
zone so as to
notify these underground facility owners/members and/or their agents of the
proposed
excavation or design project. Again, it should be appreciated that the buffer
zones around an
indicated work site utilized by one-call centers for this purpose typically
embrace a
geographic area that includes but goes well beyond the actual work site, and
in many cases
the geographic area enclosed by a buffer zone is significantly larger than the
actual dig area
in which excavation or other similar activities are planned. Similarly, as
noted above, the
area enclosed by a given member polygon generally does not provide a precise
indication of
where one or more underground facilities may in fact be found.
[0008] In some instances, one-call centers may also or alternatively have
access to
various existing maps of underground facilities in their jurisdiction,
referred to as "facilities
maps." Facilities maps typically are maintained by facilities owners/members
within the
jurisdiction and show, for respective different utility types, where
underground facilities
purportedly may be found relative to some geographic reference frame or
coordinate system
(e.g., a grid, a street or property map, GPS latitude and longitude
coordinates, etc.). Facilities
maps generally provide somewhat more detail than polygon maps provided by
facilities
owners/members; however, in some instances the information contained in
facilities maps
may not be accurate and/or complete. For at least this reason, whether using
polygon maps or
facilities maps, as noted above the one-call center utilizes a significant
buffer zone around an
identified work site so as to make an over-inclusive identification of
facilities
owners/members that may have underground facilities present.
[0009] Once facilities implicated by the locate request are identified by a
one-call center
(e.g., via the polygon map/buffer zone process), the one-call center generates
a "locate
request ticket" (also known as a "locate ticket," or simply a "ticket"). The
locate request
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-4-
ticket essentially constitutes an instruction to inspect a work site and
typically identifies the
work site of the proposed excavation or design and a description of the dig
area, typically
lists on the ticket all of the underground facilities that may be present at
the work site (e.g.,
by providing a member code for the facility owner of an underground facility
that falls within
a given polygon), and may also include various other information relevant to
the proposed
excavation or design (e.g., the name of the excavation company, a name of a
property owner
or party contracting the excavation company to perform the excavation, etc.).
The one-call
center sends the ticket to one or more underground facility owners and/or one
or more locate
service providers (who may be acting as contracted agents of the facility
owners) so that they
can conduct a locate and marking operation to verify a presence or absence of
the
underground facilities in the dig area. For example, in some instances, a
given underground
facility owner may operate its own fleet of locate technicians, in which case
the one-call
center may send the ticket to the underground facility owner. In other
instances, a given
facility owner may contract with a locate service provider to receive locate
request tickets and
perform a locate and marking operation in response to received tickets on
their behalf.
[00101 More specifically, upon receiving the locate request, a locate service
provider or a
facility owner (hereafter referred to as a "ticket recipient") may dispatch a
locate technician
to the work site of planned excavation to determine a presence or absence of
one or more
underground facilities in the dig area to be excavated or otherwise disturbed.
A first step for
the locate technician includes utilizing an underground facility "locate
device," which is an
instrument for detecting facilities that are concealed in some manner, such as
cables and
pipes that are located underground, to verify the presence or absence of
underground facilities
indicated in the locate request ticket as potentially present in the dig area
(e.g., via the facility
owner member codes listed in the ticket). An underground facility locate
device is used to
detect electromagnetic fields that are generated by a "test" signal provided
along a length of a
target facility to be identified. Locate devices typically include both a
signal transmitter to
provide the test signal (e.g., which is applied by the locate technician to a
tracer wire
disposed along a length of a facility), and a signal receiver which is
generally a hand-held
apparatus carried by the locate technician as the technician walks around the
dig area to
search for underground facilities. The signal receiver indicates a presence of
a facility when
it detects electromagnetic fields arising from the test signal. Conversely,
the absence of a
signal detected by the receiver of the locate device generally indicates the
absence of the
target facility.
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-5-
[0011] Subsequently, the locate technician then generally marks the presence
(and in
some cases the absence) of a given underground facility in the dig area based
on the various
signals detected (or not detected) using the locate device. For this purpose,
the locate
technician conventionally utilizes a "marking device" to dispense a marking
material on, for
example, the ground, pavement, or other surface along a detected underground
facility.
Marking material may be any material, substance, compound, and/or element,
used or which
may be used separately or in combination to mark, signify, and/or indicate.
Examples of
marking materials may include, but are not limited to, paint, chalk, dye,
and/or iron. Marking
devices, such as paint marking wands and/or paint marking wheels, provide a
convenient
method of dispensing marking materials onto surfaces, such as onto the surface
of the ground
or pavement.
[0012] Figures 1A and 1B illustrate a conventional marking device 50 with a
mechanical
actuation system to dispense paint as a marker. Generally speaking, the
marking device 50
includes a handle 38 at a proximal end of an elongated shaft 36 and resembles
a sort of
"walking stick," such that a technician may operate the marking device while
standing/walking in an upright or substantially upright position. A marking
dispenser holder
40 is coupled to a distal end of the shaft 36 so as to contain and support a
marking dispenser
56, e.g., an aerosol paint can having a spray nozzle 54. Typically, a marking
dispenser in the
form of an aerosol paint can is placed into the holder 40 upside down, such
that the spray
nozzle 54 is proximate to the distal end of the shaft (close to the ground,
pavement or other
surface on which markers are to be dispensed).
[0013] In Figures 1 A and 1 B, the mechanical actuation system of the marking
device 50
includes an actuator or mechanical trigger 42 proximate to the handle 38 that
is
actuated/triggered by the technician (e.g., via pulling, depressing or
squeezing with
fingers/hand). The actuator 42 is connected to a mechanical coupler 52 (e.g.,
a rod) disposed
inside and along a length of the elongated shaft 36. The coupler 52 is in turn
connected to an
actuation mechanism 58, at the distal end of the shaft 36, which mechanism
extends outward
from the shaft in the direction of the spray nozzle 54. Thus, the actuator 42,
the mechanical
coupler 52, and the actuation mechanism 58 constitute the mechanical actuation
system of the
marking device 50.
[0014] Figure 1 A shows the mechanical actuation system of the conventional
marking
device 50 in the non-actuated state, wherein the actuator 42 is "at rest" (not
being pulled) and,
as a result, the actuation mechanism 58 is not in contact with the spray
nozzle 54. Figure 1B
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-6-
shows the marking device 50 in the actuated state, wherein the actuator 42 is
being actuated
(pulled, depressed, squeezed) by the technician. When actuated, the actuator
42 displaces the
mechanical coupler 52 and the actuation mechanism 58 such that the actuation
mechanism
contacts and applies pressure to the spray nozzle 54, thus causing the spray
nozzle to deflect
slightly and dispense paint. The mechanical actuation system is spring-loaded
so that it
automatically returns to the non-actuated state (Figure 1 A) when the actuator
42 is released.
[0015] In some environments, arrows, flags, darts, or other types of physical
marks may
be used to mark the presence or absence of an underground facility in a dig
area, in addition
to or as an alternative to a material applied to the ground (such as paint,
chalk, dye, tape)
along the path of a detected utility. The marks resulting from any of a wide
variety of
materials and/or objects used to indicate a presence or absence of underground
facilities
generally are referred to as "locate marks." Often, different color materials
and/or physical
objects may be used for locate marks, wherein different colors correspond to
different utility
types. For example, the American Public Works Association (APWA) has
established a
standardized color-coding system for utility identification for use by public
agencies, utilities,
contractors and various groups involved in ground excavation (e.g., red =
electric power lines
and cables; blue = potable water; orange = telecommunication lines; yellow =
gas, oil,
steam). In some cases, the technician also may provide one or more marks to
indicate that no
facility was found in the dig area (sometimes referred to as a "clear").
[0016] As mentioned above, the foregoing activity of identifying and marking a
presence
or absence of one or more underground facilities generally is referred to for
completeness as
a "locate and marking operation." However, in light of common parlance adopted
in the
construction industry, and/or for the sake of brevity, one or both of the
respective locate and
marking functions may be referred to in some instances simply as a "locate
operation" or a
"locate" (i.e., without making any specific reference to the marking
function). Accordingly,
it should be appreciated that any reference in the relevant arts to the task
of a locate
technician simply as a "locate operation" or a "locate" does not necessarily
exclude the
marking portion of the overall process.
[0017] Inaccurate locating and/or marking of underground facilities can result
in physical
damage to the facilities, property damage, and/or personal injury during the
excavation
process that, in turn, can expose a facility owner or contractor to
significant legal liability.
When underground facilities are damaged and/or when property damage or
personal injury
results from damaging an underground facility during an excavation, the
excavator may
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-7-
assert that the facility was not accurately located and/or marked by a locate
technician, while
the locate contractor who dispatched the technician may in turn assert that
the facility was
indeed properly located and marked. Proving whether the underground facility
was properly
located and marked can be difficult after the excavation (or after some
damage, e.g., a gas
explosion), because in many cases the physical locate marks (e.g., the marking
material or
other physical marks used to mark the facility on the surface of the dig area)
will have been
disturbed or destroyed during the excavation process (and/or damage resulting
from
excavation).
[0018] Previous efforts at documenting locate operations have focused
primarily on
locate devices that employ electromagnetic fields to determine the presence of
an
underground facility. For example, U.S. Patent No. 5,576,973, naming inventor
Alan Haddy
and entitled "Apparatus and Method for Obtaining Geographical Positional Data
for an
Object Located Underground" (hereafter "Haddy"), is directed to a locate
device (i.e., a
"locator") that receives and stores data from a global positioning system
("GPS") to identify
the position of the locate device as an underground object (e.g., a cable) is
detected by the
locate device. Haddy notes that by recording geographical position data
relating to the
detected underground object, there is no need to physically mark the location
of the
underground object on the ground surface, and the recorded position data may
be used in the
future to re-locate the underground object.
[0019] Similarly, U.S. Patent No. 7,319,387, naming inventors Willson et al.
and entitled
"GPS Interface for Locating Device" (hereafter "Willson"), is directed to a
locate device for
locating "position markers," i.e., passive antennas that reflect back RF
signals and which are
installed along buried utilities. In Willson, a GPS device may be
communicatively coupled to
the locate device, or alternatively provided as an integral part of the locate
device, to store
GPS coordinate data associated with position markers detected by the locate
device.
Electronic memory is provided in the locate device for storing a data record
of the GPS
coordinate data, and the data record may be uploaded to a remote computer and
used to
update a mapping database for utilities.
[0020] U.S. Publication No. 2006/0282280, naming inventors Stotz et al. and
entitled
"Ticket and Data Management" (hereafter "Stotz"), also is directed to a locate
device (i.e., a
"locator") including a GPS receiver. Upon detection of the presence of a
utility line, Stotz'
locate device can update ticket data with GPS coordinates for the detected
utility line. Once
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-8-
the locate device has updated the ticket data, the reconfigured ticket data
may be transmitted
to a network.
[0021] U.S. Publication No. 2007/0219722, naming inventors Sawyer, Jr. et al.
and
entitled "System and Method for Collecting and Updating Geographical Data"
(hereafter
"Sawyer"), is directed to collecting and recording data representative of the
location and
characteristics of utilities and infrastructure in the field for creating a
grid or map. Sawyer
employs a field data collection unit including a "locating pole" that is
placed on top of or next
to a utility to be identified and added to the grid or map. The locating pole
includes an
antenna coupled to a location determination system, such as a GPS unit, to
provide
longitudinal and latitudinal coordinates of the utility under or next to the
end of the locating
pole. The data gathered by the field data collection unit is sent to a server
to provide a
permanent record that may be used for damage prevention and asset management
operations.
Summary
[0022] Applicants have recognized and appreciated that uncertainties which may
be
attendant to locate and marking operations may be significantly reduced by
collecting various
information particularly relating to the marking operation, rather than merely
focusing on
information relating to detection of underground facilities via a locate
device. In many
instances, excavators arriving to a work site have only physical locate marks
on which to rely
to indicate a presence or absence of underground facilities, and they are not
generally privy to
information that may have been collected previously during the locate
operation.
Accordingly, the integrity and accuracy of the physical locate marks applied
during a
marking operation arguably is significantly more important in connection with
reducing risk
of damage and/or injury during excavation than the location of where an
underground facility
was detected via a locate device during a locate operation.
[0023] More specifically, Applicants have recognized and appreciated that
conventional
techniques for using a locate device to detect underground facilities are
sometimes tentative
and typically iterative in nature, and use of locate devices with GPS
capabilities may result in
redundant, spurious and/or incomplete geographic location data collected by
such devices.
For example, during a typical locate operation, a technician attempting to
locate an
underground facility with a locate device often needs to sweep an appreciable
area around a
suspected underground facility, and make multiple passes with the locate
device over the
underground facility to obtain meaningful detection signals. Furthermore, the
technician
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-9-
often needs to rely significantly on visual observations of the area,
including relevant
landmarks such as facility connections to buildings, transformer boxes,
maintenance/public
access points, curbs, sidewalks, roadways, etc., to effectively deduce a
sensible path of an
underground facility to be located. The foregoing is particularly true if at
some point during
the locate operation the technician loses a signal from an underground
facility in the process
of being detected (e.g., due to a broken transmitter circuit path from a
damaged tracer wire,
and loss of the transmitter test signal). In view of the foregoing, it may be
readily
appreciated that collecting and logging geographic location information
throughout this
process may result in excessive and/or imprecise data, or in some instances
incomplete
relevant data (e.g., in the case of signal loss/broken tracer wire), from
which it may be
difficult to cull the data that is truly complete and representative of where
the underground
facility ultimately was detected.
[00241 Furthermore, Applicants have recognized and appreciated that the
location at
which an underground facility ultimately is detected during a locate operation
is not always
where the technician physically marks the ground, pavement or other surface
during a
marking operation; in fact, technician imprecision or negligence may in some
instances result
in significant discrepancies between detected location and physical locate
marks.
Accordingly, having documentation (e.g., an electronic record) of where
physical locate
marks were actually dispensed (i.e., what an excavator encounters when
arriving to a work
site) is notably more relevant to the assessment of liability in the event of
damage and/or
injury than where an underground facility was detected prior to marking.
[00251 Examples of marking devices configured to collect some types of
information
relating specifically to marking operations are provided in U.S. publication
no. 2008-
0228294-Al, published September 18, 2008, filed March 13, 2007, and entitled
"Marking
System and Method With Location and/or Time Tracking," and U.S. publication
no. 2008-
0245299-Al, published October 9, 2008, filed April 4, 2007, and entitled
"Marking System
and Method," both of which publications are incorporated herein by reference.
These
publications describe, amongst other things, collecting information relating
to the geographic
location, time, and/or characteristics (e.g., color/type) of dispensed marking
material from a
marking device and generating an electronic record based on this collected
information.
Applicants have recognized and appreciated that collecting information
relating to both
geographic location and color of dispensed marking material provides for
automated
correlation of geographic information for a locate mark to facility type
(e.g., red = electric
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-10-
power lines and cables; blue = potable water; orange = telecommunication
lines; yellow =
gas, oil, steam); in contrast, in conventional locate devices equipped with
GPS capabilities as
discussed above, there is no apparent automated provision for readily linking
GPS
information for a detected facility to the type of facility detected.
Applicants have further
appreciated that building a more comprehensive electronic record of
information relating to
marking operations further facilitates ensuring the accuracy of such
operations.
[0026] In view of the foregoing, various inventive embodiments disclosed
herein relate
generally to methods and apparatus for collecting, logging (electronically
storing),
formatting, processing, and/or electronically analyzing a variety of
information relating to
marking operations. More specifically, some exemplary embodiments described
herein are
directed to methods and apparatus for acquiring information relating to a
marking operation
(i.e., dispensing of a marking material so as to mark a presence or absence of
an underground
facility), generating a comprehensive electronic record of the marking
operation including
data relating to one or more actuations of a marking device to dispense a
marking material,
and storing and/or transmitting the electronic record for subsequent access,
processing and/or
analysis.
[0027] For example, in some implementations of the methods and apparatus
described
herein, when a locate technician actuates (triggers) a marking device to
dispense marking
material, control electronics in the marking device may collect and store
information from
various devices (also referred to herein generally as "input devices")
included in the marking
device (e.g., a location sensor or tracking system to provide geographic
information about
where the material is dispensed, a time sensor or timing system to provide
timing information
about when the material is dispensed, a marking material detection mechanism
to provide
information about one or more characteristics of material dispensed, etc.).
Information may
be collected at a start of a given actuation, at one or more times during the
actuation, and/or at
the end of the actuation, and for successive actuations. In some cases,
information relating to
the marking operation may be collected or otherwise available before or after
a given
actuation or a succession of multiple actuations, as an alternative to or in
addition to
information collected during one or more actuations.
[0028] Further, in some embodiments of the invention disclosed herein, one or
more
input devices of a marking apparatus may include a communication interface
(e.g., network
interface) and/or a user interface, and information received from the
interface(s) may include
or be related to a locate request ticket, in response to which the locate and
marking operation
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-11-
is being performed (i.e., "ticket information"). This ticket information may
include, for
example, a one-call center ticket number, a street address or other geographic
location of the
work site, a description of the dig area, and/or an indication of one or more
facilities to be
marked in the dig area (e.g., via facility owner member codes). Examples of
additional
and/or other information that may be received via a user interface associated
with the
marking device may include "service-related information," e.g., one or more
identifiers for
the locate technician carrying out the locate and marking operation, one or
more identifiers
for equipment used by the technician, and/or one or more identifiers for an
employer of the
technician.
