Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
3~
"PRODUCT RECOVERY METHOD FOR AN AROMATIC
HYDROCARBON ALKYLATION PROCESS"
FIELD OF THE INVENTION
The invention relates to the production and recovery of alkylaromatic
hydrocarbons by the reaction of an acyclic olefinic hydrocarbon with an
aromatic feed hydrocarbon. The invention is directly related to the separa-
tion method used to recover the product alkylaromatic hydrocarbons from
S the effluent of the alkylation reaction zone. This separation method em-ploys fractional distillation in three fractionation columns in series, with
the subiect invention being d;rectly related to the method in which these
are interconnected and to the method by which these columns are reboiled.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
The alkylation of aromatic hydrocarbons such as benzene usin~ s~lid
catalysts is a well-deYeloped art which is practiced comrnercially in large scale
industrial units. C)ne commercial application o~ this process is the alkylation of
benzene with propylene ~o Eorm cumene (isopropylbenzene), which is subsequently
used in the production of phenol and acetone. Those skilled in the art are therefore
familiar with the ~eneral design and operation o~ such alkylation processes.
The prior art is well described in the literature. For instance, a typical
flow scheme suitable for commercial use is depicted in U.S. Patent No. 4,051,191issued to D.~. Ward. This reference describes in some detail catalyst, reaction
conditions, and separatiol~ methods suitable for the recovery of cumene. ll-e
reactor effluent is passed into a recti~ication zone in which propane, charged to the
process in admixture with the feed pr~pylene, is separated ~or recycling and forrejection from the process. Liquid phase hydrocarbons recovered in the rectifi-
cation zone are then passed in~o a ~w~column fractionation train comprising ~
recycle column and a cumene or product column. The unreacted portion of benzene
feed aromatic hydrocarbon is recycled from the top of the first fractionation
column. The product cumene is recovered from the top of the second fractionationcolumn, with heavy aromatic by-products beirlg withdrawn from the bottom of the
second co 1 umn. A
_ 1 _ `~
~4S~
somewhat different product recovery fractionation train for commercial use is
described in the article at page 32 of the March 21, 1983 edition of Chemical
En~ineering magazine. This system employs four fractionation columns in series.
The first fractionation column is a depropanizer column. The third column is a
product column in which cumene is removed as the net overhead product. The net
bottoms stream oE the product column is passed into a recycle column with the
overhead stream of this column apparently being recycled to the reaction zone. The
alkylation process described in this article is based upon the use of an aluminum
chloride catalyst system as compared to the solid phosphoric acid-type catalyst
which is preferred in the previously cited reference.
It is known in the art of fractional distillation that the latent heat
present in the overhead vapors of one fractionation column may be employed in the
reboiler means of another fractionation column for the purpose of supplying heat to
the other fractionation column. This is shown for instance in U.5. Patent No.
3,254,024 issued to H.A. Huckins, Jr. et al. This reference is directed to the
separation of close boiling C8 aromatic hydrocarbons. The overhead vapor from a
xylene splitter column is therefore used from this reference to reboil an ethyl-benzene column. U.S. Patent No. 4,360,405 issued to U, Tsao is pertinent for itsshowing of a fractionation arrangement for use in the separation of close boiling
~ mixtures in which the overhead vapor of one column is compressed and passed into a
bottom portion of an immediately upstream fractionation column. The bottoms
liquid from this upstream column flows into the top of the downstream column. This
reference indicates this arrangement could be employed Eor the separation of close
boiling hydrocarbons exemplified by the xylenes.
BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
The invention provides an improved method for the separation of the
reactants and products of a process for the production of an alkylaromatic
hydrocarbon by alkylation. The improvement basically relates to increased energyefficiency and elimination of the production of low pressure steam, which has only a
small economic value in a typical petroleum refinery or petrochemical installation.
