Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
MONITORING LINER WEAR IN INDUSTRIAL MILLS
Cross-reference to Related Applications
This application claims the benefit of United States Provisional Patent
Application
USSN 63/047,958 filed July 3, 2020, the entire contents of which is herein
incorporated by
reference.
Field
This application relates to systems and methods for monitoring liner wear in
mills,
especially industrial.
Background
Mills are important pieces of equipment in comminution. The process of
crushing
and grinding ore is a highly energy consuming step in the mining industry, and
accounts
for more than 50% of mine energy consumption, equating to at least 10% of
production
costs. Comminution also accounts for about 3% of the total amount of
electrical energy
consumed globally. Improving efficiency in comminution would not only result
in higher
productivity, but also lead to reductions in energy consumption and in
emission of
greenhouse gases associated with producing the needed energy.
Liners are widely used to protect mills against wear. The purpose of mill
liners is
two-fold. First, the liner protects the shell of the mill from abrasion and
impact damage
caused by the mill charge. Second, the liner must effectively lift the charge.
The charge can
be ores to be ground (for example in the case of autogenous grinding mills)
but may also
include grinding media (for example balls in the case of semi-autogenous
grinding mills).
Monitoring mill liner condition is important for extending equipment life,
scheduling liner
change-outs, and for optimizing mill operation conditions according to wear
degree of
liners. Currently, inspection of mill liners requires mill shutdown and is
usually performed
every few weeks. Since wear rate may vary significantly due to variations in
liner quality,
properties of materials to be handled and how they are handled, a scheduled
liner schedule
may have happened too early or too late, resulting in unnecessary production
or material
losses. The scheduling approach does not provide real-time wear information
for
continuous optimization of production conditions or for prevention of
unplanned shutdown
of production caused by unexpected liner failure. Improvement of mill
efficiency could be
achieved through real-time monitoring of mill liner wear.
1
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
Improvement of mill efficiency could also be achieved through monitoring of
extent
and location of charge impact. For maximum grinding efficiency and maximum
protection
of liners, it is desirable that the charge strikes on the toe. The location of
charge impact is
controlled through control of mill rotation and is also affected by the shapes
of liners and
feed rates of ores and grinding media.
Therefore, obtaining real-time liner wear and/or charge impact information is
desirable to improve mill efficiency, and the benefits of obtaining both in
real-time could far
exceed only obtaining one or the other, especially when combined with power
draw
measurement, load cell mass measurement and Discrete Element Method (DEM)
charge
motion prediction for optimization of processing conditions (charge feed,
media feed, mill
speed) on a continuous basis.
Various configurations of electrical loops embedded in a liner bolt have been
proposed
for liner wear measurement. For example, (US Patent No. U57172144B1, 2007) in
which an
instrumented liner bolt was assumed to wear at a same rate as the liner
therefore the
measured wear on the instrumented bolt was used as an indicator of liner wear.
Ultrasonic methods have been proposed to measure wear on a liner. For example,
a
plug instrumented with an ultrasound transducer has been proposed (Japan
Patent No. JP
S61127804 (A), 1984), the instrumented plug mounted flush relative to the
inside face of the
liner. As the plug wears at the same rate as the liner, the ultrasonic wear
measurement taken
on the plug provides a measure of wear on the liner. A similar idea was
proposed later for
wear measurement on a mill liner by using an ultrasonically instrumented bolt
inserted into the
liner of the mill (PCT patent publication WO 2019046984A1, 2019). WO
2019046984A1
uses an ultrasound transducer mounted at the threaded end of the bolt to send
a longitudinal
ultrasonic wave through the bolt. The length of the bolt is determined by
measuring the round-
trip travel time of the ultrasonic wave from the transducer to the distal end
of the bolt. The bolt
is expected to wear at the same rate as the surrounding liner. Therefore, by
measuring
reduction in bolt length, the wear on the surrounding liner may be determined.
While the afore-mentioned methods may work when the wear face is perpendicular
to
the longitudinal direction of the rod, their wear measurement accuracy could
be seriously
compromised if the wear face becomes oblique to this direction, which is
highly likely during
the life time of a liner in SAG mills. Furthermore, these disclosures did not
deal with situations
where ultrasonic waves reverberate and mode-converted at the side wall of the
rod, making
ultrasonic waves reflected off the rod end unresolvable.
2
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
Several commercial products are available for monitoring of charge impact. For
example, a shell-mounted vibration sensing system to provide 360-degree real-
time ball
impact polar plot (Digital Control Lab, 2019), a wireless sensor attached to a
liner bolt to
measure the mill's toe angle (OUTOTEC M I LLSENSE MILL CHARGE SENSOR SYSTEM,
2019), and a microphone system to capture sound generated by charge impact on
liners
and provide estimation of the number of steel-on-steel impacts per unit time
to ensure that
the charge is striking on the toe.
There remains a need for improved methods of obtaining liner wear and/or
charge
impact information in real-time in industrial mills.
Summary
A method of monitoring both liner wear and charge impact in a mill comprises:
deploying a sensing probe through an opening in a shell of a mill into a liner
of the shell,
the sensing probe comprising a sensor and an elongated element having a
proximal end
and a distal end, the sensor mounted on the proximal end of the elongated
element outside
the shell, the distal end of the elongated element situated inside the liner
inside the shell
so that the distal end of the elongated element is impacted by charge during
operation of
the mill, the elongated element wearing at a same rate as the liner under
conditions within
the shell, the sensor capable of detecting impact of the charge on the
elongated element
during operation of the mill; using the sensor to determine whether the
elongated element
has decreased in length since a previous length determination and relating a
decrease in
the length of the elongated element to liner wear; and, using the sensor to
determine
variations in charge impact on the elongated element over time and relating
the variations
in charge impact over time to a force of impact events in the mill and/or a
location of the
charge in the mill.
A method of monitoring liner wear in a mill, the method comprising:
propagating
shear ultrasound waves to a distal end of an elongated element deployed
through an
opening in a shell of a mill into a liner of the shell so that the distal end
of the elongated
element is impacted by charge during operation of the mill, the elongated
element wearing
at a same rate as the liner under conditions within the shell; determining
travel time of the
shear ultrasound waves to the distal end; determining whether the travel time
has
decreased since a previous travel time determination; determining a decrease
in length of
the elongated element from a decrease in the travel time of the ultrasound
waves to the
distal end; and, relating the decrease in the length of the elongated element
to liner wear.
3
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
A method of monitoring liner wear in a mill comprising: providing acoustic
markers
on a liner bolt that affixes a liner to a shell of the mill, the liner bolt
having a distal end that
is impacted by charge during operation of the mill and wears at a same rate as
the liner
under conditions within the shell; propagating shear, longitudinal or another
type of
ultrasound waves in the liner bolt; tracking echo signals reflected off an
extreme end of a
wear face of the liner bolt at the distal end of the liner bolt and off a
current distalmost
acoustic marker; determining travel time of the ultrasound waves to the
extreme end of the
wear face, and determining a decrease in travel time to the extreme end of the
wear face
in comparison to a previous travel time determination of the ultrasound waves
to the
extreme end of the wear face; determining a decrease in length of the liner
bolt from the
decrease in the travel time of the ultrasound waves to the extreme end of the
wear face;
and, relating the decrease in the length of the liner bolt to liner wear by
determining when
a waveform of the echo signal reflected off the current distalmost acoustic
marker starts to
change due to a change in shape of the current distalmost acoustic marker
caused by wear
of the liner bolt, determining travel time of the ultrasound waves to the
current distalmost
acoustic marker, determining distances from a proximal end of the liner bolt
to the extreme
end of the wear face and to the current distalmost acoustic marker,
determining liner wear
profile from a difference between the distance from the proximal end of the
liner bolt to the
extreme end of the wear face and the distance from the proximal end of the
liner bolt to the
current distalmost acoustic marker, estimating actual liner wear profile from
the determined
liner wear profile until a next distalmost acoustic marker is reached due to
wear of the liner
bolt, updating liner wear profile information each time the liner bolt wears
down to one of
the acoustic markers as indicated by a change to the waveform of the echo
signal.
An apparatus for monitoring tumbling mill condition and tumbling mill
operation
condition comprises: means for acquiring ultrasonic waves for rod wear
measurement and
audible sound waves for detection and measurement of charge impact with a same
data
acquisition device; means for measuring angular position of the tumbling mill
at each
moment impact data is being recorded; means for conducting the wear and impact
measurements at a plurality of locations; and, means for supplying electric
power to the
apparatus.
The systems and methods described herein permit real-time monitoring of liner
wear and/or charge impact in mills, for example grinding or tumbling mills.
The systems
and methods are especially useful in industrial mills, for example mills used
in the mining
industry to break down ores. Mills for the mining industry may be autogenous
or semi-
autogenous.
4
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
Further features will be described or will become apparent in the course of
the
following detailed description. It should be understood that each feature
described herein
may be utilized in any combination with any one or more of the other described
features,
and that each feature does not necessarily rely on the presence of another
feature except
where evident to one of skill in the art.
Brief Description of the Drawings
For clearer understanding, preferred embodiments will now be described in
detail
by way of example, with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which:
Fig. 1 depicts a schematic diagram depicting a cross-section of a semi-
autogenous
grinding (SAG) mill in operation.
Fig. 2 depicts a schematic diagram of a monitoring system using a single
vibration
sensor to monitor liner wear and charge impact in the mill of Fig. 1.
Fig. 3 depicts a schematic diagram of another monitoring system using a single
vibration sensor to monitor liner wear and charge impact in the mill of Fig.
1.
Fig. 4 depicts a schematic diagram of a monitoring system using a single
ultrasound
sensor to monitor liner wear and charge impact in the mill of Fig. 1.
Fig. 5A, Fig. 5B and Fig. 5C depict schematic diagrams of an instrumented
steel
liner bolt showing different tip shapes as a result of wear in a mill.
Fig. 6A depicts an ultrasound echo signal obtained using a conventional
longitudinal
wave ultrasound transducer on a steel liner bolt with a tip beveled 300 due to
wear.
Fig. 6B depicts an ultrasound echo signal obtained using a shear wave
ultrasound
transducer on the same line bolt as in Fig. 6A with a tip beveled 30 due to
wear.
Fig. 6C depicts a comparison of echo signals reflected off tips having 300 and
600
tip angles on two steel liner bolts of the same length and diameter as in Fig.
