Note: Descriptions are shown in the official language in which they were submitted.
CA 02278334 1999-07-12
WO 99/03947 PCT/GB98/02079
REFRIGERANT COMPOSITIONS
The present invention relates to refrigerant
compositions, particularly for use as replacements in
refrigeration equipment currently employing, or designed to
employ, the refrigerants R12 and R22.
Refrigerant R12 (CC12F,) has been a commonly used
refrigerant especially in domestic refrigerators. However, R12
contains chlorine atoms and has been implicated in
environmental damage to the ozone layer. As a result efforts
have been made to replace R12 with a refrigerant formulation
which does not involve the use of refrigerants such as R12
which contain chlorine atoms. Similar comments apply to R22
which is used principally for air conditioning systems.
Among alternatives, particular attention has been
directed at R134a(C2 H2 F4;1,1,1,2-tetrafluoroethane) along with
pentafluoroethane (R125)(b.pt. -4$.6 C). Commercial
formulations of these two refrigerants involve the use of a
hydrocarbon, namely propane, propylene or isobutane. While
these refrigerant formulations are generally effective as
replacements for R12 and R22, nevertheless it has been found
that their use is not entirely satisfactory.
Difficulty has arisen with the flammability of the
fractionated composition, that is to say the vapour above the
liquid composition possesses flammability problems. As a
result these commercial formulations can produce flammable
compositions under some leak scenario conditions. The
flammability of these refrigerant compositions resides in their
hydrocarbon content. One of the purposes of incorporating the
hydrocarbon is so that formulation is compatible with the
lubricants ordinarily used in R12 and R22 refrigeration
equipment. The specific hydrocarbons have been selected
because they possess the correct boiling point in relation to
that of the fluorocarbon.
It has now been found, surprisingly, according to the
present invention, that if a hydrocarbon with at least 4 carbon
atoms other than methyl propane (isobutane) is used instead of
CA 02278334 2004-06-15
-2-
those previously advocated the flammability of the fractionated composition is
greatly
reduced. This result is very surprising as n-butane, for example, has a
significantly higher
boiling point (-0.5 C) than, say, isobutane (-11.7 C) and is accordingly less
volatile.
Indeed, the U.S. NIST (National Institute of Standards & Technology) computer
programs
REFPREP and REFLEAK have predicted that a particularly preferred such n-butane-
containing formulation would be flammable when it has been found not to be.
Further,
although there can be a considerable boiling point range between the lowest
boiling point
component and the hydrocarbon of the composition the temperature glide of the
blend is
relatively small. In a particular embodiment, although the boiling point range
is 36.2 C, the
temperature glide is only 3.9K at the boiling point of -34.6 C at one
atmosphere pressure. It
is further surprising that such a formulation has a reduced flammability
because n-butane, for
example, has a larger range of flammability limits as compared with isobutane.
Thus n-
butane has a flammability range from 1.5 to 10. 1% v/v whereas for isobutane
it is only 1.7 to
9.7% v/v.
In a preferred embodiment, the invention comprises a refrigerant composition
which
comprises:
(i) pentafluoroethane, 1,1,1,2- or 1,1,2,2-tetrafluoroethane,
1,1-difluoroethane; trifluoromethoxypentafluoroethane, 1,1,1,2,3,3,3-
heptafluoropropane or
1,1,1,2,2,3,3-heptafluoropropane, or a mixture of two or more thereof, in an
amount from 30
to 50% by weight based on the weight of the composition
(ii) an unsubstituted hydrocarbon of the formula CõHm in which n is at least 4
and m is at least 2n-2, other than methyl propane, in an amount from I to 4%
by weight
based on the weight of the composition.
with the remainder, not exceeding 60% by weight based on the weight of the
composition, being:
(iii) pentafluoroethane, trifluoromethoxydifluoronlethane or
hexafluorocyclopropane, or a mixture of two or more thereof.
CA 02278334 2004-06-15
-2a-
In another preferred embodiment, the invention comprises a refrigerant
composition
which comprises:
(i) pentafluoroethane, 1,1,1,2- or 1,1,2,2-tetrafluoroethane,
1,1-difl uoroethane, trifluoromethoxypentafluoroethane, 1, 1, 1,2,3,3,3 -
heptafluoropropane or
1, 1, 1,2,2,3,3 -heptafluoropropane, or a mixture of two or more thereof, in
an amount from 50
to 75% by weight based on the weight of the composition
(ii) an unsubstituted hydrocarbon of the formula CõH,õ in which n is at least
4
and m is at least 2n-2, other than methyl propane, in an amount from 1 to 4%
by weight
based on the weight of the composition;
with the remainder being
(iii) pentafluorethane, trifluoromethoxydifluoromethane or
hexafluorocyclopropane, or a mixture of two or more thereof.
