Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
FACILE SYNTHESIS OF GRAPHENE, GRAPHENE DERIVATIVES AND
ABRASIVE NANOPARTICLES AND THEIR VARIOUS USES, INCLUDING AS
TRIBOLOGICALLY-BENEFICIAL LUBRICANT ADDITIVES
[0001] REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS
[0002] This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Patent
Application Number
61/596936, filed February 9, 2012 and titled Tribologically Beneficial
Carbonaceous
Materials and Nano-Abrasive Lubricant Molecules From Intentional In-Situ
Pyrolysis of
Sacrificial Cyclic Carbon Constituents; U.S. Provisional Patent Application
Number
61/579993, filed December 23, 2011 and titled Graphene and Graphene
Derivatives
Synthesis By Dehydration or Pyrolysis of Carbonaceous Materials, Vapor
Exfoliation or
PAH Formation, and Subsequent Hydrophobic Self-Assembly; U.S. Provisional
Patent
Application Number 61/568,957, filed December 9, 2011 and titled Synthesis of
Graphene,
Graphene Derivatives, Carbon-Encapsulated Metallic Nanoparticles, and Nano-
Steel, and the
Use of Sequestered Carbonaceous Wastes and Greenhouse Gases in Such Synthesis
Methods;
U.S. Provisional Patent Application Number 61/546,368, filed October 12, 2011
and titled
Combustion Synthesis of Graphene Oxide and Graphene; U.S. Provisional Patent
Application
Number 61/541,637, filed September 30, 2011 and titled Lubricating Additives,
Polishing
Compositions, Nanoparticles, and Tribological Coatings, and Uses Thereof, and
Methods of
Nanoparticle, Graphene, and Graphene Oxide Synthesis; U.S. Provisional Patent
Application
Number 61/538,528, filed September 23, 2011 and titled Lubricating Additives,
Polishing
Compositions, Nanoparticles, and Tribological Coatings, and Uses Thereof, and
Methods of
Nanoparticle, Graphene, and Graphene Oxide Synthesis; U.S. Provisional Patent
Application
Number 61/503,203, filed June 30, 2011 and titled Lubricating Additives,
Polishing
Compositions, and Nanoparticles, and Methods and Uses Thereof, and Methods of
Nanoparticle Synthesis; U.S. Provisional Patent Application Number 61/491,633,
filed May
31, 2011 and titled Lubricating Compositions, Lubricant Additives, Methods of
Lubrication,
and Methods of Polishing Surfaces; and U.S. Provisional Patent Application
Number
61/452,781, filed March 15, 2011 and titled Lubricating Compositions,
Lubricant Additives,
and Methods of Lubrication
[0003] BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
[0004] FIELD OF THE INVENTION
[0005] The invention pertains to methods of industrially-scalable ex situ
synthesis of
graphene, graphene oxide, reduced graphene oxide, and other graphene
derivative structures,
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 2
PCT/US2012/029276
and nanoparticles and the uses therefor, including but not limited to
composites, composite
fabrication and coatings, the fields of tribology, nanotechnology, surface
finishing, machining
and tooling, boring, drilling, tunneling, ballistics, anti-ballistics, heat
shielding, heat
absorption, lubricant additives, lubricating compositions, coatings, methods
of lubrication,
methods of polishing hard surfaces, and methods of cutting, drilling,
hardening, protecting,
and fabricating steel and other hard surfaces. The invention further pertains
to the use of
abrasive nanoparticles in lubricating compositions for polishing, hardening,
protecting,
adding longevity to, and lubricating moving and stationary parts in devices
and systems,
including, but not limited to, engines, turbos, turbines, tracks, races,
wheels, bearings, gear
systems, and other physical and mechanical systems employing machined
interacting hard
surfaces, where the abrasive nanoparticles are formed in situ from the
lubricating
compositions or, in some cases, formed ex situ and then added to lubricants
before their use.
[0006] DESCRIPTION OF RELATED ART
[0007] Synthesis of Graphene and Graphene Derivatives.
[0008] Single-layer graphene, as a result of its observed and theoretical
physical properties,
including a large specific surface area, high intrinsic mobility, high Young's
modulus (-1.0
TPa), high thermal conductivity (-5000 Wm-1K"), high optical transmittance (-
97.7%), low
gas permeability, and high electron transport capacity, has been the subject
of considerable
study, research, and discussion in recent years (see, for example, Geim, et
al., "The Rise of
Graphene", Nat. Mater., Vol. 6, pp.183-191, 2007; and Zhu et al., "Graphene
and Graphene
Oxide: Synthesis, Properties, and Applications", Adv. Mater., Vol. 22, pp.
3906-3924, 2010).
Based on these properties of graphene, it has been considered for use in
numerous
applications such as photocatalysis, energy storage, solar cells, transparent
electrodes,
semiconductors, high strength/low weight composite materials, protective
coatings, and field
emission. Large-scale and economical production methods have, however,
remained elusive.
[0009] Pure graphene is a planar polycyclic single atomic layer of pure carbon
in a
honeycomb-like lattice of six-membered sp2-hybridized carbon rings. Graphene
is
theoretically a single pure layer of graphite, although the term graphene is
conventionally
also used to apply to a material with several stacked atomic layers of
graphite or a graphitic
layer with minor defects still having material properties similar to pure
graphene. Graphene is
relatively hydrophobic and is conventionally formed either by exfoliation of
graphite, which
may be done using supercritical carbon dioxide or by micromechanical cleavage,
or by
epitaxial growth on silicon carbide or certain metal substrates. Graphene may
also be formed
in the gas phase by passing liquid droplets of ethanol into argon plasma in an
atmospheric-
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854
PCT/US2012/029276
3
pressure microwave plasma reactor (Dato et al., "Substrate-Free Gas-Phase
Synthesis of
Graphene Sheets", Nano Lett., Vol. 8, pp. 2012-2016, 2008).
[0010] Graphene nanotube synthesis has also been reported by an aerosol
pyrolysis method
(Pinault et al., "Carbon nanotubes produced by aerosol pyrolysis: growth
mechanisms and
post-annealing effects", Diamond and Related Materials, Vol. 13, pp. 1266-
1269, 2004). A
solution of 2.5-5 wt% of ferrocene in toluene or cyclohexane was aerosolized
with argon and
pyrolyzed at 800-850 C. The early stages of carbon nanotube formation were
observed. A
layer of nanoparticles believed to include iron was first formed on a solid
substrate. An
ordered carpet of nanotubes grew from this nanoparticle layer, with one
nanotube growing
from each of the nanoparticles. High-temperature annealing of the samples led
to removal of
iron from within the nanotubes and improved order in the nanotubes.
[0011] Several recent publications have reported the formation of graphene
bonds under
combustion conditions. In one case, minute quantities of nanoparticles of all
four forms of
carbon, namely diamond, graphite, fullerene, and amorphous, were detected in a
paraffin
candle flame (Su et al., "New insight into the soot nanoparticles in a candle
flame", Chem.
Commun., Vol. 47, pp. 4700-4702, 2011). In another earlier case, small amounts
of
nanoparticle graphitic carbon were found upon acid treatment of the soot from
a methane
flame (Tian et al., "Nanosized Carbon Particles From Natural Gas Soot", Chem.
Mater., Vol.
21, pp. 2803-2809, 2009). In another earlier case, highly graphitic hollow
nanotubes were
formed from an ethanol flame (Pan et al., "Synthesis and growth mechanism of
carbon
nanotubes and nanofibers from ethanol flames", Micron, Vol. 35, pp. 461-468,
2004).
Similarly, carbon nanotubes have been synthesized using CO/H2/He/C2H2 gas
mixtures burnt
with an acetylene flame in the presence of laser-ablated iron or nickel
nanoparticle catalysts
(Vander Wal et al., "Flame Synthesis of Carbon Nanotubes using Catalyst
Particles Prepared
by Laser Ablation", Am. Chem. Soc., Div. Fuel Chem., Vol. 49, pp. 879-880,
2004).
[0012] Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) form as part of the airborne
"soot"
contained in the residual particulate matter (PM) of incomplete combustion,
pyrolysis, or
other low-oxygen thermal degradation of hydrocarbons. As these PAHs are
usually deemed
undesirable byproducts of imperfect combustion, numerous studies have focused
on how to
minimize or eliminate altogether the formation of "soot" in combustion
processes (see, for
example, Coppalle et al., "Experimental and Theoretical Studies on Soot
Formation in an
Ethylene Jet Flame", Combust. Sci. and Techn., Vol. 93, pp. 375-386, 1993).
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 4
PCT/US2012/029276
[0013] PAHs have a substantially planar structure of fused aromatic carbon
rings with
hydrogen atoms bound to the peripheral carbon atoms of the matrices. PAHs may
be thought
of as miniature nanoscopic scales of graphene.
[0014] Graphene derivatives include structures having graphitic bonds
partially incorporating
heteroatoms such as oxygen or other structural imperfections in the carbon
lattice. Graphene
derivatives, as described herein, also include structures such as nanotubes,
nanobuds,
fullerenes, nano-peapods, endofullerenes, nano-onions, graphene oxide, lacey
carbon, and
other non-graphene forms of graphitic carbon which may contain structural or
chemical
imperfections.
[0015] Graphene oxide (GO) is a family of impure oxidized forms of graphene
that includes
hydroxyl and epoxide groups bonded to various carbon atoms in the lattice
matrix. The
structural properties of GO have been extensively studied (see Mkhoyal et al.,
"Atomic and
Electronic Structure of Graphene-Oxide", Nano Lett., Vol. 9, pp. 1058-1063,
2009), yet the
exact chemical structure of GO is still the subject of much debate and
considerable
variability, at least in terms of hydroxyl and epoxide group frequency and
location observed
in the various samples studied.
[0016] GO is also known to include carboxylic acid groups believed to be
located at the
edges of the carbon sheets. These various functional groups permit further
chemical
fimctionalization of GO. Recently, the conversion of carboxyl groups to
hydroxyl groups in a
graphene derivative has been reported to produce a material that has been
called "graphenol".
Various complex and multi-step methods to convert this graphenol to graphene
via pyrolysis
have been reported, yet these methods include the use of toxic chemicals such
as hydrazine
(see U.S. Pat. App. Pub. No. 2011/0201739, by Beall, entitled Method and
System for
Producing Graphene and Graphenol and published on Aug. 18, 2011).
[0017] Not unlike graphene, GO is conventionally formed from exfoliated
graphite oxide or
by oxidation of graphene itself. GO sheets may be purposefully formed in a
wide range of
oxidation levels with measured oxygen-to-carbon ratios as high as around 1:2.
As graphene
oxide has its own unique physical and chemical characteristics apart from
graphene, its
structural variability has made it less attractive for many experimental
studies. As opposed to
graphene, GO is hydrophilic and an electrical insulator of high stiffness and
high strength
(see Dreyer et al., "The chemistry of graphene oxide", Chem. Soc. Rev., Vol.
39, pp. 228-240,
2010).
[0018] Graphene oxide was first prepared by the treatment of graphite with
potassium
chlorate and fuming nitric acid (see Brodie, "On the Atomic Weight of
Graphite", Proc. of
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 5
PCT/US2012/029276
the Royal Soc. of London, Vol. 10, p. 249, 1859). A somewhat more efficient
process
employed sulfuric acid, sodium nitrate, and potassium permanganate to convert
graphite to
graphene oxide (see Hummers et al., "Preparation of Graphitic Oxide", J. Am.
Chem. Soc.,
Vol. 80, p. 1339, 1958). Recently, a still more efficient method was reported
using sulfuric
acid, phosphoric acid, and potassium permanganate (see Marcano et al.,
"Improved Synthesis
of Graphene Oxide", ASC Nano, Vol. 4, pp. 4806-4814, 2010).
[0019] Colloidally-dispersed GO in water may be chemically reduced to graphene
using
hydrazine monohydrate. Other chemical reductants for GO include hydroquinone,
gaseous
hydrogen, and strongly basic solutions. Thermal exfoliation and reduction of
GO occurs upon
heating to 1050 C with extrusion to remove the generated byproduct of carbon
dioxide gas.
Finally, electrochemical reduction of GO may be accomplished by placing
electrodes at
opposite ends of a GO film on a non-conductive substrate, followed by the
application of an
electrical current to the film.
[0020] Although to date a complete reduction of GO to graphene has not been
reported in the
literature, GO may be reduced by a number of different processes to produce so-
called "rGO"
(reduced graphene oxide) with measured oxygen-to-carbon ratios as low as about
1:24.
[0021] It is noteworthy that rGO has been observed to exhibit many chemical,
physical, and
electrical properties more similar to those of graphene than to those of GO.
[0022] Graphene and its many derivatives are currently the subject of numerous
studies and
widespread research, in part because of their many potential applications,
including but not
limited to lubricants, molecular level coatings for composite reinforcement,
heat shielding,
ballistic transistors, integrated circuits and reinforced fibers and cables.
[0023] Use of Sequestered Waste Carbon in Graphene Production.
[0024] Various forms of carbon waste sequestration are known to the art,
including, but not
limited to, the conversion of carbonaceous wastes to things like "biochar" or
synthetic
methanol from carbon dioxide (see, for example, Hogan et al., "Biochar:
Concept to
Sequester Carbon", Encyclopedia of Earth, National Council for Science and the
Environment, Washington, D.C., 2011; Jiang et al., "Turning carbon dioxide
into fuel", Phil.
Trans. R. Soc. A, Vol. 368, pp. 3343-3364, 2010), yet the beneficial use of
such sequestered
or captured carbon wastes as carbonaceous feedstock or promoters in the
synthesis of
graphene remains unreported.
[0025] Implantable Medical Prosthetic Devices.
[0026] An important factor in the success of implanted medical prostheses is
the uniformity
of the friction surfaces, both for longevity and prevention of infection
purposes. Asperities on
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 6
PCT/US2012/029276
the surface of medically implanted metallic devices provide a location to
harbor bacteria. For
metallic devices in the vasculature or circulatory system, they also provide a
location for
dangerous platelet aggregation that can lead to heart attack or stroke. The
nanopolishing of
such implantable medical prosthetic devices to near atomic-level perfect
smoothness would
greatly advance the safety and efficacy of such devices.
[0027] Nano-Pharmaceuticals, Oncology, and Medical Imaging.
[0028] Improvements in the targeting of radiation or chemotherapeutic drugs to
a cancer site
and the ability to provide contrast for medical imaging are areas of active
research in the
medical field. Magnetite nanoparticles have been used as a tumor contrast
agent for magnetic
resonance imaging (see, for example, Tiefenauer et al., "In vivo evaluation of
magnetite
nanoparticles for use as a tumor contrast agent in MRI", Magnetic Resonance
Imaging, vol.
14, no. 4, pp. 391-402, 1996). There is considerable current study and
research into the use of
"functionalized" buckyballs as a means to deliver targeted drug therapies to
tumors in the
body (see, for example, Yoon et al., "Targeted medication delivery using
magnetic
nanostructures", J. Phys.: Condens. Matter, vol. 19, 9 pages, 2007).
[0029] Steel Production.
[0030] Pits and asperities on the surface of steel provide a surface for the
formation of
destructive oxidation in the form of ferric oxide, also known as rust. The
reduction or
elimination of these pits and asperities would increase the longevity of such
steel structures.
[0031] Graphene and GO Reaction Environments.
[0032] In some embodiments of the invention, graphene and graphene oxide
structures are
used in various solvents to act as reaction envelopes, which create a nano-
environment for
reactions to occur that are thermodynamically or otherwise unfavorable similar
to the way
enzymes work in biological systems. These graphene reaction envelopes (GREs)
and
graphene oxide reaction envelopes (GOREs) permit chemical reactions and atomic
reformations, such as restructuring atoms into crystals, to occur which would
not normally
occur outside the reaction envelope. The GRE or GORE serves as a "micro- or
nano-reaction
vessel" and then may pinch off part of the envelope into a nanoabrasive or
other nanoparticle,
thereby becoming part of the reaction product. In one embodiment, the envelope
acts as a
nano-blast furnace for the production of nano-steel from iron.
[0033] Steel may take on a number of different forms, including, but not
limited to ferrite,
austenite, pearlite, martensite, bainite, ledeburite, cementite, beta ferrite,
hexaferrum, and any
combination of these, depending on the conditions under which it is made. Nano-
steels of the
invention formed in GREs or GOREs may be in the form of ferrite, austenite,
pearlite,
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 7
PCT/US2012/029276
martensite, bainite, ledeburite, cementite, beta ferrite, hexaferrum, and any
combination of
these.
[0034] Nanosteel, Nanorobotics and Nanomachine Fabrication.
[0035] Nano-crystalline metallic alloy synthesis is known in the art (Alavi et
al., "Alkaline-
Earth Metal Carbonate, Hydroxide and Oxide Nano-Crystals Synthesis Methods,
Size and
Morphologies Consideration", pp. 237-262 in Nanocrystals, ed. by Matsuda,
InTech, Rijeka,
Croatia, 2011). Synthesis of steel-reinforced nanoparticles, nano-onions, and
methods of
producing neat nano-steel crystals and nanoscopic metal sheets, however,
remain unreported.
[0036] Nanorobotics commonly refers to the science of nanotechnology
engineering and
fabrication of mechanical devices in the range of 0.1 to 10 gm in size from
nanoscale
components. Other common names for these theoretical devices are nanobots,
nanoids,
nanites and nanomites. It is postulated that future developments in this field
will allow the
construction of, among other things, tiny remotely operated surgical
instrumentation and
nanoscale electronic devices. Easy and inexpensive methods of nano-fabrication
of tiny steel
crystals or billets would likely advance this science considerably.
[0037] Concreting and Asphalting Technology.
[0038] Concrete and asphalt concrete are two common composite materials used
in
construction. Concrete is a composite formed minimally of a cementitous
material, a fine
aggregate, a coarse aggregate, and water. Asphalt concrete is a composite
typically formed
minimally of asphalt, a highly viscous, sticky black tar-like substance
present in some crude
petroleums and natural deposits, and a coarse aggregate. Many types of
admixtures and
additives have been developed over the years in an attempt to increase the
strength of these
materials.
[0039] The most pervasive of these concrete "additives" fall into two general
categories:
water-reducing superplasticizers (also known as high-range water reducers) and
synthetic
reinforcing fibers used to produce fiber-reinforced concrete (FRC). The
superplasticizers,
including the latest generation of polycarboxylate ether based
superplasticizers (PCEs) and
polypropyleneglycol-derivative admixtures, serve to reduce the amount of water
required to
form the composite. Superplasticizers also improve the rheology (flow
characteristics) of the
concrete slurry, thereby improving workability prior to cure (see Palacios et
al., "Effect of
superplasticizer and shrinkage-reducing admixtures on alkali-activated slag
pastes and
mortars", Cement and Concrete Research, Vol. 35, pp. 1358-1367, 2004; Aitcin
et al.,
"Superplasticizers: How they Work and Why The Occasionally Don't", Concrete
International, Vol. 16, pp. 45-52, 1994).
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 8
PCT/US2012/029276
[0040] In the case of FRC, the synthetic fibers (typically polypropylene
fibers), are intended
to increase the strength of the matrix and improve the concrete's
deformability. Concrete
reinforcing fibers are meant to bridge micro-cracks in concrete and reduce
separation, thereby
allowing the concrete to maintain its ability to support its load without
failure from complete
separation along cracks (see Soroushian et al., "Mechanical Properties of
Concrete Materials
Reinforced With Polyproplene or Polyethlene Fibers", Materials Journal, Vol.
89, pp. 535-
540, 1992).
[0041] In practice, neither type of "additive" has shown dramatic increases in
the strength of
the concrete or asphalt concrete products or systems. It is believed that
graphene and certain
graphene derivatives could be used as reinforcing "additives" to concrete and
asphalt in lieu
of the methods of the current state of the art.
[0042] Military and Ballistics Science.
[0043] According to recent research at Columbia University (New York, New
York, United
States), graphene is identified as the strongest material on Earth. The
inordinate strength of
graphene is attributed by the Columbia researchers to its covalent carbon-
carbon bond matrix.
The graphene samples tested were defect-free monolayers of graphene. Testing
of the
samples revealed that a single sheet of graphene has an intrinsic strength of
42
[0044] Modern anti-ballistics science seeks to develop ever-increasing thinner
means of
providing protection from ballistic projectiles and shrapnel. Towards this
end, new means for
molecular reinforcement of polymer-matrix-composites (PMCs) are continually
being
investigated. The current state of the art employs several varieties of high-
performance
ballistic yarns and fibers, including S-glass, aramids (e.g., Kevlar 29,
Kevlar 49, Kevlar
129, Kevlar KM2, Twarone), highly oriented ultra high molecular weight
polyethylene
(e.g., Dyneema , Spectra ), PBO (e.g., Zylon ) and Polypyridobisimidazole
(PIPD)
(referred to as M5 ) etc.
[0045] Typical characteristics of these fibers are very low density and high
tensile strength,
with correspondingly high energy absorption capacity. In the case of polymer
matrix
composite (PMC) ballistic panels, the fibers' force-dispersing deformation
ability is severely
hampered by the surrounding resin of the composite, which leads to failure
under conditions
of fracture and delamination of the resin matrix upon impact from a
projectile. Graphene and
its derivatives, incorporated into textile composite ballistic pannels, would
not suffer from the
same limitations as typical PMC resin-matrices.
[0046] Graphene and its derivative structures represent a unique opportunity
and material for
anti-ballistics. Graphene and its derivatives have particularly high elastic
moduli and tensile
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 9
PCT/US2012/029276
strength, with a Young's modulus of ¨1000 Gpa and a strength of around 13-53
Gpa. In
comparison to traditional anti-ballistic fibers and composites, the potential
of graphene and
its derivatives far outshine the methods of the current state of the art.
[0047] A company known as Nanocomp Technologies Inc. (Concord, New Hampshire,
United States), working in conjunction with the U.S. Army's Natick Soldier
Center, is
seeking to develop a new generation of lightweight ballistic armor based on
carbon nanotube
(CNT) technology. In April of 2009, the company reportedly demonstrated that a
¨5 mm
thick CNT-composite ballistic panel was able to stop a 9 mm bullet. Additional
advancements in industrially-scalable graphene and graphene-derivatives
synthesis would
undoubtedly move this technology closer to commercialization.
[0048] Lubrication of Mechanical Systems.
[0049] All mechanical systems involve friction between interacting constituent
parts. Such
interaction can be as simple as a ball bearing sliding along a race, a piston
ring moving
against a cylinder sleeve, or the contact between the lobe of a camshaft and
its cam follower.
In all of these examples, friction between the interacting surfaces is a
factor to be considered.
Friction in any system is the cause of stress, fatigue, wear, heat, noise,
vibration, and
eventually failure. The other common enemy of the aforementioned metal-
containing
mechanical systems is corrosion.
[0050] In most circumstances, engineering science seeks to reduce the friction
inherent in
physical and mechanical systems with interacting surfaces by machining and
finishing those
surfaces to the highest practical smoothness. No current friction surface is
perfectly smooth,
that is to say, completely free of asperities. Interaction of these uneven
surface asperities
increases friction. As needed, interacting components of physical and
mechanical systems are
machined and polished to required tolerances to permit proper performance and
reduce
inherent friction. Marked reduction in friction through so-called "super-
polishing" of
components to high tolerances (Ra < 50 nm) to date has meant substantial
additional
production time and costs. Generally, modern machining science is forced to
trade machining
exactitude for economy.
[0051] Additionally, all internal combustion engines, including gasoline and
diesel, both
normally aspirated and turbocharged, turbines, and other gear-containing
systems require
lubrication for proper operation. Various attempts at providing optimum
lubrication of these
machines have been made in the field of engine and gear lubrication since
their inception.
The first such attempts at lubrications, such as olive oil and certain
carbolic soaps, have since
been replaced with more sophisticated hydrocarbon-based lubricants, many
containing even
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
P
WO 2012/125854 10
CT/US2012/029276
more sophisticated additive packages and each such additive attempting to
address various
inherent problems in lubricating these systems.
[0052] The current state of the art for lubrication of metal-containing
mechanical systems,
such as internal combustion engines, is the use of elasto-hydrodynamic
lubrication (EHL)
techniques that utilize methods and materials to "deal with" the problem of
asperities on
interacting metallic surfaces of mechanical systems by employing
incompressible fluids and
barrier coatings to prevent metal-to-metal contact. None of these methods
affect the so-called
Ra (Roughness Average) values of the interacting metallic component surfaces
and do
nothing to ameliorate the friction-causing effects of the asperities
themselves.
[0053] To preserve and protect metal friction surfaces and the systems that
include them,
various lubricant additives are used for a variety of purposes, such as
dispersants, corrosion
inhibitors, viscosity improvers, seal swell agents, pour point depressants,
foam inhibitors,
anti-wear agents, and antioxidants. Some lubricant additives that have been
developed to
reduce friction include the following: triorthocresyl phosphate (TOCP, or
simply TCP),
popular in aviation lubricants but known to slowly attack elastomer gaskets
and seals;
naphthenic hydrocarbon detergents, known to combine with the products of
incomplete
combustion to form hydrochloric acid; zinc dialkydithiophosphates (ZDDPs),
problematic to
vehicles equipped with catalytic converters; chlorinated paraffins, identified
globally as
extremely harmful to aquatic life; suspended solids such as
polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE,
trade name Teflon ), considered undesirable for lubrication by many; graphite
powder,
considered by many to be undesirable in systems employing bearings;
molybdenum, a metal
reported to reduce fuel economy; tungsten disulphide nano-onions, a temporary
barrier
solution; Buckminsterfullerenes, another expensive and temporary solution, and
nanodiamonds suspended in graphite to discourage typical aggregation of the
abrasive
particles, again invoking complaints by those who object to graphite employed
in systems
containing bearings. Lubricant additives often also contain phosphates and
sulfides that upon
decomposition, can contribute to the production of noxious gases.
[0054] Carbonaceous deposits within mechanical systems are almost universally
considered
undesirable, so many modern lubricants are specifically designed and
formulated to inhibit
and/or prevent the formation of any carbonaceous deposits. Conventional El-IL
wisdom
suggests that internal combustion engine oil lubricants must be formulated to
be as physically
and chemically stable as possible to resist thermal degradation of the base
lubricant and its
additives by incomplete combustion and pyrolysis, not encourage it; this
because the products
of such thermal breakdown of conventional lubricants produce harmful
carbonaceous
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 11
PCT/US2012/029276
deposits (such as sludge) that tend to clog valves, coat piston rings and
generally decrease the
operating efficiency and life expectancy of an engine. Dispersants are
commonly used in
lubricants to prevent the aggregation of sludge (see, for example, Won et al.,
"Effect of
Temperature on Carbon-Black Agglomeration in Hydrocarbon Liquid with Adsorbed
Dispersant", Langmuir, Vol. 21, pp. 924-932, 2005; Tomlinson et al.,
"Adsorption Properties
of Succinimide Dispersants on Carbonaceous Substrates", Carbon, Vol. 38, pp.
13-28, 2000;
Wang, "Synthetic and Characterization of Ethylene Carbonate Modified
Polyisobutylene
Succinimide Dispersants", University of Waterloo Masters Thesis, 2010). Blow-
by soot from
the engine that is the result of incomplete combustion has been shown to be
highly abrasive
and capable of damaging metal parts (see, for example, Jao et al., "Soot
Characterisation and
Diesel Engine Wear", Lubrication Science, Vol. 16, pp. 111-126, 2004; Ryason
et al.,
"Polishing Wear by Soot", Wear, Vol. 137, pp. 15-24, 1990; Yamaguchi et al.,
"Soot Wear in
Diesel Engines", Journal of Engineering Tribology, Vol. 220, pp. 463-469,
2006; Gautam et
al., "Effect of Diesel Soot Contaminated Oil on Engine Wear - Investigation of
Novel Oil
Formulations", Tribology International, Vol. 32, pp. 687-699, 1999). "Ashless"
engine oils
are another example of products supporting the notion that lubricating
formulations must be
kept as free of carbon particles as possible and that all carbonaceous engine
deposits are
harmful and bad. Under the current EHL paradigm, thermal degradation and
pyrolysis of
lubricant additives resulting in the formation of carbonaceous soot and
deposits is universally
deemed undesirable.
[0055] The current testing standards for lubricants and their additives are
further evidence of,
and support this, lubrication paradigm. The Noack Volatility Test (ASTM D5800)
measures
vaporization of the lubricant formulation as a function of temperature,
because formulations
become more viscous with increased vaporization. The test involves putting a
mass of motor
oil into a Noack device at 250 C with a constant flow of air over the sample
for 1 hour. Then
the sample then is weighed to determine loss of mass due to loss of volatile
organic
compounds (VOCs). The acceptable loss in mass is to be no greater than ¨13 to
15%. A
lubricant must pass this test to earn approval under the API CJ-4 motor oil
standard (United
States) or the ISLAC GF-4 motor oil standard (European Union).
[0056] Other lubricant industry evaporation tests include ASTM D972 and ASTM
D2595.
