Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02962439 2017-03-23
WO 2016/054495
PCT/US2015/053702
V-AWARE END OF TRAIN DEVICE
BACKGROUND
[0001] End-of-train devices (ETDs) are widely used, in lieu of cabooses,
for
signaling and monitoring purposes in trains that travel on railroads.
Information
monitored by an ETD may include the air pressure of a brake line, battery
condition, as
well as train movement. This information may be transmitted to a crew in a
locomotive
by a battery powered telemetry transmitter. However, existing "dumb" ETDs may
only
provide a visible indication of the rear of a train with a flashing red
taillight. Other rail
vehicles sometimes approach from the rear of the train and may get dangerously
close
to the train. Since an operator of the approaching vehicle is prone to not pay
attention
(or even fall asleep), the approaching vehicle may run into the end of the
train.
Therefore, it is desirable to design additional warning mechanisms for
preventing
collision from the rear.
BRIEF SUMMARY
[0002] The present disclosure generally relates to avoiding rear
collision of rail
vehicles on a railroad using inter-vehicle communications. According to some
aspects
of the present disclosure, a collision avoidance system may comprise an end-of-
train
device and a Vehicle (V)-aware unit on different rail vehicles. An end-of-
train device
may be positioned at about a rear end of a train. The end-of-train device may
be
configured to wirelessly communicate (e.g., using radio frequencies near 400
Megahertz (MHz)) with a rail vehicle that is moving towards the rear end of
the train,
1
CA 02962439 2017-03-23
WO 2016/054495
PCT/US2015/053702
and then detect, based on the communication, a presence of the rail vehicle in
order to
prevent a potential collision between the two.
[0003] In some embodiments, a V-aware unit may be installed at a position
visible to an operator of a rail vehicle. The V-aware unit may communicate
with an
end-of-train device to determine a rough distance between the two vehicles,
and may
then issue a visual or audio warning to the operator against collision hazard
when the
distance drops to or below a pre-determined threshold.
[0004] The "smart" end-of-train devices or units described herein may add
an
extra layer of protection to rail vehicles which are equipped with V-aware
units
described herein. The detection of presence virtually offers rail vehicle
operators the
ability to "see" the end of a train in all types of weather and terrain. The V-
aware unit
and/or the end-of-train device may also have global positioning system (GPS)
and
cellular capabilities for communications with an operational control center.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0005] Reference is now made to the following descriptions taken in
conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
[0006] FIGURE 1 illustrates a perspective view of an exemplary embodiment
of a rear collision avoidance system according to the present disclosure;
[0007] FIGURE 2 illustrates a close-up perspective view of a V-aware unit
shown in FIGURE 1;
2
CA 02962439 2017-03-23
WO 2016/054495
PCT/US2015/053702
[0008] FIGURE 3 is a flowchart illustrating an exemplary process of rail
communication for railroad collision avoidance according to the present
disclosure; and
[0009] FIGURE 4 is a schematic diagram illustrating a general-purpose
computing device that may represent various units and devices disclosed
herein.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0010] Various embodiments of rear collision avoidance systems and
associated
procedures and methods of using such systems according to the present
disclosure are
described. It is to be understood, however, that the following explanation is
merely
exemplary in describing devices, systems, and methods of the present
disclosure.
Accordingly, modifications, changes and substitutions are contemplated.
[0011] FIGURE 1 is a schematic diagram illustrating an exemplary
embodiment
of a rear collision avoidance system 100. Although the present disclosure uses
railroad
as an example application, the disclosed principles may be similarly applied
to any
other appropriate industrial setting. As shown in FIGURE 1, various rail
vehicles, such
as a train 110 and a maintenance vehicle 120 may be travelling on a railroad
102. The
maintenance vehicle 120 may be travelling behind and approaching the train
110,
which may be still or moving. Note that rail vehicles may include other types
of
vehicles such as those capable of travelling on both rail and non-rail roads.
[0012] The train 110 may comprise a locomotive 112 and a number of cars
coupled thereto. For example, a first car 114 may be attached to the
locomotive 112,
and a second (and last) car 116 may be attached to the first car 114. An end-
of-train
3
CA 02962439 2017-03-23
WO 2016/054495
PCT/US2015/053702
device 118 may be attached to the rear end of the car 116. Every two cars may
have a
coupling link (e.g., with signal cables) in between to work as a
communications link.
