Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 03076814 2020-03-23
CA National Entry of PCT/US2018/052125
CPST Ref: 71928/00016
Multi-Source, Flow-Weighted Composite Sample System
Field of Invention
[0002] This invention relates to a system and method for providing
increased
accuracy in input sample analysis from multiple discrete input sources to
and/or from one
or more receiving vessels, such as a stationary storage tank or a tanker ship,
by
accounting for flow rate differential between the respective discrete input
sources.
Background
[0003] Natural gas, like other forms of heat energy, is measure in British
Thermal
units, or BTU. One BTU is equivalent to the heat needed to raise the
temperature of one
pound of water by one-degree Fahrenheit at atmospheric pressure. Because LNG
is sold
in accordance with its BTU value, accurate analysis of the BTU value of any
particular
LNG shipment, as well as analysis of the constituent components of the LNG, as
it is
loaded on and off a respective tanker ship is crucial. For example, to
determine an
expected price for a particular shipment, when LNG is loaded onto a tanker
ship at an
overseas location, such as Trinidad and Tobago, the supplier calculates the
BTU value
of the LNG as it is loaded into the hull of the ship. Thus, the operator of
the tanker ship
carrying the LNG shipment is keenly interested in accurate BTU measurement of
both the
loaded LNG as well as the off-loaded LNG as the shipper typically burns the
LNG
vaporized in transit to run the ship and, thus, is responsible for cost of the
LNG vaporized
in transit.
CPST Doc: 22666.1
1
CA 03076814 2020-03-23
WO 2019/067313 PCT/US2018/052125
[0004] Presently, if a LNG tanker is being loaded from multiple storage
tanks or a
series of railroad tanker cars, using, for example, two to four different
pipelines, there is
no device or method to generate accurate composite data from the combined
inputs and
account for variations in flow rates of each of the discrete inputs during the
transfer/loading process. This problem applies similarly in the context of one
or more
tankers and/or railroad tanker cars using multiple pipelines to load one or
more tanks
and/or one or more railroad tanker cars.
[0005] In the context of a cryogenic LNG, for example, cargo loads are
often
composed of simultaneously transferred inputs from different storage vessels
containing
different compositions or other physical properties. The flow rates may vary
between the
input from respective sources, which leaves the operator to essentially guess
or
guesstimate the contributions from each source and apply that obtained
estimated
number to the determined energy content/composition analysis of the resulting
transferred mixture.
[0006] When time-elapse composite sampling of a multi-input mixture is
processed
through a composite system as along the lines of that described in US Patent
9,562,833,
the use of relative flow rate guesstimates for analytical purposes becomes
unreliable,
imprecise and untenable.
Summary of the Invention
[0007] The present invention envisions a solution providing a single
analytical system
capable of providing an accurate composite sample obtained from multiple input
sources
for energy content/composition analysis which reflects the variations in the
input flow
2
INCORPORATED BY REFERENCE (RULE 20.6)
CA 3,076,814
CPST Ref: 71928/00016
rates from the respective sources. The present invention can be utilized as a
stand-alone
unit or as an adjunct to an existing system, such as for example, the Mustang
Composite
Sampling System (MCSSTm), an intermittent, waterless sampling system for
liquefied
natural gas which is compliant with the requirements of ISO 8943 and which is
capable
of accumulating a representative sample by capturing small samples at regular
intervals,
either fixed or proportional to flow rate. Such a system is available from
Mustang
Sampling, LLC of Ravenswood, West Virginia and is an embodiment of a Composite
Sampling System described in US Patent 9,562,833
[0008] The system and method of the present invention consolidates the
equipment
requirements that would otherwise be required for each discrete sample take
off source.
[0009] The invention described herein contemplates combinational sampling
by a
system with the capability of providing composite samples from multiple
discrete input
sources and accounts for the flow rate of each of the admixed inputs for
energy
content/compositional analysis of natural gas.
[0010] In the context of an LNG system, the multi-source sampling system
provides
an accurate sample for analysis from a plurality of sources, e.g. two or more,
which are
later combined. Thus, the BTU value of LNG loaded on to a tanker from various
input
sources or off-loaded to a tank or railroad tanker car from various input
sources can be
accurately determined as well as the constituent components of the LNG.
