Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02547270 2012-05-10
LIFT ASSIST DEVICE AND METHOD
Field of the Invention
The invention relates to a motion assistance device that is worn by a subject,
and
which stores and provides energy for aiding a task or motion involving
articulation of one or
more joints, particularly lifting or moving a mass. In particular, the
invention provides a
device and method for assisting a subject to perform a manual task such as
lifting an object.
Background of the Invention
During bending and lifting activities, erector spinae muscles must generate a
large
extensor moment to raise the upper body, and the object lifted, into an
upright position
(McGill and Norman, 1986). Since these muscles act on short lever arms, a high
tensile
force is required, and the lumbar intervertebral discs are subjected to a high
compressive
force. Occupations and tasks which demand frequent and heavy lifting are
associated with
a greatly increased risk of disc prolapses (Kelsey et al., 1984) and with low
back pain in
general (Kelsey and White, 1980). Indeed, severe chronic or acute low back
injuries
account for 25% of workers' compensation claims in the U.S. (Guo et al.,
1995).
Injury prevention strategies include educating workers regarding proper
techniques
for lifting, sharing lifting tasks between several workers, and using
mechanical aids for lifting
(Waters and Putz-Andersson, 1994). Mechanical lifting devices, such as hoists,
are
effective in eliminating muscle strain when loads are beyond human lifting
capability.
However, when loads are within perceived human lifting capability, there is a
tendency for
subjects to lift manually as most mechanical lifting aids are slower than
human speed and
may not be easily accessible (Kazerooni, 2002).
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
Devices that are worn and support subjects in performing lifts have been
proposed.
An example of such a device is a lifting belt which acts as a rigid band
around the waist, thus
increasing intra-abdominal pressure. Current research findings suggest that
lifting belts are
not an effective means of reducing spinal loads (McGill, 1993 and 2002; NIOSH,
1994;
Lavender et al., 2000; Chen, 2003), but might enhance spinal stability
(Cholewicki, 2004;
Hodges et al., 2004). However, it has been shown that wearing a lifting belt
increases blood
pressure which may increase the incidence of hemorrhoids, hernias, and
varicose veins,
particularly testicular varicose veins (Harman et aL, 1989; Rafacz and McGill,
1996).
There is a need for an affordable effective device which is comfortably worn
and
helps a subject to perform activities that can otherwise lead to muscle
strain.
Summary of the Invention
In a first aspect of the invention there is provided a device for assisting a
subject to
perform a motion, comprising: a first anchor attachable to a first segment on
a first side of
one or more joints of the subject's body; a second anchor attachable to a
second segment
on a second side of the one or more joints; and an elastic member connecting
the first
anchor and the second anchor; wherein when said first and second anchors are
attached to
the first and second segments, articulation of the one or more joints in a
first direction
causes deformation of the elastic member and storing of energy, and
articulation of the one
or more joints in a second direction causes relaxation of the elastic member
and release of
stored energy; and wherein the release of stored energy assists the subject to
perform a
motion in said second direction.
In one embodiment, wherein tension of the elastic member is adjustable. The
elastic
member may be selected from a spring, an air-, liquid-, or gas-filled
actuator, a magnetic
actuator, an elastic band, tube, or cord, and a combination thereof. In
another embodiment,
at least one of the anchors may be fixed to clothing. The one or more joints
may be
-2-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
selected from the group consisting of waist, ankle, wrist, knee, hip, elbow,
shoulder, and at
least one joint of the back and/or neck. The first and second anchors may be
independently
selected from a bar, ring, clip, hook, buckle, roller, pulley, guide, channel,
and a receptacle.
In another embodiment, the invention further comprises: a first belt for
attaching to
the first segment; and a second belt for attaching to the second segment;
wherein the first
and second anchors are disposed on the first and second belts.
According to another aspect of the invention, there is provided a device for
assisting
a subject to perform a lift, comprising: a first anchor attachable to the
subject's shoulder;
a second anchor attachable to the subject's waist; at least a third anchor
attachable to at
least one of the subject's legs; a first elastic member connecting the first
anchor and a
second anchor; and a second elastic member connecting the second anchor and
the at least
third anchor; wherein, when the first and second elastic members are attached
to the first,
second, and third anchors, upon articulation of at least one joint selected
from (a) one or
more joints of the back, (b) the waist, and (c) the knee(s), at least one of
said first and
second elastic members is deformed or relaxed.
In one embodiment, tension of at least one of the first and second elastic
members is
adjustable. In other embodiments, at least one of said anchors may be fixed to
clothing, and
the first and second elastic members may be independently selected from a
spring, an air-,
liquid-, or gas-filled actuator, a magnetic actuator, an elastic band, tube,
or cord, and a
combination thereof. The first, second, and third anchors may be independently
selected
from a bar, ring, clip, hook, buckle, roller, pulley, guide, channel, and a
receptacle.
In another embodiment, the device may further comprise: a first belt for
attaching to
the subject's shoulders; a second belt for attaching to the subject's waist;
and a pair of leg
belts for attaching to the subject's legs; wherein the first and second
anchors are disposed
on the first and second belts, and the third anchor comprises a pair of
anchors, a first anchor
-3-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
of the pair being disposed on one of the leg belts, and a second anchor of the
pair being
disposed on a second leg belt.
In accordance with another aspect of the invention there is provided a method
for
assisting a subject to perform a motion, comprising: attaching a first anchor
to a first
segment on a first side of one or more joints of the subject's body; attaching
a second
anchor to a second segment on a second side of the one or more joints; and
connecting an
elastic member between the first anchor and the second anchor; wherein
articulation of the
one or more joints in a first direction causes deformation of the elastic
member and storing
of energy, and articulation of the one or more joints in a second direction
causes relaxation
of the elastic member and release of stored energy; and wherein the release of
stored
energy assists the subject to perform a motion in said second direction.
A further aspect of the invention relates to a method for assisting a subject
to perform
a lift, comprising: attaching a first anchor to the subject's shoulder;
attaching a second
anchor to the subject's waist; attaching at least one anchor to at least one
of the subject's
legs; connecting a first elastic member between the first anchor and the
second anchor; and
connecting a second elastic member between the second anchor and the anchor(s)
attached to at least one of the subject's legs; wherein, upon articulation of
at least one joint
selected from (a) one or more joints of the back, (b) the waist, and (c) the
knee(s), at least
one of said first and second elastic members is deformed or relaxed; and
wherein deforming
and relaxing of the elastic member assists the subject in performing a lift.
In another aspect, the invention provides a device for assisting a subject to
perform a
motion, comprising: a first anchor attachable to a first segment on a first
side of one or more
joints of the subject's body; a second anchor attachable to a second segment
on a second
side of the one or more joints; and an electric motor and cable connected to
the first anchor
and the second anchor; wherein when said first and second anchors are attached
to the first
and second segments, the electric motor senses articulation of the one or more
joints and
-4-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
controls tension in the cable; wherein controlling tension in the cable
assists the subject to
perform the motion.
In one embodiment, the device may further comprise: a third anchor attachable
to a
'third segment on a first or second side of the one or more joints; and at
least one electric
motor and cable connected to at least one of (a) the first anchor and the
second anchor, (b)
the second anchor and the third anchor, and (c) the first anchor and the third
anchor;
wherein when said first, second, and third anchors are attached to the first,
second, and third
segments, the at least one electric motor senses articulation of the one or
more joints and
controls tension in the cable; and wherein controlling tension in the cable
assists the subject
to perform the motion.
In a another aspect of the invention there is provided a device for assisting
a subject
to perform a motion, comprising a first anchor attachable to a first side of a
joint of the
subject's body, a second anchor attachable to a second side of the joint; and
an elastic
member connecting the first anchor and the second anchor such that when said
first and
second anchors are attached, articulation of the joint in a first direction
causes stretching of
the elastic member and storing of energy, and articulation of the joint in a
second direction
causes relaxation of the elastic member wherein the energy is released and
assists the
subject to perform a motion in the second direction.
In another aspect, the invention provides a device for assisting a subject to
perform a
lift comprising a first anchor attachable to the subject's shoulder, a second
anchor attachable
to the subject's lower back, a third anchor attachable to the subject's lower
leg, a first elastic
member connecting the first anchor and the second anchor, and a second elastic
member
connecting the second anchor and the third anchor; such that upon articulation
of the
subject's upper back at least one of the first and second elastic members is
stretched or
relaxed.
-5-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
In a further aspect, the invention provides a device for supporting a portion
of a
subject's body, comprising a first anchor attachable to a portion of the
subject's body, a
second anchor attachable to a stationary object, and an elastic member
connecting the first
anchor and a second anchor; such that when said first and second anchors are
attached,
upon articulation of the body portion the elastic member is stretched or
relaxed.
