Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
TITLE: CYTOPLASMIC MALE STERILE SOYBEAN AND METHOD FOR
PRODUCING SOYBEAN HYBRIDS
FIELD OF THE INVENTION
The present invention relates to the field of plant breeding.
More particularly, the invention relates to cytoplasmically male
sterile soybeans, and their use in developing desirable soybean
plants .
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
The goal of plant breeding is to combine in a single variety or
hybrid various desirable traits of the parental lines. For field crops,
these traits may include resistance to diseases and insects, tolerance
to heat and drought, reduced time to crop maturity, greater yield, and
better overall agronomic quality. With mechanical harvesting of
many crops, uniformity of plant characteristics such as germination,
stand establishment, growth rate, maturity, and fruit size, is
important. Plant breeding begins with the analysis and definition of
problems and weaknesses of the current germplasm, the
establishment of program goals and the definition of specific
breeding objectives. The next step is selection of germplasm that
possesses the traits to meet the program goals, and breeding to gain
reproducible expression of that trait.
Field crops are bred through techniques that take advantage of the
plant's method of pollination. A plant is self-pollinating if pollen
from one flower is transferred to the same or another flower of the
same plant. A plant is cross-pollinated if the pollen comes from a
CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
flower on a different plant. In self-pollinating species, such as
soybeans and cotton, the male and female organs are anatomically
juxtaposed. During natural pollination, the male reproductive
organs of a given flower pollinate the female reproductive organs of
the same flower. Maize can self or cross pollinate. In Brassica,
the plant is normally self sterile and can only be cross-pollinated.
Soybean plants are taxonomically classified in the genus Glycine,
~vhich contains two subgenera, Glycine and Soja. Under the
subgenus Soja are two species; Glycine max, a cultivated species,
and Glycine soja, a wild species.
Soybean plants are recognized to be naturally self-pollinated
plants which, while capable of undergoing cross-pollination, do so
infrequently in nature. Insects are reported by some researchers to
carry pollen from one soybean plant to another and it generally is
estimated that less than one percent of soybean seed formed in an
open planting can be traced to cross-poliination, i.e. Iess than one
percent of soybean seeds formed in an open planting is capable of
producing F 1 hybrid soybean plants, See Jaycox, "Ecological
Relationships between Honey Bees and Soybeans," appearing in the
American Bee Journal Vol. 11 0(8): 306-307 (August 1 970). This
reference and all references cited are incorporated herein by
reference. Thus intervention for control of pollination is critical to
establishment of superior varieties.
One of the most critical aspects of plant breeding is the ability to
control the pollination process so that parental lines with desired
traits are intentionally crossed to provide those same traits in the
offspring.
Large scale commercial hybrid production, as it is practiced today,
requires the use of some form of male sterility system which controls
or inactivates male fertility. A reliable method of controlling male
.
CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
fertility in plants also offers the opportunity for improved plant
breeding. This is especially true for development of maize hybrids,
which relies upon some sort of male sterility system. There are
several options for controlling male fertility available to breeders,
such as: manual or mechanical emasculation (or detasseling for
maize), cytoplasmic male sterility, genetic male sterility,
gametocides and the like. Most advances in male sterility have
occurred with maize production.
Hybrid maize seed is typically produced by a male sterility system
incorporating manual or mechanical detasseling. Alternate strips of
two inbred varieties of maize are planted in a field, and the pollen-
bearing tassels are removed from one of the inbreds (female) prior to
pollen shed. Providing that there is sufficient isolation from
sources of foreign maize pollen, the ears of the detasseled inbred will
be fertilized only from the other inbred (male), and the resulting seed
is therefore hybrid and will form hybrid plants.
The laborious, and occasionally unreliable, detasseling process
can be avoided by using cytoplasmic male-sterile (CMS) inbreds.
Plants of a CMS inbred are male sterile as a result of factors resulting
from the cytoplasmic, as opposed to the nuclear, genome. Thus, this
characteristic is inherited exclusively through the female parent in
maize plants, since only the female provides cytoplasm to the
fertilized seed. CMS plants are fertilized with pollen from another
inbred that is not male-sterile. Pollen from the second inbred may
or may not contribute genes that make the hybrid plants male-fertile.
Usually seed from detasseled fertile maize and CMS produced seed of
the same hybrid are blended to insure that adequate pollen loads are
available for fertilization when the hybrid plants are grown.
There are many other methods of conferring genetic male sterility
in the art, each with its own benefits and drawbacks. These
' CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
methods use a variety of approaches such as delivering into the plant
a gene encoding a cytotoxic substance associated with a male tissue
specific promoter or an antisense system in which a gene critical to
fertility is identified and an antisense to that gene is inserted in the
plant (see: Fabinjanski, et al. EPO 89/3010153.8 publication no.
329,308 and PCT application PCT/CA90/00037 published as WO
90/08828).
- Another system useful in controlling male fertility makes use of
gametocides. Gametocides are not a genetic system, but rather a
topical application of chemicals. These chemicals affect cells that
are critical to male fertility. The application of these chemicals
affects fertility in the plants only for the growing season in which the
gametocide is applied (see Carlson, Glenn R., U.S. Patent Number:
4,936,904). Application of the gametocide, timing of the
application and genotype specificity often limit the usefulness of the
approach.
Male sterility is a general phenomenon in the plant kingdom.
Duvick (1966) suggested that all plant species must have at least one
nuclear gene for male sterility. Laser et al. (1972) noted that there
were published reports of cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) in
approximately 140 species. The number of species in which CMS
has been found had greatly increased by the time of Kaul's (1988)
review.
Several types of male sterile soybeans have been identified
. (Palmer et al. 1987). For example, genetic male sterility (GMS),
controlled by single recessive gene, has been intensively investigated
and reviewed (Graybosch et al. 1988, Palmer et al. 1992). Those
materials have been used in genetic studies and breeding programs
such as recurrent selection.
