Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 2958817 2017-02-23
284345
USING AIRCRAFT DATA RECORDED DURING FLIGHT TO
PREDICT AIRCRAFT ENGINE BEHAVIOR
FIELD OF THE IVENTION
[0001] The present invention relates to aircraft engines.
BACKGROUND
[0002] Sensors may measure various aircraft engine parameters. For example, a
sensor
may measure the temperature of exhaust gas as it leaves a turbine. This
information may
be used to facilitate the operation and maintenance of aircraft engines. In
some cases,
exhaust gas temperatures may be used to determine when an aircraft engine
should be
serviced. For example, exhaust gas temperature may be a key metric for
deciding when an
aircraft engine should be removed from an aircraft for servicing and
maintenance
procedures. When a particular engine's exhaust gas temperature exceeds a pre-
determined
limit a certain number of times, the engine may be removed from the aircraft
for safety
reasons ¨ and this can result in substantial costs for engine and/or aircraft
owner.
[0003] Currently, an engine and/or aircraft owner may attempt try to avoid or
reduce
exhaust gas temperature exceedances by manually making decisions and taking
actions
such as assigning more degraded engines to certain airport-pairs (e.g., to
avoid high
external temperatures or short runways). This type of manual approach, which
is generally
based on operator knowledge and his or her past experiences, can be a very
time consuming
and error prone process. Automatically predicting if exhaust gas temperature
will exceed
a certain threshold for a given engine and external conditions may provide
significant
economic and safety improvements. It would therefore be desirable to provide
systems
and methods to facilitate exhaust gas temperature exceedance predictions in an
automatic
and accurate manner.
1
CA 2958817 2017-02-23
284345
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0004] FIG. 1 is a high-level architecture of a system in accordance with some
embodiments.
[0005] FIG. 2 illustrates a method that might be performed according to some
embodiments.
[0006] FIG. 3 illustrates some factors that influence exhaust gas temperature
in accordance
with some embodiments.
[0007] FIG. 4 illustrates a Gaussian mixture model and data points
representing various
engines and conditions according to some embodiments.
[0008] FIG. 5 is a system diagram in accordance with some embodiments.
[0009] FIG. 6 illustrates an interactive graphical user interface display
according to some
embodiments.
[0010] FIG. 7 is block diagram of a probabilistic model platform according to
some
embodiments of the present invention.
[0011] FIG. 8 is a tabular portion of an aircraft data recorded during flight
database
according to some embodiments.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0012] In the following detailed description, numerous specific details are
set forth in
order to provide a thorough understanding of embodiments. However it will be
understood
by those of ordinary skill in the art that the embodiments may be practiced
without these
specific details. In other instances, well-known methods, procedures,
components and
circuits have not been described in detail so as not to obscure the
embodiments.
2
CA 2958817 2017-02-23
284345
[0013] FIG. 1 is a high-level architecture of a system 100 in accordance with
some
embodiments. The system 100 includes an aircraft data recorded during flight
data source
110 that provides information to a probabilistic model platform 150. Data in
the data
source 110 might include, for example, historic engine sensor information
about a number
of different aircraft engines and prior aircraft flights (e.g., external
temperatures, exhaust
gas temperatures, engine model numbers, takeoff and landing airports, etc.).
[0014] The probabilistic model platform 150 may, according to some
embodiments,
access the data source 110, and utilize a probabilistic model creation unit
130 to
automatically create a predictive model that may be used by a probabilistic
model
execution unit 140 to generate a conditional probability distribution 160
(e.g., associated
with a likelihood of exceeding a particular exhaust gas temperature threshold)
that may be
transmitted to various user platforms 170 as appropriate (e.g., for display to
a user). As
used herein, the term "automatically" may refer to, for example, actions that
can be
performed with little or no human intervention.
[0015] As used herein, devices, including those associated with the system 100
and any
other device described herein, may exchange information via any communication
network
which may be one or more of a Local Area Network ("LAN"), a Metropolitan Area
Network ("MAN"), a Wide Area Network ("WAN"), a proprietary network, a Public
Switched Telephone Network ("PSTN"), a Wireless Application Protocol ("WAP")
network, a Bluetooth network, a wireless LAN network, and/or an Internet
Protocol ("IP")
network such as the Internet, an intranet, or an extranet. Note that any
devices described
herein may communicate via one or more such communication networks.
[0016] The probabilistic model platform 150 may store information into and/or
retrieve
information from various data sources, such as the aircraft data recorded
during flight data
source 110 and/or user platforms 170. The various data sources may be locally
stored or
reside remote from the probabilistic model platform 150. Although a single
probabilistic
model platform 150 is shown in FIG. 1, any number of such devices may be
included.