In a further aspect of the invention, the invention provides a method for
assisting a
subject to perform a motion comprising attaching a first anchor to a first
side of a joint of the
subject's body, attaching a second anchor to a second side of the joint, and
connecting an
elastic member between the first anchor and the second anchor; such that
articulation of the
joint in a first direction causes stretching of the elastic member and storing
of energy, and
articulation of the joint in a second direction causes relaxation of the
elastic member wherein
the energy is released and assists the subject to perform a motion in the
second direction.
In another aspect, the invention provides a method for assisting a subject to
perform
a lift comprising attaching a first anchor to the subject's shoulder belt,
attaching a second
anchor to the subject's lower back, attaching a third anchor to the subject's
lower leg,
connecting a first elastic member between the first anchor and the second
anchor, and
connecting a second elastic member between the second anchor and the third
anchor; such
that upon articulation of the upper back at least one of the first and second
elastic members
is stretched or relaxed.
In another aspect, the invention provides a method for supporting a portion of
a
subject's body, comprising attaching a'first anchor to a portion of the
subject's body,
attaching a second anchor to a stationary object, and connecting an elastic
member
between the first anchor and the second anchor; such that upon articulation of
said portion
of the subject's body the elastic member is stretched or relaxed.
In another aspect of the invention, tension of the elastic members may be
adjustable.
The anchors may be fixed to clothing. The invention also provides a kit
comprising
-6-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
attachable anchors and elastic members. In some embodiments of the kit the
anchors are
fixed to clothing. In some embodiments the elastic members are adjustable. The
anchors
may comprise a loop, ring, clip, buckle or hole. In further aspects of the
invention, the
elastic member may be a spring, a pneumatic actuator, or a member made of an
elastic
material. The joint may be the waist, ankle, wrist, knee, hip, elbow, shoulder
and at least
one joint of the back or neck.
In some embodiments, the invention may be configured to provide energy to the
legs, to assist a subject in performing a motion such as walking or climbing
stairs. Such an
embodiment may comprise only the bottom portion of the device shown in Figure
1, with the
same or different arrangement of elastic members connected between anchors at
the waist
and at the lower legs and/or feet.
Brief Description of the Drawings
Embodiments of the invention will now be described, by way of example, with
reference to the accompanying drawings, wherein:
Figure 1 is a drawing of a preferred embodiment of the invention, referred to
herein
as a Personal Lift Assist Device (PLAD), wherein anchors are placed at the
shoulders, below
the knees, and at the lower back of a subject, and elastic members are
connected between
the anchors;
Figure 2 is a drawing of an embodiment of the invention wherein anchors are
placed
at the shoulders, below the knees, at the lower back, at the upper back on the
subject's side,
at the lower back on the subject's side, and elastic members connecting the
anchors and
looped around the foot;
Figure 3 is a sagittal-plane diagram of erector spinae compressive and shear
forces
acting on the lumbar spine when a subject lifts an object from the floor
(without PLAD);
-7-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
Figure 4 is a sagittal-plane diagram of erector spinae forces and PLAD forces
acting
on the lumbar spine when a subject wearing PLAD lifts an object from floor
level;
Figure 5 is a diagram depicting the direction of mechanical vectors of a
subject in a
stoop position when PLAD is worn;
Figure 6 is a graph showing the calculated resultant force exerted by erector
spinae
muscles of a subject lifting a 10 kg object with and without PLAD;
Figure 7 is a graph showing the calculated compressive force exerted on the
L4/L5
disc of a subject lifting a 10 kg object with and without PLAD;
Figure 8 is a graph showing the calculated shear force exerted on the L4/L5
disc of a
subject lifting a 10 kg object with and without PLAD;
Figures 9 (a) and (b) are graphs showing the force required to deform specific
elastic
members that could be used in the (a) lower and (b) upper body portions of
PLAD;
Figure 10 is a graph showing modeled resultant force exerted by erector spinae
muscles of a subject lifting a 10 kg object with and without PLAD;
Figure 11 is a graph showing modeled compressive force exerted on the L4/L5
disc
of a subject lifting a 10 kg object with and without PLAD;
Figure 12 is a graph showing modeled shear force exerted on the L4/L5 disc of
a
subject lifting a 10 kg object with and without PLAD;
Figure 13 is a diagram showing a biomechanical analysis of the forces on the
hip
area of a subject during a lift;
Figures 14 (a) and (b) are graphs showing modeled force exerted by PLAD on the
(a)
hip and (b) tibia of a subject lifting a 10 kg object (the tibia values are
the sum of forces
exerted on both tibial tuberosities);
Figure 15 is a graph showing calculated and XsensorTM measured force exerted
on
the hip by the PLAD device when lifting a 10 kg object;
-8-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
Figure 16 is a graph showing electromyography of the erector spinae of one
male
subject lifting a 10 kg box with handles, with and without PLAD, using a stoop
position and
starting 25 cm from the floor (handle height) and ending at waist height;
Figure 17 is a graph showing the average and standard deviation
electromyography
of the erector spinae for nine male subjects who lifted a 15 kg box with
handles, with and
without PLAD, using a stoop position and starting 25 cm from the floor (handle
height) and
ending at waist height;
Figure 18 is a graph showing the net lumbar moment about the L4/L5 joint as
calculated using the Hof method and as determined using a model created with
the Visual
Nastran 4D modelling program;
Figure 19 is a graph showing flexion and extension about the x-axis moment at
the
L4/L5 joint for one lift with and without PLAD, as determined using a model
created in the
Visual Nastran 4D environment; and
Figure 20 is a graph showing electromyography of the hamstring of one male
subject
lifting a 30 kg box with handles, with and without a two elastic member PLAD
(described in
Example 10), using a stooped position and starting 25 cm from the floor
(handle height) and
ending at waist height.
Detailed Description of Preferred Embodiments
The invention provides a motion assistance device that is worn by a subject,
and
which stores and provides energy for aiding a task or motion involving
articulation of one or
more of the subject's joints. The invention further provides a method for
assisting a subject
to perform a motion. The motion can be, e.g., lifting an object. The device of
the invention
can be used, for example, for lifts and/or for repetitive tasks that may lead
to muscle strain
and/or for statically held postures. The invention provides at least one
elastic member
connecting two body points on opposite sides of one or more joints, such that
articulation of
-9-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
the joint(s) in a first direction leads to stretching or deformation of the
elastic member, and
storing of energy, and articulation of the joint(s) in a second (usually
opposite) direction
leads to relaxation of the elastic member and releasing of energy. In this
way, energy is
stored and provided to the body during articulation of the joint in the
direction of relaxation of
the elastic member.
As used herein, the term "elastic member" means a member which can be deformed
(and thereby energized), and relaxed. The term "deformed" means reversibly
bent,
stretched, or compressed such that energy is stored in the elastic member. The
term
"relaxed" means the original (undeformed) state of the elastic member prior to
being
deformed. Preferably, when deformed and then allowed to relax, the elastic
member returns
substantially to its original undeformed state and energy stored in the
elastic member is
thereby released. Examples of elastic members may include, but are not limited
to: springs,
for example, leaf, spiral, helical, or coil springs; air-, liquid-, or gas-
filled actuators, or
magnetic actuators; and elastic materials, for example, elastic bands or tubes
made of
rubber or any natural or synthetic materials; and combinations thereof. For
example, an
elastic member may comprise a "bungee" cord, or an elastic band available from
Thera-
Band (Akron, Ohio) or FlexBand (Stow, Ohio). Elastic members may be provided
as
single units or as combinations of units. For example, elastic members may
comprise single
or multiple elastic bands, the latter comprising parallel, crossed, braided,
etc. elastic bands.
According to the invention, energy released upon relaxation of the elastic
member
may aid in performing certain tasks by supplementing muscles, preventing
muscle strain
and/or disc injury. The invention may also be used to supplement weak or tired
muscles, for
example, to prevent back pain or to aid recovery from a back injury.
The invention provides an elastic member in a manner that assists one or more
muscles during lifting/bending motions. For example, an elastic member may be
aligned
parallel to the extensor and/or flexor muscles of a joint of a subject. The
term "extensor"
-10-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
refers to a muscle, the contraction of which causes articulation at a joint
with the
consequence that the associated limb or body part assumes a more straight
line, or so that
the distance between the body segments on either side of the joint is
increased or extended.
The term "flexor" refers to a muscle, the contraction of which causes
articulation of a joint so
as to bring together the two body segments which it connects. The term
"segment" refers to
a part of the body on one side of a joint. For example, the body segment
directly above the
knee joint is the upper leg, and the body segment directly below the knee
joint is the lower
leg. Examples of joints that the invention can assist include, but are not
limited to, wrist,
waist, ankle, knee, hip, elbow, shoulder, and one or more joints of the back
or neck.
