Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
RD-12,310
POLYCRYSTALLINE SILICON-BONDED CUBIC
BORON NITRIDE BODY AND METHOD
. _
SPECIFICATION
This invention re~ates generally to -the art of the
fabrication of polycrystalline bodies and is more particularly
concerned with a new silicon-bonded polycrystalline cubic boron
nitride body, and with a novel method for making such bodies in
a wide variety of sizes and shapes.
BAC~GROUND OF THE INVENTION
The superhard materials diamond and cubic boron
nitride (hereinafter sometimes referred to as CBN) have a wide
varie~y of abrasive and cu~ting tool uses as w~ll a~ uses
which do not lnvolve the relatively high impact forces incident
to grinding and sawing operations. Thus, in applications in
which wear resistance is of prima~y concern such as in conduits
or the delivery of sprays of abrasive materials, the matrix
lS of bonding medium may be much more brittle than the impact-
resistant resin and metal bonding media ~enerally used.
Because of their superior hardness, silicon and silicon-base
alloys are preferred as sources of the bonding medium in the
fabrication of conduit~ made of these superhard materials.
Efforts heretofore to produce strong and well-bonded compacts
(i.e., bonded polycrystalline bodies) of CBM by infiltrating
a particulate mass of CBN with molten silicon or an alloy
thereof have~ however, been unsuccessful, but for one notable
exception. That exception is the invention disclosed and
claimed in U. S. Patent No. 4,220,455, assigned to the
assignee hereof, in accordance with which superhard particles
--1--
A~ t~
RD-12,310
are given a coating of non-diamond carbon pxior to contac~lng
them with molten silicon or silicon-base alloy~ Both in the
case of diamond particles and that of CBN particles, the non-
diamond carbon reacts with molten sllicon to form silicon
carbide which serves to bond the par~icles in the resulting
mass o~ metal or alloy, ~ha superhard material ranging in
volume from about 1% to 80% of the resulting composite body,
according to intended use requirements.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
We have found that well-bonded polycrystalline CBN
bodies can be made by a low-pressure, high-temperature process
by coating CBN particles with molybdenum or tungs~en prior to
infiltrating a mass of such coated particles with molten
silicon or silicon-base alloy. Further, we have found that it
is not necessary to cover the surfaces of the particles
entirely or even to more than abou~ 50% to consistently produce
these new polycrystallline CBN bodiPs. It is, however,
essential that the molybdenum or the tungsten be on the CBN
particles rather than merely being in proximity to these
particles. Still further, the molybdenum and tungsten can be
used separately or in combination as coatings, that is,
molybdenum-coated ~BN particles may be admixed with tungsten-
coated CBN particles/ and CBN particles partially or completely
coated with molybdenum and tungsten can be used with cor.sistent
success in accordance with this invention. Our findings,
however, indicate that the total amount of such coating metal
prior to the infiltration should not be less than about 5% nor
more than about 20% by weight of the CBN particle mass, the
2--
7~
RD-12,310
optimum proportion thus being about 10% by weight. When the
coating metal i9 used in accordance with this invention and
consequently in conformity with these requirements, the
resulting novel poLycrystalline product is characterized by
-5 the presence of a -third phase in the form of a molybdenum or
tungsten silicide (ox both) precipitate distributed through
the silicon bonding medium. Finally, we have found that -these
new polycrystalline bodies can be made in the size and shape
desired within broad limits in a relatively low-pressure, high-
1~ temperature environment~ Thus, through these discoveries, wehave provided an advantageous alternative to the method
disclosed in the aforesaid '455 patent and have also invented
a new CBN polycrystalline product. Actually, this invention
affords even more in that the end product is substantially free
from carbides and thus not as subject to impact failure.
Our basic concept, based upon these findings, is
that molybdenum or tungsten metal present as a partial or
complete coating on the surface of a CB~ particle limits
reaction between the CBN and molten silicon (or silicon alloy)
to the extent that there is no more than the slightest amount
of reaction product phase produced at the CBN-silicon interface.
