Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
~~~~.~
_1_
Description
Means and Method for Measuring,_Inductance
Technical Field
This invention relates to the measurement of.
inductance generally and, more particularly, to an
electronically calibratable proximity, or inductive)
switch having a high degree of sensitivity while at
the same time being econornically manufactured and
suitable for use in harsh environments.
Background Art
While the present invention has numerous
applications) it is especially well suited fox use on
mobile equipment such as fork lift trucks,
manufactured, for example, by Yale Materials Handling
Corporation) that may be used in industrial and other
environments where the switches may be subjected to
mechanical abuse, low and high temperatures, and dixty
and abrasive atmospheres.
Typically, such trucks employ a number of
mechanical "microswitches" which are activated by 'the
movement of a mechanical part on the truck against a
movable a:rm on 'the microswitch. The movement of the
arm, in turn, effects the closing (or opening) of
electrical contacts within the sw itch, thus providing
an indicator signal that the switch has been closed ar
opened or a control signal as an input to some other
device.
Some points of use for microswitches in fork
lift trucks are those in connection with the hydraulic
control system, platform switches, and brake
~~~~~~3
-2-
switches. These microswitches have been found to be
troublesome, due to the tolerances in the linkage
which activates the switch, the mounting configuration
of the switch, the fastening of the wires to the
switch, the fact that the switch has contacting and
moving parts, and the mechanical tolerances of the
inner workings of the switch itself. Further, because
a mechanical switch is an easily understood and
relatively easily replaced device, it is susceptible
to being blamed for most failures, which delays the
eventual repair or replacement of the truly defective
part.
Proximity switches are known which comprise LRC
resonant circuits. When there is no metal near the
inductor of the circuit, the circuit gives a high
output. When metal comes within a selected distance
o:E the inductor, the metal and the inductor become
inductively coupled, the circuit is detuned, and the
output of the circuit drops. Another type of known
proximity switch is the magnetic switch, such as the
reed switch, which is open or closed depending upon
its proximity to a magnet. White these known devices
are satisfactory in many applications they have a
number of disadvantages. The reed switches are
generally unsatisfactory in harsh environments, as
sharp movements or vibrations can open or close the
switches. Resonant circuits require tuning of a
capacitance and an inductor and, when a given such
switch is installed in a particular piece of
equipment, metals other than the actuator may affect
performance. Resonant circuits are also prone to
electrical noise problems and are sensitive to
variations in frequency and voltage. Both types
require fairly careful mechanical adjustment and
-3-
neither can provide multilevel position sensing. Both
are relatively expensive and neither can be
electronically recalibrated once installed.
Accordingly, it is a principal object of the
present invention to provide an inductive switch which
is electronically calibratable after installation.
Another object of the invention is to 'provide an
inductive switch which is rugged and may be used in
harsh environments with wide temperature variations.
An additional object of the invention is to
provide an inductive switch which is highly accurate,
yet is economical to manufacture, is easily installed,
and requires little maintenance.
It is another object of the present invention to
provide an inductive switch such that when a plurality
of switches are used in an application, the condition
of a11 such switches may be determined sequentially
and rapidly by a single electronic circuit.
It is a further object of the present ~.nvention
to provide an inductive switch that may be readily
mounted in place of a microswitch.
Other objects of the invention, as well as
particular features and advantages thereof, will, in
part, be apparent and will, in part, be obvious from
the following description and the accompanying drawing
figures.
Disclosure of the Invention
The present invention accomplishes the above
objects, among others, by providing an inductor having
an actuator rod movable in proximity thereto to affect
the inductance thereof. An electrical pulse of
relatively short duration is applied to the inductor
and the current from the inductor is measured at a
~~~ ~.~:~
-4-
selected time interval after the -initiation of the
pulse. When a selected value of the current is
reached, the switch is triggered. A plurality of
inductors may be sequentially interrogated by one
electronic circuit, thus :.requiring low power and
affording smooth operation. Calibration of the
trigger point is accomplished electronically after
mechanical installation, thus inherently compensating
for mechanical tolerances and proximity effects.
Brief Description of the Drawings
Figures lA and 1B comprise an electrical
schematic diagram of an inductive switch system
constructed according to the present invention.
Figure 1C illustrates the arrangement of the
sheets containing Figures lA and 1B rahen joined.
Figure 2 is a cross-sectional view of an
inductive element for use in the system of Figure 1.
Figure 3 is a partial rear elevation view of a
fork lift truck employing the present invention.
Figures 4 and 5 are partial side elevation views
of a fork lift truck employing the present invention.
