Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02208764 1997-06-25
WO 96/21050 ~ ' PCT/US95I16973
CLAD PLASTIC PARTICLES SUITABLE
FOR THERMAL SPRAYING
Technical Field
The present invention relates to the treatment of plastic powder particles to
make
them suitable for thermal spray processing to form coatings on the surface of
substrates. More particularly, the present invention relates to plastic powder
particles having a thermal barrier cladding or coating thereon to prevent
decomposition of the plastic powder when sprayed in a high temperature thermal
spray process, and the method for making such particles.
Background of the Invention
One well known technique for coating surfaces with metal, ceramic or
plastic is a thermal spray process. Generally, thermal spray processes
typically
involve the step of heat softening a heat fusible material such as a metal or
ceramic followed by the step of propelling the heat softened material in
particulate
form against a surface that is to be coated with the heat softened material.
The
heat softened material and the surface form a bond. Thermal spraying can be
accomplished with a flame spray gun that normally uses a combustion or plasma
flame to effect melting of a powder. Other heating means such as electric
arcs,
resistant heaters or induction heaters can also be used, alone or in
combination.
Thus, thermal spraying of metallic, ceramic or plastic powders on a surface is
a
useful process for imparting desired properties to a surface. For example,
thermal
sprayable molybdenum-iron alloy powders, as described in U.S. Patent No.
5,292,382, are thermal sprayed on metal surfaces to improve wear resistance,
such
as sliding wear and/or fretting wear. Mineral coatings are thermal sprayed on
plastic surfaces, as described in U.S. Patent No. 4,388,373, to provide such
surfaces with greater hardness and wear resistance. In other well known
thermal
spray processes, metallic and/or ceramic materials are thermal sprayed to make
dimensional restorations to a worn surface, to provide corrosion resistance,
or to
1
CA 02208764 1997-06-25
WO 96/21050 ~ ~ PCT/US95/16973
improve its thermal conductivity. Also, plastics may be applied to a metal
surface
with a thermal spraying, process to provide a metal surface with properties
such as
improved release, a low coefficient of friction, and non-wetting.
Metal or ceramic thermal sprayable powders typically have high melting
points (for metals, around 1426°C (2600°F), and for ceramics,
about 1649°c
(3000°F), and accordingly, they must be sprayed with high temperature
gas
streams, such as plasma sprays or acetylene gas, to transfer sufficient heat
to melt
them. In contrast to metallic or ceramic powders, Thermally sprayed plastic
powders usually having lower melting points (from approximately 81.7°C
(180°F)
to around 260°C (500°F)), and therefore, such powders are
usually thermal
sprayed with low temperature gas streams, such as, hydrogen or natural gas, to
prevent super heating and oxidation thereof.
In some coating applications, it is desirable to combine relatively low
melting point plastic materials with relatively high melting point metallic or
ceramic thermal sprayable materials to impart the particular properties of
each
material to a surface simultaneously as a duplex coating in a single
application.
However, the thermal spraying of such a combination usually provides poor and
unacceptable end results because the melting points of the metal and plastic
materials are incompatible. For example, the conditions needed to properly
melt
high melting point thermal spray powders, such as metal powder, will usually
cause decomposition and loss of the plastic powder, thus preventing
simultaneous
deposition of a duplex coating containing both the high melting point metal
with
the low melting point plastic dispersed through out. On the other hand, if
conditions are selected so as to properly melt the plastic powder but prevent
decomposition thereof, then the high temperature metal powder will not melt,
and
accordingly, will not deposit on metal surfaces to form desired duplex
coatings.
