Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 022~81~ 1998-11-19
WO 97/48345 PCT/GB97/01631
UNDERWA7'ER TREATMENTS
This invention relates to an electrosur~ical instrument for the Ireatment of tissue in the
S presence of an electricallv-collductive fluid medium. to electrosurvical apparatus including
such an instrument. and to an electrode unit for use in such an instrument.
Endoscopic electrosuroery is useful for treatin~ tissue in cavities of the body~ and is
normally perfonned in the presence of a distension medium. ~'hen the distension medium
10 is a iiquid. this is commonly referred to as under~ater electrosur~ery. this term denoting
electrosur_ery hl whicll li\in~l tissue is treated usin(~ an electrosur~ical instrument ~vith a
treatment electrode or electrodes immersed hl liguid at the operation site. A ~Jaseous
medium is commonl! employed when endoscopic sur-~,erv is performed in a distensible
body cavit! of lar(Jer potential v olume in which a liguid medium would be unsuitable, as
15 is often the case in laparoscopic or ~astroenterolo~ical sur~ery
Underwater sur~ery is commonly performed usin~!~ endoscopic techniques, in which the
endoscope itself may provide a conduit (commonlv referred to as a ~ orkin~ channel) for
the passa~!~e of an electrode .~.lternativelv. the endoscope may be specifically adapted (as
~0 in a resectoscope) no include means t'or mountin(!~ an electrode. or the electrode mav be
introduced hlto a body cavit! ~ ia a separate access mealls at an an~!~le with respect to the
endoscope - a technigue commonly referred to as trian~!~ulation These variations in
technigue can be subdivided by sur~ical specialitv, where one or other of the techniques
has panicular advanta~es oiven the access route to the specific bod!~ cavity. Endoscopes
~5 with inte~ral wor~;in(!~ channels or those characterised as resectoscopes, are ~Jenerally
employed when the body cavity may be accessed throu~,h a natural body openin~ such
as the cervical canal to access the endometrial cavity of the uterus, or the urethra to access
the prostate ~land and the bladder Endoscopes specifically desi~ned for use in the
endometrial ca~ity are referred to as hysteroscopes~ and those desi~ned for use in the
30 urinar~ tract include cystoscopes. urethroscopes and resectoscopes. The procedures of
transurethal resection o r v aporisation of the prostate ~Jland are known as TURP and EVAP
CA 022~81~ 1998-11-19
WO 97/4834S PCT/GB97/01631
respectively. When there is no natural body openinlg through which an endoscope may be
passed. the technique of triangulation is commonly employed. Triangulation is commonly
used during underwater endoscopic surgery on joint cavities such as the knee and the
shoulder. The endoscope used in these procedures is commonly referred to as an
S arthroscope.
Electrosur~ery is usually carried out using either a monopolar instrument or a bipolar
instrument. With monopolar electrosurgery, an active electrode is used in the operating
region, and a conductive return plate is secured to the patient's skin. ~ ith this
10 arrangement, current passes fi om the active electrode throug~h the patient's tissues to the
external return plate Since the patient represents a significant portion of the circuit~ input
power levels have to be hi~gll (typically 150 to 250 watts)~ to compensate for the resistive
current limitin, of the patient's tissues and, in the case of underwater electrosurgery,
power losses due to the fluid medium which is rendered partially conductive by the
15 presence of blood or other body fluids. Using high power with a monopolar arrangement
is also hazardous, due to the tissue heating that occurs at the return plate, which can cause
severe skin burns. There is also the risk of capacitive coupling between the instrument and
patient tissues at the entry point into the body cavity
~0 With bipolar electrosur~ery~ a pair of electrodes (an active electrode and a return
electrode) are used toL~ether at the tissue application site. This arrangement has advantages
from the satety standpoint~ due to the relative proximity of the two electrodes so that radio
frequency currents are limited to the region between the electrodes. However, the depth
of effect is directly related to the distance between the two electrodes; and, in applications
25 requiring very small electrodes, the inter-electrode spacing becomes very smalL thereby
limiting tissue effect and the output power. Spacing the electrodes further apart would
often obscure vision of the application site, and would require a modification in surgical
technique to ensure direct contact of both electrodes with the tissue.
30 There are a number of variations to the basic design of the bipolar probe. For example,
U S. Patent Specification No.47066G7 describes one of the fundamentals of the design,
CA 022~81~ 1998-11-19
WO 97/48345 PCT/GBg7/01631
namely that the ratio of the contact areas of the return electrode and of the active electrode
is greater than 7:1 and smaller than 20:1 for cutting purposes. This range relates onlv to
cutting electrode configurations. When a bipolar instrument is used for desiccation or
coagulation~ the ratio of the contact areas of the two electrodes may be reduced to
S approximately 1:1 to avoid differential electrical stresses occurring at the contact bet~veen
the tissue and the electrode.
The electrical junction between the return electrode and tissue can be supported by wetting
of the tissue by a conductive solution such as normal saline. This ensures that the surgical
10 effect is limited to the needle or active electrode, with the electric circuit between the two
electrodes being completed by the tissue. One of the obvious limitations with the design
is that the needle must be completely buried in the tissue to enable the return electrode to
complete the circuit. Another problem is one of the orientation: even a relatively small
change in application angle from the ideal perpendicular contact with respect to the tissue
15 surface, will change the contact area ratio, so that a surgical effect can occur in the tissue
in contact with the return electrode.
