Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02853841 2014-06-06
APPARATUS AND METHOD FOR PROVING
AT LOW TEMPERATURES
BACKGROUND
After hydrocarbons have been removed from the ground, the fluid stream (such
as crude
oil or natural gas) is transported from place to place via pipelines. It is
desirable to know with
accuracy the amount of fluid flowing in the stream, and particular accuracy is
demanded when
the fluid is changing hands, or "custody transfer." Custody transfer can occur
at a fluid fiscal
transfer measurement station or skid, which may include key transfer
components such as a
measurement device or flow meter, a proving device, associated pipes and
valves, and electrical
controls. Measurement of the fluid stream flowing through the overall delivery
pipeline system
starts with the flow meter, which may include a turbine meter, a positive
displacement meter,
an ultrasonic meter, a coriolis meter or a vortex meter.
Flow characteristics of the fluid stream can change during product delivery
that can
affect accurate measurement of the product being delivered. Typically, changes
of pressure,
temperature and flow rate are acknowledged by operator intervention. These
changes are
represented as changes in the flow characteristics, and are normally verified
by the operator via
the effects of the changes and their effect on the measurement device.
Normally, this
verification is conducted by proving the meter with a proving device, or
prover. A calibrated
prover, adjacent the measurement device on the skid and in fluid communication
with the
measurement device, is sampled and the sampled volumes are compared to the
throughput
volumes of the measurement device. If there are statistically important
differences between the
compared volumes, the throughput volume of the measurement device is adjusted
to reflect the
actual flowing volume as identified by the prover.
The prover has a precisely known volume which is calibrated to known and
accepted
standards of accuracy, such as those prescribed by the American Petroleum
Institute (API) or
the internationally accepted ISO standards. The precisely known volume of the
prover can be
defined as the volume of product between two detector switches that is
displaced by the
passage of a displacer, such as an elastomeric sphere or a piston. The known
volume that is
displaced by the prover is compared to the throughput volume of the meter. If
the comparison
yields a volumetric differential of zero or an acceptable variation therefrom,
the flow meter is
then said to be accurate within the limits of allowed tolerances. If the
volumetric differential
exceeds the limits allowed, then evidence is provided indicating that the flow
meter may not be
accurate. Then, the meter throughput volume can be adjusted to reflect the
actual flowing
volume as identified by the prover. The adjustment may be made with a meter
correction
factor.
1
CA 02853841 2014-06-06
One type of meter is a pulse output meter, which may include a turbine meter,
a positive
displacement meter, an ultrasonic meter, a coriolis meter or a vortex meter.
By way of
example, Figure 1 illustrates a system 10 for proving a meter 12, such as a
turbine meter. A
turbine meter, based on turning of a turbine-like structure within the fluid
stream 11, generates
electrical pulses 15 where each pulse is proportional to a volume, and the
rate of pulses
proportional to the volumetric flow rate. The meter 12 volume can be related
to a prover 20
volume by flowing a displacer in the prover 20. Generally, the displacer is
forced first past an
upstream detector 16 then a downstream detector 18 in the prover 20. The
volume between
detectors 16, 18 is a calibrated prover volume. The flowing displacer first
actuates or trips the
detector 16 such that a start time t16 is indicated to a processor or computer
26. The processor
26 then collects pulses 15 from the meter 12 via signal line 14. The flowing
displacer finally
trips the detector 18 to indicate a stop time t18 and thereby a series 17 of
collected pulses 15 for
a single pass of the displacer. The number 17 of pulses 15 generated by the
turbine meter 12
during the single displacer pass, in both directions, through the calibrated
prover volume is
indicative of the volume measured by the meter during the time t16 to time
t18. Multiple
displacer passes are required to attain the prover volume. By comparing the
prover volume to
the volume measured by the meter, the meter may be corrected for volume
throughput as
defined by the prover.
Figure 2 illustrates another system 50 for proving an ultrasonic flow meter
52, using
transit time technology. The system 50 also includes a prover 20 and a
processor 26. By
ultrasonic it is meant that ultrasonic signals are sent back and forth across
the fluid stream 51,
and based on various characteristics of the ultrasonic signals a fluid flow
may be calculated.
Ultrasonic meters generate flow rate data in batches where each batch
comprises many sets of
ultrasonic signals sent back and forth across the fluid, and thus where each
batch spans a period
of time (e.g., one second). The flow rate determined by the meter corresponds
to an average
flow rate over the batch time period rather than a flow rate at a particular
point in time.