[0029] Accordingly, for purposes of the present disclosure, "marking
information" refers
generally to any of the various types of information relating to a marking
operation including
for example, but not limited to, service-related information, ticket
information, time
information, geographic location information, and marking material
information, alone or in
various combinations with each other.
[0030] In various embodiments discussed herein, marking information collected
in
response to actuation of the marking device, and/or otherwise generally
associated with the
locate and marking operation, may be logged in (entered into) an electronic
record of the
marking operation, and such an electronic record may be stored in memory of
the marking
device, particularly formatted, processed and/or analyzed at the marking
device itself, and/or
transmitted to another device for storage, formatting, processing and/or
analysis.
[0031] During and/or following collection and/or storage of information
regarding the
marking operation, data compiled in one or more electronic records associated
with the
marking operation may be accessed, processed and/or analyzed to provide
further information
relating to the performance of the marking operation. For example, in other
embodiments
disclosed herein, data from one or more electronic records of the marking
operation is
processed so as to electronically render (visually recreate) the marking
operation (e.g., on a
display device associated with the marking device or other display device).
[0032] In one such exemplary implementation, lines, dots or other indicators
are
displayed in relative positions on a display screen (e.g., at an appropriate
scale based on an
available display field) and represent respective actuations of the marking
device (and
corresponding physical locate marks created on a ground, pavement or other
surface). In one
aspect of this implementation, multiple different underground facilities that
may have been
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-12-
located and marked during a locate and marking operation may be electronically
rendered
based on the information contained in one or more electronic records to
provide a composite
visual representation in the available display field (e.g., in which different
marked
underground facilities are displayed in different line-types and/or different
colors).
[00331 In other aspects, electronic renderings may be generated statically
(e.g., in which
all available data in an electronic record is rendered essentially
simultaneously on an
available display field) or in an "animated" time-sequenced recreation of the
marking
operation (e.g., based on at least timing and geographic location information
in the electronic
record) once an electronic record is generated. In yet.another exemplary
implementation,
various information to be logged in an electronic record may be
passed/transmitted in
essentially real-time to one or more display devices to facilitate an
essentially real-time
electronic rendering on an available display field of a marking operation in
process.
[00341 In sum, one embodiment of the present invention is directed to an
apparatus for
generating an electronic record of a marking operation to mark on ground,
pavement, or other
surface a presence or an absence of at least one underground facility. The
apparatus
comprises an actuator to dispense a marking material so as to form at least
one locate mark
on the ground, pavement or other surface to mark the presence or the absence
of the at least
one underground facility, at least one input device to provide marking
information regarding
the marking operation, and a memory to store processor-executable instructions
and the
electronic record of the marking operation. The apparatus further comprises a
processor
coupled to the memory, the at least one input device, and the actuator. Upon
execution of the
processor-executable instructions by the processor, the processor logs in the
electronic record
an actuation data set including a plurality of actuation event entries for at
least one actuation
of the actuator, wherein at least one actuation event entry includes at least
some of the
marking information provided by the at least one input device.
[00351 Another embodiment is directed to a method for generating an electronic
record of
a marking operation to mark on ground, pavement, or other surface a presence
or an absence
of at least one underground facility. The method comprises: A) effecting at
least one
actuation of an actuator of a marking apparatus to dispense a marking material
so as to form
at least one locate mark on the ground, pavement or other surface to mark the
presence or the
absence of the at least one underground facility; B) providing marking
information regarding
the marking operation; and C) logging into an electronic record an actuation
data set
including a plurality of actuation event entries for the at least one
actuation of the actuator in
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-13-
A), wherein at least one actuation event entry includes at least some of the
marking
information provided in B).
[00361 Another embodiment is directed to an apparatus for generating an
electronic
record of a marking operation to mark on ground, pavement, or other surface a
presence or an
absence of at least one underground facility. The apparatus comprises an
actuator to dispense
a marking material so as to form at least one locate mark on the ground,
pavement or other
surface to mark the presence or the absence of the at least one underground
facility, at least
one input device to provide marking information regarding the marking
operation, wherein
the marking information includes at least one of service-related information
and ticket
information, and a memory to store processor-executable instructions and the
electronic
record of the marking operation. The apparatus further comprises a processor
coupled to the
memory, the at least one input device, and the actuator. Upon execution of the
processor-
executable instructions by the processor, the processor logs in the electronic
record actuation
data for at least one actuation of the actuator, and wherein the processor
further logs in the
electronic record at least some of the service-related information and/or at
least some of the
ticket information provided by the at least one input device.
[0037] Another embodiment is directed to a method for generating an electronic
record of
a marking operation to mark on ground, pavement, or other surface a presence
or an absence
of at least one underground facility. The method comprises: A) effecting at
least one
actuation of an actuator of a marking apparatus to dispense a marking material
so as to form
at least one locate mark on the ground, pavement or other surface to mark the
presence or the
absence of the at least one underground facility; B) providing marking
information regarding
the marking operation, wherein the marking information includes at least one
of service-
related information and ticket information; C) logging into an electronic
record actuation data
for the at least one actuation of the actuator in A); and D) logging into the
electronic record at
least some of the service-related information and/or at least some of the
ticket information
provided in B).
[00381 Another embodiment is directed to a method for providing an electronic
rendering
on a display device of a marking operation to mark on ground, pavement, or
other surface a
presence or an absence of at least one underground facility. The method
comprises: A)
accessing an electronic record of the marking operation generated by a marking
device, the
electronic record comprising a plurality of actuation data sets, each
actuation data set
associated with a corresponding locate mark created by an actuation of the
marking device,
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-14-
wherein each actuation data set comprises at least two pieces of geographic
information for
the corresponding locate mark; and B) for each actuation data set of the
electronic record,
displaying on the display device at least one electronic locate mark so as to
provide the
electronic rendering of the marking operation, based at least in part on the
at least two pieces
of geographic information for the corresponding locate mark.
[0039] Another embodiment is directed to a method for providing an electronic
rendering
on a display device of a marking operation to mark on ground, pavement, or
other surface a
presence or an absence of at least one underground facility. The method
comprises: A)
accessing an electronic record of the marking operation generated by a marking
device, the
electronic record comprising a plurality of actuation data sets, each
actuation data set
associated with a corresponding locate mark created by an actuation of the
marking device,
wherein each actuation data set comprises at least two pieces of geographic
information for
the corresponding locate mark; B) displaying, on the display device, a digital
image
representative of at least a portion of an area of the ground, pavement, or
other surface on
which the locate mark is created; and C) for at least some actuation data sets
of the electronic
record, displaying on the display device at least one electronic locate mark
overlaid on the
displayed digital image so as to provide the electronic rendering of the
marking operation,
based at least in part on the at least two pieces of geographic information
for the
corresponding locate mark and on the displayed digital image.
[0040] Another embodiment is directed to at least one computer-readable
storage medium
storing an electronic record of a marking operation, the electronic record
comprising a
plurality of actuation data sets, each actuation data set associated with a
corresponding
actuation of a marking device to dispense a marking material during the
marking operation,
wherein at least one first actuation data set of the electronic record
corresponds to a first
actuation. The at least one first actuation data set comprises: a first field
including a first
piece of geographic information for the first actuation; and at least one
second field including
at least one second piece of geographic information for the first actuation.
In one aspect, the
at least one computer-readable storage medium is combined with at least one
processor to
form a machine, wherein the at least one computer-readable storage medium
further stores
processor-executable instructions, and wherein the processor, upon execution
of the
processor-executable instructions, accesses at least one of the first field
and the at least one
second field of the at least one first actuation data set. In another aspect,
upon execution of
the processor-executable instructions by the processor, for the at least one
first actuation data
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-15-
set, the at least one processor displays on a display device at least one
electronic locate mark
so as to provide an electronic rendering of the marking operation, based at
least in part on the
first piece and the at least one second piece of geographic information for
the first actuation.
[0041] Another embodiment is directed to a marking apparatus to perform a
marking
operation. The marking apparatus comprises an actuation system, a memory to
store
processor-executable instructions, and a processor coupled to the memory and
the actuation
system. Upon execution of the processor-executable instructions by the
processor, the
processor provides an output stream of data packets, each data packet
including at least one
flag field that is set or reset upon at least one actuation of the actuation
system.
[0042] Another embodiment is directed to a method for providing information
relating to
a marking operation to mark on ground, pavement, or other surface a presence
or an absence
of at least one underground facility. The method comprises: A) effecting at
least one
actuation of an actuation system of a marking apparatus to dispense a marking
material so as
to form at least one locate mark on the ground, pavement or other surface to
mark the
presence or the absence of at least one underground facility; and B) providing
an output
stream of data packets, each data packet including at least one flag field
that is set or reset
upon the at least one actuation of the at least one actuation system.
[0043] For purposes of the present disclosure, the term "dig area" refers to a
specified
area of a work site within in which there is a plan to disturb the ground
(e.g., excavate, dig
holes and/or trenches, bore, etc.), and beyond which there is no plan to
excavate in the
immediate surroundings. Thus, the metes and bounds of a dig area are intended
to provide
specificity as to where some disturbance to the ground is planned at a given
work site. It
should be appreciated that a given work site may include multiple dig areas.
[0044] The term "facility" refers to one or more lines, cables, fibers,
conduits,
transmitters, receivers, or other physical objects or structures capable of or
used for carrying,
transmitting, receiving, storing, and providing utilities, energy, data,
substances, and/or
services, and/or any combination thereof. The term "underground facility"
means any facility
beneath the surface of the ground. Examples of facilities include, but are not
limited to, oil,
gas, water, sewer, power, telephone, data transmission, cable television (TV),
and/or internet
services.
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-16-
[0045] The term "locate device" refers to any apparatus and/or device for
detecting
and/or inferring the presence or absence of any facility, including without
limitation, any
underground facility.
[0046] The term "marking device" refers to any apparatus, mechanism, or other
device
that employs a marking dispenser for causing a marking material and/or marking
object to be
dispensed, or any apparatus, mechanism, or other device for electronically
indicating (e.g.,
logging in memory) a location, such as a location of an underground facility.
Additionally,
the term "marking dispenser" refers to any apparatus, mechanism, or other
device for
dispensing and/or otherwise using, separately or in combination, a marking
material and/or a
marking object. An example of a marking dispenser may include, but is not
limited to, a
pressurized can of marking paint. The term "marking material" means any
material,
substance, compound, and/or element, used or which may be used separately or
in
combination to mark, signify, and/or indicate. Examples of marking materials
may include,
but are not limited to, paint, chalk, dye, and/or iron. The term "marking
object" means any
object and/or objects used or which may be used separately or in combination
to mark,
signify, and/or indicate. Examples of marking objects may include, but are not
limited to, a
flag, a dart, and arrow, and/or an RFID marking ball. It is contemplated that
marking
material may include marking objects. It is further contemplated that the
terms "marking
materials" or "marking objects" may be used interchangeably in accordance with
the present
disclosure.
[0047] The term "locate mark" means any mark, sign, and/or object employed to
indicate
the presence or absence of any underground facility. Examples of locate marks
may include,
but are not limited to, marks made with marking materials, marking objects,
global
positioning or other information, and/or any other means. Locate marks may be
represented
in any form including, without limitation, physical, visible, electronic,
and/or any
combination thereof.
[0048] The terms "actuate" or "trigger" (verb form) are used interchangeably
to refer to
starting or causing any device, program, system, and/or any combination
thereof to work,
operate, and/or function in response to some type of signal or stimulus.
Examples of
actuation signals or stimuli may include, but are not limited to, any local or
remote, physical,
audible, inaudible, visual, non-visual, electronic, mechanical,
electromechanical,
biomechanical, biosensing or other signal, instruction, or event. The terms
"actuator" or
"trigger" (noun form) are used interchangeably to refer to any method or
device used to
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-17-
generate one or more signals or stimuli to cause or causing actuation.
Examples of an
actuator/trigger may include, but are not limited to, any form or combination
of a lever,
switch, program, processor, screen, microphone for capturing audible commands,
and/or
other device or method. An actuator/trigger may also include, but is not
limited to, a device,
software, or program that responds to any movement and/or condition of a user,
such as, but
not limited to, eye movement, brain activity, heart rate, other data, and/or
the like, and
generates one or more signals or stimuli in response thereto. In the case of a
marking device
or other marking mechanism (e.g., to physically or electronically mark a
facility or other
feature), actuation may cause marking material to be dispensed, as well as
various data
relating to the marking operation (e.g., geographic location, time stamps,
characteristics of
material dispensed, etc.) to be logged in an electronic file stored in memory.
[0049] The terms "locate and marking operation," "locate operation," and
"locate" are
used interchangeably and refer to any activity to detect, infer, and/or mark
the presence or
absence of an underground facility. In some instances, the term "marking
operation" is used
to more specifically refer to that portion of a locate operation in which a
marking material
and/or one or more marking objects is/are employed to mark a presence or an
absence of one
or more underground facilities. The term "locate technician" refers to an
individual
performing a locate operation. A locate operation often is specified in
connection with a dig
area, at least a portion of which may be excavated or otherwise disturbed
during excavation
activities.
[0050] The term "user" refers to an individual utilizing a locate device
and/or a marking
device and may include, but is not limited to, land surveyors, locate
technicians, and support
personnel.
[0051] The terms "locate request" and "excavation notice" are used
interchangeably to
refer to any communication to request a locate and marking operation. The term
"locate
request ticket" (or simply "ticket") refers to any communication or
instruction to perform a
locate operation. A ticket might specify, for example, the address or
description of a dig area
to be marked, the day and/or time that the dig area is to be marked, and/or
whether the user is
to mark the excavation area for certain gas, water, sewer, power, telephone,
cable television,
and/or some other underground facility. The term "historical ticket" refers to
past tickets that
have been completed.
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-18-
[00521 The term "complex event processing (CEP)" refers to a software and/or
hardware-
implemented (e.g., facilitated by a computer system, distributed computer
system,
computational analysis coded in software, and/or a combination thereof)
technique relating to
recognizing one or more events, patterns of events, or the absence of an event
or pattern of
events, within one or more input streams of information and performing one or
more actions
and/or computations in response to such recognition, in accordance with
specified rules,
criteria, algorithms, or logic. CEP generally involves detection of
relationships between
information contained in input streams (which input streams may include
indications of
previously recognized events), such as causality, membership, timing, event-
driven
processes, detection of complex patterns of one or more events, event streams
processing,
event correlation and abstraction, and/or event hierarchies. CEP may
complement and
contribute to technologies such as, but not limited to, service oriented
architecture (SOA),
event driven architecture (EDA), and/or business process management (BPM). CEP
allows
the information contained in the events flowing through all of the layers of a
service business,
an enterprise information technology infrastructure and/or management
operation to be
discovered, analyzed, and understood in terms of its impact on management
goals and
business processes, and acted upon in real time or as a management process.
[00531 It should be appreciated that all combinations of the foregoing
concepts and
additional concepts discussed in greater detail below (provided such concepts
are not
mutually inconsistent) are contemplated as being part of the inventive subject
matter
disclosed herein. In particular, all combinations of claimed subject matter
appearing at the
end of this disclosure are contemplated as being part of the inventive subject
matter disclosed
herein. It should also be appreciated that terminology explicitly employed
herein that also
may appear in any disclosure incorporated by reference should be accorded a
meaning most
consistent with the particular concepts disclosed herein.
Brief Description of the Drawings
[00541 Figures 1 A and 1 B illustrate a conventional marking device in an
actuated and
non-actuated state, respectively;
[00551 Figure 2 is a functional block diagram of a data acquisition system
according to
one embodiment of the present invention for creating electronic records of
marking
operations based on actuations of a marking device;
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-19-
[0056] Figure 3 is a perspective view of the data acquisition system of Figure
2,
illustrating an exemplary marking device according to one embodiment of the
present
invention;
[0057] Figures 4A and 4B illustrate a portion of an actuation system of the
marking
device of Figure 3 according to one embodiment of the present invention;
[0058] Figure 5 illustrates various components of an actuation system 120
according to
other embodiments of the present invention;
[0059] Figure 6 is a perspective view of an exemplary marking device being
used for
marking a dotting pattern, according to one embodiment of the present
invention;
[0060] Figure 7 is a perspective view of an exemplary marking device being
used for
marking a lines pattern, according to one embodiment of the present invention;
[0061] Figure 8 is a plan view that shows further details of the lines pattern
of Figure 7,
in connection with the information acquired for purposes of creating an
electronic record
according to one embodiment of the present invention;
[0062] Figure 9 is a flow diagram of an exemplary method for collecting
marking
information for generation of an electronic record, according to one
embodiment of the
present invention;
[0063] Figure 10 is a block diagram of an exemplary data structure for an
electronic
record of a marking operation including information retrieved during one or
more actuations
of a marking device, according to one embodiment of the present invention;
[0064] Figure 11 is a flow diagram of an exemplary method for displaying a
visual
representation of a marking operation in a display field having a
predetermined scale,
according to one embodiment of the present invention;
[0065] Figure 12 is an example of a visual representation showing electronic
locate marks
based on collected data corresponding to respective actuations of a marking
device during
marking operations, according to one embodiment of the present invention;
[0066] Figure 13 is an example of another visual representation of marking
operations,
according to one embodiment of the present invention; and
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-20-
[0067] Figure 14 is an example of another visual representation of marking
operations,
according to another embodiment of the present invention, in which electronic
locate marks
are overlaid on a digital image of a work site/dig area.