Cavity distension provides space for gaining access to the operation site, to improve
vic~ tion, and to allow for manipulation of instruments. In low volume body cavities~
20 particularlv where it is desirable to distend the cavitv under higJher pressure, liquid rather
than gas is more commonly used due to better optical characteristics, and because it
washes blood away from the operative site.
Conventional underwater electrosurgery has been performed using a non-conductive liquid
5 (such as 1.5% glycine) as an irrigant, or as a distension medium to eliminate electrical
conduction losses. Glycine is used in isotonic concentrations to prevent osmotic changes
in the blood when intra-vascular absorption occurs. In the course of an operation, veins
may be severed, with resultant infusion of the liquid into the circulation, which could cause
among other thin~s, a dilution of serum sodium which can lead to a condition known as
30 water intoxication.
CA 022~81~ 1998-11-19
W O 97/48345 PCT/GB97/01631
The applicants have found that it is possible to use a conductive liquid medium, such as
normal saline, in underwater endoscopic electrosurgery in place of non-conductive,
electrolyte-free solutions. Normal saline is the preferred distension medium in under~,vater
endoscopic surgery when electrosurgery is not contemplated~ or a non-electrical tissue
S effect such as laser treatment is being used. Although normal saline (0.9%w/v, I SOmmol/l)
has an electrical conductivity somewhat greater than that of most body tissue, it has the
advantage that displacement by absorption or extra~asation from the operative site
produces little physiological effect, and the so-called water intoxication effects of non-
conductive, electrolyte-free solutions are avoided.
Tl1e applicants have developed a bipolar instrument suitable for undenvater electrosurgery
using a conductive liguid or gaseo-ls medium This electrosurgical instrument for the
treatment of tissue in the presence of a fluid medium~ comprises an instrument body having
a handpiece and an instrument shaft, and an electrode assembly at one end of the shaft The
15 electrode assembly comprises a tissue treatment electrode which is exposed at the extreme
distai end of the instrument, and a return electrode which is electrically insulated from the
tissue treatment electrode and has a fluid contact surface spaced proximally from the
exposed part of the tissue treatment electrode. In use of the instrument, the tissue
treatment electrode is applied to the tissue to be treated whilst the return electrode, being
~0 spaced proximally from the exposed part of the tissue treatment electrode, is normally
spaced from the tissue and serves to complete an electrosurgical current loop from the
tissue treatment electrode through tl1e tissue and the fluid medium. This electrosurgical
instrument is described h1 the specification of our European Patent Application
969 1 87~6. 1 .
The electrode structure of this instrument, in combination with an electrically-conductive
fluid medium, largely avoids the problems experienced with monopolar or bipolar
electrosurgery. In particular~ input power levels are much lower than those generally
necessary with a monopolar arrangement (typically l O0 watts). Moreover, because of the
30 relatively large spacing beh~een its electrodes~ an improved depth of effect is obtained
compared with conventional bipolar arrangements.
CA 022~81~ 1998-11-19
Wo 97/48345 PCT/Gs97/0l63
An arthroscope electrode may be characterised as short ( 100 to 140 mm), and rigid with
a working diameter up to S mm. It can be introduced through a stab incision into a joint
cavity (with or without a cannula) using the triangulation technique Such an electrode is
operated with a motion which moves the electrode between the 9 O'Clock and 3 O'Clock
~ S positions on the arthroscopic image. As a result, the tissue to be treated is usually
approached at a shallow working angle with respect to the axis of the electrode. An
arthroscopic electrode thus needs to have an effect consistent with this angled approach
to the tissue. The tissue to be treated, such as meniscal cartilage, is commonly dense and
of a high electrical impedance. An arthroscope electrode requires output power and
10 voltage settings that reflect the type of tissue being treated, the size of electrode, and the
fact that arthroscopists are seeking a speed of effect comparable to that of the mechanical
shaver devices they currently employ, albeit with an electrode of smaller dimensions than
a shaver blade for improved access Joint spaces are commonly small (the joint spaces in
the knee being typically 60 to 100 mls under fluid distension), and tissue often needs
15 mechanical manipulation Known monopolar arthroscopic electrode configurations,
therefore, are of a rigid construction, having angled hook or probe-tip configurations to
produce cutting of high impedance tissue, and to connect to an ergonomic handpiece to
aid tissue manipulation.
20 The aim of the invention is to provide an improved electrosurgical instrument of this type
The present invention provides an electrosurgical instrument for the treatment of tissue in
the presence of an electrically-conductive fluid medium, the instrument comprising an
instrument shaft, and an electrode assembly at one end of the shaft, the electrode assembly
25 comprising a tissue treatment electrode and a return electrode ~vhich is electrically
in~ ted from the tissue treatment electrode by means of an insulation member, the tissue
treatment electrode having an exposed end extending laterally through a cut-out provided
in the insulation member at the distal end portion of the instrument, and the return
electrode having a fluid contact surface which overlies the insulation member in the region
30 of the cut-out, said fluid contact surface being spaced from the tissue treatment electrode
CA 022~81~ 1998-11-19
WO 97/48345 PCT/GB97/01631
in such a manner as to define, in use, a conductive fluid path that completes an electrical
circuit between the tissue treatment electrode and the return electrode.
