Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
WO 2018/142114 P(17GB2018/050253
HEATING ELEMENT AND METHOD OF ANALYSING
Technical Field
The present invention relates to a heating element such as for use in an
electronic
vapour provision system or device, for example an electronic cigarette, and
also to a
method for analysing such heating elements.
Background
Aerosol or vapour provision devices such as e-cigarettes generally comprise a
reservoir of a source liquid containing a formulation, typically including
nicotine, from
which an aerosol is generated, such as through vaporisation or other means. To
achieve
vaporisation, a vapour provision system may include a heating element coupled
to a
portion of the source liquid from the reservoir. The temperature of the
heating element is
raised, such as by passing an electrical current from a battery through the
heating
element, and source liquid in contact with the heating element is vaporised.
For example,
a user may inhale on the system to activate the heating element and vaporise a
small
amount of the source liquid, which is thus converted to an aerosol for
inhalation by the
user.
Operation of a heating element of this type relies on the phenomenon of
resistive
heating, where the electrical resistance of the heating element produces a
temperature
rise when a voltage is applied across the heating element to cause current to
flow through
it. Heating elements for e-cigarettes often comprise a conductive metal wire,
formed into a
shape such as a coil. A porous element such as a fibrous wick is arranged in
contact with
the heating element (for example, the heating element is a wire wound around a
rod-
shaped wick) and also in contact with source liquid in the reservoir.
Capillary action or
wicking in the porous element carries liquid from the reservoir to the heater
for
vaporisation.
It has been proposed that the heating and the wicking be combined into a
single
component. For example, if the heating element is fabricated from a sheet of
electrically
conductive porous material such as a metal mesh or grill, apertures in the
porous
structure provide a capillary action to draw liquid from the reservoir
directly into the
heating element for vaporisation by heating when a current flows through the
material.
The structure of a conductive mesh may produce irregular resistive properties,
leading to uneven heating which may impact vapour production.
Accordingly, characterisation of conductive porous sheet material according to
its
suitability for use as a resistive heating element is of interest.
Summary
According to a first aspect of certain embodiments described herein, there is
provided a method for obtaining a heating element for an electronic vapour
provision
1
CA 3051320 2019-07-23
WO 2018/142114 PCT/C 132018/050253
system, the method comprising: providing a sheet of electrically conductive
porous
material; measuring amounts of light transmitted through at least two
locations on the
sheet to obtain a set of optical transmission values including a maximum value
and a
minimum value; comparing a difference value calculated from the maximum and
minimum
values with a predetermined acceptable variation in optical transmission; and
selecting
the sheet for use as a heating element if the difference value falls within
the acceptable
variation.
For example, the difference value may be the difference between the maximum
value and the minimum value, and the predetermined acceptable variation is a
largest
acceptable range in the measured optical transmission values which the
difference value
should not exceed. The difference value may be expressed as a percentage,
proportion
or fraction, and the largest acceptable range is defined as a percentage,
proportion or
fraction of the maximum value or the minimum value of optical transmission
measured for
the sheet. The largest acceptable range may be not greater than 10% of the
maximum
value, for example
In another example, the difference value may be at least one of a difference
between the maximum value or the minimum value and an average value of the set
of
optical transmission values, and the predetermined acceptable variation is a
largest
acceptable deviation of the maximum value and/or the minimum value from the
average
value which the difference value should not exceed. The difference value may
be
expressed as a percentage, proportion or fraction, and the largest acceptable
deviation is
defined as a percentage, proportion or fraction of the average value of the
set of optical
transmission values measured for the sheet. The largest acceptable deviation
may be not
greater than 5% of the average value, for example.
In another example, the difference value is the percentage, proportion or
fraction
of the maximum value represented by the minimum value, and the predetermined
acceptable variation is a minimum acceptable value of this percentage. The
minimum
acceptable value may be at least 90% of the maximum value, for example.
The electrically conductive porous material may comprise a mesh of metal
fibres,
such as a mesh of sintered stainless steel fibres.
The method may further comprise determining the acceptable variation in
optical
transmission using a known relationship between optical transmission and
electrical
resistance for the electrically conductive porous material.
According to a second aspect of certain embodiments described herein, there is
provided a heating element for an electronic vapour provision system or a
blank for
forming a heating element for an electronic vapour provision system,
comprising a sheet
of electrically conductive porous material having an optical transmission
profile in which a
2
CA 3051320 2019-07-23
WO 2018/142114 PCT/GB2018/050253
minimum value of optical transmission is at least 90% of a maximum value of
optical
transmission.
According to a third aspect of certain embodiments described herein, there is
provided a heating element for an electronic vapour provision system or a
blank for
forming a heating element for an electronic vapour provision system,
comprising a sheet
of electrically conductive porous material having an optical transmission
profile in which a
difference between a minimum and a maximum value of optical transmission is
not more
than 10% of the maximum value.
According to a fourth aspect of certain embodiments described herein, there is
provided a heating element for an electronic vapour provision system or a
blank for
forming a heating element for an electronic vapour provision system,
comprising a sheet
of electrically conductive porous material having an optical transmission
profile in which
either or both of a maximum and minimum value of optical transmission differs
from an
average value of optical transmission by not more than 5%.
The electrically conductive porous material may comprise a mesh of metal
fibres,
for example a mesh of sintered stainless steel fibres.
These and further aspects of certain embodiments are set out in the appended
independent and dependent claims. It will be appreciated that features of the
dependent
claims may be combined with each other and features of the independent claims
in
combinations other than those explicitly set out in the claims. Furthermore,
the approach
described herein is not restricted to specific embodiments such as set out
below, but
includes and contemplates any appropriate combinations of features presented
herein.
For example, a heating element and associated method may be provided in
accordance
with approaches described herein which includes any one or more of the various
features
described below as appropriate.
