Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 03150291 2022-02-07
WO 2021/026183
PCT/US2020/044923
SYSTEMS AND METHODS FOR PROVIDING, IN PROGRAMMABLE MOTION
DEVICES, COMPLIANT END EFFECTORS WITH NOISE MITIGATION
PRIORITY
100011 The present application claims priority to U.S. Provisional Patent
Application Ser.
No. 62/884,359 filed August 8, 2019, the disclosure of which is hereby
incorporated by
reference in its entirety.
BACKGROUND
[00021 The invention generally relates to programmable motion systems and
relates in
particular to end-effectors for programmable motion devices (e.g., robotic
systems) for use in
object processing such as object sortation or order fulfillment.
100031 End-effectors for robotic systems may be employed, for example, in
certain
applications to select and grasp an object, and then move the acquired object
very quickly to
a new location. End-effectors should be designed to quickly and easily select
and grasp an
object from a jumble of dissimilar objects, and should be designed to securely
grasp an object
during movement. Certain end-effectors, when used on different objects of
different physical
sizes, weights and materials, may have limitations regarding how securely they
may grasp an
acquired object during rapid movement, particularly rapid acceleration and
deceleration (both
angular and linear).
100041 Many end-effectors employ vacuum pressure for acquiring and securing
objects for
transport and/or subsequent operations by robotic systems that include
articulated arms.
Other techniques for acquiring and securing objects involve electrostatic
attraction, magnetic
attraction, needles for penetrating objects such as fabrics, fingers that
squeeze an object,
hooks that engage and lift a protruding feature of an object, and collets that
expand in an
opening of an object, among other techniques.
(00051 In applications where vacuum pressure is used to acquire and secure
objects, an end-
effector may include a vacuum cup having a compliant lip that contacts the
object to be
grasped. The compliant lip may be formed of a polymeric or elastomeric
material that is
flexible enough to allow it to adapt to variations in surface structures. The
lip may facilitate
CA 03150291 2022-02-07
WO 2021/026183
PCT/US2020/044923
creating a seal with a surface despite irregularities such as bumps and
texture on the surface.
The flexibility allows the vacuum cup to conform to the shape of objects or to
wrap around
corners of objects to create an adequate seal for acquiring and securing the
object.
100061 When a good seal is not created between a flexible vacuum cup and an
object
however, (due for example, to the nature of the product or because the vacuum
cup is
overhanging an edge of the object), the portion of the lip of the vacuum cup
that is not well
sealed may contribute to making noise, sometimes a substantial amount of
noise, and the
noise level may be above safe limits if human personnel are in close proximity
to the
programmable motion device. Other types of end-effectors, however, including
vacuum cups
with less flexible lips (in addition to those using electrostatic attraction,
magnetic attraction,
needles for penetrating objects such as fabrics, fingers that squeeze an
object, hooks that
engage and lift a protruding feature of an object, and collets that expand in
an opening of an
object), are less effective at acquiring and moving a wide variety of objects.
100071 There remains a need therefore, for an end-effector system in a
programmable motion
system that may select and grasp any of a wide variety of objects, and then
move the acquired
objects very quickly to a new location while not producing an unacceptable
level of noise.
SUMMARY
100081 In accordance with an aspect, the invention provides a vacuum cup for
use in a
programmable motion device. The vacuum cup includes an open inlet for coupling
to a
vacuum source, and a vacuum cup lip on a portion of the vacuum cup that
generally
surrounds the open inlet. The vacuum cup lip includes an inner surface that
defines the open
outlet through which a vacuum may be provided, and includes noise mitigation
features on an
outer surface of the vacuum cup lip.
100091 In accordance with another aspect, the invention provides a vacuum cup
for use in a
programmable motion device. The vacuum cup includes an open inlet for coupling
to a
vacuum source, a vacuum cup lip on a portion of the vacuum cup that is
generally opposite
the open inlet, and an open outlet through which a vacuum may be provided. The
vacuum
cup includes a plurality of protrusions on an outer surface of the vacuum cup
lip.
2
CA 03150291 2022-02-07
WO 2021/026183
PCT/US2020/044923
[00101 In accordance with yet another aspect, the invention provides a method
of providing a
vacuum source in a programmable motion device. The method includes coupling
the vacutun
source to open inlet of a vacuum cup, said vacuum cup including noise
mitigation features on
an outer surface of the vacuum cup, and providing a vacuum cup open outlet
through which
the vacuum may be provided.
[00111 In accordance with a further aspect, the invention provides a system
for providing
automated processing of objects. The system includes a programmable motion
device
including an end-effector that is coupled to a vacuum source. The end-effector
includes a
vacuum cup that includes noise mitigation features on an outer surface of the
vacuum cup.