Surfaces requiring such duplex coatings to provide long wearing release or
non-stick properties include rolls used in the paper producing or converting
industry. In the past, coatings having metallic and plastic constituents have
been
applied to such rolls using a two step process wherein a roll is- first
thermal
sprayed with a wear resistant andlor a corrosion resistant metal coating, such
as a
2
CA 02208764 1997-06-25
WO 96/21050 ~ ' PCTlUS95116973
molybdenum-iron alloy, and then impregnated with a liquified plastic powder,
such as PTFE. As those skilled in the art will appreciate, this prior art two
step
process is cumbersome, costly and difficult to accomplish on site as compared
to
the present invention. The prior art two step process has limited
effectiveness
even when applied over a good thermal spray coating, because such thermal
spray
coatings do not always have the required interconnected porosity to allow
effective
penetration of the plastic. Thus, the application of plastic to a roll with
this two
step prior art process usually only results in a surface effect that quickly
wears
away leaving the roll without the desired release properties imparted by the
plastic. If adaptations in the prior art process are made so as ~to form a
higher
porosity metal that can absorb more plastic to provide a roll with durable
release
properties, the resulting matrix properties of the coating tend to be severely
reduced. The reduction in matrix properties of such coatings can lead to
surfaces
that wear and/or corrode rapidly.
As those skilled in the art will appreciate, it is highly desirable to have
the
ability to control the amount of plastic and high temperature material
deposited, as
well as the ability to control the time and manner of application, on the
surface of
a substrate to provide the surface with a duplex coating having long wearing
release or non-stick properties. However, this goal is nearly impossible with
the
prior art two step process.
Disclosure of the Invention
The present invention is designed to overcome the limitations of the prior
art described above, and toward this end, it contemplates a thermal sprayable
plastic powder particle having a high temperature cladding material thereon.
The
cladding applied to the thermal sprayable plastic powder particle makes the
particle
suitable for thermal spraying under conditions that would otherwise cause its
decomposition because the cladding acts as a thermal barrier. According to the
present invention, the cladding may comprise a single layer of high
temperature
material or multiple layers of high temperature materials.
3
CA 02208764 1997-06-25
WO 96/21050 ' ~ PCT/US95/16973
A single cladding layer on the plastic powder particle is obtained by at least
performing the following steps: substantially surrounding a plastic powder
particle
with a high temperature cladding material, heating the plastic powder particle
and
the surrounding cladding material to the softening temperature of the plastic
powder particle, and holding the temperature at the .softening temperature for
a
period of time so a.s to ensure that the cladding material bonds with the
softened
thermal sprayable plastic powder particle. The particle may then be cooled for
later preparation or use or used immediately, as further described below, in a
thermal spray process.
Additional layers of the same high temperature material, or multiple layers
of different high temperature materials may also be clad onto the clad plastic
powder particle. If a plastic particle with multiple cladding layers is
desired, the
present invention contemplates, in addition to the steps described above for
obtaining a clad plastic particle, the additional steps of: cooling the clad
particle,
and bonding another high temperature material to the cladding layer on the
plastic
powder particle with an organic binder. -
Generally, the cladding parameters, such as the number and thickness of
cladding layers, as well as the type of cladding material used, are selected
on the
basis of formulating a clad plastic powder particle that will be compatible
with the
process parameters of a high temperature thermal spray process, other
materials
blended therewith, and the desired surface properties of the substrate.
According
to the present invention, once plastic powder particles are clad with a high
temperature material, they may be sprayed directly on the surface of a
substrate
under high temperature thermal spray conditions or they may be blended with
high
temperature materials to farm a high temperature thermal spray powder blend.
Whether the clad plastic powder particles are sprayed directly or blended, the
cladding allows the plastic powder particles to be applied with a high
temperature
thermal spray process because the cladding allows adequate heating and
softening
of the plastic powder while preventing its decomposition.
4
CA 02208764 1997-06-25
WO 96!21050 ~ ~ PCT/US95116973
Accordingly, it is one object of the present invention to provide a method
for controlling the deposition of plastic powders on substrate surfaces using
high
temperature thermal spray processes.
Other objects and advantages of the present invention will become more
apparent to those skilled in the art from the following detailed description
and
figures illustrating this invention.
