Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02925533 2016-03-31
1
KNIFE SHARPENER FOR ASIAN AND EUROPEAN/AMERICAN KNIVES
Cross Reference to Related Application
The present application is a divisional application of Canadian Patent
Application No.
2,792,316 filed on March 11,2011.
Background of the Invention
For generations, knife sharpeners have been available to sharpen dull knives
but without
regard to the angle of the knife edge. Knives produced in factories were made
largely by
artisans who undertook to create a sharp edge without regard to the angle of
the edge.
Sharpness was the focus and it did not matter to the artisan what the angle
was. That was
true also after the factory knife was sold, used, and became dull. The owner
sought to
sharpen the edge somehow, with a tool file, on a sharpening stone, or perhaps
with a
sharpening "steel". The angle at which the edge facets were formed by the user
was not
recognized as important. Factory edge angles were not standardized by any of
the large or
small knife factories. They did not consider it of any importance,
particularly since the user
had no sense of the importance of the edge angle and had no means or ability
to sharpen the
edge at a specified or controlled angle. As a consequence, for generations
knife sharpeners
have been sold without specifying anything more than "the sharpener will
create a sharp
edge on your knife". In general both factory knives and sharpeners have been
sold only on
the expectation that the resulting knife will be sharp.
CA 02925533 2016-03-31
2
The consumer has had no expectations or concerns about the actual angle of the
edge ¨ only
that it be sharp enough for the job at hand. Examination of the knives
produced in Europe
shows that the total edge angle varied from about 40 degrees to 60 degrees or
larger.
American manufacturers have followed the European practices. Asian knives made
with
smaller edge angles have not been readily available or popular in the United
States, but that
has begun to change recently.
The European designs of knife edges with their relatively large angles have
evolved as a
result of their diets and methods of food preparation. In general the European
style knife is
designed for butchering and to cut tough fibrous foods such as a wide variety
of meats.
Knives manufactured in Japan and Asia are found to have edge angles of about
10 degrees to
20 degrees, most commonly about 15 degrees which they have found to be
practical for
cutting fish and other softer, less tough foods than those encountered in
Europe.
The recent interest of the Asian style cutlery has presented new challenges
for American
knife sharpeners that historically have been designed exclusively for the
larger angled
European and American, style knives, The Asian knife customer commonly has not
been
willing to trust his knife to existing European or American sharpeners and he
has continued
largely to sharpen his Asian knives tediously by hand on sharpening stones.
As a consequence of the confusion created by the introduction of Asian style
knives into
America, several sharpeners have been offered to handle both Asian and
European style
knives, These sharpeners are simply a physical combination of two sharpeners,
one for the
larger angle European knives and one for Asian style knives incorporated into
a single
CA 02925533 2016-03-31
3
housing. These commonly have one sharpening stage or section dedicated to
European
blades and another dedicated separate sharpening stage or section to sharpen
Asian blades.
Such sharpeners are consequently large, very expensive, and produce relatively
weak knife
edges particularly for the thinner low edge angle Asian blades.
A primary reason why Asian knives have not been popular in America is that
American foods
are generally more like the Europeans ¨ tougher and more fibrous. It has been
shown that
lower angle Asian knives as sold commercially do not hold up as well when
cutting tougher
American foods. The thin 15 degree edge bends over in use and quickly becomes
dull.
The attraction of the Asian edge to the American consumer is that it appears
to be sharper
than when cutting with the European knives. This is because the edge facets
are set at a total
included angle of only on average 30 degrees or so which will cut easier and
in fact feel like a
sharper wedge than the 40 degree wedge of the European edge.
Forty degree total angle edges are however stronger, do not fold over so fast
and hold up
longer when cutting the tougher American type foods. A recognition of the
inherent
weakness of the thirty degree edge has been a deterrent to wide acceptance of
the Asian edges
¨ in spite of the perception they cut with less effort.
These inventors have discovered unique simpler, more compact, less expensive
designs for
sharpeners that can handle both European and Asian style knives. In spite of
their simplicity
these new sharpeners create sharper and longer lasting edges for both classes
of knives than,
for example, any other commercially available manual sharpeners offered to
sharpen both
CA 02925533 2016-03-31
4
classes of knives. Further the new design disclosed here produces precision
edges of a quality
equal to new factory produced knives.