BRIEF DRESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
100121 The following description may be further understood with reference to
the
accompanying drawings in which:
[00131 Figure 1 shows an illustrative diagrammatic view of an automated object
processing
system in accordance with an aspect of the present invention;
100141 Figure 2 shows an illustrative diagrammatic view of an underside of an
end-effector
in accordance with an aspect of the invention that is partially grasping an
object;
100151 Figures 3A and 3B show illustrative diagrammatic views of a vacuum end-
effector in
accordance with the prior art from a side view (Figure 3A) and from below
(Figure 3B);
100161 Figures 4A and 4B show an illustrative diagrammatic partial side views
of a portion
of a vacuum cup lip initially overhanging an object (Figure 4A), and
subsequently
undergoing resonance causing noise (Figure 4B);
[00171 Figure 5 shows an illustrative diagrammatic view of an end-effector for
use in an
automated object processing system in accordance with an aspect of the
invention that
includes pairs of noise mitigation features;
[00181 Figure 6 shows an illustrative diagrammatic view of an end-effector for
use in an
automated object processing system in accordance with another aspect of the
invention
including larger noise mitigation features;
3
CA 03150291 2022-02-07
WO 2021/026183
PCT/US2020/044923
100191 Figure 7 shows an end-effector for use in an automated object
processing system in
accordance with another aspect of the invention including sets of three noise
mitigation
features;
100201 Figure 8 shows an end-effector for use in an automated object
processing system in
accordance with an aspect of the invention including wedge-shaped noise
mitigation features;
100211 Figures 9A and 9B show an end-effector for use in an automated object
processing
system in accordance with an aspect of the invention including cylindrical-
shaped noise
mitigation features from above (Figure 9A) and from below (Figure 9B);
[0022] Figure 10 shows an illustrative diagrammatic partial side view of the
end-effector of
Figure 5;
100231 Figure 11 shows an illustrative diagrammatic underside view of the end-
effector of
Figure 9B while undergoing resonance; and
[00241 Figure 12 shows an illustrative diagrammatic underside view of an end-
effector in
accordance with an aspect of the present invention that includes large semi-
spherical
protrusions as noise mitigation features.
[00251 The drawings are shown for illustrative purposes only.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[00261 In high airflow vacuum applications, a vacuum is provided that has an
airflow of at
least about 100 cubic feet per minute, and a vacuum pressure at the end
effector of no more
than about 65,000 Pascals below atmospheric (e.g., about 50,000 Pascals below
atmospheric
or 7.25 psi). Applicants have discovered that when such a high airflow vacuum
is provided
that does not create a good seal (again, due for example to the nature of the
product or
because the vacuum cup overhangs an edge of the object), the lip may vibrate
from the high
airflow creating a loud (sometimes whistling) noise.
[00271 In accordance with various aspects, the invention provides a vacuum cup
for a
programmable motion device that include integral noise mitigation features. In
accordance
with further specific aspects, the noise mitigation features may include any
of protrusions,
4
CA 03150291 2022-02-07
WO 2021/026183
PCT/US2020/044923
lands, rises, relief features, and/or bumps that extend from a non-object
contacting side of the
lip of a vacuum cup. Surprisingly, the use of such features reduces the noise
generated by a
compliant vacuum cup when used in a high airflow application.
100281 In accordance with various aspects, the noise mitigation features
increase the mass of
the vacuum cup on the outer rim, but do not negatively decrease the
flexibility of the material
of the vacuum cup lip. Such noise mitigation features are believed to reduce
the frequency at
which the vacuum cup lip vibrates when subject to the high vacuum flowrate,
while not
adversely affecting the stiffness of the vacuum cup lip, which is important to
providing the
compliance (flexibility) needed to create a seal in a wide variety of
applications.
100291 The invention involves adding material to a top side of a lip of a
molded vacuum cup,
which may be presented as small protrusions or bumps (features) encircling the
top side of
the lip of the cup in accordance with various aspects. The distance between
each of the
features, as well as the circumference(es) and height(s) and/or length(s),
width(s), and
height(s) of the features may vary in accordance with various aspects,
together with the
material of the vacuum cup lip, the thickness of the lip of the cup and the
size (diameter) of
the circumference of the centers of the circle of features, as well as the
angle (complex or
linear) of the widening of the lip of the vacuum cup within bounds of various
aspects of the
invention that provide sufficient flexibility to engage a good seal on a
variety of objects, yet
also provide a sufficient quantity of sufficiently distributed outer mass
features on the top
side of a lip of a vacuum cup.