6A.
Fig. 7A depicts a schematic diagram of a steel liner bolt having an oblique
wear
face and having reference notches incised on a low side of the steel liner
bolt.
Fig. 7B depicts an ultrasound echo signal obtained using a shear wave
ultrasound
transducer on the steel liner bolt configured as in Fig. 7A.
5
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
Fig. 8A depicts a schematic diagram of a steel liner bolt having an oblique
wear
face and having reference notches incised circumferentially around the bolt.
Fig. 8B depicts an ultrasound echo signal obtained using a shear wave lead
zirconate titanate (PZT) ultrasound transducer mounted on a proximal end of a
cylindrical
steel bolt machined to have an oblique tip of 30 and two circumferential
notches: a) 0.07
mm deep and 0.75 mm wide at 150 mm from the transducer end; and, b) 0.06 mm
deep
and 0.75 mm wide at 450 mm from the transducer end.
Fig. 8C depicts an ultrasound echo signal illustrating a change in waveform of
an
ultrasound echo from a circumferential notch as a lower edge of an angled tip
of the bolt
meets the lower boundary of the notch.
Fig. 9A depicts a perspective diagram of an instrumented cylindrical liner
bolt having
an oblique wear face and having reference notches incised on a low side of the
bolt, and a
layout of a shear wave ultrasound transducer.
Fig. 9B depicts a view of a proximal end of the bolt of Fig. 9A.
Fig. 9C depicts a perspective diagram of an instrumented non-cylindrical liner
bolt
having an oblique wear face and having reference notches incised on a low side
of the bolt,
and a layout of a shear wave ultrasound transducer.
Fig 9D depicts a view of a proximal end of the bolt of Fig. 90.
Fig. 9E depicts a perspective diagram of an instrumented non-cylindrical liner
bolt
having an oblique wear face and having reference notches incised on two sides
of the bolt,
and a layout of a shear wave ultrasound transducer.
Fig. 9F depicts a view of a proximal end of the bolt of Fig. 9E.
Fig. 9G depicts an ultrasound echo signal obtained using a shear wave lead
zirconate titanate (PZT) ultrasound transducer mounted on a proximal end of a
commercially available steel liner bolt machined with six notches: three 2 mm
deep at 240
mm, 429 mm and 680 mm the proximal (sensor) end of the bolt, and three 1 mm
deep at
260 mm, 450 mm and 700 mm from the proximal (sensor) end of the bolt, and an
oblique
tip of 5 .
Fig. 10A depicts a schematic diagram of a steel liner bolt having a rounded
wear
face and having reference notches incised circumferentially around the bolt.
6
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
Fig. 10B depicts a schematic diagram of a steel liner bolt having a rounded
wear
face and having reference notches incised symmetrically on two sides of the
bolt.
Fig. 100 depicts a schematic diagram of a steel liner bolt having a rounded
wear
face and having reference notches incised asymmetrically on two sides of the
bolt.
Fig. 10D depicts a schematic diagram of a steel liner bolt having a rounded
wear
face and having reference notches incised asymmetrically on two sides of the
bolt.
Fig. 11A and Fig. 11B depict schematic diagrams of instrumented steel liner
bolts
showing different tip shapes that the bolts may have as a result of wear in a
mill, the steel
bolts comprising reference notches on low sides thereof.
Fig. 110 and Fig. 11D depict schematic diagrams of instrumented steel liner
bolts
showing different tip shapes that the bolts may have as a result of wear in a
mill, the steel
bolts comprising reference notches on both sides thereof.
Fig. 12 depicts schematic diagram of an end view of a proximal end of an
instrumented steel liner bolt sensing probe showing an ultrasound sensing
arrangement
comprising three electrically interconnected shear wave ultrasound transducers
located on
an end face of the steel bolt.
Fig. 13 depicts schematic diagram of a side view of a proximal end portion of
an
instrumented steel liner bolt sensing probe showing an ultrasound sensing
arrangement
comprising three electrically interconnected shear wave ultrasound transducers
longitudinally spaced along the steel bolt.
Fig. 14A depicts a schematic diagram of an instrumented steel liner bolt
sensing
probe having a rounded tip, reference notches on both sides of the steel bolt
and an
ultrasound sensing arrangement comprising three electrically interconnected
shear wave
ultrasound transducers longitudinally spaced along the steel bolt, and an
illustrative
ultrasound signal.
Fig. 14B depicts a schematic diagram of an instrumented steel liner bolt
sensing
probe having a tip with a curved bevel, reference notches on both sides of the
steel bolt
and an ultrasound sensing arrangement comprising three electrically
interconnected shear
wave ultrasound transducers longitudinally spaced along the steel bolt, and an
illustrative
ultrasound signal.
7
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
Fig. 140 depicts a schematic diagram of an instrumented steel liner bolt
sensing
probe, which is the same as the steel bolt sensing probe of Fig. 14B except
for having the
tip beveled on the opposite side in comparison to the bevel on the tip in Fig.
14B, and an
illustrative ultrasound signal.
Fig. 15A depicts an instrumented steel liner bolt sensing probe having
flattened
portions on opposite sides and comprising reference notches on both of the
flattened
portions, the bolt having a cross-section comprising opposed curves joined by
straight
edges through the flattened portions of the wider body.
Fig. 15B depicts a cross-section view of an instrumented steel liner bolt
sensing
probe depicted in Fig. 15A.
Fig. 16 depicts a vibration signal upon hitting the distal end of a 200 mm
long
cylindrical steel bolt.
Fig. 17 depicts a vibration signal upon hitting the distal end of a 285 mm
long oval-
head bolt.
Fig. 18 depicts a tumbling mill with a mill monitoring apparatus mounted on a
shell
thereof.
Fig. 19A depicts a schematic diagram of a tumbling mill equipped with a strip
of
solar cells for supplying electric power to a mill monitoring apparatus.
Fig. 19B depicts a magnified view of the strip of solar cells depicted in Fig.
19A in
association with artificial lights.
Fig. 20A depicts a schematic diagram of a tumbling mill equipped with a ring
of solar
cells for supplying electric power to a mill monitoring apparatus.
Fig. 20B depicts a magnified view of the ring of solar cells depicted in Fig.
20A in
association with artificial lights.
Detailed Description
The method of monitoring both liner wear and charge impact in a mill involves
using
a system comprising a sensor, preferably a single sensor, for monitoring both
the liner wear
and charge impact in the mill. Being able to use a single sensor to monitor
both liner wear
and charge impact simplifies data collection, simplifies implementation of the
monitoring
system in existing mills, reduces maintenance of the monitoring system and
provides data
8
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
on both liner wear and charge impact at the same location on the shell not
only resulting in
better correlation of liner wear and charge impact information but most
importantly allowing
for a much higher level of optimization of the milling process than if only
wear or impact
information is available. The system comprises a sensing probe deployed
through an
opening in a rotating shell of the mill, the sensing probe comprising an
elongated element
extending into a liner of the shell so that a distal end of the elongated
element is impacted
by charge during operation of the mill. When the sensing probe is first
installed, or when
liner wear is being measured, the distal end of the elongated element is
preferably flush
with an inner surface of the liner, although the elongated element may stop
short of the
inner surface of the liner until the liner wears down to the elongated
element. The inner
surface of the liner is the surface of the liner exposed to an interior volume
of the shell into
which a material to be comminuted is charged. The elongated element comprises
a material
that wears at a same rate as the liner under conditions within the shell.
Therefore, a length
of the elongated element can be used as an indication of wear, and the rate at
which the
elongated element shortens can be used as an indication of wear rate. The
liner and the
elongated element may comprise the same or different materials provided the
materials
wear at substantially the same rate. Preferably, the liner and the elongated
element are
comprised of the same material. The liner and the elongated element preferably
comprise
a metal or metal alloy, for example a steel, iron and the like. The elongated
element may
be a bar, bolt (e.g., a liner bolt), rod or other high-aspect ratio structure.
A liner bolt is
particularly preferred because an existing liner bolt can be retrofitted with
a sensor to form
the sensing probe. The elongated element may have any suitable cross-sectional
shape,
for example circular, elliptical, triangular, tetragonal (e.g., square,
rectangular), pentagonal,
hexagonal, a shape with both curved and straight sides, etc.).
The sensing probe comprises a sensor mount on a proximal end of the elongated
element outside the shell. Thus, the elongated element extends out of both
ends of the
aperture in shell. The sensor is capable of detecting impact of a charge in
the mill on the
elongated element during operation of the mill. When the charge impacts the
elongated
element, vibrations are generated in the elongated element and the sensor
should be
capable of sensing these vibrations as they propagate through the elongated
element.
Preferably, the sensor is a vibration sensor or an ultrasound sensor. The
sensor is
acoustically coupled to the elongated element with help of either an acoustic
couplant or
an adhesive. For measurement of wear on the elongated element, the sensor may
be
operated in an active mode whereby an electric pulse is applied to the sensor
to generate
ultrasonic waves that propagate from the sensor to the distal end of the
elongated element.
Then the sensor is switched to a reception mode to capture ultrasonic waves
bounced back
9
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
from the inside of the elongated element. An electronic unit is utilized for
providing the
electrical pulse as well as conditioning, digitization and recording of the
returned ultrasonic
waves. For measurement of impact on the elongated element, the sensor may be
operated
in a passive mode whereby no electrical pulse is applied to the sensor and the
sensor
captures vibrations and acoustic waves in the elongated element caused by a
charge
impact to the elongated element. The same electronic unit is utilized for
conditioning,
digitization and recording of the vibrations and acoustic waves captured by
the sensor. The
sensor is preferably a piezoelectric transducer and is designed is such a way
that, when
excited with an electric pulse, it generates acoustic waves of much higher
frequencies than
frequencies of vibrations and acoustic waves caused by an impact on the
elongated
element. This feature allows wear on the elongated element to be measured in
the
presence of impact by removing the effect of impacts on captured ultrasound
signal through
the use of a high-pass filter.
To monitor liner wear in the mill, the sensor may be used to periodically or
continuously according to wear status. A decrease in length of the elongated
element is
related to the extent of liner wear. Once the length of the elongated element
drops to a
threshold value, the liner needs to be replaced.
The way in which the length of the elongated element is determined depends on
the type of sensor.