ASTM D972 tests the lubricant formulation at temperatures between 100 and 150
C with a
constant flow of air (2 L/min) over the sample. ASTM D2595 tests the lubricant
formulation
at temperatures between 93 and 316 C with a constant flow of air (2 L/min)
over the sample.
[0057] The modern lubricant industry almost exclusively uses a base lubricant
of linear or
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 12
PCT/US2012/029276
branched chain hydrocarbons in EHL lubricating formulations, along with
relatively small
amounts of a combination of comparatively expensive additives, including, in
some cases,
cyclic-carbon containing additives such as certain antioxidant "hindered"
phenols, certain
salicylates, and certain amines. Most often, use of cyclic-carbon containing
lubricant
antioxidant additives in the prior art is limited to efforts to improve or
protect the underlying
base lubricant mostly by inhibiting its oxidation from the radicals of in situ
formed peroxides.
[0058] The entire aforementioned EHL lubrication paradigm and the industry
testing
standards are based upon the premise that carbonaceous products of incomplete
combustion
or pyrolysis are universally harmful and undesirable inside of engines and
mechanical
systems. This suggests that the optimal result of use of lubricants containing
detergents,
dispersants, and boundary films is to maintain the lubricated internals of a
mechanical system
as perfectly clean and free of carbonaceous deposits and free of abrasive wear
as possible.
[0059] Production and Use of Fullerenes in Lubrication.
[0060] Fullerenes, first discovered in 1985 and named after the late geodesic
dome architect
Buckminster Fuller, are a class of molecules with outer shells composed
entirely of carbon
rings. The basic spherical variety of fullerene is buckminsterfullerene or
simply, a
"buckyball". Buckyballs can be endohedral in nature, with various atoms, ions,
or complexes
trapped inside their hollow cores. Endohedral metallofullerenes, which contain
metallic ions,
are the subject of significant current scientific inquiry and study.
[0061] In mathematical terms, a buckyball is a trivalent convex polyhedron
comprised of
pentagonal and hexagonal carbon rings. Buckyballs follow Euler's polyhedron
formula, in
that V ¨ E + F = 2, where V, E, and F are the number of vertices, edges, and
faces on the
exterior of the ball. In terms of the non-isomorphic fullerenes, there are
some 214,127,713
different varieties. Pure simple buckyballs are commercially available in C60
and C70
configurations, but are quite expensive; generally, $900 to $1,000 per 100 mg
of material.
[0062] Bucky-diamonds are nanoscale carbon complexes of a diamond core within
a
fullerene or fullerene-like outer shell (see, for example, Barnard et al.,
"Coexistence of
Bucky-diamond with nanodiamond and fullerene carbon phases", Physical Review
B, Vol.
68, 073406, 2003). This structure is now believed to be an intermediary
structure between the
interconversion of nano-onions and nanodiamonds. Barnard et at. predict Bucky-
diamonds to
be a metastable form of carbon as the coexistence of nanodiamond and fullerene
in a size
range of ¨500 to 1,850 atoms (-1.4 to 2.2 nm in diameter).
[0063] Barnard et at. ("Substitutional Nitrogen in Nanodiamond and Bucky-
Diamond
Particles", I Phys. Chem. B, Vol. 109, pp. 17107-17112, 2005) present that it
is possible to
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 13
PCT/US2012/029276
incorporate heteroatoms, such as nitrogen in this case, into the Bucky-diamond
structure.
Recently, Yu et al. ("Is There a Stable Bucky-diamond Structure for SiC
Cluster", submitted
to the Journal of Chemical Physics on August 24, 2011) proposed a stable
Si68C79 Bucky-
diamond structure based on computer molecular modeling. In the stable state,
the
nanodiamond core and the fullerene-like shell are not believed to be
chemically bonded to
each other. The Yu et al. modeling predicted that upon heating of this Si-C
structure, the 35-
atom core would decompose at a lower temperature than the 112-atom shell, the
core then
becoming incorporated into the shell to form a larger retained fullerene-like
shell structure
upon cooling.
[0064] Fullerenes are a promising new nanotechnology in lubrication science.
There have
been many attempts to use fullerenes as barrier lubricants to fill asperities
and provide a
tribological film on moving parts. Unfortunately, large-scale and commercially-
viable means
for the production of useful fullerenes has proven elusive. Again, the current
state of the art in
tribology has focused on tribological films and coatings on the surfaces of
moving parts.
However this old paradigm does not address the underlying cause of friction
itself, the
asperities on the interacting metal parts.
[0065] The advent of nanotechnology and the science of tribology have
introduced several
new approaches to lubrication through the use of various nanoparticles. U.S.
Patent
Application Publication No. 2007/0292698, entitled "Trimetaspheres as Dry
Lubricants, Wet
Lubricants, Lubricant Additives, Lubricant Coatings, Corrosion-Resistant
Coatings and
Thermally-Conductive Materials" by Gause and published December 20, 2007,
discloses the
use of scandium-containing metallofullerene buckyballs as a suspended solid
lubricant, in
place of simple carbon fullerenes or "buckyballs", which rapidly degrade at
elevated
temperature.
[0066] The use of externally separated singular nano-Buckydiamonds (SNBDs) as
lubricant
additives has been postulated, however these molecules are inherently
difficult to separate
from undesired agglomerates, a necessary step to make them useful in
lubrication and other
applications (See for example, Ho, D. (ed.), Nanodiamonds: Applications in
Biology and
Nanoscale Medicine, Ch. 1, "Single-Nano Buckydiamond Particles, Synthesis
Strategies,
Characterization Methodologies and Emerging Applications", by Osawa, E.,
Springer
Science + Business Media, LLC, New York, 2010).
[0067] NanoMaterials, Ltd. (Nes Ziona, Israel) has produced a series of
tungsten disulfide
nanopowder-containing lubricants. These black tungsten sulfide onion
structures are intended
to fill surface asperities and shed layers to act as a low-friction
interaction barrier surface
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 14
PCT/US2012/029276
between interacting metal engine components.
[0068] NanoLube, Inc. (Lombard, Illinois, United States) claims to produce non-
abrasive
carbon nanospheres, under the name DiamondLubeTm, that are introduced into
lubricants to
reduce friction. The NanoLubeTM product appears to be expensive but simple
fiillerenes
suspended in lightweight oil.
[0069] PlasmaChem GmbH (Berlin, Germany) markets an additive for motor oils
under the
trademark ADDO , which is claimed to contain diamond and graphite
nanoparticles formed
by detonation synthesis capable of polishing internal engine parts to mirror-
like smoothness.
The graphite is presumably added to the suspension to reduce agglomeration of
the
nanodiamonds.
[0070] Detonation nanodiamond is a nanodiamond product typically formed by
explosive
detonation of an oxygen-deficient mixture of trinitrotoluene and hexogen (see,
for example,
Mochalin etal., "The properties and applications of nanodiamonds", Nature
Nanotechnology,
Vol. 7, pp. 11-23, 2012). The resulting nanodiamonds are usually in the form
of 1- m
clusters of 5 mu diamondoid particles, each nanoparticle comprising a diamond
core with a
layer of surface functional groups.
[0071] Other methods of forming nanodiamonds use non-detonation techniques,
such as laser
ablation, high-energy ball milling of diamond microcrystals, plasma-assisted
chemical vapor
deposition, autoclave synthesis, chlorination of carbides, ion irradiation of
graphite, electron
irradiation of carbon nano-onions, and ultrasound cavitation. These resulting
non-detonation
nanodiamonds have a tendency to cluster upon synthesis, and much effort has
been devoted
to developing processes to cleanly separate the agglomerated nanodiamond
products.
[0072] The common element in the majority of these solutions to friction
reduction, as well
as the current state of the art, is the use of elasto-hydrodynamic lubrication
(EHL) techniques
that utilize methods and materials to "deal with" the problem of asperities on
interacting
metallic surfaces of mechanical systems, not to remove or "solve" the root
cause of the
problem ¨ the asperities themselves. Those methods and materials that do
attempt to address
polishing and reduction of asperities do so by employing externally added
nanodiamond
abrasives that must be suspended in materials employed to prevent their
agglomeration into
undesirably large clusters. None of the aforementioned methods and materials
involve
techniques or the means for in situ formation of beneficial carbonaceous
tribological particles
or nano-abrasives from liquid precursors, a novel approach that addresses the
inherent
problem in the current state of the art of undesired particle agglomeration
from externally-
added nanodiamond lubricant abrasives.
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 15
PCT/US2012/029276
[0073] SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
[0074] The invention relates to methods for the facile synthesis of graphene,
graphene
derivatives and nanoparticles and their use as tribologically-beneficial
lubricant additives.
The products of the methods of the invention have numerous applications in
many fields,
including, but not limited to, tribology, nanotechnology, machining and
tooling, lubrication,
metalworking, drilling, mining, paint manufacturing, anti-corrosion coating
manufacturing,
rock tunneling, routing, mould fabrication, optical lens manufacturing,
military engineering,
gem cutting and polishing, aerospace engineering, automotive engineering, high-
speed rail,
marine engineering, medicine, nuclear medicine, medical imaging and
diagnostics, trucking,
cranes and heavy equipment manufacturing, farm equipment manufacturing,
motorcycle
manufacturing, electric motor fabrication, cable and wire manufacturing,
sanding, nuclear,
solar, wind and conventional electric power generation, hydroelectric power
generation,
electronics, integrated circuit technology, battery technology, polishing
compound
manufacturing, steel manufacturing, metal polishing, and chemical hardening of
metal
surfaces.
[0075] The invention further relates to lubricating compositions comprising a
lubricant and at
least one additive selected to serve as a sacrificial carbon source in the in
situ formation of
tribologically-useful graphitic carbon structures under normally operating
locally pyrolytic
conditions. Additionally, methods for ex situ synthesis of graphene, graphene
oxide, reduced
graphene oxide, and other graphene derivative structures and abrasive
nanoparticles are
disclosed. The means for separating the ex situ synthesis products are further
revealed by use
of a "dynamic furnace" apparatus.
[0076] Additionally, the invention is particularly useful as it pertains to
lubricating
compositions and methods for polishing, hardening, and lubricating moving
parts in engines,
turbos, turbines, tracks, races, wheels, bearings, shafts, transmissions, gear
systems, and other
physical and mechanical systems employing machined interacting hard surfaces.
In one
embodiment, the methods and lubricating compositions provide, among other
things, near
frictionless perfection in metallic interacting surfaces.
[0077] In one embodiment, the lubricating composition of the invention allows
the engine,
turbo, or turbine to produce greater useful horsepower and torque than when
lubricated with a
conventional lubricant because friction is decreased through the lubricating
and polishing
effect of the lubricating compositions and methods. Efficiency indicators such
as engine
horsepower and torque are observed to increase over a time period of days, to
weeks, to
months of normal use after the initial introduction of the lubricating
composition to the
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 16
PCT/US2012/029276
engine. In some embodiments, the benefits from the methods and lubricating
composition
disclosed herein include formation of a tribological boundary of nanoparticles
or nanosheets
on the surfaces of lubricated moving parts, where such nanoparticles or
nanosheets serve to
actively remove oxidation from the metal surface, encapsulate it, and make
beneficial use of
the oxidation molecules in the performance of an intended role in friction
reduction.
[0078] In the case of medicine, nuclear medicine, medical imaging, and
diagnostics, the
invention produces highly inert, safe and infinitesimally small vectors for
delivering
radioactive isotopes, other metal ions, or other therapeutic agents bound to
ions, to locations
within the body for therapeutic reasons or to enhance the resolution of
magnetic or other
diagnostic images. Additionally, these magnetic or paramagnetic spheroids may
be used to
eradicate tumors and cancer cells in an artificially-induced strong magnetic
field, such as in
magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), to force the spheroids to rotate or
oscillate violently,
thereby producing heat sufficient to thermally obliterate the targeted cells
or tissues from
within.
[0079] In one embodiment, the invention comprises an economical dehydration
reaction or
reflux pyrolysis to form graphitic carbon from a carbonaceous material carbon
source. The
methods are upscalable for industrial production. The carbon source is
preferably a sugar or
other 6 carbon ring-containing structure, although other carbonaceous
materials may be
subjected to dehydration, pyrolysis, oxidation or incomplete combustion to
serve as the
carbon source. The carbon source is subjected to reflux pyrolysis,
oxidation/reduction,
incomplete combustion or acid dehydration to form the graphitic carbon
reactant starting
material. In one embodiment, graphitic carbon is subjected to a refluxing with
a liquid
solvent, and graphene/graphene oxide (GO) is emitted as nanoscopic scales or
"nanoscales"
suspended in a vapor/steam. In one embodiment, a graphitic carbon source can
be subjected
to physical attack by a highly-pressurized liquid or vapor to produce
mechanically exfoliated
graphene scales without the need for a pyrolysis, dehydration, or oxidation
step. The resulting
graphene/GO scales can travel in the vapor and be collected either by direct
deposition onto a
solid substrate in physical contact with the emitted vapor, or by applying the
particle-
containing vapor to an aqueous solution or liquid used to promote "hydrophobic
self-
assembly" of the scales into larger graphene/GO sheets.
[0080] In one embodiment, the reaction environment is controlled to limit the
amount of
ambient oxygen (02) in the chamber, discouraging complete combustion of the
reactants
during heating. In one embodiment, the reaction is carried out in the presence
of an added
solvent. In one embodiment, the produced GO is converted to reduced graphene
oxide (rGO)
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 17
PCT/US2012/029276
or graphene sheets suspended in a heated or unheated liquid collection medium.
The resulting
rGO or graphene sheets can be used to produce a wide range of useful products,
including,
but not limited to, protective coatings, and low weight/high strength graphene-
reinforced
composites, wires, and fibers.
[0081] In one embodiment, a carbonaceous starting material is subject to a
dehydration
reaction or pyrolysis to form graphitic carbon. In one embodiment, the
carbonaceous source
is graphitic. The graphitic carbon is subjected to refluxing in the presence
of a solvent
causing graphene/GO scales or reflux synthesized polycyclic aromatic
hydrocarbons (PAHs)
to be emitted in a resulting vapor upon heating. The graphene/GO scales or
PAHs are
collected either by deposition onto a solid substrate in physical contact with
the emitted vapor
or by applying the vapor to an aqueous liquid pool for graphene/GO hydrophobic
self-
assembly. The process is industrially-scalable. In some embodiments, the
produced GO is
converted to reduced graphene oxide (rGO) sheets suspended in a heated or
unheated liquid
medium.
[0082] In one embodiment, the invention relates to the production of abrasive
nanoparticles
useful as polishing agents. Abrasive nanoparticles, according to this
embodiment, can be
created by the addition of a metal oxide or nanodiamonds to the reaction
mixture.
[0083] In one embodiment, the resulting graphene sheets may be used to produce
a range of
useful products, including, but not limited to, low-weight, high-strength,
graphene-reinforced
composites.
[0084] In one embodiment, suitable additives to conventional lubricants
promote the in situ
formation of tribologically-useful graphitic carbon-containing nanoparticles
or microparticles
in tribologically-effective amounts. In one embodiment, the additive comprises
a chemical
structure having at least one carbon ring. In one embodiment, the
nanoparticles are abrasive
nanoparticles that act as nano-polishing agents to nano-polish friction
surfaces to a high
smoothness by reduction or removal of asperities, thereby reducing the
friction between the
wear surfaces. In one embodiment, the additive to the lubricant comprises a
form of graphitic
carbon which is formed ex situ prior to addition to the lubricant to form a
lubricating
composition.
[0085] In one embodiment, the additive to the lubricant comprises an iron
complex molecule.
In one embodiment, the additive comprises nanoparticles of carbon-containing
particulate
matter. In one embodiment, the additive is dissolved in the lubricant to form
the lubricating
composition. In one embodiment, the additive is miscible with the lubricant to
form the
lubricating composition. In one embodiment, a carbon-containing precursor
molecule in the
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 18
PCT/US2012/029276
form of one or more sugar or sugar-like amphiphiles, is employed to provide a
sugar or
sugar-like component in the lubricating composition that does not tend to
congeal or clog
internal components of the system. In one embodiment, cyclic carbon-containing
precursor
molecules are added to the lubricant in the form of an existing commercially
available
solution that already contains such precursors. The synthesized graphitic
carbon does not
improve the inherent physical lubricating properties of the conventional base
lubricant, but
rather acts to transfer and absorb heat, form tribological coatings on
internal parts, and
convert into nano-abrasives that promote nano-polishing of metal surfaces of
the lubricated
system resulting in friction reduction.
[0086] In one embodiment, further reduction of friction and increased
efficiency in
lubrication is achieved by using a conventional lubricant having a lower
viscosity than other
conventional lubricants. The effective elimination of asperities by nano-
polishing eliminates
the need to use viscous formulations that are typically intended to adhere to
the asperities
under high sheer. The smoothness of the wear surfaces also allows operation of
an engine
with a thinner film of lubrication, which results from using a lower viscosity
fluid, between
two wear surfaces without damaging the metal parts. The lower-viscosity base
fluid provides
less resistance to moving parts, thereby improving the efficiency of the
lubricating system
and mechanical system it is lubricating.
[0087] In one embodiment, the methods deliver and produce a friction-reducing
film or
coating to internal mechanical system parts via the circulating lubricating
composition while
additionally making use of naturally occurring engine combustion products to
produce a film
or coating. In other embodiments, the methods deliver and produce a friction-
reducing film or
coating via the circulating lubricant alone.
[0088] In one embodiment, the lubricating compositions improve engine, turbo,
turbine, gear,
or other component or system performance. In one embodiment, the lubricating
compositions
provide tribological friction-reducing films and coatings to automotive and
aerospace
lubricating oil compositions and applications, including the lubrication of
gear, bearing, or
journal systems. In some embodiments, the lubricating compositions reduce the
friction
between wear surfaces by micro-polishing the wear surfaces to a lower surface
roughness
over time while lubricating the system during operation.
[0089] In one embodiment, the lubricating compositions combine with naturally-
occurring
combustion products and by-products by chemical reaction to provide
tribological friction-
reducing films and coatings to friction surfaces of automotive and aerospace
mechanical
parts. In one embodiment, additives in the lubricating compositions combine by
chemical
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 19
PCT/US2012/029276
reaction with each other to provide tribological friction-reducing films and
coatings to
friction surfaces of automotive and aerospace mechanical parts.
[0090] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a method of synthesis of
graphene
comprising refluxing a reaction mixture comprising at least one solvent and at
least one
carbonaceous material promoting polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon formation
under
conditions that inhibit complete combustion of the carbonaceous material,
thereafter
collecting vapors produced by the reflux of the reaction mixture, directing
the vapors to a
substrate, whereupon graphene is deposited on the surface of the substrate;
and recovering
graphene from the surface of the substrate.
[0091] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a method of graphene oxide
production
comprising refluxing a reaction mixture comprising at least one solvent, at
least one oxidizer
and at least one compound promoting polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon formation
under
conditions to prevent the complete combustion of the carbon source into carbon
dioxide or
carbon monoxide, thereafter collecting a vapor stream produced by the reflux
of the reaction
mixture, thereafter directing the vapor stream to a substrate, whereupon
graphene oxide is
deposited on the surface of the substrate and recovering graphene oxide from
the surface of
the substrate.
[0092] A lubricating composition comprising a base lubricant and at least one
carbon-
containing additive that forms, under locally pyrolytic conditions, a
tribologically-effective
amount of at least one graphitic carbon-containing structure.
[0093] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a lubricating composition
comprising a
base lubricant and graphene, wherein the graphene was formed prior to
combination with the
base lubricant.
[0094] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a lubricating composition
comprising a
base lubricant and one or more Bucky diamonds, wherein at least some of the
Bucky
diamonds comprise iron or an iron-containing molecule.
[0095] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a method of lubricating a
mechanical
system comprising at least one internal friction surface having asperities,
the method
comprising operating the mechanical system with a lubricating composition
comprising a
nano-polishing agent to remove the asperities from the internal friction
surface, wherein the
lubricating composition comprises at least one carbon-containing additive that
forms in situ,
under locally pyrolytic conditions within the mechanical system, at least one
nano-polishing
agent.
[0096] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a tribological coating
comprising
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 20
PCT/US2012/029276
graphene oxide.
[0097] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a lubricating composition
comprising a
base lubricant and at least one carbon-containing additive that forms, under
locally pyrolytic
conditions, a tribologically-effective amount of graphene oxide
[0098] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a lubricating composition
comprising a
base lubricant and at least one carbon-containing additive that forms, under
locally pyrolytic
conditions, a tribologically-effective amount of reduced graphene oxide.
[0099] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a method of synthesizing a
plurality of
surface-graphitized abrasive nanoparticles comprising refluxing a reaction
mixture
comprising at least one solvent, at least one metal oxide, and at least one
compound
promoting polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon formation to form at least one
surface-
graphitized abrasive nanoparticle and thereafter collecting the surface-
graphitized abrasive
nanoparticles from the reaction mixture.
[0100] In one embodiment, the invention comprises methods of use of graphene
in drug
delivery formulations, medical imaging contrast formulations, metal prosthetic
devices,
polishing agents and metal prosthetic devices and steel devices polished by
the polishing
agent, detergent formulations, and macroscopic solid material comprising
surface-graphitized
abrasive nanoparticles.
[0101] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a nanoparticle comprising a
core
comprising at least one metal atom and a surface-graphitized shell around the
core. In one
embodiment, the surface-graphitized shell comprises a fullerene carbon shell.
[0102] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a microparticle agglomerate
comprising
at least one nanoparticle, wherein the nanoparticle comprises a core
comprising at least one
metal atom and a surface-graphitized shell around the core, and at least one
graphitic carbon
structure associated with the nanoparticle. In one embodiment, the surface-
graphitized shell
comprises a fullerene carbon shell and the graphitic structure comprises
graphene and/or its
derivatives.
[0103] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a lubricating composition
comprising a
base lubricant and a tribologically-effective amount a plurality of
nanoparticles comprising a
core comprising at least one metal atom and a surface-graphitized shell around
the core. In
one embodiment, the surface-graphitized shell comprises a fullerene carbon
shell.
[0104] In one embodiment, the invention comprises an additive formulation for
addition to a
base lubricant, the additive formulation comprising a base solvent and an
effective amount of
at least one carbon-containing additive whereupon the carbon-containing
additive forms,
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 21
PCT/US2012/029276
upon local pyrolysis, a tribologically-effective amount of at least one
graphitic carbon-
containing structure.
[0105] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a coating applied to a
surface of a
material, the coating comprising at least one nanoparticle comprising a core
comprising at
least one metal atom and a surface-graphitized shell around the core. In one
embodiment, the
surface-graphitized shell comprises a fullerene carbon shell.
[0106] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a composite material
comprising a
matrix material and at least one nanoparticle dispersed in the matrix
material, the nanoparticle
comprising a core comprising at least one metal atom and a surface-graphitized
shell around
the core. In one embodiment, the surface-graphitized shell comprises a
fullerene carbon shell.
[0107] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a composite material
comprising a
material coated with a solution comprising graphene, wherein the solution
comprising
graphene is made by a process comprising refluxing a reaction mixture
comprising at least
one solvent and at least one compound promoting polycyclic aromatic
hydrocarbon formation
under conditions to prevent the complete combustion of the carbon source into
carbon
dioxide or carbon monoxide, and thereafter applying the reaction mixture to
the surface of a
composite material.
[0108] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a composite material
comprising fibers
coated with a solution comprising graphene, wherein the solution comprising
graphene is
made by a process comprising refluxing a reaction mixture comprising at least
one solvent
and at least one compound promoting polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon formation
under
conditions to prevent the complete combustion of the carbon source into carbon
dioxide or
carbon monoxide, and thereafter applying the reaction mixture to the surface
of the fibers that
comprise a composite material.
[0109] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a composite material
comprising a fiber
mesh coated with a solution comprising graphene, wherein the solution
comprising graphene
is made by a process comprising refluxing a reaction mixture comprising at
least one solvent
and at least one compound promoting polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon formation
under
conditions to prevent the complete combustion of the carbon source into carbon
dioxide or
carbon monoxide, and thereafter applying the reaction mixture to the surface
of the a fiber
mesh that comprises a composite material.
[0110] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a concrete mix mixed with a
solution
comprising graphene and its derivatives, wherein the solution comprising
graphene and its
derivatives is made by a process comprising refluxing a reaction mixture
comprising at least
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 22
PCT/US2012/029276
one solvent and at least one compound promoting polycyclic aromatic
hydrocarbon formation
under conditions to prevent the complete combustion of the carbon source into
carbon
dioxide or carbon monoxide, and thereafter mixing the reaction mixture with
the concrete
mix.
[0111] In one embodiment, the invention comprises an asphalt mix mixed with a
solution
comprising graphene and its derivatives, wherein the solution comprising
graphene and its
derivatives is made by a process comprising refluxing a reaction mixture
comprising at least
one solvent and at least one compound promoting polycyclic aromatic
hydrocarbon formation
under conditions to prevent the complete combustion of the carbon source into
carbon
dioxide or carbon monoxide, and thereafter mixing the reaction mixture with
the asphalt mix.
[0112] In one embodiment, the invention comprises fiberglass coated with a
solution
comprising graphene and its derivatives, wherein the solution comprising
graphene and its
derivatives is made by a process comprising refluxing a reaction mixture
comprising at least
one solvent and at least one compound promoting polycyclic aromatic
hydrocarbon formation
under conditions to prevent the complete combustion of the carbon source into
carbon
dioxide or carbon monoxide, and thereafter applying the reaction mixture to
the surface of the
fiberglass.
[0113] In one embodiment, the invention comprises plastic coated with a
solution comprising
graphene and its derivatives, wherein the solution comprising graphene and its
derivatives is
made by a process comprising refluxing a reaction mixture comprising at least
one solvent
and at least one compound promoting polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon formation
under
conditions to prevent the complete combustion of the carbon source into carbon
dioxide or
carbon monoxide, and thereafter applying the reaction mixture to the surface
of the plastic.
[0114] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a mix of polymers configured
to prepare
a plastic mixed with a solution comprising graphene and its derivatives,
wherein the solution
comprising graphene and its derivatives is made by a process comprising
refluxing a reaction
mixture comprising at least one solvent and at least one compound promoting
polycyclic
aromatic hydrocarbon formation under conditions to prevent the complete
combustion of the
carbon source into carbon dioxide or carbon monoxide, and thereafter mixing
the reaction
mixture with a mix of polymers configured to prepare a plastic.
[0115] In one embodiment, the invention comprises graphite coated with a
solution
comprising graphene and its derivatives, wherein the solution comprising
graphene and its
derivatives is made by a process comprising refluxing a reaction mixture
comprising at least
one solvent and at least one compound promoting polycyclic aromatic
hydrocarbon formation
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 23
PCT/US2012/029276
under conditions to prevent the complete combustion of the carbon source into
carbon
dioxide or carbon monoxide, and thereafter coating the graphite with the
reaction mixture.
[0116] In one embodiment, the invention comprises wire or cable coated with a
solution
comprising graphene and its derivatives, wherein the solution comprising
graphene and its
derivatives is made by a process comprising refluxing a reaction mixture
comprising at least
one solvent and at least one compound promoting polycyclic aromatic
hydrocarbon formation
under conditions to prevent the complete combustion of the carbon source into
carbon
dioxide or carbon monoxide, and thereafter coating the wire or cable with the
reaction
mixture.
[0117] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a method of synthesizing
nano-steel
comprising refluxing a reaction mixture comprising at least one solvent, at
least one metal
oxide, and at least one compound promoting polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon
formation to
form at least one surface-graphitized abrasive nanoparticle, thereafter
collecting a vapor
stream produced by the reflux of the reaction mixture containing the surface-
graphitized
abrasive nanoparticle and subjecting the collected vapor stream to an
annealing treatment.
[0118] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a method of graphene
collection
comprising refluxing a reaction mixture comprising at least one solvent and at
least one
compound promoting polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon formation and thereafter
collecting a
vapor stream produced by the reflux of the reaction mixture.
[0119] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a method of collection of
derivative of
graphene comprising refluxing a reaction mixture comprising at least one
solvent and at least
one compound promoting polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon formation and
thereafter
collecting a vapor stream produced by the reflux of the reaction mixture.
[0120] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a collection assembly
configured to
collect the vapor produced by refluxing a reaction mixture comprising at least
one solvent
and at least one compound promoting polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon formation.
[0121] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a hydrophobic self-assembly
configured
to self-assemble graphene and its derivatives from the vapor produced by
refluxing a reaction
mixture comprising at least one solvent and at least one compound promoting
polycyclic
aromatic hydrocarbon formation.
[0122] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a method of hydrophobic self-
assembly
of graphene comprising refluxing a reaction mixture comprising at least one
solvent and at
least one carbonaceous material promoting polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon
formation under
conditions that inhibit complete combustion of the carbonaceous material,
thereafter
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 24
PCT/US2012/029276
collecting vapors produced by the reflux of the reaction mixture, directing
the vapors to an
aqueous substrate, whereupon graphene is deposited on the surface of the
aqueous substrate;
and recovering graphene from the surface of the aqueous substrate.