Summary of the Invention
US Patent Application Publication No. 2009/0233530 discloses techniques for
providing a
single sharpener to effectively sharpen both Asian/Japanese and Euro-American
knives. In
particular these techniques are shown as being incorporated in electric knife
sharpeners. The
present application discloses how such techniques can also be incorporated in
manual knife
sharpeners.
One or more manual knife sharpeners have been introduced in America during the
last two
years in response to new interest in Asian style knives. These introductions
are merely
physical combinations of two distinctly different and separate sharpeners, one
for European
style blades and one for Asian style knives in a single housing. This
invention relates to a
novel yet simple design manual knife sharpener that can put a superior edge on
both European
and Asian knives that is less expensive, of smaller size, creates better and
sharper edges than
those on most factory-made new knives and leaves an edge on Asian knives that
is more
durable than those on conventional manual sharpeners. Surprisingly this novel
design results
in 15 degree edges that are in general as durable as the conventional larger
20 degree edge,
but retains the extra apparent sharpness of a conventional 15 degree edge.
This novel sharpener is described in the following disclosure.
THE DRAWINGS
Figure 1 is a front elevational view of conventional 20 edge facets with a
large second burr;
CA 02925533 2016-03-31
Figure 2 is a front elevational view of conventional 150 edge facets with a
large second bevel;
Figure 3 is a front elevational view of primary 15 edge facets with a micro
second bevel;
Figure 4 is a top plan view of manual sharpening elements according to a 3
stage sharpener of
this invention;
Figure 5 is a front elevational view of the sharpener shown in Figure 4;
Figure 6 is a detail assembly drawing of a sharpening element in the sharpener
of Figures 4-5;
Figure 7 is a front elevation view of an example stage sharpener in accordance
with Figures
4-6; and
Figure 8 is a top view of the sharpener of Figure 7.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
This invention relates to a high quality versatile and unique manual sharpener
with only 3
sharpening stages that can sharpen with high precision in two sharpening steps
either 15
degrees Asian knives or the conventional 20 European/American style. Prior to
this
development the creation of an edge on a conventional 20 edged knife in the
most advanced
sharpeners has been obtained by a two stage process where the first stage has
an aggressive
sharpening abrasive to grind a full primary 20 facet along each side of the
edge. State of the
art sharpeners then polish the entire or majority of the primary facet length
with a finer
abrasive set at the same angle or at a slightly larger angle, about 22
(Figure 1). Similarly to
sharpen an Asian 15 edge (30 total) the first stage would be set at 15 and
the second stage
would be in the range of 15-17 degrees, the two stages being just about 2
degrees difference
in order to refine virtually the entire facet surfaces and to create a second
bevel along a
majority of the facet length as shown in Figure 2. It has been common practice
in modem
two step sharpeners to create generous facets in each step and to keep the
sharpening angles
CA 02925533 2016-03-31
6
in these steps very close so that the second refining bevel does not alter
significantly the
effective angle of the blade edge.
It is easy to visualize how 4 stage sharpeners with stage 1 set at 150, stage
2 set at 17 , and
with stages 3 and 4 set at angles of 20 and 22 degrees were commercialized to
sharpen either
or both style knives with primary angles of 15 or 20 . The two stages of 15
and 17 degrees
are used exclusively for 15 degree Asian knives and the last two stages of 20
and 22 degrees
are used exclusively to sharpen the Euro/American 20 style blades. The choice
of these
angles insured that the resulting edge of the sharpened conventional 20 degree
edge would be
not over 22 degrees and the 150 edge would be not larger than 170. What we
have shown
however is that a three stage sharpener with sharpening angles of about 15 ,
about 20 , and
about 22 respectively can be used to create edges or better of equal
sharpness and cutting
ability than a four stage design. In order to realize the improved edge
however with fewer
sharpening stages requires a non-intuitive change in the sharpener design and
sharpening
procedure.
To accomplish this the Asian style knives are sharpened first in just one
dedicated stage ¨ to
create a full primary facet set around 15 , while European American knives are
also
sharpened first in a simple but different dedicated stage set around 20 and
subsequently both
types of edges are refined by creating a tiny microscopic bevel in the third
stage set at about
22 degrees. These tiny bevels are sufficient in size to refine the edge
removing major edge
imperfections, improving the geometric perfection of the edge and increasing
the edge
strength but not so large in size that the superior effective sharpness of the
15 edge is
adversely affected. Although the primary 15 degree facets have a tiny 22
facet at the very
CA 02925533 2016-03-31
7
edge the knife still cuts with the ease of a 150 knife ¨ because the 22 facet
is very small. The
150 wedge action is not significantly disturbed.