E~ecause of the difficulty in obtaining pure stands of male sterile
CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
plants and because of the difficulty in achieving cost-effective
pollination, the use of GMS in hybrid soybean seed production is not
widely practiced at present. However, the CMS system has proven
to be efficient in hybrid seed production in several important crops,
including maize, sorghum and rice. Cytoplasmic male sterility and
restorer genes have been reported in soybeans. Davis (U.S. Patent
No. 4,545,146, U.S. Patent No. 4,763,441, and U.S. Patent No.
4,648,204) has disclosed cultivars which reportedly contribute male
sterile cytoplasm and two pairs of recessive genes rlrl, r2r2 for male
sterile maintenance. This CMS system is best described as a two gene,
sporophytic system in which varieties possessing at least one allele
that is dominant in each fertility restorer gene pair, RlRl or R2R2,
lead to viable pollen production even in the presence of CMS
cytoplasm. There has been no reported independent verification of
this system. For example, given the available seed stocks, sterility
is not expressed even when the required atypical CMS cytoplasm and
recessive restorer genes are present. See Davis U.S patent,
No.4545 146 column 7, line 30 through column 9, line 63, where the
sporophytic two-gene system is discussed.
With a sporophytic system of restoration in cytoplasmic male
sterile lines, it is the genotype of the plant (sporophyte) that
determines whether normal pollen is produced. Thus, a sporophytic
plant that is heterozygous at a restorer gene locus produces all normal
pollen even though only one-fourth of the pollen grains carry both
dominant alleles. In a gametophytic system it is the genotype of the
pollen grain (gametophyte) itself that determines whether the pollen
grain is normal or abnormal. Therefore such a plant that is
heterozygous for a restorer gene produces one-half normal arid one-
half aborted pollen grains depending ~Ipon ~vhether the dominant
s
.. .. . .
~ CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
allele or the recessive allele is present. This is often referred to as
"semi-sterility" .
The invention described herein is a gametophytic, cytoplasmic
male sterile soybean line. Further, unlike Davis, it requires
manipulation of only one restorer gene and not two, making it
easier to use in breeding.
SUMMARY
The present invention addresses the problems presented in
previously described CMS soybean systems by providing a
consistently reproducible male sterile line for use in creating soybean
hybrids that is relatively easy to use. It also provides for
maintenance of sterility by crossing the line containing the currently
described sterile cytoplasm and its recessive nuclear restorer gene
with a second variety containing fertile cytoplasm and the
corresponding recessive nuclear restorer gene as is in the CMS line.
~ Therefore, it is an object of the present invention to provide a
soybean line having a gametophytic cytoplasmic male sterile system.
Another object of the invention is to provide a cytoplasmic male
sterility soybean line wherein one can manipulate a single gene to
control sterility. Yet another object of the invention is to provide a
restorer soybean line for the cytoplasmic male sterile line described
above.
It is a further object of the present invention to provide for the
creation of soybean hybrids utilizing the gametophytic cytoplasmic
male sterile plant as the female parent when cross pollinated with the
male fertile parent soybean plant. The female parent soybean plant
will contain the sterile cytoplasm component and recessive alleles at
the nuclear restorer gene specific for that cytoplasmic male sterile
genetic component. The male parent described herein has at least
... . .
' CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
one dominant restorer allele at the nuclear restorer gene specific for
the cytoplasmic male sterile genetic component of the female parent.
The hybrid soybean seeds are harvested from the female parent of this
cross .
Other objects, features and advantages of the present invention
will become apparent from the following detailed description. It
should be understood, however, that the detailed description and the
specific examples, while indicating preferred embodiments of the
invention, are given by way of illustration only, sinGe various
changes and modifications within the spirit and scope of the
invention will become apparent to those skilled in the art from the
detailed description.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
The soybean is the world's leading source of vegetable oil and
protein meal. The oil extracted from soybeans is used for cooking
oil, margarine, and salad dressings. Soybean oil is composed of
saturated, monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fatty acids. It has
a typical composition of 11% palmitic, 4% stearic, 25% oleic, 50%
linoleic and 9% linolenic fatty acid content ("Economic Implications
of Modified Soybean Traits Summary Report", Iowa Soybean
Promotion Board & American Soybean Association Special Report
92S, May 1990). Changes in fatty acid composition for improved
oxidative stability and nutrition are constantly sought after.
Industrial uses of soybean oil which is subjected to further
processing include ingredients for paints, plastics, fibers, detergents,
cosmetics, and lubricants. Soybean oil may be split, inter-esterified,
sulfurized, epoxidized, polymerized, ethoxylated, or cleaved.
Designing and producing soybean oil derivatives with improved
functionality, oliochemistry, is a rapidly growing field. The typical
CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
mixture of triglycerides is usually split and separated into pure fatty
acids, which are then combined with petroleum-derived alcohols or
acids, nitrogen, sulfonates, chlorine, or with fatty alcohols derived
from fats and oils.
Soybean is also used as a food source for both animals and humans.
Soybean is widely used as a source of protein for animal feeds for
poultry, swine and cattle. During processing of whole soybeans, the
fibrous hull is removed and the oil is extracted. The remaining
soybean meal is a combination of carbohydrates and approximately
50% protein.
For human or animal consumption soybean meal is made into
soybean flour which is processed to protein concentrates used for
meat extenders or specialty pet foods. Production of edible protein
ingredients from soybean offers a healthy, less expensive
replacement for animal protein in meats as well as dairy-type
products .
The invention relates to a male sterile soybean line that is
cytoplasmically male sterile and which therefore can consistently
express desirable economic traits as an inbred or used as a parental
line for production of hybrids. It also relates to the restorer line
described.
This invention also is directed to methods for producing a soybean
plant by crossing the male sterile parent soybean plant of this
invention with a second parent soybean plant wherein the second
parent soybean plant is a soybean plant of the line described with a
homozygous dominant or heterozygous nuclear restorer gene specific
for that sterile cytoplasm. Thus, any such methods using the male
sterile soybean line of the invention or the restorer line are part of
this invention: selfing, back-crosses, hybrid production, crosses to
populations, and the like. All plants produced using a soybean
' CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
variety of the invention or its male restorer line as a parent are within
the scope of this invention. Advantageously, the soybean variety
could be used in crosses with other, different, soybean plants to
produce first generation (Fl) soybean hybrid seeds and plants with
superior characteristics. The variety of the invention can also be
used for transformation where exogenous genes are introduced and
expressed by the variety of the invention. Genetic variants created
either through traditional breeding methods using the male sterile
variety of the invention or through transformation of the male sterile
variety of the invention by any of a number of protocols knowll to
those of skill in the art are intended to be within the scope of this
invention .