Moreover, various devices described herein might be combined according to
embodiments
3
CA 2958817 2017-02-23
284345
of the present invention. For example, in some embodiments, the probabilistic
model
platform 150 and one or more data sources might comprise a single apparatus.
The
probabilistic model 'platform 150 function may be performed by a constellation
of
networked apparatuses, in a distributed processing or cloud-based
architecture.
[0017] A user may access the system 100 via one of the user platforms 170
(e.g., a personal
computer, tablet, or smartphone) to view information about and/or manage the
probabilistic
model in accordance with any of the embodiments described herein. According to
some
embodiments, an interactive graphical display interface 180 may let an
operator define
and/or adjust certain parameters and/or provide or receive automatically
generated
recommendations (e.g., to improve aircraft engine behavior). For example, FIG.
2
illustrates a method 200 that might be performed by some or all of the
elements of the
system 100 described with respect to FIG. 1. The flow charts described herein
do not imply
a fixed order to the steps, and embodiments of the present invention may be
practiced in
any order that is practicable. Note that any of the methods described herein
may be
performed by hardware, software, or any combination of these approaches. For
example,
a computer-readable storage medium may store thereon instructions that when
executed by
a machine result in performance according to any of the embodiments described
herein.
[0018] At S210, a signal processing unit may access historical aircraft data
recorded
during flight associated with a plurality of aircraft engines and a plurality
of prior aircraft
flights (e.g., from an aircraft data recorded during flight database).
[0019] At S220, metrics may be automatically calculated from the aircraft data
recorded
during flight on a per-flight basis. According to some embodiments, metrics
are further
automatically calculated on a per-airport basis, a per-engine type basis, a
per-engine model
basis, a per-aircraft type basis, and/or a per-aircraft model basis.
[0020] At S230, the system may automatically employ a probabilistic model to
capture
and represent relationships based on the calculated metrics. The relationships
may include,
for example, a number of different engine parameters and flight parameters.
According to
4
CA 2958817 2017-02-23
284345
some embodiments, the probabilistic model comprises a Gaussian mixture model.
As used
herein, the phrase "engine parameter" might refer to, for example, engine
degradation
information, an engine type, and/or an engine model.
[0021] At S240, the system may calculate a conditional probability
distribution for a
particular aircraft engine during a potential aircraft flight based on the
probabilistic model,
engine parameter values associated with the particular aircraft engine, and
flight parameter
values associated with the potential aircraft flight. Note that the
calculation of the
conditional probability distribution might be further associated with a rule-
based model, a
physics-based model, a data-driven model, a statistical model, and/or
artificial intelligence
model (e.g., in addition to and/or instead of the Gaussian mixture model).
[0022] At S250, information may be transmitted (e.g., via a communication port
coupled
to the signal processing unit) to render a display of an indication associated
with the
calculated conditional probability distribution. According to some
embodiments, the
conditional probability distribution represents a likelihood that an exhaust
gas temperature
value will exceed a maximum threshold value during the potential aircraft
flight.
[0023] According to some embodiments, the system may further automatically
generate a
recommended adjustment to at least one of an engine parameter value and a
flight
parameter value based on the conditional probability distribution for the
particular aircraft
engine during the potential aircraft flight. For example, the system might
automatically
recommend that a particular engine not be flown when the external temperature
exceeds a
particular value.
[0024] FIG. 3 illustrates some factors that influence exhaust gas temperature
300 in
accordance with some embodiments. According to some embodiments, the flight
parameters 300 may be associated with environment information, such as wind
information, an external air temperature, humidity information, and/or dust
information.
According to other embodiments, the flight parameters 300 may be associated
with aircraft
information, such as gross weight information, aircraft weight, fuel weight,
passenger and
CA 2958817 2017-02-23
284345
baggage weight, de-rated takeoff information, de-rated climb information, an
aircraft type,
and/or an aircraft model. According to still other embodiments, the flight
parameters 300
may be associated with airport information, such as an altitude, obstacle
clearance
information, runway topology, a runway length, a takeoff airport, and/or a
landing airport.