Detailed Description
[0068] Following below are more detailed descriptions of various concepts
related to, and
embodiments of, inventive systems, methods and apparatus for generating
electronic records
of marking operations based on marking device actuations. It should be
appreciated that
various concepts introduced above and discussed in greater detail below may be
implemented
in any of numerous ways, as the disclosed concepts are not limited to any
particular manner
of implementation. Examples of specific implementations and applications are
provided
primarily for illustrative purposes.
[0069] I. Overview
[0070] In some embodiments of the present invention, a marking device employed
by a
locate technician to dispense marking material is particularly configured to
acquire "marking
information" relating to a marking operation based at least in part on
actuations of the
marking device, and create an electronic record of at least some of the
marking information.
As discussed in greater detail below, examples of marking information relating
to the
marking operation that may be logged into an electronic record may include,
but are not
limited to:
= timing information (e.g., one or more time stamps) associated with one or
more
actuations of the marking device and/or one or more events occurring during a
given actuation;
= geographic information (e.g., one or more geographic coordinates) associated
with
one or more actuations of the marking device (in some instances, the
geographic
information may be accompanied by timing information, such as a time stamp,
for
each acquisition of geographic information);
= marking material information: one or more aspects/characteristics of a
marking
material (e.g., a color, brand, type, serial number, UPC code, weight,
inventory
information, etc. associated with the marking material) dispensed in response
to
one or more actuations of the marking device;
= service-related information: one or more identifiers for the locate
technician
performing the marking operation, the marking device itself (e.g., a serial
number
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-21-
of the marking device), and/or the locate contractor dispatching the locate
technician; and
= ticket information: information relating to one or more facilities to be
marked,
location information (e.g., an address, geo-coordinates, and/or text
description)
relating to the work site and/or dig area in which the locate and marking
operation
is performed, excavator information, etc.
[00711 One or more electronic records based on the marking information may be
generated, logged/stored in local memory of the marking device, formatted in
any of a variety
of manners, processed and/or analyzed at the marking device itself, and/or
transmitted to
another device (e.g., a computer) for storage, processing and/or analysis.
[00721 In various implementations of the methods and apparatus described
herein, data
from one or more electronic records, including multiple pieces of geographical
location
information (geo-location data), time and date information, and duration, as
well as a total
number of actuations, characteristics of the marking material (e.g., color,
brand, type)
dispensed during the actuations, and the like, may be processed and analyzed
to provide
insight into the marking operation. In one embodiment, a computer-generated
image or other
visual representation of the marking operation may be electronically rendered;
for example,
this visual representation may provide electronic indications ("electronic
locate marks") of
the relative placement of marking material dispensed during a marking
operation, and
electronic locate marks corresponding to different types of facilities may be
color-coded.
Such a visual representation of the marking operation may be used, for
example, to provide
immediate feedback to the locate technician (e.g., via a display device
associated with the
marking device), provide essentially real-time feedback to a supervisor
monitoring the
marking operation from a remote location, provide a visual record of the
marking operation
(e.g., for archiving purposes, once the marking operation is completed and one
or more
electronic records are generated), and/or to verify the quality (e.g.,
accuracy and
completeness) of work performed during the locate and marking operation.
[00731 H. Marking Device
[0074] Figures 2 and 3 illustrate a functional block diagram and perspective
view,
respectively, of one example of a data acquisition system 100, including a
marking device
110 and optionally a remote computer 150, according to one embodiment of the
present
invention. One or both of the marking device 110 and the remote computer 150
of the data
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-22-
acquisition system 100 may be configured to sense one or more actuations of
the marking
device 110 (e.g., to dispense marking material during a marking operation),
and collect
information based on one or more actuations of the marking device so as to
generate an
electronic record.
[0075] As shown in Figure 2, in one embodiment marking device 110 includes
control
electronics 112, the components of which are powered by a power source 114.
Power source
114 may be any power source that is suitable for use in a portable device,
such as, but not
limited to, one or more rechargeable batteries, one or more non-rechargeable
batteries, a solar
photovoltaic panel, a standard AC power plug feeding an AC-to-DC converter,
and the like.
[0076] The marking device 110 is configured to hold a marking dispenser 116,
which as
shown in Figure 3 is loaded into a marking material holder 140 of the marking
device 110. In
one exemplary implementation, the marking dispenser 116 is an aerosol paint
canister that
contains paint; however, it should be appreciated that the present invention
is not limited in
this respect, as a marking material dispensed by the marking device 110 may be
any material,
substance, compound, and/or element, used to mark, signify, and/or indicate.
Examples of
marking materials may include, but are not limited to, paint, chalk, dye,
and/or marking
powder.
[0077] As also shown in Figure 2, in one embodiment control electronics 112 of
marking
device 110 may include, but are not limited to, a processor 118, at least a
portion of an
actuation system 120 (another portion of which may include one or more
mechanical
elements), a local memory 122, a communication interface 124, a user interface
126, a timing
system 128, and a location tracking system 130.
[0078] The processor 118 may be any general-purpose processor, controller, or
microcontroller device. Local memory 122 may be any volatile or non-volatile
data storage
device, such as, but not limited to, a random access memory (RAM) device and a
removable
memory device (e.g., a universal serial bus (USB) flash drive). As discussed
further below,
the local memory may store a marking data algorithm 134, which may be a set of
processor-
executable instructions that when executed by the processor 118 causes the
processor to
control various other components of the marking device 110 so as to generate
an electronic
record 135 of a marking operation, which record also may be stored in the
local memory 122
and/or transmitted in essentially real-time (as it is being generated) or
after completion of a
marking operation to a remote device (e.g., remote computer 150).
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-23-
[0079] In one exemplary implementation, a Linux-based processing system for
embedded
handheld and/or wireless devices may be employed in the marking device 110 to
implement
various components of the control electronics 112. For example, the
Fingertip4TM processing
system, including a Marvell PXA270 processor and available from InHand
Electronics, Inc.
(www.inhandelectronics.com/products/fingertip4), may be used. In addition to
the PXA270
processor (e.g., serving as the processor 118), the Fingertip4TM includes
flash memory and
SDRAM (e.g., serving as local memory 122), multiple serial ports, a USB port,
and other I/O
interfaces (e.g., to facilitate interfacing with one or more input devices and
other components
of the marking device), supports a variety of wired and wireless interfaces
(WiFi, Bluetooth,
GPS, Ethernet) to facilitate implementation of the communication interface
124, and connects
to a wide variety of LCD displays (to facilitate implementation of a user
interface/display).
[0080] Communication interface 124 of marking device 110 may be any wired
and/or
wireless communication interface by which information may be exchanged between
marking
device 110 and an external or remote device, such as a remote computing device
that is
elsewhere in the dig area (i.e., not a part of the marking device 110) or
outside the dig area.
For example, data that is provided by components of data acquisition system
100 and/or
stored in local memory 122 (e.g., one or more electronic records 135) may be
transmitted via
communication interface 124 to a remote computer, such as remote computer 150,
for
processing. Examples of wired communication interfaces may include, but are
not limited to,
USB ports, RS232 connectors, RJ45 connectors, Ethernet, and any combination
thereof.
Examples of wireless communication interfaces may include, but are not limited
to, an
Intranet connection, Internet, Bluetooth technology, Wi-Fi, Wi-Max, IEEE
802.11
technology, radio frequency (RF), Infrared Data Association (IrDA) compatible
protocols,
Local Area Networks (LAN), Wide Area Networks (WAN), Shared Wireless Access
Protocol (SWAP), combination thereof, and other types of wireless networking
protocols.
The wireless interface may be capable of capturing signals that reflect a
user's intent. For
example, the wireless interface may include a microphone that can capture a
user's intent by
capturing the user's audible commands. Alternatively, the wireless interface
may interact
with a device that monitors a condition of the user, such as eye movement,
brain activity,
and/or heart rate.
[0081] User interface 126 of marking device 110 may be any mechanism or
combination
of mechanisms by which a user may operate data acquisition system 100 and by
which
information that is generated by data acquisition system 100 may be presented
to the user.
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-24-
For example, user interface 126 may include, but is not limited to, a display
device (including
integrated displays and external displays, such as Heads-Up Displays (HUDs)),
a touch
screen, one or more manual pushbuttons, one or more light-emitting diode (LED)
indicators,
one or more toggle switches, a keypad, an audio output (e.g., speaker, buzzer,
and alarm), and
any combination thereof. In one implementation, the user interface 126
includes a
"menu/on" button to power up the marking device and provide a menu-driven
graphical user
interface (GUI) displayed by the display device (e.g., menu items and/or icons
displayed on
the display device) and navigated by the technician via a joystick or a set of
four
"up/down/left/right" buttons, as well as a "select/ok" button to take some
action pursuant to
the selection of a menu item/icon. As described below, the display may also be
used in some
embodiments of the invention to display information relating to a placement of
marking
material in a dig area, a location of an underground facility in a dig area,
or any other suitable
information that may be displayed based on information acquired to create an
electronic
record 135.
[00821 In various embodiments, the one or more interfaces of the marking
device 110-
including the communication interface 124 and user interface 126-may be used
as input
devices to receive information to be stored in the memory 122 as part of an
electronic record
of a marking operation. In some cases, marking information received via the
interface(s)
(e.g., via the communication interface 124) may include ticket information
regarding
underground facilities to be marked during a marking operation. As another
example, using
an interface such as the user interface 126, service-related information may
be input,
including an identifier for the marking device used by the technician, an
identifier for a
technician, and/or an identifier for the technician's employer. Alternatively,
some or all of
the service-related information similarly may be received via the
communication interface
124 (and likewise some or all of the ticket information may be received via
the user interface
126).
[00831 The actuation system 120 of marking device 110 shown in the block
diagram of
Figure 2 may include both electrical and mechanical elements according to
various
embodiments discussed in further detail below, and for purposes of
illustration is shown in
Figure 2 as included as part of the control electronics 112. The actuation
system 120 may
include a mechanical and/or electrical actuator mechanism (e.g., see the
actuator 142 shown
in Figure 3) to provide one or more signals or stimuli as an input to the
actuation system 120.
Upon receiving one or more signals or stimuli (e.g., actuation/triggering by a
locate
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-25-
technician or other user), the actuation system 120 causes marking material to
be dispensed
from marking dispenser 116. In various embodiments, the actuation system 120
may employ
any of a variety of mechanical and/or electrical techniques (e.g., one or more
switches or
other circuit components, a dedicated processor or the processor 118 executing
instructions,
one or more mechanical elements, various types of transmitters and receivers,
or any
combination of the foregoing), as would be readily appreciated by those of
skill in the
relevant arts, to cause the marking dispenser 116 to dispense marking material
in response to
one or more signals or stimuli. The actuation system 120 also provides one or
more output
signals in the form of an actuation signal 121 to the processor 118 to
indicate one or more
actuations of the marking device, in response to which the processor 118 may
acquire/collect
various marking information and log data into the electronic record 135.
Additional details
of exemplary actuation system implementations are provided below in connection
with
Figures 3 through 5.
[0084] In some embodiments, the actuation system 120 may be configured so as
not to
cause marking material to be dispensed from marking dispenser 116 in response
to one or
more signals or stimuli; rather, the actuation system may merely facilitate a
logging of data
from one or more input devices in response to operation of an
actuator/trigger, without
necessarily dispensing marking material. In some instances, this may
facilitate "simulation"
of a marking operation (i.e., simulating the dispensing of marking material)
by providing an
actuation signal 121 to the processor 118 indicating one or more simulated
actuation events,
in response to which the processor may cause the logging of various data for
creating an
electronic record without any marking material actually being dispensed.
[0085] Location tracking system 130 of marking device 110 constitutes another
type of
input device that provides marking information, and may include any device
that can
determine its geographical location to a certain degree of accuracy. For
example, location
tracking system 130 may include a global positioning system (GPS) receiver or
a global
navigation satellite system (GNSS) receiver. A GPS receiver may provide, for
example, any
standard format data stream, such as a National Marine Electronics Association
(NMEA) data
stream, or other data formats. An error correction component 131 may be, but
is not limited
to, any mechanism for improving the accuracy of the geographic information
provided by
location tracking system 130; for example, error correction component 131 may
be an
algorithm for correcting any offsets (e.g., due to local disturbances in the
atmosphere) in the
geo-location data of location tracking system 130. While shown as part of a
local location
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-26-
tracking system of the marking device 110, error correction component 131
alternatively may
reside at a remote computing device, such as remote computer 150. In other
embodiments,
location tracking system 130 may include any device or mechanism that may
determine
location by any other means, such as performing triangulation by use of
cellular
radiotelephone towers.
[0086] In one exemplary implementation, the location tracking system 130 may
include
an ISM300F2-C5-V0005 GPS module available from Inventek Systems, LLC of
Westford,
Massachusetts (see www.inventeksys.com/html/ism300f2-c5-v0005.html). The
Inventek
GPS module includes two UARTs (universal asynchronous receiver/transmitter)
for
communication with the processor 118, supports both the SIRF Binary and NMEA-0
183
protocols (depending on firmware selection), and has an information update
rate of 5 Hz. A
variety of geographic location information may be requested by the processor
118 and
provided by the GPS module to the processor 118 including, but not limited to,
time
(coordinated universal time - UTC), date, latitude, north/south indicator,
longitude, east/west
indicator, number and identification of satellites used in the position
solution, number and
identification of GPS satellites in view and their elevation, azimuth and SNR
values, and
dilution of precision values. Accordingly, it should be appreciated that in
some
implementations the location tracking system 130 may provide a wide variety of
geographic
information as well as timing information (e.g., one or more time stamps) to
the processor
118.
[0087] In another embodiment, location tracking system 130 may not reside
locally on
marking device 110. Instead, location tracking system 130 may reside on any on-
site
computer, which serves as a location reference point, to which the location of
marking device
110 may be correlated by any other means, such as, but not limited to, by a
triangulation
technique between the on-site computer and marking device 110.
[0088] With respect to other input devices of the marking device 110 that may
provide
marking information, the control electronics 112 may also include a timing
system 128
having an internal clock (not shown), such as a crystal oscillator device, for
processor 118.
Additionally, timing system 128 may include a mechanism for registering time
with a certain
degree of accuracy (e.g., accuracy to the minute, second, or millisecond) and
may also
include a mechanism for registering the calendar date. In various
implementations, the
timing system 128 may be capable of registering the time and date using its
internal clock, or
alternatively timing system 128 may receive its time and date information from
the location
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-27-
tracking system 130 (e.g., a GPS system) or from an external timing system,
such as a remote
computer or network, via communication interface 124. In yet other
implementations, a
dedicated timing system for providing timing information to be logged in an
electronic record
135 may be optional, and timing information for logging into an electronic
record may be
obtained from the location tracking system 130 (e.g., GPS latitude and
longitude coordinates
with a corresponding time stamp).
[0089] Marking material detection mechanism 132 of the marking device 110
shown in
Figure 2 is another type of input device that provides marking information,
and may be any
mechanism or mechanisms for determining a presence or absence of a marking
dispenser 116
in or otherwise coupled to the marking device 110, as well as determining
certain
attributes/characteristics of the marking material within marking dispenser
116 when the
dispenser is placed in or coupled to the marking device. As shown in Figure 3,
in some
embodiments the marking material detection mechanism 132 may be disposed
generally in an
area proximate to a marking material holder 140 in which a marking dispenser
116 may be
placed.
[0090] For example, in one embodiment, the marking material detection
mechanism 132
may include one or more switch devices (e.g., a make/break single pole/single
throw contact
switch) disposed at one or more points along the marking material holder 140
and electrically
coupled to the processor 118. The switch device(s) may also be coupled to
ground or a DC
supply voltage, such that when the switch device is in a first state (e.g.,
closed/making
contact) the ground or DC supply voltage is passed to the processor 118 (e.g.,
via an I/O pin
of the processor which provides an interrupt to, or is periodically monitored
by, the
processor), and when the switch is in a second state (e.g., open/no contact)
the ground or DC
supply voltage is not passed to the processor 118. When the marking dispenser
116 is present
in the holder 140, the switch device(s) is in one of two possible states and
when there is no
marking dispenser the switch device(s) is in another of the two possible
states (e.g., the
marking dispenser, when present, may depress the switch device(s) so as to
make contact and
pass the ground/DC voltage to the processor). In this manner, the marking
material detection
mechanism 132 may provide a signal to the processor indicating the presence or
absence of
the marking dispenser 116 in the marking device 110.
[0091] The marking material detection mechanism 132 also or alternatively may
include
a barcode reader to read barcode data from a dispenser 116 and/or a radio-
frequency
identification (RFID) reader for reading information from an RFID tag that is
provided on
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-28-
marking dispenser 116. The RFID tag may include, for example, a unique serial
number or
universal product code (UPC) that corresponds to the brand and/or type of
marking material
in marking dispenser 116. The type of information that may be encoded within
the RFID tag
on marking dispenser 116 may include product-specific information for the
marking material,
but any information of interest may be stored on an RFID tag. For example,
user-specific
information and/or inventory-related information may be stored on each RFID
tag for a
marking dispenser 116 to facilitate inventory tracking of marking materials.
In particular, an
identifier for a technician may be stored on an RFID tag when the technician
is provided with
a marking dispenser 116, and information relating to weight, amount dispensed,
and/or
amount remaining may be written to the RFID tag whenever the marking dispenser
is used.