This hitherto unknown and unrecognized capability of molybdenum
and tungsten coatings we believe to be attributable to the
control provided by these metals over the kinetics of such
reaction. Thus, the coatings do not serve either as physical
barriers or as the bonding media per se, but dissolve in the
silicon or silicon-base alloy melt and later precipitate on
cooling in the form of the respective silicides. In any event,
the ultimate novel and very beneficial result of the
RD-12,310
application of this phenomenon is real and drama-tic as
evidenced by the results of our several experiments detailed
below.
Although molybden~n and tunysten have been applied in
coatings to CBN particles to produce sur~ace modified c~brasive
particles, there is no disclosure or application ~herein O:e
the above-described phenomenon.
Briefly descrihed, the new method of this invention
includes the steps of applying a coating of molybdenum or
tungsten to CBN particles; then placing a mass of the coated
particles in a suitable mold cavity and infiltrating the mass
of particles with molten silicon or silicon-base alloy with
applied pressure at a temperature above 1400Co When the mold
contents have been cooled and the silicon or alloy has soli-
dified, the resulting body is removed with the CBN particles
being securely bonded by the silicon or alloy, which is
distributed throughout the mass and contains (depending on the
coating employed) molybdenum silicide or tungsten silicide in
precipitate form.
In its product aspect, this invention is the
polycrystalline body prepaxed by the process of this invention
as defined aboveO Accordingly, the resulting product is a
hard, wear-resistant preshaped, bonded polycrystalline article
in which, preferably, a major portion (i.e., greater than 50
volume percent) of the volume is cubic boron nitride. In the
best practice of this invention, the CBN particle volume
fraction of the polycrystalline ~ody is of the order of 65 to
80 v/o. As stated above, the products of this invention
include a characteristic third phase in the form of a
-4
5 ~ ~ 3 ~
RD-12,31G
precipitate of the silicide reaction product of the molybden~n
or tungsten coating on the CBN partlcles. In tho~e instances
in which a silicon alloy is employed as the in:Eiltrant, small
amounts of silicide of the alloying element may a].so occur.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF I'HE DR~WINGS
FIG. 1 is a vertical sectional view through an
apparatus for applying semi~iso~tatic pressure to a cell
assembly disposed in a finely divided particulate mass;
FIG. 2 is a vertical sectional view through a
graphite mold for the simultaneous application of heat and
pressure to the stabilized geometry of the semi-isostatic
system and the cell assembl.y enclosed therein;
FIG. 3 iS a photomicrograph (1400x) of a bonded
polycrystallina CBN product of this invention;
FIG. 4 is a photomicrograph (llOOx) of a product
without benefit of tungsten or molybdenum coating on the CBN
particles;
FI~. 5 is a photomicrograph (1400x~ of another
pxoduct of this invention prepared from CBN particles
substantially completely coa~ed with tungsten;
FIG. 6 iS a photomicrograph (1400x) of still another
product of this invention prepared from CBN particles only
partially coated with tungsten;
FIG. 7 is a scanning electron photomicrograph (lOOOx)
of the Fig. 5 bonded polycrystalline product showing the
tungsten silicide precipitate phase as the light material in
the gray-appearing silicon bonding medium, and
3q.~
RD-12,310
FIG. ~ is a photomicroyraph (3000x) like that of
Fig. 7 of the bonded polycrys-tal]ine prodl1ct shown therein.
DETAILED DE~CRIPTION OF THE INVEMI'ION
The new bonded polycrystalline CBN procluc-ts of this
S invention are made in accordance wlth the best practice of
our present process through the use of the apparatus shown in
Figs. 1 and 2. As disclosed in U~ S. Patent 3,982,911, issued
September 28, 1976, and assigned to the assignee hereof, the
apparatus in Fig. 1 romprises cell assembly 10 consisting of a
metal cup 11 (a cylindrical wall complete with bottom wall
sec~ion) of reractory metal such as zirconium containing a
disc 12 of silicon (or appropriate silicon alloy)/ a mass 13
of CBN particles coated with tungsten, molybdenum, or a
mix ofsuch coated particles and a plug 14 of suitable inert
material serving as a closure for the assembly.