Although not limited thereto, the invention is particularly suitable for
aiding subjects
during lifting tasks. While many trunk muscles are involved in lifting tasks,
the erector
spinae (columns of muscles running the length of the human spine which insert
into ribs and
vertebrae) are muscles of critical importance. During bending and lifting
activities, the
erector spinae must generate a large extensor moment to raise the upper body,
and the
object lifted, into an upright position (McGill and Norman, 1986). Since the
erector spinae
muscles act on a short lever arm, a high tensile force is required, and the
lumbar
intervertebral discs are subjected to a high compressive reaction force.
According to a preferred embodiment, the invention provides a device for
assisting a
subject during forward- or side-leaning and/or during a lifting task. In such
embodiment,
referred to herein as a personal lift assist device or "PLAD", the device
comprises an elastic
member that assists the erector spinae muscles of the back. The elastic member
connects
to the body at the shoulders or upper trunk, and at least one of the waist,
lower legs, or the
feet. This connection leads to transfer of some of the forces and moments from
a subject's
spinal column to his/her shoulders, waist, and lower leg. The term "waist"
means the lower
back at or about the hip or belt line and includes' the pelvic girdle. Thus,
articulation of the
-11-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
waist refers to articulation of all joints between and including the L4/L5
vertebrae to the
pelvic girdle.
This embodiment transfers compression force from the upper body to the lower
body.
It relies on the subject's hip to act as a fulcrum and transfers the weight of
the upper torso to
the lower leg at either the level of the feet or of the leg's tibial
tuberosity. The feet are able
to bear enormous body weight and are well suited to receive this transfer of
weight. The
tibial tuberosity is a strong bony plateau below the knee which is the site of
attachment of
the quadriceps muscles, and it also bears the body weight of people with
prosthetic devices
for below-knee amputations. The hip level force of this embodiment acts on the
pelvic
girdle, and not the lumbar vertebrae. The pelvic girdle is a solid bony
structure that is well
adapted to receiving force. Typical magnitudes of point forces generated by
this
embodiment range from 125 N to 325 N. These forces, when spread evenly across
the back
of the pelvis, are well within the compressive strength characteristics of
bone (Hobson,
1992).
The preferred embodiment also reduces some of the force requirements needed by
the hip extensors (gluteal muscles and hamstring muscles) and knee extensors
(quadricep
muscles). As a subject wearing PLAD lowers his/her body, the elastic member is
deformed
(stretched). This stretch provides stores energy to assist with extension of
the hips and
knees during the upward phase of a lift. This assistance provided by PLAD can
be modelled
mathematically and demonstrated by monitoring the level of electrical activity
of the muscles
(electromyography) of subjects performing lifts with and without PLAD (see
below
examples).
An example of such a preferred embodiment is depicted in Figure 1, and
comprises
an adjustable shoulder belt 10, an adjustable waist belt 45, and two
adjustable leg belts 30.
The term "belt" is used herein to refer to a harness that comfortably and
securely attaches to
subject's body, and may include one or more adjustable straps, optionally with
padding, with
-12-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
fasteners such as buckles, that encompass the body in the area of the
shoulder(s), waist, or
leg(s), as required. Each belt has an anchor for connecting one or more
elastic members
thereto. The term "anchor" refers to a locus to which an elastic member may be
securely
attached, or through which an elastic member may pass. An anchor may comprise,
for
example, a bar, a ring, a clip, a hook, a buckle, a roller, a pulley, a guide,
a channel, or a
receptacle, or the like, or a combination thereof. The term "receptacle"
refers to any suitable
means adapted for receiving a coupling or connector, or an orifice through
which an elastic
member may be inserted, looped, or tied. For example, as shown in Figure 1,
two elastic
members 40, 50 may be connected between the shoulder 10 and waist 45 belts,
and two
additional elastic members 60, 70 may be connected between the waist 45 and
leg 30 belts,
in substantially parallel arrangements, using shoulder, waist, and leg anchors
5, 25, and 35,
respectively. Alternatively, for example, the two elastic members connected
between the
shoulder and waist belt anchors may be connected in crossed arrangement, in an
"X"
formation (not shown in Figure 1). In another embodiment, elastic members may
be
connected between the shoulder and waist belt anchors in both substantially
parallel and
crossed arrangement (not shown in Figure 1). In yet another embodiment, one or
more
continuous elastic members may be connected from the shoulder anchors to the
leg
anchors, passing over or through the waist anchors. In such embodiment, the
waist anchors
maybe configured as guides, so as not to constrain sliding and stretching of
the elastic
member.
Suitable lengths of elastic members may be selected for each subject. For
example,
when a subject is wearing the PLAD, the length of each elastic member is
adjusted so as to
have some slack (i.e., no tension) when the subject is standing upright and to
be taut when
the subject is bent forward at approximately 10 from vertical.
Suitable strength or resistance (i.e., the force required to deform the
elastic member
by a given amount) of elastic member may be determined by one or more of the
following.
-13-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
An empirical approach may be used wherein various strengths of elastic member
are tried
until a subject finds the preferred strength for a given task, and/or an
elastic member
strength that is comfortable. A selection procedure may also involve
consideration of
selection criteria, including any of a subject's body weight, upper body
weight (defined as the
weight of the body above the L5 vertebra; for 75% of the adult population,
this is equal to
about 55% of total body weight), body size, body strength, and the weight of
the object being
lifted. Analyses currently in progress are aimed at elucidating the
appropriate selection
criteria. Elastic bands and tubing such as those made by Thera-Band are
available in
various colour-coded levels of strength, selection of which is expected to be
straight-forward
upon identification of the appropriate selection criteria.
As shown in Figure 1 and briefly discussed above, in a preferred embodiment of
PLAD, anchors 5 are disposed on the shoulder belt 10 at each shoulder, anchors
25 are
disposed on the waist belt 45, and anchors 35 are disposed on the lower-leg
belts 30. The
anchors secure one or more elastic members 40, 50, 60, 70, which are strung
between
them. In Figure 1, anchor 35 is depicted as a ring while anchor 25 is depicted
as a bar
around which elastic members 40, 50, 60 and 70 may be looped. The anchor or
anchors
associated with a belt may be mounted in such a way that they are elevated
from the belt
and hence elevated from that point on the subject's body. For example, as
shown in Figure
1, the bar comprising anchor 25 associated with the waist belt is elevated
from the belt a
distance "a", using a spacer or standoff 20. This creates or increases a
fulcrum for the
elastic members attached thereto. In other embodiments, waist, shoulder,
and/or leg belts,
or belts for other body segments, may similarly employ such a fulcrum.
When a subject wearing PLAD bends his/her upper body (i.e., the portion of the
body
above the L4 vertebra) forward or sideways, the elastic members are stretched
and thus
support a portion of the weight of the upper body at all angles greater than,
for example, 10
from vertical. Following the bend, the subject may resume an upright stance,
assisted by
-14-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
release of energy from the elastic members. If the subject is also lifting an
object, then the
lift is also assisted since while resuming an upright stance, energy is
released from the
elastic members and decreases the demands on the back muscles.
In the preferred embodiment, the elastic member is stretched by bending of the
body
and relaxed by upward straightening of the body. The subject uses the force of
gravity
acting on his/her upper body, particularly when it is several degrees or more
from vertical, to
aid in stretching the elastic member and storing energy. The subject then
gains energy from
the elastic member while straightening the back, which may or may not include
lifting an
object.
In another embodiment of PLAD, an elastic member is strung between the
shoulder,
waist, and/or lower leg belts with sufficient tension to assist a subject to
hold a static leaning
position, such as forward-leaning. The static stretch of the elastic member is
used to
counterbalance the holding of a lift, or the maintaining of a forward-leaning
stance. In this
embodiment, a large force would be required to further stretch or deform the
elastic member
after the subject has reached the equilibrium point of the lean, at a desired
angle from
vertical. In this manner, a body part's weight with or without a lifted
object's weight can be
counterbalanced by the energy stored in the elastic member. Thus, the body
part, or body
part with lifted object, is held in static equilibrium with little to no
muscle force needed to
counterbalance the weight. By this mechanism, the muscles are able to relax
during the.
static holding task. In a related embodiment of the invention, tension in one
or more elastic
members may be adjusted so that the subject can obtain the maximum comfort and
benefit.
Such an embodiment could support a leaning subject's upper body weight,
thereby
preventing muscle fatigue if the subject maintains that position for an
extended amount of
time. Examples of professions which might require prolonged forward leaning
include dental
assistant, surgeon, and assembly line worker.