The surprising discovery is that the Asian blade can be sharpened well by
using Stages 1 and
3 that are separated by an unconventional large difference on the order of 7
degrees if the
second bevel is kept physically very small. However, in order to achieve an
optimum edge
with this three stage design the length of the second bevel created at about
22 on the Asian
knives in Stage 3 must purposely be microscopically small and created only at
the very tip of
the first stage 150 bevel. By that technique the profile of the Asian edge
facet remains
basically a 15 edge with a very tiny bevel of 22 at the very tip of the
primary 15 bevel as
shown in Figure 3. The length of the 22 bevel must be extremely small and
created with a
fine grain abrasive. This gives the nominal 15 edge essentially the strength
of a
conventional 22 edge that has been highly polished. This necessitates that an
extremely fine
abrasive be used in Stage 3. A micro-sized diamond abrasive is used in stage 3
to create the
exceedingly well formed but microscopic sized facet. The ultra fine abrasive
insures that
only an extremely small facet is formed even if the user makes an excessive
number of passes
of the blade thru that Stage.
In order to optimize performance of this improved three stage procedure
requires careful
selection of the abrasive material and the abrasive grit size. In all stages
it is advantageous to
use diamond abrasives that because of their hardness will hold their shape
well and create the
small facets accurately at the correct angle and size. The grit in Stages 1
and 2 can best be in
the range of 240 to 400 grit to sharpen sufficiently fast, while the abrasive
in Stage 3 should
best be in the range of 600 to 2000 grit to insure the best highly polished
edge. The particle
CA 02925533 2016-03-31
8
size of a 2000 grit abrasive is only about 12 microns which is about 1/4 the
thickness of a
human hair.
As mentioned earlier, the Asian blades with edge facets formed at 150 seem
sharper, that is
they cut with less effort because like a wood splitting wedge, a lower-angle
wedge splits the
wood easier. However experience shows that the 150 splitting wedge becomes
dull faster
than a 200 splitting wedge. The same relationship holds true with 15 and 20
degree edge
knives. The surprising thing is that a very small, virtually microscopic
larger angle bevel can
be placed along the 15 edge to lengthen the life of the edge, to resist
dulling significantly
while retaining the lower cutting effort characteristics of the lower angle
150 blades.
Durability of the 15 blade is increased close to that of a 22 edge without
loss of sharpness
of the edge when cutting foods in the kitchen. This discovery makes it
possible to offer a
sharpener with only 3 stages that can do both 20 and 15 (half angle) knife
edges and yet
improve significantly the durability of the thin 150 edge. In this 3 stage
sharpener it is clear
why the third stage set at about 22 must not be aggressive and therefore must
use a very fine
abrasive disk preferably with a low force being applied between the abrasive
and the knife
edge.
In use the operator of this new sharpener will use Stage I only for Asian
knives to place a
primary facet along their edge. While factory made Asian knives are referred
to here and
elsewhere as 15 degree knives, the angle of their primary cutting edge facets
does indeed vary
widely as sold by their manufacturers, over a range of 14 to 18 degrees
commonly and
occasionally with outliers as small as 100 or as large as 20 . The outliers
can be considered
either as factory mistakes or intentional but these can be found with "Asian"
labels. In this
application any knife with cutting edge angles less than 18 is considered
Asian and in an
CA 02925533 2016-03-31
9
attempt to design for and discuss this wide range we will refer to these
generally as 15 degree
knives. The single facet sharpening stage designed and dedicated here for this
wide range of
Asian knives is perhaps best set somewhere between 12-18 degrees, preferably
15 degrees, in
order to closely approximate the best factory angles that are considered to be
best for Asian
type foods.
Knives classified as European/American likewise have edge angles that vary
widely between
manufacturers and styles but their edge facets are commonly anywhere from 17
to 23 degrees
with outliers well beyond that range. We concluded for the design of this new
sharpener that
the European/American knives that the existing knives are best considered to
be between 17-
23 degrees as they are made for the factory. While knives with edge angles of
about 17-18
degrees can be found with either label on them, knives in that range are
unlikely to be
considered satisfactory by the knowledgeable buyers who want a knife edge that
will be
better suited to cut their particular softer more delicate Asian food or their
Western tougher
more fibrous foods. Our unique sharpener is designed to provide either class
of customer
with the near ideal knife edge angle for their particular food.