In still other embodiments, the flight parameters 300 might be associated with
pilot
information, such as de-rated definition information, a company policy, an
airport policy,
an amount of experience (e.g., a number of years, a number of flights, a
number of miles
flown, etc.), and/or Ni manual zone information. Note that embodiments may
combine
some or all of these examples of "flight parameters" 300 and/or other types of
flight
parameters (e.g., hundreds of different parameters) in connection with the
Gaussian
mixture model along with one or more engine parameters, such as engine
degradation
information, an engine type, and/or an engine model. By way of example, the
system may
capture the following data:
P(EGT, Environment, Aircraft, Airport, Engine, Pilot)
where EGT equals the exhaust gas temperature. In this case, a potential use of
the data
might comprise calculating:
P(EGT I Environment, Aircraft, Airport, Engine, Pilot)
[0025] This information may be used in connection with modeling and
calculation of
exhaust gas temperature probability distribution given an independent
variable, such as
aircraft weight at takeoff. FIG. 4 illustrates 400 a Gaussian mixture model
420 and data
points 410 representing various engines and conditions according to some
embodiments.
The data points 410 represent an exhaust gas temperature (in degrees Celsius
along the X
axis) plotted with respect to aircraft weight at takeoff (in tons along the Y
axis) for a given
airport. Although a limited number of data points 410 are displayed in FIG. 4
for clarity,
note that embodiments may include any number of data points 410 (e.g., tens of
thousands
of data points 410). Also note that each data point 410 may represent a flight
from various
6
CA 2958817 2017-02-23
284345
engines and conditions. The distribution might be associated with, for
example, how a
specific airline operates.
[0026] The Gaussian mixture model 420 may be used to represent the data as
follows:
P(EGT, Weight I Airport = XYZ)
which may correspond to a huge decrease in the number of data points 410 the
system may
need to store. For example, wherein the aircraft weight at takeoff is 95 tons
(as illustrated
by the dashed line 430 in FIG. 4):
P(EGT I Airport = SDU, Weight = 95)
decision making may be supported such that the probability 440 of exceeding a
threshold
exhaust gas temperature of 900 C is about 50% (and a decision may be made as
to whether
the weight of the aircraft should be reduced).
[0027] Another application of the proposed model consists of supporting the
investigation
of root cause for past events when exhaust gas temperature exceeded a certain
threshold
value. Given n parameters (xi, i = 1, 2, ..., n) in the model associated to
EGT, n weights (wj,
j = 1, 2, ..., n) may be calculated according to the equations below. The
parameters used in
the calculation are those corresponding to the specific event under
consideration. Weight
wj is associated to the importance of parameter xj in the occurrence of the
event. The greater
the weight, the greater the corresponding parameter importance. Therefore,
evaluation and
comparison of such weights may provide information about the probable root
causes of the
event:
X = [xd, k E [1, 2, ... , n}
= [xk], k E [1, 2, ... , n} - [j)
p(EGT > EGTõ,õx1X)
w, =
p(EGT > EGTõ,,x1X1)
7
CA 2958817 2017-02-23
284345
[0028] FIG. 5 is a system diagram 500 in accordance with some embodiments. In
particular, a data pre-processing and metric calculation 514 may receive
aircraft data
recorded during flight 512 and provide a result to a pre-compute airport-based
Gaussian
mixture model 516. Note that this might be performed only once with historical
data (but
could be updated in case of major changes in airline operation). An airport
Gaussian
mixture model database (mu, sigma, weight) 520 (with one model being
calculated per-
airport) may provide an output to calculate conditional probability given
independent
variables 530 (which might, for example, be selected 540 via an exhaust gas
temperature
calculator tool) to generate a conditional probability distribution 550. The
conditional
probability distribution 550 may be used (along with information from the
airport Gaussian
mixture model database 520 and an exhaust gas temperature 542 selected via the
estimator
tool) by an exceedance probability calculation 560 to generate an exceedance
probability
562.
[0029] In this way, a probabilistic model may be created to support an
airline's decision
making process regarding aircraft engine use and/or assignment. The system may
employ
Gaussian mixture models to capture the relationship between exhaust gas
temperature and
other variables calculated from historical aircraft data recorded during
flight. This
relationship may then be used to derive the probability of exhaust gas
temperature
exceedance given other variables that the airline has the ability to change.
As a result,
time-on-wing may be increased through data analytics, bringing cost avoidance
and less
disruptions to the airline. Note that embodiments may use historical aircraft
data recorded .
during flight to model maximum exhaust gas temperature airborne and its
relationship to
variables that might impact exceedance. These variables might be, for example,
airport-
related, aircraft-related, environment-related, engine-related, and/or pilot-
related (e.g.,
aircraft weight, engine degradation, runway length, pilot experience, external
temperature,
etc.).