The subject invention is characterized by the use of a relatively high pressure
cumene or product column, with the overhead vapor of this column being employed
~52~
to reboil the immediately preceding recycle column. The inYention is also
characteri~ed by the passage of a cumene rich bottoms stream from the cumene
column to a relatively low pressure stripping column. The overhead vapor stream of
the stripping column is rich in cumene and is compressed back into the cumene
column. The subject invention is also an improvement in that the bottoms liquid
pump normally employed on the bottoms stream of the cumene column is no longer
required.
A broad embodiment of the invention may be characterized as a process
for the production of an alkylaromatic hydrocarbon which comprises contacting a
feed acyclic olefinic hydrocarbon and a feed aromatic hydrocarbon with an
alkylation catalyst in an alkylation reaction zone maintained at alkylation-
promoting conditions and producing a reaction zone effluent stream comprising the
feed aromatic hydrocarbon, a product alkylaromatic hydrocarbon and high-boiling
by-product hydrocarbons and subsequently recovering the product alkylaromatic
hydrocarbon by a method which comprises the steps of passing a process stream
comprising the feed aromatic hydrocarbon, the product alkylaromatic hydrocarbon
and the by-product hydrocarbons into a recycle fractionation column operated at
conditions which effect the separation of entering hydrocarbons into at least a net
overhead stream, which is rich in the feed aromatic hydrocarbon, and a first
bottoms stream, which comprises the product alkylaromatic hydrocarbon and the by-
product hydrocarbons; passing the first bottoms stream into a product fractionation
column operated at conditions effective to separ te entering hydrocarbons into afirst overhead vapor stream, which is rich in the product alkylaromatic hydrocarbon,
and a second bottoms stream, which is also rich in the product alkylaromatic
hydrocarbon and contains the by-product hydrocarbons; at least partially condensing
the first overhead vapor stream in a reboiler means supplying heat to a lower
portion of the recycle column, withdrawing a first portion of the resultant
condensate from the process as a net product stream and returning a second portion
of the condensate to the product column as reflux liquid; passing the second bottoms
stream into a stripping column operated at fractional distillation conditions, including a
pressure at least 15 psi (103 kPa) lower than maintained in the product fraction--
ation column, and effective to separate entering hydrocarbons into a second
overhead vapor stream comprising the product alkylaromatic hydrocarbon and a
third bottoms stream, which comprises the by-product hydrocarbons and is
substantially free of the product alkylaromatic hydrocarbon; and compressing the
--3--
~2~L523~
second overhead vapor stream and then passing the second overhead vapor stream
into the product fractionation column.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWING
The drawing illustrates a preferred embodiment of the invention wherein
product cumene is recovered from the overhead vapor of cumene column 22 by
condensation of the overhead vapor in the reboiler 20 of the recycle column, with
the cumene rich bottoms stream of the cumene column flowing through line 31 intothe low pressure stripper 32 The high~boiiing by-products leave through line 39
while the cumene is recycled by compression in means 35 to the cumene column.
DETAILED DESCRlPll~)N
The production of alkylaromatic hydrocarbons is an important industrial
process Although these hydrocarbons can be recovered from reaction products suchas reformates or from natural occurring petroleum, the most commercially feasible
route to the production oE alkylaromatics appears to be the direct alkylation of a
feed aromatic hydrocarbon with a feed acyclic olefinic hydrocarbon. A wide variety
of alkylaromatic product hydrocarbons can be produced because of the various feed
hydrocarbons in both the aromatic and acyclic categories which can be supplied to
the alkylation zone. For instance, the feed aromatic hydrocarbon can be either
benzene or toluene. The acyclic olefin can range from ethylene as in the production
of ethyl benzene to a mixture OI C10 to C15 acyclic olefins used in the alkylation
processes designed to produce linear alkyl benzenes (LAB) destined for use as
precursors in the production of detergents. The subject description will be basically
couched in terms of the alkylation of benzene with propylene as this is the preferred
embodiment of the invention. However, it is not thereby intended to preclude from
the scope of the invention those other alkylation processes and hydrocarbon
mixtures to which the subiect invention is applicable.