Figures 6 and 7 are partial rear elevation views
of a fork lift truck employing the present invention.
Figure 8 is an electrical schematic diagram of a
portion of that of Figure lA according to an
alternative embodiment of the present invention.
Best Mode for Carrying Out the InventionA
Referring now to the Drawing, Figure 1
illustrates an inductive switch system according to
the present invention, generally indicated by the
reference numeral 10, which includes inductors 12, 13,
14, and 15, an example of which inductors is inductor
~~~1.2~
-5-
12 shown in cross-section on Figure 2. Associated
with each of inductors 12, 13, and 15 are,
respectively, position detection circuits 18, 19, and
22. Associated with inductor 14 are position
detection circuits 20 and 21, the function of these
two position detection circuits being described in
detail later.
The construction and operation of an inductor
and its associated position detection circuit will be
described with reference to inductor 12 and position
detection circuit 18 only, as it can be seen that the
other inductors and position detection circuits are
constructed identically to the former with the
exception of inductor 14 which has two associated
position detection circuits.
Inductor 12 is connected as shown to receive, at
first end 26, an electrical pulse from a divide-by-ten
ring counter 28 which receives as an input a 7.68 KHz.
clock. A unity-gain operational amplifier 30 is
connected between divide-by-ten ring counter 28 and
inductor 12 and acts as a buffer to provide
isolation. Second end 32 of inductor 12 is connected
to position detection circuit 18 to provide an input
to camparator 34 and is also connected to ground
through a sense resistor 35. The reference voltage to
comparator 34 is determined by a potentiometer 36 and
its associated resistor network. The output of
comparator 34 provides data input to data flip-flop
38. Data flip-flop 38 is connected to be stroked by
divide-by-ten ring counter 28 and to provide an output
on a lead 40, which output may be connected to other,
conventional circuitry for indication or control
functions. Data flip-flop 38 also provides an
inverted output to the reference side of comparator 34
~~6~~~.~~3
-6-
through feedback resistor 42. An LBD 44 may be
provided at the inverted output of data flip-flop 38
to indicate the position of the switch.
Referring now to Figure 2, inductor 12 includes
a channel-shaped bobbin 50 on which is wound a coil
52. Formed in bobbin 50, centrally of inductor 12, is
a bore 54. Bobbin 50 is disposed such that bore 54 is
axially aligned with actuator rod 56 which is movable
from the position shown in solid lines to the position
shown in dashed lines where it extends partially :into
a portion of the bore around which coil 52 is wound.
Actuator rod 56 also may extend through inductor 12 so
that it protrudes (not shown) from the side of bobbin
50 opposite the side where it entered. Inductor 12
may also include a concentrator 58 adjacent a wall of
bobbin 50. Actuator rod 56 may be assumed to be
operatively connected, for example, to a moving part
of a machine (not shown), where it is desired that a
selected position of said part will cause a change in
the output signal on lead 40 (Figure 1).
For purposes of the discussion herein, and in
accordance with standard practice when dealing with
equipment such as fork lift trucks, the "iron in"
condition, that is, when actuator rod 56 (Figure 2) is
inserted into inductor 12 to, or past, its "trigger
point", is the inactive, or "off", condition.
Conversely, the "iron out" condition, that is, when
actuator rod 56 is withdrawn from inductor 12 away
from the trigger point, is the active, or "on"
condition. This is the preferable arrangement, since
it is inherently fail safe, as a broken wire in the
system circuitry or a short circuit in the driver
circuitry appears to the position detection circuit as
infinite inductance. Consequently, the operation
~~~ i~."~'q~
being controlled by the switch wi:L1 remain :Ln :its off
position when such failure occurs.
For a description of the operation of the
invention, it w:Ll1 be assurned that actuatox rod 56 is
in its solid-line, or iron out, position shown on
Figure 2 or otherwise does not extend into inductor 12
to its trigger point, but is moving toward its dashed-
line, or iron in, position which will be assumed to be
at or past the trigger point. Divide-by-ten ring
counter 28 provides a relatively short first step
pulse of current at a potential of about 5 volts to
inductor 12 through operational amplifier 30. The
inductance of inductor 12 is 'then at a relatively low ;
level thus allowing a relatively high flow of current
through the inductor and presenting a relatively high
voltage input to comparator 34, which voltage is the
voltage across sense resistor 35. Since this voltage
will be above the reference voltage to comparator 34
of on the order of 2.5 volts plus or minus a voltage
increment introduced by feedback resistor 42, the
output of the comparator, and, thexefore, the data
input to data flip-flop 38 will be high, which, when
the data flip-flop is subsequently strobed by divide-
by-ten ring counter 28, provides a high output on lead
40 and a low output to feedback resistor 42. The
latter output allows LED 44 to energize. At a
selected interval of time after the initiation of the
first step pulse, preferably at the end of the first
pulse, a second step pulse is generated which is
applied to inductor 13 and, simultaneously, the second
step pulse strobes data flip-flop 38 which, there
being na change in condition, initiates no change in
the state of the data flip-flop which outputs a high
~~~~~.~3
_g_
signal on lead 40 and a low signal to feedback
resistor 42.
