Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02249429 1998-09-18
WO 97/35124 PCT/US97/02333
A HYBRID ELASTOMER-AND-METAL SPRZ1VG ISOLATOR
Background and Summary of the Invention
This invention is directed to a novel vibration isolator. More
particularly, the present invention is directed to a hybrid elastomeric-and-
metal spring vibration isolator with a low natural frequency at its rated
load.
While this isolator may be considered for any of a number of
general applications, it has particular advantages in mounting large diesel
IO engines in such a way as to minimize/eliminate transmission of low
frequency vibrations of the engine to its support structure. Specific
applications of such diesel engines include, but are not limited to,
locomotive engines and diesel engines on fishing boats.
It is the current practice in mounting large diesel engines, which;
in some cases, with associated driven gear units, generators and auxiliary
equipment, can weigh up to thirty tons, to produce a support deck that has
positive camber (i.e., is bowed upwardly in the middle). This is to offset the
vertical deflection that takes place when the engine assembly is positioned
on them. This positive camber significantly complicates the preparation of
support pads for the engine assembly. The platform must be deflected to its
final curvature before the pads can be machined. Equipment and tools to
facilitate such mounting pad preparation are heavy, complex and
expensive. Further, the process using this equipment is time consuming
and labor intensive, requiring as much as several days time to complete.
Some installations use elastomeric mounts for the engine assembly
with natural frequencies of 7Hz, or higher. Since large diesel engines have
operational speeds in the 200-2000 rpm range, idle excitations will generally
fall in the 6-10 Hz range. Since the natural frequency of the mounting
system lies in the range of idle speed excitations for such engines,
excitation of the suspension at its natural frequency (resonance) can occur
when the diesel engine is at idle. Resonant operation does not merely result
in full transmission of the engine's vibration to the support, as would result
from hard mounting the engine directly thereto but, rather, can actually
CA 02249429 1998-09-18
WO 97/35124 PCT/US97/02333
amplify the vibrational excitation up to ten times the response level of a
hard mounted engine assembly. Obviously, such amplification can have
undesirable effects and it is an important design consideration to try to
move the natural frequency of the system outside the operating frequency of
the engine or, if that is not possible, to a frequency (e.g., 3-5 Hz) through
which the engine quickly passes during startup to prevent the build up of
destructive harmonic vibrations.
Elastomeric isolators which could produce natural frequencies in
the 3-5 Hz range have high static deflection and associated creep and drift
that makes them unsuitable for some diesel engine applications where only
minor (one inch or less) relative displacement can be tolerated due to
connections to associated upstream and downstream hardware (e.g., air
inlet ducts, exhaust ducts, fuel lines, auxiliary electrical power
connections, compressed air lines). Further exacerbating the problem is
the fact that the manner in which these conventional elastomeric blocks are
mounted on the platform and attached to the engine assembly makes it
difficult to focalize or semi-focalize the mount. Without some form of
focalization in a low frequency suspension, the lateral translational and
rotational modes of response will normally be coupled (due to the
positioning of the mounts well below the center of gravity of the assembly)
resulting in even greater undesired rocking motion of the engine.
The hybrid elastomer-and-metal spring vibration isolator of the
present invention provides an isolation system with a low natural frequency
(e.g., 3-5 Hz). This isolator comprises an elastomeric sandwich mount
having a large elastomeric section bonded to first lower and second upper
metal plates. The elastomeric section has a plurality of cored out pockets
that receive helical metal springs. The upper and lower plates have
cavities molded into them, the cavities extending into the cored out pockets
through the center of the springs. The protruding end surface of the
cavities are coated with a layer of elastomer which serves to provide
cushioned snubbing in the compressive direction. The coil springs react
against the nether (i.e., underneath) surfaces of the upper and lower
plates, with a protective bearing seat being provided for the upper plate to
protect the elastomer bonded thereto. The coil springs are designed with
initial preload to fully support the static weight of the supported device so
2
CA 02249429 1998-09-18
WO 97/35124 PCT/US97/02333
the elastomer experiences only dynamic loading. This significantly
extends the service life of the isolator by reducing dynamic stress/strain
levels on the elastomer.
A tension bolt with a length that exceeds the normal distance
between the cavities of the upper and lower plates is equipped with a pair of
load-transferring metal washers which engage elastomer-coated snubbing
surfaces which, in turn, serve to provide cushioned snubbing of relative
movement between upper and lower plates of the sandwich mount in the
expansion direction. In addition, the interior coated surfaces reduce sound
from metal-to-metal contact that would otherwise result between the
tension bolt and the bare surfaces of the cavities. This tension bolt and its
associated securement nut provide a first level of coil spring
precompression restraint for the isolator, as well as limit the extension
relative deflection, and hold the assembly together. A special retaining nut
which engages a protruding end of the tension bolt preloads the metal
springs to a second higher level of precompression which is substantially
equal to the static load carried by the isolator. This retaining nut is
designed to be removed prior to installation of the engine on the isolator
platform.