The CBN particles are preferably size-graded to
contain a full size range from less than 1 to 200 microns and
are coated with molybdenum or tungsten to the extent of at
least 50~ to ~0% of the surface area thereof by the ~eans and
method set out below. Following vibration, consolidation of
the CBN powder mixture as disclosed in said U.S. '911, cell 10
is disposed in pressure mold 20 surrounded by a mass 21 of very
fine (about 500 mesh) particles of hexagonal boron nitride
providing an approximately isostatic system for the application
of pressure whereby the shape and density of the contents of
cup 11 are determined. Mold 20, comprising ring 22 and pistons
23 and 23a, is constructed of tool steel. Once a semi-isostatic
system has been established within the confines of piston 23,
t~
RD~12,310
sleeve 22a and piston 23 a pressure of about 90 kpsi is
exerted on the system.
The nature of the hexagonal boron nitride containment
is such that the fine particles slip over each other and
readjust in approximation of a hydrostatic action in response
to the uniaxially-applied force and exert pressure over the
entire surface o~ cell lO. It is assumed that the applied
pressure is transmitted substantially undiminished to the cell
and the prime purpose of -this pressure application is to bring
about a consolidation which is effective to diminish the size
of the voids and maximize the presence of capillary-size voids
in the CBN powder mas~.
After completlon of the above-mentioned semi-isostatic
pressure application, either one of the pistons 23, 23a is
withdrawn and the consolidated semi-isostatic syst~m 21 is
removed from mold 20 and placed in a hole of identical diameter
in graphite mold 30, the transferred semi-isostatic system 21
now being contained within the wall of hole 31 between graphite
pi~tons 32 and 32a. The graphite mold is provided with a
th~rmocouple 33 to provide indication of temperature applied
to the semi-isostatic system 21. The mold 30, with the system
21 as so contained, is introduced into a conventional hot-
pressing furnace (not shown) and while pistons 32 and 32a apply
a uniaxial pressure of about 10 kpsi to system 21, the
temperature thereof is raised above the melting-point tempera-
ture of the silicon or silicon-base alloy bonding medium.
Under this combined application of heat and pressure, the
molten bonding m~dlum is forced into the reyion between the
CBN crystals and infused through the mass 13 by capillary
'3~
RD-12,310
action, the inner cr~stalline voids being sufficiently clean
ancl small for that effect to be marked throughout the structure
of the mass. The molybdenum or tungsten coating on the
particles reacts with the infiltratiny silicon forming the
respective silicide.
Apparently as a consequence of these latter
preferential silicide-forming reactions, there is very little
or essentially no reaction of the molten bonding medil~n with
the CBN particle surface being covered completely by a coating
of molybdenum or tungsten. The protection on a partially
coated CBN particle, which such coating affords, extends to
adjoining uncoated surface portions to control the kinetics of
reactions between the infiltrating melt and that CBN particle.
As a main consequence, there is little or essentially no
reaction product along the interface between the silicon or
silicon-base alloy and the individual CBN particle. As far
as can be determined, the molybdenum or tungsten coatin~ is
converted to silicide, which precipitates in the binder ~ha~e
as the infiltrated particulate mass is cooled. This relatively
clean (i.e. relatively free from the products of reaction
hetween CBN and silicon) interface condition is essential to a
well-bonded polycrvstalline CBN product and thus is character-
istic of the novel polycrystalline, silicon-bonded CBN bodies
of this invention.
The time involved in infiltration and reac~ion of the
silicon or alloy thereof with the molybdenum- and/or t~ngsten-
coated particulate CBN mass in a mold cavity will generally be
relatively short depending, to some extent, on the size of the
shaped mixture, but usually will not exceed approximately 15
minutes.