The end-of-train device 118 may communicate with a head-end device in the
locomotive 112 through all the cars. The end-of-train device 118 may,
alternatively or
additionally, communicate with the locomotive 112 via radio communications.
For
example, if one or more cars (e.g., the car 116) gets decoupled from the
preceding cars,
the end-of-train device 118 may quickly detect this issue (e.g., within 30
seconds), and
may inform the locomotive 112 via radio communications. Thus, the end-of-train
device 118 may be a "smart" unit that sends back data to a crew in the
locomotive via
radio-based telemetry.
[0013] The end-of-train device 118 may have any suitable shape and/or
dimension (e.g., 6 inches by 6 inches by 24 inches). The end-of-train device
118 may
have an electronic unit comprising one or more processors, memories,
transceivers,
etc., that enable functions described herein. The structure of the end-of-
train device 118
may be flexibly configured depending on the application. For example, the end-
of-train
device 118 may be implemented as an end-of-train unit that is coupled to
another
existing end-of-train device (e.g., by inserting Company A's end-of-train unit
into the
data port of Company B's end-of-train unit device). Alternatively, functional
modules
described herein may be integrated in one end-of-train device without
additional add-
ons.
[0014] The rail vehicle 120 may be equipped with a purpose-built Vehicle
(V)-
aware unit 130. The V-aware unit 130 and the end-of-train device 118 together
may
4
CA 02962439 2017-03-23
WO 2016/054495
PCT/US2015/053702
make up the rear collision avoidance system 100. The end-of-train device 118
is also V-
aware in the sense that it communicates with the V-aware unit 130 to detect
its
presence.
[0015] FIGURE 2 provides a close-up view of an exemplary embodiment of
the
V-aware unit 130. The V-aware unit 130, sometimes referred to as a collision
avoidance unit, device, or system, may be a device that communicates with an
end-of-
train device to avoid any potential collision thereof (e.g., by calculating or
estimating a
distance between the V-aware unit 130 and the end-of-train device 118). The V-
aware
unit 130 may comprise, on the outside, a display 131, an audible alarm 132, a
program
setting button 133, a power connection 134, and an antenna connection 135. It
should
be understood that the V-aware unit 130 may further comprise internal
components,
such as processors, memories, transceivers, etc., that work with the external
components.
[0016] As shown in FIGURE 2, the V-aware unit 130 may communicate with
the end-of-train device 118 to detect a presence of the train 110. Suppose an
operator is
driving the vehicle 120 closer and closing towards the train 110. In some
embodiments,
when the V-aware unit 130 gets into a radio coverage range (e.g., 1200 feet)
from the
end-of-train device 118, the V-aware unit 130 may start communicating,
intermettently
or continuously, with at least one transceiver in the end-of-train device 118
over a radio
link for determining at least a distance range between the two. The range
(e.g., 40-50
feet, or 300-350 feet) may depend on communication technology used. For
example,
wireless communications may use radio frequencies near about 400 MHz. Warning
CA 02962439 2017-03-23
WO 2016/054495
PCT/US2015/053702
may start when the estimated vehicle distance is about 40-50 feet. For higher
distance
accuracy, communications may comprise sending and receiving chirp signals in a
radio
frequency band near about 2.4 Gigahertz (GHz).
[0017] The display 131 may start showing a warning message to an operator
of
the rail vehicle 120 at a pre-set distance. The warning message may take any
form (e.g.,
text of "Collision Warning!!!" accompanied by vehicle diagrams). As a result,
the
operator of the rail vehicle 120 may "see" the end of the train 110 in all
types of
weather and terrain, even when when the train 110 is actually beyond a line of
sight.
Transceivers (e.g., GPS, cellular, or radio) on the V-aware unit 130 may be
designed to
have strong output power in order to operate in harsh outdoor environment.
Note that
many of the functions of the V-aware 130 described herein may be similarly
implemented or adapted on the end-of-train device 118. For example, the end-of-
train
device 118 may send data regarding the approaching rail vehicle 120 to an
engineer (or
operator) sitting in the locomotive 112.