Brief Description of the Drawings
The drawings, not drawn to scale, include:
FIG. 1 is a flow diagram of the method for making a thermal sprayable
clad plastic powder particle as well as a method for applying a duplex coating
to a
surface according to the present invention;
FIG. 2 is a cross-sectional illustration of a thermal sprayable clad plastic
powder particle made according to the method shown in FIG. 1;
FIG. 3 is a photograph of the cross-section of a duplex coated substrate,
magnified 100 times, after having been treated with a thermal spray powder
blend
containing: (a) 30 weight percent of a clad plastic powder particles
comprising 60
weight percent particle polytetra fluoro ethylene (PTFE) clad with an inner
cladding layer of approximately 20 weight percent TiOZ and an outer cladding
layer of approximately 20 weight percent A1203 and (b) 70 weight percent of a
high temperature powder comprising 87 weight percent alumina and 13 weight
percent titania according to the methods of the present invention;
FIG. 4 is a photograph of the cross-section of a coated substrate, magnified
100 times, after having been treated with a thermal spray powder comprising 20
weight percent of clad ETFE (Ethyl-Tetra-Fluoro-Ethylene) particles in FIG 3
blended with 80 weight percent of the same high temperature powder; and
FIG. 5 is a photograph of the cross-section of a coated substrate, magnified
50 times, after having been treated with a thermal spray powder blend
containing:
(a) 10 weight percent clad plastic powder comprising 60 weight percent ETFE
clad
with two layers, each 20 weight percent, of Ti02 powder in two steps and (b)
90
weight percent aluminum bronze powder.
5
CA 02208764 1997-06-25
WO 96121050 T ~ PCT/US95/16973
Best Mode For Carr~g_(.~ut the Invention
FIG. 1 is flow chart 10 of steps comprising a method for applying a duplex
coating on a substrate surface containing plastic dispersed throughout a high
temperature material, such as metal or ceramic. The exemplary method shown in
FIG. 1 includes 'the basic steps 12, 14 and 16 to provide a cladding layer on
the
thermal sprayable plastic powder particle to make the plastic powder particles
suitable for use in high temperature thermal spray applications, and includes
additional steps 18 through 22 to apply additional cladding layers to the
thermal
sprayable plastic powder particles, and step 24 for coating the surface of a
substrate by thermal spray.
According to the present invention, a clad plastic powder particle suitable
for use in a high temperature thermal spray process may be formed, as shown by
step 12, by mixing plastic powder particles, such as PTFE, sized between lam
and 90~cm, for example, with a sufficient quantity of titanic powder
(typically less
than l~cm in diameter) to substantially cover the surface of the plastic
powder
particle. It has been found that mixing approximately 80 weight percent PTFE
with approximately 20 weight percent titanic powder provides sufficient
coverage
of titanic over the surface of the PTFE particles.
Although PTFE is used as an representative thermal sprayable plastic
powder in step 12, it should be appreciated that the present invention may be
practiced with other fluoropolymer powders such as ETFE, tetxa fluoroethylene
(TFE), fluorinated ethylene propylene FEP), chlorofluoroethylenes,
chlorotxifluoroethylenes, fluorohydrocarbons. The present invention may also
be
practiced with other non-fluoropolymer powder materials such as polyamides,
polyvinyl chlorides, epoxys, polyimides and polyesters having desirable non-
stick
properties.
After the mixing step 12, the PTFE/titania blend is heated in step 14 to
approximately 232°C (450"F), and held, as shown in step 16 at
232°C (450°F)
for approximately 30 minutes. This time and temperature has been found to be
sufficient to soften at least the surface of the PTFE particles so that the
fine titanic
particles in closest contact with PTFE will bond thereto. The softening
6
CA 02208764 1997-06-25
R'O 96/21050 ~ ' PCTIUS95116973
temperature of a plastic particle is usually a temperature close to, but below
the
melting point of the plastic. Because the entire softened PTFE surface is
substantially in contact with titania particles, the surface is coated with a
layer of
titania particles about one titanic particle thick (approximately less than
l~cm).