The invention also provides an electrosurgical instrument for the treatment of tissue in the
5 presence of an electrically-conductive fluid medium, the instrument comprising an
instrument shaft, and an electrode assembly at one end of the shaft. the electrode assembly
comprising a tissue treatment electrode and a return electrode which is electrically
insulated from the tissue treatment electrode by means of an insuiation member, the tissue
treatment electrode having an exposed end extending laterally through a cut-out provided
l O in the insulation member~ wherein the return electrode has a distal end portion with a fluid
contact surface which overlies the insulation member in the region of the cut-out and faces
laterally in a first direction, and wherein the insulation member projects laterally outwardly
between said distal end portion and the tissue treatment electrode, the tissue treatment
electrode facing laterally in a second direction opposite to said first direction.
The laterally-projecting part of the insulation member increases the conductive fluid path
length from the tissue treatment electrode to the return electrode, and forces the electric
field outwardly, thereby preventin~ preferential arcing between the return electrode and
the nearest part of tlle tissue treatment electrode and promoting arcing between the tissue
20 treatment electrode and the neighbourillg tissue
The return electrode is spaced from the tissue treatment electrode so that, in use, it does
not contact the tissue to be treated, and so that the electrical circuit is always completed
by the conductive fluid, and not simply by arcing between the electrodes. Indeed, the
25 arrangement is such that arcing between ad~acent parts of the electrode assembly is
avoided, thereby ensuring that the tissue treatment electrode can become enveloped in a
vapour pocket so that tissue entering the vapour pocket becomes the preferred path for
current to flow bacl; to the return electrode via the conductive fluid.
30 The electrosurgical instrument of the invention is useful for dissection, resection,
vaporisation. desiccation and coagulation of tissue, as well as for combinations of these
CA 022~81~ 1998-11-19
WO 97/48345 PCT/GB97/01631
functions. It has a particular application in arthroscopic surgery as it pertains to
endoscopic and percutaneous procedures performed on joints of the body includin~, but
not limited to~ such techniques as they apply to the spine and other non-synovial joints.
Arthroscopic operative procedures may include: partial or complete meniscectomv of the
~ 5 knee joint including~ meniscal cystectomy; lateral retinacular release of the knee joint;
removal of anterior and posterior cruciate ligaments or remnants thereof~ labral tear
resection acromioplasty, bursectomy and subacromial decompression of the shoulder joint;
anterior release of the temperomandibular joint: synovectomy, cartilage debridement,
chondroplasty division of intra-articular adhesions, fracture and tendon debridement as
10 applied to any of tlle synovial joints of the body, inducin~ thermal shrinkage of joint
capsules as a treatment for recurrent dislocation, subluxation or repetitive stress injury to
any articulated joint of the body; discectomy either in the treatment of a disc prolapse or
as part of a spinal fusion via a posterior or anterior approach to the cervical, thoracic and
lumbar spine or any other fibrous joint for similar purposes, excision of diseased tissue; and
I S haemostasis.
The instrument of the invention is also useful for dissection~ resection, vaporisation,
desiccation and coagulation of tissue, as well as combinations of these functions, with
particular application in uroloSgical endoscopic (urethroscopy, cystoscopy, ureteroscopy
~0 and nephroscopy) and percutaneous surger)~ Urological procedures may include electro-
vaporisation of the prostate ~land (EVAP) and other variants of the procedure commonly
referred to as transurethral resection of the prostate (TURP) including, but not limited to,
interstitial ablation of the prostate gland by a percutaneous or perurethral route whether
performed for benign or malignant disease, transurethral or percutaneous resection of
urinary tract tumours as they may arise as primary or secondary neoplasms, and further as
they may arise anvwhere in the urological tract from the calyces of the kidney to the
external urethral meatus, division of strictures as they may arise at the pelviureteric
junction (PUJ). ureter, ureteral orifice, bladder neck or urethra, correction of ureterocoele;
shrinkage of bladder diverticular, cystoplasty procedures as they pertain to corrections of
30 voiding dysfunction, thermally induced shrinka~e of the pelvic floor as a corrective
treatment for bladder neck descent; excision of diseased tissue, and haemostasis
. . . ~ .
CA 022~81~ 1998-11-19
WO 97/48345 PCT/GB97/01631
Surgical procedures using the electrosurgical instrument of the invention may also include
introducing the electrode assembly to the surgical site, ~vllether through an artificial
conduit (a cannula) or a natural conduit, which may be in an anatomical body cavity or
space, or one created surgically. The cavity or space may be distended during the
S procedure using a fluid, or may be naturally held open by anatomical structures. The
surgical site may be bathed in a continuous flow of conductive tluid such as saline solution
either to fill and distend the cavity, or to create a locallv-irrigated environment around the
tip of the electrode assembly in a gas filled cavity. The irrioating fluid may be aspirated
from the surgical site to remove products created by application of the RF energy, tissue
10 debris or blood. Tlle procedures may include simultaneous viewing of the site via an
endoscope, or using an indirect visualisation means. An irri~ated bipolar electrosurgical
instrument is described in the specification of our International Patent Application
GB96/0 1 472
15 Advantageously, the exposed end of the tissue treatment electrode is constituted by a
plurality of tissue contact filamentary members made of an electrically-conductive material,
the filamentary members being electrically connected to a common electrical supply
conductor.