-15-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
With the PLAD embodiment, the amount of muscular force required of the erector
spinae is reduced lumbar moments, compressive forces, and shear forces during
bending
and/or lifting are reduced. Furthermore, these reductions reduce the
likelihood of lower back
pain caused by, for example, repetitive bending and/or lifting.
Detailed calculations of forces and moments produced during bending and
lifting,
with and without PLAD, including an assessment of the forces transferred to
other body
parts, and a comparison of erector spinae electromyography with and without
PLAD, are
presented in the examples below. Evidence shows that PLAD reduces the moment,
compressive, and shear forces on the disc between the L4 and L5 vertebrae as
well as the
amount of work required of the erector spinae muscles.
A second embodiment of the invention (see Figure 2) provides additional
support for
side-leaning or lifting in a twisted position when compared to PLAD. In this
embodiment of
the invention, an additional elastic member 65 is attached to an anchor 80
disposed on the
side of the waist belt 45 and to an anchor 75 disposed on a side portion 85 of
the shoulder
belt 10. The leg belt 30 has a a tibial tuberosity anchor 35, and an
additional elastic member
55 is looped under the foot. This combination allows the weight of the upper
body to be
transferred to both the tibia and the foot.
A third embodiment of the invention provides support of the upper body while
leaning
forward or sideways in a sitting position. In this embodiment, an elastic
member is fixed to a
subject's upper body (e.g., using a shoulder belt) and to a stationary object,
for example, a
piece of furniture such as a chair. With proper positioning and tension of the
elastic
member, the weight of the upper body can be supported by the elastic member as
the
subject leans forward or sideways. Examples of professions which might require
prolonged
forward-leaning in a sifting position include jeweler and microchip
technician.
A fourth embodiment of the invention incorporates an elastic member into
clothing
such as overalls. According to this embodiment, anchors are fixed, for
example, sewn-in, to
-16-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
clothing and the,,elastic members may pass through channels sewn-in to the
clothing, which
allow the elastic members to stretch while holding them in place. Elastic
members may be
anchored at intermediate points to accommodate different ranges of motion of
particular
body parts. Clothing may include stirrups that go under the feet, or built-in
socks or shoes
that have an integrated loop which passes under the foot, to anchor the
elastic member (see
Figure 2). Such an embodiment may be provided in different sizes, with
different tensions of
elastic members, for different body types/sizes and lifting tasks.
In a fifth embodiment of the invention, an electric motor may be incorporated
into the
device (e.g., incorporated into the waist belt) and connected to two or more
anchors using
an elastic member or a non-elastic member such as a cable. The electric motor
senses a
subject's motions and controls tension in the elastic member or cable on the
basis of the
subject's body dimensions, load weights, trunk angles and speeds, trunk
twists, etc., and
controls the length of the elastic member or cable to balance the exerting
force.
In a sixth embodiment of the invention, tension of an elastic member can be
controlled by the subject. For example, an adjustable knob may be attached to
an anchor
and an elastic member, such that tension in the elastic member is changed when
the knob is
turned.
To demonstrate the effectiveness of the PLAD embodiment of the invention,
calculations were made to study the activity of a subject's erector spinae
muscle during a
floor to waist-height lift of an object while wearing the personal lift assist
device. Static
balance equations were developed (see Example 1) that act about a point "A" in
the spinal
column. Typically "A" is in the region of the L4/L5 disc or the L5/S1 disc. A
summary of the
forces generated during such a lift are presented in Figure 3 (where "W," is
the weight of the
subject's upper body, "W2" is the weight of the item being lifted, "W" is the
total weight to be
lifted by the back muscles which is the sum of W, and W21 "WX" is the
horizontal component
of W, "WY" is the vertical component of W, "Fm" is the force exerted by the
erector spinae
-17-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
muscle to effect a lift of W, "d" is the distance between the center of the
erector spinae and
the center of the L4/L5 intervertebral disc, "A" is a point at the L4/L5
vertebrae joint, "S" is
the shear force acting at A during the lift of W, "C" is the compressive force
acting at A
during the lift of W, "MA" is the sum of the moments at A, "b," is the
horizontal distance
between A and the center of mass of W1, "b2" is the horizontal distance
between A and the
center of mass of W21 "b" is the horizontal distance between the center of
mass of W and A,
and "a" is the angle of the spine relative to vertical). Figure 4 depicts the
forces when a
subject is wearing the PLAD device (where "W," is the weight of the subject's
upper body,
"W2" is the weight of the item being lifted, "W" is the sum of.W, and W2, "WX"
is the horizontal
component of W, "WY" is the vertical component of W, "Fm" is the force exerted
by the erector
spinae muscle, "FPLAD" is the force exerted by PLAD, "FPLAD(X)" is the force
exerted by PLAD in
the x-direction, "FPLAD(y)" is the force exerted by PLAD in the y-direction,
"d" is the distance
between the erector spinae and the vertebrae, "A" is a point at the L4/L5
vertebrae, "C" is
the resultant compressive force acting at A during the lift of W and is
derived in Example 3,
"S" is the resultant shear force acting at A during the lift of W and is
derived in Example 4,
"MA" is the sum of the moments at A, "b," is the horizontal distance between A
and the
center of mass of W1, "b2" is the horizontal distance between A and the center
of mass of W2,
"b" is the horizontal distance between the center of mass of W and A, "a" is
the angle of the
spine relative to vertical, "f3" is the angle of FPLAD relative to horizontal,
and "a" is the shortest
distance between the spine and FPLAD).
All scientific and patent publications cited herein are hereby incorporated in
their
entirety by reference.
The following examples further illustrate the present invention and are not
intended
to be limiting in any respect.
-18-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
Examples
The human biomechanical system is very complex. Although we can measure many
basic properties, other properties cannot be measured. For example, internal
forces on
spinal structures, redundancy of muscular forces, and coordination of these
forces to
produce desired motor activities cannot be measured. For this reason,
evaluation of the
effects of PLAD have been determined by mathematical calculations and by
modelling; the
results of both methods can be seen in the figures. Mathematical proof that
the PLAD can
reduce lumbar moments and compressive and shear forces of the hip and knee was
first
calculated using a simple 2D link segment modelling approach and the equations
presented
in Examples 1A to 1 D. These results were validated by a preliminary
electromyography
(EMG) study of the erector spinae of one subject performing a lift with and
without PLAD.
Subsequently, in depth research into the effects of PLAD was performed with
many subjects
and the effect of PLAD was thoroughly studied by EMG, elastic member strain
quantification,
and a sophisticated 3-D link segment model.
Example 1: Development of static equations for lifts
A simple two-dimensional model was developed to predict how the erector spinae
muscle activity is affected by the personal lift assist device of the
preferred embodiment of
the invention (shown in Figure 1). This model can be explained arithmetically
through a
moment arm analysis of the forces generated during lifting without PLAD (as
shown in
Figure 3) and with PLAD (as shown in Figure 4). The development of static
balance
equations improves our understanding of forces that act about a point A in the
spinal
column, typically at the L4/L5 disc or the L5/S1 disc of the spinal column.
-19-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
Example 1A: Development of static equations for lifts without PLAD
If we assume the weight of a subject's upper body is "W," and the weight of
the
object to be lifted is "W2", then the vertical force exerted to lift a load,
"W", can be found
using equation 1.
W=W1+W2 (1)
The distance, "b", between the center of gravity of "W" and the L4/L5 disc of
the spinal
column is found by equation 2, wherein "b," is the distance between the center
of gravity of
the subject's upper body and the L4/L5 disc, and "b2" is the distance between
the center of
gravity of the object to be lifted and the L4/L5 disc (see Figure 3).
b = (b,W, + b2 W2) / W (2)
The distance between the erector spinae and the lumbar vertebrae, or the
"effective
lever arm", is denoted as "d". An equilibrium equation can be obtained for the
sum of the
moments at a point A, denoted "MA" where the force exerted by the erector
spinae muscle is
denoted as "Fm".
2MA = 0 = Fm d - W b (3)
The force exerted on the erector spinae muscle, "Fm", can be calculated with
equation 4:
Fm=Wb/d (4)
The compressive force, "C", acting on the lumbar spine is then given by
equations 5 to 7
where a is the inclination of the trunk to vertical.
C = Fm + W cos a (5)
C=Wb/d+Wcos a (6)
C=W(b/d+cosa) (7)
The amount of the compressive force acting on the lumbar spine is a minimum
value which
neglects stabilizing activity created by the co-contraction from other trunk
muscles.
