Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
2-0607
WO 2011/075248 PCT/US2010/056408
CONTROL VALVE HAVING LIVE LOADED PACKING FOLLOWER
WITH LEAK-OFF AND INDEPENDENT SECONDARY SEAL
FIELD OF THE INVENTION
[0001] The present invention relates generally to control valves and, more
specifically, to a
live loaded packing follower arrangement for use on control valves, and to
control valves
incorporating such an arrangement.
BACKGROUND
[0002] It is generally known that process plants, such as refineries, chemical
plants or pulp
and paper plants, consist of numerous process control loops connected together
to produce
various products. Flow control valves are disposed in the process control
loop, and typically
use a control element such as a valve plug, a valve disc, a globe, or other
suitable control
element, in order to manipulate a fluid flowing through the system, such as
gas, steam, water,
or a chemical compound.
[0003] It is generally understood that various control valve configurations
may be
specifically applicable for certain applications. For example, when a quick-
opening valve
with a narrow control range is suitable, a rotary control valve, such as a
butterfly valve, may
be used. Alternatively, when precise control over a large control range is
required, a sliding
stem control valve having a valve plug may be used. In any configuration, such
control
valves are generally coupled to a control device such as an actuator, which
controls the exact
opening amount of the control valve in response to a control signal. In each
case, the valve
stem extends into the valve body and is connected to the control element.
[0004] In order to prevent or minimize leakage past the valve stem, control
valves typically
employ valve packing around the valve stem. Such valves often use a packing
flange and a
packing follower, which apply pressure to the valve packing. The valve packing
is typically
separated into two distinct packing sets separated by a lantern ring. In such
an arrangement, a
leak-off port is provided through the valve body to provide flow communication
adjacent the
lantern ring. Such an arrangement allows personnel to determine whether the
packing below
the lantern ring has failed.
1
2-0607
WO 2011/075248 PCT/US2010/056408
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
100051 Figure 1 is a cross-sectional view of an exemplary prior art control
valve having a
rotating stem and employing a live loaded packing follower with a leak-off
port through the
valve body.
[00061 Figure 2 is an enlarged fragmentary cross-sectional view of aspects of
another
exemplary prior art control valve having a sliding stem and also employing
another live
loaded packing follower arrangement with a double packing set.
[00071 Figure 3 is an enlarged fragmentary cross-sectional view of four
different
conventional packing set arrangements, each employing a pair of packing sets
separated by
one or more lantern rings.
[00081 Figure 4 is a cross-sectional view of a live loaded packing assembly
assembled in
accordance with the teachings of the disclosed invention.
100091 Figure 5 is an enlarged fragmentary cross-sectional view of the
assembly shown in
Figure 4.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[00101 Although the following text sets forth a detailed description of an
exemplary
embodiment of the invention, it should be understood that the legal scope of
the invention is
defined by the words of the claims set forth at the end of this patent. The
detailed description
is to be construed as exemplary only and does not describe every possible
embodiment of the
invention since describing every possible embodiment would be impractical, if
not
impossible. Based upon reading this disclosure, those of skill in the art may
be able to
implement one or more alternative embodiments, using either current technology
or
technology developed after the filing date of this patent. Such additional
embodiments would
still fall within the scope of the claims defining the invention.
[00111 A prior art valve packing and packing follower arrangement is shown in
Figure 1
installed on an exemplary control valve 10 of the type commonly employed in
process
control systems, with the control valve 10 of Figure 1 illustrating a rotary
stem control valve
10. The control valve 10 includes a valve body 12, a valve inlet 14, a valve
outlet 16, and a
flow passage 18 that extends between the inlet 14 and the outlet 16. The flow
passage 18
includes a control passage 20, and a moveable control element 22 is movably
disposed in the
control passage 20. In the example of Figure 1, the control element 22 in the
control valve 10
takes the form of a rotary control element. The control element 22 of Figure 1
may be, for
2
2-0607
WO 2011/075248 PCT/US2010/056408
example, a valve disc, a globe or ball, or any other form of a rotating
control element. In the
example of Figure 1, the control element 22 is connected to a valve stem 24
which, as
outlined above, is a rotary stem. The valve stem 24 is operatively coupled to
an actuator,
which may be any kind of suitable actuator of the types commonly employed in
the art. The
control element 22 is positioned such that the valve plug is disposed in the
control passage
20, and using the actuator the position of the control element 22 within the
control passage 20
may be controlled, so as to control the amount of fluid flow through the
control passage. The
control valve 10 includes a packing box 28 which, in the example shown, is
disposed within
the valve body 12, and a prior art primary packing set is disposed in the
packing box 28.