20 In a preferred embodiment~ a single coiled filament constitutes the filamentary members,
the coils of the filament constitutin~ the filamentary members. The filament may have a
diameter Iyin~ in the range of from 0.05 mm to 0 5 mm.
In another preferred embodiment~ a plurality of separate, individual fil~m~nt~ constitute the
25 fil~ment~ry members. The filaments may each have a length Iving within the range of from
0.5 mm to 5 mm, and a diameter Iying within the range offrom 0.05 mm to 0.5mm.
Preferably, the filamentary members are made of tungsten, or of an alloy of tungsten or
platinum.
Alternatively, the exposed end of the tissue contact electrode is constituted by a mesh.
CA 022~81~ 1998-11-19
Wo 97/48345 PCT/GB97/0163
Preferably, the instrument further comprises suction means for applying a sub-atmospheric
pressure to the interior of the insulation member, whereby vapour bubbles produced in the
region of the tissue treatment electrode are evacuated via the interior of the instrument.
Advantageously, the cut-out is formed in a lateral surface of the insulation member
adjacent to the distal end thereof In this case, the instrument can be used as a side-effect
instrument. Alternatively, the cut-out is formed obliquely across the distal end face of the
insulation member, whereby the e~posed end of the tissue treatment electrode has both an
10 axially-facing tissue contact portion and a laterally-facing tissue contact portion. In this
case, the instrument can be used as both an end-et'fect instrument and as a side-effect
instrument .
Advantageously, the dimensions and configuration of the tissue treatment electrode, the
l 5 fluid contact surface and the insulation member are such that, when the electrode assembly
is immersed in a conductive fluid medium, the ratio of (i) the length of the shortest
conductive path through the fluid medium between the fluid contact surface and that part
of the tissue treatment electrode which is furthest from the fluid contact surface, to (ii) the
length ofthe shortest conduction path through the fluid medium bet~een the fluid contact
20 surface and the tissue treatment electrode is at most 2 to l.
Preferably~ the laterally-projecting portion of the insulation member defines an insulation
barrier to divert electrical current flow through the fluid medium thereby to increase said
shortest conduction path lengtll between the fluid contact surface and the tissue treatment
~5 electrode. The first direction may define a treatment axis, and said two shortest conductive
paths may lie in a common plane containing the treatment axis.
The invention also provides an electrode unit for an electrosurgical instrument for the
treatment of tissue in the presence of an electrically-conductive fluid medium, the electrode
30 unit comprising a shaft having at one end means for connection to an instrument handpiece,
and, mounted on the other end of the shaft, an electrode assemblv comprising a tissue
CA 022~81~ 1998-11-19
wO 97/48345 PCT/GB97/01631
treatment electrode and a return electrode which is electrically insulated from the tissue
treatment eiectrode by means of an insulation member, the tissue treatment electrode
having an exposed end extending laterally through a cut-out provided in the insulation
member, and the return electrode having a fluid contact surface which overlies the
S insulation member in the region of the cut-out, said fluid contact surface being spaced from
the tissue treatment electrode in such a manner as to define, in use, a conductive fluid path
that completes an electrical circuit between the tissue treatment electrode and the return
electrode.
10 The invention further provides electrosurgical apparatus comprising a radio frequency
generator and an electrosurgical instrument for tlle treatment of tissue in the presence of
an electrically-conductive fluid medium. the instrument comprising an instrument shaft. and
an electrode assembly at one end of the shaft, the electrode assembly comprising a tissue
treatment electrode and a return electrode which is electrically insulated from the tissue
15 treatment electrode by means of an insulation member, the tissue treatment electrode
having an exposed end extending laterally throu~h a cut-out provided in the insulation
member at the distal end portion of the instrument, the return electrode having a fluid
contact surface which overlies the insulation member in the region of the cut-out, -and the
radio freguency generator havillg a bipolar output connected to the electrodes, said fluid
20 contact surface bein(l spaced from the tissue treatment electrode in such a manner as to
define, in use, a conductive fluid path that completes an elecrical circuit between the tissue
treatment electrode and the return electrode.
Advantageously, the radio frequency generator includes control means for varying the
25 output power delivered to the electrodes. The control means may be such as to provide
output power in first and second output ranges. the first output range being for powering
the electrosurgical instrument for tissue desiccation and the second output range being for
powering the electrosurgical instrument for tissue removal by cutting or vaporisation.
Conveniently, the first output range is from about 150 volts to 200 volts, and the second
30 output range is from about '50 volts to 600 volts, the voltages being peak voltages.
CA 022~S81~ 1998-11-19
wO 97/48345 PCT/GB97/01631
Preferably, the control means is such as to alternate the output power between first and
second powers in the first and second output ranges. Alternatively, the control means is
such as to pulse the output power at a power within the second output range.