The step of heating the PTFE/titania blend 14 to soften the PTFE surface is
one of
the most important steps of the process because it overcomes the tight bonding
of
PTFE molecules that essentially make PTFE, and other fluropolymer materials,
almost inert materials. In other words, but for the heat softening step 14,
titanic,
or any other high temperature material, would not adhere to the PTFE surface.
Once a cladding has been placed on the heat softened PTFE surface of a
particle, the resulting clad particle may be directly used in a high
temperature
thermal spray process, if desired, or additional cladding layers may be
applied.
Or, it may be cooled for later use. If additional cladding layers are to be
applied,
the titanic clad particle is cooled, in step 18, to room temperature. Once
cooled,
the titanic clad particle is ready for further cladding with the same or
another high
temperature material, such as alumina particles. The cooling step 18 is
necessary
because the organic binders used to bind alumina particles, as further
described
below, would otherwise vaporize if applied to a relatively hot clad plastic
particle.
For example, the cladding of alumina particles to a titanic clad PTFE
particle, step 20, as first disclosed herein, involves the application of well
known
techniques for cladding thermal sprayable materials together using organic
binders.
See, for example, U.S. Patent No. 3,655,425, wherein a process using organic
binders is disclosed for bonding various thermal sprayable materials together.
To
obtain a cladding layer of alumina particles on the clad PTFE particles, a
sufficient quantity of alumina is mixed with the clad PTFE so as to surround
the
clad PTFE particles and an organic binder, such as phenolic varnish, is added
to
the mixture to bind the alumina to the cladding layer.
FIG. 2 is a cross-sectional view of a clad thermal sprayable plastic
powder particle made according to process steps 12 through 20 of FIG. 1.
According to the process example provided above, the cladding steps result in
a
clad plastic powder particle 28 having a plastic core 30, such as a
fluoropolymer
7
CA 02208764 1997-06-25
WO 96/21050 ~ ~ PCTIUS95/16973
or fluoro plastic, that is surrounded by an intermediate layer of 20 weight
percent
titanic 32 and an outer layer of 20 weight percent akumina 34. There is an
organic
binder 36 at the interface of the titanic particles 32 and alumina particles
34, and
also at the interface of adjacent alumina particles 34. Because the titanic
and
akumina particles 32 and 34, that form the intermediate and outer layers, have
much higher melting points than the plastic core 30 therein, the intermediate
and
outer layers act as a thermal barrier for the lower melting point plastic core
30
when the clad PTFE particle 28 is subjected to high temperature conditions in
a
high temperature thermal spray process.
Without departing from the scope of the present invention, those skilled in
the art will recognize that many variations can be made to the cladding on the
plastic powder particles, such as variations in material type, number of
materials
forming layers, and weight percentages thereof. For example, an intermediate
layer may be formed with titanic and alumina, rather than just titanic, by
mixing
the plastic powder particles with an admixture of titanic and akumina. Also,
multiple intermixed cladding layers of titanic and akumina, for example, may
be
obtained by mixing an excess amount (amount greater than needed to cover the
surface of the PTFE particles) of titanic and alumina particles with PTFE
particles, heating the mixture to the softening temperature (approximately
232°C
(450°F)) of the PTFE so that titanic and alumina adhere to the PTFE,
cooling the
titania/alumina clad PTFE particles mixed with the remaining non-adhered
titanic
and alumina, adding an organic binder to the mixture of titania/alumina clad
F'TFE
particles, titanic and alumin.a so as to adhere additional titanic and alumina
to the
titania/alumina clod PTFE particles.