100121 As shown in Figure 1, the control valve 10 includes a packing follower
32 which
surrounds a portion of the valve stem 24, and which includes a lower portion
34 that extends
into the packing box 28 into a position to apply a compressive force to the
primary packing
set 30. The packing follower 32 is held in place by an upper retaining flange
36, which may
be suitably bolted to the valve body 12 (either directly to the valve body, or
to a bonnet,
should the valve have a bonnet). A series of disc spring washers 38 are
provided, and are
positioned between the retaining flange 36 and the packing follower 32.
Consequently, by
adjusting the bolting force of the retaining flange 36, the amount of
compressive force on the
primary packing set 30 can be controlled. The control valve 10 also includes a
lower
retaining flange 40, which again is suitably bolted to the valve body 12. The
lower retaining
flange 40 bears against a bushing 42, which in turn compresses a secondary
packing set 44
also disposed in the packing box 28. By adjusting the bolting force of the
lower retaining
flange 40, the amount of compressive force on the secondary packing set 44 can
be
controlled. Consequently, in order to suitably compress both the primary
packing set 30 and
the secondary packing set 44, two retaining flanges (the upper retaining
flange 36 and the
lower retain flange 40) are required. A leak-off port 46 is provided, which
typically extends
through the valve body 12. Both the primary packing set 30 and the secondary
packing set 44
include lantern rings (shown in greater detail in Figure 3), which allow any
leakage past
either one of the packing sets 30, 44 to flow into the leak-off port 46. In
the arrangement
shown, the secondary packing set 44 is static and provides a means to repair
the packing bore.
In many applications, the secondary packing set may be omitted.
[0013] Figure 2 illustrates another conventional arrangement in which another
conventional packing follower 32A is positioned to engage another conventional
packing set
30A, with the packing follower 32A adjustably held in place by the retaining
flange 36. The
retaining flange 36 is attached to the valve body by being bolted to a valve
bonnet 26.
3
2-0607
WO 2011/075248 PCT/US2010/056408
Again, the disc spring washers 38 are positioned between the retaining flange
36 and a
packing follower 32A. As with the example of Figure 1, a leak-off port 46 is
provided, which
extends through the bonnet 26, and the packing assembly includes an upper
packing set and a
lower packing set separated by lantern rings (shown in greater detail in
Figure 3) to allow any
leakage past the lower packing set to be communicated to the leak-off port 46.
In the
example of Figure 2, the valve stem 24 is a sliding stem 24B, which is
operatively connected
to a control element such as any conventional sliding stem control element
(not shown).
100141 Referring now to Figure 3, four (4) conventional packing set
arrangements are
shown. In each of the examples of Figure 3, the packing set arrangements
include an upper
packing set A and a lower packing set B, separated by one or more lantern
rings L. Each of
the lantern rings L includes a port P, and the port P is arranged to
communicate with the leak-
off port 46 in the valve body as discussed above.
[00151 Referring now to Figures 4 and 5, a control valve 110 assembled in
accordance with
the teachings of the disclosed example of the present invention is shown. The
illustrated
control valve 110 is a rotary stem control valve. However, upon reading the
present
disclosure, those of skill in the art will be able to readily adapt the
teachings discussed herein
to sliding stem control valves, in which the valve stem is connected to, for
example, a valve
plug, a valve sleeve, or any other form of a sliding control element. The
control valve 110
includes a valve body 112, a valve inlet 114, a valve outlet 116, and a flow
passage 118 that
extends between the inlet 114 and the outlet 116. The valve inlet 114, the
valve outlet 116,
and the flow passage 118 are only visible in Figure 4. The flow passage 118
includes a
control passage 120, and a moveable control element 122 is movably disposed in
the control
passage 120. The control passage 120 and the control element 122 are only
visible in Figure
4. Once again, in the example of Figures 4 and 5, the control element 122 is a
rotary control
element 122A connected to a valve stem 124 which, in the example of Figures 4
and 5, is a
rotary valve stem 124A. Alternatively, the teachings discussed herein may be
applied to a
sliding stem, such as the sliding stem 24B outlined in Figure 2. The control
element 122A of
Figure 4 may be, for example, a valve disc, a globe or ball, or any other form
of a rotating
control element. The valve stem 124 is operatively coupled to an actuator,
which may be any
kind of suitable actuator of the types commonly employed in the art. The
control element
122 is positioned such that the control element 122 is disposed in the control
passage 120,
and the position of the control element 122 within the control passage 120 can
be controlled
using the actuator, so as to control the amount of fluid flow through the
control passage 120.