[0092] In one exemplary implementation, the marking material detection
mechanism 132
may include a Micro RWD MIFARE-ICODE RFID reader module available from IB
Technology (Eccel Technology Ltd) of Aylesbury, Buckinghamshire, UK (see
www.ibtechnology.co.uk/ products/icode.htm). The Micro RWD reader module
includes an
RS232 communication interface to facilitate communication between the
processor 118 and
the reader module (e.g., via messages sent as a string of ASCII characters),
and supports both
reading information from an RFID tag attached to a marking dispenser as well
as writing
information to an RFID tag attached to the marking dispenser. In one aspect of
an exemplary
implementation, an antenna constituted by one or more turns of wire (e.g., two
turns of awg
26 wire, 6.5 cm in diameter, about 1 uH) is coupled to the Micro RWD reader
module and
disposed in the marking material holder 140 of the marking device 110 (see
Figure 3),
proximate to a marking dispenser 116 when placed in the holder 140, so as to
capture close
near field signals (e.g., from an RFID tag on the dispenser, within about 2
inches) and
exclude far field signals. In another aspect, the Micro RWD reader module may
be
configured to read RFID tags having an ICODE SLI format (e.g., ISO 15693 ICODE
SLI).
In yet another aspect, an RFID tag may be affixed to an aerosol paint can
serving as the
marking dispenser, such that the tag conforms to a plastic cap of the paint
can and is disposed
at a particular location relative to a notch in the cap (e.g., 90 degrees +/-
15 degrees from the
notch) that allows access to the spray nozzle of the can and is in a
relatively predictable
position substantially aligned with the antenna when the paint can is placed
in the marking
material holder 140. Examples of RFID tags suitable for this purpose are
available from BCS
Solutions, Inc. (see www.bcssolutions.com/solutions/rfid) and include, but are
not limited to,
the HF Bullseye Wet Inlay SLA Round 40.
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-29-
[0093] In yet other embodiments, marking material detection mechanism 132 may
alternatively or further be configured to detect properties of marking
material as it is
dispensed. For example, the marking material detection mechanism may include
one or
more of an optical sensor, an olfactory sensor, an auditory sensor (e.g., a
microphone), a
weight sensor, and any combination thereof. For example, in one embodiment an
optical
sensor in the marking device may be used to identify the composition and/or
type of marking
material in the marking dispenser by analyzing light reflected by the material
as it is
dispensed. Similarly, an olfactory sensor may be used to identify one or more
characteristics
of the marking material based on an odor profile of the material, and an
auditory sensor may
be used to identify the difference between paint being sprayed from an aerosol
can and
aerosol without paint being sprayed from a can (e.g., as the dispenser becomes
emptied of
paint).
[0094] In one embodiment, information provided by one or more input devices of
the
marking device 110 (e.g., the timing system 128, the location tracking system
130, the
marking material detection mechanism 132, the user interface 126, the
communication
interface 124) is acquired and logged (stored in memory) upon actuation of the
actuation
system 120 (e.g., triggering an actuator). Some embodiments of the invention
may
additionally or alternatively acquire/log information from one or more input
devices at one or
more times during or throughout an actuation, such as when a technician is
holding a
mechanical or electrical actuator for some period of time and moving to
dispense marking
material in a line (e.g., see Figure 7). In various aspects of such
embodiments, marking
information derived from one or more input devices may be collected at a start
time of an
actuation, at one or more times during an actuation, and in some cases at
regular intervals
during an actuation (e.g., several times per second, once per second, once
every few seconds).
Further, some marking information may be collected at an end of an actuation,
such as time
information that may indicate a duration of an actuation.
[0095] Additionally, it should be appreciated that while some marking
information may
be received via one or more input devices at the start of each marking
operation and upon
successive actuations of the marking device, in other cases some marking
information may be
collected by or provided to the marking device once, prior to a marking
operation (e.g., on
power-up or reset of the marking device, as part of an electronic instruction
or dispatch by a
locate company, and/or in response to a request/query from a locate
technician), and stored in
local memory 122 for later incorporation into an electronic record. For
example, prior to a
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-30-
given marking operation and one or more actuations of the marking device,
ticket information
and/or service-related information may have already been received (e.g., via
the
communication interface 124 and/or user interface 126) and stored in local
memory 122.
Upon generation of an electronic record of a given marking operation,
information previously
received via the interface(s) may be retrieved from the local memory (if
stored there initially)
and entered into an electronic record, in some case together with information
collected
pursuant to one or more actuations of the marking device. Alternatively,
ticket information
and/or service-related information may be received via the interface(s) and
stored in an entry
in the electronic record 135 "directly" in response to one or more actuations
of the marking
device (e.g., without being first stored in local memory).
[0096] In sum, according to embodiments of the present invention, various
marking
information from one or more input devices, regardless of how or when it is
received, may be
stored in an electronic record of a marking operation, in which at least some
of the marking
information is logged pursuant to one or more actuations of the marking
device.
[0097] In one embodiment, the optional remote computer 150 of the data
acquisition
system 100 may be a centralized computer, such as a central server of an
underground facility
locate service provider. In another embodiment, remote computer 150 may be a
computer
that is at or near the work site (i.e., "on-site"), e.g., a computer that is
present in a locate
technician's vehicle.
[0098] Whether resident and/or executed on either the marking device 110 or
the remote
computer 150, as noted above the marking data algorithm 134 includes a set of
processor-
executable instructions (e.g., stored in memory, such as local memory 122 of
the marking
device) that, when executed by processor 118 of the marking device 110 or
another
processor, processes information (e.g., various marking information) collected
in response to
(e.g., during) one or more actuations of the marking device 110, and/or in
some cases before
or after a given actuation or series of actuations. As also discussed above,
according to
various embodiments the actuations of marking device 110 may effect both
dispensing
marking material and logging of marking information, or merely logging of
marking
information for other purposes (e.g., simulating the dispensing of marking
material) without
dispensing marking material. In either situation, marking data algorithm 134,
when executed
by the processor 118, may cause the processor to perform collection,
logging/storage
(creation of electronic records), and in some instances further processing and
analysis of
various marking information with respect to marking device actuations. For
example, as
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-31-
discussed in further detail below in connection with Figure 9, the operations
of marking data
algorithm 134 as effected by the processor 118 may include, but are not
limited to, the
following:
(1) reading in (acquiring) data that is generated by any component (e.g., one
or more
input devices); for example, data may be read in that is acquired at a start
of a
given actuation, throughout the duration of the actuation, at the end of the
actuation, before or after the actuation, and any combination thereof;
(2) processing the information that is collected and associating the collected
information with respective actuations; for example, any information collected
may be parsed/packaged so as to be associated with any one or more actuations
of
the marking device, irrespective of when the data was actually acquired;
(3) formatting the acquired information, e.g., as multiple time-stamped event
entries
constituting actuation data sets forming an electronic record, wherein each
actuation data set corresponds to a particular actuation; and
(4) using respective actuation data sets of an electronic record to visually
recreate the
marking operation (e.g., render a computer-generated representation in a
display
field, wherein respective actuation data sets correspond to electronic locate
marks).
[0099] It should also be appreciated that the marking data algorithm 134 may
include one
or more adjustable parameters that govern various aspects of the collection
and logging of
marking information (e.g., the rate at which various marking information is
collected from
one or more input devices), and that these parameters may be adjusted or set,
for example, by
an administrator at a remote computer, after which the marking data algorithm
is downloaded
to the marking device for execution by the processor 118. Alternatively, in
other
implementations, adjustable parameters of a marking data algorithm already
resident on a
marking device may in some cases be adjusted remotely via the communication
interface, or
locally via the user interface.
[00100] While the functionality of various components of the marking device
110 was
discussed above in connection with Figure 2, Figure 3 shows some structural
aspects of the
marking device 110 according to one embodiment. For example, the marking
device 110
may include an elongated housing 136 in which is disposed one or more elements
of the
actuation system 120, one or more elements of the control electronics 112 and
the power
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-32-
source 114. Elongated housing 136 may be hollow or may contain certain
cavities or molded
compartments for installing any components therein, such as the various
components of
marking device 110 that are shown in Figure 2. The elongated housing 136 and
other
structural elements associated with the housing, as discussed below, may be
formed of any
rigid, semi-rigid, strong, and lightweight material, such as, but not limited
to, molded plastic
and aluminum.
[00101] Incorporated at a proximal end of elongated housing 136 may be a
handle 138,
which provides a convenient grip by which the user (e.g., the locate
technician) may carry the
marking device 110 during use (i.e., the exemplary marking device depicted in
Figure 3 is
intended to be a hand-held device). In one implementation, the power source
114 may be
provided in the form of a removable battery pack housing one or more
rechargeable batteries
that are connected in series or parallel in order to provide a DC voltage to
marking device
110, and disposed within a compartment in the handle 138. Such an arrangement
facilitates
use of conventional removable/rechargeable battery packs often employed in a
variety of
cordless power tools, in which the battery pack similarly is situated in a
handle of the tool. It
should be appreciated, however, that the power source 114 in the form of a
battery pack may
be disposed in any of a variety of locations within or coupled to the
elongated housing 136.
[00102] As also shown in Figure 3, mounted near handle 138 is user interface
126, which
may include a display 146. The display 146 may be a touch screen display to
facilitate
interaction with a user/technician, and/or the user interface also may include
one or more
buttons, switches, joysticks, a keyboard, and the like to facilitate entry of
information by a
user/technician. One or more elements of the control electronics 112 (e.g.,
the processor 118,
memory 122, communication interface 124, and timing system 128) also may be
located in
the proximal end of the elongated housing in the vicinity of the user
interface 126 and display
146. As with the power source 114, it should be appreciated that one or more
elements of the
control electronics 112 may be disposed in any of a variety of locations
within or coupled to
the elongated housing 136.
[00103] In the embodiment of Figure 3, the location tracking system 130
similarly may be
positioned on the proximal end of the elongated housing 136 to facilitate
substantially
unobstructed exposure to the atmosphere; in particular, as illustrated in
Figure 3, the location
tracking system 130 may be situated on an a ground plane 133 (providing an
electrical
ground at least at the antenna frequency of the location tracking system,
e.g., at
approximately 1.5 GHz) that extends from the proximal end of the housing 136
and is
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-33-
approximately parallel to the ground, surface or pavement when the marking
device is being
normally operated by a technician (so as to reduce signal modulation with
subtle movements
of the marking device).
[00104] As also shown in Figure 3, incorporated at the distal end of elongated
housing 136
is a marking dispenser holder 140 for holding one or more marking dispensers
116 (e.g., an
aerosol paint canister). Dispenser 116 may be one or more replaceable
dispensers or one or
more reusable refillable dispensers (including a fixed reservoir forming a
part of the device
110) or any other suitable dispenser. Also situated at the distal end of the
housing is the
marking material detection mechanism 132 to detect a presence or absence of
the marking
dispenser 116 in the marking material holder 140, and/or one or more
characteristics of the
marking material 148, as well as an actuation mechanism 158, which in some
implementations may constitute part of the actuation system 120 and be
employed to interact
with the marking dispenser 116 so as to effect dispensing of the marking
material 148.
[00105] With respect to the actuation system 120, as shown in Figure 3, at
least a portion
of the actuation system 120 is indicated generally along the length of the
elongated housing
for purposes of illustration. More specifically, however, in various
implementations the
actuation system 120 may include multiple components disposed in various
places in, on or
coupled to the marking device 110. For example, in the embodiment of Figure 3,
the
actuation system 120 includes an actuator 142, which for example may be a
mechanical
mechanism provided at the handle 138 in the form of a trigger that is pulled
by a finger or
hand of an user/technician. The actuation system 120 further includes the
actuation
mechanism 158 disposed at the distal end of the marking device that is
responsive to the
actuator 142 to dispense marking material. In general, in various exemplary
implementations
as discussed in further detail below, the actuation system 120 may employ any
of a variety of
mechanical and/or electrical techniques to cause the marking dispenser 116 to
dispense
marking material 148 in response to one or more signals or stimuli. In the
embodiment
shown in Figure 3, the signal/stimulus is initially provided to the actuation
system via the
mechanical actuator 142; i.e., a locate technician or other user triggers
(e.g., pulls/depresses)
the actuator 142 to provide a signal/stimulus to the actuation system 120,
which in turn
operates the actuation mechanism 158 to dispense marking material in response
to the
signal/stimulus.
[00106] In response to the signal/stimulus provided by the actuator 142, as
discussed
above the actuation system may also provide an actuation signal 121 to the
processor 118 to
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-34-
indicate an actuation. As discussed in further detail below in connection with
Figure 9,
pursuant to the execution by the processor 118 of the marking data algorithm
134, the
actuation signal 121 may be used to cause the logging of information that is
provided by one
or more components of the marking device 110 so as to generate an electronic
record of the
marking operation.
[001071 Figures 4A and 4B illustrate a portion of the actuation system 120
according to
one embodiment of the present invention. Figure 4A shows the actuator 142 in
an un-
actuated state, whereas Figure 4B shows the actuator 142 in an actuated state
(in which a
signal/stimulus is provided by the actuator). In the example of Figures 4A and
4B, the
actuator 142 is coupled to a mechanical coupler 152, similar to that shown in
Figures 1 A and
1B, which extends along a length of the elongated housing and is in turn
coupled to a
mechanical actuation mechanism 158 at the distal end of the housing (not shown
in Figures
4A and 4B) that ultimately effects dispensing of marking material when the
actuator is in the
actuated state. The portion of the actuation system 120 shown in Figures 4A
and 4B also
includes a sensor 160 which is configured to provide an actuation signal 121
to the processor
118 to indicate one or both of the respective actuated and un-actuated states
of the actuator
142.
[001081 In one implementation, the sensor 160 may include a switch device
(e.g., a
make/break single pole/single throw contact switch) disposed along the handle
138 of the
marking device such that, when pulled, the actuator contacts (e.g., depresses)
the switch
causing a state of the switch to toggle. In another implementation, the sensor
160 may
include a switch device such as a reed (magnetic) switch disposed at some
point along the
length of the elongated housing; in such an implementation, the mechanical
coupler 152 may
have a magnet disposed along it at an appropriate position relative to the
reed switch, such
that movement of the mechanical coupler 152 upon actuation of the actuator 142
causes a
state of the reed switch to toggle. Electrically, a switch device serving as
the sensor 160 may
be coupled to ground or a DC supply voltage, such that when the switch device
is in a first
state (e.g., closed/making contact) the ground or DC supply voltage is passed
to the processor
118 (e.g., via an I/O pin of the processor which provides an interrupt to, or
is periodically
monitored by, the processor), and when the switch is in a second state (e.g.,
open/no contact)
the ground or DC supply voltage is not passed to the processor 118. In this
manner, the
sensor 160 may provide the actuation signal 121 to the processor indicating
actuation (and
release) of the actuator 142.
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-35-
[00109] Figure 5 illustrates various components of an actuation system 120
according to
other embodiments of the present invention. Generally speaking, the actuation
system 120
may include the actuator 142, the sensor 160 to detect actuation and release
of the actuator
142 (and also provide a corresponding actuation signal 121 representing same
to the
processor 118), a link transmitter 168 coupled and responsive to the sensor
160 to transmit
one or more signals and/or other stimulus via an actuation link 164, and a
link receiver 162 to
receive the one or more signals and/or other stimulus from the actuation link
164 and, in
response to same, operate the actuation mechanism 158. The link transmitter
168, the link
164, and the link receiver 162 may include one or more electrical and/or
mechanical
components.
[00110] For example, the link receiver 162 may include a linear solenoid
mechanically
coupled to the actuation mechanism 158 and whose movement is responsive to one
or more
signals and/or stimuli received from the link 164. In various exemplary
implementations, the
link transmitter 168 and the link 164 simply may include a wire that couples
the sensor 160 to
the solenoid to activate the solenoid upon changes of state in the actuation
signal 121.
Alternatively, the transmitter 168 may be an RF transmitter that is activated
in response to the
actuation signal 121, the link 164 may be a wireless link, and the receiver
162 may include an
RF receiver.
[00111] Other examples of transmitter/link/receiver combinations include, but
are not
limited to, an acoustic transmitter/link/receiver (e.g., a sound wave source
that provides a
sound wave of a certain tone, duration, and/or amplitude when the actuator is
actuated, and a
corresponding sound wave detector), an optical transmitter/link/receiver
(e.g., a light or laser
source that provides an optical signal of a certain wavelength, duration,
and/or amplitude
when the actuator is actuated, and a corresponding optical detector), a fluid
transmitter/link/receiver (e.g., a fluid system that provides a fluid control
output of a certain
volume, pressure, and/or duration when the actuator is actuated, and a
corresponding fluid
sensor for sensing the presence of, for example, a short blast of water of a
certain volume,
pressure, and/or duration to indicate an actuation; the fluid system may be,
for example, a
closed-loop system that has source reservoir at top of the marking device, a
fluid line to
proximity with the fluid sensor, a return reservoir for capturing water during
the actuation
process, and appropriate pressure regulation and ducts for cycling water from
the return
reservoir back to the source reservoir), and an air transmitter/link/receiver
(e.g., an air system
that provides an air control output of a certain volume, pressure, and/or
duration when the
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-36-
actuator is actuated, and a corresponding air sensor for sensing the presence
of, for example,
a blast or puff of air of a certain volume, pressure, and/or duration to
indicate an actuation).