The shear force, "S", acting on the lumbar spine is then given by equation 8:
S=Wsina (8)
-20-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
Example 1 B: Development of static equations for lifts with PLAD
We may quantify the affects of wearing the PLAD embodiment of the invention
pictured in Figure 1 by adding it to the relevant equations. Figure 4 depicts
the parameters
involved with a subject wearing such a device. The force exerted by the
erector spinae
muscle, "Fm", in this condition can be calculated with equation 10 where the
force exerted by
the device is represented as "FPLAD" and the distance between the anchor of
the lower back
and the L4/L5 disc, or moment arm of the device, is denoted as "a".
Fm d + FPLAD a - W b = ZMA = 0 (9)
Fm = (W b - FPUaD a) / d (10)
Comparing equations 4 and 10 shows that the amount of force exerted by the
erector
spinae when a subject is wearing PLAD and bending from the waist to lift an
object from the
floor, is an amount [FPLAD a/d] less than the same situation without PLAD,
where the distance
between the erector spinae and lumbar vertebrae, "d", is constant.
The compressive force acting on the lumbar spine, "C", is given by equation 12
where "f3" is the angle between "FP,.AD" and horizontal.
C = Fm + W COS a + FPLAD COS 0 (11)
C = (Wb - FPLAD a) / d + W cos a + FPLAD cos (3 (12)
The angle between "FPLAD" and the back muscles is negligible, so cos (3 is
close to zero.
Therefore, the amount of compressive force for a subject wearing PLAD is
decreased by an
amount [FPL,D (1- (a/d)] where "d" is constant. The compressive force can be
decreased
further by increasing the distance "a" (see reference numeral 20 in Figures 1
and 2). A
distance of 20 cm for "a" has been used in the prototypes of PLAD tested to
date.
-21-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
The shear force "S" acting on the lumbar spine when a subject wears PLAD can
be
calculated with equation 13:
S = W sin a - FPLAD sin (3 (13)
By comparing equations 8 and 13, it is apparent that by wearing PLAD it is
possible to
oppose the shearing force of the upper body and decrease it by an amount
[FP,AD sin (3]. As
a point of reference, many lifting tasks incur compressive forces of around
4000 N and shear
forces of around 500 N (Shirazi-Adl et al., 1986).
Example 2. Preliminary study to determine the effect of PLAD on the
compressive
and shear forces experienced by a subject
To obtain a preliminary quantification of the effect of wearing PLAD on the
compressive and shear forces exerted on the body, a study was conducted with
one human
male subject. This subject lifted a 10 kilogram object from floor to waist
height using a
stooped posture with and without wearing the first prototype of PLAD (see
Figure 5 where
"FPLAD" is the force exerted by the PLAD device, "Fm" is the force exerted by
the erector
spinae muscle, "W," is the weight of the subject's upper body, "W2" is the
weight of the item
being lifted, "W" is the total weight to be lifted which is the sum of W, and
W21 "S" is the
shear force acting at a point on the spine during the lift of W, and "C" is
the compressive
force acting at a point on the spine during the lift of W). The subject was
videotaped at 30
Hz with a PanasonicTM digital camera at right angles to the lifting task. The
variables (a, b,
a, R and length of the elastic members) were digitized using custom software
(DIGTM,
developed in the Biomechanics Laboratory, Queen's University at Kingston,
Kingston,
Ontario, Canada). These variables were used to measure joint coordinates, body
angles,
relevant anthropornetric dimensions, and distances between the load and
related locations
-22-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
in different angles during lifting. The data extracted from the software
program, and the
equations of Examples 1A and 1 B were used to quantify the effect of PLAD on
the erector
spinae.
This study together with a study of the tension developed within the elastic
elements
of the PLAD (see Example 3 and Figure 9) allowed preliminary quantification of
the effect of
PLAD on compressive and shear forces acting on the subject's back. It was
determined that
PLAD reduced compressive force at the L4/L5 intervertebral joint by
approximately 600 N
and reduced shear force at the L4/L5 intervertebral joint by approximately 140
N. With this
result, the study outlined in Example 9 was undertaken to obtain statistically
significant
quantification of the effect of PLAD on reducing compressive and shear forces
acting on the
back.
Example 3: Effect of material and configuration changes to elastic members,
and
determination of FPLAD values.
The amount of energy that may be stored and released from a deformed elastic
member is determined by its configuration and/or the material of which the
elastic member is
made. Examples of different configurations of elastic members for the shoulder
to waist
portion of PLAD are crossed, straight, side or a combination thereof. In a
study of the
resultant forces (FPLA0) exerted by the device, known weights were
systematically added to
elastic members made of various materials to study the elastic member stress-
strain
relationship. Regression equations were used to derive the stretch
coefficients, "k", for the
elastic members in different configurations. These stretch coefficients were
determined from
the slope of the graphs of Figure 9 which graphically displays equation 14,
where "j" is the
distance of deformation (i.e., displacement) of the elastic member.
FPL,D=kj (14)
As expected, it was determined that "FPLAD" increased as the amount of
deformation
-23-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
(e.g., stretching) of the elastic member increased. The particular elastic
member used for
the study described in Example 2 was selected based on the typical amount of
deformation
seen during lifting tasks (see Figure 9(a) and 9(b)). It was observed that
when a subject
used a squatting lifting technique, there was minimal deformation (i.e.,
stretching) of the
elastic member of approximately 10 cm and the FPLAD was approximately 75 N to
100 N.
When a stooping lifting technique was used, there was approximately 25 cm of
deformation
and FP,AD was approximately 150 N to 175 N.
Example 4: Calculated effect of PLAD on erector spinae based on mathematical
calculations
By inserting FP,AD values obtained from the study described in Example 2 into
equation 12, Fm values were determined for many angles of the upper body to
vertical. By
using equation 5 and data gathered for the study described in Example 2 for a
subject
moving from a stooped to a standing posture, resultant (Figure 6), compressive
(Figure 7),
and shear (Figures 8) forces were calculated for a point A located near the
L4/L5 disc of the
spine. It was determined that when the subject is wearing PLAD, the amount of
force
exerted by the erector spinae is less than without PLAD. The effect of PLAD is
greatest at
large angles, e.g., angles greater than about 30 from vertical.
Figure 7 compares the compressive force exerted on the L4/L5 disc at different
angles with and without PLAD. A larger moment arm of the device, or distance
between
the L4/L5 disc and the waist-level anchor point "a" of force application of
the device (see 20
in Figure 1), leads to.smaller compressive force requirements by the erector
spinae muscles.
However, one must balance this with practical issues such as bulkiness of the
device. A
moment arm of 20 cm was used in this study.
The amount of shear force exerted on the L4/L5 disc was calculated from
equations
8 and 13. Figure 8 depicts the results with and without PLAD. PLAD is able to
oppose the
-24-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
shear force exerted from the upper body and the lifted object. It is important
for safety to
minimize the magnitude of shear force on the spine (McGill, 1997).
Example 5. Calculated effect of PLAD on erector spinae based on modelling
Using the physical constraints of body motion and by estimating the forces
acting on
different component structures, we can reasonably predict the magnitudes of
spinal forces
for loads held in various postures. For a better understanding of PLAD's
effects on the
erector spinae, a first generation model was created in AutoCADTM 2002
(Autodesk, Inc.,
San Rafael, California) and the ACIS format was transferred to Visual Nastran
4D 2003
(MSC Software Corp., Santa Ana, California). The elastic members used in PLAD
were
assumed to be similar to a linear spring constraint in this program. A shaft
was attached to
the upper body in a manner similar to that of a spine. A revolute motor was
applied at the
end of the shaft to lift the upper body modelling the erector spinae.
To find the forces exerted on the erector spinae on the basis of this model,
the
calculated torque around the revolute motor (MA in Figure 4) was found. As
seen in equation
15, dividing the torque or moment around the z-axis, by the distance between
the spine and
erector spinae, "d", gives the amount of force (Fm) exerted by this muscle.
Fm= MZ/ d (15)
The distance between the erector spinae and the spine, "d", (the moment arm
distance), was
considered to be 6 cm for an average person. The resultant force exerted by
the erector
spinae as found by modelling is shown in Figure 10; for comparison, the
calculated resultant
force is shown in Figure 6. These figures show that there is a significant
difference between
the forces exerted by the erector spinae when PLAD is worn and when it is not,
with less
force when PLAD is worn.
-25-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
There are some differences between the calculated results and the results
found by
modelling, for example, in terms of curve shape and magnitude. The model lifts
the load
dynamically (20 degrees/sec), therefore it calculates the effect of the upper
body and load
acceleration on the produced model. Thus it shows higher values at the
beginning and
smaller values at the end of the lift, perhaps because the lever arm gets
shorter.