[0123] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a method of production of
graphene
comprising refluxing a reaction mixture comprising at least one solvent and at
least one
carbonaceous material promoting polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon formation
under
conditions that inhibit complete combustion of the carbonaceous material,
thereafter
collecting vapors produced by the reflux of the reaction mixture, directing
the vapors to a
substrate, whereupon graphene is deposited on the surface of the substrate,
and recovering
graphene from the surface of the substrate.
[0124] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a method of lubrication of a
mechanical
system comprising operating the mechanical system with a lubricating
composition
comprising an effective amount of at least one carbon-containing additive that
promotes the
in situ chemical formation of a tribologically-effective amount of at least
one tribologically-
useful graphitic carbon-containing structure during operation of the
mechanical system.
[0125] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a method of increasing the
efficiency of
an engine comprising operating the engine with a lubricating composition
comprising an
effective amount of at least one carbon-containing additive that promotes the
in situ chemical
formation of a tribologically-effective amount of at least one tribologically-
useful graphitic
carbon-containing structure during operation of the mechanical system.
[0126] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a method of decreasing the
negative
horsepower of an engine comprising operating the engine with a lubricating
composition
comprising an effective amount of at least one carbon-containing additive that
promotes the
in situ chemical formation of a tribologically-effective amount of at least
one tribologically-
useful graphitic carbon-containing structure during operation of the
mechanical system.
[0127] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a method of decreasing the
torque of an
engine comprising operating the engine with a lubricating composition
comprising an
effective amount of at least one carbon-containing additive that promotes the
in situ chemical
formation of a tribologically-effective amount of at least one tribologically-
useful graphitic
carbon-containing structure during operation of the mechanical system.
[0128] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a method of production of a
tribological
resin, film, coating or lacquer comprising refluxing a reaction mixture
comprising at least one
solvent and at least one carbonaceous material promoting polycyclic aromatic
hydrocarbon
formation under conditions that inhibit complete combustion of the
carbonaceous material,
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 25
PCT/US2012/029276
thereafter mixing the reaction mixture with a resin, film, coating or lacquer
prior to
application or setting of the resin, film, coating or lacquer.
[0129] In one embodiment, the invention comprises a dynamic furnace configured
for the
production of surface-graphitized abrasive nanoparticles comprising refluxing
a reaction
mixture comprising at least one solvent, at least one metal oxide, and at
least one compound
promoting polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon formation to form at least one
surface-
graphitized abrasive nanoparticle, thereafter collecting a vapor stream
produced by the reflux
of the reaction mixture containing the surface-graphitized abrasive
nanoparticle and
subjecting the collected vapor stream to a high shear environment comprising
high speed
rotation, high frequency oscillation or vibration, hydrodynamic squeezing,
frictional impact
with one or more moving parts, high speed stirring, or any combination
thereof, and
thereafter collecting the surface-graphitized abrasive nanoparticles. In one
embodiment, the
dynamic furnace further comprises a surface topography comprising fins, rods,
bumps,
depressions, holes, asperities, tunnels and any combination thereof.
[0130] BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0131] The invention will be described with reference to the accompanying
drawings, in
which like elements are referenced with like numerals.
[0132] Figs. lA and 1B show schematic representations respectively of the
graphene/GO and
SGAN preparation steps in an embodiment of the invention.
[0133] Fig. 2A shows a process flow chart for the formation of a graphene/G0-
reinforced/coated substrate or graphene/GO scale vapor from a carbonaceous or
graphitic
starting material in an embodiment of the invention.
[0134] Fig. 2B shows a process flow chart for the formation of a graphene/GO
film-coated
substrate or a graphene/GO/rGO sheet from a graphene/GO scale vapor in an
embodiment of
the invention.
[0135] Fig. 3 shows a schematic graphene/GO/SGAN synthesis and collection
system in an
embodiment of the invention.
[0136] Fig. 4 shows an SEM image of an SGAN spheroid on an SEM stub coated by
a first
vapor deposition method with a sampled area in an embodiment of the invention.
[0137] Fig. 5A shows an SEM image of another SGAN spheroid on the SEM stub
with a first
sampled area.
[0138] Fig. 58 shows a second sampled area of the SGAN spheroid of Fig. 5A.
[0139] Fig. 5C shows a third sampled area of the SGAN spheroid of Fig. 5A.
[0140] Fig. 6 shows an SEM image of a crystalline structure on the SEM stub
with a sampled
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 26
PCT/US2012/029276
area in an embodiment of the invention.
[0141] Fig. 7 shows an SEM image of an SGAN spheroid containing nano-steel in
an
embodiment of the invention.
[0142] Fig. 8 shows an SEM image of an SGAN spheroid on an SEM stub coated by
a
second vapor deposition method with a sampled area in an embodiment of the
invention.
[0143] Fig. 9 shows an SEM image of another SGAN spheroid on the SEM stub.
[0144] Fig. 10 shows an SEM image of an area with numerous SGAN spheroids on
the SEM
stub.
[0145] Fig. 11 shows an SEM image of a gold/palladium coated area of the SEM
stub.
[0146] Fig. 12 shows a TEM image of a first area of a graphene product on a
carbon TEM
grid in an embodiment of the invention.
[0147] Fig. 13 shows a TEM image of a second area of the graphene product of
Fig. 12.
[0148] Fig. 14 shows a TEM image of a third area of the graphene product of
Fig. 12.
[0149] Fig. 15 shows a TEM image of a fourth area of the graphene product of
Fig. 12.
[0150] Fig. 16 shows a TEM image of a fifth area of the graphene product of
Fig. 12.
[0151] Fig. 17 shows a TEM image of a sixth area of the graphene product of
Fig. 12.
[0152] Fig. 18 shows a TEM image of an area of a graphene product on a copper
TEM grid
in an embodiment of the invention.
[0153] Fig. 19 shows a TEM image of an area of another graphene product on a
copper TEM
grid in an embodiment of the invention.
[0154] Fig. 20 shows the results of surface roughness measurements on a non-
wear surface of
a machined stainless steel cam follower after exposure to a lubricating
composition in an
embodiment of the invention.
[0155] Fig. 21 shows the results of surface roughness measurements on a wear
surface of a
machined stainless steel cam follower after exposure to a lubricating
composition in an
embodiment of the invention.
[0156] Fig. 22 shows an SEM image of a first portion of a non-wear surface of
a cam
follower retaining ring after exposure to a lubricating composition in an
embodiment of the
invention.
[0157] Fig. 23 shows an SEM image of a second portion of the non-wear surface
of the cam
follower retaining ring.
[0158] Fig. 24 shows an SEM image of a third portion of the non-wear surface
of the cam
follower retaining ring.
[0159] Fig. 25 shows an SEM image of a fourth portion of the non-wear surface
of the cam
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 27
PCT/US2012/029276
follower retaining ring.
[0160] Fig. 26 shows an SEM electron micrograph of a fifth portion of the non-
wear surface
of the cam follower retaining ring.
[0161] Fig. 27 shows an SEM image of a sixth portion of the non-wear surface
of the cam
follower retaining ring.
[0162] Fig. 28 shows an SEM image of a seventh portion of the non-wear surface
of the cam
follower retaining ring.
[0163] Fig. 29 shows an SEM image of an eighth portion of the non-wear surface
of the cam
follower retaining ring.
[0164] Fig. 30 shows an SEM image of a ninth portion of the non-wear surface
of the cam
follower retaining ring.
[0165] Fig. 31 shows an SEM image of a tenth portion of the non-wear surface
of the cam
follower retaining ring.
[0166] Fig. 32 shows an SEM image of an eleventh portion of the non-wear
surface of the
cam follower retaining ring.
[0167] Fig. 33 shows an SEM image of a first close up of the crystalline
structure on the left
side of Fig. 32.
[0168] Fig. 34 shows an SEM image of a twelfth portion of the non-wear surface
of the cam
follower retaining ring.
[0169] Fig. 35 shows an SEM image of the crystalline structure on the left
side of Fig. 32.
[0170] Fig. 36 shows an SEM image of a second close up of the crystalline
structure on the
left side of Fig. 32.
[0171] Fig. 37 shows an SEM image of a thirteenth portion of the non-wear
surface of the
cam follower retaining ring.
[0172] Fig. 38A shows an SEM image of a spheroid on the non-wear surface of
the cam
follower retaining ring with a first sampled area.
[0173] Fig. 38B shows a second sampled area of the SGAN spheroid of Fig. 38A.
[0174] Fig. 38C shows a third sampled area of the SGAN spheroid of Fig. 38A.
[0175] Fig. 39A shows a first sampled area of the crystalline structure of
Fig. 35.
[0176] Fig. 39B shows a second sampled area of the crystalline structure of
Fig. 35.
[0177] Fig. 39C shows a third sampled area of the crystalline structure of
Fig. 35.
[0178] Fig. 39D shows a fourth sampled area of the crystalline structure of
Fig. 35.
[0179] Fig. 39E shows a fifth sampled area of the crystalline structure of
Fig. 35.
[0180] Fig. 39F shows a sixth sampled area of the crystalline structure of
Fig. 35.
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 28
PCT/US2012/029276
[0181] Fig. 39G shows a seventh sampled area of the crystalline structure of
Fig. 35.
[0182] Fig. 40A shows a first sampled area of another spheroid on the non-wear
surface of
the cam follower retaining ring.
[0183] Fig. 40B shows a second sampled area of the SGAN spheroid of Fig. 40A.
[0184] Fig. 40C shows a third sampled area of the SGAN spheroid of Fig. 40A.
[0185] Fig. 41 shows an SEM image of another crystalline structure on the non-
wear surface
of the cam follower retaining ring with a sampled area.
[0186] Fig. 42 shows a first TEM image of material from the surface of the cam
follower.
[0187] Fig. 43 shows a second TEM image of material from the surface of the
cam follower.
[0188] Fig. 44 shows a third TEM image of material from the surface of the cam
follower.
[0189] Fig. 45 shows a fourth TEM image of material from the surface of the
cam follower.
[0190] Fig. 46 shows a fifth TEM image of material from the surface of the cam
follower.
[0191] Fig. 47 shows a sixth TEM image of material from the surface of the cam
follower.
[0192] Fig. 48 shows a seventh TEM image of material from the surface of the
cam follower.
[0193] Fig. 49A shows an eighth TEM image of material from the surface of the
cam
follower.
[0194] Fig. 49B shows a magnified view of an upper left portion of the image
of Fig. 49A.
[0195] DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
[0196] The invention relates to methods for the facile synthesis of graphene,
graphene
derivatives and nanoparticles, and their use as tribologically-beneficial
lubricant additives.
The products of the methods of the invention have numerous applications,
including but not
limited to molecular level coatings for composite reinforcement, heat
shielding, ballistic
transistors, integrated circuits, reinforced fibers and cables, and nano-
polishing agents.
[0197] Cyclic, as used herein, refers to any molecule with at least one five-
membered, or
larger, ring, where at least half of the atoms forming the ring are carbon
atoms. The ring may
be aromatic or non-aromatic.
[0198] Tribologically-effective, as used herein, refers to any amount of
additive or amounts
of multiple additives to a lubricated system sufficient to be tribologically
beneficial to such
lubricated system.
[0199] Tribologically beneficial, as used herein, refers to any additive that
reduces friction in
a mechanical system in which it is formed, found or employed.
[0200] Tribological agent, as used herein, refers to a molecule that
measurably reduces
friction in a mechanical system in which it is formed, found, or employed.
[0201] Bucky-diamond or nano-Bucky-diamond, as used herein, refers to any
nanoparticle
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 29
PCT/US2012/029276
having a nano-diamond core that may comprise non-carbon hetero-atoms, and a
fullerenic
carbon shell formed around the core.
[0202] Surface-graphitized abrasive nanoparticle (SGAN), as used herein,
refers to any
nanosized particle comprising at least one non-carbon hetero-atom enveloped by
an outer
shell comprising substantially carbon.
[0203] Spheroid, as used herein, refers to a particle that is shaped
substantially like a sphere
but is not necessarily perfectly round.
[0204] A matrix material, as used herein, refers to any material forming a
continuous phase
in a composite of two or more materials.
[0205] A spinel structure, as used herein, refers to any cubic mineral crystal
of the general
formula A2+1323+042- with the oxide anions (0) arranged in a cubic close-
packed lattice, the A
cations occupying all of the tetrahedral sites, and the B cations occupying
all of the
octahedral sites in the lattice.
[0206] An inverse spinel structure, as used herein, refers to any cubic
mineral crystal of the
general formula A21323+042" with the oxide anions arranged in a cubic close-
packed lattice,
the A cations occupying half of the octahedral sites, and the B cations
occupying half of the
octahedral and all of the tetrahedral sites in the lattice.
[0207] Graphitic carbon, as used herein, refers to any structure having a
carbon lattice matrix,
including, but not limited to, graphite, graphene, graphene oxide, fullerene,
fullerene-like
structure, endo-fullerene, nano-onion, nano-peapod, nanotube, nanobud, reduced
graphene
oxide, lacy carbon, and polycyclic aromatic compounds.
[0208] Carbon lattice matrix, as used herein, refers to, any 2-dimensional
polycyclic carbon
structure formed of sp2- or sp3-hybridized carbon atoms.
[0209] Dynamic furnace, as used herein, refers to a heated nanoparticle
synthesis furnace
apparatus that employs an agitative, sonic, centrifugal, centripetal,
compressive or shearing
force, or a combination of these forces, during the synthesis stage of the
nanoparticle product
formation.
[0210] Ex situ method for synthesis of graphene, graphene oxide, reduced
graphene oxide
and other graphene derivative structures and nanoparticles.
[0211] In one aspect, the invention relates to an ex situ method for synthesis
of graphene,
graphene oxide, reduced graphene oxide, and other graphene derivative
structures and
nanoparticles. An economical dehydration reaction or reflux pyrolysis can be
used to form
graphitic carbon from a carbonaceous material carbon source. The methods
disclosed are
industrially-scalable for industrial production. The carbon source is
preferably a sugar
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 30
PCT/US2012/029276
containing a 6-membered ring structure, although many other carbonaceous
materials may be
subjected to dehydration, pyrolysis, or oxidation and used. The carbon source
is subjected to
reflux pyrolysis, oxidation/reduction, or acid dehydration to form a graphitic
carbon reactant
starting material. In other embodiments, the dehydration/ oxidation/pyrolysis
synthesis step to
produce suitable graphitic carbon is bypassed and graphitic carbon itself is
used as the
reactant starting material. The graphitic carbon can be subjected to refluxing
with a liquid
solvent, and graphene/graphene oxide (GO) can be emitted as nanoscopic scales
or
"nanoscales" suspended in vapor/steam. Alternatively or additionally, a
graphitic carbon
source may be subjected to a highly-pressurized liquid or vapor to produce
graphene scales
without pyrolysis, dehydration, or oxidation step. The resulting graphene/GO
scales travel in
the vapor and are collected either by direct deposition onto a solid substrate
in physical
contact with the emitted vapor, or by applying the particle-containing vapor
to an aqueous
solution or liquid used to promote "hydrophobic self-assembly" of the scales
into larger
graphene/GO sheets.
[0212] In one embodiment, the reaction environment is controlled to limit the
amount of
ambient oxygen (02) in the chamber, thereby discouraging combustion of the
reactants
during heating. In one embodiment, the reaction is carried out without the use
of an added
solvent. In one embodiment, the produced GO is converted to reduced graphene
oxide (rGO)
or graphene sheets suspended in a heated or unheated liquid collection medium.
The resulting
large hydrophobically self-assembling sheets are easily reduced to rGO or
graphene, which
may be used in industry to produce a range of useful products, including, but
not limited to,
protective coatings, and low weight/high strength graphene-reinforced
composites, wires, and
fibers.
[0213] Turning to the figures, Fig. lA depicts a schematic representation of
the graphene/GO
preparation steps in an embodiment of the invention in which a reaction
mixture, including an
essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material carbon source, is reacted to
form graphitic
carbon by pyrolysis, dehydration, an oxidation/reduction reaction, or
incomplete combustion.
In one embodiment, a graphitic carbon starting material is used, eliminating
the need for a
pyrolysis or dehydration reaction step.
[0214] In one embodiment, the reaction mixture is refluxed to form a vapor
stream.
Graphene/graphene oxide (GO) nanoscales are carried away in the resulting
vapor stream
emitted during heating of the slurry or solution. The graphene/GO scales are
collected,
preferably by bubbling the vapor through a liquid that traps and suspends the
scales.
Alternatively graphene/GO scales form on the surface of the liquid when the
vapor stream is
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 31
PCT/US2012/029276
directed to the surface. In a process referred to herein as "hydrophobic self-
assembly,"
individual graphene/GO scales join to form sheets of graphene/GO layers at the
surface of the
liquid.
[0215] In one embodiment, the carbon source is heated directly by an external
heating source
in a pyrolysis or dehydration reaction to form graphitic carbon and water. In
one
embodiment, the carbon source is sucrose. In one embodiment, the resulting
formed water
serves as a solvent to permit refluxing of the reaction products. In one
embodimentõ the
reaction to form graphitic carbon proceeds as essentially represented in
Equation 1:
carbon source heat graphitic carbon + water (1)
[0216] In one embodiment, the carbon source is exposed to an acid in a
pyrolysis or
dehydration reaction to form graphitic carbon and water. In one embodiment,
the carbon
source is sucrose and the acid is concentrated sulfuric acid. In one
embodiment, the resulting
formed water serves as a solvent to permit refluxing of the reaction products.
In one
embodiment, the reaction product is a graphitic foam. In one embodiment, the
reaction
product is a graphitic slurry. In one embodiment, the reaction to form
graphene proceeds as
essentially represented in Equation 2:
carbon source > graphitic carbon + water (2)
[0217] In one embodiment, the carbon source is reacted with an oxidizer to
form graphitic
carbon in the form of a graphene oxide. In one embodiment, the reaction to
form GO
proceeds as essentially represented in Equation 3:
heat, additive
carbon source + oxidizer > graphene oxide (GO) (3)
where the applied heat drives the reaction and the optional additive serves to
catalyze the
reaction and/or improve the yield of the desired reaction product.
[0218] A GO reaction product is schematically shown as Molecule (1) below:
HO COOH COOH OH
OH
IIIIIII OH .60
o 0
00
HOOC
s Oleo
COOH
1-100C 001111111111111 0 1
0
.6
OH
COOH COOH
(1)
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 32
PCT/US2012/029276
[0219] In the above embodiments, the reaction conditions are selected such
that the reaction
does not lead to complete combustion of the carbon source into carbon dioxide
or an
incomplete combustion to form carbon monoxide. The reaction conditions are
rather
designed, preferably by control of the reaction atmosphere, to form graphitic
carbon-carbon
bonds. In some embodiments, a portion of the carbon source is purposefully
combusted to
provide the heat required for conversion of another portion of the carbon
source to form the
desired graphitic bonds. In some embodiments, the reaction occurs under non-
ideal
combustion conditions, such as pyrolysis or smoldering.
[0220] Pyrolysis, as used herein, refers to the decomposition of a carbon
source at an
elevated temperature with low oxygen or other oxidizer levels.
[0221] Smoldering, as used herein, refers to a slow, low-temperature,
flameless reaction
sustained by the heat from oxygen directly reacting with the surface of a
solid or liquid fuel.
[0222] Scales or nanoscales, as used herein, refer to discrete sections of
graphene or
graphene derivative.
[0223] Efforts to improve combustion efficiency have obscured the true value
of compounds
previously thought of as useless waste, such as the carbonaceous "phlegm" of
early coal
furnaces (see, for example, Coal-Tar and Ammonia, 56 ed., by Lunge, D. Van
Nostrand Co.,
New York, 1916), that actually contains graphitic material, including
graphene. Likewise,
modern combustion advances have overlooked the value of many old processes,
now deemed
outmoded, that are actually capable of adaptation to purposeful maximization
of soot
particulates formation ultimately into graphene, a graphene derivative, a
carbon-encapsulated
metallic nanoparticle, or nano-steel.
[0224] Although the formation of PAHs in carbonaceous particulates "soot" as a
product of
incomplete combustion is known, the usefulness of such PAHs has heretofore
been minimal
due to their limited size and tendency, as reported in the current art, to
typically drift away
from the synthesis conditions necessary for continued growth. Wiersum et al.
("The
Formation of Polyaromatic Hydrocarbons, Fullerenes and Soot in Combustion:
Pyrolytic
Mechanisms and the Industrial and Environmental Connection", pp. 143-194 in
Gas Phase
Reactions in Organic Synthesis, ed. by Vallee, Gordon and Breach Science
Publishers,
Amsterdam, 1997) report a number of different gas phase reactions to form
PAHs. None of
the known gas-phase PAH synthesis methods to date produce graphene or any form
of planar
graphitic carbon greater than 222 carbon atoms in size.
[0225] In one embodiment, the methods and processes disclosed herein promote
PAH
production through extended exposure to favorable synthesis conditions by
collecting and
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 33
PCT/US2012/029276
trapping product vapors of the reaction mixture, permitting resulting PAHs to
grow to sizes
exhibiting the general properties of graphene. Other embodiments, methods, and
processes
disclosed herein are designed to specifically promote continued PAH growth
conditions by
their self-assembly in steam-rich or aqueous solution conditions into large
graphene sheets.
These processes permitting graphene synthesis, either from compounds promoting
PAH
formation alone or from compounds promoting PAH formation and carbonaceous or
graphitic reactant materials, are scalable to meet industrial production
volumes.
[0226] In one embodiment, one or more compounds that promote the formation or
growth of
PAHs are used in the production of graphene, graphene derivatives, carbon-
encapsulated
metallic nanoparticles, or nano-steel. These compounds may include, but are
not limited to,
chemicals that are known intermediates in PAH formation and chemicals that
form
intermediates of PAH formation.
[0227] In one embodiment, the initial reactions occur in a solvent system
under reflux
conditions to promote the synthesis of PAH units that later self-assemble into
larger graphene
sheets. In some embodiments, the reflux conditions are azeotropic reflux
conditions (see, for
example, Udeye et al., "Ethanol heterogeneous azeotropic distillation design
and
construction", Internat. I of Phys. Sci., Vol. 4, pp. 101-106, 2009; Sun et
al., "ZrOC12.8H20:
An Efficient, Cheap and Reusable Catalyst for the Esterification of Acrylic
Acid and Other
Carboxylic Acids with Equimolar Amounts of Alcohols", Molecules, Vol. 11, pp.
263-271,
2006). In some reflux conditions, a promoter is added. In some embodiments,
the promoter is
a form of graphitic carbon. In some embodiments, the promoter is biochar, coal
phlegm,
nano-coal, an activated form of nano-coal, activated charcoal, graphite
particles, soot
particulate matter, or another sequestered carbonaceous waste form.
[0228] A sequestered carbonaceous waste, as used herein, is any carbonaceous
waste product
of synthesis, pyrolysis, or incomplete combustion, which is typically
collected and isolated to
prevent conversion into or release as an atmospheric greenhouse gas. In one
embodiment, a
sequestered carbonaceous waste can be utilized as a carbon source in the
reaction mixture, in
which instance the added carbon promotes the reaction, in part, by serving as
a thermal
conductivity-enhancing heat transfer agent (see, for example, Baby et al.,
"Enhanced
Convective Heat Transfer Using Graphene Dispersed Nanofluids", Nanoscale
Research
Letters, Vol. 6, no. 289, 2011).
[0229] The sequestered carbonaceous waste may be collected from the emissions
of any
process, including but not limited to the emissions of a diesel truck or the
emissions of a coal-
fired power plant. In some embodiments, a diesel particulate filter is used to
collect the
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 34
PCT/US2012/029276
carbonaceous waste as part of a "diesel emission control strategy." In other
embodiments, a
scrubber is used to collect the carbonaceous waste. The California Air
Resources Board
(CARB) recently enacted legislation requiring reduced particulate and noxious
gas emissions,
including from diesel trucks and buses, achieved by the addition of a filter
to the exhaust
systems of trucks (see California Code of Regulations, Title 13, Div. 3, Ch.
14 et seq.).
[0230] In some embodiments, designed as an alternative to so-called
"regenerative"
technologies that combust collected soot and continue to release greenhouse
gasses to the
environment, a reusable filter is employed. When it is time for a truck driver
or other user to
replace a dirty particulate filter, instead of disposing of the dirty filter
and buying a new filter,
the user exchanges the contaminated filter for a clean one. The sequestered
carbonaceous
waste contained in the used filter is preferably removed from the particulate
filter or scrubber
and used as a carbon source for graphene or graphene derivative synthesis. The
filter or
scrubber is preferably reused to collect additional carbonaceous waste from
emissions as the
process is repeated, as the process seeks to incorporate a large portion of
the carbon
sequestered into the graphene product rather than into greenhouse gas
emissions. In some
embodiments, the sequestered carbonaceous waste is harvested from the
particulate filter or
scrubber by being dissolved in an organic solvent. In other embodiments, the
sequestered
carbonaceous waste is harvested using water, an aqueous mixture, or steam.
[0231] PAH-promoting compounds for use in processes include, but are not
limited to,
dimethyl ether, propyne, propadiene, alcohols, including, but not limited to,
propargyl
alcohol and isopropanol, acetylene, and compounds that promote C1 to C5
hydrocarbon
radical formation.
[0232] Methyl radicals (CHO are known to promote the growth of both PAHs (see
Shukla et
al., "Role of Methyl Radicals in the Growth of PAHs", I Am. Soc. Mass
Spectrom., Vol. 21,
pp. 534-544, 2010) and graphene (see Wellmann et al., "Growth of graphene
layers on
HOPG via exposure to methyl radicals", Surface Science, Vol. 542, pp. 81-93,
2003).
[0233] Dimethyl ether forms methyl radicals and promotes PAH formation under
gaseous
combustion conditions in the presence of another carbon source (see Yoon et
al., "Synergistic
effect of mixing dimethyl ether with methane, ethane, propane, and ethylene
fuels on
polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon and soot formation", Combustion and Flame,
Vol. 154, pp.
368-377, 2008). Other hydrocarbon radicals, including, but not limited to,
C2H., C21-13*,
C3H3., C4H3., C4H5., and C5H3., are also capable of nucleating and growing
PAHs (see Pope
et al., "Exploring Old and New Benzene Formation Pathways in Low-Pressure
Premixed
Flames of Aliphatic Fuels", Proceedings of the Combustion Institute, Vol. 28,
pp. 1519-1527,
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 35
PCT/US2012/029276
2000).
[0234] The propargyl radical (C3H3') has been proposed as a key intermediary
for PAH
formation in a number of kinetic studies (see McEnally et al., "Computational
and
Experimental Study of Soot Formation in a Coflow, Laminar Ethylene Diffusion
Flame", 27th
Symposium (International) on Combustion, pp. 1497-1505, 1998; Shafir et al.,
Kinetics and
Products of the Self-Reaction of Propargyl Radicals", I Phys. Chem. A, Vol.
107, pp. 8893-
8903, 2003; Tang et al., "An Optimized Semidetailed Submechanism of Benzene
formation
from Propargyl Recombination", I Phys. Chem. A, Vol. 110, pp. 2165-2175,
2006).
[0235] Propyne and propadiene also promote PAH formation (see Gazi et al., "A
Modelling
Study of Allene and Propyne Combustion in Flames", Proceedings of the European
Combustion Meeting, 2011). Acetylene also may play a role in PAH nucleation
and growth
(see Frenlach et al., "Aromatics Growth beyond the First Ring and the
Nucleation of Soot
Particles", Preprints of the 202nd ACS National Meeting, Vol. 36, pp. 1509-
1516, 1991).
[0236] Figs. 2A and 2B show process flow charts for forming various graphene
products
from either a non-graphitic carbonaceous starting material or a graphitic
starting material.
[0237] Referring to Fig. 2A, when starting with a non-graphitic carbonaceous
starting
material, the carbonaceous material may be converted to a graphitic material
by several
different pathways.
[0238] In one embodiment, the carbonaceous material is combined with an acid
and
converted by a dehydration reaction, either with or without the addition of
heat and refluxing
of the reagents. In one embodiment, the carbonaceous material is a sugar. In
some
embodiments, the sugar is sucrose. In one embodiment, the acid is concentrated
sulfuric acid.
[0239] In one embodiment, the carbonaceous material is heated without a
solvent. The
carbonaceous material may be heated with or without an additive, which may be
an oxidizer,
a metal oxide, or a catalyst, optionally followed by collection and
condensation of any
produced gas or vapor, to form the graphitic material. The use of an oxidizer
or metal oxide
promotes the formation of GO over graphene, whereas in the absence of an
oxidizer or metal
oxide, graphene forms preferentially over GO. In one embodiment, the
carbonaceous material
is preferably heated to a high temperature, such as by a direct or an indirect
flame. In one
embodiment, the additive is a metal-containing compound. In one embodiment,
the metal is
iron. In some embodiments, the additive is a metal oxide. In one embodiment,
the additive is
ferric oxide. In other embodiments, the additive is ferrocene.