This sequence continues, with a third generated
pulse being applied to inductor 14 and simultaneously
strobing the data flip-flop in position detection
circuit 19, etc. 'Phus, pu:Lses are sequentially
applied to each inductor in switch 10, with each pulse
simultaneously strobing the data flip-flop associated
with the inductor to which the preceding pulse was
applied.
The interrogation pulses are preferably applied
at the end of the current build up pulses, but the
interrogation pulses may be applied somewhat before or
somewhat after the end of the current build up
pulses. The sequential energization and strobing
provides for a low and even demand on the power supply
and allows for smoother operation of the system,
although there is no requirement in practicing the
present invention that a succeeding pulse be used to
interrogate a data flip-flop or that the sequential
steps described for illustrative purposes be employed.
Assume, now, that inductor 12 has received a
number of pulses without change in the output of data
flip-flop 38; but, that before that inductor receives
its next pulse, actuator rod 56 has reached the
trigger point, or "iron in" condition in the
inductor. l3ow, with this pulse, the inductance in
coil 52 will be relatively high, the current from the
coil will be relatively low as will the level of
voltage input to comparator 34 which will give a low
input to data flip-flop 38. Then, when data flip-flop
is strobed by the next succeeding pulse to inductor
13, the state of the flip-flop will switch and a low
signal will appear on lead 40 and a high level will be
~~~~~~~
-9-
applied to feedback resistor 42 and LED 44, thus
extinguishing the L>;D. Feedback resistor 42 adds a
slight increment to the reference voltage to
comparator 34, thus introducing a small amount of
hysteresis into the circuit to prevent electronic
chattering or oscillation.
As actuator rod 56 is withdrawn from bore 54,
the trigger point will again be reached, comparator 34
will have a high output, and, when data flip-flop 38
is subsequently strobed, its outputs will return to
their original values, LED 44 will energize, and
feedback resistor 42 will subtract a small increment
from the reference voltage.
As noted above, inductor 14 has two associated
position detection circuits 20 and 21 connected in
parallel with 'the output of the inductor. This
arrangement illustrates one particular advantage of
the present invention - that of being able to provide
two trigger points with a single actuator. This is
accomplished by adjusting the potentiometers in
position detection circuits 20 and 21 so that each
will respond to a different degree of insertion of an
actuator rod into inductor 14, thus allowing two
control functions with the same inductor element. In
order to give greater differentiation between the two
trigger points, one can give the actuator rod a
variable shape longitudinally, such as by having a
step in the diameter of the rad. It may also be
advantageous in some applications to use a rod having
sections of both ferromagnetic and paramagnetic
materials such as soft iron and aluminum. Of course,
the number of trigger points with a single inductor is
not limited to two. It is also not necessary that the
actuator rod have a round cross-section, but it is
~(~~~:~.~~
-lo-
preferable that the rod have the same cross-sectional
shape as the bore of the inductor. An important
feature of the present invention is that the
selection, or not, of muli:iple trigger points may be
accomplished electronically after the inductor has
been installed and requires no mechanical adjustments.
Zn some retro:Eit applications, the use of a
compound actuator rod may be especially advantageous.
One such application is where an existing
ferromagnetic element which one desires to use as an
actuator rod is attached to other elements at each
end. There:Eore, when an inductor is placed around the
actuator rod, an "iron out" condition cannot be
achieved and the inductor will have relatively
constant high inductance regardless o:E the position of
the rod. Here, the solution is to place a thin copper
sleeve over a portion of the rod to shield that
portion from the inductor. The copper sleeve i.s so
positioned that, when that portion of the rod on which
the sleeve is mounted is inserted into the inductor)
the inductance will be low and an "iron out" condition
will be achieved and, when that portion of the rod on
which the sleeve is mounted is withdrawn from the
inductor, the inductance will be high and an "iron in"
condition will be achieved. Although the copper
sleeve does not shield the rod to the extent that the
inductor "sees" per:Eect air, the difference is enough
that satisfactory performance may be realized. The
copper sleeve is preferably adhesively attached to the
rod.