5 The invention will now be described in greater detail, by way of example, with reference
to the drawimrs, in which -
Figure I is a diagram showing an electrosurgical apparatus constructed in accordancewith the invention;
Figures 2 to 6 are diagrammatic side elevations of tlle electrode assemblies of five forms
of electrode unit constructed in accordance with the invention~
Figure 7 is a perspective view of a modified form of the electrode assembly of Figure 3,
Figure 8 is a perspective view of part of the assembly of Figure 7; and
Figure 9 is a cross-section ta~;en on the lines A-A of Figure 7.
20 Each of the electrode units described below is intended to be used with a conductive
distension medium such as normal saline, and each unit has a dual-electrode structure, with
the conductive medium acting as a conductor between the tissue being treated and one of
the electrodes. hereinafter called the return electrode. The other electrode is applied
directly to the tissue and is hereinafter called the tissue treatment (active) electrode. In
25 many cases. the use of a liquid distension medium is preferable~ as it prevents excessive
electrode temperatures in most circumstances, and largely eliminates tissue sticking.
Referring to the drawings, Figure l shows electrosurgical apparatus including a generator
I having an output socliet ~ providing a radio frequency (RF) output for an instrument in
30 the form of a handpiece 3 via a connection cord 4. Activation of the generator I may be
performed from the handpiece ~ via a control connection in the cord 4, or by means of a
CA 022~81~ 1998-11-19
WO 97/48345 PcT/Gs97/0I63
footswitch unit 5, as shown, connected separatelv to the rear of the generator I by a
footswitch connection cord 6. In the illustrated embodiment, the footswitch unit S has two
footswitches Sa and Sb for selectina a desiccation mode and a vaporisation mode ofthe
generator 1 respectively. The generator front panel has push buttons 7a and 7b for
5 respectively settin~ desiccation and vaporisation power levels, which are indicated in a
display 8. Push buttons 9a are provided as an alternative means for selection between the
desiccation and vaporisation modes.
The handpiece 3 mounts a detachable electrode unit E, such as the electrode units El to ES
10 to be described below
Figure ' shows tl-e first form of electrode unit El for detachable fastening to the
electrosurgical instrument handpiece 3~ the electrode unit comprising a shaft 10~ which is
constituted by a semi-flexible tube made of stainless steel or phynox electroplated in
15 copper or gold, with an electrode assembly 12 at a distal end thereof At the other end (not
shown) of the shaft 10, means are provided for connecting the electrode unit El to the
handpiece 3 both mechanically and electrically.
The RF aenerator I (not shown hl Fi~ure 2) delivers an electrosurgical current to the
~0 electrode assembly 12. The generator includes means for varying the delivered output
power to suit different electrosur~ical requirements. The generator may be as described in
the specification of our European Patent Application 96304558.8.
The electrode unit El includes an active electrode 14 which is constituted by a plurality of
25 filaments made of tungsten or an alloy of tungsten or platinum. The active (brush)
electrode 14 is connected to the RF ~enerator I via an insulated central copper conductor
(not shown). A ceramic insulation sleeve 16 surrounds the central conductor, the filaments
14a of the brush electrode passing along the insulation sleeve and extending laterally
therefrom through a cut-out 1 6a. A return electrode 18, which is constituted by the distal
30 end of the instrument shaft~ surrounds the proximal end of the sleeve 16. An outer
insulating coatin(l 20 (which could be polyvinylidene fluoride, a polyimide,
CA 022~S81~ 1998-11-19
wO 97/48345 PCT/GB97/01631
polytetrafluoroethylene, a polyolefin, a polyester or ethylene tetrafluoroethylene)
surrounds the proximal portion of the shaft adjacent to the return electrode 18. The return
~ electrode 18 is formed with a hood-like extension 1 8a which extends over the surface of
the sleeve 16 which is opposite to the cut-out 1 6a. The electrode unit El can, thus, provide
5 maximum tissue enga~ement for shallow working angle applications, and is known as a
side-effect electrode.
This electrosurgical instrument is particularly useful for rapid tissue debulking. One of the
problems whicll could be encountered when tissue is rapidiy debulked using an
10 arthroscopic electrode configuration, particularly when workin~ in small joint spaces, is
the production of vapour bubbles generated as an end product of tissue vaporisation. Such
bubbles obscure vision, and can coalesce at the site of tissue application, so that the
electrical circuit between tne active and return electrodes becomes compromised by the
absence of conductive fluid. Irregular active electrodes having filamentary, mesh or coiled
15 spring forms ~o some way to solving this problem, as they reduce the vaporisation
threshold as disclosed in the specification of our International Patent Application
GB97/000~5. Another advanta~e of these electrode forms is that the bubbles generated
by vaporisation are smaller than those formed by solid electrodes. As the brush electrode
14 of this electrosurgical instrument is of irregular shape, it also has the advantage of
20 producing relatively small vapour bubbles as the product of tissue vaporisation. The
production of vapour bubbles is. however, further reduced as a result of the lower
threshold power of vaporisation which results from use of the electrode unit El. This
improvement results from the hood~ e extension 1 8a of the return electrode 18 which
extends over the bacl~ of the active electrode 14. This reduces the separation between the
25 active electrode 14 and the return electrode 18, thereby reducing the electrical field and the
vaporisation threshold power of the active electrode. This enhances the speed ofvaporisation of the tissue at a lower power than would otherwise be required for the given
active electrode area, and hence reduces the formation of vapour bubbles. As the hood-like
extension 1 8a extends along the entire length of the active electrode 14, a large active
30 electrode size can be supported. despite the reduction in electrode separation.