[0018] A volume of the audible alarm 132 may be configured higher or
lower
by turning the audible alarm 132. For instance, the audible alarm 132 may be a
standard
off-the-shelf piezo audible alarm with a baffle, which may be turned to
increase or
decrease volume. Audible alarming may also be turned on and off The button 133
may
be used to set, change, or program various settings of the V-aware unit 130.
The power
connection 134 may be wired to vehicle power, e.g., between 18 and 75 direct
current
(DC) volts, that is provided when the vehicle engine is started or the vehicle
electronics
are started. The V-aware unit 130 may have any suitable number of transceivers
6
CA 02962439 2017-03-23
WO 2016/054495
PCT/US2015/053702
coupled to any suitable number of antennas. For example, the antenna
connection 135
may be connected to a coaxial cable, which in turn is connected to an antenna
on the
rail vehicle 120.
[0019] According to some aspects disclosed herein, the V-aware unit 130
may
be used to mitigate accidents by informing the rail vehicle operator of
potential
dangers. The V-aware unit 130 may be installed where the display 131 is in
clear view
of the operator, or at any other appropriate position. The display 131 of the
V-aware
unit 130 may show, in real time, a distance (or estimated distance range)
between the
rail vehicle 120 and the train 110. An estimated or calculated distance may be
updated,
intermittently or in real time, as the rail vehicle 120 becomes closer to, or
further away
from, the train 110.
[0020] Since the end-of-train device 118 may be installed at the rear end
of the
train 110, and the V-aware unit 130 may be installed at a fixed location on
the rail
vehicle 120, determining distances between these objects may have equivalent
forms.
For example, if a distance between the V-aware unit 130 and the end-of-train
device
118 is known, one may easily determine a distance between the head of rail
vehicle 120
and the back of the train 110. A calculated distance may be adjusted depending
on
where the V-aware unit 130 is located on the rail vehicle 120, depending on a
length of
the vehicle 120, or depending on whether the rail vehicle 120 has equipment
mounted
or coupled to its front or rear that extends the length of the vehicle 120.
[0021] The V-aware unit 130 may issue visual alerts and/or audible alerts
to the
host operator when the vehicle 120 is approaching the train 110. Distances at
which
7
CA 02962439 2017-03-23
WO 2016/054495
PCT/US2015/053702
alarms are issued may be flexibly configured, such as 1000, 800, 600, 300,
200, 100,
75, 50, and 25 feet. The alarming distance may depend on a speed of the
vehicle 120,
which may be determined using a GPS module. For example, at higher speeds, the
vehicle 120 may require a longer alarming distance to give sufficient time for
the
operator to act (e.g., apply manual brake to stop the rail vehicle 120).
[0022] When a distance between the V-aware unit 130 and the end-of-train
device 118 drops to or below a certain pre-determined threshold (e.g., 300
feet at high
speeds, or 24 feet at low speeds), alarms may be triggered. The audible alarm
132 may
sound continuously, informing the vehicle operator of a collision hazard.
There may
also be pre-determined audio patterns that intensify as the distance
decreases. For
instance, three beeps may sound when the train 110 is closer than 75 feet, six
beeps
may sound when the train 110 is closer than 50 feet, and beeping may be
continuous
when the train 110 is closer than 25 feet.
[0023] The V-aware unit 130 and/or the end-of-train device 118 may record
and
keep data logs. In an embodiment, when a distance between them drops to or
below a
threshold, a violation of a safety rule may be identified by the V-aware unit
130, or the
end-of-train device 118, or both. A memory may store a data log of violations
of safety
rules. The date and time of each event may be saved in an onboard memory.
Additional
events may be logged when the operator presses a button or makes changes to
configuration settings. Further, data logging may be continuous or triggered
by
violation events. Exemplary events that trigger data logging may include
distance
threshold (proximity of 1000 feet, 600 feet, 300 feet, 75 feet, 50 feet, and
25 feet),
8
CA 02962439 2017-03-23
WO 2016/054495
PCT/US2015/053702
configuration changes, and button presses by the operator. A unit may log the
timestamp at which any of these events had occurred, along with information
about the
event itself
[0024] The V-aware unit 130 and/or the end-of-train device 118 may be
configured to have GPS and cellular modules to communicate with an Operations
Control Center ("OCC"). In some embodiments, data that records violations may
be
reported to an OCC. Data may be transmitted wirelessly over GPS or cellular
communications links. In dark territories where there are no GPS or cellular
links, data
may be transmitted to an OCC via radio communication links (e.g., at about 400
MHz).