[00112] While not explicitly shown in Figure 5, in yet other embodiments it
should be
appreciated that the sensor 160 may be coupled to the processor 118 (to
provide the actuation
signal 121 representing actuation/release of the actuator), and in turn the
processor may
provide a signal to the link transmitter 168, such that dispensing of marking
material may in
part be under the control of the processor 118 executing particular
instructions for this
purpose. More specifically, while in some implementations dispensing of
marking material
may be directly responsive to actuation of the actuator (and cease upon
release of the
actuator), in other implementations dispensing of marking material may be
initiated in some
manner upon actuation of the actuator, but then continued dispensing of
marking material
may not necessarily be dictated by continued actuation, or release, of the
actuator. Rather,
the processor 118 may provide one or more signals or commands to the link
transmitter 168
to govern dispensing of marking material in some manner that does not
necessarily track each
actuation and release of the actuator.
[00113] For example, in one implementation the processor 118 may execute
instructions
such that, once the actuation signal 121 from the sensor 160 indicates
actuation of the
actuator, the processor 118 provides a signal to the link transmitter 168 that
causes dispensing
of marking material for some predetermined or user-defined amount of time,
irrespective of
release of the actuator. Additionally or alternatively, the processor may
provide one or more
signals to the link transmitter 168 that causes dispensing of marking material
for multiple
discrete amounts of time with a single actuation (e.g., three bursts of 1
second each per
actuation). From the foregoing, it should be generally appreciated that a wide
variety of
marker sizes and patterns may be generated from the marking device in an
automated or
semi-automated manner based on processor-based control of the actuation system
120. It
should also be appreciated that automated or semi-automated processor-based
control of the
dispensing of marking material may also govern in some fashion how, how often,
and/or
what type of marking information is collected and logged to generate an
electronic record of
a marking operation, as discussed further below in connection with Figure 9.
[00114] III. Exemplary Marking Techniques
[00115] Figures 6 and 7 provide examples of how the marking device 110 shown
in
Figures 2 and 3 may be employed by a technician during a marking operation.
Referring now
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-37-
to Figure 6, a perspective view of marking device 110 when in use for marking
a "dotting
pattern" is presented. In marking operations, a dotting pattern may be
utilized to
preliminarily and quickly indicate the presence or absence of a target
facility during an initial
locate of a target facility. By way of example, Figure 6 shows an underground
facility 310,
which may be any facility, such as an underground gas line, water pipe, sewer
pipe, power
line, telephone line, cable television conduit, and the like. Figure 6 also
shows a dotting
pattern 312 that is formed by multiple locate marks 314 dispensed via marking
device 110.
The locate marks 314 of dotting pattern 312 are formed by successive short
bursts of marking
material (e.g., brief actuations); i.e., each locate mark 314 corresponds to
one brief actuation
of the marking device 110.
[001161 Referring now to Figure 7, a perspective view of marking device 110
when in use
for marking a "lines pattern" is presented. In marking operations, a lines
pattern is typically
the end product of a marking operation. This pattern extends the dotting
pattern (e.g., dotting
pattern 312 of Figure 6) so as to create lines (e.g., a series of dashes) that
indicate the
presence or absence of an underground facility. These lines subsequently
provide important
reference marks to an excavator so as to avoid damage to a facility during
excavation
activities or other disturbances of the ground. By way of example, Figure 7
shows
underground facility 310, which may be any concealed facility, such as an
underground gas
line, water pipe, sewer pipe, power line, telephone line, cable television
conduit, and the like.
Figure 7 also shows a lines pattern 412 that is formed by multiple locate
marks 414 dispensed
via marking device 110. A characteristic of locate marks 414 of lines pattern
412 is that each
locate mark 414 is formed by an extended burst of marking material (e.g., a
longer actuation
of the marking device) as compared with a dotting pattern. As with the dotting
pattern shown
in Figure 6, however, each locate mark 414 of the lines pattern shown in
Figure 7 may
correspond to one actuation of marking device 110. In some alternative
implementations, as
discussed above, a series of locate marks (e.g., all three marks 414) may be
automatically
generated by one actuation of marking device 110 pursuant to processor-based
control of the
actuation system.
[001171 Figure 8 illustrates a plan view that shows further details of the
lines pattern 412
of Figure 7. In the example of Figure 8, each locate mark 414-1, 414-2, and
414-3
corresponds to one actuation ("act") of marking device 110, i.e., locate mark
414-1
corresponds to act-1, locate mark 414-2 corresponds to act-2, and locate mark
414-3
corresponds to act-3. Furthermore, each actuation and its corresponding locate
mark 412 has
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-38-
a start time tl, an end time t2, and a duration (At). While Figure 8 shows
three locate marks,
it should be appreciated that lines pattern 412 may be formed by any number of
locate marks.
[00118] IV. Format, Content and Process of Generating Electronic Records of
Marking
Operations
[00119] In one embodiment of the present invention for generating an
electronic record of
a marking operation, the processor 118 of the marking device 110, executing
the marking
data algorithm 134, may collect various marking information and generate an
electronic
record having one or more "actuation data sets" respectively associated with
one or more
actuations (act-1, act-2, act-3.....act-n) and corresponding locate marks, as
shown in Figure 8.
Marking information may be collected and entered into such an electronic
record at various
times relative to the start time tl and the end time t2 of a given actuation,
e.g., at tl only, at t2
only, at both tl and t2, at any time(s) between tl and t2, and/or before or
after tl and t2.
[00120] Examples of marking information that generally (but not necessarily)
is acquired
with respect to tl and t2 of each actuation, and points between ti and t2
("actuation data"),
may include, but are not limited to:
(1) timing information: time and date for one or both of ti and t2
(hereinafter also
referred to as "time stamp data"), and/or duration (At) of the actuation,
which may
be provided in some instances by timing system 128; and
(2) geographic information: latitude and longitude data from location tracking
system
130 (hereinafter also referred to as "geo-location data") (e.g., GPS data may
be
expressed in degrees, minutes, and seconds (i.e., DDD , MM', and SS.S"),
degrees
and decimal minutes (DDD and MM.MMM'), or decimal degrees
(DDD.DDDDD )).
[00121] Examples of marking information that may be acquired before, during or
after a
given actuation or succession of actuations, and also entered into an
electronic record,
include, but are not limited to:
(3) marking material information, such as the presence, color, brand and/or
type of
dispensed marking material or a simulated dispensing of such marking material
(i.e., hereinafter also referred to as "product data");
(4) service-related information: identification (ID) number of the locate
service
provider (e.g., a party/company who dispatches the locate technician,
hereinafter
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-39-
also referred to as "service provider ID"); ID number of the user and/or
technician
(hereinafter also referred to as "user ID"); ID number of the marking device
being
used for the marking operation (hereinafter also referred to as "device ID");
and
(5) ticket information, such as the requesting party, type of facility
requested to be
marked by the requesting party, and address of the work site/dig area for the
marking operation (hereinafter also referred to as "locate request data").
Ticket
information may be received as, or derived from, a locate request ticket or
any
other suitable source.
[001221 In exemplary methods for generating an electronic record of marking
operations
according to some embodiments of the invention, as discussed in greater detail
below, for a
given actuation the processor 118 may request the location tracking system 130
to provide
geographic information at one or more times during the actuation (e.g.,
periodically at regular
intervals). Thus, an actuation data set of an electronic record for a given
actuation of the
marking device may have multiple pieces of geographic information (and
associated time
stamps) representing the location of the marking device at multiple times
during a
corresponding actuation. Additionally, for a given actuation, the processor
118 also may
request the marking material detection mechanism 132 to provide marking
material
information as part of the actuation data set. The processor also may include
ticket
information and service-related information, which may be collected (e.g., via
one or more of
the user interface 126 and the communication interface 124) before a
corresponding
actuation, stored in memory 122 and retrieved from the memory for entry into
the electronic
record upon or during the corresponding actuation, or collected and entered
into the
electronic record upon or during the corresponding actuation.
[001231 While the collection and logging of marking information to generate an
electronic
record is discussed in some aspects, for purposes of illustration, in terms of
actuation data
sets (i.e., a set of data that is associated and logged with a corresponding
actuation of the
marking device), it should be appreciated that various embodiments of the
present invention
are not limited in this respect. More generally, an electronic record of a
marking operation
may be generated in any of a variety of manners, have a variety of file
formats and/or data
structures, and include any of a variety of marking information (some of which
may be
germane to one or more actuations of the marking device and some of which may
be common
to multiple actuations or the overall marking operation in general).
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-40-
[00124] Figure 9 is a flow diagram of an exemplary process 600 for collecting
marking
information during operation of a marking device 110 and generating an
electronic record,
according to one embodiment of the present invention. It should be appreciated
that as
various marking information is collected and logged in the process 600, such
marking
information also may be transmitted from the marking device (e.g., to remote
computer 150)
to facilitate essentially real-time monitoring of the marking operation,
and/or remote
generation of an electronic record of the marking operation.
[00125] In block 602 of the process 600 shown in Figure 9, ticket information
and/or
service-related information may be received (e.g., via one or more of the user
interface 126
and the communication interface 124 of marking device 110) and this
information optionally
may be stored in whole or in part in local memory 122 of the marking device.
The ticket
information and/or service-related information may be received electronically
in any of a
variety of formats, and the processor may be configured to appropriately parse
the
information for subsequent entry into an electronic record. For example, in
some
embodiments, the ticket information may be received as part of an electronic
locate request
ticket, and individual respective pieces of ticket information (e.g., ticket
number, work site
address information, requesting party, etc.) may be extracted or derived from
the electronic
locate request ticket. In other embodiments, various aspects of ticket
information may be
input by a user/technician via the user interface. Similarly, with respect to
service-related
information, a user/technician may manually enter some aspects of this
information, while
other aspects may already be available in other memory locations (e.g., the
marking device
ID or serial number, a technician ID to which the marking device is assigned
or checked-out,
etc.). Accordingly, while block 602 is illustrated as one element of the
process 600, it should
be appreciated that respective pieces of information received as input in
block 602 may be
received at different times and via different interfaces/sources.
[00126] In block 604, the locate technician utilizes the user interface 126 to
indicate the
initiation of a marking operation. For example, the technician may press a
button, operate a
joy-stick, or touch a touch screen display portion of a graphical user
interface to commence a
marking operation. In response, a "job initiation signal" is provided to the
processor 118
(e.g., via a switch closure and a ground or DC level applied to an I/O pin of
the processor, or
by the user interface providing a signal to the processor) to initiate
generation of an electronic
record. Alternatively, a remote job initiation signal may be received by the
processor via the
communication interface from another device, such as the remote computer 150.
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-41-
[00127] In response to the job initiation signal, in block 606 the processor
opens a file in
the memory 122 in which to store the electronic record 135, and assigns a file
identifier to the
opened file. In one example, the file identifier assigned to the opened file
may be or include
one or more of a job number ("job ID") or ticket number derived from the
ticket information
and/or the service-related information, an identifier for the marking device
itself, and an
identifier for a remote computer associated with the marking device (e.g., for
either remote
control operation of the device and/or data uploading/downloading). To this
end, if ticket
information and/or service-related information is not previously available
(e.g., if no
information is received in block 602), the technician optionally may be
prompted to manually
enter (e.g., via a "wizard" or sequence of dialogues germane to obtaining
relevant
information displayed on the display of the user interface) various elements
of ticket
information and/or service-related information from which a file identifier
may be derived, or
provide other information that may be used as a file identifier.
[00128] A file opened in block 606 for purposes of storing an electronic
record may have
any of a variety of formats and include any of a variety of data structures.
In one
embodiment, the processor initially opens up a "flat file" for collection and
logging of
marking information to facilitate generation of an electronic record. As known
in the art, a
flat file is a plain text or mixed text/binary file containing one entry (data
record) per line, in
which each entry may have multiple fields containing respective values, and
wherein the
respective values may be separated by delimiters (e.g., commas) or have a
fixed length. In
one exemplary implementation, the processor 118 logs data into a flat file
opened for the
electronic record as a succession of time stamped "event entries." Some event
entries may be
related specifically to actuation and/or logged in response to actuation of
the marking device
(e.g., the processor 118 receiving an actuation signal 121). Other event
entries may be more
generally related in some manner to overall operation of the marking device or
the marking
operation itself, but not necessarily associated with one or more particular
actuations (e.g.,
start/pause/stop marking operation, power/battery status, communication
link/network
connection status, etc.), and these other event entries may be logged at
virtually any time (in
some cases irrespective of one or more actuations).
[00129] Accordingly, it should be appreciated that in one aspect of this
embodiment a flat
file for an electronic record may contain a succession of time stamped event
entries on
respective lines, in which one or more event entries may have multiple
delimited fields/values
and at least some of the event entries relate to actuation of the marking
device. In another
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-42-
aspect, one or more fields/values in a given event entry may specifically
indicate in some
manner whether or not the event is associated with an actuation of the marking
device. In
general, an "actuation event entry" constitutes an entry in a file for an
electronic record that is
in some manner specifically related to, and/or logged in response to or
during, actuation of
the marking device, and multiple actuation event entries for a given actuation
constitute an
actuation data set for that actuation. Again, it should be appreciated that a
file for an
electronic record may include one or more other event entries that may not be
particularly
associated with an actuation.
[00130] In other embodiments, the file for an electronic record may or may not
be a flat
file, and event entries associated with actuations (actuation event entries)
may be somehow
identified and differentiated from other event entries that are not associated
with an actuation.
For example, a file for an electronic record may include a particular data
structure or format
that segregates or separates in some manner event entries associated with
successive
actuations from those event entries that are not particularly associated with
actuations (and/or
may be common to multiple actuations or a group of actuations). In yet other
embodiments,
as discussed below, marking information may be initially collected and logged
in a first file
for an electronic record in a first format (e.g., a flat file including a
succession of time-
stamped event entries as "raw data" for the marking operation) that may be
stored and/or
transmitted for any of a variety of purposes, and then reformatted and/or
reorganized in some
manner in one or more subsequent files (e.g., a file having a particular data
structure that
segregates/separates actuation-related information from other information in
different
fields/elements of a data structure) for archiving and/or transmission to one
or more other
devices/processors.
[00131] Once a file for an electronic record is opened in block 606, in block
608 the
processor can begin collecting and logging various marking information, i.e.,
logging in the
electronic record (and/or transmitting via the communication interface)
actuation event
entries and/or other event entries. In one exemplary implementation, the
processor may be
programmed so as to poll one or more input devices and/or other components of
the marking
device to receive information, either once or multiple times/periodically
following the job
initiation signal, and log responses to these polls ("polling events") as
event entries with
associated time stamps. Examples of entries corresponding to polling events
that may be
logged into the file for the electronic record (and/or transmitted) include,
but are not limited
to, one or more "power status event entries" including power information
associated with the
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-43-
power source 114, one or more "ticket information event entries" including
ticket information
(e.g., as received from the user interface or the communication interface,
retrieved from local
memory, etc.), one or more "service-related information event entries"
including the service-
related information (e.g., as received from the user interface or the
communication interface,
retrieved from local memory, etc.), and one or more "communication interface
event entries"
including status information regarding operation of the communication
interface (e.g.,
network communication available/unavailable).
[00132] Additionally or alternatively, the processor may be programmed so as
to respond
to one or more signals designated as "interrupt events" from one or more
components of the
marking device. Such interrupt events cause logging of information in the
electronic record
(and/or transmission of information) upon/following the processor detecting
the
corresponding signal(s). For example, the "job initiation signal" itself may
constitute an
interrupt event, in response to which the processor 118 not only opens a file
for the electronic
record but, once the file is opened, the processor may request timing
information from the
timing system 128 and log into the electronic record a "start job event entry"
including a job
initiation time stamp associated with receipt of the job initiation signal.
[00133] In a similar manner, following commencement of a marking operation,
the locate
technician may utilize the user interface 126 (e.g.., press a button, operate
a joy-stick, or
touch a touch screen display portion of a graphical user interface) to pause,
restart, and/or
indicate completion of the marking operation, and these actions may constitute
interrupt
events. For example, as indicated in block 610 of Figure 9, a "pause signal"
may be provided
by the user interface to the processor, in response to which the processor may
request timing
information from the timing system and log a "pause job event entry" including
a pause job
time stamp associated with the at least one pause signal. When the technician
is ready to
continue, as shown in block 612 of Figure 9 the technician may indicate this
via the user
interface and a "restart job event entry" similarly may be logged. When the
marking
operation is deemed by the technician to be completed, as noted in block 614
of Figure 9 the
technician may utilize the user interface so as to provide a "stop signal" to
the processor, in
response to which the processor may request timing information from the timing
system and
log a "stop job event entry" including a stop job time stamp associate with
the stop signal.
[00134] While various events are noted above as examples of "polling events"
as opposed
to "interrupt events," it should be appreciated that the invention is not
limited in these
respects, and that the marking data algorithm 134 executed by the processor
118 may be
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-44-
configured in any of a variety manners to designate various functions
performed by and/or
information provided by various components of the marking device as polling
events or
interrupt events. For example, the power source 114 may be configured to
provide a "low
battery signal" to the processor, which when present is treated by the
processor as an interrupt
event that may be logged by the processor and/or that may cause the processor
to take some
particular action (e.g., provide an audible/visible alert; disable logging of
further data, etc.).
In one aspect, absent the "low battery signal," the processor may request
status information
from the power source once or occasionally as a polling event. Similarly, the
communication
interface 124 may be configured to provide a "no network connection available
signal" to the
processor, which when present is treated by the processor as an interrupt
event (that is logged
and/or causes the processor to take some action), and when not present, the
processor may
poll the communication interface to request status information as a polling
event.