¢~
RD-12,310
The new polycrystalline, silicon-bonded body of CBN
will, in the preferred practice, consist of crystals ranging
in size from submicron up to about 200 microns and ~he propor-
tion of CBN crystals or particles in the polycrystalline body
will range upwardly of 50 volume percent and preferably be
from about 6S to 80 percent by volume. Further, th~ bonding
medium, which is composed predominately of silicon and sili-
cides, will be substantially uniformly distributed throuyhout
the particulate structure and the polycrystalline body will be
substantially pore-free.
A special advantage of this invention is that the
polycrystalline silicon-bonded bodies can be produced directly
in a greater variety of shapes and sizes. Consequently, it is
now possible to produce in as-cast form bodies such as tubes,
rings, and certain other complex shapes, which could only be
produced heretofore by expensive machining operations.
The product of this invention process (i.e., a body
oE CBN particles and bonding medium consisting essentially of
silicon and silicides) can be used in a variety of ways, for
example, it can be brazed or otherwise attached to a suitable
support, such as sintered ox hot-pressed silicon carbide,
silicon nitride, or cemented carbide. These bodies, however,
are not contemplated for use in applications which involve
significant impact-resistant requirements such as in sawing
operations. The difficulty in such applications is the fact
that the bonding medium imparting the tensile strength to the
polycrystalline structure is much too brittle for such appli-
cations.
~D-12,310
The coatings of molybdenum or tungsten on the CBN
particles used in accordance wi-th the process of this
invention are preferably applied in the manner and
according to the specific instructions set ou-t ln
United States Patent Number 4,011.,064 -to Johnston
dated ~arch 8, 1977 assigned to the assignee hereof.
The best practice of the present invention in respec-t
to this aspect of the process thus involves the best
practice of the invention disclosed and claimed in that
patent. Further, silicon alloys useful in the practice
of this invention are disclosed in U.S. Patent Number
4,124,401 to Lee et al dated November 7, 1978.
Those skilled in the art will gain a further and
better understanding of this invention by the following
illustrative, but not limiting, examples of this invention
as actually carried out in experiments conducted in the
laboratory. The CBN particles were commercial varieties
manufactured by the General Electric Company:
EXAMPLE I
100- to 120-mesh cubic boron nitride particles
were tungsten-coated as described in EXAMPLE I of the
United States Patent Number 4,011,064 referenced
above and a 900~gram charge of these coated particles
was placed in a 0.562 inch diameter zirconium cup on
25 top of a 650-milligram disc of silicon-30% rhenium
with the cup being closed by means of a hexagonal boron
ni.tride and cap. The entire cell assembly was then
- 10 -
RD-12,310
encapsulated in boron nitrlde powder and cold
pressed -to 90 kpsi, after which the body was trans-
ferred to a graphite die Eor hot pressiny~ Hot
pressing was carried Ollt as follows: 0 to 1550C
in 5 minutes at a maximum pressure of 8700 psi, the
cell assembly was held at temperature and pressure
maxima for one minute and then slow-cooled to room
temperature. Examination of a polished cross-
section of the resulting bonded polycrystalline
product revealed that the individual CBN particles
were well~bonded, there being very little damage to
their surfaces~
EXPMPLE II
To test the effect of removing the tungsten
coating, another similar experiment was carried
out in which CBN particles like those of EXAMPLE I
were tungsten-coated in accordance with the
EXAMPLE I procedure and then one batch of about
half of them was subjected to treatment to break
off the tungsten coating as brittle flakes which
were then gravity separated from the somewhat
lighter CBN material. Two cell assemblies were
prepared as described in EXAMPLE I, one of tungs-ten-
coa~ed CBN particles and the other of particles from
which substantially all the tungsten coating had
been removed.