In a particular embodiment of the prover 20, and with reference to Figure 3, a
piston or
compact prover 100 is shown. A piston 102 is reciprocally disposed in a flow
tube 104. A pipe
120 communicates a flow 106 from a primary pipeline to an inlet 122 of the
flow tube 104.
The flow 108 of the fluid forces the piston 102 through the flow tube 104, and
the flow
eventually exits the flow tube 104 through an outlet 124. The flow tube 104
and the piston 102
may also be connected to other components, such as a spring plenum 116 that
may have a
biasing spring for a poppet valve in the piston 102. A chamber 118 may also be
connected to
the flow tube 104 and the piston 102 having optical switches for detecting the
position of the
piston 102 in the flow tube 104. A hydraulic pump and motor 110 is also shown
coupled to the
2
CA 02853841 2014-06-06
flow line 120 and the plenum 116. A hydraulic reservoir 112, a control valve
114 and a
hydraulic pressure line 126 are also shown coupled to the plenum 116. As will
be shown
below, the piston 102 can be adapted according to the principles taught
herein.
In some applications, the fluids flowing in the pipelines (primary pipelines
and those of
the measurement station) are maintained at low temperatures. As used herein,
low
temperatures, for example, are generally less than about -50 F, alternatively
less than about -
60 F, alternatively less than about -220 F, and alternatively less than
about -250 F. These low
temperatures may also be referred to as very low temperatures or cryogenic
temperatures.
Examples of fluids maintained at low temperatures include liquid natural gas
(LNG), liquefied
petroleum gas (LPG) and liquid nitrogen. Low temperatures of the metered
fluids cause
numerous problems, such as unsuitability of the prover's sensing devices, wear
on components
such as seals, and reduced lubrication on the flow tube's inner surface for
the low temperature
fluids, which tend to be non-lubricating. Carbon steel reacts negatively to
low temperature
product flowing in the pipeline.
To address these problems, meters operating in very low temperatures are
proved by
indirect proving methods. Generally, indirect proving is accomplished by
proving a meter
suitable for very low temperature service using a prover that is not rated for
very low
temperature service. First, a fluid, generally water, is flowed through a
proving meter, and the
proving meter is proved in the normal way to establish a meter factor for the
proving meter.
The proving meter is then used on actual flowing low temperature product to
obtain the meter
factor for the meter measuring the low temperature product. Consequently, the
proving meter
is calibrated using a fluid unlike the actual product delivered through the
meter (at least with
regard to density), leading to incorrect results in the actual product meter
to be calibrated.
Thus, there is a need for a prover adapted for very low temperatures, at least
to increase
durability of the prover and to provide direct proving of very low temperature
products.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
For a detailed description of exemplary embodiments, reference will now be
made to
the accompanying drawings in which:
Figure 1 is a schematic representation of a system for proving a meter, such
as a turbine
meter;
Figure 2 is a schematic representation of another system for proving a meter,
such as an
ultrasonic meter;
Figure 3 is a schematic representation of a bi-directional piston-type prover;
Figure 4 is a piston in accordance with the teachings herein;
Figure 5 is a side view of the piston of Figure 4;
3
CA 02853841 2014-06-06
=
Figure 6 is a cross-section view of the piston of Figures 4 and 5;
Figure 7 is a schematic of a piston in a prover flow tube in accordance with
the
teachings herein; and
Figure 8 is a schematic of an alternative embodiment of the piston and prover
of Figure
7.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
In the drawings and description that follow, like parts are typically marked
throughout
the specification and drawings with the same reference numerals. The drawing
figures are not
necessarily to scale. Certain features of the invention may be shown
exaggerated in scale or in
somewhat schematic form and some details of conventional elements may not be
shown in the
interest of clarity and conciseness. The present disclosure is susceptible to
embodiments of
different forms. Specific embodiments are described in detail and are shown in
the drawings,
with the understanding that the present disclosure is to be considered an
exemplification of the
principles of the disclosure, and is not intended to limit the disclosure to
that illustrated and
described herein. It is to be fully recognized that the different teachings of
the embodiments
discussed below may be employed separately or in any suitable combination to
produce desired
results.
Unless otherwise specified, in the following discussion and in the claims, the
terms
"including" and "comprising" are used in an open-ended fashion, and thus
should be interpreted
to mean "including, but not limited to ...". Any use of any form of the terms
"connect",
"engage", "couple", "attach", or any other term describing an interaction
between elements is
not meant to limit the interaction to direct interaction between the elements
and may also include
indirect interaction between the elements described. The term "fluid" may
refer to a liquid or
gas and is not solely related to any particular type of fluid such as
hydrocarbons. The terms
"pipe", "conduit", "line" or the like refers to any fluid transmission means.