Compressive and shear forces exerted on the L4/L5 disc were found by modelling
the forces along the shaft of the model and the erector spinae, with results
show in Figures
11 and 12. These modeled results can be compared to calculated results shown
in Figures
7 and 8. Results of the modelling and the calculations agree in that decreased
compressive
and shear forces are experienced by the PLAD user. The higher compressive
force at the
beginning of a lift is likely due to greater acceleration of the upper body
and a higher lever
arm compared to the end of the lift.
Example 6: Calculated effect of PLAD on hip and knee forces based on
mathematical
calculations
PLAD transfers compression force from the upper body to the lower body. It
relies
on the subject's hip to act as a fulcrum and transfers the weight of the upper
torso to the
lower leg at the level of the leg's tibial tuberosity and/or feet (see Figures
1 and 2). The tibial
tuberosity or tibial plateau below the knee is a strong bony area which is the
site of
attachment of the quadriceps muscles, and it also bears the body weight of
people with
prosthetic devices for below-knee amputations.
This example determines how much force is exerted on the hip and how much is
exerted on the tibia in a subject wearing the preferred embodiment (Figure 1).
Figure 13
shows the force vector analysis in the hip area where p is the angle between
the tension
force vector of the upper-body elastic members (T,) relative to horizontal, a
is the angle
between the tension force in the lower elastic member (T2) relative to
vertical. The p and 6
-26-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
angles (Figure 13) were found by the DIGTM digitization software developed at
Biomechanics
Laboratory, Queen's University at Kingston, Ontario. The reaction force vector
on the hip
(Fh) is angled relative to horizontal, this angle is represented as 0. The
equilibrium
equations for the force exerted by PLAD on the hip are equations 16 and 17,
where the force
along the x-axis is denoted "Fx", and the force along the y-axis is denoted
"Fr".
Y-Fx = 0 = -Fhcos 0 + T2sina +T,cosp (16)
EFy = 0 = Fhsin 0 + T,sinp - T2cosa (17)
T, (and similarly TO was determined from equation 14 where the coefficient "k"
is determined
as discussed in Example 6, and where "j" is the distance of the deformation of
the elastic
member. T, and T2 were also measured directly and the results agreed with
those obtained
from equation 14.
Typical point force magnitudes experienced at the hip by a subject wearing
PLAD
range from 125 N to 325 N, as shown in Figure 14. The hip level force of PLAD
acts on the
pelvic girdle, and not the lumbar vertebrae. The pelvic girdle is a solid bony
structure that is
well adapted to receiving force. These forces, when spread evenly across the
back of the
pelvis, are well within the compressive strength characteristics of bone
(Hobson 1992).
Example 7: Calculated effect of PLAD on hip and knee forces based on modelling
To validate the above described mathematical constructs, a validation study
was
performed using one subject. In this study, measurements of the external
reaction forces
applied by the PLAD to the subject at the site of the waist belt (at the hips
on the pelvic
girdle) during a lift were made. The measurements were acquired using an
XsensorTM
Pressure Mapping System (XsensorTM Technologies Corp., Calgary, Alberta),
comprised of
-27-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
a blanket matrix of capacitance pressure sensors (420 mm x 420 mm). The
XsensorTM
blanket was placed between the lower back of the subject wearing PLAD, and the
PLAD
waist belt. To calibrate the XsensorTM system, a known force was then applied
to the
XsensorTM blanket while the subject wearing PLAD and the XsensorTM blanket lay
on his/her
stomach. The subject wearing the PLAD and the XsensorTM blanket then stood
upright and
lifted a 10 kg object from the floor to waist height and data were collected
over the course of
the lift. Data from each sensor were received by a computer, converted to
force using Force
= Pressure x Area, and used for analyses. The calculated forces at the hip
area are shown
in Figure 14 and the calculated and measured results on the waist belt (hip
area) are shown
in Figure 15. There is a linear relationship between the angle of the
subject's torso and the
forces exerted on the hip and tibial tuberosis. As the subject leaned forward,
the force
exerted on the hip increased. The similarity between this approach and that of
Example 6
confirmed that the mathematical approach makes a reasonable approximation of
the actual
forces on the pelvis.
Example 8. Effect of PLAD on erector spinae based on electromyography (EMG) of
erector spinae muscles of one subject
A study using electromyography (EMG) of the erector spinae muscles was
conducted to determine PLAD's effectiveness in reducing demands on the erector
spinae
muscles. Reduced demand should be reflected by less EMG activity in the
erector spinae
muscles during a PLAD supported lift. As shown in Example I B, by wearing a
PLAD device
a subject experiences reduced compressive and shear forces. To confirm this
finding, one
healthy 25 year old male subject was tested. The skin overlying the subject's
erector spinae
at the levels of T10 and L3 vertebrae was cleaned with alcohol and abraded
with skin
preparation pads. Two pairs of disposable ECL 135 Medi-Trace TM Mini
electrodes (Graphics
Control Corp., Buffalo, New York) were attached over the erector spinae
muscles about 4
-28-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
cm from the midline of the back. A fifth electrode was positioned over the
spinous process
of the T1 vertebrae as a reference. A Bognoli 16 Channel Electromyography
System
(Delsys Inc., Boston, Massachusetts) was used to collect the EMG signal. The
EMG signal
was filtered with a band-pass filter of 5-300 Hz, A-D converted at 500 Hz,
full-wave rectified,
averaged with a time interval of 0.02s, and recorded on a microcomputer.
The subject stood in front of a waist-height table with an 10 kg object on the
floor.
He lifted the object from floor to table in 2x 10 trials, the first ten trials
with PLAD and the
second ten trials without PLAD. The PLAD device used in this study had four
elastic
members in parallel configuration, the two on the back were Thera-BandTM tubes
and the
two on the legs were bungee cords, the subject's particular style of lifting
was a stooped
posture and required about 2 seconds to complete the entire lift cycle. A
program written in
LabviewTM announced the time to start the forward bend by an audible tone.
After 2
seconds, another audible tone was emitted by the computer to signal the end of
the lift. An
accelerometer attached to the load allowed tracking of the start and end of
the lifting cycle in
the collected EMG data.
The results are presented in Figure 16. These profiles represent the time from
initial
standing to stooping to collect the box and then standing up to place the box
on the desktop.
Although only one subject was used, all trials reflected a reduction of EMG
activity during the
upward lifting phase when PLAD was used. Lu mbar flexion increased smoothly as
the
subject bent forward until a peak in the EMG signal indicated that the action
of the back
muscles was decelerating the upper body. While the object to be lifted was
being grasped,
a dip in the EMG trace suggested a momentary `flexion-relaxation' phenomenon.
The EMG
signal then reached its main peak as the weight was lifted. This second and
larger peak in
the EMG signal was influenced by the rapid shortening of the muscles as the
lumbar spine
was extended (Dolan and Adams, 1993). It was clearly established by this trial
that PLAD is
-29-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
effective in reducing demands on the erector spinae muscles as measured by
reduced EMG
activity in the erector spinae muscles during a PLAD supported lift.
Example 9. Effect of PLAD through testing of human subjects
Using data acquired through human subject box lifting trials, two objective
assessment methods are presented below that show PLAD's effectiveness in
reducing the
forces and moments on the lumbar spine. The first method (Example 9B) uses
electromyography measurements to demonstrate that there is a reduction in the
activity of
the erector spinae muscles, thus indicating a reduction in back muscle force
requirements
for a lifting task when PLAD is used. The second approach (Example 9C)
demonstrates
mathematically that some of the force requirements during lifting are
redistributed from the
back muscles to the PLAD, thus reducing the back muscle force requirements.
Example 9A. Procedural details for box lifting trials
After the ethics process (approved by Queen's University at Kingston),
subjects were
asked to follow a standardized data collection procedure that was designed to
randomize
trials and minimize fatigue for all human experiments. Ten males and ten
females between
18 to 30 years of age with no history of back pain or other musculoskeletal
problems or
cardiovascular problems were recruited for each PLAD/no PLAD experiment.
Following the
experiments, all twenty subjects reported that PLAD provided assistance when
performing
the lifts. At the time of writing, data for the females had not been analyzed.
Accordingly,
data for the male subjects will be discussed herein. The EMG data for one of
the ten males
was not recorded; the data presented for the box lifting trials is for nine
male subjects.