Brief Description of the Drawings
Various embodiments will now be described in detail by way of example only
with
reference to the accompanying drawings in which:
Figure 1 shows a schematic plan view of an example electrical heating element
to
which embodiments can apply;
Figure 2 shows a schematic side view of example apparatus suitable for
carrying
out methods according to embodiments;
Figure 3 shows a graph of an example relationship between optical transmission
and electrical resistance;
Figure 4 shows images of porous conductive sheet material (Figures 4A and 4B)
and corresponding 2D intensity contour maps (optical transmission profiles)
derived from
the images (Figures 4C and 4D):
3
CA 3051320 2019-07-23
WO 2018/142114 PCT/G132018/050253
Figure 5 shows a scatter graph of measured average intensity values against
measured electrical resistance for multiple sample heating elements;
Figure 6 shows a graph of an example 1D optical transmission profile of a
sample
of porous conductive sheet material;
Figure 7 shows a schematic side view of a further example apparatus suitable
for
carrying out methods according to embodiments; and
Figure 8 shows a flow chart of steps in an example method.
Detailed Description
Aspects and features of certain examples and embodiments are discussed /
described herein. Some aspects and features of certain examples and
embodiments may
be implemented conventionally and these are not discussed / described in
detail in the
interests of brevity. It will thus be appreciated that aspects and features of
apparatus and
methods discussed herein which are not described in detail may be implemented
in
accordance with any conventional techniques for implementing such aspects and
features.
As described above, the present disclosure relates to (but is not limited to)
heating
elements suitable for use in electronic aerosol or vapour provision systems,
such as e-
cigarettes. Throughout the following description the terms "e-cigarette" and
"electronic
cigarette" may sometimes be used; however, it will be appreciated these terms
may be
used interchangeably with aerosol (vapour) provision system or device.
Similarly,
"aerosol" may be used interchangeably with "vapour".
One type of heating element that may be utilised in an atomising portion of an
electronic cigarette (a part configured to generate vapour from a source
liquid) combines
the functions of heating and liquid delivery, by being both electrically
conductive (resistive)
and porous. An example of a suitable material for this is an electrically
conductive
material such as a metal or metal alloy formed into a fine mesh, web, grill or
similar
configuration having a sheet format, i.e. a planar shape with a thickness many
times
smaller than its length or breadth. The mesh may be formed from metal wires or
fibres
which are woven together, or alternatively aggregated into a non-woven
structure. For
example, fibres may be aggregated by sintering, in which heat and/or pressure
are
applied to a collection of metal fibres to compact them into a single mass.
These structures can give appropriately sized voids and interstices between
the
metal fibres to provide a capillary force for wicking liquid. The material is
therefore porous.
Also, the metal is electrically conductive and therefore suitable for
resistive heating,
.. whereby electrical current flowing through a material with electrical
resistance generates
heat. Structures of this type are not limited to metals, however; other
conductive materials
may be formed into fibres and made into mesh, grill or web structures having
porosity and
4
CA 3051320 2019-07-23
WO 2018/142114 PCT/C132018/050253
resistivity. Examples include ceramic materials, which may or may not be doped
with
substances intended to tailor the physical properties of the mesh.
Figure 1 shows a plan view of an example heating element of this format. The
heating element 10 is generally rectangular, with two long sides and two short
sides, and
planar in that its thickness into the plane of the page is many times smaller
than its length
or its width in the plane of the page. In use within an e-cigarette, it is
mounted across an
air flow channel 12 so that air travelling along the channel 12 flows over the
surface of the
element 10 to collect vapour. The thickness of the heating element 10 is
orthogonal to the
direction of air flow, shown by the arrows A. The heating element 10 is
mounted such that
its edge portions 13 along the long sides extends through a wall or walls
defining the
airflow channel 12, and into a reservoir of source liquid 14 held in an
annular space
surrounding the airflow channel 12. Capillary action draws liquid 14 from the
reservoir
towards the central region of the heating element, At its short edges, the
heating element
10 has shaped connector portions 16 which are connected to electrical leads or
other
conducting elements (not shown) configured to pass electrical current through
the heating
element 10 to generate the required resistive heating, indicated by the arrows
I. The
heating element 10 has a series of slots 18 along its long sides, orthogonal
thereto. These
act to modify the current flow path away from a straight path between the
connector
portions 18 since the current is forced to flow around the ends of the slots.
This alters the
current density in these areas to form regions of a higher temperature that
can be
beneficial in producing a desirable vaporisation action.
The heating element 10 may be formed by stamping or cutting (such as laser
cutting) the required shape from a larger sheet of porous material.
The present invention is not limited to heating elements of the size, shape
and
configuration of the Figure 1 example, however, and is applicable widely to
heating
elements formed from planar porous conductive materials.
Heating elements of this type may be made from a conductive material which is
a
nonwoven sintered porous web structure comprising metal fibres, such as fibres
of
stainless steel. For example, the stainless steel may be AISI (American Iron
and Steel
Institute) 316L (corresponding to European standard 1.4404). The material's
weight may
be in the range of 100 ¨ 300 g/m2. Its porosity may be greater than 50%, or
greater than
70%, where porosity is the volume of air per volume of the material, with a
corresponding
density less than 50% or less than 30%, where density is the volume of fibres
per volume
of the material. Thickness of the material may be in the range of 75 ¨ 250 pm.
A typical
fibre diameter may be about 12 pm, and a typical mean pore size (size of the
voids
between the fibres) may be about 32 pm. An example of a material of this type
is Bekipor
5
CA 3051320 2019-07-23
WO 2018/142114 PCT/G132018/050253
(RIM) ST porous metal fibre media manufactured by NV Bekaert SA, Belgium,
being a
range of porous nonwoven fibre matrix materials made by sintering stainless
steel fibres.