Production of a genetically modified plant tissue by
transformation combines teachings of the present disclosure with a
variety of techniques and expedients known in the art. In most
instances alternate expedients exist for each stage of the overall
process. The choice of expedients depends on the variables such as
the plasmid vector system chosen for the cloning and introduction of
the desired recombinant DNA molecule, as well as the particular
structural gene, promoter elements and upstream elements used.
Persons skilled in the art are able to select and use appropriate
alternatives to achieve functionality. Culture conditions for
expressing desired structural genes and cultured cells are known in
the art. Also as known in the art, soybeans are transformable and
regenerable such that whole plants containing and expressing desired
genes under regulatory control may be obtained. General
descriptions of plant expression vectors and reporter genes and
transformation protocols can be found in Gruber, et al., "Vectors for
Plant Transformation", in Methods in Plant Molecular Biology &
Biotechnology, Glich et al., (Eds. pp. 89-119, CRC Press, 1993).
' CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
Moreover GUS expression vectors and GUS gene cassettes are
available from Clone Tech Laboratories, Inc., Palo Alto, California,
while luciferase expression vectors and luciferase gene cassettes are
available from Pro Mega Corp. (Madison, Wisconsin). General
methods of culturing plant tissues are provided for example by Maki
et al., "Procedures for Introducing Foreign DNA into Plants" in
Methods in Plant Molecular Biology & Biotechnology, Glich et al.
(Eds. pp. 67-88 CRC Press,1993); and by Phillips et al., "Cell-Tissue
Culture and In-Vitro Manipulation" in Corn & Corn Improvement,
3rd Edition, Sprague et al. (Eds. pp. 345-387 American Society of
Agronomy Inc., 1988.) Methods of introducing expression
vectors into plant tissue include the direct infection or co-cultivation
of plant cells with Agrobacterium tumefaciens, Horsch et al., Science,
227:1229 (1985). Descriptions of Agrobacterium vector systems
and methods for Agrobacterium-mediated gene transfer provided by
Gruber, et al. supra.
Useful methods include but are not limited to expression vectors
introduced into plant tissues using a direct gene transfer method such
as microprojectile-mediated delivery, DNA injection, electroporation
and the like. More preferably expression vectors are introduced
into plant tissues using the microprojectile media delivery with the
biolistic device. One example is that described at European Patent
30, 749. Transformant plants obtained with the protoplasm of the
invention are intended to be within the scope of this invention.
As used herein, the term plant includes plant cells, plant
protoplasts, plant cell tissue cultures from which soybean plants can
be regenerated, plant calli, plant clumps, and plant cells that are
intact in plants or parts of plants, such as embryos, pollen, ovules,
flowers, pods, leaves, roots, root tips, anthers, and the like.
Further reproduction of the variety can occur by tissue culture and
' CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
regeneration. Tissue culture of various tissues of soybeans and
regeneration of plants therefrom is well known and widely published.
For example, reference may be made to Komatsuda, T. et al.,
"Genotype X Sucrose Interactions for Somatic Embryogenesis in
Soybean," Crop Sci. 31 :333-337 (1991); Stephens, P.A. et al.,
"Agronomic Evaluation of Tissue-Culture-Derived Soybean Plants,"
Theor. Appl. Genet. 82:633-635(1991); Komatsuda, T. et al.,
"Maturation and Germination of Somatic Embryos as Affected by
Sucrose and Plant Growth Regulators in Soybeans Glycine gracilis
Skvortz and Glycine max (L.) Merr.," Plant Cell, Tissue and Organ
C ulture, 28 103 - 113 (1992); Dhir, S . et al ., "Regeneration of Fertile
Plants from Protoplasts of Soybean (Glycine max L. Merr.):
Genotypic Differences in Culture Response," Plant Cell Reports
11 285-289(1992) Pandey, P. et al., "Plant Regeneration from Leaf
and Hypocotyl Explants of Glycine wightii (W. and A.) VERDC. var
longicauda," Japan J. Breed. 42:1-5 (1992); and Shetty, K., et al.,
"Stimulation of In Vitro Shoot Organogenesis in Glycine max
(Merrill .) by Allantoin and Amides," Plant Science 81: 245-25 1 ( 1 992)
as well as U.S. Patent 5,024,944, issued June 18, 1991 to Collins et al.
and U.S. Patent 5,008,200, issued April 16, 1991 to Ranch et al., the
disclosures of which are hereby incorporated herein in their entirety
by reference.
It is well known in the art that cytoplasm genetics are inherited in
most plants, including soybeans, through the female parent only. In
these plants, pollen does not transmit a cytoplasm component. This
invention provides for a male sterile soybean plant having a sterile
cytoplasm wherein the cytoplasm genetic component is for a sterile
(S) cytoplasm. This male sterile soybean plant further has recessive
alleles (rf x rf x ) at the nuclear restorer gene locus specific for that
cytoplasm. This combination of (S) cytoplasm and (rf x rf x )
Il
. CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
genotype for the restorer gene confers a male sterile phenotype to the
plant. This male sterile phenotype can be maintained and can be
further exploited in the creation of Fl hybrid soybean seed.
The male sterile soybean line, described herein, having
cytoplasmic genotype (S) and nuclear restorer genotype (rf x rf x )
can be maintained by cross-pollination with the male fertile isoline
described (maintainer line) having a fertile, or normal, cytoplasmic
genotype (F) and the (rf x rf x ) nuclear restorer genotype. The
female parent (male sterile line) is referred to as the A~-line. The
male parent (male fertile line) is referred to as either the B-line or the
maintainer line. This seed harvested from the female parent inherits
the cytoplasmic genotype (S) from the female. The remainder of the
genotype is essentially the same for the male and female parent, thus,
the seed harvested from the female parent plant is the same
genetically as the female parent plant itself -- including the
cytoplasmic male sterility.