[0030] The process may involve the calculation of metrics from aircraft data
recorded
during flight. These metrics may be, for example, calculated on a per-flight
basis. The
8
CA 2958817 2017-02-23
284345
system may then employ Gaussian mixture models to capture and represent
relationships,
which may drastically reduce the number of parameters needed to be stored.
Once a
probabilistic model is created, the system may calculate a conditional
probability
distribution of maximum exhaust gas temperature given the variables that
affect its
exceedance (e.g., parameters known in advance) and, from this distribution,
the system
may obtain a probability of exhaust gas temperature exceeding a given
threshold.
[0031] By changing the independent variables that affect exhaust gas
temperature
exceedance, an operator may receive a different exceedance probability, which
can guide
an airline with respect to the decision making process and potentially
increase time-on-
wing for aircraft engines. That is, exhaust gas temperature is a key metric
for deciding
=
when to remove an aircraft engine removal, and when the number of exhaust gas
temperature exceedances overcomes a certain threshold, the engine needs to be
removed
for safety reasons (generating costs). Incorporating embodiments described
herein, an
airline may have the ability to make decisions based on actual data (rather
than operator
knowledge) giving the airline an ability to act proactively. This may
considerably reduce
the number of exhaust gas temperature exceedances (avoiding costs). Note that
probabilistic models may be very robust given the abundance of aircraft data
recorded
during flight, and the use of historical data may make the models very close
to the real-
world operation and the processing time may be short because the models can be
pre-
calculated.
[0032] Once an airline knows that the exhaust gas temperature exceedance
probability is
high, it might act proactively by, for example: restricting the maximum weight
the aircraft
could transport, re-assigning the engine under investigation to a different
airport with
smaller exceedance probability, restrict takeoffs to certain run-ways,
restrict takeoffs to
certain wind conditions, enforce de-rate, restrict engine use to certain
pilots, and/or change
any other variable affecting exhaust gas temperature exceedance guided by the
probability
calculated using embodiments described herein. Note that some or all of the
steps might
be automatically recommended by the system in view of the appropriate data.
9
CA 2958817 2017-02-23
284345
[0033] According to some embodiments, the system may receive, from an operator
via an
interactive graphical display interface, an adjustment to at least one of an
engine parameter
value and a flight parameter value. The system may then re-calculate the
conditional
probability distribution for the particular aircraft engine during the
potential aircraft flight
based on the probabilistic model in accordance with the adjustment and display
an
indication associated with the re-calculated conditional probability
distribution. For
example, FIG. 6 illustrates an interactive graphical user interface display
600 according to
some embodiments. The display 600 may be associated with an algorithm that
calculates
a conditional probability 610 of exhaust gas temperature given the independent
variables
and the likelihood of exhaust gas temperature being larger than a selected
limit (e.g., 875
C as illustrated by the dashed line 612 in FIG. 6):
P(MAX EGT I T/O Weight = 75, T/O egthdm =0, airport = SDU)
where the value Prob(MAX EGT > 875 C) = 0.24 is illustrated by the shaded
area under
the conditional probability 610 in FIG. 6.
[0034] The display 600 further includes an exhaust gas temperature estimator
620 having
sliders that can be adjusted by an operator to change takeoff weight and
takeoff EGT
margins as desired. EGT margins consist of standard metrics associated to
engine
performance. One example is EGT Hot Day Margin (EGTHDM), which considers the
worst case operating scenario in terms of reaching and EGT exceedance. The
estimator
620 further includes an input box where the operator can enter an exhaust gas
temperature
(e.g., 875 C) and a "Run" icon to begin execution of the algorithm (and a
rending of the
results on the display 600).
[0035] The embodiments described herein may be implemented using any number of
different hardware configurations. For example, FIG. 7 is block diagram of a
probabilistic
model platform 700 that may be, for example, associated with the system 100 of
FIG. 1
and/or the system diagram 500 of FIG. 5. The probabilistic model platform 700
comprises
a processor 710, such as one or more commercially available Central Processing
Units
CA 2958817 2017-02-23
284345
("CPUs") in the form of one-chip microprocessors, coupled to a communication
device
720 configured to communicate via a communication network (not shown in FIG.
7). The
communication device 720 may be used to communicate, for example, with one or
more
remote user platforms. The probabilistic model platform 700 further includes
an input
device 740 (e.g., a computer mouse and/or keyboard to input adaptive and/or
predictive
modeling information) and/an output device 750 (e.g., a computer monitor to
render
display, transmit recommendations, and/or create reports). According to some
embodiments, a mobile device and/or personal computer may be used to exchange
information with the probabilistic model platform 700.