Again, the present invention is not limited to heating elements made from this
material, and is applicable widely to heating elements made from planar porous
conductive materials. Note also that while the material is described as
planar, this refers
to the relative dimensions of the sheet material and the heating elements (a
thickness
many times smaller than the length and/or width) but does not necessarily
indicate
flatness, in particular of the final heating element made from the material. A
heating
element may be flat but might alternatively be formed from sheet material into
a non-flat
shape such as curved, rippled, corrugated, ridged, formed into a tube or
otherwise made
concave and/or convex.
A consequence of manufacturing processes such as weaving and sintering to
make woven or nonwoven porous web structures from conductive fibres is that
the
material may have an uneven density of fibres, giving an inhomogeneous
structure and
leading to uneven electrical resistivity across a sample of the material. Any
irregular
resistivity, i.e. localised regions with higher or lower resistivity than the
average resistivity
for a sample of the material, will produce a corresponding irregularity in
resistive heating,
in that higher resistance regions will become hotter than average and lower
resistance
regions will be cooler than average. For an application such as vaporisation
of source
liquid in an electronic cigarette that relies on heating to a specified
temperature (or range
of temperatures for a tailored pattern of current density across a heating
element) to
produce a required level of vaporisation, irregularities of resistance across
a heating
element can be undesirable. A homogeneous structure having consistent
resistance may
be more suitable. Completed electronic cigarette devices may fail product
testing after
manufacture if it is found that the heating element produces uneven heating
not
corresponding to a specified heating profile. Techniques for identifying in
advance heating
element material with appropriate resistive properties are therefore of
interest, allowing
unsuitable material to be rejected before it is incorporated into a complete
device or
component therefore. Also, characterisation of the material via a property or
properties
that relate to its suitability for use in fabricating heating elements is also
of interest.
The present invention utilises a recognition that a homogeneous physical
structure
and corresponding homogenous resistance across a sample of porous conductive
material can give rise to other homogenous properties that can be used to
characterise a
sample, for example as being more or less suitable for use as a heating
element. In
particular, optical transmission properties have been found to correlate to
electrical
resistance properties. Consequently, samples of porous conductive material
with
homogenous optical transmission, that is optical transmission with a low
variability across
6
CA 3051320 2019-07-23
WO 2018/142114 PCT/C132018/050253
the sample (such as falling within a small predetermined range), can be
recognised as
also having homogenous or near-homogeneous resistance.
It has been found that the optical transmission of a porous conductive web
material is indicative of its electrical resistance. Optical transmission is
the fraction or
proportion of an incident light intensity which is transmitted through an
object or part of an
object. The web of conductive fibres comprises voids and apertures and is not
solid, and
hence allows some light to pass through, so its optical transmission can be
measured. A
denser web will transmit a lower fraction of incident light than a more open
web. Also, a
more dense web contains more metal fibres and therefore has a lower resistance
whereas conversely a more open web contains fewer metal fibres and has a
correspondingly higher resistance. On combining these two properties, it has
been found
that there is a relationship between transmitted light intensity and
electrical resistance, for
samples of the same web material exposed to the same level and wavelength of
incident
light. Each sample has an optical transmission characteristic (amount of light
it will
transmit) and a value of electrical resistance, and these two properties are
related. The
optical transmission is proportional to the electrical resistance. For a
predetermined and
fixed illumination set-up, transmission is equivalent to the absolute amount
of transmitted
light, so the measured light intensity is also proportional to the electrical
resistance. In the
following, the terms "transmission" and "intensity" may be used
interchangeably, except
where a particular meaning is specified.
Optical transmission is proportional to electrical resistance, and each of
these
properties is applicable to the entirety of a sample of conductive sheet
material (where
averages values for the properties can be derived). Additionally, the
properties can be
considered on a smaller scale by considering how the properties vary across
the sample.
The variation arises owing to the fibre-based structure of the materials of
interest, in that
local fibre density may vary and not be consistent at all points within a
sample.
Consequently, both optical transmission and electrical resistance may show a
variation
across a sample, with the variations of the two properties being correlated
owing to the
proportional relationship. A large variation may indicate that a sample of
material is not
suitable for use in fabricating one or more electrical heating elements,
because the
resistance variation will produce uneven heating, with hot and cold spots
being generated
when current is passed. However, optical transmission variation may be more
convenient
to measure than the variation of resistance. Accordingly, the optical
transmission
characteristic of a sample of conductive porous sheet material may usefully be
used to
specify its suitability for use in fabricating heating elements for electronic
vapour provision
systems.
7
CA 3051320 2019-07-23
WO 2018/142114 PCT/G 132018/050253
The variation of a physical property across a sample (being the difference
between local values of that property) can be considered as a profile. For a
planar
sample, the property might be measured (or sampled, detected or recorded) at
multiple
(at least two) locations across the length and width of the sample so as to
give a two-
dimensional profile. The locations might be arranged as a regular array over
the sample
surface, or may be a random selection of locations scattered over the sample.
Alternatively, a one-dimensional or linear profile might be obtained by
measuring the
property at a series of points along a line or path (which may or may not be
straight)
extending across the sample's length or width, where the points are regularly
or irregularly
spaced. A larger quantity of measurement locations will give a more detailed
profile, but a
smaller quantity of measurements can be obtained and processed more quickly
and may
adequately represent the sample's properties within the required precision of
the
fabrication process. Accordingly, a profile obtained by any of these
techniques (or indeed
other techniques that will be evident to the skilled person) may be used
within
embodiments of the present invention, where the profile of interest is a
profile of optical
transmission, representing a plurality of measurements of optical transmission
obtained at
locations over the surface of a sample of porous conductive material. In any
case, the
profile is a spatial profile representing the spatial variation of optical
transmission.