A vibration sensor is a passive sensor that detects vibrations. During the
operation
of the mill, the vibration sensor detects at least one structural resonant
frequency of the
elongated element caused by impact of charge on the elongated element in the
mill. The
vibration sensor determines from the at least one structural resonant
frequency whether
the at least one structural resonant frequency has increased since a previous
structural
resonant frequency determination. Because the frequency of at least one of the
structural
resonances increases in a known relationship that is a function of the type of
material of
which the elongated element is made as the elongated element becomes shorter,
the
decrease in the length of the elongated element can be calculated from the
increase in the
frequency of the at least one structural resonance. The elongated element is
expected to
wear at the same rate as the surrounding liner, therefore liner wear can be
estimated from
the reduction of elongated element length.
An ultrasound sensor suitable for monitoring liner wear may comprise an
ultrasound
transducer or a plurality of ultrasound transducers, which can be operated in
an active
mode. When the ultrasound sensor comprises a plurality of ultrasound
transducers, each
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
of the transducers may be operated independently or may be electrically
interconnected to
operate together. When operated independently, the plurality of ultrasound
transducers is
part of a multi-channel ultrasound system, whereas electrically
interconnecting the
ultrasound transducers permits the use of a single-channel ultrasound system.
The
ultrasound transducer or transducers may emit longitudinal ultrasound waves,
shear
ultrasound waves or both. In a preferred embodiment, the ultrasound transducer
or
transducers emit shear ultrasound waves or both shear and longitudinal
ultrasound waves.
In the active mode, during or not during operation of the mill, an ultrasound
wave is
propagated by the transducer or plurality of transducers to the distal end of
the elongated
element. Round-trip travel time of the ultrasound wave to the distal end and
back to the
ultrasound sensor is determined and compared to the travel time of the
ultrasound wave in
a previous travel time determination. If the travel time has decreased since
the previous
travel time determination, the elongated element has become shorter. The
decrease in the
length of the elongated element is calculated from a decrease in the travel
time of the
ultrasound wave to the distal end using a known relationship that is a
function of the type
of material of which the elongated element is made, and in some cases the
temperature of
the material. The elongated element is expected to wear at the same rate as
the
surrounding liner, therefore the liner wear can be estimated from the
reduction of elongated
element length.
An ultrasound sensor can also be used to monitor charge impact in the mill
during
operation of the mill. In doing so, the ultrasound sensor is operated in
passive mode in the
same manner as a vibration sensor. Monitoring charge impact involves
determining
variations in charge impact on the elongated element over time. The variations
in charge
impact over time may be related to force (strength) of the impacts and/or a
number of
impact events per unit time, which can be used to determine a location of the
charge in the
mill. Monitoring charge impact is done during operation of the mill. A
vibration sensor
continuously detects vibrations of the elongated element caused by the impact
of charge
on the elongated element in the mill, and determines the variations in charge
impact on the
elongated element over time from variations in amplitude of the vibrations
over time. An
ultrasound sensor can be operated in passive mode and used to monitor charge
impact in
the same manner as a vibration sensor. The charge impact is preferably
monitored on a
continuous basis. By monitoring charge impact continuously, 360-degree real-
time charge
impact polar plots for the mill can be obtained, which can be used to locate
the charge in
the mill.
11
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
Data collected by the sensor is either processed locally by a microcontroller
or a
microprocessor in an ultrasonic data acquisition unit, or transmitted to a
remote computer
for determination of liner wear and charge impact information. The information
is then sent
to a control center of the mill for continuous optimization of production
through adjustment
of grinding media feed, charge feed, water feed and rotation speed.
In some embodiments, acoustic insulation is provided between the elongated
element and the shell, between the elongated element and the liner, or between
the
elongated element and both the shell and the liner. In some embodiments, a
tube is
deployed through the opening in the shell into the liner, and the elongated
element is
disposed in the tube to separate at least a portion of the elongated element
from the liner.
The acoustic insulation reduces propagation of vibrations from the surrounding
liner and/or
the shell to the elongated element. Likewise, separating the elongated element
from the
liner with a tube reduces propagation of vibrations from the surrounding
liner.
The shell of the mill bounds the volume in which the material to be comminuted
is
charged along with any desired grinding medium or media. The material to be
charged into
the mill is preferably an ore, and the grinding medium should be harder than
the ore
particles to resist being comminuted by ore particles while assisting with
comminution of
the ore particles. The shell is preferably rotatable about a horizontal so
that while the shell
rotates, the ore charge together with the grinding medium are mixed together
by a rolling
action causing the ore particles to be abraded by contact with other ore
particles, and with
grinding medium if grinding medium is being used. The shell is preferably
cylindrical in
shape, although the shell could have a different shape. The shell is also
typically made of
metal, for example steel, iron or the like.
In the apparatus for monitoring tumbling mill condition and tumbling mill
operation
condition, the means for measuring angular position of the tumbling mill at
each moment
impact data is being recorded preferably comprises a 3-axis accelerometer
capable of
measuring both dynamic acceleration resulting from motion or shock and static
acceleration, such as gravity. The means for conducting the wear and impact
measurements at a plurality of locations preferably applies to a plurality of
locations in a
same cross-section for improved sensitivity and also for early detection of
unbalanced load
or uneven wear in the circumferential direction. Preferably, the means for
conducting the
wear and impact measurements at a plurality of locations applies to a
plurality of cross-
sections in a flow direction of ore. Preferably, the means for measuring
angular position of
the tumbling mill is used for monitoring rotation speed of the mill vs angular
position of the
monitoring apparatus as an indicator of mill operation and health condition.
Preferably, the
12
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
means for supplying electric power to the apparatus comprises solar cells,
more preferably
artificial lights and solar cells. Preferably, the means for supplying
electric power to the
apparatus is turned on when mill monitoring is needed and off after mill
monitoring period
is over.
Referring to Fig. 1 (adapted from Royston D. (2007) Mining, Metallurgy &
Exploration. 24, 121-132), one embodiment of a semi-autogenous grinding (SAG)
mill 1
comprises a cylindrical steel shell 2 lined with a steel liner 3 on an inner
surface of the shell
2. The liner 3 comprises lifting protrusion 3a (only one labeled) extending
inwardly into the
shell 2 to lift an ore charge as the shell 2 rotates, the ore charge
comprising ore particles 4
and grinding media 5 (e.g., steel balls, only two labeled) mixed with the ore
particles 4. The
shell 2 is shown having a counter-clockwise rotation direction R-R, the bulk
of the charge
forming a toe 6 closer to a bottom of the rotating shell 2 and a shoulder 7
closer to a top of
the rotating shell 2 substantially diametrically opposed to the toe 6. As the
shell 2 rotates,
the ore particles 4 and the grinding media 5 from the shoulder 7 fall down to
the toe 6 along
various charge trajectories 8 (only two labeled). Constant motion between the
ore particles
4 in contact with each other, and between the ore particles 4 in contact with
the grinding
media 5, causes comminution of the ore particles 4 into smaller sizes. Charge
shape (toe
6 and shoulder 7) depends on rotation speed of the shell 2, profile of the
liner 3 (e.g., size,
shape and separation of the lifting protrusions 3a), characteristics of the
ore 4, charge
volume and filling fraction of the charge in the shell 2. A single liner wear
and charge impact
sensing probe 10 is inserted through an aperture in the shell 2 at one
location so that the
end of the probe 10 is initially flush with or lower than the inner surface 3b
of the liner 3.
As the shell 2 rotates, the sensing probe 10 moves with the shell 2 thereby
continuously changing angular location with respect to the ore charge. As the
sensing
probe 10 moves through the ore charge from the toe 6 to the shoulder 7, the
sensing probe
10 experiences a larger number of impact events than experienced while the
sensing probe
10 moves between the shoulder 7 and the toe 6. The sensing probe 10 detects
the change
in the number of impact events throughout each cycle of the shell 2, and
knowing the
location of the sensing probe 10 at the transitions between many and few
charge impacts
allows delineation of the location of the toe 6 and shoulder 7 of the ore
charge in the shell
2. The sensing probe 10 also detects the force (strength) of impact of the ore
charge against
the liner 3. Further, the sensing probe 10 is used for periodic or constant
monitoring of liner
wear. With the liner 3 moving relative to the ore charge, the ore charge
abrades the liner
wearing down the liner. The sensing probe 10 can determine the rate of wear.
Based on
real-time wear and charge impact information (e.g., strength and location of
the charge),
13
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
continuous optimization of production is allowed through adjustment of
grinding media feed
(e.g., grinding ball feed), charge feed and rotation speed according degree of
liner wear
and ore quality.
Three variations of the sensing probe 10 are depicted in Fig. 2, Fig. 3 and
Fig. 4,
which depict three examples of liner wear and charge impact monitoring systems
20, 30,
40, respectively.
Referring to Fig. 2, in one embodiment a monitoring system 20 comprises a
single
vibration sensor 21 to monitor liner wear and charge impact in the mill of
Fig. 1 while the
mill is operating. The system 20 comprises an elongated member 22 (e.g., a
liner bolt) that
extends through a through-aperture in the shell 2 of the mill so that a
proximal end of the
elongated member 22 is outside the shell 2 and a distal end of the elongated
member 22
is initially flush with an inner surface 3b of the liner 3. The elongated
member 22 is secured
in the through-aperture by a threaded fitting adapter 23 that is threaded on
to corresponding
threads in the through-aperture. If the through-aperture is not threaded, the
fitting adapter
23 may simply be a nut. The vibration sensor 21 is mounted on the elongated
member 22
proximate the proximal end of the elongated member 22 outside the shell 2. The
vibration
sensor 21 is electronically wired through a cable 24 to a mill monitoring
apparatus 29 so
that vibration data collected by the vibration sensor 21 can be recorded and
processed
locally or transmitted to a remote computer for processing to determine liner
wear and
charge impact information from the vibration data. Liner wear and charge
impact
information is then sent to the controller or control center of the mill for
continuous
optimization of production through adjustment of grinding media feed, charge
feed, and
rotation speed.
The vibration sensor 21 is acoustically isolated from the shell 2 with an
acoustic
insulation fixture 26 inserted in the through-aperture between the shell 2 and
the elongated
member 22 in order to reduce interference from vibrations in the shell 2. An
ore charge
comprising the ore particle 4 and the grinding media 5 impacts the liner 3
along an impact
direction 9 thereby abrading the line 3 and the distal end of the elongated
member 22.