. . . ~ . . .
CA 022~8l~ l998-ll-ls
WO 97/48345 PCT/GB97/01631
The robustness of the electrode assembly 12 is also important in arthroscopic surgery. both
because of the tendencv of surgeons to use an electrode assembly as a cold manipulator,
and because of the ri(Jid nature of the tissue to be treated - particularly bone and cartilage.
The hood-like extension l ga adds mechanical strength to the electrode assembly 1~, as it
5 extends over the ceramic insulation sleeve 16, thereby reducing the risk of ceramic fracture
and potential breakdown of insulation.
The electrode unit El is intended primarily for use in arthroscopic surgery which requires
rapid tissue debulking by vaporisation. In use, the electrosurgical instrument is manipulated
10 to introduce the electrode assembly l ' into a selected operation site (for example, within
the joint space of a knee)~ so that the brush electrode 14 contacts the tissue to be treated,
and with the tissue and the electrode assembly immersed in saline The footswitch jb (or
the push button 7b) is then operated to set the required power level for vaporisation. The
~enerator l then provides sufficient RF power to the electrode assembly 12 to vaporise the
15 saline surrounding the brush electrode 14, and to m~int~in a vapour pocket surrounding
this electrode. Usin~ a brushing technique, with firm pressure against the tissue surface,
rapid debulking of the tissue is achieved. Gently touching the tissue will reduce the effect,
and can be used to sculpture and smooth the residual tissue surface.
20 Because of its speed of debulkin(~ and side-effect configuration, the electrode unit E I also
has advantages in urological surgery as an EVAP technique for use in conjunction with a
resectoscope. A resectoscope electrode unit is introduced very differentlv, in that it is
mounted on an endoscope prior to passa~e of the assembled instrument through a working
sheath introduced via tl1e urethra. The proximal end of the electrode unit is connected to
25 a trigger assembly and an electrical contact which is integral with the resectoscope. By this
means, the electrode unit can be moved back and forth through a defined range of motion
by operating the tri(~ ,er mechanism. As the electrode unit is assembled prior to
introduction, the size of the tip is not constrained by workin~ channel dimensions, but
rather bv the diameter of the working sheath which can be up to 10 mm. Part of this
30 diameter is occupied by the support wires to the electrode unit, which wires are commonly
bent in a downward angle, with respect to the endoscopic image, to the working tip, so
CA 022~81~ 1998-11-19
WO 97/4B345 PCT/GB97/0163
that they do not interfere with either visualisation or its operation. The brush electrode 14
can have a iength Iying within the range of from 3 mm to 4 mm and a width Iying in the
range offrom 2 mm to 3mm, and this size is necesary for urological surgery given that, on
average, 20-30 grams of prostate tissue must be removed.
Because of the reservoir effect of the urinary bladder, and the mounting of the endoscope
to view the tip of the active electrode from below, bubble generation during vaporisation
is less of a problem during endoscopic urology, as the bubbles flow away from the
endoscope to accumulate in the bladder. Nevertheiess, the use of the electrode unit El
10 substantially reduces the possibility of bubble generation causino problems.
Although the electrode unit El is intended primarily for use in the vaporisation of tissue,
it can also be used for desiccation, particularly of synovial membranes or to separate
muscle attachmenrs. In this case, once the electrode assembly 12 has been introduced into
15 a selected operation site~ the RF generator l is actuated usin~ the footswitch 5a or the
push button 7a to set the reguired power level for desiccation. The generator will then
provide sufficient RF power so the electrode assembly l 2 to maintain the saline ad~acent
to the brush electrode 14 substantially at its boiling point without creating a vapour pocket
surrounding that electrode The instrument can then be manipulated by moving the brush
20 electrode 14 across the surface of the tissue to be treated in a side-to-side 'painting"
technique.
The electrode unit El can also be used for blending tissue. Thus, by automaticallv
alternating the output of the RF generator I between the desiccation and vaporisation
25 power levels, more haemostasis is produced then is possible in the vaporisation mode. As
a consequence. the speed of tissue debulking can be reduced, which is useful when cutting
or debulking vascular tissue structures. Alternatively, the output of the RE generator I can
be pulsed at the vaporisation power level, without cycled activation of the desiccation
mode. This produces a less aggressive tissue vaporisation than occurs in the vaporisation
30 mode, with a consequellt reduction in both bubble formation and the risk of tissue charring.