Anthropometric data for each subject was used to determine body locations for
12
Fastrak motion sensors (Fastrak Electromagnetic Tracking System, Polhemus
Inc.,
Colchester, Vermont). To capture the 3-D position data of the body during box
lifting trials,
-30-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
these motion sensors were attached to a subject's skin over the appropriate
landmarks on
arms (hands, forearms, upper arms), thighs and the head, as well as at the
trunk center of
mass and L4/L5 spinous processes as known in the art. Then, eight bipolar EMG
electrodes
(Delsys Inc., Boston, Massachusetts) were fixed bilaterally over the following
muscles of the
trunk according to sites recommended by McGill et al. (1986) and Cholewicki et
al. (1996):
erector spinae (5 cm from the spinous process) at the level of the fourth
lumbar vertebrae
(L4); erector spinae (5 cm from the spinous process) at the level of the ninth
thoracic
vertebrae (T9); external oblique at the level of the belly button (and 10 cm
laterally); and
rectus abdominus at the level of the belly button (and 3 cm laterally). Before
the lifts were
performed, the EMG signals were normalized with respect to maximal isometric
contractions
using standardized postures designed to maximally activate the erector spinae,
rectus
abdominus and external oblique muscle groups.
The PLAD device used for this study was similar to that described above (see
Figure
1). Four elastic members were used to connect the shoulder belt anchors to the
waist belt
anchor. A first pair of these elastic members was connected in a substantially
parallel
arrangement, as in Figure 1, while the second pair of elastic members was
connected in a
crossed arrangement, as in an "X" formation. The PLAD was easily adjustable to
allow for
different body sizes. Different colours (colours indicate strength or
resistance to stretch) of
Thera-BandTM elastics were used initially. However, grey coloured Thera-BandTM
were
preferred by most subjects and subsequently, the box lifting trails were
performed with grey
coloured Thera-Band TM used for the elastic members of the upper body portion
of PLAD.
Bungee cords were used as for the elastic members of the lower body portion of
PLAD. The
waist belt lever arm "a" (reference numeral 20 in Figure 1) was 20 cm in
length. All six of the
elastic members had strain gauges attached in series between the elastic
members and the
waist belt anchor. The strain gauges were custom made (Department of
Mechanical
Engineering, Queen's University at Kingston, Kingston, Ontario) from a flat
dog-bone shaped
-31-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
piece of solid aluminum with a hole in either end and a micromeasurement
strain gauge
(part number EA13-125TG, Measurement Group Inc., Raleigh, North Carolina)
adhered to
.its central portion. Loops of wire threaded through the holes in the strain
gauges attached
the strain gauges to the waist anchors and the elastic members. The signals
from the strain
gauges were amplified by an A-Tech Strain gauge amplifier 600 (A-Tech
Instruments Ltd.,
Scarborough, Ontario). A synchronization switch on each box was used to
synchronize the
EMG and 3-D position data for the start and end of each lift.
Each subject then followed a standardized data collection procedure of
performing
box lifts. Each box had two handles located on either side and 25 cm from the
bottom of the
box, so all lifts began at 25 cm from the floor although the wording "from
floor to waist
height" may be used. Male subjects lifted 5 kg, 15 kg and 25 kg boxes, and
female subjects
lifted 5 kg, 10 kg and 15 kg boxes using freestyle, stooped or squat lifting
styles in either
asymmetric or symmetric conditions. A total of 54 lifts were performed by each
subject
under PLAD/no PLAD conditions. Once all of the lifting conditions (three
weights, three
techniques and three postures) were completed successfully for the PLAD (or no
PLAD)
condition, the subject was fitted for the no PLAD (or PLAD) condition, the
trial order was
randomized, and the lifts were repeated. During the box lifting trails, data
were collected
simultaneously from the twelve Fastrak sensors, six elastic member strain
gauge sensors,
eight EMG electrodes and the synchronization switch on two synchronized
computers,
displayed, and stored in separate files. At the end of the testing session,
subjects were
given a comfort questionnaire and a pressure points/range of motion
questionnaire. The
results of the questionnaire were that all twenty subjects felt that PLAD had
assisted them to
perform all of the lifts, and subjects with sufficient upper body weight to
cause 200 N of force
to transfer to the lower leg (at the tibial tuberosity) commented on minor
discomfort. An
embodiment with a loop around the foot (as shown in Figure 2) may be preferred
in such
cases.
-32-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
Example 9B. EMG study
Processing of EMG data involved removal of baseline noise, signal
rectification,
expression of EMG as a percentage of maximal isometric contraction and
smoothing with a
2.7 Hz double-pass Butterworth filter. Data were reduced to the start of
downward trunk
motion, through the lift and end of trunk extension. Data were then normalized
to a 100 %
time base. Then at each time interval, data were averaged and standard
deviations
calculated to provide ensemble averages for each muscle for each trial
condition.
Since the amount of muscle electrical activity detected with EMG can be
roughly
equated to muscular force output, it is possible to ascertain the demand on
muscles with
PLAD and without PLAD. If the amount of electrical activity is reduced, then
the muscle
force requirements are also reduced. Since the load being lifted is a constant
between
conditions, PLAD is responsible for this reduced muscular force requirement.
Throughout the lifting cycle the PLAD EMG activity was smaller than the no
PLAD
condition, especially when the PLAD elastic elements were stretched during the
lift. This
was especially true for the start of the lift where greater forces were needed
to get the load
off the floor. Overall, the EMG data indicated that PLAD reduced the demand on
back
musculature by 2% to 25% (Figure 17). This was confirmed for all lift
conditions and EMG
locations from the mean ensemble average and the standard deviations. An
example of
such data for nine male subjects for the stoop lift condition and at the L4
vertebrae EMG
location is shown in Figure 17. From this study, it is thus expected that PLAD
can reduce
the risk of lower back injury and pain, and accelerate recovery from back
injury.
Example 9C. Elastic member strain gauge study
The forces measured by the six strain gauges mounted on the PLAD in series
with
the elastic members ranged from approximately 50 N to 200 N and assisted with
the initial
phase of the lift. In terms of reduction of erector spinae muscle force
required for a lift, this
-33-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
result translates into a 400 N to 1300 N reduction in muscle force required by
the erector
spinae. This result was consistent across all subjects, loads, techniques and
postures and
confirms that the PLAD reduces the compressive and shear forces at L4/L5 and
reduces the
amount of erector spinae activity during a variety of lifting conditions.
Example 9D. 3-D dynamic models for PLAD analysis
Two dynamic biomechanical models were developed to estimate moments on the
lumbar spine in three dimensional tasks with and without PLAD. For visual
dynamic analysis
of PLAD, a model was developed in Visual Nastran 4D (VN model), a dynamic
mechanical
modelling program that can be integrated with other software and aid with the
design
process. The second model was based on the Hof model which has already been
validated
by Plamondon et al. (1996).
3-D linked-segment model created in Visual Nastran 4D
A 3-D linked-segment model (VN model) was created using Visual Nastran 4D
software. This model can be used to calculate the mechanical torques and
forces at any
defined joint within the VN model. In this example, the VN model was used to
determine
L4/L5 moments and compression and shear forces. The data acquired by the
twelve
Fastrak sensors of the box lifting trials (see Example 9A) were inputs to the
VN model, and
other programs were written to extract and apply the position and rotation
data of the
Fastrak sensors. For example, SimulinkTM and MatlabTM programs read,
controlled, and
assigned the data from each body segment to the VN model. The VN model also
received
and assigned data from six strain gauges attached to the elastic members on
the PLAD
device (see Example 9C) to calculate the moments during PLAD application. The
data
entered the VN model through SimulinkTM where euler angles, which represent
the
orientation of each body segment with respect to a ground reference frame,
were
-34-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
manipulated using transformation matrices, to calculate the angles between
each two.,
adjacent body segments based on the euler angles of the two segments. Three
revolute
motors in X, Y, and Z directions were mounted on each simulated joint to
assign the angles
to adjacent body segments and measure the forces and moments based on angular
and
positional changes (flexion-extension, lateral bending, and rotation,
respectively).
Validation of the VN model
There are several well-established linked-segment biomechanical models in the
scientific literature, some of which incorporate EMG data with data from body
landmarks and
accelerations of body segments. However, the VN model is unique to this
application.
Hence, it was important to demonstrate its validity in resolving the forces
and moments at
each joint. The approach used for validation was the Hof (1992) model.
A LabviewTM program was written to take the ten FastrakTM sensor positions and
orientations and find the 3-D moments exerted on the L4/L5 position. The
program also
received data from the strain gauges attached to the elastic members of the
PLAD (see
Example 9C) and calculated the moments at L4/L5 during PLAD use. To estimate
the
moment with respect to an arbitrary moving position P, the equations presented
by
Plamondon et al. (1996) were used.
The net reaction forces at the L4/L5 position were calculated with an upper
body
model only. The reaction moments are reported about the three orthogonal
orthopaedic
axes on the trunk at L4/L5. The moments in flexion/extension (X-axis), lateral
bending (Y-
axis), and axial rotation (twisting) (Z-axis), are about the transverse axis,
sagittal axis, and
longitudinal axis of the trunk, respectively. Joint forces and joint moments
at L4/L5 were
calculated with and without PLAD for 20 subjects.