The control valve 110 includes a bore 127 which is sized to receive the valve
stem 124. The
4
2-0607
WO 2011/075248 PCT/US2010/056408
valve body 112 includes a packing box 128, and a primary packing set 130 is
disposed in the
packing box 128. The packing set is sized to fit around the valve stem 124.
[0016] Referring now to Figure 5, the control valve 110 includes a packing
follower 132
which has a central bore 133 and which surrounds a portion of the valve stem
124. The
packing follower 132 includes a first or upper portion 136 and a second or
lower portion 138,
and the lower portion 138 extends into the packing box 128 into a position to
apply a
compressive force to the primary packing set 130 as will be explained in
further detail below.
The packing follower 132 includes a bearing surface 140 which, in the example
shown, takes
the form of an annular flange 142. An outer portion of the upper portion 136
includes threads
144, while the central bore 133 includes a counterbore 146 adjacent the upper
portion 136. A
threaded nut 148 includes a central bore 150 sized to fit over the valve stem
124, and the
threaded nut is sized to engage the threads 144 of the packing follower 132. A
secondary seal
ring 150 is disposed in the counterbore 146 of the packing follower 132. A
bushing 152
includes an upper portion 152a and a lower portion 152b, and is disposed in
the counterbore
146 above the secondary seal ring 150. In the example shown, the bushing 152
is positioned
within the counterbore 146 such that the upper portion 152a engages a spring
156, which
bears against an inner portion 154 of the threaded nut 148, and the lower
portion 152b
engages the secondary seal ring 150. Accordingly, by adjusting the threaded
nut 148 on the
threads 144, the compressive force applied to the secondary seal ring 150 can
be adjusted. In
the example shown, a spring 156 is disposed between the inner portion 154 of
the threaded
nut 148 and the upper portion 152a of the bushing 152. Further, in the example
shown, the
spring 156 takes the form of a disc spring washer 158.
[0017] A packing flange 160 is attached to the valve body 112 (or to the valve
bonnet if the
particular valve includes a bonnet), and is adjustably secured by a series of
attachment bolts
162 positioned through a series of holes 164. The packing flange 160 includes
a central
aperture 166 sized to receive the upper portion 136 of the packing follower
152 as well as the
threaded nut 148 without interference. The packing flange 160 also includes a
downwardly
facing surface 168. A spring 170 is disposed between the bearing surface 140
of the packing
follower 132. In the disclosed example, the spring 170 takes the form of a
series of stacked
disc spring washers 172. Consequently, because the packing follower 132 is
operatively
coupled to the packing flange 160 by a spring 170, the downward force on the
packing
follower 132 can be adjusted via adjusting the position of the packing flange
160 relative to
the valve body 112.
2-0607
WO 2011/075248 PCT/US2010/056408
[00181 The lower portion 138 of the packing follower 132 preferably includes a
counterbore 174 sized to receive a cylindrical bushing 176. In the disclosed
example, the
bushing 176 serves as a valve stem guide. The lower portion 138 of the packing
follower 132
is positioned to bear against the packing set 130. Preferably, the packing set
130 may include
conventional components, such as a pair of filament rings 178 separated by
laminated rings
180, and straddled by upper and lower washers 182. The packing set 130 need
not include,
and as shown does not include, a lantern ring of the type conventionally
employed in the art.
The lower portion 138 of the packing follower 132, in conjunction with the
bushing 176, a
position to bear against an upper portion of the packing set 130, such as by
bearing against
the upper washer 182.
100191 The packing follower 132 includes a leak-off port 184 which, in the
disclosed
example, extends generally radially outward through the annular flange 142.
The leak-off
port 184 is in flow communication with the bore 133 that extends through the
packing
follower 132, and the leak-off port 184 preferably is connected to a conduit
186, which
typically is connected to some means or mechanism for diverting leakage or for
detecting
leakage. In the event of any leakage past the packing assembly 130, the
leakage will flow
into a space 188 between the valve stem 124 and the bore 133 of the packing
follower 132.
[00201 A control valve and/or a valve packing assembly assembled in accordance
with one
or more aspects of the present disclosure may extend and/or maximize the
service life of the
valve packing. In accordance with he disclosed example, the load on the
primary packing set
may be adjusted in a manner that is independent of the load on the secondary
seal. Therefore,
the primary packing set and the secondary seal can each be loaded at a desired
load, without
overloading one of the sealing components to the disadvantage of the other
sealing
component.
