Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
wo s~/27688 2 ~i 8 ~ 9 ~ 6
PROr~UCTION OF PENTAFLUORO~THANE.
This invention relates to a process for the production of p.,.,~a~iUUI~
According to the present invention there is provided a process for the production of
y~.lL~uu~u.,.ll~l~ which comprises contactiilg a lly ilunuulu~ u.u~ having the
S formula:
C,H,CI,,KF, y wherein x and y are each i-~-r~ , 0, 1, 2 or 3 proYided that x + y is 3,
with hydrogen fluoride in the vapour phase and in the presence of a ~1 catalyst
10 which compi ises zinc or a compûund of zinc and chromia, chroinium fluoride or chromium
oxyfluoride
We have found that use of this particular cataiyst for the n. ~ of the defined
~, .L, ' ' unUul U~LII~I.,3 provides for highly selective production of y~ iu
with minimai formation of cl~iul~ n UW~bU~7 in particular Ll,luluy.,.lL~I uu~
15 Preferred . . methods of yll,y~aLiùn, methods of l~ and forins of
the cataiyst are described in our published European Appiication
No 502, 605, the contents of wi~ich are hl;,OIyulaL~d herein by reference.
The i r ' t at which the process is efrected may be in the range from about 2û0 to
about 450C, preferably from about 3û0C to about 45ûC and especiaily from about 35ûC
20 to about 450C ~tm~rhprir~ or s,.~. , ' pressures mat be
employed, aithough to aid throughput of vapours thorough the equipment we prefer top
employ . . ' pressure, say a r ' ~ ~ ' pressure up to abûut 30barg,
and particuiariy a pressure on the range from about 5 barg to about 20barg.
The relative proportion of hydrogen fiuoride to starting compound of formuia
25C2~i~Cll~F~y wherein
x and y are each ;.,.~ ~.. i, - ~Iy 0, 1, 2 or 3 provided that x + y is 3 (hereafter referred to as
the starting compound), may vary witilin wide limits aithough we generaily prefer to employ
a -' molar excess of hydrogen fluoride. The moiar ratio of hydrogen fluoride to
starting compound will therefore usuaiiy be greater than about 2:1 and we prefer to employ
30 a molar ratio of hydrogen fluûride to starting compound in the range from about 2:1 to
about 20:1 and preferably in the range from about 5:1 to about 15;1, especiaily in the range
from about 5:1 to about 10: i.
-1-
-
WO gY27G~X ~ ~ 8 ~ 3 ~ ~. C 1 ,6(i
Preferably the feed to the process of the invention is ' ' "~, free of hydrogen
chloride. Thus, the process of the invention is preferably effected with a feed to the process
comprising less than 10 mole % hydrogen chloride, especiaily less than 5 mole % hydrogen
chloride.
5 The starting, , for the process of the present invention may be a single
compound of formula C2H~Ci~t~ +y for example ~I1U~UI~LI~2LL~1IV~
di~,lliul ullinuwu~ ., or Ll i~hlvl wlinuul u~,L~Ie although usually the star.+ing ~ ,v~
~11 comprise a ~ of two or more and even a ~ .. comprisirlg all of the
starting c~ ~ Inrl~ of formuia C2HlCll+~FI+y since the starting L~U~;iiUII for the process
10 of the present invention is ~u..~ v produced itself by the vapour phase catalytic
reaction of ~wwlu~u~ with hydrogen fluoride to form a c~ 1.u~ which usualiy
comprises amounts of mûst or even ail of the ~-y~,u~l iulu,~uulu~,Li~--w of formuia
C2H,CI,+,F~
According to a preferred ,.. t v. I' .. 1 of the invention there is provided a process for the
15 production of ~ n nuul, ~ which comprises (i) contacting i;~ ~ ~,hlulu.,lilJ~ lC with
hydrogen fiuoride in the vapour phase in the presence of a n catalyst whereby to
form a product stream comprising a h~ I u ~ . . .n. .. ~ u~Lh~.~i of formula C2H~Cll+"F~+r
~vherein % and y are each; ~ 0, 1, 2 or 3 provided that x + y is 3, and (ii)
contacting the product stteam from step (i) with hydrogen fluoride in the vapour phase and
20 in the presence of a n ' ' catalyst comprising zinc andlor nickel or a compound of
zinc and/or nickel and chromia, chron~ium fluoride or chromium u~nuoliLl~ whereby to
produce ~ liuu~ '
The l~ Lu-~; at which step (i) is effected may be in the range from about 1 50C to
about 35û'C, preferably from about 180~C to about 320C and especially from about 200C
25 to about 3û0C. A~ . ' or c~ .1.. . n 1 l ~1 h \ ;~, pressures mat be
employed, although to aid throughput of vapours through the equipment we prefer to
employ 9U~ ' h, pressure, say a ~u~ .sl ll . ;. . pressure up to about 30 barg,
and ~ icuLI~ a pressure in the range from about 5 barg to about 20barg.