In the traditional prior art fractionation method of recovering the
product alkylarornatic hydrocarbon, the overhead streams of the fractionation
columns has ~een condensed in water cooled heat exchangers resulting in the
production of relatively low pressure steam. This is shown ~or instance in the
~sz~
previously cited article which illustrates the production of steam in the overhead
system of all four fractionation columns. While this low pressure steam does
contain a considerable amount of latent heat, it is typically at such a low
temperature that the steam cannot be widely applied in the typical refinery. Thelow pressure steam generated in this manner therefore has little or no economic
value. This results in all or mos~ of the heat which is discharged in the overhead
system of the column being unrecovered and being a net charge against the utility
cost of operating the process. lt is an objective of the subject invention to provide
an improYed ~ractional distillation type separa~ion method for use in recovering the
product o~ alkylation reaction zones. It is a specific objectiYe of the subject
invention to reduce the utility costs of operating the fractionation system used to
recover a product alkylaromatic hydrocarbon made in an alkylation ~one. It is
another objective of the subject invention to minimize the capital cost of a lowutility cost fractionation system.
i 5 In the subject invention, the product alkylaromatic hydrocarbon is
recovered as the net ovèrhead products of a relatively high pressure, as compared to
the prior art, product column. The product column is the intermediate column of a
three column fractionation train employed in the subject invention. The relatively
high pressure maintained in the product column results in the overhead vapor of this
column being sufficiently hot to reboil the preceding recycle column. The preceding
column is referred to as the recycle column in reference to its traditional function
of providing a relatively high-purity stream of unconverted feed aromatic hydro-carbon for recycling back to the reaction zone. The overhead product of the
product column may therefore be of relatively high purity as the lighter hydro-
carbons are removed upstream. For instance, it would normally contain greater
than 99 mole percent cumene when cumene is being produced in the product. In thesubject invention, the net bottoms stream removed from the product column will
also be rich in the product alkylaromatic hydrocarbon and may have a concentration
of the product hydrocarbon greater than 95 mole percent. The other components ofthe bottoms stream of the product column will comprise the high boiling by-products
produced in the alkylation zone. These by-products are normally undesirable in the
product alkylaroma~ic hydrocarbon, and ~hey are therefore pre~erably withdrawn
~rom the process as a separate stream. The by-products are produced by undesiredoligomerization and alkylation reactions. For instance, in the production of cumene
the high-boiling by-products would comprise propylene oligmers and diisopropyl-
benzene and possibly triis3propylbenzene.
It is normally desirable to minimize the temperature of that portion of
the fractionation equipment in which these high boiling by-products are separated
into the by-product stream which is removed from the process. There~ore, the
desire to increase the overhea~ temperature of the product cclumn is in conflictwith the desire to minimize the temperature at the bottom of the product column
when the high boiling by-products are withdrawn as a concentrated stream from the
bottom of the product column. This conflict could be resolved by operating the
product column at a relatively low pressure and employing a compressor to increase
the temperature of the overhead vapor stream prior to its bein~ used to reboil arecycle colurnn. This is in the fashion of a traditional heat pump sys~em. The
overhead vapor stream of the procluct column is, however, normally a rather highvolume vapor stream which would require a large and very expensive compressor and
~ignificant utilities for its operation.
In the subject process, the produc~ rich bottoms stream of the produc~
column is flashed into a relatively low pressure strippin~ column. This column is
operated at a lower pressure than the product column. It is preferably operated at a
pressure which is below about 25 ps;g (172 kPag). it is preferred that the pro-
duct column is operated at a pressure at least 15 psi (103 kPa), andmore preferably
20 psi (138 kPa), greater than ~he pressure maintained in the stripping column.
The temperatures required at the bottom of the stripping column
are therefore lower than the temperature which would be required in the bottom of
the product column, which is operating at the increased pressure. The cumene rich
overhead stream of the stripping column is now compressed into the product column.