In order to implement this novel design principle any of a variety of knife
guiding means or
abrasive configurations can be employed. For example, the guiding means can be
a single
slot in each stage that directs the knife edge simultaneously against one or
more abrasive
elements located on each side of the edge in order to sharpen both edge facets
of a given
knife at once. Alternatively each stage can consist of two knife guiding
slots, the first of
which locates and directs one side of the knife edge, that is one facet
against one or more
abrasive sharpening element in order to sharpen that first facet and then the
knife is placed in
the second knife guiding slot of that stage to locate and direct the opposite
edge facet against
CA 02925533 2016-03-31
one or more sharpening elements at the correct angle in order to sharpen the
opposite facet
running along the knife edge.
In general what we will now describe is an example of a special sharpener
incorporating the
essence of this new sharpening approach. It utilizes special sharpening
elements for
sharpening knives that have a double facet along the cutting edge, comprising
three
sharpening elements each made of a pair of disks mounted on a rotatable shaft
supported by
molded-in bearings that are part of the molded sharpener structure. The
sharpening disks are
faced with an abrasive coated member that has the surface contour of a
truncated cone. The
disks are pressed fitted onto the rotatable shaft with the small ends of the
truncated cones
pressed into contact with each other on the shaft. The abrasive coated members
are metal
stampings pressed with the truncated cone geometry. The body of the disks can
be a plastic
structure that supports the metal stampings and where the disk structure has a
hub-like
configuration that fits snugly on the rotatable shaft.
The physical design of this exemplatory sharpener that incorporates the basic
elements of
this new approach to sharpening both of the popular 15 and 20 degree knives
using this new
and novel 3 stage approach can take many forms. A preferred design is
described here in
detail. Other variations using this principle will be obvious to those skilled
in this area.
Figures 4 and 5 further illustrate this preferred arrangement and design of
multiple
sharpening elements used in this new knife sharpener. These sharpening
elements are of the
type disclosed in US Patent No. 8,043,143. Figure 5 is an elevation of the
arrangement and
the plan view is seen in Figure 4. The basic overall sharpening element 3
incorporated in
Figures 4 and 5 is shown in Figure 6. Each sharpening element 3 comprises
CA 02925533 2016-03-31
11
of two individual sharpening disks 7 which have diamond abrasive coated
surfaces 4
juxtaposed and pairs of these disks 7 are pressed onto a precision steel shaft
5 to form
sharpening element 1 The facing individual diamond coated surfaces 4 have the
nominally
shape of precision truncated cones. The two disks 7 are press-fitted onto the
ground steel
shaft 5 in intimate physical contact at their smaller cylindrical surfaces.
The facing diamond
abrasive coated surfaces 4 of the disks 7 are formed on the surfaces of thin
metal stampings 6
formed with a truncated cone shaped contour. The stampings are mounted in turn
on
precision plastic molded supporting hub 8 that have an exterior contoured
surface that mates
with the interior shape of the metal abrasive coated stampings 6. The shafts 5
of each
sharpening element are supported in bearings 21 and are free to rotate as the
knife is drawn
back and forth to sharpen the edge. The bearings 21 are part of the molded
supporting
structure 13 of the sharpener, Figures 4 and 5.
The molded supporting hubs 8 of the disks are molded with a precision interior
diameter
cylindrical hole to be a press fit to the diameter of the shaft 5 that can
have a slight knurling
to make a better fit to shaft 5. The path of the knife edge when sharpening
follows broken
line a-a (Figure 6) as the knife is pulled across the element 3 so that one
facet of the knife is
abraded on the left disk 7 and the right facet is abraded on the right disk 7.
The knife edge
passes through at a non-perpendicular angle to shaft 5. Such angle is
preferably in the range
of 10-15 degrees off axis.
The plastic molded hubs 8 of the sharpening disks have around their perimeter
one or more
indexing tabs 9 to insure that each of the metal stampings, which has
corresponding slots on
their diameter will fit snugly into the tabs 9 in order to prevent rotation of
the abrasive coated
stampings on their supporting molded hubs 8. Alternatively or in addition the
stampings can
CA 02925533 2016-03-31
12
be held onto the molded support 7 with an adhesive. The angle of the surfaces
of the abrasive
coated truncated cone shaped surfaces are customized in each stage to sharpen
the knife
facets at precisely the appropriate angle for each stage.