The various
characteristics mentioned above, as well as other features and characteristics
described in more
detail below, will be readily apparent to those skilled in the art upon
reading the following
detailed description of the embodiments, and by referring to the accompanying
drawings.
The embodiments described herein include a prover, such as a piston-type pipe
prover,
that is adapted for use with low temperature fluids. Particularly, the prover
is used with fluids
at low temperatures less than -50 F. More particularly, the prover is used
with fluids at low
temperatures less than -200 F. There is presented herein various combinations
of components
and principles which provide the cryogenic prover, or methods of direct
proving of liquids at
extremely low temperatures. For example, a sensing device in the prover is
improved for low
temperatures, such as by adjusting material components or replacing sensors.
In some
4
CA 02853841 2014-06-06
embodiments, the surface finish of the inner surface of the flow tube is
improved for lubricating
non-lubrous LNG and LPG products. In further embodiments, a piston rotator is
provided to
prevent deterioration of piston seals.
Referring initially to Figure 3, the prover 100 may alternatively include a
detection
member or target ring 130, disposable at various locations along the axial
length of the piston
102. The flow tube 104 includes a sensor 128, also disposable at various
locations along the
axial length of the flow tube 104, for detecting passage of the target ring
130. The target ring
130 is the trip instigator for entry into and exit from the calibrated
measuring section of the
flow tube 104 of the prover 100. At very low temperatures, proper
communication between the
sensor 128 and the target ring 130 is negatively affected due to, for example,
the unsuitability
of the detector 128 or the materials of the target ring 130 at very low
temperatures.
Referring now to Figure 4, an embodiment of a prover piston 202 is shown. The
piston
202 may be used in a variety of provers, such as prover 100. The piston 202 is
especially suited
for a bi-directional prover. The piston 202 includes a body 230 with ends 206,
208. A middle
portion of the body 230 includes a ring 210 coupled thereto. An inner portion
of the piston
body 230 includes an inner surface 212 with a plate 214 extending
therebetween, generally
perpendicular to the longitudinal axis of the piston 202. A first set of vanes
216 extends from
the plate 214. The vanes 216 generally extend perpendicular to the plate 214,
but also at an
angle to the plate 214 such that the vanes may receive a fluid acting on the
plate 214 and
redirect a force applied to the plate 214. The angle of the vanes relative to
the plate 214 is
variable. In some embodiments, a second set of vanes is similarly disposed on
an opposite side
of the plate 214 to effect the same functions in a bi-directional manner.
Referring briefly to Figure 5, a side view of the piston 202 is shown
illustrating the
body 230 having the ends 206, 208 and the ring 210.
In some embodiments, the ring 210 is the target ring associated with the
piston 202. In
some embodiments, the ring 210 includes materials having magnetic properties.
In certain
embodiments, the ring 210 comprises carbon-free materials. In exemplary
embodiments, the
ring 210 comprises high mu 0.0 metal. In exemplary embodiments, the ring 210
comprises
HYMU or HYMU 80 metal components. In exemplary embodiments, the ring 210
comprises
various combinations of nickel, iron, copper and/or molybdenum. The attachment
of the target
ring 210 to the piston 202 is designed to allow expansion and contraction of
the target ring 210
such that it can expand and contract yet maintain a constant physical
relationship not exceeding
one in ten thousand repeatability.
With reference to Figure 7, a flow tube 204 containing the piston 202 may
include a
magnetic pickup coil 232 mounted thereon. The piston 202 is moveably and
reciprocally
5
CA 02853841 2014-06-06
=
disposed in a flow passage 224 of the flow tube 204 such the piston 202 can
pass the magnetic
pickup coil 232 in a bi-directional manner. As the target ring 210 passes the
pickup coil 232,
the ring and coil communicate via the magnetic reluctance principle. The
target ring 210
provides the magnetic force flux which is received by the pickup coil 232. The
target ring 210
passes in a pre-determined proximity, referred to as the air gap, and causes a
deflection in the
existing magnetic field of the pickup coil 232. The change in reluctance of
the resulting
magnetic circuit generates a voltage pulse, which is then transmitted to a
preamplifier. The
preamplifier strengthens the signal, which is used to trigger a prover
computer, such as those
disclosed herein, to collect meter pulses from the meter which is being
proven.