[0240] In one embodiment, the carbonaceous material is heated in a refluxing
solvent to form
the graphitic material. The carbonaceous material may be combined with an
additive, which
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 36
PCT/US2012/029276
may be an oxidizer, a metal oxide, or a catalyst. The use of an oxidizer or
metal oxide
promotes the formation of GO over graphene, whereas in the absence of an
oxidizer or metal
oxide, graphene forms preferentially over GO. In one embodiment, the additive
is a metal-
containing catalytic compound. In some embodiments, the metal is iron. In one
embodiment,
the additive is a metal oxide. In one embodiment, the metal oxide is ferric
oxide. In some
embodiments, the additive is ferrocene. In some embodiments, the solvent
includes one or
more of an alcohol, water, and a mineral oil. The solvent preferably permits a
high-
temperature refluxing of the reaction mixture. The solvent also preferably
helps to dissolve
the reactants, to prevent combustion of the reactants, and to promote vapor
production for
collection of the product. In some embodiments, the use of a solvent improves
the reaction
yield and increases the interaction between reagents to promote the formation
of the graphene
or GO products.
[0241] In one embodiment, when the carbonaceous material is combined with a
metal oxide
in the reaction mixture, surface-graphitized abrasive nanoparticles (SGANs),
including
SGAN spheroids, are formed. The SGANs can be recovered for any use, such as a
nano-
polishing agent or as an additive to a lubricant. It is contemplated that
recovery of the SGANs
from the reaction mixture can be accomplished by use of a magnet or externally
applied
magnetic field. Recovery may also be accomplished by centrifugation. In one
embodiment,
the reaction mixture comprising the SGANs can be used as an additive to a
lubricant.
[0242] In one embodiment, a large-scale DC arc-discharge apparatus, a chamber,
or a
cylinder can be used to promote SGAN formation. In some embodiments, the
ferric oxide is
provided to the system as a powder to promote SGAN formation. In one
embodiment, the
ferric oxide comprises a nanopowder. In one embodiment, a high carbon content
vapor can be
supplied to the system.
[0243] In one embodiment, the SGANs can be produced in a high shear
environment in a
"dynamic furnace". The high shear environment of the "dynamic furnace" may be
provided
by any method or combination of methods, including, but not limited to,
rotating the tube
furnace at high speeds, oscillating or vibrating the furnace at high
frequencies, employing
sonication, hydrodynamic squeezing, frictional impact with one or more moving
parts, and
stirring the "dynamic furnace" contents at high speeds. In one embodiment, the
speed of
rotation of the "dynamic furnace" can be on the order of about 1,000 to 11,000
RPM. In one
embodiment, the "dynamic furnace" additionally can include a surface
topography, which
may include, but is not limited to, fins, rods, bumps, depressions, holes,
asperities, and
tunnels, to provide additional shearing forces, thereby increasing the
shearing of the reaction
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 37
PCT/US2012/029276
mixture. In one embodiment, reaction gases can be supplied to the "dynamic
furnace"
apparatus. In one embodiment, SGAN synthesis can occur at elevated
temperatures, elevated
pressures, or reduced pressures. Temperatures in the "dynamic furnace" can be
on the order
of-2O0 to ¨800 F.
[0244] In one embodiment, the "dynamic furnace" comprises an incorporated tube
furnace
for formation of SGANs. An insulating portion can surround two concentric
rotatable
cylinders. The cylinders can include through-holes that allow material to pass
between the
area outside an outer cylinder, the area between the two cylinders, and the
area inside the
inner cylinder. The cylinders can be coaxial and rotatable in opposite
directions at high
speeds to produce high shearing forces. The dynamic tube furnace can also
include a feed line
for liquid components and a preheater leading into the main chamber. A
separate feed line for
gaseous components can also be included. The main chamber may be a single
chamber or a
two-zone chamber.
[0245] The inner surface of the outer cylinder or the outer surface of the
inner cylinder may
include fins, paddles, rods, bumps, or similar structures to provide shearing
to the system. In
one embodiment, the tube furnace can be designed in the form of a Wankel
engine to provide
the frictional contact, sheering, and squeezing to promote SGAN formation. The
"dynamic
furnace" can include a housing, a rotor, an eccentric wheel, and an inner gear
meshing with
an outer gear. As the rotor travels around in the "dynamic furnace" housing,
frictional
contact, sheering, and squeezing of the fluid between the rotor and the
housing can promote
SGAN formation. In one embodiment, the surfaces of one or more of these
structures are
electrified or electrifiable. In one embodiment, the electrified surfaces can
act as an
electrified cathode in the integral tube furnace.
[0246] In one embodiment, the carbonaceous material is a non-graphitic carbon
source,
which may include, but is not limited to, a sugar, sucrose, a sugar
amphiphile, a graphene-
promoting amphiphile, a sugar substitute, a starch, cellulose, an olefin, an
acetate, one or
more non-graphitic hydrocarbons, an alkane, an alkene, an alkyne, a ketone,
toluene,
gasoline, diesel fuel, kerosene, coal, coal tar, coke, or any combination of
these. In one
embodiment, coal and diesel fuel are preferred carbon sources. In one
embodiment the coal is
a pulverized coal. In one embodiment the coal is a nano-coal, such as the nano-
coal sold by
Nano Fuels Technology, LLC (Reno, Nevada, United States), having particle
sizes in the sub-
micron range.
[0247] A sugar amphiphile or a sugar-like amphiphile may be any molecule with
a
hydrophilic sugar portion and a hydrophobic portion, including, but not
limited to those
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 38
PCT/US2012/029276
described by Fenimore ("Interfacial Self-assembly of Sugar-based Amphiphiles:
Solid- and
Liquid-core Capsules", University of Cincinnati Ph.D. thesis dated October 16,
2009), Jadhav
et al. ("Sugar-Derived Phase-Selective Molecular Gelators as Model Solidifiers
for Oil
Spills", Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., Vol. 49, pp. 7695-7698, 2010), Jung et al.
("Self-Assembling
Structures of Long-Chain Sugar-Based Amphiphiles Influenced by the
Introduction of
Double Bonds", Chem. Eur. I, Vol. 11, pp. 5538-5544, 2005), Paleta et al.
("Novel
amphiphilic fluoroalkylated derivatives of xylitol, D-glucose and D-galactose
for medical
applications: hemocompatibility and co-emulsifying properties", Carbohydrate
Research,
Vol. 337, pp. 2411-2418, 2002), Germaneau ("Amphiphilic Sugar Metal Carbenes:
From
Fischer Type to N-Heterocyclic Carbenes (NHCs)", Rheinische Friederich-Wilhems-
Universitat Bonn Ph.D. thesis, 2007), and Ye et al. ("Synthesis of Sugar-
Containing
Amphiphiles for Liquid and Supercritical Carbon Dioxide", Ind. Eng. Chem.
Res., Vol. 39,
pp. 4564-4566, 2000).
[0248] A graphene-promoting amphiphile may be any molecule with a hydrophilic
graphene-
promoting portion and a hydrophobic portion, including, but not limited to
those marketed by
Dow Chemical Company (Midland, Michigan, United States) under the trademarks
TRITONTm or TERGITOLTm, including, but not limited to, the TRITON X series of
octylphenol ethoxylates and the TERGITOL NP series of nonylphenol ethoxylates.
[0249] Alternatively, a graphitic starting material may be used. The graphitic
material may be
any material including graphitic carbon, including, but not limited to,
natural graphite,
synthetic graphite, one or more polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs),
graphene,
activated carbon, biochar, coal phlegm, one or more benzenoids, naphthalene,
or any
combination of these.
[0250] Referring to Fig. 2A, the graphitic material in a solvent is heated. In
some
embodiments, the solvent includes one or more of an alcohol, water, and a
mineral oil. In
some embodiments, the mixture is heated to a boiling temperature. In some
embodiments, the
boiling solvent is refluxed.
[0251] In one embodiment, liquid graphene product resulting from reflux of the
reaction
mixture is collected in the reaction vessel itself. The graphene-containing
liquid may be
applied directly to a material or substrate to form a graphene-reinforced
material, a graphene-
coated substrate, a GO-reinforced material, or a GO-coated substrate.
[0252] Alternatively, the graphene-containing liquid may be further heated to
form a vapor
containing graphene/graphene derivative scales. A graphene/graphene derivative
scale, as
used herein, is understood to be one to several layers of graphene or graphene
oxide carried
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 39
PCT/US2012/029276
in the vapor stream of the refluxing solvent or solvent mixture. The layers in
the scale may be
mostly planar or they may be crinkled or folded in the vapor stream. The
length and width
dimensions of the layers are preferably significantly larger than the
thickness of the layers.
[0253] Referring to Fig. 2B, the graphene/graphene derivative scale-containing
vapor may
either be applied to a solid or a liquid.
[0254] The graphene/graphene derivative scales may be applied to a solid
substrate by
placing the solid substrate in the vapor stream or by applying the vapor
stream to the solid
substrate to form a graphene/graphene derivative film coated substrate. Any
crinkling or
folding in the scale layers is preferably reduced upon deposition on the solid
substrate. In
some embodiments, the deposited scales are annealed after deposition to
improve their
uniformity. In some embodiments, the deposited scales are annealed by heating
of the
substrate. In some embodiments, reactive end groups on neighboring deposited
scales react
with each other to form larger graphene/graphene derivative sheets. In some
embodiments, a
reducing agent is used to convert GO to rGO in the layers.
[0255] Alternatively, the graphene/graphene derivative scale-containing vapor
may be
applied to an aqueous pool. The vapor may be applied to the surface of the
aqueous pool from
above or by bubbling through the aqueous pool.
[0256] In one embodiment, the aqueous pool is a water pool with no additives.
If the water
pool contains no additives, the graphene/graphene derivative scales
hydrophobically self-
assemble to graphene/graphene derivative sheets at the water surface. In one
embodiment, the
deposited scales are annealed at the water surface to improve their
uniformity. In one
embodiment, reactive end groups on neighboring scales react with each other to
form larger
graphene/graphene derivative sheets at the water surface. In some embodiments,
a reducing
agent is used to convert GO to rGO in the assembling or assembled layers.
[0257] The aqueous pool may include one or more surfactants as an additive to
aid in the
hydrophobic self-assembly of the graphene/graphene derivative scales to the
graphene/graphene derivative sheets at the water surface. Any crinkling or
folding in the
scale layers is preferably reduced either by interaction with the surfactant
or upon arrival at
the water surface. In one embodiment, the deposited scales are annealed at the
water surface
to improve their uniformity. In one embodiment, reactive end groups on
neighboring scales
react with each other to form larger graphene/graphene derivative sheets at
the water surface.
[0258] The aqueous pool may include one or more reducing agents to convert GO
to rGO
during the hydrophobic self-assembly of the GO scales to rGO sheets at the
water surface. In
one embodiment, the reducing agent is hydrazine. Any crinkling or folding in
the scale layers
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 40
PCT/US2012/029276
is preferably reduced upon arrival at the water surface. In one embodiment,
the deposited
scales are annealed at the water surface to improve their uniformity. In one
embodiment,
reactive end groups on neighboring scales react with each other to form larger
graphene/graphene derivative sheets at the water surface.
[0259] The graphene/graphene derivative sheets may be applied to a solid by
contacting the
solid to the graphene/graphene derivative sheets at the surface of the water.
The solid surface
may be dipped in a vertical, horizontal, or angled orientation into the liquid
surface.
Alternatively, the solid surface may be located initially in the water and
brought upward to
the liquid surface in a vertical, horizontal, or angled orientation or the
water may be drained
to bring the graphene/graphene derivative sheets to the solid surface.
[0260] Alternatively, some of the water from the aqueous pool is permitted to
evaporate
slowly, leaving a viscous gelled graphene or graphene jelly in the upper
liquid portion of the
pool.
[0261] The carbon source may be in numerous forms, including, but not limited
to, liquefied,
powdered solid, or granular solid. In one embodiment, the carbon source
preferably includes
at least one essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material having a chemical
structure
containing at least one 6-member carbon-containing ring, such as sucrose, the
structure of
which is shown as Molecule 2:
HO
OH
H040,
0
õott
OFf
HO OH (2)
[0262] In one embodiment, the carbon source is of a form having a significant
amount of
graphitic carbon.
[0263] The carbon-containing rings in the carbonaceous material, especially
any aromatic
carbon rings, are believed to be conserved to some degree in the chemical
reactions of the
growing carbon-ring matrix of the graphene or GO products; that is to say, the
6-membered
carbon ring structure is believed to be retained to some degree in the
graphene or GO
products themselves.
[0264] The essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material may include one or
any
combination of the following, but is not limited to:
1. a sugar, including, but not limited to:
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 41
PCT/US2012/029276
a. a molasses or molasses substitute, including, but not limited to sweet
sorghum,
sugar beet molasses, pomegranate molasses, mulberry molasses, carob
molasses, date molasses, grape molasses, backstrap molasses, black treacle,
maple syrup or corn syrup, including, but not limited to high-fructose corn
syrup;
b. an invert sugar, including, but not limited to, inverted sugar syrup;
c. a deoxy sugar, including, but not limited to deoxyribose, fucose or
rhamnose;
d. a monosaccharide, including, but not limited to glucose, fructose,
galactose,
xylose or ribose;
e. a disaccharide, including, but not limited to sucrose, lactulose, lactose,
maltose, trehalose or cellobiose;
f. a polysaccharide, including, but not limited to starch, glycogen,
arabinoxylan,
cellulose, chitin or pectin;
g. a sugar alcohol, including, but not limited to erythritol, threitol,
arabitol,
xylitol, ribitol, mannitol, sorbitol, dulcitol, iditol, isomalt, maltitol or
lactitol;
or
h. an amphiphile, including, but not limited to a sugar amphiphile or a
graphene-
promoting amphiphile;
2. a sugar substitute, including, but not limited to stevia, aspartame,
sucralose, neotame,
acesulfame potassium, saccharin, or a sugar alcohol;
3. a hydrocarbon, including, but not limited to naphthalene, diesel fuel,
kerosene,
gasoline, or an alkane, including, but not limited to methane, ethane,
propane,
cyclopropane, butane, isobutane, cyclobutane, pentane, isopentane, neopentane,
cyclopentane, hexane, octane, kerosene, isoparaffins, liquid paraffins or
paraffin
waxes;
4. a coal form, including, but not limited to peat, lignite, bituminous coal,
sub-
bituminous coal, pulverized coal, nano-coal, steam coal, cannel coal,
anthracite,
charcoal, carbon black, activated charcoal, "activated nano-coal" or sugar
char;
5. an alcohol, including, but not limited to ethanol, methanol, or
isopropanol; or
6. an oil, including, but not limited to linseed oil, citronella oil, geraniol
or mineral oil.
[0265] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
pyranose, a furanose, a cyclic carbomer, or a benzenoid (see Katritzky et al.,
"Aqueous High-
Temperature Chemistry of Carbo- and Heterocycles. 20.1 Reactions of some
Benzenoid
Hydrocarbons and Oxygen-Containing Derivatives in Supercritical Water at 460
C", Energy
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 42
PCT/US2012/029276
& Fuels, Vol. 8, pp. 487-497, 1994), including, but not limited to, oxygen-
containing
benzenoids.
[0266] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
sugar. In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises
sucrose. In one embodiment the sugar comprises a molasses or molasses
substitute, which
may comprise, but is not limited to, sweet sorghum, sugar beet molasses,
pomegranate
molasses, mulberry molasses, carob molasses, date molasses, grape molasses,
backstrap
molasses, black treacle, bee's honey, maple syrup, or corn syrup, including,
but not limited
to, high-fructose corn syrup. In some embodiments, the sugar comprises an
invert sugar,
which may comprise, but is not limited to, inverted sugar syrup.
[0267] In one embodiment, the sugar comprises a deoxy sugar, which may
comprise, but is
not limited to, deoxyribose, fucose, or rhamnose.
[0268] In one embodiment, the sugar comprises a monosaccharide, which may
comprise, but
is not limited to, glucose, fructose, galactose, xylose, or ribose.
[0269] In one embodiment, the sugar comprises a disaccharide, which may
comprise, but is
not limited to, sucrose, lactulose, lactose, maltose, trehalose, cellobiose,
or sophorose.
[0270] In one embodiment, the sugar comprises a polysaccharide, which may
comprise, but
is not limited to, starch, glycogen, arabinoxylan, cellulose, chitin, or
pectin.
[0271] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
sugar alcohol, which may include, but is not limited to, erythritol, threitol,
arabitol, xylitol,
ribitol, mannitol, sorbitol, dulcitol, iditol, isomalt, maltitol, or lactitol.
[0272] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
sugar substitute, which may include, but is not limited to, stevia, aspartame,
sucralose,
neotame, acesulfame potassium, or saccharin.
[0273] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
sugar derivative, which may include, but is not limited to, sophoritol, a
phenolic glycoside, a
steviol glycoside, a saponin, a glycoside, a glucoside, or amygdalin.
[0274] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
cyclomethicone, which may include, but is not limited to, phenyl trimethicone
or
cyclopentasiloxane.
[0275] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
steroid, which may include, but is not limited to, sapogenin or diosgenin.
[0276] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
cinnamate, which may include, but is not limited to, methyl or ethyl
cinnamate. In one
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 43
PCT/US2012/029276
embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material comprises
cinnamic acid. In
one embodiment, the additive comprises cinnamon oil.
[0277] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
phenylphopanoid, which may include, but is not limited to, cinnamic acid,
coumaric acid,
caffeic acid, ferulic acid, 5-hydroxyferulic acid, sinapic acid,
cinnamaldehyde, umbelliferone,
resveratrol, a monolignol, which may comprise, but is not limited to,
coniferyl alcohol,
coumaryl alcohol, or sinapyl alcohol, or a phenylpropene, which may comprise,
but is not
limited to, engenol, chavicol, safrole, or estragole.
[0278] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
benzoate, which may include, but is not limited to, ferric, benzyl, ethyl,
methyl, phenyl,
cyclohexanol, 2-phenyl-, pentaerythritol tetra-, sodium, or potassium
benzoate. In one
embodiment, the additive includes benzoic acid. In one embodiment, the
essentially non-
graphitic carbonaceous material comprises aminobenzoic acid. In one
embodiment, the
essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material comprises 2-hydroxymethyl
benzoic acid
methyl ester. In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous
material
includes ubiquinone.
[0279] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
carboxylate, including but not limited to trimethyl cis, cis-1,3,5-
cyclohexanetricarboxylate.
[0280] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
benzopyran, which may include, but is not limited to, chromene, isochromene,
or a
substituted benzopyran.
[0281] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
naturally-occurring or synthetic flavone or isoflavone, which may include, but
is not limited
to, flavan-3-ol or flavanone.
[0282] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
salicylate, which may include, but is not limited to, ferric, methyl, ethyl,
butyl, cinnamyl,
cyclohexyl, ethylhexyl, heptyl, isoamyl, octyl, benzyl, phenyl, p-cresol, o-
cresol, m-cresol, or
sodium salicylate. In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic
carbonaceous material
includes salicylic acid. In one embodiment, the additive includes
aminosalicylic acid.
[0283] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises an
antioxidant. In one embodiment, the antioxidant is a cyclic antioxidant. In
one embodiment,
the antioxidant is a phenolic antioxidant, which may include, but is not
limited to, 2,6-di-terti-
butylphenol, 2-tert-butyl-4,6-dimethylphenol, 2,6-di-tert-butyl-4-ethylphenol,
2,6-di-tert-
buty1-4-n-buty 'phenol, 2,6-di-tert-butyl-4-1-butylphenol, 2,6-d i-cyc
lopenty1-4-methy lphenol,
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 44
PCT/US2012/029276
2-(a-methylcyclohexyl)-4,6-dimethylphenol, 2,6-di-
octadecyl-methylphenol, 2,4,6-tri-
cyclohexylphenol, 2,6-d i-tert-buty1-4-methoxymethy lphenol, 2,6-di-
tert-buty1-4-
methoxyphenol, 2,5-di-tert-butyl-hydroquinone, 2,5-di-tert-amyl-hydroquinone,
2,6-
dipheny1-4-octadecy loxyph en ol, 2,2'-
methylene-bis-(6-tert-butyl-4-methylphenol), 2,2!-
methylene-bis-(6-tert-buty1-4-ethylphenol), 2,2'-
methylene-bis-[4-methy1-6-(a-
methylcyclohexyl)-phenol], 2,2'-methylene-
bis-(4-methyl-6-cyclohexylphenol), 2,2'-
methylene-bis-(6-nony1-4-methylphenol), 2,21-
methylene-bis46-(a-methylbenzy1)-4-
nonylphenol], 2,2'-methylene-bis[6-(a,a-dimethylbenzy1)-4-nonylphenol], 2,2T-
methylene-
bis-(4,6-di-tert-butylphenol), 2,T-ethylidene-bis-(4,6-di-tert-butylphenol),
2,T-ethylidene-
bis-(6-tert-buty1-4-isobutylphenol), 4,4T-methylene-
bis-(2,6-di-tert-butylphenol), 4,4'-
methy lene-b s-(6-tert-buty1-2-methy 'phenol), 1,1-bis-
(5-tert-buty1-4-hydroxy-2-
methy lpheny1)-butane, 2,6-di-(3-
tert-butyl-5-methyl-2-hydroxybenzy1)-4-methy lphenol,
1,1,3-tris-(5-tert-buty1-4-hydroxy-2-methylpheny1)-butane, and any naturally-
occurring plant-
based phenolic antioxidant, which may include, but is not limited to, ascorbic
acid, a
tocopherol, a tocotrienol, rosemarinic acid, and other phenolic acids and
flavonoids, such as
those found, for example, in grapes, berries, olives, soy, tea leaves,
rosemary, basil, oregano,
cinnamon, cumin, and turmeric.
[0284] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises 4-
vinylphenol, anthocyanidin, or chromenylium.
[0285] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
cyclic amino acid, which may include, but is not limited to, phenylalanine,
tryptophan, or
tyrosine.
[0286] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
cyclohexane derivative, which may include, but is not limited to, 1,3-
cyclohexadiene or 1,4-
cyc lohexadiene.
[0287] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
benzene derivative which may include, but is not limited to, a polyphenol,
benzaldehyde,
benzotriazole, benzyl 1-naphthyl carbonate, benzene, ethyl benzene, toluene,
styrene,
benzonitrile, phenol, phthalic anhydride, phthalic acid, terephthalic acid, p-
toluic acid,
benzoic acid, aminobenzoic acid, benzyl chloride, isoindole, ethyl phthalyl
ethyl glycolate,
N-phenyl benzamine, methoxybenzoquinone, benzylacetone, benzylideneacetone,
hexyl
cinnamaldehyde, 4-amino-2-hydroxytoluene, 3-aminophenol, or vanillin.
[0288] In one embodiment, the benzene derivative comprises a benzenediol,
which may
include 1,2-dihydroxybenzene (catechol), 1,3-dihydroxybenzene (resorcinol), or
1,4-
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 45
PCT/US2012/029276
dihydroxybenzene (hydroquinone).
[0289] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
naphthoate, including but not limited to methyl 2-methoxy-1-naphthoate or
methyl 3-
methoxy-2-naphthoate.
[0290] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises an
acrylate, including but not limited to benzyl 2-propylacrylate or 2-naphthyl
methacrylate.
[0291] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
phthalate, including but not limited to diallyl phthalate.
[0292] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
succinate, including but not limited to bis(2-carboxyphenyl) succinate.
[0293] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
carpate, including but not limited to methyl 0-methylpodocarpate.
[0294] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
fluorophore, which may include, but is not limited to, fluorescein
isothiocyanate, rhodamine,
phthalocyanine, or copper phthalocyanine.
[0295] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
pharmaceutical, which may include, but is not limited to, acetylsalicylic
acid, acetaminophen,
ibuprofen, or a benzodiazepine.
[0296] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
phosphate, which may include, but is not limited to, a cresyldiphenyl
phosphate, a dicresyl
phosphate, a triorthocresyl phosphate, a tricresyl phosphate, a paracresyl
phosphate, an
orthocresyl phosphate, or a metacresyl phosphate.
[0297] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
compound that degrades to one or more of the above-mentioned additives under
the heat of
the operating conditions of the engine or mechanical system, such as certain
terpenes or
certain natural aromatic or non-aromatic cyclic esters, ketones, or aldehydes,
which may
include, but is not limited to, methyl salicylate (wintergreen oil), cinnamon
leaf/bark oil
(cinnamaldehyde), limonene (dipentene), pinene, and camphene.
[0298] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
commercial edible personal/sexual lubricating composition including a sugar or
sugar-
substitute amphiphile.
[0299] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
commercial ultraviolet ray sunscreen formulation, which may include octyl
methoxycinnamate (oxctinoxate), butyl-methoxydibenzoylmethane (B-MDM,
Avobenzone),
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 46
PCT/US2012/029276
octyl-dimethyl-para-aminobenzoic acid (OD-PABA), octocrylene, oxybenzone,
alkyl
benzoate, diethylhexyl 2,6-naphthalate, phenoxy-ethanol, homosalate,
ethylhexyl triazone, 4-
methyl-benzylidene camphor (4-MBC), or a polysorbate.
[0300] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
commercial skin cream formulation, which may include, but is not limited to
carbomer,
ascorbyl palmitate, tocopheryl acetate, ketoconazole, or mineral oil.
[0301] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
commercial hand sanitizer formulation, which may include carbomer, tocopheryl
acetate, or
propylene glycol.
[0302] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
commercial human or animal hair care product, which may include benzophenone,
alkyl
benzoate, phenoxyethanol, sorbitan oleate, a styrene copolymer, propylene
glycol,
hydroxyisohexy1-3-cyclohexene carboxaldehyde, butylated hydroxytoluene,
ketoconazole,
petrolatum, mineral oil, or paraffinum liquidum.
[0303] In one embodiment, the commercial hair care product is a curl
activating or relaxing
solution, which may include carbomer, hexyl cinnamal, benzyl salicylate,
trolamine
salicylate, benzyl benzoate, limonene, eugenol, 1,3-Bis(hydroxymethyl)-5,5-
dimethy-
limidazolidine-2,4-dione (DMDM Hydantoin), para-aminobenzoic acid (PABA), 2-
ethy lhexyl 4-d imethy laminobenzoate (Padimate 0), butylphenyl
methylpropional,
propylparaben, phenolsulfonphthalein (PSP, phenol red), or a polysorbate.
[0304] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
commercial hair dye formulation, which may include hydrated iron oxide
(Fe(OH)3), para-
phenylenediamine, ortho-, meta-, or para-aminophenol, 4-amino-2-
hydroxytoluene, trideceth-
2 carboxamide MEA, phenyl methyl pyrazolone, phenoxyethanol, a polyquaternium,
hexyl
cinnamal, butylphenyl methylpropional, phenolsulfonphthalein (PSP, phenol
red),
hydroxyisohexyl 3-cyclohexene carboxaldehyde, titanium dioxide, or iron oxide.
[0305] In one embodiment, the essentially non-graphitic carbonaceous material
comprises a
commercial pesticide, which may include, but is not limited to, ortho-
phenylphenol (OPP),
phenylhydroquinone (PHQ) or phenylbenzoquinone (PBQ).
[0306] The oxidizer may be in any form, including, but not limited to,
gaseous, liquefied,
powdered solid, or granular solid. The oxidizer may include one or any
combination of the
following, but is not limited to potassium nitrate, gaseous oxygen, sodium
nitrate, ammonium
dichromate, ammonium nitrate, ammonium perchlorate, potassium perchlorate,
potassium
permanganate, calcium nitrate, hydrogen peroxide, sodium bicarbonate, or
mercury
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 47
PCT/US2012/029276
th iocyanate.
[0307] In one embodiment, the reaction mixture includes a solvent. The solvent
may include
an alcohol, including one or any combination of the following, but is not
limited to methanol,
ethanol, isopropyl alcohol, n-propanol, or a gelled alcohol formulation,
including, but not
limited to a jellied, denatured alcohol formulation, such as a formulation
including ethanol
and methanol as found in Sterno brand canned heat (The Sterno Group, LLC, Des
Plaines,
Illinois, United States), or a gelled alcohol formulation such as found in
hand sanitizers,
including formulations containing such thickening agents as polyacrylic acid,
or propylene
glycol.
[0308] In one embodiment, the reaction mixture includes one or more catalysts
or other
additives. The additive or catalyst may include one or any combination of the
following, but
is not limited to sodium bicarbonate, aluminum bicarbonate, sodium aluminum
phosphate,
sodium aluminum sulfate, potassium carbonate, potassium phosphate, potassium
hydroxide,
aluminum hydroxide, magnesium hydroxide, magnesium sulfate, magnesium
phosphate,
cream of tartar, citric acid, ascorbic acid, sucrase, invertase, ferrocene, or
a transition metal
oxide catalyst, which may be in a nanopowder form, the catalyst including one
or any
combination of the following, but not limited to an iron oxide, including
iron(II) oxide,
iron(II, III) oxide, iron(III) oxide, iron(II) hydroxide, iron(III) hydroxide,
or iron(III) oxide-
hydroxide, aluminum oxide, a copper oxide, including, but not limited to
copper(I) oxide, or
copper(II) oxide, a nickel oxide, including, but not limited to nickel(I)
oxide, or nickel(II)
oxide, a titanium oxide, including, but not limited to titanium dioxide,
titanium(I) oxide, or
titanium(II) oxide, or a lead oxide, including, but not limited to lead(II)
oxide, lead(IV) oxide,
lead tetroxide, or a lead sesquioxide.