For a given design of electrical heating element, a range of values of
acceptable
electrical resistance might be defined. For ease, an acceptable value may be
defined as
an average value, representative of resistance across the sample. However, a
measured
average value which is found to fall within the acceptable range may mask a
large
variation in the resistance profile over the sample, in that some positions
might have a
local resistance that deviates greatly from the acceptable value. Such a
sample will
generate patchy uneven heating, and therefore will likely be considered
unsuitable for use
as a heating element.
Therefore, for any resistivity specification, in addition to defining a
required
absolute value of resistance (which may or may not be an average value), one
can define
a variation or tolerance about the absolute value that represents a variation
of local
resistance values across the whole sample which can be tolerated in terms of
requirements for even heating. For example, it is possible to define an
acceptable amount
of resistance above and below the required value, or a maximum acceptable
difference
between highest and lowest resistance values. The smaller the range of
acceptable
values, the more homogeneity is specified for a sample.
Using the proportionality between electrical resistance and optical
transmission
noted above and discussed further below, this requirement for homogenous
resistance
can be translated into a requirement for homogenous optical transmission
(which
8
CA 3051320 2019-07-23
WO 2018/142114 PCT/GB2018/050253
represents the homogeneity of the physical structure of the sample material).
The optical
transmission profile of a sample indicates the degree of homogeneity in
optical
transmission, where the difference between highest and lowest values in the
profile
represents the variation in optical transmission, and a smaller difference
indicates higher
homogeneity (a more consistent physical structure).
Accordingly, embodiments of the invention define that a sample of planar
conductive porous material has an optical transmission profile in which the
lowest
(minimum) value of optical transmission is at least 90% of the highest
(maximum) value of
optical transmission. Instead, one may define that the range of the optical
transmission
profile, being the difference between the highest and lowest values, is not
more than 10%
of the highest value. For example, the lowest value may be 90% of the highest
value, or
may be at least 91% of the highest value, or at least 92% of the highest
value, or at least
93% of the highest value, or at least 94% of the highest value, or at least
95% of the
highest value, or at least 96% of the highest value, or at least 97% of the
highest value, or
at least 98% of the highest value, or at least 99% of the highest value.
Alternatively, the optical transmission profile for a sample may be specified
as
comprising highest and lowest values which differ by no more than 5% of an
average
optical transmission value for the profile, where the average may be
calculated, for
example, from all values included in the profile, or from a subset of values
included in the
profile, or from all values available for the sample or from a subset of all
values available
(where the profile may or may not include all available values). Other
averages may be
used if preferred. For example, the highest and lowest values may differ by no
more than
4% of the average, or by no more than 3% of the average, or by no more than 2%
of the
average, or by no more than 1% of the average.
Individual heating elements or portions of material appropriately sized for
processing into individual heating elements which have already been separated
from a
larger sheet of material may have an optical transmission specification
falling within these
definitions. Also, regions of a larger sheet of material that have an
appropriate optical
transmission profile, for example according to the above definitions, may be
identified as
areas from which individual heating elements with suitable resistance values
can be
formed.
Figure 2 shows a schematic representation of example apparatus suitable for
measuring optical transmission of a sheet of porous conductive material. The
apparatus
comprises an optical (light) source, an optical (light detector), and a means
to arrange a
sample for measurement between the source and the detector. More specifically,
in this
example a sample 10a of heating element material (already configured as a
single heater
10, or a larger sheet) is placed in position for measurement. Results may be
enhanced if
9
CA 3051320 2019-07-23
WO 2018/142114 PCT/GB2018/050253
the sample is held in a flat position generally perpendicular to the incident
light, so if the
sample shows some curling, wrinkling or other deformation (such as if it has
been cut
from a roll of material), it may be placed between two sheets 20 of clear
plastic or glass,
and secured by clamping. The sheets can be chosen to minimise optical loss
through
them, such as with reference to the optical characteristics of the sheet
material for the
wavelength of light emitted from the source 22, and/or by using very thin
material. In this
way, the proportion of the optical change arising from transmission through
the heating
element sample 10 is maximised, to improve resolution of the test.
The sample 10a is placed over a light source 22, which emits light at a first
intensity 11 which is incident on the lower side of the sample 10a. The sample
10a
occupies a finite area (i.e. it is not a point) and to record an optical
transmission profile it
is necessary to obtain transmission values at a plurality of locations across
the sample
10a. The apparatus of Figure 2 is configured to enable this in a single
measurement, in
that the whole area of interest can be exposed to the light from the light
source 22 in a
single exposure. Note that the area of interest may be the whole area of the
sample 10a if
it has already been cut, and possibly shaped, into the required dimensions for
a
completed heating element, or may be a smaller portion within the sample area
if the
sample is large and intended to be cut into individual heating element parts.
To achieve
this extensive spatial exposure the light source can be an area light source
or a bar light
source, capable of producing light of roughly the same intensity over an area
at least as
large as the area of the sample to be measured (the area of interest).
Alternatively, one
could employ a point light source with lenses to expand the optical field and
flatten the
intensity profile across the field. The light may be of any wavelength, as
desired, and in
particular can be of a single wavelength or may be a broad spectrum or white
light source.
On the opposite side of the sample 10 from the light source 22 there is
arranged a
camera or other light detector 24. The detector 24 may comprise an array of
point
detectors, for example, such as a CCD array. The aim is to detect light
passing from the
source 22 through all parts of the sample 10a within the area of interest, so
the detector
area should be appropriately sized. Also, the detector 24 should be configured
for
detection of the particular wavelength or wavelengths of light emitted from
the source 22.
In other words, the detector 24 preferably has high sensitivity to the
wavelength of the
source 22.
Although the example shows the source 22 under the sample 10a, with the
detector 24 above, the opposite configuration may be used so that light is
directed
downwardly through the sample from source to detector, or arranged in a more
horizontal
configuration. If the apparatus is incorporated into a production line for
automated
analysis of heating elements being delivered for inclusion into electronic
cigarettes, the
CA 3051320 2019-07-23
WO 2018/142114 PCT/C 132018/050253
configuration of the production line and the mechanism used to deliver and
remove
samples to and from the apparatus may determine the arrangement of the
components.