A particular advantage of the switch of the
present invention is that there are no components that
require tuning, such as with LRC circuits, and the
switch can be electronically calibrated after
~~~~1~~
-11-
installation :in the field. For example, within
reasonable limits, the inductor element may be
installed in a piece of machinery without regard to
exact tolerances or special concern for the proximity
of :Ferromagnetic materials unrelated to the switch.
Then, whatever (usually a rod) the motion of which is
to actuate the switch is moved to the desired trigger
point and the potentiometer in the position detection
circuit is adjusted to give the exact "trigger
1p point". Such means of ca:Libration compensates for
inaccuracies in the physical mounting of the inductor
element and its associated actuator rod as well as any
lash of the rod, metal parts in proximity to the
inductor element, and even variations in the
construction of the inductor element itself.
For the inductive switch system described) a
pulse interval of on the order of about 130
microseconds has been found to be satisfactory,
although pulse intervals may range from about 10
microseconds to about 1 millisecond. Because of the
shortness o.f the pulse, a large number of switches can
be 'interrogated sequentially. The lower end of the
range of pulse lengths is limited by what practical
electronics can handle, while the upper end of the
range becomes limited by the higher inductances
required. The width of the interrogation pulse can he
conveniently selected to be the same time intervll as
the energizing pulse, although it may also be selected
to be less. When selecting component values and
impulse times, it must be kept in mind that the
inductor should preferably discharge to a zero level,
or essentially a zero level, before the succeeding
pulse is applied. It is also desirable 'that the
inductance-versus-actuator rod position curve be
'~~,.'f)Cl ~1,~~
-12-
fairly linear and steep i.n the area of the trigger
point. Use of an inductor as a constant current
generator provides smoothing and keeps the system
noise free.
I'or the values of the components shown on Figure
1, an inductor coil having about 4680 turns of #39 AWG
copper wire (approximately 8760 inches) wound with an
inner diameter of about 0.385 inch and a length of
about 0.360 inch gives satisfactory performance. Such
a coil exhibits an inductance of about 218 milliHenrys
and a resistance of about 622 Ohms at 25 degrees
Centigrade. It has been found that the inductive
switch system described is accurate and repeatable to
at least a few thousandths of an inch and is
inherently temperature independent over a fairly large
range; however, if some application exhibit an
intolerable position-versus-inductance temperature
coefficient, temperature compensation may be provided
within the coil structure or within the electronic
circuitry by means known in the art.
It has been found that the use of a concentrator
extends the length of the transfer function of the
inductor without requiring the use of a longer coil.
~A similar lengthening may be obtained by using
multiple stacked coils and/or permitting the actuator
rod to extend through the bore of the inductor. This
lengthening effect can be of particular value when,
for example, the inductor of 'the present invention is
being substituted for, say, a microswitch in an
existing application.
The material. of the actuator rod of an inductor
is preferably soft iron and the concentrator is
preferably formed from cold-rolled steel, although the
system is quite tolerant of alloy variations. For a
~~~ i~.~~
-13-
cail having on the order of the above dimensions, the
concentrator should be at least on the order of 0.06-
inch thick and extend to the outer perimeter of the
coil of the inductor. The concentrator element rnay
also be a bracket on which the inductor is mounted.
It has been found that when the perimeter of the
concentrator extends to the outer perimeter of the
coil, it has essentially the same effect as a steel
plate of infinito area. Thus, standardizing the
material immediately adjacent the inductor by having
the outer dimensions of the concentrator at least
coextensive with the coil reduces proximity effects by
making them uniform and thereby enhances ease of
installation because the user will obtain uniform
performance regardless of whether the inductor is
mounted on metal of a greater or lesser area.
The bobbin may be constructed of any suitable
dielectric material and glass-filled nylon has been
found to be especially satisfactory,
It can be seen that a11 components of the
inductive switch system are conventional and, in
effect, the invention uses imprecise parts to make a
very precise device. As noted above, the actuator rod
may be that already existing in a retrofit situation
and the inductor used may even be that formerly used
in an RLC switch, so that no mechanical changes at all
may be required - it only being necessary to connect
the electronics of the present invention. Since the
current from the inductor is being measured
resistively, there are no components in the system
which require tuning. The inductive switch system)
having but one moving part - the actuator rod - and na
exposed contacts is very rugged and environmentally
secure and, if necessary, the electronics can be
~C!(~~~.~~
_1t,_
located well avray from areas that might be detrimental
to them.