Because the line 3 and the elongated member 22 wear at the same rate, a
reduction in the
length of the elongated member 22, as calculated from increasing frequency of
one of the
structural resonances caused by the charge impacting on the elongated member
22 and
as detected by the vibration sensor 21, is a measure of the wear and wear rate
of the liner
3. Further, as described above, the amplitude of the vibrations in the
elongated member 22
caused by the charge impacting on the elongated member 22 and as detected by
the
vibration sensor 21, is a measure of the force of the charge impacts; and, the
change in
14
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
amplitude of the vibrations over time during a rotational cycle of the shell 2
indicates a
change in the number of impacts overtime, which provides an indication of the
location of
the charge, specifically the toe 6 and shoulder 7 of the charge, in the shell
2.
Referring to Fig. 3, in another embodiment a monitoring system 30 comprises a
single vibration sensor 31 to monitor liner wear and charge impact in the mill
of Fig. 1 while
the mill is operating. As with the system 20 of Fig. 2, the system 30
comprises an elongated
member 32 (e.g., a liner bolt) on which the vibration sensor 31 is mounted, a
threaded fitting
adapter 33 to secure the elongated member 32 in the through-aperture of the
shell 2 and
a mill monitoring apparatus 39 electronically connected to the vibration
sensor 31 by a
cable 34. The system 30 operates identically to the system 20 of Fig. 2 except
that the
system 30 also comprises a hollow tube 35 inserted through the liner 3 in
which the
elongated member 32 is housed. The hollow tube 35 separates the elongated
member 32
from the liner 3 to acoustically insulate the elongated member 32 from
vibrations in the liner
3. There is a gap between the hollow tube 35 and the elongated member 32 to
facilitate
separation. The hollow tube 35 comprises a material that wears at the same
rate as the
liner 3 and the elongated member 32. For example, the hollow tube 35 can be
made of
steel, specifically the same kind of steel as the elongated member 32.
Referring to Fig. 4, in yet another embodiment a monitoring system 40
comprises a
single ultrasound sensor 41 to monitor liner wear and charge impact in the
mill. Similar to
the system 20 of Fig. 2, the system 40 comprises an elongated member 42 (e.g.,
a liner
bolt) on which the ultrasound sensor 41 is mounted, a threaded fitting adapter
43 to secure
the elongated member 42 in the through-aperture of the shell 2 and a mill
monitoring
apparatus 49 electronically connected to the ultrasound sensor 41 by a cable
44. The
ultrasound sensor 41 is capable of being operated in a passive mode and an
active mode.
In the passive mode, the ultrasound sensor 41 operates similarly to the
vibrations sensors
21, 31 of the systems 20, 30 of Fig. 2 and Fig. 3, respectively. Thus, in the
passive mode,
during operation of the mill, the ultrasound sensor 41 detects amplitude of
the vibrations in
the elongated member 42 caused by the charge impacting on the elongated member
42,
which is a measure of the force of the charge impacts; and, detects the change
in amplitude
of the vibrations over time during a rotational cycle of the shell 2, which is
an indication in
a change in the number of impacts overtime, thereby providing an indication of
the location
of the charge in the shell 2, specifically the location of the toe 6 and
shoulder 7 of the charge
in the shell 2. In the active mode, the ultrasound sensor 41, which comprises
an ultrasound
transducer, emits an ultrasound wave in the elongated member 42, which travels
to the
distal end of the elongated member 42 and back to the ultrasound sensor 41
where the
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
arrival of the ultrasound wave is detected and the round-trip travel time
determined. As the
length of the elongated member 42 shortens, the round-trip travel time
shortens, so by
comparing the round-trip travel time to a previous round-trip travel time for
the ultrasound
wave, a reduction in the travel time is used to determine the wear and rate of
wear of the
elongated member 42, which is directly related to the wear and rate of wear of
the liner 3.
In a manner similar to the operation of the system 20 described above, the
mill monitoring
apparatus 49 records and processes collected signals, or transmits the
collected data to a
remote computer for processing to determine liner wear and charge impact
information
from the ultrasonic data and vibration data. Liner wear and charge impact
information is
then sent to the controller or control center of the mill, either from the
mill monitoring
apparatus or from the remote computer, for continuous optimization of
production through
adjustment of grinding media feed, charge feed, and rotation speed.
In an operating mill, wear at the distal end of the elongated element of the
monitoring system is often uneven. While the distal end is flat when the
monitoring system
is first installed, wear at the distal end of the elongated element can result
in a variety of
different wear profiles depending on how and where the charge impacts and
abrades the
elongated element. While a longtitudinal ultrasound wave based wear sensing
method may
work when the wear face is perpendicular to the longitudinal direction of the
elongated
element, such a sensing method may quickly lose its capability to measure wear
accurately if
the wear face becomes oblique to the direction of the ultrasound wave because
the reflected
wave from the distal end of the elongated element will be partially redirected
to an outer wall
of the elongated element and then reverberate and be mode-converted at the
wall to other
types of waves, resulting in the echo signal reflected off the distal end of
the elongated element
being unsolvable for length measurement of the elongated element. To overcome
this
difficulty, shear ultrasound waves may be used. The use of shear ultrasound
waves
significantly reduces mode-conversion and reverberation of unwanted reflected
waves at
the outer wall of the elongated element and provides a capability to measure
wear on the
distal end of the elongated element in a continuous manner even when the wear
profile is
not uniform. In practice, the sensor for transmitting and receiving shear
ultrasound waves
can be a thin-film piezoelectric shear wave transducer with operation
frequencies in a range
of Ito 10 MHz.
In an embodiment of a method of monitoring liner wear in a mill, a shear
ultrasound
wave is propagated to a distal end of the elongated element, which, as
described above,
is deployed through an opening in the shell of the mill into the liner of the
shell so that the
distal end of the elongated element is impacted by charge during operation of
the mill. Also
16
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
as described above, the elongated element comprises a material that wears at a
same rate
as the liner under conditions within the shell. The travel time of the shear
ultrasound wave
to the distal end is determined, and then whether the travel time has
decreased since a
previous travel time determination is also determined. A decrease in length of
the elongated
element is determined from a decrease in the travel time of the ultrasound
wave to the
distal end, and the decrease in the length of the elongated element is related
to liner wear.
With reference to Fig. 5A, Fig. 5B and Fig. 50, an instrumented steel liner
bolt
having different tip shapes as a result of wear in a mill are shown. The
instrumented bolt
comprises an elongated body 52 having a distal end 52a (i.e., the tip)
inserted through the
shell into the liner of the mill, and a proximal end 52b located outside the
shell of the mill.
A wear and impact sensor comprising a shear wave ultrasound transducer 51 is
mounted
on the proximal end 52b of the instrumented bolt 52. Before wear begins, the
distal end
52a of the instrumented bolt 52 is flat (Fig. 5A), which should be flush with
the inner surface
of the liner when the sensing probe is installed or when liner wear is being
measured. Over
time, and depending on liner design and location of the bolt 52, the bolt 52
will wear at the
same rate as the surrounding liner and the tip may take a different shape
(i.e., wear profile)
than being flat (Fig. 5B and Fig. 5C). In Fig. 5B the distal end is oblique,
while in Fig. 5C
the distal end is rounded. To measure wear properly, it is desirable to
measure the longest
distance (bolt length) Lhigh and the shortest distance Llow between the
proximal end 52b
and the distal end 52a of the bolt 52 (Fig. 5B), or the distances Liow, Lmid,
and Lhigh between
the proximal end 52b and the lower edge C, upper edge E, and the extreme end B
of the
wear face (Fig. 50). When combined with liner wear simulation, the values of
Liow, Lmid,
and Lhigh would allow an operator to better understand wear degree and
behavior of the
liner near the bolt 52 than if only one of these distances is available.
Instead of using a conventional longitudinal wave ultrasound transducer, the
shear
wave ultrasound transducer 51 is used to measure Lhigh. An echo signal
obtained for the
instrumented bolt 52 of Fig. 5A with the shear wave ultrasound transducer 51
is shown in
Fig. 6B. The echo signal is well resolved and is of much higher quality than
an echo signal
obtained for the instrumented bolt 52 of Fig. 5A using a longitudinal wave
ultrasound
transducer, which is shown in Fig. 6A. It is clear that the shear wave
ultrasound transducer
can provide for more accurate length measurement than the longitudinal wave
ultrasound
transducer. However, the waveform of the echo signal can change when bolt
length or wear
profile at the distal end 52a of the bolt 52 changes. An example of waveform
change caused
by a change in wear profile is shown in Fig. 6C. The waveform of the echo
signal in the bolt
52 in Fig. 5B with an oblique wear face beveled at an angle of 30 with
respect to a lateral
17
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
axis of the elongated member is indicated as 300 in Fig. 60, while the
waveform in an
identical bolt except with an oblique wear face beveled at an angle of 600 is
indicated as
600 in Fig. 60. A comparison of the two waveforms shows that the arrival time
of the
strongest peak (highest amplitude) of the echo signal would not provide the
most accurate
measurement of the bolt length Lhigh. Instead, earliest arrival 101 of the
echo signal from
the tip provides a better measurement of Lhigh as the earliest arrival time
101 is substantially
the same in both cases.
With reference to Fig. 5B and Fig. 5C, depending on wear profile, bolt length
and
ultrasound transducer frequency, when are available all echoes from the
extreme end of
the wear face of the bolt 52, which is point A on the bolt 52 of Fig. 5B and
point B on the
bolt 52 of Fig. 5C, and from respective lower edge C (Fig. 5B) and lower and
upper edges
D and E (Fig. 5C) of the wear face of the bolt 52, ultrasound travel times
whereby the
distances from the proximal end 52b of the bolt to the extreme end and lower
and upper
edges of the wear face of the distal end 52a of the bolt are determined. Then
the wear
profile is determined as the differences among the above-measured distances.
In practice
it can happen that the received echo signal is predominantly reflected off the
extreme end
of the wear face of bolt 52, but not from lower and upper edges of the wear
face, making
measurement of Low and Lmin difficult. Also, the velocity (or time of flight)
of shear ultrasonic
waves propagating inside a bolt are sensitive to temperature. Without
correcting the effect
of temperature on the time of flight, a 10 C temperature variation would
result in a length
measurement error of 0.15 mm for every 100 mm increase of bolt length. This
error may
add up to other measurement errors to render the accuracy of the final wear
measurement
less acceptable.