Also it may be desired to enclose or partly enclose the apparatus to exclude
stray light
from the measurements.
In use, the source 22 directs a roughly uniform field of light at intensity II
onto the
sample 10a. If the sample 10a is an individual heating element or a pre-cut
blank to be
formed into an individual element, the light field as it impinges on the
sample may be
roughly at least the same area as the heating element, so that all parts of
the sample are
illuminated. If the sample 10a is a sheet from which individual heating
elements are to be
separated, a part of the sheet only may be illuminated, for example
corresponding to the
area of a single heating element. In the former case, analysis of the optical
transmission
can allows a heating element to be accepted or rejected for use in a vapour
provision
system. In the latter case, the analysis can indicate whether a particular
area of a sheet of
material is suitable to be separated for use as a heating element.
The incident light field at intensity II impinges on the sample 10a, and part
of the
light is transmitted through the sample (with part being reflected and
diffracted and part
being absorbed), giving a reduced intensity 12 on the far side of the sample
10a. This light
is detected by the detector 24, such as by photographing the illuminated
sample 10a if the
detector 24 is a camera. The optical transmission of the sample is 12/11,
being the fraction
of incident light which is transmitted. For a fixed apparatus with constant
optical output, 11
remains the same for every sample, so an absolute measurement of 12 is
equivalent to
the optical transmission. If the detector remains the same with fixed
detection capability,
the measured 12 for different samples may be compared directly to determine
variation
between samples. For the present proposal, in which variation across an
individual
sample is of interest, this consistency of apparatus and measurement
conditions is less
relevant, but may nevertheless aid accuracy.
Experiments (such as described further below) have shown that there is a
linear
relationship between measured transmitted light intensity and sample
resistance (for a
given testing configuration).
Figure 3 shows an example graph of a relationship between transmitted
intensity
and resistance. The line 30 shows a linear proportional relationship, of the
form
R = al + b, where R is resistance and 1 is the measured (average) intensity.
Heating
element material with a higher resistivity transmits a higher proportion of
incident light, so
that intensity measured on the far side of a sample is higher. For a
particular model or
design of electronic cigarette, the heating element can be determined in
advance to
require a resistivity between a first value RL and a second higher value RH
(for example,
assuming a range of resistivities can be tolerated). An optical transmission
measurement
11
CA 3051320 2019-07-23
WO 2018/142114 PCT/C132018/050253
can be made on a sample heating element, and if the measured intensity falls
between a
first value IL and a second higher value IH, corresponding respectively to the
resistance
values RL and RH as determined from the relationship represented by the graph
of Figure
3, it can be readily ascertained that the sample is suitable for use in the
electronic
cigarette. An intensity value below IL or above IH indicates that the
resistivity is too low or
too high (i.e. outside the range of RL to RH), and the sample can be rejected.
This graph
also demonstrates how optical transmission variability across a single sample
can be
used to assess the level of homogeneity of electrical resistance, since the
correlation
between transmission and the resistance is clear.
Using apparatus such as the Figure 2 example, the transmitted light is
measured
across the area of the sample, and the measurement is made with a degree of
spatial
resolution such as is obtainable using a camera or other array of detectors
such as a
CCD array. While the graph of Figure 3 shows the relationship between average
intensity
and resistance, where the average intensity for a sample is derived by
averaging
individual values within the spatially resolved measurement data obtained for
a sample,
assessment of optical transmission as proposed herein utilises the resolved
data to obtain
an optical transmission profile.
Experiments have been carried out to demonstrate the proposal herein, which
showed that there is a clear correlation between the resistance of a sample of
porous
sheet material suitable for use as an electrical heating element and its
optical
transmission, indicated by the proportion of light that passes through the
sample. This
relationship may be used to assess the resistance consistency of a sample by
analysis of
the optical transmission profile, indicating that optical transmission with a
variation within
specified limits is a valuable characteristic of such material, Knowledge of
optical
transmission profiles can enable the rejection of sections of material which
are not
expected to yield components operating within a required tolerance for
resistive heating.
This can reduce the number of products which require rejection late in the
production
process by permitting earlier rejection of faulty or defective material.
In the experiments, the apparatus was configured to backlight samples of
material
.. by placing the sample over a light source and directing light upwards
through the sample,
as in the Figure 2 example. A 1 megapixel digital camera was used as the light
detector,
having a 22.5 mm variable focus lens; this was deemed to provide ample
resolution. A bar
light was chosen as the light source, since it was considered to provide a
higher output
intensity than an available area light, and a flatter lighting field than a
spot light. Bar lights
.. of three wavelengths were investigated to determine if the colour of the
illumination
affected the quality of the information obtainable. Comparing the gain and
range between
the highest and lowest intensity levels in images taken of backlit samples,
and the
12
CA 3051320 2019-07-23
WO 2018/142114 PCT/C132018/050253
uniformity of light produced by the source, resulted in selection of a red
light over a green
light and an infrared light. The infrared light showed low intensity range and
gain; the
green and red lights were much better in these regards, with the green light
showing
consistently high gain. However, many cameras have higher sensitivity to red
light, so the
red light source was chosen for the experiments. Red light is typically
defined as having a
wavelength in the range of about 620 to 720 nm.
To obtain initial images in the experiments, samples of Bekipor (RIM) material
(described above), which were cut to a size of 45 mm by 45 mm, were held
between two
sheets of clear plastic to keep them flat during imaging. The sample was held
at 30 mm
from the light source, and the camera positioned at 160 mm from the sample,
following
some testing to determine spacings for good image quality. Varying the
spacings was
found to have little effect on image quality, so the distances were chosen to
give an
appropriate field of view for the size of the samples.