In another embodiment, and with reference to Figure 8, a sensing assembly
comprising
a pair of ultrasonic transceivers 328, 330 is mounted on a flow tube 304 of a
piston or compact
prover. The transceivers 328, 330 may also be referred to as ultrasonic speed
of sound
transceivers. A piston assembly 302 is bi-directionally moveable in a flow
passage 324 of the
flow tube 304. The transceivers 328, 330 communicate via a straight line sonic
signal 332.
When the leading edge of the piston 302, whether it be the end 306 or the end
308, aligns with
the transceivers 328, 330, the signal 332 is interrupted. Interruption of the
signal 332 triggers a
prover computer, causing operation of the remainder of the prover and prover
computer in the
normal way and consistent with the teachings herein. In additional
embodiments, the
transceivers 328, 330 include inductive type linear displacement transducers,
or are adapted to
transmit other interruptable signals 332 such as laser beam, LED beam, or
radar beam.
Still referring to Figures 7 and 8, the flow passages 224 and 324 include
inner surfaces
226, 326, respectively. Typically, the prover flow tube or barrel comprises
piping material well
defined by applicable material specifications. The internal finish of the
prover barrel, such as
those on surfaces 226, 326, is normally graphite impregnated epoxy applied by
conventional
spray paint methodology. Due to the non-lubricity of certain hydrocarbon
products to be
proved, such as butanes, propanes and LPG's, the coating on the finished inner
surfaces assists
the displacer piston in moving smoothly through the prover barrel. This is a
requirement for
consistent and accurate proving. However, these coatings are not suitable for
the lower
temperatures defined herein. Thus, the surfaces 226, 326 of the embodiments of
Figures 7 and
8 include a microfinish. The microfinish of the surfaces 226, 326 allows a
microscopic film of
product to be maintained at the surfaces 226, 326, thereby maximizing the
already low degree
of lubrication the product is able to inherently afford. In exemplary
embodiments, the
microfinishes applied to the surfaces 226, 326 include approximately 32
microinch to 16
microinch obtained by honing, milling or grinding.
6
. CA 02853841 2014-06-06
Referring now to Figure 6, a cross-section taken along an axial length of the
prover
piston 202 is shown. The piston body 230 includes at its end 206 a first ring
240, a second ring
242 and a socket 244, primarily for assembly purposes. The rings 240, 242
provide alternative
locations for the target ring as described herein to be disposed, in addition
to the location
described with respect to target ring 210. The first set of vanes 216 extends
in a first direction
from the plate 214, and a second set of vanes 246 extends in a second
direction generally
opposite the first direction to effect bi-directional movement of the piston
202. Further, the
vanes 216, 246 are variably angled to provide the functions as described more
fully below.
Generally, the displacer seals on the piston 202 provide a leak-proof barrier
to prevent
product from transitioning from one side of the piston 202 to the other. The
seals can
deteriorate based on two main causes. First, the friction of passage of the
piston through the
prover during normal operation can, over time, deteriorate the seal surface.
The length of time
to deterioration and seal failure is determined by frequency of use of the
prover. The second
factor that contributes to wear of the piston assembly is the gravitational
forces on the seals
caused by the weight of the piston. Focusing on this second factor can provide
benefits.
Rotational movement of the piston about its axis, causing the piston 202 to
spiral in the
flow tube 204 as it is displaced, will reduce the wear factor and prolong the
life of the piston
seals. The rotational vanes 216, 246 provide the rotational or spiral movement
of the piston
202. Introduction of flow perpendicular to the piston end will rotate the
piston according to a
variable angle A of the vanes. Stops may be put in the prover ends
corresponding to the piston,
and which are not encumbered by the vanes. The stops prevent the vanes from
being distorted
by the piston coming to rest at the end of the flow tube or prover barrel.
The teachings of the embodiments described herein may be employed in any
suitable
combination. The disclosure is not limited to the specific embodiments and
combinations
described herein. The teachings herein include a direct meter proving method,
such that fluid
flowing to the meter is diverted directly to the prover despite the fluids
being at very low
temperatures that cannot be managed by current piston and compact provers. The
fluid may be
directed through the prover and then downstream to piping that re-introduces
the product into
the carrying pipeline. While not common, the prover sometimes is located
upstream of the
meter such that the flow is directed to the prover and then flows through the
meter. The
purpose of the prover is to provide a known volume to compare to an indicated
metered
volume. The two volumes are then standardized using correction factors for
temperature,
pressure and density parameters for the product to establish a meter factor.