On microscoplc examination (magnification=
1400x), it was observed that there was only a very
thin reaction ~one between the par~icles of tungsten-
RD~12,310
coated CBN and the infused silicon alloy, while in
the case of the other specimen (maynification-llOOx),
there was a rather wide reac-tion zone. These results
are shown, respectively, by Figs. 2 and 3.
EXAMPLE III
~ .
The effect of partial coa~iny of tunysten was
demonstrated in another experiment like those above
in which two compacts were macle, one with 8.6 weight
percent tungsten coating and the other with 2.7 weight
percent tungsten coating. Scanning electron micro-
scopic examination of the CBN particles used to
produce the latter compact showed somewhat less than
complete coating of the particle surfaces approxima-
ting 60 to 75 percent coverage thereof.
Again, microscopic examination of both
polycrystalline bodies (1400x) produced revealed
clean bonding interface conditions, that is, very
little reaction product in the CBN particle-silicon
alloy bonding medium interface zone. The 8.6
weight percent product is illustrated in Fig. 4
while the other is the subject of Fig. 5.
EXAMPLE IV
The effect of using particles of -tungsten in
admixture with the CBN particles instead of as
partial or complete coatings was t~sted in an experi-
ment carried out generally as described above. Thus,
two CBN particle batches ~ere prepared, one being
treated with 8.6 weight percent tungsten ~o provide
-12-
.9~ RD-li!,310
the particles with a more or less complete coating
in each instance, while in the other batch the CBN
particles were simply admixed with 8 weight percent
tungsten particles about 0.8 micron in size. The
compacts of these two batches prepared as described
above were on microscopic examination (900x) found
! to be altoyether different from each o~her. The
tungsten-coated CBN particle compact was observed
to be well bonded as evidenced by a clean CBN-
bonding medium boundary. The other compact,
however, exhibited a poor CBN-bonding medium
boundary condition fouled with substantive amounts
of r~action product material.
EXAMPLE V
lS Another experiment like that of EXAMPLE I
was carried out with one gram of 230/270-mesh
tungsten-coated, cubic boron nitride prepared with
a tungsten coating as described in the aforesaid
'064 patent. A 660-milligram silicon-rhenium alloy
disc was placed in the bottom of the 0.562-inch
diameter zirconium cup as the preliminary step.
The cup was closed as described in EXAMPLE I
and thP entire cell assem~ly ~a~ éncapsulated in
hexagonal boron nitrid powder and cold pressed
to 90 kpsi. After transfer of the stabilized mass
~ o~ cell assembly and hexagonal boron nitride into
a graphite die, the mass was subjected to a
pressure/heating cycle as described in EXAMPLE I.
~13-
RD~12,310
On removal and sectioning, the polycrystalline
produc~ showed the CBN particles to be well
infiltrated and bonded in place.
EXAMPLE VI
A disc of silicon-30% rhenium weighiny 600
milligrams was placed in the bot~om of A zirconium
cup as described above. On top o~ the disc was
placed one gram of 325-400 mesh Type I, uncoated
CBN. The cup was then closed as also described
above and this cell assembly was encapsulated in
hexagonal boron nitride powder and cold pressed at
90 kpsi, and then subjected to the pressure/heating
cycle as described in EXAMPLE I. The completed
polycrystalline CBN body was cross-sectioned and
polished and upon ex~mination was found to have
been infiltrated by the molten alloy, but the CBN
particles had been quite severely damaged at the
interfaces with the metal.
EXAMPLE VII
A disc of silicon-22% titanium weighing
136 milligrams was placed in the bottom of a
O.350-inch diameter æirconium cup which was then
filled with 325-400 mesh Type I CBN in uncoated
condition. After closing the cup as described
above, encapsulating the body in hexagonal boron
nitride powder and cold pressing to 90 kpsi,
the stabilized mass was transferred to a graphite
die and subjected to the heating/pressure cycle
-14-
~ 5~ RD 12,310
described in EXA~PLE I. Again, a polished sec-tlon o~
the completed polycrystalline CBN body revealed severe
damage to the CBN particles.