In a further preferred embodiment, the invention comprises a refrigerant
composition
which comprises:
(i) 1,1,1,2- or 1,1,2,2-tetrafluoroethane, or a mixture of pentafluoroethane
and
1,1,1,2- or 1,1,2,2- tetrafluoroethane, in an amount from 30 to 94% by weight
based on the
weight of the composition,
(ii) an unsubstituted hydrocarbon of the formula C,,Hm in which n is at least
and m is at least 2n-2, other than methyl propane, in an amount from 1 to 4%
by weight
based on the weight of the composition,
(iii) pentafluoroethane in an amount from 5 to 60% by weight based on the
weight of the composition;
with the proviso that the concentration of pentafluoroethane in the
composition is not
5 to 20% by weight based on the weight of the composition.
In a preferred embodiment, the invention also comprises the use of a
refrigeration
composition which comprises:
(i) pentafluorethane, 1,1,1,2- or 1,1,2,2-tetrafluoroethane, 1,1-
difluoroethane,
1,1,1,2,3,3,3,- heptafluoropropane or 1, 1, 1,2,2,3,3,-heptafluoropropane, or
a
CA 02278334 2004-06-15
-2b-
mixture of two or more thereof, in an amount from 30 to 94% by weight
based on the weight of the composition and
(ii) an unsubstituted hydrocarbon of the formula CõHm in which n is at least 4
and m is at least 2n-2, other than methyl propane, in an amount from 1 to 10%
by weight
based on the weight of the composition, as a replacement for
chlorodifluoromethane.
(iii) pentafluoroethane in an amount from 5 to 60% by weight based on the
weight of the composition, as a replacement for chlorodifluoromethane.
According to the present invention there is provided a refrigerant composition
which
comprises
(a) R125, R218 (octafluoropropane; b.pt. -36.7 C),
trifluoromethoxy-difluoromethane (b.pt. -34.6 C) or
hexafluoro-cyclopropane (b.pt. -31.5 C),
or a mixture of two or more thereof, in an amount
from 5 to 60% by weight based on the weight of the composition
(b) R125, R134a, R134 (1,1,2,2-tetrafluoroethane), 1,1-
difluoroethane (R152a; b.pt. - 24.7 C),
trifluoromethoxypentafluoroethane (b.pt. -23.3 C),
1,1,1,2,3,3,3-hepafluoropropane (R227ea; b.pt. -
18.3 C) or 1,1,1,2,2,3,3 -heptafluoropropane
(R227ca; b.pt. -16.3 C, or a mixture of two or
more thereof, in an amount from 30 to 94% by weight
based on the weight of the composition and
(c) an unsubstituted hydrocarbon of the formula C,,Hm in
CA 02278334 2004-06-15
-3-
which n is 4 or 5 and m is at least 2n-2, other than methyl propane, in
an amount from I to 10% by weight based on the weight of the
composition.
The present invention also provides a process for producing refrigeration
which
comprises condensing a composition of the present invention and thereafter
evaporating the
composition in the vicinity of a body to be cooled. The invention also
provides a
refrigeration apparatus containing, as refrigerant, a composition of the
present invention.
Component (c) will be present in an amount from 1 to 10%, especially I to 8%,
preferably 2 to 6% and more preferably 2 to 5%, and in particular 3 to 4%,
most preferably
about 3.5%, by weight of the composition.
It will be appreciated that component (a) and component (b) can both be R125.
In
this situation the composition can, therefore, be binary and the amount of
R125 will be from
90 to 99% by weight. In all other situations, the composition will be at least
ternary.
Among the preferred compositions of the present invention are those which
contain
one or more of R125, R134a and R218. Thus component (a) preferably comprises
R125
and/or R218 while component (b) preferably comprises R125 and/or R134a.
The presence of R218 (b.pt - 36.7 C) is particularly useful where the only
other
fluorocarbon is R134a. In such circumstances R218 is particularly present in
an amount
from 5 to 20% by weight, especially 5 to 15%, and more preferably 7 to 12% by
weight of
the composition.
Component (a) is present in an amount from 5 to 60% by weight, generally 5 to
50%
by weight. If R125 does not form part of component (a) then the amount will
typically be
from 5 to 20%, especially 5 to 15% and preferably 7 to 12%, by
CA 02278334 1999-07-13
. ;
.. , ,
-4-
weight. It will be appreciated that if the composition contains R125, the
concentration of R125 can be split between components (a) and (b).