~ . , . , . ~
CA 022~81~ 1998-11-19
WO 97/48345 PCT/GBg7/0163
~ 16
Figures 3 to 6 show electrode units E2 to E5 which are modified versions of the electrode
unit El. Accordingly, like reference numerals will be used for like parts, and only the
modifications will be described in detail. Thus, the active electrode 14 of the electrode unit
E' is a coiled-spring electrode mounted within the cut-out 16a. The coiled spring
5 electrode 14 is made of tungsten or an alloy of tun~sten or platinum, and its proximal end
is connected to the RF gellerator I via an insulated central copper conductor (not shown).
The electrode unit E3 of Figure 4 is of "sputnik" form, having an active electrode 14
constituted by a pluralitv of needle-like protrusions 14a extending from a thin metal base
10 plate 14b mounted within the cut-out 16a in the insulation sleeve 16. Both the base plate
14b and the protrusiolls 14a are made of tun~gsten or an alloy of tungsten or pl~tinllm The
needle-like protrusions 14a are connected to the RF generator I via a common insulated
central copper conductor (not shown). This unit E3 is less complex to manufacture as
compared with the brush-type form of the unit Ell and u7ill produce similar effects.
15 Moreover, it allows for variations in the density of the needle-like protrusions 14a over the
area of the base plate 14b.
Fi~Jure 5 shows the electrode unit E4 having an active electrode 14 which is constituted by
a mesh made of tungsten or an alloy of tun~,sten or platinum This electrode unit E4 can
~0 be provided with a suction pump ~not shown) which can remove vapour bubbles via the
shaft of the instrument through the active electrode 14 This enhances the elimination of
vapour bubbles from an operation site, which is particularly advantageous duringa_Pressive tissue debulkino The suction pump must be controlled so that the flow of
bubbles through the electrode 14 is balanced to the output characteristics of the RF
~5 generator I to prevent excessive cooling of the active electrode and a resultant increase
in its vaporisation power threshold. The thermal mass ofthe mesh active electrode 14 is
lower than that of a solid form active electrode, and this assists in rapidly re-establishing
the vapour pocket around the active electrode should this collapse following excessive
cooling. The control means for the suction pump may involve the use of an intermittent
30 suction technique.
CA 022~S81~ 1998-11-19
WO 97/48345 PCT/GB97/0163
Figure 6 shows the electrode unit E5 having an active electrode 14 ofthe coiled spring
type. Here, however, the cut-out 16a is formed obliquely (at 45") across the distal end face
ofthe insulation sieeve 16, so that the exposed end of the active electrode 14 has both an
axially-facing tissue contact portion and a laterally-facing tissue contact portion. The tip
5 of the coiled electrode 14 is also angled at 45 degrees to the axis of the instrument, so that
this electrode unit is both an end-effect electrode and a side-effect electrode. The main
advantage of this electrode unit ES is that it can be used in conjunction with endoscopic
sur~ery techniques which require workin~ channel introduction.
10 The Fi~ures 7 to 9 show a modified form of the electrode unit E' of Figure 3. This
electrode unit E2' has an active electrode 14' in the form of a coiled-spring electrode
mounted within a cut-out 1 6a' in the insulation member 16'. The coiled-spring electrode
14' is made of tungsten or an alloy of tungcten or platinum~ and its proximal end is
connected to the RF generator by an insulated central copper conductor (not shown). As
15 shown in Figure 8, the insulation member 16' is formed with a recess 1 6b' which receives
the return electrode 18' and its extension 1 8a' (not shown in Figures 7 and 8).
As shown in Figure 9, the active electrode 14' has a distal end portion which is exposed at
the distal end of the instrument for tissue contact. This embodiment has advantages over
~0 the earlier embodiments~ particularly where access is needed to remote areas of a joint
cavity Thus. in such remote johlt cavity areas, the extension of the insulation member 16
of each of the embodiments of Figures 2 to 5 may prevent the associated active electrode
14 accessin~ these areas
25 Figure 9 illustrates the way in which the insulation member 16' projects laterally in the
region between the active electrode 14' and the extension 1 8a' of the return electrode 18'.
This laterally-projecting part of the insulation member 16' increases the conductive fluid
path length from the active electrode 14' to the return electrode 18', and forces the electric
field outwardly, thereby preventin~ preferential arcin~ between the return electrode and
30 the nearest part of the active electrode, and promoting arcing between the active electrode
and the neighbouring tissue The return electrode 1 8l is spaced from the active electrode
.
CA 022~81~ 1998-11-19
wO 97/48345 PCT/Gs97/0l63
18
14' so that, in use, it does not contact the tissue to be treated, and so that the electrical
circuit is always completed bv the salhle, and not simplv arcing between the electrodes.
Indeed, the arrangement is such that arcing between adjacent parts of the electrode
assembly is avoided, thereby ensuring that the active electrode 14' can become enveloped
S in a vapour pocket, so that tissue entering the vapour pocket becomes the preferred path
for current to flow bacl; to the return electrode ~ 8' via the conductive fluid.