The relative proportion of hydrogen fluoride to ~w ~lvl u~ ' may vary within wide
30 limits although we generally prefer to employ a r~ ' ' molar e%cess of hydrogen
fluoride. The molar ratic~ .cf hydrogen fiuoride to perchloroethylene will therefore usually be
Breater than about 3 :1, preferably Breater than 5 :1 and we prwfer to employ a molar ratio of
-2-
wo ssl~76ss 2 t ~4 9 ~ 766
hydrogen fluoride to Pt;~ 1UIV~ J~ in the range from about 5:1 to about 20:1 andpreferably in the range from about 7:1 to about 15:1, especially in the range from about 7:1
toabout 12:1.
The catalyst employed in steps (i) and (ii) may be the same or different so that the two
5 step process may be effected, if desired, in a single reaction vessel over a single catalyst bed
comprising zinc or a compound of zinc and chromia, chromium fluoride or chromiumUAy~UUli~ whereby to produce p~,lL~nuu-u~,LI~
However, in this preferred r~ V~ ' of the invention we have further found that
dif~erent catalysts are preferable for steps (i) and (ii) of the process. Thus, it is preferred to
10 employ a catalyst having a high activity (per pass conversion) for the conversiorl of
l~,. l,lJul u~,,h~ .., in step (i) of the process whilst it is important to employ a catalyst which
d~ lr~ a high selectivity for the production of P~ IIUUII '' from the
L~v~,llululluul~ ' in step (ii).
According to a second aspect of the invention there is provided a process for the
15 production of F A I '~ which comprises (i) contacting i~ l, ' ' u~ , with
hydrogerl fluoride in the vapour phase in the presence of a first n.. ;- ;~ . catalyst whereby
to form a product stream comprising a h~ilu~!~lulluul~ ' offormuia C2HICl,,~xF,~,,
wherein x and y are each ;.. ~ y 0, 1, 2 or 3 provided that x + y is 3, and (u)
contacting the product strea~n from step (i) with hydrogen fluoride m the vapour phase and
20in the presence of a second ~ cat~yst which is different from the first n . -
cataiyst whereby to produce r ' A ~ .~
Preferably a catalyst as defined for the process of the first aspect of the invention is
employed in step (ii) of the process since we have found this cataiyst to have a ' "~
higher selectivity for the production of ~ iUUI~ ' ' from the defined
25ll~u~,hlulu[luulu~ than arly other catalyst we have tried.
The cataiyst employed in step (i) of the process however may be any known ~ "
cataiyst which has a high activity for the conversion of ~ llulv~,~ll)!ull~, to
. ' ' vnuul~ ' for example catalysts based upon alumina or aluminium fluoride
and which may also comprise one or more metais, for example nicicei7 cobait, iron etc. We
30 1 ' ,y prefer to employ a chromia cataiyst in step (i) since this cataiyst has a
s~ ulLi '~ higher per pass conversion of p~,ll ' ' u.,Lh~h,.l~ to 11,~ .L u~lJu~unuu
-3-
wo ~n768# 2 ~ 8 4 9 ~3 I r~ l/ v~ r ~ 166
under com,arable con~itions that~i that of a catalyst compnsing zinc or a compound of zinc
and chromia.
The catalysts for step (i) and (ii) of the process may be present in different reaction zones
of the sarne reactor vessel or they may each ~ carried in a sep2irate reactor voesel. ~y a
5 ~Ireaction zone" there is meant a zone or reg~on contairiing a catalyst under certain
conditions of l~ y~.~Lul~ and pressure and by different reaction zones there is meant zones
or regions at differer~t temperatures.