This overhead stream is much smaller than the overhead stream of the product
column. It therefore can be compressed with a much smaller compressor than wouldbe necessary to compress the overhead vapor stream o~ the product column. The
utilities cost of operating this compressor are also greatly lower. It is also
significant to point out that the pressure differential between the columns
eliminates ~he need for a pump to transport ~he bo~toms liquid of the product
column into the stripping column.
The application of the subject invention ~o ~he typical alkylation zone
may be discerned by reference to the drawing. In this representati~n of the
preferred embodiment, She feed stream of benzene from line 1 is admixed with a
propylene-propane feed stream from line 2. High-puri~y propylene could be charged
to the process but the normal source of propylene will often contain significant
23~
amounts of propane. The propane passes through the process as an inert compound and
does not interfere with the reaction. With the presently preferred solid phosphoric
acid (SPA) catalyst system, the presence of propane in the reaction zone is in fact
desired and it is therefore partially recycled into the reaction zone from the downstream
depropanizing zone. Recycle benzene and propane carried by line 17 are admixed
with the feed hydrocarbons and the resultant hydrocarbon admixture is passed
through line 3 into the reaction zone 4. The reactants are therein contacted wi~h a
suitable alkylation catalyst maintained at alkyla~ion-promoting conditions. Thise~ects the production of a reaction zone effluent stream carried by line 5 whichcomprises an admixture of unreacted benzene, propane, the product cumene and thehigh boiling by-product hydrocarbons formed in the reaction zone. The reactor
effluent also contains hexenes and nonenes. The reaction zone effluent stream ispassed into a depropanizing zone 6. The exact form of the depropanizing zone tends
to vary between competing processes and differen~ commercial installations. ThislS zone can comprise a single depropanizing column or two rectified flash zones as
shown in the prior art. This zone is preferably arranged to produce a net effluent
stream of relatively high-purity propane wi~hdrawn through line 7 to balance the ne$
charge rate of propane to the process and a recycle stream transported through line
8 which will contain propane and possibly benzene. A normally liquid phase process
stream is removed from the depropanizing zone in line 9 for passage into the
fractionation train employed in the subject invention. This process stream will
comprise benzene, cumene, and the by-product high-boiling or heavy hydrocarbons.This process stream is passed via line 9 into an intermediate point of the recycle
column l O. The recycle column is operated at conditions which effect the
separation of the entering hydrocarbons into an overhead vapor stream removed
through line ll and the bottoms stream removed in line 18. The overhead vapor
stream should be essentially free of cumene and any heavier boiling hydrocarbonswhich enter the column. The overhead vapor stream passes through the overhead
condenser 12 and then flows into the overhead receiver 13. The liquid phase
benzene which thereby accumulates in the receiver is withdrawn through line 14 and
divided into the recycle stream carried by line 16 and the reflux stream re~urned to
the recycle column via line 15. Not shown on ~he drawing are the customary
effluent streams associated with the upper portion of the recycle solumn. These
two streams comprise a vapor off gas line for the overhead receiver and a drag
benzene line which may be removed from the recycle column or from the overhead
--7--
~29~523~
receiver liquid.
The net bo~toms liquid from the recycle column carried by line 21
comprises the product cumene and the by-product heavy hydrocarbons. It should beessentially free of propane and benzene. The ne$ bottoms stream is passed into the
cumene column 22 and is therein separated into a bottoms stream removed in line 28
and an overhead vapor stream removed through line 23. In accordance with the
subject invention, the overhead vapor stream passes through the reboiler means 20
of the recycle column thereby supplying heat to the bottom of the recycle column.