In the present invention, the mode of restoration is gametophytic.
In other words, it is the genotype of the pollen grain, or gametophyte,
that determines whether the pollen is normal or abnormal. A
genotype of Rf x rf x at the restorer gene locus, in the presence of
sterile (S) cytoplasm, will result in 50% fertile pollen and 50% sterile
or aborted pollen. Buchert, J.G., "The state of genome-plasmon
interaction in the restoration of fertility to cytoplasmically pollen-
sterile maize", Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 47:14~6-1440.(1961)
This invention further provides for the production of hybrid
soybeans through cross-pollination by utilizing the male sterile
soybean plant described herein as the female parent and the line
carrying at least one dominant restorer allele as the male parent, also
described. Seed is harvested from the female parent and used to
gro~ Fl hybrid soybean plants.
_ .
' CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
In the preferred embodiment of this invention, the cytoplasmic
male sterile plant is created by a cross of Glycine max7 line 167, as
the female parent and Glycine soja, line 035, as the male parent.
Glycine max, line 167, with its specific sterile cytoplasm (S) genetic
component is restored to fertility by dominant fertility alleles (Rf x
Rf x ) at the nuclear restorer locus specific for that sterile cytoplasm
genetic component. Glycine soja, line 035, has fertile cytoplasm (F)
and carries the recessive alleles (rf x rf x ) at the nuclear restorer
locus for the specific cytoplasm carried in line 167. In addition,
Glycine soja, line 035, carries a homozygous translocation (T/T),
resulting in a higher than expected percent pollen sterility in the
progeny. The seeds are harvested from the female plant, planted and
upon maturity, self-pollinated to create a F2 population. From this
F2 population, plants carrying the (rf x rf x ) genotype are selected
and used as a female parent in a series of back-crosses with Glycine
soja, line 035. From the back-cross progeny select progeny with a
high percentage sterile pollen grains and interchanged chromosomes
(T/T). The resulting genotype for cytoplasm:nucleus is S: (rf x rf
x ) (T/T). At least five backcross cycles were completed. The
resulting progeny can be crossed to either the B-line for maintaining
seed source for hybrid production or to any restored soybean line as
described above. In addition, the use of genetic traits, such as
flower or pubescence color, tightly linked to the restorer gene could
act as a phenotypic marker in the field. Of course, the G. Soja
phenotype cannot be directly used in hybrid production because of its
unacceptable agronomic characteristics. B~lt it can be readily
crossed with the cultivated types of soybean to result in the desired
parental lines after sufficient backcrossing.
It should be emphasized that in the creation of hybrid soybean
lines, both manual cross-pollination and insect-mediated cross
13
' CA 02262513 1999-02-08
pollination can be used. Manual intermating is difficult and time
consuming, therefore, not practical for commercial production.
Insect-mediated cross-pollination, using bees for example, is more
conducive to commercial production. The male sterile plant of this
invention is used as the female parent and the restored line is used as
the male parent. The insects carry the pollen from the male parent
plant to the female parent, thus cross-pollinating the plant. The
seed is then harvested from the female parent. Several methods are
known in the art for increasing the attractiveness of the flowering
soybean plants to bees, such as limiting rainfall or irrigation during
flowering to increase nectar flow, selecting plants with a larger
blossom size or the presence of an odor attractive to insects such as
bee sex pheromones.
The concept of the invention described herein allows for the
controlled growth of soybean hybrids. These hybrids will allow for
the increased yields and other benefits of increased heterosis and
hybrid vigor.
EXAMPLE I
Materials and Methods
Experiments were initiated to investigate chromosome
translocation frequency of G. soja and to identify possible
combinations showing interaction of male sterile cytoplasm and
sterile maintaining gene(s). Six sites in China, located at
Gongzhuling, Jilin; Zhengzhou, Henan; Xuzhou, Jiangsu; Hang zhou,
Zhejiang; Changsha, Hunan and Quanzhou, Fujian, were chosen to
grow experimental materials. The wide range of geographic
distribution of those sites, covering from 25 to 44 degrees north
latitude, provided the opportunity to select experimental samples on
14
' CA 02262S13 1999-02-08
a broad genetic basis. 133 varieties of G. max and 213 collections
of G. soja came from different maturity groups and could mature
normally at one of the above-mentioned six sites. These varieties
were used as female and male parents respectively in the crosses.
The genotypes of both G. max and G. soja were screened to
present the greatest genetic diversities. For instance, the female
cultivated parents were composed of landrace as well as modern
cultivars. Both typical annual wild soybean and semi-wild soybean
were included in male parents.
376 cross combinations of G. max by G. soja were made during the
experimental time period. F I seeds produced from most
combinations were grown in a photoperiod-controlled room at
Gongzhuling, Jilin; some were grown in Zhengzhou, Henan. The
fertility of pollen grains of Fl plants were checked by I2-KI staining
and the percentage of sterile pollen grains was calculated.
Abortions in the pod weighing less than 28 milligrams were
considered to be either aborted ovules or early seed abortion.
Results and Discussion
Palmer et al (1976, 1984) confirmed that the semi-sterility of Fl
pollen grains from crosses of G. max by G. soja were due to a
chromosome translocation in G. soja. Spontaneous translocation
was found to be rare in G. ma~. Taking G. max as a common non-
translocation parent, as high as 59.6% of 213 combinations of G. max
X G. soja used in this study had translocated chromosomes. This
result was not surprising. Delannay et al (1982) checked 19 samples
of G. soja collections from China for frequency of translocation and
found that 16 of them (i.e. ~4%) had a suspected translocation.
A specific cross of G. ma~ line Ru Nan Tian E Dan (It is called
167 in this invention) by G. soja line 5090035 (It is called 035 in
CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
this invention) was found to have extremely high pollen grain
sterility of 88.01% in F1 plants. To exclude the possibility induced
by accidental factors such as experimental errors or unfavorable
growing conditions, two additional crosses including reciprocal ones
were made. The results of pollen checking are listed in Table 1.