[00211 Further, when assembled as discussed herein, the valve body and/or the
valve
bonnet maybe devoid of a leak-off port. Also, in the event the teachings of
the present
invention are applied to an existing control valve already having an existing
leak-off port
drilled in the bonnet or in the valve body, the existing leak-off port may be
temporarily
plugged or permanently plugged.
100221 Those of skill in the art will appreciate that on many valves it is
desirable to have
some means to determine if the valve packing is leaking, and it is also
desirable to have some
means to capture the leakage. In the past, these needs have been addressed by
using a double
packing arrangement in which a leak-off port is provided between two packing
sets, with the
6
2-0607
WO 2011/075248 PCT/US2010/056408
two packing sets separated by a lantern ring. This approach may suffer from
one or more
potential drawbacks. For example, although a desired load can be applied to
the top packing
set, only a fraction of that load is transmitted to the lower packing set. Of
course the lower
packing set needs to provide an adequate seal against the pressure within the
control valve,
but the load on the lower packing set is compromised by the upper packing set.
Moreover,
using two packing sets results in much higher friction in the valve stem, and
more
consolidation of packing material results in loss of packing stress thus
causing increased
leakage. Consequently, the conventional leak-off port has to be provided in
the valve body or
the valve bonnet. The conventional leak-off port drilled through the valve
body or through
the valve bonnet increases the manufacturing cost of the control valve, and
also creates
potential installation and service issues, as the lantern ring must be
properly aligned with the
leak-off port.
[0023] In accordance with the disclosed example, it is possible to address
various packing
issues using aspects of known technology, and also to provide for a leak-off
function that
does not compromise the performance of the packing. In accordance with the
exemplary
form outlined herein, it is possible to subject the packing assembly to a
relatively constant
and correct or desired amount of load or stress in order to affect a seal, and
this is often
achieved by using live-load springs. It is also possible to follow the
teachings herein in order
to use no more packing than the minimum required to effect a seal. This
approach minimizes
the adverse effects of thermal expansion of the packing, and also reduces
packing friction. In
the present approach, it is also possible to install less-pliable anti-
extrusion rings on either
side of the packing, as these anti-extrusion rings reduce or prevent the
packing from
extruding out of the packing area, and it is also possible to provide stem
bushings or other
type of stem guide, as this helps to keep the stem aligned within the packing
set, and to use a
smooth, polished valve stem, as this approach reduces packing friction and
wear and
minimizes the occurrence of leak paths.
[0024] When assembled in accordance with the exemplary form of the invention
outlined
herein, the resulting control valve and/or the packing assembly exhibits
improved
performance as compared to existing packing assemblies, such as, for example,
the SS-84
packing available from Emerson. In accordance with the disclosed example, the
present
improved packing assembly outlined herein may be more compact and simple, and
therefore
the present packing assembly can be used on other products. The present
improved design
also provides independent live load for the leak-off seal, and an additional
bushing to protect
the stem. Further, the present exemplary design does not require drilling a
leak-off hole in
7
2-0607
WO 2011/075248 PCT/US2010/056408
the valve body or the bonnet. A leak-off hole is difficult to machine and
locate, and creates
an interrupted surface in the packing bore. Accordingly, it is desirable to
have a design in
which the valve body and/or the valve bonnet are devoid of a separate leak-off
port.
[00251 The exemplary form of the invention discussed herein also may
experience several
additional advantages. For example, the packing studs may be placed at a
greater diameter
compared to conventional assemblies, which allows for better disc spring
washer design.
Further, the secondary seal ring disposed within the disclosed packing
follower does not have
pressure across it. Instead, the secondary seal ring only needs to divert any
packing leakage,
such as toward the leak-off port in the packing follower, which is at or near
atmospheric
pressure. The disclosed assembly may thus result in a valve that is more
suitable for long
service and infrequent maintenance, such as applications within nuclear
containment
environments.
[00261 Numerous modifications and alternative embodiments of the invention
will be
apparent to those skilled in the art in view of the forgoing description.
Accordingly, this
description is to be construed as illustrative only and is for the purpose of
teaching those
skilled in the art the best mode of carrying out the invention. The details of
the present
disclosure may be varied without departing from the spirit of the invention,
and the exclusive
use of all modifications which are within the scope of the claims is reserved.
8