The meter factor is
derived by dividing the volume of the fluid passing through the meter
(determined by the
prover volume while proving) by the corresponding meter-indicated volume. The
prover
7
CA 02853841 2014-06-06
volume is the volume displaced between the detector switches. The prover
volume is
established by precisely determining the volume between detector switches
(also called the
base volume of the prover) by a method called the waterdraw method, as
described by the
American Petroleum Institute.
Accuracy of a bidirectional piston-type pipe prover and the overall
measurement
station, when operating at temperatures of less than -50 F, and specifically
at temperatures
approximating -220 F, is significantly affected by limitations in component
materials. A
valve, such as a 4-way valve, is unavailable for very low temperatures and
therefore renders
other prover types inoperable for very low temperatures. The detector sensing
ring and the
detector devices in provers are unsuitable for low temperature service. Self-
lubricating
coatings for use with non-lubrous products such as LPG are unavailable for low
temperature
service. The embodiments described herein address these problems and others.
Exemplary embodiments of a flow meter prover for low temperature fluids
include an
inlet configured to be directly coupled to a pipeline carrying the low
temperature fluids, an
outlet configured to be directly coupled to the pipeline carrying the low
temperature fluids, a
flow tube coupled between the inlet and the outlet, and a displacer moveable
in a flow passage
of the flow tube, wherein the flow tube and the displacer are configured to
receive the low
temperature fluids. In an embodiment, the prover further includes a magnetic
pickup coil
coupled to the flow tube and a magnetic member coupled to the displacer
communicating with
the magnetic pickup coil via magnetic reluctance. The displacer may be a
piston and the
magnetic member may be a target ring wrapped around the piston. In another
embodiment, the
prover includes a magnetic pickup coil coupled to the flow tube and a carbon-
free target
member coupled to the displacer communicating with the magnetic pickup coil.
The carbon-
free target member may include at least one of high mu ( ) metal, HYMU metal,
and HYMU
80 metal. The carbon-free target member may include a combination of nickel,
iron, copper
and/or molybdenum. In a further embodiment, the prover includes a pair of
ultrasonic
transceivers coupled to the flow tube and communicating a signal across the
flow passage in the
flow tube and wherein the displacer is moveable in the flow passage to
interrupt the signal.
In some embodiments, the flow passage of the prover includes an inner surface
having a
microfinish. The microfinish maintains a microscopic film of the low
temperature fluids
between the flow passage inner surface and the displacer for lubrication. The
microfinish may
be in the range of 32 microinch to 16 microinch. The microfinish may be
obtained by at least
one of honing, milling, and grinding the inner surface. In other embodiments,
the displacer
includes a vane disposed at an angle relative to the flow direction of the low
temperature fluids.
The displacer may be a piston including a set of inner vanes extending along a
longitudinal axis
8
CA 02853841 2014-06-06
of the piston and set an angle relative to the axis. The vane rotates the
displacer in response to
the flow of the low temperature fluids.
Exemplary embodiments of a flow meter prover for low temperature fluids
include a
flow tube having a flow passage therein and a magnetic pickup coil mounted
thereon and a
piston disposed in the flow passage and including a carbon-free magnetic
member, wherein the
piston is moveable to move the magnetic member past the magnetic pickup coil
and
communicate with the magnetic pickup coil via magnetic reluctance. An inner
surface of the
flow passage may include a microfinish to maintain a microfilm of lubricating
fluid. The
piston includes a set of piston rotating vanes. In further embodiments, the
prover includes a
pair of ultrasonic transceivers disposed on the flow tube and communicating
across the flow
passage, and wherein the piston movement interrupts the ultrasonic transceiver
communication.
Exemplary embodiments of a system for proving low temperature fluids include a
pipeline carrying the low temperature fluids, a prover coupled into the
pipeline and receiving
the low temperature fluids, wherein the prover includes a flow tube including
a piston
moveably disposed therein and at least one of a magnetic pickup coil and a
pair of ultrasonic
transceivers coupled to the flow tube and communicating with the piston. The
low temperature
fluids include a temperature of less than about -50 F, and alternatively a
temperature of less
than about -220 F. In an embodiment, the piston includes a carbon-free
magnetic target
member. An inner surface of the flow tube may include a microfinish to
maintain a microfilm
of lubricating fluid. The piston may be rotatable while being moved axially.
The scope of the claims should not be limited by the preferred embodiments set
forth in
the examples, but should be given the broadest purposive construction
consistent with the
description as a whole.
9