Figures 3-7 illustrate the application of the
present invention to various functions in a fork lift
truck, generally indicated by the reference numeral
62, In each case, it may be assumed that the inductor
has replaced a microswitch or other switching element
having the undesirable features discussed above.
Figures 3 and 4 show the platform lift/lower
switching mechanism, generally indicated by the
reference numeral 64, mechanically linked to a control
handle 66. Switching mechanism 64 includes actuator
rods 68 and 70, with the rods disposed so that
movement of control handle 66 will cause the rods to
move axially in and out of inductors 72 and 74)
respectively. Thus, if control handle 66 is raised,
actuator rod 68 will advance into inductor 72 and
actuator rod 70 will be withdrawn from inductor 74.
The withdrawal of actuator rod 70 out of inductor 74
and away from its trigger point, to its iron out
condition, causes the platform of the fork lift truck
to rise. Lowering of control handle 66 will reverse
the movement of actuator rods 68 and 70 and withdrawal
of actuator rod 68 from inductor 72 and away from its
trigger point, to its iron out condition, causes the
platform to lower.
Figures 5 and 6 show the mounting of brake
switch inductor 82 and its associated actuator rod
84. Actuator rod 84 is advanced or withdrawn from
inductor 82 by releasing or depressing brake pedal 86
which causes shaft 88 to rotate.
Figures 5 and 7 show the mounting of platform
switch inductor 94 and its associated actuator rod
96. Here, when treadle 97 of fork lift truck 62 is
-15-
depressed, bolt 98 will be driven downward,
compressing spring 100 and withdrawing actuator rod 96
to the trigger point of the platform switch.
Likewise, releasing tread7.e 97 causes actuator rod 96
to be advanced into inductor 94. Figure 7 also
indicates a significant advantage of the inductive
switch of the present invention, that of being able to
tolerate a large amount of overtravel, which most
mechanical switches cannot.
Figure 8 shows a portion of position detection
circuit 18 of Figure lA, generally indicated by the
reference numeral 18', with elements common to Figure
1A given primed reference numerals, together with its
associated inductor 12' and operational amplifier
30'. In addition to the common elements shown on
Figure lA, a resistor 110 is inserted in the feedback
loop of operational amplifier 30', a grounded
capacitor 112 is connected to the output of the
operational amplifier, and a capacitor is connected
around resistor 35'. The embodiment shown on Figure 8
is particularly advantageous when the input line to
operational amplifier 30' is relatively long and is
located in an environment where electromagnetically
coupled transient potentials may be developed. This
is especially true in the case of electrically driven
fork lift trucks where the chopper drive for the
electric motor may be switching currents of 200-300
amperes. With position detection circuit 18 on Figure
1, the transient may be high enough that, depending on
the devices specified, operational amplifier 30 may be
driven out of its common mode range and lock up.
In position detectiozr circuit 18', capacitor 112
prevents the output of operational amplifier 30' from
responding too quickly, while resistor 110 limits the
~~~)~~.~~
-16-
current that can be fed back. Likewise, capacitor 114
is prov:i.ded to help discharge any effects of the
transient which may pass to position detection circuit
18'. The values of resistor 110 and capacitors 112
and 114 are chosen so that these elements do not
interfere with normal operation.
The electronics (not shown) associated with the
inductors shown on Figures 3-8 may be located away
from the inductors and may be in a completely sealed
structure on fork lift truck 62, access normally being
required only fox purposes of ca:Libration. With the
electronics so protected, nothing in the switch system
is susceptible to failure due to exposure to dirt,
dust, or some degree of abuse. The inductive element
itself is easily replaced by mechanics of ordinary
skill.
Some considerations in the design of inductors
and the measurement of inductance are discussed in
"Inductance Calculations", by Frederick W. Grover)
1980, Published by the Instrument Society of America,
and "Absolute Measurements in Electricity and
Magnetism", by Andrew Gray, 1967, published by Dover
Publications, which books and the references cited
therein are made a part hereof by reference.
It will thus be seen that the objects set forth
above, among those made apparent from the preceding
description, are efficiently attained and, since
certain changes may be made in the above construction
without departing from the scope of the invention, it
is intended that all matter contained in the above
description or shown on the accompanying drawing
figures shall be interpreted as illustrative only and
not in a limiting sense.
~~~~~~~
-17-
It is also to be understood that the following
claims are intended to cover all of the generic and
specific features of the invention herein described
and all statements o:l: the scope of the invention
which, as a matter of language, might be said to fall
therebetween.