100301 For example, a vacuum cup of an end effector may have an innermost
diameter
(vacuum passage) of about 0.5 inches to about 1.5 inches, while a lip of the
vacuum cup may
have an outer diameter of about 1.5 inches to about 4.5 inches. A high flow
vacuum may be
provided, e.g., by a blower, having a vacuum pressure at the end effector of
no more than
about 65,000 Pascals below atmospheric (e.g., about 50,000 Pascals below
atmospheric or
7.25 psi).
100311 Figure 1 for example, shows a system 10 including a programmable motion
device 12
having an end effector 14 in accordance with an aspect of the present
invention. A vacuum
source 16 is coupled to the end effector 14 via a hose 18, and the
programmable motion
device 12 is programmed to select objects 20, 22, 24 from an input area 26
(including for
example a belted conveyor 28), and to provide selected objects to an output
area 30 that
CA 03150291 2022-02-07
WO 2021/026183
PCT/US2020/044923
includes, for example, one or more output boxes 32 under the control of one or
more
computer processing systems 34. Operation of the programmable motion device
(e.g., robot)
12, including for example, current jobs and future intended movements or needs
of the robot
12, may be displayed on a monitor 36, and an override stop switch 38 may also
be provided
for safety purposes.
[00321 Figure 2 shows an underside of a vacuum cup 40 of the end effector 14,
wherein the
vacuum cup 40 is grasping an object 42 such that a seal is not formed against
the object
because the vacuum cup extends over an edge of the object. Using the high flow
vacuum of
embodiments of the present invention (e.g.. about 50,000 Pascals below
atmospheric), the
object is grasped and maintained by the vacuum cup.
[00331 Figures 3A and 3B show a vacuum cup 50 in accordance with the prior
art. The
vacuum cup 50 includes an attachment portion 52 for attaching to an end
effector section, a
flexible bellows portion 54, and a flexible flanged portion 56 for creating a
seal against
objects. The inner surface of the flexible flanged portion 56 includes ribs 58
spaced radially
inward of an outer lip 59 of the vacuum cup. The ribs 58 support the flanged
portion (i.e.,
keep the flanged portion from collapsing onto an object), when under the force
of a sealed
vacuum against an object.
(00341 With reference to Figures 4A and 4B, when a seal is not created by the
end vacuum
cup 50 on an object 42 (e.g., because the object is grasped near an edge of
the object),
although the object may be able to be lifted by the force of the high flow
vacuum passing
between the ribs 58 (as shown in Figure 4A), the overhanging portion of the
vacuum cup lip
59 may be drawn toward the object 42 (as shown in Figure 4B). Under select
circumstances
(e.g., the flexibility/stiffness of the flexible lip, the thickness of the
flexible lip, the air flow
rate, and the shape and volume of the open area that is not contacting the
object), the vacuum
cup lip may vibrate, causing substantial noise.
(00351 Figure 5 shows a vacuum cup 60 in accordance with an aspect of the
present
invention. The vacuum cup 60 includes an attachment portion 62 for attaching
to an end
effector section, a flexible bellows portion 64, and a flexible flanged
portion 66 for creating a
seal against objects. The inner surface of the flexible flanged portion 66
includes ribs 67
spaced radially inward of an outer lip 69 of the vacuum cup. The vacuum cup 60
further
includes noise mitigation features 68 in the form of partial spheres that are
spaced from one
6
CA 03150291 2022-02-07
WO 2021/026183
PCT/US2020/044923
another along a circumference of the vacuum cup lip. The noise mitigation
features may be
formed of, for example, silicone adhesive. The noise mitigation features may
be evenly
spaced with respect to the ribs 67 such that two features are provided (on the
top) between
ribs (on the bottom).
100361 Figure 6 shows a vacuum cup 70 in accordance with another aspect of the
present
invention that includes single, larger features associated with ribs.
Similarly, the vacuum cup
70 includes an attachment portion 72 for attaching to an end effector section,
a flexible
bellows portion 74, and a flexible flanged portion 76 for creating a seal
against objects. The
inner surface of the flexible flanged portion 76 includes ribs 77 spaced
radially inward of an
outer lip 79 of the vacuum cup. The vacuum cup 70 further includes noise
mitigation
features 78 in the form of fewer larger spheres than the embodiment of Figure
5 that are
spaced from one another along a circumference of the vacuum cup lip. The noise
mitigation
features may be formed of, for example, silicone adhesive. The noise
mitigation features
may be evenly spaced with respect to the ribs 67 such that one feature is
provided (on the top)
between ribs (on the bottom).