TABLE 1
Pollen Fertilities of Fl Plants From Reciprocal
Crosses 167 X 035 and Their Parents
Year of Combination Growing Condition Percentage of
Cross Made of Fl Plants Sterile Pollen of
F1(%)
Year 1 167 x 035Photo-controlled in GZ* 88.01
Year 3 167 x 035Photo-controlled in GZ* 92.70
Year 3 035 x 167Photo-controlled in GZ* 58.44
Year 3 167 Field in ZZ** 2.38
Year 3 035 Field in ZZ** 2.17
Year 5 167 x 035 Field in ZZ** 88.37
*Gongzhuling, Jilin; **Zhengzhou, Henan
The data in Table I demonstrates that the pollen fertility of
parents 167 and 035 was normal. The high degree of pollen sterility
found in Fl plants of 167 X 035 could be repeated in different years
and different growing conditions. The average percentage of sterile
pollen grains were 89.69% in three years with a very low difference
of 4.69% between the highest and the lowest value. It clearly
demonstrated that genetic causes were responsible for the sterility.
.
' CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
The semi-sterility of Fl plants in cross 035 X 167 is believed to
result from the involvement of chromosome translocation in one of
the two parents. Considering the high frequency of translocation in
G. soja, line 035 was suspected to have one chromosome translocated.
A modern soybean cultivar Zhengzhou 64-1, which appears to have
no translocation, was chosen as common parent to cross with 035 and
167 respectively to test and verify these suppositions. The results
in Table 2 indicated that the semi-sterility of pollen grains in Fl
plants appeared in reciprocal crosses in which line 035 was included
but not in crosses having line 167 as a parent. Therefore the
possibility of chromosome translocation in 167 could be eliminated.
TABLE 2
Pollen Fertilities of Fl Plants From Crosses
of Zhengzhou 64-1 by 03 5 and 1 67
Year of Cross Combination Growing Condition Percentage of
Made of Fl Plants Sterile Pollen of Fl
(%)
Year 3 Zhengzhou 64-1Photo-controlled in GZ* 55.60
x 035
Year 3 035 x Photo-controlled in GZ* 54.95
Zhengzhou 64-1
Year 5 Zhengzhou 64-1 Field in ZZ** 0.26
x 167
Year 5 167 x Field in ZZ** 3.04
Zhengzhou 64-1
17
-
' CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
* Gongzhuling, Jilin; **Zhengzhou, Henan
Heterozygotes for a chromosome translocation should also cause
semi-aborted ovules. The percentage of aborted ovules in the Fl
plants of Zhengzhou 64-1 x 035 and 035 x Zhengzhou 64-1 were
43.00% and 35.78% compared to those of 7.03% and 6.74% in 167
and 035 respectively. Beiling (1915) stated that in Stizolobium sp.,
pods with all ovules aborted abscised. The same situation is
believed to happen in soybean. If those aborted ovules within the
pods possibly abscised were added to the observed abortion ovules,
the percentage of aborted ovules would be close to 50%. Both
semi-sterile pollen and semi-aborted ovules in Fl of crosses
involving 035 confirmed the existence of translocation in G. soja line
of 035.
The reciprocal crosses resulted in different percentages of sterile
pollen in Fl plants. Percent sterile pollen was 32.26% higher in the
positive cross of 167 x 035 than that in the negative cross of 035 x
167 (table 1). The effects of 167 cytoplasm on the fertility of Fl
plants were obviously revealed and such effects were found to be true
only when line 035 nuclear genome was in 167 cytoplasm. The
interaction of 167 cytoplasm with 035 nuclear gene(s) predicted the
possibility of obtaining a cytoplasmic-nuclear male sterile line. The
nuclear substitution backcrosses were initiated in 1990. Three
BCl Fl plants were obtained in 1991. The percent of sterile pollen
in each BCIFI plants was 99.93%, 93.53% and 99.27% respectively.
The second backcross was conducted and 0,1,10 BC2FI seeds were
harvested from the three BC 1 F 1 plants respectively. All BC2F 1
seeds were planted in greenhouse in winter 1991 and four BC2F I
plants derived from the same BCIFI plant were obtained. The only
BC2FI seed harvested from another BCIFI plant failed to germinate.
18
CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
- The whole backcross procedure is illustrated as follows:
Year Location Cross Procedure Average
Percentage of
Sterile Pollen
(%)
Year 5 summer Zhengzhou 167 x 035
Year 6 summer Zhengzhou Fl x 035 88.37
Year 7 summer Zhengzhou BClFl x 035 97.58
Year 7 winter Gongzhuling BC2Fl x 035 99.57
Year 8 summer Zhengzhou BC3F1 x 035 99.93
Year 9 summer Zhengzhou BC4~1 x 035 99.93
BC5F1 035
(A-line)(B-line?
The continuous backcrosses were ended in summer of Year 9 and
highly male sterile plants, the CMS A-line, and its maintainer, the
male fertile B-line, were obtained. CMS A-line and B-line obtained
here with G. soja phenotype will be called OA and OB, respectively,
hereafter in this invention.
Some important characteristics of OA are described below:
Morphology: The OA and OB had typical phenotype of annual
wild soybean with vining stem, small leaves, and black seeds
weighing 2.5g/100 seeds. OA and OB have an indeterminate type of
stem termination, gray pubescence, and white flowers with purple
throats. The OA was similar to its maintainer OB morphologically
except for delayed leaf senescence at maturity, few pods set, and
large amounts of unfertilized small pods ranging from 0.5 - I .0 cm on
1~
,
' CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
mature plants.
Micrograph of pollen grain: Light microscopy showed the pollen
grains of OA were small, with the diameter of 17.15 (m compared to
21.73 (m of normal pollen in OB. The wall of the pollen appeared
well developed but the content was shrunken. The pollen could not
be stained by 12-KI and was light brown.