As described previous1y, it is preferable that hydrogen chloride is ' "~ absent in
step (ii) of the process. Hydrogen chloride is produced as a substantial by-product from step
10 (i) of the process and according to a further aspect of the invention there is provided a
process for the production of pc.~l~lluulu~ , which comprises (i) contacting
p~ u.u~L~ nc wit~i hydrogen fluoride in the vapour phase in the presence of a
.1 cataiyst whereby to forin a product stream corciprising a
u-,ll~ unuu~u~ of formuta C2HiCl~F~, wherein x and y are cach ;~ ly O,
1~ 1, 2 or 3 pro~ided that x + y is 3, and hydrogen chioride, (A) separating hydrogen chloride
from the product strea~n from step (i~ and ('li) contacting the product strearn from step (A)
with hydrogen fluoride in the vapour piiiase in the presence of a n ' ' catalystwhereby to producti pwlLafluùl~ '
Removal of hydrogen chioride from tne product stream from step (i) in step (A) may be
20 w..~ , effected by distiiiirig the product stream from step (i~ and recovering a bottoms
product comprising hydrogen chloride and 8 tops stream comprisin~ tbe organic
r of the product stream from step (i) and hydrogen fluoride. Tbis product streammay then be fed to step (ii)
The process is preferably operated on a continuous basis in wbich make up
2~ u-u~,LI-~ & and hydrogen iiiuoride are fed to step (i) and additional hydrogen fluoride
may, if required be fed to step (ii).
The product stream frorn step (ii) may be purified so as to recover iiw~ ulu~
Any unreacted h~L~ ~ n u~ a offormula C2H,CI"xF~ may be rec~cled to step
(i) or step (ii) of the process.
30 In a further preferred &_ ': ' t, the product steam from step (ii) is passed over a
~ cataiyst beated to low t~ J"~ ui~,." for exatnple a ~I;u~ iuit in the range
from about 80C to about 200C in order to convert any ' impurities present to
21 ~3~98 l 66
wo sslt76ss r~ ,L . 7
saturated l.y~,u~ u.ulluul. ~ which may, as described above be recycled to step (i) or
(ii) ofthe process.
Fu~ uulc, any ~ u~u~ 4n~iulu~ 4~1c present in the peil~4nuùl~ ' recovered
from the process may be removed by contacting the i tt ~ j5~1l4~ 1U~ 4ii~ with
5 hydrogen in the vapour phase and in the presence ûf a ~ U~."14.;UII cata'iyst, for example a
' catalyst comprising pailadium supported on active carbon, as is desci-ibed in our published
T ' Application No. W094/02439.
In rl.ll.u~l ,.. .,l~ of lor aspects ofthe invention where the catalyst for step (i~ and the
cata'iyst for step (ii) are carried in separate reaction vessels, then the twû reaction vessels
10 (hereafter "reactors") may be arranged in parallel or in series.
In ~."I.u ~ in which the step (i) and step (ii) i-eactors are arranged in series, the
product stream from one of the step (i) ûr (ii) reactiûn vesseiis is passed to the other vessel
and the prûduct steam of this ûther reaction Yessel is fed to a 1,. " ;r ~ . system in which
step (A) is effected. Thus, the product stream from the step (i) reactor may be passed to the
15 step (ii) reactûr and the product steam from the step (ii) reactûr may be fed to a l ~
system in which step (A) is effected. A'~ , the product stream frûm the step (i)reactor may be passed to the puriirication system in which step (A) is eirfected and one or
more streams from the ~ . system comprising unreacted star~irig materiais and
of formuia C2~1Ciy+lFyl, may be passed to the step ~li) reactor. The product
20 stre~im from the step (ii) reactor may be passed to the step (i) reactor.
However, as aiready desci-ibed it is also preferable ti~iat hydrogen ci~ioride is ' ".~,
removed before step (ii) of the process. Hydrogen c~ioride is produced as a substantiai
by-product from step (i) of the process and we prefer therefore that the product strearn
from the step (i) reactor is fed to the purification system in wilich step (ii) is effected and the
25 product stream from the step (ii) reactor is passed to the step (i) reactor.
ln ~ i. ' in which the step (i) and step (ii) reaction vessels are arrarlged in
parallei, the product streams from the reactors are preferabiy fed to a common ~,...;~. -:;.~11
system in wbich step (A) is effected and from which i;.,lllalluull ' is recovered,
U~l~,U...~C~ ,LIu~u~,~h~l~,.lc is recycled to the step (i) reaction vessel and uul~,u..._.Lcd
30 ~, , ' of formula CzHCl~+IF~ are recycled to the step (ii) reactiûn vessel.
