Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
RD-26,1153 CA 02238208 1998-05-21
-1-
PROTECTIVE COATING BY
HIGH RATE ARC PLASMA DEPOSITION
This invention relates to deposition of protective coatings or
films on various substrates such as glass, metals, and plastics. More
particularly the invention is directed to adherent protective coatings
on plastic surfaces such as sheets, films, and shaped articles.
Coatings which are abrasion resistant and protect against radiation
damage to the plastic substrate are provided by the invention
disclosed herein. The term protective coating means one or more
layers of deposited material which provides protection against
abrasion and UV degradation and reflects IR radiation.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
The technological importance of thin films has led to the
development of a variety of deposition methods.
Chemical vapor deposition (CVD) produces a solid film on a
substrate surface by thermal activation and surface reaction of
gaseous reagents which contain the desired constituents of the film.
Energy required to pyrolyze the reactants is supplied by heating the
substrate. For reasonable reaction rates the substrate is heated to
relatively high temperatures in the range of about 5000 to 2000 F
degrees. These temperatures preclude application of the process to
heat sensitive substrate materials.
Plasma enhanced chemical vapor deposition (PECVD)
supplies energy to the reactants by an electrical discharge in a gas
which forms a plasma in the deposition chamber. Generally the
substrate is immersed in the plasma.
Polycarbonate is often the engineering material of choice for
glazing and optical applications because of its high impact strength,
RD-26,153 CA 02238208 1998-05-21
-2-
low density, optical clarity, and good processibility. However, the
polycarbonate material is soft, lacks glass-like abrasion resistance,
and is sensitive to temperatures above about 300 F. Prior work had
shown that a silicon oxide coating by plasma-enhanced chemical
vapor deposition (PECVD) can improve the abrasion resistance of
polycarbonate, qualifying it for glazing applications. However, the
prior PECVD technology using silane and nitrous oxide as the
precursors was slow and therefore uneconomical, having a typical
deposition rate of only about 0.05 microns per minute. Organosilicon
precursors were later used in PECVD for a plasma-generated
abrasion-resistant polymer coating, but the deposition rate was not
significantly improved.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
A plasma arc method for preparing a clear weather stable
protective coatings on polycarbonate (PC) has been developed. The
coating can be essentially stoichiometric silicon dioxide or silicon
oxide-based which contains small amounts of carbon and hydrogen.
The term "silicon oxide-based" as used herein means a material
which comprises oxides of silicon and small amounts of carbon and
hydrogen, organic residue from the organosilicon compounds used
to form the material. The coating imparts glass-like abrasion
resistance to the polycarbonate article. The coating was deposited
at rates of up to about 20 microns per minute at a reduced pressure
with oxygen and an organosilicon compound such as
hexamethyldisiloxane (HMDSO) injected into an argon plasma
generated by an arc plasma torch. In the practice of this invention
the surface to be coated is positioned in the path of the active
species generated by the plasma as they pass into and through the
deposition or coating chamber of the apparatus.
RD-26,153 CA 02238208 1998-05-21
-3-
The polycarbonate substrate surface can be pretreated with
a primer interfacial layer before deposition of the abrasion resistant
coating material. The term "substrate", as used herein, refers to a
structure such as a sheet or film which acts as the base or support
for the material which forms the coating or is one of a series of
coatings. Generally, the substrate, although it can be a thin film, is
relatively thick compared to the thickness of the coating.
This invention comprises methods for high-rate deposition of
silicon oxide-based weather-stable, abrasion-resistant, and
radiation-stable protective coatings on plastics such as
polycarbonate. The term "high rate" deposition refers to deposit of
coatings at a rate greater than about 5 microns per minute. The
coatings must be optically clear and abrasion resistant and may
satisfy other functional requirements such as providing infrared or
ultraviolet protection, and adhesion improvement. The coating
process must be operative at temperatures below the thermal
damage threshold, generally the glass transition temperature, of the
plastic substrate or an intermediate functional layer, such as an
ultraviolet radiation absorbing layer, on which the coating or coatings
are deposited. It is preferred to operate with the substrate at a
temperature at least 20 C below the glass transition temperature,
e.g. about 135 C for polycarbonate substrates.