Male sterile stability: The BC4Fl plants were used to grow in
three conditions with different treatments of photoperiod regimes and
temperatures. The male sterility remained stable and at a very high
level. The growing conditions were as follows:
Year 8 winter: The plants were grown in the greenhouse in
Gongzhuling. Twenty four hours of light were given for two
weeks and then reduced to 13.5 hours till flowering. The
temperature was variable due to an unstable heating system. The
percentage of sterile pollen was 97.95%.
Year 9 summer: The plants were grown in the fields in Zhengzhou.
They were planted in early June and flowered in early August. The
temperature kept very high all over the growing season. Pollen
sterility was 99.93%
Year 9 summer: Plants also were grown in a photo-controlled
room in Gongzhuling. Light was provided for 14 hours after
emergence until full pod setting. The temperature was low during
the planting time in early May and was increased during flowering
time in early July. The percentage of sterile pollen was 99.94%.
The data indicated that the percentage of sterile pollen grains of
CMS plants remained almost the same in highly varied environments,
and also revealed that the male sterility was quite stable.
Female Fertility: A common parent of 167 was used to cross to
OA and OB at the same time. The success rates of crosses (i.e. the
pod setting rates) were used to estimate female fertility. The
CA 02262S13 1999-02-08
parallel crosses were done by the same person to reduce the artificial
experimental error to the lowest level. The results are shown in
Table 3.
TABLE 3
Results of Female Fertility Test
Cross No. of Cross No. of Pod Success Rates
Combination Made Setting (%)
OA x 167 123 33 26.82
OB x 167 123 35 28.46
The pod setting rate on O~ was just 1.64% lower than that on OB.
The significance test revealed no difference between the two cases at
the 0.01 Ievel. The female of OA seemed normal.
The distinct difference of male sterility of F1s between reciprocal
crosses 167 x 035 and 035 x 167, and the maintenance of high level
male sterility after continuous nuclear substitution back-crosses,
could only be explained by the cytoplasmic-nuclear male sterile
system. Without intending to be limited by theory, we tentatively
suppose that the combination of sterile cytoplasm S in the 167 line
and a pair of recessive restorer genes rf x rf x in the 035 line (i.e.
S(rf x rf x )) caused the male sterility in CMS OA. The mode of
genetic control in the OB and line 167 should be N(rf x rf x ) and
S(Rf x Rf x ) respectively. However, the high level of male
sterility in the F1 of 167 x 035 may need explanation. One
explanation, without intending to be limited by theory, is that the
involvement of a chromosome translocation in the 035 line may have
ca~lsed semi-sterility in the Fl of 167 x 035 due to the heterozygous
translocation (T/N). However, the ratio of plants with the
... .
CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
heterozygous translocation would be expected to be reduced to 1/32
in the BC5 population. Alternatively, the restorer gene Rf x may
have been incompletely dominant to rf x . This has been found in
CMS systems in other species. Other alternative possibilities
include that this CMS system is a gametophytic type, in which the
heterozygote of Rf x rf x produced semi-sterile pollen grains, or,
finally, that the nuclear gene(s) responsible for male sterility was
dominant. These possible explanations (except chromosome
translocation) can be confirmed by more precise genetic studies, but
again, the inventor(s) do not intend to be limited by theory.
The CMS OA and QB have the phenotype of G. soja, which
contributed the nuclear genome in recurrent backcrosses. As
previously described, it could not be used directly in hybrid soybean
production due to its unacceptable agronomic characteristics.
However, the CMS male sterile system can be easily expanded to
cultivated types of soybean. The key point is that G. soja and G.
max are closely related species, and there is virtually no barrier to
gene flow between them. In fact, gene transfer from one to another
has frequently been practiced in conventional breeding programs
without any obstacles.
EXAMPLE 2
G.soja is believed to be the ancestor of G.max. Most of its
agronomic characters are not acceptable to modern agriculture.
Therefore the cytoplasmic male sterile line OA having the phenotype
of G.soja described herein in this invention can not directly be used
in hybrid soybean production. As mentioned above there is no
specific barrier between G.soja and G.max and any forms of
intermating between them can be practiced. It is well known in the art
that several ways are available for the transfer of cytoplasmic male
22
.
CA 02262S13 1999-02-08
sterile genetic comp~nents existing in G.soja line OA to G.max. One
of them is test- crosses to screen for the cytoplasmic male sterile
component carried in the nuclear genome in G.soja line OB among
G.ma~ soybean. In other words, the test-crosses are used to screen
among G.max for the recessive gene rf x rf x at the nuclear restorer
locus in OB that could maintain the male sterility in OA.
In example 1 of this invention, the BC3FI (It will be called
OABC3 in the following description) of the backcrosses of
( I 67x03 5)x03 5 was obtained in year 8 . Its percentage of sterile
pollen grains was as high as 99.93%. The test-crosses were carried
out by taking OABC3 as female parent and a number of G.max as
male parents. The followings were the procedures of test-cross and
back-crosses with a soybean variety Yi Chuan Lu Da Dou as male
parent.
Year Location Cross Procedure Average Percentage of
Sterile Pollen (%)
Year 8 Summer Zhengzhou OABC3XYi Chuan lu Da Dou
Year 8 Winter Gongzhuling FlXYi Chuan lu Da Dou 99.00
Year 9 Summer Zhengzhou BC I F I XYi Chuan lu Da Dou 99.05
Year 9 Winter Gongzhuling BC2FlXYi Chuan lu Da Dou 99.92
Year 10 Summer Zhengzhou BC3FlXYi Chuan lu Da Dou 99.95
Year 10 Winter Gongzhuling BC4FlXYi Chuan lu Da Dou 99.95
BC5FI Yi Chuan lu Da Dou
A-line B-line
A new CMS A-line was obtained by continuous backcrossing
OABC3 with Yi Chuan Lu Da Dou. The new CMS A-line and its
maintainer B-line, Yi Chuan lu Da Dou will be called YA and YB
23
,
CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
hereafter in this invention .Both YA and YB have a typical cultivated
soybean phenotype. The chromosome translocation in G.soja OA
and OB was eliminated in YA and YB after five cycles of
backcrosses .