[0309] In one embodiment, sucrose and sodium bicarbonate are combined in about
a 4:1
volume ratio, with ethanol added as a solvent, to form the reaction mixture.
[0310] In one embodiment, the reactants are mixed with a flammable solvent
such as
methanol, ethanol, or isopropanol. In some of these embodiments, the carbon
source is
dissolved in the flammable solvent. In other embodiments, the reactants form a
slurry with
the solvent.
[0311] In one embodiment, the reaction is performed in the absence of a
solvent.
[0312] In one embodiment, powdered sugar and sodium bicarbonate powder are
combined in
a 4-to-1 ratio and mixed with a metal oxide catalyst prior to exposure to
heat.
[0313] In one embodiment, the reaction mixture may additionally or
alternatively include one
or more of sodium bicarbonate, naphthalene, and linseed oil.
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 48
PCT/US2012/029276
[0314] In one embodiment, sucrose and potassium nitrate are combined in a
ratio of about
35:65 to form the reaction mixture (see Rocket Manual for Amateurs by B.R.
Brinley,
Ballantine Books, New York, New York, 1960, and Amateur Experimental Rocketry,
Vol. 7
by Richard Nakka, self-published on CD only, January 2011). In one embodiment,
the
reaction mixture further includes a metal oxide in the range of about 1% to
about 30%,
preferably about 5%.
[0315] In one embodiment, powdered sugar and an alcohol, preferably ethanol or
isopropanol, are placed in a reaction vessel and mixed to form a paste
reaction mixture. The
reaction mixture is heated to produce a vapor containing vapor-exfoliated
graphene/graphene
derivative scale. In some embodiments, the reaction mixture further includes
iron oxide in the
form of BayFerrox iron oxide powder pigment (Lanxess, Cologne, Germany). In
other
embodiments, the iron oxide is in the form of high-purity Fe304 (15-20 nm)
nanopowder
(U.S. Research Nanomaterials, Inc., Houston, Texas, United States).
[0316] In one embodiment, powdered sugar and gelled alcohol, in the form of a
conventional
hand sanitizer, including water, polyacrylic acid, and 40% isopropyl alcohol,
are placed in a
reaction vessel and mixed together to form a reaction mixture. The reaction
mixture is heated
to produce a vapor containing vapor-exfoliated graphene/graphene derivative
scales. In some
embodiments, the reaction mixture further includes iron oxide in the form of
BayFerrox iron
oxide powder pigment (Lanxess, Cologne, Germany). In other embodiments, the
iron oxide is
in the form of high-purity Fe304 (15-20 nm) nanopowder (U.S. Research
Nanomaterials, Inc.,
Houston, Texas, United States).
[0317] In one embodiment, a reaction mixture of powdered sugar and an alcohol,
preferably
ethanol, is heated in a reaction vessel using a hot plate to a temperature
lower than in
previously-described embodiments using a direct flame. The reaction mixture is
heated to a
point causing vapor formation containing vapor-exfoliated graphene/graphene
derivative
scales. In one embodiment, the reaction mixture further includes iron oxide in
the form of
BayFerrox iron oxide powder pigment (Lanxess, Cologne, Germany). In one
embodiment,
the iron oxide is in the form of high-purity Fe304 (15-20 nm) nanopowder (U.S.
Research
Nanomaterials, Inc., Houston, Texas, United States).
[0318] In one embodiment, the iron oxide source is a substrate onto which the
other reactants
are placed. In one embodiment, the iron oxide source is a rusted iron-based
metal part. The
reactants are then heated as in one of the previously-described embodiments.
[0319] In one embodiment, the carbonaceous material is coal or a coal
derivative. In one
embodiment, the coal is a pulverized coal. In one embodiment, the coal is a
nano-coal. In one
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 49
PCT/US2012/029276
embodiment, the carbonaceous material is one or more of coal, coke, and coal
tar. In one
embodiment, the coal or coal derivative is heated in a high boiling point
temperature solvent
to reflux temperatures. In one embodiment, the process is a poor or improper
form of a coal
tar distillation or coke oven with reaction gases being re-condensed and
dripping back into
the reaction mixture.
[0320] In one embodiment, the carbonaceous material is sucrose. In some
embodiments,
concentrated sulfuric acid converts the sucrose to graphitic carbon, which may
form with a
foam morphology from trapped reaction gases, by a dehydration reaction as
shown in
Equation 4:
98% sulfuric acid
C121422011 12 Cgraphitic 11 1120 (4)
[0321] In one embodiment, an excess of sulfuric acid is used, such that any
water vapor or
other gases formed during the dehydration reaction are released from the
reaction mixture
and the graphitic carbon product is not in the form of a foam. In one
embodiment, excess heat
is provided to the system to promote the release of all reaction gases.
[0322] In one embodiment, heat is used to convert the sucrose to carbon by a
dehydration
reaction as shown in Equation 5:
C121122011 heal > 12 C 11 1120 (5)
graphitic +
[0323] In one embodiment, a graphitic carbon source and a liquid are placed in
a reaction
vessel and mixed together to form a slurry mixture. The graphitic carbon
source may be any
material including graphitic carbon, including, but not limited to, natural
graphite, synthetic
graphite, one or more polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), graphene,
activated carbon,
biochar, coal phlegm, one or more benzenoids, naphthalene, or any combination
of these. In
one embodiment, the graphitic carbon source is natural or synthetic graphite.
In one
embodiment, the graphite is ground into a fine powder. In one embodiment, the
graphitic
carbon source is an activated carbon. In one embodiment, the liquid includes
one or any
combination of an alcohol, water, or mineral oil. In one embodiment, the
liquid is an acid or a
strongly acidic solution. In one embodiment, the alcohol is methanol. The
slurry mixture is
heated to produce a vapor containing vapor-exfoliated graphene/graphene
derivative scales.
In one embodiment, the reaction mixture further includes iron oxide in the
form of
BayFerrox iron oxide powder pigment (Lanxess, Cologne, Germany). In one
embodiment,
the iron oxide is in the form of high-purity Fe304 (15-20 nm) nanopowder (U.S.
Research
Nanomaterials, Inc., Houston, Texas, United States).
[0324] In one embodiment, a graphitic carbon product from the dehydration of
sucrose and a
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 50
PCT/US2012/029276
solvent are placed in a reaction vessel and mixed together to form a slurry
mixture. In one
embodiment, the solvent may include one or any combination of an alcohol,
water, and
mineral oil. In one embodiment, the alcohol is methanol, ethanol, or
isopropanol. The slurry
mixture is heated to produce a vapor containing vapor-exfoliated
graphene/graphene
derivative scales. In v, the reaction mixture further includes iron oxide in
the form of
BayFerrox iron oxide powder pigment (Lanxess, Cologne, Germany). In one
embodiment,
the iron oxide is in the form of high-purity Fe304 (15-20 nm) nanopowder (U.S.
Research
Nanomaterials, Inc., Houston, Texas, United States).
[0325] In one embodiment, the heat source is a direct open flame. In one
embodiment, the
heat source is a fuel mixed with the reactants ignited by an ignition source.
In one
embodiment, the heat source is a hot plate. In one embodiment, an additional
reagent is added
to promote formation of a reaction gas. In one embodiment, the additional
reagent is sodium
bicarbonate and the reaction gas is carbon dioxide. In one embodiment, the
reactants are
heated to autoignition.
[0326] In one embodiment, the chemical reaction may purposefully occur under
pyrolysis
conditions. In one embodiment, a reaction may purposefully occur under
conditions of
insufficient oxygen for combustion or minimal oxygen or within a partial
vacuum chamber.
In one embodiment, at least some of the reactants are heated during product
formation in a
controlled low-oxygen atmosphere. In one embodiment, a reaction may
purposefully employ
an additive to promote incomplete combustion and formation of soot or other
products of
incomplete combustion or pyrolysis. In one embodiment, the reaction may be
carried out
quickly by exposing the reaction mixture to the heat of a direct flame.
[0327] In one embodiment, solid reactants are mixed and heated with a direct
flame in a
reaction container such as a crucible. Although the fuel for the flame may be
any fuel within
the spirit of the present invention, the fuel in these embodiments is
preferably a relatively
clean-burning fuel such as methane, ethane, propane, or butane.
[0328] In one embodiment, the heat source is direct flame.
[0329] In one embodiment, the system is externally heated to a temperature
just below an
autoignition temperature for the system to initiate product formation.
[0330] In one embodiment, the graphene or GO is formed as a product of heating
an
intumescent. Intumescents are commonly used as fire retardants. An
intumescent, as used
herein, is any carbonaceous material that swells but does not burn when
exposed to heat. The
intumescent may include one or any combination of the following, but is not
limited to
dicresyl phosphates, tricresyl phosphates, including, but not limited to
paracresyl phosphates,
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 51
PCT/US2012/029276
orthocresyl phosphates, or metacresyl phosphates polymer resin precursors, or
certain epoxy
resins, including, but not limited to thermosetting resins, including, but not
limited to phenol-
formaldehyde (PF) resins, melamine resins, cyanate ester resins, or
polycyanurates,
polyphenylene ether (PPO) resins, ethylene propylene diene monomer (EPDM)
resins, or
polyolefin plastomer (POP) resins.
[0331] In one embodiment, heating the intumescent produces a poor heat-
conducting light
char. In one embodiment, heating the intumescent produces a heavy char. In one
embodiment, the resulting char is subjected to solvent attack and reheated to
produce the
graphene or GO product. In one embodiment, the resulting char may then serve
as the
carbonaceous material for addition to, and reaction with, an oxidizer. In one
embodiment, the
char may be combined with an oil and heated to produce the graphene or GO
reaction
product.
[0332] In one embodiment, as outlined supra, the carbonaceous material carbon
source added
to the reactants, or additive, may include one or any combination of the
following, but is not
limited to linseed oil, a light paraffinic oil, a naphthalenic compound, a
resin, a resin
precursor, an alkyd, an alkyd resin, or an alkyd precursor, including, but not
limited to, a
polyol, including, but not limited to maltitol, xylitol, sorbitol, isomalt,
pentaerythritol,
ethylene glycol, glycerin or polyester.
[0333] In one embodiment, the reactants include one or more polyols, one or
more acid
anhydrides, or one or more unsaturated fatty acid triglycerides.
[0334] It is envisioned that modifications to the above-described methods may
provide for
easier collection of the graphene or GO and may produce a higher yield.
[0335] In one embodiment, no liquid or gel mixing medium is used. In one
embodiment, the
mixing medium is methanol. In one embodiment, the mixing medium is water. In
one
embodiment, the mixing medium is a solid, semi-solid, or gelatinous flammable
material,
which may be mixed with the carbon source. In one embodiment, the flammable
material is a
gel fuel made from denatured alcohol, water, and gel, such as Sterno brand
canned heat (The
Sterno Group LLC, Des Plaines, Ilinois, United States). In one embodiment, the
denatured
alcohol includes ethanol with one or more additives, which may include one or
any
combination of the following, but is not limited to methanol, isopropanol,
acetone, methyl
ethyl ketone, methyl isobutyl ketone, or denatonium.
[0336] In one embodiment, the gel fuel is made from vinegar, calcium
carbonate, and
isopropanol. In such embodiments, the gel fuel may be gently heated to become
more fluid
for mixing with the reactants and then cooled to re-gel. In such an
embodiment, a direct flame
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 52
PCT/US2012/029276
may be used only initially to ignite the gel fuel and initiate the reaction,
with the flame being
sustained by the burning of the gel fuel itself.
[0337] In one embodiment, the vapor-borne graphene or graphene derivative
scales are
collected by deposition onto a solid surface contacting the vapor-borne
scales.
[0338] In one embodiment, the vapor-borne graphene or graphene derivative
scales are
collected using clean coal technology. In one embodiment, a scrubber (see, for
example,
Semrau, "Practical process design of particulate scrubbers", Chem. Eng., Vol.
84, pp. 87-91,
1977), preferably a wet scrubber, is used to collect any vapor-borne graphene
or GO scales.
In one embodiment, flue gases are treated with steam to collect vapor-borne
particles
including any vapor-borne graphene or GO scales.
[0339] In one embodiment, the vapor-borne graphene or graphene derivative
scales are
collected by bubbling the produced vapor stream through a liquid. In one
embodiment, the
liquid is water. In other embodiments, the liquid is an oil, which may
include, but is not
limited to a vegetable oil or a lubricating oil. In one embodiment, a
surfactant is added to the
water to promote formation of a uniform layer of graphene or graphene
derivative at the
surface of the water. In one embodiment, the liquid is heated to promote the
formation, via
self-assembly, of a uniform layer of graphene or graphene derivative at the
surface of the
liquid. In one embodiment, the liquid is heated to near its boiling
temperature. In one
embodiment, additives are used to raise the boiling temperature of the liquid.
In one
embodiment, ultrasound is applied to the liquid to promote graphene or
graphene derivative
self-assembly on the liquid surface. In one embodiment, ultraviolet light is
applied to the
liquid to promote graphene or graphene derivative self-assembly on the liquid
surface. In one
embodiment, an argon atmosphere above the liquid promotes graphene or graphene
derivative self-assembly on the liquid surface. In one embodiment, a reduced
pressure is used
to promote self-assembly of the graphene or graphene derivative (see Putz et
al., "Evolution
of Order During Vacuum-Assisted Self-Assembly of Graphene Oxide Paper and
Associated
Polymer Nanocomposites", ASC Nano,Vol. 5, pp. 6601-6609, 2001).
[0340] In one embodiment, the solvent remaining in the reaction flask
containing graphitic
material after completion of the pyrolysis step is used as a coating to form a
composite
reinforced by the graphitic material. In one embodiment, the graphitic-
containing solvent is
applied by dipping the material to be coated into the graphitic-containing
solvent. In one
embodiment, individual fibers are coated. In other embodiments, a fiber mesh
is coated. In
one embodiment, multiple layers are deposited to cover up any cracks in the
graphitic
material, thereby strengthening the coating.
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 53
PCT/US2012/029276
[0341] In one embodiment, the graphitic-containing solvent is mixed with a
structural
material to form a graphene-reinforced composite. In one embodiment, the
graphitic
containing solvent is combined with pre-impregnated composite fibers (pre-
preg) to form a
graphene-reinforced composite material. In one embodiment, the carbon source
for the
graphitic material is a resin precursor for the particular resin to be
reinforced by the graphitic
material.
[0342] In one embodiment, the aqueous collecting liquid used to accumulate the
combustion
product vapor is used in a mould to facilitate the fabrication of solid
composite materials that
make use of the combustion products.
[0343] In one embodiment, the reaction vapors are collected and channeled
directly onto the
interior or exterior surface of a mould, without the use of a liquid
collection medium.
[0344] In one embodiment, the reaction vapors are collected and channeled
directly onto the
surface of a solid substrate. In one embodiment, the solid substrate is a
fiber and a graphene-
reinforced fiber composite is formed upon deposition. In one embodiment, the
fiber is carbon
fiber. In one embodiment, the fiber is polymeric. The graphene coating may be
applied to the
fiber either before or after weaving individual fibers together depending on
the application
and the desired properties for the graphene-fiber composite. In one
embodiment, multiple
layers are deposited to cover up cracks in the graphene sheets, thereby
strengthening the
coating.
[0345] In one embodiment, the resulting collected vapor is suspended on a
liquid that is later
drained, evaporated, or otherwise removed, allowing the graphene, GO, or rGO
sheets to coat
the inside of a mould or to be deposited on a solid or liquid substrate
already in such mould
or introduced into the mould, for the purpose of producing a composite
material.
[0346] In the system of Fig. 3, a reaction mixture is placed in a reaction
vessel 10. Heat is
applied to the reaction vessel 10 by a heating element 12. Generated reaction
gases and gas
borne product build pressure in the reaction vessel 10 and exit the reaction
vessel by a
conduit 14. The reaction gas stream exits the conduit 14 above the surface of
liquid 16. In
another embodiment (not shown), conduit 14 directs the vapor below the surface
of liquid 16
whereupon it bubbles to the surface 18 of the liquid 16. In one embodiment
(not shown), a
sparger is attached to the end of conduit 14 provides multiple release points
to distribute the
reaction gas stream bubbles either under or above the surface the liquid. The
reaction gases
are released into the atmosphere 22 above the liquid surface 18, while the
graphene/graphene
derivative product remains in the liquid, primarily accumulating at the liquid
surface 18.
Alternatively, the conduit 14 may release the reaction gas stream directly
into the atmosphere
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 54
PCT/US2012/029276
22 above the liquid surface 18. In some such embodiments, the reaction gas
stream is directed
toward the liquid surface 18 by the conduit 14.
[0347] A temperature control element 24 may be used to control the temperature
of the liquid
by providing heat or cooling to promote formation of large graphene oxide
sheets by
hydrophobic self-assembly at the liquid surface. Either the temperature
control element 24 or
a separate ultrasound element may provide ultrasonic vibration to promote
formation of large
graphene oxide sheets at the liquid surface. A cover (not shown) can be
employed to cover
liquid 16 to therefore create a closed controllable environment 22 above the
liquid 16. In one
embodiment (not shown), an increased pressure is maintained in the environment
22 by a
pressure source through a valve. In one embodiment, the pressure source is an
inert gas, such
as argon, to provide an inert environment above the liquid. In one embodiment
(not shown), a
release valve enables the release of excess pressure from the atmosphere 22.
The reaction
vessel 10 preferably includes a pressure equalizing valve 34 to relieve excess
vacuum formed
in the reaction vessel 10, which prevents liquid from being drawn in to the
conduit 14 toward
the reaction vessel 10 during refluxing and reaction.
[0348] In one embodiment, the reaction vessel is a Bfichner flask apparatus.
In one
embodiment, the top of the flask is stoppered and tubing is connected to the
flask's hose barb.
In one embodiment, the other end of the tubing is placed under a liquid
without any kind of
sparger at the end of the tubing. In one embodiment, the pressure equalizing
valve is
connected to a line extending through the stopper on the top of the Biichner
flask.
[0349] In one embodiment, the graphene or graphene derivative formed at the
surface of the
liquid is transferred to a solid substrate by simply contacting such solid
substrate with the
surface of the liquid, such as by a Langmuir-Blodgett-type deposition (see,
for example,
Blodgett, "Films built by depositing successive monomolecular layers on a
solid surface", J.
Amer. Chem. Soc., Vol. 57, pp. 1007-1022, 1935).
[0350] In one embodiment, the collected GO or graphene product is further
reduced or
otherwise treated to remove remaining impurities from the product.
[0351] In one embodiment, the GO reaction product is converted to reduced
graphene oxide
(rGO). In one embodiment, the GO is chemically reduced to rGO, as generically
represented
in Equation 4:
graphene oxide + reducing agent > reduced graphene oxide (rGO) (6)
[0352] In one embodiment, the GO is colloidally dispersed in water or another
liquid and
chemically reduced to rGO using hydrazine monohydrate (see Stankovich et al.,
"Synthesis
of graphene-based nanosheets via chemical reduction of exfoliated graphite
oxide", Carbon,
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 55
PCT/US2012/029276
Vol. 45, pp. 1558-1565, 2007, Gao et al., "Hydrazine and Thermal Reduction of
Graphene
Oxide: Reaction Mechanisms", J. Phys. Chem. C, Vol. 114, pp. 832-842, 2010),
Si et al.,
"Synthesis of Water Soluble Graphene", Nano Lett., Vol. 9, pp. 1679-1682,
2008). In another
embodiment, the GO is chemically reduced to rGO using hydroquinone (see Wang
et al.,
"Facile Synthesis and Characterization of Graphene Nanosheets", I Phys. Chem.
C, Vol.
112, pp. 8192-8195, 2008). In another embodiment, the GO is chemically reduced
to rGO
using gaseous hydrogen (see Wu et al., "Synthesis of high-quality graphene
with a pre-
determined number of layers", Carbon, Vol. 47, pp. 493-499, 2009). In other
embodiments,
the GO is chemically reduced to rGO using a strongly basic solution (see Fan
et al.,
"Deoxygenation of Exfoliated Graphite Oxide under Alkaline Conditions: A Green
Route to
Graphene Preparation", Adv. Mater., Vol. 20, pp. 4490-4493, 2008, Boehm et
al., "Das
Adsorptionsverhalten sehr &inner Kohlenstoff-Folien", Z. Anorg. Allg. Chem.,
Vol. 316, pp.
119-127, 1962).
[0353] In one embodiment, heat or an electrical current is used to reduce the
GO to rGO. In
one embodiment, the GO is thermally exfoliated and reduced to rGO upon heating
to 1050 C
and extrusion to remove generated carbon dioxide (see McAllister et al.,
"Single Sheet
Functionalized Graphene by Oxidation and Thermal Expansion of Graphite", Chem.
Mater.,
Vol. 19, pp. 4396-4404, 2007). In one embodiment, the GO is electrochemically
reduced to
rGO by placing electrodes at opposite ends of a graphene oxide film on a non-
conductive
substrate and applying an electrical current (see Zhou et at., "Controlled
Synthesis of Large-
Area and Patterned Electrochemically Reduced Graphene Oxide Films", Chem.-Eur.
J., Vol.
15, pp. 6116-6120, 2009).
[0354] In one embodiment, the addition of hydrazine monohydrate to the water,
through
which the produced graphene oxide is bubbled, followed by heating the aqueous
solution to
¨80 C converts the graphene oxide product to a self-assembled film of reduced
graphene
oxide platelets at the air-water interface (see Zhu et al., "Transparent self-
assembled films of
reduced graphene oxide platelets", Appl. Phys. Lett., Vol. 95, pp. 103,104-1-
103,104-3,
2009). Additional external forces may be applied to the liquid to encourage
self-assembly of
the rGO platelets, including, but not limited to, ultrasonic vibrations or
ultraviolet light.
[0355] In one embodiment, the above-described products are used in combination
with
polymer resins to form high-strength composites. The polymer resins are
preferably epoxy
polymer resins. In some embodiments, the composites further include carbon
fibers.
[0356] In one embodiment, the polymer resin and the graphene/graphene
derivative are
formed as alternating layers in the composite. In one embodiment, a
graphene/graphene
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 56 PCT/US2012/029276
derivative layer is deposited as a vapor onto a polymer resin layer. In one
embodiment, a
graphene/graphene derivative layer is deposited from an aqueous surface onto a
polymer
resin layer. In one embodiment, a graphene/graphene derivative paste is
applied to a polymer
resin layer.
[0357] In one embodiment, the graphene/graphene derivative is formed directly
on the
polymer resin layer by dehydration of sucrose using concentrated sulfuric
acid, where the
polymer resin material is highly resistant to sulfuric acid. Highly sulfuric
acid-resistant
polymeric materials include, but are not limited to, polyvinyl chloride (PVC),
chlorinated
PVC (CPVC), polyvinylediene fluoride,
polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE),
poly(chlorotrifluoroethylene) (CTFE), epoxy resin fiberglass, and EP21AR epoxy
(Master
Bond, Inc., Hackensack, New Jersey, United States).
[0358] In one embodiment, the resin is one of the following or a hybrid-type
combination of
the following polymer resins (1) one or more thermoplastic alkyl phenol
resins, typically used
in the manufacture of tires, (2) one or more NOVOLAC -type paraoctylphenol
(POP)
formaldehyde resins, (3) one or more POLYTONE8-type para-tertiary butylphenol
(PTBP)
formaldehyde non-heat-reactive tackifying resins, (4) one or more
polyphenylene ether (PPE)
resins, and (5) one or more polyphenylene oxide (PPO) resins, including, but
not limited to,
one or more siloxane polyphenylene oxide resins.
[0359] In one embodiment, the graphene/graphene derivative is mixed with the
polymer resin
before the resin sets. In one embodiment, carbon fibers are also mixed with
the
graphene/graphene derivative and un-set polymer resin. The type of polymer
resin and the
relative levels of graphene/graphene derivative and carbon fiber are
preferably selected to
provide an appropriate balance of strength and flexibility preferred for a
particular specific
use or application for the resulting composite product.
[0360] In one embodiment, the resin for the polymer of the composite is also
the carbon
source for the graphene/graphene derivative part of the composite.
[0361] In one embodiment, the graphene/GO-reinforced polymer composite is used
in
structural applications conventionally restricted to metallic materials, such
as the frame of a
vehicle. In one embodiment, the polymer composite is re-moldable, and hence
recyclable
from use in one structure to use in another structure.
[0362] In a method of forming gelled graphene or graphene jelly, an aqueous
pool containing
graphene/graphene derivative scales was allowed to evaporate over time. In one
embodiment,
the starting materials for producing the reaction mixture to produce the
graphene/graphene
derivative scales comprise sucrose, baking powder, ethanol, and iron oxide. In
one
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 57
PCT/US2012/029276
embodiment, the water in the aqueous pool evaporated very slowly and after a
period of
about one month at about room temperature, half of an original volume of ¨800
mL of fluid
remained in the beaker. A gooey gel layer, which could be peeled off, formed
at the top of the
fluid. Under this top layer, there was a cloudy whitish layer about 11/2"-
thick, having the
consistency of a thin jelly. Although the composition and physical
characteristics of these
graphene jellies were not further tested, it is expected that these forms of
graphene have
useful physical and chemical properties.
[0363] In one embodiment, the aqueous gelled graphene or the aqueous pool with
the
collected graphene or graphene derivative is used in place of water in the
formation of a
composite material. In one embodiment, the aqueous gelled graphene or the
aqueous pool
with the collected graphene or graphene derivative is used in place of water
in a cement
mixture to form a graphene-reinforced concrete with improved strength relative
to convention
concrete. In one embodiment, the aqueous gelled graphene or the aqueous pool
with the
collected graphene or graphene derivative is used in the formation of asphalt
concrete to form
graphene-reinforced asphalt concrete with improved strength relative to
convention asphalt
concrete.
[0364] In one embodiment, carbon dioxide or carbon monoxide is used as a
carbon source in
the production of graphene, a graphene derivative, a carbon-encapsulated
metallic
nanoparticle, or nano-steel, thereby potentially removing excess carbon from
the
environment. Carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide are convertible into a number
of different
products suitable as carbonaceous feedstock for the synthesis methods
contained herein, such
as synthetic methanol (see, for example, Sakakura et al., "Transformation of
Carbon
Dioxide", Chem. Rev., Vol. 107, pp. 2365-2387, 2007, Yu et al., "Copper- and
copper-N-
heterocyclic carbene-catalyzed C-H activating carboxylation of terminal
alkynes with CO2 at
ambient conditions", PNAS, Vol. 107, pp. 20184-20189, 2010, Jiang et al.,
"Turning carbon
dioxide into fuel", Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A, Vol. 368, pp. 3343-3364, 2010). In
one
embodiment, the carbon monoxide or carbon dioxide is first converted into one
or more
intermediate forms of carbonaceous material, capable of combustion or
pyrolysis reactions to
incorporate the carbon atom from such gasses into a useful carbon-carbon
graphitic bond. In
one embodiment, the intermediate in such conversion is an alcohol formed by
reaction of
carbon dioxide with hydrogen gas. In one embodiment, the carbon dioxide is
supplied
directly to the reflux mixture for reaction with hydrogen gas generated by
refluxing of the
reflux mixture, thereby forming the synthetic methanol in situ.
[0365] In one embodiment incorporating iron oxide, the process operates like a
nano-scale
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 58
PCT/US2012/029276
Bessemer furnace to form nano-steel. Referring specifically to Fig. 7,
significant charging is
observed all over the sample, especially at the edges of the spheroid. Since
the sample is
charging in general, the probable feature causing this charging is the
presence of a non-
conductive matter all over the sample. The only possible non-conductive
material based on
the elemental analysis would be an oxide. Thus it is concluded that there is a
layer of oxide
all over the stub. Regarding the charging of the spheroids, as a sharp edge is
not observed in
the images, the spheroids must contain both conductive and non-conductive
matter. The most
probable cause for this phenomenon would be elemental iron trapped in a non-
conductive
carbon-oxide matrix.
[0366] Elemental iron conducts and glows under the SEM but the non-conductive
carbon-
oxide matrix is strong enough to prevent the spheroid structure from breaking
up in spite of
being non-conductive and not being able to pass on the charge to the oxide
layer all over the
sample. The inference is that the oxide outer layer is graphene oxide and the
conductive
material is iron, given that the EDS reports the presence of only iron,
carbon, and oxygen. If
the outer shell of the balls were pure carbon, such as if the structure were
graphene or a
fullerene, it would have been conductive and no charging of samples would be
seen, as is the
case for carbon nanotubes or carbon tape materials commonly used as SEM
accessories.