A plasma deposition method for coating abrasion resistant
coatings on plastic using an expanded thermal plasma of argon
generated by an arc plasma torch and injecting an organosilicon
precursor and oxygen into the plasma as it exits the torch to deposit
a silicon oxide-based coating under reduced pressure on the target
surface has been developed. Polycarbonate film (10 mil thick) and
sheet (0.125"-thick) pre-coated with about 4 to 8 microns of a
silicone hardcoat were coated with silicon oxide-based using the
RD-26,153 CA 02238208 1998-05-21
-4-
plasma deposition method of this invention without direct cooling of
the substrate. Optically clear coatings free of microcracks were
produced without thermal damage to the substrate. The silicon
oxide coating greatly improved the abrasion resistance of the
composite as evidenced by Taber abrasion tests. The term
"composite" refers to the substrate with its silicon oxide-based
abrasion resistant coating and any other functional coatings which
may be present.
A water-cooled arc with a 4mm cylindrical bore was used to
deposit the coatings as described herein. The arc generator
consists of a copper anode separated from 3 needle cathodes of
thoriated tungsten by at least one electrically isolated metal plate.
With argon flowing, a dc voltage is applied to the electrodes to
generate a plasma. The plasma expands through a diverging or
bell-shaped nozzle-injector into a deposition chamber maintained at
a reduced pressure by a vacuum pump. The stainless steel nozzle-
injector has two or more shower-ring gas distributors for the injection
of reactive gases into the argon plasma stream. The nozzle-injector
is heated to a temperature sufficient, e.g., about 200 C, to avoid
condensation of reactive gas organosilicons such as HMDSO. The
substrate is mounted on the jet axis by means of a metal stage at a
working distance of about 15 to 70 centimeters from the anode. A
retractable shutter can be inserted between the mounting stage and
the nozzle to regulate the exposure of the substrate to the plasma.
Polycarbonate and silicon hardcoated polycarbonate substrates can
be prepared for deposition coating by washing with isopropyl alcohol
and vacuum drying at about 80 C to remove volatile contaminants.
The bore or central channel of the plasma torch need not be
cylindrical. The bore can be cone shaped, widening as it approaches
the discharge end of the torch.
RD-26,153 CA 02238208 1998-05-21
-5-
In a typical deposition procedure the argon plasma is
established with a manually or automatically controlled blockade or
shutter inserted between the plasma source and the substrate.
Oxygen is then introduced into the plasma to produce an
oxygen/argon plasma. The shutter is retracted and the substrate is
exposed to the oxygen/argon plasma for a short time, up about 30
sec, before the organosilicon reagent such as HMDSO, is
introduced into the plasma for silicon oxide deposition over a period
ranging from about 3 to 30 seconds. Table 1, below, shows the
deposition rate for several deposition conditions. In general, the
heat load on the substrate can be reduced by lowering the argon
flow, by increasing the working distance as measured from the
anode, and by lowering the arc power. Condition G70 allows an
exposure of 60 sec without thermal damage to a 0.125" thick sheet
of polycarbonate having a silicon hardcoat surface layer. Condition
G71 permits an exposure of 15 sec without thermal damage to a 10
mil thick polycarbonate film.
Table 1. Illustrative coating conditions and deposition rates
I unit G71 G70 G66 G67 G64 G59
Substrate PC MR5* Glass Glass Glass Glass
film
Aroonfsowrate I/min 1.5 2.0 3.0 4.0 6.0 6.0
Oxygen flow I/min 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 1.0
rate
HMDSO flow I/min 0.12 0.12 0.12 0.12 0.12 0.12
rate
VUak't'~g cm 38 38 38 38 38 33
distartoe
Chamber torr 0.24 0.28 0.33 0.41 0.55 0.59
RD-26,153 CA 02238208 1998-05-21
-6-
Arc power Kwatt 4.19 4.38 4.53 4.71 5.00 4.95
Deposition rate N/min 5 8 8 8 14 16
* Polycarbonate with a silicone hardcoat
Table 2 compares the abrasion resistance of two
polycarbonate samples (0.125" thick) with and without silicon oxide-
based coating deposited as disclosed herein and that of an uncoated
glass plate. Haze was measured by using a Pacific Scientific XL-
835 colorimeter before and after the sample is abraded on a
Teledyne Taber 5150 abrader (two CS1 OF wheels, 500g each) for a
number of cycles. Note the essentially glass-like abrasion resistance
of the sample with the 1.3 pm silicon oxide coating. The colorimeter
was zeroed with an open path (no solid sample) before use. The
negative readings at 0 cycles (before Taber abrasion) are artifacts of
the calibration procedure.
Table 2. Abrasion resistance of Polycarbonate with and without
PECVD silicon oxide surface coating
% Haze
Sample 0 100 300 600 1000 cycles
PC w/ silicone hardcoat -0.6 2.3 5.7 12.1 16.2
PC with 1.3 p silicon -0.3 0.8 1.3 1.4 1.9
oxide plasma coating
Glass -0.7 0.5 1.1 1.7 1.7
High rate deposition of a continuously-graded or a discretely-
graded transparent coating on plastic resin substrate, e.g.
polycarbonate, was achieved by using a wall-stabilized plasma arc
system of this invention. The coating was deposited at a rate of
about 8 microns per minute at a reduced pressure, with oxygen and
RD-26.153 CA 02238208 1998-05-21
-7-
an organosilicon compound as the reagents. Gradation was
achieved by varying the feed rate of oxygen, the organosilicon
reagent, or both. These graded coatings are characterized by
gradual transition from a composition which is essentially an
interfacial material to a composition which is substantially an
abrasion-resistant material. An interfacial material is one which is
situated between the substrate surface and the abrasion-resistant
material. In general the interfacial material has chemical and
physical characteristics which make it compatible with and adherent
to both the substrate and the abrasion-resistant material. The
coating greatly improves the abrasion resistance of the coated
polycarbonate composite.
A continuously graded coating was deposited by varying the
feed rate continuously throughout the coating process. A discretely
graded coating was made by changing the flow rate in a step
fashion. It was demonstrated that an arc plasma could be operated
smoothly with such changes in reagent feed rates, and both the
gradation layer and the abrasion-resistant layer at the top surface of
the coating could be made in an integrated process. A deposition
rate of about 8 microns per minute was typical. Good abrasion
resistance was achieved with a 3 pm thick abrasion-resistant layer
on a proper gradation layer on polycarbonate.
Suitable silicon-containing reagents include silane, disilane, or
organosilicon compounds like tetramethyldisiloxane (TMDSO),
hexamethyldisiloxane (HMDSO), tetraethyl orthosilicate,
hexamethyldisilane, octamethylcyclotetrasiloxane (D4), and
tetramethylcyclotetrasiloxane. The oxidant can be oxygen or nitrous
oxide.
In a typical deposition procedure the argon plasma was
established with the shutter inserted between the substrate and the
RD-26,153 CA 02238208 1998-05-21
-8-
nozzle-injector. Oxygen was then introduced to the nozzle-injector
to produce an oxygen/argon plasma. The shutter was retracted and
the substrate was exposed to the oxygen/argon plasma for a short
time before the silicon-containing reagent was introduced
downstream from the oxygen injection point to initiate deposition
over a period ranging from about 3 to 60 sec. The feed rates of both
HMDSO and oxygen could be varied during deposition to change the
coating properties. Typically, low oxygen/HMDSO ratios were used
for the gradation portion of the coating and high oxygen/HMDSO
ratios were used for the abrasion-resistant top or outermost layer.
In Table 3 the abrasion resistance of coated polycarbonate
samples (0.125" thick) with and without gradation is compared.
Haze was measured by using a Pacific Scientific XL-835 colorimeter
before and after the sample was abraded on a Teledyne Taber 5150
abrader (two CS10F wheels, 500g each) for the indicated number of
cycles.
Table 3. Coatings on Polycarbonate and Their Performance in
Taber Abrasion Resistance Measurements
No. Gradation Flawrate(Vmn) Coatngthidkness(N) Initial %,Ahaze
Ar/021i'-MDSO Graded Abrasion haze after Cydes
(%) 600 1,000
G96 none 210.62/0.12 0 2 0.7 49 -
G115 disamte 2J0.16-0.6210.12 2 3 1.7 0 1.6
This invention provides a method for preparing clear silicon
oxide-based coatings at high rates by plasma arc deposition.
Demonstration of the method uses silane or an organosilicon
compound as the silicon source, and oxygen or nitrous oxide as the
RD-26,153 CA 02238208 1998-05-21
-9-
oxidant. Deposition rates up to about 30 microns per minute were
achieved.
This embodiment of the invention is a method for high-rate
deposition of silicon oxide. Prior work had shown that a silicon oxide
coating can be made by plasma-enhanced chemical vapor
deposition (PECVD). Coatings so prepared showed good gas-
barrier properties useful for food and medical packaging, added
abrasion resistance to polycarbonate and other plastics, dielectric
properties suitable for an insulator in integrated circuits, and
protective function for anti-corrosion applications. However, the prior
art PECVD process is slow, with a typical deposition rate of about
0.05 microns per minute. It is very important to develop a high-rate
deposition method of protective coating which improves the coating
economics.
A method of making silicon oxide coatings at high rates was
developed by using a wall-stabilized plasma arc, as described
herein, which comprises generating an argon plasma jet in a
vacuum chamber, injecting a silicon-containing precursor and an
oxidant into the plasma jet, and impinging the jet or the residue of
the jet and its reactive species on a substrate situated in a reduced-
pressure environment. The reactant gases are injected into the
plasma jet at a point beyond the plasma generator, i.e. after the jet
has exited the generator.
In a typical deposition procedure the argon plasma was
established with the shutter inserted between the substrate and the
nozzle-injector. Oxygen or nitrous oxide was then introduced to the
nozzle-injector to produce an oxygen/argon plasma. The shutter
was retracted and the substrate was exposed to the oxygen/argon
plasma for a short time (1 to 30 sec) before the silicon-reagent was
introduced downstream from the oxygen to initiate silicon oxide
RD-26,153 CA 02238208 1998-05-21
-10-
deposition. Table 4 lists coating conditions and the corresponding
deposition rates. The major constituents of the coatings are si!icon
and oxygen, although carbon and hydrogen are also present, in
small amounts in some samples.
Table 4. Coating Conditions and Deposition Rates
Unit 339 [G59 G241 G253
Argon flow rate I/min 3.0 6.0 1.0 1.0
Oxidant 20 02 02 02
Silicon reagent %SiH4/Ar HMDSO TMDSO D4
Working cm 38 33 25.5 25.5
distance
Chamber torr .33 0.59 0.15 0.16
pressure-
Arc voltage V 32.5 42.5 41.5 41.5
Arc current A 51.5 60.0 60.5 61.0
Deposition rate pm/min 1 16 12 24
The high-rate deposition system of this invention was
designed to deposit thin-film coatings on both high and low
temperature substrates, including plastics. The system consists of a
vacuum chamber with an arc torch for plasma generation, plasma
gas and reactant gas injection means, a nozzle-injector for injedion,
activation and reaction of chemical reagents, a substrate stage. and
a pumping station to provide the reduced pressure for the vacuum
chamber.
This method was used to deposit abrasion-resistant coatings
of silicon oxide, from various silanes or siloxanes and oxygen or
nitrous oxide. Titania coatings can be deposited from titanium
isopropoxide and oxygen. Zinc oxide can be deposited from diethyl
or dimethyl zinc with oxygen. Diamond-like carbon coatings can be
RD-26,153 CA 02238208 1998-05-21
-11 -
deposited from various hydrocarbons. Substrate materials included
metal, glass, metallized glass, and plastics.
Various coatings were deposited by using the arc plasma
deposition system. They include abrasion-resistant coatings from
various siloxanes and oxygen, silica coatings from silane and nitrous
oxide, titania coatings from titanium isopropoxide and oxygen, and
diamond-like carbon coatings from various hydrocarbons. Substrate
materials include metal, glass, metallized glass, and plastics such as
polycarbonate, with and without a silicone hardcoat. Clear,
abrasion-resistant coatings, 30 cm x 30 cm in area with a deposition
rate of 30 Nm/min at the center, were demonstrated. The coating
greatly improves the abrasion resistance of polycarbonate.
A water-cooled cascaded arc with either a cylindrical or a
divergent arc channel was used. The arc generator consisted of a
copper anode separated from 3 needle cathodes of thoriated
tungsten by from 1 to 8 electrically isolated copper disks. With argon
flowing, a DC voltage was applied to the electrodes to generate a
plasma. The plasma expanded through a conical nozzle-injector into
a chamber maintained at a reduced pressure, thus forming a plasma
jet. The nozzle-injector had several shower-ring gas distributors
having from 8 to 32 holes each evenly distributed or slit-ring injectors
for the injection of gas/vapor into the argon plasma jet. The oxygen
injector was upstream from the siloxane injector. The nozzle-injector
was heated to about 200 C to avoid condensation of the high boiling
point reagents such as HMDSO and titanium isopropoxide. A
polycarbonate substrate was supported in the jet axis by means of a
temperature-controlled copper stage at a working distance of about
15 to 70 centimeters from the anode. A retractable shutter was used
to regulate the exposure of the substrate to the plasma.
Polycarbonate and polycarbonate with silicone hardcoat substrates
RD-26,153 CA 02238208 1998 -05 -21
-12-
were washed with isopropyl alcohol and vacuum dried at about 80 C
before use for deposition.
As previously the argon plasma was established with the
shutter inserted between the substrate and the nozzle-injector.
Oxygen was introduced to the nozzle-injector to produce an
oxygen/argon plasma. The shutter was retracted and the substrate
was exposed to the oxygen/argon plasma for a short time (0 to 30
sec) before a siloxane such as HMDSO or D4 was introduced
downstream from the oxygen to initiate deposition over a period of
time ranging from about 3 to 30 sec. A deposition rate of 10-30
microns per minute was typical, with no thermal damage to the
polycarbonate substrate. Polycarbonate films as thin as 10 mils
have been coated. The coating greatly increased the abrasion
resistance of the polycarbonate, exhibiting a haze increase of less
than about 2% after 1,000 cycles of Taber abrading by a pair of
CS10F wheels with a load of 500 g per wheel.
Other coatings deposited include zinc oxide, titanium oxide,
and diamond-like carbon. The titanium oxide and zinc oxide
coatings demonstrated a UV-filtering capability. The diamond-like
carbon coating exhibited superior dielectric properties with a
breakdown strength in the range of 300-400 V/pm.
Clear titanium oxide coatings on polycarbonate surfaces were
prepared at low temperatures by plasma arc deposition . The
coating was typically deposited at a rate of about 0.2 microns per
minute at a reduced pressure with oxygen and titanium isopropoxide
being injected into an argon plasma generated by a cascaded arc.
Transparent titanium oxide coatings have been used on
optical lenses on UV-sensitive plastics for UV filtering, and as a
component in stack coatings for IR reflection in glazing applications.
The coating can be made by metal organic chemical vapor
RD-26,153 CA 02238208 1998-05-21
-13-
deposition (MOCVD), reactive sputtering, and plasma-enhanced
chemical vapor deposition (PECVD). MOCVD requires the substrate
be heated to about 400 C, thus can only be applied to high-
temperature substrates such as glass. Reactive sputtering or
PECVD can be operated at lower temperatures, but the deposition
rate is low at about 0.01 -0.05 microns per minute.
The method of this invention provides high-rate deposition of
metal oxide films such as titanium and zinc oxides on substrates
such as glass metal, and plastics.
Titanium oxide coatings were deposited at high rates and low
temperatures by using a an argon plasma jet in a vacuum chamber,
injecting an organotitanium reagent and oxygen into the plasma jet,
and directing the jet to a substrate situated in a reduced pressure
environment. Optically clear titanium oxide coatings were obtained
with no microcracks. The UV-filtering capability of the coating was
demonstrated.
The wall-stabilized plasma arc with a cylindrical bore,
previously described, was used. The stainless steel nozzle-injector
had two shower-ring gas distributors having 8 to 16 holes each for
the injection of gas/vapor into the argon plasma jet. A retractable
shutter was used to regulate the exposure of the substrate to the
plasma. The argon plasma was established with the shutter inserted
between the substrate and the nozzle-injector. Oxygen was
introduced to the nozzle-injector to produce an oxygen/argon
plasma. The shutter was retracted and the substrate was exposed
to the oxygen/argon plasma for a short time, generally up to about
seconds, before titanium isopropoxide was introduced
downstream from the oxygen to initiate titanium oxide deposition
over a period ranging from 1 to 2 minutes. Although glass was used
30 as the substrate, essentially similar coating conditions can be used
RD-26,153 CA 02238208 1998-05-21
-14-
for coating deposition on polycarbonate without causing thermal
damage to the plastic. In one example, the titanium oxide coating of
about 0.5 pm thick was made at a deposition rate of about 0.23
microns per minute. The coating was transparent. Its UV filtering
capability was confirmed by UV-visible spectroscopy. The coating
was chemically stable in warm water soak test. No haze increase
was observed after the coating was immersed in 65 C water for 15
days.
Zinc oxide coatings have been deposited on glass, quartz,
and polycarbonate substrates using diethyl zinc and oxygen as
reagents. The UV filtering capability of the resulting coating was
demonstrated.
A cylindrical vacuum chamber 0.7 m in diameter and 1 m long
is oriented horizontally. At one end is a 0.7 m swing-open door for
excess to the inside of the chamber. An arc generator is mounted at
the center of the door outside of the chamber and is electrically
supported by a power supply and an starter. A nozzle-injector is
attached to the arc from inside the chamber, and various
feedthroughs are used to penetrate the door for vapor and gas
delivery and electrical heating to support the nozzle-injector. The
vapor lines and the nozzle-injector are kept at about 150 C by
heating tapes to avoid vapor condensation. A vertical copper
substrate stage with forced liquid circulation for temperature control
is on wheels and is movable along rails for working distance
adjustment. A molybdenum shutter is placed between the nozzle-
injector and the substrate stage. It is mounted to a movable (linear
motion) feedthrough for insertion and retraction. At the other end of
the chamber is a 12" flange leading to a throttling gate valve and a
pumping station consists of two Roots blowers in series backed by a
mechanical vacuum pump.
RD-26,153 CA 02238208 1998-05-21
-15-
Polycarbonate sheet 4" square, 1/8" thick was used as the
substrate. Other substrates used include glass slides, silicon wafers,
polycarbonate sheets and films, polyimide films graphite sheet,
carbon steel coupons and epoxy-coated glass. The substrate can
be prepared by first removing any masking films, washing the
substrate twice with isopropyl alcohol to remove any residue of the
adhesive, and baking in vacuum at 80 C. It is then taken out of the
vacuum oven and quickly mounted to the substrate stage preheated
to 80 C or other pre-set temperatures. The door is closed and the
chamber is pumped down by opening the roughing valve to the
mechanical pump. When a partial vacuum (10 torr) is reached, the
gate valve is opened and the Roots blowers are turned on to
establish full pumping.
With the shutter inserted, the arc is ignited with argon flowing.
Oxygen is then introduced through the nozzle-injector to produce an
oxygen/argon plasma. The shutter is retracted and the substrate is
exposed to the oxygen/argon plasma for a period of time, typically 0
to 10 sec, for pretreatment. After that, the silicon reagent is
introduced into the injector downstream from the oxygen injector to
initiate deposition. The deposition lasts from a few seconds to a few
minutes, depending on the deposition rate and the coating thickness
targeted, and is ended by shutting off the silicon reagent. The
coating is post-treated by oxygen/argon plasma for a period of time,
typically 0 to 10 sec, before the arc is extinguished. Listed in Table
7 are typical operating conditions and the corresponding deposition
results.
A particularly preferred silicon reagent is
octamethylcyclotetrasiloxane, identified herein as D4. Coatings
prepared from this precursor exhibited a surprising improvement in
UV stability. The low absorbance of the coating at several
RD-26,153
CA 02238208 1998-05-21
-16-
wavelengths correlates well with superior performance in
accelerated weathering tests. With other organosilicon reagents
such as TMDSO abrasion resistance generally degrades after 1000
hours of exposure. See Tables 5 and 6, below.
Table 5
UV Absorbance of D4 and TMDSO Coatings at 5 m Thickness
Wavelength D4 coating TMDSO coating
(nm) G339 G168
300 (UVB) 0.012 0.057
325 0.012 0.040
350 (UVA) 0.007 0.031
G339 deposited at 0.04 torr; G168 at 0.21 torr
Table 6
Taber Abrasion Resistance of D4 and TMDSO Coatings
before and after QUVB
Coating hickness ( ) Precursor Deposition QUVB oHaze
Pressure (hours) 1,000 cycles
(torr)
500 g each
G265-6 1.3 TMDSO 0.11 0 3.7%
G265-3 1.3 TMDSO 0.11 1,200 6.8%
G297 2.0 D4 0.03 0 1.6%
G 310-1 1.9 D4 0.04 1,000 1.4%
All coatings were deposited on polycarbonate substrates with silicon
hardcoat surface.
In other examples (G295, G296), the isopropyl alcohol wash
and vacuum baking of the samples were omitted and the deposition
was done at room temperature. No loss of deposition rate or the
abrasion resistance of the coating was observed (vs. G297).
RD-26,153 CA 02238208 1998-05-21
-17-
Chemical reactions take place during the deposition process.
Possible reactions include oxidation and polymerization. The
oxidation reaction is encouraged by the presence of oxygen in the
plasma. With an increase in oxygen-to-siloxane ratio in the feed, the
coating deposited showed an increased oxygen content and a
decreased carbon content as measured by X-ray photoelectron
spectroscopy. Beyond a certain oxygen-to-siloxane ratio, totally
inorganic oxide coatings were obtained. For oxygen to HMDSO ratio
of about 5:1 produced an essentially carbon-free coating of silicon
oxide.
Polymerization of siloxane is a competing chemical reaction
which can form a clear adherent coating from siloxane alone in the
absence of oxygen. Plasma assisted polymerization of siloxane is
also well documented in the PECVD literature. In the presence of
oxygen, however, oxidation be the dominant reaction in the
formation of silicon oxide and consumption of siloxane.
It is believed that chemical reactions occur in the gas phase,
but it is also possible that the reaction continues at the surface of the
substrate. Chemical reactions require the collision of reactants.
Therefore, the higher the pressure the higher the probability of
reaction. The pressure along the plasma channel drops from above
200 torr at the argon inlet to as low as 0.03 torr in the chamber, with
major transition taking place in the arc and the nozzle-injector. The
reaction zone is therefore primarily in the nozzle-injector,
downstream from the injection point of siloxane. The substrate
surface is another place where collision of species occurs.
The argon plasma contributes to the activation of oxygen and
siloxane. The arc is known for its high plasma density and ionization
efficiency, and is generally referred to as a thermal plasma
approaching local thermodynamic equilibrium.
RD-26,153 CA 02238208 1998 -05 -21
-18-
Table 7. Typical Abrasion-Resistant Coatings on Polycarbonate with
Hardcoat
Run no. G95 G202 G265 G255 G297
Apparatus
Arca 8C(4mm) 8C(4mm) 3D(3,4,5mm) 3D(3,4,5mm) 1D(2-5mm)
Nozzle-
injectorb 25- 2-stage 25- 4"conic 40- 4"conic 40- 4"conic 40- 4"trombone
Operating conditions
Vvbr" 38 25.5 23 25.5 25.5
dstar>oec (an)
Substrate. 25 80 80 80 80
temp (-C)
Arc current 61 60 61 60 60
(A)
Arc voltage 77 77 42 42 30
M
Pressure 0.17 0.16 0.11 0.14 0.03
(torr)
Siloxane HMDSO TMDSO TMDSO D4 D4
used
Flow rate
(I/min)
Ar/02/
siloxaned 2/0.62/0.12 1.5/0.8/0.18 1/0.4/0.14 1/0.8/(80 -C) 1.5/0.8/(80 -C)
Results
Dep. ra6ee 8 12 8 21 14
04Tn)
CoAhg area <10 10 >40 >40 >40
(a,ndia)
Thidmesse ( m) 1.4 2.0 1.3 1.8 2.0
Coating performance
AHaze at 1,000 3.5 2.9 3.7 3.9 1.6
Taber
cycles (CS-1 OF)
Water soak (65 - pass pass pass pass
-C, 10 day)
Thermal cycling - pass pass pass pass
a The 8C(4mm) is a 8-plate arc with a 4mm cylindrical arc channel. The
3D(3,4,5mm) is a 3-plate arc with a stepwise expanding channel at 3, 4, and 5
RD-26,153 CA 02238208 1998-05-21
-19-
mm. The 1D(2-5mm) is a 1-plate arc with a divergent arc channel expanding from
2 to 5 mm in diameter.
b A nozzle-injector may consist of a main body with 2 shower injection
rings, an adapter to the anode with or without an oxygen slit injector, and an
extension that expands toward the substrate. The 25- 2-stage is a nozzle-
injector
with an anode adapter expanding from 4 to 11 mm, followed by a cylindrical
section at 11 mm dia, and a main body expanding at 25o. The 25=-4inch conic is
a
nozzle-injector expanding at a total angle of 25o throughout, with an anode
adapter
with oxygen injection and a conic extension 4" long. The 40--4 inch conic is a
nozzle-injector expanding at 40o throughout, with an anode adapter with oxygen
injection and a conic extension 4 inches long. The 40--4 inch trombone is a
nozzle-injector similar to the 40--4"conic except that the extension flares
out more
by using a 4 inch section cut out from a trombone.
C Working distance is the distance from anode to substrate.
d D4 flow rate was not measured but was controlled by keeping the liquid
temperature constant at 80 -C.
e Average of 10 cm diameter area at center.
