Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
Background of the Invention
This invention relates to measuring ap~aratus and
more particularly to apparatus for measuring the size of solid
particles falling in a fluid of known viscosity.
There are a number of presently available techniques
for ascertaining the dimensions of small particles. These have
included, in addition to the well known sieve or screen analyses,
tne measurement of the particles microscopically, sedimentation
techniques, permeability systems, adsorption and photo-extinction.
In the oil and gas field, for example, the measurement of rock
and sand particles, etc., commonly is accomplished by passing
the particles through a series of screens of different sizes to
obtain a rough quantification of the size of the ~articles
retained on each screen. For particles in the less than fine
sand size range or in other cases in which more ra~id particle
size information is desired, ho~lever, the screen analysis tech-
nique has proven deficient, and it frequent:Ly is desirable to
turn to one or more of the other available measuring systems.
Also, most sedimentary rocks were deposited by ~ater, and it is
highly desirable to use a closely related technique in the particle
size analysis of such rocks.
Sedimentation techniques are generally more reliable
and accurate than some of the other methods for determining the
size of the smaller size particles. The sedimentation
techniques are based in whole or in part on the well known Stokes'
Law relating the velocity of the particles settling in a fluid
to the size and density of the particles and the viscosity and
density of the fluid. By making certain simplifying assumptions
the particle size may be ascertained in a reasonably straightfor~ard
--1--
. ~7~
manner without the need for tedious microscopic examination of
~he particlec or overly expensive and sophisticated equipment.
The sedimentation ~echniques and equipment employed
heretoforer however, have exhibited a number of disadvantages.
~s an illustration, when using several types of prior techniques
and apparatus for this purpose the particles often agglomerated
or were otherwise unevenly disper~ed at the time of deposition
with the result that the overall accuracy of the measurements
was impaired. Furthermore, and this has been of special moment
in analyzing core samples and in other instances where there is
a need for prompt and accurate particle size data, the amount of
time required for making the measurements was excessive in many
instarces.
Summary
One general object of this invention, therefore, is to
provide new and more efficient sedimentation apparatus and tech-
niques for measuring the size of solid particles falling in a
fluid of known visc03ity.
More specifically, it is an object of this invention to
provide such apparatus and techniques in which the resulting
measurements are suitably reliable for many petrophysic~
applications.
Another object of the invention is to vrovide measuring
apparatus and techniques of khe character indicated in which the
size of the particles being measured may be determined more rapidly
than with sedimentation syskems of the type used heretofore.
A ~urther object of khis invention is to provide
apparatus for measuring the size of solid particles in which the
apparatus has comparatively simple mechanical and electrical
components and is economical to manufacture and strai~htforward
in operation.
~2--
3~
In one illustrative embodiment of the invention, the
apparatus includes a sedimentation container for a column of
distilled water or other fluid of known viscosity. A particle
dispenser is disposed above the fluid in the containex, and a
balance member is suspended in the container. The particle
dispenser is supported for unique swinging movement i~mediately
above the surface of the fluid column to discharge the particles
into the fluid where they settle and are received by the balance
member. An electrical circuit connected to the balance member
13 times the fall of the particles and determines their size from
the calculated settling velocities.
In accordance with one feature of the invention, in
certain particularly important embodiments, the particle
dispenser is of cup-shaped or hemi-ellipsoidal configuration.
The dispenser is supported for s~inging movement immediately
above the surface of the fluid in the sedimentation container
and is effective to rapidly and substantially simultaneously
transfer all of the particles thereto. The arrangement is such
that the particles enter the fluid at a slow velocity. The
electrical circuit is effective to determine the settling velocitiec
on the ~asis of the time and distance travelled before constant
particle velocities have been achieved. With this arrangement,
the size of the particles may be determined with suitable aCcuracY
and more rapidly than wi*ll sedimentation systems of ~he ty~e
previously em~loyed.
~ ~3~;~6
In accordance with another feature of the invention,
in several important arrangements, ~he particles are dispe~sed
through ultrasonic techniques. The dispersal of ~he particles
is effective to ensure a more even particle distribution a~ the
time or shortly after the particles come in contact with the
surface of the fluid and provides a substantial improvement
in the overall accuracy of the resulting measurements. Also,
the ultrasonic energy tends to dislodge clay coatings that
frequently are tightly attached to the particlefiS allowing
a more accurate particle size analysis of the sample.