The V-aware unit 130 and/or the end-of-train device 118 may, alternatively or
additionally, have transceivers that work near (at and close to) various
frequencies such
as 430 MHz, 220 MHz, 900 MHz, 2.4 GHz, GPS frequencies, and cellular
frequencies.
[0025] Referring back to FIGURE 1, when used with a wayside device 140,
the
end-of-train device 118 may send data to an operator in the locomotive 112
when key
locations are passed. In some embodiments, the wayside device 140 may be
mounted as
along a first rail, a second rail, or both. In some embodiments, for example,
the wayside
device 140 may be a smart tag that is permanently or removably coupled to the
web of
a running rail. The wayside device 140 may also be mounted at a distance away
from
the running rails.
[0026] In practice, sometimes the train 110 (e.g., carrying many freight
cars)
may be several miles long. In this case, the operator in the locomotive 112
may not be
able to determine exactly when the end-of-train device 118 has passed a
certain point
9
CA 02962439 2017-03-23
WO 2016/054495
PCT/US2015/053702
(in a station or a switching yard). For example, when a long train is being
backed up in
a switching yard, the operator may not know exactly when to stop. By placing
the
wayside device in the yard, the operator may prevent the end of the train 110
from
hitting a yard barrier.
[0027] To work with embodiments of collision avoidance systems disclosed
herein, rail personnel including a train crew, a vehicle operator, and
supervisors at an
operations control center ("OCC") may adapt procedural changes. Note that the
procedures and processes are given for example only, thus they may be modified
(e.g.,
some steps omitted and some added) within the principles described herein.
[0028] According to some aspects of the present disclosure,
responsibilities of a
train crew (e.g., in the locomotive 112) may include confirming that an
appropriate
end-of-train device with capabilities described herein is installed and
operational.
[0029] According to some aspects of the present disclosure,
responsibilities of a
vehicle operator (e.g., for the rail vehicle 120) may include the following:
1. Ensure that the vehicle is equipped with a V-aware unit and that the unit
is
operating as designed.
2. When operating an over the road hi-rail vehicle, ensure that a V-aware unit
is turned
off when the vehicle is off tracks (e.g., during transit to a mounting area).
3. When operating a hi-rail dedicated vehicle:
a. Keep a V-aware unit turned on.
CA 02962439 2017-03-23
WO 2016/054495
PCT/US2015/053702
b. Before entering a mainline, call Control Tower for clearance and follow all
proper rail movement rules and regulations.
c. Maintain proper distance while traveling to work area.
[0030] According to some aspects of the present disclosure, OCC employee
responsibilities may include the following:
1. Establish and maintain adequate means of communication with a rail
vehicle
(e.g., maintenance vehicle) during vehicle movement.
2. Prior to maintenance vehicles entering a track, ensure that all vehicles
are
equipped with V-aware units and that the units are operational.
[0031] Embodiments herein may provide a safe procedure for operating rail
vehicles installed with an end-of-train device and a V-aware unit on mainline
tracks.
According to some aspects of the present disclosure, shift supervisor
responsibilities
may include the following:
1. Authorize and assemble work maintenance crew to perform track work.
2. Select a qualified person of the work crew to be designated to
coordinate the
crew activities with a Control Tower and to provide on-track safety for all
members of the work crew. The designated qualified person may request and
initiate a track work block and may comply with the authorities safety
procedures, policies, and standards in order to ensure optimum safety to all
personnel.
11
CA 02962439 2017-03-23
WO 2016/054495
PCT/US2015/053702
[0032] According to some aspects of the present disclosure, vehicle
operator(s)
responsibilities may include the following:
1. Confirm that appropriate personnel are on site.
2. Confirm type of maintenance or repair with the shift supervisor and work
crew.
3. Provide and supervise on-track safety guidelines for all crew members in
and
around the work block.
4. Possess, establish, and maintain adequate means of communications with a
Control Tower and the work crew throughout the maintenance operation.
5. Ensure proper clearance is obtained by a Control Tower before entering
mainline tracks.