To address a lack of ultrasound wave reflection from lower edge(s) of the wear
face
of an elongated element, one or more acoustic reference markers (e.g.,
notches, shallow
holes, through holes and the like) may be inscribed longitudinally spaced
apart along one
or more sides of the elongated element. Holes are preferably oriented
transversely in the
elongated element. Each of the one or more acoustic reference markers act as
reflectors
for ultrasound waves directed to the sides of the elongated element. The echo
signal from
each of the acoustic reference markers as well as from the extreme end of the
tip will appear
as peaks in the waveform of the reflected ultrasound waves. The echo signal
for a given
notch will change in waveform when the acoustic reference marker is reached by
the
advancing wear face and disappear from the waveform as the elongated element
wears
past the given acoustic reference marker. The separation in the waveform
between the
echo signal associated with the extreme end of the tip and the echo signal
associated with
18
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
the acoustic reference marker being reached by the wear face provides a
measure of the
difference in length of the elongated element between the extreme end of the
tip and the
lower edge of the tip, thereby providing a measure of the shortest distance
between the
proximal end and the distal end of the elongated element. When the waveform of
the echo
signal reflected off the current distalmost acoustic reference marker starts
to change due
to a change to the shape of the acoustic reference marker by the advancing
wear face,
travel times of the ultrasound waves from the proximal end of the elongated
element to the
extreme end of the wear face and to the acoustic reference marker being
touched by an
edge of the wear face are determined. Then by using the determined travel
times, the
distances from the proximal end of the elongated element to the extreme end of
the wear
face and to the acoustic reference marker being touched by an edge of the wear
face are
determined. Then the difference of Lhigh and Liow (i.e., AL) or of Lhigh and
Lmid (i.e., ALmid),
is determined. From this point on and until a next acoustic reference marker
is reached by
the new advancing wear face, the value of AL, and if applicable, the value of
ALmid, is used
as a measure of liner wear profile surrounding the elongated element. The
value of AL or
Of ALddd is updated each time an acoustic reference marker has been detected
as just being
reached by the wear face, as indicated by a change to the waveform of the echo
signal
reflected off the acoustic reference marker.
Acoustic reference markers also allow length measurement accuracy to be
validated during mill operation when no access to liners is available for
manual wear
measurement. If the ultrasonic length measurement is reliable, the length
reading should
be the same as the longitudinal distance of an acoustic reference marker from
the
ultrasound transducer when the lower edge of the wear face reaches the bottom
boundary
of the acoustic reference marker or when the extreme end of the wear face
passes the
bottom boundary of the acoustic reference marker. If a cross-correlation
method is used
for time-of-flight measurement, notches will be good check points for updating
a reference
signal. More specifically, the reference signal can be updated whenever the
lower edge of
the wear face reaches the bottom boundary of an acoustic reference marker or
when the
extreme end of the wear face passes the bottom boundary of an acoustic
reference marker.
The number of acoustic reference markers inscribed along the sides of the
elongated
element depends on the length of the elongated element and a desired frequency
at which
the values of AL and AL*, are to be updated or the length measurement accuracy
is to be
validated. Preferably, one of the acoustic reference markers is a lowermost
notch that is
closest to the proximal end of the elongated element, and which represents a
minimum
acceptable length of the elongated element. Once the lower edge of the wear
face of the
elongated element has worn down to the lowest-most acoustic reference marker,
the
19
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
sensing probe will need to be replaced. A good location for an uppermost
acoustic
reference marker would be where the liner wear profile is expected to have
fully developed
into a fairly stable shape as the wear face progresses further.
At a given distance along the elongated element, one acoustic reference marker
or
a number of acoustic reference markers may be inscribed at different
perimetrical locations
around the elongated element. At installation, the elongated element should be
oriented so
that the one or more acoustic reference markers are aligned with a future
lower edge point
of the wear face when the elongated element wears. The future lower edge point
can
usually be predicted from a general trend of liner wear observed in the mill.
If the elongated
element is expected to wear on opposed sides of the elongated element to form
a rounded
tip, acoustic reference markers may be inscribed in opposite sides at a given
longitudinal
location along the elongated element. A perimetrical acoustic reference marker
that
extends completely around a perimeter of the elongated element would
accommodate any
wear profile that the elongated element might acquire due to wear.
As the temperature changes, the ultrasound velocity in the elongated member
changes, resulting in a change of travel times of the ultrasound waves from
the proximal
end of the elongated member to the extreme end of the wear face and acoustic
reference
markers. To correct the effect of temperature on the time of flight of the
ultrasound waves
propagating inside the elongated element, echo signals from the various
acoustic reference
markers can be used to determine the current ultrasound velocity. For example,
let dk and
tk be the distance between the proximal end of the elongated member and a
selected
acoustic reference marker k and the roundtrip travel time of the corresponding
echo signal,
the current ultrasound velocity vc can be obtained as vc = 2*dk/tk. If the
distance between
the proximal end of the elongated member and the selected acoustic reference
marker is
unknown but the initial length of the elongated member is known, the current
ultrasound
velocity can be determined as vc = (210/to)*(tko/tk), where lo is the initial
bolt length, to and
tko respectively the round trip travel times of the ultrasound waves from the
proximal end of
the elongated member to the distal end and the selected acoustic reference
marker k of
the elongated member measured at the same time and before the elongated member
was
put to use, and tk the currently measured round trip travel time of the
ultrasound waves from
the proximal end of the elongated member to the selected acoustic reference
marker K.
Then the value of vc is used to calculate the distances from the proximal end
to the edge(s)
and the extreme end of the wear face at the distal end of the elongated
element.
As indicated above, in order to make installation of the sensing probe more
practical
without having to align a marked side of the elongated element towards a given
direction,
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
perimetrical acoustic reference markers are used. Perimetrical acoustic
reference markers
are particularly useful for generating echo signals for determining current
ultrasound
velocity when calculating length of the elongated element. One difficulty with
using a
perimetrical acoustic reference marker is that when the lower edge of the worn
tip of the
elongated element is passing a lower boundary of an acoustic reference marker,
the
change in waveform of the echo signal from the acoustic reference marker may
not be
obvious because the remaining portion of the acoustic reference marker is
still the main
contributor to the echo signal. Therefore, the signal processing method should
be sensitive
enough to a small change in waveform in order to determine the correct timing
for
measurement of the difference in length of the elongated element between the
extreme
end and an edge of the wear face. Another difficulty with a perimetrical
acoustic reference
marker is that the echo signal from a perimetrical acoustic reference marker
will remain and
could interfere with the echo signal from extreme end of the tip until the
extreme end of the
tip completely passes the acoustic reference marker and the acoustic reference
marker will
not exist anymore, reducing accuracy of the measurement of the longest
distance between
the proximal and distal ends of the elongated element. Although perimetrical
acoustic
reference markers may not provide as accurate length measurement results as
acoustic
reference markers on a longitudinal side of the elongated element for the
period between
when the lower edge of the tip touches the acoustic reference marker and when
the
extreme end of the tip point passes the acoustic reference marker, the
convenience of
installing a sensing probe without having to orient the sensing probe may
overweigh the
slight sacrifice in accuracy of the length measurement.
In another aspect, signature differences in the echo signal waveforms
generated
from different angles of a worn tip could be used to determine wear profile of
the tip. To
achieve this, the waveform of the echo signal reflected off the wear face will
be compared
with waveforms stored in a database containing a mapping between waveforms and
corresponding wear profiles. A wear profile in the said database that provides
the maximum
similarity between its corresponding waveform and the waveform of the
currently captured
echo signal reflected off the wear face will be used as an estimate of the
actual wear profile
of the tip. Using signature differences in waveform to determine wear profile
could replace
or supplement the use of acoustic reference markers.
With reference to Fig. 7A and Fig. 8A, embodiments of instrumented steel liner
bolts
having an oblique wear face are illustrated, the bolts 52 having two reference
notches, a
first notch n1 and a last notch nk, incised thereon. In Fig. 7A, the reference
notches n1 and
ilk are incised only on a low side of the bolts 52 so that the notches n1 and
nk are aligned
21
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
with the future lower edge C when the bolt 52 wears. In Fig. 8A, the reference
notches ni
and nk are incised as perimetrical notches around a perimeter of the bolt 52,
which obviates
the need to predict alignment of the notches n1 and nk with the future lower
edge C when
the bolt 52 wears. The first notch ni is preferably incised at such a height
that when the
lower edge C reaches the first notch n1, the wear profile is already well
developed whereby
the shape of the wear profile remains fairly stable as the bolt 52 further
wears. The last
notch nk is incised at a level of minimum acceptable wear length Lmin for the
bolt 52. Echo
signal from any of the notches n1 and nk or any other notches in-between is
used to
determine and correct effect of temperature on time of flight of the
ultrasonic waves
propagating inside the bolt 52, to permit accurate measurement of Lnigh and
AL.
Fig. 7B shows an example of a waveform obtained for the instrumented bolt of
Fig.
7A and using shear ultrasound waves. The bolt was a cylindrical steel rod
machined to
have a length of 500 mm and a tip of 30 . The tip angle is measured between a
line
extending from the upper edge of the tip parallel to the proximal face and a
line parallel to
a face of the tip of the bolt. The bolt was machined with two notches:
notches: a) 1 mm
deep at 150 mm from the proximal end; and, b) 1 mm deep at 484 mm from the
proximal
end. The proximal end had a cut face to which was mounted a 2.25 MHz shear
wave lead
zirconate titanate (PZT) wafer with shear wave polarization parallel to the
face of the tip. In
Fig. 7B, echoes from the extreme end A of the tip and from the first notch n1
and last notch
Ilk are indicated with SA, Sni, and Snk, respectively and are clearly
identifiable. However, no
echo from the lower edge C of the worn tip of the bolt 52 is observable. As
the lower edge
of the worn tip progresses further to reach the notch n1, the waveform of Si
changes.
When this change in the waveform is observed, the difference AL between Lnign
and Low is
determined by using the echo signal Sn1 reflected off the first notch n1 and
an echo signal
SA reflected off the extreme end A of the tip. As wear progresses further,
Lnigh can always
be determined using the echo signal SA reflected off the extreme end A of the
tip, and the
newly obtained value of AL will be used as a measure of liner wear profile
surrounding the
instrumented bolt until the lower edge C reaches the next notch and then the
value of AL
will be updated. Once the lower edge C passes a notch, the echo signal for
that notch
disappears from the waveform.