[00135] Another example of an interrupt event is given by the actuation signal
121
provided by the actuation system 120 upon actuation of the actuator 142 (i.e.,
a signal
change-of-state indicating a transition from a non-actuated state to an
actuated state), in
response to which the processor logs one or more actuation event entries in
the electronic
record. More specifically, in one implementation, the receipt of a non-
actuated to actuated
transition state of the actuation signal 121 by the processor may cause an
initial actuation
event entry to be logged as a "start actuation event entry" having an
associated time stamp
(i.e., a start time for the corresponding actuation) and also cause the
processor to
subsequently poll one or more input devices for information during the
corresponding
actuation and until release of the actuator (i.e., subsequent change of state
of the actuation
signal 121). In this manner, an actuation data set for a given actuation may
include multiple
actuation event entries.
[00136] For example, during actuation of the actuator, the processor may poll
the location
tracking system 130 so as to receive geographic information, and in turn log
one or more
"geo-location data event entries" in the actuation data set for the
corresponding actuation. As
discussed above in connection with Figures 2 and 3, in one exemplary
implementation the
location tracking system is configured to provide geographic information at an
information
update rate of approximately 5 Hz, and the processor may log respective
updates of
geographic information provided by the location tracking system at this update
rate during an
actuation as multiple geo-location data event entries of the actuation data
set. It should be
appreciated, however, that methods and apparatus according to various
embodiments of the
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-45-
present invention are not limited in this respect, and that other geographic
information update
rates may be employed in various implementations (e.g., update rates of up to
approximately
100 Hz), based in part on the particular location tracking system employed.
Furthermore, it
should be appreciated that in some implementations the geographic information
provided by
the location tracking system 130 may include one or more longitude
coordinates, latitude
coordinates, and a corresponding geo-location data time stamp at which a given
set of
longitude/latitude coordinates are obtained by the location tracking system;
accordingly, a
given geo-location data event entry in an actuation data set may include a
longitude
coordinate, a latitude coordinate, and the corresponding geo-location data
time stamp.
[00137] Similarly, in some implementations, pursuant to an interrupt provided
by the
actuation signal 121, the processor may subsequently poll one or more of the
timing system
128 and the marking material detection mechanism 132 so as to receive timing
information
and/or marking material information during a corresponding actuation, and in
turn log one or
more of a "timing event entry," and a "marking material detection event entry"
as part of the
actuation data set. Any of a variety of marking material information as
discussed above may
be collected and logged during actuation in response to processor polling of
the marking
material detection mechanism (e.g., causing an RFID tag reader to read various
information
from an RFID tag affixed to the marking dispenser).
[00138] Additionally, in some implementations, pursuant to an interrupt
provided by the
actuation signal 121, the processor may subsequently poll one or more of the
user interface
126, the communication interface 124, and the local memory 122 to retrieve
ticket
information and/or service-related information for logging into an actuation
data set. As
discussed above, in some implementations the receipt/retrieval of ticket
information and/or
service-related information may be treated as a polling event not necessarily
associated with
actuations, and this information need not be included in one or more actuation
data sets.
However, in other implementations it may be desirable to include at least some
aspect of
ticket information and/or service related information in each actuation data
set,
notwithstanding the possible redundancy of data content in respective
actuation data sets
(e.g., see Table 2, discussed further below in connection with Figure 10).
[00139] Another example of an interrupt event is given by a change-of-state of
the
actuation signal 121 indicating a transition from the actuated state to the
non-actuated state,
i.e., release of the actuator 142. In response to this event, the processor
may request
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-46-
information from the timing system 128 and log an "end actuation event entry"
including an
end time stamp.
[00140] Yet another type of interrupt event causing the processor to log one
or more event
entries may be provided by the marking material detection mechanism 132 in the
form of a
signal that indicates whether or not a marking dispenser is contained in or
appropriately
coupled to the marking device. To this end, as discussed above in connection
with Figures 2
and 3, the marking material detection mechanism may include a toggle switch
that provides a
two-state signal to the processor (e.g., dispenser in/dispenser out) as an
interrupt. Upon
receiving an interrupt indicating a transition from "dispenser out" to
"dispenser in," the
processor may collect and log this event as a "dispenser in event entry" with
a corresponding
time stamp, and then request other marking material information relating to
the marking
material in the dispenser from the marking material detection mechanism. In
view of the
foregoing, it should be appreciated that in some embodiments, marking material
information
may not necessarily be collected during one or more actuations of the marking
device, but
alternatively may be collected only upon a "dispenser in" event being
detected. Upon
detection of an interrupt event indicating a transition from "dispenser in" to
"dispenser out,"
the processor similarly may collect and log this event as a "dispenser out
event entry."
[00141] In yet another embodiment, the processor 118, executing marking data
algorithm
134, may be configured to repeatedly/regularly poll all available input
devices and other
components of the marking device (e.g., in a predetermined order, in response
to receipt of
the job initiation signal) and generate an essentially continuous stream of
data packets
including marking information received pursuant to these polling events. In
one aspect of
this embodiment, each data packet of marking information may include a header,
one or more
flag fields, and one or more information payload fields. For example, in one
implementation,
the header for each packet may include one or more of a job ID (e.g., ticket
identifier),
technician ID, device ID (e.g., serial number), packet type ID, and/or a time
stamp
corresponding to logging of information/generation of the packet. Each packet
also may
include one or more payload fields for carrying information provided by the
polled device(s)
or components, and one or more flag fields that are set (or reset) upon
occurrence of one or
more predetermined interrupt events (e.g., pull/depress actuator, release
actuator, marking
dispenser in, marking dispenser out, low power, communication link fail,
etc.). In this
manner, a continuous stream of data may be provided as an output by the
processor, in which
certain interrupt events, such as an actuation and/or release of the actuator,
"tag" certain data
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-47-
packets via an interrupt flag. In yet other aspects of this embodiment, all
data packets thusly
generated may be stored in the file opened for the electronic record and/or
transmitted from
the marking device in essentially real time; alternatively, only certain data
packets with one
or more predetermined flags set may be stored and/or transmitted.
[00142] Table 1 below illustrates an example of a portion of the contents of a
relatively
simple flat file for an electronic record that may be generated by the process
600 of Figure 9:
TIME LAT LONG EVENT MARKER
COLOR
1:23:00.00 PM -80.3851 25.5604 Spraying ORANGE
1:23:00.20 PM -80.3851 25.5604 Spraying ORANGE
1:23:00.40 PM -80.3851 25.5604 Spraying ORANGE
1:23:00.60 PM -80.3851 25.5604 Spraying ORANGE
1:23.00.80 PM -80.3851 25.5604 Spraying ORANGE
1:23:01.00 PM -80.3851 25.5604 Spraying ORANGE
1:23:01.20 PM -80.3851 25.5604 Spraying ORANGE
1:23:01.40 PM -80.3851 25.56039 Spraying ORANGE
1:23:01.60 PM -80.3851 25.56039 Spraying ORANGE
1:23:01.80 PM -80.3851 25.5604 Spraying ORANGE
1:23:02.00 PM -80.3851 25.5604 Spraying ORANGE
Table 1
The portion of the file shown in Table 1 corresponds to multiple actuation
event entries (one
entry per line) collected and logged during an actuation of the marking
device. Each entry
has a time stamp (e.g., entries are logged at a rate of approximately five
events per second)
and further includes multiple fields having respective values (e.g., as comma
separated
values) for latitude and longitude coordinates received from the location
tracking device, an
event indicator indicating that the device is "Spraying" (the actuator is
actuated), and a color
of the marking material being dispensed.
[00143] As noted above, it should be appreciated that the portion of the file
shown in
Table 1 is provided primarily for purposes of illustration, and that the
format and/or content
for respective event entries and the file itself for an electronic record
generated by and/or
based on the information collection process discussed above in connection with
Figure 9 may
have any of a variety of different formats and/or content.
[00144] To this point, Tables 2 through 5 below provide examples of various
events for
which event entries may be logged in a file for an electronic record and/or
transmitted by the
marking device, exemplary formats for these event entries, and exemplary file
formats for
files having multiple such entries, according to another embodiment of the
present invention.
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-48-
[00145] Job Started/Paused/Restarted/Completed Events: This event entry format
provides information about when a marking operation ("job") was started and
completed in
addition to capturing details about if and when the job was paused and
restarted.
Format INFO+JOBS: (DATE) (TIME) (WAND_ID) (JOB_ID) (STATE) <CR><LF>
Examples INFO+JOBS: DATE(2009-04-15) TIME(12:03:44) WAND(2334) JOB(4000)
(STARTED)
<CR> <LF>
INFO+JOBS: DATE(2009-04-15) TIME(12:11:44) WAND(2334) JOB(4000) (PAUSED)
<CR> <LF>
INFO+JOBS: DATE(2009-04-15) TIME(12:51:44) WAND(2334) JOB(4000)
(RESTARTED) <CR> <LF>
INFO+JOBS: DATE(2009-04-15) TIME(13:09:44) WAND(2334) JOB(4000) (END) <CR>
<LF>
Table 2
[00146] Actuation State Change Events: For purposes of this event format, the
actuator
is deemed to have three possible states, i.e., PRESSED, HELD and RELEASED.
Marking
information from one or more input devices/other components of the marking
device is
recorded with these events to provide information about the job in progress.
Format INFO+ WPTR: (DATE) (TIME) (GPS data) (PAINT info) (TRIGGER SWITCH
STATE) <CR><
Examples INFO+WPTR: DATE(2009-04-15) TIME(12:04:44)
GPS($GPGGA,120443,4807.038,N,01131.000,E,1,08,0.9,545.4,M,46.9,M,,*47 )
CLR(RED)
SWCH(PRESSED)<CR><LF>
INFO+WPTR: DATE(2009-04-15) TI M E(12:04:45)
GPS($GPGGA,120445,4807.038,N,01131.000,E,1,08,0.9,545.4,M,46.9,M,,*47)
CLR(RED)
SWCH(HELD)<CR><LF>
INFO+WPTR: DATE(2009-04-15) TIME(12:04:46)
GPS($GPGGA,120446,4807.038,N,01131.000,E,1,08,0.9,545.4,M,46.9,M,,*47 )
CLR(RED)
SWCH RELEASED <CR><LF>
Table 3
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-49-
[00147] Marking Device Status Events: The status event collects various
marking
information and/or information on operating characteristics of the device on a
periodic basis
while a job is in progress (e.g., pursuant to processor polls).
Format INFO+STAT: (DATE) (TIME) (GPS data) (PAINT status) (MEMORY used in %)
(BATT
level) <CR><LF>
Examples INFO+STAT: DATE(2009-04-15) TIME(12:04:00)
GPS($GPGGA,120400,4807.038,N,01131.000,E,1,08,0.9,545.4,M,46.9,M,,*47 )
CLR(RED) MEM(65) BAT(3)<CR><LF>
Table 4
[00148] Error Events: Should any input device or other component of the
marking device
encounter a significant error condition, this may be logged as an event. In
some cases, the
user/technician also may be notified of the error through the user interface
126 (visible alert
on display, audible alarm/alert, etc.). Similar event formats may be adopted
for warning
alerts/events and informational alerts/events.
Format INFO+ERR: (DATE) (TIME) (GPS data) (PAINT status) (MEMORY used in %)
(BATTERY level) <CR><LF>
Examples INFO+ERR: DATE(2009-04-15) TIME(12:04:00)
GPS($GPGGA,120400,4807.038,N,01131.000,E,1,08,0.9,545.4,M,46.9,M,,*47 )
CLR(RED) MEM(65) BAT(3)<CR><LF>
Table 5
[00149] With respect to file formats for electronic records including the
event entries
outlined above in Tables 2 through 5, two exemplary file formats, namely ASCII
and XML,
are provided below for purposes of illustration. In various implementations, a
given marking
device may be particularly configured to store and/or transmit electronic
records and
respective entries therein in either format (or other formats). With respect
to identification of
files/electronic records, a standard naming scheme/format may be adopted, for
example,
including an identifier for the remote computer with which the marking device
may be
communicating ("ServerlD"), an identifier for the marking device itself
("WandID"), and an
identifier for the marking operation/job ("JobID"), and having the format
"ServerlD WandID Job ID."
[00150] ASCII Data Format: This format allows low-level remote processing
engines to
quickly and easily receive, parse, and react to marking information logged
and/or transmitted
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-50-
by the marking device. An example of an electronic record formatted in ASCII
based on the
event entries outlined in Tables 2 through 5 is as follows:
INFO+JOBS: DATE(2009-04-15) TIME(12:03:44) WAND(2334) JOB(4000)
(STARTED) <CR> <LF>
INFO+STAT: DATE(2009-04-15) TIME(12:04:00)
GPS($GPGGA,120400,4807.038,N,01131.000,E,1,08,0.9,545.4,M,46.9,M,,*47 )
CLR(RED) MEM(65) BAT(3)<CR><LF>
INFO+WPTR: DATE(2009-04-15) TI M E(12:04:44)
GPS($GPGGA,120443,4807.038,N,01131.000,E,1,08,0.9,545.4,M,46.9,M,,*47 )
CLR(RED) SWCH(PRESSED)<CR><LF>
INFO+WPTR: DATE(2009-04-15) TIME(12:04:45)
GPS($GPGGA,120445,4807.038,N,01131.000,E,1,08,0.9,545.4,M,46.9,M,,*47 )
CLR(RED) SWCH(HELD)<CR><LF>
INFO+WPTR: DATE(2009-04-15) TIME(12:04:46)
GPS($GPGGA,120446,4807.038,N,01131.000,E,1,08,0.9,545.4,M,46.9,M,,*47 )
CLR(RED) SWCH(RELEASED)<CR><LF>
INFO+STAT: DATE(2009-04-15) TI M E(12: 05:00)
GPS($GPGGA,120500,4807.038,N,01131.000,E,1,08,0.9,545.4,M,46.9,Mõ*47 )
CLR(RED) BAT(3)<CR><LF>
INFO+JOBS: DATE(2009-04-15) TIME(12:10:03) WAND(2334) JOB(4000)
(PAUSED)<CR> <LF>
INFO+JOBS: DATE(2009-04-15) TIME(13:01:43) WAND(2334) JOB(4000)
(RESTARTED)<CR> <LF>
INFO+WPTR: DATE(2009-04-1 5) TIME(13:01:50)
GPS($GPGGA,130150,4807.038,N,01131.000,E,1,08,0.9,545.4,M,46.9,Mõ*47 )
CLR(RED) SWCH(PRESSED)<CR><LF>
INFO+WPTR: DATE(2009-04-15) TI M E(13:01:5 1)
GPS($GPGGA,130151,4807.038,N,01131.000,E,1, 08,0.9,545.4,M,46.9,Mõ*47 )
CLR(RED) SWCH(RELEASED)<CR><LF>
INFO+JOBS: DATE(2009-04-15) TIME(13:20:30) WAND(2334) JOB(4000)
(END)<CR> <LF>
(00151] XML Data Format: This format allows transmission of self-describing
data
elements from the marking device, in some instances reducing processing errors
and reducing
the risks and effort involved in upgrades and data changes. An example of an
electronic
record formatted in XML based on the event entries outlined in Tables 2
through 5 is as
follows:
<WAND ID=2334>
<JOB ID=4000>
<ACTIVITY>
<DATE>2009-04-15 </DATE>
<TIME>12:03:44</TIME>
<STATU S> Sta rted </STATU S>
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-51-
</ACTIVITY>
<ACTIVITY>
<DATE>2009-04-15</DATE>
<TIME>12:04:00</TIME>
<GPS>($GPGGA,
120400,4807.038,N,01 131.000,.000,E,1 , 08, 0.9, 545.4, M,46.9, Mõ'47 </G PS>
<PAINT>
<COLOR>Red</COLOR>
<VALI D>True<NALI D>
<SN>2342343243355</SN>
</PAI NT>
<SWITCH>Pressed</SWITCH>
</ACTIVITY>
</JOB>
</WAN D>
[00152] Yet another alternative format for storing and organizing marking
information in
an electronic record of a marking operation, according to one embodiment of
the invention, is
shown in Table 6 below. By way of example, Table 6 shows the format and
content of three
actuation data sets of an electronic record of a marking operation for a given
facility, in
which each actuation data set includes information associated with multiple
actuation event
entries logged during a corresponding actuation and resulting locate mark
(e.g., act-l, act-2,
and act-3), as shown for example in Figure 8. As discussed above, it should be
appreciated
that the format and content shown below in Table 6 may constitute an
"original" electronic
record generated by the processor pursuant to the process 600 shown in Figure
9, or may be
derived from raw data collected and logged pursuant to the process 600 (e.g.,
as a flat file, an
ASCII formatted file, or an XML formatted file) and subsequently reorganized
and
particularly formatted.