Since the outer layer is charging, it must be non-conductive, and so the most
likely form of
carbon is graphene oxide. Also, as mentioned before, the entire stub charges
to some extent,
as shown in the SEM images. Therefore, it is also concluded that layers of
graphene oxide are
present all throughout the sample.
[0367] In one embodiment, the nano-steel is machined to form a nano-circuit or
other
nanostructure. In some embodiments, a laser etching nano-beam is used to shape
the nano-
steel.
[0368] Test Results
[0369] Several tests were run to create and recover graphene and its
derivatives, and to
produce SGANs, according to the invention.
[0370] Test 1
[0371] In a method of synthesis of SGANs, a reaction mixture was heated using
a direct
flame. BayFerrox iron oxide powder pigment (Lanxess, Cologne, Germany),
powdered
sugar, and ethanol were placed in a reaction vessel and mixed into a paste to
form a reaction
mixture. The reaction mixture was heated with the direct flame of a propane
torch, and an
SEM stub was held above the heated reaction mixture in the smoke and/or vapor
produced by
heating the reaction mixture.
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 59
PCT/US2012/029276
[0372] The surface of the SEM stub was then viewed using a Philips XL series
XL 30
ESEM-FEG (FEITM Company, Hillsboro, Oregon, United States), using EDAX
GenesisTM
version 4.61 software (AMATEK Inc., Mahwah, New Jersey, United States) and a
Scandium Imaging Platform. The resulting electron microscope images of
surfaces of the
stub are shown in Figs. 4 through 7. The accompanying elemental analysis by
EDS for the
sampled area (with the copper and aluminum readings from the stub itself being
removed)
showed only carbon, oxygen, and iron in the weight (wt%) and atomic (At%)
percentages
shown in Table 1 for the areas in the boxes sampled in Figs. 4 through 7.
Figs. 4 through 6
show spheroid structures with diameters in the range of -2-5 microns, and all
of the figures
show non-spheroid, irregularly-shaped structures with lengths in the range of
1-5 microns.
Table 1
Synthesis Structure Elemental Analysis Data
Sampled C 0 Fe C 0 Fe
Area (wt%) (wt%) (wt%) (At%) (At%) (At%)-_
Fig. 4 69.96 28.94 1.09 76.11 23.64 0.26
Fig. 5A 78.79 19.65 1.56 83.93 15.71 0.36
Fig. 5B 74.72 24.11 1.17 80.28 19.45 0.27
Fig. 5C 79.04 19.51 1.45 84.09 15.58 0.33
Fig. 6 34.19 55.07 10.74 43.92 53.11 2.97
[0373] The sampled areas of the spheroids of Figs. 4 through 5C all show
primarily carbon
and oxygen with similar low values of iron. Referring specifically to Fig. 4,
the EDAX
beam is aimed at a large area of a spheroid structure having a diameter of
almost 5 p.m.
Referring specifically to Fig. 5A, the EDAX point beam is aimed at a divot on
the surface of
a spheroid having a diameter between 2 and 3 p.m. Referring specifically to
Fig. 5B, the
EDAX beam is aimed at a small white area on the surface of the spheroid of
Fig. 5A, with
this image clearly showing the spheroid nature of the structure and the
presence of surface
imperfections. Referring specifically to Fig. 5C, the EDAX beam is aimed on a
wider
portion of the spheroid of Fig. 5A. This structure is believed to contain
significantly higher
internal iron levels than those measured by EDS, with the low reading of iron
by EDS
indicating low EDAX beam penetration of the outer shell into the spheroid
cortex. The
spheroid structures are believed to be multi-layer graphene oxide nano-onions,
with the
multiple graphene oxide layers shielding the internal iron from detection by
EDS.
[0374] Fig. 6 shows the irregular structure of one of the non-spheroid
features observed on
the surface of the stub. The morphology of these structures is believed to be
graphene oxide
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 60
PCT/US2012/029276
paper. The brighter areas of this image indicate higher concentrations of
iron. The amount of
iron in this structure, as measured by EDS, is almost ten times greater than
what is measured
in the spheroid structures. It is believed that the electron beam is able to
penetrate this thin
graphene oxide paper more than it is able to penetrate into the multi-layer
spheroids, so that
more iron is reported in this sample.
[0375] The observed spheroid structures were determined to be highly stable,
as focusing of
the EDAX beam on the structure for more than 20 minutes had no observable
effect on the
structure.
[0376] In some SEM images, a square area of shade on the stem was observed,
indicating
electron excitation and a non-conductive surface, presumably coated with a
graphene oxide
film.
[0377] Test 2
[0378] In another method of synthesis of SGANs, a reaction mixture was heated
using a
direct flame. BayFerrox iron oxide powder pigment (Lanxess, Cologne,
Germany),
powdered sugar, and gelled alcohol, in the form of a common hand sanitizer
formulation
including water, polyacrylic acid, and ¨60% isopropyl alcohol, were placed in
a reaction
vessel and mixed together to form a reaction mixture. The reaction mixture was
heated with
the direct flame of a propane torch and an SEM stub was held above the heated
reaction
mixture in the smoke and/or vapor produced by heating the reaction mixture.
[0379] The surface of the SEM stub was studied using a Philips XL series XL
30 ESEM-
FEG (FEITM Company, Hillsboro, Oregon, United States), using EDAX GenesisTM
version
4.61 software (AMATEK Inc., Mahwah, New Jersey, United States) and a Scandium
Imaging Platform. The resulting electron microscope images of surfaces of the
stub are
shown in Figs. 8 through 11. The accompanying elemental analysis by EDS (with
the copper
and aluminum readings from the stub itself being removed) showed only carbon
(64.40
wt%/79.37 At%), oxygen (16.95 wt%/15.68 At%), and iron (18.65 wt%/4.94 At%)
for the
sampled area of Fig. 8. The observed structures on the SEM stub were generally
smaller than
those observed from the previous synthesis using ethanol rather than gelled
alcohol. The
number of spheroid structures in relation to flake structures was observed to
be much higher
than in the synthesis using ethanol. Fig. 10 shows an area of high
concentration of spheroid
structures.
[0380] Fig. 11 shows a larger area of the SEM stub at a lower magnification.
The image
shows that a very thin film has been deposited continuously over a large area
of the SEM
stub. For imaging purposes, a gold/palladium coating was vapor-deposited onto
the sample.
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 61
PCT/US2012/029276
The gold/palladium coating, however, was observed to be much thicker than the
graphene
oxide vapor coating, leading to the complete masking of any graphene oxide
vapor coating
detail by the gold/palladium coating. It is also significant to note that the
gold/palladium
coating shows that the graphene oxide vapor coating was unbroken on the whole
stub.
[0381] Test 3
[0382] In another method of synthesis of SGANs, a reaction mixture was heated
using a
direct flame. BayFerrox iron oxide powder pigment (Lanxess, Cologne,
Germany), activated
charcoal, methanol, and mineral oil were placed in a reaction vessel and mixed
together to
form a reaction mixture. The reaction mixture was heated with the direct flame
of a propane
torch and an SEM stub was held above the heated reaction mixture in the smoke
and/or vapor
formed from heating the reaction mixture.
[0383] The surface of the SEM stub was studied using a Philips XL series XL
30 ESEM-
FEG (FEITM Company, Hillsboro, Oregon, United States), using EDAX GenesisTM
version
4.61 software (AMATEK Inc., Mahwah, New Jersey, United States) and a Scandium
Imaging Platform. The resulting electron microscope images of surfaces of the
stub revealed
structures similar in appearance to those from the above-described
experiments, including
spheroids in the range of 5-15 lam in diameter and larger irregular
crystalline structures
having minimum width dimensions in the range of 10-50 gm. The accompanying
elemental
analysis by EDS (with the copper and aluminum readings from the stub itself
being removed)
showed, in addition to carbon, oxygen, and iron, a number of impurities
including calcium,
copper, sodium, silicon, and lead, all of which can form face-centered cubic
(FCC) crystals.
[0384] Test 4
[0385] In another method of synthesis of nanoparticles, a reaction mixture was
heated using a
hot plate to a lower temperature than in the previously described method using
a direct flame.
Iron oxide powder, powdered sugar, and ethanol were placed in a Buchner flask.
The top of
the flask was stoppered and plastic tubing was connected to the hose barb. The
other end of
the plastic tubing was placed under water in a beaker of distilled water. The
reaction mixture
was heated, causing vapor formation, which bubbled through the distilled
water. After
completion of the reaction, the water was allowed to evaporate slowly in the
beaker, with the
surface of the water having a gelatinous consistency and with a white residue
being deposited
on the walls of the beaker above the water surface as the water evaporated.
Although the
white residue was not characterized, it is believed to be made of SGANs.
[0386] Test 5
[0387] In another method of synthesis of nanoparticles, powdered sugar ("365
Organic
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 62
PCT/US2012/029276
Powdered Sugar" from Whole Foods Market, LP (Austin, Texas, United States).
Ingredients:
Organic Cane Sugar, Organic Tapioca Starch), hand sanitizer ("Instant Hand
Sanitizer" from
Greenbrier International, Inc. (Chesapeake, Virginia, United States).
Ingredients: Ethyl
Alcohol 62%, Water, Triethanolamine Glycerin, Proplyene Glycol, Tocopheryl
Acetate, Aloe
Barbadensis Gel, Carbomer, Fragrance), isopropanol ("99% Isopropyl Alcohol"
from Meijer
Distributing Inc. (Grand Rapids, Michigan, United States)), baking powder
("Dr. Oetker
Baking Powder" from Dr. Oetker Canada, Ltd. (Mississauga, Ontario, Canada).
Ingredients:
Sodium Acid Pyrophosphate, Sodium Bicarbonate, Corn Starch), and mineral oil
("Walgreens Mineral Oil Intestinal Lubricant" from Walgreen Co. (Deerfield,
Illinois, United
States)) were combined in a flask. The flask was heated with a direct flame to
convert the
sugar to graphitic carbon. The top of the flask was stoppered and tubing
directed the reaction
gas stream containing the vapor-exfoliated graphene scales to bubble into a
water bath.
Mineral oil was added to the flask as needed to maintain liquid in the flask.
[0388] A metal spatula was contacted to the surface of the water bath to
collect the reaction
product which had formed there after being transported by the vapor stream. A
visible film
was observed on the metal spatula after the spatula was allowed to dry
overnight. Although
the metal spatula was dipped into the liquid at an angle, reaction product may
alternatively be
transferred to a solid surface by dipping the solid surface parallel or
perpendicular to the
liquid surface depending on the solid surface and the desired surface coating.
Alternatively,
the solid surface may be drawn up through the interface from below the liquid
surface or by
draining the liquid to deposit the product onto the solid surface in the
liquid.
[0389] The coated metal surface was then wiped against a carbon TEM grid to
transfer some
of the graphene coating to the TEM grid. The coating on the TEM grid was
observed using a
Philips TEM (FEITM Company, Hillsboro, Oregon, United States), serial number
D609, and
the images in Figs. 12 through 17 were recorded. These structures are similar
in composition
and morphology to structures referred to as holey carbon or lacey carbon. Fig
12 shows a
fairly large, uniform graphene sheet morphology. Fig. 13 shows a large
graphene sheet
morphology with a tendril extending to the left of the image. Fig. 14 shows
folded multilayer
graphene sheets. Figs. 16 and 17 show thin strands of graphene connecting
larger sheet areas,
with Fig. 15 showing a higher magnification of the multiple layers of such a
strand. In
addition to the images in Figs. 12 through 17, portions of the TEM grid
appeared completely
black under the TEM, because the deposited layer was too thick for the
electron beam to pass
through. In several other areas, the film appeared not to be completely dry
and the graphene
coating was observed to change shape under the electron beam.
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 63
PCT/US2012/029276
[0390] Test 6
[0391] In a method of forming graphene sheets, activated charcoal, water,
mineral oil, and
isopropanol were heated in a capped &lamer flask. As soon as the mixture began
to boil and
reflux, a white smoke began to be generated with the vapor. The whitish smoke
was carried
with the vapor out of the flask through plastic tubing and applied to the
surface of an aqueous
pool, where an opaque film formed on the surface. After waiting several
minutes after the
film had formed, portions of the film were transferred to copper TEM grids for
further study.
[0392] The copper TEM grids were studied using a Philips Tecnai F20 (S)TEM
(FEITM
Company, Hillsboro, Oregon, United States). Representative images of the
samples are
shown in Figs. 18 and 19. For elemental analysis, the EDAX beam was used to
determine
the carbon-to-oxygen ratios at eight different points in the sample. The
resulting analysis
showed that the carbon-to-oxygen ratio in the samples was between 97.4:2.6
atomic % to
99.1:0.9 atomic % with an average of 98.4:1.6 atomic % from the eight samples.
In
comparison to the experiments with iron oxide in the reaction mixture, in the
absence of iron
oxide the resulting product was almost pure carbon in the form of graphene.
[0393] In situ production of tribologically-effective amounts of beneficial
carbonaceous
deposits in lubricating compositions.
[0394] Embodiments of the invention employ cyclic-carbon containing additives
for base
lubricants intended to pyrolyze quickly in situ and produce tribologically-
effective amounts
of beneficial carbonaceous deposits and molecules within an engine or
mechanical system. In
one embodiment, the additive forms beneficial abrasive graphitic particles in
situ in the
lubrication composition that serve as nanopolishing agents to nano-polish
friction surfaces
and remove asperities before the base lubricant begins to degrade
significantly. Once the
friction surfaces are nano-polished to near atomic-level perfection, there are
no longer
asperities on the friction surfaces to harbor harmful deposits. Thus, harmful
deposit formation
on internal system parts and the need for conventional detergent additives in
lubricating
compositions are drastically reduced or even eliminated.
[0395] The additives disclosed herein are not selected to improve or protect
the underlying
base lubricant. Instead, the additives are selected to promote rapid in situ
preferential
formation of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons or other graphitic carbon forms
that are
tribologically-useful graphitic carbon-containing nanoparticles or
microparticles in
tribologically-effective amounts. In one embodiment, the additive includes a
carbon ring-
containing additive consisting of only carbon, hydrogen, and oxygen atoms. In
one
embodiment, the carbon ring-containing additive is a hydrocarbon. Any radicals
in the
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 64
PCT/US2012/029276
lubricating composition preferably aid in the formation of the useful
graphitic carbon
particles. In one embodiment, the nanoparticles act as nano-polishing agents
to nano-polish
friction surfaces to a high smoothness by reduction or removal of asperities,
thereby reducing
the friction between the wear surfaces. Over time, conventional base
lubricants tend to lose
viscosity, putting friction surfaces at risk for damage. With use of
embodiments of the current
invention, friction surfaces become increasingly nano-polished, so any
thinning of the base
lubricant through continued use actually allows the mechanical system to run
more efficiently
through reduction in the viscosity of the base lubricant. In one embodiment,
the base
lubricant starts as a heavier weight oil and progressively thins to a lighter
weight oil over time
as the friction surfaces become nano-polished. In one embodiment, the
lubricating
composition effectively lubricates despite extended drain or replacement
intervals as
compared to conventional base lubricants.
[0396] Instead of promoting degradation over time to form compounds that turn
into
amorphous carbon sludge, at least one of the additives preferentially promotes
formation of
one or more tribologically-useful graphitic carbon forms described herein.
[0397] Lubricating compositions of the present invention preferably include an
additive
selected to serve as a sacrificial carbon source for in situ formation of
graphitic carbon, while
the base lubricant continues to lubricate an operating engine or other
mechanical system. The
base lubricant may be a petroleum-refined or a synthetic oil, grease or
liquid. The additive
can be pyrolyzed to form graphitic carbon under the conditions of the
operating engine or
other mechanical system. In one embodiment, the additive can be pyrolyzed at a
temperature
of between ¨ 50 C and ¨ 550 C. In one embodiment, the additive can be
pyrolyzed at a
temperature less than ¨ 50 C or a temperature greater than ¨ 550 C. In an
operating engine,
such conditions may be reached locally at friction surfaces or on internal
engine, turbo,
turbine or gear surfaces.
[0398] The additive is provided in a tribologically-effective amount such that
in situ
structures are formed and present in the lubricating composition to initially
provide a
sufficiently efficacious tribological coating on the friction surfaces of a
lubricated system.
The amount of additive to be added to the lubricant can be varied according to
the desired
rate of change of performance of the operating engine or other mechanical
system, and the
quantity of base lubricant to remain undiluted. Addition of a higher amount of
additive
increases the rate of formation of the in situ structures but will also dilute
the base lubricant.
An effective amount of additive may therefore comprise from ¨ 10 mg per liter
of base
lubricant to ¨ 500 g per liter of base lubricant. These amounts are not
intended to limit the
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 65
PCT/US2012/029276
invention in any manner and can be determined on a case by case basis by the
formulator.
[0399] In one embodiment, the tribologically-effective amount of additive
decreases friction
in the lubricated system relative to lubrication by the conventional lubricant
to which it is
added. In one embodiment, the tribologically-effective amount of additive
decreases friction
in the lubricated system by at least 1% relative to lubrication by the
conventional lubricant to
which it is added. In one embodiment, the tribologically-effective amount of
additive
decreases friction in the lubricated system by at least 2% relative to
lubrication by the
conventional lubricant to which it is added. In one embodiment, the
tribologically-effective
amount of additive decreases friction in the lubricated system by at least 3%
relative to
lubrication by the conventional lubricant to which it is added. In one
embodiment, the
tribologically-effective amount of additive decreases friction in the
lubricated system by at
least 4% relative to lubrication by the conventional lubricant to which it is
added. In one
embodiment, the tribologically-effective amount of additive decreases friction
in the
lubricated system by at least 5% relative to lubrication by the conventional
lubricant to which
it is added. In one embodiment, the tribologically-effective amount of
additive decreases
friction in the lubricated system by at least 10% relative to lubrication by
the conventional
lubricant to which it is added.
[0400] In one embodiment, a tribologically-effective amount of additive
decreases negative
horsepower in the lubricated system relative to lubrication by the
conventional lubricant to
which it is added. In one embodiment, the tribologically-effective amount of
additive
increases measured horsepower in the lubricated system by at least 1% relative
to lubrication
by the conventional lubricant to which it is added. In one embodiment, the
tribologically-
effective amount of additive increases measured horsepower in the lubricated
system by at
least 2% relative to lubrication by the conventional lubricant to which it is
added. In one
embodiment, the tribologically-effective amount of additive increases measured
horsepower
in the lubricated system by at least 5% relative to lubrication by the
conventional lubricant to
which it is added. In one embodiment, the tribologically-effective amount of
additive
increases measured horsepower in the lubricated system by at least 10%
relative to
lubrication by the conventional lubricant to which it is added. In one
embodiment, the
tribologically-effective amount of additive increases measured horsepower in
the lubricated
system by at least 20% relative to lubrication by the conventional lubricant
to which it is
added. In one embodiment, the tribologically-effective amount of additive
increases
measured horsepower in the lubricated system by at least 50% relative to
lubrication by the
conventional lubricant to which it is added.
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 66
PCT/US2012/029276
[0401] In one embodiment, a tribologically-effective amount of additive
increases torque
output in the lubricated system relative to lubrication by the conventional
lubricant to which
it is added. In one embodiment, the tribologically-effective amount of
additive increases
torque output in the lubricated system by at least 1% relative to lubrication
by the
conventional lubricant to which it is added. In one embodiment, the
tribologically-effective
amount of additive increases torque output in the lubricated system by at
least 2% relative to
lubrication by the conventional lubricant to which it is added. In one
embodiment, the
tribologically-effective amount of additive increases torque output in the
lubricated system by
at least 5% relative to lubrication by the conventional lubricant to which it
is added. In one
embodiment, the tribologically-effective amount of additive increases torque
output in the
lubricated system by at least 10% relative to lubrication by the conventional
lubricant to
which it is added. In one embodiment, the tribologically-effective amount of
additive
increases torque output in the lubricated system by at least 20% relative to
lubrication by the
conventional lubricant to which it is added. In one embodiment, the
tribologically-effective
amount of additive increases torque output in the lubricated system by at
least 50% relative to
lubrication by the conventional lubricant to which it is added.
[0402] In one embodiment, a tribologically-effective amount of additive
decreases the
surface roughness of an internal friction surface in the lubricated system
relative to
lubrication by the conventional lubricant to which it is added. In one
embodiment, the
tribologically-effective amount of additive decreases the surface roughness of
an internal
friction surface in the lubricated system by at least 5% relative to
lubrication by the
conventional lubricant to which it is added. In one embodiment, the
tribologically-effective
amount of additive decreases the surface roughness of an internal friction
surface in the
lubricated system by at least 10% relative to lubrication by the conventional
lubricant to
which it is added. In one embodiment, the tribologically-effective amount of
additive
decreases the surface roughness of an internal friction surface in the
lubricated system by at
least 20% relative to lubrication by the conventional lubricant to which it is
added. In one
embodiment, the tribologically-effective amount of additive decreases the
surface roughness
of an internal friction surface in the lubricated system by at least 50%
relative to lubrication
by the conventional lubricant to which it is added. In one embodiment, the
tribologically-
effective amount of additive decreases the surface roughness of an internal
friction surface in
the lubricated system by at least 75% relative to lubrication by the
conventional lubricant to
which it is added. In one embodiment, the tribologically-effective amount of
additive
decreases the surface roughness of an internal friction surface in the
lubricated system by at
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 67
PCT/US2012/029276
least 90% relative to lubrication by the conventional lubricant to which it is
added.
[0403] In one embodiment, the measurable change in friction, reduction in
negative
horsepower, or reduction in surface roughness occurs within 100 operating
hours of the
lubricated system after adding the tribologically-effective amount of the
additive. In one
embodiment, the measurable change in friction, reduction in negative
horsepower, or
reduction in surface roughness occurs within 80 operating hours of the
lubricated system after
adding the tribologically-effective amount of the additive. In one embodiment,
the
measurable change in friction, reduction in negative horsepower, or reduction
in surface
roughness occurs within 60 operating hours of the lubricated system after
adding the
tribologically-effective amount of the additive. In one embodiment, the
measurable change in
friction, reduction in negative horsepower, or reduction in surface roughness
occurs within 40
operating hours of the lubricated system after adding the tribologically-
effective amount of
the additive. In one embodiment, the measurable change in friction, reduction
in negative
horsepower, or reduction in surface roughness occurs within 20 operating hours
of the
lubricated system after adding the tribologically-effective amount of the
additive. In one
embodiment, the measurable change in friction, reduction in negative
horsepower, or
reduction in surface roughness occurs within 10 operating hours of the
lubricated system after
adding the tribologically-effective amount of the additive. In one embodiment,
the
measurable change in friction, reduction in negative horsepower, or reduction
in surface
roughness occurs within 5 operating hours of the lubricated system after
adding the
tribologically-effective amount of the additive. In one embodiment, the
measurable change in
friction, reduction in negative horsepower, or reduction in surface roughness
occurs within 2
operating hours of the lubricated system after adding the tribologically-
effective amount of
the additive. In one embodiment, the measurable change in friction, reduction
in negative
horsepower, or reduction in surface roughness occurs within one operating hour
of the
lubricated system after adding the tribologically-effective amount of the
additive. In one
embodiment, the measurable change in friction, reduction in negative
horsepower, or
reduction in surface roughness occurs within 30 operating minutes of the
lubricated system
after adding the tribologically-effective amount of the additive. In one
embodiment, the
measurable change in friction, reduction in negative horsepower, or reduction
in surface
roughness occurs within 10 operating minutes of the lubricated system after
adding the
tribologically-effective amount of the additive. In one embodiment, the
measurable change in
friction, reduction in negative horsepower, or reduction in surface roughness
occurs within 5
operating minutes of the lubricated system after adding the tribologically-
effective amount of
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 68
PCT/US2012/029276
the additive. In one embodiment, the measurable change in friction, reduction
in negative
horsepower, or reduction in surface roughness occurs substantially
instantaneously after
adding the tribologically-effective amount of the additive.
[0404] Lubricating compositions including at least one additive, as described,
improve
engine performance and nano-polish lubricated metal surfaces. At least one of
the additives is
chemically modified in situ to form lubricating and nano-polishing particles,
which have been
observed on lubricated metal surfaces both by scanning electron microscopy
(SEM) and
transmission electron microscopy (TEM). Observed spheroid structures on non-
friction
surfaces are generally in the 1-10 micron size range and are determined to be
made primarily
of carbon, oxygen, and iron. These microparticle structures are separated down
to a basic
particle no larger than ¨3 nm in dimension and hard enough to nano-polish
steel surfaces to
the measured surface roughness (Ra) of 3.44 nm.
[0405] For one embodiment, this basic particle has been analytically
determined to be an
SGAN and, more specifically, a metallic SGAN. In some embodiments, the
metallic SGAN
is a ferric SGAN. The core of the SGAN can be a cubic close-packed crystal
structure with a
face-centered cubic metal. The cubic close-packed crystal can be of a metal
oxide of the
spinel family, which may include, but is not limited to, magnetite (Fe304),
spinel (MgA1204),
gahnite (ZnA1204), hercynite (FeA1204), cuprospinet (CuFe204), franklinite,
galaxite,
jacobsite (MnFe204), trevorite (NiFe204), ulvospinet (TiFe204), zinc ferrite,
chromite
(FeCr204), and magnesiochromite (MgCr204). In other embodiments, the core can
be a non-
spinel cubic crystal structure.
[0406] The cubic crystal structure can include at least one iron atom. In some
embodiments,
the crystal core can be ferric hydroxide in spinel form (Belleville et al.,
"Crystallization of
ferric hydroxide into spinel by adsorption on colloidal magnetite", Journal of
Colloid and
Interface Science, Vol. 150, pp. 453-460, 1992). In one embodiment, the
crystal core can be
FexCul.õRh2Se4, where 0 <x < 0.3, in spinel form (Kim et al., "Magnetic
properties of the
spinel phase for FexCu1_x162Se4", J Appl. Phys., Vol. 64, 342190, 1988).
[0407] In one embodiment, the crystal core forms in situ. In one embodiment,
the additive
includes a crystal core. In some embodiments, the crystal core can be formed
by one or more
mechanisms described by Dekker ("Chapter 5: Deoxidation in Low Carbon Steel
Killed with
Aluminum" in Ph.D. Thesis, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Leuven, pp. 43-65,
Belgium,
2002), Botta et al. ("Mechanochemical synthesis of hercynite", Materials
Chemistry and
Physics, Vol. 76, pp. 104-109), or Chen et al. ("Synthesis of hercynite by
reaction sintering",
Journal of the European Ceramic Society, Vol. 31, pp. 259-263, 2011).
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 69
PCT/US2012/029276
[0408] In one embodiment, the shell of the SGAN is believed to be a carbon
fullerene or
fullerene-like structure. In some embodiments, the carbon source is believed
to be converted
to PAHs in situ as disclosed by Bohme ("PAH and Fullerene Ions and
Ion/Molecule
Reactions in Interstellar and Circumstellar Chemistry", Chem. Rev., Vol. 92,
pp. 1487-1508,
1992), Mansurov ("Formation of Soot from Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons as
well as
Fullerenes and Carbon Nanotubes in the Combustion of Hydrocarbon", Journal of
Engineering Physics and Thermodynamics, Vol. 84, pp. 125-159, 2011), or
Ravindra et al.
("Atmospheric polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons: Source attribution, emission
factors and
regulation", Atmospheric Environment, Vol. 42, pp. 2895-2921, 2008) to form
graphene
sheets, wherein the graphene is then converted to a fullerene in the presence
of iron by a
mechanism such as the one disclosed by Chuvilin et al. ("Direct transformation
of graphene
to fullerene", Nature Chemistry, Vol. 2, pp. 450-453, 2010). In one
embodiment, the carbon
deposits on the surface of an iron particle are believed to be in the form of
coke such as
disclosed by Meima et al. ("Catalyst deactivation phenomena in styrene
production", Applied
Catalysis A: General, Vol. 212, pp. 239-245, 2001). In one embodiment, the
SGAN is
believed to be surface graphitized.
[0409] In one embodiment, the carbon may be deposited on the surface of an
iron particle in
the form of a cross-linked styrene sphere, such as the process of Friedel-
Crafts alkylation,
cross-linking and polymerization described by Barar et al. ("Freidel-Crafts
Cross-Linking for
Polystyrene Modification", Ind. Eng. Chem. Prod. Res. Dev., Vol. 22, pp. 161-
166, 1983).
[0410] In the observed SGANs, at least some of the measured iron is expected
to be in the
form of magnetite, which would make SGANs ferrimagnetic. In other embodiments,
the
SGAN or crosslinked styrene spheres may include one or more ferromagnetic,
paramagnetic,
or superparamagnetic particles. In one embodiment, the SGANs are believed to
form in situ,
agglomerate, and are coated with graphitic carbon in the form of one or any
combination of
polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), graphene, graphene oxide (GO),
microtubule, and
fullerene to form larger microparticles. Under sheer, these agglomerates are
believed to break
down into smaller units or shed surface layers but re-agglomerate once removed
from the
high-sheer environment.