[0036] The processor 710 also communicates with a storage device 730. The
storage
device 730 may comprise any appropriate information storage device, including
combinations of magnetic storage devices (e.g., a hard disk drive), optical
storage devices,
mobile telephones, and/or semiconductor memory devices. The storage device 730
stores
a program 712 and/or a probabilistic model 714 for controlling the processor
710. The
processor 710 performs instructions of the programs 712, 714, and thereby
operates in
accordance with any of the embodiments described herein. For example, the
processor 710
may receive historical aircraft data recorded during flight associated with a
plurality of
aircraft engines and a plurality of prior aircraft flights. Metrics from the
aircraft data
recorded during flight may be automatically calculated by the processor 710 on
a per-flight
basis, and a probabilistic model may be employed by the processor 710 to
capture and
represent relationships based on the calculated metrics, the relationships
including a
plurality of engine parameters and flight parameters. A conditional
probability distribution
may then be calculated by the processor 710 for a particular aircraft engine
during a
potential aircraft flight based on the probabilistic model, engine parameter
values
associated with the particular aircraft engine, and flight parameter values
associated with
the potential aircraft flight, and an indication associated with the
calculated conditional
probability distribution may be displayed.
11
CA 2958817 2017-02-23
284345
[0037] The programs 712, 714 may be stored in a compressed, uncompiled and/or
encrypted format. The programs 712, 714 may furthermore include other program
elements, such as an operating system, clipboard application, a database
management
system, and/or device drivers used by the processor 710 to interface with
peripheral
devices.
[0038] As used herein, information may be "received" by or "transmitted" to,
for example:
(i) the probabilistic model platform 700 from another device; or (ii) a
software application
or module within the probabilistic model platform 700 from another software
application,
module, or any other source.
[0039] In some embodiments (such as the one shown in FIG. 7), the storage
device 730
further stores an aircraft data recorded during flight database 800. An
example of a
database that may be used in connection with the probabilistic model platform
700 will
now be described in detail with respect to FIG. 8. Note that the database
described herein
is only one example, and additional and/or different information may be stored
therein.
Moreover, various databases might be split or combined in accordance with any
of the
embodiments described herein.
[0046] Referring to FIG. 8, a table is shown that represents the aircraft data
recorded
during flight database 800 that may be stored at the probabilistic model
platform 700
according to some embodiments. The table may include, for example, entries
identifying
aircraft engines and historic flight data associated with those engines. The
table may also
define fields 802, 804, 806, 808, 810 for each of the entries. The fields 802,
804, 806, 808,
810 may, according to some embodiments, specify: a flight identifier 802,
engine data 804,
aircraft data 806, airport data 808 and exhaust gas data 810. The aircraft
data recorded
during flight database 800 may be created and updated, for example, when data
is imported
into the system, a new airport is to be modeled, etc.
[0041] The flight identifier 802 may be, for example, a unique alphanumeric
code
identifying a particular aircraft flight that occurred in the past. The engine
data 804 might
12
CA 2958817 2017-02-23
284345
identify a particular engine, a type of engine, an engine model, etc. The
aircraft data 806
might identify a particular aircraft, a type of aircraft, an aircraft model,
etc. The airport
data 808 might identify a particular airport (e.g., with "LAX" representing
Los Angeles
International Airport) and/or a characteristic of the airport (e.g., runway
length, etc.). The
exhaust gas data 810 might represent, for example, a series of temperature
values that were
measured by sensors during the flight associated with the flight identifier
802.
[0042] Thus, some embodiments may provide an automatic and efficient way to
facilitate
exhaust gas temperature exceedance predictions in an accurate manner.
[0043] The following illustrates various additional embodiments of the
invention. These
do not constitute a definition of all possible embodiments, and those skilled
in the art will
understand that the present invention is applicable to many other embodiments.
Further,
although the following embodiments are briefly described for clarity, those
skilled in the
art will understand how to make any changes, if necessary, to the above-
described
apparatus and methods to accommodate these and other embodiments and
applications.
[0044] Although specific hardware and data configurations have been described
herein,
note that any number of other configurations may be provided in accordance
with
embodiments of the present invention (e.g., some of the information associated
with the
databases described herein may be combined or stored in external systems). For
example,
although some embodiments are focused on exhaust gas temperature, any of the
embodiments described herein could be applied to other key engine factors
related to
hardware deterioration, such as engine fuel flow.
[0045] While there have been described herein what are considered to be
preferred and
exemplary embodiments of the present invention, other modifications of these
embodiments falling within the scope of the invention described herein shall
be apparent
to those skilled in the art.
13