EXAMPLE 3
The following shows the results of pollen fertility measured in
four populations of a three way testcross in Table 4. S.P.G. refers to
the percent of sterile pollen that was measured and F,SS,S refer to
fertile, semi-sterile and sterile respectively. Note that the female
parent is on the left and male parent is on the right. All of the data
were collected in the Henan province, where the lines originated
from .
YA is a Glycine max which is cytoplasmically male sterile and with
recessive alleles of its nuclear restorer gene (S-rf x rf x ). YB is a
Glycine max line which has fertile cytoplasm with recessive alleles at
the same nuclear restorer gene (F-rf x rf x ) Line 167 has a sterile
cytoplasm genetic component and has been restored to fertility
through the homozygous dominant alleles of its nuclear restorer gene
(S-Rf x Rf x )
In the first column, there are shown results of YA, crossed with a
F 1 from a cross between line 167 and YB. The genetics are
expected to be S-rf x rf x (YA), crossed with S-Rf x rf x (167 X
YB). Note that in the case of this male, only Rf-carrying pollen
grains will be viable because of the cytoplasm from line 167. The
results of this cross are progeny that are expected to show 50%
sterility, with their genetics being S-Rf x rf x. Note here that
since line 167 has gametophytic cytoplasmic sterility, and not
sporophytic cytoplasmic sterility, pollen grains resulting from the
167 X YB Fl carrying the recessive restorer allele will be nonviable.
CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
This e~cplains the results of 50% sterility. As noted below, the ratio
of fertile progeny to semi-sterile progeny to sterile progeny is 0: 1 0: 1 .
The one sterile plant is believed to result from what has been well
documented instances of cytoplasmic reversions to fertility that
enables a recessive restorer allele to be transmitted. In these cases,
reversions to fertility are expressed by development of pollen grains
carrying the recessive rf-allele. When this occurs, fully male-sterile
progeny plants can develop (S-rf x rf x ). In maize, frequency of
this is dependent upon genotype. (Gabay-Laughnam, S., G. Zabala,
J.R., "S-Type Cytoplasmic Male Sterility in Maize", pp. 395-432.
In Ch. S. Levings IIl and I.K. Vasil (eds), "The Molecular Biology of
Plant Mitochondria", Kuwar Academic Publishers, Netherlands.
( 1 995))
In the second column are the results of crossing YA with a F1
resulting from YB crossed with the 167 line. Here the genetics
involved are S-rf x rf x by F-Rf x rf x with a 1:1 ratio predicted
consisting of progeny that are S-rf x Rf x and S-rf x rf x . In this
case, both the Rf x allele and the rf x allele are transmitted
because the original Fl was carrying fertile cytoplasm. As can be
seen, the number of fertile progeny to semi-sterile progeny to sterile
progeny is 0: 1 9: 1 6, and thus is reflective of the expected 1: I ratio of
semi-sterile to sterile progeny plants.
In the third column, a F1 is made by crossing YA with the 167 line,
res~llting in progeny that are S-Rf x rf x . This is used as female
parent in a cross with YB. Progeny are once again e~pected to
segregate 1:1 for semi-sterile:sterile plants as both the Rf x allele
and the rf x alleles are viable through the female. The two fertile
plants can be e~cplained by instances of cytoplasmic reversions to
fertility, as described above.
In the fourth column, a cross between a Fl of the 167 line and YB
' CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
with YB, should result in a 1:1 segregation of semi-sterile to sterile
progeny. As can be observed, the ratio is actually closer to 2:1 of
semi-sterile to sterile progeny. These results may be explained by
examining a similar phenomenon in maize observed by Gabay-
Laughnan, Zabala, and Laughnan (1995). These authors observed a
phenomenon in which pollen is produced that looks and stains as
normal but that is non-functional. As of the date of publication,
they observed seven independent occurrences of this in four different
inbred lines. In the soybean example, therefore, some of the
apparent semi-sterile plants could actually be functionally sterile
plants, even though they have a normal pollen grain staining
appearance. If not for this phenomenon, they would have been
classified as all sterile plants.
Table 4
Pollen Fertility in Four Populations of Three Way Test Crosses
% of S.P.G. YABC5 YABC5X(Y (YABC5X16 (167XYB)X
X( 1 67XYB) BXl 67) 7)XYB YB
1-10 0 0 2 5
10.1-20 0 0 0 0
20. 1 -30 0 0 0 0
30.1-40 0 0 0 2
40. 1 -50 4 5 2 4
50. 1 -60 5 9 7 22
60. 1 -70 1 5
70. 1 -80 0 0 0 0
80. 1 -90 ~ ~ ~ ~
90.1-100 1 16 7 14
F:SS:S F:SS:S F:SS:S F:SS:S
.
- CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
0:10:1 0:19:16 2:10:7 5:29:14
Pollen fertility in two F2 populations was also measured, and as
can be seen in Table 5 below, the first a cross between YA and the
167 line, and the second a cross between the 167 line and YB.
These results also reflect the genetics involved. In the YA x 167 F2
population the genetics are a S-rf x rf x by a S-Rf x Rf x resulting
in a S-Rf x rf x . The F2 generation then would be 1:1 of S-Rf x
Rf x and S-rf x Rf x with one half fertile and one half semi-sterile
progeny. In the second cross of 167 by YB, the results are expected
to be S-Rf x rf x and in the F2 generation, S-Rf x Rf x, S-rf x Rf
x, with again a 1:1 ratio between fertile and semi-sterile progeny.
Here again, the 6 sterile progeny in the first cross and the 7 sterile
progeny in the second cross can be explained despite the genetics
involved, by cytoplasmic reversions, as described above. Many
factors can enter into the results which are practically obtained from
crosses between two known genetic lines. Environment is a factor,
as are the anomalies mentioned above where in a gametophytic
system the recessive allele is transmitted by the female. Taking
these practical considerations into mind, one can see that the data
here shows convincingly the one gene gametophytic system
involved here. Once again without intending to be limited by theory,
the inventors emphasize that there may be the possibility of modifier
gene(s) in some of the genetic materials, but these modifiers are still
compatible with the gametophytic single gene system described
hereln.