In accordance with a further feature of some
embodiments of the invention, the particle dispenser is
provided with an open mouth portion and a lid pivotally
carried by the dispenser and extending over only a part
of the open mouth portion. ~uring a rapid but smooth swinging
movement of the dispenser the lid inhibits the pre-
mature discharge of the particles until after the dispenser
-3a~
~ 3~
has moved through an angle of abvut ninet~ degrees. The
lid then pivots to its open position to ~pread all of
the par~icles on the liquid surface at substantially the same
time. As a result, the overall accuracy of the apparatus i5
further enhanced.
The foregoing and other objects, features and advantages
of the invention will be more readily understood fxom the
following descxiption of certain preferred embodiments, when
read with reference to the accompanying drawings.
Brief Description of the Drawings
Figure 1 is a perspective view of apparatus for
measuring the size of solid particles in accordance with one
illustrative embodiment of the invention.
Figure 2 is a transverse sectional view of the
ap~aratus taken along the line 2-2 in Figure 1.
Figure 3 is a fragmentary sectional view taken
along the line 3-3 of Figure 2.
Figure 4A is an enlarged fragmentary sectional view
of the particle dispenser of the apparatus, together with
certaill associa~ed components.
Figure 4B is an enlarged fragmentary sectional vie~
similar to Figure 4A but showing the particle dispenser as it
swings to discharge the particles into the container.
Figure 5 is an enlarged fragmentary sec-tional view of
a particle dispenser in accordance with another illustrative
embodiment of the invention.
Figure 6 is a schematic block diagram of an electrical
circuit useful in connection with the apparatus.
~escription of Certain Preferred Embodiments
The determination of particle size by means of sedimenta-
tion techniques is based on the well known principle that small
particles suspended in a fluid medium settle with a constant
velocity when the fluid resistance force is equal to the downward
constant force of gravity acting on the ~articles. T~e settling
velocities of the particles depend on the surface texture,
radius, shape and density of-the particles and on the density
and viscosity of the fluid.
Stokes' Law is a mathematical expression relating
these factors:
R = 6~rnv = 4 ~ r (dl - d2)g
R = resistance in g.cm/sec2 of fluid to movement of suspended
spherical particles
r = radius of sphere in cm
n = viscosity of the fluid in poises
v = velocity of the sphere in cm/sec
dl = density of spherical particles, g./cm3
d2 = density of fluid, g./cm3
g = acceleration of gravity, cm/sec2
By u~ilizing a suspending fluid of a known vi~cos-,ty,
and by knowing the density of the fluid and of the particles
being measured, the velocity of the particles may be dete~ted
to determine the radius or particle size.
Rather than attempting to achieve a cons~ant velocity
for the particles, the apparatus described herein initiates the
introduction of the particles into the fluid at a slow velocity
and then detects the mean or average velocity as the particles
drop through the fluid over a known but comparatively short
distance.
In addition, although the measurement of the particles
by ~okes' Law assumes that the particles are spherical and have
-5-
smooth friction-fxee surfaces, the described apparatus advantage-
ously uses an empirical data bank of settling velocity versus
median particle size for particles with shapes more sirnilar to
the particles to be evaluated.
Referring now to Figure 1 of the drawings, there is
shown an apparatus for accomplishing this result. The apparatus
includes a sedimentation container 10 for the known viscosity
fluid, a particle dispenser 12 disposed above the fluid in the
container, an ultrasonic transducer 14 for dispersing the
particles and a balance system 16 suspended in the container
for receiving the dispensed particles. Th~se components are
mounted within an upstanding cabinet 1~ which is closed on
three sides but has an open front 19 to permit ready access to
the apparatus. The cabinet 18 illustratively is of aluminum
and may be provided with a door (not shown) adjacent the uoper
portion of the open front 19 ko prevent ambient air currents
from dist~rbing the particles and the fluid.
The sedimentation container 10 is in the form of an
upstanding cylinder or tube containing a column of fluid 20 of
known viscosity. The container 10 illustratively is of trans~
parent plastic material with an outside diameter of ten inches,
a length of thirty inches and a wall thickness of one-fourth
inch. Although a wide variety of known viscosity fluids may be
used in the container 10, distilled water is preferred because
of its easily determinable properties and ready availabili~y.
A constant length water column is maintained hy an overflow
conduit 22 which communicates with the upper portion of the
container and which extends downwardly into a drain (not shown)
a short distance beneath a suita~le stopcock valve 23.
Po3itioned immediately above the surface of ~he fluid
20 in the sedimentation container 10 is the particle dispenser 12.