Various other features, advantages and characteristics of the
present invention will become apparent after a reading of the following
specification.
3
CA 02249429 1998-09-18
WO 97/35124 PCT/US97/02333
Brief Description of the Drawings
The preferred embodiments are described in detail in conjunction
with the following figures, like reference numerals representing like
elements.
Fig. 1A is a cross-sectional side view of a hybrid elastomer-and-metal
spring vibration isolator as seen along line A-A of Fig. 1C;
Fig. 1B is a cross-sectional end view of the isolator as seen along line B-
B of Fig. 1 C;
Fig. 1C is a top view of the isolator of Fig. 1A;
Fig. 2 is a side view of the isolation system of the present invention
supporting a diesel engine; and
Fig. 3 is an end view of the isolation system with engine in place in
accordance with Fig. 2.
Detailed Description of the Preferred Embodiments
A first preferred embodiment of the hybrid elastomer-and-metal
spring vibration isolator is shown in Figs. 1A, 1B and 1C generally at 20.
As best seen in Fig. 1A, isolator 20 comprises a sandwich mount 22
composed of a large elastomeric section 24 positioned between first lower
metal plate 26L and second upper metal plate 26U. Plates 26L and 26U are
preferably bonded to the lower and upper surfaces, respectively, of
elastomeric section 24.
Elastomeric section 24 has a plurality of cored out pockets 28 shown
in Fig. 1A as being three in number. The actual number of pockets may
vary between two and five, depending of the particular needs of the
application, three being preferred for this particular usage. The shape of
pockets 28 is generally frustoconical, tapering outwardly from top to bottom.
It is envisioned that for some applications, pockets 28 may, alternatively,
have a cylindrical configuration. The first plurality of pockets 28 receive a
4
CA 02249429 1998-09-18
WO 97/35124 PCT/US97l02333
second like plurality of helical metal springs 30 which react between the
nether surfaces of plates 26L and 26U. A radiused spring seat 31 is
provided to prevent the coil spring 30 from initiating a stress crack in
elastomeric section 24. The coil springs 30 are designed to fully support the
static load of the supported member, in the case of a diesel engine assembly,
the thirty ton weight (typical) of that system. Elastomer in section 24 sees
no static load which significantly reduces the strain load extending the
useful life of the elastomer.
In the application where the vibration isolator 20 is used as part of a
system to mount a large diesel engine, by lowering the system's natural
frequency (SNF) to a range of between 3 and 5 Hz, the SNF is removed from
the idle speed range of the diesel engine to a speed range that the engine
moves rapidly through during start up. This essentially eliminates the
possibility of sustained system resonance and the destructive build up of
I5 forces which can be associated therewith.
Lower and upper plates 26L and 26U have a plurality of extruded
cavities 32 which are received in pockets 28 inside springs 30. Cavities 32U
are shown being cast integrally with plate 26U while cavities 32L are
formed separately from plate 26L and their flanges 36L are received within
depressions 34 so flanges 36L are flush with the outer surface of plate 26L.
Cavities 32 are shown as being frustoconical but, in certain applications,
could be cylindrical. The frustoconical shape is preferred for minimizing
part contact during relative movement of associated parts. The protruding
ends of cavities 32L and 32U have a layer (38L, 38U) of elastomer bonded
thereto to provide cushioned snubbing of compressive movement. The first
stage of compressive motion will be damped by the hybrid elastomer-and-
metal spring 20, with some energy being dissipated as heat but the majority
of the energy being returned to the system through the restorative action of
the hybrid spring. Should the jostling or vibration of the engine cause
downward movement of upper plate 26U toward lower plate 26L in excess of
the design maximum, by way of example, 3/8 inch, elastomer layers 38L
and 38U will cushion the snubbing action of the opposed protruding ends of
cavities 32L and 32U minimizing the shock or concussion impact of the
interface, and limiting total vertical deflection to about 1/2 inch.