In step (A) the stream fed to the purification system in a series or parailel reactors
typically comprises c~ll",uun.l~ of formuia C2HCI~,,F9+" in particular
-5-
wo~s~276sx ~ "~a~ 766
u~ luoroethaneS and chlorot~lanuu~ u.u~ uùlu.,.l~.~ and
di~,lulu~cllanuulu., i~ll~J, ~.ll~uoluc~ll~.~, r,llv.u~ all..ulu.,.l~lL, unreacted hyrlro~en
fluoride and perchloroethylene, by-product hydrogen chloride and small amounts of other
by-products, for example~ I, I, I-trifluoro-2~1,1ù.u.,~ .c and 1,1,1,2 t~,..ul'.uu,,
5 This stream may be fed, for example, to a purificatiorl system which comprises a first
distillation column from which hydro~erl fluoride, d~llu~uLIilluulu~ HCFC 123/123a]
and other heavies are remQved as a bottom fraction whilst the remainder of the stream is
removed as a top fraction The bottom fraction from this f rst colurnn may be rcc~cled to
the reactor or to one or bûth of the reactors
10 The top frzction from the first coiumrl, after ar~ueous scrubbin~ rind drying if desired in
order to remove the acid cr, ~ r- r~, hydrogen chloride and hydrogen fiuoride, rr~ay be fed
to a second distillation colu.~nn from which ~,. ta~uul . ' - ~HFA 1251 is withdrawn
together with ~ Vl V~.lt~ilUVII ' ' [CFC 11 51 as a top fraction whilst the remainder of
the streanL comprising mainly ~,hlulu~c~laauolu ' [HCFC 124/124a~,
hlulullinuulu~ [HCFC 1331133a], lGLlalluul ' ~HFA 134/134a3 and
ni . 5,Flh 1. ~CFC 1141114a] is withdrawn as a bottom fraction The
p~ tonuulu~,.L.._ containing ~ withdrawn as a top fraction may be
further treatcd to effcct f~ r- ir.~iiVll of the r ' as doscribed k- . r . ~1~. ,~' " c.
The bottom fraction from the second column may be fed to a third &stillation column
from which Icllariuul~ ' [EIFA 134/134a] is withdrawn as a top fraction whilst the
rem2inder o~the strearn is withdrawn 2s a bottom fraction 2nd passed to a fo~rth distillation
columnfromwhich~ vlul~ u,u,lh [HCFC 1241124a]iswithdrawnasatop
fraction whilst L~lhlU~ULC~I~UVI~ ' ~CFC 1141114a] and ~ ul~iiluulu~ HCFC
133/133a] are withdrawn as a bottom fraction The ~,hlvlU.~,t~ [HCFC
124/124a] may be recycled to a reactor for P to ~ 1- ---- [HFA 12~]
The bottom fraction from the fourth column is usually disposod of, for instance by thermal
oxidation
The pllrifir~tinn system employed p}~ferably comprises a first distillation column in
whichunre2cted~1u.~ ..cand ._.l~l ~ ' offormulaC2EICl~,,Frt,in
30 which x is 1, 2 or 3, are separated (as a bottoms stream) from the other ,,. - - ~ (as a
tops stream) and recycled to the step ~i) re2ctor, and at least one further distillation column
bywhich~ ~uu.v.,~.~ isseparatedfromtheother.~ y 1~ofthe ~ sstreamand
v
W095127688 2 ! ~ 4 Y ~ /66
recovered and ~IJulu~ nuulu~ is separated from di~l.lulu~L.~llùo.. ' and
recycled.
The tops stream from the first distillation column is preferably treated in order to remove
at least hydrogen chloride. In particular the tops steam from the first distillation column may
5 be scrubbed with water to remove hydrogen fluoride and hydrogen chloride before being
fed tû the at least one further distillation column. However, in this case the hydrogen
fluoride in the tops stream is also removed, resulting in a lower hydrogen fluoride efficienc,v
fûr the process. Alternatively, the tops stream from the first distillation column rnay itself be
distilled in order to separate a tops stream comprising hydrogen chloride, ~.~,..L~Iùo., '
10 and ~llu~r ' '~ u~ from a bottoms stream comprising the other ~ u~ This
bottoms stream may then be fed to the at least one further distillation column, whilst the
tops stream may be fed to a distillation column in order to recover p~.~uu.- ' from
the tops stream.