- 3 ~
The di~penser 12 includes ~ cup-shaped or hemi-ellipsoidal sample
container 25 having an open mouth 26 and a lid 27. As best shown
in Figure 4A, in the uprigllt position of the container 25 the
lid 27 extends over only a part of the open mouth 26 and is
pivotally secured to the inner upper periphery of the container by
a shaft 28. When the lid is in its closed, Figure 4A, position,
it covers approximately one-half of the container mouth.
The sample container 25 is supported at the inner end
of a crank arm 30. The arm 30 extends through a suitable aper-
ture in the cylindrical ~7all of the sedimentation container 10and is provided at its outer end with a hollow handle 3~ con
taining a mercury switch 33. By manually rota~ing the handle 32
the sample container 25 may be swung to an inverted position as
a result of the crank arm 30. As the container passes through
an angle of approximately ninety degrees, the switch 33 closes
for purposes that will become more fully apparent hereinafter.
A tank 35 is suitably suppor~ed adjacent the cabinet
18 above the level o~ the sample container 25. The tank 35
contains distilled water and a wetting agent and is provided
witil a discharge conduit 3~ leading to a position a short
distance above the sample container 25~ The flow of wetting
agent and water from the tank to the sample container is con-
trolled by a stopcock valve 37 in the conduit 36.
The ultrasonic transducer 14 comprises a horn 40 which
is suspended above the particle dispenser 12 such that ~he horn's
tip 42 (Figure 4~) protrudes into the open mouth 26. The horn
40 is mounted on a support clamp 44 affixed to the upper side
wall of the cabinet 18 and is electrically connected by a cable
45 to an ultrasonic generator 46. As will be understood, the
3~ generator 4~ is effec~ive to energize the horn 40 to vibrate the
~ ~t7~
tip 42 at an ultrasonic frequency, illustratively 20,000 ~z.
The horn 40 and the generator 46 may be of conventional con
struction and in the illustrated embodiment comprise the Model
185 Sonifier available commercially from the Branson Sonic Power
Co., Danbury, Connecticut. The generator 46 is supplied with
power from a power cord 47 leading to a relay box 48 mounted on
the side wall of the cabinet 18. Power from a suitable alternating
current source (not shown in Figure 1) is supplied to the relay
box 48 by a power cord 49.
A sample collecting pan 50 is suspended within the
sedimentation container 10 and forms a part of the balance
system 16. The pan 50 is of circular configuration and illus-
tratively may be fabricated from acrylic plastic. The pan 50
is located a known distance beneath the upper surface of the
column of fluid 20 and is supported by three filament wires ;~
connected to the corners of a spacer triangle 52. The triangle
52 is suspended a sllort distance above ~he ultrasonic transducer
14 by three chains 58 connected to the hook 5~ of a balance unit
60 mounted on the top of the cabinet 18. The unit 60 may be of
23 conventional construction and illustratively i5 of the type
available commercially from the llettler Instrument Corp.,
Heightstown, New Jersey, and identified as its ~odel PK300. The
unit 60 is supplied with electrical power from a line cord 61
and produces varying output signals proportional to the weight
of the particles on the pan 16.
A ring shaped member 62 is supported within the
container 10 at the level of the upper surface of the water
column 20. The member 62 is affixed to the upper peripheral
edge of the container 10 by tllree straps 64. Approximately
33 one~half of the vertical height of tlle member Z~ i~ submerged
~ ~73~
in the column 20 such that the upper surface of the column
outside of the suspended ring remains smooth and ripple
free. As best shown in Figure 3, the pan suppor ing fila-
ments 55 are externally disposed with respect to the member
62. The arrangement is such that the member 62 isolates
the filaments 55 and prevents their dis~urbance wnen the
sample being tested is introduced into the column.
The various electrical components of the apparatus
are connected in a circuit schematically illustrated in Figure
6. The particle weight sensed by the balance member 60 is
transmitted over a line 66 and an interface circuit 67 to a
computer 70. The computer 70 operates under the control of the
relay box 48 and i5 connected thereto by a line 72~ The
computer is of conventional construction and is provided with
a suitable timing circuit to detect the incoming weight
information from the balance member 60 at uniform timed in-
tervals up to the total time selected by the operator of the
apparatus. The computer is programmed to determine the
particle size data according to Stokes' Law using the empirical
settling velocities discussed here~ofore, and this data app~ars
on an output lead 74. The lead 74 is connected to a printer 76
to record the output data, an X-Y plotter 77 to provide a
graphic display of the data and a cathode ray tube display
78 which serves as a visual display.