Once these parameters for the apparatus were established, images of samples
were taken with the camera, and processed to provide a format from which
useful
intensity information could be extracted.
Figure 4 shows the results of some of this imaging. An inspection program was
developed to collect the raw image data (photograph) captured by the camera
into
regions to each of which an intensity value is attributed, so that the data
could be
displayed as a 2D intensity contour map to highlight the different regions of
the image.
Figures 4A and 4B show two examples of raw images, of different samples, and
Figures
40 and 4D respectively show the corresponding 2D intensity contour maps, where
the
darker areas are low intensity and the paler areas are high intensity. The
light and dark
areas in the original images correlate with the various regions in the contour
maps.
Images of this type were used together with resistance measurements to
establish that
regions in an image showing a high intensity correspond to parts of the sample
having a
higher resistance (since less conductive material is present) and regions
showing a low
intensity correspond to a lower resistance (since more conductive material is
present,
blocking the incident light from the light source and preventing its
transmission to the
camera for imaging). The 2D maps can be thought of 2D optical transmission
profiles, as
described above, since they represent the variation of optical transmission
across a
sample.
To establish the relationship between optical transmission or intensity and
resistance, testing was performed to determine the resistance of some samples.
Each
sample was in turn held between conductive clamps, and an ohm meter was used
to
measure the resistance of each sample five times, and an average resistance
for each
sample was calculated from these measurements, The averaging was intended to
take
13
CA 3051320 2019-07-23
WO 2018/142114 PCT/G 132018/050253
account of any variations in temperature, tension in the clamped samples, and
position of
the clamps. The samples were a set of one hundred slotted heating elements
stamp-cut
from sheet Bekipor (RTM) material to have a shape like that in the Figure 1
example.
Images were taken of the samples to generate intensity data like the Figure 40
and 4D profiles, and used to derive an average intensity value for each
sample, being a
single numeric value indicating the measured intensity of light transmitted
through the
finite area of a sample. Various approaches to determining a suitable
representative value
were considered. The image data was divided into contiguous regions, each
having a
numerical value indicating the recorded intensity for that area; this gives
numerical
transmission profile data, and the 2D intensity contour maps such as those in
Figure 4 are
graphical representations of this type of data. Different averaging methods
involve the
selection of different sets of values to be averaged, such as the full area of
the sample, or
different groups of values intended to model the parts of the sample where the
current
path used in resistive heating will likely pass. The averaging resulted in a
single intensity
value per sample which could then be directly plotted against the average
resistance
values. For the one hundred samples, the averaging used data lying in a path
chosen to
model the actual serpentine current flow that occurs in a slotted heating
element. Thermal
images of a heating element with an applied current of 1A were examined to
establish the
shape and size of the current path to be modelled.
Figure 5 shows a graph of the intensity values plotted against the resistance
values for these one hundred samples, to which a straight line has been
fitted. The data
has an R2 value of 0.9173, where R2 is the usual statistical measure of how
close data lie
to their fitted line. This is a high value (since R2 can have a maximum value
of 1), from
which we can deduce that the proportional relationship between intensity and
resistance
is valid. Hence the proposed use of optical transmission profiles as a
characteristic to
specify planar conductive porous material is sound.
Since the relationship between optical transmission (or measured transmitted
intensity) and resistance is proven, we consider analysis of the optical
profile as a credible
indicator of the resistance variability within a sample of material.
As described above, an optical transmission profile is defined as a set of
transmission measurements (values) spatially distributed across a sample (in
one or two
dimensions), and the magnitude of the difference between the highest and
lowest values
is indicative of the spatial variation of electrical resistance within the
sample, arising from
any inhomogeneities in the physical structure of the sample material. Hence,
we can
analysis a profile to determine the magnitude of the difference (where the
difference
between the highest and lowest values is also known as the range).
Additionally, this can
be compared against a pre-specified acceptable maximum value for the range to
14
CA 3051320 2019-07-23
WO 2018/142114 PCT/GB2018/050253
determine whether a sample is suitable for use as a heating element, in that
it can be
expected to perform as required for heating. The acceptable maximum value for
the range
might be derived from the corresponding acceptable variation in resistance,
using a
relationship such as that shown in the graph of Figure 5.
Consider the example 2D profile of Figure 4C. The palest areas, such as area
40,
correspond to the maximum measured transmitted light intensity and the darkest
areas,
such as area 42, correspond to the minimum measured transmitted light
intensity. Area
40 (and other areas of the same shade) has a corresponding numerical value
indicating
the amount of light detected in that area; let us designate this as H,
representing the
highest measured value. Similarly, area 42 (and other areas of the same shade)
has a
corresponding numerical value indicating the amount of light detected in that
area; let us
designate this as L, representing the lowest measured value. The range, or
variation, for
the profile, being the magnitude of the difference between the highest and
lowest values,
is therefore H¨L (or equivalently, IL-HI).
This range can be used to characterise a sample, and further be used to
classify
the sample according to whether it is suitable for use as a heating element,
for which the
range will desirably be at or below a specified threshold corresponding to a
maximum
tolerable variation in resistivity. If we designate the range from the optical
transmission
profile as V where V = H-L, and the threshold as T, then a test for V5T can
establish that
a sample meets the criterion for use as a heating element. If the sample is a
pre-cut
heating element, it can be passed for incorporation into an electronic
cigarette or a
component for an electronic cigarette such as an atomiser or a cartomiser. If
the sample
is a pre-cut blank to be formed into a heating element, it can be passed for
further
processing into the final form of the heating element. If the sample is a
portion of a large
sheet of material, the portion can be designated for separation from the sheet
and further
processing into a heating element.