Fig. 8B shows an example of a waveform obtained for the instrumented bolt of
Fig.
8A and using shear ultrasound waves. The bolt was a cylindrical steel rod
machined to
have a length of 500 mm and a tip angle of 30 . The tip angle is measured
between a line
extending from the upper edge of the tip parallel to the proximal face and a
line parallel to
a face of the tip of the bolt. The bolt was machined with two circumferential
notches: a) 0.07
22
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
mm deep and 0.75 mm wide at 150 mm from the proximal end; and, b) 0.06 mm deep
and
0.75 mm wide at 450 mm from the proximal end. The proximal end had a cut face
to which
was mounted a 4 MHz shear wave lead zirconate titanate (PZT) wafer with shear
wave
polarization parallel to the face of the tip. As illustrated in Fig. 8B, the
ultrasound method
was able to detect both an ultrasound echo 150 from the 150 mm notch and an
ultrasound
echo 450 from the 450 mm notch, as well as an ultrasound echo 80 from the tip
of the steel
bolt.
As illustrated in Fig. 8C, the waveform of the ultrasound echo 450 from the
450 mm
notch undergoes a distinct change as the lower edge of the angled tip of the
bolt meets the
lower boundary of the 450 mm notch (lower panel) when compared to the waveform
of the
ultrasound echo 450 from the 450 mm notch when the lower edge meets the upper
boundary of the 450 mm notch (upper panel).
While notches between the first notch n1 and the last notch nk are not
illustrated in
Fig. 7A (and Fig. 8A), there are preferably a sufficient number of other
notches between
the first and last notches to provide sufficient updates of AL to sufficiently
calculate the
extent and rate of wear on a continuous basis. The same approach applies to
situations
where the instrumented bolt 52 has a rounded wear tip, such as in Fig. 5C
where the
extreme end of the tip is B, and the lower edges of the tip are D and E. If
perimetrical
notches were inscribed on both sides of the instrumented bolt 52 in Fig. 5C,
echo signals
related to both of the edges D and E can be monitored.
The methods described above for determining wear at the distal end of an
instrumented bolt are applicable to different bolt geometries, for examples,
those illustrated
in Fig. 9A with a circular cross-section of a body of the bolt 52, and Fig. 9C
and Fig. 9E with
non-circular cross-sections. In Fig. 9B and Fig. 9C, the bolt 52 is assumed to
wear quasi-
uniformly in one lateral direction, while non-uniformly in the orthogonal
lateral direction.
Therefore, the methods described above are applied to the non-uniform wear
profile to
determine Lbigb, AL and LI., for the bolts 52 in all three cases. As seen in
Fig. 9E, notches
can be incised on more than one side of the instrumented bolt 52 for
determination of AL
using the methods described above. Fig. 9E depicts the instrumented bolt 52
with notches
incised on two sides of the bolt 52 indicated by nia, nka and nib, nkb,
respectively. Having
notches on more than one side is useful in situations where a future lower
side of the wear
face (i.e., the side with lower edge C) is unknown at the time of bolt
installation but the
value of AL and Low are to be determined regardless of the orientation of the
bolt 52 at
installation. To increase the detectability of echo signals reflected off the
worn tip and
23
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
notches, it may be preferable to align the polarization direction (the double-
headed arrows
in Fig. 9B, Fig. 9D and Fig. 9F) of the shear wave transducer with the
direction of notches
or with a direction that is tangential with the lower edge and the extreme end
of the wear
face. The sensitivity of a worn tip or of a notch to the polarization
direction of the shear
wave transducer may vary according to bolt length and location of the notch.
The
applicability of the disclosed method is not limited by the polarization
direction of the shear
wave transducer illustrated in Fig. 9B, Fig. 9D and Fig. 9F or presented
elsewhere in this
disclosure.
Fig. 9G shows an example of a waveform obtained for the instrumented bolt of
Fig.
9E and using shear ultrasound waves. The bolt was a 723 mm long oval-head bolt
with 90
mm and 51 mm being the wide and the narrow widths of the head section, and 48
mm and
666 mm the diameter and the length of the cylindrical section. The bolt was
machined to
have a tip angle of 5 . The tip angle is measured between a line extending
from the upper
edge of the tip parallel to the proximal face and a line parallel to a face of
the tip of the bolt.
The bolt was machined with six notches: three 2 mm deep at 240 mm, 429 mm and
680
mm the proximal (sensor) end of the bolt, and three 1 mm deep at 260 mm, 450
mm and
700 mm from the proximal (sensor) end of the bolt. Notch width for all notches
was 0.90
mm. The proximal end had a cut face to which was mounted a 2.5 MHz shear wave
lead
zirconate titanate (PZT) wafer with shear wave polarization parallel notches.
As illustrated
in Fig. 9G, the ultrasound method was able to detect ultrasound echoes 100
from all three
of the 1 mm deep notches and ultrasound echoes 200 from all three of the 2 mm
deep
notches, as well as an ultrasound echo 180 from the tip of the steel bolt.
In the following section, methods for determining the values of Lhigh, AL and
Liow,
and, if applicable, the values of Lid and ALmid, are described.
Refer to Fig. 10A, for an elongated element having a perimetrical notch that
extends
completely around a perimeter of the elongated element, the method for
determining the
wear profile of a rounded worn tip comprises: tracking echo signals reflected
off the current
distalmost notch on the elongated element (e.g., ni); when the waveform of the
echo signal
reflected off the notch starts to change (this happens when the lower edge C
of the wear
face reaches the notch), determining the round-trip travel times of the echo
signals from
the notch, ti, and from the extreme end B of the wear face, tB(ni), where
tB(ni) denotes the
value of tB when notch n1 is being reached by the lower edge C of the wear
face, and then
determining the distances from the proximal end 52b of the elongated element
to the notch,
d1, and to the extreme end B of the wear face, dB(ni), where dB(ni) denotes
the value of
dB when notch n1 is being reached by the lower edge C of the wear face,
according to dl =
24
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
yeti/2 and de(ni) = vete(ni)/2, where vc is the ultrasound velocity in the
elongated element
and determined as per procedure disclosed in this application; then
determining AL
according to
AL dB (TO ¨ jd12 ¨ (W/2)2,
where W is the diameter or thickness of the body of the bolt 52. From this
point on and until
the next notch is reached by the wear face, estimates of current Lhigh and
Liow values are
determined according to Lh,gh = vc1B/2, and Liõ = vc113/2 - AL in which vc and
tp are
respectively the current ultrasound velocity and the current the round-trip
travel time from
the proximal end 52b of the elongated element to the extreme end B of the wear
face, and
aL was obtained above. The above approach also applies to an oblique wear face
where
the extreme end B of the wear face joins the edge point E. However,
perimetrical notches
as presented would not allow the values of Lmid and ALmid to be determined.
Refer to Fig. 10B, for an elongated element having notches symmetrically on
two
sides of the element, the method for determining the wear profile of a rounded
worn tip
comprises: tracking echo signal reflected off the current distalmost pair of
notches on the
elongated element (e.g., nia and nib); when the waveform of the echo signal
reflected off
the notches starts to change (this happens when the lower edge C of the wear
face reaches
the notch nu), determining the round-trip travel times of echo signals from
the notches (nu
and nib), tia, and from the extreme end B of the wear face, te(ni.), where
te(nia) denotes
the value of tB when notch nia is being reached by the lower edge C of the
wear face; then
determining distances from the proximal end 52b of the elongated element to
the notches
(ma and nib), di. (which is the same as dib), and to the extreme end B of the
wear face,
dB(ni.), where dB(nia) denotes the value of dB when the notch nia is being
reached by the
lower edge C, according to dia = vetia/2 and de(nia) = vete(nia)/2, where vc
is the
ultrasound velocity in the elongated element and determined as per procedure
disclosed in
this application; then determining DL according to
AL dB(nia) ¨ jclia2 ¨ (W/2)2 ,
where W is the diameter or thickness of the body of the elongated element 52.
After the
lower edge C passes the notch ma, the echo signal reflected off the notch ma
will disappear
but the echo signal reflected off the notch nib will remain and will start to
change in
waveform when the upper edge E of the wear face reaches the notch nib, and
when this
happens, measuring the current round-tip travel time from the proximal end 52b
of the
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
elongated element to the extreme end B of the wear face, te(nib); determining
the distance
from the proximal end 52b of the elongated element to the extreme end B of the
wear face,
dB(nib), according to de(nib) = vete(nib)/2; then determining ALmid according
to
ALmid dB(nib) ¨ jdiõ2 ¨ (W/2)2.
From this point on and until the next notch is reached by the wear face,
estimates
of current Lhigh, Lmid and Low values are determined according to Lhigh=
vc1B/2, Lmid = vetB/2
- ALTha, and Low = vc1B/2 - AL in which vc and tB are respectively the current
ultrasound
velocity and the current the round-trip travel time from the proximal end 52b
of the
elongated element to the extreme end B of the wear face, and ALmk, and AL were
obtained
above. The above approach also applies to an oblique wear face where the
extreme end
B of the wear face joins the edge point E. For an elongated element having
only notches
on the low side of the bolt (i.e., side of lower edge C), AL, Lhigh and Liow
can be obtained
according to the same procedure described above.
It is possible to further determine on which side of an elongated element
falls the
lower edge C or the upper edge E or the extreme end A by incising notches on
two sides
of an elongated element but at different heights. Referring to Fig. 10C and
10D, let h be
the distance between a pair of notches nia and nib (nk, and nkb) in the
longitudinal direction
of the elongated element. Without losing generality, assuming nib is closer to
the extreme
end of the wear face of the bolt in the longitudinal direction. If the lower
edge C is on the
side of notch nib (Fig. 10C), notch nib will be reached by the wear face
(lower edge C)
before notch nia is reached by the upper edge E. If the lower edge C is on the
side of the
notch nia, then either one of notches nia and nib could be reached by the wear
face before
the other (Fig. 10D). In order to determine the wear profile on worn tip of
the elongated
element, proceed as follows: tracking echo signal reflected of notch nia, and
whenever a
change in waveform of the echo signal is observed, determining the round-trip
travel times
of echo signals from the notch nia, tia, and from the extreme end B of the
wear face, tB(nia),
where tB(nia) denotes the value of tB when notch nia is being reached by an
edge of the
wear face; and then determining the values of di, and cle(nia) according to
dia = vetia/2
and dB(nia) = vc"tB(nia)/2, where vc is the ultrasound velocity in the
elongated element and
determined as per procedure disclosed in this application; then calculating
ALa dB(nia) (47/2)2,
26
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
where W is the diameter or thickness of the body of the elongated element 52;
tracking
echo signal reflected of notch nib, and whenever a change in waveform of the
echo signal
is observed, determining the round-trip travel times of echo signals from the
notch nib, tib,
and from the extreme end B of the wear face, te(nib), where Willi)) denotes
the value of te
when notch nib is being reached by an edge of the wear face; and then
determining the
values of dib and dB(nib) according to dib = vetib/2 and dB(nib) =
vetB(nib)/2, where vc is
the ultrasound velocity in the elongated element and determined as per
procedure
disclosed in this application; then calculating
ALb de(nib) ¨ (W/2)2 =
If AL, > ALb, then the lower edge C is on the side of notch nia and AL = AL,,
ALmw = ALb.