Figure 18 shows a comparison of the VN and Hof models, and validates the VN
model. From this figure, the VN model appears to be more conservative than the
Hof model,
-35-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
which may be attributed to errors in anthropometrics and in estimation of body
segment
endpoints. Despite this underestimation, this result confirms that the VN
model can be used
to assist with PLAD design in a virtual environment.
Moment results of the VN model for one lift during flexion-extension (X
moment) at
the L4/L5 position is shown in Figure 19. The greatest magnitude of the X
moment occurs
during the final stage of lowering and first stages of lifting. It is at this
stage that the elastic
members are under their greatest deformation (stretch). There is approximately
a 25%
reduction in the moment about L4/L5 during this phase. This reduction in force
is transferred
by PLAD from the back to other places in the body, namely the two attachment
points at the
shoulders and lower legs. The moments about the Y axis (lateral bending) and Z
axis
(rotation) were much smaller than the moment about the X-axis (flexion-
extension). This
pattern was repeated for each lifting task. The elastic member strain-gauge
sensors also
verified that the PLAD was reducing force by about 300 to 400 N for all lift
types.
Example 10. Effect of PLAD on hip extension.
To this point, the effectiveness of PLAD in reducing forces required by the
back
muscles has been demonstrated. This example describes the effect of PLAD on
hip
extension. There is a contribution between the spine and leg muscles during
lifting tasks.
The leg muscles are responsible for extending the trunk and for holding it
during a static
task, especially for a long period of time. Our results show that the elastic
members parallel
to the leg muscles also improve the efficiency of lifting. To model this, a
free body diagram
of the forces exerted on the hip during flexion of the trunk (bending in stoop
or squat
posture) was developed.
To find the moment about the hip joint with and without the PLAD in two
dimensions,
two translational forces and one rotational moment are required. When the PLAD
is added,
other forces, including the tension force of the elastic member exerted on the
upper body
-36-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
and the tension force of the elastic member exerted on the legs, produce a
resultant force
applied to the hip. The required equations have been developed and simulations
are in
progress.
Preliminary EMG data were collected from one male subject during a lift of a
30 kg
box with handles in a symmetrical lifting technique in a stooped posture with
and without a
two elastic member PLAD prototype. This two elastic member PLAD had two white
Flex-
Band elastics that were each attached between shoulder anchors on a shoulder
belt and
tibial tuberosity anchors on leg belts and were threaded over a roller bar
that was attached
to a waist belt at a fulcrum distance "a" of 20 cm (see reference numeral 20
of Figure 1).
The two elastic members were held in distinct channels on the roller bar such
that they were
kept in line over the left buttock, or in line over the right buttock. The
handles were located
25 cm from the bottom of the box, on both sides of the box. The box was lifted
from floor to
waist height. The study showed a significant reduction of force of hamstring
muscles during
the lifting task with the PLAD (as shown in Figure 20). The data suggest that
the forces
exerted by the hamstring and other posterior hip muscles (e.g., gluteus
maximus) close to
the hip joint were reduced when PLAD was used. Therefore, PLAD is effective
not only for
the reduction of moments and forces on L4/L5; but also helps to reduce the
moments and
forces on the hip.
Equivalents
Although this invention is described in detail with reference to preferred
embodiments
thereof, these embodiments are offered to illustrate but not to limit the
invention. It is
possible to make other embodiments that employ the principles of the invention
and that fall
within its spirit and scope as defined by the claims appended hereto.
-37-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
References
Adams, M. A., Hutton, W. C., Stott, J. R. R. (1980) "The resistance to flexion
of the
lumbar intervertebral joint", Spine 3: 245-253.
Abdoli-Eramaki, M., Agnew, M. J., Stevenson, J. M. (2004a) "Integration of
electromagnetic tracking systems and virtual reality simulation for 3-D
dynamic analyses of
spinal loading" Eighth International Symposium on the 3-D Analysis of Human
Movement,
Tampa, Florida, 2004.
Abdoli-Eramaki, M., Stevenson, J. M. (2004b) "Is an on-body lift assistive
device
possible?" XVIII Annual International Society for Occupational Ergonomics and
Safety
Conference," Houston, Texas, 2004.
Abdoli-Eramaki, M., Stevenson, J. M., Agnew, M. J. (2004c) "Recent advantages
in
validation of the on body Personal Lift Augmentation Device (PLAD)," Windsor,
Ontario,
Association of Canadian Ergonomists.
Chen, Y. (2003) "The effect of the tightness of abdominal belts on the
determination
of maximal acceptable weight of lift," International Journal of Industrial
Ergonomics, 31, 111-
117.
Cholewicki, J., McGill, S. M. (1996) "Mechanical stability of the in vivo
lumbar spine:
Implications for injury and chronic low back pain", Clin. Biomech. 11(1): 1-
15.
Dolan, P. and Adams, M.A. (1993) "The relationship between EMG activity and
extensor moment generation in the erector spinae muscles during bending and
lifting
activities," Journal of Biomechanics, 26 (4), 513-522.
Guo, H. R., Tanaka, S., Cameron, L. L., Seligman, P. J., Behrens, V. J., Ger,
J., Wild,
D.K., and Putz-Anderson, V. (1995) "Back pain among workers in the United
States: national
estimates and workers at high risk," American Journal of Industrial Medicine,
28.
-38-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
Harman, E. A., Rosenstein, R. M., Frykman, P. N. and Nigro, G. A. (1989). "The
effects of a weight training belt on blood pressure during exercise," Journal
of Applied Sport
Science Research, 3 (1): 13-18.
Hobson, D. A. (1992) "Comparative effects of posture on pressure and shear at
the
body-seat interface," Journal of Rehabilitation Research and Development,
29(4): 21-31.
Hodges, P. W., Richardson, C. A. (1997) "Feedforward contraction of
transversus
abdominus is not influenced by the direction of arm movement," Exp. Brain Res.
114: 362-
370.
Hof, A. T. (1992) "An explicit expression for the moment in multibody
systems," J.
Biomech., 25:1209-1211.
Kazerooni, H. (2002) "Human power amplifier for lifting load with slack
prevention
apparatus," U.S. Patent Serial No.: 6,622,990.
Kelsey, J. L., Githens, P. B., White, A. A., Holford, T. R., Walter, S. D.,
O'Connor, T.,
Ostfeld, A. M., Weil, U., Southwick, W. 0., and Calogero, J. A. (1984) "An
epidemiologic
study of lifting and twisting on the job and risk for acute prolapsed lumbar
intervertebral
disc," Journal of Orthopedics, 2, 61-66.
Kelsey, J. L., White, A. A. (1980) "Epidemiology and impact of low back pain,"
Spine,
5, 133-142.
Lavender, S. A., Shakeel, K., Andersson, G. B., and Thomas, J. S. (2000)
"Effects of
a lifting belt on spine moments and muscle recruitments after unexpected
sudden loading,"
Spine, 25(12), 1569-1576.
McGill, S. M. (2002) Low Back Disorders: Evidence-Based Prevention and
Rehabilitation, Human Kinetics: Champaign, Illinois, USA.
McGill, S. M. (1997) "The biomechanics of low back injury: Implications on
current
practice in industry and the clinic," J. Biomech. 30(5): 465-475.
-39-
CA 02547270 2006-05-25
WO 2005/056124 PCT/CA2004/002134
McGill, S. M. (1993) "Abdominal Belts in industry: A position paper on their
assets,
liabilities and use," American industrial hygiene association journal, 54
(12): 752-754.
McGill, S. M., Norman, R. W. (1986) "Partitioning of the L4/L5 dynamic moment
into
disc, ligamentous and muscular components during lifting." Spine, 11(7): 666-
677.
NIOSH publication number 94-122 (1994) Workplace Use of Back Belts, US
Department of
Health and Human Services, National Institute for Occupational Safety and
Health:
Cincinnati, Ohio, USA.
Plamondon, A., Gagnon, M., Desjardins, P. (1996) "Validation of two 3-D
segment
models to calculate the net reaction forces and moments at the L5/S1 joint in
lifting," Clin.
Biomech. 11(2): 101-110.
Rafacz, W., McGill, S. M. (1996) "Wearing an abdominal belt increases
diastolic
blood pressure," J Occup Environ Med, 38(9): 925-7.
Shirazi-Adl, A., Ahmed, A. M., and Shrivastava, S. C. (1986) "Mechanical
response
of a lumbar motion segment in axial torque alone and combined with
compression," Spine,
11(9) 914-927.
Waters, T. R., and Putz-Andersson, V., (1994) "Applications Manual for the
revised
NIOSH lifting equation," US Department of Health and Human Services, National
Institute for
Occupational Safety and Health Publication, 94-110.
-40-