This results in at least a partial condensation and preferably a total condensation of
the overhead vapor stream and the production of a condensate which is passed into
the overhead receiver 24. This condensate liquid is high-purity cumene which is
withdrawn through line 25 and divided into ~he reflux stream, returned to the
cumene column throu~h line 27 and the net product s~ream of the process which isremoved through line 26. The heat given up by the overhead vapor stream in the
reboiler vaporizes at least a portion of the bottom liquid circulating through line l9
to thereby provide vapors which pass into ~he bottom of the recycle column and
effect the reboiling of the column.
The cumene column 22 is reboiled by means of h~at supplied to the
bottoms liquid circulating through line 29 and partially vaporized in reboiler means
30. The net bottoms stream removed from the cumene column in line 31 is passed
through pressure reducing valve 40 into an upper portion of the stripping column 32.
This column is operated at fractionation conditions which are effective to separate
the entering hydrocarbons into the overhead vapor stream withdrawn through line 33
and the bottoms liquid withdrawn through line 36. The bottoms liquid of line 36
should be rich in the heavy hydrocarbon by-products of the alkylation reaction. A
portion of the bottoms liquid is circulated through line 37 and the reboiler means 3
which receives heat from an external source such as high pressure steam or hot oil.
The high boiling by-products for the alkylation reaction are therefore concentrated
into a relatively small net bottoms stream discharged from the process through line
39. The overhead vapor stream of line 33 has a high concentration (greater than 90
mole percent) of cumene. The overhead vapor stream is preferably heated in the
heating means 34 and is then compressed in means 35. The cumene rich overhead
vapor stream then continues through line 33 and is pref erably passed into the
cumene column at a lower point near or below the lowest most tray within this
column. The overhead vapor stream could, however, be passed into the column at
-
~Z~5:~34
higher points if 50 desired.
The subject invention is practiced wi~h a reaction zone containing a solid
catalyst. Preferably, the catalyst is one commonly referred to as an SPA catalyst.
Suitable SPA catalysts are available commercially. As used herein the term "SPA
catalyst" or its equivalent is intended to refer generically to a solid catalyst which
contains as one of its principal raw ingredients an acid of phosphorus such as ortho-,
pyro- or tetra-phosphoric acid. These catalysts are normally formed by mixing the
acid with a siliceous solid carrier to form a wet paste. This paste may be calcined
and then crushed to yield catalyst particles, or the paste may be extruded or
pelleted prior to calcining to produce more uniform catalyst particles. The carrier
is preferably a naturally occurring porous silica-containing material such as
kieselguhr, kaolin, infusorial earth and diatomaceous earth. A minor amount of
various additives such as mineral talc, fullers earth and iron compounds including
iron oxide have been added to the carrier to increase its strength and hardness. The
combination of the carrier and the additives normally comprises about 15-30 wt. %
of the catalyst, with the remainder being the phosphoric acid. However, the amount
of phosphoric acid used in the manufacture of the catalyst may vary from about 8-
80 wt. % of the catalyst as described in U.S. Patent No. 3,402,130. The amount of
the additive may be equal to about 3-20 wt. % of the total carrier material. Further
details as to the composition and production of typical SPA catalysts may be
obtained from U.S. Patent Nos. 3,050,~72; 3,050,473and3,132,109 and from other
references.
The subject inventlon is not restricted to use with a SPA type catalyst.
For instance the previously cited article describes the use of AIC13 catalysts and
indicates this is a commonly used catalyst in the production of ethyl benzene. In
addition, the patent literature describes a vast array of zeolite alkylation catalysts
and processes for their use. It is therefore contemplated to practice the subject
invention using a catalyst comprising an amorphous or a crystalline alumino silicate
such as a "ZSM-5" zeolite. Due to the nature of the aluminosilicates they are
normally not used in the pure form but are composited into a porous support matrix
in combination with an alumina or silica or clay. The alkylation reactions with these
materials have been described as being both vapor-phase and liquid-phase processes.
The reaction conditions for use with differing catalysts, which are set out in the
references, will Yary from the preferred conditions set out herein for use in
conjunction with SPA-type catalysts. Further information on zeolitic alkylation
_g_
~S%3~
catalysts may be obtained from a number of sources including U.S. Patents No.