The concentration of component (b) is from 30 to 94% by weight, generally
50 to 90% and especially 75 to 90%, by weight.
Typically hydrocarbons which can be employed as component (c), and which
may be saturated or unsaturated, include methylenecyclopropane, 1-butene, cis
and
trans-2-butene, butane, cyclobutane, cyclopentene, cyclopentane, 2-methyl-l-
butene,
2-methyl-2-butene, 3-methyl-l-butene, 1-pentene, cis and trans-2-pentene, 2-
methylbutane, pentane and mixtures of two or more thereof. The use of n-butane
(R600) is particularly preferred.
Specific formulations which have been found to be effective are as follows:
% by weight % by weiizht
(a) (b)
R218 9 R125 46 46.5
R134a 88 50 50
n-butane 3 4 3.5
Worst case fractionation study:
The apparatus used for these determinations consisted of a small stainless
steel cylinder (343 cm' intemal volume) which was charged with the blend under
evaluation in various fill ratios and was then placed in a temperature
controlled bath
brought to the appropriate temperature and allowed to equilibrate for at least
30
minutes. The temperature in the bath was controlled to within 0.1 C and was
monitored with a platinum resistance thermometer. Once equilibrated a 75 cm'
sample cylinder was attached to the test cylinder using quick connections and
the
void spaces between the test cylinder and the sample cylinder evacuated with a
vacuum pump. The system was left for at least 15 minutes to check for leaks
and
then vapour from the test cylinder was slowly introduced into the sample
cylinder
using a metering valve. Once the pressure in the sample cylinder reached 1
atmosphere the introduction was stopped, the two cylinders isolated and then
the
sample cylinder was removed for analysis by GLC. The GLC was
CA 02278334 1999-07-12
WO 99/03947 PCT/GB98/02079
calibrated using three separate analyses of a standard which
were made up in such a way as to be quite close to the vapour
composition expected for the test mixture. This sampling was
repeated and a duplicate sample analysed on the GLC. This was
5 repeated at various temperatures with various fill ratios and
the worst case result was the one with the highest hydrocarbon
content.
The results obtained as shown below. The flammability
tests, determined using the method detailed in ASTM E 681-85,
show that the formulations of Examples 1 and 4 are
significantly superior to those of Examples 2, 3 and 5, while
possessing good refrigeration performance. It will be noted
that the vapour of the composition of Example 1 (and 4) was
non-flammable. It is clear that similar comments apply to the
composition R125 - 46.501, R134A - 50% and R600 - 3.5%.
CA 02278334 1999-07-12
WO 99/03947 PCT/GB98/02079
-6-
L uid Com sition % w/w
R125 R218 R134a R600a R600
Eatam e 1 46 - 50 - 4
Exam e 2 46 - 50 4
Exam te 3 46.5 - 50 3.5 -
Exam le 4 - 9 88 - 3
Exam le 5 9 88 3 -
Retr'tqeration Performance as an altemative to 8,22
Evaporator Refr' eration Effect / kW Coetticient of Performance
Temperature / C R22 Example 1 EXample 2 Example 3 R22 Example 1 Example 2
Example 3
-15 0.932 0.855 0.823 0.711 1.269 1.204 1.194 0.966
-10 1.328 1.124 1.133 1.058 1.492 1.443 1.436 1.323
-5 1.723 1.437 1.476 1.413 1.716 1.700 1.695 ' 1.624
0 2.118 1.796 1.852 1.775 1.939 1.976 1.970 1.869
2.513 2.200 2262 2.145 2.163 2.270 2.262 2058
Refrigeration Periomtance as an aftemath-e to R12
Evaporator Ret ' eration Effect / kW Coefficient of Performance
Temperature / C R12 Example 4 Example 5 R12 Exam le 4 Example 5
-15 0.585 0.706 0.738 0.942 1.002 1.036
-10 0.786 0.877 0.889 1.227 1.312 1.314
-5 1.018 1.119 1.128 1.513 1.623 1.591
0 1.281 1.434 1.453 1.799 1.933 1.869
5 1.575 1.820 1.865 2.085 2.244 2148
Fractionatlon and Flammabiltty test resutts
Fractionated Vapour Composition / % w/w ~ow~er Fkammaba
Blend R125 R218 R134a R600a R600 Umk x,rtv in Air
Example 1 60.7 - 34.6 - 4.7 Non Flammable
Exam le 2 64.4 29.1 6.5 - 12
Example 3 64.7 - 29.8 5.5 - 15
Example 4 - 22.9 72.5 - 4.6 Non Flammable
Example 5 - 21.5 72.5 6 - 9
. i ~