The range V may be calculated as an absolute value from the actual measured
optical transmission. If the threshold is set also as an absolute value, which
will be
applicable in the case of a specified material type and known measurement
conditions
(fixed specified apparatus), the two can be directly compared For more general
applicability, we can consider percentage differences or proportions. For
example, the
minimum value from the optical profile can be required to fall within a
particular
percentage of the maximum value, such as the minimum value is 90% or more of
the
maximum value. Conversely, the range can be required to correspond to a
particular
proportion or percentage of the maximum value or the minimum value, such as
the range
is no more than 10% of the maximum value or the range does not exceed 10% of
the
minimum value. Alternatively, the maximum value and the minimum value can be
required
CA 3051320 2019-07-23
WO 2018/142114 PCT/G132018/050253
to fall within a particular percentage of an average optical transmission
value for the
profile, such as within 5% or less of the average value, or the minimum value
is at least
95% of the average value and the maximum value is not more than 105% of the
average
value.
Note that when producing a 2D profile such as Figure 4C, it is typical to
divide the
measured values into contiguous groups of values, each group being a small
spread of
values within the full spread of data, defined between a maximum and a minimum
for that
group. A shade or colour is assigned to each group, which are then used to
generate the
map. If the data is in this form, there will be a group of maximum values and
a group of
.. minimum values, and a single maximum and a single minimum for the whole
data set may
not be available. If so, a choice can be made of a representative value from
each group to
use when determining the range for the profile. For example, one could use the
minimum
value defined for one group and the maximum value defined for the other group,
or the
minimum values or maximum values for each group, or a midpoint value for each
group.
For current purposes, a value such as these examples representing a minimum
group
and a value representing a maximum group are considered equivalent to an
actual
minimum value and an actual maximum value for the purpose of assessing and
defining
the range or variation in an optical transmission profile.
The contour map type of profile in Figure 4C represents measured transmission
data from many closely spaced locations which effectively cover the whole of
the sample
so that the complete sample surface is mapped. Alternatively, one can use
measurements more widely spaced across the sample surface to define the
profile: the
measurements may be arranged in a regular array, or be randomly spaced and
located.
Such measurements might be individually acquired with suitably configured
apparatus, or
.. might be extracted from a larger set such as from a complete image of the
sample like the
Figure 4A photograph.
One may also define or acquire a one-dimensional (1D) optical transmission
profile, where a series of optical transmission values (or intensity
measurements) are
spaced along a line, rather than spread across both the length and width of a
sample. The
line may or may not be straight. If the data is of this type, the profile can
be represented
as a line graph, rather than a contour map.
Figure 6 shows an example of an optical transmission profile of a 1D, linear
type.
For ten evenly spaced positions along the surface of a sample, the transmitted
light
intensity has been measured. A maximum intensity level of H and a minimum
intensity
level of L were detected. The difference between these levels is the range or
variance V,
which can characterise the sample, and be compared with a threshold value to
assess the
suitability of the sample as described above.
16
CA 3051320 2019-07-23
WO 2018/142114 PCT/G 132018/050253
The example profiles of Figures 4 and 6 present the optical data in terms of
its
spatial distribution. In reality, there is no requirement to do this for the
present purpose,
since we are interested in the maximum and minimum values and these can
readily be
extracted from a set of measurements without reference to the spatial
arrangement.
However, the spatial information may be relevant for some purposes.
As noted above, optical transmission data suitable for analysis according to
the
examples herein can be obtained as a set of individual measurements, rather
than
extracting separate values from a image or similar data array. In this case,
the apparatus
can be modified compared with the example of Figure 2.
Figure 7 shows a schematic side view of a second example apparatus. As before,
a sample 10a is held between a light source and a light detector. In this
example,
however, the light source is effectively a point source, such as a light
emitting diode (LED)
or a laser 22a, and the detector is effectively a point detector (in that it
has no spatial
resolution), such as a photodiode 24a. The LED 22a emits a beam of light at
first intensity
11 which is arranged to be incident (preferably perpendicularly) on a selected
location 23
on the surface of the sample 10a. Owing to absorption, diffraction and
reflection only a
portion 12 of the incident light 11 is transmitted through the sample 10a, and
detected by
the detector 24a, to give a first transmission/intensity measurement. The
sample 10a is
movably mounted in the measurement position, such as on a translation stage,
so that it
can be moved in the plane orthogonal to the light propagation direction, as
indicated by
the arrow 25. Thus, after the first measurement is made, the sample 10a can be
translated to a new position so that the incident light 11 impinges on a
different part of the
sample 10a, and the transmitted light 12 is detected as a second measurement.
In this
way, a set of measurements can be acquired to collectively form an optical
transmission
profile.
Alternative arrangements may be employed to achieve the same effect. For
example, the sample 10a may be kept stationary and the source 22a and the
detector 24a
may be moved between measurement positions. If the source and detector are
held on a
common stage, they can be conveniently translated together while maintaining
their
alignment along a common beam axis. They may be separately mounted instead.
Also, a
point source may be used with a large area detector, in which case translation
of the
source or the sample will access the required set of measurement locations.
Alternatively,
a large area source may be used with a point detector, together with
translation of the
detector or the sample.
Figure 8 shows a flow chart of steps in an example method of sample analysis
according to an example. In a first step S1, an acceptable variation in
optical transmission
is defined. This may be for a particular design of heating element, formed
from a
17
CA 3051320 2019-07-23
WO 2018/142114 PCT/G 132018/050253
particular material, for example, and may be defined with reference to a
resistance/transmission relationship such as that depicted in Figure 5, by
deciding what
deviation or variation in resistance can be tolerated and ascertaining the
range of optical
tolerance to which this variation corresponds. The absolute value of
resistance may not
be of interest; rather the method is concerned with assessing uniformity or
homogeneity
of resistance within a sample, so detect there is not too much variation
within a single
sample. The acceptable variation may be a percentage or proportion of a
maximum or
minimum optical transmission.