The sample of particles to be evaluated is prepared
for testing by cleaning the particles of hydrocarbons, salt~
etc., and then obtaining their air suspended drv weight. The
dry weight is entered in the computer 70 together with the
smallest particle size for which a measurement is desired and
the length of the column of fluid within the container 10, that
is, the vertical distance from the fluid surface to the sample
~L~,t~
collecting pan 50O The computer also contains i~formation as
to settling velocities versus grain size for the type of
particles being mea~ured (e.g~ nonspherical particles), the
viscosity of the sedimentation fluid, the date and time of
the test and other desired identifying data.
- The thus prepared particles are inserted into the
sample container 25. The stopcock valve 37 is opened to intro-
duce a suitable wetting solution in distilled water from the
tank 35 through the conduit 36 int~ the container 25. As best
shown in Figure 4A, the quantity of particles and solution
introduced into the container 25 is such that the surface level
of particles and solution is located a short distance above
the tip 42 of the ultrasonic horn 40.
The ultrasonic generator 46 is then energized to
vibrate the horn ~0 and thereby wet the sample par~icles and
also evenly disperse the particles within the dispensing COII-
tainer 25. Within a short period of time, illustratively
fifteen seconds, after the energization of the generator 46,
the handle 32 is rapidly rotated in a clockwise direction,
as viewed in Figures 4A and 4B, through an angle of one
hundred and eighty degrees to swing the container 25 through
a similar angle from the position shown in Figure 4A to that
illustrated in Figure 4B. Durin~ the initial portion of
this swinging movement, the lid 27 remains in its closed
position to maintain the particles within the container 2S.
As the container passes through an angle of approximately
ninety degrees and approaches its inverted position, the
force of gravity and the liyuid in the container causes
tne lid 27 to swing open and ~ubstantially simultaneou~ly
deposit all of the particles within the container
onto the surface of the fluid 20. The container 25
is lccated in close proximity with the fluid ~urface, and
., . ~
3~
because of this rapid movement and the even dispersal of the
particles by the ultrasonic horn 40 the particles come in contact
with t~e surface at a uniform and slow vert.ical velocity
As the handle 32 is rotated to move th~ dispensing
container 25 through an angle of ninety degrees, the mercury
switch 3-3 closes to energize selected relays in the box 4
These relays simultaneously and automatically turn off the
ultrasonic transducer 14 and activate the co~puter 70 (Figure 6)
to zero the balance system 16 and to initiate the computer program.
Upon the closing of the mercury switch 33 the computer
70 automatically begins xecording weights from the balance system
15 at preselected uniform timed intervals, illustratively five
seconds, for a period of time sufficient to enable all of the
particles from the dispenser 12 to move by gravity through the
fluid column 20 and reach the particle receiving pan 50. For
the common sands and shales the grain density store~ in the computer
is 2.65 gm/cm3, and for distilled water in the column the stored
fluid density is 1.0 gm/cm3. The computer calculates the percent
of each grain size received by the pan ~0 according to Stokes'
Law using the stored settling velocity versus grain size infor-
mation and the calculated data appears on the output line 74 and
is recorded by the printer 76 and the plotter 77O In addition,
the CRT display 78 provides a vi~ual indication of the particle
size distribution.
Figure 5 is illustrative of an alternative vibra~ory
ultrasonic transducer 82 useful in connection with the invention.
The transducer 82 is in the shape of an open cylinder or ring and is
affixed to the inner periphery of the sedimentation container 10
immediately beneatl~ the level of the flu.id 20. A suitable layer
83 of insulating material separates the transducer 82 from the
~ ~ ~ 3 ~; ~i 6
wall of the container. The transducer is suppli~d with power
over the cable connected to the ultrasonic generator 46 (~igure 1)
to vibrate the transducer at an ultrasonic frequency and thereby
evenly disperse the solid particles as they descend in the fluid
thxough the transducer. The frequency and amplitude of the
vibrations are selected so as to disperse the par~icles without
influencing the balance pan 16.
Among its other advantages, the apparatus described
and illustrated herein is effective to determine the size o
the solia particles in an extremely rapid manner. As an illus-
tration, for particles having a size of up to 0.063 mm the
measurements can be completed in less than one minute in a
water column of 30.8 cm., while the time required to perform
equivalent measurements on smaller particles down to 0.044 mm
is approximately 1.35 minutes. The resulting measurements also
~xhibit good accuracy and repeatability.
The terms and expressions which have been employed
are used as texms of description and not of limitation, and
there is no intention in the use of such terms and expressions
of excluding any equivalents of the features shown and described
or portions thereof, but it is recognized that various modifica-
tions are possible within the scope of the invPntion claimed.