6. Ensure that a V-aware unit is installed and operational.
[0033] According to some aspects of the present disclosure, vehicle
operator(s)
may verify that an end-of-train device is equipped with an end-of-train unit
(e.g.,
attached or integrated) prior to leaving a yard or siding. If the end-of-train
device is
equipped with the end-of-train unit, ensure that it is operational and
functioning as
designed.
[0034] According to some aspects of the present disclosure, employees at
a
control tower may establish and maintain adequate means of communications with
maintenance vehicle(s) and operator(s) throughout a maintenance operation. A
control
tower may ensure proper clearance is given to a maintenance vehicle before
entering
12
CA 02962439 2017-03-23
WO 2016/054495
PCT/US2015/053702
the mainline track. A control tower may coordinate all activities with the
maintenance
vehicle via a vehicle operator.
[0035] FIGURE 3 is a flowchart illustrating a process 300 of rail
communication for railroad collision avoidance. The process 300 may be
implemented
in a collision avoidance system (e.g., the system 100), in which a first
vehicle (e.g., the
rail vehicle 120) is equipped with a V-aware unit (e.g., the V-aware unit
130), and a
second vehicle (e.g., the train 110) is equipped with an end-of-train unit
(the end-of-
train device 118). The two vehicles may be operated by different operators and
located
at a distance on the railroad (with second vehicle in front). The V-aware unit
may be
located at a position visible to a first operator, and the end-of-train unit
may be located
at about a rear end of the second vehicle. Note that the process 300 may be
performed
by various devices and personnel, and may not exhaustively list all steps
necessary to
use the system 100.
[0036] To start off at action 302, a first operator who is driving the
first vehicle
may confirm that the V-aware unit located thereon is turned-on and
operational. At
action 304, a second operator who is driving the second vehicle may confirm
that the
end-of-train unit located thereon is turned-on and operational. At action 306,
signals
may be transmitted between the first and second vehicles to generally
determine (e.g.,
calculate or estimate) at least a distance range between the first and second
vehicles.
Signal transmission may more specifically occur between the V-aware unit and
the end-
of-train unit. In some embodiments, transmitting signals between the V-aware
unit and
the end-of-train unit uses at least radio frequencies near 400 MHz or 2.4 GHz.
At action
13
CA 02962439 2017-03-23
WO 2016/054495
PCT/US2015/053702
308, audio and/or visual warnings may be issued to at least one of the first
and second
vehicles against a potential collision between the two. In an embodiment, a
warning
may be issued to the first operator as a displayed message on the V-aware
unit. The
operator may take appropriate actions such as stopping the first vehicle. The
end-of-
train unit may similarly send a warning to an operator of the second device
for actions.
[0037] Methods and processes described herein may be implemented on any
general-purpose computing device or system, such as a computer or a
microcontroller
with sufficient processing power, memory resources, and communication
capabilities to
handle the necessary workload placed upon it. FIGURE 4 is a schematic diagram
illustrating a general-purpose computing device 400 that may represent various
units or
systems disclosed herein. For example, the computing device 400 may be used as
whole or part of the V-aware unit 130 and the end-of-train device 118. The
computing
device 400 may implement one or more embodiments of the methods and processes
disclosed herein, such as the process 300.
[0038] The computing device 400 may comprise a processor 402 (which may
be referred to as a central processor unit or CPU), one or more memory devices
(e.g.,
including secondary storage 404, read only memory (ROM) 406, and random access
memory (RAM) 408), one or more transceivers 410. Although illustrated as a
single
processor, the processor 402 is not so limited and may comprise multiple
processors.
The processor 402 may be a unit capable of data processing, such as one or
more CPU
chips, cores (e.g., a multi-core processor), field-programmable gate arrays
(FPGAs),
application specific integrated circuits (ASICs), digital signal processors
(DSPs), or
14
CA 02962439 2017-03-23
WO 2016/054495
PCT/US2015/053702
combinations thereof. The processor 402 may be implemented using hardware
(e.g.,
circuitry) alone or a combination of software and hardware.
[0039] The secondary storage 404 may be used for non-volatile storage of
data
and as an over-flow data storage device if the RAM 408 is not large enough to
hold all
working data. The secondary storage 404 may be used to store programs that are
loaded
into the RAM 408 when such programs are selected for execution. The ROM 406
may
be used to store instructions and perhaps data that are read during program
execution.