[0411] The magnetic nature of the SGANs or iron-containing crosslinked styrene
spheres
makes them attractive to each other, to graphitic carbon, and to iron-
containing surfaces and
iron-containing particles suspended in the lubricating composition. When a
ferric SGAN or
larger aggregate nears a steel friction surface, the particle would then be
attracted to the
surface and serve both to aid in lubrication and to micro-polish the friction
surface. The core
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 70
PCT/US2012/029276
supporting the shell of the SGAN would provide the strength required to polish
steel parts.
[0412] The disclosed SGANs are superior nano-polishers to nanodiamonds. Since
the core of
the SGAN is not believed to be chemically bonded to its shell, the shell is
believed to be able
to spin independently of the core, so as to act as a nano-ball bearing.
Additionally, the
unbound shell of the SGAN is believed to be less rigid than nanodiamond and
thus more able
to diffuse impact forces.
[0413] In one embodiment, rather than the crystalline metal-containing cores
described
above, the SGAN may have an aromatic carbon ring-containing core. In one
embodiment, the
aromatic carbon ring-containing core may be a styrene- or styrene derivative-
containing core.
In one embodiment, the aromatic carbon ring-containing core may form in situ
in the
lubricating composition by self-assembly of aromatic carbon ring-containing
amphiphilic
molecules. In one embodiment, the aromatic carbon ring-containing amphiphilic
molecules
may be styrene or styrene derivative amphiphilic molecules. In one embodiment,
the self-
assembled core may contain reactive groups that allow the molecules to
chemically cross-link
to each other once self-assembled. In one embodiment, a fullerene shell may
form around the
self-assembled core to form a nanoparticle similar to the above-described
SGANs to form a
nano-polishing agent.
[0414] In addition to the tested additives, many other classes of additives
may be used in
lubricating compositions to achieve similar results. The additive preferably
has a structure
with at least one cyclic ring, which may be aromatic or non-aromatic, and at
least one
functional group extending from the ring or from a chain extending from the
ring. In one
embodiment, the structure includes fused rings. The additive preferably has a
structure
including at least one oxygen atom in addition to carbon and hydrogen. In one
embodiment,
other heteroatoms may be present in the chemical structure, although they may
not be
required to achieve the desired results and may be disfavored.
[0415] In one embodiment, the additive is dissolved in the lubricating
composition. In one
embodiment, the additive is a liquid that is miscible with the lubricant. In
one embodiment,
the additive includes a particulate. Since conventional engine oil filters are
designed to filter
out substantially all particles greater than ¨40 Rm in size, about half of the
particles ¨20 Rm
in size, and about 10-20% of particles ¨10 gm in size, the particulate
additives to the engine
oil preferably have an average particle size less than ¨10 lam to prevent
clogging of an oil
filter. In one embodiment, substantially all of the particles have a size less
than ¨10 gm. In
one embodiment, the particulate additives have an average particle size less
than ¨5 Rm. In
one embodiment, substantially all of the particles have a size less than ¨5
gm. In one
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 71
PCT/US2012/029276
embodiment, the particulate additives have an average particle size less than
¨1 gm. In one
embodiment, substantially all of the particles have a size less than ¨1 gm.
[0416] In one embodiment, the additive comprises powdered sugar (sucrose).
Powdered
sugars are commercially available in a variety of fineness and are commonly
used for baking.
6X powdered sugars have an average particle size of less than ¨200 gm. 10X
powdered
sugars have an average particle size of less than ¨150 gm. Fondant sugars are
powdered
sugars with an average particle size under ¨50 gm. Commercially available
fondant sugars
include "Celebration" (British Sugar, Peterborough, UK, Great Britan), a
superfine sugar
with an average particle size of ¨11 gm, "Silk Sugar" (British Sugar,
Peterborough, United
Kingdom, Great Britain), an ultrafine sugar with an average particle size of
¨8 gm, and C&H
Baker's Drivert (C&H Sugar Company, Inc., Crockett, California, United States)
with an
average particle size of ¨5 - 7 gm.
[0417] In one embodiment, the powdered sugar has an average particle size less
than ¨5 gm.
In one embodiment, substantially all of the particles have a size less than ¨5
gm. In some
embodiments, the powdered sugar has an average particle size less than ¨1 gm.
In one
embodiment, substantially all of the particles have a size less than ¨1 gm. In
one
embodiment, the powdered sugar is formed to the predetermined particle size by
grinding
crystalline sucrose in a dry environment. In one embodiment, the powdered
sugar is ground
using a known dry micro-milling technique of grinding crystals to micron or
sub-micron
particle sizes. In one embodiment, the powdered sugar is formed to the
predetermined
particle size by evaporative techniques such as evaporation of solvent from
microdroplets of
a dissolved sugar solution or lyophilization (freeze-drying) of a dissolved
sugar solution.
[0418] In one embodiment, sugar, preferably micro-powdered or nano-powdered
sucrose, is
added to a conventional lubricating fluid to serve as the carbon source for in
situ formation of
graphitic carbon while the lubricating composition lubricates an operating
engine. In one
embodiment, only sugar is added to a conventional base lubricant. In one
embodiment, sugar
and Marvel Mystery Oil (original formula, Turtle Wax, Inc., Westmont,
Illinois, United
States, naphthenic hydrocarbon and terpene source) are added to a conventional
base
lubricant. In one embodiment, sugar and mineral oil are added to a
conventional base
lubricant. In one embodiment, sugar is combined with an oil surfactant to
compatibilize the
sugar prior to addition to the base lubricant (see Hiteshkumar et al., "Self-
assembly in sugar-
oil complex glasses", Nature Materials, 6, pp. 287-290, 2007). In one
embodiment,
compatibilization of the sugar prevents the sugar from clogging a filter in
the lubricated
system as a gel or solid. In one embodiment, the oil surfactant is a terpene.
In one
¨
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 72
PCT/US2012/029276
embodiment, the terpene is limonene. In one embodiment, the sugar and oil
surfactant are
combined in a ratio less than about 1:1. In one embodiment, the sugar-oil
surfactant mixture
is in a liquid state at the time of being added to the lubricating fluid. In
one embodiment, the
sugar is a sugar amphiphile.
[0419] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a pyranose, a furanose, a
cyclic carbomer,
or a benzenoid (see Katritzky et al., "Aqueous High-Temperature Chemistry of
Carbo- and
Heterocycles. 20.1 Reactions of some Benzenoid Hydrocarbons and Oxygen-
Containing
Derivatives in Supercritical Water at 460 C", Energy & Fuels, Vol. 8, pp. 487-
497, 1994),
including, but not limited to, oxygen-containing benzenoids.
[0420] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a sugar other than sucrose.
In one
embodiment the sugar comprises a molasses or molasses substitute, which may
comprise, but
is not limited to, sweet sorghum, sugar beet molasses, pomegranate molasses,
mulberry
molasses, carob molasses, date molasses, grape molasses, backstrap molasses,
black treacle,
bee's honey, maple syrup, or corn syrup, including, but not limited to, high-
fructose corn
syrup. In some embodiments, the sugar comprises an invert sugar, which may
comprise, but
is not limited to, inverted sugar syrup.
[0421] In one embodiment, the sugar comprises a deoxy sugar, which may
comprise, but is
not limited to, deoxyribose, fucose, or rhamnose.
[0422] In one embodiment, the sugar comprises a monosaccharide, which may
comprise, but
is not limited to, glucose, fructose, galactose, xylose, or ribose.
[0423] In one embodiment, the sugar comprises a disaccharide, which may
comprise, but is
not limited to, sucrose, lactulose, lactose, maltose, trehalose, cellobiose,
or sophorose.
[0424] In one embodiment, the sugar comprises a polysaccharide, which may
comprise, but
is not limited to, starch, glycogen, arabinoxylan, cellulose, chitin, or
pectin.
[0425] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a sugar alcohol, which may
include, but is
not limited to, erythritol, threitol, arabitol, xylitol, ribitol, mannitol,
sorbitol, dulcitol, iditol,
isomalt, maltitol, or lactitol.
[0426] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a sugar substitute, which may
include, but
is not limited to, stevia, aspartame, sucralose, neotame, acesulfame
potassium, or saccharin.
[0427] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a sugar derivative, which may
include, but
is not limited to, sophoritol, a phenolic glycoside, a steviol glycoside, a
saponin, a glycoside,
a glucoside, or amygdalin.
[0428] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a cyclomethicone, which may
include, but
is not limited to, phenyl trimethicone or cyclopentasiloxane.
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 73
PCT/US2012/029276
[0429] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a steroid, which may include,
but is not
limited to, sapogenin or diosgenin.
[0430] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a cinnamate, which may
include, but is
not limited to, methyl or ethyl cinnamate. In one embodiment, the additive
comprises
cinnamic acid. In one embodiment, the additive comprises cinnamon oil.
[0431] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a phenylphopanoid, which may
include,
but is not limited to, cinnamic acid, coumaric acid, caffeic acid, ferulic
acid, 5-hydroxyferulic
acid, sinapic acid, cinnamaldehyde, umbelliferone, resveratrol, a monolignol,
which may
comprise, but is not limited to, coniferyl alcohol, coumaryl alcohol, or
sinapyl alcohol, or a
phenylpropene, which may comprise, but is not limited to, engenol, chavicol,
safrole, or
estragole.
[0432] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a benzoate, which may
include, but is not
limited to, ferric, benzyl, ethyl, methyl, phenyl, cyclohexanol, 2-phenyl-,
pentaerythritol
tetra-, sodium, or potassium benzoate. In one embodiment, the additive
includes benzoic acid.
In some embodiments, the additive comprises aminobenzoic acid. In one
embodiment, the
additive comprises 2-hydroxymethyl benzoic acid methyl ester. In one
embodiment, the
additive includes ubiquinone.
[0433] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a carboxylate, including but
not limited to
trimethyl cis, c is-1,3 ,5-cyc lohexanetricarboxylate.
[0434] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a benzopyran, which may
include, but is
not limited to, chromene, isochromene, or a substituted benzopyran.
[0435] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a naturally-occurring or
synthetic flavone
or isoflavone, which may include, but is not limited to, flavan-3-ol or
flavanone.
[0436] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a salicylate, which may
include, but is not
limited to, ferric, methyl, ethyl, butyl, cinnamyl, cyclohexyl, ethylhexyl,
heptyl, isoamyl,
octyl, benzyl, phenyl, p-cresol, o-cresol, m-cresol, or sodium salicylate. In
one embodiment,
the additive includes salicylic acid. In one embodiment, the additive includes
aminosalicylic
acid.
[0437] In one embodiment, the additive comprises an antioxidant. In one
embodiment, the
antioxidant is a cyclic antioxidant. In one embodiment, the antioxidant is a
phenolic
antioxidant, which may include, but is not limited to, 2,6-di-terti-
butylphenol, 2-tert-buty1-
4,6-dimethylphenol, 2,6-di-tert-butyl-4-ethylphenol, 2,6-di-tert-butyl-4-n-
butylphenol, 2,6-di-
tert-buty1-4-1-butylphenol, 2,6-di-cyclopenty1-4-methylphenol, 2-(a-
methylcyclohexyl)-4,6-
dimethylphenol, 2,6-di-octadecyl-methylphenol, 2,4,6-tri-cyclohexylphenol, 2,6-
di-tert-butyl-
_
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 74
PCT/US2012/029276
4-methoxymethylphenol, 2,6-di-tert-butyl-4-methoxyphenol, 2,5-di-tert-butyl-
hydroquinone,
2,5-di-tert-amyl-hydroquinone, 2,6-dipheny1-4-octadecyloxyphenol, 2,2'-
methylene-bis-(6-
tert-buty1-4-methylphenol), 2,2'-methylene-bis-(6-tert-butyl-4-ethylphenol),
2,2'-methylene-
bis44-methy1-6-(a-methylcyclohexyl)-phenol], 2,2'-
methylene-bis-(4-methy1-6-
cyclohexylphenol), 2,2'-methylene-bis-(6-nony1-4-methylphenol), 2,2'-methylene-
bis46-(a-
methylbenzy1)-4-nonylphenol], 2,2'-methylene-bis46-(a,a-dimethylbenzyl)-4-
nonylphenol],
2,2'-methylene-bis-(4,6-di-tert-butylphenol), 2,2'-
ethylidene-bis-(4,6-di-tert-butylphenol),
2,2'-ethylidene-bis-(6-tert-butyl-4-isobutylphenol), 4,4'-
methylene-bis-(2,6-di-tert-
butylphenol), 4,4'-
methylene-bis-(6-tert-butyl-2-methylphenol), 1,1-bis-(5-tert-buty1-4-
hydroxy-2-methylpheny1)-butane, 2,6-di-(3-
tert-buty1-5-methy1-2-hydroxybenzy1)-4-
methylphenol, 1,1,3-tris-(5-tert-buty1-4-hydroxy-2-methylpheny1)-butane, and
any naturally-
occurring plant-based phenolic antioxidant, which may include, but is not
limited to, ascorbic
acid, a tocopherol, a tocotrienol, rosemarinic acid, and other phenolic acids
and flavonoids,
such as those found, for example, in grapes, berries, olives, soy, tea leaves,
rosemary, basil,
oregano, cinnamon, cumin, and turmeric.
[0438] In one embodiment, the additive comprises 4-vinylphenol, anthocyanidin,
or
chromenylium.
[0439] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a cyclic amino acid, which
may include,
but is not limited to, phenylalanine, tryptophan, or tyrosine.
[0440] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a cyclohexane derivative,
which may
include, but is not limited to, 1,3-cyclohexadiene or 1,4-cyclohexadiene.
[0441] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a benzene derivative which
may include,
but is not limited to, a polyphenol, benzaldehyde, benzotriazole, benzyl 1-
naphthyl carbonate,
benzene, ethyl benzene, toluene, styrene, benzonitrile, phenol, phthalic
anhydride, phthalic
acid, terephthalic acid, p-toluic acid, benzoic acid, aminobenzoic acid,
benzyl chloride,
isoindole, ethyl phthalyl ethyl glycolate, N-phenyl benzamine,
methoxybenzoquinone,
benzylacetone, benzylideneacetone, hexyl cinnamaldehyde, 4-amino-2-
hydroxytoluene, 3-
aminophenol, or vanillin.
[0442] In one embodiment, the benzene derivative additive comprises a
benzenediol, which
may include 1,2-dihydroxybenzene (catechol), 1,3-dihydroxybenzene
(resorcinol), or 1,4-
dihydroxybenzene (hydroquinone).
[0443] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a naphthoate, including but
not limited to
methyl 2-methoxy- 1 -naphthoate or methyl 3-methoxy-2-naphthoate.
[0444] In one embodiment, the additive comprises an acrylate, including but
not limited to
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 75
PCT/US2012/029276
benzyl 2-propylacrylate or 2-naphthyl methacrylate.
[0445] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a phthalate, including but
not limited to
diallyl phthalate.
[0446] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a succinate, including but
not limited to
bis(2-carboxyphenyl) succinate.
[0447] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a carpate, including but not
limited to
methyl 0-methy lpodocarpate.
[0448] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a fluorophore, which may
include, but is
not limited to, fluorescein isothiocyanate, rhodamine, phthalocyanine, or
copper
phthalocyanine.
[0449] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a pharmaceutical, which may
include, but
is not limited to, acetylsalicylic acid, acetaminophen, ibuprofen, or a
benzodiazepine.
[0450] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a phosphate, which may
include, but is not
limited to, a cresyldiphenyl phosphate, a dicresyl phosphate, a triorthocresyl
phosphate, a
tricresyl phosphate, a paracresyl phosphate, an orthocresyl phosphate, or a
metacresyl
phosphate.
[0451] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a compound that degrades to
one or more
of the above-mentioned additives under the heat of the operating conditions of
the engine or
mechanical system, such as certain terpenes or certain natural aromatic or non-
aromatic
cyclic esters, ketones, or aldehydes, which may include, but is not limited
to, methyl
salicylate (wintergreen oil), cinnamon leaf/bark oil (cinnamaldehyde),
limonene (dipentene),
pinene, and camphene.
[0452] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a commercial edible
personal/sexual
lubricating composition including a sugar or sugar-substitute amphiphile.
[0453] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a commercial ultraviolet ray
sunscreen
formulation, which may include octyl methoxycinnamate (oxctinoxate), butyl-
methoxydibenzoylmethane (B-MDM, Avobenzone), octyl-dimethyl-para-aminobenzoic
acid
(OD-PABA), octocrylene, oxybenzone, alkyl benzoate, diethylhexyl 2,6-
naphthalate,
phenoxy-ethanol, homosalate, ethylhexyl triazone, 4-methyl-benzylidene camphor
(4-MBC),
or a polysorbate.
[0454] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a commercial skin cream
formulation,
which may include, but is not limited to carbomer, ascorbyl palmitate,
tocopheryl acetate,
ketoconazole, or mineral oil.
[0455] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a commercial hand sanitizer
formulation,
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 76
PCT/US2012/029276
which may include carbomer, tocopheryl acetate, or propylene glycol.
[0456] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a commercial human or animal
hair care
product, which may include benzophenone, alkyl benzoate, phenoxyethanol,
sorbitan oleate,
a styrene copolymer, propylene glycol, hydroxyisohexy1-3-cyclohexene
carboxaldehyde,
butylated hydroxytoluene, ketoconazole, petrolatum, mineral oil, or paraffinum
liquidum.
[0457] In one embodiment, the commercial hair care product is a curl
activating or relaxing
solution, which may include carbomer, hexyl cinnamal, benzyl salicylate,
trolamine
s al icy late, benzyl benzoate, limonene, eugenol, 1,3-B is(hydroxymethyl)-5,5-
dimethy-
limidazolidine-2,4-dione (DMDM Hydantoin), para-aminobenzoic acid (PABA), 2-
ethylhexyl 4-dimethy laminobenzoate (Padimate 0), butylphenyl methylpropional,
propylparaben, phenolsulfonphthalein (PSP, phenol red), or a polysorbate.
[0458] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a commercial hair dye
formulation, which
may include hydrated iron oxide (Fe(OH)3), para-phenylenediamine, ortho-, meta-
, or para-
aminophenol, 4-amino-2-hydroxytoluene, trideceth-2 carboxamide MEA, phenyl
methyl
pyrazolone, phenoxyethanol, a polyquaternium, hexyl cinnamal, butylphenyl
methylpropional, phenolsulfonphthalein (PSP, phenol red), hydroxyisohexyl 3-
cyclohexene
carboxaldehyde, titanium dioxide, or iron oxide.
[0459] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a commercial pesticide, which
may
include, but is not limited to, ortho-phenylphenol (OPP), phenylhydroquinone
(PHQ) or
phenylbenzoquinone (PBQ).
[0460] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a compound with a two-
dimensional
structure, which may include, but is not limited to, lignin, graphene, or
graphene oxide.
[0461] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a carbon form, which may
include, but is
not limited to, peat, lignite, bituminous coal, sub-bituminous coal,
pulverized coal, nano-coal,
steam coal, cannel coal, anthracite, charcoal, carbon black, activated
charcoal, black liquor,
graphite, graphene, graphene oxide, or sugar char. In one embodiment, the
carbon form
serves as a heat transfer agent in the lubricating composition.
[0462] In one embodiment, the carbon form comprises a nanopowder. In one
embodiment,
the carbon form has an increased surface area. In one embodiment, the carbon
form
comprises a nano-activated charcoal. The nano-activated charcoal may comprise
particles of
activated charcoal that have been ground from a conventional activated
charcoal to
nanoparticle size. The activated charcoal may be ground using any conventional
method to
produce nanometer-sized particles. In one embodiment, the activated charcoal
is ground
using known wet or dry nano-milling techniques of grinding solids to sub-
micron particle
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 77 PCT/US2012/029276
sizes. In one embodiment, the nano-activated charcoal has an average particle
size less than
¨100 nm. In one embodiment, substantially all of the particles have a size
less than ¨100 nm.
In some one embodiment, the nano-activated charcoal has an average particle
size less than
¨50 nm. In one embodiment, substantially all of the particles have a size less
than ¨50 nm.
[0463] In one embodiment, the carbon form comprises graphitic carbon. In one
embodiment,
the graphitic carbon comprises at least one PAH, which may include, but is not
limited to,
naphthalene, acenaphthylene, acenaphthene, fluorine, phenanthrene, anthracene,
fluoranthene, pyrene, benzo [a] anthracene, chrysene,
benzo [b] fluoranthene,
benzo[k] fluoranthene, benzo[j]fluoranthene, benzo [a]
pyrene, benzo[e]pyrene,
dibenz[a,h]anthracene, benzo[g,h,i]perylene, indeno[1,2,3-c,d]pyrene,
tetracene, coronene,
corannulene, pentacene, triphenylene, and ovalene.
[0464] In one embodiment, the carbon form comprises a biochar or biocoal
product of a
hydrothermal carbonization process.
[0465] In one embodiment, the additive provides the same benefits provided by
tricresyl
phosphate (TCP) to the lubricating system. TCP is considered a carcinogen and
a factor in
aerotoxic syndrome and is being phased out of use in many lubricating systems.
[0466] In some embodiments, the additive comprises a "dirty" or poorly-refined
form of
mineral oil with high levels of PAH contamination. Industrially-produced white
mineral oil
includes very low levels of PAHs, which must be essentially completely removed
in order to
sell the mineral oil as "USP" or "food grade". In one embodiment, the
separated waste
mineral oils from these processes (having the highest concentrations of PAHs)
are used
unprocessed and directly as additives or in combination with other additives.
The white
mineral oil component in this waste product serves as a wetting agent in the
lubricating
composition and the PAHs serve as a heat transfer agent and graphitic carbon
source in the
formation of SGANs and SGAN-containing microsphere agglomerates.
[0467] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a compatibilizer. A
compatibilizer, as
used herein, refers to a compound that aids in the dispersal of a carbon
source in a lubricant
or lubricating composition. In some embodiments, the compatibilizer is an
amphiphile. In
some embodiments, the compatibilizer comprises a surfactant. In some
embodiments, the
compatibilizer comprises a lipid. In some embodiments, the compatibilizer
comprises a
polymer. In some embodiments, the compatibilizer also serves as a carbon
source.
[0468] In some embodiments, the compatibilizer comprises a sugar amphiphile. A
sugar
amphiphile or a sugar-like amphiphile may be any molecule with a hydrophilic
sugar portion
and a hydrophobic portion, including, but not limited to, those described by
Fenimore
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 78
PCT/US2012/029276
("Interfacial Self-assembly of Sugar-based Amphiphiles: Solid- and Liquid-core
Capsules",
University of Cincinnati Ph.D. thesis dated October 16, 2009), Jadhav et al.
("Sugar-Derived
Phase-Selective Molecular Gelators as Model Solidifiers for Oil Spills",
Angew. Chem. Int.
Ed., Vol. 49, pp. 7695-7698, 2010), Jung et al. ("Self-Assembling Structures
of Long-Chain
Sugar-Based Amphiphiles Influenced by the Introduction of Double Bonds", Chem.
Eur.
Vol. 11, pp. 5538-5544, 2005), Paleta et al. ("Novel amphiphilic
fluoroalkylated derivatives
of xylitol, D-glucose and D-galactose for medical applications:
hemocompatibility and co-
emulsifying properties", Carbohydrate Research, Vol. 337, pp. 2411-2418,
2002),
Germaneau ("Amphiphilic Sugar Metal Carbenes: From Fischer Type to N-
Heterocyclic
Carbenes (NTICs)", Rheinische Friederich-Wilhems-Universitat Bonn Ph.D.
thesis, 2007),
and Ye et al. ("Synthesis of Sugar-Containing Amphiphiles for Liquid and
Supercritical
Carbon Dioxide", Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., Vol. 39, pp. 4564-4566, 2000). Sugar
amphiphiles
may also include, but are not limited to, sophorolipids (Zhang et al.,
"Synthesis and
interfacial properties of sophorolipid derivatives", Colloids and Surfaces A:
Physicochem.
Eng. Aspects, Vol. 240, pp. 75-82, 2004), or rhamnolipids (Christova et al.,
"Rhamnolipid
Biosurfactants Produced by Renibacterium salmoninarum 27BN During Growth on n-
Hexadecane", Zeitschrift fur Naturforschung Tell C Biochemie Biophysik
Biologie Virologie,
Vol. 59, pp. 70-74, 2004).
[0469] In one embodiment, the compatibilizer comprises a non-sugar graphene-
promoting
amphiphile. A graphene-promoting amphiphile may be any molecule with a
hydrophilic
graphene-promoting portion and a hydrophobic portion, which may include, but
is not limited
to, cetyltrimethylammonium bromide or those marketed by Dow Chemical Company
(Midland, Michigan, United States) under the trademarks TRITONTm or
TERGITOLTm,
including, but not limited to, the TRITONTm X series of octylphenol
ethoxylates and the
TERGITOLTm NP series of nonylphenol ethoxylates. In some embodiments, the
graphene-
promoting amphiphile is a non-ionic amphiphile. Graphene-promoting amphiphiles
may also
comprise, but are not limited to, glycerol monostearate and nonoxyphenol
surfactant.
[0470] In one embodiment, the compatibilizer comprises polyethylene glycol.
[0471] In one embodiment, the compatibilizer is used in combination with a
particulate
additive. In one embodiment, the compatibilizer promotes solubilization of the
particulate
additive in the base lubricant.
[0472] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a metal oxide, which may
comprise, but is
not limited to, iron oxide, aluminum oxide, copper oxide, nickel oxide,
titanium oxide, and
lead oxide.
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 79
PCT/US2012/029276
[0473] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a form of iron. In some
lubricating
systems, such as many jet engine turbines, little or no iron is inherently
present in the system.
Carbon-encapsulated iron particles formed in situ, however, are believed to
provide the nano-
polishing ability to lubricating compositions of the invention. Therefore, in
one embodiment,
the lubricating fluid is supplemented with an iron-containing additive.
[0474] In one embodiment, the iron-containing additive comprises an iron
oxide. In one
embodiment, the iron oxide is BayFerrox iron oxide powder pigment (Lanxess,
Cologne,
Germany). In one embodiment, the iron-containing additive comprises an iron
oxide
nanopowder. In one embodiment, the iron source comprises an iron complex
molecule.
[0475] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a cyclic iron-containing
compound,
including, but not limited to, (i-12-trans-Cyclooctene)2Fe(C0)3;
(benzylideneacetone)iron
tricarbonyl, ferric enterochelin, tricarbonylbis[(1,2-h)-cycloctene]-iron,
iron(4+) cyclooctane-
1,2-diide - carbon monoxide, sodium ferrate(1-); sodium bis(3-(4,5-dihydro-4-
((2-hydroxy-5-
n itropheny 1)azo)-3 -methyl-5-oxo-1H-pyrazol-1 -y 1)benzene-1 -sulphonam id
ato(2-)) ferrate(1-
); ferritin; (cyclo-1,3-C4H8-S2)Fe(C0)4; iron 2,4-dinitrobenzene-1,3-diol;
iron phthalocyanine;
ferrocene; ferric benzoate; ferric salicylate; cyclic ferrates; or iron
protein succinylate.
[0476] In one embodiment, the additive comprises an acyclic iron-containing
compound,
including, but not limited to, diiron nonacarbonyl, iron pentacarbonyl,
acyclic ferrates, liquid
iron, iron oxalate, hydrated iron oxide (Fe(OH)3), or an iron-containing
nutritional
supplement. In one embodiment, the iron-containing nutritional supplement
comprises
carbonyl iron. In one embodiment, the iron-containing complex is a catecholate-
iron
complex.
[0477] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a siderophore, which may
include, but is
not limited to, 2,3-dihydroxybenzoic acid (2,3'-DHB), NAP,N"-((3S,7S,115)-
2,6,10-trioxo-
1,5,9-trioxacyclododecane- 3,7,11-triyptris(2,3-dihydroxybenzamide)
(enerobactin), or 2,4-
dihydroxybenzoic acid (2,4'-DHB).
[0478] In one embodiment, the additive comprises an anthelmintic, including,
but not limited
to, 2-deoxy-paraherquamide (PHQ).
[0479] In one embodiment, the additive comprises an aromatic amino acid
precursor,
including, but not limited to, (3R,4R)-3- [(1-carboxyv inyl)oxy]-4-hy
droxycyclohexa-1,5-
d iene-1 -carboxyl ic ac id (chorismic acid).
[0480] In one embodiment, the additive comprises a molecule capable of
sequestering iron,
which may include, but is not limited to, ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid, 2-
aminophenol (see
Pulgarin et al., "Iron Oxide-Mediated Degradation, Photodegradation, and
Biodegradation of
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 80
PCT/US2012/020276
Aminophenols", Lan gmuir, Vol. 11, pp. 519-526, 1995 and Andreozzi et al.,
"Iron(III)
(hydr)oxide-mediated photooxidation of 2-aminophenol in aqueous solution: a
kinetic study",
Water Research, Vol. 37, pp. 3682-3688, 2003), or tetraphenyl oxo-
metalloporphyrins.