If AL, < ALb, then the lower edge C is on the side of notch nib and AL = ALb,
ALmid = AL,.
If AL, ALb, the wear profile would be considered symmetrical about the central
axis of
the elongated element. From this point on until next pair of notches have been
reached by
the wear face, estimates of current Lhigh, Lmid and Liow values are determined
according to
Lhigh = VC1B/2, Lmid = VC1B/2 - ALmid, and Low= vetB/2 - AL in which vc and tB
are respectively
the current ultrasound velocity and the current the round-trip travel time
from the proximal
end 52b of the elongated element to the extreme end B of the wear face, and
ALmid and
AL were obtained above. It is to note that the above approach applies to an
elongated
element having an oblique tip on which the extreme end B of the wear face
coincides with
its upper edge point E and ALmjd = 0. In order for the method to work, the
longitudinal
distance (value of h) between two notches of the same pair needs to be
sufficiently large
so that echoes from the two notches are resolvable.
Ultrasound signal received by the wear measurement system not only contains
the
echo signal from the extreme end of the tip of the elongated element, but also
background
echoes from other part of the elongated element, for example, from thread of a
bolt and
notches. When the two categories of echoes overlap, the echo signal from the
extreme end
of the tip of the elongated element will be less discernable, making the
measurement of
Lhigh less accurate. As the elongated element wears, the element becomes
shorter and
shorter, and as a result the echo signal from the extreme end of the tip of
the element
arrives sooner and sooner. In the meantime, the background echoes remain
stable
therefore can be subtracted from the received ultrasound signal to make the
echo signal
from the extreme end of the tip of the elongated element more discernable,
resulting in
more accurate measurement of Lhigh. This is particularly beneficial when the
worn tip is no
longer flat. In practice, a set of reference signals were to be taken at
various temperatures
27
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
far before the current wear measurement takes place. For each reference
signal, the travel
time from the proximal end of the elongated element to a selected acoustic
marker (e.g.,
notch) is determined. For a current wear measurement, first an ultrasound
signal from the
instrumented elongated element is taken. From this signal, the travel time
from the proximal
end of the elongated element to the same selected acoustic marker (e.g.,
notch) is
determined and then compared with a table of travel times to the same acoustic
marker for
all stored reference signals. The reference signal that has produced a travel
time value
closest to that produced by the current signal is selected and subtracted from
the current
signal for removable of background echoes for the determination of Lhigh.
Since bolt
temperature can affect the waveform of ultrasound signal, for the subtraction
to work best
for removal of background echoes, the current ultrasound signal and the
selected reference
signal need to be acquired at the same temperature. This travel time-based
selection of
reference signal provides an effective way in selecting a reference signal
which was
acquired at a temperature closest to the current temperature of the elongated
element.
With reference to Fig. 11A, Fig. 11B, Fig. 11C, Fig. 11D, Fig. 12, Fig. 13,
Fig. 14A,
Fig. 14B and Fig. 14C, for instrumented steel liner bolt sensing probes, three
ultrasound
sensors with shear wave ultrasound transducers 61a, 61b, 61c, for example
shear wave
PZT wafers, are mounted at proximal ends 62b of the steel bolts 62 along a
central lateral
line Y-Y (see Fig. 12). The ultrasound transducers 61a, 61b, 61c may be
mounted in a
coplanar manner on proximal end faces of the steel bolts 62, or the ultrasound
transducers
61a, 61b, 61c may be mounted longitudinally offset from each other as shown in
Fig. 13.
The three ultrasound transducers 61a, 61b, 61c can be operated independently,
in which
case a three-channel ultrasonic system is used. The three ultrasound
transducers 61a,
61b, 61c could instead be interconnected electrically to be excited at the
same time,
whereby the ultrasound echo signals received by each of them will overlap, in
which case,
only a single channel ultrasonic system is needed. If the Low sides of the
steel bolts 62 can
be predicted according to existing knowledge on liner wear evolution, first
and last notches
ni and nk, and any other notches, may be incised on the Liow sides of the
steel bolts 62
(Fig. 11A and Fig. 11B). In Fig. 11A and Fig. 11B, the shear wave ultrasound
transducers
61a, 61b, 61c shown mounted in a coplanar manner on the faces of the proximal
ends 62b
will capture echo signals reflected off the notches ni and ilk and the extreme
ends A and
B of the tips of the steel bolts 62, and Lhigh, AL and Llow are determined in
the same manner
as described previously. If the Liow sides of the steel bolts 62 cannot be
predicted, first
notches nia, nib and last notches nka, nkb, and any other notches, may be
incised on
opposite sides of the steel bolts 62 at the same heights as shown in Fig. 11C
and Fig. 11D,
or at different heights as shown in Fig. 100 and Fig. 10D. Determinations of
Lhigh, AL and
28
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
Liow , and if applicable, Lmid and ALmid, are accomplished in a similar manner
as described
previously. In Fig. 11C and Fig. 11D, the ultrasound transducers 61a capture
echo signals
reflected off the first and last notches nia and nka, the ultrasound
transducers 61c capture
echo signals reflected off the first and last notches nib and nkb, and the
ultrasound
transducers 61c capture echo signals reflected off the extreme ends A, B of
the tips of the
steel bolts 62.
The three ultrasound transducers 61a, 61b, 61c shown can be of different types
provided at least one is a shear wave ultrasound transducer. For example,
ultrasound
transducers 61a and 61b may be shear wave ultrasound transducers, while
ultrasound
transducers 61c are longitudinal wave ultrasound transducers. Since
longitudinal and shear
ultrasound waves travel at different velocities, echo signals from notches nia
and nka,
captured by ultrasound transducers 61a will arrive at different times than
echo signals from
notches nib and "kb captured by ultrasound transducers 61c, thereby
simplifying the
determination of which edge D or E in Fig. 11D is reaching a notch.
With reference to Fig. 13 in particular, to increase measurement accuracy, the
ultrasound transducers 61a and 61c proximate lateral peripheries of the steel
bolts 62 may
be mounted at locations more distal of the proximal face away from threads 64
of the steel
bolts 62, and further to the peripheries of the steel bolts 62 than depicted
in Fig. 12. Such
an arrangement gives the ultrasound transducers 61a and 61c higher sensitivity
to echo
signals from the notches and the extreme ends of the tip. Furthermore,
ultrasound
transducers 61a and 61c will not be or will be less affected by echo signals
from the threads
64. In addition, longitudinally separating the ultrasound transducers 61a,
61b, 61c
facilitates measuring AL,õid and Lmid in addition to of Liiign, AL and Liow_
If a single-channel
electronic system is used, three ultrasound transducers 61a, 61b, 61c will
need to be
interconnected electrically_ To avoid overlap of echo signals, the minimum
distance
between the ultrasound transducers 61a, 61b, 61c is preferably sufficiently
larger than the
expected value of AL shown in Fig. 11B and Fig. 11D.
Fig. 14A, Fig. 14B and Fig. 140 show steel bolt sensing probes having tips
with
different wear profiles. The steel bolts 62 are incised with first notches nia
and nib on
opposite sides of the steel bolts 62 and with last notches nka and "kb on
opposite sides of
the steel bolts 62. The ultrasound sensing arrangement comprises the three
shear wave
ultrasound transducers 61a, 61b, 61c electrically interconnected and
longitudinally spaced
along the steel bolts 62.
29
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
Fig. 14A shows a schematic of echo signals received by the interconnected
ultrasound transducers 61a, 61b, 61c when the steel bolt 62 has a rounded wear
profile.
The first notch nia will be reached by lower edge D of the tip before the
other first notch nib
will be reached by lower edge E of the tip. At the moment the waveform of echo
signal
Sn1a(61a), which is from the first notch nia and captured by the ultrasound
transducer 61a,
starts to change, the measurement of arrival times of the echo signal
Snia(61a) from the first
notch nia and the echo signal SB(61b) from the extreme end B of the tip
captured by the
ultrasound transducer 61b permits determination of AL. At the moment the
waveform of
echo signal S1111)(610, which is from the other first notch nib and captured
by the ultrasound
transducer 61c, starts to change, the measurement of arrival times of the echo
signal
Sn1b(61c) from the other first notch nib and the echo signal SB(61b) from the
extreme end B of
the tip captured by the ultrasound transducer 61b permits determination of
ALmid. The
values of AL and ALmid permit future values of Liow and Linid to be evaluated
according to
Liow Lhigh - AL and Loki Lhigh - ALmid, where Lhigh is determined by using the
arrival time
of the echo signal SE1(61b) from the extreme end B of the tip.
Fig. 14B shows a schematic of echo signals received by the interconnected
ultrasound transducers 61a, 61b, 61c when the steel bolt 62 has a curved bevel
wear
profile. The ultrasound sensing arrangement shown in Fig. 14B can also be used
to
determine which side of the steel bolt 62 is the Lhaw side when the tip of the
steel bolt 62
has a curved bevel wear profile. In Fig. 14B, echo signal Sni3(613) from the
first notch nia is
captured by the ultrasound transducer 61a and will be affected by the lower
edge C of the
tip before echo signal Sn1b(61c) from the other first notch nib captured by
the ultrasound
transducer 61c will be affected by the extreme end A of the tip. Echo signal
SA(61C) from the
extreme end A of the tip captured by the ultrasound transducer 61c will always
arrive later
than the echo signal Sn1b(61c) from the other first notch nib until the other
first notch nib is
reached by the extreme end A of the tip. At the moment the echo signal Sni
a(61 a) from the
first notch nia starts to change, the measurement of arrival time of echo
signal Sni a(61a) and
arrival time of echo signal Spoi permits the value of AL to be determined.
Then future
value of Low can be evaluated according to Low Lhigh - AL where Lbw!, is
determined by
using the arrival time of the echo signal SA(61) from the extreme end A of the
tip. Since the
echo signal Snla(61a) from the first notch nia changes before the echo signal
Slim(
61c) from.
the other first notch nib, the Liow side must be on the side of the ultrasound
transducer 61a.
Fig. 140 shows a schematic of echo signals received by the interconnected
ultrasound transducers 61a, 61b, 61c when the steel bolt 62 has a curved bevel
wear profile
on an opposite side as the curved bevel in Fig. 14B. Here, echo signal Sill
b(61c) from the
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
other first notch nib captured by the ultrasound transducer 61c changes twice
before echo
signal Sn1a(61a) from the first notch nia captured by the ultrasound
transducer 61a changes.
Because the echo signal Sn1b(61c) from the other first notch nib changes
before the echo
signal Sn1a(61a) from the first notch nia, the Law side must be on the side of
the ultrasound
transducer 61c. However, signal processing is more difficult. As the steel
bolt 62 wears,
echo signal SA(61a) from the extreme end A of the tip captured by the
ultrasound transducer
61a will be moving in direction M towards, then overlapping with, and then
moving away
from the echo signal Sn1b(61c) from the other first notch nib. However, the
echo signal Sn1b(61c)
from the other first notch nib is stable before the other first notch nib has
been reached by
the extreme end A of the tip. When the echo signal SA(61a) from the extreme
end A of the
tip and the echo signal Snib(61c) from the other first notch nib overlap, a
copy of the echo
signal Snib(610 from the other first notch nib recorded earlier can be
subtracted from the
current echo signal to make the echo signal from the extreme end A of the tip
stand out to
ensure measurement quality of Lhigh. Furthermore, to achieve good measurement
accuracy
of Low, the distance between the ultrasound transducers 61a and 61c should be
far enough
so that when lower edge C of the tip moves close to the other first notch nib,
the echo signal
Snlb(61c) from other first notch nib is well separated from echo signal
SA(61a) from the extreme
end A of the tip.
With reference to Fig. 15A and Fig. 15B, to further improve wear measurement
accuracy, a steel bolt sensing probe 70 is provided with a steel bolt 72 that
is flattened on
opposite sides of a distal portion 73 of the steel bolt 72. The steel bolt 72
has a distal end
72a and a proximal end 72b. The distal portion 73 is wider than the proximal
end 72b,
which has a cross-section comprising opposed curves joined by straight edges.
The
flattened sides of the distal portion 73 are inscribed with reference notches
nia, n2, and nka
and nib, n2b and nkb. Mounted on a face of the proximal end 72b is an
ultrasound sensing
arrangement comprising three shear wave ultrasound transducers 71a, 71b, 71c.
Curved
sides of the proximal end 72b have threads 74 on which a nut may be threaded
to secure
the sensing probe 70 in the through-aperture in the shell of the mill.
Measurements are
made in the same manner as described above.
Fig. 16 shows a vibration signal upon hitting the distal end of a 200 mm long
cylindrical steel bolt with the metallic shaft of a screw driver. The distal
end of the bolt had
a 600 tip. The signal was captured with the same shear wave ultrasound
transducer used
in Fig. 8B. Fig. 17 shows a vibration signal upon hitting the distal end of a
285 mm long
oval-head bolt with the metallic shaft of a screw driver. The distal end of
the bolt had a 450
tip. The signal was captured with the same shear wave ultrasound transducer
used in Fig.
31
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
9G. The validity of using a same shear wave ultrasound transducer for both
impact
detection in a passive (listening) mode and wear measurement in an active
(pulse echo)
mode has therefore been proven.
The active mode for wear measurement uses ultrasound waves with center
frequency
in the 1 MHz to 10 MHz range. Depending on the highest frequency component of
the
signal, a sampling rate of 20 MHz to 100 MHz would usually be adequate.
However, most
noticeable vibrations caused by an impact on a rod suitable for mill
monitoring fall in the
audible frequency range, namely 20 to 20 kHz. A sampling frequency of 20 MHz
to 100
MHz suitable for some ultrasonic waves would be too high for impact
measurement
because at this high sampling rate a very large number of samples will be
needed to cover
a few cycles of an audible signal, which is not only unnecessary but also very
demanding
in terms of storage capability and calculation power of the electronics. In
order to use one
single acoustic mill monitoring apparatus to effectively handle both
ultrasound signals and
audible signals, the following method may be employed. First of all, for
active wear
measurement, a trigger signal at a repetition frequency of 100 Hz to 500 Hz is
used to
trigger the excitation of ultrasonic waves in a rod and use the same trigger
signal to trigger
the digitizer to acquire the ultrasonic echo signal from the rod at a high
sampling rate (for
example, 80 MHz). A large number of acquired ultrasonic signal traces is
averaged to
improve the signal to noise ratio and then the averaged signal is used for
determination of
wear. For passive impact monitoring, the trigger signal is sent at a much
higher repetition
frequency, for example 100 kHz, and the trigger signal is used to trigger the
digitizer to
acquire only one sample point of the impact signal but without triggering the
high voltage
excitation pulse to the transducer. Therefore, the trigger frequency (100 kHz)
becomes the
sampling frequency of the audible impact noise signal instead of the 80 MHz of
the digitizer.
This approach can be realized through proper hardware, firmware and software
designs of
the apparatus.
As seen in Fig. 18, in implementation, a mill monitoring apparatus 59 may be
affixed
to a shell 12 of a tumbling mill 11 and rotates with the shell 12. The mill
monitoring
apparatus 59 comprises a means for determining its angular position a. And
this angular
position a is used as a reference for determining angular positions of
wear/impact sensors
with respect to a vertical line V (00) when an impact signal is being
recorded. While the
means for determining the angular position of the mill monitoring apparatus 59
could be a
tilt sensor, an accelerator or a gyroscope, a 3-axis accelerometer capable of
measuring
both dynamic acceleration resulting from motion or shock and static
acceleration, such as
gravity, is a good choice. In mounting, the mill monitoring apparatus 59 is
positioned in
32
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
such a way that the Z-axis Z of the accelerometer inside the mill monitoring
apparatus 59
points to the direction perpendicular to the surface of the shell 12 and the X-
axis X of the
accelerometer points to the rotation direction (big arrow) of the mill 11. By
monitoring the
angular position of the mill monitoring apparatus 59, rotation speed of the
mill 11 vs. angular
position of the mill monitoring apparatus 59 can also be determined and used
as an
indicator of mill operation and health condition. The mill monitoring
apparatus 59 could be
affixed to a feed head or a discharge head of the mill 11, if deemed
practical. To reduce
adverse effects of high temperature of the tumbling mill 11 to the electronics
as well as
interference from impact induced vibration on accelerometer angle measurement,
the mill
monitoring apparatus 59 is thermally and acoustically insulated from the shell
12 of the
tumbling mill 11 with thermal insulation and vibration absorption pads 13.
The mill monitoring apparatus can monitor a plurality of locations through
multiplexing. For example, with a 16-channel apparatus, four cross-sections at
different
locations in the flow direction of ore can be monitored. At each cross-
section, 4 probes can
be installed at 900 apart from each other. By using 4 probes in one cross-
section, impact
noise can be measured with any of the 4 probes passing under the impact
region, therefore
increasing the chance of metal-to-metal impact being detected. Multiple
location wear and
impact monitoring in the same cross-section may also provide early detection
of
unbalanced load or uneven wear in the circumferential direction. A 4-by-4
probe
arrangement allows for the above measurements in four cross-sections. The
number of
available channels and arrangement of probe locations can be adjusted
according to the
specific needs of production. Data recorded during multiple revolutions of the
mill and from
different locations can be used jointly to provide more reliable and more
profound insight
into the health and operation conditions of the mill than a small set of
measurements from
a single sensor.
An electric power source is important to continuous operation of the mill
monitoring
apparatus. Unless the mill monitoring apparatus is energy sufficient during
the entire
monitoring period (depending on energy consumption, battery capacity, length
of intended
monitoring period, and environmental temperature), there will be need to
supply energy
from an outside energy source to the apparatus to sustain its operation. Power
supply
through an electrical cable to the apparatus on a rotating shell is not
trivial. There are a
variety of ways to harvest energy from a rotating mill, but there seem to be
no commercial
products that are robust, practical, cost-competitive and efficient enough to
harvest the
energy needed.
33
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
WO 2022/000072
PCT/CA2021/050844
In one embodiment of an alternative solution as illustrated in Fig. 19A and
Fig. 19B,
a strip of flexible solar cells 84 is installed around the shell 12 of the
tumbling mill 11, the
mill 11 having a feed head 14 and a discharge head (not shown) on opposite
faces of the
shell 12. Artificial lights 85 (only one labeled) are used to irradiate the
strip of flexible solar
cells 84 to generate electricity. The electricity thus generated is used to
power the mill
monitoring apparatus. Depending on the electrical power needed, the number of
artificial
lights 85 can be adjusted to provide enough electricity. When it is time to
measure liner
wear or charge impact, the lights 85 are switched on. When the measurement is
over, the
lights 85 are switched off. According to the present state of the art, a
combination of
monocrystalline silicon cells and incandescent light would provide the highest
energy
output compared with combinations of other types of photovoltaic cells and
artificial light,
and therefore a choice of power supply for the mill monitoring apparatus. As
well, spotlight
type incandescent bulbs are preferred due to the capability to direct produced
light to
energy cells. Alternatively, as illustrated in Fig. 20A and Fig. 20B, the
strip of flexible solar
cells 84 can be installed as a ring on the feed head 14 or the discharge head
(not shown)
of the shell 12 of the mill, if deemed practical.
In addition to monitoring wear and impact on liners within the shell, the
invention
applies to monitoring wear and impact on liners inside feed head and discharge
head as
well.
The novel features will become apparent to those of skill in the art upon
examination
of the description. It should be understood, however, that the scope of the
claims should
not be limited by the embodiments, but should be given the broadest
interpretation
consistent with the wording of the claims and the specification as a whole.
34
CA 03181236 2022- 12- 2