The ROM 406 is a non-volatile memory device that typically has a small memory
capacity relative to the larger memory capacity of the secondary storage 404.
The RAM
408 is used to store volatile data and perhaps to store instructions. Access
to both the
ROM 406 and the RAM 408 is typically faster than to the secondary storage 404.
[0040] A transceiver 410 may serve as an output and/or input device of
the
computing device 400. For example, if the transceiver 410 is acting as a
transmitter, it
may transmit data out of the computing device 400. If the transceiver 410 is
acting as a
receiver, it may receive data into the computing device 400. The transceiver
410 may
work with cables or act as wireless antennas. The transceiver 410 may take the
form of
modems, Ethernet cards, universal serial bus (USB) interface cards, serial
interfaces,
wireless transceiver cards such as code division multiple access (CDMA),
global
system for mobile communications (GSM), long-term evolution (LTE), worldwide
interoperability for microwave access (WiMAX), GPS, and/or other air interface
protocol radio transceiver cards, and other well-known devices capable of
wireless
communications. The transceiver 410 may enable the processor 402 to
communicate
CA 02962439 2017-03-23
WO 2016/054495
PCT/US2015/053702
with other devices via radio, GPS, or cellular interfaces. Input/output (I/O)
devices 412
may include output devices such as a screen display or speaker and input
devices such
as buttons and dial pads.
[0041] It is understood that by programming and/or loading executable
instructions onto the computing device 400, at least one of the processor 402,
the RAM
408, and the ROM 406 are changed, transforming the computing device 400 in
part into
a particular machine or apparatus (e.g., a V-aware unit or an end-of-train
device having
the novel functionality taught herein). It is fundamental to the electrical
engineering and
software engineering arts that functionality that can be implemented by
loading
executable software into a computer can be converted to a hardware
implementation by
well-known design rules. Decisions between implementing a concept in software
versus
hardware typically hinge on considerations of stability of the design and
numbers of
units to be produced rather than any issues involved in translating from the
software
domain to the hardware domain. Generally, a design that is still subject to
frequent
change may be preferred to be implemented in software, because re-spinning a
hardware implementation is more expensive than re-spinning a software design.
Generally, a design that is stable that will be produced in large volume may
be
preferred to be implemented in hardware, for example in an ASIC, because for
large
production runs the hardware implementation may be less expensive than the
software
implementation. Often a design may be developed and tested in a software form
and
later transformed, by well-known design rules, to an equivalent hardware
implementation in an ASIC that hardwires the instructions of the software. In
the same
manner as a machine controlled by a new ASIC is a particular machine or
apparatus,
16
CA 02962439 2017-03-23
WO 2016/054495
PCT/US2015/053702
likewise a computer that has been programmed and/or loaded with executable
instructions may be viewed as a particular machine or apparatus.
[0042] While various embodiments of rear collision avoidance systems and
related methods of using such systems have been described above, it should be
understood that they have been presented by way of example only, and not
limitation.
Thus, the breadth and scope of the present disclosure should not be limited by
any of
the above-described exemplary embodiments, but should be defined only in
accordance
with the following claims and their equivalents. Moreover, the above
advantages and
features are provided in described embodiments, but shall not limit the
application of
the claims to processes and structures accomplishing any or all of the above
advantages.
[0043] Additionally, the section headings herein are provided for
consistency
with the suggestions under 37 CFR 1.77 or otherwise to provide organizational
cues.
These headings shall not limit or characterize the invention(s) set out in any
claims that
may issue from this disclosure. Specifically and by way of example, the
description of a
technology in the "Background" is not to be construed as an admission that
technology
is prior art to any invention(s) in this disclosure. Neither is the "Brief
Summary" to be
considered as a characterization of the invention(s) set forth in the claims
found herein.
Multiple inventions may be set forth according to the limitations of the
multiple claims
associated with this disclosure, and the claims accordingly define the
invention(s), and
their equivalents, that are protected thereby. In all instances, the scope of
the claims
17
CA 02962439 2017-03-23
WO 2016/054495
PCT/US2015/053702
shall be considered on their own merits in light of the specification, but
should not be
constrained by the headings set forth herein.
18