This confirms that the system is manipulated through a
gametophytic single gene, as opposed to the sporophytic double gene
system of Davis. It should be noted that soybean is a diploidized
polyploid and that multiple genes can relate to a particular trait;
' CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
ho~vever, they are typically quiescent. In any event, with this
invention only one nuclear gene needs to be controlled to impact
sterility. As is evident to one skilled in the art this makes genetic
manipulation through crossing, backcrossing, or the like
considerably easier.
TABLE 5
Pollen Fertility in two F2 Populations
% of S.P.G. (YA X 167) F2 (167 X YB) F2
0-10 111 115
10.1-20 4
20. 1 -30 7 6
30. 1 -40 22 8
40. 1 -50 42 27
50.1-60 31 58
60.1-70 2 3
70. 1 -80 2 0
80.1-90 0 0
90.1-100 6 7
F:SS:S F:SS:S
1 1 1 :1 10:6 1 15:103:7
EXAMPLE 4
The sterility trait in the instant invention is stable throughout
tested temperature and photoperiod changes. Table 6 sho~vs the
28
CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
percent of sterile pollen grains over varying photoperiods.
Temperatures were varied as shown in Table 7, where the first
temperature shown is the daytime temperature and the second is the
nighttime temperature, with three variations shown. As can be seen,
the sterility remained highly stable in the face of such fluctuations.
TABLE 6
Percentage of Sterile Pollen Grains of OA at Different Photoperiods
When Day-Night Temperature Regime was Set at 30-20 ~C
Photoperoid (hours)
Materials Replication 12.5 14.0 15.5
OA 1 99.92 99.94 99.80
2 99.96 99.96 99.70
3 99.69 99.79 99.65
Average 99.82 99.90 99.72
- CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
TABLE 7
Percentage of Sterile Pollen Grains of OA at Different Day-
Night Temperature Regime When Photoperiod was Set at 14.0 Hours
Temperature ( ~C )
Materials Replication. 25-15 30-20 35-25
OA l 99.91 99.65 99.85
2 1 00.00 99.78 99.75
3 99.93 99.85 99.60
Average 99.94 99.76 99.93
- CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
Deposits
A deposit of approximately 2500 seeds of the lines A(OA), B(OB)
and 167 is and has been made with the China Center For Type Culture
Collection ( CCTCC ), Wuhan, Hubei, 430072 pursuant to the
Budapest Treaty. Additionally, Applicant(s) will meet all the
requirements of 37 C.F.R. _1.801 - 1.809, including providing an
indication of the viability of the sample when the deposit is made.
This deposit will be maintained in the CCTCC Depository, which is a
public depository, for a period of 30 years, or 5 years after the most
recent request, and will be replaced if it ever becomes nonviable
during that period. At the time of indication of allowability,
appl icant will impose no restrictions on the availability of the
deposited material from the CCTCC; however, Applicant has no
authority to waive any restrictions imposed by law on the transfer of
biological material or its transportation in commerce. Applicant
does not waive any infringement of its rights granted under this
patent or under the Plant Variety Protection Act .
The foregoing invention has been described in detail by way of
illustration and example for purposes of clarity and understanding.
However, it will be obvious that certain changes and modifications
such as single gene modifications and mutations, somoclonal variants,
variant individuals selected from large populations of the plants of
the instant inbred and the like may be practiced within the scope of
the invention, as limited only by the scope of the appended claims.
All references cited herein are hereby incorporated herein by
reference .
~ CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
REFERENCES
1. BEILING, G., 1915. Linkage and semi-sterility. American
Nature, 49:582-584.
2. DAVIS, W.H., 1985. Route to hybrid soybean production.
United States Patent 4,545,146.
3. DELANNAY, X., KILEN, T.C., PALMER, R.G., 1982.
Screening of soybean (G. max) accessions and G. soja accessions for
chromosome interchange and inversions. Agronomy abstract,
American Society of Agronomy, Madison, Wisconsin. pp. 63.
4. DUVICK, D.N., 1966. Inference of morphology and Sterility on
breeding methodology. In "Plant Breeding", pp. 85-138. Ed.
FREY, K.J., A symposium held at Iowa State University Press, Ames.
5. GRAYBOSCH, R.A. and PALMER, R.G., 1988. Male sterility in
soybean - An overview. American Journal of Botany. 75(1):144-
156.
6. KAUL, M.L.H., 1988. Male sterility in higher plant.
Monographs on Theor. and Appl. Genet. Vol. 10. Springer-Verlag,
Berlin.
7. LASER, K.D. and LERSTEN, N.R.,1972. Anatomy and cytology
of microsporogenesis in cytoplasmic male sterile angiosperms.
Botanical Review, Vol. 38, No. 3, 425-454.
8. PALMER, R.G., 1976. Cytogenetics in soybean improvement.
Proc. Sixth Soybean Res. Conf., American Seed Trade Assoc. Publ.
6 :55-66.
9. PALMER, R.G., ALBERTSEN, M.C., HORNER, H.T. and
SKORUPSKA, H., 1992. Male sterility in soybean and maize:
developmental comparisons. The Nucleus, Vol. 35(1), 1-18.
l 0. PALMER, R.G. and HEER, H., 1984. Agronomic
characteristics and genetics of a chromosome interchange in soybean.
E~lphytica, 33 :651 -653. 32
- CA 02262~13 1999-02-08
I l.' PALMER, R.G. and KILEN, T.C., 1987. Qualitative genetics
and cytogenetics. In "Soybeans: improvement, production and
uses", 135-209, Ed. Wilcox, J.R., American Society of Agronomy, No.
I 6, Madison, Wisconsin, U. S .A.
Although the invention has been described with preferred
embodiments, it is to be understood that variations and modifications
may be resorted to as will be apparent to those skilled in the art.
Such variations and modifications are to be considered within the
purview and scope of the claims appended hereto.