[0011] The system relies on an input from each discrete source being
monitored and
controlled by a mass flow meter that is set to correspond to the established
rate of flow
for that particular source (e.g. pipeline). By way of example, if a first
tanker car takeoff
3
Date Recue/Date Received 2020-06-15
CA 03076814 2020-03-23
WO 2019/067313 PCT/US2018/052125
pipeline has a 60% flow rate and a second tanker car takeoff pipeline has a
40% flow rate
with respect to the total flow rate of sample to enter a tanker, the
respective total
volumetric flow rates through respective mass flow controllers are adjusted to
each
provide a throughput to a common vapor sample accumulator that corresponds to
the
proportional, native flow rates of the respective sources. The system also
permits
samples to be extracted and analyzed from at least one active source even when
one or
more of the discrete sources is shut down with no flow.
[0012] In short, the invention contemplates that prior to analysis,
vaporized gas
samples from discrete sources which can be from a sample probe or a sample
conditioning system are combined into an accumulator chamber in a calculated
ratio.
This ratio reflects the respective flow ratios between the discrete sources.
For the
purpose of discussion, although the following description contemplates a two-
source
stream embodiment, the inventive concept is not so limited and could include
any number
of sources. In the case of a two-source input, the flow of vaporized gas into
the
accumulator is controlled by means of two mass flow controllers, one for each
source, to
generate a composition sample proportional to the input flows. Each vaporized
gas
stream exiting the mass flow controller is introduced into the mixing
accumulator through
an accumulator impingement tube/mixing wand projecting into the interior of
the
accumulator. As a result, an output from the accumulator is a mixture of the
input gases
and will be identical to the final mixture involved in the transfer loading,
and, therefore,
appropriate for analysis as the final combined cargo load. If a system
includes additional
input sources, e.g. five or six, each additional input is associated with one
or more mass
flow controllers.
4
INCORPORATED BY REFERENCE (RULE 20.6)
CA 03076814 2020-03-23
WO 2019/067313
PCT/US2018/052125
[0013] The
system includes a device capable of measuring proportional flow rate
and capable of determining an effective (flow weighted) composition or energy
value
for multiple streams, regardless of different flow ratios, without the
addition of a
dedicated sampling point and its associated equipment. This provides for the
ability
to blend LNG while avoiding the issue of dew point dropout.
[0014] It is an
object of the present invention to overcome the aforementioned
problems associated with conventional structures of the prior art such as with
compositional analysis of LNG flow from multiple input and/or output flow
paths.
[0015] It is
therefore an object of the present invention to provide a system,
device and method for conveniently and more accurately measuring the
composition
of product from multiple sources being onloaded to or offloaded from a vessel
such
as a tank, tanker, barge, truck, or railroad tanker car.
[0016] It is a
further object of the present invention to provide for enhanced
proportional compositional analysis with respect to multiple input and/or
output flow
paths of product such that the percentage composition based on flow rate can
be
determined for each path.
[0017] Still yet
another object of the present invention is to provide for more
accurate calculation of compositional and/or BTU values for both onloaded and
offloaded LNG thereby allowing for enhanced sales transactions of LNG.
[0018] Objects
of the invention are satisfied by a system for capturing a
composite gas sample from multiple input sources during transfer processing,
comprising: at least a first and a second feedstock input lines; a sample
takeoff
assembly associated with each input line for extracting samples from said
feedstock
INCORPORATED BY REFERENCE (RULE 20.6)
CA 03076814 2020-03-23
WO 2019/067313
PCT/US2018/052125
input lines; a sampling device having a mass flow controller associated with
each
sample takeoff assembly, each mass flow controller having a sample output and
being configured to receive a signal representative of the flow rate from each
of said
first and second feedstock input lines, where each mass flow controller
adjusts the
flow rate of its respective sample from its respective sample output in
response to
receiving representative signals; at least a first and second sample output
line
respectively connected with the sample output of each mass flow controller,
each
sample output line being connected to an input of a sample accumulator for
introduction
to the sample accumulator of samples from the output of the mass flow
controllers.
[0019] Further
objects of the invention are met by a sampling device, comprising:
at least two inputs each configured to receive samples from a corresponding
feedstock input line; a sample accumulator; a mass flow controller associated
with
each feedstock input line, each mass flow controller having a sample output
and
being configured to receive a signal representative of the flow rate at each
input,
where each mass flow controller adjusts the flow rate of its respective sample
from
its respective sample output in response to receiving representative signals;
and at
least a first and second sample output line respectively connected with a
sample
output of each mass flow controller, each sample output line being connected
to an
input of the sample accumulator for introduction to the sample accumulator of
samples
from the output of the mass flow controllers.
[0020] Further
objects of the invention are met by a method for accounting for the
flow rate from a plurality of sample fluid sources to a combined input for
increased
measurement accuracy in energy content/composition analysis, the method
6
INCORPORATED BY REFERENCE (RULE 20.6)
CA 03076814 2020-03-23
WO 2019/067313 PCT/US2018/052125
comprising: determining the flow rate of a sample fluid in each of the
plurality of sample
fluid sources; extracting a sample from each of the plurality of sample fluid
sources;
passing each such extracted sample to and inputting such sample into a common
sample accumulator at an adjusted flow rate corresponding to the determined
flow rate
of its sample fluid source; accumulating a plurality of fluid samples in the
accumulator
to create a composite sample; and outputting a select amount of said composite
sample from the accumulator for energy content/compositional analysis of the
composite sample..
Brief Description of the Drawings
[0021] Figure 1 is a block diagram illustrating a system in accordance with
the
present invention.
[0022] Figure 2 is a schematic representation of an embodiment of the multi-
source, flow-weighted corn posited sample system in the context of a binary
(two input)
system.
[0023] Figure 3 is a schematic representation of an equipment cabinet
according
to an embodiment of the invention.
Description of the Illustrations
[0024] As used herein "substantially", "relatively", "generally", "about",
and
"approximately" are relative modifiers intended to indicate permissible
variation from the
characteristic so modified. They are not intended to be limited to the
absolute value or
characteristic which it modifies but rather approaching or approximating such
a physical
or functional characteristic.
7
INCORPORATED BY REFERENCE (RULE 20.6)
CA 03076814 2020-03-23
WO 2019/067313 PCT/US2018/052125
[0025] In the detailed description, references to "one embodiment", "an
embodiment",
or "in embodiments" mean that the feature being referred to is included in at
least one
embodiment of the invention. Moreover, separate references to "one
embodiment", "an
embodiment", or "in embodiments" do not necessarily refer to the same
embodiment;
however, neither are such embodiments mutually exclusive, unless so stated,
and except
as will be readily apparent to those skilled in the art. Thus, the invention
can include any
variety of combinations and/or integrations of the embodiments described
herein.
[0026] The terminology used herein is for the purpose of describing
particular
embodiments only and is not intended to be limiting of the invention. As used
herein, the
singular forms, "a", "an" and "the" are intended to include the plural forms
as well, unless
the context clearly indicates otherwise. It will be further understood that
the root terms
"include" and/or "have", when used in this specification, specify the presence
of stated
features, integers, steps, operations, elements, and/or components, but do not
preclude
the presence or addition of at least one other feature, integer, step,
operation, element,
component, and/or groups thereof.
[0027] It will be appreciated that as used herein, the terms "comprises,"
"comprising,"
"includes," "including," "has," "having" or any other variation thereof, are
intended to cover
a non-exclusive inclusion. For example, a process, method, article, or
apparatus that
comprises a list of features is not necessarily limited only to those features
but may
include other features not expressly listed or inherent to such process,
method, article, or
apparatus.
8
INCORPORATED BY REFERENCE (RULE 20.6)
CA 3,076,814
CPST Ref: 71928/00016
[0028] It will also be appreciated that as used herein, any reference to a
range of
values is intended to encompass every value within that range, including the
endpoints
of said ranges, unless expressly stated to the contrary.
[0029] Figure 1 is a block diagram illustrating a system 100 for
transferring gas, such
as LNG, from a tank 4 and railroad tanker car 2 to a tanker 14. However, the
description
herein is not limited to such an example and LNG could be transferred between
various
sources such as from two tanks into a third tank. Initially, the LNG from both
the tank 4
and railroad tanker car 2 are transferred towards tanker 14 on respective gas
streams/lines 3. As the LNG travels towards tanker 14 on respective
lines/streams 3, the
flow rate of LNG in each respective stream/line 3 is measured and recorded by
sensors
9 and samples of the LNG are extracted via corresponding take-off probes 7,
preferably
conforming to requirements of ASME B31.3-214, such as a Certiprobee available
from
Mustang Sampling, LLC of Ravenswood, West Virginia. In one example, each
sensor 9
can be incorporated with a respective take-off probe 7 such that the flow rate
is measured
at the point at which LNG is extracted from the input streams/lines 3. The LNG
extracted
from each take-off probe 7 may then be passed to a vaporizer 6 of, for
example, of the
type described in US Patent 8,056,399. The vaporized, extracted LNG sample is
then
conditioned and regulated to prevent hydrocarbon liquid condensation from
Joule-
Thomson cooling, etc. by a single or redundant multipath sample conditioning
system 8.
An exemplary system for obtaining extracted conditioned samples consistent
with these
objectives and capable for use with the invention herein, is a Mustang
Intelligent
Vaporizer Sampling System available from Mustang Sampling, LLC of Ravenswood
West
Virginia and/or a system of the type illustrated and described in US Patent
9,057,668.
9
Date Recue/Date Received 2020-06-15
CA 3,076,814
CPST Ref: 71928/00016
Once the LNG sample from the
sources, e.g. tank 4 and railroad tanker car 2, has been converted to vapor by
the
vaporizers 6 and passed through the downstream sample conditioners 8, the
conditioned
sample streams are introduced into, accumulated, and homogenized by multi-
source,
flow-weighted sample system 200. Although not illustrated, in one example, the
system
100 may include only one vaporizer 6 and sample conditioning system 8 which
receive
input from each stream/line 3 to process all streams/lines 3 of the system 100
at which
point the sample streams can be output from the sample conditioning system 8
to the
system 200.
[0030] Figure 2 schematically represents an example of the sample system
200
according to a binary embodiment of the invention. The illustrated sample
system 200
adapted for use in the case of two parallel input sources (e.g., from a group
consisting of
one or more tanker trucks, railcars and storage tanks) contemplates a number
of inlet
lines 202 corresponding to the number of input streams/lines 3. Therefore,
each input
inlet line 202 corresponds to a respective output of a sample conditioner 8.
Accordingly,
as illustrated, the flow of each sample inlet 202 is controlled by a
corresponding MFC
206. The MFCs 206 can be separated or as part of an overall MFC unit having
multiple
inputs, multiple MFCs 206 and multiple respective outputs. In the case of the
illustrated
binary system, the two MFCs 206 have circuitry that is in electronic signal
communication
with an Allen Bradley 850 series Programmable Logic Controller (PLC) or
equivalent
digital controller. In the illustrated example, the MFCs 206 are in the form
of conventional
mass flow controllers. As used herein, MFC is intended to include any
conventional flow
Date Recue/Date Received 2020-06-15
CA 03076814 2020-03-23
WO 2019/067313 PCT/US2018/052125
control means whether volumetric, ratio, differential, turbine, rotor,
ultrasonic and/or
Coriolis.
[0031] The PLC, itself, is in remote signal communication with and may be
controlled
by a Distributed Control System (DCS) or an adequate equivalent communications
control
system. The DCS monitors the flow rates of each respective transfer
stream/line 3 by
processing appropriate flow sensor 9 readings and transmits by way of a
conventional
communication protocol, such as a MODBUS Remote Terminal Unit (RTU), a
percentage
(%) flow setting for the respective MFC 206 to the PLC. This represents the
percentage
(%) flow of each respective transfer line 3 measured by the sensors 9 which
contributes
to the combined sample where the total for the combined percentages totals
100%. The
PLC then transmits one or more signals to each MFC 206 identifying the
percentage (%)
flow for each respective transfer line based on the data received from the
DCS. Each
MFC 206 receives the one or more signals and adjusts a flow rate of a
respective line 3
accordingly such that the vapor output of each MFC 206 from each line 3
corresponds to
the detected flow rate of the corresponding line 3. In one example, each MFC
206 can
control the flow rate of its respective line 3 by use of a solenoid valve.
[0032] The output from each of the respective MFCs 206 is then communicated
via a
respective output line 204 to a mixing accumulator 208 with impingement
tubes/wand that
can be of a type described and disclosed in US Patent 8,056,399. This admixed
sample
represents the combination of the inputs received from the two transfer
sources (i.e. tank
4 and railroad tanker car 2) to the receiving vessel which may be a ship (i.e.
tanker 14)
or large static storage facility. The admixed sample output from the mixing
accumulator
208 can be directed to a selected destination such as an analyzer/gas
chromatograph 13
11
INCORPORATED BY REFERENCE (RULE 20.6)
CA 03076814 2020-03-23
WO 2019/067313 PCT/US2018/052125
for energy content/compositional analysis such as the gas chromatograph
described in
US patent 8,056,399 or to the Mustang composite sampling system or grab
cylinder
array 12 such as that described previously herein and in the above-referenced
US patent
9,562,833.
[0033] As illustrated in FIG. 2, the sample system 200 further includes
inputs to the
gas chromatograph 13 for receiving the input vapor samples from each input
inlet line
202 for directly sampling the sample vapors for energy content! composition
prior to input
of the vaporized samples into the respective MFCs 206. This allows the sample
system
200 to generate composition data prior to flow rate control by the MFCs 206
thereby
allowing the sample system 200 to generate test data for testing and
calibration of the
sample system 200. Further, each input line from the inlet input to the gas
chromatograph
13 can include one or more check valves controlled by the PLC to shunt one
line should
it be desired to analyze the streams individually.
[0034] FIG. 3 is a schematic representation of an equipment cabinet 300 for
housing
the sample system 200 according to an embodiment of the invention. As FIG. 3
illustrates
an enclosure of the sample system 200 illustrated in FIG 2, like designations
are repeated.
The equipment cabinet 300 includes a housing 302 having configured therein two
MFCs
206, the mixing accumulator 208, flow meters 306 corresponding to the output
of each MFC
206, the gas chromatograph 13, drains 305 to remove moisture or excess liquid,
breathers
307 for equalizing the enclosure to prevent explosions, a heater 308 to
maintain
temperature regulation of the composite sample and a thermostat 310 operating
in
conjunction with the heater 308. Although FIG. 3 depicts only two mass flow
controllers
206, it is understood that the description herein is not limited to this
depiction and that the
12
INCORPORATED BY REFERENCE (RULE 20.6)
CA 03076814 2020-03-23
WO 2019/067313 PCT/US2018/052125
equipment cabinet 300 could house additional MFCs 206 for processing
additional input
lines or that one MFC with multiple inputs and outputs could be used to
control flow rates
of multiple lines. The admixed sample output from the mixing accumulator 208
can be
output to a Mustang composite sampling system via a first output 314 and/or
to a grab
cylinder array via a second output 316.
[0035] FIG. 3 also illustrates a first enclosure 311 for housing input
power to the
sample system 200 and a second enclosure 312 for housing the PLC and DCS
processing circuitry. Alternatively, the DCS could be remotely located and in
direct or
wireless communication with the PLC. The first enclosure 311 can provide a
visual
indicator for field verification of the actual flow meter percentage flow
rate. In addition to,
or alternatively, the actual flow meter percentage flow rate information can
be transmitted
via the PLC to the DCS for remote notification and verification. The equipment
cabinet
300 further includes a plurality of pressure regulators 318 and 320. The
pressure
regulators 318 maintain the appropriate pressure internally for the incoming
input vapor
samples received on the input inlet lines 202. In other words, the pressure
regulators 318
ensure the appropriate pressure on individual lines based on the percentage
flow setting
of each MFC 206. The pressure regulator 320 may be a forward or back pressure
regulator so long as it maintains the appropriate pressure for the admixed
sample output
from the mixing accumulator 208.
[0036] FIG. 3 illustrates one example of a housing for the sample system
200.
However, the invention is not limited to such a composition and additional
embodiments
are contemplated. It is therefore understood that the invention is not limited
to the specific
embodiment disclosed herein, and that many modifications and other embodiments
of the
13
INCORPORATED BY REFERENCE (RULE 20.6)
CA 03076814 2020-03-23
WO 2019/067313 PCT/US2018/052125
invention are intended to be included within the scope of the invention.
Moreover,
although specific terms are employed herein, they are used only in generic and
descriptive sense, and not for the purposes of limiting the description of the
invention.
[0037] Further, although an illustrated binary embodiment of the invention
has been
described in the forgoing specification, it is understood by those skilled in
the art that
many modifications and embodiments of the invention will come to mind to which
the
invention pertains, having benefit of the teaching presented in the foregoing
description
and associated drawing. For example, a system with four, five, six or more
inputs, each
being subject to proportional weighting, would fall within the scope of the
invention. Also,
while primarily disclosed in the context of LNG, a cryogenic, the invention is
applicable to
analysis of combined non-cryogenic fluids. It is therefore understood that the
invention
is not limited to the specific embodiment disclosed herein, and that many
modifications
and other embodiments of the invention are intended to be included within the
scope of
the invention. Moreover, although specific terms are employed herein, they are
used only
in generic and descriptive sense, and not for the purposes of limiting the
description of
the invention.
14
INCORPORATED BY REFERENCE (RULE 20.6)