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-52-
Table 6 Exam le actuation data set for act-1
Service provider ID 0482
User ID 4815
Device ID 7362
T1 timestamp data 12-Jul-2008; 09:35:15.2
T2 timestamp data 12-Jul-2008; 09:35:16.1
Duration (At) 00:00:00.9
Ti geo-location data 2650.9348,N,08003.5057,WDecimal Degrees)
1St interval location data 2650.9353,N,08003.5055,WDecimal Degrees)
2" interval location 2650.9356,N,08003.5055,W (Decimal Degrees)
act-1 data
Nth interval location 2650.9246,N,08003.5240,W (Decimal Degrees)
data
T2 geo-location data 2650.9255,N,08003.5236,WDecimal Degrees)
Product data Color=Red, Brand=ABC, Type/Batch = 224B-1
Locate request data Requestor: XYZ Construction Company,
Requested service address: 222 Main St, Orlando, FL
Table 6 continued) Example actuation data set for act-2
Service provider ID 0482
User ID 4815
Device ID 7362
T1 timestamp data 12-Jul-2008; 09:35:17.5
T2 timestamp data 12-Jul-2008; 09:35:18.7
Duration (At) 00:00:01.2
T1 geo-location data 2650.9256,N,08003.5234,WDecimal Degrees)
1st interval location data 2650.9256,N,08003.5226,W (Decimal Degrees)
2" interval location 2650.9256,N,08003.5217,W (Decimal Degrees)
act-2 data
Nth interval location 2650.9260,N,08003.5199,W (Decimal Degrees)
data
T2 geo-location data 2650.9266,N,08003.5196,WDecimal Degrees)
Product data Color=Red, Brand=ABC, Type/Batch = 224B-1
Locate request data Requestor: XYZ Construction Company,
Requested service address: 222 Main St, Orlando, FL
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-53-
Table 6 (continued) Example actuation data set for act-3
Service provider ID 0482
User ID 4815
Device ID 7362
T1 timestamp data 12-Jul-2008; 09:35:18.7
T2 timestamp data 12-Jul-2008; 09:35:19.8
duration (At) 00:00:01.1
T1 geo-location data 2650.9273,N,08003.5193,WDecimal Degrees)
1st interval location data 2650.9281,N,08003.5190,WDecimal Degrees)
2" interval location 2650.9288,N,08003.5188,W (Decimal Degrees)
act-3 data
Nth interval location 2650.9321,N,08003.5177,W (Decimal Degrees)
data
T2 geo-location data 2650.9325,N,08003.5176,W (Decimal Degrees)
Product data Color=Red, Brand=ABC, Type/Batch = 224B-1
Locate request data Requestor: XYZ Construction Company,
Requested service address: 222 Main St, Orlando, FL
[00153] In addition to the information shown in Table 6, a job ID or some
other identifier
for the electronic record as a whole (e.g., a ticket number), as well as a
total number of
actuations for a given marking operation (e.g., the total number of actuation
data sets in a
given electronic record in this embodiment), may be included in the electronic
record.
[00154] With regard to color information that may be included in any of the
event entries
and electronic records discussed herein, Table 7 below shows an example of the
correlation
of marking material color to the type of facility to be marked.
Table 7 Correlation of color to facility type
Marking material Facility Type
color
Red Electric power lines, cables or conduits, and lighting cables
Yellow Gas, oil, steam, petroleum, or other hazardous liquid or gaseous
materials
Orange Communications, cable television, alarm or signal lines, cables, or
conduits
Blue Water, irrigation, and slurry lines
Green Sewers, storm sewer facilities, or other drain lines
White Proposed excavation
Pink Temporary survey markings
Purple Reclaimed water, irrigation, and slurry lines
Black Mark-out for errant lines
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-54-
[00155] Figure 10 illustrates an exemplary data structure for an electronic
record 135,
according to another embodiment of the present invention, that may be
generated by and/or
based on information collected during the process 600 discussed above in
connection with
Figure 9 and based on the organization of information shown in Table 6 above.
As shown in
Figure 10, the record 135 includes a file identifier 701 (e.g., one or more of
Job ID, WandID,
ServerID, etc.) and a plurality of actuation data sets 1 through N (with
reference numbers
702A, 702B, 702C...702N), wherein each actuation data set is associated with a
corresponding actuation of a marking device. For purposes of the following
discussion,
Figure 10 shows additional details of the data structure for actuation data
set 3 702C, showing
several fields in which data (e.g., actuation event entries) may be entered to
constitute the
actuation data set. While only the exemplary details of the data structure of
actuation data set
3 are shown in the electronic record 135 of Figure 10, it should be
appreciated that multiple
actuation data sets of the electronic record 135 may have the same data
structure as that
shown for actuation data set 3 in Figure 10.
[00156] The data structure of the actuation data set 3 702C of the electronic
record 135
shown in Figure 10 includes a start location field 704 (corresponding to Ti
geo-location data
shown in Table 2), an end location field 713 (corresponding to T2 geo-location
data shown in
Table 2), a start time field 706 (corresponding to Ti timestamp data shown in
Table 2), an
end time field 708 (corresponding to T2 timestamp data shown in Table 2) and a
duration
field 709 (corresponding to the duration At shown in Table 2). Additionally,
the data
structure for entry 3 702C includes one or more fields 712A, 712B,... 712N for
intermediate
location data (corresponding to 1St interval location data, 2"d interval
location data. .Nth
interval location data shown in Table 2). Finally, the data structure for the
entry 3 702C may
include one or more ticket information fields 714 (e.g., corresponding to
Locate request data
in Table 2) and one or more service-related information fields 716 (e.g.,
corresponding to
Service provider ID, User ID, and Device ID in Table 2).
[00157] In addition to one or more actuation data sets corresponding to
actuations of a
marking device, the electronic record 135 shown in Figure 10 may include one
or more
additional elements. For example, Figure 10 shows an additional element 718 of
the
electronic record to store the total number of entries in the record.
Furthermore, according to
another embodiment, various other information that may be common to multiple
(or all)
actuation data sets of a given electronic record may be stored in one or more
additional
elements of the electronic record that are not contained within one or more of
the actuation
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-55-
data sets themselves. For example, in one alternative implementation, one or
more of the
ticket information field 714, the service-related information field 716, and
the marking
material properties field 710, which are shown as part of the data structure
for a given
actuation data set of the electronic record, may instead be elements of the
electronic record
that are not included within any one actuation data set (e.g., the information
contained in one
or more of the ticket information field and the service-related information
field may be
common to all actuation data sets of a given electronic record).
[00158] V Computer-generated Visual Representation of a Marking Operation
[00159] With reference again to Figures 2 and 3, in yet another embodiment the
processor
118, executing marking data algorithm 134, and/or one or more remote computers
150
executing marking data algorithm 134, may additionally process various marking
information
provided in real time from a marking device and/or stored in an electronic
record of a
marking operation and control a display device (e.g., display 146 of marking
device 110 or
some other display device) to render a computer-generated visual
representation of a marking
operation. Such a visual representation of the marking operation may be used,
for example,
to provide immediate feedback to the locate technician, provide essentially
real-time
feedback to a supervisor monitoring the marking operation from a remote
location, provide a
visual record of the marking operation (e.g., for archiving purposes, once the
marking
operation is completed and one or more electronic records are generated),
and/or to verify the
quality (e.g., accuracy and completeness) of work performed during the marking
operation.
[00160] In various aspects of this embodiment, a visual representation may be
static in that
all available information is presented in a display field at one time after
completion of the
marking operation and generation of an electronic record; alternatively, the
visual
representation may be dynamic in that information representing successive
actuations of the
marking device is displayed in essentially real-time, or may be displayed
after completion of
the marking operation and generation of the electronic record in a time-
sequenced animation
that "recreates" the marking operation on the time scale in which it was
performed originally.
[00161] In other aspects, the relative positions of all locate marks
represented by actuation
event entries logged and/or transmitted by the marking device may be displayed
(e.g., based
on geo-location data and some appropriate scale of an available display field
of display 146)
to provide a visual representation of the marking operation. A visual
representation of a
marking operation may also be rendered in one or more particular colors
corresponding to
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-56-
one or more particular underground facilities marked during the marking
operation (e.g., see
Table 7).
[00162] In one exemplary implementation, such a visual representation may
include one
"electronic locate mark" displayed in a display field for each
actuation/dispensing action of a
marking device, such that there is essentially a one-to-one correspondence
between electronic
locate marks and physical locate marks for a given underground facility marked
during a
marking operation. Alternatively, in another exemplary implementation of such
a visual
representation, an essentially continuous solid line (or other line type) may
be displayed in a
display field to represent a given underground facility marked during a
marking operation. In
another aspect, the processor may process the geo-location data in respective
actuation data
sets of an electronic record so as to filter, average, interpolate and/or
otherwise "smooth" data
(e.g., so as to provide "cleaner" visual renderings and/or connect successive
locate marks
represented by the respective actuation data sets of the electronic record);
alternatively, "raw
data" provided by the marking device may be utilized for the visual
representation. In yet
another aspect of this embodiment, visual representations of multiple marking
operations for
different underground facilities within the same work site/dig area may be
generated in the
same display field of a display device so as to provide a composite visual
representation, in
which different underground facilities may be uniquely identified in some
manner (e.g., by
different line types and/or different colors).
[00163] Figure 11 illustrates a flow chart for a process 800 according to one
embodiment
of the present invention for generating a visual representation of a marking
operation based
on an electronic record and/or essentially real-time information transmission
from the
marking device 110. As noted above, the process 800 may result from the
execution of one
embodiment of the marking data algorithm 134 on the processor 118 of the
marking device
110 (to render the visual representation on the display 146 of the marking
device), or by one
or more other remote computers (to render the visual representation on one or
more other
display devices).
[00164] In block 802 of the process 800, if an electronic record has already
been generated
for the marking operation in which one or more underground facilities are
marked, the record
is examined to determine the geographic extents of the locate marks to be
visually rendered
on a display device. In particular, the processor 118 may review the geo-
location data of all
actuation data sets of the electronic record to determine (e.g., based on the
respective latitude
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-57-
and longitude coordinates of the available geo-location data) the maximum
extents of the
marking operation to be visually rendered.
[00165] The maximum extents of the marking operation may be determined in any
of a
variety of manners according to different exemplary implementations. For
example, in one
exemplary implementation, in block 802 the processor 118 may determine the
centroid of all
electronic locate marks represented by respective actuation data sets of the
electronic record
to be displayed. The processor then determines the geographic extent of the
collection of
electronic locate marks by determining one or more latitude/longitude
coordinate pairs from
the available data having a greatest distance from the centroid. In one
example, the processor
may determine a single farthest point from the centroid, and a distance
between this farthest
point and the centroid serves as a radius of a circle that provides an
"extents area circle." In
another example, the "farthest opposing corners" of a rectangle around the
centroid may be
determined by assigning the centroid as the origin of a reference coordinate
system, and
finding the coordinate pairs in opposing quadrants of the coordinate system
having a greatest
distance from the centroid (e.g., the +LAT/+LONG and -LAT/-LONG coordinate
pairs at a
greatest distance from the origin) to provide an "extents area rectangle."
Other types of
polygons and closed shapes (ovals) may be employed to provide an extents area
for the
marking operation to be displayed.
[00166] Alternatively, if an electronic record has not been previously
generated and
information received in essentially real-time from the marking device is to be
displayed in a
display field, a default extents area may be selected in advance based on any
of a variety of
criteria. For example, address and/or site description information provided in
a ticket
pursuant to which the marking operation is performed may provide a basis on
which an
extents area for the marking operation may be estimated a priori. Similarly,
as discussed
further below in connection with Figure 14, an available digital image of the
work site/dig
area may be employed to determine or estimate an initial extents area for the
marking
operation.
[00167] In block 804, the extents area of the marking operation to be visually
rendered is
then mapped to an available display field of a display device, using any
appropriate scaling
factor as necessary, to ensure that all of the geo-location data in the
electronic record fits
within the display field. For example, in one exemplary implementation, a
transformation
may be derived using information relating to the available display field
(e.g., a reference
coordinate system using an appropriate scale for a given display field of a
display device) to
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-58-
map data points within the extents area to the available display field. In
another aspect of this
example, a buffer area around the extents area may be added to provide one or
more suitable
margins for the displayed visual representation, and/or to accommodate
different shapes of
extents areas to the available display field of the display device, and an
appropriate
transformation may be derived based on this optional additional buffer area.
[001681 Once a transformation is derived to map the marking operation extents
area to the
available display field of a display device, in block 806 one or more
electronic locate marks
is/are rendered in the display field based on applying the transformation to
the geo-location
data present in the data set of one or more corresponding actuation data sets
of the electronic
record. In one exemplary implementation, one electronic locate mark is
rendered in the
display field for each actuation data set of an electronic record. With
reference again to Table
6 and Figure 10, in one embodiment each actuation data set includes at least
Ti geo-location
data for a start of an actuation of a marking device and one or more other
pieces of geo-
location data during actuation. Using multiple pieces of geo-location data per
actuation data
set, an electronic locate mark may be rendered as a line in the display field
(e.g., so as to
visually represent one of the physical locate marks 414-1, 414-2 or 414-3
shown in Figure 8).
In another exemplary implementation, an electronic locate mark may be rendered
for each
geo-location data in a given entry, such that multiple electronic locate marks
correspond to
one actuation (e.g., a series of dots electronically rendered to graphically
represent a line-type
physical locate mark). In one aspect, as discussed above, a given electronic
locate mark may
be rendered in a particular color and/or line type to represent a type of
underground facility
represented by the mark (e.g., as indicated by marking material information
included in the
electronic record).
[00169] Figure 12 illustrates a plan view of an exemplary composite visual
representation
900 that "electronically recreates" a marking operation for various
underground facilities
present in a dig area, based for example on the process 800 discussed above.
In particular,
Figure 12 illustrates a number of electronic locate marks corresponding to
actuations of a
marking device whose relative positions in the display field are derived from
actuation data
sets of the electronic record, as discussed above. In the example of Figure
12, act-1 through
act-7 form a lines pattern 910 representing a first marked underground
facility, act-8 through
act- 14 form a lines pattern 912 representing a second marked underground
facility, act- 15
through act-24 form a lines pattern 914 representing a third marked
underground facility, and
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-59-
act-25 through act-35 form a lines pattern 916 representing a fourth marked
underground
facility.
[00170] As noted above, while in one embodiment there may be a one-to-one
correspondence between electronic locate marks rendered in a single or
composite visual
representation and physical locate marks placed in a dig area during a marking
operation, or
there may be multiple electronic locate marks for a corresponding physical
locate mark, in
yet other embodiments a single or composite visual representation may provide
a variety of
other indicators/digital representations of marked underground facilities in a
computer-
generated visual rendering. For example, Figure 13 illustrates another example
of a
composite visual representation 1000 based on the same electronic record used
to generate
the composite visual representation 900 of Figure 12, in which continuous
lines are used to
indicate the respective marking operations. To this end, in one exemplary
implementation, an
additional step may be included in the process 800 shown in Figure 11, in
which the
processor may process the geo-location data in an electronic record by
filtering, averaging,
interpolating and/or otherwise "smoothing" the data so as to connect
successive discrete
locate marks represented by the respective actuation data sets of the
electronic record and
thereby provide a substantially smooth continuous line for display.
[00171] In the example of Figure 13, as also noted above, different
underground facility
types may be indicated in different color lines, and the different
colors/facility types may be
derived from the electronic record (e.g., based on the correlations provided
in Table 7).
Furthermore, in other aspects, text indicators may be included in the visual
representation,
and/or other types of coding may be used (different line styles such as
patterns, width, bold,
etc.; a succession of symbols or other graphic icons, etc.) to indicate
different facility types,
and/or some other aspect of a given facility (e.g., the material used for a
particular pipe,
conduit, cable, sheathing; the diameter of a particular pipe, conduit, cable;
offsets to one or
more environmental landmarks, etc.). By way of example, Figure 13 indicates
that the four
underground facilities in the composite visual representation correspond to a
power line 1010
(which may be rendered in the color red), a first sewer line 1012 (which may
be rendered in
the color green), a second sewer line 1014 (which also may be rendered in the
color green),
and a telecommunications line 1016 (which may be rendered in the color
orange). While not
shown explicitly in Figure 13, an exemplary composite visual representation
may include
additional textual, numeric and/or graphic elements to provide other
information available in
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-60-
the electronic record for the marking operations (e.g., timestamp information,
ID information,
coordinates for location information, offset indications, etc.).
[00172] In some marking operations, a technician may use the marking device
not only to
mark an underground facility's placement/path relative to the ground, pavement
or other
surface, but also to "annotate" the marking operation in some fashion. For
example, in some
instances a technician actually "writes" with the marking device (e.g., by
actuating the
marking device to dispense paint) to provide text annotations, offset
indications, arrows,
other symbols, and the like on the ground, pavement or other surface.
Accordingly, the
electronic record for a marking operation may include one or more actuation
data sets
corresponding to actuations in which the technician was "writing" to annotate
the marking
operation in some fashion rather than marking the path of an underground
facilities. In some
cases, providing such technician annotations on a visual representation of a
marking
operation may be desirable; however, in other instances such annotations may
provide erratic
markings on a visual representation, in which case additional processing of
geo-location data
or other information in the electronic record (e.g., filtering, averaging,
interpolating and/or
otherwise "smoothing" the data) may be employed.
[00173] In yet another embodiment, a single or composite visual representation
of a
marking operation may rendered on a display device together with a digital
image
representative of at least a portion of a dig area at a work site, such that
one or more
electronic locate marks appear in appropriate relative positions overlaid on
the displayed
digital image. Figure 14 illustrates yet another example of a composite visual
representation
1100, albeit based on an electronic record different than that used to
generate the visual
representations of Figures 9 and 10, in which continuous lines are used to
indicate the
respective different underground facilities marked, and these lines are
overlaid on a digital
image of a dig area. It should be appreciated that although continuous lines
representing
underground facilities are depicted on a digital image in Figure 14, in other
embodiments
discrete electronic locate marks corresponding to successive actuations of a
marking device
(or multiple discrete electronic locate marks per actuation) may be overlaid
on a digital image
of the dig area.