100371 Figure 7 shows a vacuum cup 80 in accordance with a further aspect of
the present
invention that incudes differently sized features. The vacuum cup 80 includes
an attachment
portion 82 for attaching to an end effector section, a flexible bellows
portion 84, and a
flexible flanged portion 86 for creating a seal against objects. The inner
surface of the
flexible flanged portion 86 includes ribs 87 spaced radially inward of an
outer lip 89 of the
vacuum cup. The vacuum cup 80 further includes noise mitigation features 85,
88 in the
form of spheres that are spaced from one another along a circumference of the
vacuum cup
lip. The noise mitigation features may be formed of, for example, silicone
adhesive. The
noise mitigation features may be evenly spaced with respect to the ribs 87
such that three
features of two different sizes are provided (on the top) between ribs (on the
bottom).
100381 Figure 8 shows a vacuum cup 90 in accordance with another aspect of the
present
invention that includes edge-shaped features. Similarly, the vacuum cup 90
includes an
attachment portion 92 for attaching to an end effector section, a flexible
bellows portion 94,
and a flexible flanged portion 96 for creating a seal against objects. The
inner surface of the
flexible flanged portion 96 includes ribs 97 spaced radially inward of an
outer lip 99 of the
vacuum cup. The vacuum cup 90 further includes noise mitigation features 98 in
the form of
wedges that are spaced from one another along a circumference of the vacuum
cup lip. The
7
CA 03150291 2022-02-07
WO 2021/026183
PCT/US2020/044923
noise mitigation features may be formed of, for example, silicone adhesive.
The noise
mitigation features may be evenly spaced with respect to the ribs 97 such that
one feature is
provided (on the top) between ribs (on the bottom).
100391 Figures 9A and 9B show a vacuum cup 100 in accordance with a further
aspect of the
present invention that includes cylindrically-shaped features. The vacuum cup
100 includes
an attachment portion 102 for attaching to an end effector section, a flexible
bellows portion
104, and a flexible flanged portion 106 for creating a seal against objects.
The inner surface
of the flexible flanged portion 106 includes ribs 107 spaced radially inward
of an outer lip
109 of the vacuum cup. The vacuum cup 100 further includes noise mitigation
features 108
in the form of cylinders that are spaced from one another along a
circumference of the
vacutun cup lip. The noise mitigation features may be formed of, for example,
silicone
adhesive. The noise mitigation features may be evenly spaced with respect to
the ribs 107
such that two features are provided (on the top side) between ribs (on the
bottom side).
100401 With further reference to Figure 10, in accordance with the above
aspects of the
present invention, when a seal is not made between a vacuum cup (e.g., 60) and
an object 42,
the noise mitigation features (e.g., 68) near the vacuum cup lip (e.g., 69)
dampen the
vibration of the vacuum cup lip, significantly reducing noise. Each of the
noise mitigation
features also discussed above (e.g., 68, 78, 85, 88, 98) may function
similarly to reduce noise.
Further, certain types of noise mitigation features (such as those discussed
above with respect
to Figures 9A and 9B), may contact each other as shown in Figure 11 when the
lip moves
inward due to a high vacuum flow, further contributing to noise mitigation.
100411 The noise mitigation features may, for example, range from about 0.008
cubic
centimeters to about 1.75 cubic centimeters, and may preferably each be less
than about 1
cubic centimeter in volume in certain embodiments. The noise mitigation
features may also
be formed of any of a silicone based adhesive, epoxy-based adhesive, or other
polymeric
material.
100421 Figure 12 shows vacuum cup similar to that of Figure 6 with larger
noise mitigation
features. In particular, Figure 12 shows a vacuum cup 110 in accordance with
another aspect
of the present invention that includes larger partial spherically-shaped
features. Similarly, the
vacuum cup 110 includes an attachment portion 112 for attaching to an end
effector section, a
flexible bellows portion 114, and a flexible flanged portion 116 for creating
a seal against
8
CA 03150291 2022-02-07
WO 2021/026183
PCT/US2020/044923
objects. The inner surface of the flexible flanged portion 116 includes ribs
117 spaced
radially inward of an outer lip 119 of the vacutun cup. The vacuum cup 110
further includes
larger noise mitigation features 118 in the form of large spheres that are
spaced from one
another along a circumference of the vacuum cup lip. The noise mitigation
features may be
formed of, for example, silicone adhesive. The noise mitigation features may
be evenly
spaced with respect to the ribs 117 such that one feature is provided (on the
top) between ribs
(on the bottom).
(00431 In accordance with various embodiments therefore, the invention
provides a system
for providing automated processing of objects, where the system includes a
programmable
motion device including an end effector that is coupled to a vacuum source,
with the end
effector including a vacuum cup that includes noise mitigation features on an
outer surface
thereof.
100441 Those skilled in the art will appreciate that numerous modifications
and variations
may be made to the above disclosed embodiments without departing from the
spirit and scope
of the present invention.
100451 What is claimed is:
9