In a second step S2, a plurality of optical transmission values are measured
at a
plurality of locations on a sample which requires assessment. Apparatus such
as that in
Figure 2 or Figure 7 might be used. The plurality of measurement values form a
data set
representing an optical transmission profile for the sample, and may be
plotted for spatial
analysis as in the examples in Figures 4C, 4D or 6.
Moving on to step S3, the maximum and minimum optical transmission values in
the data set are identified. In a next step S4, the range for the data set is
calculated, being
the difference between the maximum and minimum values. This can be in the
format of
an absolute value of the difference, or as a percentage, proportion or
fraction of the
maximum or minimum value, depending on the definition used for the acceptable
variation.
In step S5, the calculated range from step S4 is compared to the acceptable
variation established in step S1. If the range is less than the acceptable
variation, the
method moves to step S6 in which the sample is used as, or to fabricate, a
heating
element such as for an electronic vapour provision system. If the range is
greater than the
acceptable variation, the sample is rejected for such use, in step S7.
As an example, the acceptable variation might be predetermined or defined to
be
8% of the maximum measured optical transmission. If the range calculated from
the
maximum and minimum measurements is 8% of the maximum or less, the sample can
be
passed as fit for use.
In an alternative, the acceptable variation can be defined in step Si in terms
of a
difference from (or percentage, proportion or fraction of) an average value,
instead of a
range between maximum and minimum values. In such a case, step S4 of the
method
becomes a step in which an average value of optical transmission is calculated
from the
values measured in step S2, and the difference (or deviation or variance) of
the maximum
and/or the minimum values from this average is calculated. In step S5, the
comparison is
a comparison of this difference with the acceptable variation.
As an example, the acceptable variation might be predetermined or defined to
be
3% of the average measured optical transmission. If the maximum measured value
differs
18
CA 3051320 2019-07-23
WO 2018/142114 PCT/C132018/050253
from the average by no more than 3% of the average and/or the minimum measured
value differs from the average by no more than 3% of the average, the sample
can be
passed as fit for use.
In a further alternative, the acceptable variation can be defined in step Si
as
requiring the minimum value to be at least a certain percentage, proportion or
fraction of
the maximum value (or vice versa). Then, step 4 becomes a calculation in which
the
minimum and maximum values are compared to determined the percentage,
proportion or
fraction of the maximum value which the minimum value comprises, and in step 5
the
comparison is to compare this calculated percentage, proportion or fraction
with the
acceptable variation. The comparison is passed if the calculated percentage,
proportion
or fraction is not less than the defined acceptable variation.
As an example, the acceptable variation might be predetermined or defined to
be
95% of the maximum measured optical transmission. If the measured minimum
value is
95% or more of the measured maximum value, the sample can be passed as fit for
use.
In these various examples, the value or values calculated or derived from the
maximum value and minimum value (either the range of the profile, the
deviation of the
maximum and/or minimum from the average, or the proportion of the maximum
represented by the minimum) can be considered as a difference value, which is
a value
calculated from the maximum and minimum values in an optical transmission
profile and
indicative of the variation of optical transmission values recorded for a
sample
Thus far the proposals herein have been discussed in the context of heating
elements intended to operate by resistive heating in which a heating element
is connected
to an electrical power source so that current flows through the heating
element, and
electrical resistance of the heating element material causes the current flow
to generate
heat. This can be referred to as ohmic heating or Joule heating, using the
passage of a
current through a conductive heating element, the current being delivered from
an
external power supply such as a battery in the electronic cigarette. The
amount of heat
generated depends on the resistance of the heating element, so use of a
heating element
with appropriate resistive properties is important.
As an alternative, it is possible to use induction (inductive) heating to
generate
heat in a heating element within an electronic cigarette. Induction heating is
a
phenomenon that allows heating of an electrically conductive item, typically
made from
metal, by electromagnetic induction. An electronic oscillator is provided to
generate a high
frequency alternating current that is passed through an electromagnet. In
turn, the
electromagnet produces a rapidly alternating magnetic field, which is arranged
to
penetrate the object to be heated, in this case a heating element made from a
conductive
porous sheet material. The magnetic field generates eddy currents in the
conductive
19
CA 3051320 2019-07-23
WO 2018/142114 PCT/GB2018/050253
material, and this flowing current generates heat via the resistance of the
material. Hence,
induction heating also requires current flow to generate heat from a
material's electrical
resistance, but the current is an eddy current generated by an external
magnetic field,
rather than a current obtained by a potential difference applied from an
electrical power
supply. The material for the heating element is required to have appropriate
resistive
properties, as before.
Accordingly, examples of the proposed herein are applicable to heating
elements
and material therefore, and the analysis/characterisation thereof, which are
intended to be
used with an induction heating arrangement in an electronic cigarette. For a
given
induction heating design, a particular resistance or range of resistance will
be required, so
heating elements may be assessed for compliance using optical analysis as
described
herein. Also, heating elements characterised by their optical transmission
properties, as
reflecting homogeneity of structure and resistance, are relevant to induction
heating
arrangements.
The various embodiments described herein are presented only to assist in
understanding and teaching the claimed features. These embodiments are
provided as a
representative sample of embodiments only, and are not exhaustive and/or
exclusive. It is
to be understood that advantages, embodiments, examples, functions, features,
structures, and/or other aspects described herein are not to be considered
limitations on
the scope of the invention as defined by the claims or limitations on
equivalents to the
claims, and that other embodiments may be utilised and modifications may be
made
without departing from the scope of the claimed invention. Various embodiments
of the
invention may suitably comprise, consist of, or consist essentially of,
appropriate
combinations of the disclosed elements, components, features, parts, steps,
means, etc.,
other than those specifically described herein. In addition, this disclosure
may include
other inventions not presently claimed, but which may be claimed in future.
CA 3051320 2019-07-23