[0481] In one embodiment, the additive comprises nanodiamond intended to serve
as the
nucleating core of nanoparticles or microparticles incorporating the graphitic
carbon formed
in situ in the lubricating composition.
[0482] The ex situ pyrolytic synthesis of SGANs and SGAN-containing
agglomerates also
accommodates the use of such molecules in non-lubricating applications. In one
embodiment,
the particles or agglomerates can be applied to the surface of a material as a
coating to
strengthen the material or increase the heat shielding or heat absorption of
the material. In
one embodiment, the coating can be a thermal coating, a drill coating, or a
torch-resistant
coating. In one embodiment, the material can be a ballistic projectile, which
may include, but
is not limited to, bullets and missiles. In one embodiment, the material can
be an anti-ballistic
device, including, but not limited to, military tank armor or personal armor,
including, but not
limited to, bullet-resistant vests or plates. In one embodiment, the material
can be a tool,
including, but not limited to, a cutting bit, a tunneling device, an abrasive
polish, an abrasive
paper, or a boring device. In one embodiment, the material can be a thermal
shield, such as a
re-entry heat shield panel, a nosecone, or a rocket engine cone for a
spacecraft. In one
embodiment, the particles or agglomerates can be combined with a material to
form a
composite material with greater strength or greater heat shielding or heat
absorption
properties than the base material itself. In some embodiments, the material
can be a tire,
fireproofing, firefighting equipment, or firefighting apparel.
[0483] In one embodiment, the SGANs or SGAN-containing agglomerates of the
invention
can be used in electrochemical systems. In one embodiment, the SGANs or SGAN-
containing agglomerates of the invention can be used as nano-batteries to hold
an electrical
charge.
[0484] Test Results
[0485] Several lubricating compositions, including sacrificial carbon sources
with structures
expected to promote graphitic carbon formation under engine operating
conditions, were
tested in a series of motor scooters or motorized dirt bikes. These tests were
conducted to test
the efficacy of the compositions in small internal combustion engines, engines
of a size and
configuration such that improvements in friction reduction would be
sufficiently obvious to a
mechanic or operator without employing an external dynamometer to measure the
changes.
[0486] Test 7
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 81
PCT/US2012/029276
[0487] The conventional Valvoline (Ashland Inc., Lexington, Kentucky, United
States)
10W-40 motor oil of a poorly functioning 8,850 mile 1999 Honda Elite 80 (Model
CH80)
(Honda de Mexico, S.A. de C.V., Guadalajara, Jalisco - Mexico) motor scooter
was replaced
with a lubricating composition of the invention. Prior to addition of the
lubricating
composition, the engine of the motor scooter would barely maintain idle. When
tested, the
scooter would start, but soon after, would stall. When the motor scooter did
operate, the top
indicated speed was approximately 30 miles per hour.
[0488] The lubricating composition tested included several hundred milligrams
of Whole
Foods Market (Austin, Texas, United States) Organic Powdered Sugar (powdered
sucrose
and tapioca) mixed with Walgreens (Deerfield, Illinois, United States)
Intestinal Lubricant
(USP mineral oil) mixed into Motul (Aubervilliers, France) 5100 10W-40 semi-
synthetic
motor oil. The lubricating composition had an opaque appearance due to the
large presence of
sugar suspended in the solution.
[0489] Upon addition of the lubricating composition to the motor scooter, the
engine was
started and was then able to maintain an idle. Immediately thereafter, the
motor scooter was
taken for a performance evaluation test ride. The lubricating composition was
found to almost
instantly increase the top speed of the motor scooter from 30 to 35 MPH
indicated. A distinct
difference in the sound of the engine was also noted, with the engine sounding
much
smoother and quieter with use of the lubricating composition. After the test
ride, the
lubricating composition was drained from the engine when a characteristic
epoxy-like smell
was noted in the oil. This characteristic epoxy-like odor was expected and is
believed to
indicate the presence of epoxy-type precursor compounds in the oil, having
formed from the
incomplete pyrolysis of some of the remaining sugar molecules in the
lubricating
composition.
[0490] Test 8
[0491] Another lubricating composition tested in the same 1999 Honda Elite 80
motor
scooter (Model CH80) (Honda de Mexico, S.A. de C.V., Guadalajara, Jalisco -
Mexico)
consisted of one individual serving packet (one gram) of Sweet'n Low
(Cumberland
Packing Corp., Brooklyn, New York, United States) zero calorie sweetener
(dextrose,
saccharin, cream of tartar, calcium silicate) in a few milliliters of
CitraSolv (Danbury,
Connecticut, United States) natural cleaner and degreaser (d-limonene source),
that was then
combined with a Valvoline (Ashland Inc., Lexington, Kentucky, United States)
10W-40
conventional motor oil.
[0492] The motor scooter operated similarly on the saccharin-containing
lubricating
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 82
PCT/US2012/029276
composition to the sugar-containing lubricating composition described above.
After testing,
this lubricating composition was drained from the motor scooter with little
visible particulate
noted. The drained oil was otherwise unremarkable, save the strong citrus
smell from the
limonene-containing CitraSolv cleaner and degreaser.
[0493] Test 9
[0494] Yet another lubricating composition was tested in the same 1999 Honda
Elite 80
(Model CH80) (Honda de Mexico, S.A. de C.V., Guadalajara, Jalisco - Mexico)
motor
scooter, that included Whole Foods Market (Austin, Texas, United States)
Organic Powdered
Sugar (powdered sucrose and tapioca) mixed with activated charcoal as an
additive to
Valvoline (Ashland Inc., Lexington, Kentucky, United States) 10W-40
conventional motor
oil.
[0495] According to the Valvoline motor oil's Material Safety Data Sheet, the
oil has a
reported flash point of 204 C (399.2 F) and a reported boiling point of 299
C (570.2 F).
The normal operating temperature of the air-cooled engine's cylinder head was
measured to
be ¨80 C (176 F).
[0496] During the test, the engine cowling was modified to completely block
all air flow
from the cooling fan to the cylinder head. This meant that as the engine ran,
the air
surrounding the cylinder head was trapped and began to heat-up. The rising
temperature of
the cylinder head was monitored by a Cen-Tech (Zhangzhou Eastern Intelligent
Meter Co.
Ltd., Zhangzhou, Fujian, China) 96451 Non-Contact Infrared Thermometer with
Laser
Targeting.
[0497] The engine was run in this condition until the cylinder head reached a
measured
temperature of approximately 225 C (437 F). At this point in temperature,
smoke was
observed billowing from the crankcase breather valve and the plastic cowling
around the
engine was seen to begin melting. While in this condition and at this
temperature, the engine
was again run WOT (wide-open throttle) and the engine continued to run without
seizing. A
short time thereafter, the engine was turned off and allowed to cool down.
Then the motor
scooter was test ridden for a few miles during which it was observed to run
perfectly
smoothly with no noted degradation in performance.
[0498] Test 10
[0499] In yet another lubricating composition, ¨200 mL of Whole Foods Market,
LP (Austin,
Texas, United States) apricot kernel oil (amygdalin source) was combined with
¨550 mL of
Valvoline (Ashland Inc., Lexington, Kentucky, United States) 10W-40
conventional motor
oil. This lubricating composition was placed in a 125 mile 2011 JMStar
(Shanghai JMStar
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 83
PCT/US2012/029276
Motorcycle Co., Ltd., Shanghai, China) 150 cubic centimeter displacement GY6-
style engine
motor scooter.
[0500] Although no measured increase in indicated top speed of the motor
scooter was
discernible during the evaluation test ride, the engine sounded qualitatively
better and
smoother using the lubricating composition, than with the conventional oil
alone.
[0501] Test 11
[0502] In another lubricating composition, several ounces of Roddenberry's
Cane Patch
Invert Sugar Cane Syrup (Bay Valley Foods, LLC, Green Bay, Wisconsin, United
States) and
¨100 mL of Marvel Mystery Oil (Turtle Wax, Inc., Westmont, Illinois, United
States,
naphthenic carbon source) were combined with Valvoline (Ashland Inc.,
Lexington,
Kentucky, United States) 10W-40 conventional motor oil. This lubricating
composition was
placed in a Baja Motor Sports (Phoenix, Arizona, United States) Dirt Runner
125 cubic
centimeter displacement motorized dirt bike.
[0503] Prior to the test, the dirt bike ran, but not particularly well. Once
the lubricating
composition was added to the engine, the engine sounded qualitatively better
and ran
smoother than with the conventional lubricant. At the conclusion of the
performance
evaluation test rides, the oil was drained from the dirt bike's engine and the
anticipated and
characteristic epoxy-like smell was again noted, indicating the presence of
phenolic
resin/epoxy precursors in the lubricant.
[0504] Test 12
[0505] In another lubricating composition, approximately 50 mL of Spectrum
USP-grade
benzyl benzoate (Spectrum Chemical Mfg. Corp., New Brunswick, New Jersey,
United
States) was mixed with 50 mL of 5W-30 G-Oil (Green Earth Technologies,
Celebration,
Florida, United States) Ultimate Biodegradable green motor oil, a conventional
tallow-based
motor oil. The approximately 100 mL of lubricating composition was then added
to the
existing engine oil in a 125 mile 2011 JMStar (Shanghai JMStar Motorcycle Co.,
Ltd.,
Shanghai, China) 150 cubic centimeter displacement GY6-style engine motor
scooter. This
lubricating composition qualitatively seemed to perform the best of all the
lubricating
compositions tested.
[0506] A significant change in engine noise was observed after addition of the
lubricating
composition and the maximum engine RPMs were later noted to have increased by
1000
RPM from approximately 10,000 RPM to 11,000 RPM.
[0507] Test 13
[0508] In another lubricating composition, approximately 20 drops of Aura
Cacia Organic
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 84
PCT/US2012/029276
Cinnamon Leaf Oil (Frontier Natural Products Co-Op, Norway, Iowa, United
States, methyl
cinnamate source) and approximately 10 mL of Walgreens (Deerfield, Illinois,
United States)
Intestinal Lubricant (USP mineral oil), were combined with ¨200 mL of Green 5W-
30 G-
Oil (Green Earth Technologies, Celebration, Florida, United States) Ultimate
Biodegradable
green motor oil. This lubricating composition was placed in a Baja Motor
Sports (Phoenix,
Arizona, United States) Dirt Runner 125 cubic centimeter displacement
motorized dirt bike.
This lubricating composition performed similarly to the previous lubricating
composition
including benzyl benzoate, yet a pungent cinnamon-like odor was noted while
operating.
[0509] Test 14
[0510] In another lubricating composition, approximately 100 mL of a mixture
of Spectrum
USP-grade benzyl benzoate (Spectrum Chemical Manufacturing Corp., New
Brunswick,
New Jersey, United States), Walgreens (Deerfield, Illinois, United States)
Intestinal Lubricant
(USP mineral oil), and Lucas Automatic Transmission Fluid Conditioner (Lucas
Oil
Products, Inc., Corona, California, United States, antioxidant source) was
added to the engine
base lubricant of a new (2-mile) 2011 50 cc-engine scooter, model GMW-M2
(Taizhou
Zhongneng Motorcycle Company, Ltd., Taizhou, China) with a modified
transmission and
exhaust system. An almost instant increase in horsepower of the engine was
noted and the top
speed of the scooter almost instantly increased from 33 to 39 MPH, indicated,
an 18%
increase.
[0511] Test 15
[0512] In another lubricating composition, a formulation comprising three
quarts of a ZDDP-
containing high grade synthetic motorcycle motor oil mixed with about one
quart of a
mixture comprising Marvel Mystery Oil original formula, Turtle Wax, Inc.,
Westmont,
Illinois, United States), Lucas Synthetic Oil Stabilizer (Lucas Oil Products,
Inc., Corona,
California, United States), Lucas Automatic Transmission Fluid Conditioner
(Lucas Oil
Products, Inc., Corona, California, United States), and zMAX8 (Oil-Chem
Research
Corporation, Bedford Park, Illinois, United States), in a volume ratio of
about 60:17:70:30
was used to replace the existing motor oil in a 1999 Yamaha R1 (Yamaha Motor
Co., Ltd.,
Iwata, Japan) test motorcycle with a 1000 cc engine. Engine performance
testing with this
formulation was accomplished using a Dynojet 250i dynamometer (Dynojet
Research Inc.,
Las Vegas, Nevada, United States) to measure the power and torque output at
the rear wheel
of the test motorcycle both 10 minutes after the oil change and again one week
after the oil
change. A summary of the dynamometer test results for these two test runs is
shown in Table
2(a) and Table 2(b):
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 85
PCT/US2012/029276
Table 2(a): Dynamometer test results - maximum output
Power Output :7,44Y-0 Original 10 Minutes 1 Week
z
Maximum Horsepower 135.14 136.08 138.49
Maximum Torque (ft/lbs) 73.06 74.04 75.31
Table 2(b): Dynamometer test results - largest measured increase
Power Output 10 Minutes 1 Week
Horsepower @ 7,500 RPM 102.96 107.90
[0513] As can be seen in Table 2(a), an increased output of about 1 horsepower
and about 1
ft-lb of torque is observed in the 10-minute test, in comparison to the
horsepower and torque
previously measured on the motorcycle using another commercially-available
high grade
motorcycle motor oil. The effect of the new lubrication composition was even
more dramatic
after 7 days of use. At the subsequent 1-week test, an additional increase in
registered
horsepower and torque output of 3% to 4% over the 10-minute test values was
observed.
Specifically, the registered horsepower increased by about 3 to 5 HP across
the entire range
of engine speeds tested (4500 RPM to about 11,000 RPM). As seen in Table 2(b),
a
horsepower output of 102.96 was measured at 7500 RPM during the 10-minute
test,
compared to a horsepower output of 107.90 measured at 7500 RPM during the
subsequent 1-
week test. The maximum torque increased from about 74.04 to about 75.3 ft-lbs
from the 10-
minute test to the 1-week test.
[0514] Test 16
[0515] In another lubricating composition, about three to about four ounces of
a mixture of
Marvel Mystery Oil (original formula, Turtle Wax, Inc., Westmont, Illinois,
United States),
Lucas Synthetic Oil Stabilizer (Lucas Oil Products, Inc., Corona, California,
United States),
Lucas Automatic Transmission Fluid Conditioner (Lucas Oil Products, Inc.,
Corona,
California, United States), zMAX micro-lubricant (Oil-Chem Research
Corporation,
Bedford Park, Illinois, United States), were combined with Marvel Air Tool Oil
(Turtle Wax,
Inc., Westmont, Illinois, United States), in a volume ratio of about
12:3:14:10:9 and then
added to the existing engine lubricant in a 2006 Audi A4 2.0 liter Turbo (Audi
AG,
Ingolstadt, Germany) test automobile, producing phenomenal performance and
fuel economy
results. This additive package, as well as similar additive concentrate
formulations, may be
added directly to the motor oil already in a vehicle to improve engine
performance without
the need for replacing the existing motor oil.
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 86
PCT/US2012/029276
[0516] Test 17
[0517] In yet another lubricating composition, a concentrated additive package
not intended
to influence the performance of any existing base motor oil or its additives,
was
accomplished by using about one quart of a mixture of Marvel Mystery Oil
(original formula,
Turtle Wax, Inc., Westmont, Illinois, United States), Lucas Synthetic Oil
Stabilizer (Lucas
Oil Products, Inc., Corona, California, United States), Lucas Automatic
Transmission Fluid
Conditioner (Lucas Oil Products, Inc., Corona, California, United States), and
Marvel Air
Tool Oil (Turtle Wax, Inc., Westmont, Illinois, United States), in a volume
ratio of about
12:3:14:16.
[0518] This concentrated additive package was added to a high-quality, non-
ZDDP-
containing, synthetic motor oil and introduced into a 2006 Audi A4 2.0 liter
Turbo (Audi AG,
Ingolstadt, Germany) test automobile, producing phenomenal performance and
fuel economy
results. This additive package, as well as similar additive concentrate
formulations, may be
added directly to the motor oil already in a vehicle to improve engine
performance without
the need for replacing the existing motor oil.
[0519] Lubricating Composition Experimental Observations for Tests 16 and 17
[0520] Subsequently, metal engine components from the Audi A4 test automobile
(Audi AG,
Ingolstadt, Germany) were removed and subjected to non-destructive scientific
analyses. In
this case, a machined steel camshaft cam follower and cam follower retaining
ring were
removed from the test automobile after 150,000 miles of use with various
incarnations of the
lubricating composition. According to the manufacturer, these parts are made
of stainless
steel. The results of those analyses follow.
[0521] The first of the scientific analyses of the engine components was a
surface roughness
analysis using a NewyiewTM 7300 white light optical surface profiling
interferometer (Zygog
Corporation, Middlefield, Connecticut, United States). The removed cam
follower's friction
and non-friction surfaces were evaluated and compared using the
interferometer. The
arithmetic mean (Ra), peak-valley (PV), and root-mean-squared (RMS) average
surface
roughnesses were determined. The results and findings are summarized in Fig.
20, Fig. 21,
and Table 3.
Table 3: Optical Surface Profiling Results
Cam Follower Section Ave. Roughness (Ra, tun) ,PV (pm)7 RMS (nm)
Original/Unworn Surface 221.6 2.27 284.51
Polished/Friction Surface 3.44 0.11 5.51
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 87
PCT/US2012/029276
[0522] As can be seen, an almost two order of magnitude improvement in surface
smoothness was achieved using formulations of the present invention. Average
surface
roughness (Ra) was reduced from a minimum starting value of at least Ra =
221.6 nm to a
measured end value of Ra = 3.44 nm.
[0523] Fig. 20 shows that the non-wear surface, which did not make repeated
close contact
with the walls of the cylinder head during operation of the automobile, was
measured to have
an Ra value of 221.6 nm, which is typical for such an engine part in a high-
quality automobile
(average automobile cam follower tolerances Ra = 300 to 400 nm). The graphical
representation in the bottom left quadrant of Fig. 20 shows what can be
considered an
estimation of the approximate beginning surface roughness measurements for the
cam
follower section evaluated, that is to say, its estimated relative condition
upon assembly into
the test automobile's engine.
[0524] Fig. 21, however, shows that the wear surface, which was in constant
frictional
contact with the walls of the cylinder head during operation of the engine,
was measured to
have an Ra value of 3.44 nm, almost two orders of magnitude lower than the
measured
roughness of the non-wear surface, which indicates the approximate and
estimated original
state of the cam follower at time of manufacture and assembly of the engine.
The original
machining asperities observed in Fig. 20 are oriented perpendicularly to the
asperities
observed in Fig. 21, indicating that the original machining asperities in the
wear surface were
completely removed at one point in the polishing process.
[0525] These data indicate that the wear surface of the cam follower has been
super-polished
during operation of the engine. While super-polishing of surfaces of materials
such as fused
silica, silicon, and silicon carbide down to a surface roughness Ra value of
0.4 nm is possible
under highly controlled laboratory circumstances, polished metal surfaces
typically have a
much higher Ra value in the range of hundreds of nanometers. Liu et al.
(SIMTech Technical
Reports, Vol. 8, No. 3, pp. 142-148, Jul-Sept. 2007) report a two-step super-
polishing process
capable of producing (under laboratory conditions) a stainless steel lens
mould insert with a
surface roughness Ra value of 8.5 nm.
[0526] Since two pieces of metal in contact are not capable of producing
surfaces of the
smoothness observed in Fig. 21 without a polishing agent, the wear surface of
the cam
follower was tested further to try to determine the polishing agent in the
lubricating
composition capable of producing a surface as smooth as surface achieved in
the test of the
invention. The wear surface of a cam follower is typically made of surface-
hardened steel,
and the nanoparticle polishing agents, one of which is referenced herein as an
SGAN, in
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 88
PCT/US2012/029276
order to be able to polish a surface, is expected to be harder than the
surface being polished.
The 2-dimensional surface topology of the wear surface in Fig. 21 shows a
number of circular
features in the size range of one or two nanometers in diameter, which is on
the scale of the
expected size of the SGAN or other abrasive nanoparticles that would be
necessary in order
to achieve such a low surface roughness Ra value.
[0527] The non-wear surface from a retaining ring of the cam follower was
studied using a
Philips XL series XL 30 ESEM-FEG (FEITM Company, Hillsboro, Oregon, United
States),
using EDAX GenesisTM version 4.61 software (AMATEK Inc., Mahwah, New Jersey,
United States) and a Scandium Imaging Platform. The resulting electron
microscope images
of surfaces of the retaining ring are shown in Figs. 22 through 41. The
accompanying
elemental analysis from energy-dispersive x-ray spectroscopy (EDS) for the
four surfaces
showed only carbon, oxygen, and iron in the weight (wt%) and atomic (At%)
percentages
shown in Table 4(a) for the areas in the black boxes sampled in Figs. 22
through 25,
respectively, except for Fig. 22, which showed traces (< 1 At%) of potassium
and chromium.
The images show spheroid structures on the non-wear surface with diameters in
the range of
¨2-3 microns.
Table 4(a): Preliminary Elemental Analysis Data
Sampled 0 Fe C 0 Fe
Area ' (wt%) (wt%) (wt%) (At%) (At%) (At%)
Fig. 22 22.87 15.51 57.44 46.76 26.88
25.26
Fig. 23 82.18 7.22 10.60 91.43 6.03 2.54
Fig. 24 84.89 11.18 3.93 90.19 8.92 0.90
Fig. 25 83.47 13.68 2.85 88.47 10.88 0.65
[0528] Figs. 26 through 37 show additional SEM images of the cam follower
retaining ring
surface. In Figs. 29 through 37, the length scale "Mm" in the figures is
actually in
micrometers. During the lubrication process, these larger structures are
broken down into
smaller nanostructures.
[0529] Since the sampled areas from Figs. 22 through 25 showed varying ratios
of carbon,
oxygen, and iron, subsequent experiments were run to sample different areas of
the same
structure to determine whether the structures were homogeneous. Figs. 38A-C,
Figs. 39A-G,
and Figs. 40A-C show the structures with the areas in the black boxes being
the sampled
areas.
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 89 PCT/US2012/029276
Table 4(b): First Spheroid Elemental Analysis Data
Sampled C.; 0 C 0 Fe,;
Area '(wt%) " (wt%) '4(Wt%r (At%) i (At%) (At).
Fig. 38A 73.41 11.36 15.23 86.15 10.01 3.84
Fig. 38B 76.91 12.12 10.97 87.03 10.30 2.67
Fig. 38C 37.57 5.57 56.87 69.60 7.74 22.66
[0530] Figs. 38A, 38B, and 38C show three different sampled areas from a
single large
spheroid, that is -2 microns in diameter. As shown in Table 4(b), only carbon,
oxygen, and
iron were detected. In Fig. 38A, an average of most of the surface was taken,
whereas in Fig.
38B, a smaller portion of the surface was sampled with similar results.
Finally, a small
protrusion extending from the bottom of the spheroid was sampled as shown in
Fig. 38C.
This small protrusion has almost ten times the amount of iron as in the other
two sampled
areas.
Table 4(c): Crystalline Structures Elemental Analysis Data
Sampled C '0 Ca Fe C 0 Ca Fe
'Area (wt%) (wt%) (wt%) (wt%) (At%) (At%) (wt%) (AN
Fig. 39A 62.25 26.50 8.62 1.17 72.83 23.28 3.02
0.30
Fig. 39B 68.72 20.30 6.81 1.74 78.81 17.48 2.34 0.43
Fig. 39C 52.37 5.33 1.91 38.83 79.56 6.08 0.87
12.69
Fig. 39D 83.38 8.94 3.94 0.74 90.19 7.26 1.28
0.17
Fig. 39E 81.26 5.92 7.92 ND 90.55 4.95 2.65 ND
Fig. 39F 75.62 8.54 10.89 1.75 87.17 7.39 3.76
0.43
Fig. 39G 84.67 8.96 3.62 1.07 90.77 7.21 1.16
0.25
Fig. 41 85.31 12.10 ND 2.59 89.84 9.57 ND 0.59
[0531] Figs. 39A, 39B, 39C, 39D, 39E, 39F, and 39G show seven different
sampled areas of
a large, irregular crystalline structure that is more than 13 microns wide. As
shown in Table
4(c), carbon, oxygen, calcium, and iron were detected in all of the samples
except for Fig.
39E, which had no iron. Additionally, chlorine was detected in each of these
samples in an
amount to bring the totals to 100 %. The ratio of calcium to chlorine ranged
from about 1:1 to
about 6:1. Within this range, ratios of calcium to chlorine of about 1.5:1,
about 2:1, and about
3:1 were also observed. The amount of iron detected was fairly minimal in
comparison to the
Fig. 38 series, except for the 12.69 At% for the sampled area of Fig. 39C.
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 90
PCT/US2012/029276
Table 4(d): Second Spheroid Elemental Analysis Data
Sampled Fe. C 0 Fe tt
Area '(Wt%) (wt("%o) (Wt%) (At%) (At%) (At%).
Fig. 40A 69.94 9.27 20.79 85.95 8.55 5.50
Fig. 40B 34.41 4.47 61.12 67.59 6.59 25.82
Fig. 40C 61.14 6.91 31.95 83.52 7.09 9.39
[0532] Figs. 40A, 40B, and 40C show three different sampled areas from a
single smaller
spheroid that is ¨1.3 microns in diameter. As shown in Table 4(d), only
carbon, oxygen, and
iron were detected. As shown in Fig. 40A, the spheroid was sampled in the
middle with
results similar to that of the sampled area of Fig. 38A, although the iron
content was higher
and the oxygen content was lower. As shown in Fig. 40B, the spheroid was
sampled at the
upper right edge with an iron content almost five times higher than the area
shown in Fig.
40A, similar to what was observed for the area in Fig. 38C. Finally, as shown
in Fig. 40C, the
spheroid was sampled at the left edge with an iron content almost twice as
high as in the area
of Fig. 40A but much lower than the area of Fig. 40B.
[0533] Finally, Fig. 41 shows a large sampled area of a large, rhombus-shaped
crystalline
structure that is between 4 and 5 microns wide. As shown in Table 4(c), only
carbon, oxygen,
and iron were detected. The ratios were similar to those of the low-iron areas
of the
spheroids, except the iron content was even lower in this case.
[0534] Subsequently, hexane was added to a sample of the used lubrication
composition. The
mixture was centrifuged, and a sediment fraction and a fluid fraction of the
centrifuged
mixture were tested with time-of-flight (TOF) secondary ion mass spectrometry
(SIMS) and
transmission electron microscopy (TEM) with an FEITM CM20 TEM with EDAX
GenesisTM
software. Although these tests did not identify any particular structures in
the lubricating
composition, interestingly, no measurable iron was detected in either the
sediment fraction or
the fluid fraction of the oil. Only carbon, oxygen, and in some cases, zinc,
calcium, or
chromium were detected in the sample. From these tests, as evidenced by the
lack of iron, it
became clear that the features observed by SEM on the surfaces of the cam
follower retaining
ring are not present in detectable levels in the fluid itself.
[0535] A sample of the material on the cam follower surface was obtained for
TEM
observation by gently rubbing the TEM mesh grid on the surfaces of the cam
follower and
then viewing the features on the grid with the TEM. Representative images of
the observed
features are shown in Figs. 42 through 49B, revealing a number of different
morphologies
and structures. The images confirm the presence of graphene or graphene oxide
sheets,
CA 02857947 2014-06-02
WO 2012/125854 91
PCT/US2012/029276
carbon nanotubes, carbon nanospheroids, carbon nano-onions, and other
fullerene structures
and precursors. The dark areas in the images are believed to represent higher
concentrations
of iron, based on elemental analysis. Graphene is known to encapsulate iron
particles (see, for
example, Cao et al., "Synthesis and characterization of graphene encapsulated
iron
nanoparticles", Nanoscience, vol. 12, no. 1, pp. 35-39, 2007). Fig. 42 shows a
relatively flat
sheet morphology in the lower part of the image and a more crumpled sheet in
the upper part
of the image. Smaller spheroid structures in the range of ¨5 nm to ¨50 nm in
diameter are
also visible on the image. Fig. 43 shows primarily a moderately-crumpled sheet
morphology
with nanotubular structures near folds of the sheets.
[0536] Fig. 44 shows a higher magnification of an area with similar morphology
to Fig. 43.
In Fig. 44, spheroid, tubular, and sheet morphologies are visible. Fig. 45
shows some tortuous
tubular structures at high magnification. Fig. 46 shows a dark globular mass
with an indistinct
morphology at high magnification, which may be an aggregation of SGANs based
on the
dark interior of the structure. Fig. 47 shows a large carbon nanotube
structure. Fig. 48 shows
two carbon nano-onion structures. Finally, Figs. 49A and 49B show a
crystalline-looking
mass with tubular and spheroid morphologies but no apparent sheet morphology.
[0537] Accordingly, it is to be understood that the embodiments of the
invention herein
described are merely illustrative of the application of the principles of the
invention.
Reference herein to details of the illustrated embodiments is not intended to
limit the scope of
the claims, which themselves recite those features regarded as essential to
the invention.