[00174] In the embodiment of Figure 14, a number of different image sources
and image
types may be employed to provide the digital image on which a visual
representation of a
marking operation may be overlaid. For purposes of the present disclosure,
such a digital
image (also referred to herein as an "input image") may be any image
represented by source
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-61-
data that is electronically processed (e.g., the source data is in a computer-
readable format) to
display the image on a display device. An input image may include any of a
variety of
paper/tangible image sources that are scanned (e.g., via an electronic
scanner) or otherwise
converted so as to create source data (e.g., in various formats such as XML,
PDF, JPG, BMP,
etc.) that can be processed to display the input image. An input image also
may include an
image that originates as source data or an electronic file without necessarily
having a
corresponding paper/tangible copy of the image (e.g., an image of a "real-
world" scene
acquired by a digital still frame or video camera or other image acquisition
device, in which
the source data, at least in part, represents pixel information from the image
acquisition
device).
[0001] In some exemplary implementations, input images according to the
present
disclosure may be created, provided, and/or processed by a geographic
information system
(GIS) that captures, stores, analyzes, manages and presents data referring to
(or linked to)
location, such that the source data representing the input image includes
pixel information
from an image acquisition device (corresponding to an acquired "real world"
scene or
representation thereof), and/or spatial/geographic information ("geo-encoded
information").
[0002] In view of the foregoing, various examples of input images and source
data
representing input images according to the present disclosure, to which the
inventive
concepts disclosed herein may be applied, include but are not limited to:
= Manual "free-hand" paper sketches of the geographic area (which may include
one or more buildings, natural or man-made landmarks, property boundaries,
streets/intersections, public works or facilities such as street lighting,
signage, fire
hydrants, mail boxes, parking meters, etc.);
= Various maps indicating surface features and/or extents of geographical
areas,
such as street/road maps, topographical maps, military maps, parcel maps, tax
maps, town and county planning maps, call-center and/or facility polygon maps,
virtual maps, etc. (such maps may or may not include geo-encoded information);
= Facility maps illustrating installed underground facilities, such as gas,
power,
telephone, cable, fiber optics, water, sewer, drainage, etc. Facility maps may
also
indicate street-level features (streets, buildings, public facilities, etc.)
in relation to
the depicted underground facilities. Examples of facility maps include CAD
drawings that may be created and viewed with a GIS to include geo-encoded
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-62-
information (e.g., metadata) that provides location information (e.g.,
infrastructure
vectors) for represented items on the facility map;
= Architectural, construction and/or engineering drawings and virtual
renditions of a
space/geographic area (including "as built" or post-construction drawings);
= Land surveys, i.e., plots produced at ground level using references to known
points such as the center line of a street to plot the metes and bounds and
related
location data regarding a building, parcel, utility, roadway, or other object
or
installation;
= A grid (a pattern of horizontal and vertical lines used as a reference) to
provide
representational geographic information (which may be used "as is" for an
input
image or as an overlay for an acquired "real world" scene, drawing, map,
etc.);
= "Bare" data representing geo-encoded information (geographical data points)
and
not necessarily derived from an acquired/captured real-world scene (e.g., not
pixel
information from a digital camera or other digital image acquisition device).
Such
"bare" data may be nonetheless used to construct a displayed input image, and
may be in any of a variety of computer-readable formats, including XML);
= Photographic renderings/images, including street level, topographical,
satellite,
and aerial photographic renderings/images, any of which may be updated
periodically to capture changes in a given geographic area over time (e.g.,
seasonal changes such as foliage density, which may variably impact the
ability to
see some aspects of the image); and
= An image, such as any of the above image types, that includes one or more
dig
area indicators, or "virtual white lines," that provide one or more
indications of or
graphically delimit a dig area, as described in U.S. Patent Application Serial
No.
12/366,853, incorporated by reference herein. The virtual white lines may
include
lines, drawing shapes, shades, symbols, coordinates, data sets, or other
indicators
that are added to an image, and may assist a locate technician in the
performance
of a locate operation by identifying the area of interest, i.e., the dig area.
In this
manner, a searchable electronic record according to the concepts disclosed
herein
may be generated based on a previously marked-up input image on which the dig
area is indicated.
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-63-
[0003] It should also be appreciated that source data representing an input
image may be
compiled from multiple data/information sources; for example, any two or more
of the
examples provided above for input images and source data representing input
images, or any
two or more other data sources, can provide information that can be combined
or integrated
to form source data that is electronically processed to display an image on a
display device.
[0004] As noted above, in some implementations an input image may be indexed
to
Global Positioning System (GPS) coordinates or another coordinate system that
provides
geo-spatial positioning. An input image may include geo-coding or other
geographical
identification metadata and may be provided in any computer-readable format.
An input
image may also include images of map symbols, such as roads and street names,
that may be
superimposed upon or displayed separately from an underlying geographic area
when the
input image is displayed on a display device.
[00175] Based on the foregoing, a digital image may be displayed in an
available display
field of a display device either before or after electronic locate marks are
displayed in the
available display field. For example, in one implementation, after the block
806 in Figure 11,
all or a portion of the digital image may be mapped to the available display
field based on any
relevant geographic information accompanying the digital image (e.g., GPS
coordinates to
which the image is indexed). Alternatively, the digital image may be mapped
first to the
available display field of the display device depending on appropriate scaling
and/or
transformation parameters as would be readily appreciated by one of ordinary
skill in the art,
and thereafter one or more electronic locate marks similarly may be mapped to
the available
display field in appropriate positions relative to the underlying digital
image. In the example
of Figure 14, a first visual representation of a gas line 1130 is depicted, a
second visual
representation of a communication line 1120 is depicted, and a third visual
representation of
an electric line 1110 is depicted on an aerial image of a residential dig area
for purposes of
illustration. As discussed above in connection with other embodiments, these
visual
representations may be displayed in different colors and/or line types to
denote different
types of underground facilities and/or various attributes of a given facility.
As also illustrated
in Figure 14, other types of markings may be included as part of the displayed
image,
including environmental landmarks (streets), property boundaries, tie-downs
(reference lines
between marked facilities and environmental landmarks and/or property
boundaries) and their
associated dimensions, junction boxes or transformers 1140, and one or more
text boxes 2173
(e.g., to indicate an address of the work site over the residence), and the
like.
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-64-
[001761 The various examples of visual representations illustrated in Figures
11-14 may be
used for various purposes, including, but not limited to:
(1) The display may be viewed by the marking technician for substantially
immediate feedback of his/her work performed, which can be compared against
the
ticket information to ensure that the full scope of the current marking
operation has
been completed satisfactorily.
(2) The display may be viewed by a supervisor (using remote computer 150 that
is
receiving the data) as substantially immediate feedback of work performed by
the
marking technician, which again can be compared against the ticket information
to
ensure that the full scope of the current marking operation has been completed
satisfactorily. When the supervisor is viewing the marking operation in real
time,
he/she may contact the marking technician in real time in the event that the
marking
operation is unsatisfactory;
(3) The display may be viewed by a quality control supervisor (using remote
computer 150 that has received the data) as feedback of work performed by the
technician, which again can be compared against the ticket information to
ensure that
the full scope of the current marking operation has been completed
satisfactorily. By
viewing the marking operation, the quality control supervisor may dispatch a
quality
control technician or other personnel in the event that there is the marking
operation is
unsatisfactory, and
(4) The display may be viewed by a training supervisor as feedback of work
performed by the marking technician, which can be used to assess employee
performance and direct training activities.
[001771 In the data acquisition system of embodiments of the present
disclosure and the
method of analyzing marking operations based on actuations of a marking
device, the data
that may be acquired and analyzed for any purpose and is not limited to the
data described
with reference to Figures 1 through 14 and the various tables herein. The data
of interest that
may be acquired and analyzed may include, but is not limited to, t1 timestamp
data, t2
timestamp data, geo-location information, direction information, any
information included in
the standard data stream of the locate tracking system (e.g., GPS system),
color/type of
marking material, amount of marking material in marking dispenser, serial
number of
marking dispenser (e.g., barcode, RFID), ID information (e.g., individual,
vehicle, wage
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-65-
and/or hour compliance), battery status of the marking device, angle of spray
of marking
material (e.g., using an inclinometer), wired/wireless connection status,
Bluetooth signal
strength, storage capacity of the local memory, temperature, humidity, light
level, movement
of the marking device, mode of operation of the marking device, docking state
of the marking
device (e.g., docked/undocked, charging/not charging), alerts against
expectations in
performance (e.g., compare amount and/or type of marking material sprayed
against facility
maps), and any combination thereof.
[001781 The information, such as shown in various tables herein, that may be
acquired by
use of the data acquisition system and methods described herein, may be used
for any
purpose. In an embodiment, the information of the data acquisition system may
be analyzed
against expected marking operations in order to gain benefits in, for example,
operating
efficiency, personnel management, inventory management, quality control,
training
operations, safety, customer satisfaction, and the like.
[001791 Additionally, the information that is acquired by use of the data
acquisition system
and the methods of the present disclosure may be correlated to other aspects
of locate and
marking operations. This correlation may occur, for example, by performing
complex event
processing (CEP) using multiple data streams from multiple devices. For
example, the
marking device data streams (e.g., respective event entries or one or more
electronic records
transmitted by the marking device) may be correlated to other data streams of
multiple
marking devices or any other devices in order to aggregate, assess, evaluate,
draw insights
from, take action on this information, and any combination thereof.
Correlating disparate
data streams may be useful in order to better interpret and/or gain new
interpretations that are
useful. For example, by analyzing the aggregated data, field service providers
may gain
visibility into the distributed workforce, may take corrective and/or any
other constructive
action to improve process management, may improve and/or develop best
practices, and any
combination thereof. In an embodiment, certain trends may be identified by
correlating
historical records of the amount of time that is spent performing locate and
marking
operations to other information, such as, but not limited to, the time of day,
time of year,
address of the locate site, experience of the locate technician, weather
conditions, heavy or
light traffic times, and the like.
[001801 While various inventive embodiments have been described and
illustrated herein,
those of ordinary skill in the art will readily envision a variety of other
means and/or
structures for performing the function and/or obtaining the results and/or one
or more of the
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-66-
advantages described herein, and each of such variations and/or modifications
is deemed to
be within the scope of the inventive embodiments described herein. More
generally, those
skilled in the art will readily appreciate that all parameters, dimensions,
materials, and
configurations described herein are meant to be exemplary and that the actual
parameters,
dimensions, materials, and/or configurations will depend upon the specific
application or
applications for which the inventive teachings is/are used. Those skilled in
the art will
recognize, or be able to ascertain using no more than routine experimentation,
many
equivalents to the specific inventive embodiments described herein. It is,
therefore, to be
understood that the foregoing embodiments are presented by way of example only
and that,
within the scope of the appended claims and equivalents thereto, inventive
embodiments may
be practiced otherwise than as specifically described and claimed. Inventive
embodiments of
the present disclosure are directed to each individual feature, system,
article, material, kit,
and/or method described herein. In addition, any combination of two or more
such features,
systems, articles, materials, kits, and/or methods, if such features, systems,
articles, materials,
kits, and/or methods are not mutually inconsistent, is included within the
inventive scope of
the present disclosure.
[00181] The above-described embodiments can be implemented in any of numerous
ways.
For example, the embodiments may be implemented using hardware, software or a
combination thereof. When implemented in software, the software code can be
executed on
any suitable processor or collection of processors, whether provided in a
single computer or
distributed among multiple computers.
[00182] The various methods or processes outlined herein may be coded as
software that is
executable on one or more processors that employ any one of a variety of
operating systems
or platforms. Additionally, such software may be written using any of a number
of suitable
programming languages and/or programming or scripting tools, and also may be
compiled as
executable machine language code or intermediate code that is executed on a
framework or
virtual machine.
[00183] In this respect, various inventive concepts may be embodied as a
computer
readable storage medium (or multiple computer readable storage media) (e.g., a
computer
memory, one or more floppy discs, compact discs, optical discs, magnetic
tapes, flash
memories, circuit configurations in Field Programmable Gate Arrays or other
semiconductor
devices, or other tangible computer storage medium) encoded with one or more
programs
that, when executed on one or more computers or other processors, perform
methods that
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-67-
implement the various embodiments of the invention discussed above. The
computer
readable medium or media can be transportable, such that the program or
programs stored
thereon can be loaded onto one or more different computers or other processors
to implement
various aspects of the present invention as discussed above.
[00184] The terms "program" or "software" are used herein in a generic sense
to refer to
any type of computer code or set of computer-executable instructions that can
be employed to
program a computer or other processor to implement various aspects of
embodiments as
discussed above. Additionally, it should be appreciated that according to one
aspect, one or
more computer programs that when executed perform methods of the present
invention need
not reside on a single computer or processor, but may be distributed in a
modular fashion
amongst a number of different computers or processors to implement various
aspects of the
present invention.
[00185] Computer-executable instructions may be in many forms, such as program
modules, executed by one or more computers or other devices. Generally,
program modules
include routines, programs, objects, components, data structures, etc. that
perform particular
tasks or implement particular abstract data types. Typically the functionality
of the program
modules may be combined or distributed as desired in various embodiments.
[00186] Also, data structures may be stored in computer-readable media in any
suitable
form. For simplicity of illustration, data structures may be shown to have
fields that are
related through location in the data structure. Such relationships may
likewise be achieved
by assigning storage for the fields with locations in a computer-readable
medium that
conveys relationship between the fields. However, any suitable mechanism may
be used to
establish a relationship between information in fields of a data structure,
including through
the use of pointers, tags or other mechanisms that establish relationship
between data
elements.
[00187] Also, various inventive concepts may be embodied as one or more
methods, of
which an example has been provided. The acts performed as part of the method
may be
ordered in any suitable way. Accordingly, embodiments may be constructed in
which acts
are performed in an order different than illustrated, which may include
performing some acts
simultaneously, even though shown as sequential acts in illustrative
embodiments.
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-68-
[001881 All definitions, as defined and used herein, should be understood to
control over
dictionary definitions, definitions in documents incorporated by reference,
and/or ordinary
meanings of the defined terms.
[001891 The indefinite articles "a" and "an," as used herein in the
specification and in the
claims, unless clearly indicated to the contrary, should be understood to mean
"at least one."
[001901 The phrase "and/or," as used herein in the specification and in the
claims, should
be understood to mean "either or both" of the elements so conjoined, i.e.,
elements that are
conjunctively present in some cases and disjunctively present in other cases.
Multiple
elements listed with "and/or" should be construed in the same fashion, i.e.,
"one or more" of
the elements so conjoined. Other elements may optionally be present other than
the elements
specifically identified by the "and/or" clause, whether related or unrelated
to those elements
specifically identified. Thus, as a non-limiting example, a reference to "A
and/or B", when
used in conjunction with open-ended language such as "comprising" can refer,
in one
embodiment, to A only (optionally including elements other than B); in another
embodiment,
to B only (optionally including elements other than A); in yet another
embodiment, to both A
and B (optionally including other elements); etc.
[001911 As used herein in the specification and in the claims, "or" should be
understood to
have the same meaning as "and/or" as defined above. For example, when
separating items in
a list, "or" or "and/or" shall be interpreted as being inclusive, i.e., the
inclusion of at least
one, but also including more than one, of a number or list of elements, and,
optionally,
additional unlisted items. Only terms clearly indicated to the contrary, such
as "only one of'
or "exactly one of," or, when used in the claims, "consisting of," will refer
to the inclusion of
exactly one element of a number or list of elements. In general, the term "or"
as used herein
shall only be interpreted as indicating exclusive alternatives (i.e. "one or
the other but not
both") when preceded by terms of exclusivity, such as "either," "one of,"
"only one of," or
"exactly one of." "Consisting essentially of," when used in the claims, shall
have its ordinary
meaning as used in the field of patent law.
[001921 As used herein in the specification and in the claims, the phrase "at
least one," in
reference to a list of one or more elements, should be understood to mean at
least one element
selected from any one or more of the elements in the list of elements, but not
necessarily
including at least one of each and every element specifically listed within
the list of elements
and not excluding any combinations of elements in the list of elements. This
definition also
CA 02739119 2011-03-31
WO 2010/039192 PCT/US2009/005299
-69-
allows that elements may optionally be present other than the elements
specifically identified
within the list of elements to which the phrase "at least one" refers, whether
related or
unrelated to those elements specifically identified. Thus, as a non-limiting
example, "at least
one of A and B" (or, equivalently, "at least one of A or B," or, equivalently
"at least one of A
and/or B") can refer, in one embodiment, to at least one, optionally including
more than one,
A, with no B present (and optionally including elements other than B); in
another
embodiment, to at least one, optionally including more than one, B, with no A
present (and
optionally including elements other than A); in yet another embodiment, to at
least one,
optionally including more than one, A, and at least one, optionally including
more than one,
B (and optionally including other elements); etc.
[001931 In the claims, as well as in the specification above, all transitional
phrases such as
"comprising," "including," "carrying," "having," "containing," "involving,"
"holding,"
"composed of," and the like are to be understood to be open-ended, i.e., to
mean including
but not limited to. Only the transitional phrases "consisting of and
"consisting essentially
of shall be closed or semi-closed transitional phrases, respectively, as set
forth in the United
States Patent Office Manual of Patent Examining Procedures, Section 2111.03.
[001941 What is claimed is:
