Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02941683 2016-09-09
CONVERSION OF CLARIFIER TO SUCTION PIPE SYSTEM
SPECIFIC \TIC) N
Background of the Invention
This invention is concerned with wastewater treatment
systems. In particular, the invention encompasses a conversion
of a suction duct clarifier to a suction pipe clarifier in an
efficient manner without the need for penetrating the floor of
the clarifier tank.
Suction duct clarifiers do not elevate sludge collected by
the rake arms, but instead include horizontal pipes that convey
raked sludge into a center sludge collection drum that surrounds
the center influent column, is sealed against the column and
rotates along with the rake arms. A floor opening is located
within the annular space emcompassed by the drum, and this
provides a vertical duct for movement of the sludge from the drum
1
CA 02941683 2016-09-09
,=
down below the floor to a horizontal RAS return pipe that conveys
the sludge out of the clarifier. This pipe is under suction, so
that suction exists in the sludge collection drum and draws the
sludge to that drum from suction ducts supported by the rake
arms.
On the other hand, suction pipe clarifiers include a series
of sludge uplifting pipes on each rake arm, which include
horizontal and vertical sections that deliver sludge ultimately
to an elevated sludge collection box positioned around the center
influent column. Raked and collected sludge rises up through
these pipes and into the sludge collection box, by differential
hydraulic pressure, since the liquid level in the sludge
collection box is lower than the liquid level in the tank. The
collection box rotates along with the rake arms, and is sealed
against the exterior surface of the center influent column. The
influent column includes in its outer wall at least one opening,
usually four, through which sludge from the collection box flows
inwardly into the center of the influent column where it is
delivered into a sludge discharge downpipe. The sludge delivered
to the downpipe does not mingle with influent wastewater rising
up through the influent column.
The sludge travels down the vertical sludge discharge pipe,
which at its lower end extends down into the concrete basin floor
to connect with an under-floor RAS return pipe that conveys the
2
CA 02941683 2016-09-09
sludge out and away from the clarifier. Typically a pump is
provided outside the clarifier to establish suction to help
withdraw this sludge through the RAS pipe.
A significant number of treatment plants have undertaken to
convert an existing suction duct clarifier to a suction pipe
clarifier. To accomplish this requires removal of the equipment,
including the central influent column, from the concrete basin
floor. Then, the concrete must be partly demolished to provide
for a conduit flow path from a new vertical sludge discharge
pipe, for downward flow of sludge and for connecting this pipe
under the concrete surface to the existing horizontal RAS return
pipe a few feet away that will convey the sludge out of the
clarifier. This conversion is disruptive and expensive. All this
is in addition to the addition of a new elevated sludge
collection box such as described above, positioned on the center
column and located centrally inside the clarifier's feedwell.
This is accompanied by a series of sludge uplift pipes connected
to the rake arms to allow raked sludge to be delivered into the
elevated sludge collection box.
Many treatment plants have been hesitant to make this
desirable conversion because of the disruption, time
required, and high cost.
3
CA 02941683 2016-09-09
Summary of the Invention
With the invention the suction duct/suction pipe clarifier
conversion is made much more efficiently, with no need to
penetrate existing concrete. A new sludge discharge vertical
downpipe is provided in a center column/influent column, with a
90' elbow fixed to the bottom end of this pipe before reaching
the tank floor. The elbow opening is oriented horizontally, and
this is welded to a hole formed in the wall of the center column
being installed, so that the RAS vertical discharge pipe is
sealed to the column at that opening or exit port. A sludge
transfer box or SRD (sludge return device) box of the invention
is then secured to the outside of the center column surrounding
the exit port of the downpipe, and this SRD box has a bottom that
is directly over and sealed to the floor around the existing
downward floor channel or conduit that was formerly used to
withdraw sludge from the surrounding sludge collection drum of
the existing suction duct system. Thus, an enclosed volume is
created that includes both the downpipe elbow port and the
floor opening.
In addition, the same changes are made that encompass a
conventional conversion, with the components that are part of a
suction pipe clarifier system. The elevated sludge collection
box is added, surrounding the center column and within the
feedwell and/or energy dissipating inlet. The collection box is
4
CA 02941683 2016-09-09
a rotating component, rotating along with the rake arms and
surrounding the center column. In the sludge collection box is a
steel floor with a seal material at the central opening of the
floor, so as to provide a moving seal against the outside of the
center column. A series of preferably PVC pipes rise up from the
rake arms into the sludge collection box and deliver the sludge
due to a hydraulic head difference between the collection box
and the outside liquid in the tank.
The sludge collection box, which is open to atmospheric
pressure, must deliver the collected, elevated sludge into the
new vertical sludge discharge downpipe that is concentrically
located within the center influent column. Holes are made in the
center column to allow flow, and these holes lead inwardly across
an annular floor to the sludge discharge pipe for discharge. A
doughnut-shaped plate forms this annular floor, welded into the
center column to seal off the wastewater inflow (which is
dispersed into the tank out through exit holes lower in the
center column) from the location where the sludge moves from the
sludge collection box to the vertical sludge discharge pipe.
It is therefore a principal object of the invention to
enable an efficient and inexpensive conversion of a suction duct
clarifier system to a suction pipe clarifier system, without
disturbing the existing concrete floor of the clarifier basin.
This and other objects, advantages and features of the invention
5
CA 02941683 2016-09-09
Will be apparent from the following description of a preferred
embodiment, considered along with the accompanying drawings.
Description of the Drawings
Figure 1 is a perspective view showing components of a prior
art suction duct clarifier system.
Figure 2 is a schematic elevation view showing the
center column and a sludge collection device of the prior art
suction duct clarifier.
Figure 3 is a perspective view showing a portion of a
suction pipe clarifier system.
Figure 4 is a schematic elevation view, partially in
section, showing a conversion according to the invention, from a
suction duct clarifier to a suction pipe clarifier, illustrating
the connections and flow at the bottom of the central center
column.
Figure 5 is a simplified perspective view showing a portion
of the center column and connections at the base end of the
column, in the conversion according to the invention.
Figure 6 is an elevation view showing a clarifier converted
according to the invention, with most of the width of the
clarifier illustrated.
Figure 7 is a schematic plan view, partially in section,
showing an elevated sludge collection box and associated
6
CA 02941683 2016-09-09
components which are part of the clarifier conversion.
Figure 8 is a perspective view showing a portion of
the interior of the sludge collection box.
Description of Preferred Embodiments
Figure 1 is a perspective view showing, in part, a suction
duct clarifier system 10 of the prior art, of the type which can
be converted to a suction pipe clarifier system according to the
invention. The drawing shows a clarifier basin floor 12, rake
arms 14 that rotate and include rakes 16 that rake sludge along
the basin floor, a sludge collection manifold and drum 18 at the
base of a center column 20, the drum 18 being rotatable along
with the rake arms, a large feedwell 22 above the rake arms
(rotatable or stationary), and a drive unit 24 at the top of the
center column, for rotating the movable components. A foot
bridge is also indicated at 26, for access to the drive unit and
other central components for maintenance. Below the rakes 14 is
a sludge suction duct (not shown) that conveys the raked sludge
to the sludge collection drum 18, where the sludge collects to
be discharged out through a discharge port in the floor. The
collection drum 18 is rotatable and has seals engaging against
the floor (the term "floor" as used herein includes a floor
plate, where present) and against the center column 20.
Figure 2 is a schematic elevation view showing some of the
7
CA 02941683 2016-09-09
components at the base of the center column 20. The sludge
collection drum 18 surrounds the center column and is sealed
against the column at seals 30, and also sealed at 31 against the
basin floor 12. A rake arm 14 is indicated at right, and sludge
flow via a suction duct from the rakes into the drum 18 is
indicated schematically at 28. The interior of the drum 18 is
under suction, which draws the sludge into the drum.
The collected sludge inside the drum 18 is discharged at 32,
through a floor port. The sludge descends to a RAS return (exit)
pipe 34, to be delivered out of the clarifier. A pump, not
shown, typically is located outside the clarifier, drawing
suction on the RAS return pipe 34 and thus to the drum 18.
Figure 3 shows a portion of a suction pipe clarifier 40
which is the object of the conversion described herein. Figure 3
shows the general layout of this type of clarifier system.
Instead of transferring sludge from the rakes 42 with horizontal
pipes just above the basin floor to a central collection drum at
the floor, this type of clarifier omits the collection drum, and
the raked sludge flows up to an elevated sludge collection box
44. An outer edge of the collection box can be seen in the
drawing, the box being preferably rectangular in shape. The
sludge arrives via a series of sludge lift pipes 46, rising from
positions adjacent to the rake arms and then through horizontal
pipe sections 46a and then upwardly to the interior of the sludge
8
CA 02941683 2016-09-09
collection box 44, up through the floor of the box. In Figure 3
a feedwell is shown at 22, a center column at 20, and the edge
of a infeed dispersion well or EDI (energy dissipating inlet) is
seen at 48, concentric with the center column and the feedwell.
A foot bridge is seen at 50.
Figure 6 (showing a converted clarifier of the invention)
also shows many of these components. The sludge collection box
44, preferably rectangular, is shown at an elevated position,
surrounding the center influent column 20 and rotatable with the
rake arms 42. The sludge rise/ pipes are shown at 46, 46a, and
these pipes ascend at 46b up into the sludge collection box 44 as
discussed above. In Figure 6 the liquid surface is indicated at
52. An upright cage, typically five feet square, is not clearly
seen in the drawing but typically surrounds the center/influent
column and is secured to and rotatable with the rake arms.
With the conversion according to the invention, the sludge
collection box 44 is added, as are the sludge transfer/lift
pipes 46. Sludge flows by differential hydraulic pressure, from
the bottom of the basin up through the pipes 46 to the sludge
collection box 44, with a liquid level inside the box that is
below the liquid level 52 in the tank.
Figure 4, a schematic elevation view, shows an important
feature of the conversion method and system of the invention.
The center column, which is the influent column 20, receives
9
CA 02941683 2016-09-09
influent wastewater from an under-floor influent pipe indicated
at 54. The pipe rises to the floor level, and from there the
influent rises up through the center influent column as indicated
by arrows at 56. The invention includes placement of a new
sludge discharge downpipe 58 into the center of the influent
column, as shown. The original center/influent column will
normally be replaced by a larger-diameter column 20 with this
conversion, to provide adequate influent sludge flow area given
the presence of the discharge pipe 58. This discharge pipe,
which can be, for example, a 24" pipe within a 48" infuent
column, has an elbow 58a at its bottom end, and it terminates at
or extends through a circular hole 60 which is formed in the
wall of the column 20. The end of the discharge pipe 58, 58a is
secured and sealed to the influent column opening 60, preferably
by welding.
The invention takes advantage of the existing floor port 32
of a suction duct clarifier for outflow of sludge from the
clarifier, without the need to penetrate the existing basin
floor 12. A sludge return device (SRD) or box 62 is provided at
exterior of the center column 20 and fixed into place on a base
plate 64. This SRD 62, as also shown in the schematic
perspective of Figure 5, is sealed against the exterior of the
column as well as against the floor, i.e. the base plate 64.
Figure 5 shows that the floor port 32 typically is somewhat box-
CA 02941683 2016-09-09
shaped, with a configuration that may contour to the center
column 20. The SRD 62 preferably is a metal box contoured to fit
closely against the exterior of the center column 20, and it may
have a removable plate at 66 for maintenance (shown removed in
Figure 5).
With the conversion of the invention, the suction duct
clarifier becomes a suction pipe clarifier, in which raked sludge
is elevated to the sludge collection box 44, then flows inwardly
through a wall of the influent column to the discharge pipe or
downpipe 58. From there it flows down the pipe 58 and is
directed by the SRD 62 of the invention down through the existing
floor port 32, down through an existing subfloor channel 32a and
to the existing subfloor sludge return pipe 34. Again, suction
may be applied from an exterior pump to the pipe 34, thereby
helping move the sludge.
An issue that arises in many conversions involve the space
required for the SRD, located at the base of the center column
and against the tank floor. A five-foot square cage usually
surrounds the center column, connected to and rotatable with the
rake arms, a cage of this size being an industry standard to
connect to an industry standard drive mechanism. This is
especially true for clarifiers on the order of about 130 feet
diameter. If the center column has a diameter of four feet, the
five-foot square cage will not be able to rotate around the SRD
11
CA 02941683 2016-09-09
box. One possible solution would be to raise the rake arms
upwardly (by about 27 inches) to clear the SRD, but with a
limited sidewall depth of about 13 feet, and the positioning of
the sludge collection box, the energy dissipating inlet and the
feedwell, there typically is not sufficient vertical space to do
this and properly configure the RAS pipes to maximize clarifier
performance and minimize installation complexity. A solution
according to the invention is to provide the cage with a larger
size at bottom, the portion that rotates around the SRD. For
example, a 7'4" square bottom portion (non-standard size for
clarifier diameters of 30 - 200 feet) of the cage can be
provided, transitioning to the standard five-foot square cage at
a level above the SRD, so that the cage can freely rotate around
the center column and the attached SRD. Typically with the
conversion of the invention all submerged metal components of the
clarifier are replaced, and the new rotating cage is simply
fabricated with a wider bottom section than what is above the
level of the SRD.
Figure 7 is a plan section view indicating some of the
construction details of the newly added sludge collection box 44.
The collection box 44 preferably is rectangular and has an
annular floor 44a that encircles the center column 20 and is
sealed against that column, such as by neoprene seal material
that rubs around the outside of the stationary column as the
12
CA 02941683 2016-09-09
collection box 44 rotates along with the rake arms, riser
pipes, etc.
As shown in Figures 7 and 8, sludge riser pipes 46b enter
the collection box through the floor 44a. The sludge exits these
riser pipes preferably near the bottom, and valves 46c can be
provided for controlling the rate of sludge flow out of each pipe
46b into the interior of the sludge collection box. This can be
via openings as shown in Figure 8, the opening size of each valve
being controlled by a tube fitted within each tube 46b, to either
fully align an inner tube opening with the outer pipe opening, or
partially align the openings, or close the valve by selecting a
non-aligned position. As stated above, the bottom 44a of the
sludge collection box is below the level of liquid in the
clarifier tank, preferably at least two feet or so below, so that
sludge will flow into the box 44 by hydraulic pressure head
differential. The floor 44a of the collection box has a large
central opening, somewhat larger than the exterior of the center
column 20 which remains stationary relative to the rotating
collection box. A seal is made, between the floor 44a and the
column at 44d, and this may be with a flexible, durable material
such as neoprene.
The sludge exits the collection box via the newly added
sludge discharge downpipe 58 which is seen in the schematic plan
view of Figure 7. The downpipe is stationary, and the center
column 20 is stationary. Openings are provided in the center
13
CA 02941683 2016-09-09
column, indicated at 70 in Figure 7, sufficient for flow of
sludge inwardly toward the center of the column 20. The inside of
the center column is sealed off at a level essentially at that of
the collection box bottom 44a (or lower), allowing the sludge
from the box simply to enter the center column, to flow across an
annular floor 72 secured in sealed connections (as by welding) to
the interior wall of the center column 20 and to the upper end of
the sludge discharge downpipe 58. The sludge drops by gravity into
the centrally located downpipe 58.
The center column of a suction duct clarifier nearly always
serves as the influent column, as is depicted in the drawings,
rather than separate, inner influent column being positioned
inside the center column.
With the clarified conversion method and system of the
invention, a suction duct clarifier is converted into a suction
pipe clarifier at minimal cost, without the need for any
penetration or demolition of concrete at the tank floor.
The above described preferred embodiments are intended to
illustrate the principles of the invention, but not to limit its
scope. Other embodiments and variations to these preferred
embodiments will be apparent to those skilled in the art and
may be made without departing from the spirit and scope of the
invention as defined in the following claims.
14