3,755,483; 4,300,011; 4,469,90~ and 4,489,214.
The reaction zone is maintained at alkylation-promoting conditions. As
previously stated the conditions must be adjusted to compensate for the specificcatalyst being employed and the reactants being charged to the process. In the case
of an SPA type catalyst these condltions include a pressure of about 300 to 1000 psig
(2069 tD 6895 kPag) and a temperature of about 300 to 600F (149 tD 316~). Theliquid hourly space velocity o~ reactants may range ~rom about 0.5 to 2.5 m 1. It
is preferred that an excess of the aromatic hydrocarbon be present in the reaction zone.
The mole ratio of the ~romatic hydrocarbon to the olefin should be within ~he broad
range of 3:1 to 20:1. A ra~io of about 8:1 is preferred for the production of cumene.
It is preferred that the reactant stream be mixed-phase through the reactor. The feed
stream therefore preferably contains some unreactive light paraffins having the same
number of carbon atoms per molecule as the ole~in. In the production of cumene it is
preferred that the amount of propane in the reaction zone feed stream be at least equal
to the amou~t of propylene in this stream. This may be accomplished by using a dilute
propylene feed stream or by recycling propane. The previously cited article indicates
representative conditions for the use of an Al C13 catalyst system include a tempera-
ture below 275F (135~C) and a pressure of less than 50 psig (345 kPag).
The preferred embndiment of the invention may accordingly be described
as a process for the production of an alkylaromatic hydrocarbon which comprises
contacting a feed acyclic olefinic hydrocarbon and a feed aromatic hydrocarbon
with a solid alkylation catalyst in an alkylation reaction zone maintained at
alkylation-promoting conditions and producing a reaction zone effluent stream
comprising the feed aromatic hydrocarbon, a monoalkylaromatic product hydro-
carbon and highboiling by-product hydrocarbons and subsequently recovering the
product alkylaromatic hydrocarbon by a method which comprises the steps of
passing a process stream comprising the feed aromatic hydrocarbon, the mono-
alkylaroma~ic product hydrocarbon and the by-product hydrocarbons into a recyclefractionation column operated at conditions which effect the separation of entering
hydrocarbons into at least a net overhead stream, which is rich in the feed aromatic
hydrocarbon, and a first bottoms stream, which comprises the product hydrocarbonand the by-product hydrocarbons; passing the first bottoms stream into a product~ractionation column operated at conditions effective to separate entering hydro-
carbons into a first overhead vapor stream, which is rich in the product hydrocarbon
-10-
~Z~523~
and slJbstantially free of the by-product hydrocarbons, and a second bottoms stream,
which is rich in the product hydrocarbon and also comprises the by-product
hydrocarbons; at least partially condensing the first overhead vapor stream in ar~boiler means supplyin~ heat to the bot~om portion of the recycle column,
wi~hdrawing a ~irst portion of the resultant condensate from the process as a net
product str~am and returning a second portion of the condensate to the product
column as reflux liquid; passing the second bottoms stream into a stripping column
operated at ~ractiona~ distillation conditions, including a pressure which is at least
15 psi (103 kPa) and more preferably 20 psi (138 kPa) lower than is maintained
in the product fractionation column, effective to separate entering hydrocarbons into a second overhead vapor stream comprising the product alkylaromatic hydrocarbon
and a third bottoms stream, which comprises the by-product hydrocarbons and is
substantially free ofthe product hydrocarbon; and compressing the second oYerhead
vapor stream and then passing the second overhead vapor stream into a bottom
portion ofthe product fraction column. As used herein the term substantially
free is intended to indicate a molar concentration of the indicated substance
less than about 2 and preferably less than 1 percent. The term "rich" is in-
tended to indicate a concentration of the specified compound or class of com-
pounds exceeding about 75 mole percent.