5
CA 02249429 1998-09-18
WO 97/35124 PCT/US97/02333
A plurality of tension bolts 40 extend through holes in the end of
cavities 32 and secure separable lower cavities 32L to the isolator assembly
20. Double securing nuts 42 are threaded on to bolts to a particular design
distance from the bolt head 41. This distance establishes a maximum
expansion distance for the isolator assembly 20 and will be associated with
a certain level of preload for the coil springs 30. A pair of steel washers
44I.
and 44U are used to limit movement of the plate 26U in the extension
direction. The interior of cavities 32L, 32U are coated with an elastomeric
layer 46 to provide cushioning for the snubbing performed by washers 44L
and 44U as they limit relative movement in the extension direction. Should
the supported member cause plate 26U to move beyond the design distance,
for example, 1/2 inch upwardly, each washer 44L and 44U will contact its
respective coating 46 thereby cushioning the snubbing of this relative
movement. Further, the longitudinal periphery of lower plate 26L is
provided with a pair of reinforcing ribs 45 which resist flexing of the lower
plate 26L when the isolator 20 is subjected to upward (extension) loads. I n
addition, coating 46 prevents clatter from metal-to-metal contact between
the bolt head 41 or securing nuts 42 with the interior of cavities 32L and
32U, respectively.
Preload retention nuts 48 are attached to the portions of bolts 40
extending beyond securing nuts 42. Each retention nut 48 is formed with a
pilot 49 on its plate-engaging surface to facilitate centering in cavity 32U.
When engaged, retention nuts 48 fully preload coil springs 30 to a level
between 50% and 100% of the static load the isolator 20 will undergo. Once
isolators 20 are in position on and secured to deck 11 (Fig. 3) by bolts (not
shown) through holes 50 in lower plate 26L so that cavities 32L cannot be
displaced, retention nuts 48 are removed. Spring isolator 20 will expand as
far as securing nuts 42 allow, due to the force stored in coil springs 30,
from
the first level of preload (most preferably, an amount equal to the entire
static load) to a second lesser level of preload determined by the position of
securing nuts 42 on bolts 40. The supported member 13 will then be
positioned on the isolator assemblies 20 and secured thereto by bolting into
holes 52 in upper plate 26U. The isolators 20 return to their fully loaded
positions. As mentioned earlier, this leaves the elastomeric sections 2r1
without any static load (fizlly unloaded).
6
CA 02249429 1998-09-18
WO 97/35124 PCT/US97/02333
Figs. 2 and 3 depict a plurality of pairs of isolators 20 used to
suspend a 30 ton diesel engine assembly 13. Such large engines are used in
locomotive and marine applications. The longitudinal axes, or force
reaction lines, of the isolators will normally be inclined from the vertical
by
an amount of between 20 and 30° (Fig. 3) to semi-focalize the isolator
force
reaction lines thereby decoupling the translational and rotational modes of
response. Full focalization requires the force reaction lines to be tilted
relative to the fore-and-aft and lateral axes, as well, to decouple all three
rotational modes from their respective translational modes. In this
instance, only semi-focalization is needed and, so the reaction lines are
tilted relative to the vertical axis only causing the lateral vibrational
motion
of the diesel engine 13 to be decoupled from the rolling response about its
longitudinal axis. Isolators 20 are positioned on either side of the engine
longitudinal centerline in opposing pairs, shown in Fig. 2 as utilizing five
pairs of isolators. The number required will vary with the particular
engine 13. The upper surface 27 of upper plate 26U has an angle of incline
equal to that of the focalization angle such that surface 2? will extend
horizontally to engage the lower surface of a mounting wing 15 of engine 13.
The tapped holes 52 will be drilled into top plate 26U at a complementary
angle so that the attachment bolts (not shown) can be vertically threaded
into them securing wing 15 to isolator 20.
In essence, the supported engine 13 floats on the hybrid elastomer-
and-metal spring isolator 20 with the elastomer 24 and coil spring 30 free to
dynamically react vibrational forces, such that little, if any, vibration is
transmitted across the isolator and, should any vibrations be so transmitted
as a result of engagement of either the compressive or extension snubbers,
such engagement is cushioned. Compression snubbers, in the form of
elastomeric cushioning layers 38L and 38U on protruding ends of cavities
32L and 32U respectively, along with extension snubbers in the form of
tension bolts 40 cushioned by metal washers 44L and 44U engaging
elastomeric layers 46, limit actual total excursion of the engine 13 to ~1/2
inch, or whatever other level of limited motion is desired. The isolation of
assembly 20 is further enhanced by providing a design natural frequency in
the range of three to five Hz., a range through which the engine mounted
thereupon on briefly transitions during warm up, eliminating the
destructive build up of resonant vibrations.
7
CA 02249429 1998-09-18
WO 97/35124 PCT/US97l02333
Various changes, alternatives and modifications will be apparent to
one of ordinary skill in the art following a reading of the foregoing
description. It is intended that all such changes, alternatives and
modifications as fall within the scope of the appended claims be considered
part of the present invention.
8