With respect to the selection of cladding material, the present invention
contemplates that any high temperature ceramic or metal material can be
applied
as cladding on the thermal sprayable plastic powder particles by at least
following
steps 12 though 16 described above. Such cladding materials include metals,
metal oxides, metal nitrides, metal chlorides, metal sulfides, and metal
carbides,
metal alloys and elements. Typically, the material selected for cladding on
the
thermal sprayable plastic powder particles is based on the cladding material's
8
CA 02208764 1997-06-25
WO 96/21050 ~ ' PCTIUS95116973
compatibility with the substrate to which the clad plastic powder is to be
applied
or with the material to which the clad plastic powder is to be mixed. For
instance, if the substrate surface or the high temperature thermal spray
material is
alumina, then the plastic powder particles 30 could be clad with alumina or
titania
or both. If the substrate to be coated is stainless steel, one may choose a
nickel or
perhaps cobalt clad on the plastic.
As mentioned above, once the clad plastic powder 30 particles have been
formed, they may be applied directly to a substrate surface in a high
temperature
thermal spray process or they may be blended with another high temperature
thermal sprayable material to form a high temperature thermal sprayable powder
blend as shown in step 22 in FIG. 1. In situations where the clad plastic
powder
particles 30 are to be mixed with high temperature thermal sprayable materials
to
form a high temperature thermal spray powder blend, the quantity of clad
thermal
sprayable plastic particles 30 used in the blend can be varied so as to
control the
degree of non-stick or coefficient of friction properties ultimately desired
at the
surface of a substrate to be treated.
Also, as those skilled in the art will readily appreciate, the quantity and
type of high temperature thermal sprayable material blended with the clad
plastic
particles 30 is selected based on the properties of the substrate that are in,
need of
improvement or change. For example, ceramic materials may be used to improve
wear resistance, high alloy materials may be selected to improve corrosion
resistance, and aluminum or copper materials may be selected to improve or
modify thermal conductivity. Thus, by careful blending of high temperature
thermal sprayable materials and clad thermal sprayable plastic powder
particles,
those skilled in the art will appreciate that controlling the deposit of a
duplex
coating material on a substrate that has the appropriate release and wear
properties, is possible with the present invention.
The invention will be further described in the following illustrative
examples wherein all parts are by weight unless otherwise expressed.
- 30
9
CA 02208764 2000-11-27
W O 96/21050 PCTNS95I16973
EXAMPLE 1
80 weight percent F'TFE; particles were blended with 20 weight percent
titanic particles and heated to 232°C (450°F) for approximately
30 minutes to
form titanic clad PTFE particles. The titanic clad PT'FE particlcs were cooled
and
further clad with alumina using organic binders to form multiply-clad P'TFE
particles comprising a plastic acre of approximately 60 weight percent PTFE,
an
inner cladding layer of approai~mately 20 weight percent titanic and an outer
cladding layer 20 weight per~cer~t alumina. The resulting clad P1'FE particles
were
mined with a high temperature thermal sprayable powder consisting of 87 weight
percent alumina and 13 weight percent titanic in a ratio of approximately 30
weight percent clad PTFE particles to approximately 70 weight percent high
temperature thermal sprayable powder. The mixture was applied to a carbon
steel
substrate using a thermal spray process with a Metco 7MB (T' N1~ plasma flame
gun
employing the following parameters:
~I2 powder port
GH nozzle;
Argon primary gas at 14.5 kPa (100 psi) and 2265 liter/hr (80 cubic
feet/hr) flow;
Hydrogen secondary gas at 7.25 Kpa (50 psi) and 425 liters/hr. (15 cubic
feet/hr) flow;
500 amps, 75 volts, 37.5 kw;,
sprayed at the rate of 6 lbs/hr (2.72 kg/hr);
spray distance of 4 inches (10.16cm); and
PSA air cooler set at 5(1 psi (7.25 Kpa) crossed at 6 inches (15.24 cm).
The resulting coating is shown in FIG. 3. The coating shown therein was
sectioned and prepared metallographically to study inclusion and distribution
of
PTFE. As FIG. 3 shows, the cross-section shows particles of PTFE dispersed
through out a continuous matrix of 8796 alumina-13~ titanic. Coating hardness
was measured on a Rockwell hardness tester and found to have a hardness of
approximately Rc 55. Coatings having the morphology and hardness of the cross-
section shown in FIG. 3 have been tested in the pulp and paper industry on
rolls
CA 02208764 1997-06-25
w0 96/21050 ~ ' PCT/US95/16973
requiring special wear and release properties for manufacturing of recycled
paper.
EXAMPLE 2
80 weight percent ETFE particles were blended with 20 weight percent
titanic particles and heated to 232°C (450°F) for approximately
30 minutes to
form titanic clad ETFE particles. The titanic clad ETFE particles were cooled
and
further clad with alumina using organic binders to form multiply cladded ETFE
particles comprising a plastic core of approximately 60 weight percent ETFE,
an
inner cladding layer of approximately 20 weight percent titanic and an outer
cladding layer 20 weight percent alumina. The resulting clad ETFE particles
were
mixed with a high temperature thermal sprayable powder consisting of 87 weight
percentalumina and 13 weight percent titanic in a ratio of approximately 20
weight percent clad ETFE particles to approximately 80 weight percent high
te_m__pe_ra_tu_re -t_her~-sprayablapowdcr: -The ~a~,:r~ eras Applied-undeWl:e
same
thermal spray conditions recited in Example 1. The resulting coating is shown
in
FIG. 4. The coating shown therein was sectioned and prepared
metallographically
to study inclusion and distribution of ETFE. As FIG. 4 shows, the cross-
section
shows particles of ETFE dispersed through out a continuous matrix of 87%
alumina-13 % titanic but there is lower concentration of ETFE in this coating
than
in the coating shown in FIG. 3.
EXAMPLE 3
80 weight percent ETFE particles were blended with 20 weight percent
titanic particles and heated to 232 ° C (450 °F) for
approximately 30 minutes to
form titanic clad ETFE particles. The titanic clad ETFE particles were cooled
and
further clad another 20 weight percent titanic particles using an organic
binder to
form multiply cladded ETFE particles comprising a plastic core of
approximately
60 weight percent ETFE, an inner cladding layer of approximately 20 weight
percent titanic and an outer cladding layer 20 weight percent titanic. The
resulting
clad ETFE particles were mixed with a high temperature aluminum bronze metal
thermal sprayable powder iii a ratio of approximately 10 weight percent clad
11
CA 02208764 1997-06-25
WO 96/21050 ' ~ PCT/US95/16973
ETFE particles to approximately 90 weight percent aluminum. Coatings on a
carbon steel substrate were formed under the same thermal spray conditions set
forth in Example 1. The resulting coating is shown in FIG. 5 which is a
photograph of the coating's cross-section, magnified 50 times. The cross
section
shown in FIG. 5 shows ETFE (dark areas) dispersed through out the bronze
matrix (light areas). The measured hardness of the coating was Rlsy 70. This
coating could be used, for example, as a low friction surface for the lands of
extrusion screws.
EXAMPLE 4
80 weight percent PTFE powder sized between 15 ~cm and 44 ~m-was
treated with 20 weight percent titanic according to the method steps 12
through 16.
The treated powder was cooled and screened to obtain 15 ~cm to 53 ~cm
particles.
The resulting titanic clad P'TFE particles were further clad with 80 weight
percent
molybdenum particles using an organic binder to hold the molybdenum to the
titanic. The resulting multiply-clad particles were screened to obtain
particle size
between 30 um and 90 ~cm. These particles were directly plasma sprayed under
conditions described in Example 1 to deposit a duplex coating. The resulting
dense molybdenum/titania matrix provides wear resistance while the dispersed
PTFE therein provides substantially reduced coefficient of friction. This
coating is
an outstanding candidate for guide rails and machine ways.
It is contemplated that useful coatings can be applied with the present
invention to a wide variety of things such as prosthetic devices, bearings,
valves,
self lubricating surfaces, ships, conveyor chain guides, among other things.
While
the applications for such coatings is virtually endless, it will be
appreciated that
the instant specification and examples are set forth by way of illustration
and not
limitation, and that various modifications and changes may be made without
departing from the spirit and scope of the present invention.
12