~Vhere aqueous scrubbing is employed to remove hydrogen chloride and hydrogen
15 fluoride, the at least one further distillation column preferably comprises two distillation
columns in which in the first further column F '` . ' is separated from
cllulut~,hafluul~ ' and ~' ' ' ul~LIa~uOl. ' and in the second column
di~,hlu~uLI,ll~uul ' is separated from ~llulull,ll~luulu ' Where distillation iSempioyed to separate hydrogen chloride from the tops stream from the first distillation
20 columr~ the at least one further distillation column need only comprise one distillation
column in which ~,IIUIUICLI~I1UUI~ ' is separated from !'- ' ' uL~LIanuOI~ ''
r~..L~.~...~.~ in those ~ . ' of/or aspects of the invention in which two reactor
vessels arc employed, we have also found that we are able to employ for at least one of the
reactors an "adiabatic" reactor, that is a reactor to whiGh none, or little, thermal regulation,
25 i.e. heating or cooling, is required. Indeed, where desired, it is possible that both reactors
may be adiabatic. In these ~;., we generally prefer to employ an adiabatic reactor
for the reactor in which step (ii) of the process is effected, that is the l~Lu~uu~ ' ' of a
compound of formula C2H~Cl~+~F~+y~ and more preferably that both reactors are adiabatic.
-7-
wo951276~8 2184~8 1 r~ ,s~0766
The invention is i~lustrated but not ~inuted by the f~Dowing oxan~ples.
Example 1.
I Sg of a chromia catalyst having a particle size of 2.0 to 3 .~rnm was charged to a 112
5 inch internai diameter Inconei reactor tube and hydrogen fluoride was passed over the
cataiyst at 380C and a pressure of 3 barg for i6 hours. The L~ ~a~ule was then lowered
to 350C, the pressu~e was increased to 10 barg and hydrogen fluoride and
p~., ullu~ U~}.J ~U.I~ were passed over the cataiyst at a molar rabio of hydrogen fluoride to
or~anic of 6:1, giving a contact time of 30 seconds. The reactor off-gases were sampled~
10 scrubbed to remove acids and anaiysed by Gas Cl", ~ ,hy. The results are shown in
Table 1.
From the results, the yield of p~,..;ldlUUI~ '' was 18% and ~he seiecbvity to
p n.. ~ f and ily~lu~ ulunUul~ offormulaCH~CI~+~ y~as88%.
15 Example 2.
The procedure of example I was repeated except that the cataiyst employed comprised
8% (by weight of the cab~iyst) zinc and chromia. The cataiyst was prepared by
CO~ L~!-;L~Iti..~ zinc hydroxide and chrornium hydroxide frûm a soluborl of zinc nibrate and
~0 chromium ((Ill) nibrate, and then calcining the hydroxides.
The results for this catalyst are also silown in Table 1.
wo ss/27688 2 1 ~3 4 9 8 1 r~ 7~6
TABLE I
OFF-GAS EXAMPLE.
S COMPOSITION.
(mole %) 1 2
C2F5H 17 18
C2F4CIH 32 14
C2F3Ci ,H 35 55
C2F2CI3H 2 <I
C2F3CIH2 2 10
C2F5CI 0.1 3
C2CI4 1 I <I
Exarnple 3.
The procedure of example 2 was repeated except that hydrogen fluoride arld C2F3CI2H
25 were passed over the cataiyst using a molar ratio of hydrogen fluoride to organic of 5:1.
The conversion of C2F3CI2H was 80% and the selectivity to ~ lu~ e and
~,LI~Iultlla{luul~ ~ - was 99.2%.
Exarnpie 4.
30 The procedure of exarnple I was repeated except that hydrogen fluoride and FC-123
were passed over the catalyst using a molar ratio of hydrogen fluoride to organic of ~. S: 1.
g
WO~Y276~ 2 1 ~4 ~8 ~ 766
The conversion of FC-123 at 32DC was 100% and the selectivity to FC-125 and E~C 124
was96.2%. CFC-1151evelswere 1.4%.
Example 5.
The same catalyst as in exasnple 2 was tested at a pressure of 10 barg and a molar ratio of
hydrogen fluoride to p~ U~ e of 5. I, giving a contact time of ~5 seconds. Over
the l~,.~4J."~lul e range 27C - 3 ~ 0C, the following results were obtained:
OffGasCnmr~.citi~ (mole%)
Temp (C) FC-125 FC-124 FC-123 FC-122 FC-133a Pcr
270Cl 1.2 29 32.1 0 3 33.7
280<I 3 39.6 23.9 0.4 30. 1
15290 <I 7 49.8 15.1 0.6 24.6
300 1 12.3 53.1 9.4 0.8 20.9
3103.6 21.8 52.6 4.6 1.2 14.3
-10-