To consider the operation of the electrode unit E2' in more detail, when it operates in a
tissue cutting or vaporising mode, a vapour bubble is formed around the tip 14'a of the
10 active electrode 14'. This tip 1 4'a constitutes an active electrode treatment portion. This
bubble is sustained by arcing ~vithin it. The greater the applied voltage, the greater is the
size of the bubble The energy dissipated by each arc is impedance-limited by the rem~inins~
fluid in the conduction path and by the source impedance of the generator. However, an
arc behaves as a ne(rative impedance in that, if the energy in the arc is sufficiently high, an
15 ionised path of very low impedance is formed. This can lead to an unstable condition of
ever-decreasing ionised path impedance unless the impedance of the fluid between the
bubble and the return electrode 18' is sufficient to act as a limit on dissipated power. It is
also possible for the vapour pocket around the active electrode treatment portion 14'a to
encroach the return electrode 18'. In these circumstances, the arc energy is limited only by
20 generator source impedance. but such power limitation is poor and cannot be adjusted
according to electrode size. For these reasons. the dimensions and configuration of the
insulation member 16 should be such as to define a minimum conduction path length of
Imm between the active electrode treatment portion 14'a and the fluid contact surface of
the return electrode 18' This minimum path length is, in the case of the embodiment shown
25 in Figure 9, the arc length a of the insulation member 16' plus the step dimension c of the
laterally-projecting part of the insulation member.
A further consideration is the possibility of a vapour pocket forming only over part of the
exposed treatment portion 14'a ofthe active electrode 14'. When the applied voltage and
30 power are sufficiently high, a vapour pocket will form around the active electrode exposed
treatment portion 14'a Preferably, the pocket is formed uniformly over the entire length
CA 022~81~ 1998-11-19
WO 97/48345 pcTlGs97lol63
19
of the treatment portion. In such a situation~ the load impedance presented to the generator
can change by as much as a factor of 20. However. when there are significant differences
in the conduction path len~th between the return electrode fluid contact surface I ga' and
different parts of the exposed active electrode treatment portion 1 4'a, a voltage gradient
5 is established over the len~th of each electrode. With some insulation member and active
electrode configurations, the voltage ~radient can be sufficiently large to enable vapour
pocket formation only over that part of the exposed treatment portion closest to the fluid
contact surface, leavin~ the extreme distal end of the exposed treatment portion still in
contact with the conductive fluid. Thus, the voltage gradient is established within the
10 conductive fluid where the edge of the vapour poc~et intersects the surface of the active
electrode treatment portion 14'a. The electrical behaviour of such a partially-enveloped
active electrode treatment portion 14'a is very different from that of a fully-enveloped
treatment portion. In terms of controlling ~enerator output by sensing peak voltage, the
behaviour of the electrode assembly is no Ion~er bistable. However, the power demand is
15 considerably hi~her as a result of the vaporisation voltage presented across the low
impedance w etted region of the active electrode treatment portion 1 4'a. The clinical effect
is not only the required vaporisation, but also an undesirable thermal d~m~sging effect
resulting from the increased power dissipation.
20 Partial envelopin~ of the active electrode treatment portion 1 4'a can be largely avoided by
ensuring that the ratio of the lengtll b of the conductive path between the furthermost point
of the active electrode treatment portion and the len~th of the shortest conductive path
between the active electrode treatment portion and the fluid contact surface is at most 2 1,
ie b/(a+c) < 2. The laterally-projecting portion of the insulation member 16' defines an
25 insulation barrier to direct electrical current flow through the fluid medium, thereby
increasing the shortest conductive path between the fluid contact surface 18'a and the
active electrode 14'.
It will be noted from Figure 9 that the downward extent of the exposed active electrode
30 treatment portion. ie. the distance d by which the active electrode projects beyond the
shrouding parts of the insulation member 16' on each side, is at least one half of the width
, . . ..
CA 022~81~ 1998-11-19
WO 97/48345 PCT/GB97/01631
of the exposed treatment portion in a transverse plane. This allows the instrument to be
rotated about the axis of its shaft to some extent without losin;, the required surgical effect.
Figure 9 also shows that the active electrode 14' has an exposed end (the tip 14'a) which
S extends laterally through the cut-out 16'a in a first direction which is opposite to the
direction in which the fluid contact surface 18a' faces. This first direction defines a
treatment axis which lies in a common plane with the two shortest conductive paths
referred to above. The electrode units of the embodiments of Figures 2 to 6 also include
this feature.
It should be noted that the insulation member 16 of each of the embodiments of Figures
2 to 6 also has laterally-projecting part which increases the conductive fluid path length
from the active electrode 14 to the return electrode 1~. These electrode units also are such
that the ratio of the length of the conductive path between the furthermost point of the
15 active electrode treatment portion and the fluid contact surface of the return electrode, and
the length of the shortest conductive path between the active electrode treatment portion
and the fluid contact surface is at most 2:1.
In order further to improve access to remote joint cavity areas, the distal portion of the
~0 electrode shaft of each of the embodiments described above could be angled, say between
15~ and 30", with respect to the main portion of the instrument shaft. In a further
modification, titanium could be used as the material for each of the active electrodes.
It will be apparent that modifications could be made to the embodiments described above.
25 For example, the embodiments of Figs I to 4 and 6 could each be provided with a suction
pump for removing vapour bubbles via the shaft of the instrument through the active
electrode. It would also be possible to make the insulation sleeve 16 of each of the
embodiments of a silicone rubber (such as a silicone polyurethane), glass, a polyimide or
a thermoplastics material.