Figures 4 and 5 show for example, how the special sharpening elements 3 are
arranged to
implement this new sharpener and sharpening concept. The orientation and
alignment of the
blade edge is shown as a broken line in Stages 1, 2 and 3 and are marked A-A,
B-B, and C-C,
respectively. Asian 15 degree knives would be sharpened in Stage 1 and Stage 3
while
Euro/American 20 degree knives would be sharpened in only Stages 2 and 3. The
truncated
abrasive surfaced disks of Stage one (1) would be precisely shaped and coated
with an
appropriate abrasive sized to create quickly a full primary facet commonly in
the range of 12
to 18 degrees, and preferably 15 degrees, to optimize the edge angle for Asian
blades. The
truncated abrasive surfaced disks of Stage two (2) would be shaped and coated
with an
abrasive sized to quickly place a full primary facet on European/American
style blades
optimally within the range of 17 to 23 degrees, and preferably 20 degrees, to
optimize the
edge angle for these quite different blades to be used by the consumer for a
different task than
the Asian blades. The abrasive surfaced disks of Stage three (3) would be
shaped and coated
with an ultrafme abrasive to create the ultra small secondary facet (bevel)
along each side of
the edge, regardless of whether it be an Asian or European/American blade
edge. That small
facet would be placed at an angle close to, but larger than the angle of Stage
2, by perhaps 2
to 4 degrees. Preferably the angle in Stage 3 would be 22 degrees.
Figures 7 and 8 show the exterior design and appearance of one sharpener that
employs the
arrangement of sharpening elements as shown in Figures 4 and 5. The sharpening
Stages 1, 2
and 3 employ vertical slots 15, 17 and 19 respectively in Figures 7 and 8 to
guide the knife
CA 02925533 2016-03-31
13
blades as they are pulled manually across the sharpening elements that are
shown in Figures
4 and 5. In this arrangement and design both facets of the knife edge
structure are sharpened
simultaneously. Alternative manual designs of the sharpening elements such as
abrasive
pads, interdigitating pads of US Patent No. 5,390,431 or multiple crossed
abrasive, skiving,
or steeling elements can be used to sharpen or condition the knife edges in 3
stage manual
sharpening arrangements using the novel 3 stage procedure disclosed here to
professionally
sharpen both Asian and European/American knives in the same sharpener and
realize
factory quality edges. Other designs that incorporate different knife guiding
means to
individually and sequentially sharpen the right and left facets, one at a
time, can be
considered for knives that have single sided edges, such as the traditional
Asian knife out of
Japan. See US Patent No. 5,404,679 for example.
To sharpen a knife in this novel combination of three (3) stages the user
must, if he has an
Asian knife, sharpen the Asian knife first in Stage 1 to develop a full 15
degree edge facet
along each side of the edge. The abrasive in Stage 1 is sufficiently
aggressive to sharpen the
facets fairly quickly leaving a primary facet of 15 . The user of this type
knife must not
sharpen in Stage 2 if he wishes to maintain the cutting properties of his
normal 15 edge.
Instead he moves the knife to Stage 3 where he micro-hones the edge gently
with a very
fine micron sized abrasive, preferably diamond, set at for example at 22
degrees. The very
fine particle sized abrasive insures creation of a microscopically small
facet, but a well
formed facet along the tip of the large primary edge facet. The facet is small
enough that it
does not significantly alter the geometry of original primary 150 facet along
the edge - thus
insuring the nominal 15 wedge acting shape of the edge is left intact. This
small micro-
facet at 22 is sufficient to strengthen the 15 (half angle) edge and
increase its durability to
CA 02925533 2016-09-15
14
that comparable to a 20 edge. The larger angle at the very edge makes it more
difficult for
the cutting action to bend over the edge structure, which is the most common
mode of edge
failure.
The physical arrangements of the sharpening abrasive plates and the knife
guiding means to
establish the sharpening angles can, for example be similar to those described
in US Patent
No. 5,390,431 and US Patent No. 5,582,535, but other configurations are wholly
practical.
Other configurations are possible.
Figures 4-10 illustrate a manual knife sharpener in accordance with this
invention. As
noted, the knife sharpener incorporates many of the principles of the electric
knife
sharpener described in co-owned US Patent Application Publication No. US
2009/0233530.
The knife sharpener also utilizes sharpening elements of the type described in
co-owned US
Patent No. 8,043,143. As illustrated the manual sharpener includes three
states designated
by the numbers 1, 2 and 3 in Figures 4-6. In each of these stages the
appropriate sharpening
elements and guide surfaces G, as shown in Figure 7, would be provided to
sharpen the
knife blade in the previously described manner.
